eating onion tacos in ichisi: a cross-cultural food encounter in protohistoric georgia

10
• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon 79 EATING ONION TACOS IN ICHISI: A CROSS .. CULTURAL FOOD ENCOUNTER IN PROTOHISTORIC GEORGIA by Ramie A Gougeon, Division of Anthropology and Archaeology, University of West Florida INTRODUCTION Examinations of the intersection of an- thropological archaeology and foodways have grown in recent years into a nearly sub-disciplinary status. Like many foci in anthropological research, we might ascribe the rise of the attention given to foodways to trends observed in broader Western popular culture over the past few decades. For example, "foodie" has been part of the American lexicon since at least the early 1980s (Barr and Levy 1985), and the Food Network has been very popu- lar since its launch in 1993. From the new "Food Studies" series proffered by AltaMira Press to the archaeological explorations of food and identity undertaken by participants in the 2006 Southern Illinois University Center for Archaeological Inves- tigations Visiting Scholar symposium (Twiss 2007), food has taken its place amongst the likes of ceram- ics, lithics, architecture, and settlement patterns as a useful entry point to understanding human be- havior. There are obvious reasons why food and foodways make such powerful subjects in archaeo- logical studies. As it is a biological necessity, food has been explored from the perspectives of nutri- tion and health (e.g. Wing and Brown 1979). The ability to control certain foods or food surpluses has been viewed as a tool of the sociopolitical elite and taken as a proxy for higher sociopolitical status (e.g. Ambrose et al. 2003; Rees 1997, 2002; Zeder and Arter 1996). Socio-cultural and political prac- tices related to food, including degrees of incorpo- ration of domesticated food sources, have recently been examined as indicators of social inequality (Cuellar 2013) and as responses to environmental changes (Scarry and Reitz 2005). Archaeologists have explored the connections between food pref- erences and social identities (Bush 2004; Dietler 2007; Scott 1996, 2007; Twiss 2007), as well as more mechanical/ material studies of food prepara- tion techniques (Myers 2006) and vessel attributes (Hally 1984, 1986). In recent years, considerable attention has been paid to the concept of feasting as evident in the archaeological record (Dietler and Hayden 2010). Because of our species' intimate relation- ship with food, research into food and foodways can provide a myriad of insights into cultural phe- nomenon, not to mention readily accessible and tangible examples to bring to our assorted profes- sional and avocational audiences. As a case in point, I will examine a seemingly simple interac- tion that occurred in present-day Georgia between a group of native Southeasterners and sixteenth century Spanish soldiers. Through this very short account and some archaeological evidence, I will explore traditional foodways of the New and Old World at a critical juncture in history, and discuss how even the most humble of meals can be inter- preted through a variety of analytical lenses. EATING ONIONS IN lcHISI In March 1540, Hernando deSoto and his army were in the province of lchisi, located along

Upload: uwf

Post on 08-Apr-2023

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

IIIII

• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon • 79

EATING ONION TACOS IN ICHISI: A CROSS .. CULTURAL FOOD ENCOUNTER IN PROTOHISTORIC GEORGIA

by Ramie A Gougeon, Division of Anthropology and Archaeology, University of West Florida

INTRODUCTION

Examinations of the intersection of an­thropological archaeology and foodways have grown in recent years into a nearly sub-disciplinary status. Like many foci in anthropological research, we might ascribe the rise of the attention given to foodways to trends observed in broader Western popular culture over the past few decades. For example, "foodie" has been part of the American lexicon since at least the early 1980s (Barr and Levy 1985), and the Food Network has been very popu­lar since its launch in 1993. From the new "Food Studies" series proffered by AltaMira Press to the archaeological explorations of food and identity undertaken by participants in the 2006 Southern Illinois University Center for Archaeological Inves­tigations Visiting Scholar symposium (Twiss 2007), food has taken its place amongst the likes of ceram­ics, lithics, architecture, and settlement patterns as a useful entry point to understanding human be­havior.

There are obvious reasons why food and foodways make such powerful subjects in archaeo­logical studies. As it is a biological necessity, food has been explored from the perspectives of nutri­tion and health (e.g. Wing and Brown 1979). The ability to control certain foods or food surpluses has been viewed as a tool of the sociopolitical elite and taken as a proxy for higher sociopolitical status (e.g. Ambrose et al. 2003; Rees 1997, 2002; Zeder and Arter 1996). Socio-cultural and political prac­tices related to food, including degrees of incorpo-

ration of domesticated food sources, have recently been examined as indicators of social inequality (Cuellar 2013) and as responses to environmental changes (Scarry and Reitz 2005). Archaeologists have explored the connections between food pref­erences and social identities (Bush 2004; Dietler 2007; Scott 1996, 2007; Twiss 2007), as well as more mechanical/ material studies of food prepara­tion techniques (Myers 2006) and vessel attributes (Hally 1984, 1986). In recent years, considerable attention has been paid to the concept of feasting as evident in the archaeological record (Dietler and Hayden 2010).

