!

!"#$%!&$'

$()*+',-'.(//+0)1)(,23! "#$%&'()#$*#+! #%"&,-.)'(*/! %00%/('! ,0!(&)#'/&)#*).! $*&%/(! /"&&%#(! '(*1".)(*,#!(2&,"+2! )#).3'*'! ,0! $3#)1*/'! ,0! .)&+%4'/).%!5&)*#!#%(6,&7'!

! !! )89:;<!=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8C!$DE@DA!DF!-;BGD:DH;IC!JKLJ!!.(//+0)1)(,2'.(0+4)+5'"63! )::DEB<@>! -ADF>::DA! MD:N! .O! /D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC!

$>H<A@Q>8@! DF! 7B8>:BDGDRIC! +A<P9<@>! -ADRA<Q! B8!#>9AD:EB>8E>! <8P! /DR8B@BS>! 'EB>8E>C! 0B:E;>GG!$>H<A@Q>8@!DF!5BD>8RB8>>AB8R!

!!*8@AB8:BE!<P9G@!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!HG<I:!<!EAB@BE<G!ADG>!B8!G><A8B8R!<8P!Q>QDAI!<:!T>GG!<:!Q>PB<@B8R!

F98E@BD8<G! A>EDS>AI! FADQ! UA<B8! G>:BD8:! GB?>! :@AD?>! <8P! @A<9Q<@BE! UA<B8! B8V9AB>:O! %W@AB8:BE!

:@A<@>RB>:! @D! <BP! F<SDA<UG>!QDP9G<@BD8!DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! <E@! <:! BQHDA@<8@! <PV98E@BS>! @DDG:! DF!

8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8O! (A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! X@$/'Y! B:! <8! >W<QHG>! DF! <! 8D84

B8S<:BS>! @>E;8BZ9>! @;<@! E<8! :9EE>::F9GGI! B8P9E>! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! E;<8R>:! B8! @;>! ;9Q<8! UA<B8C!

<G@;D9R;! @;>! 98P>AGIB8R! Q>E;<8B:Q:! <A>! 8D@! EDQHG>@>GI! 98P>A:@DDPO! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC!

E;<A<E@>AB[<@BD8! DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! E;<8R>:! B8! G<AR>4:E<G>! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! B:! <! F98E@BD8<G! <8P!

8>E>::<AI! :@>H! @DT<AP:! 8D84B8S<:BS>GI! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! QDP9G<@BD8! Q>PB<@>P! UI!

@$/'!B8!;9Q<8:O!(;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8C!@;9:C!<BQ>P!@D!98P>A:@<8P!@;>!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'C!D8!G<AR>4:E<G>!

UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! A>EDAP>P! @;AD9R;! Q<R8>@D>8E>H;<GDRA<H;I! X1%+Y! @;AD9R;! @;A>>!

:H>EBFBE! <BQ:! @;<@! TBGG! HADSBP>! 8DS>G! B8:BR;@:! B8@D! @;>! Q>E;<8B:QX:Y! @;AD9R;! T;BE;! HG<:@BE!

E;<8R>:! <A>! HADQD@>P! UI! @$/'C! :H>EBFBE<GGI! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! QD@DA! G><A8B8RO! (;B:! PB::>A@<@BD8!

H9A:9>P!<!:I:@>Q<@BE!B8S>:@BR<@BD8!DF!@;>:>!E;<8R>:!B8!T;DG>4;><P!EDA@BE<G!PI8<QBE:!9:B8R!UD@;!

QDP>G4FA>>! <8P! QDP>G4U<:>P! <8<GI:B:! @>E;8BZ9>:O! (TD! >WH>ABQ>8@:! T>A>! ED8P9E@>P! @D!

!

PB::DEB<@>!U>@T>>8!8>@TDA?!E;<8R>:!Q>PB<@>P!UI!@$/'!<@!A>:@!<:!T>GG!<:!T;>8!ED9HG>P!TB@;!<!

@<:?!B8!DAP>A!@D!P>@>AQB8>!DH@BQ<G!ED8PB@BD8:!FDA!9:B8R!@$/'!FDA!EGB8BE<G!H9AHD:>:O!&>:9G@:!FADQ!

'@9PI! L! 9:B8R!QDP>G4FA>>! <8<GI:B:! :;DT>P! @;<@! <! :H>EBFBE! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! <@! A>:@!T<:!

QDP9G<@>P! 9H! @D! <! H>ABDP! DF! \K!QB89@>:! D9@G<:@B8R! @;>! P9A<@BD8! DF! @;>! :@BQ9G<@BD8O! 09A@;>A!

QDP>G4U<:>P!<8<GI:B:!DF!@;B:!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!:;DT>P!@;<@!@;>:>!PBFF>A>8E>:!T>A>!PABS>8!

UI!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!HABQ<ABGI! B8SDGSB8R!;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI!R<QQ<!U<8P! ED88>E@BSB@I! @D!<8P! FADQ!

@;>! :9HHG>Q>8@<AI! QD@DA! <A><! @D! <::DEB<@>P! A>RBD8:! XG>F@! HABQ<AI! QD@DA! EDA@>W! X:@BQ9G<@>P!

A>RBD8YC!G>F@!HA>FAD8@<G!<8P!H<AB>@<G!EDA@BE>:YO!&>:9G@:!FADQ!'@9PI!J!:;DT>P!@;<@!@;>!@$/'!>W>A@:!

;BR;GI! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! >FF>E@:! D8! @;>! BQH<E@! DF! D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@IC! TB@;B8! @;>!

F98E@BD8<GGI! A>G>S<8@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?C! D8! U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;! QD@DA!

G><A8B8RO! (;>:>! A>:9G@:! <PS<8E>! D9A! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! Q>PB<@>P! UI! @$/'! <8P!

@;9:C!;<S>!BQHGBE<@BD8:!B8!@;>!EGB8BE<G!9:>!DF!@$/'!FDA!>8;<8EB8R!>FFBE<EI!DF!8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8!

B8!H<@B>8@:!TB@;!:@AD?>!<8P!@A<9Q<@BE!UA<B8!B8V9AIO!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!

!!

"#$%&'()#$*#+!#%"&,-.)'(*/!%00%/('!,0!(&)#'/&)#*).!$*&%/(!/"&&%#(!'(*1".)(*,#!(2&,"+2!)#).3'*'!,0!$3#)1*/'!,0!.)&+%4'/).%!5&)*#!#%(6,&7'!

!!!!!

5I!!

)89:;<!=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8!!!

$B::>A@<@BD8!:9UQB@@>P!@D!@;>!0<E9G@I!DF!@;>!+A<P9<@>!'E;DDG!DF!@;>!"8BS>A:B@I!DF!1<AIG<8PC!/DGG>R>!-<A?C!B8!H<A@B<G!F9GFBGGQ>8@!

DF!@;>!A>Z9BA>Q>8@:!FDA!@;>!P>RA>>!DF!$DE@DA!DF!-;BGD:DH;I!

JKLJ!!

!!!!!

)PSB:DAI!/DQQB@@>>]!!$AO!MD:N!.O!/D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC!-;$C!/;<BA!!$AO!5A<PG>I!2<@FB>GPC!-;$C!/D4/;<BA!$AO!.>D8<APD!+O!/D;>8C!1$!$AO!%GB[<U>@;!^9B8G<8C!-;$!$AO!+A>RDAI!2<8EDE?C!-;$!

!

!

!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

_!/DHIABR;@!UI!)89:;<!=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8!

JKLJ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ii !

!!

.7.8&!$89:'

(;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8!B:!P>PBE<@>P!@D!QI!;9:U<8PC!):;TB8!<8P!!

QI!H<A>8@:C!=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8!`!-DDA8BQ<O

iii !

!&;:9<=7.>7?7:$#'

*!TD9GP! GB?>! @D! :B8E>A>GI! @;<8?!<GG! @;D:>!T;D!;<S>! @<9R;@!<8P!;>GH>P!Q>! @;AD9R;! @;>!

HADE>::!DF!FB8B:;B8R!QI!PB::>A@<@BD8C!H<A@BE9G<AGI]!

• 1I!<PSB:DA!<8P!Q>8@DAC!MD:N!X->H>Y!/D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC!FDA!;B:!B8S<G9<UG>!R9BP<8E>C!

Q>8@DA:;BH!<8P!:9HHDA@! @;AD9R;D9@!QI!RA<P9<@>!@A<B8B8R! XFDA!J!P>RA>>:aYC!<8P!

QD:@! BQHDA@<8@GIC! FDA! Q<?B8R! Q>! @;>! :EB>8@B:@! *! <Q! @DP<IO! *! TBGG! U>! FDA>S>A!

RA<@>F9G! @D! ;BQ! FDA! RBSB8R! Q>! @;>! DHHDA@98B@I! <8P! FA>>PDQ! @D! >WHGDA>! QI!

A>:><AE;!B8@>A>:@:!<8P!FD:@>AB8R!QI!B8P>H>8P>8E>!<8P!RADT@;!b!*!ED9GP!8D@!;<S>!

<:?>P!FDA!<!U>@@>A!Q>8@DA!<8P!FAB>8P!@;<8!;BQO!

• 1I! ED4<PSB:DAC! .>D8<APD! X.>DY! /D;>8C! FDA! @<?B8R!Q>! D8! B8! ;B:! G<U! <@! #*2C! <8P!

RBSB8R!Q>!<8!DHHDA@98B@I!DF!<!GBF>@BQ>!@D!TDA?!TB@;!<8P!PD!A>:><AE;!<QD8R!:DQ>!

DF! @;>! FB8>:@! :EB>8@B:@:O! *! <Q! H<A@BE9G<AGI! @;<8?F9G! @D! ;BQ! FDA! @A><@B8R!Q>! TB@;!

A>:H>E@! <8P! >8ED9A<RB8R! QI! B8P>H>8P>8E>C! P>:HB@>! Q>! U>B8R! D8GI! <! PDE@DA<G!

:@9P>8@!B8!;B:!G<UO!!

• $AO! 5A<P! 2<@FB>GPC! FDA! :>ASB8R! D8! QI! PB::>A@<@BD8! EDQQB@@>>C! <:! ED4E;<BAC! FDA!

HADSBPB8R!S<G9<UG>!:9RR>:@BD8:!<8P!B8:BR;@:!@;AD9R;D9@!@;>!PB::>A@<@BD8!HADE>::C!

<8P!FDA!<GT<I:!HADQD@B8R!<8P!FD:@>AB8R!QI!RADT@;!<:!<!A>:><AE;>AO!

• $AO! +A>RDAI! 2<8EDE?C! FDA! :>ASB8R! D8!QI! PB::>A@<@BD8! EDQQB@@>>! <8P! HADSBPB8R!

S<G9<UG>! B8:BR;@:C! <8P! FDA! >8ED9A<RB8R!QI! G><A8B8R! <8P! F9A@;>AB8R!QI! GDS>! FDA!

:@<@B:@BE:C!UI!<8:T>AB8R!<!QBGGBD8!Z9>:@BD8:!4!<GT<I:!TB@;!<!:QBG>O!!

iv !

• $AO! %GB[<U>@;! X5>@:IY! ^9B8G<8! FDA! :>ASB8R! D8! QI! PB::>A@<@BD8! EDQQB@@>>C! <8P!

HADSBPB8R!Q>!TB@;!B8S<G9<UG>!B8:BR;@:C!8>T!H>A:H>E@BS>:!<8P!FDA!<GT<I:!H9:;B8R!

Q>!@D!>WE>GO!

• 1I! H>>A! Q>8@DAC! <8P! <! S>AI! P><A! FAB>8PC! 1<AED! '<8PAB8BC! FDA! @><E;B8R! Q>!

T;<@>S>A! *! ?8DT! @DP<I! <UD9@! 8D84B8S<:BS>! UA<B8! :@BQ9G<@BD8C! FDA! U><AB8R!TB@;!

@;>! TDA:@! T>>?>8PcG<@>! >S>8B8R! :E;>P9G>:C! <8P! QD:@! BQHDA@<8@GIC! FDA! ;B:!

ED8:@<8@!:9HHDA@!<8P!R9BP<8E>!@;AD9R;!<8!>WEA9EB<@B8RGI!:@A>::F9G!H;<:>!DF!QI!

GBF>O!*!TBGG!<GT<I:!DT>!@;>!@BQ>GI!EDQHG>@BD8!DF!@;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8!@D!;BQa!

• )8D@;>A!H>>A!Q>8@DA!<8P!<!RA><@!FAB>8PC!#B?;BG!X#B?Y!';<AQ<C!FDA!<GT<I:!Q<?B8R!

:9A>!*!T<:!D8!@A<E?!@D!FB8B:;!D8!@BQ>C!<8P!FDA!ED8:@<8@GI!B8:HBAB8R!Q>!@D!>WE>G!<8P!

FDA!G>@@B8R!;BQ!UD@;>Ac8<R!;BQ!TB@;!ED8:@<8@!Z9>:@BD8:C!>S>8!<EAD::!ED8@B8>8@:a!*!

TBGG!<GT<I:!U>!RA<@>F9G!@D!;BQ!FDA!;>GHB8R!Q>!R>@!@;AD9R;!@;>!G<:@!G<HC!T;>@;>A!B@!

Q><8@!Q>!UA<B8:@DAQB8R!DA!EDQHG<B8B8Ra!!

• (;A>>! F<8@<:@BE! FAB>8P:! <8P! EDGG><R9>:! FADQ! @;>! /D;>8! G<UC! 1BE;<>G! $BQI<8C!

)GB::<! 0D9A?<:C! '98UB8! X'IGSB>Y! 'D8RC! T;D! ;<S>! U>>8! <8! B8EA>PBUG>! :D9AE>! DF!

QD@BS<@BD8C! G><PB8R! UI! >W<QHG>! TB@;! @;>BA! PBGBR>8E>! <8P!QD:@! BQHDA@<8@GI! FDA!

<GT<I:!U>B8R!@;>A>C!<8P!FDA!UAB8RB8R!G<9R;@>A!<8P!F98!QI!T<I!P9AB8R!:DQ>!DF!QI!

@D9R;>:@!@BQ>:a!!

• )! F>GGDT! ->H>! <PSB:>>C! 2<A:;<S<AP;<8! X2<A:;9Y! )R<:;>C! FDA! U>B8R! <! :9H>AU!

EDGG><R9>! <8P! FAB>8PC! <8P! <! RD4@D! H>A:D8! @D! PB:E9::! <8P! A<8@! <UD9@! :BR8<G!

HADE>::B8R! <8P!1<@G<U! HADRA<QQB8Ra! *! DT>!QI! A>R<B8>P! ED88>E@BD8!TB@;! <8P!

v !

GDS>! FDA!Q<@;>Q<@BE:! @D! ;BQ! <8P! ;B:! H<@B>8E>! <:! ;>!TAD@>! >Z9<@BD8:! V9:@! :D! *!

TD9GP!8D@!U<PR>A!;BQ!TB@;!QDA>!H<B8F9G!Z9>:@BD8:a!!!

• (;>!#*12!1%+!EDA>! @><Q4!(DQ!2DGADIPC!0A>P!/<AS>A!<8P!$<8B!&9UB8:@>B8C! FDA!

E;>>AB8R!Q>!D8!@D!FB8B:;C!T;BG>!ED8:@<8@GI!:9HHDA@B8R!Q>!@;AD9R;!@;>!@AB<G:!<8P!

@ABU9G<@BD8:!DF!G><A8B8R!"8BW!<8P!5<:;!HADRA<QQB8Ra!!

• (;>! 29Q<8! /DA@BE<G! -;I:BDGDRI! '>E@BD8! X2/-'Y! A>:><AE;! EDDAPB8<@DA:C! ';<:;B!

&<SB8PA<8! <8P! &B@<! =DG<I<E;>SC! FDA! @;>BA! ED8:@<8@! :QBG>:! T;BG>! T<G?B8R! Q>!

@;AD9R;! @;>! 2>AE9G><8! @<:?! DF! T<PB8R! @;AD9R;! @;>! <PQB8B:@A<@BS>! HADE>::! DF!

A>EA9B@B8R!<8P!ED8P9E@B8R!EGB8BE<G!A>:><AE;!TB@;!;9Q<8!:9UV>E@:!<@!@;>!#*2a!!

• (;>!#*2!5BDT9GF!)PS<8E>P!/G9:@>A!/DQH9@B8R!<8P!B@:!:9HHDA@!@><QC!FDA!>8<UGB8R!

@;B:!A>:><AE;!Q>@;DPDGDRIO!

• (><Q! #>9A<G! %8RB8>>AB8R! <8P! -AD:@;>@BE:! .<U! <@! "1$4! H<A@BE9G<AGIC! (A>8@!

5A<PU>AAIC! 0>8R! &D8RC! &DPDGH;>! +>8@BGB! <8P! (><Q! 29Q<8! /DA@BE<G! -;I:BDGDRI!

'>E@BD8!<@!@;>!#*2C!FDA!<GG!@;>BA!;>GH!<8P!:9HHDA@!@;AD9R;!@;>!I><A:O!

• )!F<U9GD9:!<8P!B8PB:H>8:<UG>!:>@!DF!FAB>8P:C!FDA!!"##$%&'"!'($#)!<:!T>GG!<:!!"**$%&'

+,! @;AD9R;!\!P>RA>>:! X<8P!:>>QB8RGI!8>S>A4>8PB8R!:E;DDGB8RaYC!<8P!FDA!<GT<I:!

?>>HB8R!Q>!B8!@D9E;!TB@;!A><GB@I!@;<@!>WB:@>P!D9@:BP>!@;>!G<Ua!

• 1I!TD8P>AF9G!A>G<@BS>:C!FDA!@;>BA!ED8:@<8@!T>GG!TB:;>:!<8P!HA<I>A:O!

• 1D:@! BQHDA@<8@GIC!QI! GDSB8R!H<A>8@:C! FDA!<GT<I:!>8ED9A<RB8R!Q>!@D!H9A:9>!QI!

PA><Q:C!FDA!:9HHDA@B8R!<GG!QI!P>EB:BD8:C!<8P!<UDS>!<GGC!FDA!@><E;B8R!Q>!@D!TDA?!

;<AP!<8P!:@ABS>!@D!>WE>Ga!*!<Q!FDA>S>A!B8P>U@>P!@D!QI!)HH<!<8P!)QQ<!FDA!U>B8R!

vi !

QI!:D9AE>!DF! :@A>8R@;!<8P! FDA! @;>BA!98ED8PB@BD8<G! GDS>C! @D!:>>!QI! @;AD9R;! @;B:!

PB::>A@<@BD8O!!

• .<:@C! <8P! 98PD9U@>PGIC! @;>! QD:@! BQHDA@<8@! H>A:D8! B8! QI! GBF>C! QI! ;9:U<8P!

):;TB8C!FDA!;B:!B8EA>PBUG>!GDS>C!FAB>8P:;BHC!:9HHDA@C!98P>A:@<8PB8R!<8P!H<@B>8E>O!

$>:HB@>!?8DTB8RGI!T<?B8R! B8@D!<! A>G<@BD8:;BH!TB@;!<!H>A:D8!T;D!;<P!:E;>P9G>4

G>::!JdWe!T>>?:C!<8P!8D@;B8R!U9@!ED8:@<8@!:EB>8@BFBE!U<8@>A!DA!:@A>::!@D!DFF>A!D8!

QD:@!P<I:C!;>!:@BGG! <GT<I:!Q<8<R>P! @D! FB8P!<!T<I! @D!Q<?>!Q>!:QBG>!<8P!>8VDI!

GBF>O! *@! B:! QD:@! FB@@B8R! @D! :<I! @;<@! *! ED9GP! 8D@! ;<S>! EDQHG>@>P! @;B:! PB::>A@<@BD8!

TB@;D9@!;BQa!*!ED8:BP>A!QI:>GF!G9E?I!@D!;<S>!;BQ!B8!QI!GBF>C!<8P!<Q!A><GGI!@;ABGG>P!

@D!U>!<UG>!@D!:;<A>!@;B:!<E;B>S>Q>8@!DF!<!GBF>@BQ>!TB@;!;BQO!!

'

'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

vii !

$!"=7'9@'&9:$7:$#'

!"#$%!&$'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'(!

.+5(41)(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'((!

!4B2,C*+5D+E+2)/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'(((!

$1F*+',-'4,2)+2)/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'G((!

=(/)',-'@(DH0+/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'(I!

=(/)',-'$1F*+/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'I!

&J1K)+0'L3'82)0,5H4)(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'L!#K+4(-(4'!(E/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'M!#(D2(-(4124+'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'N!

&J1K)+0'O3'%+G(+C',-'=()+01)H0+'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'LP!QJ6/(,*,D(41*'+--+4)/',-').&#'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'LO!<J1)'412'F01(2'2+)C,0B'121*6/(/'(2-,0E'1F,H)'2+H0,K*1/)(4()6R'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'LS!:+H0,K*1/)(4'+--+4)/',-').&#',2'F01(2'2+)C,0B/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'LT!

09@9A>!PBA>E@BD8:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!JL!?+)J,5/'),'/)H56'4J12D+/'(2'F01(2'2+)C,0B/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'OO!

)Y!5GB8P!1DP>G4FA>>!)8<GI:B:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!J\!5Y!/D88>E@BSB@I!)8<GI:B:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!Jd!

&J1K)+0'U3'/K+4(-(4'1(E'L'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UP!82)0,5H4)(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UP!?+)J,5/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UL!

%WH>ABQ>8@<G!HADE>P9A>!<8P!$<@<!<EZ9B:B@BD8!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!\L!$<@<!-A>4HADE>::B8R!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!\\!*8P>H>8P>8@!/DQHD8>8@!)8<GI:B:!<8P!/G9:@>AB8R!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!\\!

%+/H*)/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UM!.(/4H//(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UT!

+>8>A<G!/D8:BP>A<@BD8:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!\e!/GB8BE<G!*QHGBE<@BD8:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!\e!

&,24*H/(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UN!

&J1K)+0'M3'/K+4(-(4'1(E'O'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UV!82)0,5H4)(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'UV!?+)J,5/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'MO!

%WH>ABQ>8@<G!HADE>P9A>!<8P!$<@<!<EZ9B:B@BD8!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!dJ!$<@<!-A>4HADE>::B8R!<8P!'I8@;>@BE!)H>A@9A>!1<R8>@DQ>@ABE!X')1Y!)8<GI:B:!OOOOOOOO!dJ!/D88>E@BSB@I!<8<GI:B:!9:B8R!+A<8R>A!/<9:<GB@I!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!dd!

%+/H*)/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'MW!/;<8R>:!B8!.DT!+<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!df!/;<8R>:!B8!2BR;!+<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!dg!

viii !

.(/4H//(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'SP!

&J1K)+0'S3'/K+4(-(4'1(E'U'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'SM!82)0,5H4)(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'SM!?+)J,5/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'SW!

%WH>ABQ>8@<G!HADE>P9A>!<8P!$<@<!<EZ9B:B@BD8!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!he!%WH>ABQ>8@<G!(<:?!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!hf!5>;<SBDA<G!$<@<!)8<GI:B:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!iK!#>9ADQ<R8>@BE!$<@<!)8<GI:B:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!iL!

%+/H*)/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'TU!5>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:!P9AB8R!)P<H@<@BD8!<8P!'<SB8R:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!i\!0AD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!E;<8R>:!P9AB8R!)P<H@<@BD8!<8P!'<SB8R:!OOOOOO!ih!

#>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!B8!)P<H@<@BD8!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!if!#>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!B8!'<SB8R:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!ig!

.(/4H//(,2'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'WL!-DG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!D8!=B:9DQD@DA!)P<H@<@BD8!<8P!'<SB8R:!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!eL!-DG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!D8!G>F@!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!B8!)P<H@<@BD8!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!eJ!-DG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!D8!G>F@!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!B8!'<SB8R:!eh!+<QQ<!D:EBGG<@BD8:!<8P!#>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!ee!

&J1K)+0'T3'>7:7%!='.8#&X##89:'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'WV!

%+-+0+24+/'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'NO!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

ix !

=8#$'9@'@8>X%7#'

&J1K)+0'O'0BRO! LO! )! :E;>Q<@BE! :9QQ<AI! DF! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! X@$/'Y! >FF>E@:!DS>A!1LjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOJK!!&J1K)+0'U'0BRO!LO!%WH>ABQ>8@<G!@BQ>GB8>!:;DTB8R!-A>!<8P!-D:@4@$/'!A>:@!1%+!A>EDAPB8R:jjjjj\J!0BRO!JO!&><G! @$/'!>8R<R>P!<!H<AB>@D4QD@DA!8>@TDA?! BQQ>PB<@>GI!<8P!JK!QB89@>:!<F@>A!:@BQ9G<@BD8!A>:H>E@BS>GIjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjO\h!0BRO! \O! &><G! @$/'! <G:D! E<9:>P! @;>!H<AB>@D4QD@DA!8>@TDA?! @D! @A<8:B>8@GI! >8R<R>! FAD8@<G!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjO\i!!&J1K)+0'M'0BRO! LO! '@A9E@9A<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! QDP>G! FDA! +A<8R>A! /<9:<GB@I! XDA! ('*Y! <8<GI:B:! DF!;IHD@;>:B[>P! E<9:<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! U>@T>>8! A>RBD8:! DF! <! UBG<@>A<G! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOdL!0BRO!JO!%WH>ABQ>8@<G!@BQ>GB8>!:;DTB8R!-A>!<8P!-D:@4@$/'!A>:@!1%+!A>EDAPB8R:jjjjjdJ!0BRO!\O!!/;<8R>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'!B8!GDT!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!FDA!@;>!\!:@BQ9G<@BD8!ED8PB@BD8:jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjdf!0BRO!dO!!/;<8R>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'!B8!;BR;!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!FDA!@;>!\!:@BQ9G<@BD8!ED8PB@BD8:jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjhK!!&J1K)+0'S'0BRO! LO! %WH>ABQ>8@<G! @BQ>GB8>! :;DTB8R! -A>! <8P! -D:@4@$/'! 1%+! A>EDAPB8R:! P9AB8R!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!`!:<SB8R:jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjhg!0BRO!JO!-<8>G:!:;DTB8R!@;>!:EA>>8!<HH><A<8E>!P9AB8R!@<:?!H>AFDAQ<8E>jjjjjjjjjiK!0BRO!\O!/;<8R>:!B8!Q><8!PBA>E@BD8<G!>AADA!Xk!:@<8P<AP!>AADAY!<EAD::!:9UV>E@:!DS>A!@;>!@AB<G!UGDE?:!B8!@;>!>WH>ABQ>8@jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjid!0BRO! dO! ! $BFF>A>8E>:! B8! G><A8B8R! A<@>:! P9AB8R! )P<H@<@BD8! <8P! '<SB8R:! FDGGDTB8R!@$/'jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOOih!0BRO! hO! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'!TB@;B8! @;>! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<@!@;>!>8P!DF!)P<H@<@BD8jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOOii!0BRO! iO! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'!TB@;B8! @;>! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<@!@;>!>8P!DF!'<SB8R:jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjie!0BRO! eO! &>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8!)P<H@<@BD8! FDGGDTB8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! B:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! PBFF>A>8@! FADQ! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q!@$/'jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOOOOif!0BRO! fO! &>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8!'<SB8R:! FDGGDTB8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! B:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! PBFF>A>8@! FADQ! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q!@$/'jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOeK!!!

x !

=8#$'9@'$!"=7#'

'&J1K)+0'M'(<UG>O! LO! (<BG<A<E;! EDDAPB8<@>:! DF! &>RBD8:! DF! *8@>A>:@! X&,*Y! B8! .>F@! 0AD8@DH<AB>@<G!#>@TDA?jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjOdh!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

1 !

&Y!Q$7%'L3'8:$%9.X&$89:'

#>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8! B:! @;>! Q<B8:@<I! B8! @;>! GD8R4@>AQ! @A><@Q>8@! DF! F98E@BD8<G!

PB:<UBGB@B>:! B8! H<@B>8@:! :9FF>AB8R! FADQ! PB:DAP>A! GB?>! :@AD?>! <8P! @A<9Q<@BE! UA<B8! B8V9AIO!

*QHADSB8R!>FFBEB>8EI!DF!A>;<UBGB@<@BS>!<HHAD<E;>:!E<8!@;9:!:BR8BFBE<8@GI! BQHADS>!Z9<GB@I!

DF! GBF>! B8! @;>:>!H<@B>8@:!T;BG>!ED8EDQB@<8@GI! A>P9EB8R!ED:@:!DF!;><G@;E<A>!HADSB:BD8O! *8!

@;B:!ED8@>W@C!@>E;8BZ9>:!@;<@!;>GH!;<A8>::!<8P!<9RQ>8@!B8@AB8:BE!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IC!BO>OC!@;>!

8>ASD9:! :I:@>Ql:! <UBGB@I! @D! QDPBFI! B@:>GF! B8! A>:HD8:>! @D! 8>T! >WH>AB>8E>:C! B8! @;>!

A>EDS>AB8R!UA<B8!<E@!<:!BQHDA@<8@!<PV98E@:!DF!8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8!B8!@;>!EGB8BE<G!:>@@B8RO!

#D84B8S<:BS>! EDA@BE<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! @>E;8BZ9>:! :9E;! <:! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@!

:@BQ9G<@BD8! X@$/'Y! B:! <! H<B84FA>>C! QB8BQ<G! AB:?! Q>@;DP! @D! F98E@BD8<GGI! QDP9G<@>!

8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! B8! ;9Q<8:C! @;9:! <E@B8R! <:! <! HD@>8@B<GGI! BQHDA@<8@! <PV98E@BS>! @DDG! FDA!

8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8!X$BQI<8!`!/D;>8C!JKLLm!29QQ>G!`!/D;>8C!JKKiYO!(;>!TBP>:HA><P!

9:>!DF! @;B:! @>E;8BZ9>C! @;9:C! A<B:>:! <8! BQHDA@<8@!Z9>:@BD8! <UD9@! @;>!98P>AGIB8R!8>9A<G!

Q>E;<8B:Q:!Q>PB<@B8R!@;>!DU:>AS>P!8>9ADHG<:@BE!E;<8R>:O!!

-A>SBD9:! A>:><AE;! ;<:! :;DT8! @;<@! <8DP<G! XHD:B@BS>! HDG<AB@IY! @$/'! B8EA><:>:!

EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I!T;BG>!E<@;DP<G!X8>R<@BS>!HDG<AB@IY!@$/'!P>HA>::>:!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I!

B8! R>8>A<G! X1O! #B@:E;>! >@! <GOC! JKKf<YO! ! 'H>EBFBE<GGIC! <8DP<G! @$/'! DS>A! :>8:DABQD@DA!

EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:!;<:!U>>8!:;DT8!@D!BQHADS>!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@IC!<:!>SBP>8E>P!UI!

B8EA><:>P! <QHGB@9P>:! DF!QD@DA! >SD?>P!HD@>8@B<G:! <:!T>GG! <:! >8;<8E>P! :DQ<@D:>8:DAI!

HADE>::B8R!X1<@:98<R<C!#B@:E;>C!(:9VBC!`!&D@;T>GGC!JKKdYO!09A@;>AC!ED9HGB8R!<8DP<G!@$/'!

@D!@;>!QD@DA!EDA@>W!TB@;!<!U>;<SBDA<G!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!@<:?!;<:!U>>8!:;DT8!@D!>8;<8E>!

H>AFDAQ<8E>! BQHADS>Q>8@:! X)8@<G! >@! <GOC! JKKdm!1O!)O!#B@:E;>! >@! <GOC! JKK\m! &>B:! >@! <GOC!

2 !

JKKgYO! 6;BG>! @;>A>! B:! :9FFBEB>8@! >SBP>8E>! @D! :9HHDA@! @;>! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! QDP9G<@BD8!

B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'C! @;>A>! B:! :9AHAB:B8RGI! G>::! A>:><AE;! <UD9@! @;>! H9@<@BS>!Q>E;<8B:Q! DF!

<E@BD8!DF!@$/'O!&>E>8@GIC!<8DP<G!@$/'!;<:!U>>8!:;DT8!@D!B8P9E>!<8!<E@BSB@I4P>H>8P>8@!

UA<B84P>ABS>P! 8>9AD@ADH;BE! F<E@DA! <::DEB<@>P! :I8<H@BE! HG<:@BEB@I! B8! ADP>8@! QDP>G:!

X0AB@:E;!>@!<GOC!JKLKYO!*8!;9Q<8:C!Q<R8>@BE4A>:D8<8E>!:H>E@AD:EDHI!:9RR>:@:!@;<@!<8DP<G!

@$/'! <E@:! UI!P>EA><:B8R! GDE<G! R<QQ<4<QB8D4U9@IABE! <EBP! X+)5)Y! G>S>G:!T;BG>! E<@;DP<G!

@$/'! G><P:! @D! EDAA>G<@>P! A>P9E@BD8! B8! GDE<G! RG9@<Q<@>! <8P! +)5)! G>S>G:! X'@<RR! >@! <GOC!

JKKgYO! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:! HADSBP>! :DQ>! B8:BR;@! <UD9@! ;DT! @$/'!HADP9E>:! B@:! 8>9ADHG<:@BE!

>FF>E@:m!;DT>S>AC!B@!B:!PBFFBE9G@!@D!PA<T!B8F>A>8E>:!<UD9@!:H>EBFBE!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!B8P9E>P!

UI!@$/'!B8!:@BQ9G<@>P!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:O!!

'@9PIB8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@IC! <8! >Q>AR>8@! HADH>A@I! DF! B8@>A<E@BD8:! DF! U<:BE!

8>9AD8<G! HADE>::>:! <8P! F98E@BD8:C! B:! <8! BQHDA@<8@! :@>H! B8! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! @;>! UA<B8l:!

F98E@BD8<G! <8P! EDQH9@<@BD8<G! HADE>::>:! @D! Q<?>! QDA>! ;DGB:@BE! B8@>AHA>@<@BD8:! <UD9@!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! U<:B:! DF! U>;<SBDAO! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! <8! <HHAD<E;! EDQUB8B8R! @$/'! <8P!

8>9ADBQ<RB8R! DF! G<AR>4:E<G>! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! B:! <! HADQB:B8R! <HHAD<E;! @D! :@9PI!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G!8>@TDA?!B8@>A<E@BD8:!A>:9G@B8R!FADQ!GDE<G!8>9AD8<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I!@;<@!B:!

QDP9G<@>P!UI!@$/'C!@D!HADSBP>!<!P>>H>A!98P>A:@<8PB8R!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'O!

*QHDA@<8@GIC! @;B:! <HHAD<E;! <G:D! ;>GH:! P>S>GDH! HD@>8@B<G! 8>9A<G! UBDQ<A?>A:! DF! HG<:@BE!

A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! @;>! UA<B8! @;<@! E<8! ;<S>! F<A4A><E;B8R! BQH<E@! D8! <PQB8B:@>AB8R! <8P!

QD8B@DAB8R! DF! 8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BS>! B8@>AS>8@BD8:! B8! H<@B>8@:O! (;>A>! B:! :DQ>! A>E>8@!

>SBP>8E>! DF! 8>@TDA?4G>S>G! E;<8R>:! B8P9E>P! UI! <8DP<G! @$/'! DS>A! QD@DA! EDA@>WC!

EDQH<A>P! @D! :;<QC! <@! A>:@! B8! >G>E@AD>8E>H;<GDRA<H;BE! X%%+Y! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! X-DG<8n<C!

3 !

#B@:E;>C! `! -<9G9:C! JKLKY! <:! T>GG! <:! ;>QDPI8<QBE! UA<B8! A>:HD8:>:! A>EDAP>P! @;AD9R;!

F98E@BD8<G!Q<R8>@BE!A>:D8<8E>!BQ<RB8R!XF1&*Y!X-DG<8n<C!-<9G9:C!)8@<GC!`!#B@:E;>C!JKLLY!

<8P!HD:B@AD8!>QB::BD8!@DQDRA<H;I!X-%(Y!X.<8R!>@!<GOC!JKKhYO!(;>:>!:@9PB>:!P>QD8:@A<@>!

@;<@!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DS>A!<!FDE<G!UA<B8!A>RBD8!HADP9E>:!E;<8R>:!B8!TBP>:HA><P!

UA<B8!<E@BSB@IC!<@@ABU9@>P!B8!H<A@!@D!@;>!<G@>A<@BD8:!DF!B8@>A<E@BD8:cED88>E@BSB@I!U>@T>>8!

PBFF>A>8@!8>9A<G!A>RBD8:!@;<@!EDQHAB:>!<!G<AR>4:E<G>!F98E@BD8<G!UA<B8!8>@TDA?O!2DT>S>AC!

<! EDQHA>;>8:BS>! <EED98@! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! QDP9G<@BD8! UI! @$/'! B:! :@BGG! G<E?B8RC!

:H>EBFBE<GGI! @D! EDQH<A>! B@:! >FF>E@:! D8! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! <@! A>:@! S>A:9:! P9AB8R! QD@DA! @<:?!

H>AFDAQ<8E>! @;<@! B:! 8>E>::<AI! @D! 98P>A:@<8P! @;>! 8<@9A>! DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! QDP9G<@BD8!

B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'O!!

'H>EBFBE<GGIC!B@!B:!BQHDA@<8@!@D!P>@>AQB8>!T;>@;>A!@;>!U>;<SBDA<G!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!

<A>! Q>A>GI! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;! >8;<8E>P! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?! <E@BS<@BD8! DA! B8! F<E@C! EDA@BE<G!

8>@TDA?! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! T;>A>B8! HA>SBD9:GI! B8<E@BS>cG>::! <E@BS>! 8DP>:! DF! @;>! 8>@TDA?!

<8P! @;>BA! B8@>A<E@BD8:!TB@;! D@;>A! 8DP>:! U>EDQ>!QDA>! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! <E@BS<@>P! X,o';><C!

MD;<8:>845>ARC! (AB>FC! +pU>GC! `! &9:;TDA@;C! JKKeYO! (;B:! B:! <8! BQHDA@<8@! :@>H! @DT<AP:!

P>S>GDHB8R! QDA>! >FF>E@BS>! <HHGBE<@BD8:! FDA! @;>A<H>9@BE! H9AHD:>:! B8! H<@B>8@:! TB@;!

@A<9Q<@BE! UA<B8! B8V9AI! <8P! :@AD?>! @D! HADP9E>! F<SDA<UG>! UB<:>:! B8! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?!

DAR<8B[<@BD8!FDA!BQHADSB8R!F98E@BD8<G!QD@DA!H>AFDAQ<8E>O!

(;>! HABQ<AI! FDE9:! DF! @;B:! PB::>A@<@BD8C! @;9:C! B:! @D! :I:@>Q<@BE<GGI! P>@>AQB8>!

HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!D8! G<AR>4:E<G>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!TB@;!@;>!<BQ!DF!

>WHG<B8B8R! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! Q>E;<8B:Q:! QDPBFB>P! UI! @$/'! @;AD9R;! @;A>>! :H>EBFBE! <BQ:!

