dolphins, gibbons, and giant salamanders · 2018-04-13 · dolphins, gibbons, and giant...

44
DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological Society of London

Upload: others

Post on 31-May-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

DOLPHINS, GIBBONS,

AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity?

Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological Society of London

Page 2: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 3: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 4: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 5: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 6: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 7: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 8: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 9: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 10: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

SO LONG, AND THANKS FOR ALL THE FISHING: THE SORRY STORY OF THE YANGTZE RIVER DOLPHIN

Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological Society of London

Page 11: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

CHINA

•26−28 individuals

•1 population

•1 reserve:

Bawangling National

Nature Reserve

Hainan gibbon (Nomascus hainanus)

World’s rarest ape,

primate, and probably

mammal species

Page 12: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 13: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 14: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

In the

past...

“猪不吃”

Chinese giant salamander

Page 15: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 16: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 17: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 18: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 19: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 20: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 21: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 22: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 23: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

Page 24: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 25: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

• Several international workshops held in China to develop the baiji recovery programme (1986, 1993, 2001, 2004)

• All workshops strongly recommended semi-natural reserve

Page 26: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

• Several international workshops held in China to develop the baiji recovery programme (1986, 1993, 2001, 2004)

• All workshops strongly recommended semi-natural reserve

• Chinese researchers attempted six baiji capture attempts between 1993 and 1995 – one baiji was translocated, but died

Page 27: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Yangtze River dolphin

• Several international workshops held in China to develop the baiji recovery programme (1986, 1993, 2001, 2004)

• All workshops strongly recommended semi-natural reserve

• Chinese researchers attempted six baiji capture attempts between 1993 and 1995 – one baiji was translocated, but died

• Widely popularised in the international literature (e.g., ‘Last Chance to See’ by Douglas Adams)

• But: NO Western funding or practical support was ever provided to actively implement the repeated recommendations for the recovery programme

Page 28: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 29: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological
Page 30: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• How can we gather robust information to inform conservation?

Hainan gibbon

Page 31: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• How can we gather robust information to inform conservation?

Across time and space

Hainan gibbon

Page 32: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• How can we gather robust information to inform conservation?

Across time and space

Across evolution (comparative approach)

Hainan gibbon

Page 33: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• How can we gather robust information to inform conservation?

Across time and space

Across evolution (comparative approach)

Intensive fieldwork

Hainan gibbon

Page 34: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• Surviving population still breeding – new social group formation

• Inbreeding – related at level of half-sibling or cousin

• Inbreeding risks are stochastic, not deterministic

Recovery from extremely low population size is possible

Hainan gibbon

Page 35: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• Different goals: preserve population, or population growth?

• Reactive management, or proactive/preventative planning?

• no rapid pre-decided response plan in case of emergency

• Complacency vs urgency – interest in outside expertise?

• Limited available funding, and limited wider awareness

Hainan gibbon

Page 36: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 37: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 38: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 39: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 40: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

Page 41: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Chinese giant salamander

• Chinese giant salamander ex situ management:

• Conservation breeding?

• Farming?

Page 42: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

Conflict over interventionist versus non-interventionist conservation?

Understanding of factors impacting very small populations?

Paradoxically limited sense of urgency?

Training in wider conservation theory?

Different cultural contexts and values?

...“doomed to extinction”?

What causes conflicts in

developing collaborative

conservation in China?

Understanding the problems

?

Page 43: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological

• It is still possible to ensure a future for China’s biodiversity

• We have data to make informed management decisions

• It may not be biologically too late to recover species

• Improve collaborations – international AND within China

Develop a common language for conservation

Conclusions

Page 44: DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS · 2018-04-13 · DOLPHINS, GIBBONS, AND GIANT SALAMANDERS: Is it possible to save China’s threatened biodiversity? Samuel T. Turvey, Zoological