Because of our species' intimate relation­ship with food, research into food and foodways can provide a myriad of insights into cultural phe­nomenon, not to mention readily accessible and tangible examples to bring to our assorted profes­sional and avocational audiences. As a case in point, I will examine a seemingly simple interac­tion that occurred in present-day Georgia between a group of native Southeasterners and sixteenth century Spanish soldiers. Through this very short account and some archaeological evidence, I will explore traditional foodways of the New and Old World at a critical juncture in history, and discuss how even the most humble of meals can be inter­preted through a variety of analytical lenses.

EATING ONIONS IN lcHISI

In March 1540, Hernando deSoto and his army were in the province of lchisi, located along

80 • Early Georgia • volume 42, number 1 •

the Ocmulgee River below the present-day city of Macon (Hudson 1994b, 1997). Despite unknow­ingly having thousands of miles yet to traverse, the expedition was already facing considerable dissen­tion in the ranks. Since landing in La Florida in May of the previous year, Soto and his men had met with considerable resistance and hardships (Hudson 1997). Promised and hoped-for riches were not forthcoming, and food was scarce (Hud­son 1990). In fact, the Spanish rank-and-file only found themselves in lchisi because of a ruse played upon them by their leader. Soto had left with a smaller contingency of cavalry from a village locat­ed somewhere in the province of T oa several days before, completing a rather arduous nighttime ride and covering some 34 miles (easily double their usual distance traveled per day) (Hudson 1997:157-158; Hudson 1990:83). As interpreted by Hudson (1997), Soto knew that his tired but suspicious sol­diers would think he was after wealth they were not privy to and would follow him eventually. Re­gardless of whether we will ever know So to's exact chain of logic, this is indeed what came to pass, and the soldiers were reunited with their leader in the chiefdom of lchisi.

The Soto expedition was large, numbering some 600 men of varying social status (noblemen to slaves), and a veritable wagon train of dogs, 240 horses, and a large herd of pigs (Hudson 1997). In spite of their numbers, they appeared to carry only minimal provisions and clearly intended to collect foodstuffs from the various peoples they would encounter (Hudson 1990). There were a number of instances documented in the accounts of the expedition of food crises determining where the Spaniards went (Hudson 1994a). Depending upon the subsistence strategies of the groups to share stores of food, or even the time of year in which they arrived in an area, the supplies they so desperately needed were often found wanting. In the previous chiefdom they found only abandoned villages and little to no food, so by the time they had traversed a section of the Ocmulgee River to the principal town of lchisi they were once again in dire straits. Upon entering the town of lchisi they were offered corn cakes and onions, the latter of

1111

which the Spanish accounts wax rather poetic. As Rangel (through Oviedo) reported it:

Este dia salieron indios e indias a los rest,:ebir: venian ellas vestidas de blanco, e parest,:ian bian, e daban a los chripstianos tortillas de mahiz e unos manojos de t,:ebolletas ni mas ni menos que las de Castilla, tan gordas como la cabet,:a del declo pulgar e mas. E fue aqueste un manjar que les ayud6 mu­cho de ahy adelante; y comianlas con tortillas asa­das y cot,:idas y crudas, y erales gran socorro, porque son muy buenas.

This day [March 29, 1540) Indian men and women came forth to receive them. The women came clothed in white, and they made a fine ap­pearance, and they gave to the Christians tortillas of corn and some bundles of spring onions exactly like those of Castile, as fat as the tip of the thumb and more. And that was a food which helped them much from then on; and they ate them with tortil­las, roasted and stewed and raw, and it was a great aid to them because they are very good [Rangel 1993:271).

I know of no direct evidence of onions found in archaeological contexts, though this is very likely a result of how they would have been consumed (i.e., boiled or eaten raw) and the un­likelihood of opportunities for preservation (see Hally 1981). It is possible that these onions were, in fact, wild garlic (Allium canadense) (Peterson 1977). Wild garlic has an onion-like flavor and occurs naturally across the Southeast. It blooms from April to July, but grows throughout the year, including forming new bulbs in winter and spring. An interesting medicinal property of wild garlic is that, eaten raw, it can be used to treat or prevent scurvy, a disease resulting from vitamin C deficien­cy (Angier 1978). Rangel may not have known just how accurate he was in describing the food as "a great aid to them."