D9@GB8>P! U>GDTO! (;B:! B8SDGS>:! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! QDP>G4FA>>! <:! T>GG! <:! QDP>G4U<:>P!

4 !

<8<GI@BE<G! <HHAD<E;>:! @D! T;DG>! ;><P! UA<B8! PI8<QBE:! @D! HADSBP>! <! ABRDAD9:!

E;<A<E@>AB[<@BD8! DF! @;>:>! >FF>E@:! D8! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?! DAR<8B[<@BD8! <8P! PI8<QBE:O!

'H>EBFBE<GGIC!@;>:>!>FF>E@:!TBGG!U>!:@9PB>P!B8!A>G<@BD8!@D!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8!B8!@;>!

ED8@>W@!DF!E;<8R>:!B8P9E>P!B8!:DQ<@DQD@DA!8>@TDA?:!8>E>::<AI!FDA!QD@DA!G><A8B8RO!!

'

#K+4(-(4'!(E/'

#K+4(-(4' !(E' LA' $,' (5+2)(-6' 0+/)(2D' ,/4(**1),06' F01(2' 2+)C,0B' 5621E(4/' 1--+4)+5' F6'

E,),0'4,0)(41*').&#'H/(2D'1'0,FH/)'E,5+*Z-0++'121*6)(41*'1KK0,14JA'

*8!@;B:!ED8@>W@C!<!Q>@;DP!EDQUB8B8R!B8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:!X*/)Y!<8P!

:@<@B:@BE<G!EG9:@>AB8R!B:!<!ADU9:@C!UGB8P!<8P!P<@<4PABS>8!<HHAD<E;!@D!P>:EABU>!G<AR>4:E<G>!

UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! E;<8R>:O! (;B:! @>E;8BZ9>! B:! S>AI! 9:>F9G! @D! BP>8@BFI! F98E@BD8<G!

8>@TDA?:! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;! 8>9A<G! HADE>::>:! <8P! P>:EABU>! @;>BA! D:EBGG<@DAI! PI8<QBE:O!

2>A>C!8>9ADGDRBE<GGI!;><G@;I!<P9G@:!TBGG!U>!@>:@>PC!U>FDA>!<8P!9H!@D!\K!QB8!<F@>A!>8P!DF!

@$/'C! @D! HA>EB:>GI! BP>8@BFI! :H>EBFBE! 8>@TDA?:! QDP9G<@>P! UI! @$/'! <8P! >:@<UGB:;! @;>!

@>QHDA<G! HADFBG>! DF! H>A:B:@>8E>! DF! @;>:>! >FF>E@:! B8! @>AQ:! DF! @;>BA! >G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G!

PI8<QBE:! A>EDAP>P! UI!Q<R8>@D>8E>H;<GDRA<H;I! X1%+YO! 1%+! B:! H<A@BE9G<AGI! 9:>F9G! B8!

@;B:!ED8@>W@!DTB8R!@D!B@:!;BR;!@>QHDA<G!<8P!:H<@B<G!:DG9@BD8C!;BR;!:BR8<G4@D48DB:>!A<@BDC!<:!

T>GG! <:! @;>! HA<E@BE<G! <PS<8@<R>:! DF! QB8BQ<G! :>@49H! @BQ>! 8>E>::<AI! FDA! @>QHDA<G!

ED8:@A<B8@:!BQHD:>P!UI!@;B:!>WH>ABQ>8@<G!P>:BR8O!

2IHD@;>:B:!L]!+BS>8!@;<@!HA>SBD9:!:@9PB>:!;<S>!BP>8@BFB>P!:>8:DABQD@DA!8>@TDA?:!@D!U>!

E;<A<E@>AB[>P! UI! D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@I! B8! <GH;<! Xf4LJ! 2[Y! <8P! U>@<! XL\4\K! 2[Y! X1<8@B8BC!

->AA9EEBC!P>G!+A<@@<C!&DQ<8BC!`!/DAU>@@<C!JKKeYC! B@! B:!;IHD@;>:B[>P!@;<@!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!

5 !

A>EA9B@B8R!H<AB>@D4QD@DA!A>RBD8:!E;<A<E@>AB[>P!:H>E@A<GGI!UI!E;<8R>:! B8!<GH;<!<8P!U>@<!

U<8P! HDT>A! <F@>A! A><G! @$/'! A>G<@BS>! @D! :;<Q! TD9GP! U>! BP>8@BFB>PO! )PPB@BD8<GGIC! ;BR;!

FA>Z9>8EI!R<QQ<!U<8P!<E@BSB@I!Xq!dK!2[Y!Q<I!U>!<G@>A>P!UI!@$/'!:B8E>!B@!B:!A>FG>E@BS>!DF!

>8R<R>Q>8@!DF!GDE<G!8>9AD8<G!EBAE9B@AIcHADE>::>:O!'B8E>!U>;<SBDA<G!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!;<S>!

U>>8!>WH>E@>P!@D! G<:@!<@! G><:@!\K!QB8!@D!<8!;D9A!<F@>A!:@BQ9G<@BD8!X1O!#B@:E;>C!/D;>8C!

6<::>AQ<88C! -ABDABC! .<8RC! )8@<GC! -<9G9:C! 29QQ>GC! 5DRRBDC! `! 0A>R8BC! JKKf<YC! B@! T<:!

;IHD@;>:B[>P! @;<@! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! TD9GP! A>Q<B8! <G@>A>P! <@! G><:@! 9H! @D! \K! QB8! <:!

:@9PB>P!;>A>O!!

!

#K+4(-(4' !(E' OA' $,' 5+)+0E(2+' +--+4)/' ,-' E,),0' 4,0)(41*' ).&#' ,2' (2)+014)(,2/' C()J(2'

/K+4(-(4' E,),0' 2+)C,0B[/\' (5+2)(-(+5' (2' #!L' H/(2D' 1' 5621E(4' 4,22+4)(G()6ZF1/+5'

121*6)(41*'1KK0,14JA'

(;>! ADU9:@! QDP>G4FA>>! Q>@;DP! B8! ')! L! TBGG! ;>GH! HADSBP>! <8! 98UB<:>P!

BP>8@BFBE<@BD8!DF!8>@TDA?:!QDP9G<@>P!UI!A><G!@$/'!<:!EDQH<A>P!@D!:;<QO!2DT>S>AC!D8>!

GBQB@<@BD8! DF! @;B:! Q>@;DP! B:! @;<@! B@! PD>:! 8D@! BP>8@BFI! E;<8R>:! B8! TB@;B8! 8>@TDA?!

B8@>A<E@BD8:C! GB?>! E;<8R>:! B8! ED88>E@BSB@I! U>@T>>8! PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:! B8SDGS>P! B8! @;<@!

8>@TDA?O! (;9:C! B@! B:! BQHDA@<8@! @D! Z9<8@BFI! @;>:>! B8@>A<E@BD8:! TB@;B8! @;>! BP>8@BFB>P!

8>@TDA?!QDP9G<@>P!UI! @$/'! <:! B@! E<8!U>!9:>F9G! <:! <!Q<A?>A!DF! >W@>8@!DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BE!

<G@>A<@BD8:! B8P9E>P! UI! @;>! @$/'C! T;BE;! E<8! @;>8! U>! A>G<@>P! @D! U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:!

DU:>AS>P!TB@;!@$/'O!*8!@;B:!ED8@>W@C!:@A9E@9A<G!>Z9<@BD8!QDP>GB8R!X'%1Y!B:!<8!>W@A>Q>GI!

ADU9:@!Q>@;DP!@;<@!E<8!U>!<HHGB>P!@D!<!ED88>E@BSB@I!QDP>G!:H>EBFB>P!U>@T>>8!PBFF>A>8@!

UA<B8!A>RBD8:!B8SDGS>P!B8!<8I!RBS>8!8>@TDA?!X5rE;>G!`!0AB:@D8C!JKKKm!&DT>C!JKLKm!&DT>!

6 !

>@! <GOC! JKKJm! ';<AQ<C! 5<AD8C! `! &DT>C! JKKgYO! 2DT>S>AC! P9>! @D! B8;>A>8@! @>QHDA<G!

EDAA>G<@BD8! TB@;B8! 8>9A<G! <E@BSB@I! @BQ>! :>AB>:C! +A<8R>A! /<9:<GB@I! >:@BQ<@BD8! U<:>P! D8!

Q9G@BS<AB<@>! A>RA>::BD8! X/;>8!>@! <GOC! JKLLY!TBGG! U>!<HHGB>P! @D! :@9PI! B8@>A<E@BD8:!TB@;B8!

8>@TDA?:O!

2IHD@;>:B:! J]! 5<:>P! D8! ')! LC! B@! B:! >WH>E@>P! @;<@! <! H<AB>@D4QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! TBGG! U>!

QDP9G<@>P!UI!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!A>G<@BS>!@D!:;<QO!(;9:C!@;>!8DP>:!XBO>OC!UA<B8!A>RBD8:!

DU@<B8>P! UI! @A<8:FDAQB8R! 1%+! :>8:DA! P<@<! @D! <8<@DQBE<G! UA<B8! A>RBD8! @;AD9R;! <8!

B8S>A:>!:DG9@BD8Y!TB@;B8!<!:H>EBFBE!G>F@!H<AB>@D4FAD8@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?!X/;>8!>@!<GOC!JKLLm!

';<AQ<! >@! <GOC! JKKgY! TBGG! U>! :9UV>E@>P! @D! P<@<4PABS>8! +A<8R>A! /<9:<GB@I! )8<GI:B:! @D!

>:@BQ<@>!H<@;!ED>FFBEB>8@:!DF!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@IO! *@! B:!>WH>E@>P!@;<@!<8DP<G!@$/'!TBGG!

:H>EBFBE<GGI!B8EA><:>!:@A>8R@;!DF!8>@TDA?!B8@>A<E@BD8:!DF!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>W!X1LY!TB@;!

HA>QD@DA! <8P! :9HHG>Q>8@<AI! QD@DA! EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:C! X';<AQ<! >@! <GOC! JKKgY! T;BG>!

E<@;DP<G!@$/'!B:!>WH>E@>P!@D!P>EA><:>!@;>:>!B8@>A<E@BD8:O!'H>EBFBE<GGIC!@;B:!ED88>E@BSB@I!B:!

>WH>E@>P! @D! U>! DEE9AAB8R! B8! ;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI! U>@<! <8P! R<QQ<! XUAD<P4U<8PY! D:EBGG<@DAI!

U<8P:!X<?B8!@D!ED;>A>8E>YO!*@!B:!<G:D!GB?>GI!@;<@!GD8R4A<8R>!B8@>A<E@BD8:!DF!HA>QD@DA!<8P!

:9HHG>Q>8@<AI!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:!TB@;!H<AB>@<G!<8P!HA>FAD8@<G!EDA@>W!Q<I!U>!<G@>A>P!B8!@;>!

<GH;<!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P!UI!A><G!@$/'!X<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<GY!EDQH<A>P!@D!:;<QO!

!

#K+4(-(4'!(E'UA'$,'5+)+0E(2+')J+' (2-*H+24+',-'4J12D+/' (2'F01(2'2+)C,0B',0D12(]1)(,2'

[(5+2)(-(+5' (2' #!L' ^' O\' (25H4+5' F6'E,),0' 4,0)(41*' ).&#' ,2' *+102(2D' ),' 151K)'E,),0'

K+0-,0E124+'),'1'2,G+*'/+2/,0(E,),0'4,2)+I)'[(A+A_'G(/H,E,),0'151K)1)(,2\A'

7 !

(;>! >FF>E@! DF! :H>EBFBE! 8>@TDA?! B8@>A<E@BD8:! BO>OC! EDA@BE<G! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8C! QDP9G<@>P! UI!

@$/'!D8!H>AFDAQ<8E>!E;<8R>:!<::DEB<@>P!TB@;!QD@DA! G><A8B8R! B:!8D@!?8DT8O!2>A>C! B@! B:!

BQHDA@<8@!@D!9:>!<!U>;<SBDA<G!G><A8B8R!@<:?!@;<@!B:!ADU9:@!>8D9R;!@D!B8P9E>!H>AFDAQ<8E>!

E;<8R>:! TB@;B8! A><:D8<UGI! :;DA@! HA<E@BE>! P9A<@BD8! DF! <UD9@! \K! QB89@>:! X@;>!

;IHD@;>:B[>P! P9A<@BD8! DF! H>A:B:@>8E>! DF! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! D8! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:YO!

(;9:C!@D!>:@<UGB:;!@;B:!A>G<@BD8:;BH!U>@T>>8!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!EDAA>G<@>:!<8P!H>AFDAQ<8E>!

E;<8R>:C! @;A>>!RAD9H:!DF!8>9ADGDRBE<GGI!;><G@;I!<P9G@:!TBGG!H<A@BEBH<@>! B8!<!SB:9DQD@DA!

<P<H@<@BD8!@<:?!A>Z9BAB8R!@;>Q!@D!<P<H@!@;>BA!;<8P!QDS>Q>8@:!@D!<G@>A>P!:EA>>84E9A:DA!

A>G<@BD8:;BH:! <F@>A! A>E>BSB8R! <8DP<G! @$/'C! E<@;DP<G! @$/'! DA! :;<Q! DS>A! G>F@! 1L!

A>:H>E@BS>GIO! &>E>8@GIC! <8DP<G! @$/'!DS>A!1L!;<:!U>>8! :;DT8! @D! BQHADS>! A>@>8@BD8!DF!

:9E;! G><A8B8R! X+<G><C! =<[Z9>[C! -<:ABE;<C! ,AU<8! P>! sBSAIC! `! />G8B?C! JKLKYC! U9@! @;>!

98P>AGIB8R!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!E;<8R>:!<A>!8D@!?8DT8O!

2IHD@;>:B:! \OL]! )8DP<G! @$/'! B:! >WH>E@>P! @D! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! <EE>G>A<@>! G><A8B8R! XB8EA><:>!

A<@>!DF!G><A8B8RY!EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'O!

2IHD@;>:B:! \OJ]! *@! B:! >WH>E@>P! @;<@! @;>! :@A>8R@;>8>P!8>@TDA?! B8@>A<E@BD8:! DF!1L!TB@;!

HA>QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:!TBGG!EDAA>G<@>!U>;<SBDA<GGI!TB@;!;BR;>A!Q<R8B@9P>!DF! G><A8B8R!

B8!:9UV>E@:!A>E>BSB8R!<8DP<G!@$/'!EDQH<A>P!@D!@;D:>!A>E>BSB8R!:;<QO!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!B8!@;B:!

RAD9H! DF! :9UV>E@:C! >8;<8E>P! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! B8@>A<E@BD8:! B:! >WH>E@>P! @D! EDAA>G<@>!TB@;!

F<:@>A! A<@>! DF! G><A8B8RO! /<@;DP<G! @$/'! ED9GP! HADP9E>! @;>! DHHD:B@>! >FF>E@:! DA! 8D!

PBFF>A>8E>:!EDQH<A>P!@D!:;<QO!)G@>A8<@BS>GIC!<8DP<G!@$/'!ED9GP!HADP9E>!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!

B8!@;B:!H<AB>@D4FAD8@<G!8>@TDA?!TB@;D9@!<G@>AB8R!G><A8B8R!H>AFDAQ<8E>C!:9RR>:@B8R!@;<@!B@:!

8 !

Q>E;<8B:Q!DF!<E@BD8!Q<I! B8!H<A@!U>! A>G<@>P! @D! B8P9EB8R!UB<:>:! B8!8DP>:!DF! :@BQ9G<@>P!

8>@TDA?:O!!

!

#(D2(-(4124+''

! (;B:! A>:><AE;! HADRA<Q! B:! @;>! FBA:@! @D! HADSBP>! <! EDQHA>;>8:BS>C! :I:@>Q<@BE!

<EED98@! DF! >SBP>8E>! FDA! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! <G@>A<@BD8:! B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'! D8! G<AR>4:E<G>! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?!E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:!<8P!@;>BA!A>G<@BD8:;BH!@D!U>;<SBDA<G!U>8>FBEB<G!>FF>E@:!:>>8!TB@;!

@$/'O!(;B:!B:!<8!BQHDA@<8@!:@>H!@DT<AP:!98P>A:@<8PB8R!@;>!Q>E;<8B:Q:!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!

QDP9G<@BD8!E<9:>P!UI! @$/'! B8!DAP>A! FDA!<HHADHAB<@>!EGB8BE<G!<HHGBE<@BD8! B8!H<@B>8@:! FDA!

8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8O! *@! TBGG! ;>GH! B8P>8@BFI! U>;<SBDA<G! TB8PDT:! DF! DHHDA@98B@I! <F@>A!

<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!@$/'!FDA!@;>A<H>9@BE!B8@>AS>8@BD8:!B8!H<@B>8@:!@;<@!TBGG!;>GH!Q<WBQB[>!@;>!

U>8>FB@! DF! :@BQ9G<@BD8! <:! <8! <PV98E@BS>! @;>A<H>9@BE! @DDGO! 09A@;>AC! @;>! 8DS>G@I! <8P!

B88DS<@BD8! DF! @;B:! A>:><AE;! GB>:! B8! @;>! Q>@;DPBE<G! B8S>:@BR<@BD8! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?!

E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:!98P>AGIB8R!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IO! (;B:!TBGG! ;>GH! BP>8@BFI!HD@>8@B<G! 8D84B8S<:BS>!

8>9A<G!UBDQ<A?>A:!DF!8>9A<G!HG<:@BEB@IC!T;BE;!E<8!U>!>W@A>Q>GI!9:>F9G! B8!HA>PBE@B8R!<8P!

QD8B@DAB8R!H<@B>8@!A>:HD8:>!@D!@$/'!<:!T>GG!B@:!>FFBE<EI!<:!<!@A><@Q>8@O!1DA>!R>8>A<GGIC!

@;B:!TBGG! BQH<E@!P>S>GDHB8R!QDA>!DUV>E@BS>!<8P!Z9<8@B@<@BS>!EGB8BE<G!D9@EDQ>!Q><:9A>:!

B8! H<@B>8@:! @;<@! E<8! U>! 9:>P! FDA! ><AGI! PB<R8D:B:! <8P! HADRA>::BS>! H<@B>8@! >S<G9<@BD8! B8!

8>9ADGDRBE<G!PB:DAP>A:m! @;B:!TBGG!RA><@GI!;>GH! F<EBGB@<@>!>FF>E@BS>!8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8!<8P!

>8;<8E>!F98E@BD8<G!Z9<GB@I!DF!GBF>!B8!@;>:>!H<@B>8@:O!!!!!

! 0BS>! <PPB@BD8<G! E;<H@>A:! <A>! B8EG9P>P! B8! @;B:! PB::>A@<@BD8! HADHD:<GO! (;>! :>ED8P!

E;<H@>A! HA>:>8@:! <! A>SB>T! DF! @;>! A>G>S<8@! GB@>A<@9A>O! (;>! @;BAP! @;AD9R;! FBF@;! E;<H@>A:!

9 !

HA>:>8@!P>@<BG:!DF!@;>!@;A>>!:H>EBFBE!<BQ:!A>:H>E@BS>GIO!(;>!FB8<G!E;<H@>A!HA>:>8@:!<!UAB>F!

R>8>A<G!PB:E9::BD8!DF!@;>!:EDH>!DF!@;B:!A>:><AE;O!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

10 !

&Y!Q$7%'O3'%7`87<'9@'=8$7%!$X%7''

!"#$%&%&'()*+&,-*+&%+.(/%*0-)(-1**0&)(,)%#1.+)%"&(+&/(&01*"%#+'%&'2(&"30.(%&,%'4),(%&(

1&/0*,)+&/%&'(&01*"5.+,)%-%)67((([`+2B1)1B0(/J212'^'#1250(2(_'OPLO\(

a!'K10)',-')J(/'*()+01)H0+'0+G(+C'J1/'F++2'KHF*(/J+5'1/'4()+5'1F,G+bA'

!

-./#012#'

*8!A>E>8@!I><A:C!8D84B8S<:BS>!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8!@>E;8BZ9>:!GB?>!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!X@$/'Y!;<S>!R<B8>P!BQQ>8:>!HDH9G<AB@I!DTB8R!@D!@;>BA!>FF>E@:!D8!QDP9G<@B8R!

EDA@BE<G! <E@BSB@I! <8P! ED8:>Z9>8@GI! QD@DA! <8P! EDR8B@BS>! H>AFDAQ<8E>O! 2DT>S>AC! @;>!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRI! 98P>AGIB8R! :9E;! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! E;<8R>:! B:! G>::! 98P>A:@DDPO! (;B:! <A@BEG>!

EAB@BE<GGI!>S<G9<@>:!@;>!ED8@>QHDA<AI!<HHAD<E;!DF!EDQUB8>P!@$/'!<8P!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!<:!

<! Q><8:! @D! HADSBP>! 8DS>G! B8:BR;@:! B8! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! @;>! 8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! <8P!

8>9ADHG<:@BE!HADE>::>:!QDP9G<@>P!UI!@;B:!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8!@>E;8BZ9>O!6>!>8P!UI!UAB>FGI!

:9RR>:@B8R!F9A@;>A!GB8>:!DF!B8Z9BAIO!

!

%W@>A8<G! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! PBA>E@! >G>E@ABE<G! E9AA>8@! @D! @;>! ;><P! B:! D8>! DF! @;>! DGP>:@!

@>E;8BZ9>:! 9:>P! @D! QDP9G<@>! EDA@BE<G! >WEB@<UBGB@IO! (;>! 8D8B8S<:BS>! S>A:BD8! DF! PBA>E@!

E9AA>8@!<HHGBE<@BD8!@D!@;>!:E<GH!:9AF<E>!B:!QDA>!EDQQD8GI!?8DT8!<:!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!

E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! X@$/'YO! @$/'!QDP9G<@>:! EDA@BE<G! >WEB@<UBGB@I! UI! ED8:@<8@GI! <HHGIB8R!

T><?! >G>E@ABE<G! E9AA>8@! DS>A! @BQ>! @D! B8EA><:>! XHD:B@BS>! HDG<AB@IY! DA! P>EA><:>! X8>R<@BS>!

HDG<AB@IY! EDA@BE<G! >WEB@<UBGB@I! X#B@:E;>! >@! <GO! JKKfYO! (;B:! @>E;8BZ9>! ;<:! A>E>8@GI! U>>8!

A>B8@ADP9E>P! B8! 8>9AD:EB>8E>! A>:><AE;! UI! SBA@9>! DF! B@:! HD@>8@B<G! FDA! UD@;! @;>!

11 !

B8S>:@BR<@BD8!DF! E<9:<G! UA<B84U>;<SBDA! A>G<@BD8:;BH:! <8P! FDA! @;>! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8!DF!Q<8I!

PB:><:>:O! *@! B:!TDA@;!Q>8@BD8B8R!;>A>! @;<@!HADRA>::! B8!8>9AD:EB>8E>!DF@>8!P>H>8P:!D8!

@;>!ED8S>AR>8E>!DF!>SBP>8E>!FADQ!Q9G@BHG>!Q>@;DP:O!'B8E>!>S>AI!:B8RG>!@>E;8BZ9>!;<:!

B@:! DT8! GBQB@<@BD8:C! @;>A>! B:! <! EG><A! @;>DA>@BE<G! <PS<8@<R>! B8! EDQUB8B8R! PBFF>A>8@!

<HHAD<E;>:O! *8! @;>! G<:@! P>E<P>C! EDQUB8>P! @A<8:EA<8B<G! Q<R8>@BE! :@BQ9G<@BD8! X(1'Y4

8>9ADBQ<RB8R! :@9PB>:! ;<S>! RA><@GI! :@BQ9G<@>P! A>:><AE;! B8! 98P>A:@<8PB8R!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! <8P! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! >FF>E@:! B8P9E>P! UI! 8D8B8S<:BS>! UA<B8! :@BQ9G<@BD8!

X'B>U8>A!>@!<GO!JKKgYO!*8!@;B:!<A@BEG>C!;DT>S>AC!T>!EAB@BE<GGI!>S<G9<@>!@;>!>Q>AR>8E>!DF!@;>!

<HHAD<E;!@D!EDQUB8>!@$/'!TB@;!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!@>E;8BZ9>:!@D!98P>A:@<8P!@$/'4B8P9E>P!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G!>FF>E@:!D8!T;DG>!UA<B8!F98E@BD8<G!8>@TDA?:O!5>E<9:>!@;>!Q<VDAB@I!DF!

>SBP>8E>!;<:!U>>8!R<B8>P!A>E>8@GI!FADQ!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!@;>!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>W!X1LY!B8!

;><G@;I!:9UV>E@:C!T>!ED8E>8@A<@>!D8!@;>:>!:@9PB>:!<8P!>8P!UI!PB:E9::B8R!F9@9A>!A>:><AE;!

PBA>E@BD8:O!

'

9G+0G(+C',-').&#'15E(2(/)01)(,2'

@$/'!B:!@IHBE<GGI!<HHGB>P!@;AD9R;!<!UBHDG<A!>G>E@ADP>!QD8@<R>O!(;>!>G>E@ADP>:C!EDS>A>P!

UI!<!:HD8R>!:D<?>P!B8!<!ED8P9E@B8R!:DG9@BD8!GB?>!:<GB8>!DA!@<H!T<@>AC!<A>!<@@<E;>P!@D!@;>!

:9UV>E@l:! :E<GHO! (;>! <8DP>! B:! @;>!HD:B@BS>GI! E;<AR>P! >G>E@ADP>C! <8P! @;>! E<@;DP>! B:! @;>!

8>R<@BS>GI!E;<AR>P!>G>E@ADP>O!(;>!HABQ<AI!:@BQ9G<@BD8!H<A<Q>@>A:!@;<@!<A>!ED8@ADGG>P!UI!

@;>! >WH>ABQ>8@>A! B8EG9P>]!3Y! >G>E@ADP>! :B[>C!4Y! B8@>8:B@I! DF! :@BQ9G<@BD8C!5Y! P9A<@BD8!DF!

:@BQ9G<@BD8C!<8P!6Y!>G>E@ADP>!QD8@<R>O!(IHBE<GGIC!G<AR>!>G>E@ADP>!:B[>:!Xh!W!h!EQ!DA!h!W!e!

EQY! <A>! 9:>P! @D! Q<B8@<B8! <! GDT! E9AA>8@! P>8:B@I! :9E;! @;<@! @;>! :?B8! :>8:<@BD8! DF! @;>!

12 !

>G>E@ABE<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! B:! U><A<UG>! <8P! <G:D! @D! <SDBP! GDE<G! :?B8! U9A8:O! (;>! B8@>8:B@I! DF!

>G>E@ABE<G!E9AA>8@!9:>P!QD:@!EDQQD8GI!A<8R>!U>@T>>8!L!<8P!J!Q)C!TB@;!@;>!G<@@>A!U>B8R!

QDA>! EDQQD8! B8! QD8@<R>:! TB@;! D8>! >G>E@ADP>! U>B8R! HG<E>P! D8! <8! >W@A<4E>H;<GBE!

GDE<@BD8! GB?>! @;>! <AQO! /D9HG>P! TB@;! @;>! G<AR>! >G>E@ADP>! :9AF<E>! <A><C! @;>:>! GDT!

B8@>8:B@B>:! <GGDT!Q<B8@>8<8E>! DF! <8! DH@BQ<GC! :<F>! E9AA>8@! P>8:B@I! U>@T>>8! Jd! <8P! Jg!

t)cEQJ!X#B@:E;>!>@!<GO!JKKfYO!6;>8!<HHGB>P!FDA!:>S>A<G!QB89@>:C!@$/'!HADP9E>:!G<:@B8R!

>FF>E@:! B8! @;>!;9Q<8!EDA@>WO!(;>!P9A<@BD8!DF! @;>!>WEB@<UBGB@I! E;<8R>:! B8P9E>P!UI! @$/'!

P>H>8P:! D8! :@BQ9G<@BD8! P9A<@BD8O! (;>:>! <A>! :@<UG>! FDA! 9H! @D! <UD9@! <8! ;D9A! BF! @$/'! B:!

<HHGB>P! FDA! g! bL\! QB8! X#B@:E;>! >@! <GO! JKKfYO! 0B8<GGIC! @;>! >G>E@ADP>! QD8@<R>! FDA! @$/'!

<PQB8B:@A<@BD8!B:!P>@>AQB8>P!U<:>P!D8!@;>!A>RBD8!U>B8R!:@BQ9G<@>PO!1D:@!EDQQD8GIC!FDA!

@;>!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!@;>!G>F@!1LC!@;>!<E@BS>!>G>E@ADP>!B:!HG<E>P!DS>A!@;>!A>HA>:>8@<@BD8<G!

FB>GP!DF!@;>!ABR;@!;<8P!GDE<GB[>P!9:B8R!:9HA<@;A>:;DGP!(1'!H9G:>:C!T;>A><:!@;>!A>F>A>8E>!

>G>E@ADP>! B:! R>8>A<GGI! HG<E>P! D8! @;>! ED8@A<G<@>A<G! :9HA<DAUB@<G! A>RBD8! X#B@:E;>! >@! <GO!

JKKfYO!

'

QJ6/(,*,D(41*'+--+4)/',-').&#'

%<AGI! B8S>:@BR<@BD8:! DF! @;>! H;I:BDGDRBE<G! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! <8P! A>E>8@! EDQH9@<@BD8<G!

QDP>G:! DF! E9AA>8@! B8P9E@BD8! B8! @;>! EDA@BE<G! @B::9>! UI! @$/'! :9RR>:@! @;<@! :;DA@4@>AQ!

HDG<AB[<@BD8!TB@;! @$/'!E<8!E;<8R>!Q>QUA<8>!>W4!EB@<UBGB@I! A<@;>A! @;<8!<E@9<GGI! B8P9E>!

<E@BD8! HD@>8@B<G:O! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! <8DP<G! @$/'! B8EA><:>:! Q>QUA<8>! >WEB@<UBGB@I! XBO>OC!

B8EA><:>:!A>:@B8R!Q>QUA<8>!HD@>8@B<G:Y!T;BG>!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!;IH>AHDG<AB[>:!Q>QUA<8>!

HD@>8@B<G:O! *@! B:! @;9:! BQHDA@<8@! @D! A>EDR8B[>! @;<@! @$/'! E<8!Q>PB<@>! <GQD:@! BQQ>PB<@>!

13 !

E;<8R>:! B8!Q>QUA<8>! >WEB@<UBGB@IC!T;BE;! BQH<E@:! @;>! A>:HD8:>!DF! @;>! B8SDGS>P!8>9A<G!

EBAE9B@! @D! <8I! B8EDQB8R! B8H9@:C! <8P! <G:D! Q>4! PB<@>! <E@BSB@I4P>H>8P>8@! E;<8R>:! B8!

:I8<H@BE! @A<8:QB::BD8!HADH>A@B>:!T;>8!ED9HG>P!TB@;!:DQ>!U>;<SBDA<G! @A<B8B8R! X#B@:E;>!

>@!<GO!JKKfYO!&>E>8@GIC!B@!T<:!P>QD8:@A<@>P!@;<@!<8DP<G!@$/'!Q>PB<@>:!B@:!H;I:BDGDRBE<G!

>FF>E@:! UI! GD8R4@>AQ! :I8<H@BE! HD@>8@B<@BD8! X.(-Y! P9>! @D! <E@BSB@I4P>H>8P>8@! A>G><:>! DF!

UA<B84P>ABS>P!8>9AD@ADH;BE!F<E@DA!X5$#0Y!X0AB@:E;!>@!<GO!JKLKYO!'B8E>!5$#0!B:! BQHDA@<8@!

FDA!Q>PB<@B8R!@A<8:G<@BD8!<8P!@A<8:EABH@BD8!<::DEB<@>P!TB@;!HAD@>B8!:I8@;>:B:!FDA!.(-C!B@!B:!

98P>A:@<8P<UG>! @;<@! DFFGB8>! Q>QDAI! ED8:DGBP<@BD8! <8P! GD8R4@>AQ! A>@>8@BD8! E<8! U>!

:H>EBFBE<GGI!BQHADS>P!UI!<8DP<G!@$/'O!

*@! B:!<G:D! BQHDA@<8@! @D!;BR;GBR;@! @;>!HD@>8@B<G! B8@>A<E@BD8!U>@T>>8!H;I:BDGDRBE<G!

>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!<8P!;DQ>D:@<@BE!8>9A<G!HG<:@BE!Q>E;<8B:Q:!U>E<9:>!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I!

QDP9G<@BD8!UI!@$/'!Q<I!HADP9E>!:DQ>!QDPBFBE<@BD8!B8!@;>!@;A>:;DGP!FDA!.(-!<8P!GD8R4

@>AQ! :I8<H@BE! P>HA>::BD8O! 'I8<H:>:! @;<@! <A>! <@! <! ;BR;>A! G>S>G! DF! >WEB@<@BD8C! GB?>GI! @D!

DEE9A! TB@;! ED8PB@BD8B8R! UI! <8DP<G! @$/'C! E<8! ;<S>! <! ;BR;>A! @;A>:;DGP! FDA! .(-C! @;9:!

Q<?B8R! :9U:>Z9>8@! .(-! B8P9E@BD8! G>::!HADU<UG>O!,8! @;>! ED8@A<AIC! :I8<H:>:!<@! <! GDT>A!

G>S>G!DF!U<:>GB8>!>WEB@<UBGB@IC!GB?>GI!@D!DEE9A!TB@;!ED8PB@BD8B8R!UI!E<@;DP<G!@$/'C!E<8!;<S>!

<!GDT>A!@;A>:;DGP!FDA!.(-C!@;9:!Q<?B8R!:9U:>Z9>8@!.(-!B8P9E@BD8!QDA>!HADU<UG>!X@;B:!B:!

B8! <EEDAP<8E>! TB@;! @;>! 5B>8>8:@DE?4! /DDH>A4198AD>! A9G>YO! (;B:! FDAQ! DF! ;DQ>D:@<@BE!

HG<:@BEB@I!B:!<8!>::>8@B<G!Q>E;<8B:Q!FDA!8>9AD8:!@D!HA>S>8@!<8!98ED8@ADGG>P!B8EA><:>!B8!

:I8<H@BE! >FF>E@BS>8>::O! 1DA>DS>AC! B@! ;<:! BQHDA@<8@! BQHGBE<@BD8:! A>R<APB8R! @;>!

<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!@$/'!@D!F<EBGB@<@>!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IC!<:!A>G<@>P!@D!QD@DA!G><A8B8RC!U>E<9:>!B@!

14 !

P>@>A4!QB8>:!<HHADHAB<@>!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I!DF!UA<B8!A>RBD8:!B8SDGS>P!B8!

@;>!RBS>8!F98E@BD8<G!@<:?!H>AFDAQ<8E>O!

-DG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! DS>A! @;>! QD@DA! EDA@>W! D8! :H>EBFBE!

8>9AD@A<8:QB@@>A:! T>A>! A>E>8@GI! B8S>:@BR<@>P! 9:B8R!Q<R8>@BE! A>:D8<8E>! :H>E@AD:EDHI!

X1&'Y! X'@<RR! >@! <GO! JKKgYO!1&'! B:! <8! BQ<RB8R! @>E;8BZ9>! @;<@! <GGDT:! @;>! >:@BQ<@BD8! DF!

PBFF>A>8@! 8>9AD@A<8:QB@@>A! ED8E>8@A<@BD8! :9E;! <:! R<QQ<! <QB8D! U9@IABE! <EBP! X+)5)YC!

RG9@<Q<@>C! >@EO! (;>:>! A>:9G@:! :;DT>P! @;<@! LK! QB8! DF! <8DP<G! @$/'! DS>A! G>F@! 1L!

:H>EBFBE<GGI! A>P9E>P!+)5)! G>S>G:! B8! @;>! EDA@>W!T;BG>! E<@;DP<G! @$/'! A>P9E>P!RG9@<Q<@>!

G>S>G:! ED9HG>P!TB@;! EDAA>G<@>P! P>EA><:>:! B8!+)5)! G>S>G:O! &>E>8@GIC! '@<RR! >@! <GO! XJKLLY!

<G:D!P>QD8:@A<@>P!@;<@!E;<8R>:!B8!+)5)!ED8E>8@A<@BD8!>GBEB@>P!UI!<8DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!1L!

EDAA>G<@>:! TB@;! @;>! <QD98@! DF! QD@DA! G><A8B8R! <EAD::! B8PBSBP9<G:]! @;>! <QD98@! DF!

P>EA><:>!B8!+)5)!ED8E>8@A<@BD8!P9>!@D!@$/'!T<:!HD:B@BS>GI!EDAA>G<@>P!TB@;!@;>!<QD98@!

DF!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!B8!<!:>AB<G!A><E@BD8!@BQ>!@<:?!X'&((YO!*8@>A>:@B8RGIC!T;>8!@;>!:9UV>E@:!

H>AFDAQ>P!@;>!'&((!B8!<!F98E@BD8<G!Q<R8>@BE!A>:D8<8E>!BQ<RB8R!XF1&*Y!:E<88>AC!+)5)!

A>:HD8:BS>4! 8>::! <G:D! EDAA>G<@>P! TB@;! @;>! P>EA><:>:! B8! UGDDP! DWIR>8<@BD84P>H>8P>8@!

X5,.$Y! :BR8<G! B8! @;>! G>F@!1L! XED8@A<G<@>A<G! @D!H>AFDAQB8R!;<8PY!P9AB8R! @;>! @<:?O! (;9:C!

@;>:>!FB8PB8R:!;BR;4!GBR;@!@;>!ADG>!DF!+)5)>ARBE!QDP9G<@BD8!UI!<8DP<G!@$/'!B8!F<EBGB@<@B8R!

QD@DA! G><A8B8R!<8P!<A>!:9RR>:@BS>!DF!<!HD::BUG>!A>G>S<8E>!DF!+)5)!B8!.(-4GB?>!:I8<H@BE!

HG<:@BEB@I!B8!;9Q<8!QD@DA!G><A8B8RO!09@9A>!:@9PB>:!Q9:@!B8S>:@BR<@>!@;>!A>G>S<8E>!DF!@;B:!

+)5)>ARBE!QDP9G<@BD8!B8!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!FDGGDTB8R!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!:B8E>!UD@;!<8DP<G!<8P!

E<@;DP<G! @$/'! QDP9G<@BD8! P>EA><:>P! +)5)! ED8E>8@A<@BD8! B8! @;>! DABRB8<G! :@9PI!

ED8P9E@>P!UI!'@<RR!>@!<GO!XJKKgYO!

15 !

)8!>Q>ARB8R!@;>Q>!FADQ!@;>!<FDA>Q>8@BD8>P!B8@ADP9E@BD8!B:!@;<@!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!

:>>QB8RGI! uGDE<GB[>Pv! EDA@BE<G! >WEB@<UBGB@I! DS>A! 1L! A>:9G@:! B8! QDP9G<@BD8! DF! EDQHG>W!

QD@DA!H>AFDAQ<8E>!:9RR>:@B8R!@;<@!@$/'!<FF>E@:!QDA>!TBP>:HA><P!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:C!@;9:!

