Transcript
Page 1: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

BSHFEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignevaluationJimCoe&JeremySmith,November2017

Page 2: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

2

contents

Summary.............................................................................................31 Introduction...................................................................................7

1.1 Purposeofthisreview.................................................................................................71.2 Reviewapproach.........................................................................................................71.3 Backgroundtothereview............................................................................................8

2 Strategyandstrategicassumptions................................................82.1 Campaignprinciples.....................................................................................................82.2 BSHF’sstrategicrole..................................................................................................13

3 Implementationandmanagement...............................................163.1 SupportBSHFprovides..............................................................................................163.2 Sharinglearningandtrackingprogress......................................................................18

4 Campaignoutcomes.....................................................................194.1 Improvedevidencebase............................................................................................194.2 Enhancedengagementandinterest..........................................................................204.3 Towardschangesinpolicyandpractice....................................................................234.4 Impactonpeoplewhoarestreethomeless..............................................................244.5 Commentaryonprogressandachievements............................................................26

5 Lookingahead..............................................................................275.1 Growingthecampaign...............................................................................................275.2 AEuropeancampaign?..............................................................................................295.3 Futurecoordinationapproachandstructures...........................................................305.4 Developingthestrategy.............................................................................................31

6 Recommendations........................................................................33Appendix1:Campaigntimeline.........................................................35Appendix2:Campaignprinciples.......................................................36Appendix3:Surveyresponses:campaignoutcomes..........................37Figure1:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonthecampaignprinciples.......................................9Figure2:Volunteers’viewsofthecampaign..........................................................................12Figure3:Partners’survey:FeedbackonBSHFsupport...........................................................16Figure4:Partners’survey:Feedbackonspecificresourcesupport........................................17Figure5:Volunteers’previousinvolvementinhomelessnessissues......................................22Figure6:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonbenefitstolocalhomelesspeople.....................25Figure7:Summarycampaigntimeline....................................................................................35Figure8:Partners’survey:Perspectivesoncampaignoutcomes...........................................37Figure9:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonorganisationalbenefits......................................37

Page 3: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

3

Summary

INTRODUCTION TheEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignisfundedandcoordinatedbyBSHF.Itwassetupontheprinciplethat“thetimehascometostopmanaginghomelessnessandstartendingit”.Thisevaluationfocusesonthefollowingmainareas:(a)Strategicassumptions(b)Campaigndeliveryandmanagement,and(c)Campaignoutcomes.Theevaluationdrawson: • Areviewofrelevantdocuments. • Asurveycompletedby8citypartnerorganisations(outof20thatreceivedit)from

across5cities. • Interviews(20intotal)withBSHFstaffandconsultants,strategicpartners,citylevel

partnersandvolunteersin4cities(Croydon,Valencia,TorbayandBrussels).• Ashortsurveyforvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign,circulatedtovolunteersin

WestminsterandBarcelona,throughwhichwereceived111responsesintotal.

CAMPAIGN PRINCIPLES Thecampaignisdeeplyambitiousinitsgoaltoachievesystemicchange.Thesixcampaignprinciplesframethisambition,andsoitisencouragingthatsurveyfeedbacksuggeststhatpartnersstronglysupportallthecampaignprinciples. Thetwokeyorganisingprinciples–HousingFirstandcommunityinvolvement–arebothdeliberatelydisruptiveofthestatusquo.Contributorsstronglysupport(theneedfor)thiselementofdisruption. ThefactthatHousingFirsthasalreadysometractionandcredibilityishelpfulinreducingthepotentiallyalienatingeffectofthisdisruption.SurveyresultsshowthatpartnersstronglysupporttheHousingFirstapproachandstronglyagreethatthisprojectisupholdingtheapproachinpractice.Interviewfeedbackwasslightlymorenuanced,withsomestressingtheneedtomovefromthecurrentsituationtoasystemwhichincorporatesHousingFirst(butnotastheonlyapproach). Partnersshowedstrongbuyintotheprincipleofcommunityinvolvement,althoughinmanycasesthishasn’t(yet)extendedbeyondinvolvementinConnectionsWeeks.Volunteerssurveyedindicatedthattheywerewillingtoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture.Somewouldlikeopportunitiesforongoinginvolvementandseveralwerekeentohearmoreabouttheprogressofthecampaign. Itcouldbeclearerwhatthecommunityinvolvementexpectationsareinpractice.Somepartnersfeltthatcommunitymembers’ongoinginvolvementinthecampaignshouldbebetterintegratedfromthebeginning.

Page 4: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

4

BSHF’S STRATEGIC ROLE Asanindependentvoice,BSHFiswellplacedtoinitiateandcoordinatethecampaign.ButsomepointedtothefactthatBSHFisnewtothefieldashavingsomepotentialdisadvantagesthatneedtobemanaged,notablyarounditsreachandcontactsacrossEuropeandthebreadthofcitieswhichareinvolved.Mostfeltthatcityselectionwasinitiallymadeonapragmaticratherthanastrategicbasis.Thismadesensepracticallybutithasskewedthegeographyofparticipatingcitiesinthecampaigntodate.ThereareearlysignsofthisnowshiftingtoamoreEuropean-wideapproach. Theflexibilitythatthecampaigngivestocitylevelpartnerscreatesapositivecontextforactionatthatlevel.

IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT Thecampaignconcentratesattentionandhelpsraiseparticipants’morale.Partnersvaluethesenseofsolidaritythatbeingpartofthecampaignbrings.Forsome,itbringsaddedcredibilitytotheircitylevelwork. PartnersareverypositiveabouttheoverallsupportthatBSHFprovidesandaboutthespecificsupportpackagesonoffer.Partnersarepositiveabouthowlearningissharedbutsaythereisroomformore.Thereisanaturaltendencyforcitiestoexchangewithcitiesintheirowncountry,buttheremaybeincreasingopportunitytoextract-andmorewidelyshare-generalisablelessonsfromcities'experiences.Approachestotrackingandreportingshouldbefurtherdevelopedasthecampaigngrows.

CAMPAIGN OUTCOMES Thecampaignisbeginningtodemonstrateasetofoutcomesthatshowprogresstowardsthegoalofsecuringsustainablehousingforstreethomelesspeople. Forsomecities,conductingthestreetsurveyshasgeneratedvaluablenewdataandevidence. Inmanycities,therearepositivesignsofgrowthofinterestin,andsupportto,thecampaignanditsprinciplesfromlocalcivilsocietyorganisationsandassociations.Partnersmentionedthatthereisevidenceoflocalmediacoverageandsocialmediadissemination.CommunityengagementhasgenerallybeenstrongduringConnectionsWeeks.Inmostcases,effortsatinvolvingthecommunityinamoreongoingwayareintheirearlystages.Thisisanareathatmanycitiesarecommittedtodeveloping. Therearesomesignsthatmunicipalauthoritiesareengagingwiththecampaign.Therearesomeexamplesofapparentinfluenceonmunicipalauthorities’policyandpracticeemerging,but-notsurprisinglygiventhechallengesinvolved-progresstendstobeslowevenwherecommitmentsareinplace.

Page 5: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

5

Therearesomeearly(butnotalwaystotallyclear)signsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplehavebeenbeinghousedasaresultofthecampaign(orthatthecampaignhasinsomewaycontributedtothis).Partnersmentionthatthereareotherbenefitstostreethomelesspeople–forexamplethroughthehumanisingexperienceofthesurveyengagement–butwehavelimitedinformationaboutthis.Thecampaignisnotyetachievingchangeatscalebutitwouldnotberealistictoexpecttoseethissosoon.Thereareenoughsignsofprogresstobeencouragedabouttheapproachbeingtaken.Inanumberofcities,shortageofhousingstock/landseemstobeakeybarrier.ItseemsthatevenwherecityauthoritiescollaboratecloselywithcampaignpartnersandsupportHousingFirst,theymaybeunabletoapplyitinpractice.

LOOKING AHEAD ThereisasetofconsiderationsandoptionsforBSHFaroundwhether,howandhowfast,andwhere,togrowthecampaign. Partnerssupportgrowthinthenumberofparticipatingcitiesinprinciplebutidentifysomeconcernsinpractice,includinginrelationtothecampaign’scapacitytosupportamuchlargernumberofcitieswhilebeingsurethatthosealreadyinvolvedhavereachedalevelofengagementsuchthattheirrelianceonBSHFislimited.Somefeltitwouldbehelpfultodemonstratesuccessmoredefinitivelybeforeexpandingthenumberofcitiesinvolved. Citylevelcampaignsseemtobemosteffectivewhentheybuildonexisting,iflatent,supportforchange.Therearesomestrategicchoicesthatthecampaignmightwanttomakearoundhowmuchtofocusontheareaswherethereismostlikelytobe(relatively)quickprogress.Asthecampaigngrows,theremayneedtobesomeadditionalcampaigncommunication(internallyandexternally)inlanguagesotherthanEnglish.Somepartnersseethepotentialtodevelopamorecoordinatedcampaigningapproach.Thecurrent,city-basedmodelisaviableonebutsomefeltthatcomplementingthiswithsomemorecentralisedadvocacyisanalternativeworthconsidering. Therearesomedifferentoptionsforhowthestructuralcoordinationofthecampaigncouldevolve.Alltheoptionshavesomeadvantagesbutnoneofthemprovideanobviousandclearrouteforward.It’sgoodthatresourcingtosupportthecampaignisinplaceoverthemediumterm–butthismaynotfullyresolvethequestionofresourcing,dependingondecisionsaboutthecampaign'sstrategicpurposeandthefuturerolethatBSHFwillplay. Nowisagoodtimetoreviewtheoverallcampaignstrategy.Thereareasetofinter-relatedchoicesabout(a)whatsortof‘campaign’itshouldbe

Page 6: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

6

(b)whatthegrowthstrategyshouldbe(c)whatkindofstrategicpartnershipsshouldsupportnationallevelaction(d)whatresourcesareneededandwheretheyshouldcomefrom(e)thebestsystemsforsharinglearningandencouragingcross-fertilisation,andtherolethatBSHFshouldplayinthis.Thereisaquestionaboutwhoisinvolvedinconsideringfuturestrategy,withsomedifferentoptionsabouthowthatcouldbedone.