The timing of Soto' s visit to Ichisi is also interesting to consider. The month of March likely brought with it a wide variety of wild plant foods, including the onions upon which the Spanish men feasted. But the spring season was also a time of considerable food stress, as the stores of the fall and winter were largely spent and the corn upon

---

which they relied so heavily had only recently been planted. According to Antoine LePage DuPratz, the historic Natchez began their calendar year in March with the first new moon:

The third moon is that of the Little Corn. This month is often awaited with impatience, their harvest of the great corn never sufficing to nour­ish them from one harvest to another [Swanton

1946:260].

In summer, green corn ceremonies or the "busk" marked several events, including the newly available food staples (Brown 2011; Swanton 1946). For the people of lchisi to give the Spaniards corn­meal cakes and onions in March is a curious mix­ture of signals possibly indicating food security (having enough corn to present to the Spanish as cornmeal cakes) and food crisis (augmenting the staple food with a newly available and possibly abundant wild food) . I would be remiss if I did not also see the potential of coercion on the part of the Spanish, who could have (and often did in their conquests in the New Worldi) take staple foods by force. We may never know why the people of Ichisi chose to feed the Spaniards as they did. How each side viewed this food offering is of considerable in­terest, though, and might be interpreted through what we know about historic Southeastern Native Americans and sixteenth century Spanish officers and soldiers.

FLATBREADS IN SPANISH HANDS To the Spanish, we can presume that the

corn cakes given to them were used as any flat­bread would have been before and since the six­teenth century: as a utensil or vehicle for meats, vegetables, and any other foodstuffs offered as the primary dish. We might assume that the Spaniards were at least familiar with leavened flatbread tradi­tions due to exposure to Moorish traditions during their centuries of control over the Iberian Penin­sula. Flatbreads are a part of nearly every meal in many cultures across northern Africa, the Middle East, and southwest-central Asia (Al-Dmoor 2012), to say nothing of the leavened and unleavened flat­breads of Jewish traditions. There is also a long and rich flatbread tradition across Mediterrane-

IIIII IIIP"' ""''

• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon • 81

an Europe, including the Spanish capas (Prichep 2012). Requiring only the basic ingredients of flour, water, yeast, and salt, it is no mystery that any Old World civilization with early access to do­mesticated grains, ii not to mention millennia of interactions across and around the Mediterranean Sea, all share this tradition. Therefore, when the Spanish arrived in lchisi in 1540, the unleavened cakes of ground maize would have been a familiar form of food to them, if made of somewhat novel materials.

Our account from Georgia is not the only time the Spanish would encounter a grain or cereral-based carbohydrate as an accompaniment or offering with food in the New World. Although food historian Jeffrey Pilcher has been quoted as saying the taco was created in the eighteenth cen­tury (Friesen 2012), the many Mesoamerican re­gional traditions of wrapping meats, vegetables, insects, snails, small fishes, and even salt in un­leavened flatbreads of ground corn predates his supposed first literary mention by many centuries. Twenty years prior to So to's encounter in Georgia, Bernal Diaz del Castillo documented a feast hosted in 1520 by Spanish conquistador Hernan Cortes in Coyoacan for his officers, complete with wine from a recently arrived ship from Spain and pigs brought from Cuba (Carrasco 2008). It has been presumed by some writers (e.g. Esparza 2011) that this feast also included corn flatbread supplied by the natives, which is not an unreasonable assump­tion given numerous descriptions of tortillas else­where in the narrative.

The Nahuatl-speaking Aztecs had a large focal vocabulary pertaining to what we might now call the corn tortilla, including tlaxca~, a root of many nouns, verbs, and adjectives used to describe the production of tortillas by and for particular people under particular circumstances, and many specific types of tortillas (Karttunen 1992; Wired Humanities Projects n.d.). For instance, tlaxcalli is a flat bread made of corn meal, tlaxcalpaclwli de- _ scribes tortillas made of colored corn, ueitlaxcalli is used to name thin and large white corn tortillas, and quauhtlaxqualli identifies thick and large white corn tortillas (Karttunen 1992; Wimmer n.d.). The word "taco" has been alternately interpreted