B8P9EB8R!HG<:@BEB@I!B8!U>;<SBDAO!

'

<J1)'412'F01(2'2+)C,0B'121*6/(/'(2-,0E'1F,H)'2+H0,K*1/)(4()6R'

(;>! :@9PI! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! B8SDGS>:! >W<QB8<@BD8! <8P! Z9<84! @BFIB8R! HADH>A@B>:! DF!

B8@>A<E@BD8:! U>@T>>8! @;>! B8@>AED88>E@>P! EDQHD8>8@:! DF! 8>9A<G! EBAE9B@:C! <@! Q9G@BHG>!

:H<@B<G! :E<G>:! GB?>! FADQ! @;>! QBEAD:E<G>! G>S>G! DF! 8>@TDA?:! DF! <! RAD9H! DF! :I8<H:>:! DA!

8>9AD8:! @D! @;>!Q<EAD:E<G>! G>S>G!DF!8>@TDA?:!DF!S<ABD9:!HDH9G<@BD8:!DF!8>9AD8:! @D! @;>!

8>@TDA?:! B8! @;>! T;DG>! UA<B8O! -ABQ<ABGIC! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! <A>! :@9PB>P! U<:>P! D8! @;>!

;IHD@;>:B:! @;<@!QD:@!DF! @;>!EDQHG>W!EDR8B@BS>!U>;<SBDA:!>W;BUB@>P!UI!<8BQ<G:!>Q>AR>!

FADQ!@;>!B8@ABE<@>!DAR<8B[<@BD8!DF!<8P!B8@>A<E@BD8!U>@T>>8!@;>!U<:BE!8>9AD8<G!>G>Q>8@:C!

BO>OC! 8>9AD8:!DS>A! <8P! <UDS>! @;>! F98E@BD8:! <8P!HADH>A@B>:! DF! @;>! EDQHD8>8@!8>9AD8:!

@;>Q:>GS>:! X'HDA8:! JKLKYO! *8! F<E@C! B8! @;B:! Q9G@B:E<G>! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <AE;B@>E@9A>C! @;>!

B8@>A<E@BD8!U>@T>>8!8>@TDA?:! <@!PBFF>A>8@! :E<G>:!HG<I:! <8! B8@>RA<G! ADG>! B8!P>@>AQB8B8R!

RGDU<G!F98E@BD8O!*8!;9Q<8:C!8D8B8S<:BS>!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!@>E;8BZ9>:!DFF>A!@;>!U>:@!HD::BUG>!

Q><8:! @D! :@9PI! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! <8P! @;>BA! HADH>A@B>:! B8! ;9Q<8:! B8! HA>:>8@! @BQ>:O! 5I!

@A<E?B8R!8>9A<G! <E@BSB@I! B8! A><G! @BQ>C!PBA>E@GI!DA! B8PBA>E@GIC! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R!Q>@;DP:!;>GH!

HADSBP>! <! EDQHG>W! :H<@BD@>QHDA<G! P>:EABH@BD8! DF! HG<:@BE! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! ;9Q<8:C!

T;BE;! DEE9A:! <:! <! A>:9G@! DF! >WH>AB>8E>! <8P! <G:D! FDGGDTB8R! B8:9G@:! DA! B8V9AB>:! @D! @;>!

8>ASD9:!:I:@>QO!-<A@BE9G<AGIC!B@!B8SDGS>:!P>@<BG>P!B8S>:@BR<@BD8:!DF!ED88>E@BSB@I!U>@T>>8!

16 !

PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:! DF! @;>! UA<B8C! DA! B8! D@;>A! TDAP:C! :@9PI! DF! PI8<QBE:! DF! 8>@TDA?:!

B8SDGSB8R!A>RBD8:!@;<@!<A>!uED88>E@>Pv!F98E@BD8<GGI!<8PcDA!:@A9E@9A<GGIO!

(;9:C! :@9PIB8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! Q<I! :>AS>! <:! <8! B8S<G9<UG>! @DDG! @D! :@9PI!

98P>AGIB8R! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! HADE>::>:! B8FG9>8E>P! UI! 8D8B8S<:BS>! UA<B8! :@BQ9G<@BD8!

@>E;8BZ9>:! :9E;! <:! @$/'O! *8! @;B:! ED8@>W@C! A>RBD8<G! E>A>UA<G! UGDDP! FGDT! XA/50YC! 5,.$!

:BR8<G:! <8P! D:EBGG<@DAI! PI8<QBE:! @;AD9R;! Q<R8>@D>8E>H;<GDRA<H;IC! <8P!

>G>E@AD>8E>H;<GDRA<H;I!X%%+YC!ED9HG>P!TB@;!G<AR>4:E<G>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<8<GI:B:C!E<8!;>GH!

BP>8@BFI!8D8B8S<:BS>!8>9A<G!Q<A?>A:!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!B8!@;>!;9Q<8!UA<B8O!(;>!@BQB8R!DF!

@$/'!A>G<@BS>!@D!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!P>FB8>:!T;BE;!Z9>:@BD8:!E<8!U>!@<E?G>P!9:B8R!<!EDQUB8>P!

@$/'! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! <HHAD<E;O! 6;>8! @$/'! B:! <HHGB>P! uDFFGB8>v! U>FDA>! 8>9ADBQ<RB8RC!

@;>:>! @>E;8BZ9>:! E<8! Q<H! @;>! :H<@BD4@>QHDA<G! H<@@>A8! DF! F98E@BD8<G! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!

B8P9E>P! B8! @;>!UA<B8!UI! @$/'!DA! @;>! G<:@B8R! F98E@BD8<G! BQH<E@!DF! @$/'!D8!A>:@4!DA! @<:?4

A>G<@>P!8>9A<G!<E@BSB@I!<@!@;>!:I:@>Q:!G>S>GO!-<A@BE9G<AGIC!@;B:!QBR;@!<G:D!;>GH!EG<ABFI!:DQ>!

;>@>ADR>8>D9:! >SBP>8E>! <UD9@! ;DQ>D:@<@BE! 8>9A<G! HG<:@BEB@I!QDP9G<@>P! UI! @$/'O! (;B:!

DFFGB8>! <HHAD<E;C! B8! T;BE;! @$/'! <8P! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! <A>! :>H<A<@>P! B8! @BQ>C! B:! <G:D!

@>E;8BE<GGI! ><:B>A! @D! BQHG>Q>8@! @;<8! @;>! uD8GB8>v! <HHAD<E;C! B8! T;BE;! @$/'! <8P!

8>9ADBQ<RB8R!DS>AG<H! B8! @BQ>!TB@;! @$/'!;<SB8R! @;>!HD::BUBGB@I! @D!<PS>A:>GI!<FF>E@!P<@<!

<EZ9B:B@BD8! P9AB8R! 8>9ADBQ<RB8RO! 2DT>S>AC! @;B:! D8GB8>! <HHAD<E;! B:! @;>! D8GI!Q><8:! @D!

9:>! @$/'! @D! @>:@! ;DT! EDA@BE<G! QDP9G<@BD8! B8:@<8@<8>D9:GI! QDPBFB>:! @;>! <E@BSB@I! <8P!

ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8!@;>!QDP9G<@>P!8>9A<G!EBAE9B@:!DA!8>@TDA?:O!

'

:+H0,K*1/)(4'+--+4)/',-').&#',2'F01(2'2+)C,0B/'

17 !

6;BG>!@;>A>!B:!:9FFBEB>8@!>SBP>8E>!@D!:9HHDA@!@;>!:BR8BFBE<8@!B8FG9>8E>!DF!@$/'!B8!B8P9EB8R!

8>9ADHG<:@BE!E;<8R>:!A>FG>E@>P!B8!DU:>AS<UG>!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:C!@;>!>W<E@!Q>E;<8B:Q!

DF! <E@BD8! DF! @$/'! B8! HADP9EB8R! @;B:! 8>9ADQDP9G<@BD8! B:! 8D@! EDQHG>@>GI! EG><AO! (;9:C!

A>E>8@!>FFDA@:!@D!EDQUB8>!@$/'!<8P!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!B8!>WH>ABQ>8@<G!H<A<PBRQ:!;<S>!U>>8!

98P>A@<?>8!@D!HADSBP>!<!QDA>!Q>@;DPBE<G!E;<A<E@>AB[<@BD8!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!QDP9G<@BD8!

UI! @$/'! @;AD9R;! @;>!9:>!DF!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<8<GI:B:! @>E;8BZ9>:O!5<9P>TBR!>@!<GO! XJKKLY!

>W<QB8>P! :>8:DABQD@DA! UA<B8! <E@BS<@BD8!U>FDA>! <8P! <F@>A! h!QB8!DF! @$/'!DS>A! G>F@!1LC!

P9AB8R! H>AFDAQ<8E>! DF! <! :>Z9>8@B<G! FB8R>A4DHHD:B@BD8! @<:?O! (;B:! TDA?! T<:! @;>! FBA:@!

<@@>QH@!@D!P>@>E@!@$/'4B8P9E>P!QDP9G<@BD8:!DF!UA<B8!<E@BSB@I!SB<!E;<8R>:!DF!@;>!5,.$!

1&*!A>:HD8:>!@D!<!T>GG4P>FB8>P!F98E@BD8<G!E;<GG>8R>O!(;>!<9@;DA:!FD98P!@;<@!B8EA><:>P!

>WEB@<UBGB@I! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;! <8DP<G! @$/'! DEE9AA>P! TB@;! B84! EA><:>P! <E@BS<@BD8! B8!

:>8:DABQD@DA! EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:!T;BG>! E<@;4!DP<G! @$/'! G>P! @D!P>EA><:>P!<E@BS<@BD8! B8! @;>!

:<Q>!A>RBD8:O!2DT>S>AC! @;>! FBA:@! :@9PI!@D! @A<E?!E;<8R>:!<@! A>:@!<:!T>GG!<:! @<:?4A>G<@>P!

XFB8R>A! QDS>Q>8@:Y! UA<B8! <E@BS<@BD8! 9:>P! HD:B@AD8! >QB::BD8! @DQDRA<H;I! X.<8R! >@! <GO!

JKKhYO!(;>!<9@;DA:! :@9PB>P! A/50!E;<8R>:!<F@>A!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!JK!QB8!DF! @$/'!DS>A! G>F@!

1LO! *@!T<:!FD98P!@;<@!A><G!@$/'C! BO>OC!UD@;!<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<GC! B8EA><:>P!A/50! B8!1LC!

:>8:DABQD@DA! EDA@>WC! FAD8@<G! EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:! EDQH<A>P! TB@;! :;<QC! <8P! @;>:>! >FF>E@:!

H>A:B:@>P! FDA!9H! @D!hK!QB8!<F@>A!>8P!DF! @$/'O!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!<8DP<G! @$/'!<G:D! B8EA><:>P!

A/50!B8!:9UEDA@BE<G!UA<B8!A>RBD8:!EDQH<A>P!TB@;!E<@;DP<G!@$/'O!(;>:>!FB8PB8R:!T>A>!@;>!

FBA:@! @D! :;DT! >WH>ABQ>8@<GGI! @;<@! @;>! HA>:9Q>P! GDE<G! @$/'! <HHGBE<@BD8! DS>A! 1L! Q<I!

HADP9E>! GD8R4G<:@B8R!8>9ADHG<:@BE! <G@>A<@BD8:! B8!QDA>!TBP>:HA><P!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!DS>A!

<8P!U>ID8P!:@BQ9G<@>P!1L!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:O!

18 !

2DT>S>AC!Q>@;DP:! @D! <8<GI[>! <8P! Z9<8@BFI! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:!T>A>! G>::!

P>S>GDH>P! <@! @;<@! @BQ>C! <8P! A>E>8@! @>E;8D4! GDRBE<G! <PS<8E>:! ;<S>! F<EBGB@<@>P! QDA>!

P>@<BG>P!EDQH9@<@BD8:!DF!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!@;AD9R;!<8<GI:B:!DF!EDQHG>W!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!

P<@<!:>@:!DF!;BR;!PBQ>8:BD8<GB@I!<8P!SDG9Q>O!(;9:C!@;>!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!E;<A<E@>AB[<@BD8!DF!

UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! @D! :@9PI! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! QDP9G<@BD8! UI! @$/'! B:! <! A>E>8@!

P>S>GDHQ>8@O! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! RA<H;! @;>DA>@BE<G! <8<GI:>:! ;<S>! U>>8! <HHGB>P! @D!

E;<A<E@>AB[>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!E;<8R>:!B8!%%+!X-DG<8n<!>@!<GO!JKLKY!<:!T>GG!<:!F1&*!X-DG<8n<!

>@! <GO! JKLLY! FDGGDTB8R! LK! QB8! DF! <8DP<G! @$/'! DS>A! G>F@! 1LO! +A<H;! @;>DAI! B:! <!

Q<@;>Q<@BE<G!<HHAD<E;!@D!Z9<8@BFI!@;>!ED:@!DF!B8FDAQ<@BD8!@A<8:F>A!<8P!HADE>::B8R!B8!<!

P>FB8>P! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! UI! E<GE9G<@B8R! <QD98@! DF! B8@>AED88>E@BSB@I! X>PR>:Y! U>@T>>8!

PBFF>A>8@!UA<B8!A>RBD8:!X8DP>:Y!<:!T>GG!<:!G>8R@;!DF!ED88>E@BD8:!TB@;B8!@;<@!8>@TDA?O!

(;>! A>:9G@:! :;DT>P! @;<@! LK!QB8! DF! <8DP<G! @$/'!QDP9G<@>P! ;BR;4FA>Z9>8EI! D:EBGG<@DAI!

<E@BSB@I!B8!U>@<!XLhb\K!2[Y!<8P!R<QQ<!XiKbgK!2[Y!B8!@;>!F98E@BD8<G!%%+!:I8E;AD8B[<@BD84!

U<:>P!ED88>E@BSB@I!Q>@ABE!P9AB8R!H>AFDAQ<8E>!DF!<!:BQHG>!FB8R>A4@<HHB8R!QD@DA!@<:?!8D@!

D8GI! B8! >G>E@ADP>:! DS>A! @;>! :@BQ9G<@>P! QD@DA! EDA@>WC! U9@! <G:D! B8! UBG<@>A<G! FAD8@<GC!

H<AB>@<GC!<8P!HA>QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:!EDQH<A>P!TB@;!:;<Q!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!,8!@;>!D@;>A!

;<8PC!TB@;!@;>!;BR;>A!:H<@B<G!A>:DG9@BD8!DF!F1&*C!B@!T<:!HD::BUG>!@D!:;DT!@;<@!LK!QB8!DF!

<8DP<G! @$/'! <E@9<GGI! B8EA><:>P! :;DA@! A<8R>! ED88>E@BD8:! FADQ! 1L! @D! HA>QD@DA! <8P!

H<AB>@<G! EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:C! T;BG>! ED8EDQB@<8@GI! B8EA><:B8R! B8@>A4ED88>E@>P8>::! B8!

HA>FAD8@<G!EDA@>W!B8!A>:@B8R!UA<B8!PI8<QBE:!X-DG<8B<!>@!<GO!JKLLYO!

*8@>A>:@B8RGIC! A>E>8@! :@9PB>:!<G:D!EDQH<A>P!E;<8R>:! B8! F1&*!P9AB8R!:BQ9G@<8>D9:! @$/'!

<HHGBE<@BD8!P9AB8R!P<@<!<EZ9B:B@BD8! B8!@;>!1&*!:E<88>A!XuD8GB8>v!<HHAD<E;C!7TD8!>@!<GO!

19 !

JKKfm!)8@<G!>@!<GO!JKLLYO!*8!@;>!FBA:@!:@9PI!X7TD8!>@!<GOC!JKKfYC!<8DP<G!@$/'!T<:!<HHGB>P!

DS>A! G>F@!1L!P9AB8R! RA<:H4A>G><:>!;<8P!QDS>Q>8@:! 9:B8R! d! W! JL4:! :@BQ9G<@BD8!H;<:>:!

XA>:@B8R4@$/'4@$/'4@$/'4@$/'YO! #D! EDA@BE<G! <E@BS<@BD8! T<:! P>@>E@>P! B8! <8I! DF! @;>!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!H;<:>:!>WE>H@!@;>!FD9A@;!@$/'!H;<:>O!)E@BS<@BD8!T<:!FD98P!8D@!D8GI!98P>A!

@;>!>G>E@ADP>!U9@! <G:D! B8! @;>! G>F@! :9HHG>Q>8@<AI!QD@DA! EDA@>W!<8P! @;>! ABR;@!HD:@>ABDA!

H<AB>@<G!EDA@>WO!2DT>S>AC!B8!@;B:!:@9PIC!E<@;DP<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8!T<:!8D@!<HHGB>PO!(;>A>FDA>C!

B8!<8D@;>A!:@9PI!X)8@<G!>@!<GO!JKLLYC!@;>!<9@;DA:!<PPA>::>P!@;>!Z9>:@BD8!<:!@D!T;>@;>A!

<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!A>:9G@! B8!PBFF>A>8@B<G!5,.$!F1&*!:BR8<G!E;<8R>:!P9AB8R!<!A>:@!

ED8PB@BD8!<:!T>GG!<:!@;>!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!D8!@;>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BS<@>P!

UI! <! SDG98@<AI! FB8R>A4@<HHB8R! @<:?O! )G@;D9R;! :H>EBFBE! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <8<GI@BE<G!

<HHAD<E;>:!T>A>!8D@!9:>P!;>A>C!8>B@;>A!<8DP<G!8DA!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!@;>!1L!FDA!JK4:!

:@BQ9G<@BD8! P9A<@BD8! B8P9E>P! <! P>@>E@<UG>! 5,.$! :BR8<G! E;<8R>O! 2DT>S>AC! EDQH<A>P!

TB@;! <! SDG98@<AI! FB8R>A4@<HHB8R! @<:?! TB@;D9@! :@BQ9G<@BD8C! <8DP<G! @$/'! P9AB8R! FB8R>A!

@<HHB8R!A>:9G@>P!B8!<!P>EA><:>!B8!@;>!5,.$!A>:HD8:>!B8!@;>!:9HHG>Q>8@<AI!QD@DA!<A><!

X'1)YO!/<@;DP<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8!PBP!8D@!A>:9G@!B8!:BR8BFBE<8@!E;<8R>!B8!5,.$!A>:HD8:>!B8!@;>!

'1)C! <G@;D9R;! <! @>8P>8EI! @DT<AP! P>EA><:>P! <E@BSB@I! ED9GP! U>! :>>8O! *8! @;>! ED8@ADG!

>WH>ABQ>8@C! B8!T;BE;!@;>!>G>E@ADP>:!T>A>!HG<E>P!DS>A! G>F@!<8P!ABR;@!DEEBHB@D4@>QHDAD4

H<AB>@<G! V98E@BD8C! 8>B@;>A! E<@;DP<G! 8DA! <8DP<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! A>:9G@>P! B8! <! :BR8BFBE<8@!

E;<8R>!DF!5,.$!:BR8<G!P9AB8R!FB8R>A!@<HHB8R!B8!<8I!UA<B8!<A><!B8EG9PB8R!'1)C!HA>QD@DA!

EDA@>WC!<8P!1LO!

!

20 !

!

0BRO!LO!-]!<!:E;>Q<@BE!:9QQ<AI!DF!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!X@$/'Y!>FF>E@:!DS>A! 1L! XUBHDG<A! >G>E@ADP>! QD8@<R>! TB@;! D8>! >G>E@ADP>! DS>A! 1LC! <8P! D@;>A! DS>A!ED8@A<G<@>A<G! :9HA<DAUB@<G! A>RBD8YO! 7]! 1L! @$/'! Q>PB<@>:! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! E;<8R>:! B8!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@I! X:;DT8!<:!QD@DA4>SD?>P!HD@>8@B<G:C! BO>OC!1%-:!>WHA>::>P!<:!<!A<@BD!@D!U<:>GB8>Y!@;<@!D9@G<:@:!P9A<@BD8!DF!:@BQ9G<@BD8!9H!@D!dK!QB8O!8'<G:D!G><P:!@D!E;<8R>:!B8!U>;<SBDA!:9E;!<:!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!D8!<!:>AB<G!A><E@BD8!@BQ>!@<:?!X'&((YO!)8DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!1L! BQHADS>:! QD@DA! H>AFDAQ<8E>! D8! '&((! QDA>! @;<8! E<@;DP<G! <8P! :;<Q! @$/'! XBO>OC!RA><@>A!P>EA><:>! B8! A><E@BD8! @BQ>! B8! @;>!><AGI! UGDE?:YO!9]! A>HA>:>8@<@BS>! EDA@BE<G! UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!TB@;! B8@>A<E@B8R! A>RBD8<G! 8DP>:! @;<@! <A>! GB?>GI!QDP9G<@>P! UI! @$/'! DS>A!1LO!-0/C! HA>FAD8@<G! EDA@>Wm! '1)C! :9HHG>Q>8@<AI! QD@DA! <A><m! -1C! HA>QD@DA! EDA@>Wm! 'LC!HABQ<AI! :DQ<@D4! :>8:DAI! EDA@>Wm! 1LC! HABQ<AI! QD@DA! EDA@>Wm! --/C! HD:@>ABDA! H<AB>@<G!EDA@>WO! /DQHG>W! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! A>EDAP>P! @;AD9R;! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! ED9GP! ;>GH!BP>8@BFI! <8P!Z9<8@BFI!TBP>:HA><P! E;<8R>:! B8! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! <8P! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! @D! HADSBP>! QDA>! 8DS>G! B8:BR;@:! B8@D! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! Q>E;<8B:Q:!QDP9G<@>P! UI! @$/'O! #D@>]! P<@<! :;DT8! B8! RA<H;:! <A>! A>HA>:>8@<@BS>! DF! HA>SBD9:GI!H9UGB:;>P!A>:9G@:!X#B@:E;>!>@!<GO!JKKfYO!!

21 !

(DR>@;>AC!@;>:>!FB8PB8R:!HADSBP>!F9A@;>A!:9HHDA@!FDA!@;>!8D@BD8!@;<@!@$/'!<HHGB>P!

DS>A!<!:H>EBFBE!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8C!GB?>!1LC!B8P9E>:!TBP>:HA><P!E;<8R>:!DF!E>A>UA<G!<E@BSB@I!

<@!EDA@BE<G!<8P!:9UEDA@BE<G!G>S>G:!<8P!<G@>A:!F98E@BD8<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!U>4!@T>>8!@;B:!EDA@>W!

<8P!QD@DA!<::DEB<@BD8!EDA@BE>:O!

!

:"#"0,';$0,2#$<%/'

6;BG>! @;>:>! A>E>8@! :@9PB>:! HADSBP>! :DQ>! B8:BR;@! <UD9@! HD@>8@B<G! 8>@TDA?4G>S>G!

8>9ADHG<:@BE!QDP9G<@BD8!UI!GDE<GB[>P!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!@$/'!DS>A!1LC!B@!B:!>SBP>8@!@;<@!D9A!

98P>A:@<8PB8R!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!<G@>A<@BD8:!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'!B:!F<A!FADQ!EDQHG>@>O!09@9A>!

:@9PB>:! <A>! 8>>P>P! @D! :I:@>Q<@BE<GGI! B8S>:@BR<@>! @;>! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! E;<8R>:! B8! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'! @D! HADSBP>! <! HG<9:BUG>! Q>E;<8B:@BE! <EED98@! DF!

8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! <8P!>WHG<B8!U>;<SBDA<G! 8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! E;<8R>:! @;<@! <A>!QDP9G<@>P!

UI!@$/'!X:>>!0BRO!LYO!09A@;>AQDA>C!@;B:!<HHAD<E;!E<8!;>GH!>W<QB8>!;DQ>D:@<@BE!HG<:@BEB@I!

B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'! <@! @;>! G>S>G! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:C! <8! BQHDA@<8@! H;>8DQ>8D8! FDA! @;>!

<HHGBE<@BD8! DF! @$/'! B8! @A><@B8R! PB:><:>:! ?8DT8! @D! ;<S>! H<@;DGDRBE<G! <G@>A>P! EDA@BE<G!

>WEB@<UBGB@I! XBO>OC! :@AD?>YO! )8! BQHDA@<8@! HDB8@! @D! U>! 8D@>P! ;>A>! B:! @;<@! @;>! <8<GI@BE<G!

<HHAD<E;! 9:>P! @D! P>:EABU>! <8P! Z9<8@BFI! UA<B8! PI8<QBE:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! B8FG9>8E>:! @;>!

B8F>A>8E>:! @;<@! E<8! U>! PA<T8! FADQ! @;>! P<@<O! 1D:@! DF! @;>! A>E>8@! :@9PB>:! P>:EABU>P!

<UDS>C! B8EG9PB8R!RA<H;!@;>DA>@BE<G!<8<GI:B:C!9:>P!ED88>E@BSB@I4QDP>G!U<:>P!<8<GI:>:!@D!

P>:EABU>! E;<8R>:! B8! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:O! 2DT>S>AC! 9:B8R!QDP>G4FA>>C! P<@<4PABS>8!

<HHAD<E;>:!B8!@;>!F9@9A>C!GB?>!B8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:C!Q<I!<G:D!U>!BQHDA@<8@!

@D!B8B@B<GGI!BP>8@BFI!:H>EBFBE!8>@TDA?:!QDP9G<@>P!UI!@$/'!B8!<8!98UB<:>P!Q<88>AO'

22 !

1DA>DS>AC! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <8<GI@BE<G! <HHAD<E;>:! <A>! 9:>F9G! @DDG:! @D! 8D8B8S<:BS>GI!

>S<G9<@>!8D@!D8GI!@;>!F98E@BD8<G!E;<8R>:!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'!U9@!<G:D!@D!@A<E?!@;>!>FF>E@:!DF!

D@;>A! 8D84B8S<:BS>! :@BQ9G<@BD8! Q>@;DP:! @;<@! ;<S>! <G:D! U>>8! A>HDA@>P! @D! HADP9E>!

8>9ADHG<:@BE!<G@>A<@BD8:!B8!@;>!;9Q<8!UA<B8!X>OROC!@A<8:EA<8B<G!A<8PDQ!8DB:>!:@BQ9G<@BD8C!

@A<8:EA<8B<G! <G@>A8<@B8R! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8C! <8P! (1'YO! )GG! @;>:>! <HHAD<E;>:!TBGG! ;<S>!

BQHDA@<8@!BQHGBE<@BD8:!B8!F9@9A>!EGB8BE<G!<HHGBE<@BD8:!DF!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8!<:!T>GG!<:!;>GH!

P>FB8>!8D8B8S<:BS>!Q<A?>A:!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IO!

*8! :9QQ<AIC! :9E;! EDQUB8>P! <HHAD<E;>:! @D! :@9PI! <8P! Z9<8@BFI!

8>9ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G!HADE>::>:!<::DEB<@>P!TB@;!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!<A>!EAB@BE<G!@D!;>GH!BP>8@BFIC!

QD8B@DAC!<8P!HD@>8@B<@>!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!@;<@!B:!EA9EB<G!FDA!F98E@BD8<G!A>EDS>AI!B8!H<@B>8@:!

:9FF>AB8R!FADQ!UA<B8!G>:BD8:!GB?>!:@AD?>!<8P!@A<9Q<@BE!UA<B8!B8V9AIO!!

!

?+)J,5/'),'/)H56'4J12D+/'(2'F01(2'2+)C,0B/'

0DGGDTB8R! FADQ! @;>! PB:E9::BD8! <UDS>C! B@! B:! B8@9B@BS>! @;<@! @;>! :@9PI! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:!

B8SDGS>:!P>@<BG>P! B8S>:@BR<@BD8:!DF!ED88>E@BSB@I!U>@T>>8!PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:!DF! @;>!UA<B8C!

DA!B8!D@;>A!TDAP:C!:@9PI!DF!PI8<QBE:!DF!8>@TDA?:!B8SDGSB8R!A>RBD8:!@;<@!<A>!uED88>E@>Pv!

F98E@BD8<GGI! <8PcDA! :@A9E@9A<GGIO! (;>!Q>@;DP:!9:>P! @D! :@9PI! @;>:>!8>@TDA?!HADH>A@B>:!

P>H>8P!@D!<!G<AR>!>W@>8@!D8!@;>!@IH>!DF!@;>!8>9A<G!P<@<!@;>I!<A>!<HHGB>P!@DO!2>A>C!<!F>T!

DF!@;>!Q>@;DP:!9:>P!@D!:@9PI!;9Q<8!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!HADH>A@B>:!TBGG!U>!PB:E9::>PC!B8!@;>!

ED8@>W@!DF!@;>!P<@<!@;>I!<A>!<HHGB>P!@D!<8P!@;>BA!A>G<@BS>!<PS<8@<R>:!<8P!PB:<PS<8@<R>:O!

)G:DC! A>G>S<8@!ED8@>QHDA<AI!A>:><AE;!>SBP>8E>!>QHGDIB8R!@;>:>!Q>@;DP:! B8! @;>!:@9PI!

DF!8>9A<G!HG<:@BEB@I!TBGG!U>!PB:E9::>PO!!

23 !

-='7*$%;'><;,*?@0,,'-%1*A/$/'

'B%;,!,%;,%#'8<+!<%,%#'-%1*A/$/'

*8P>H>8P>8@! EDQHD8>8@! <8<GI:B:! X*/)Y! B:! <! UGB8P! :D9AE>! :>H<A<@BD8! @>E;8BZ9>! @;<@!

<GGDT:! P>EDQHD:B8R! EDQHG>W! P<@<! B8@D! @;>BA! Q<WBQ<GGI! B8P>H>8P>8@C! 98P>AGIB8R!

ED8@ABU9@B8R! :D9AE>! :BR8<G:! X;>A>! HA>:9Q>P! @D! DABRB8<@>! FADQ! :H>EBFBE! F98E@BD8<G! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?:!DA!8>9A<G!R>8>A<@DA:Y!@;AD9R;!<!GB8><A!P>QBWB8R!HADE>::!UI!QB8BQB[B8R!Q9@9<G!

B8FDAQ<@BD8! <QD8R! @;>:>! :D9AE>:O! *8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! 8>9A<G! P<@<C! */)! ;<:! U>>8!

:9EE>::F9GGI! <HHGB>P! @D!;>QDPI8<QBE!P<@<! A>EDAP>P! @;AD9R;! F1&*! @D! BP>8@BFI! :H<@B<GGI!

B8P>H>8P>8@C! @>QHDA<GGI! DS>AG<HHB8R! H<@@>A8:! DF! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! X)GU>A@C! &DU>A@:D8C! `!

1B<GGC!JKKgm!%:HD:B@D!>@!<GOC!JKKhm!1<8@B8B!>@!<GOC!JKKem!S<8!P>!=>8!>@!<GOC!JKKhYO!2>A>B8C!

><E;! H<@@>A8! DA! EDQHD8>8@! :>H<A<@>P! UI! @;>! <GRDAB@;Q! B:! A>HA>:>8@<@BS>! DF! <! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?!TB@;!F98E@BD8<GGI!B8@>A4ED88>E@>P!A>RBD8:O!(;>!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!@;B:!@>E;8BZ9>!@D!

F1&*!P<@<!;<:!A>S><G>P!:@<UG>!H<@@>A8:!DF!<E@BSB@I!DA!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!@;<@!<A>!<E@BS<@>P!

8D@!D8GI!P9AB8R!:H>EBFBE! @<:?!H>AFDAQ<8E>C!U9@!<G:D!P9AB8R!<T<?>C!<G>A@C! A>:@B8R!:@<@>:O!

)PPB@BD8<GGIC! @;B:!Q>@;DP!EDQUB8>P!TB@;!:@<@B:@BE<G!EG9:@>AB8R!;<:!<G:D!U>>8!<HHGB>P!@D!

>G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! UA<B8! P<@<! @D! P>EDQHD:>! B@! B8@D! :H<@B<GGI! DS>AG<HHB8RC! @>QHDA<GGI!

B8P>H>8P>8@! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! TB@;! @;>! DUV>E@BS>! DF! :@9PIB8R! @;>BA! EDQHG>W! D:EBGG<@DAI!

PI8<QBE:!X/D8@A>A<:4=BP<G!`!7>ABE?C!JKKdYO!(;>!Q<B8!<PS<8@<R>!DF!9:B8R!@;B:!Q>@;DP!B:!

@;<@!B@!<GGDT:!UGB8PC!P<@<4PABS>8!:>H<A<@BD8!DF!ED8@ABU9@B8R!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!FADQ!EDQHG>W!

P<@<!QBW@9A>:C!@;9:!<GGDTB8R!QDA>!DUV>E@BS>!<8P!98UB<:>P!>WHGDA<@BD8!DF!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!

PI8<QBE:! P9AB8R! F98E@BD8<GGI! A>G>S<8@! U>;<SBDA<G! :@<@>:O! 2DT>S>AC! <8! B8;>A>8@!

PB:<PS<8@<R>!DF!@;B:!Q>@;DP!B:!@;<@!B@!E<88D@!@A<E?!PI8<QBE!B8@>A<E@BD8:!DA!ED88>E@BSB@I!

24 !

E;<8R>:!<QD8R!UA<B8! A>RBD8:!TB@;B8! BP>8@BFB>P!8>@TDA?:O!#>S>A@;>G>::C! B@! :>AS>:!<:!<8!

>WE>GG>8@! FBA:@! H<::! @D! BP>8@BFI! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! >8R<R>P! B8! :H>EBFBE! EDR8B@BS>! <8P!

U>;<SBDA<G!HADE>::B8RC!T;BE;!E<8!@;>8!U>!:@9PB>P!B8!RA><@>A!P>@<BG!9:B8R!D@;>A!<8<GI@BE<G!

Q>@;DP:O! *8@>A>:@B8RGIC! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! @;B:!Q>@;DP! @D! F1&*! A>:@B8R! UA<B8! P<@<! :;DT>P!

@;<@!<!E>A>U>GG<A!QD@DA!8>@TDA?!T<:!>8R<R>P!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!QDA>!:@AD8RGI!<F@>A!<P<H@BS>!

G><A8B8R!DF!8DS>G!:EA>>84E9A:DA!A>G<@BD8:;BH:!<:!EDQH<A>P!@D!U>FDA>!G><A8B8R!X)GU>A@!>@!

<GOC!JKKgYO!(;B:!:@9PI!T<:!@;>!FBA:@!@D!:;DT!@;<@!A>:@B8R!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!ED9GP!U>!<!

S>AI!9:>F9G!@D!:@9PI!8>9ADHG<:@BE!>S>8@:!DEE9AAB8R!B8!@;>!;9Q<8!UA<B8O!!

!

7='8<%%,2#$C$#A'-%1*A/$/'

):!@;>!8<Q>!:9RR>:@:C!@;B:!RAD9H!DF!<8<GI:B:!@>E;8BZ9>:!<A>!9:>P!@D!:@9PI!F98E@BD8<G!<8P!

PI8<QBE! B8@>A<E@BD8:! U>@T>>8!PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:! DA! EDQHD8>8@! 8DP>:! DF! <! RBS>8! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?O!(;>:>!@>E;8BZ9>:!<A>!PBFF>A>8@!FADQ!@;>!HA>SBD9:!EG<::!DF!QDP>G4FA>>!<8<GI:B:!

B8! @;<@! UI! P>FB8B@BD8C! @;>I! <::9Q>! :DQ>! ?B8P! DF! QDP>G! U<:>P! D8! Q><:9A>:! DF!

ED88>E@BSB@IO! 0DA! @;>! :<?>! DF! :BQHGBEB@IC! @;>:>! TBGG! U>! PB:E9::>P! 98P>A! @TD! Q<B8!

E<@>RDAB>:C!8<Q>GI!Q>@;DP:! @;<@!<GGDT!:@9PIB8R! E<9:<G! B8@>A<E@BD8:!<8P! @;D:>! @;<@!PD!

8D@O!!

!

81"/1*'8<%%,2#$C$#A'-%1*A/$/'

)! 89QU>A! DF! <8<GI@BE<G! QDP>G:! <A>! 9:>F9G! @D! :@9PI! PBA>E@BD8<G! A>G<@BD8:;BH:! B8! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!<8P!E<8!U>!H<A@BE9G<AGI!9:>F9G! B8!98P>A:@<8PB8R!<8P!>G<UDA<@B8R!@;>!

8>9A<G! HADE>::B8R! B8SDGS>P! B8! :H>EBFBE! U>;<SBDA:O! (;>! Q>@;DP:! @;<@! F<GG! 98P>A! @;B:!

25 !

EG<::BFBE<@BD8! B8EG9P>! 9A%1+$2' 21"/1*' +<;,*$%&' D98>=E' F01%&,0' 21"/1*$#A' +<;,*$%&E'

G#0"2#"01*',H"1#$<%'+<;,*$%&'DGI>='1%;'F01!)'#),<0,#$21*'1%1*A/$/O!(;>:>!Q>@;DP:!<A>!

TBP>GI! <HHGBE<UG>! UD@;! @D! F1&*! <:! T>GG! <:! >G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! UA<B8! PI8<QBE:! <8P!

EDQH9@>! E<9:<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! Q>@ABE:! B8! <! 8>@TDA?! U<:>P! D8! PBFF>A>8@! 98P>AGIB8R!

<::9QH@BD8:O!$/1!<8P!+A<8R>A!E<9:<G!Q><:9A>:!E<8!>WHGDA>!UD@;!GB8><A!<8P!8D84GB8><A!

P>H>8P>8EB>:! B8! @;>! P<@<!T;BG>! '%1! <8P! +A<H;! @;>DA>@BE<G!Q>@ABE:! HABQ<ABGI! >WHGDA>!

GB8><A!A>G<@BD8:;BH:!B8!@;>!P<@<!X&DT>C!JKLKY!X#D@>!@;<@!RA<H;!@;>DAI!Q>@ABE:!E<8!<G:D!U>!

EDQH9@>P! D8! 8>@TDA?:! U9BG@! TB@;! 8D84GB8><A! ED88>E@BSB@I! Q><:9A>:YO! +A<H;! @;>DAI!

HAB8EBHG>:! FB8P! B@:! ADD@:! B8! @;>! F<E@! @;<@! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! :;DT! HADH>A@B>:! DF! :E<G>4

B8S<AB<8E>C!EAB@BE<G!PI8<QBE:!<8P!EDQHG>W!<AE;B@>E@9A>!XDA!:Q<GG!TDAGP8>::YC!T;BE;!;>GH:C!

Q<WBQB[>!RGDU<G!>FFBEB>8EI!UI!A>P9EB8R!ED:@!DF!B8FDAQ<@BD8!@A<8:F>A!<8P!EDQQ98BE<@BD8O!

(;>!Q<B8!<PS<8@<R>!DF!@;>:>!Q>@;DP:!DUSBD9:GI!B:!@;>!<UBGB@I!@D!@>:@!E<9:<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!

U>@T>>8!8DP>:!DF!A>G>S<8@!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:O!-<A@BE9G<AGIC!TB@;!'%1!<8P!+A<H;!@;>DA>@BE<G!

