distributive justice lecture 2: welfarism 1i kymlicka chapter 2 i john stuart mill, p 166 in solomon...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Distributive JusticeLecture 2: Welfarism 1
Hilde Bojerwww.folk.uio.no/[email protected]
February 4, 2011
![Page 2: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Reading
2
I Bojer chapter 4
I Kymlicka chapter 2
I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy
![Page 3: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
What is welfarism
Welfarism
3
I Utilitarianism
I Economic welfare theory
Note: Kymlicka writes about utilitarianism only,not economic welfare theory.But most of his text applies equally to both
![Page 4: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism
4
I Jeremy Bentham 1748 – 1832
I John Stuart Mill 1806 – 1873
Contemporary?Mainly economists, but they are influential
![Page 5: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism
5= The greatest possible happiness for the greatest possible numberMathematically impossibleImplications for distributional policy ?Happiness is not distributableCannot be handed out by the government –or anyone elseCannot be transferred from one person to anotheris not an economic good.
![Page 6: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism cont.
6In order to implement utilitarian policy:we must know
I What is meant by happiness
I How to measure happiness
I Which factors determine happiness
![Page 7: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
What is happiness?
7What is meant by happiness?Happiness = welfare = utilityUtilityutilitarianismStrictly : what is usefulThe individual herself decides whether she is happy, and how happyPreference utilitarianismThe opposite would be paternalism
![Page 8: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
How to measure happiness
8In my textbook: not possibleBut I seem to have been wrongThere is a rich literature on the subjectPlease see the two websites I have postedLayard is not the most recent, but still influential andrepresentativeThere are various national surveys, in Norway and other countriesThese seem to show thataggregate happiness increases with national incomeup to a certain level
![Page 9: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
9Above this level: income does not increase happinessIn cross section surveyshappiness usually increases with incomeConclusion?Happiness depends (perhaps) on relative, not absolute, incomein rich countriesBut there is no consensus on this point
![Page 10: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
What determines happiness?
10Reasonable assumption, borne out by empirical studies:Income is one factor, if not the only one.We will discuss as if income is the only factorOK if the effect of income can be separated from other factors anddiscussed separately
![Page 11: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
11I shall drop the term happinessand substitute utilityand/orindividual welfareEconomicst use the term utility exclusivelyWelfare, or individual welfare, is mostly used by philosophersIndividual welfare is distinct from social welfare
![Page 12: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Two important concepts
12Utility functionDescribes how utility varies with incomeWe assume that the higher the income, the more utility you derivefrom itMarginal utilityMU is the increase in utility from 1 unit increase in incomeWe assume that the higher the income, the smaller MUalso seems consistent with empirical research
![Page 13: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
13Pause for diagram Figure 4.1 in textbook
![Page 14: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism
14Greatest happiness of the greatest number:means more preciselyDistribute a given income so that the sum of utilities is as great aspossibleFor two persons, Anne and Peter:Maximise utility of Peter + utility of AnneWhen Peter’s income + Anne’s income is a constant (given)Given size of the cake
![Page 15: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Maximising sum of utilities
15More generallyMaximise U1 + U2 + .....Unsubject to a given total income
![Page 16: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarian distribution
16Policy implications of utilitarianismFor a give amount of income:(A given size of the cake)Distribute it so that all marginal utilities are equal.
![Page 17: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarian distribution
17Why?An example:Assume thatAnne’s marginal utility = 5Peter’s marginal utility = 2We take 1 krone from Peter and give to AnneTotal utility decreases with 2 units lost by PeterBut increases with 5 units gained by AnneTotal utility increases with 5 - 2 = 3.
![Page 18: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarian distribution
18If the MU’s are diffferent, it will always be possible to increasetotal utilityby redistributing from a person with low MUto a person with high MU
![Page 19: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
19Remember: The higher the income, the lower the MUSo: redistributing from a low MUto a higher MUwill implytaking from a higher income and giving to a lower
![Page 20: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
20ProvidedAll utility functions are equalIf all people have the same preferencesutilitarianism implies that all incomes should be equal.and is therefore regarded as an egalitarian theory
![Page 21: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
21Do all people have equal preferences?What if preferences are not equal?Then utilitarianism implies neither equality of welfarenor equality of income
![Page 22: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Utilitarian distribution
22Pause for diagramBojer: fig 4.3
![Page 23: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
Welfare-egalitarian distribution
23Equality of welfare, not the utilitarian equality of MUsPause for diagramBojer: fig 4.2
![Page 24: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Utilitarianism
24What are the reasons for different preferences?
![Page 25: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
25
1. Ethical equality
2. Ethical individualism
3. Humanism
4. Respect for preferences
5. Consequentialism
![Page 26: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
Ethical properties of utilitarianism cont
26Comments:1. Ethical equality: All individuals count equally2. Ethical indidualism
I No group rights (or wrongs)
I No common good
I No discrimination
![Page 27: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
Ethical individualism
27Does not imply that utilitarianism excludespublic goodse.g. EnvironmentDefencePublic transportationetc etcThe environment is relevant to the extent that itaffects the welfare of one or more individuals
![Page 28: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
283. HumanismOr anthropocentrismIt is HUMAN welfare that countsAnimals and natureto the extent that they affect the welfare of individual humansNot all utilitarians will agreeIs it possible to include the welfare of animals in total welfare?
![Page 29: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
294. Respect for preferencesAll preferences?Children? Animals?
![Page 30: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
30Distinguished utilitarian: John Harsanyi:Anti-social preferences should not be includedBut how do we decide which preferences to respect and which toignore?And who decides?
![Page 31: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
31On preferences, and what is meant by utilityPlease read Kymlicka carefully
![Page 32: Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1I Kymlicka chapter 2 I John Stuart Mill, p 166 in Solomon and Murphy. Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1 What is welfarism Welfarism](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022041723/5e5055020a89af494032d97f/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Distributive Justice Lecture 2: Welfarism 1
Ethical properties of utilitarianism
325. ConsequentialismOpposite to deontological theoriesRule utilitarianismAct utilitarianismWhich preferences should decide on the rules?(If society shapes preferences)