82 •Early Georgia• volume 42, number 1 •

as a bastardization of tlaxcaLli or merely the Spanish word for "small snack." A more interesting sugges­tion was brought to my attention by noted Spanish colonial ethnohistorian and archaeologist, John Worth (personal communication, April 2012). He notes, as others have, that alternate translations of h d " ,. 1 d h "1 " " d t e wor taco me u e t e nouns p ug or wa -

qing to fill a hole," and the verbs "to tack" or "to plug a hole," apt descriptions for some of the heav­ier modern variations on this food available today. However, Worth suggests that "taco" may also be in reference to the specific wadding used in can­nons of the sixteenth century. In many black pow­der firearms, gunpowder is placed in the barrel and followed by a patch or piece of cloth to hold and secure the shot, both of which are subsequently rammed down the barrel. Early European artillery utilized patches or plugs in breech-loaded pieces in the sixteenth century (Padfield 1974), although in slightly different ways. Padfield (1974) reports the post-firing sequence of a breech-loading piece like one recovered from Henry VIII's warship, the Mary Rose, which sank in 1545. First, the wedge holding the chamber in place would be hammered out and the chamber removed. Next, a piece of oakum, straw, or "junk" would be placed in the open breech end of the barrel. The shot would be placed upon this "wad," presumably to hold the shot in place while a refilled chamber was be­ing prepared (see also Munday 1987). Arnold and Weddle (1978) note a different form of patch used in Spanish breech-loaders. Citing Vigon (1947), they note that the removable chambers would be filled three-fifths full with gunpowder, and an­other fifth with a wooded plug termed a tap6n or taco. The plug was preferably a light wood so as to avoid excessive pressure in the chamber upon firing. An artifact recovered from a 1554 Padre Island shipwrecks (41Knl0; Artifact Number 132-14) interpreted to be a taco is from a branch of a tropic species, possibly Buchenavia, Conocarpus, or Laguncularia (Arnold and Weddle 1978).

The tortillas obtained by Spanish soldiers in Mesoamerica and probably also the Southeast, particularly when held in the hand with a dollop of whatever other food was available to them at the time, may very well have reminded them of shot in

:.: .. ::.:.:1111111111111~ 111 111111111

a patch or wad, just as it presumably had in the Old World. The similarities in the sizes and shapes of the cakes or tortillas and their artillery tacos must have made for a natural affiliation in their minds. This renaming of foods after military hardware is not without parallels: both sopes and chalupas, com­mon items found on Mexican restaurant menus today, started out as names of types of small boats or landing craft.

FLATBREAD IN THE NATIVE SouTHEAST In the late Mississippian period, that pe­

riod of approximately 600 years ending with the Spanish entrada of the sixteenth century, South­eastern Native Americans relied to a great extent on the intensive cultivation of maize (Hudson 1976:292-294; Swanton 1946:304-310). What we know about the specific "races" of maize or corn cultivated in the prehistoric Southeast has come to us largely from the rise of the use of flotation in archaeological excavations (Cutler and Blake 2001; Struever 1968; Yarnell et al. 1993), while our reli­ance on ethnographic and ethnohistoric analogies about specific corn preparation methods and the resulting dishes consumed by Southeastern Indi­ans remains (Hally 1986; Swanton 1946:351-359). Swanton's summaries of a number of historic ac­counts lead me to suppose that native Southeast­erners consumed their corn in three primary ways: as roasted ears, as sofki (also sofkee, or hominy) or other porridge or gruel-like dishes, and as various sorts of boiled or baked "breads." Roasting of ears occurred from the time young corn was still green through the growing season. The prepara­tion of hominy and other gruels involved soaking maize kernels in a lye solution to loosen the hulls, which could then be separated from the kernels by mechanical manipulation (i.e., stirring whilst in the pot or drained and pounded in a mortar) and removed by then skimming the surface of the liquid or winnowing the pounded grains (Bench­ley 2003:127-128). In some instances, the kernels were pounded in a mortar with wood ash, with the resulting flour then sifted or winnowed prior to boiling (Myers 2006:511-514). Swanton's assem­bled accounts of boiled and baked breads include a number of specific preparations and dishes, sev-

eral of which are familiar to us today. For instance, the Choctaw are said to have made a tamale-like loaf or cylinder of corn flour dough, which was then wrapped in corn husks and boiled (Swanton 1946:355 after Foreman 1933:308-309). The Cad­do reportedly had a dumpling made by dropping rolled balls of corn flour and water into boiling liquid until cooked, at which time the small boiled breads were allowed to dry on a stone before eating (Swanton 1946:355 after Smith 1907: 18).