<8<GI:>:C! B@! B:! <G:D! HD::BUG>! @D! U9BGP!T;DG>! 8>@TDA?!QDP>G:! <8P! >:@BQ<@>! ED88>E@BSB@I!

H<A<Q>@>A:! <:! @;>I! E;<8R>! TB@;! A>:H>E@! @D! :H>EBFBE! U>;<SBDA:O! (;B:! DFF>A:! <! ADU9:@!

<HHAD<E;! @D! @B>! @DR>@;>A! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! @D! U>;<SBDA<G!Q><:9A>:! B8! ;9Q<8:O!

(;>A>! B:! 8D! :H>EBFBE! P>Q>AB@! DF! @;>:>! Q>@;DP:C! ;DT>S>AC! <:! TB@;! <8I! QDP>G4U<:>P!

<8<GI@BE<G! <HHAD<E;>:C! <HHADHAB<@>!QDP>G! P>FB8B@BD8:! D8! @;>! H<A@! DF! @;>! >WH>ABQ>8@>A!

<A>!EA9EB<G!@D!PA<TB8R!Q><8B8RF9G!B8@>AHA>@<@BD8:!DF!@;>!A>:9G@:!DF!:9E;!EDQH9@<@BD8<GGI!

B8@>8:>!<8<GI:>:O!!

! ):!>WH>E@>PC!@;>:>!<8<GI@BE<G!<HHAD<E;>:C!:H>EBFBE<GGI!RA<H;!@;>DA>@BE<G!<8<GI:B:C!

<A>!R<B8B8R!HDH9G<AB@I!@D!>W<QB8>!E;<8R>:!B8!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:C!H<A@BE9G<AGI!B8!@;>!ED8@>W@!

26 !

DF! PI8<QBE! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! 8>9ADGDRBE<G! PB:DAP>A:! <8P! 8>9A<G! HG<:@BEB@I! FDGGDTB8R!

G><A8B8R!X5<::>@@!`!59GGQDA>C!JKKgm!%O!59GGQDA>!`!'HDA8:C!JKKgm!&DT>C!JKLKYm!<!F>T!DF!

@;>:>! BQHDA@<8@! FB8PB8R:!<A>!PB:E9::>P!;>A>O!1DPBFBE<@BD8!DF! F98E@BD8<G!ED88>E@BSB@I! B8!

PDA:<G!<@@>8@BD8C!P>F<9G@!<8P!SB:9<G!A>:@B8R!:@<@>!8>@TDA?:!XF1&*Y!B8!A>:HD8:>!@D!@A<B8B8R!

<! SB:9<G! H>AE>H@9<G! G><A8B8R! @<:?! ;<:! U>>8! A>E>8@GI! P>QD8:@A<@>P! X.>TB:C! 5<GP<::<AA>C!

/DQQB@@>ABC! .9E<! &DQ<8BC! `! /DAU>@@<C! JKKgYO! 2>A>C! +A<8R>A! E<9:<:GB@I! ED88>E@BSB@I!

E;<8R>:! U>@T>>8! FAD8@<G! >I>! FB>GP! <8P! SB:9<G! EDA@>W! A>FG>E@B8R! @DH4PDT8! <@@>8@BD8<G!

HADE>::B8R!<8P!UD@@DQ49H!SB:9<G!HADE>::B8R!B8!@;>!FAD8@<G!A>RBD8:!FDGGDTB8R!@A<B8B8R!<G:D!

EDAA>G<@>P! TB@;! <QD98@! DF! U>;<SBDA<G! G><A8B8RO! 'H>EBFBE<GGIC! RA><@>A! E;<8R>:! B8! +/!

Q><:9A>:! TB@;B8! @;B:! 8>@TDA?! EDAA>G<@>P! TB@;! TDA:>! U>;<SBDA<G! H>AFDAQ<8E>C!

:9HHDA@B8R! @;>! 8D@BD8! @;<@! 8>@TDA?! DAR<8B[<@BD8! E<8! U>! <8! >WE>GG>8@! HA>PBE@DA! DF!

U>;<SBDAO!&>E>8@GIC! B@!;<:!<G:D!U>>8!:;DT8!9:B8R!RA<H;!@;>DAI!<8<GI:B:! @;<@! F98E@BD8<G!

UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!X1%+Y!:;DT!<E@BS>!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!P>H>8PB8R!D8!@;>!U>;<SBDA<G!:@<@>!b!

<E@BS>!H>AFDAQ<8E>!DF!<!:BQHG>!QD@DA!@<:?!G><P:!@D!B8EA><:>P!GD8R4A<8R>!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!

ED88>E@BSB@I! B8! U>@<! FA>Z9>8EI! U<8P:! XLh4\K! 2[Y! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! <:! EDQH<A>P! @D! A>:@!

X5<::>@@C!1>I>A4.B8P>8U>ARC!)E;<APC!$9?>C!`!59GGQDA>C!JKKiYO!*8@>A>:@B8RGIC!G>::>A!ED:@4

>FFBEB>8EI! DF! B8FDAQ<@BD8! @A<8:F>A! B8! @;B:! ;BR;>A! FA>Z9>8EI! D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@I! <G:D!

EDAA>G<@>:! TB@;! QDA>! BQH<BA>P! TDA?B8R! Q>QDAI! B8! H<@B>8@:! TB@;! :E;B[DH;A>8B<! <:!

EDQH<A>P!@D!;><G@;I!ED8@ADG:!X5<::>@@!>@!<GOC!JKKgYO!(;>:>!FB8PB8R:C!@;9:C!>QH;<:B[>!@;>!

9:>F9G8>::! DF! :@9PIB8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! @D! 98P>A:@<8P! PBFF>A>8E>:! B8! 98P>AGIB8R! 8>9A<G!

HADE>::>:!B8!S<ABD9:!U>;<SBDA<G!:@<@>:O!!

27 !

*QHDA@<8@GIC! @;>:>! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:! Q<I! <G:D! :>AS>! <:! BQHDA@<8@!

8>9A<G!Q<A?>A:!DF!F98E@BD8<G!A>EDS>AI!B8!H<@B>8@:!TB@;!8>9ADGDRBE<G!PB:DAP>A:C!<:!T>GG!<:!

Q<A?>A:! DF! <E@BS>! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8O! (;B:! ;<:! U>>8! S<GBP<@>P! UI! @;>! FB8PB8R!

@;<@! QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! A>EDS>AB8R! :@AD?>! H<@B>8@:! :;DT>P! G>::>A! :Q<GG4

TDAGP!DAR<8B[<@BD8C!TB@;!G>::!DH@BQ<G!>FFBEB>8EI!@;<@!EDAA>G<@>P!TB@;!BQHADSB8R!F98E@BD8!

DS>A! @BQ>! X6<8R!>@!<GOC! JKLKYO! 09A@;>AC! @;B:!8>@TDA?!<G:D! :;DT>P!RA><@>A!TB@;B8!8DP>!

HADE>::B8R! B8! @;>! BH:BG>:BD8<G!QD@DA! EDA@>W! <8P! ED8@A<G>:BD8<G! E>A>U>GG9QC!TB@;! <E@BS>!

E;<8R>:! B8! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! @D! @;>:>! A>RBD8:! DS>A! @BQ>C! <8P! :H>EBFBE<GGI! @;>:>!

8>@TDA?! E;<8R>:! EDAA>G<@>P!TB@;! EGB8BE<G!Q><:9A>:! DF!QD@DA! F98E@BD8O! (DR>@;>A! @;>:>!

A>:9G@:!:9RR>:@!@;<@!:@9PIB8R!<8P!E;<A<E@>AB[B8R!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!9:B8R!E<9:<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!

Q><:9A>:! B8! ;9Q<8:! E<8! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! BQHADS>! D9A! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF! F98E@BD8<G! <8P!

<P<H@BS>!8>9ADHG<:@BE!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!B8!;9Q<8:O!!

!

J<%?81"/1*'8<%%,2#$C$#A'-%1*A/$/'

(;>:>!<HHAD<E;>:!B8SDGS>!9:B8R!ED88>E@BSB@I!<8<GI:>:!9:B8R!:BQHG>!GB8><A!EDAA>G<@BD8!<8P!

H<A@B<G! G><:@! :Z9<A>:! @>E;8BZ9>:! X1E*8@D:;! `! .DU<9R;C! JKKdYO! -<A@BE9G<AGIC! :BQHG>!

EDAA>G<@BD8! <8<GI:B:! U>@T>>8! PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:! U<:>P! D8! @;>! F1&*! UGDDP! DWIR>8! G>S>G!

P>H>8P>8@!X5,.$Y!:BR8<G!@BQ>!:>AB>:C!@>AQ>P!F98E@BD8<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!DA!FE1&*C!;<:!U>>8!

TBP>GI!9:>P! @D! :@9PI!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!UD@;!<@! A>:@! <8P!P9AB8R!U>;<SBDA! X0DW!`!&<BE;G>C!

JKKeYO!(;B:! B:!<!TBP>GI!9:>P!@>E;8BZ9>!TB@;!@;>! GBQB@<@BD8!@;<@! B@! A>Z9BA>:! BP>8@BFIB8R!<!

HABDABC!:>>P!A>RBD8:!<8P!@;>!E<S><@! B:!@;<@!@;>!F98E@BD8<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!<8<GI:B:!P>H>8P:!

D8!BP>8@BFBE<@BD8!DF!@;>!:>>PO!":B8R!@;B:!@>E;8BZ9>C!@;>!:BR8<@9A>!DF!<8I!F98E@BD8<G!UA<B8!

28 !

8>@TDA?! B:! :BQHGI! @;>! :H<@B<G! Q<H! DF! @;>! EDAA>G<@>P! A>RBD8:! :>>8! B8! UD@;! ;9Q<8:!

X5A>::G>A!`!1>8D8C!JKLKm!$D:>8U<E;!>@!<GOC!JKKem!JKKem!0DW!`!&<BE;G>C!JKKem!1<8@B8B!>@!

<GOC!JKKeY!<:!T>GG!<:! B8!<8BQ<G:! XS<8!1>>A!>@!<GOC!JKLKYO! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! FE1&*!;<:!U>>8!

:@9PB>P! TBP>GI! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! A>:@B8R! :@<@>! 8>@TDA?:! U>E<9:>! @;>:>! <A>! F98E@BD8<G!

8>@TDA?:!@;<@!<A>!<E@BS<@>P!P9AB8R!@<:?!H>AFDAQ<8E>!X$D:>8U<E;!>@!<GOC!JKKem!+A>BEB9:!`!

1>8D8C!JKKdY!<8P!<G:D!<A>!QDPBFB>P!UI! @A<B8B8RcG><A8B8R! X)GU>A@!>@!<GOC!JKKgm!.>TB:!>@!

<GOC! JKKgYO! ,@;>A! 8D84E<9:<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! Q><:9A>:! @;<@! <A>! Q<B8GI! EDQH9@>P! D8!

D:EBGG<@DAI!UA<B8!PI8<QBE:!B8EG9P>!Q><:9A>:!DF!ED;>A>8E>!B8!:H>EBFBE!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:!DF!

UA<B8!<E@BSB@I!X5ADD?>:!>@!<GOC!JKLLYO!(;>!HAB8EBHG>!DF!<HHGIB8R!@;B:!@>E;8BZ9>!B:!:BQBG<A!@D!

@;<@! FE1&*! >WE>H@! @;<@! B@! B:! <HHGB>P! @D! D:EBGG<@DAI! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! <8P! B:! S>AI! 9:>F9G! B8!

P>:EABUB8R! >G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! HADH>A@B>:! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:C! T;BE;! E<8! HADSBP>!QDA>!

B8:BR;@!<UD9@!98P>AGIB8R!F98E@BD8<G!8>9A<G!HADE>::>:O!!

+BS>8!@;<@!@;>:>!A>:@B8R!:@<@>!8>@TDA?:!X&'#Y!<A>!?8DT8!@D!U>!QDPBFB<UG>C! B@! B:!

8D@!:9AHAB:B8R!@;<@!UA<B8!G>:BD8:!E<8!<G:D!<G@>A!@;>BA!PI8<QBE:O!(D!@;B:!>FF>E@C! X/<A@>A!>@!

<GOC! JKLKY! >G>R<8@GI! P>QD8:@A<@>P! @;<@! A>P9E>P! FE1&*! H<@@>A8:C! >:H>EB<GGI!

B8@>A;>QB:H;>ABE! ED88>E@BSB@I! B8! @;>! :DQ<@DQD@DA! &'#! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! EDAA>G<@>P! TB@;!

9HH>A!>W@A>QB@I!BQH<BAQ>8@!<F@>A!:@AD?>O!(;B:!ED88>E@BSB@I!T<:!<E@9<GGI!8D@!<FF>E@>P!UI!

<8! <E@9<G! :@A9E@9A<G! G>:BD8C! T;BE;! :9RR>:@:! @;<@! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! :@>Q:! FADQ!

A><:D8:!D@;>A! @;<8!Q>A>! :@A9E@9A<G! ED88>E@BD8:O!,8! @;>!D@;>A!;<8PC! XS<8!1>>A!>@!<GOC!

JKLKY! EDAADUDA<@>! @;B:! >SBP>8E>! B8! <8! <8BQ<G! :@AD?>! QDP>GC! T;>A>B8! A>EDS>AI! DF!

F98E@BD8! EDAA>G<@>:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI!TB@;! A>EDS>AI! DF! @;B:! B8@>A;>QB:H;>ABE! ED88>E@BSB@I! B8!

@;>! :>8:DABQD@DA!&'#O! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:! HADSBP>! F9A@;>A! :9HHDA@! FDA! @;>!;IHD@;>:B:! @;<@!

29 !

G><A8B8Rc@A<B8B8R!<A>!GB?>GI!@D!U>!@A<E>P!@;AD9R;!E;<8R>:!B8!&'#!<E@BSB@IO!(;B:!B:!B8@9B@BS>!

ED8:BP>AB8R!@;<@!<!GD@!DF!QD@DA!:?BGG!G><A8B8R!GB@>A<@9A>!<@@ABU9@>:!ED8:DGBP<@BD8!@D!DFFGB8>!

Q>E;<8B:Q:C! B8EG9PB8R! @;D:>! DEE9AAB8R! B8! :G>>H! X8OPOYO! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:! ;<S>! :@AD8R!

BQHGBE<@BD8:! B8! P>:BR8B8R! <8P! P>S>GDHB8R! 8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8! A>RBQ>:O! 0DA! D8>C! B@! B:!

HD::BUG>!@D!@A<E?!@;>!F98E@BD8<G!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!B8!@;>!UA<B8!FDGGDTB8R!G>:BD8:!<8P!@;B:!E<8!

U>!9:>P!@D!@>:@!@;>!>FFBE<EI!DF!<!H<A@BE9G<A!A>RBQ>O!09A@;>AC!B@!Q<I!<G:D!U>!BQHDA@<8@!B8!

P>@>AQB8B8R! DH@BQ<G! @BQ>! TB8PDT:! @D! :@<A@c<EE>G>A<@>! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8! HAD@DEDG:!

P>H>8PB8R!D8!@;>!:@<@>!DF!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8O!!

*8! :9QQ<AIC! @;>! :@9PI! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! B:! <8! BQHDA@<8@! @DDG! @D! 98P>A:@<8P!

8>9A<G! HADE>::>:! 98P>AGIB8R! EDR8B@BD8! <8P! U>;<SBDA! <:! T>GG! <:! FDA! @A<E?B8R! <8P!

98P>A:@<8PB8R!PI8<QBE!8>9ADHG<:@BE! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! @;>!UA<B8! @;<@!ED8:@<8@GI!DEE9A:!

TB@;! >WH>AB>8E>! <8P! <G:D! FDGGDTB8R! G>:BD8:! @D! @;>! UA<B8O! (;B:! :>E@BD8! PB:E9::>P! <8!

DS>ASB>T!DF!:DQ>!DF!@;>!Q>@;DP:!9:>P!B8!@;>:>!<8<GI:>:C!<8P!QDA>!P>@<BG:!DF!A>G>S<8@!

Q>@;DPDGDRI!@;<@!B:!9:>P!B8!@;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8!TBGG!U>!PB:E9::>P!G<@>A!X/;<H@>A:!\C!dC!hYO!

'

!!!!!!!

'

!!!!

30 !

&Y!Q$7%'U3'#Q7&8@8&'!8?'L'

K<' $;,%#$@A' 0,/#$%&' </2$**1#<0A' .01$%' %,#(<0L' ;A%1+$2/' 1@@,2#,;' .A' +<#<0' 2<0#$21*' #98G'

"/$%&'1'0<."/#'+<;,*?@0,,'1%1*A#$21*'1!!0<12)M'

a$J(/'C,0B'J1/'F++2'KHF*(/J+53'[`+2B1)1B0(/J212_'&,2)0+01/Z`(51*_'#1250(2(_'^'&,J+2_'

OPLL\b'

!82)0,5H4)(,2'

#D8B8S<:BS>! EDA@BE<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! @>E;8BZ9>:! :9E;! <:! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!X@$/'Y!;<S>!U>>8!TBP>GI!9:>P!@D!QDP9G<@>!EDA@BE<G!>WEB@<UBGB@IC!H<A@BE9G<AGI!

B8!@;>!QD@DA!EDA@>WC!@D!HADQD@>!HG<:@BEB@I!<8P!<9RQ>8@!F98E@BD8<G!A>EDS>AI!<GD8R!TB@;!

F98E@BD8<G! A>;<UBGB@<@BS>! @>E;8BZ9>:! (M. Nitsche, Cohen, Wassermann, Priori, Lang,

Antal, Paulus, Hummel, Boggio, & Fregni, 2008b)O! 2DT>S>AC! @;>! Q>E;<8B:Q:!

98P>AGIB8R!8>9ADHG<:@BE!E;<8R>:!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'!<A>!HDDAGI!98P>A:@DDPO!,8>!<HHAD<E;!

@D!R<B8!B8:BR;@!B8@D!@;>:>!Q>E;<8B:Q:!B:!@;>!B8S>:@BR<@BD8!DF!E;<8R>:!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'!D8!

A>:@B8R! UA<B8! <E@BSB@IC! T;BE;! B:! ?8DT8! @D! :;DT! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! QDP9G<@BD8! <F@>A! QD@DA!

G><A8B8R! X)GU>A@! >@! <GOC! JKKgYO! &>E>8@GIC! >SBP>8E>! DF! E;<8R>:! B8! A>:@B8R! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I!

BQQ>PB<@>GI! <F@>A! @$/'! ;<:! U>>8! :;DT8! B8! F1&*! <8P! %%+! 9:B8R! ED88>E@BSB@I4U<:>P!

QDP>G!PABS>8!<8<GI:B:!X-DG<8n<!>@!<GOC!JKLKm!JKLLYO!2DT>S>AC!A>:@B8R!D:EBGG<@DAI!PI8<QBE:!

HD:@4@$/'!T>A>!G>::!PBFF>A>8@B<UG>!A>G<@BS>!@D!:;<Q!X-DG<8n<!>@!<GOC!JKLKYO!(;9:C!;>A>!T>!

:D9R;@!@D!9:>!UGB8PC!P<@<4PABS>8!<8<GI:B:!DF!T;DG>4;><P!UA<B8!<E@BSB@I!<:!B@!Q<I!HADSBP>!

98UB<:>P!B8:BR;@:!@;<@!<PS<8E>!@;>!98P>A:@<8PB8R!DF!Q>E;<8B:Q:!<FF>E@>P!UI!@$/'O!!

*8!@;B:!ED8@>W@C!<!Q>@;DP!EDQUB8B8R!B8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:!X*/)Y!<8P!

31 !

:@<@B:@BE<G! EG9:@>AB8R! B:! <! ABRDAD9:C! UGB8P! <HHAD<E;! @;<@! <GGDT:! :>H<A<@BD8! DF! :9AF<E>!

:9QQ>P! EDA@BE<G! <E@BSB@I! B8@D! 98P>AGIB8R! F98E@BD8<G! 8>@TDA?! F98E@BD8! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;!

:H>EBFBE! :H>E@A<G! :BR8<@9A>:O! (A<E?B8R! E;<8R>:! B8! @;>:>! 8>@TDA?:! B8! @>AQ:! DF! @;>BA!

:H>E@A<G! E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:! E<8! U>! S>AI! 9:>F9G! @D! P>:EABU>! F98E@BD8<G! 8>9A<G! HADE>::>:!

>8R<R>PcQDPBFB>P!UI!<!:H>EBFBE!>WH>ABQ>8@<G!B8@>AS>8@BD8O!-A>SBD9:GIC!@;B:!@>E;8BZ9>!<:!

<HHGB>P! @D! >G>E@AD>8E>H;<GDRA<H;BE! X%%+Y! P<@<! A>EDAP>P! P9AB8R! H>AFDAQ<8E>! DF! <!

SB:9DQD@DA! G><A8B8R! @<:?! T<:! 9:>F9G! @D! BP>8@BFI! F98E@BD8<G! D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?:!

<::DEB<@>P! TB@;! 8>9A<G! HADE>::>:! DF! QD@DA! G><A8B8R! X/D8@A>A<:4=BP<G! `! 7>ABE?C! JKKdYO!

2>A>! T>! <HHGB>P! @;B:! Q>@;DP! @D! T;DG>4;><P! 1%+! <E@BSB@I! @D! BP>8@BFI! @;>! @>QHDA<G!

HADFBG>!DF!E;<8R>:!B8P9E>P!B8!D:EBGG<@DAI!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!9H!@D!\K!QB89@>:!<F@>A!@$/'O!

'

?+)J,5/'

IN!,0$+,%#1*'!0<2,;"0,'1%;'91#1'12H"$/$#$<%'

(T>GS>! ABR;@4;<8P>P! Xi! F>Q<G>:YC! 8>9ADGDRBE<GGI! ;><G@;I! <P9G@:! XJ\4dK! IA:C! Q><8! <R>!

JeOJ!k!hOe!IA:Y!H<A@BEBH<@>P!B8!@;B:!:@9PI!<F@>A!HADSBPB8R!B8FDAQ>P!ED8:>8@!<:!<HHADS>P!

UI! @;>! *8:@B@9@BD8<G! &>SB>T! 5D<AP! X*&5Y! <@! @;>! #<@BD8<G! *8:@B@9@>! DF! #>9ADGDRBE<G!

$B:DAP>A:!<8P!'@AD?>O!#>9ADQ<R8>@BE!P<@<!T>A>!A>EDAP>P!<@!iKK!2[!TB@;!<!U<8PTBP@;!DF!

K4LhK!2[!9:B8R!<!/(0!Jeh!1%+!:I:@>Q!X/(0!'I:@>Q:C!*8EOC!/<8<P<Y!EDQHD:>P!DF!<!T;DG>4

;><P! <AA<I! DF! Jeh! A<PB<G! L:@! DAP>A! RA<PBDQ>@>Ac'^"*$! E;<88>G:! ;D9:>P! B8! <!

Q<R8>@BE<GGI! :;B>GP>P! ADDQ! X=<E99Q:E;Q>G[>C! +>AQ<8IYO! 'I8@;>@BE! \AP! RA<PB>8@!

U<G<8EB8R!T<:!9:>P!@D!A>QDS>!U<E?RAD98P!8DB:>!D84GB8>O!-<A@BEBH<8@:C!UGB8P!@D! @IH>!DF!

:@BQ9G<@BD8C! H<A@BEBH<@>P! B8! \! :>::BD8:! b<8DP<GcE<@;DP<Gc:;<Q! @$/'C! <@! G><:@! Jd! ;D9A:!

32 !

<H<A@C!TB@;!@;>!DAP>A!DF!:@BQ9G<@BD8!H:>9PD4A<8PDQB[>P!<8P!U<G<8E>PO!(<AR>@!A>RBD8!FDA!

:@BQ9G<@BD8! BO>OC! ED8@A<G<@>A<GcG>F@! 1L! T<:! P>@>AQB8>P! UI! @A<8:EA<8B<G! Q<R8>@BE!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!@<AR>@B8R!@;>!DH@BQ<G!:E<GH!HD:B@BD8!@D!>GBEB@!QD@DA!>SD?>P!HD@>8@B<G:!DF!@;>!

ABR;@!<UP9E@DA!HDGGBEB:!UA>SB:O!)!-;DA>:DA!**!)9@D!XQDP>G!-1fhKC!*,1%$C!'<G@!.<?>!/B@IC!

"(Y!P>SBE>!T<:!9:>P!@D!<HHGI!@$/'!DS>A!1L!9:B8R!<!UBHDG<A!QD8@<R>!TB@;!@;>!E>H;<GBE!

A>F>A>8E>!>G>E@ADP>!DS>A! @;>!ABR;@!:9HA<DAUB@<G!<A><O!(;>!:@BQ9G<@BD8!T<:!P>GBS>A>P!UI!

Jh!EQJ!ED8P9E@B8R!>G>E@ADP>:!EDS>A>P!UI!:<GB8>4:D<?>P!:HD8R>C!<@!<8!B8@>8:B@I!DF!L!Q)!

XE9AA>8@!P>8:B@I!KOKd!Q)cEQJm! @D@<G!E;<AR>!KOKdf!/cEQJY! FDA!JK!QB8! B8!@;>!<8DP<G!<8P!

E<@;DP<G! @$/'! :>::BD8:! <8P! FDA! 9H! @D! JK! :>ED8P:! B8! @;>! :;<Q! :>::BD8! <EEDAPB8R! @D! <!

HA>SBD9:GI!P>:EABU>P!Q>@;DP!(Gandiga, Hummel, & Cohen, 2006)O!&>:@!1%+!A>EDAPB8R:!

T>A>!H>AFDAQ>P! B8! h! UGDE?:!DF! h!QB89@>:! ><E;! X:>>! FBRO! LYC! L! U>FDA>! X-A>Y! <8P!d! <F@>A!

:@BQ9G<@BD8C!<GGDTB8R!Q><:9A>Q>8@!DF!E;<8R>:!9H!@D!\h!QB89@>:!HD:@4@$/'O!$9AB8R!@;>!

A>EDAPB8RC! H<A@BEBH<8@:!T>A>! B8:@A9E@>P! @D! :@<I! EDQHG>@>GI! :@BGG! <8P! A>G<W>P!TB@;! @;>BA!

>I>:!EGD:>PO!!

'

0BRO! LO! ! )Y! %WH>ABQ>8@<G! @BQ>GB8>! :;DTB8R! -A>! <8P! -D:@4@$/'! A>:@! 1%+! A>EDAPB8R:O!&>EDAPB8R:!T>A>!H>AFDAQ>P!B8!h!QB8!B8@>AS<G:C!BQQ>PB<@>GI!<F@>A!@$/'!X-D:@4*QQYC!<8P!<@! LKC! JKC! <8P! \K!QB89@>:! <F@>A! @$/'! X-D:@4LKC! -D:@4JKC! <8P! -D:@4\K! A>:H>E@BS>GIYO! 5Y!5BHDG<A! >G>E@ADP>! QD8@<R>! FDA! <8DP<G! @$/'! <HHGBE<@BD8! DS>A! G>F@! 1L! B:! :;DT8m! A>P!A>HA>:>8@:! <8DP>! <8P! UG<E?! A>HA>:>8@:! E<@;DP>O! (;>:>! HDG<AB@B>:! T>A>! A>S>A:>P! FDA!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!<HHGBE<@BD8O!'

33 !

91#1'O0,?!0<2,//$%&'

$<@<!FADQ!><E;!A>:@!UGDE?!X\!QB8C!>WEG9PB8R!@;>!FBA:@!<8P!G<:@!QB89@>!DF!A>EDAPB8RY!H>A!

:9UV>E@!T>A>!P>Q><8>P!<8P!U<8P4H<::!FBG@>A>P!U>@T>>8!KOLh4LhK!2[!9:B8R!<!d@;!DAP>AC!

[>AD4H;<:>C! 59@@>ATDA@;! FBG@>A! <8P! 8D@E;4FBG@>A>P! <@! iK! <8P! LJK! 2[! 9:B8R! <! J8P! DAP>A!

/;>UI:;>S4@IH>L!FBG@>A!@D!A>QDS>!GB8>!8DB:>O!!

!

B%;,!,%;,%#'8<+!<%,%#'-%1*A/$/'1%;'8*"/#,0$%&'

%<E;!A>:@!UGDE?!DF!P<@<!T<:!:9UV>E@>P!@D!<8!>W@>8P>P!*8FDQ<W!B8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!

<8<GI:B:! X*/)Y! @D! P>EDQHD:>! B@! B8@D! :H<@B<GGI! DS>AG<HHB8RC! @>QHDA<GGI! B8P>H>8P>8@!

EDQHD8>8@:O! )GG! <8<GI:>:! T>A>! H>AFDAQ>P! 9:B8R! E9:@DQ!TAB@@>8! HADRA<Q:! >QHGDIB8R!

@;>!%%+.)5! @DDGUDW! X$>GDAQ>!`!1<?>BRC! JKKdY! B8!1)(.)5!eOLL! X(;>!1<@;TDA?:C! *8EC!

#<@TBE?C!1)YO!!!

/DQHD8>8@! EG9:@>AB8R!T<:! H>AFDAQ>P! B8! \! ED8:>E9@BS>! :@>H:O! G#,!' 3]! 74Q><8:!

EG9:@>AB8R! <GRDAB@;Q! T<:! 9:>P! @D! H<A@B@BD8! ED8:B:@>8@! H<@@>A8:! DF! <E@BS<@BD8! <EAD::!

:9UV>E@:!FDA!><E;!:@BQ9G<@BD8!ED8PB@BD8!TB@;B8!><E;!UGDE?O!(;>!<GRDAB@;Q!T<:!B@>A<@BS>GI!

DH@BQB[>P! @D! >W@A<E@! 7!Q9@9<GGI! >WEG9:BS>! EG9:@>A:! UI!QB8BQB[B8R! @;>! :9Q! DF! :Z9<A>P!

%9EGBP><8! PB:@<8E>:! DF! ><E;! DUV>E@! B8! @;>! EG9:@>A! FADQ! B@:! E>8@ADBPO! 0><@9A>:! 9:>P! FDA!

EG9:@>AB8R! B8EG9P>!XLY!:E<GH!EDQHD8>8@!Q<H!XJY!HDT>A! B8!F98E@BD8<G!A;I@;Q:!XP>G@<]L4d!

2[C!@;>@<]!d4f!2[C!<GH;<]!f4L\!2[C!U>@<]!L\4\K!2[C!GDT!R<QQ<]!\K4hK!2[C!;BR;!R<QQ<]!eK4

LKK!2[Y!EDQH9@>P!UI!B8@>RA<@B8R!HDT>A!:H>E@A<G!P>8:B@I!X-'$Y!DU@<B8>P!9:B8R!Q9G@B@<H>A!

Q>@;DPC! U>@T>>8! FA>Z9>8EI! B8@>AS<G:! X\Y! EDQHD8>8@! ?9A@D:B:! <8P! XdY! EDQHD8>8@!

>8@ADHI!XJfL!F><@9A>:!@D@<GYO!/G9:@>A:!TB@;!<A@BF<E@:!T>A>!BP>8@BFB>P!UI!SB:9<G!B8:H>E@BD8!

34 !

DF!EG9:@>A!Q><8!:E<GH!Q<H!<8P!?9A@D:B:!S<G9>:!<8P!T>A>!>WEG9P>P!FADQ!F9A@;>A!<8<GI:>:O!

G#,!'4]!74Q><8:!E>8@ADBP:! FADQ!:@>H!L!T>A>!;B>A<AE;BE<G!EG9:@>A>P!U<:>P!D8!%9EGBP><8!

PB:@<8E>! B8ED8:B:@>8EB>:! X@;A>:;DGP>P! <@! KOgY! @D! GB8?! E;<8RB8R! EG9:@>A:! <EAD::! @BQ>O!

/DH;>8>@BE!EDAA>G<@BD8!ED>FFBEB>8@:!T>A>!F9A@;>A!EDQH9@>P!U>@T>>8!EG9:@>AB8R!P>EB:BD8!

<8P!P<@<!:@A9E@9A>!@D!<::>::!@;>!Z9<GB@I!DF!EG<::BFBE<@BD8!:9RR>:@>P!UI!EG9:@>AB8RO!G#,!'5]!

(;B:!:@>H!T<:!H>AFDAQ>P!@D!@>:@!@;>!89GG!;IHD@;>:B:!@;<@!8D!PBFF>A>8E>:!>WB:@>P!U>@T>>8!

@;>! \! :@BQ9G<@BD8! ED8PB@BD8:O! /G9:@>A:! BP>8@BFB>P! FADQ! :@>H! J! FDA! ><E;! :@BQ9G<@BD8!

ED8PB@BD8!T>A>!:9UV>E@>P!@D!;B>A<AE;BE<G!EG9:@>AB8R!X<:!B8!:@>H!JYC!FBA:@!TB@;B8!><E;!UGDE?C!

<8P! 8>W@! <EAD::! UGDE?:O! /DH;>8>@BE! EDAA>G<@BD8! ED>FFBEB>8@:!T>A>! EDQH9@>P! :BQBG<A! @D!

'@>H!JO!0B8<GGIC!:H>E@A<G!E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:!DF!BP>8@BFB>P!EG9:@>A:!XA>HA>:>8@<@BS>!DF!8>@TDA?:Y!

T>A>! EDQH<A>P! U<:>P! D8! ghw! ED8FBP>8E>! B8@>AS<G:! DF! UDD@:@A<HH>P! PB:@ABU9@BD8:!

X8xLKKKKKY!DF!Q><8!HDT>A!B8!><E;!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8PO!

'

%+/H*)/'

(;>!UGB8P!*/)!P>EDQHD:B@BD8!<8P!EG9:@>AB8R!Q>@;DP!BP>8@BFB>P!\4h!F98E@BD8<G!EG9:@>A:!FDA!

><E;!:@BQ9G<@BD8!ED8PB@BD8!<@!<GG!@BQ>:!DF!Q><:9A>Q>8@C!A>@<B8B8R!DS>A!gKw!DF!<A@BF<E@4

FA>>! P<@<O! /DH;>8>@BE! ED>FFBEB>8@:! EDQH9@>P! FDA! UD@;! :@>H:! DF! ;B>A<AE;BE<G! EG9:@>AB8R!

T>A>! RA><@>A! @;<8! KOg! B8PBE<@B8R! EDAA>E@! EG9:@>AB8RO! )GG! \! :@BQ9G<@BD8! ED8PB@BD8:! T>A>!

A>HA>:>8@>P!<EAD::!d!F98E@BD8<G!8>@TDA?:!BP>8@BFB>P!HA>4@$/'!UI!:@>H!\!EG9:@>AB8RO!!

2DT>S>AC!@;B:!Q>@;DP!BP>8@BFB>P!<8!>FF>E@!DF!A><G!@$/'!A>G<@BS>!@D!:;<Q!B8!<!G>F@!

H<AB>@D4QD@DA!8>@TDA?!E;<A<E@>AB[>P!UI!<!HADRA>::BS>!P>EA><:>!B8!<GH;<!<8P!B8EA><:>!B8!

R<QQ<! U<8P! HDT>AC! :@<A@B8R! BQQ>PB<@>GI! <8P! G<:@B8R! 9H! @D! @;>! -D:@4JK! UGDE?! <F@>A!

35 !

:@BQ9G<@BD8! X0BRO! JYO! (;B:! 8>@TDA?! <HH><A>P! D8GI! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'! B8! -D:@4*QQ! <8P! <G:D!

@A<8:B>8@GI! >8R<R>P! FAD8@<G! A>RBD8:! B8! @;>! -D:@4LK! UGDE?! <F@>A! @$/'! X0BRO! \YO!":B8R! @;B:!

<HHAD<E;C!8D!PBFF>A>8E>:!U>@T>>8!<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!T>A>!FD98PO!#D!PBFF>A>8E>:!

U>@T>>8! A><G! @$/'! <8P! :;<Q!T>A>! BP>8@BFB<UG>! B8! @;>! G<:@! UGDE?! BO>OC! -D:@4\K!QB89@>:!

FDGGDTB8R!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

0BRO!JO!&><G!@$/'!>8R<R>P!<!H<AB>@D4QD@DA!8>@TDA?!X)Y!BQQ>PB<@>GI!<8P!X5Y!JK!QB89@>:!<F@>A!:@BQ9G<@BD8!A>:H>E@BS>GIO!X(DHDHGD@:!DF!EG9:@>A!Q><8:!<A>!:;DT8C!TB@;!<E@BS<@BD8!B8!F>Q@D@>:G<OY!X/Y!(;>!:H>E@A<G!:BR8<@9A>!DF!@;B:!8>@TDA?!:;DT>P!<!HADRA>::BS>!P>EA><:>!B8!<GH;<! HDT>A! <8P! B8EA><:>! B8! GDT! <8P! ;BR;! R<QQ<! HDT>AO! %AADA! U<A:! A>HA>:>8@! ghw!ED8FBP>8E>!B8@>AS<G:O!'BR8BFBE<8@!PBFF>A>8E>:!B8!HDT>A!<A>!B8PBE<@>P!UI!y!XH!z!KOKhYO!!!!

36 !

'

'

'

'

'

'

!!!!!0BRO!\O!)Y!&><G!@$/'!<G:D!E<9:>P!@;>!H<AB>@D4QD@DA!8>@TDA?!@D!@A<8:B>8@GI!>8R<R>!FAD8@<G!EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:O! (;B:! 8>@TDA?!T<:! ;B>A<AE;BE<GGI! EG9:@>A>P! PBFF>A>8@! FADQ! @;>! H<AB>@D4QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! B8! FBRO! J! P9>! @D! PBFF>A>8@! @DHDGDRIO! 5Y! (;>! :H>E@A<G! :BR8<@9A>! DF! @;B:!8>@TDA?!B:!<G:D!E;<A<E@>AB[>P!UI!;BR;>A!HDT>A!B8!;BR;>A!FA>Z9>8EB>:C!8<Q>GIC!U>@<C!GDTC!<8P!;BR;!R<QQ<O!%AADA!U<A:!A>HA>:>8@!ghw!ED8FBP>8E>!B8@>AS<G:O!! .(/4H//(,2'

(;>!@>QHDA<G!HADFBG>!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!E;<8R>:!B8!G<AR>4:E<G>!D:EBGG<@DAI!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!

B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'!B:!HA>:>8@GI!98?8DT8O!2>A>C!T>!:;DT!@;<@!A><G!@$/'!DS>A!1L!HADP9E>:!

E;<8R>:! B8! A>:@B8R! EDA@BE<G! PI8<QBE:! B8! <! A>G<@>P! H<AB>@D4QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! B8PBE<@BS>! DF!

TB@;B848>@TDA?! >8;<8E>P! GDE<G! EDA@BE<G! HADE>::B8RO! *QHDA@<8@GIC! T>! :;DT! @;<@! @;>:>!