RECOMMENDATIONS 1. ReviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundHousingFirstaresetoutandcommunicated,to

ensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.

2. Developguidancethatencouragespartnerstoupdatevolunteersandotherinterestedpartnersoncampaignprogress.

3. Reviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundcommunityinvolvementaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.

4. Considerpracticalwaystoencouragelearningopportunitiesbetweencities,boththroughBSHFandbilaterally,takingintoaccountdifferentiatedneeds(accordingtogeographyandhistoryofinvolvementforexample).

5. Developanapproachtocampaigntrackingandmonitoringthatsupportsbettergenerationofandaccesstoreal-timeinformation.Somepracticalstepscouldincludedeveloping:

• An‘outcomebank’withsomeguidanceonwhatoutcomesareofparticularinterest;

• Acampaign‘evidencedatabase’thatallcanaddto;• Supportandguidancearoundreviewinginformationinwaysthatfeedinto

planning;• Supporttoeffortstodevelopcasestudiesthatillustrateprogressbeingmade.

6. Considerdevelopingsomeprotocolsandguidancearoundcommunicatingdifficultmessages,suchasinrelationtomigrantsandrefugees.

7. Establish-aspartofcampaigntracking–asetofcommondefinitions/indicatorsthatclearlyexpressthechangesthecampaignseeks(whichwouldincludenumbersofpeoplehousedinHousingFirstaccommodation,butalsomeasurestodowithhowthathousingstatusissustained);andagreehowthatinformationwillberecordedandreported.

8. Considersettingupaprocessorforumtoconsidercommonchallengesandhowtoovercomebarrierslinkedtolimitsonhousingstockandland.

9. Developagrowthstrategythatsetsoutideasonthespeedandsequencingofexpansiontonewcitiesandthebestmixofcitiestoinvolve,andimplicationsarisingfromthis(aroundlanguageforexample).

10. Considerthepotentialforcomplementingcityleveladvocacywithsomecoordinatedadvocacythatdrawsonexperiencesacrosscities.

11. Considerwhetherandhowbesttoinvolvepartnersindevelopingstrategicoptions.

Page 7: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

7

1 Introduction

1.1 PURPOSEOFTHISREVIEW

TheEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignisfundedandcoordinatedbyBSHF.Itwassetupontheprinciplethat“thetimehascometostopmanaginghomelessnessandstartendingit”.Insupportofthisgoal,thecampaignhasbeen:• creatinggreaterawarenessofroughsleeping,thepeoplewhoareaffected,andwhat

canbedoneaboutit;• findinganddeliveringbetter,quickerwaystohelppeopleoffthestreets–inparticular

thosewithmultipleandcomplexneeds-andintopermanenthousing.1Inlinewithourproposal,thisevaluationfocusesonthefollowingmainareas(a)Strategicassumptions(b)Campaigndeliveryandmanagement,and(c)Campaignoutcomes.Insettingoutanenquiryframeworkinmoredetail,wenotedthat“itmakessensetofocusinparticularon• the‘interimoutcomes’(signsofprogresstowardsthelongertermgoal);and• theoverallapproachandimplementationofit(toestablishhowwellsetupthe

campaignistoachievetheresultsitseeks).Thisreportaddressestheseareasandfollowstheguidanceinthecallforproposalsthattheend-productreportshould“identifythestrengths,resultsandimpactofthecampaign'sworktodate,andrecommendanychangesorenhancementsthatwouldimprovethequality,reachandimpactofwhatwedo”.

1.2 REVIEWAPPROACH

Theevaluationdrawson:1/Areviewofrelevantdocuments.2/Asurveycompletedby8citypartnerorganisations(outof20thatreceivedit)fromacross5cities.Wehaveincludeddatafromthesurveythroughoutthereport,butgiventherelativelylowresponserate,weshouldnotethatfindingsmaynotnecessarilyberepresentativeofoverallopinionamongstcitypartners.1FromBSHF,callforproposals–oneyearfollowupevaluation

Page 8: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

8

3/Interviews(20intotal)withBSHFstaffandconsultants,strategicpartners,citylevelpartnersandvolunteersin4cities(Croydon,Valencia,TorbayandBrussels).4/Ashortsurveyforvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign,circulatedtovolunteersinWestminsterandBarcelona,throughwhichwereceived111responsesintotal.Thesurveywascompletedby34volunteersfromWestminsterand77fromBarcelona(whereitwasavailableinSpanishandCatalan).Thissurveywasnotsentouttoothercityvolunteerstoavoidmakingtoomanyrequestsofcitypartnersduringthecourseoftheevaluation.WereviewedallinformationandsharedinitialfindingsandconclusionsinasessionwithBSHFstaffbeforedraftingthisreport.

1.3 BACKGROUNDTOTHEREVIEW

Theprogrammewasinitiatedin2015.BSHFandFEANTSAinitiallyselectedsixcitiesforinvolvement.Threeofthesecitiesmaintainedtheirinvolvementandwerejoinedbyafourth,Croydon,inthepilotphaseoftheprogramme.In2016,BSHFcommissionedanevaluationofthepilotphaseofthecampaign,whichvalidatedtheconceptandwaspositiveaboutprogresstodate.Followingthepilotphase,othercitieshavejoinedthecampaign,andBSHFhasdevelopedamorestructuredprogrammeofsupport(discussedinsection3.1).WesetoutasummarycampaigntimelineinAppendix1.

2 Strategy and strategic assumptions

2.1 CAMPAIGNPRINCIPLES

Thecampaignisdeeplyambitiousinitsgoaltoachievesystemicchange.Thesixcampaignprinciplesframethisambition,andsoitisencouragingthatsurveyfeedbacksuggeststhatpartnersstronglysupportallthecampaignprinciples.ThecampaignprinciplesarelistedinAppendix2.Weaskedforfeedbackinthesurvey(a)whetherthesearetherightprinciples,and(b)howwelltheyarebeingfollowedinimplementation.Plottingtheseresultsreveals:• Thereisgoodsupportfortheprinciples,althoughsupportiscomparativelylessstrongin

regardtothe‘improvingsystems’approach,althoughitisnotclearwhythisshouldbe

Page 9: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

9

• Surveyrespondentsseesomeprinciplesasbeingmoreclearlyimplementedthanothers,notablythatthereismoreworktodoaroundtrackingprogress.Thisisconsistentwithinterviewfeedback(wediscusstrackingandmonitoringinsection3.2).

Figure1:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonthecampaignprinciples

Thisgraphplotsaverageresponses,onascaleof1-5fromstronglydisagreetostronglyagreeThetwokeyorganisingprinciples–HousingFirstandcommunityinvolvement–arebothdeliberatelydisruptiveofthestatusquo.Contributorsstronglysupport(theneedfor)thiselementofdisruption.Disruptionisbuiltintothecampaign.Asthe2016evaluationexplainedit,“Intendedtobedisruptive,thecampaignhelpedsomepeoplewhohadbeenworkinginthisareaforalongtime,whowerefrustratedbythelackofprogress,tobreakorchangetherules”.Respondentsstressedthatthecampaignisdesignedasachallengeto‘businessasusual’mentalitiesandpracticesandtothe“homelessnessindustry”.Whileoneintervieweenotedthatbeingdisruptiveis"anunintendedconsequenceofusingadifferentapproach”,othersembracedisruptionasapositiveforce.

HousingFirst

Knowingwho'soutthere

Trackingprogress Involvingthe

communityImprovinglocal

systems

Learning&sharing

1.00

2.00

3.00

4.00

5.00

1 4

stronglyagree

Rightprinciple?

stronglydisagree

stronglystronglydisagreeBeingapplied?agree

Page 10: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

10

Butforthisradicaldisruptiontotakeholdthroughnewwaysofaddressingproblemsofhomelessnessbeingadopted,thereisaneedtobringpeoplealong.Sothereisatensionthatcitypartnersmustnavigate:“Peopleinthesectormayfeelwearecriticisingtheirintentionswhenwearecriticisingtheirmethods.Thereisariskoflosingpeoplewhohaveworkedagainsthomelessnessforalongtime…weneedtoengagethemsensitively”.Asweexplorebelow,citypartnershavemadesomeprogressinbuildingsupportamongstcommunitiesandgroups,butthisisnotastraightforwardorquickundertaking.ThefactthatHousingFirsthasalreadysometractionandcredibilityishelpfulinreducingthepotentiallyalienatingeffectofthisdisruption.Inmanyways,HousingFirstisradicallychallenging.Butthereisevidencetosupportit(althoughsomeofthismaybecontested)anditbuildsonsomeexistinginterestinpartsofEurope.Intervieweesreportthatmanyinthehomelessnesssectorrecognisethatexistingapproacheshavenotworked.Sointhatsense,althoughHousingFirstrepresentsaradicalreorientation,thereareatleastsomepositiveconditionsinplacethathelpcreateapotentialtobuildsomemomentumaroundit.SurveyresultsshowthatpartnersstronglysupporttheHousingFirstapproachandstronglyagreethatthisprojectisupholdingtheapproachinpractice.Interviewfeedbackwasslightlymorenuanced,withsomestressingtheneedtomovefromthecurrentsituationtoasystemwhichincorporatesHousingFirst(butnotastheonlyapproach).HousingFirstrepresentsashiftfrommanagingtoendinghomelessness.Accordingtoonepartner,“itturnsontheirheadthethingswethoughtweknow…[it]hasbeenvaluableandchallenging”.Anotherstressedthat“Itisbasedonhousingbeingaright.Thisiscentraltowhyitworks”.Onepartnerdescribeditasagoodwaytoby-passtheexisting,over-complexsystem.Thereisstronginterestandbuy-intoHousingFirstamongstparticipantsinthecampaign.Thecampaignisupholdingthiscentralprincipletotheextentthatsomecities’involvement,includingtheinvolvementofsomeofthepilotcities,hasfalteredonthelackofstrongcommitmentto,andprioritisationof,HousingFirstprinciples.Butit’salsothecasethatsomepartnersareinterpretingHousingFirstaspartofapackageofapproaches.Onecitypartnernotedthat“Itisrighttoendconditionalityofsupport,butthisisnotforeveryone.HousingFirstisnotapanacea-youneedarangeofoptions”andanotherthat“Itworksiftargetedattherightpeople”.ThisraisesaquestionastowhetherthecampaignisadvocatingHousingFirstasthesolution,orasoneelementofawidersolution.Perhapstheredoesnothavetobeadefinitiveviewaboutthiswithinthecampaign,buthavingaclearerlinemightbehelpful.