One type of artifact recovered from the Lit­tle Egypt (9Mu102) and King (9Fl5) sites in north­west Georgia gives us an interesting glimpse into one method of preparing cornmeal for the "tortil­las" reported by Rangel and enjoyed by the Span­iards at lchisi. At least three fragments of large vessels exhibiting unusual oxidation discoloration patterns were recovered from these sites (Hally 1983). The pattern consists of a large, circular discoloration on the exterior of a vessel fragment that would have been on its side, concave surface up, during use. Sooting, where it occurs on these fragments, suggests they were placed across rocks, logs, or other props with the deepest portion of the concave form over direct heat. The portion of the vessels directly exposed to fire are discolored but are not sooted due to the complete oxidation of volatile compounds in the fuel (Hally 1983:7, 11). Soot in the form of distilled and oxidized resins and carbon can accumulate further up the walls of the vessels away from the direct heat of the fire. Depths of these vessel fragments thus used were between 2 and 5.5 em (Hally 1983: 12). Hally in­terprets these unique vessel fragments to have been griddles created from broken cooking and storage vessels, possibly (though not verifiably) for the pur­pose of cooking corncakes as described in historic accounts. Swanton's (1946:355-357) voluminous work records several methods for preparing corn breads or "pone," including placing loaves of corn flour dough on preheated hearth surfaces and cov­ered with ashes or an earthen vessel or basin and then heaped over with coals to bake them. I would suggest that the patterns of sooting and oxidation observed in the King and Little Egypt vessels are more likely to have occurred during parching of maize kernels after soaking but prior to pounding.

'1111~ IJJr"' .......

• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon • 83

This process as performed by eighteenth century Louisiana Native Americans is described by Du­Pratz (1758) in Swanton (1946:358-359): maize ker­nels are partially cooked in water, dried and mixed with ashes, and then, through constant stirring to avoid burning the grains, scorched or parched in a "dish made expressly for the purpose" before being pounded in a mortar. At this point, the resulting flour could be stored for use in any number of the dishes described above and their many variations.

FooowAYS CoNSIDERED

If this incident was merely an interesting glimpse at two worlds at a point of irreversible historic change that would probably be enough to warrant this discussion. In this brief consideration I have demonstrated how a number of analytical lenses can be brought to bear on the event to gain new insights about Native and Spanish lifeways in the earliest years of contact. For example, archaeo­logical evidence in the form of sooted vessel frag­ments can be used to explore culinary practices, like how maize kernels were processed by parching. Paleobotanical analyses of the foods (plant and animal) mentioned in explorers' accounts can be applied to environmental reconstructions. The specific timing of the event I've outlined above, coupled with the foods mentioned in the brief ac­count, can be an in-road to examining food secu­rity in middle range agricultural societies. Further studies might use other mentions of particular foodstuffs along So to's route to explore the differ­ent cultural constructions of just what "food" is. That is to say, the Spaniards had particular notions of what was acceptable to eat, as did the Native groups they encountered. How that picture might have changed as they moved across the. Southeast would be an interesting topic to explore.

More than being merely a vehicle for ex­ploring past lifeways, though, this incident is part of a long history of a multicultural food tradition that continues to evolve. For instance, early nine­teenth century immigrations of Germans to Mexi­co brought distinctive Old World flavors, sounds, and customs to borderland traditions (Walsh 2012). Tacos al pastor or "shepherd style tacos" are typically pork sliced off a vertical spit, a tradi-

84 •Early Georgia• volume 42, number 1•

tion brought to the Southwest and Mesoamerica by Lebanese migrants in the 1960s (Pilcher 2012). Americans have likewise since taken their bor­rowed foods around the world, a phenomenon his­torian Pilcher (2012) describes in his work Planet Taco. As he notes, it has been American entrepre­neurs and restaurateurs who have brought tacos, or the American version anyway, to places as far­flung as Australia and Amsterdam, incorporating local flavors and preferences into this very flexible food.

The history of the taco is more than a series of transformations of native New World foods to better meet Old World ideals and tastes. Food traditions are hardly static, even among the groups that see their traditional foods embraced and changed by the Western world. For example, in the Southwest, the Navajo "fry bread" tradition was born out of the staples provided by the United States Army, namely flour (wheat), sugar, salt, and lard. Today, "Indian fry bread" and "Indian tacos" are mainstays of vendors on the powwow circuit. Fry bread even appears in Native American pop culture references. iii That three of the four ingre­dients in fry bread are "Western" has no bearing whatsoever on this food's place in Native Ameri­can tradition and identity.

Returning to Soto and Ichisi, we might ask what each side took away from this encoun­ter. The answer is: likely little, at least as far as their particular food traditions at that moment are concerned. Each side was steeped in their own food taboos and foodways. Southeastern Indians encountered by Soto and his men did not take up the domestication of hogs in the immediate wake of his visits, nor did they adopt the particular reli­giously oriented food taboos or feast/fast days of their Spanish Catholic visitors. Native changes in subsistence patterns were to come considerably later (Pavao-Zuckerman 2007). With the possible exceptions of fruits like peaches, something that could be adapted to native palettes and serve in roles already held by the wild plum or ripe persim­mon, and maybe the chickpeas that were a part of Spanish rations (Rodriguez-Salgado 1988, Ki­ple 2007) and not unlike their own beans in form and preparation requirements, what little if any

Span ish food they might have seen or experienced would ha,·e been completely unlike that to which they were accu romed.