8>@TDA?! E;<8R>:! <A>! H>A:B:@>8@! FDA! 9H! @D! Jh! QB8! HD:@4@$/'O! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:! <A>!

BQHDA@<8@!B8!<PS<8EB8R!D9A!98P>A:@<8PB8R!DF!@;>!Q>E;<8B:Q:!Q>PB<@B8R!G<:@B8R!>FF>E@:!

DF!8D84B8S<:BS>!EDA@BE<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DS>A!1L!<8P!B@:!B8FG9>8E>!DS>A!<!PB:@ABU9@>P!FAD8@D4

H<AB>@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?O!

'

37 !

F,%,01*'8<%/$;,01#$<%/'

6>! P>QD8:@A<@>! FDA! @;>! FBA:@! @BQ>! @;>! F><:BUBGB@I! DF! 9:B8R! <! P<@<4PABS>8! Q>@;DP!

EDQUB8B8R! */)! <8P! :@<@B:@BE<G! EG9:@>AB8R! @D! :@9PI! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! E;<8R>:! B8! EDA@BE<G!

8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! <FF>E@>P! UI! @$/'C! UD@;! B8! @>AQ:! DF! ! ! <G@>A>P! A>RBD8<G! <E@BSB@I! <8P!

EDA@BE<G! PI8<QBE:O! (;>! BP>8@BFB>P! 8>@TDA?! ;>A>! EDQHAB:>:! 8>9A<G! A>RBD8:! @;<@! <A>!

F98E@BD8<GGI!<8P!:@A9E@9A<GGI!B8@>AED88>E@>P!<8P!A>G>S<8@!@D!QD@DA!ED8@ADG!<8P!G><A8B8RO!

'9AHAB:B8RGIC! D9A! Q>@;DP! F<BG>P! @D! FB8P! PBFF>A>8E>:! U>@T>>8! <8DP<G! <8P! E<@;DP<G!

HDG<AB@B>:!DF!@$/'O!'>S>A<G!F<E@DA:!ED9GP!<EED98@!FDA!<U:>8E>!DF!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:O!

'B8E>!<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<G!HDG<AB@B>:!DF!:@BQ9G<@BD8!<A>!PBA>E@>P!DS>A!@;>!:<Q>C!A>G<@BS>GI!

G<AR>! EDA@BE<G! <A><! X1LYC! EDA@BE<G! <E@BSB@I! P>@>E@>P! UI!1%+C!TB@;B8! FDGP:! B8! 98P>AGIB8R!

EDA@BE<G!RIABC!Q<I!U>!B8:>8:B@BS>!XBO>OC!E<8E>G!D9@Y!@D!:9U@G>!PBFF>A>8E>:!B8!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!

<E@BS<@BD8! DF! 98P>AGIB8R! 8>9A<G! HDH9G<@BD8:O! *8P>>PC! A>E>8@! >SBP>8E>! FADQ! Q<R8>@BE!

A>:D8<8E>! :H>E@AD:EDHI! :;DTB8R! GDE<GB[>P! A>P9E@BD8! B8! {4<QB8D4U9@IABE! <EBP! BO>OC!

+)5)>ARBE! <E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! UD@;! <8DP<G! <8P! E<@;DP<G! @$/'!Q<I! :9HHDA@! @;>! G<E?! DF!

PBFF>A>8E>!B8!EDA@BE<G!D:EBGG<@DAI!PI8<QBE:!DU:>AS>P!;>A>!(Stagg et al., 2009)O!(;B:!B:!<G:D!

ED8:B:@>8@!TB@;! <! 8D84HDG<AB@I! :H>EBFBE! B8EA><:>! B8! A>RBD8<G! E>A>UA<G! UGDDP! FGDT! FD98P!

TB@;!HD:B@AD8!>QB::BD8! @DQDRA<H;I! B8! :@BQ9G<@>P!1LC! ABR;@! FAD8@<G!HDG>C! ABR;@!HABQ<AI!

:>8:DABQD@DA!EDA@>W!<F@>A!@$/'!A>G<@BS>!@D!:;<Q!(Lang et al., 2005)O!

!

8*$%$21*'B+!*$21#$<%/'

@$/'! B:! A<HBPGI! R<B8B8R! HDH9G<AB@I! <:! <8! <PV98E@! FDA! 8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8! DF!QD@DA! <8P!

EDR8B@BS>!BQH<BAQ>8@:!(Floel & Cohen, 2010; Hummel et al., 2010; Miniussi et al., 2008;

38 !

Sparing et al., 2009)O! (;9:C! EG><A>A! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF! F98E@BD8<G! E;<8R>:! B8P9E>P! B8!

:H>EBFBE!8>@TDA?:!>8R<R>P!UI! @$/'!ED9GP! G><P! @D!<!QDA>!HAB8EBHG>P!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF! @;B:!

@>E;8BZ9>O! *F! 8>@TDA?! E;<8R>:! <:! BP>8@BFB>P! ;>A>! <A>! :;DT8! @D! H<A<GG>G! U>;<SBDA<G!

BQHADS>Q>8@:!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'C!B@!B:!ED8E>BS<UG>!@;<@!B8!@;>!F9@9A>C!B8PBSBP9<G!<8<GI:B:!DF!

@;>! E;<8R>:! B8! EDA@BE<G! PI8<QBE:! B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'! ED9GP! HA>PBE@! @;>! Q<R8B@9P>! DF!

U>;<SBDA<G!>FF>E@:C!<8!B::9>!DF!HD@>8@B<G!EGB8BE<G!A>G>S<8E>O!'9E;!8>9A<G!UBDQ<A?>A:!ED9GP!

ED8@ABU9@>!@D!>FF>E@BS>!A>;<UBGB@<@BD8!:@A<@>RB>:!UI!<GGDTB8R!PBA>E@!QD8B@DAB8R!DF!H<@B>8@!

A>:HD8:>!@D!@A><@Q>8@O!

'

&,24*H/(,2'

*8!:9QQ<AIC!@;>:>!A>:9G@:!PDE9Q>8@!<!:@AD8R!>FF>E@!DF!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!B8!>8;<8EB8R!

GDE<G! EDA@BE<G! HADE>::B8R! B8! <! :H>EBFBE! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! QD@DA! 8>@TDA?O! (;B:! FB8PB8R! ;<:!

BQHGBE<@BD8:! FDA! @;>! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF!Q>E;<8B:Q:! 98P>AGIB8R! @$/'! >FF>E@:! D8! EDA@BE<G!

F98E@BD8! <8P! FDA! DH@BQB[B8R! B@:! 9:>! @D! <9RQ>8@! 8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! B8! H<@B>8@:! TB@;! UA<B8!

G>:BD8:!GB?>!@A<9Q<@BE!UA<B8!B8V9AI!X(5*Y!<8P!:@AD?>!FDA!8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8O!

'

!

!

!

!

!

!

39 !

&Y!Q$7%'M3'#Q7&8@8&'!8?'O'

K<' ;,#,0+$%,' ,@@,2#/' <@' +<#<0' 2<0#$21*' #98G' <%' $%#,012#$<%/' ($#)$%' /!,2$@$2' +<#<0'

%,#(<0LD/='$;,%#$@$,;'$%'G-3'"/$%&'1';A%1+$2'2<%%,2#$C$#A?.1/,;'1%1*A#$21*'1!!0<12)M'

!82)0,5H4)(,2'

'@9PIB8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:! @D! 98P>A:@<8P! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! B:! <!

A>G<@BS>GI! 8>T! <HHAD<E;O! &>E>8@GIC! RA<H;! @;>DA>@BE<G! <8<GI:>:! ;<S>! U>>8! <HHGB>P! @D!

E;<A<E@>AB[>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!E;<8R>:!B8!%%+!X-DG<8n<!>@!<GOC!JKLKY!<:!T>GG!<:!F1&*!X-DG<8n<!

>@!<GOC!JKLLY!FDGGDTB8R!LK!QB89@>:!DF!<8DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!1LO!*8@>A>:@B8RGIC!B@!T<:!:>>8!@;<@!

F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! B8! F1&*! <E@BSB@I! <@! A>:@! <8P! ;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI! D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@I!

:I8E;AD8B[<@BD8! B8! %%+! P9AB8R! FB8R>A! QDS>Q>8@! T<:! QDP9G<@>P! 8D@! D8GI! B8! @;>!

:@BQ9G<@>P!QD@DA! EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:C! U9@! <G:D! B8! UBG<@>A<G! FAD8@<GC! H<AB>@<G! <8P! HA>QD@DA!

EDA@BE<G! A>RBD8:! EDQH<A>P! @D! :;<Q! :@BQ9G<@BD8O! )! E<S><@! B8! 9:B8R! RA<H;! @;>DA>@BE<G!

<8<GI:B:!<:!B8!@;>:>!>WH>ABQ>8@:!B:!@;<@!B@!B:!QDA>!DF!<8!>WHGDA<@DAI!<HHAD<E;!@D!BP>8@BFI!

E;<8R>:! B8!ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8!8>@TDA?:C!<8P! B:!:9UV>E@! @D!UB<:>:!T;>8!@;A>:;DGPB8R! B:!

H>AFDAQ>P! D8! DU@<B8>P! ED88>E@BSB@I! :@A>8R@;:! <EAD::! PBFF>A>8@! A>RBD8:O! ! -<A@BE9G<AGIC!

T;>8!@;>!8>@TDA?!QDP9G<@>P!UI!@$/'!B:!8D@!EG><AGI!BP>8@BFB>PC!B@!Q<I!U>!QDA>!PBFFBE9G@!

@D!@>:@!PI8<QBE!B8@>A<E@BD8:!TB@;B8!@;<@!8>@TDA?O!!

*8! @;B:! A>R<APC! T>! ;<S>! HA>SBD9:GI! BP>8@BFB>P! @;<@! <8DP<G! @$/'! DS>A!1L!QDP9G<@>:! <!

FAD8@DH<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!@;<@!D9@G<:@:!@;>!:@BQ9G<@BD8!P9A<@BD8!FDA!9H!@D!\K!QB89@>:!9:B8R!

P<@<4PABS>8!B8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:!<8P!EG9:@>AB8R!X')LY!DF!A>:@B8R!1%+!P<@<O!

2DT>S>AC!@;>!E;<8R>:!B8!B8@>A<E@BD8:C!DA!ED88>E@BSB@IC!U>@T>>8!@;>!A>RBD8:!B8SDGS>P!B8!

40 !

@;<@! 8>@TDA?! <A>! 8D@! EG><AGI! 98P>A:@DDP! I>@O! 1DA>! BQHDA@<8@GIC! @;>! PBFF>A>8E>:! B8!

@>QHDA<G! PI8<QBE:! XHADFBG>Y! U>@T>>8! <8DP<G! <8P! E<@;DP<G! @$/'! B8! @;>:>! 8>@TDA?!

B8@>A<E@BD8:! DEE9AAB8R! <F@>A! @$/'! <A>! 8D@! ?8DT8O! 2>A>C! T>! :D9R;@! @D! <HHGI! <! 8>T!

Q>@;DP! @D! :@9PI! ED88>E@BSB@I! E;<8R>:! TB@;B8! @;B:! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! <8P! <G:D!

E;<A<E@>AB[>! @;>BA! @>QHDA<G! HADFBG>! <F@>A! @;>! >8P! DF! @$/'O! *8! @;B:! ED8@>W@C! :@A9E@9A<G!

>Z9<@BD8! QDP>GB8R! X'%1YC! <! Q>@;DP! TBP>GI! 9:>P! B8! @;>! :DEB<G! :EB>8E>:C! B:! <! S>AI!

HDT>AF9G!Q>@;DP!@D!:@9PI!F98E@BD8<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8!<!RBS>8!8>@TDA?!<8P!;<:!U>>8!

TBP>GI! <HHGB>P! @D! F1&*! U<:>P! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! X5rE;>G! `! 0AB:@D8C! JKKKm! &DT>C!

JKLKm!&DT>!>@!<GOC!JKKJm!';<AQ<!>@!<GOC!JKKgYO!)8!BQHDA@<8@!<PS<8@<R>!DF!:9E;!<!Q>@;DP!

B:!@;<@! B@!E<8!:@9PI!<8P!BP>8@BFI!E<9:<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!:@A>8R@;:C!T;BG>!<GGDTB8R!S<GBP<@BD8!

DF! QDP>G:! TB@;! ;IHD@;>:B[>P! ED88>E@BSB@I! TB@;B8! <! RBS>8! 8>@TDA?O! )8! BQHDA@<8@!

<PS<8@<R>!DS>A!E9AA>8@!RA<H;!@;>DA>@BE<G!<8<GI:B:!B:!@;<@!B@!<G:D!E<8!>:@BQ<@>!PBA>E@BD8!DF!

ED88>E@BSB@I! BO>OC! HD:B@BS>! DA! 8>R<@BS>! A<@;>A! @;<8! <U:DG9@>!Q<R8B@9P>! DF! ED88>E@BSB@I!

:@A>8R@;O! 2DT>S>AC! <! GBQB@<@BD8! DF! @;>! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! @;B:! Q>@;DP! PBA>E@GI! @D!

8>9ADBQ<RB8R!P<@<!B:!@;<@!B@! B:!<::9Q>:!G<E?!DF!@>QHDA<G!EDAA>G<@BD8!TB@;B8!@BQ>!:>AB>:C!

T;BE;! B:! SBDG<@>P! B8! 8>9A<G! P<@<O! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! Q9G@BS<AB<@>! S>E@DA! <9@DA>RA>::BD8!

QDP>GB8R! Q>@;DP:! :9E;! <:! u+A<8R>A! /<9:<GB@Iv! >:@BQ<@BD8C! <A>! 9:>F9G! @D! <EED98@! FDA!

@>QHDA<G! EDAA>G<@BD8:! TB@;B8! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! @BQ>! :>AB>:! X1DA<@@BC! '<9R<AC! `! '@A<8R>C!

JKLLYO!2>8E>C!;>A>! @;B:!Q>@;DP!T<:!<HHGB>P! @D!1%+!<8<@DQBE<G! :D9AE>! GDE<GB[>P!P<@<!

TB@;!@;>!DUV>E@BS>!DF!P>:EABU>!@;>!@BQ>4ED9A:>!X9H!@D!\K!QB89@>:!<F@>A!@;>!>8P!DF!@$/'Y!

DF! D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?! B8@>A<E@BD8:!QDP9G<@>P! UI!QD@DA! EDA@BE<G! @$/'!TB@;B8! <! FAD8@D4

H<AB>@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?!:;DT8!B8!FBRO!LO!(;B:!8>@TDA?!;<:!U>>8!BP>8@BFB>P!@D!U>!DF!EGB8BE<G!

41 !

A>G>S<8E>! B8!QD@DA! >W>E9@BD8! B8! :@AD?>!H<@B>8@:! X';<AQ<!>@! <GOC! JKKgYO! ! ';<AQ<!>@! <GOC!

XJKKgY! BP>8@BFB>P!<8P!:@9PB>P!<!UBG<@>A<G! X<8P!:IQQ>@ABE<GY! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?O! ! *8!

@;B:! E<:>C! ;DT>S>AC! @;>! 98BG<@>A<GC! G>F@4:BP>P! EDQHD8>8@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! T<:!

QDP>G>P!<8P!<8<GI[>P!<:!@;>!@$/'!T<:!P>GBS>A>P!D8GI!@D!@;>!G>F@!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>W!

X1LY!<8P!<G:D!DTB8R! @D! @;>! A>G>S<8E>!DF! @;>! G>F@! :BP>!DF! @;B:!8>@TDA?! @D! ABR;@4;<8P>P!

A><E;B8R! <8P! HDB8@B8R!QD@DA! U>;<SBDA! X$DID8! >@! <GOC! JKKgm! ';<PQ>;A!`!6B:>C! JKKhYO!

(;B:! <8<GI@BE<G! Q>@;DPC! D8>! FDAQ! DF! (BQ>! '>AB>:! *8F>A>8E>! X('*YC! EDQ>:! TB@;! @;>!

<PS<8@<R>!@;<@!B@!8<@9A<GGI!<EEDQQDP<@>:!:@DE;<:@BE!HADE>::>:C!<8P!@;9:!B:!T>GG!:9B@>P!

@D!@;>!9UBZ9B@D9:!S<AB<UBGB@I!@;<@!B:!FD98P!B8!8>9A<G!@BQ>!:>AB>:!P<@<O!09A@;>AQDA>C!98P>A!

HADH>A! ED8PB@BD8:C! ('*! Q>@;DP:! E<8! U>! >FF>E@BS>GI! 9:>P! @D! A>G<@>! 8>9A<G! <E@BSB@I! @D!

EDR8B@BS>!F98E@BD8!X5A>::G>A!`!'>@;C!JKLLYO!2>A>!T>!E;D:>!@D!<HHGI!@;B:!Q>@;DPC!FDA!@;>!

FBA:@!@BQ>C!@D!:@9PI!@;>!>FF>E@:!DF!8D84B8S<:BS>!@$/'!D8!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@IO!

!

!

42 !

0BRO! LO! '@A9E@9A<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! QDP>G! FDA! +A<8R>A! /<9:<GB@I! XDA! ('*Y! <8<GI:B:! DF!;IHD@;>:B[>P! E<9:<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! U>@T>>8! A>RBD8:! DF! <! UBG<@>A<G! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?O! .]! .>F@m! -0]! -A>FAD8@<G! EDA@>W! X5ADPQ<88! <A><! LKYm! -1]! =>8@A<G! -A>QD@DA!EDA@>Wm!1L]!-ABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>Wm!-.]!-<AB>@<G!EDA@>W!X5ADPQ<88!<A><!eYO!!'

?+)J,5/'

IN!,0$+,%#1*'!0<2,;"0,'1%;'91#1'12H"$/$#$<%'

(;>!>WH>ABQ>8@<G!HADE>P9A>!<8P!P<@<!<EZ9B:B@BD8!T<:!@;>!:<Q>!<:!B8!:H>EBFBE!<BQ!L!X@;>!

>WH>ABQ>8@<G!@BQ>GB8>!B:!:;DT8!<R<B8!B8!FBRO!JYO!#>9ADQ<R8>@BE!P<@<!@;9:!DU@<B8>P!T>A>!

:9UV>E@>P!@D!ED88>E@BSB@I!<8<GI:B:!<:!P>:EABU>P!B8!@;>!FDGGDTB8R!:>E@BD8:O!

'

!!!!!0BRO! JO! ! )Y! %WH>ABQ>8@<G! @BQ>GB8>! :;DTB8R! -A>! <8P! -D:@4@$/'! A>:@! 1%+! A>EDAPB8R:O!&>EDAPB8R:!T>A>!H>AFDAQ>P!B8!h!QB8!B8@>AS<G:C!BQQ>PB<@>GI!<F@>A!@$/'!X-D:@4*QQYC!<8P!<@! LKC! JKC! <8P! \K!QB89@>:! <F@>A! @$/'! X-D:@4LKC! -D:@4JKC! <8P! -D:@4\K! A>:H>E@BS>GIYO! 5Y!5BHDG<A! >G>E@ADP>! QD8@<R>! FDA! <8DP<G! @$/'! <HHGBE<@BD8! DS>A! G>F@! 1L! B:! :;DT8m! A>P!A>HA>:>8@:! <8DP>! <8P! UG<E?! A>HA>:>8@:! E<@;DP>O! (;>:>! HDG<AB@B>:! T>A>! A>S>A:>P! FDA!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!<HHGBE<@BD8O!!

91#1'O0,?!0<2,//$%&'1%;'GA%#),#$2'-!,0#"0,'>1&%,#<+,#0$2'DG->='-%1*A/$/'

&<T! 8>9ADQ<R8>@BE! P<@<!T>A>! U<8P4H<::! FBG@>A>P! U>@T>>8! KOLh4LhK! 2[! 9:B8R! <! [>AD4

H;<:>!0*&!FBG@>A!<8P!HDT>A!GB8>!8DB:>!T<:!A>QDS>P!9:B8R!8D@E;!FBG@>A!XiK!2[!<8P!;BR;>A!

;<AQD8BE:YO! (;>! P<@<! T>A>! @;>8! @A<8:FDAQ>P! B8@D! @;A>>4PBQ>8:BD8<G! >:@BQ<@>:! DF!

:D9AE>!HDT>A!9:B8R! :I8@;>@BE!<H>A@9A>!Q<R8>@DQ>@AI! X')1Y! X=AU<!`!&DUB8:D8C!JKKLY!

U<:>P! D8! ED4A>RB:@A<@BD8! TB@;! :@A9E@9A<G! UA<B8! BQ<R>:! DU@<B8>P! FDA! ><E;! B8PBSBP9<G!

:9UV>E@O! |(L4T>BR;@>P!:@A9E@9A<G!UA<B8! BQ<R>:! X1<R8>@B[<@BD8!-A>H<A>P!&<HBP!+A<PB>8@!

43 !

%E;D! 4!1-&)+%Y! T>A>! <EZ9BA>P! :>H<A<@>GI! FDA! ><E;! :9UV>E@! TB@;! A>H>@B@BD8! @BQ>! BO>OC!

(%c(&!x!JOieJ:!ciOJhi:C!KOg\ehWKOg\ehQQJ!B84HG<8>!A>:DG9@BD8C!TB@;!Lgf!:GBE>:!<@!LQQ!

@;BE?8>::! H>A! SDG9Q>!H>A! SDG9Q>C!)EZ9B:B@BD8!1<@ABW! x! JhiWJhiC! 0,=!x! JdKWJdKQQ}O!

%<E;!SDW>G!TB@;B8!@;>!EDA@>W!B:!<::DEB<@>P!TB@;!<!U><QFDAQ>A!XJeh!W!L!S>E@DAYC!<!98BZ9>!

:>@!DF!T>BR;@B8R! F<E@DA:! @;<@!')1!R>8>A<@>:! FADQ!@;>!A>EDAP>P!Q<R8>@BE! FB>GP!<@!><E;!

:>8:DAC! @D! R>8>A<@>! <! SDG9Q>@ABE! A>HA>:>8@<@BD8! DF! UA<B8! <E@BSB@IO! (;>! FBG@>A! D9@H9@! <@!

><E;!SDW>G!B:!<!SBA@9<G!E;<88>GC!<!GB8><A!EDQUB8<@BD8!DF!@;>!Q><:9A>Q>8@:!DS>A!@BQ>!FDA!

@;<@!:H>EBFBE!UA<B8!GDE<@BD8O!')1!P>@>AQB8>:!DH@BQ<G!:H<@B<G!FBG@>A:!U<:>P!D8!<!QB8BQ9Q4

S<AB<8E>! U><QFDAQ>A! @;<@! >:@BQ<@>:! E9AA>8@! PBHDG>! HDT>A! E;<8R>:! B8! <! SDW>G! TB@;B8!

H<A@BE9G<A!@BQ>!TB8PDT:!<8P!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:!<8P!@;>!DH@BQ<G!DAB>8@<@BD8!DF!@;>!PBHDG>!

T<:!>:@BQ<@>P!9:B8R!@;>!S>E@DA4U<:>P!<HHAD<E;!X&9@@>A!>@!<GOC!JKKgYO!)!PBHDG>!:H<EB8R!DF!

e!QQC!EDAA>:HD8PB8R!@D!<!E9UBE!SDW>G!TBP@;!DF!e!QQC!T<:!9:>P!FDA!><E;!P<@<:>@!BO>O!H>A!

UGDE?! DF! A>EDAPB8R! U>FDA>! <8P! <F@>A! @$/'O! 'B8RG>4:@<@>! ')1! BQ<RB8R! @D! >:@BQ<@>! @;>!

HDT>A! :D9AE>! PB:@ABU9@BD8! B8! @;>! UA<B8! <8P! 8DAQ<GB[<@BD8! T<:! <EEDQHGB:;>P! SB<! <!

ED8:@<8@! 8DB:>! >:@BQ<@>! U<:>P! D8! @;>! S>AI! ;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI! HDT>A! XqLKK! 2[Y! XBO>OC!

%:@BQ<@>P! -DT>A! x! &<T! 'D9AE>! -DT>Ac/D8:@<8@! #DB:>! %:@BQ<@>Y! <:! B8! X&9@@>A! >@! <GOC!

JKKgYO!09A@;>AC!@;>!@BQ>4FA>Z9>8EI!A>HA>:>8@<@BD8!DF!HDT>A!<EAD::!@;>!LfK!:>ED8P:!DF!

@;>! ')1! FBG@>A! D9@H9@! <@! ><E;! SBA@9<G! E;<88>G! T<:! EDQH9@>P! UI! ED8SDG9@BD8! TB@;! <!

:GBPB8R!2<QQB8R!TB8PDT!XJKK!QBGGB:>ED8P!TBP>Y!TB@;!eh!w!DS>AG<H!B8!DAP>A!@D!IB>GP!<!\$!

@BQ>! :>AB>:! X\iKL! P<@<! HDB8@:Y! DF! <E@BS<@BD8! FDA! ><E;! SDW>G! DF! <8<@DQBE<G! :D9AE>! DF!

8>9ADQ<R8>@BE! <E@BSB@I! TB@;! <8! DH@BQ<G! @BQ>4! <8P! :H>E@A<G4A>:DG9@BD8O! (;>! ')1!

EDS<AB<8E>! Q<@ABW! T<:! E<GE9G<@>P! B8! @;>! FA>Z9>8EI! U<8P:! A>G>S<8@! @D! :>8:DABQD@DA!

44 !

HADE>::B8R! <:! P>:EABU>P! B8! @;>! GB@>A<@9A>! X<8P! @;>:>! T>A>! <G:D! BP>8@BFB>P! @D! U>!

QDP9G<@>P!B8!:H>EBFBE!<BQ!LY!BO>OC!<GH;<]!f4L\!2[C!U>@<]!L\4\K!2[C!GDT!R<QQ<]!\K4hK!2[C!

;BR;!R<QQ<]!eK4LKK!2[O!!

!

8<%%,2#$C$#A'1%1*A/$/'"/$%&'F01%&,0'81"/1*$#A''

(;>!8>@TDA?!:;DT8!B8!FBRO!LC!A>G>S<8@!@D!QD@DA!F98E@BD8!X';<AQ<!>@!<GOC!JKKgYC!B:!U<:>P!

D8!<8<@DQBE<G!ED88>E@BSB@I!U<:>P!D8!@;>!/D/D1<E!P<@<U<:>!XTTTOEDEDQ<EODARYO!*@!T<:!

:9UV>E@>P!@D!+A<8R>A!/<9:<GB@I!Q9G@BS<AB<@>!A>RA>::BD8!<8<GI:B:!9:B8R!HADRA<Q:!TAB@@>8!

B8! @;>! &! :@<@B:@BE<G! EDQH9@B8R! >8SBAD8Q>8@! @;<@! <PDH@:! <! P<@<4PABS>8! <HHAD<E;! FDA!

>:@BQ<@BD8! DF! @;>! G<RR>P! >FF>E@:! DF! @>QHDA<G! EDAA>G<@BD8! TB@;B8! 8>9A<G! @BQ>! :>AB>:O!

=>E@DA!<9@D4A>RA>::BS>!QDP>GB8R!X=)&YC!<:!<HHGB>P!@D!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!P<@<C! B:!<!HABQ<ABGI!

P<@<4PABS>8! <HHAD<E;! @D! >:@BQ<@>! @>QHDA<G! XDA! G<RR>PY! B8@>A4A>RBD8<G! >FF>E@:! TB@;B8! <!

8>@TDA?O! 1DP>G! DAP>A! T<:! P>@>AQB8>P! @D! U>! L! FDA! @;>:>! P<@<! XU<:>P! D8! @;>! )*/!

EAB@>ABD8YO!(;>!Q<B8!PBFF>A>8E>!U>@T>>8!=)&!<8P!'@A9E@9A<G!>Z9<@BD8!QDP>GB8R!X'%1Y!B:!

@;<@! @;>! G<@@>A!QDP>G:! B8:@<8@<8>D9:! A>G<@BD8:;BH:!U>@T>>8! A>RBD8:! B8!<!8>@TDA?C! <8P!

BQHDA@<8@GI! <GGDT:! @>:@B8R! ;IHD@;>:B:4PABS>8! QDP>G:! DF! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P! >:@BQ<@B8R!

>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!:@A>8R@;:C!?8DT8!<:!H<@;!ED>FFBEB>8@:O!+BS>8!@;<@!8>B@;>A!DF!@;>:>!

Q>@;DP:! B8PBSBP9<GGI! DH@BQ<GGI! A>HA>:>8@:! @;>! @A9>! :@<@>! DF! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! PI8<QBE:C!

'@A9E@9A<G!=>E@DA!)9@DA>RA>::BD8!BO>OC!'=)&!TD9GP!U>!<8!>WE>GG>8@!<HHAD<E;!@D!EDQUB8>!

@;>!:@A>8R@;:!DF!@;>:>!@TD!<HHAD<E;>:!@D!>:@BQ<@>!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!B8!<!;IHD@;>:B:4

PABS>8!Q<88>AO!2DT>S>AC!:B8E>!@;B:!B:!<!A>G<@BS>GI!8>T!<HHAD<E;C!B@!B:!8D@!I>@!@D!:>@!9H!@D!

P><G! TB@;! 8>9A<G! 8>@TDA?:! B8SDGSB8R! UBPBA>E@BD8<G! B8@>A<E@BD8:C! :9E;! <:! @;D:>! FD98P!

45 !

U>@T>>8!HA>QD@DA!<8P!:9HHG>Q>8@<AI!QD@DA!<A><:!X.-1!<8P!'1)C!A>:H>E@BS>GIY!B8!D9A!

8>@TDA?! DF! B8@>A>:@O! (;>A>FDA>C! RBS>8! @;>! :9H>ABDA! @>QHDA<G! A>:DG9@BD8! DF! 1%+! P<@<!

XEDQH<A>P!@D!F1&*YC!('*!DA!+A<8R>A!E<9:<GB@I!>:@BQ<@BD8!T<:!@;>!QD:@!:9B@<UG>!Q>@;DP!

@D!>:@BQ<@>!8>@TDA?!B8@>A<E@BD8:!B8!D:EBGG<@DAI!UA<B8!<E@BSB@IC!B8!<!Q<88>A!@;<@!DH@BQ<GGI!

QDP>G:! 8>9A<G! @BQ>! :>AB>:C! B8! DAP>A! @D! HADSBP>! S<G9<UG>! B8:BR;@:! B8@D! 8>9A<G!

Q>E;<8B:Q:cHADE>::>:! @;<@!Q<I!U>!QDPBFB>P!UI! E;<8RB8R!8>@TDA?! B8@>A<E@BD8:O! (;9:C!

;>A>!@;B:!Q>@;DP!T<:!<HHGB>P!@D!@>:@!<8!<8<@DQBE<G!QDP>G!DF!ED88>E@BSB@I!DF!D:EBGG<@DAI!

PI8<QBE:! B8! <! UBG<@>A<G! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! A>G>S<8@! @D! QD@DA! F98E@BD8! TB@;! @;>!

DUV>E@BS>!DF!E;<A<E@>AB[B8R!@;>!@>QHDA<G!HADFBG>!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!QDP9G<@BD8! B8P9E>P!UI!

QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!EDQH<A>P!@D!:;<QO!

$1F*+' LA! (<BG<A<E;! EDDAPB8<@>:! DF! &>RBD8:! DF! *8@>A>:@! X&,*Y! B8! .>F@! 0AD8@DH<AB>@<G!#>@TDA?!

!

!(;>! <8<@DQBE<G! A>RBD8:l! @BQ>! :>AB>:! T>A>! DU@<B8>P! FADQ! :B8RG>! e! QQ! E9UBE!

SDW>G:!<AD98P!@;>!(<G<BA<E;!EDDAPB8<@>:!:H>EBFB>P!FDA!1LC!-1SC!'1)!U<:>P!D8!<!Q>@<4

<8<GI:B:! DF! @;>! UA<B8! Q<H:! DF! :>8:DABQD@DA! EDA@BE<G! <E@BS<@BD8! X'>>! (<UG>! LY! X1<I?<C!

/DAED:C!.>9AR<8:C!`!=<BGG<8ED9A@C!JKKiY!<8P!FDA!-0!<8P!H<AB>@<G!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:!U<:>P!D8!

EDDAPB8<@>:! DF! 5ADPQ<88! <A><:! :H>EBFB>P! UI! X';<AQ<! >@! <GOC! JKKgY! FADQ! <! :@<8P<AP!

(<G<BA<E;! <@G<:O! (;>:>! <8<GI:>:! T>A>! H>AFDAQ>P! 9:B8R! F98E@BD8:! B8! )0#*! JKLK! X/DWC!

LggiYO! (;>! QDP>G! >:@BQ<@BD8! T<:! H>AFDAQ>P! <@! @;>! B8PBSBP9<G! :9UV>E@! G>S>G! FDA! ><E;!

46 !

FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P!DF!B8@>A>:@!X<GH;<C!U>@<C!GDT!R<QQ<!<8P!;BR;!R<QQ<YC!TB@;B8!><E;!UGDE?!

DF!:@<8P<APB[>P!A>:@!P<@<!A>EDAPB8R!FDA!>S>AI!:>::BD8!DF!@$/'!X)8DP<Gc/<@;DP<Gc';<QYO!

,TB8R!@D!HG<9:BUG>!P<I4@D4P<I!PBFF>A>8E>:!B8!HDT>A!TB@;B8!<!:9UV>E@C!@;>!>:@BQ<@>P!H<@;!

ED>FFBEB>8@:C!DA!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!Q><:9A>:C!FDA!HD:@4@$/'!UGDE?:!DF!A>EDAPB8R!T>A>!

:9U:>Z9>8@GI! U<:>GB8>! EDAA>E@>P! BO>OC! 8DAQ<GB[>P! X-A>4@$/'! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! X%/Y!

FDA! ><E;! H<@;! T<:! :9U@A<E@>P! FADQ! EDAA>:HD8PB8R! H<@;:! B8! ><E;! DF! @;>! d! -D:@4@$/'!

UGDE?:Y! FDA! ><E;! FA>Z9>8EI! U<8P! H>A! :9UV>E@O! ! 0ADQ! <! HA<E@BE<G! H>A:H>E@BS>C! <U:DG9@>!

>FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! Q><:9A>:! <A>! <G:D! 8D@! S>AI! B8FDAQ<@BS>C! :B8E>! @;>:>! Q<I! S<AI!

<EAD::!S<ABD9:!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!Q>@;DP:!<8P!<G:D!<EAD::!8<@9A>!DF!P<@<!9:>P!FDA!QDP>GB8R!

X8<Q>GIC! :H>E@A<G! HDT>AC! H;<:>! GDE?B8R! S<G9>:C! >@EYO! (;9:C! B@! B:! >SBP>8@! @;<@! T;BG>!

ED8:BP>AB8R! >FF>E@:! DF! <8! B8@>AS>8@BD8! :9E;! <:! @$/'! D8! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@IC!

8DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! DFF>A:! <! U>@@>A! HG<@FDAQ! @D! :@9PI! <8P! P>:EABU>! @;>!

>Q>AR>8@!E;<8R>:!B8!8>@TDA?!E;<A<E@>AB:@BE:!FDGGDTB8R!@;>!@$/'O!

! +AD9H4G>S>G! :@<@B:@BE<G! <8<GI:B:!T<:!H>AFDAQ>P!UI! A988B8R! <!QBW>P!>FF>E@:! @TD4

T<I! A>H><@>P! Q><:9A>:! <8<GI:B:! DF! S<AB<8E>! X)#,=)Y! TB@;! J! TB@;B8! :9UV>E@! F<E@DA:C!

8<Q>GIC! @IH>!DF!:@BQ9G<@BD8!<8P!@BQ>!Xd!UGDE?:Y! FDA!@;>!UBDGDRBE<GGI!>W@<8@!ED88>E@BD8:!

TB@;B8! @;>! G>F@! H<AB>@D4FAD8@<G! 8>@TDA?! Xf! @;<@! <A>! :;DT8! B8! FBRO! LYO! (;B:! <8<GI:B:! T<:!

H>AFDAQ>P!FDA!><E;!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P!DF!B8@>A>:@!@;<@!B:!<8<GI[>PC!8<Q>GIC!<GH;<C!U>@<C!GDT!

<8P! ;BR;! R<QQ<O! -D:@4;DE! H<BATB:>! EDQH<AB:D8:! T>A>! H>AFDAQ>P! SB<! (9?>I! @>:@:!

XEDAA>E@>P! FDA! Q9G@BHG>! EDQH<AB:D8:YO! )GG! <8<GI:>:! T>A>! H>AFDAQ>P! 9:B8R! E9:@DQ!

HADRA<Q:!TAB@@>8!B8!1<@G<U!eOLL!X(;>!1<@;6DA?:C!*8EOC!#<@BE?C!1)Y!<8P!)0#*!X)8<GI:B:!

DF! 098E@BD8<G! #>9A<G! *Q<R>:C! |SO! )0#*~JKLL~LJ~JL~LKLd}YO! '@<@B:@BE<G! <8<GI:>:! T>A>!

47 !

H>AFDAQ>P!9:B8R!@;>!&4H<E?<R>!XSO!JOLdOLY!<8P!'@<@B:@BE<G!-<E?<R>!FDA!@;>!'DEB<G!'EB>8E>:!

X'-''C!LfOKYO!!

'

%+/H*)/'

(;>A>!T<:!8D! :BR8BFBE<8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! W! @BQ>! B8@>A<E@BD8C! B8@>A>:@B8RGIC! FDA! <8I!DF! @;>! f!

;IHD@;>:B[>P!H<@;:!X8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@IYC!B8!<8I!DF!@;>!d!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:!

@>:@>P! B8! @;B:! <8<GI:B:O! ! 2DT>S>AC! @;>! <8<GI:B:! A>S><G>P! <! Q<B8! >FF>E@! FDA! @IH>! DF!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!FDA!@;>!FDGGDTB8R!ED88>E@BD8:]!'9HHG>Q>8@<AI!QD@DA!<A><!@D!.>F@!HA>QD@DA!

EDA@>W! X'1)4.-1Y! XHzKOKKKLY! <8P! '9HHG>Q>8@<AI! QD@DA! <A><! @D! .>F@! HABQ<AI! QD@DA!

EDA@>W!X'1)4.1LY!XHxKOKKgfY!B8!@;>!GDT!R<QQ<!U<8PO!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!B8!@;>!;BR;!R<QQ<!

U<8PC! <! :BR8BFBE<8@!Q<B8! >FF>E@!T<:! FD98P! FDA! @;>! ED88>E@BD8! U>@T>>8! '1)! <8P! .-1!

XHxKOKdKdYC!<:!T>GG!<:!.>F@!HA>FAD8@<G!EDA@>W!<8P!'1)!X.-04'1)Y!XHxKOKddKYO!!

48 !

!