Page 11: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

11

Speakingconceptually,briefly:inthecontextofreferencestoHousingFirstasa‘paradigmshift’,systemsthinkerDonellaMeadowssetoutthebestwaystochangethestructuresofasystem.Sheadvocatedthatthesecondmosteffectivewaytoshiftasystemisbycreatinganewparadigm-butthatthemosteffectiveapproachistotranscendparadigms,“tostayflexible,torealisethatnoparadigmis‘true’toeveryone”.2WemightseeplacingHousingFirstmoreflexiblyasonepotentialsolution,ratherthanasthesolution,fitswellwiththis‘transcendingparadigms’approach.SeeRecommendation1.Partnersshowedstrongbuy-intotheprincipleofcommunityinvolvement,althoughinmanycasesthishasn’t(yet)extendedbeyondinvolvementinConnectionsWeeksManypartnersstressedthatvolunteerinvolvementhasbroughtinnewactors,newenergyandnewperspectives.Asoneintervieweeputit,communityinvolvement“improvedthequalityofthediscussion,madepeoplestepbackandnotassumedoingthesamethingthesamewayisright”.Thisisexpressedintheprinciplethat“Weneedtotakean'unprofessional'approachtoserviceprovision”.Theprincipleofcommunityinvolvementwasverystronglysupportedbythevolunteerssurveyed,withextraordinarilyhighagreementamongstBarcelonavolunteers(seeFigure2)ConnectionsWeeksthemselveshavehadsomechallengesinsomecities,butmanyfelttheywerepositiveexperiences.Inonecity,someintervieweesraisedaspecificissuearoundtheConnectionsWeekduplicatingexistinginitiatives.Weheardonecriticismofthecampaignthatithasn’tbeenclearenoughinsettingoutwhatwasmeantbycommunityinvolvement,beyondtheConnectionsWeeks.Theactualpictureseemsmoremixedthanthis,withsomecities,notablyCroydon,activelyembeddingthiselementwithinthewidercampaign,andothersshowingadevelopingcommitmenttobuildinginongoingcommunityinvolvementinfuture(seesection4.2).Butinsomeothercities,therehasnotbeenmuch,ifany,communityinvolvementbeyondtheConnectionsWeeksthemselves.Volunteerssurveyedindicatedthattheywerewillingtoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture.Somewouldlikeopportunitiesforongoinginvolvementandseveralwerekeentohearmoreabouttheprogressofthecampaign.Insurveyfeedback,volunteersstressedthattheyparticipatedinthecampaignbecausetheywantedtocontributeinsomeway,andshowsolidarity,andthattheywelcomedapracticalwayofshowingtheirconcernandfulfillingadesiretodosomething.Forsomeitwasawaytobecomebetterinformed-“ithasbeenveryimportantformetohavetheopportunityto

2DonellaMeadows,ThinkinginSystems,p162-4,Earthscan,2009

Page 12: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

12

listento[homelesspeople]directly”.AcoupleofvolunteersinWestminstermentionedthattheyhadexperiencedhomelessnessthemselves.SeveralvolunteersinBarcelonaspecificallymentionedtheimportanceofhavinggoodinformationinordertobeabletoaddresstheproblem(i.e.goingbeyondmoregeneralisedreasonsforbeinginvolvedandexplicitlyidentifyingthattheyfeltthisparticularinterventionwasaworthwhileone).Inbothcitiescoveredbythevolunteers’survey,volunteersexpressedstrongwillingnesstoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture,withsomesuggestingthisrepresenteduntappedpotential:“thereweredozensofpeoplewillingtogivetheirtimetocarryondoingstuffandthiswasnotexploited”.ThisseemedtobeastrongerfeelingamongstWestminstervolunteers,althoughasmallnumberofBarcelonavolunteersdidalsoraiseit:“Oncethecounthasbeenmadehowcanacommunitycallbemadetosolvetheproblem?”Probablylinkedtothis,thevolunteers’surveyindicatesthat-whilststillpositiveoverall-volunteersinthetwocitiesconcernedagreedrelativelylessstronglyabouttheeffectivenessofcommunityinvolvementinthiscase,thecontributiontheyhadmade,andwhatthecampaignhasachieved.ThereisstrongeragreementineachcasefromvolunteersinBarcelonathanfromthoseinWestminster:

Figure2:Volunteers’viewsofthecampaign

Graphshowsaverageresponsesonascale1-5,where1=stronglydisagreeand5=stronglyagree

4.58

4.25

4.21

3.87

3.69

3.48

4.89

4.71

4.69

4.42

4.17

3.66

1 2 3 4 5

Itisimportantthatthereis'acommunitysolu=ontoacommunityproblem'

IwasgiventhesupportIneededtotakepartinthecampaign

It’sbeenclearwhathasbeenexpectedofme

Thiscampaignoffersaneffec=vewaytoinvolvethecommunityinaddressinghomelessnessinmycity

IfeelIhavemadeavaluablecontribu=ontotacklinghomelessnessinmycity

Thecampaignhasledtoposi=veresultsforhomelesspeopleinmycity

Pleasetellushowmuchyouagreewiththefollowingstatements:

Westminster Barcelona

Page 13: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

13

Indeed,inresponsetothesurveyquestion“thecampaignhasledtopositiveresultsforhomelesspeopleinmycity”,36%ofvolunteersinWestminsterreplied‘don’tknow’,makingthisthemostcommonanswer.InBarcelona,21%replied‘don’tknow’.Thissuggestsitcouldbegoodforpartnerstothinkaboutwaystokeepvolunteersbetterinformedaboutcampaignprogress.SeveralvolunteersinWestminstermentionedthattheywantedtoknowmore,andbekeptuptodate,aboutwhatwashappeningwiththecampaign:“Ipersonallyhaven'theardagreatdealaboutitsinceIdidmysmallpart”;“Iwouldliketohaveheardmoreabouttheoutcomesandfindingsofthework”.ThesmallnumberofvolunteersweinterviewedforthereviewmentionedthattheyhavelittlesenseofitbeingaEuropeancampaignandwouldwelcomemorecontactwithothercities,andtobemoreawareofthebiggerpicture.SeeRecommendation2.Itcouldbeclearerwhatthecommunityinvolvementexpectationsareinpractice.Somepartnersfeltthatcommunitymembers’ongoinginvolvementinthecampaignshouldbebetterintegratedfromthebeginning.Therewassomefeedbackfrompartnersquestioninghowessentialcommunityinvolvementactuallyisinadvancingthegoalsofthecampaign.Inacoupleofcitiespartnersexpressedasensealongthelinesthat:“thereisnoneedtoinvolvethecommunityforitsownsake,ifyoucanachieveyourgoalsbydirectengagement”.Thisraisesaquestionastowhethercommunityinvolvementisameanstoapolicyendand/orsomethingbroaderthanthat.Inturn,itmaybeunclearwhatpartnersaresigninguptowhentheycommittothecommunityinvolvementprincipleaspartofthecampaign.Giventhis,itcouldbehelpfultohaveaclearerandmoreexplicitpositiononthestrategicpurposeofinvolvingcommunitiesacrossthecampaignasawhole.Inparticular,thiscouldhelpacceleratecommunityinvolvementefforts,inthatitwouldbeclearerfromthestartwhatthatlookslike.Thisisconsistentwiththerecommendationfromapartnerthat“Keywouldbetoplanwhatyouaregoingtodoafterwards[tofacilitateongoingcommunityinvolvement]beforetheendoftheConnectionsWeek.Thequickeryougetitgoingthebetter”.SeeRecommendation3.

2.2 BSHF’SSTRATEGICROLE

Asanindependentvoice,BSHFiswellplacedtoinitiateandcoordinatethecampaign.BSHFsawaneedandanopportunityandsteppedin.OtherrespondentscorroboratedBSHF’sownsensethatitiswellplacedandabletooperateasanhonestbroker:“wehave

Page 14: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

14

independenceandhaveusedthattoouradvantage”.Oneexternalinterviewee,forexample,feltthat,“Itneedsoutsiderstoshakethingsup.It'sverylaudablethatBSHFtooktheplunge.Thatothershavejoinedthecampaignvindicatesthat”.GivenhowwellplacedBSHFistoidentifygoodpractice,wethinkit’salogicalandpositivesteporganisationallyforBSHFtofollowthisthroughandbemorepracticallyinvolvedinfindingwaystoreplicategoodpractice.Asoneinternalintervieweeexplainedit,“Weareinauniquepositiontofindoutthingsthatwork,sohaveadutytotrytogetthosetoworkinotherplaces”.ButsomepointedtothefactthatBSHFisnewtothefieldashavingsomepotentialdisadvantagesthatneedtobemanaged,notablyarounditsreachandcontactsacrossEuropeandthebreadthofcitieswhichareinvolved.Mostfeltthatcityselectionwasinitiallymadeonapragmaticratherthanastrategicbasis.Thismadesensepracticallybutithasskewedthegeographyofparticipatingcitiesinthecampaigntodate.ThereareearlysignsofthisnowshiftingtoamoreEuropean-wideapproach.Internalintervieweesaswellaspartnersrecognisedthattheapproachintheearlystageswasessentiallypractical,togowheretheinterestwas.Thefactthatpartnersputthemselvesforwardshowedsomecommitment,butbeyondthattheinitialcitieswerenotselectedonthebasisofanywiderstrategiclogic.SeveralrespondentsfeltthatthemixofcitieshastendedtodependonBSHF'sexistingcontacts,althoughthisopiniondownplaystherolethatFEANTSAhasplayedinsuggestingcitiestoapproach.Oneintervieweesuggestedthatthelimitationsarenotsimplydowntoreach:“TheissueislessabilityofBSHFtoreachcities,buthowcitiesreceivethemessageofthecampaign”.Theapproachtodatehashadsomecostintermsofgeographicalspread,withthecampaigntodateshowingadisproportionateUKfocus(bothintermsofcitiesselectedandofcitiesthathaveremainedengagedinthecampaign).