Likewise, the Spanish seemed to only note the familiar in the various chronicles of their expe­ditions. Bernal Diaz del Castillo may or may not have witnessed an early sixteenth century taco par­ty, but he did note encountering what he thought to be onions, leeks, and garlic on the march to Tenochtitlan in 1519 (Kiple 2007: 159). Flatbreads, even if only of unleavened cornmeal, were familiar to the Spanish and were able to be incorporated into their existing expectations about what consti­tuted acceptable and palatable food. Foodstuffs foreign to the Spanish went largely unnoted and, in some instances, the lack of understanding of the significance of particular offerings had dire conse­quences. Soto himself was party to the execution of the ruler Atahualpa Inca at Cajamarca in north­ern Peru in 1532, an event which likely precipitat­ed from the unknowing and insulting rejection of an offering of maize beer, or chicha by the Span­iards (Staller 2006:456-460). Without question, the consequences of Soto's later excursion across the Southeast were equally horrific, long-lasting, and devastating, but for one short period of time in central Georgia, the incredible changes to come were left unconsidered over a simple meal of on­ion tacos shared by the Spanish and the people of lchisi.

Acknowledgements

This paper began as an "Archaeology Cafe" presen­tation sponsored by the Florida Public Archaeology Network (FPAN). My thanks go to Mr. Michael Thomin for organ­izing and filming the event. Without a recordation of my ad libs and responses to audience questions, much of this paper would not have been recoverable. A considerable amount of gratitude is owed Ms. Gina Matthiesen, who proposed the idea for the original talk ("Everybody likes tacos!"). Dr. John Worth is thanked for his help with translations, etyrnol­ogy, and a few references. As the paper evolved, supportive audiences were found at monthly meetings of the Pensacola Archaeological Society and the Emerald Coast Archaeologi­cal Society. Appreciation is extended to Jared Wood for his part in bringing this work to publication. Two anonymous reviewers made excellent suggestions that improved the man­uscript. While comments and criticisms were sought and cor­rections attempted, all remaining errors are mine alone.

Notes ;In 1519, vassals of Mutezuma came to Cortes and said

they would be allied with him as vassals of Spain and in­quired about what King Don Carlos might require in tribute. They seemed to offer anything, including gold, silver, jewels, slaves, and cloth, provided that Cortes and his men did not travel to their land. They went on that "it was very barren and lacking in all provisions and it would grieve him if [Cortes) and those who came with [him) should be in want" (Pagden 1971 :69). By this point, it was well-established that the Span­ish soldiers took what they wanted and could quickly overtax the provisioning abilities of the host. This is not the only reported account of a native leader feigning inadequate re­sources to avoid a visit from Cortes. I am certain a more complete account of the So to expedition would find parallel accounts.

;;Cereals had long been the core of the Mediterranean diet since Classical times, and certainly the more stable of the triad of grain-olive-vine that came to define the so-called "Mediterranean diet" glamorized in recent years (Garnsey 1999).

;;;Sherman Alexie's take on the Christian "loaves and fishes" parable in his screenplay for the movie Smoke SignaLs (1998) is worth seeking out.

REFERENCES CITED Al-Dmoor, Hanee M. 2012 Flat Bread: Ingredients and Fortification.

Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops and Food 4:2-8. Blackwell Publishing.

Ambrose, S. H., Buikstra, J. E., and Krueger, H. W. 2003 Status and Gender Differences in Diet at

Mound 7 2, Cahokia, Revealed by Isotopic Analysis of Bone. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 22: 217-226.

Angier, Bradford 1978 Field Guide to Medicinal Wild Plants. Stack­

pole Books, Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania.

Arnold, J. Barto III, and Robert Weddle 1978 The Nautical Archaeology of Padre Island: The

Spanish Shipwrecks of 1554. Texas Antiqui­ties Committee Publication Number 7. Academic Press, New York.

Barr, Ann, and Paul Levy 1985 The Official Foodie Handbook. Arbor House

Publishing Company, New York.

• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon • 85

Benchley, Elizabeth D. 2003 Mississ ippian Alkali Processing of Corn.

The Wisconsin Archeologist 84(1&2): 127-137.

Brown, Ian W. 2011 Festivals, Indian. In American Centuries: The

Ideas, Issues, and Values that Shaped U.S. His­tory: 16th Century to the 20th Century, edited by Karen Kupperman, pp. 101-104. Facts on File, MTM Publishing, Inc., New York.