0BRO!\O!!/;<8R>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'!B8!GDT!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! FDA! @;>! \! :@BQ9G<@BD8! ED8PB@BD8:! XQ<B8! >FF>E@! 4! <S>A<R>P! <EAD::! <GG! d!UGDE?:m!Q><8!k!:@<8P<AP!>AADAYO!y!HzKOKh!!8)1%&,/'$%'P<('F1++1'.1%;'%,#(<0L'2<%%,2#$C$#A'

-D:@4;DE! @>:@:! X(9?>I! <PV9:@>P! H<BA4TB:>! EDQH<AB:D8:Y! A>S><G>P! @;<@! <! :BR8BFBE<8@!

PBFF>A>8E>!U>@T>>8!';<Q!<8P!/<@;DP<G4@$/'!XHzKOKKLm!<PV9:@>P!H4S<G9>:!<A>!A>HDA@>P!

FDA!HD:@4;DE! EDQH<AB:D8:YC!TB@;!RA><@>A!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/! FDGGDTB8R!/<@;DP<G4@$/'! B8! @;>!

'1)4.-1!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! B8! @;>!HD:@4:@BQ9G<@BD8!H>ABDP! X:>>! FBRO! \YO!

(;>!PBFF>A>8E>!U>@T>>8!)8DP<G!<8P!/<@;DP<G4@$/'!RAD9H:!FDA!@;B:!ED88>E@BSB@I!PBP!8D@!

A><E;!:BR8BFBE<8E>!XHxKOLeY!P>:HB@>!<!:@AD8R!@A>8PC!<8P!@;>!PBFF>A>8E>!U>@T>>8!@;>!';<Q!

<8P!)8DP<G4@$/'!8><AGI!A><E;>P!:BR8BFBE<8E>!XHxKOKfYO!!!

49 !

0DA!@;>!'1)4.1L!H<@;C!HD:@4;DE!@>:@:!A>S><G>P!<!:BR8BFBE<8@!PBFF>A>8E>!U>@T>>8!

';<Q!<8P!)8DP<G4@$/'! XHxKOKLYC!TB@;! RA><@>A! 8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! B8! @;B:! H<@;! B8! @;>! ';<Q!

ED8PB@BD8! EDQH<A>P! @D! )8DP<G4@$/'O! (;>A>! T>A>! 8D! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! U>@T>>8!

)8DP<G!<8P!/<@;DP<G4@$/'!DA!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q4@$/'O!,S>A<GGC!)8DP<G4@$/'!<HH><A>P!

@D!HADP9E>!@;>!G><:@!B8EA><:>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!<EAD::!UD@;!@;>:>!H<@;:O!

'

8)1%&,/'$%'Q$&)'F1++1'.1%;'%,#(<0L'2<%%,2#$C$#A''

-D:@4;DE!H<BATB:>!EDQH<AB:D8:!A>S><G>P!<!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!;BR;>A!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!B8!@;>!'1)4

.-1! H<@;! B8! @;>! ';<Q4@$/'! EDQH<A>P! @D! )8DP<G4@$/'! XHxKOKJdY! <:! T>GG! <:! ';<Q!

EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G4@$/'!XHxKOKK\iY!X:>>!FBRO!dYO!2DT>S>AC!FDA!@;>!.-04'1)!H<@;C!@;>!

B8EA><:>!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!T<:!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!RA><@>A!FDA!@;>!';<Q!EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G4

@$/'! XHxKOKJgYO! (;>A>!T>A>! 8D! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! U>@T>>8! )8DP<G! <8P! /<@;DP<G4

@$/'!>FF>E@:!D8!>B@;>A!DF!@;>:>!H<@;:!P>:HB@>!<!:@AD8R!@A>8PO!

!

50 !

!

0BRO!dO!!/;<8R>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'!B8!;BR;!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! FDA! @;>! \! :@BQ9G<@BD8! ED8PB@BD8:! XQ<B8! >FF>E@! 4! <S>A<R>P! <EAD::! <GG! d!UGDE?:m!Q><8!k!:@<8P<AP!>AADAYO!y!HzKOKh!!

.(/4H//(,2'

2IHD@;>:B:4U<:>P! <8<GI:>:! DF! <! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'!

A>S><G>P! <! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>! U>@T>>8! ';<Q! <8P! A><G! X)8DP<G! `! /<@;DP<GY! @$/'C!

:H>EBFBE<GGI! B8! ;BR;! FA>Z9>8EIC! R<QQ<! U<8P! D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@IC! <8<GDRD9:! @D! A>:9G@:!

FD98P!U<:>P!D8!<HHAD<E;!<PDH@>P!B8!'H>EBFBE!)BQ!L!X=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8C!/D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC!

'<8PAB8BC!`!/D;>8C!JKLLYO!09A@;>AQDA>C!@;>:>!E;<8R>:!<HH><A!@D!U>!PABS>8!UI!8>@TDA?!

51 !

<E@BSB@I!HABQ<ABGI! B8SDGSB8R!@;>!ED88>E@BD8:!@D!<8P!FADQ!@;>!'1)!@D!<::DEB<@>P!A>RBD8:!

X.1L!X:@BQ9G<@>P!A>RBD8YC!.-1!<:!T>GG!.-0YO!!

*8@>A>:@B8RGIC!B@!<HH><A:!@;<@!@;>!B8EA><:>:!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!<A>!Q9E;!GDT>A!B8!<GG!

@;>!d!H<@;:!FDGGDTB8R!)8DP<G!@$/'!EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'O!6;BG>!@;>A>!

T>A>!8D!:BR8BFBE<8@!PBFF>A>8E>:!U>@T>>8!/<@;DP<G!<8P!)8DP<G4@$/'C!@;>A>!<HH><A>P!@D!

U>!<!@A>8P!FDA!RA><@>A!B8EA><:>:!B8!@;>!FDAQ>A!X:>>!FBR:O!\!`!dYO!+BS>8!@;<@!@;B:!B:!A>:@B8R!

:@<@>! A>EDAPB8R! DF! :HD8@<8>D9:! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! DS>A! \K! QB89@>:! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'C!

FG9E@9<@BD8:!<A>!GB?>GI!>WH>E@>P!TB@;!:9UV>E@l:!:@<@>!DF!QB8PC!>S>8!B8!@;>!<U:>8E>!DF!<8I!

B8@>AS>8@BD8C! :9E;! <:! P9AB8R! @;>! ';<Q4@$/'! ED8PB@BD8O! ,8>! HD::BUG>! B8@>AHA>@<@BD8! B:!

@;<@!@;>:>!:HD8@<8>D9:!E;<8R>:!DA!S<AB<@BD8:!B8!A>:@B8R!:@<@>!<E@BSB@I!ED9GP!<EED98@!FDA!

B8V>E@B8R!;BR;>A!8DB:>!B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!H<@@>A8:O!*8!F<E@C!<!E>A@<B8!DH@BQ<G!<QD98@!DF!

8DB:>!Q<I!<E@9<GGI!F<SDA!@;>!<UBGB@I!@D!Z9BE?GI!@A<8:B@BD8!U>@T>>8!PBFF>A>8@!uQDP>:v!DA!

D:EBGG<@DAI!:@<@>:!DF!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!@;<@!<A>!uB8!@98>v!TB@;!PBFF>A>8@!?B8P:!DF!U>;<SBDA!

X59[:�?BC!JKKim!59[:�?B!`!$A<R9;8C!JKKdm!'>V8DT:?B!`!-<9G:>8C!JKKiYO!2DT>S>AC! B8!@;>!

ED8@>W@! DF! QDP9G<@B8R! <! 8>@TDA?! XDA! u8>@TDA?! HABQB8RvYC! <:! B:! <@@>QH@>P! TB@;!

<HHAD<E;>:! GB?>! 8D84B8S<:BS>! @$/'C! A>P9EB8R! 8DB:>! B8! @;>! :I:@>QC! <8P! ED8EDQB@<8@GI!

B8EA><:B8R! :BR8<G4@D48DB:>! A<@BD! X'#&Y! ED9GP! HD@>8@B<GGI! U>! S>AI! F<SDA<UG>! @D! UB<:!

U>;<SBDA:!@;<@!FDGGDT!:@BQ9G<@BD8C!B8!<!P>:BA<UG>!Q<88>AO!!

(IHBE<GGIC!:DQ>!uH>A@9AU<@BD8:vC!<?B8!@D!:>8:DAI!DA!QD@DA!U>;<SBDA<G!:@BQ9GBC!@D!

@;>!8>@TDA?!E<8!<E@9<GGI!HADSBP>!:DQ>!:@<UBGB@I!@D!<8!D:EBGG<@DAI!8>@TDA?!@;<@!@IHBE<GGI!

FG9E@9<@>:! U>@T>>8! EAB@BE<G! <8P! :@<UG>! :@<@>! PI8<QBE:! X59[:�?BC! JKKiYO! *8! @;B:! E<:>C! <!

HD::BUG>! B8@>AHA>@<@BD8! DF! @;>:>! PBFF>A>8E>:! U>@T>>8! 8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! FDGGDTB8R! )8DP<G!

52 !

S>A:9:! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'! ED9GP! U>! @;<@! )8DP<G4@$/'!Q<I! GB?>GI! ;>GH! Q<B8@<B8!

:@><PI!:@<@>C!DA!GB?>GI!:DQ>!FDAQ!DF!;DQ>D:@<:B:C!B8!@;>!8>@TDA?!DS>A!<!E>A@<B8!P9A<@BD8!

FDGGDTB8R! @;>! :@BQ9G<@BD8C! \K! QB89@>:! B8! @;B:! E<:>O! (;9:C! B@! B:! ED8E>BS<UG>! @;<@! @;>!

8>@TDA?! ED9GP! GB?>GI!;<S>!<! GDT>A! @;A>:;DGP! FDA! :I8<H@BE!HG<:@BEB@I! B8P9E@BD8! FDGGDTB8R!

)8DP<G! @$/'C! B8! GB8>!TB@;! @;>! A9G>:! DF! ;DQ>D:@<@BE! HG<:@BEB@I! X'@<RR! `! #B@:E;>C! JKLLYO!

1DA>DS>AC! @;>! E;<8R>:! :>>8! B8!;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I! <A>!<G:D!

ED8:B:@>8@! TB@;! @;>! FB8PB8R:! DF! ;BR;>A! QDP9G<@BD8! DF! +)5)4>ARBE! 8>9AD@A<8:QB@@>A!

<E@BSB@I!B8!@;>!/<@;DP<G!EDQH<A>P!@D!)8DP<G!@$/'!X<:!:@9PB>P!UI!BP>8@BFIB8R!<!A>RBD8!DF!

B8@>A>:@! B8! @;>! :@BQ9G<@>P! 1L! A>RBD8m! '@<RR! >@! <GOC! JKKgYO! (DR>@;>AC! @;>:>! ED9GP! U>!

B8@>AHA>@>P! <:! u8>@TDA?! HABQB8Rv! B8P9E>P! UI! )8DP<G! @$/'C! T;BE;! B:! BP>8@BFB>P! ;>A>!

@;AD9R;!D:EBGG<@DAI!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!H<A<Q>@>A:O!2DT>S>AC!<:!HA>SBD9:GI!PB:E9::>PC!

B@!B:!BQHDA@<8@!@D!A>EDR8B[>!@;<@!@;B:!HD::BUG>!A>P9E@BD8!B8!'#&!GB?>GI!HADP9E>P!UI!)8DP<G!

@$/'!Q<I!8D@!8>E>::<ABGI!:>AS>!<:!uHABQB8Rv!FDA!<GG!?B8P:!DF!:9U:>Z9>8@!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!

U>;<SBDA!DA!B8@>AS>8@BD8:O!(;B:!@<:?4P>H>8P>8E>!DF!@;>!>FF>E@:!DF!8>@TDA?!HABQB8R!Q<I!

;>GH! >WHG<B8C! B8! H<A@C! @;>! ED8@ADS>A:B<G! >SBP>8E>! D8! @>:@B8R! DF! ;DQ>D:@<@BE! HG<:@BEB@I!

>FF>E@:!DF!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!@$/'!X#B@:E;>!>@!<GOC!JKKeYO!

0B8<GGIC!<8!BQHDA@<8@!E<S><@!B8!B8@>AHA>@<@BD8!DF!@;>:>!A>:9G@:!B:!@;>!Q>@;DP!9:>P!

@D!A>EDAP!<8P!<8<GI[>!@;>!8>9A<G!P<@<O!(TD!Q<VDA!8>9A<G!:9U:@A<@>:!@;<@!B8FG9>8E>!@;B:!

FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<A>!@;>!E>A>U>GG9Q!<8P!@;>!U<:<G!R<8RGB<O!+BS>8!@;>!GBQB@<@BD8!DF!

1%+l:!:>8:B@BSB@I!@D!8>9A<G!<E@BSB@I!DF!P>>H4:><@>P!8>9A<G!A>RBD8:!:9E;!<:!@;>!E>A>U>GG9Q!

<8P! U<:<G! R<8RGB<C! B@! B:! <GQD:@! BQHD::BUG>! @D! HADSBP>! <! EDQHD:B@>! P>HBE@BD8! DF! <GG!

<::DEB<@>P! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! B8FG9>8E>P! UI! @$/'! RBS>8! @D! 1LO!

53 !

09A@;>AQDA>C! @;B:! <8<GI:B:! T<:! <! HABDAB! ;IHD@;>:B:! PABS>8! @D! :@9PI! @;>! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!

8>@TDA?C! U<:>P! D8! A>:9G@:! DU@<B8>P! @;AD9R;! @;>! UGB8P! <8<GI@BE<G! <HHAD<E;! B8SDGSB8R!

*8P>H>8P>8@! EDQHD8>8@! <8<GI:B:! <8P! EG9:@>AB8R! X*/)Y! B8! 'H>EBFBE! )BQ! LO! (;9:C! BF!

<PPB@BD8<G! 8>@TDA?:! <A>! QDP9G<@>P! UI! 1L! @$/'C! @;D:>! <A>! ED8FD98PB8R! >FF>E@:! @;<@!

E<88D@!U>! BP>8@BFB>P!DA!P>:EABU>PC!TB@;B8!@;>!:EDH>!DF!@;B:!A>:><AE;!<HHAD<E;!<PDH@>P!

;>A>O!!

*8! :9QQ<AIC! @;>A>! <HH><A:! @D! U>! <! :BR8BFBE<8@! >FF>E@! DF! A><G4@$/'! X)8DP<G! `!

/<@;DP<GY!D8!UB<:B8R!@;B:!G>F@!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?C!>S>8!<@!A>:@C!EDQH<A>P!@D!';<QO!

(;>:>!FB8PB8R:!<A>!BQHDA@<8@!U>E<9:>!@;>I!:;DT!FDA!@;>!FBA:@!@BQ>!@;<@!@$/'!:H>EBFBE<GGI!

B8FG9>8E>:!D:EBGG<@DAI!8>@TDA?!ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8!@;B:!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!@;<@! B:! BQHGBE<@>P!

S>AI!:@AD8RGI!B8!EDR8B@BS>!<8P!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!U>;<SBDAO!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!B@!<G:D!HADSBP>:!FDA!

<G@>A8<@BS>!<HHAD<E;>:! @D! GB?>GI!Z9<8@BFI!<8P!EDQH<A>!>FF>E@:!DF! @$/'! B8!H<@B>8@:!TB@;!

S<ABD9:!8>9ADGDRBE<G!PB:DAP>A:!X'E;G<9RC!&>8R<C!`!#<BAC!JKKfm!'H<AB8R!>@!<GOC!JKKgYC!TB@;!

@;>! DUV>E@BS>! DF! >:@BQ<@B8R! PD:>4A>:HD8:>! A>G<@BD8:;BH:! B8! @;>Q! <8P! B8FDAQ! QDA>!

HA9P>8@!EGB8BE<G!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!@;B:!@>E;8BZ9>!FDA!B8@>AS>8@BD8<G!H9AHD:>:O!!

!

'

'

'

'

'!

54 !

&Y!Q$7%'S3'#Q7&8@8&'!8?'U'

K<';,#,0+$%,'#),'$%@*",%2,'<@'2)1%&,/'$%'.01$%'%,#(<0L'<0&1%$R1#$<%'D$;,%#$@$,;'$%'G-3'S'

4=' $%;"2,;'.A'+<#<0' 2<0#$21*' #98G'<%' *,10%$%&' #<'1;1!#'+<#<0'!,0@<0+1%2,' #<'1'%<C,*'

/,%/<0$+<#<0'2<%#,N#'D$M,ME'C$/"<+<#<0'1;1!#1#$<%=M'

'

82)0,5H4)(,2'

(;>! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! 8>9ADQDP9G<@DAI! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! @D! <9RQ>8@! QD@DA! G><A8B8R! B:! <!

Z9>:@BD8!DF!:BR8BFBE<8@!HA<E@BE<G!<8P!EGB8BE<G!BQHDA@<8E>O!1DA>DS>AC!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!B:!<8!

>WE>GG>8@!QDP>G!DF! B8@AB8:BE!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! B8!;9Q<8:! @;<@!E<8!U>!Q><:9A>P! B8PBA>E@GI!

@;AD9R;!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:O!(;9:C!EDQUB8B8R!@$/'!<8P!QD@DA! G><A8B8R!<GGDT:!:@9PIB8R!

B8@>A<E@BD8:! U>@T>>8! QDP9G<@BD8! DF! B8@AB8:BE! <8P! >W@AB8:BE! 8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IO! *8! @;B:!

ED8@>W@C!<!EDQQD8!<HHAD<E;!;<:!U>>8!@;>!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!<8DP<G!@$/'!ED8E9AA>8@!TB@;!

QD@DA! G><A8B8R! B8! <8! >WH>ABQ>8@<G! ED8@>W@! X1O! #B@:E;>C! /D;>8C! 6<::>AQ<88C! -ABDABC!

.<8RC! )8@<GC! -<9G9:C! 29QQ>GC! 5DRRBDC! `! 0A>R8BC! JKKf<m! '@<RR! `! #B@:E;>C! JKLLm! '@<RRC!

5<E;@B<AC!`!MD;<8:>845>ARC!JKLLYO!-A>SBD9:!A>:><AE;!;<:!:;DT8!@;>!U>8>FBEB<G!>FF>E@:!DF!

<8DP<G!QD@DA! EDA@BE<G! @$/'! DS>A! HABQ<AI!QD@DA! EDA@>W! X1LY! B8! BQHADSB8R! SB:9DQD@DA!

G><A8B8R! DF!QD@DA! :>Z9>8E>:! B8SDGSB8R! FB8R>A! @<HHB8R! X#B@:E;>! >@! <GOC! JKK\Y! <:!T>GG! <:!

:>Z9>8@B<G!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!HB8E;4FDAE>!X&>B:!>@!<GOC!JKKgYO!!

&>E>8@GIC!B@!;<:!U>>8!:;DT8!@;<@!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!<G:D!<HH><A:!@D!U>8>FB@!

FADQ!8>9ADQDP9G<@BD8!UI! @$/'O! *8! @;B:!H<A<PBRQC! :9UV>E@:!<A>! A>Z9BA>P! @D!<P<H@! @;>BA!

QD@DA!H>AFDAQ<8E>!G>S>G:!B8!8DS>G!>8SBAD8Q>8@:!B8!T;BE;!SB:9<G!B8FDAQ<@BD8!<UD9@!;<8P!

QDS>Q>8@!B:!<G@>A>P!<8P!PB::DEB<@>P!FADQ!B@:!?B8>:@;>@BE!H>AE>H@BD8!X+<G><!>@!<GOC!JKLKm!

55 !

2<PBHD9A4#B?@<A<:;C! .>>C! $>:QD8PC! `! ';<PQ>;AC! JKKem! 298@>AC! '<EEDC! #B@:E;>C! `!

(9A8>AC! JKKgYO! -ABQ<ABGIC! B8S>:@BR<@BD8:! 9:B8R! @;B:! <P<H@BS>! QD@DA! G><A8B8R! H<A<PBRQ!

;<S>! B8SDGS>P! :9UV>E@:! H>AFDAQB8R! F<:@C! :@A<BR;@! E>8@>A4D9@! A><E;B8R!QDS>Q>8@:! @D! <!

@<AR>@! 9:B8R! <! ADUD@BE! Q<8BH9G<8P9Q! T;BG>! 98U>?8DT8! @D! @;>! :9UV>E@C! <! FDAE>!

H>A@9AU<@BD8!B:!<HHGB>P!UI!@;>!ADUD@!E<9:B8R!<!PB::DEB<@BD8!B8!@;>!SB:9<G!<8P!?B8>:@;>@BE!

F>>PU<E?! DF! @;>! QDS>Q>8@O! ,S>A! @;>! ED9A:>! DF! :>S>A<G! @AB<G:! XDS>A! \K4dK! QB89@>:YC!

:9UV>E@:! <P<H@! @;>BA! QD@DA! H>AFDAQ<8E>! UI! >W>A@B8R! EDQH>8:<@DAI! FDAE>:! B8! @;>!

DHHD:B@>! PBA>E@BD8C! @;9:! A>P9EB8R! @;>BA! H>AFDAQ<8E>! >AADA:! @D! A><E;! <! U>;<SBDA<G!

<:IQH@D@>O!6;>8! @;>:>! :9UV>E@:! <A>! @>:@>P! D8! @AB<G:! T;>A>! @;>! FDAE>! H>A@9AU<@BD8! B:!

A>QDS>PC! BQQ>PB<@>GI!<F@>A!@;B:!@A<B8B8R!UGDE?C!@;>I!:;DT!;9R>!P>SB<@BD8!>AADA:!B8!@;>!

EDQH>8:<@DAI! PBA>E@BD8! DHHD:B@>! @D! @;<@! DF! @;>! FDAE>4FB>GP! XBO>OC! u<F@>A4>FF>E@:vY]! @;>!

Q<R8B@9P>!DF!@;>:>!<F@>A4>FF>E@:!E<8!U>!ED8:BP>A>P!<?B8!@D!Q<R8B@9P>!DF!G><A8B8R!B8!@;B:!

H<A<PBRQO!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!@;>!A<@>!DF!A>P9E@BD8!DF!>AADA:!<EAD::!@AB<G:!B8!@;>!@A<B8B8R!UGDE?!

B:!QD:@GI!A>F>AA>P!@D!<:!A<@>!DF!G><A8B8RC!T;BG>!@;>!A<@>!DF!A>P9E@BD8!DF!>AADA:!@D!U<:>GB8>!

B8! @;>!<F@>A4>FF>E@:!UGDE?! B:!DF@>8!E<GG>P!A<@>!DF!P><P<H@<@BD8!DA! A>@>8@BD8!DF! @;>! FDAE>!

FB>GPO! 09A@;>AQDA>C! A>G><A8B8R! DF! <! RBS>8! H>A@9AU<@BD8! FDA! <! :>ED8P! @BQ>! B:! @IHBE<GGI!

F<:@>A!@;<8!B8B@B<G! G><A8B8RC!<!H;>8DQ>8D8!?8DT8!<:!u:<SB8R:v!X29<8RC!2<B@;C!1<[[D8BC!

`!7A<?<9>AC!JKLLm!7A<?<9>A!`!1<[[D8BC!JKLLm!'QB@;C!+;<[B[<P>;C!`!';<PQ>;AC!JKKiYO!

X298@>A! >@! <GOC! JKKgY! FD98P! @;<@! <8DP<G! @$/'! <HHGB>P! DS>A! 1LC! EDQH<A>P! @D!

:;<QC!P9AB8R!@;>!@A<B8B8R!UGDE?!DF!@;B:!<P<H@BS>!G><A8B8R!G>P!@D!B8EA><:>P!Q<R8B@9P>!DF!

<F@>A4>FF>E@:! :9RR>:@B8R! @;<@! <8DP<G! @$/'! F<EBGB@<@>P! <EZ9B:B@BD8! DF! @;>! 8DS>G! :>8:DAB4

QD@DA! Q<HHB8R! DF! @;>! PB::DEB<@BD8! U>@T>>8! @;>! SB:9<G! <8P! ?B8>:@;>@BE! F>>PU<E?O! )!

56 !

A>E>8@!:@9PI!ED8FBAQ>P!@;<@!<8DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!1L!HADSBP>P!P9AB8R!@A<B8B8R!BQHADS>:!@;>!

A>@>8@BD8!DF! @;>!<EZ9BA>P!SB:9DQD@DA!Q<HHB8R! BO>OC!RA><@>A!H>A:B:@>8E>!DF!<F@>A4>FF>E@:!

T;BE;! <A>! >AADA:! B8! @;>! PBA>E@BD8! DHHD:B@>! @D! @;>! D8>! BQHD:>P! UI! @;>! @A<B8B8R! UGDE?!

X+<G><!>@!<GOC!JKLKYO!)PPB@BD8<GGIC!@;B:!:@9PI!<G:D!:;DT>P!@;<@!<HHGBE<@BD8!DF!<8DP<G!@$/'!

DS>A!@;>!E>A>U>GG9Q!P9AB8R!@A<B8B8R!B8EA><:>P!@;>!A<@>!DF!G><A8B8RC!T;>A>B8!@;>!>AADA:!B8!

@;>!@A<B8B8R!UGDE?!A><E;!@;>!<:IQH@D@>!F<:@>A!@;<8!B8!@;>!:;<Q!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!!

6;BG>!B@!B:!?8DT8!@;<@!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!<HHGB>P!ED8E9AA>8@GI!P9AB8R!<P<H@BS>!

QD@DA! G><A8B8R! BQHADS>:!A>@>8@BD8!DF!@;>!8>TGI!<EZ9BA>P!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8RC! B@! B:!

8D@!?8DT8!T;>@;>A!uDFFGB8>v!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!E<8!HADP9E>!<8I!E;<8R>:!B8!<EZ9B:B@BD8!

<8PcDA! :<SB8R:! DF! :9E;! G><A8B8RO! %SBP>8@GIC! @;>! 8>9A<G! EDAA>G<@>:! DF! :9E;! H>AFDAQ<8E>!

E;<8R>:! B8! @>AQ:! DF! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! <A>! <G:D! 98?8DT8O! 'H>EBFBE<GGIC!

H>AFDAQ<8E>!B8!:<SB8R:!FDGGDTB8R!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!:9U:>Z9>8@!@D!@$/'!DS>A!1L!B:!

98?8DT8C!<8P!<:!<A>!@;>!8>9A<G!EDAA>G<@>:!DF!@;>:>!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:!XBF!<8IYO!(;B:!B:!<8!

BQHDA@<8@! Z9>:@BD8C! H<A@BE9G<AGIC! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! QD@DA! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8! U>E<9:>! @$/'!

E<8! U>! <!QDA>! 9:>F9G! <PV98E@! BF! >FF>E@:! DF! <! UAB>F! UD9@! DF! :@BQ9G<@BD8! E<8! D9@G<:@! @;>!

:@BQ9G<@BD8! P9A<@BD8! <8P! HADP9E>! F98E@BD8<G! E;<8R>:! B8! QD@DA! H>AFDAQ<8E>O!

)PPB@BD8<GGIC!A>;<UBGB@<@BD8!:>::BD8:!<A>!DF@>8!A>H><@>P!Q9G@BHG>!@BQ>:C!@;9:C!B8FG9>8E>!DF!

@$/'! D8! A>4G><A8B8R! <! 8DS>G! @<:?cRD<G! B:! >Z9<GGI! EAB@BE<GO! 0B8<GGIC! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF! @;>!

EDA@BE<G!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!@;<@!DEE9A!TB@;!:9E;!8>9ADHG<:@BE!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!FDGGDTB8R!<!

UAB>F! H>ABDP! DF! QD@DA! EDA@BE<G! @$/'! E<8! ;>GH! R9BP>! QDA>! <HHADHAB<@>! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8!

B8@>AS>8@BD8:!B8!@;>!H>ABDP!<F@>A!@$/'O!!

57 !

(;9:C! @;>! HABQ<AI! DUV>E@BS>! DF! @;B:! :@9PI! T<:! @D! P>@>AQB8>! @;>! A>G<@BD8:;BH!

U>@T>>8!QD@DA!H>AFDAQ<8E>!E;<8R>:!<::DEB<@>P!TB@;!:9E;!<P<H@BS>!QD@DA! G><A8B8R!<:!

T>GG! <:! :<SB8R:! <8P! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! <:! Q><:9A>P! UI! >FF>E@BS>! UA<B8!

8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@IO! +BS>8! @;>! >:@<UGB:;>P! ADG>! DF! @;>! FAD8@DH<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?! B8!

Q>PB<@B8R! :>8:DABQD@DA! <P<H@BS>! G><A8B8R! X)8R9>A<C! &>9@>A4.DA>8[C! 6BGGB8R;<QC! `!

'>BPG>AC! JKKgm! $DID8! >@! <GOC! JKKgm! 2B?D:<?<C! #<?<Q9A<C! '<?<BC! `! #<?<;<A<C! JKKJm!

7A<?<9>A!>@!<GOC!JKKdm!'>BPG>AC!JKLKm!'>BPG>A!`!#DGGC!JKKfYC!@;>!;IHD@;>:B[>P!ED88>E@BSB@I!

B8! @;>! G>F@! FAD8@DH<AB>@<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?! <:! B8! :H>EBFBE! <BQ!J!T<:!>W<QB8>P! B8! RA><@>A!

P>@<BG!;>A>!@D!<E;B>S>!@;B:!DUV>E@BS>O!

'

?+)J,5/'

IN!,0$+,%#1*'!0<2,;"0,'1%;'91#1'12H"$/$#$<%'

(;BA@I! ABR;@4;<8P>P! 8>9ADGDRBE<GGI! ;><G@;I! <P9G@:! T>A>! A>EA9B@>P! @D! H<A@BEBH<@>! B8! @;B:!

:@9PI!<F@>A!HADSBPB8R! B8FDAQ>P!ED8:>8@!<:!<HHADS>P!UI! @;>! *8:@B@9@BD8<G!&>SB>T!5D<AP!

X*&5Y! <@! @;>! #<@BD8<G! *8:@B@9@>! DF! #>9ADGDRBE<G! $B:DAP>A:! <8P! '@AD?>O! (;>! H<A@BEBH<8@:C!

UGB8P>P!@D!@IH>!DF!:@BQ9G<@BD8C!T>A>!<::BR8>P!H:>9PD4A<8PDQGI!@D!D8>!DF!@;>!@;A>>!@$/'!

RAD9H:! 4! <8DP<GC! E<@;DP<G! DA! :;<Q! X8xLK! ><E;YO! (<AR>@! A>RBD8! FDA! :@BQ9G<@BD8! BO>OC!

ED8@A<G<@>A<GcG>F@! 1L! FDA! ><E;! :9UV>E@! T<:! P>@>AQB8>P! UI! @A<8:EA<8B<G! Q<R8>@BE!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!@<AR>@B8R!@;>!DH@BQ<G!:E<GH!HD:B@BD8!@D!>GBEB@!QD@DA!>SD?>P!HD@>8@B<G:!DF!@;>!

ABR;@!<UP9E@DA!HDGGBEB:!UA>SB:O!)!-;DA>:DA!**!)9@D!XQDP>G!-1fhKC!*,1%$C!'<G@!.<?>!/B@IC!

"(Y!P>SBE>!TBGG!U>!9:>P!@D!<HHGI!@$/'!DS>A!1L!9:B8R!<!UBHDG<A!QD8@<R>!TB@;!@;>!E>H;<GBE!

A>F>A>8E>! >G>E@ADP>! DS>A! @;>! ABR;@! :9HA<DAUB@<G! <A><O! +BS>8! @;>! A>E>8@! >SBP>8E>! D8!

58 !

B8@>8:B@I4A>G<@>P! S<AB<@BD8:! B8! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! BO>OC! RA><@>A! B8@>8:B@I! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;!

:@AD8R>A! E;<8R>:! B8! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! A>EDAP>P! @;AD9R;! F1&*! (Zheng, Alsop, & Schlaug,

2011)C! T>! E;D:>! @D! B8EA><:>! @;>! :@BQ9G<@BD8! B8@>8:B@I! FADQ! L! Q)! @D! LOh! Q)! B8! @;B:!

>WH>ABQ>8@O!(;>!:@BQ9G<@BD8!T<:!P>GBS>A>P!UI!Jh!EQJ!ED8P9E@B8R!>G>E@ADP>:!EDS>A>P!UI!

:<GB8>4:D<?>P! :HD8R>C! <@! <8! B8@>8:B@I! DF! LOh! Q)! XE9AA>8@! P>8:B@I! KOKi! Q)cEQJm! @D@<G!

E;<AR>!KOKeJ!/cEQJY!FDA!JK!QB8!B8!@;>!<8DP<G!<8P!E<@;DP<G!@$/'!:>::BD8:!<8P!FDA!9H!@D!

JK!:>ED8P:!B8!@;>!:;<Q!:>::BD8!<EEDAPB8R!@D!<!HA>SBD9:GI!P>:EABU>P!Q>@;DP!X+<8PBR<!>@!

<GOC!JKKiYO!!

#>9ADQ<R8>@BE! P<@<! T>A>! A>EDAP>P! <@! iKK! 2[! TB@;! <! U<8PTBP@;! DF! K4LhK! 2[!

9:B8R! <! /(0! Jeh!1%+! :I:@>Q! X/(0! 'I:@>Q:C! *8EOC! /<8<P<Y! EDQHD:>P! DF! <!T;DG>4;><P!

<AA<I! DF! Jeh! A<PB<G! L:@! DAP>A! RA<PBDQ>@>Ac'^"*$! E;<88>G:! ;D9:>P! B8! <! Q<R8>@BE<GGI!

:;B>GP>P! ADDQ! X=<E99Q:E;Q>G[>C! +>AQ<8IY! TB@;! :I8@;>@BE! \AP! RA<PB>8@! U<G<8EB8R! @D!

A>QDS>!U<E?RAD98P!8DB:>!D84GB8>O!1%+!P<@<!T>A>!A>EDAP>P!<:!H<A@BEBH<8@:!H>AFDAQ>P!<!

E>8@>A4D9@! :EA>>8! E9A:DA! HDB8@B8RcA><E;B8R! @<:?! UI! ED8@ADGGB8R! <! VDI:@BE?]! U>FDA>! <8P!

<F@>A!JK!QB89@>:!DF!@$/'O!(;>!>WH>ABQ>8@<G!@BQ>4GB8>!B:!:;DT8!B8!FBRO!L!U>GDTO!

!

IN!,0$+,%#1*'K1/L'

-<A@BEBH<8@:! T>A>! B8:@A9E@>P! @D! H>AFDAQ! E>8@>A4D9@! HDB8@B8R! QDS>Q>8@:! DF! <! :EA>>8!

E9A:DA! @D!D8>!DF! @;A>>!A<8PDQGI!<HH><AB8R!H>ABH;>A<G! @<AR>@:! X<@!\KDC!gKDC!LhKDY!<@!LK!

EQ! FADQ! @;>! E>8@A<G! ;DQ>4EBAEG>! UI! ED8@ADGGB8R! <! VDI:@BE?O! MDI:@BE?! QDS>Q>8@:! T>A>!

:<QHG>P!<@!LKK!2[!<8P!PB:HG<I>P!B8!A><G!@BQ>!D8!<!QD8B@DA!9:B8R!.<U=B>T!fOi!X#<@BD8<G!

*8:@A9Q>8@:C! *8EOY! <:! @;>! E9A:DA!T;BG>! PBA>E@! SB:BD8! DF! ;<8P!QDS>Q>8@!T<:! DEEG9P>PO!

59 !

'9UV>E@:!H>AFDAQ>P!@AB<G:!DF!@;>!@<:?!B8!UGDE?:!DF!JK!@AB<G:C!T;>A>B8!DAP>A!<8P!89QU>A!DF!

HA>:>8@<@BD8! DF! @;>! \! @<AR>@:! T<:! H:>9PD4A<8PDQB[>P! <8P! U<G<8E>PO! '9UV>E@:!

H>AFDAQ>P!J!UGDE?:!XdK!@AB<G:Y!B8!-A>4>WHD:9A>c5<:>GB8>!HABDA!@D!<PQB8B:@A<@BD8!DF!@$/'C!

<8P! L! UGDE?! DF! 5<:>GB8>! <F@>A! <PQB8B:@A<@BD8! DF! @$/'O! (;B:! T<:! P>:BR8>P! @D! QB8BQB[>!

ED8FD98P!P9>!@D!U<:>GB8>!H>AFDAQ<8E>!E;<8R>:C!BF!<8I!B8P9E>P!UI!@$/'O!!

!0BRO! LO! %WH>ABQ>8@<G! @BQ>GB8>! :;DTB8R! -A>! <8P! -D:@4@$/'! 1%+! A>EDAPB8R:! P9AB8R!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!`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

$9AB8R! >WHD:9A>! @D! SB:9DQD@DA! PB:@DA@BD8! H;<:>C! :EA>>8! E9A:DA4VDI:@BE?!

QDS>Q>8@!A>G<@BD8:;BH!T<:!AD@<@>P!EGDE?TB:>!9H!@D!\KDO!-<A@BEBH<8@:!T>A>!B8:@A9E@>P!@D!

H>AFDAQ!@;>!QDS>Q>8@!u<:!:@A<BR;@!<8P!<:!F<:@!<:!HD::BUG>v!@D!;B@!@;>!@<AR>@!<HH><AB8R!

D8! @;>! :EA>>8m! @;>! @<AR>@! @9A8>P! RA>>8!T;>8! @;>! E9A:DA! ;B@! B@O! (;>!QDS>Q>8@! DF! @;>!

:EA>>8! E9A:DA! T<:! @>AQB8<@>P!T;>8! @;>! :9UV>E@:! ;B@! @;>! EBAE9QF>A>8E>! DF! @;>! LK! EQ!

A<PB9:! EBAEG>! <AD98P! @;>! ;DQ>4EBAEG>C! <8P! ><E;! 8>T! @AB<G! :@<A@>P! TB@;! @;>! E9A:DA!

<9@DQ<@BE<GGI! A>4E>8@>A>P! @D! @;>! ;DQ>4EBAEG>O! (;>! @<AR>@! <HH><A<8E>! T<:! VB@@>A>P!

60 !

<AD98P! <! hKK!Q:! B8@>AS<G! XA<8PDQGIY! <F@>A! H<A@BEBH<8@:! E>8@>A>P! @;>! E9A:DA! B8! ;DQ>4

EBAEG>!<8P!;>GP! :@BGG! FDA! @;>!hKK!Q:O!%<E;! @<AR>@! A>Q<B8>P!D8! @;>! :EA>>8! FDA!<UD9@!\Oh!

:>ED8P:!<F@>A!T;BE;!@;>!@AB<G!T<:!<UDA@>Pm!<GG!@<AR>@:!T>A>!HA>:>8@>P!>Z9<GGI!B8!H:>9PD4

A<8PDQ! DAP>A! @D! <SDBP! <8I! PBA>E@BD8<G! UB<:>:O! (;>! B8@>A4@AB<G! B8@>AS<G! T<:! VB@@>A>P!

U>@T>>8!\!<8P!h!:>ED8P:O!-<A@BEBH<8@:!H>AFDAQ>P!<!@D@<G!DF!JL!UGDE?:!DF!JK!@AB<G:!><E;C!