Table1:InvolvementofUKandmainlandEuropeancitiesinthecampaign

Total StillinvolvedAllcities 14 10UK 6 6

Thismakeupisbeginningtochange.WeunderstandthenewtrancheofcitieswillhelpintroducefurtherdiversityandmovethecentreofgravityfurtherEast.Developingthisgeographicalspreadwillbekeytothenextphaseofthecampaign(seesection5.1).Adoptingamodelthatinvolvesworkingwithandthroughothers,whilstoperatinginanewareabringschallengesintermsofhowcontactsareforgedandpartnersidentified.It’s

Page 15: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

15

difficultforanewactortobuilditsnetworksinnewcountries:thereisinevitablyacertainrelianceonstrategicsupportfromexistingactorsandthishasn’talwaysbeenfullyonoffer.OnerespondentalsomentionedthatBSHF’srelativelysmallsizecouldmakeitdifficulttomaintainasenseofownershipoverthecampaign.BSHFisalerttothisandismanagingthischallengebynotgoingbeyondtheboundariesofwhatislikelytobesustainable.Theflexibilitythatthecampaigngivestocitylevelpartnerscreatesapositivecontextforactionatthatlevel.Theparametersofthecampaignaresetbytheprinciples,andbeyondthatthereisalotoflatitudedelegatedtocitylevel:“thereisalevelthatyoumustdo,therestisflexible”.Citylevelpartnersverymuchappreciatethisapproachasnotedelsewhere.It'sanapproachthatseemsverymuchinlinewitha‘directednetwork’modelofcampaigns,which“aretypicallyledbyacentralbodythatframestheissuesandcoordinatesenergiestowardssharedmilestonesbutalsoleavesafairamountoffreedomandagencyto…supportersand…allies”.Areviewofthisapproachfoundthatthesetypesofdirected-networkcampaigns“performedexceptionallywellintermsofbothimpactandforceamplification”comparedtomoretraditionalmodels”.3Thecampaignconcentratesattentionandhelpsraiseparticipants’morale.Partnersvaluethesenseofsolidaritythatbeingpartofthecampaignbrings.Forsome,itbringsaddedcredibilitytotheircitylevelwork.Thefactthatmultiplecitiesareengagedinacommonendeavourhasbeenhelpfultomanyofthecitylevelpartners.Onefeltthat“hearingthatothershavethesameproblemsmadeusfeellessisolated”andanothernotedthat“havingtheopportunitytoworkalongsideagroupofpeoplewithasharedcommitmenttosignificantsystemchangeisanalltoorareopportunity”.EventhoughthecampaignisnotyetestablishedacrossEurope,somepartnersstillexpressedthesensethattohavea‘Europeancampaign’aroundwhichpeoplewererallyinghelpedthemfeelpartofsomethingbigger.Thiswasgoodformoraleandhasboostedcredibility-“ithelpsusstrengthenourargumentstobeabletorefertothecampaign”-aswellashelpingtogivesomeadditionalfocustothecampaignlocally.Incontrast,oneintervieweefeltthat"it’snot[yet]anadvantagetomentiontheEuropeancampaignlocally.ItneedstoreachfurtherbeyondtheUKandSpainfirst".Andonepartneralsosensedthatthecampaign’scredibilitywasnotyetestablished:“[weare]waiting…formoreresults.Itneedsmoretime”.

3TomLiacas&JasonMogus,“NetworkedChange:HowProgressivecampaignsarewoninthe21stcentury”,NetChangeConsulting,2016

Page 16: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

16

3 Implementation and management

3.1 SUPPORTBSHFPROVIDES

PartnersareverypositiveabouttheoverallsupportthatBSHFprovides.PartnerscommendedBSHFforbeing“veryresponsive”andparticularlyforthefacilitativenatureofthesupportbeingprovided:“BSHFhavebeenperfect..theyhavegivenalotoflatitudetolocaldecisions,andsupportisthereifneeded”.Onepartnernotedthat“logisticalsupport…isfaultless”.Surveyresultscorroboratethisinterviewfeedback.Acrossarangeofareas,themajorityinmostcasesstronglyagreedthatthesupportBSHFhadprovidedhasbeeneffective:

Figure3:Partners’survey:FeedbackonBSHFsupport

Andpartnersarepositivetooaboutthespecificsupportpackagesonoffer.

0

0

1

0

0

0

0

1

0

1

0

0

1

0

2

1

1

0

0

0

0

0

4

1

3

3

1

2

4

3

4

5

5

6

6

0% 100%

Establishingeffec7vewaysoftrackingandassessingprogressbeingmade

SeCngoutclearexpecta7onsofusasapartnerorganisa7on

Helping(us)tofosterpartnershipsatlocallevel

Coordina7ngthecampaignataEuropeanlevel

Suppor7ngmyorganisa7ontoplanandtakeac7on

Communica7ngaboutthecampaign

Sharinglearningandexperiencesbetweenci7es

BSHFhasbeeneffec.vein...

Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree

Page 17: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

17

Surveyresponsesshowthatpartnersvaluethedifferentelementsofsupportavailable.Resultssuggestthatpartnersparticularlyvaluetheannualgathering,andthebespokesupport:

Figure4:Partners’survey:Feedbackonspecificresourcesupport

Partners’feedbackonthewebinarswasalsopositive:“Thecampaignislearningbydoing,solivefeedbackonprogressofothersattemptingthesamethingisveryinterestinganduseful”.Acoupleofpartnerssuggestedfuturewebinarscouldbemoreinteractive,withmorespacetoshareexperiences.Partnerscommendedthetoolkittoo,withonecallingit“fantastic”,althoughonerespondentcommentedthatitwasdifficulttonavigate.Asonepartnerputit,“Ifyouhavethetoolkitandwebinars,youhavethebasisforthecampaigninyourowncity”.

11

2

3

2

1

3

2

5

5

0

7

onlinetoolkitwebinarstailoredsupportannualgathering

Howhelpfulhavethefollowingresourcesbeen...

Nothelpful Par<allyhelpful

Generallyhelpful Veryhelpful

Page 18: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

18

SomepartnersmentionedthepossibilityofBSHFbeingmoreactivelyinvolvedincampaignpromotionandcommunication(seesection5.2).Volunteerssurveyedalsofeltwellsupported,showinggoodagreementstostatements‘IwasgiventhesupportIneeded’and‘It’sbeenclearwhatwasexpectedofme’[seeFigure2).

3.2 SHARINGLEARNINGANDTRACKINGPROGRESS

Partnersarepositiveabouthowlearningissharedbutsaythereisroomformore.Thereisanaturaltendencyforcitiestoexchangewithcitiesintheirowncountry,buttheremaybeincreasingopportunitytoextract-andmorewidelyshare-generalisablelessonsfromcities'experiences.Accordingtoonepartner,“Weareconstantlylearningfromothers.BSHFisgoodatsharingthelearning–throughtoolkits,regularupdates,bringingpeopletogether”.Andpartnersvaluethissharingofintelligence.Asonesurveyrespondentputit,itis“Incrediblyusefultogetmultipleperspectivesonsimilarissues,learningmoreaboutdifferentcontextsandpotentialsolutionsfromotherareas”.Buttherewasalsoastrandoffeedbackalongthelinesthatthereisscopeformoresharingofinformationandreflections,throughBSHF’scoordinationrolebutalsobilaterallybetweencities.Whilstrecognisingthatcontextsaredifferent,especiallybetweencountries,somecitypartnerspointedtoanumberoflikelyissuesincommonwherethevalueinsharingisnotbeingfullyexploited.Somepartnersidentifiedthatmoreorganic,city-to-citysharingisalreadyhappening,andthatinteractionbetweencities“doesnotdependonmediationfromBSHF.Weknowpeoplewell”.Therearesomesignsofnewercitieslearningfromtheoriginaltranche.Butothersfeltthiswasstillpatchyandpartial:“Peoplestickwiththepeopletheyknow”;“Thereisnotenoughcommunicationbetweencities…[we]needmoreregularupdatesoraregularforumforexchange”.Onepartnermadetheimportantpointthat,asnumbersofparticipatingcitiesgrow,thenlearningopportunitiesmayneedtobemoredisaggregated–forexamplebyseparating‘old’and‘new’citiesinwebinarsandinotherlearningmoments.SeeRecommendation4.Approachestotrackingandreportingshouldbefurtherdevelopedasthecampaigngrows.Somerespondentsidentifiedaneedforaclearerreal-timesenseofcampaignoutcomesandachievements.Oneintervieweeforexampleacknowledgedthat“Tangibleresultsarenotcollatedproperly…Thereisalotofinformationgoingaroundthatisnotbeingcollated”.

Page 19: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

19

Surveyfindingsalsopointtopartnersseeing‘trackingprogress’asbeingacomparativelyweakareaofimplementationinthecampaigntodate(seeFigure1).Thisareadidn’tfeaturestronglyinpartnerfeedbackbutneverthelesswethinkthatwhilstsomeinformationisflowing,trackingsystemswillneedtobestrengthened,especiallyasthecampaigngrows,sothatinformationismorecomprehensivelycollectedandshared.Astronger,moreembeddedapproachtomonitoringprogresswould• GiveBSHFandcitypartnersaclearersenseofwhetherthecampaignisontrack,and

allowforinformedreview,andsupportadaptationwhereneeded.• Helpparticipantsshowthedirectionoftravelandhighlightachievements,importantto

buildingsupportforthecampaign-“Ifcommunitiesareachievingsuccess,andthevalueofHousingFirstisdemonstrated,itwillsnowball”.