Bush, Leslie L. 2004 Boundary Conditions: Macrobotanical Re­

mains and the Oliver Phase of Central Indiana, A.D. 1200 - 1450. The University of Ala­bama Press, Tuscaloosa.

Carrasco, David 2008 Introduction. In The History of the Conquest

of New Spain by Bernal Diaz del Castillo, ed­ited by David Carrasco, pp. xi-xxvii. The University of New Mexico Press, Albuquer­que.

Cuellar, Andrea M. 2013 The Archaeology of Food and Social In­

equality in the Andes. Journal of Archaeologi­cal Research 21:123-174.

Cutler, Hugh C., and Leonard W. Blake 2001 North American Indian Corn. In Plants

from the Past, edited by Leonard W. Blake and Hugh C. Cutler, pp. 1-18. The Univer­sity of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.

Dietler, Michael 2007 Culinary Encounters: Food, Identity, and

Colonialism. In The Archaeology of Food and Identity, edited by Katheryn C. Twiss, pp. 218-242. Center for Archaeological Investi­gations, Occasional Paper No. 34. South­ern Illinois University, Carbondale.

Dietler, Michael, and Brian Hayden (editors) 2010 Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Per­

spectives on Food, Politics, and Power. The University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.

86 •Early Georgia• volume 42, number 1 •

DuPratz, Antoine S. LePage 17 58 Histoire de la Louisiane. 3 vols. Paris.

Esparza, Bill 2011 Tacos 101 with Bill Esparza. Electronic

document, http:/ /www.lataco.com/taco/ tacos-101-with-bill-esparza-part-1-history­and-etiquette, accessed 2 January 2013.

Foreman, Grant 1933 Advancing the Frontier, 1830-1860. The Uni­

versity of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

Friesen, Katy June 2012 Where Did the Taco Come From? Elec­

tronic document, http:/ /www.smithso­nianmag.com/arts-culture/Where-Did­the-Taco-Come-From.html?. Accessed 9 September 2012.

Hally, David J. 1981 Plant Preservation and the Content of

Paleobotanical Samples, A Case Study. American Antiquity 46:723-74 2.

1983 Use Alteration of Pottery Vessel Surfaces: An Important Source of Evidence for the Identification of Vessel Function. North American Archaeologist 4(1):3-26.

1984 Vessel Assemblages and Food Habits: A Comparison ofT wo Aboriginal Southeast­ern Vessel Assemblages. Southeastern Ar­chaeology 3(1):46-64.

1986 The Identification of Vessel Function: A Case Study from Northwest Georgia. Amer­ican Antiquity 51(2):267-295.

Hudson, Charles 1976 The Southeastern Indians. University of Ten­

nessee Press, Knoxville. 1990 A Synopsis of the Hernando de Soto Ex­

pedition, 1539-1543. DeSoto Trail: National Historic Trail Study. Final Report. Southeast Regional Office, National Park Service, Department of the Interior. Washington, D.C.

1994a The Hernando deSoto Expedition: 1539-1543. In The Forgotten Centuries: Indians and

. · :::.::::1111111111111111 111 111111111

Europeans in the American South 1521-1704, edited by Charles Hudson and Carmen Chaves Tesser, pp. 74-103. University of Georgia Press, Athens.

1994b The Social Context of the Chiefdom of lchisi. In Ocmulgee Archaeology 1936-1986, edited by David J. Hally, pp. 175-180. Uni­versity of Georgia Press, Athens.

1997 Knights of Spain, Warriors of the Sun. Univer­sity Press of Georgia, Athens.

Karttunen, Frances 1992 An Analytical Dictionary of Nahuatl. Univer­

sity of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

Kiple,. Kenneth F. 2007 A Movable Feast: Ten Millennia of Food Glo­

balization. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

Munday, John 1987 Naval Cannon. Shire Album 186. Shire

Publications, Bucks, England.

Myers, Thomas P. 2006 Hominy Technology and the Emergence

of Mississippian Societies. In Histories of Maize: Multidisciplinary Approaches to the Pre­history, Linguistics, Biogeography, Domestica­tion, and Evolution of Maize, edited by John E. Staller, Robert H. T ykot, and Bruce F. Benz, pp. 511-520. Academic Press, Burl­ington, Massachusetts.

Padfield, Peter 1974 Guns at Sea. St. Martin's Press, New York.

Pavao-Zuckerman, Barnet 2007 Deerskins and Domesticates: Creek Sub­

sistence and Economic Strategies in the Historic Period. American Antiquity 72(1):5-33.

