doc.: 11-10/895r3 submission july 2010 dee denteneer (philips), bruce kraemer (marvell) slide 1...

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010

Dee Denteneer (Philips), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)Slide 1

P802.11s Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

Authors:

Name Affiliation Address Phone email

Dee Denteneer PhilipsHTC 34; 5656 AE

Eindhoven, the Netherlands

+31 40 2749743

[email protected]

Bruce Kraemer Marvell5488 Marvell Lane, Santa

Clara, CA 95054+1 (321) 427-4098

[email protected]

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


Introduction

• This document contains the report to the IEEE 802 Executive Committee in support of a request for conditional approval to send IEEE P802.11s Draft 7.0 to Sponsor Ballot.

• This document (11-10/0895r3) was approved during the closing plenary session of the 802.11 working group on 16 July 2010.– Passed in the Task Group yes 7, no 0, abstain 0

– Passed in the Working Group yes: 51 , no: 0 , abstain: 0

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010

Dee Denteneer (Philips), B.Kraemer (Marvell)Slide 3

TGs draft text stability

200

250

300

350

July-06 April-08 Mar-09 Dec-09 Jun-10

# pa

ges

1.02.0

3.0

4.0

Mar-10

5.0 6.0

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2009


802.11 WG Letter Ballot Results – P802.11s

Ballo

t ID

Ballot Close Date

Title Ballot Type

Po

ol

Retu

rn

%R

eturn

Ab

stain

%A

bs

tain

Ap

pro

ve

Disa

pp

rove

%A

pp

rove

147 04 May 2009

Technical Letter Ballot for Draft 3.0 Technical 248 201 81 34 17 132 35 79

159 08 January

2010

First Recirculation Ballot for Draft 4.0 Recirculation 248 210 85 33 16 150 27 85

161 15 April 2010

Second Recirculation Ballot for Draft 5.0

Recirculation 248 210 85 32 15 159 19 89

165 28 June 2010

Third Recirculation Letter Ballot for Draft 6.0

Recirculation 248 210 85 33 16 157 20 89

Response to Draft 6.0 and its comment resolutions* 92

*, during the San Diego meeting, 5 members indicated satisfaction with the Draft and their intent to vote yes on the next recirculation

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2009


802.11 WG Letter Ballot Results – P802.11s

Ballo

t ID

Ballot Close Date

Title Ballot Type Number of comments

147 04 May 2009

Technical Letter Ballot for Draft 3.0 Technical 1196 (T778, E418)

159 08 January 2010

First Recirculation Ballot for Draft 4.0 Recirculation 809 (T449, E360)

161 15 April 2010

Second Recirculation Ballot for Draft 5.0

Recirculation 421 (T271, E150)

165 28 June 2010

Third Recirculation Letter Ballot for Draft 6.0

Recirculation 253 (T152, E101)

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010

Dee Denteneer (Philips), B.Kraemer (Marvell)Slide 6

Unsatisfied comments by commenter*Voter LB147 LB159 LB 161 LB165

Benveniste 3

Bumiller 5

Cam-Winget 16

Chan 2

Ecclesine 1

Erceg 6

Hart 7

Montemurro 9

Myles 2

Ptasinski 4

Roy 2

Stacey 2

Stephenson 7

Wang, Qi 0

Wentink 11

Total 38 12 27

Statistics on unsatisfied comments incorporate feedback gathered during the San Diego session as collected in the back up slides

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


Unsatisfied Comments – Topics

Topic LB147 LB159 LB161 LB165

Frame formats 6 3

General/Editorial 5 5

Power Management 3 3 1

Reservation 2 2

Mac-various 5 4

Routing 3 1

Security-various 14

Security-Base 20

Total 38 0 12 27

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


Unsatisfied comments

• The composite of all unsatisfied comments and the resolutions approved by the comment resolution committee received during working group ballot may be found in the embedded document on the right:

– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.

• A copy of this same data presented using MyBallot access database report format is attached.

– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.

Microsoft Office Excel 97-2003 Worksheet

Adobe Acrobat Document

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


TGs Timeline Open Close

Fourth recirculation (TGs draft 7.0) 24-Jul-10 8-Aug-10

Clean recirculation (TGs draft 7.0) 22-Sep-10 2-Oct-10

Professional editing + MEC 24-Jul-10 13-Sep-10

Pool formation 22-July-10 7-Sep-10

First sponsor ballot 11-Oct-10 10-Nov-10

Second sponsor ballot 13-Dec-10 12-Jan-11

Third sponsor ballot 24-Jan-11 13-Feb-11

Fourth sponsor ballot 1-Mar-11 16-Mar-11

Fifth sponsor ballot 1-Apr-11 16-Apr-11

EC to RevCom Jul-11

RevCom to SB Sep-11

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010

D. Stanley (Aruba), B.Kraemer (Marvell)Slide 10

802.11 EC Motion – 4.10 Conditional Approval to send P802.11s to Sponsor Ballot

• Grant conditional approval to forward P802.11s to Sponsor Ballot.

• Moved: Bruce Kraemer 2nd: <name>– Yes No Abstain

• Working Group 11 vote on the Motion Passed: xx y, x n, x a

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


BACK UP SLIDES

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

July 2010


Responses received indicating a change of vote

• Stephen McCann [[email protected]]– I would like to inform you that my comment (CID 4106) from

LB165 has now been satisfied and subsequently I would like to change my vote to “Approve”

• Walker, Jesse [[email protected]]– . Mark that I am satisfied with the resolutions of all. Thanks.

• Matthew Fischer [[email protected]]– I wish to change my vote to YES.

• liwen chu [[email protected]]– I am OK with the resolutions of my comments. So I will vote Yes to the new

802.11s draft.

• Dan Harkins [[email protected]]– I am satisfied with resolution of all of my comments (assuming my motion to

address the remainder of them passes) and I will change my No vote to a Yes.

doc.: 11-10/895r3

Submission

Responses received indicating acceptance of some of the resolutions

• [email protected]– I accept the resolutions to the 5 comments listed below

• Qi Wang [[email protected]]. – I am satisfied at the resolutions to my LB165 comments, as

recorded in the document 2010/725R6.

• Dave Stephenson (daves) [[email protected]]– 11-10-0726r2 satisfactorily resolves my two comments, CIDs

4165 and 4170

July 2010


doc.: 11-10/895r3 submission july 2010 dee denteneer (philips), bruce kraemer (marvell) slide 1...

Documents