• Helpbuildaninternalsenseofmomentum.• Provideclearerevidenceonthenumbersofpeoplebenefittingfromthecampaign(see

section4.4)• Allowforthecollectionandcollationofindividualstories.The100kHomesCampaigndevelopedasetofSMARTobjectivesandatarget-focusedapproach.Butthisdoesn’tsoundlikethesortofapproachBSHFshouldadopt,giventhatit’shardtoseehowlinearmodelsofchangeareappropriatetothiscampaigncontext,andinthelightoftheneedforanytrackingsystemdevelopednottobetooformalised,ortoactasaconstraintonlocalflexibility.Henceonepartnernotedthat“ThewholethingistoocomplexforBSHFtosetoutaframeworkforwherepeopleshouldbe”.Butsomelight-touchsystemsthatallowprogresstobecapturedandconsideredarelikelytobebeneficial.SeeRecommendation5.

4 Campaign outcomes Thecampaignisbeginningtodemonstrateasetofoutcomesthatshowprogresstowardsthegoalofsecuringsustainablehousingforstreethomelesspeople.

4.1 IMPROVEDEVIDENCEBASE

Forsomecities,conductingthestreetsurveyshasgeneratedvaluablenewdataandevidence.The2016evaluationidentifiedthatresultsinValencia“werehighlysignificant…forthefirsttimeitprovideddetailedinformationaboutthemake-upofthatpopulationandpeople’sindividualneeds”,andthatthesurveyrevealednewinformationaboutpeoplelivingonthestreetsinBarcelonatoo.

Page 20: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

20

Thissenseoftheusefulnessofthedatacamethroughinthesurveyresults,withhighagreementthatthecampaignhasbeensuccessfulinproducingnewevidence(Figure8),andthatithasresultedinhavingbetterdata(Figure9).Partnershighlightedthatthesurveyshaduncoveredcertainparticularlyrelevantpiecesofinformation,suchasthenumberofhomelesspeoplewithGPs,ornumberswhohadbeenarrested,orwhohadattendedAccident&Emergencyservices.Insomecities,thesefindingsrevealednewinformationandhelpedmakethecaseforaction:“Datahasbeenuseful,particularlysomeoftheimpactmeasures,thethingsthatmakepeopletakenotice–andsomeofthehumanstories–theseareimpactful”.Butpartnersdidnotuniversallyregardthedatafromthesurveysassignificant.Somebelievedthatthatdatadidnotaddtoinformationthatalreadyexisted,andthattheaddedvalueofthesurveyswaslimited:“Itconfirmedwhatweknew.Wehadgoodlocaldata,thenumberswerenosurprise.Itgaveusevidence,casestoriesofthesituationofthestreethomeless”.GlasgowhasnotyetconductedaConnectionsWeek,partlybecauserobustdataalreadyexists.Alsoonerespondentmadethepointthatdatasnapshotsarenotasusefulaslivedatathatallowsfortrackingofprogress.Aspartofthedevelopingcampaignsupportprogramme,CroydonpartnershavebeenselectedtoworkwithCommunitySolutions–thecoordinatorsofthe100KHomesCampaignintheUS–tolookatwaysthatthiscouldbedone.

4.2 ENHANCEDENGAGEMENTANDINTEREST

Inmanycities,therearepositivesignsofgrowthofinterestin,andsupportto,thecampaignanditsprinciplesfromlocalcivilsocietyorganisationsandassociations.The2016evaluationnotedthat,inWestminster,“[TheConnectionsWeek]wasthefirsttimeforyearsthatthemanyorganisationsdeliveringhomelessnessservicesinWestminsterhadworkedtogetheronasingleproject”.Andtherearesomeadditionalsigns,indifferentcities,ofadevelopingengagementandwillingnesstoexploresolutionscollaboratively.Inonecity,forexample,thecampaignSteeringGroupnowincludesarepresentativeoffaith-basedgroups,asignificantadditioninthatinthepastfaith-basedgroupshavetendedtobemarginaltopublicsector-ledinitiatives.Therearesignsofprogresselsewheretoo.Acitypartnernotedpreviousresistancetoengagefromgroupsworkingwithroughsleepersbutthatthemajorityofgroupsnow“arenowwillingtositroundatableandcoordinatearesponse”.Andanothercitypartnerfeltthat,“themovementisgrowing…somearerespondingpositively,othersare[still]notsosure”.

Page 21: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

21

PartnersfeltthatholdingtheConnectionsWeekhasbeenimportantinbuildingconsensus;it“madeusvisible,ledtomoreassociationsjoiningthecampaign–itmadeusmorecredible”.And,moregenerally,“thecampaignhas…improvedthequalityofthediscussion”.Butinsomeplacescontinuingchallengesremain,withtalkinonecityof“asenseofterritoriality”andinanotherthat“otherNGOsrejectHousingFirstandsticktothesameapproach”.Partnersmentionedthatthereissomeevidenceoflocalmediacoverageandsocialmediadissemination.The2016evaluationnotedthattherehadbeen“solidandpositivecoverage”ofthecampaigninmediaandsocialmedia.Thereportedrangeofsocialmediacoverageforthecampaigninsurveyresults(across‘very’,‘mostly’and‘partly’successful)probablyreflectsvariationinpartners’existingsocialmediapresence.Surveyresponsesshowtoothatasmallnumberofpartnersidentifythattherehasbeen‘verysuccessful’localmediacoverage,withhalfsuggestingthatcoveragehasbeen‘mostlysuccessful’).Reportedresultsfornationalmediacoverageare,notsurprisingly,lower(Figure8).WeunderstandthatincitieslikeCroydonandBrusselstherehasbeensomepositivelocalmediapick-up,inthelattercaseincludingbyjournalistvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign.Oneissuethatcouldprovechallenginginrelationtomediacoverage,andcommunicationsandframingmoregenerally,isthat,asoneintervieweeexplained,“alotofthecitieshavegothighlevelsofpeoplewhoaremigrantsorrefugees…that’snotthestorypeoplewanttohearordealwith…[but]ifyouaretalkingaboutthedata,aboutcollectingstoriesanddata,youcan’tthenignoreitwhenit’snottellingyouwhatyouwanttohear”.SeeRecommendation6.CommunityengagementhasgenerallybeenstrongduringConnectionsWeeks.Asnotedabove,onecornerstoneelementofthecampaignisthat“weareenablingpeopletohaveanopportunitytodosomethingaboutit.Thecampaignisallaboutthewholecommunity”.TheConnectionsWeekshavegenerallybeensuccessfulinattractingsupportfromlargenumbersofvolunteers,withagoodmixofpreviouslycommittedvolunteersandthosewithnohistoryofpastinvolvement.Volunteersurveyresponsesconfirmthatahighproportionofvolunteershadnotpreviousinvolvementinsupporthomelessnessefforts(nearly50%inWestminsterandover50%inBarcelona):

Page 22: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

22

Figure5:Volunteers’previousinvolvementinhomelessnessissues

Barcelonan=70,Westminstern=32Partnersnotedthatinsomecities,suchasBrusselsandCroydon,itwasstrikinghowvolunteerscamefromdiversebackgrounds(althoughoneWestminstervolunteerfelt“itwasgearedtowardsyoungerpeople…whowerenotparticularly'thecommunity'”).Thissupporthasbroughtenergytothecampaign:“TherewasabigchangewhenwedidtheConnectionsWeek…Forustoseethelevelsofsupport,peoplewantingtohelp,itwasaverygoodexperience.Otherassociationswerescepticalaboutusingvolunteers,itwasagooddemonstrationthatitwaspositive.Sincethen…moreassociationsarerealisingthatcitizensmustbepartofamovement”.Inmostcases,effortsatinvolvingthecommunityinamoreongoingwayareintheirearlystages.Thisisanareathatmanycitiesarecommittedtodeveloping.Croydonhasledthewayindevelopinganapproachthatsupportsongoingcommunityinvolvement,throughestablishingfive‘TaskandFinish’groups.Thegroupsaremakingprogress,slowly,andvolunteerinvolvementisopeningdoorsforthecampaign:“wearelinkedinwithmorecompanies,largeorganisationswewouldn’totherwisehavebeen”.Otherpartnersaregenerallypositiveaboutinvolvingcommunitymembersinfindingsolutionstoproblemsofhomelessness.Oneintervieweestressedthat,“Professionalsdon’thavetheanswer,that’swhythecommunityengagementaspectissoimportant,awaytodiversifythegroupofpeopleworkingontheproblem”.Anotherpointedoutthat,“[involving

21% 21%

57%

28% 28%

44%

Iwasac.velyinvolved Ihadsomepastinvolvement

Ihadnopastinvolvement

“Wereyouinvolvedinanyvolunteerworktotrytohelpendhomelessness,orhelppeopleaffectedbyhomelessness,inyourcitypriorto

thiscampaign?”

Barcelona

Westminster

Page 23: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

23

membersofthecommunity]givesabroaderrangeofopinions…professionalscomeupwiththesameanswers…itmakesyourealisehownarrowyourfocusis”.Butreflectingonhowcommunitymembershadbeeninvolvedinthecampaigntodate,acoupleofsurveyrespondentsidentifiedthatprogressinthisareahadbeenlessthantheyhadhoped.Onenotedthat“abitmoretimeisneededtoworkouthowcommunityinvolvementwillworkinpractice”.Asnotedabove(section2.1),volunteersarekeentobemoreinvolvedinthecampaign.Somecitypartnersaredevelopingconcreteideasandplanstoexpandthiselementofthework.Insomecities,volunteersareprovidingpastoralsupport,torehousedformerhomelesspeopleforexample,orthereareplanstosetupandexpandthiskindofsupport.Volunteerinvolvementislikelytoinvolvecommunitymembersasadvocatestoo-“some[volunteers]havegoodcontactswithdecisionmakers…weareworkingonit,thatwillbeabiggerpartinthefuture”.Andtherearesomeplanstoinvolvevolunteersinfindingsolutions;inonecase,forexample,ateamofvolunteersisbeingtaskedwithsourcinghousing.