Peterson, Lee Allen 1977 A Field Guide to Edible Wild Plants: Eastern/

Central North America. Houghton Mifflin Company, New York.

Pilcher, Jeffrey M. 2012 Planet Taco: A Global History of Mexican

Food. Oxford University Press, New York.

Prichep, Deena 2012 Mediterranean Flatbreads: A Framework

for Flavor. Electronic document, http:// www.npr.org/2012/0l/10/144966039/ mediterranean-flatbreads-a-framework-for­flavor, accessed 2 January 2013.

Rangel, Rodrigo 1993 Account of the Northern Conquest and

Discovery of Hernando de Soto. Trans­lated and edited by John E. Worth with footnotes by John E. Worth and Charles Hudson. In The De Soto Chronicles, Vol 1: The Expedition of Hernando de Soto to North America in 1539-1543, edited by Lawrence A Clayton, Vernon J. Knight, Edward Carter Moore. The University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.

Rees, Mark A 1997 Coercion, Tribute, and Chiefly Authority:

The Regional Development of Mississip­pian Political Culture. Southeastern Archae­ology 16(2):113-133.

2002 Subsistence Economy and Political Culture in Protohistoric Central Mississippi Valley. In Between Contacts and Colonies: Archaeolog­ical Perspectives on the Protohistoric Southeast, edited by Cameron B. Wesson and Mark A Rees, pp. 170-197. The University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.

Rodriguez..Salgado, M. J. 1988 Armada 1588-1988. Penguin Books, Lon­

don, England.

Scarry, C. Margaret, and Elizabeth J. Reitz 2005 Changes in Food ways at the Parkin Site, Ar­

kansas. Southeastern Archaeology, 24(2): 107-120.

• Eating Onions in Ichisi • Gougeon • 87

Scott, Elizabeth M. 1996 Who Ate What? Archaeological Food Re­

mains and Cultural Diversity. In Case Stud­ies in Environmental Archaeology, edited by Elizabeth J. Reitz, Lee A Newsom, and Syl­via J. Scudder, pp. 339-356. Plenum Press, New York.

2007 Pigeon Soup and Plover in Pyramids: French Foodways in New France and the Illinois Country. In The Archaeology of Food and Identity, edited by Katheryn C. Twiss, pp. 243-259. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Occasional Paper No. 34. Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.

Staller, John E. 2006 The Social, Symbolic, and Economic Sig­

nificance of Zea mays L. in the Late Ho­rizon Period. In Histories of Maize: Mul­tidisciplinary Approaches to the Prehistory, Linguistics, Biogeography, Domestication, and Evolution of Maize, edited by John E. Stall­er, Robert H. Tykot, and Bruce F. Benz, pp. 449-467. Academic Press, Burlington, Mas­sachusetts.

Struever, S. 1968 Flotation Techniques for the Recovery of

Small-Scale Archaeological Remains. Amer­ican Antiquity 33(3):353-362.

Swanton, John R. 1946 The Indians of the Southeastern United States.

Smithsonian Institution Press, Washing­ton, D.C.

Twiss, Katheryn C. (editor) 2007 The Archaeology of Food and Identity. Center

for Archaeological Investigations, Occa­sional Paper No. 34. Southern Illinois Uni­versity, Carbondale.

Vigon, Jorge 1947 Historia de la artilleria Espanola, Volume 1.

Instituto Jeronimo Zurita, Madrid, Spain.

88 •Early Georgia• volume 42, number 1 •

Walsh, Robb 2012 Texas Eats: The New Lone Star Heritage Cook­

book, with More Than 200 Recipes. Random House, New York.

Wimmer, Alexis n.d. Dictionnaire de la langue Nahuatl Clas­

sique. Electronic document, http:// sites. estvideo.net/malinal/, accessed 18 April 2013.

Wing, Elizabeth S., and Antoinette B. Brown 1979 Paleonutrition: Method and Theory in Prehis­

toric Foodways. Academic Press, New York.

Wired Humanities Projects n.d. Nahuatl Dictionary. Electronic document,

http:/ /whp. uoregon.edu/ dictionaries/ na­huatl/, accessed 28 March 2014.

Yarnell, Richard, Thomas Maher, and Jean Black 1993 A Bibliography of Aboriginal Archaeologi­

cal Plant Food Remains from Eastern North America: 1901-1991. Research Report 11, Research Laboratories of Anthropology. University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.

Zeder, Melinda A, and Susan R. Arter 1996 Meat Consumption and Bone Use in a

Mississippian Village. In Case Studies in Environmental Archaeology, edited by Eliza­beth J. Reitz, Lee A Newsom, and Sylvia J. Scudder, pp. 319-337. Plenum Press, New York.