<:! :;DT8! B8! FBRO! LO! (;>! @<:?! H>AFDAQ<8E>! B:! BGG9:@A<@>P! P9AB8R! HA>4>WHD:9A>C!

<P<H@<@BD8c:<SB8R:!<8P!T<:;D9@!H;<:>:!B8!FBRO!JO!!

0BRO! JO! -<8>G:! :;DTB8R! @;>! :EA>>8! <HH><A<8E>! P9AB8R! @<:?! H>AFDAQ<8E>! XG>F@! @D! ABR;@Y]!(<AR>@! HD:B@BD8:! A>G<@BS>! @D! ;DQ>4EBAEG>! XLK! EQ! PB:@<8E>Y! D8! :EA>>8! :;DT8! @D! :9UV>E@!B8B@B<GGIm!D8>!@<AR>@!<HH><A>P!<@!<!@BQ>!<8P!:EA>>8!E9A:DA!QD@BD8!B8PBE<@>P!UI!<!P<:;>P!GB8>! ;>A>! B:! Q<HH>P! D8>4@D4D8>! B8! @;>! HA>4>WHD:9A>! H;<:>m! :EA>>84E9A:DA! VDI:@BE?!QDS>Q>8@! A>G<@BD8:;BH! B:! AD@<@>P!\KD! EGDE?TB:>!P9AB8R!>WHD:9A>! @AB<G:! FDAEB8R!:9UV>E@:!@D!G><A8!8DS>G!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8Rm!FB8<GGIC!@;>!<EZ9B:B@BD8!DF!@;B:!8>T!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8R!DA!uB8@>A8<G!QDP>Gv!B:!A>FG>E@>P!UI!>AADA:!B8!DHHD:B@>!PBA>E@BD8!DF!:EA>>84E9A:DA!AD@<@BD8!B8!@;>!HD:@4>WHD:9A>!@AB<G:O!'

7,)1C$<01*'91#1'-%1*A/$/'

*8PBSBP9<G! @AB<G!P<@<!T>A>! GDT4H<::! FBG@>A>P!TB@;!E9@4DFF!DF!LK!2[!TB@;!<!d@;!DAP>A!P9<G4

H<::!59@@>ATDA@;!FBG@>AO!0DA!><E;!@AB<GC!B8B@B<G!PBA>E@BD8<G!>AADA!X*$%C!B8!P>RA>>:Y!:EDA>!T<:!

E<GE9G<@>P!<:!@;>!<8RG>!U>@T>>8!<!S>E@DA!FADQ!B8B@B<G!HD:B@BD8!DF!@;>!VDI:@BE?!@D!@;<@!<@!

H><?! S>GDEB@I! <F@>A! QDS>Q>8@! D8:>@! <8P! <! S>E@DA! >W@>8PB8R! FADQ! :@<A@! HD:B@BD8! @D!

@<AR>@O! -><?! S>GDEB@I! T<:! 9:>P! @D! EDQH9@>! *$%! :B8E>! @;>! QDS>Q>8@! T<:! S>AI! :Q<GG!

61 !

X)8R9>A<!>@!<GOC!JKKeYO!*$%!B:!@;D9R;@!@D!A>HA>:>8@!@;>!:@<@>!DF!@;>!B8@>A8<G!QDP>G!DF!@;>!

8DS>G!>8SBAD8Q>8@!<8P!T<:!@;>!HABQ<AI!P>H>8P>8@!S<AB<UG>!<EAD::!@AB<G:!@;<@!T<:!9:>P!

@D!>:@<UGB:;!G><A8B8R!A<@>:!FDA!><E;!:9UV>E@!U<:>P!D8!<!:B8RG>4>WHD8>8@B<G!E9AS>!FB@@>P!@D!

@;>! P<@<! P9AB8R! @;>! >WHD:9A>! H;<:>! @AB<G:! B8! )P<H@<@BD8! <8P! '<SB8R:C! RBS>8! UI! @;>!

R>8>A<G!>Z9<@BD8C! y = Ae!bx + c !|T;>A>!)!`!E!<A>!ED8:@<8@:}!X29<8R!>@!<GOC!JKLLYO!!

'

J,"0<+1&%,#$2'91#1'-%1*A/$/'

#>9ADQ<R8>@BE!P<@<!T>A>!>HDE;>P!B8@D!\LKK!Q:!<AD98P!@;>!HDB8@!DF!QDS>Q>8@!D8:>@!b!

LLKK!Q:!U>FDA>!QDS>Q>8@!D8:>@!<8P!JKKK!Q:!<F@>A!QDS>Q>8@!D8:>@!@D! B8EG9P>!HD:@4

H>AFDAQ<8E>! 8>9A<G! HADE>::B8R! DF! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! >AADA:C! ED8:B:@>8@! TB@;! HA>SBD9:!

Q>@;DPDGDRI!9:>P!B8!D9A! G<U!X/D8@A>A<:4=BP<G!`!7>ABE?C!JKKdY!FDA!><E;!@AB<GO!$<@<!FADQ!

UGDE?:! DF! JK! @AB<G:! ><E;! T>A>! ED8E<@>8<@>P! <8P! P>48DB:>P! XKOLh4LhK! 2[! U<8P4H<::!

FBG@>AB8RC!8D@E;!FBG@>A>P!@D!A>QDS>!HDT>A! GB8>!8DB:>Y!<8P!:9UQB@@>P!@D!@;>!')1!:D9AE>!

GDE<GB[<@BD8!<8<GI:B:! @D! EDQH9@>!<8<@DQBE<G! :D9AE>!T<S>FDAQ:O! (;>!Q>@;DP!9:>P!T<:!

BP>8@BE<G! @D! @;<@! P>:EABU>P! B8! 'H>EBFBE! )BQ! JC! ;DT>S>AC! <! PBHDG>! :H<EB8R! DF! h! QQC!

EDAA>:HD8PB8R!@D!<!E9UBE!SDW>G!TBP@;!DF!h!QQC!T<:!9:>P!FDA!><E;!P<@<:>@!BO>O!H>A!UGDE?!

DF!JK! @AB<G:O!(;>! @BQ>4FA>Z9>8EI!A>HA>:>8@<@BD8!DF!HDT>A!DU@<B8>P!@;AD9R;!@;>!'B8RG>4

:@<@>! ')1! BQ<RB8R! <EAD::! @;>! iJK! :>ED8P:! DF! @;>! ')1! FBG@>A! D9@H9@! <@! ><E;! SBA@9<G!

E;<88>G!T<:!EDQH9@>P!UI!ED8SDG9@BD8!TB@;!<!:GBPB8R!2<QQB8R!TB8PDT!XLKK!QBGGB:>ED8P!

TBP>Y!TB@;!8D!DS>AG<H!B8!DAP>A!@D!IB>GP!<!\$!@BQ>!:>AB>:!XiJK!P<@<!HDB8@:Y!DF!<E@BS<@BD8!

FDA!><E;!SDW>G!DF!<8<@DQBE<G!:D9AE>!DF!8>9ADQ<R8>@BE!<E@BSB@I!TB@;!<8!DH@BQ<G!@BQ>4!<8P!

:H>E@A<G4A>:DG9@BD8O!(;>!')1!EDS<AB<8E>!Q<@ABW!T<:!E<GE9G<@>P! B8! @;>! FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:!

62 !

A>G>S<8@!@D!:>8:DABQD@DA!HADE>::B8R!<:!P>:EABU>P!B8!@;>!GB@>A<@9A>!X<8P!@;>:>!T>A>!<G:D!

BP>8@BFB>P! @D! U>!QDP9G<@>P! B8! :H>EBFBE! <BQ! LY! BO>OC! <GH;<]! f4L\!2[C! U>@<]! L\4\K!2[C! GDT!

R<QQ<]!\K4hK!2[C!;BR;!R<QQ<]!eK4LKK!2[O!(;>:>!T>A>!:9UV>E@>P!@D!+A<8R>A!E<9:<GB@I!

>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!QDP>GGB8R!B8!@;>!:<Q>!T<I!<:!P>:EABU>P!B8!/;<H@>A!d!X'H>EBFBE!<BQ!

JYO!):!P>:EABU>P! B8! 'H>EBFBE!)BQ!J!1>@;DP:C! 8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! XE;<8R>!

FADQ! 5<:>GB8>Y! T<:! EDQH9@>P! FDA! ><E;! DF! @;>! f! H<@;:! <@! @;>! >8P! DF! )P<H@<@BD8! <8P!

'<SB8R:O! *8! DAP>A! @D! P>@>AQB8>! A>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P!

U>;<SBDA<G! Q><:9A>:! DF! QD@DA! H>AFDAQ<8E>! E;<8R>C! @;>! A<@>! DF! G><A8B8R! P9AB8R!

)P<H@<@BD8! <8P! '<SB8R:! T<:! :>H<A<@>GI! XFDA! ><E;! H>ABDPY! A>RA>::>P! B8! <! Q9G@BHG>!

A>RA>::BD8!QDP>GC!D8!@;>!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!X%/Y!DF!@;>!f!H<@;:!B8!@;>!G<:@!

UGDE?! DF!)P<H@<@BD8! <8P! '<SB8R:C! A>:H>E@BS>GIO! (;>! G<:@! UGDE?!T<:! E;D:>8!U>E<9:>! @;>!

A<@>! DF! G><A8B8R! A>HA>:>8@:! @;>! <EZ9B:B@BD8! DF! @;>! 8DS>G! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! Q<HHB8R! <:!

A>Z9BA>P!UI!@;>!@<:?C!T;BE;!DEE9A:!T;>8!@;>!H>AFDAQ<8E>!<:IQH@D@>!B:!A><E;>P!XEGD:>!

@D![>AD!>AADA:YC!@IHBE<GGI!<@!@;>!G<:@!UGDE?!DF!)P<H@<@BD8c'<SB8R:O!(;>:>!B8@>A<E@BD8:!T>A>!

:H>EBFBE<GGI!>W<QB8>P!U<:>P!D8!<!HABDAB!;IHD@;>:B:!RBS>8!@;>!H9@<@BS>!ADG>!DF!@;>!<E@BSB@I!

DF! @;>:>! A>RBD8:! B8! Q>PB<@B8R! SB:9DQD@DA! <P<H@BS>! G><A8B8RO! (;>:>! >FF>E@:! T>A>!

>W<QB8>P!B8!<GH;<C!U>@<C!GDT!<8P!;BR;!R<QQ<!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:O!!

)GG!<8<GI:>:!T>A>!H>AFDAQ>P!9:B8R!E9:@DQ!HADRA<Q:!TAB@@>8!B8!1<@G<U!eOLL!X(;>!

1<@;6DA?:C! *8EOC! #<@BE?C! 1)Y! <8P! )0#*! X)8<GI:B:! DF! 098E@BD8<G! #>9A<G! *Q<R>:C! |SO!

)0#*~JKLL~LJ~JL~LKLd}YO!'@<@B:@BE<G!<8<GI:>:!T>A>!H>AFDAQ>P!9:B8R! @;>!&4H<E?<R>! XSO!

JOLdOLY!<8P!'@<@B:@BE<G!-<E?<R>!FDA!@;>!'DEB<G!'EB>8E>:!X'-''C!LfOKYO!!

!!

63 !

%+/H*)/'

7,)1C$<01*'2)1%&,/';"0$%&'-;1!#1#$<%'1%;'G1C$%&/'

(;>! U>;<SBDA<G! P<@<! :;DT>P! @;<@! <GG! RAD9H:! X)8DP<GC! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'Y! T>A>!

<UG>!@D!<P<H@!@D!@;>!8DS>G!SB:9DQD@DA!PB:@DA@BD8!X:>>!FBRO!\YO!(;>A>!T>A>!8D!PBFF>A>8E>:!

B8!U<:>GB8>!H>AFDAQ<8E>!DF! @;>! @<:?C! 98P>A!98<G@>A>P! :EA>>84E9A:DA! ED8PB@BD8:C! <EAD::!

@;>!RAD9H:C!U>FDA>!<8P!<F@>A!@$/'!X)#,=)C!HqKOKhYO!2DT>S>AC!<:!>WH>E@>PC!@;>A>!T<:!<!

:BR8BFBE<8@!PBFF>A>8E>! B8! @;>!A<@>!DF! G><A8B8R!P9AB8R!<P<H@<@BD8!<EAD::!RAD9H:! XD8>4T<I!

)#,=)! HxKOKKeYO! (;>! G><A8B8R! A<@>! T<:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! ;BR;>A! B8! @;>! RAD9H! A>E>BSB8R!

)8DP<G! <:! EDQH<A>P! @D! @;>! D8>! A>E>BSB8R! /<@;DP<G! @$/'! XHxKOKKiYO! )PPB@BD8<GGIC! @;>!

Q><8!A<@>!DF!G><A8B8R!P9AB8R!<P<H@<@BD8!FDA!)8DP<G!@$/'!RAD9H!T<:!;BR;>A!@;<8!';<Q!<:!

T>GGC! U9@! @;B:! PBFF>A>8E>!T<:! 8D@! :BR8BFBE<8@! XHxKOKfY! X:>>! FBRO! dYO! ! ,8! @;>! D@;>A! ;<8PC!

@;>A>! T>A>! 8D! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! <EAD::! @;>! \! RAD9H:! B8! @;>! A<@>! DF! G><A8B8R!

Q><:9A>P!P9AB8R!:<SB8R:!XD8>4T<I!)#,=)C!HxKO\idYC!<G@;D9R;!)8DP<G!@$/'!RAD9H!;<P!

@;>! ;BR;>:@! Q><8! G><A8B8R! A<@>C! <8P! @;>! /<@;DP<G! @$/'! RAD9H! ;<P! @;>! GDT>:@! Q><8!

G><A8B8R!A<@>!X'>>!FBRO!dYO!

64 !

!0BRO!\O!/;<8R>:!B8!Q><8!PBA>E@BD8<G!>AADA!Xk!:@<8P<AP!>AADAY!<EAD::!:9UV>E@:!DS>A!@;>!@AB<G!UGDE?:! B8! @;>! >WH>ABQ>8@O! )GG! \! RAD9H:! :;DT>P! B8EA><:>P! >AADA! BQQ>PB<@>GI! <F@>A!B8@ADP9E@BD8!DF!SB:9DQD@DA!PB:@DA@BD8!X\KD!EGDE?TB:>!AD@<@BD8YC!<:!:>>8!B8!@;>!FBA:@!UGDE?!DF! <P<H@<@BD8! <8P! :<SB8R:C! <8P! ED8:>Z9>8@GI! <P<H@>P! @;>BA! QD@DA! H>AFDAQ<8E>! BO>OC!G><A8>P! DA! <EZ9BA>P! @;>! 8DS>G! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! Q<HHB8RC! <:! >SBP>8E>P! UI! A>P9E@BD8! B8!PBA>E@BD8<G!>AADA!<EAD::!@AB<G!UGDE?:O!!!!

65 !

!0BRO!dO!!$BFF>A>8E>:!B8!G><A8B8R!A<@>:!P9AB8R!)P<H@<@BD8!<8P!'<SB8R:!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'!XQ><8!A<@>! k! :@<8P<AP! >AADAYO! )8DP<G! @$/'! RAD9H! :;DT:! @;>! F<:@>:@! G><A8B8R! A<@>! <EAD::!)P<H@<@BD8! <8P! '<SB8R:C! T;BG>! /<@;DP<G! @$/'! RAD9H! :;DT:! @;>! :GDT>:@! G><A8B8R! A<@>O!'BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! <A>! B8PBE<@>P! UI! y! HzKOKhm! :@AD8R! @A>8P:! <A>! B8PBE<@>P! TB@;!EDAA>:HD8PB8R!H4S<G9>:O!!'

:0<%#<?!10$,#1*'%,#(<0L'2<%%,2#$C$#A'2)1%&,/';"0$%&'-;1!#1#$<%'1%;'G1C$%&/'

*8@>A>:@B8RGIC! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@I! @;<@! HA>PBE@>P! U>;<SBDA<G! G><A8B8R! A<@>:! T<:!

HABQ<ABGI! B8!@;>!<GH;<C! GDT!<8P!;BR;!R<QQ<!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:C!:BQBG<A!@D!@;>!FB8PB8R:!B8!

'H>EBFBE!)BQ:!L!<8P!JO!6B@;B8!@;>!:EDH>!DF!@;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8C!@;>!Q9G@BHG>!A>RA>::BD8:!@;<@!

T>A>! :BR8BFBE<8@! <8PcDA! 8><AGI! :BR8BFBE<8@C! ;<SB8R! <@! G><:@! D8>! H<@;! <:! <! :BR8BFBE<8@!

HA>PBE@DA!DF! G><A8B8R! A<@>:C!TBGG!D8GI!U>!PB:E9::>P! B8!P>@<BG! F9A@;>AO!$9AB8R!)P<H@<@BD8C!

Q9G@BHG>! A>RA>::BD8:C! TB@;! @;>! 8DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! ED>FFBEB>8@:! <:!

66 !

HA>PBE@DA:C! T>A>! 8><AGI! :BR8BFBE<8@! FDA! HA>PBE@B8R! G><A8B8R! A<@>:! <EAD::! RAD9H:! B8! @;>!

<GH;<! X<PV9:@>P! &JxKOihC! HxKOLgYC! <8P! ;BR;! R<QQ<! U<8P! X<PV9:@>P! &JxKOeeC! HxKOLLYO!

2DT>S>AC!P9AB8R!'<SB8R:C! @;>!Q9G@BHG>! A>RA>::BD8:!T>A>!;BR;GI! :BR8BFBE<8@! B8!HA>PBE@B8R!

G><A8B8R!A<@>:!B8!@;>!<GH;<!U<8P!X<PV9:@>P!&JxKOggC!HxKOKKLY!<:!T>GG!<:!@;>!GDT!R<QQ<!

U<8P! X<PV9:@>P! &JxKOgiC! HxKOKKgLYO! *8! @;>! ;BR;! R<QQ<! U<8PC! @;>!Q9G@BHG>! A>RA>::BD8!

8><AGI! A><E;>P! :BR8BFBE<8E>! X<PV9:@>P!&JxKOihC!HxKOLgYO! 'H>EBFBE<GGIC! @;>!8>@TDA?!H<@;:!

@;<@!T>A>!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!>8R<R>P!TB@;B8!@;>:>!FA>Z9>8EI!U<8P:!B8EG9P>P!@;>!ED88>E@BD8:!

U>@T>>8! '1)4.-1C! '1)4.1LC! .-04.-1! P9AB8R! )P<H@<@BD8C! <8P! <PPB@BD8<GGIC! @;>!

ED88>E@BD8:!U>@T>>8!.-04'1)!<8P!.-.4'1)!P9AB8R!'<SB8R:O!!

!

0BRO! hO! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'!TB@;B8! @;>! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<@!@;>!>8P!DF!)P<H@<@BD8!XQ><8!!k!:@<8P<AP!>AADAYO!!

67 !

!

!!0BRO! iO! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! FDGGDTB8R! @$/'!TB@;B8! @;>! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<@!@;>!>8P!DF!'<SB8R:!XQ><8!!k!:@<8P<AP!>AADAYO!!!

0BRO! h! :;DT:! @;>! 8DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <F@>A! @$/'!TB@;B8! @;>! H<@;:!

@;<@!T>A>!:BR8BFBE<8@!HA>PBE@DA:C!<EAD::!@;>!\!:@BQ9G<@BD8!RAD9H:!B8!)P<H@<@BD8C!T;BG>!0BRO!

i!:;DT:!@;>!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!<EAD::! @;>!\!RAD9H:!<F@>A! @$/'C! B8!'<SB8R:! B8! @;>! BP>8@BFB>P!

:BR8BFBE<8@!HA>PBE@DA:O! *@! B:! BQHDA@<8@!@D!8D@>!;>A>!@;<@!8D!:@<@B:@BE<G!EDQH<AB:D8:!T>A>!

Q<P>!U>@T>>8! @;>!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/:!<EAD::! @;>!\!RAD9H:C!U>E<9:>! @;B:!T<:!8D@!PBA>E@GI!

A>G>S<8@!@D!@;>!A>:><AE;!DUV>E@BS>!;>A>O! *8!R>8>A<GC!)8DP<G!@$/'!<HH><A>P!@D!;<S>!@;>!

G><:@! 8DAQ<GB[>P! ED88>E@BSB@I! EDQH<A>P! @D!/<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'! <EAD::! <GH;<! <8P!

R<QQ<!U<8P!D:EBGG<@BD8:C! :BQBG<A! @D! @;>! A>:@B8R! :@<@>!8DAQ<GB[>P! ED88>E@BSB@I!H<@@>A8:!

68 !

DU:>AS>P! B8! 'H>EBFBE! )BQ! JO! )PPB@BD8<GGIC! 8DAQ<GB[>P! ED88>E@BSB@I! B8! @;>! )8DP<G! @$/'!

ED8PB@BD8!<HH><A:!@D!U>!B8!@;>!PBA>E@BD8!DHHD:B@>!@D!@;<@!DF!/<@;DP<G!@$/'!X:>>!FBRO!hYO!!

!

J,#(<0L'2<%%,2#$C$#A'$%'-;1!#1#$<%''

!

0BRO! eO! &>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8!)P<H@<@BD8!FDGGDTB8R!)8DP<G!@$/'!B:!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!PBFF>A>8@!FADQ!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'!X5<A:! :;DT! Q><8! :GDH>:! k! :@<8P<AP! >AADAm! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! <A>! B8PBE<@>P! UI! y!HzKOKhm!:@AD8R!@A>8P:!<A>!B8PBE<@>P!TB@;!EDAA>:HD8PB8R!H4S<G9>:YO!!!!!

(;>! ;IHD@;>:B:4PABS>8! <8<GI:B:! T<:! <BQ>P! @D! :@9PI! @;>! A>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8!

D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?! 8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8! )P<H@<@BD8! <:!T>GG! <:! '<SB8R:O!

2>A>C! T>! FD98P! @;<@! 8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! FDA! '1)4.-1! B8! <GH;<! U<8P! B8! @;>! )8DP<G! @$/'!

69 !

RAD9H!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!HA>PBE@:!G><A8B8R!A<@>!B8!)P<H@<@BD8!XB8EA><:>!B8!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!G><P:!

@D! B8EA><:>! B8! G><A8B8R! A<@>m! :>>! FBRO! eYO! *8@>A>:@B8RGIC! @;B:! A>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8!

8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B:! A>S>A:>P! FDA! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'! XPBFF>A>8E>!

U>@T>>8!:GDH>:!B:!:BR8BFBE<8@!<@!HzKOKhYO!!!

*8! @;>! ;BR;! R<QQ<! U<8PC! <! :BQBG<A! H<@@>A8! T<:! DU:>AS>P! FDA! @;>! A>G<@BD8:;BH!

U>@T>>8!'1)4.1LO!2DT>S>AC!FDA!@;>!.-04.-1!<:!T>GG!<:!'1)4.-1!H<@;:C!P>EA><:>:!B8!

8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! G>P! @D! <8! B8EA><:>! B8! G><A8B8R! A<@>! FDA! )8DP<G! @$/'! RAD9HO! )R<B8C! @;>!

A>G<@BD8:;BH!FDA!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'!T<:!B8!@;>!DHHD:B@>!PBA>E@BD8!<:!EDQH<A>P!@D!

)8DP<G!@$/'!X:>>!FBRO!eYO!!

!

J,#(<0L'2<%%,2#$C$#A'$%'G1C$%&/'

6;BG>! @;>A>! T>A>! 8D! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! U>@T>>8! G><A8B8R! A<@>:! <EAD::! RAD9H:! B8!

'<SB8R:C! B8@>A>:@B8RGIC! @;>A>!T>A>!:BR8BFBE<8@!PBFF>A>8E>:! B8!@;>! B8FG9>8E>!DF!8DAQ<GB[>P!

%/!TB@;B8!@;>!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!B8!HA>PBE@B8R!G><A8B8R!A<@>!<EAD::!@;>!\!:@BQ9G<@BD8!

RAD9H:!X:>>!FBRO!fYO!*8!@;>!<GH;<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@IC!B8EA><:>:!B8!'1)4.-1!<8P!.-14

.1L!H<@;!%/! G>P!@D!<8! B8EA><:>! B8! G><A8B8R!A<@>! B8!@;>!)8DP<G! @$/'!RAD9HO!/D8S>A:>GIC!

B8EA><:>:!B8!@;>:>!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/:!G>P!@D!<!P>EA><:>!B8!G><A8B8R!A<@>!B8!UD@;!/<@;DP<G!<8P!

';<Q! @$/'O!,8! @;>! D@;>A! ;<8PC! P>EA><:>! B8! '1)4.1L!H<@;! %/! HA>PBE@>P! B8EA><:>:! B8!

G><A8B8R! A<@>:! FDA! @;>! )8DP<G! @$/'! RAD9Hm! <R<B8C! DHHD:B@>! >FF>E@:! T>A>! :>>8! FDA! @;>!

/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'!4!B8EA><:>!B8!@;B:!H<@;!G>P!@D!B8EA><:>!B8!G><A8B8R!A<@>:O!

! !

70 !

!

0BRO! fO! &>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! #DAQ<GB[>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <8P! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8!'<SB8R:! FDGGDTB8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! B:! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! PBFF>A>8@! FADQ! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'!X5<A:! :;DT! Q><8! :GDH>:! k! :@<8P<AP! >AADAm! :BR8BFBE<8@! PBFF>A>8E>:! <A>! B8PBE<@>P! UI! y!HzKOKhm!:@AD8R!@A>8P:!<A>!B8PBE<@>P!TB@;!EDAA>:HD8PB8R!H4S<G9>:YO!!! !

*8! @;>!;BR;! FA>Z9>8EI!R<QQ<!U<8P!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@IC! @;>!HD:B@BS>!HA>PBE@DA:!DF!

G><A8B8R!A<@>:!B8EG9P>P!HABQ<ABGI!H<@;:!U>@T>>8!.-0!<8P!.-.!@;AD9R;!@;>BA!B8FG9>8E>:!D8!

.-1!<8P!'1)O!*8!GDT>A!R<QQ<!U<8P!X\K4hK!2[YC!B8EA><:>!B8!.-04.-1C!.-.4.-1C!.-04'1)!

8DAQ<GB[>P! %/:! G>P! @D! B8EA><:>:! B8! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8! @;>! )8DP<G! @$/'! RAD9HC!T;BG>! @;>!

DHHD:B@>!>FF>E@:!T>A>!:>>8!FDA!@;>!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'!RAD9H:!X<8!>WE>H@BD8!B:!@;>!

.-04'1)! H<@;! FDA! @;>! ';<QC! T;>A>B8! B8EA><:>:! B8! 8DAQ<GB[>P! %/! HD:B@BS>GI! HA>PBE@>P!

71 !

G><A8B8R!A<@>:YO! *8! @;>!;BR;!R<QQ<!U<8P!XeK4LKK!2[YC! @;>!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!U>@T>>8!.-.4

'1)!<G:D!HD:B@BS>GI!HA>PBE@>P!G><A8B8R!A<@>!B8EA><:>:m!<8P!@;B:!T<:!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!PBFF>A>8@!

@;<@! /<@;DP<G! <8P! ';<Q! @$/'! RAD9H:C! T;BE;! <R<B8! :;DT>P! @;>! DHHD:B@>! A>G<@BD8:;BH!

U>@T>>8C!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!<8P!G><A8B8R!A<@>:O!

!

.(/4H//(,2'

(D!:9QQ<AB[>C! @;>:>! A>:9G@:! :;DT!FDA! @;>! FBA:@! @BQ>C! @;>!8>9A<G!EDAA>G<@>:C! B8! @>AQ:!DF!

D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@I! @;<@! HA>PBE@! U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:! DF! <P<H@<@BD8! <8P!

:<SB8R:! B8! SB:9DQD@DA! <P<H@<@BD8! FDGGDTB8R! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! @$/'O! *8! H<A@BE9G<AC! @;B:!

Q>@;DP!<G:D!BP>8@BFB>P!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!PBFF>A>8E>:!B8!8>9A<G!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!@;<@!T>A>!

:>>8!B8!@;>!<U:>8E>!DF!:BR8BFBE<8@!U>;<SBDA<G!PBFF>A>8E>:!P9AB8R!:<SB8R:O!

! !

O<*10$#A?/!,2$@$2',@@,2#/'<@'#98G'<%'T$/"<+<#<0'-;1!#1#$<%'1%;'G1C$%&/'

*@!T<:!FD98P!@;<@!)8DP<G!@$/'!:BR8BFBE<8@GI! B8EA><:>P!@;>!A<@>!DF! G><A8B8R!EDQH<A>P!@D!

/<@;DP<G! @$/'! B8! <P<H@<@BD8O! (;9:C! H<A@BEBH<8@:! H>AFDAQB8R! <! U>;<SBDA<G! @<:?! @;<@!

B8SDGS>:!G><A8B8R!<!8DS>G!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8R!T>A>!<UG>!@D!uG><A8!@;>!A>E<GBUA<@BD8v!

HADE>::!Q9E;!F<:@>A!<F@>A!)8DP<G!@$/'!DS>A!G>F@!1LC!@;<8!/<@;DP<G!@$/'!<:!T>GG!<:!';<Q!

@$/'! X:@AD8R! @A>8P! @DT<AP! :BR8BFBE<8E>YO! (;B:! B:! @;>! FBA:@! >SBP>8E>! @D! :9RR>:@! @;<@!

uDFFGB8>v!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!Q<I!;>GH!B8!:H>>PB8R!XUDD:@B8RY!@;>!HADE>::!DF!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!

<P<H@<@BD8! @D! 8>T! >8SBAD8Q>8@:O! 098E@BD8<GGIC! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! <P<H@<@BD8! FDAQ:! <!

:BR8BFBE<8@!HDA@BD8!DF!D8>l:!QD@DA!A>H>A@DBA>C!<8P!B:!@;>A>FDA>!<HHGBE<UG>!@D!TBP>!A<8R>!

DF! <E@BSB@B>:! DF! P<BGI! GBSB8R! XFDA! >OROC! <! :@AD?>! H<@B>8@! B:! ED8:@<8@GI! E;<GG>8R>P! TB@;!

72 !

G><A8B8R! @D! T<G?! D8! <! G>S>G! :9AF<E>! TB@;! 8D! DU:@<EG>:! <8P! U>B8R! <UG>! @D! <P<H@! @;>:>!

<EZ9BA>P!H>AFDAQ<8E>!R<B8:!@D!T<G?B8R!D8!98>S>8!:9AF<E>:!TB@;!Q<8I!DU:@<EG>:C!<:!B8!<!

;DQ>cR<AP>8YO! 0ADQ! @;>! H>A:H>E@BS>! DF!QD@DA! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8C! @;B:! B:! <! S>AI! :BR8BFBE<8@!

FB8PB8R! U>E<9:>! B@! E<8! ;>GH! 9:B8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! @D! u8>9A<GGI! HABQ>v! <8! B8PBSBP9<G! @D!

DH@BQB[>!@A<B8B8R!TB@;B8!<8I!RBS>8!:>::BD8!DF!A>;<UBGB@<@BS>!B8@>AS>8@BD8O!!

! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! <! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! ;BR;>A! A<@>! DF! G><A8B8R! FDGGDTB8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! B8!

:<SB8R:! TD9GP! ;<S>! HADS>P! >S>8! QDA>! 9:>F9GO! '<SB8R:! B:! <?B8! @D! HA<E@BE<G! :B@9<@BD8:!

T;>A>B8!D8>!G><A8:!<!8>T!U>;<SBDAC!<8P!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!R<B8:!DA!<PS<8E>:!D8!:9U:>Z9>8@!

A>H>@B@BD8:! DF! @;>! :<Q>! U>;<SBDA<G! :>@O! 2>A>! T>! FD98P! @;<@! )8DP<G! @$/'! RAD9H! :@BGG!

:;DT>P!<!Q9E;!;BR;>A!A<@>!DF!G><A8B8R!B8!:<SB8R:!EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!@$/'!

RAD9H:C! <G@;D9R;! @;>:>! PBFF>A>8E>:! PBP! 8D@! A><E;! :@<@B:@BE<G! :BR8BFBE<8E>O! ,8>! HD::BUG>!

A><:D8! FDA! @;B:! ED9GP! U>! @;>! uT<8B8Rv! DF! @;>! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'! DS>A! @BQ>O! @$/'! T<:!

<PQB8B:@>A>P! FDA! JK!QB89@>:C! <8P! :<SB8R:! @AB<G:!T>A>! H>AFDAQ>P! <F@>A! <P<H@<@BD8! <8P!

T<:;D9@C! <GQD:@! \h4dK!QB89@>:! FDGGDTB8R! @;>! >8P! DF! :@BQ9G<@BD8O! *@! B:! GB?>GI! @;<@! @;B:!

ED9GP! ;<S>! A>P9E>P! @;>! HD@>8EI! DF! @;>! :@BQ9G<@BD8! >FF>E@:! B8! :<SB8R:O! (;B:! @>QHDA<G!

TB8PDT!<G:D!>WE>>P:!T;<@!T>!BP>8@BFB>P!HA>SBD9:GI!B8!'H>EBFBE!)BQ!LC!T;>A>B8!>FF>E@:!DF!

@$/'!D8! A>:@B8R!UA<B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!T<:!:>>8!9H! @D!Jh4\K!QB89@>:!<F@>A! @;>!>8P!DF!

:@BQ9G<@BD8O!

!

O<*10$#A?/!,2$@$2',@@,2#/'<@'#98G'<%'*,@#'@0<%#<?!10$,#1*'%,#(<0L'12#$C$#A'$%'-;1!#1#$<%''

-A>SBD9:! A>:><AE;! ;<:! :;DT8! @;>! >FF>E@:! DF! )8DP<G! @$/'! D8! BQHADSB8R! :>8:DAI4QD@DA!

<P<H@<@BD8C!HABQ<ABGI!UI!:@9PIB8R!<8P!EDQH<AB8R!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:!:>>8!T;BG>!G><A8B8R!

73 !

@D!H>AFDAQ!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!X+<G><!>@!<GOC!JKLKm!298@>A!>@!<GOC!JKKgYO!2DT>S>AC!T>!

:;DT! ;>A>! FDA! @;>! FBA:@! @BQ>C! @;>! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! A>G<@BD8:;BH! U>@T>>8! 8>@TDA?!

ED88>E@BSB@I!<8P!@;>!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:!:>>8!FDGGDTB8R!@$/'O!!

-A>SBD9:! GB@>A<@9A>! B8S>:@BR<@B8R!@;>!8>9A<G!EDAA>G<@>:!DF!SB:9DQD@DA!<P<H@<@BD8!

;<S>! :;DT8! @;<@! @;<@! HA>FAD8@<G! EDA@>W! XHABQ<ABGI! PDA:DG<@>A<G! -0/Y! <8P! UBG<@>A<G!

HD:@>ABDA!H<AB>@<G!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:C!<GD8R!TB@;!@;>!:9HHG>Q>8@<AI!QD@DA!<A><!HG<I!<!S>AI!

EAB@BE<G! ADG>! B8!Q>PB<@B8R! @;>! U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:! A>Z9BA>P! @D! H>AFDAQ! >AADA4A>P9E@BD8!

<8P! ED8:>Z9>8@GI! G><A8B8R! @;>! 8DS>G! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! Q<HHB8R! X)8R9>A<! >@! <GOC! JKKgm!

$>GG<41<RRBDA>C!1<GF<B@C!,:@AIC!`!-<9:C!JKKdm!$DID8!>@!<GOC!JKKgm!7A<?<9>A!>@!<GOC!JKKdm!

7A<?<9>A!`!1<[[D8BC!JKLLYO!"8P>A:@<8P<UGIC!@;>:>!A>RBD8:!E<8! GB?>GI!PBA>E@GI! B8FG9>8E>!

@;>:>! E;<8R>:! UI! <FF>E@B8R! 1L! <E@BSB@I! <:! T>GG! <:! B8PBA>E@GI! @;AD9R;! @;>! HA>QD@DA!

EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8O!(;>!HA>QD@DA!EDA@>WC!B8!<PPB@BD8!<G:D!HG<I:!<!:BR8BFBE<8@!ADG>!B8!SB:9<G!@D!

QD@DA! @A<8:FDAQ<@BD8:! @;<@! <A>! 8>E>::<AI! FDA! A><E;B8R! <8P! HDB8@B8RC! <:! B:! @IHBE<GGI!

A>Z9BA>P!UI!@;B:!@<:?!X';<PQ>;A!`!6B:>C!JKKhYO!!

2>A>C!T>! FB8P! @;<@! P9AB8R! <P<H@<@BD8C! '1)! @;AD9R;! :@A>8R@;>8B8R! B@:! H<@;:! @D!

.-1!X<GH;<Y!<8P!.1L!X;BR;!R<QQ<YC!PBA>E@GI!B8EA><:>:!@;>!G><A8B8R!A<@>C!BO>OC!;<:@>8:!@;>!

HADE>::!DF!G><A8B8R!@;>!8>T!>8SBAD8Q>8@<G!ED8@>W@!T;>A>B8!EDQH>8:<@DAI!QDS>Q>8@:!

;<S>! @D! U>! Q<P>! @D! DFF:>@! @;>! >W@>A8<GGI! BQHD:>P! :EA>>84E9A:DA! H>A@9AU<@BD8O!

*8@>A>:@B8RGIC!P>EA><:B8R!;BR;!FA>Z9>8EI!R<QQ<!U<8P!ED88>E@BSB@I!U>@T>>8!.-0!@D!'1)C!

<8P! '1)! @D! .-1C! PBA>E@GI! B8EA><:>:! G><A8B8R! A<@>! B8! <P<H@<@BD8O! (;B:! 8>R<@BS>!

A>G<@BD8:;BH! ED9GP! HABQ<ABGI! U>! >WHG<B8>P! UI! @TD! @;B8R:]! LY! @;>! .-04'1)! H<@;!

:9HHA>::BD8! ED9GP! GB?>GI! U>! B8SDGS>P! B8! u:9HHA>::B8Rv! DA! uB8;BUB@B8Rv! @;>! HA>4HD@>8@!

74 !

EDR8B@BS>! HADE>::>:! <::DEB<@>P! TB@;! @;>! :>8:DAI4QD@DA! Q<HHB8R! >WB:@B8R! FDA! :EA>>84

E9A:DA! A>G<@BD8:;BH:! B8! @;>!<U:>8E>!DF!>W@>A8<G!H>A@9AU<@BD8:! X\K!P>R! AD@<@BD8Ym!JY! @;>!

'1)4.1L! H<@;! :9HHA>::BD8! ED9GP! U>! PBA>E@GI! A>G<@>P! @D! :9HHA>::B8R! @;>! H;I:BE<G!

QDS>Q>8@!TB@;! @;>!98T<8@>P!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8RO!(;B:! B:! S>AI! GB?>GI!U>E<9:>! @;>!