4.3 TOWARDSCHANGESINPOLICYANDPRACTICE

Therearesomesignsthatmunicipalauthoritiesareengagingwiththecampaign.Somelocalauthoritiesaresupportingthecampaignasactual,ordefacto,partners,aswithTorbayandCroydon.Inothercases,therearesomesignsofengagement:“Itisdifficulttoworkwithpolicy-makers,wearetryingtochangetheirwholeapproach.Butthedoorisopen,theylisten”.Andthereareexamplesemergingofsolutionsbeingdevelopedorconsidered,oratleastidentified.InCroydon,forexample,contractspecificationsaroundlengthofstayintransitionalaccommodationarebeingreviewed,havingbeenraisedthroughthecampaign.Meanwhile,Torbayhasestablishedamulti-stakeholderSystemsOptimisationGrouptoshareinformationanddiscusssupportprovision.This,itwassaid,hascoincidedwiththecampaign,notcausedbyit,butthecampaignisfeedinginusefulexamplesandevidencetothegroup.Therearesomeexamplesofapparentinfluenceonmunicipalauthorities’policyandpracticeemerging,but-notsurprisinglygiventhechallengesinvolved-progresstendstobeslowevenwherecommitmentsareinplace.EvidencefromValencia,forexample,showsprogressbeingmade,butalsohowslowlythingscanmove:• The2016evaluationnotedthatthe“Mayor,regionalgovernmentandmunicipality…are

supportingaHousingFirstpilotinthecityasaresultofthe[ConnectionsWeek]”;• Towardstheendof2016,thishadbeenformallyannounced,asnotedinthecampaign

Decemberupdate:“FollowingtheirRegistryWeek,ameetingbetweenRAISFundación,

Page 24: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

24

Valencia’sMayorandtheregionalgovernmentledtotheannouncementofaHousingFirstpilotbeinglaunchedinthecity”;

• Finally,inAugust2017,acityupdateconfirmsanagreementtolaunchthispilotisinplace:“asignedagreementwiththecitycouncilforaHousingFirstpilottolaunchintheautumn.Thecommitmentisforfiveunitsratherthantheinitial10plannedyetitisagoodfirststep”.

Asimilardynamic–withprospectsofchange,butslowprogress–isevidentinWestminster,wherethe2016evaluationreportsa“meetingofagenciesonpost-RegistryWeekcommitments,inputintocouncilroughsleepingstrategy”.Amorerecentupdateonthisisthat“[thelocalauthority]saidtheywerere-evaluatingtheWestminsterroughsleepingstrategy.Thenitwentquiet.Theyarestillengaged…”Inothercitiestoo,localauthoritiesaremakingsomepositivecommitments.HousingFirstisapolicypriorityfortheGlasgowgovernment,forexample.AndinSpain,HousingFirstisincludedinnationalstrategy,withtheonusnowoncityandregionalauthoritiestodevelopplansaccordingly.Buttherearealsoexamplesoflocalmunicipalitiesshowingcontinuingresistance,oratleastreluctancetoengagemeaningfully.Onecitypartner,forexample,reportedthat“Thelocalauthorityisnotagainsttheinitiative,thereissomeinterest,buttheyarenotreallycommitted,theyhaveanothervision…Wearebuildingmomentum…Wehaven’tseenachangeintheirvision.Thetaskofthecampaignistochangeit.Butit’snoteasy”.Inanothercity,weheardthatthelocalcouncilbaulkedatleasinglandforhousingatlowcostbecauseofarunofbadpublicityrelatingtohomelesspeople,drugsandpettycrime.Onecitypartnersuggestedthattheslownessofprogressraisedaquestionofhowseriousthecommitmentoftherelevantauthoritiesreallyis,alsostressingtheimportanceofmaintainingenergywithinthecampaignwhereprogressisstalled.

4.4 IMPACTONPEOPLEWHOARESTREETHOMELESS

Byimpactwemeanthe“significantorlastingchangesinpeople’slives,broughtaboutbyagivenactionorseriesofaction”.4Therearesomeearly(butnotalwaystotallyclear)signsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplehavebeenbeinghousedasaresultofthecampaign(orthatthecampaignhasinsomewaycontributedtothis).InTorbay,thecampaignhascontributedtoten(orbysomeaccountseight)peoplebeinghoused.Thiswasconfirmedinarecentcampaignbulletin,whichnotedthatTorbayhad“madegreatprogressintheircampaignbyfindinghomesforeightoftheindividualswhohadbeensleepingonthestreets…[as]adirectresultofthelocalcampaign'sactions”.

4ChrisRoche,‘ImpactAssessmentforDevelopmentAgencies:LearningtoValueChange’Oxfam,1999

Page 25: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

25

Numberssuggestedbyrespondentsinvariouscitieshavenotalwaysconsistent;wehearddifferentfiguresfromdifferentpeopleinthesamecity.Areasonableestimatewouldbethatmaybe20peopleintotalhavebeenhousedthroughthecampaigntodate,halfofthemfromTorbay.Additionally,itappearsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplewhoweresurveyedduringConnectionsWeeksweresubsequentlyaccommodated,butnotdirectlythroughthecampaignitself(inCroydon,BrusselsandTorbay).LookingaheadthereisapositiveforecastfromGlasgow,whichisabouttoimplementnewHousingFirstdemonstrationprojects,withfirstresultsexpectedbytheendoftheyear.SeeRecommendation7.Partnersmentionthatthereareotherbenefitstostreethomelesspeople–forexamplethroughthehumanisingexperienceofthesurveyengagement–butwehavelimitedinformationaboutthis.The2016evaluationnotedthehumanisingvalueof“Speakingwithsomeonewhohadtimetotalk,ateachperson'spaceandwasn'tdrivenbycommissionedoutreachtargets”.SomepartnersechoedthissensethatthequalityofengagementduringtheConnectionsWeeksitselfhassomebenefitandonevolunteeralsomadethispoint:“ThefeedbackIreceivedfromsomeoftheroughsleepersIspoketowasthatitfeltdifferenttohavemembersofthecommunityratherthantheprofessionalworkerstalktothem”.Anothernotedthat“Imetsomepeoplewhohadn'thadaconversationwithsomeoneinweeks”.Thesurveyresultspointtosomeotherperceivedbenefits,althoughnotstrongly,inthattherewasatleastsomedisagreementexpressedinresponsetoeachquestion:

Figure6:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonbenefitstolocalhomelesspeople

1

2

2

1

2

0

1

3

3

5

3

2

1

0

1

1

0% 100%

Enhancedconnec0onswiththelocalcommunity

Be:erinforma0onaboutservicesandsupportavailable

Astrongervoiceindecisionsabouttheirfuture

Be:erprospectsforgoodhousingoutcomes

Forpeoplewhoarehomelessandsleepingonthestreetslocally,thecampaignhasledto...

Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree

Page 26: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

26

Verypractically,inCroydon,anumberofthosesurveyedweren’tpreviouslyknowntotheoutreachteam,meaningthat“23peoplenotknowntooutreachservicesarenowbeingsupported”.Onevolunteermentionedthevalueinhomelesspeoplebeinginvolvedinthesearchforsolutions:“Itwouldbeinterestingtobeabletoincreasethecommunicationbetweenthehomelessandthosethatoffertheservicessincetherearemanythingstoimprove,andtheythemselvescanhavepracticalandeffectivesolutions”.Wehavenothaddirectinputfrompeoplewhoarestreethomelessaspartofthisreview.

4.5 COMMENTARYONPROGRESSANDACHIEVEMENTS

Thecampaignisnotyetachievingchangeatscalebutitwouldnotberealistictoexpecttoseethissosoon.Thereareenoughsignsofprogresstobeencouragedabouttheapproachbeingtaken.BSHFandpartnersarerightlyinterestedinhowsuccessfullythecampaignishelpingthosewhoarestreethomelessgetintosecure,sustainablehousing.Butcampaignsaimingtosecuresystemicchangearenotobviouscandidatesforquickwins:“Ifitwasstraightforwarditwouldhavebeensolvedalready”.Itisalsoimportantcontext,asmentionedinthesurvey,thatmanypartnersareundertakingthisworkalongsideexistingworkloads:“ourmajorissuehasbeencapacity…Thecampaigndoesneedlongterminvestmentoftimetobesuccessful”.Inanumberofcities,shortageofhousingstock/landseemstobeakeybarrier.ItseemsthatevenwherecityauthoritiescollaboratecloselywithcampaignpartnersandsupportHousingFirst,theymaybeunabletoapplyitinpractice.Manypartnersflaggedissuesaroundshortageofhousingandeventhedifficultiesofacquiringlandforhousing.Onecouncilislookingatusingexistinghousingstockdifferentlyforexample.Butinotherlocations,theblockageseemstomorecomplexthanbeingjustaboutfreeingupexistinghostelaccommodation.Inonecity,forexample,“TheCouncilaretalkingaboutit,it’sontheagenda.Thechallengeistosecuretheaccommodation”.Inanother,thereappeartobeideas,butalsoproblems,aroundleasingoracquiringland.Itseemstherearesomecommonthemesaroundhousingsupplyandhowthebarrierstothiscanbeovercomeandhowpartnerscanbestbeinvolvedinfindinghousingsolutionsthatcouldbeusefullyexploredacrosscities.SeeRecommendation8.

Page 27: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

27

5 Looking ahead

5.1 GROWINGTHECAMPAIGN

ThereisasetofconsiderationsandoptionsforBSHFaroundwhether,howandhowfast,andwhere,togrowthecampaign.Partnerssupportgrowthinthenumberofparticipatingcitiesinprinciplebutidentifysomeconcernsinpractice,includinginrelationtothecampaign’scapacitytosupportamuchlargernumberofcitieswhilebeingsurethatthosealreadyinvolvedhavereachedalevelofengagementsuchthattheirrelianceonBSHFislimited.The2016evaluationindicatesacampaigntarget“toengageupto50Europeancities…by2020”.Thisspeedofgrowthseemsunlikelygiventhereisalimittohowmanynewcitiescouldreasonablybetakenoneachyear.Butitdoesreflectapresumptionofgrowth,andthatthisismanageable,basedonthelogicthat“themorewegrowitthemoreimpactitwillpotentiallyhave”.Feedbackfrominterviewsandfromsurveyrespondentssuggeststhatpartnerssupporttheideaofgrowthinprincipleandcanseethebenefits,includingintermsofconsolidatingthecampaign,generatingincreasedinterestandvisibility,andbuildingandsharingknowledgeamongstacommunityofcities.Butpartnersarealsoawareoftherisksandchallenges.Wediscussissuesaroundcoordination,governanceandresourcingbelow.Somealsomentionedconcernsaroundpossibledispersalanddilutionofeffortandfocus:“[thecampaign]needsastrongcentralbodytokeepthefocusonimpactandfacilitatethesharing.ThismaybelostifBSHFisspreadtoothinly”.Hencetherewasastrandofopinionamongstpartnersthatanygrowthneedstobemanagedcarefullyandsequencedright.Onepartnersuggestedthat“Youneedtohaveaveryactiveanddynamiccoregroup,withamomentum,beforeyoutoexpandfurther”.Anothernotedthat“Maybeweshouldbecarefulnottohavetoomanycitiesinvolved,becauseitwillbedifficulttobecomeactive,involvedandpersonal,whichisimportantinsuchcampaigns”.Somefeltitwouldbehelpfultodemonstratesuccessmoredefinitivelybeforeexpandingthenumberofcitiesinvolved.Onepartnernotedthat“Ifwe'renotabletoevidenceimpactofthecampaign,theconcernisthatthecampaignisonlyatalkingshop...Weneedtokeepshowingpeoplethatitdoeswork”.Anotherfeltthatitwouldbeeasiertopromoteandexpandthecampaign,onceresultsareclearer:“theproblemisthattherearesomeexamplesbut…theydon’tseemrelevanttoEurope…Ifwecanshow[it’spossibleinEurope]thatwouldbevaluable”.In

Page 28: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

28

relationtothis,variouspartnersfromothercitieshavehighhopesforTorbayasacitythatcanleadthewayinshowingthatthisapproachcanbesuccessful.Onedescribeditas“agoodtestingground”,althoughsuccessheremayraiseaquestionofhowtransferableeffectivepracticeinasmalltownwitharelativelyfavourablecontextistolarger,morecomplicatedcities.Citycampaignsseemtobemosteffectivewhentheybuildonexisting,iflatent,supportforchange.Therearesomestrategicchoicesthatthecampaignmightwanttomakearoundhowmuchtofocusontheareaswherethereismostlikelytobe(relatively)quickprogress.It’sbecomingapparentthatasetofconditionshelpunderpincitylevelprogress:• Support,oratleastconstructiveinterest,frommunicipalauthorities;• Partnerswhoarecommittedtothecampaignprinciplesandwillingandabletoshow

leadershiptoadvancethem;• Partnerswhohaveexistinglocallinksandrelationships,orhavethepotentialtodevelop

them,includingwithdecision-makers.

It’sprobablytruethatincitieswheremostprogresshasbeenmadesofar,alocal‘willingnesstochange’coincidedwiththecampaign,ratherthanbeingcreatedbyit.Thecampaignhasthenhelpedbuildandinstitutionalisethissupport.Therelationalaspecttothisiskey.Asonepartnerputit,“Youhavetoinvesttimeinbuildingtrustwithalltheservice-providers.Ittookalongtimebutoncewehavethetrust,wecoulddeliverabetterapproach…Thecampaignhasbeenavehicle,itgaveusanethostogatherpeoplearound”.Andanotherpartnersimilarlyhighlightedthisideaofthecampaignprovidingafocustomobilisearound:“Thecampaignisgreatincoalescinganeedforsystemicchange…Thecampaignhasunblockedthepathtoclosercooperation”.Thispointstotheexistenceinsome,perhapsmany,citiesofalatentdesireforchangethatthecampaignisabletoexploit.Thissuggeststhatthecampaignistimely.Atleastsomecityauthoritiesareopentochangeandthereisopportunitytopushon,andtakethisnewapproachtoendinghomelessnesstoanotherlevel.Butalsothatitislikelytobe“difficulttosucceedwithoutlocalauthoritysupport”.Andthatraisesthequestionofhowmuchthecampaigniswillingtotakeon‘hardercases’,wherethebarrierstochangearegreaterandthepaceofchangelikelytobeslower.Thislinksinwithdiscussionaboutexpandingthegeographicalreachofthecampaign.Thereislikelyatrade-offbetweenfindingconducivecities,wheresuccessisrelativelylikely,andexpandingtonewpartsofEurope,suchasCentralandEasternEurope.Oneonhand“beingcrediblyEuropeanandachievingnothingforbeingspreadtoothinlyisaworseoption”butontheother“theriskatthemomentthoughisthattheyworkwhereitiseasiest”.Maybetherightresponsetothisistobedeliberateinselectingamixofcities,ensuringtherearesomewhereconditionssuggesttherearereasonableprospectsofquickerwins(aswithTorbayforexample)butalsoinvolvingcitieswherethechallengesaregreater?

Page 29: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

29

Asthecampaigngrows,theremayneedtobesomeadditionalcampaigncommunication(internallyandexternally)inlanguagesotherthanEnglish.CampaigncommunicationiscurrentlyinEnglish,whichmeansthat“languageisaproblemforsomecountriesandsomepeople”.Asitexpands,onesuggestionwasthatthecampaign“couldhavesomelevelofexchangeinEnglish,andsomeotherlevelsusingotherlanguageswhichallowsmorepeopleandmorecountriestobeinvolved”.Decisionsaboutlanguagearealsoaboutpositioning:“ExternallyitwouldbebetterifthereweremorelanguagesthanjustEnglish.Itwouldthenraisemoreattentioninsomeothercountries”.SeeRecommendation9.

5.2 AEUROPEANCAMPAIGN?

Somepartnersseethepotentialtodevelopamorecoordinatedcampaigningapproach.Thecurrent,city-basedmodelisaviableonebutsomefeltthatcomplementingthiswithsomemorecentralisedadvocacyisanalternativeworthconsidering.Severalintervieweesmadesuggestionsaroundhavingmoreofaunifyingcampaigngoaland/orsetofmessages.Asoneputit,“WhatBSHF[provide]iscentralresourcesandtraining,whichisuseful,buthasalimit.Wehavetodecideifwewanttocreateacommunicationcampaignshowingthingsarehappeninginmanycities”.Anotherasked:“Theprojectcancontinuetoprovidehelptoindividualcities,andthenwhat?ArewetryingtohaveaEuropeancampaign?”Maintainingthefocusofthecampaignatcity-levelacrossmultiplecities,withadegreeofcrossfertilisationbetweencities,isaviableoptionforthefuture.Butsomepointedtothedrawbacksofthis,offeringthecritiquethat,withoutanoverarching,unifyinggoal,thecampaignlacksavisionof“howtoreachatippingpointbywhich…themovementofthemostvulnerablepeopleoffthestreetsacrossEurope[gathers]momentum”.SomefelttoothatmoreproactivecommunicationswouldhelpgenerateagreatersenseofbeingpartofaEuropeanmovement.Andforsome,theabsenceofnationalorregionalleveladvocacyalsomissestheopportunitytojointhedotsandsupportlocallevelwork,asthefollowingquotesillustrate:• “Alotoftheproblemsrelatetonationally-decided,centralgovernmentpolicy…[asthe

campaigngrows]herecouldbescopeforsomesemi-coordinatedadvocacyfromacrosscities”.

• “Therearepocketsofsupport[forHousingFirstandthecampaign]amongNGOsandauthoritiesacrossEurope,soweneedtoconnectthemup”.

Page 30: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

30

• “Thereisaninternationalassociationofmayors.Woulditbeusefultoraisequestionofhomelessnessatthislevel?Ifwegoonbothsides,wemightprogressmorequickly”.

SeeRecommendation10.

5.3 FUTURECOORDINATIONAPPROACHANDSTRUCTURES

Therearesomedifferentoptionsforhowthestructuralcoordinationofthecampaigncouldevolve.Alltheoptionshavesomeadvantagesbutnoneofthemprovideanobviousandclearrouteforward.Alongsimilarlinestotheoptionssetoutinthe2016evaluation,weseefourpossiblestructuralmodelsforthecampaign.1/BSHFremainsthecoordinatingbody.Oneoptionsetoutin2016evaluation.Thisisthemoststraightforwardandhasworkedtodate.But,asnoted,itislikelytobedifficultforBSHFtoleadagenuinelypan-Europeancampaignwithoutactivestrategicpartnerships:“ThereisalackofleadershipintermsofEuropeanhomelessnesscampaigning.BSHFisdoingthebestitcan,theygivegoodsupport,buttogofurther,weneedtheinvolvementofstrongEuropeanactors”.MaintainingthisapproachalsocreatesahighlevelofrelianceonBSHF’scontinuinginvolvement.2/BSHFoperatesinconjunctionwithaEuropeanstrategicpartner.Again,thiswasoutlinedasanoptioninthe2016evaluation.Onthefaceofit,FEANTSAistheobviousstrategicpartneratthepan-Europeanlevel,butthatwoulddependonprioritiesbeingaligned.BeyondFEANTSA,bymostaccounts,therearelimitedoptions,withfewifanyothershavingtherightkindofcombinationofgeographicalreachandinterest.3/BSHFpartfundsaleadbody.Thiswasathirdoptionsuggestedinthe2016evaluation,drawingontheCommunitySolutionsmodelappliedinCanada.Presumablyoption2couldevolveintothis,asBSHFprogressivelystepsback.Butithasthesamechallengesaswithoption2:notably,whowouldbetheleadbody?4/BSHFmaintainsoverarching(lighttouch)campaigncoordinationwithaseriesofcountryleadpartnersand/orcoalitionsresponsibleforcoordinationatcountrylevel.Thisoptionwasnotconsideredinthe2016evaluationreportbutacoupleofcontributorstothisreviewsuggestedsomethingalongthoselines.Suchamodelwouldbeconsistentwithcampaignaspirationtobebottom-upanditwould(intheoryatleast)allowfordifferentlevelsofcoordination,andofcommunication–bylinguisticgroup/nationallyforexample.Butitdoesintroduceanotherlayeroforganisationsowouldinvolvemorecomplicatedcampaignmanagementarrangement.Still,itcouldbeapossiblelongertermsolutionworthconsidering.

Page 31: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

31

It’sgoodthatresourcingtosupportthecampaignisinplaceoverthemediumterm–butthismaynotfullyresolvethequestionofresourcing,dependingondecisionsaboutthecampaign'sstrategicpurposeandthefuturerolethatBSHFwillplay.BSHFhascommittedabudgettosupportthiswork,whichwethinkisveryhelpfulinensuringsomeleveloffuturestability.Existingbudgetsessentiallycoverstaffcostsandfundingforsupport–throughwebinars,bespokesupportfromconsultants,andanannualgathering.WhilstthisrepresentsasignificantcommitmentofsupportfromBSHF,therearestillquestionsastowhetherthisisadequateforfutureneed.Thereareplanstogrowthecampaignfairlysubstantially,withoutequivalentgrowthinresourcingorbudgets.Therationaleforthisisessentiallythat(i)growthbringseconomiesofscaleandthat(ii)citypartnerscanthemselvesplayanexpandedrole,sothatsupportbecomesmorebilaterallydriven,forexample.Theseseembroadlyreasonableassumptionsalthoughattheoptimisticendofthespectrum.However,oneconsequenceisthat,withgrowth,it’slikelythattheroleofBSHFbecomeslessaboutleadingthecampaignandmorearoundprovidinganoverallframeworkwithinwhichlocalcampaignscanoperate.Thiswillprobablymakeithardertotroubleshoot(andofferadditionalsupportwhere/ifneeded,forexample)andtherewilllikelybelessofarolethatBSHFcanplayinsharinglearning,andencouragingthis,acrosscities.Therecouldbepinchpoints,tooaroundtheexpandingcostsofmeetingsasnumbersgrowand,possibly,futuretranslationcosts.Itisalsountestedwhetherchampionswithinexisting(ornew)citiescantakemoreofarole.Oursenseisthattheyarewillingbutalreadystretched.AsBSHFisaware,thesequestionsaboutresourcingarelinkedtothoseaboutpartnershipsandstrategy.Partnershipswouldlikelybringadditionalresourcing.Anddifferentstrategiescomewithdifferentresourceimplications.IfthecampaignevolvestowardshavingacomplementaryEuropeanand/ornationaldimensionalongthelinesmentionedaboveinsection5.2,forexample,thenthereisaneedforcentralresourcingthatwouldn’totherwisebethere.Soitdoesn’tmakesensetothinkaboutresourcingoutofcontext.WhilstitisgoodthatafoundationalelementofBSHF’sresourcingsupportisbanked,thisdoesnotmakeitasettledissue.

5.4 DEVELOPINGTHESTRATEGY

Nowisagoodtimetoreviewtheoverallcampaignstrategy.Thereareasetofinter-relatedchoicesabout(a)whatsortof‘campaign’itshouldbe(b)whatthegrowthstrategyshouldbe(c)whatkindofstrategicpartnershipsshouldsupportnationallevelaction(d)whatresourcesareneededandwheretheyshouldcomefrom

Page 32: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

32

(e)thebestsystemsforsharinglearningandencouragingcross-fertilisation,andtherolethatBSHFshouldplayinthis.Thestrategydeployedhasbeenappropriatetodate.Butasweflaginthisreport,therearesomedifferentideas,andviablealternativeoptions,thatitmightbegoodtoexplore.ButthenagainifBSHFdoesn’thavethescopeorinterestinturningthecampaignintosomethingdifferentfromwhatitiscurrently,thenthatitselfcouldstillbeaperfectlyreasonablepositiontoadopt.Inanycase,itwouldbehelpfultobeclearabouttheparametersandscopeforevolution.Thereisaquestionaboutwhoisinvolvedinconsideringfuturestrategy,withsomedifferentoptionsabouthowthatcouldbedone. Whatthefuturestrategymightlooklikeislinkedtoaquestionaroundwhomightbeinvolvedindevelopingthatstrategy.TodateithasbeenBSHF’svisionandstrategydrivingthecampaign’sevolution.BSHF–astheinitiatorandcoordinatorofthecampaign–hassetoutanoverarchingstrategicapproachwithinwhichthereisoperationalflexibility.ItmaybethatBSHFwouldliketoretainalevelofstrategic‘control’ofthecampaigninfuture.ButnowmightbeagoodtimeforBSHFtothinkaboutwhether,andhowmuch,toinvolvecitypartnersinthinkingthroughfuturestrategyoptions.Onepartnercalledforastructureddiscussionaboutstrategyamongstpartners,andothersmootedasimilaridea:“Theyaredoingagoodjob,but…maybeneedtogivespacetootheractors,shareleadership…”Thinkingaboutastrategydevelopmentprocess,theoptionsforthisareessentially:1. BSHFsetsoutthecampaignstrategyandinviteotherstobepartofit.2. BSHFretainsresponsibilityforstrategybutseekspartners’inputs(whichthisreportand

discussionarounditshouldprovide)beforesettingouttheproposedfuturestrategicdirection.

3. BSHFjointlydevelopsstrategywithpartners(orsomesubgroupof‘nominatedrepresentatives’)throughacollaborativeprocess.

Therearestrengthsandweaknessestoeachoftheseapproaches–butitcouldbehelpfultomakecleartheprocessandthelevelofparticipationofcitypartners.SeeRecommendation11.

Page 33: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

33

6 Recommendations Recommendation1ReviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundHousingFirstaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.Recommendation2Developguidancethatencouragespartnerstoupdatevolunteersandotherinterestedpartnersoncampaignprogress.Recommendation3Reviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundcommunityinvolvementaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.Recommendation4Considerpracticalwaystoencouragelearningopportunitiesbetweencities,boththroughBSHFandbilaterally,takingintoaccountdifferentiatedneeds(accordingtogeographyandhistoryofinvolvementforexample).Recommendation5Developanapproachtocampaigntrackingandmonitoringthatsupportsbettergenerationofandaccesstoreal-timeinformation.Somepracticalstepscouldincludedeveloping:• An‘outcomebank’withsomeguidanceonwhatoutcomesareofparticularinterest;• Acampaign‘evidencedatabase’thatallcanaddto;• Supportandguidancearoundreviewinginformationinwaysthatfeedintoplanning;• Supporttoeffortstodevelopcasestudiesthatillustrateprogressbeingmade.Recommendation6Considerdevelopingsomeprotocolsandguidancearoundcommunicatingdifficultmessages,suchasinrelationtomigrantsandrefugees.Recommendation7Establish-aspartofcampaigntracking–asetofcommondefinitions/indicatorsthatclearlyexpressthechangesthecampaignseek(whichwouldincludenumbersofpeoplehousedinHousingFirstaccommodation,butalsomeasurestodowithhowthathousingstatusissustained);andagreehowthatinformationwillberecordedandreported.Recommendation8Considersettingupaprocessorforumtoconsidercommonchallengesandhowtoovercomebarrierslinkedtolimitsonhousingstockandland.Recommendation9Developagrowthstrategythatsetsoutideasonthespeedandsequencingofexpansiontonewcitiesandthebestmixofcitiestoinvolve,andimplicationsarisingfromthis(aroundlanguageforexample).

Page 34: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

34

Recommendation10Considerthepotentialforcomplementingcity-leveladvocacywithsomecoordinatedadvocacythatdrawsonexperiencesacrosscities.Recommendation11Considerwhetherandhowbesttoinvolvepartnersindevelopingstrategicoptions.

Page 35: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

35

Appendix 1: Campaign timeline

Figure 7: Summary campaign timeline

Oct�15

Jan�16

Apr�16

Jul�16

Oct�16

Jan�17

Apr�17

Jul�17

Oct�17

Valencia CW

Barcelona CW CW

Westminster CW CW

Brno

Copenhagen

Lyon

CW CW

CW

CW

CW

CW

CW

PILOT�PHASE

u

u u u

u u

u

KEY

Cardiff

u u u

Croydon

Brussels

Torbay

Glasgow

Alicante

Brighton

Toolkit�producedWebinars

participating�city

engaged�city

CW�=�Connections�Week

Peer�exchange�visit

Budapest

Leicester

BSHF-organised�city�gatheringsOther�city�meetings

Page 36: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

36

Appendix 2: Campaign principles

1. Housing First: Ensuring (or working towards ensuring) homeless people are housed in permanent, safe, appropriate and affordable housing with support to sustain it.

2. Knowing who’s out there: Getting to know every homeless person by name by going onto the streets to find them and assess their needs.

3. Tracking progress: Regularly collecting person-specific data to accurately track progress toward ending homelessness.

4. Many people are concerned about the individuals in their communities who have no roof to sleep under and they want to play a meaningful part in helping to find solutions.

5. Improving local systems: Building coordinated housing and support systems that are simple to navigate, while targeting resources quickly to those who need it the most.

6. Learning from and sharing with others: Working collaboratively to help the campaign make the biggest difference to those who are homeless.

Page 37: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that

37

Appendix 3: Survey responses: campaign outcomes

Figure8:Partners’survey:Perspectivesoncampaignoutcomes

Figure9:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonorganisationalbenefits

0

0

0

0

1

0

1

1

2

2

3

4

3

3

3

5

2

4

3

2

2

4

3

1

4

2

2

2

2

0

0

0

0% 100%

ProducingusefulnewevidenceforNGOs,chari>esandagenciesworkingonhomelessnessissues

Genera>nglocalmediacoverage

BuildingabeCerunderstandingoftheproblemstobetackledinordertoendstreethomelessness

Crea>nginterestonsocialmedia

Influencingdecisionmakersinlocal,regionalormunicipalauthori>es

Involvingmembersofthecommunityinhomelessnesscampaigning

Genera>ngna>onalmediacoverage

Genera>ngcommunitysolu>onstocommunityproblems

Howsuccessfulwouldyousaythelocalcampaignhasbeensofarin...

Notatall Partly Mostly Very

1

0

0

0

0

4

5

4

0

0

2

3

3

6

3

1

0

1

2

4

0% 100%

Be,erlinkstorelevantlocalorganisa9ons

Astrongerinfluenceonlocaldecisionmakers

Improvedworkingrela9onshipswithrelevantlocalorganisa9ons

Aclearerideaabouteffec9vewaystohelppeopleoffthestreets

Be,erdata

Asaresultofpar-cipa-nginthecampaign,myorganisa-onorlocalcoali-onhas...

Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree


Top Related