ADG>! DF! -0/! B8! B8;BUB@B8R! HABDA! <::DEB<@BD8:! @D! G><A8! 8>T! D8>:! ;<:! U>>8! HA>SBD9:GI!

P>:EABU>P! X)8R9>A<! >@! <GOC! JKKgm! +>8@BGBC! 5A<PU>AAIC! 2<@FB>GPC!`! /D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC! JKKgm!

+>8@BGBC! 5A<PU>AAIC! ,;C! 2<@FB>GPC! `! =BP<GC! JKLLYO! *8! <PPB@BD8C! @;>! ADG>! DF! @;>! '1)! B8!

H<A@BE9G<AGI! BP>8@BFIB8R! u:>@:v! DA! uA9G>:v! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! QD@DA! G><A8B8R! <8P! <BPB8R!

:>G>E@BD8!DF!<HHADHAB<@>!U>;<SBDA:cA>:HD8:>:!B:!<G:D!:9FFBEB>8@GI!>:@<UGB:;>P!X2B?D:<?<!>@!

<GOC!JKKJm!#<E;>SC!7>88<APC!`!29:<B8C!JKKfYO!*8!@>AQ:!DF!@;>!8<@9A>!DF!PBFF>A>8E>:!B8!@;>!

8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! <EAD::! PBFF>A>8@! D:EBGG<@DAIcFA>Z9>8EI! U<8P:C! B@! B:! ED8E>BS<UG>! @;<@!

ED88>E@BD8:!TB@;B8!<8P!U>@T>>8!@;>:>!A>RBD8:!<A>!GB?>GI!@D!>WB:@!<EAD::!Q9G@BHG>!:E<G>:!

BO>OC! :;DA@! A<8R>! ED88>E@BD8:C! GB?>GI! Q>PB<@>P! @;AD9R;! +)5)>ARBE! <E@BSB@IC! <:! T>GG! <:!

QDA>! GD8R4A<8R>! ED88>E@BD8:! @;<@! ED9GP! G><P! @D! D:EBGG<@BD8:! B8! <! GDT>A! FA>Z9>8EI!

U<8PTBP@;!X59[:�?BC!JKKiYO!*8!D@;>A!TDAP:C!B@!E<8!U>!:<BP!@;<@!@$/'!<HH><A:!@D!B8FG9>8E>!

UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! <@!Q9G@BHG>! :E<G>:C! <8P! @;>A>FDA>! DFF>A:! @;>! HD::BUBGB@I! @D!QDA>!TBP>GI!

B8FG9>8E>!8>@TDA?:! B8!<!T<I! @;<@!Q<I!U>!:9B@<UG>!DA!DH@BQ<G! FDA!HADP9EB8R!U>;<SBDA<G!

E;<8R>:!XP>H>8PB8R!D8!@;>!HDG<AB@I!DF!@$/'YO!!

*@!B:!B8@>A>:@B8R!@D!8D@>!@;<@C!8DAQ<GB[>P!%/!FDA!)8DP<G!@$/'!<@!>8P!DF!<P<H@<@BD8!

<HH><A:!@D!U>!A>G<@BS>GI!GDT>A!@;<8!FDA!/<@;DP<G!DA!';<Q!@$/'!XFBRO!hYO!(;>:>!FB8PB8R:!<A>!

:BQBG<A! @D! @;D:>!:>>8! FDA! A>:@B8R!:@<@>!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I! B8!'H>EBFBE!)BQ!JO!)8!<AR9Q>8@!

E<8!U>!Q<P>!@;<@C!B8!:DQ>!FDAQC!)8DP<G!@$/'!<HH><A:!@D!;>GH!B8EA><:>!@;>!uR<B8v!B8!@;>!

75 !

:I:@>QC!:9E;!@;<@!S>AI!:Q<GG!E;<8R>:!B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!E<8!:@BGG!U>!S>AI!@BR;@GI!ED9HG>P!

@D!:@AD8RGI!HD:B@BS>!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:! BO>OC! B8EA><:>P!G><A8B8R!A<@>:O!(;B:!FB@:!S>AI!T>GG!

TB@;B8! @;>! FA<Q>TDA?!DF!)8DP<G! @$/'l:! <UBGB@I! @D! B8EA><:>! :BR8<G4@D48DB:>! X'#&Y! B8! @;>!

:I:@>QO!/D8S>A:>GIC!/<@;DP<G!@$/'!<HH><A:!@D!GDT>A!@;>!R<B8!B8!@;>!:I:@>QC!<8PcDA!<G:D!

A>P9E>:! '#&! B8! @;>! :I:@>QC! T;BE;! Q<I! Q<?>! B@! Q9E;! ;<AP>A! @D! HADP9E>! U>;<SBDA<G!

E;<8R>:!B8!@;>!P>:BA>P!PBA>E@BD8O!09@9A>!A>:><AE;!@D!E<A>F9GGI!>WHGDA>!@;B:!H;>8DQ>8D8!

TD9GP!U>! BQQ>8:>GI!;>GH!E;<A<E@>AB[B8R!QDA>!EG><AGI! @;>!8<@9A>!DF!>FF>E@:!DF!>W@>A8<G!

UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8!D8!<!RGDU<GGI!TBA>P!8>9A<G!8>@TDA?!BO>OC!@;>!T;DG>!UA<B8O!!

!

O<*10$#A?/!,2$@$2',@@,2#/'<@'#98G'<%'*,@#'@0<%#<?!10$,#1*'%,#(<0L'12#$C$#A'$%'G1C$%&/'

,8>!DF!@;>!QD:@!B8@>A>:@B8R!FB8PB8R:!DF!@;B:!:@9PI!T<:!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!E;<8R>!B8!FAD8@D4

H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!B8!@;>!<U:>8E>!DF!:BR8BFBE<8@!U>;<SBDA<G!PBFF>A>8E>:!<EAD::!@;>!\!

:@BQ9G<@BD8!RAD9H:!B8!:<SB8R:O! *8@>A>:@B8RGIC!@;>!8DAQ<GB[>P!>FF>E@BS>!ED88>E@BSB@I!DA!%/!

U>@T>>8! '1)4.-1C! .-14.1L! X<GH;<YC! .-04.-1C! .-04'1)C! .-.4.-1! XGDT! R<QQ<Y! <8P!

.-.4'1)!X;BR;!R<QQ<Y!<GG!HD:B@BS>GI!HA>PBE@!B8EA><:>:!B8!G><A8B8R!A<@>!P9AB8R!'<SB8R:!B8!

@;>!)8DP<G!@$/'!RAD9HO!09A@;>AQDA>C!@;B:!A>G<@BD8:;BH!B:!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!:@AD8R>A!@;<8!@;>!

DHHD:B@>!A>G<@BD8:;BH!U>@T>>8!@;>!EDAA>:HD8PB8R!H<@;:!<8P! G><A8B8R!A<@>:! B8!/<@;DP<G!

<8P!';<Q!@$/'O!'BQBG<A!@D!<P<H@<@BD8C!@;>!'1)4.1L!H<@;C!B8!@;>!<GH;<!U<8P!B8!:<SB8R:!

XB8:@><P! DF! ;BR;! R<QQ<! B8! <P<H@<@BD8Y! 8>R<@BS>GI! HA>PBE@:! B8EA><:>:! B8! G><A8B8R! A<@>:O!

(<?>8! @DR>@;>AC! @;>:>! H<@;:C! <8P! ;>8E>! @;>! 8>@TDA?! <HH><A:! @D! uA>S>AU>A<@>v! B8! <!

:@AD8R!F<:;BD8!P9AB8R!:<SB8R:!B8!@;>!)8DP<G!@$/'!RAD9H!EDQH<A>P!@D!/<@;DP<G!<8P!';<Q!

@$/'O!-D@>8@B<GGIC!@;B:!ED9GP!BQHGI!@;<@!T;>8!<!8>T!U>;<SBDA!B:!G><A8>P!B8!@;>!ED8@>W@!DF!

76 !

<!;,'%<C<!>8SBAD8Q>8@!XDA!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!Q<HHB8R!B:!<EZ9BA>PY!FDGGDTB8R!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DF!

1L! TB@;! )8DP<G! @$/'C! @;>! 98P>AGIB8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! XFAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! B8! @;B:! E<:>Y! B:!

A>EA9B@>P!Q9E;!QDA>! ADU9:@GIC! <8P! GB?>GI!QDA>!DH@BQ<GGI! @;<8! B8! @;>! <U:>8E>!DF! @$/'!

BO>OC!';<QO!!

2>A>C!T>!P>QD8:@A<@>!>SBP>8E>!FDA!HD@>8@B<G!u8>@TDA?!HABQB8Rv!@;<@!B:!B8P9E>P!

UI!)8DP<G!@$/'C!T;BE;!;<:!U>>8!:H>E9G<@BS>!@;9:!F<AO!*F!@;B:!B:!B8P>>P!@;>!E<:>C!@;B:!>FF>E@!

DF!)8DP<G! @$/'!Q<I!U>EDQ>!>S>8!QDA>!EGB8BE<GGI! A>G>S<8@!<8P!:BR8BFBE<8@O!-<A@BE9G<AGIC!

HADSBPB8R! 8D84B8S<:BS>! )8DP<G! @$/'! @D! <! RBS>8! 8>@TDA?! XUI! :@BQ9G<@B8R! D8>! DA! QDA>!

8DP>:!DF!@;<@!8>@TDA?Y!P9AB8R!@;>!FBA:@!:>::BD8!DF!G><A8B8R!DA!U>;<SBDA!QDPBFBE<@BD8!Q<I!

;<S>! :@AD8R! A<QBFBE<@BD8:! B8! B8P9EB8R! <8P! :9:@<B8B8R! :BQBG<A! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! H<@@>A8:! B8!

:9U:>Z9>8@! A>H>@B@BD8:! DF! @;>! @<:?cU>;<SBDAO! 'B8E>! @;B:! >FF>E@! T<:! DU:>AS>P! ;>A>! UI!

uDFFGB8>v! <PQB8B:@A<@BD8! DF! )8DP<G! @$/'C! B@! TD9GP! U>! 8>E>::<AI! @D! >WHGDA>! @;B:!

H;>8DQ>8D8! B8! RA><@>A! P>@<BG! P9AB8R! ED8E9AA>8@! @$/'! <8P! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! XuD8GB8>vYO!

#>S>A@;>G>::C! @;B:! Q<I! ;<S>! :BR8BFBE<8@! BQHGBE<@BD8:! B8! 9:B8R! )8DP<G! @$/'! @D! UDD:@!

8>@TDA?! ADU9:@8>::! DA! BQQ98B@IC! <8P! ED8:>Z9>8@GI! HADP9E>! F<SDA<UG>! U>;<SBDA<G!

E;<8R>:!B8!@;>!ED8@>W@!DF!EDR8B@BS>!<8P!QD@DA!A>;<UBGB@<@BD8O!,8!@;>!ED8@A<AIC!@;>!D@;>A!

Z9>:@BD8! @D!U>! <8:T>A>P! B:! BF! HADSBPB8R!/<@;DP<G! @$/'! E<8! uT><?>8v!8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I!

H<@@>A8:C! <8P! @;>A>FDA>! U>! 9:>P! @D! >W@B8R9B:;! 98T<8@>P! U>;<SBDA<G! H<@@>A8:! :9E;! <:!

<PPBE@BD8!>@EO!,S>A<GGC!@;B:!B:!<8!BQHDA@<8@!F9@9A>!PBA>E@BD8!@D!@<?>!B8!@;>!:@9PI!DF!>FF>E@:!

DF!8D84B8S<:BS>!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8!:B8E>!@;>:>!>FF>E@:!DF!@$/'!Q<I!@A>Q>8PD9:GI!B8EA><:>!

@;>!:EDH>!<8P!>FFBE<EI!DF!S<ABD9:!@A><@Q>8@!B8@>AS>8@BD8:!FDA!<!Q9G@B@9P>!DF!8>9ADGDRBE<G!

<8P!H:IE;B<@ABE!PB:DAP>A:O!):!:@<@>P!HA>SBD9:GIC! B8!@;>!$B:E9::BD8!B8!'H>EBFBE!)BQ!JC!D8>!

77 !

GBQB@<@BD8! DF! @;>! E9AA>8@! <HHAD<E;! B:! @;<@! B8FG9>8E>:! DF! P>>H>A! :9UEDA@BE<G! :9U:@A<@>:!

:9E;!<:!@;>!E>A>U>GG9Q!<8P!U<:<G!R<8RGB<!D8!@;B:!FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!E<88D@!

U>! BP>8@BFB>P! <8P! :@9PB>PO! (;9:C! F9@9A>! A>:><AE;! Q9:@! <G:D! <HHGI! <G@>A8<@BS>! P<@<!

<EZ9B:B@BD8! <8P! <8<GI:>:! @D! @><:>! <H<A@! @;>! ADG>! DF! @;>:>! A>RBD8:! B8! Q>PB<@B8R! @$/'!

>FF>E@:!D8!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!U>;<SBDAO!

!

F1++1'</2$**1#$<%/'1%;'J,"0<!*1/#$2$#A'

)8! BQHDA@<8@! H<@@>A8! @;<@! >Q>AR>:! B8! >W<QB8B8R! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@I! B:! @;<@!

R<QQ<!D:EBGG<@BD8:!:>>Q!@D!HG<I!<8! B8@>RA<G!ADG>!P9AB8R! G><A8B8R!<8P!:<SB8R:!FDGGDTB8R!

@$/'O! (;B:! B:! H<A@BE9G<AGI! B8@>A>:@B8R! U>E<9:>! R<QQ<! D:EBGG<@BD8:! <A>! HD:@9G<@>P! @D! U>!

QD:@! EA9EB<G! <:! <! E>8@A<G! @BQB8R! Q>E;<8B:Q! FDA! :I8<H@BE! HG<:@BEB@I! UI! E<9:B8R!

:I8E;AD8D9:!D:EBGG<@BD8:!DF!Q9G@BHG>!EDA@BE<G!<A><:!X59[:�?BC!JKKiYO!5I!Q><8:!DF!E<9:B8R!

D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@I! B8! PB:EA>@>! <E@BS>! EDA@BE<G! GDE<@BD8:cEDG9Q8:C! R<QQ<! D:EBGG<@BD8:!

>8<UG>!@D!<HHADHAB<@>GI!@BQ>!HA>4:I8<H@BE!<8P!HD:@4:I8<H@BE!<E@BSB@I!:9E;!@;<@!:I8<H@BE!

<E@BSB@I! E<8! U>! :9B@<UGI! QDP9G<@>PO! )8P! @;B:! H;>8DQ>8D8! :>>Q:! @D! <GGDT! GB8?B8R! DF!

:>8:DAI4H>AE>H@9<G! UB8PB8R! @D! 8>9A<G! HG<:@BEB@I! UI! T<I! DF! :I8E;AD8D9:! R<QQ<!

D:EBGG<@DAI! <E@BSB@IO! ):! HA>SBD9:GI! P>QD8:@A<@>PC! :B8E>! @$/'! :@AD8RGI! QDP9G<@>:!

+)5)>ARBE!EBAE9B@:!X'@<RR!>@!<GOC!JKKgYC! B@! B:!HD::BUG>!@D!ED8E>BS>!@;>!PBA>E@! B8FG9>8E>!DF!

@$/'!D8!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IO! *8! @;B:! A>R<APC! B@! B:!QDA>! B8@>A>:@B8R! @D!8D@>! @;<@!)8DP<G! <8P!

/<@;DP<G!@$/'!QDP9G<@>!@;>!U<G<8E>!U>@T>>8!+)5)>ARBE!<8P!+G9@<Q<@>ARBE!EBAE9B@:!B8!<!

HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! Q<88>A! X'@<RR! >@! <GOC! JKKgYO! (;>A>FDA>C! @;>I! <A>! GB?>GI! <UG>! @D!

PBFF>A>8@B<GGI! QDPBFI! R<QQ<! D:EBGG<@BD8:C! T;BE;! ED9GP! B8! @9A8! A>R9G<@>! PDT8:@A><Q!

78 !

U>;<SBDA<G!8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IO!(;B:!:@9PI!HA>:>8@:!@;>!FBA:@!HB>E>!DF!>SBP>8E>!@D!:;DT!@;<@!

R<QQ<!D:EBGG<@DAI!ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8!<! A>G>S<8@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G!8>@TDA?! B:!QDP9G<@>P!

B8!<!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!Q<88>A!UI!@$/'!P9AB8R!G><A8B8R!X:>>!0BRO!hC!)P<H@<@BD8YO!(;9:C!B@!B:!

HD::BUG>! @D! :H>E9G<@>! @;<@! @;>! Q>E;<8B:Q! DF! <E@BD8! DF! @$/'! B8! @>AQ:! DF! QDP9G<@B8R!

8>9ADHG<:@BEB@IC! B8! H<A@C! Q<I! U>! UI! QDP9G<@B8R! R<QQ<! D:EBGG<@BD8:! PBA>E@GIO! (;B:! B:! <!

:BR8BFBE<8@! :@>H! FDAT<AP! B8! 98P>A:@<8PB8R! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! >FF>E@:! DF! 8D84B8S<:BS>! UA<B8!

:@BQ9G<@BD8O! 09@9A>! A>:><AE;! 8>>P:! @D! >WHGDA>! @;B:! B8! RA><@>A! P>@<BGC! @D! H<A@BE9G<AGI!

ED8:BP>A! UA<B8! :@BQ9G<@BD8! @>E;8BZ9>:! @;<@! E<8! >QHGDI! uFA>Z9>8EI4QDP9G<@BD8v! BO>OC!

PBA>E@GI!:@BQ9G<@>!@;>!D:EBGG<@DAI!UA<B8!<E@BSB@I!B8!<!:H>EBFBE!FA>Z9>8EI!DF!B8@>A>:@O!

!!

*8! :9QQ<AIC! @;B:! :@9PI! BP>8@BFB>P! :BR8BFBE<8@! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! PBFF>A>8E>:! B8!

U>;<SBDA<G! <P<H@<@BD8! B8P9E>P! UI! @$/'! <8P! Z9<8@B@<@BS>GI! >:@<UGB:;>P! @;>! 98P>AGIB8R!

8>9A<G! EDAA>G<@>:! Q>PB<@B8R! @;>:>! PBFF>A>8E>:! B8! @>AQ:! DF! D:EBGG<@DAI! 8>@TDA?!

ED88>E@BSB@I! TB@;B8! <! G>F@! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! 8>@TDA?O! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:! <A>! <8! BQHDA@<8@!

EAB@BE<G! :@>H! B8! @;>! PBA>E@BD8! DF! >G9EBP<@B8R!Q>E;<8B:Q! DF! <E@BD8! DF! @$/'! B8! HADP9EB8R!

EDQHG>W!EDR8B@BS>4QD@DA!U>;<SBDA<G!E;<8R>:O!

'

'

!!!!!!!

79 !

&Y!Q$7%'T3'>7:7%!='.8#&X##89:'

,S>A<GGC! @;>! FB8PB8R:! FADQ! @;B:! A>:><AE;! ;<S>! :BR8BFBE<8@GI! <PS<8E>P! @;>!

98P>A:@<8PB8R! DF! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'C! T;BE;! B:! H<A@BE9G<AGI! A>G>S<8@! B8! @;>!

ED8@>W@! DF! QD@DA! A>;<UBGB@<@BD8O! 2>A>C! <! 8DS>G! Q>@;DP! DF! :@9PIB8R! 8>9ADHG<:@BEB@I!

Q>PB<@>P!UI!@$/'!T<:!BP>8@BFB>P!<8P!<HHGB>P!@;<@!B8SDGS>P!E;<A<E@>AB[<@BD8!DF!E;<8R>:!

B8! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! D:EBGG<@DAI! PI8<QBE:! FDGGDTB8R! <PQB8B:@A<@BD8! DF! @$/'O! (;>! EDA@BE<G!

PI8<QBE:!QDP9G<@>P!UI!<!UAB>F!UD9@!DF!QD@DA!EDA@BE<G!@$/'!;<:!U>>8!BP>8@BFB>P!@D!DEE9A!

B8! <! FAD8@D4H<AB>@<G! QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! 9:B8R! <! ADU9:@C! P<@<4PABS>8! 8>@TDA?! <8<GI:B:!

<HHAD<E;O! )PPB@BD8<GGIC! @;>!QDP9G<@BD8! DF! >FF>E@BS>! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I!TB@;B8! @;B:!

8>@TDA?! T<:! E;<A<E@>AB[>P! 9:B8R! <! P<@<4PABS>8! Q9G@BS<AB<@>! ED88>E@BSB@I! QDP>GB8R!

<HHAD<E;O! 09A@;>AC! @;>! U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:! <8P! @;>BA! A>G<@BD8:;BH! TB@;! QDP9G<@BD8! DF!

:9E;! F98E@BD8<G! A>DAR<8B[<@BD8! B8! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@I! T>A>! <G:D! >W<QB8>P!

P9AB8R!<P<H@BS>!QD@DA! G><A8B8RO!(<?>8!@DR>@;>AC!@;>:>!FB8PB8R:!HADSBP>!EAB@BE<G! B8:BR;@:!

B8@D!@;>!HD::BUG>!8<@9A>!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!>FF>E@:!Q>PB<@>P!UI!@$/'O!@$/'C!<8DP<G!@$/'!B8!

H<A@BE9G<AC! <HH><A:! @D! F<SDA<UGI! QDP9G<@>! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@I! B8! <! T<I! @;<@! 8D@! D8GI!

DH@BQB[>:! @;>! HADE>::B8R! UI! BQHADSB8R! :BR8<G4@D48DB:>C! U9@! <G:D! <HH><A:! @D! F<SDA!

ADU9:@8>::!B8!8>@TDA?!<E@BSB@I!H<@@>A8:O!*QHDA@<8@GIC!@;B:!PB::>A@<@BD8!P>QD8:@A<@>PC!FDA!

@;>! FBA:@! @BQ>C! @;<@! @$/'!Q<I!>W>A@! B@:! HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE! 8>9ADH<G:@BE! >FF>E@:! B8! H<A@C! UI!

PBA>E@GI! QDPBFIB8R! R<QQ<! D:EBGG<@DAI! UA<B8! 8>@TDA?! <E@BSB@IO! (;>:>! FB8PB8R:C! B8! @;>!

ED8@>W@! DF! >W@<8@! GB@>A<@9A>! <UD9@! TBP>:HA><P! U>;<SBDA<G! >FF>E@:! DF! @$/'C! Q<I! ;>GH!

>WHG<B8!;DT!@;>:>!U>;<SBDA<G! E;<8R>:!<A>!HADP9E>PO!09A@;>AQDA>C! @;>:>! FB8PB8R:!Q<I!

80 !

HD@>8@B<GGI! B8FDAQ! QDA>! HA9P>8@! <HHGBE<@BD8! DF! @;B:! @>E;8BZ9>! FDA! EGB8BE<G! <8P!

@;>A<H>9@BE!H9AHD:>:!B8!@;>!ED8@>W@!DF!EDR8B@BS>!<8P!:>8:DAI4QD@DA!A>;<UBGB@<@BD8O!

)@!@;B:!HDB8@C!B@!B:!<G:D!BQHDA@<8@!@D!A>EDR8B[>!E>A@<B8!GBQB@<@BD8:!B8;>A>8@!@D!@;>!

HADHD:>P!Q>@;DPDGDRIO!):!PB:E9::>P!HA>SBD9:GIC!>W<QB8B8R!>G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G!EDA@BE<G!

PI8<QBE:!DFF>A:!<8!>WE>GG>8@!<HHAD<E;!@D!:@9PI!D:EBGG<@DAI!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:C!U9@!:9E;!8D84

B8S<:BS>! :E<GH!Q><:9A>Q>8@! @>E;8BZ9>:! GB?>!1%+!<A>! G>::! :>8:B@BS>!98P>AGIB8R!P>>H>A!

:9U4EDA@BE<G! 8>9A<G! <E@BS<@BD8! DF! E>A>U>GG9Q! <8P! U<:<G! R<8RGB<O! 'B8E>! @;>:>! A>RBD8:!

ED8@ABU9@>!:BR8BFBE<8@GI!@D!QD@DA!H>AFDAQ<8E>!<8P! G><A8B8RC! B@!TBGG!U>!8>E>::<AI!@D!9:>!

D@;>A! 8>9ADBQ<RB8R! @>E;8BZ9>:! B8! @;>! F9@9A>C! GB?>! F1&*C! @D! :@9PI! @;>! EDQUB8>P!

<E@BS<@BD8!DF!@;>:>!A>RBD8:!@D!@;>!HADHD:>P!8>@TDA?!;>A>!@D!HADSBP>!<!QDA>!EDQHG>@>!

<EED98@!DF!8>9ADHG<:@BE!QDP9G<@BD8!DF!<!QDA>!R>8>A<G!QD@DA!8>@TDA?!UI!@$/'O!

#>S>A@;>G>::C! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! @;>! S<:@! GB@>A<@9A>! D8! @;>! U>;<SBDA<G! >FF>E@:! DF!

@$/'C! @;>! FB8PB8R:! FADQ!@;B:! A>:><AE;!Q<I!;>GH! :BR8BFBE<8@GI!<PS<8E>! @;>!?8DTG>PR>! B8!

@;>! FB>GP! UI! HADSBPB8R! <! QDA>! EDQHA>;>8:BS>! P>:EABH@BD8! DF! HG<9:BUG>! 8>9ADHG<:@BE!

Q>E;<8B:Q:!QDP9G<@>P!UI!@$/'!<8P!PB:EABQB8<@>!U>@T>>8!@;>!HDG<AB@I4:H>EBFBE!>FF>E@:!

DF! @$/'O! *QHDA@<8@GIC! :9E;! Q>@;DP:! TBGG! ;>GH! BP>8@BFI! <8P! P>:EABU>! 8>9ADQDP9G<@BD8!

B8P9E>P! UI! 8D84B8S<:BS>! EDA@BE<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! B8! R>8>A<GO! 0ADQ! <! HA<E@BE<G! H>A:H>E@BS>C!

@;B:!B:!EAB@BE<G!@D!;>GH!BP>8@BFIC!QD8B@DA!<8P!HD@>8@B<@>!8>9ADHG<:@EBB@I!@;<@!B:!EA9EB<G!FDA!

F98E@BD8<G! A>EDS>AI! B8! H<@B>8@:! :9FF>AB8R! FADQ! UA<B8! G>:BD8:! GB?>! :@AD?>! <8P! @A<9Q<@BE!

UA<B8!B8V9AIO!*8!F<E@C!B8!@;>!I><A:!@D!EDQ>C!Q>@;DP:!DF!E;<A<E@>AB[B8R!8>@TDA?!PI8<QBE:!

<8P!HADH>A@B>:!9:B8R!8D84B8S<:BS>!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!@>E;8BZ9>:!Q<I!;<S>!:BR8BFBE<8@!S<G9>!

B8!<PS<8EB8R!D9A!98P>A:@<8PB8R!DF!@;>!EDQH9@<@BD8<G!HADE>::>:!H>AFDAQ>P!UI!@;>!UA<B8!

81 !

P9AB8R!;9Q<8!EDR8B@BD8!<8P!U>;<SBDA!<8P!QDA>!BQHDA@<8@GIC!@D!>WHG<B8!@;>!@A>Q>8PD9:!

HG<:@BEB@I!>W;BUB@>P!UI!@;>!UA<B8!B8!@;>!F<E>!DF!>WH>AB>8E>!<8P!B8V9AIO!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

82 !

%7@7%7:&7#''

)GU>A@C!#O!5OC!&DU>A@:D8C!%O!1OC!`!1B<GGC!&O!/O!XJKKgYO!(;>!A>:@B8R!;9Q<8!UA<B8!<8P!QD@DA!G><A8B8RO!8"00,%#'.$<*<&A'U'87C!3VXLJYC!LKJ\bLKJeO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOE9UOJKKgOKdOKJf!

)8R9>A<C! MO! )OC! &>9@>A4.DA>8[C! -O! )OC! 6BGGB8R;<QC! $O! (OC! `! '>BPG>AC! &O! $O! XJKKgYO!/D8@ABU9@BD8:! DF! 'H<@B<G! 6DA?B8R! 1>QDAI! @D! =B:9DQD@DA! .><A8B8RO! W<"0%1*' <@'2<&%$#$C,'%,"0</2$,%2,O!PDB]LKOLLiJcVDE8OJKKgOJL\hL!

)8@<GC!)OC!#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!7B8E:>:C!(O!ÄOC!7A9:>C!6OC!2DFFQ<88C!7O4-OC!`!-<9G9:C!6O!XJKKdYO!0<EBGB@<@BD8!DF!SB:9D4QD@DA!G><A8B8R!UI!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DF!@;>!QD@DA! <8P! >W@A<:@AB<@>! SB:9<G! <A><:! B8! ;9Q<8:O! K),' I"0<!,1%' X<"0%1*' <@'%,"0</2$,%2,C!3VXLKYC!JfffbJfgJO!PDB]LKOLLLLcVOLdiK4ghifOJKKdOK\\ieOW!

5<::>@@C!$O! 'OC!`!59GGQDA>C! %O! (O! XJKKgYO!29Q<8!UA<B8! 8>@TDA?:! B8! ;><G@;! <8P!PB:><:>O!8"00,%#' Y!$%$<%' $%' J,"0<*<&AC! 44XdYC! \dKb\deO!PDB]LKOLKgec6/,OKUKL\>\Jf\JPg\PP!

5<::>@@C!$O!'OC!59GGQDA>C!%O!(OC!1>I>A4.B8P>8U>ARC!)OC!)H9PC! MO!)OC!6>B8U>AR>AC!$O!&OC!`!/DHHDG<C! &O! XJKKgYO! /DR8B@BS>! FB@8>::! DF! ED:@4>FFBEB>8@! UA<B8! F98E@BD8<G! 8>@TDA?:O!O0<2,,;$%&/'<@' #),'J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A'<@' G2$,%2,/'<@' #),'Z%$#,;'G#1#,/'<@'-+,0$21C!3[\XJfYC!LLedebLLehJO!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKgK\idLLKi!

5<::>@@C! $O! 'OC! 1>I>A4.B8P>8U>ARC! )OC! )E;<APC! 'OC! $9?>C! (OC! `! 59GGQDA>C! %O! XJKKiYO!)P<H@BS>! A>ED8FBR9A<@BD8! DF! FA<E@<G! :Q<GG4TDAGP! ;9Q<8! UA<B8! F98E@BD8<G! 8>@TDA?:O!O0<2,,;$%&/'<@' #),'J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A'<@' G2$,%2,/'<@' #),'Z%$#,;'G#1#,/'<@'-+,0$21C!3[5XhLYC!LghLfbLghJ\O!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKiKiKKhLK\!

5A>::G>AC! 'O! .OC!`!1>8D8C!=O! XJKLKYO! .<AR>4:E<G>!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:! B8! EDR8B@BD8]! >Q>ARB8R!Q>@;DP:! <8P! HAB8EBHG>:O! K0,%;/' $%' 2<&%$#$C,' /2$,%2,/C! 36XiYC! JeebJgKO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO@BE:OJKLKOKdOKKd!

5A>::G>AC! 'O! .OC! `! '>@;C! )O! 7O! XJKLLYO! 6B>8>A4+A<8R>A! E<9:<GB@I]! <! T>GG! >:@<UGB:;>P!Q>@;DPDGDRIO!J,"0<B+1&,C!]^XJYC!\J\b\JgO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKLKOKJOKhg!

5ADD?>:C!1O! MOC!2<G>C! MO!&OC!Ä9Q>AC! MO!1OC!'@>S>8:D8C!/O!1OC!0A<8EB:C!'O!(OC!5<A8>:C!+O!&OC!,T>8C! MO! -OC! >@! <GO! XJKLLYO! 1><:9AB8R! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I! 9:B8R! 1%+]!1>@;DPDGDRI! <8P! EDQH<AB:D8! TB@;! FE1&*O! J,"0<B+1&,O!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKLLOKJOKhd!

59GGQDA>C!%OC!`!'HDA8:C!,O!XJKKgYO!/DQHG>W!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:]!RA<H;!@;>DA>@BE<G!<8<GI:B:!DF!:@A9E@9A<G! <8P! F98E@BD8<G! :I:@>Q:O! J1#"0,' 0,C$,(/' J,"0</2$,%2,C! 3[X\YC! LfibLgfO!PDB]LKOLK\fc8A8Jheh!

59[:�?BC!+O!XJKKiYO!_)A#)+/'<@'#),'.01$%!XHO!ddfYO!,WFDAP!"8BS>A:B@I!-A>::C!"')O!59[:�?BC! +OC! `! $A<R9;8C! )O! XJKKdYO! #>9AD8<G! D:EBGG<@BD8:! B8! EDA@BE<G! 8>@TDA?:O! G2$,%2,'

DJ,('`<0LE'J`=C!5[6XhiegYC!LgJibLgJgO!PDB]LKOLLJic:EB>8E>OLKggedh!5rE;>GC! /OC!`! 0AB:@D8C! 7O! XJKKKYO! )::>::B8R! B8@>A<E@BD8:! <QD8R! 8>9AD8<G! :I:@>Q:! 9:B8R!

F98E@BD8<G!8>9ADBQ<RB8RO!J,"01*'%,#(<0L/' U' #),'<@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*'<@' #),' B%#,0%1#$<%1*'J,"01*'J,#(<0L'G<2$,#AC!35Xf4gYC!feLbffJO!

/<A@>AC!)O!&OC!):@<FB>SC!'O!=OC!.<8RC!/O!%OC!/D88DAC!.O!(OC!&>8R<E;<AIC!MOC!'@A9U>C!1O!MOC!-DH>C!$O! .O! 6OC! >@! <GO! XJKLKYO! &>:@B8R! B8@>A;>QB:H;>ABE! F98E@BD8<G! Q<R8>@BE! A>:D8<8E>!BQ<RB8R!ED88>E@BSB@I!HA>PBE@:!H>AFDAQ<8E>!<F@>A!:@AD?>O!-%%1*/'<@'J,"0<*<&AC!\aX\YC!

83 !

\ihb\ehO!PDB]LKOLKKJc<8<OJLgKh!/;>8C!+OC!+G>8C!$O!&OC!'<<PC!ÄO!'OC!-<9G!2<QBG@D8C!MOC!(;DQ<:D8C!1O!%OC!+D@GBUC!*O!2OC!`!/DWC!

&O! 6O! XJKLLYO! =>E@DA! <9@DA>RA>::BD8C! :@A9E@9A<G! >Z9<@BD8! QDP>GB8RC! <8P! @;>BA!:I8@;>:B:!B8!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!P<@<!<8<GI:B:O!8<+!"#,0/'$%'.$<*<&A'1%;'+,;$2$%,C!63XLJYC!LLdJbLLhhO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOEDQHUBDQ>POJKLLOKgOKKd!

/D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC!MO!.OC!`!7>ABE?C!'O!%O!XJKKdYO!*8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:!DF!PI8<QBE!UA<B8! A>:HD8:>:! P9AB8R! SB:9DQD@DA! <P<H@<@BD8O! J,"0<B+1&,C! 43X\YC! g\ibgdhO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKK\OLKOK\e!

/DWC!&O!6O! XLggiYO!)0#*]! :DF@T<A>! FDA!<8<GI:B:!<8P!SB:9<GB[<@BD8!DF! F98E@BD8<G!Q<R8>@BE!A>:D8<8E>! 8>9ADBQ<R>:O! 8<+!"#,0/' 1%;' .$<+,;$21*' 0,/,102)E' 1%' $%#,0%1#$<%1*'X<"0%1*C!4VX\YC!LiJbLe\O!

$>GG<41<RRBDA>C! =OC! 1<GF<B@C! #OC! ,:@AIC! $O! MOC! `! -<9:C! (O! XJKKdYO! '@BQ9G<@BD8! DF! @;>!HD:@>ABDA! H<AB>@<G! EDA@>W! B8@>AF>A>:! TB@;! <AQ! @A<V>E@DAI! <PV9:@Q>8@:! P9AB8R! @;>!G><A8B8R!DF!8>T!PI8<QBE:O!K),' W<"0%1*' <@' %,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),' <@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),'G<2$,#A'@<0'J,"0</2$,%2,C!46XddYC!ggeLbggeiO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*OJf\\4KdOJKKd!

$>GDAQ>C!)OC!`!1<?>BRC!'O!XJKKdYO!%%+.)5]!<8!DH>8!:D9AE>!@DDGUDW!FDA!<8<GI:B:!DF!:B8RG>4@AB<G! %%+! PI8<QBE:! B8EG9PB8R! B8P>H>8P>8@! EDQHD8>8@! <8<GI:B:O! W<"0%1*' <@'%,"0</2$,%2,'+,#)<;/C!356XLYC!gbJLO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOV8>9Q>@;OJKK\OLKOKKg!

$BQI<8C! 1O! )OC! `! /D;>8C! .O! +O! XJKLLYO! #>9ADHG<:@BEB@I! B8! @;>! ED8@>W@! DF! QD@DA!A>;<UBGB@<@BD8! <F@>A! :@AD?>O! J1#"0,' 0,C$,(/M' J,"0<*<&AC! aXJYC! eibfhO!PDB]LKOLK\fc8A8>9ADGOJKLKOJKK!

$D:>8U<E;C!#O!"O!0OC!0<BAC!$O!)OC!1B>[B8C!0O!1OC!/D;>8C!)O!.OC!6>8R>AC!7O!7OC!$D:>8U<E;C!&O!)O!(OC!0DWC!1O!$OC!>@!<GO!XJKKeYO!$B:@B8E@!UA<B8!8>@TDA?:!FDA!<P<H@BS>!<8P!:@<UG>!@<:?!ED8@ADG! B8!;9Q<8:O!O0<2,,;$%&/'<@' #),'J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A'<@'G2$,%2,/'<@'#),'Z%$#,;'G#1#,/'<@'-+,0$21C!3[6XJiYC!LLKe\bLLKefO!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKeKd\JKLKd!

$DID8C! MOC!5>GG>EC!-OC!)Q:>GC!&OC!->8;98>C!=OC!1D8E;BC!,OC!/<AAB>AC! MOC! .>;NABEIC! 'OC! >@!<GO!XJKKgYO!/D8@ABU9@BD8:!DF! @;>!U<:<G!R<8RGB<!<8P!F98E@BD8<GGI! A>G<@>P!UA<B8!:@A9E@9A>:!@D! QD@DA! G><A8B8RO! 7,)1C$<"01*' .01$%' 0,/,102)C! 3VVXLYC! iLbehO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOUUAOJKKfOLLOKLJ!

%:HD:B@DC! 0OC! 'E<A<UB8DC! (OC! 2ISÅAB8>8C! )OC! 2BQU>ARC! MOC! 0DAQB:<8DC! %OC! /DQ<8BC! 'OC!(>P>:E;BC!+OC!>@!<GO! XJKKhYO! *8P>H>8P>8@!EDQHD8>8@!<8<GI:B:!DF! F1&*!RAD9H!:@9PB>:!UI! :>GF4DAR<8B[B8R! EG9:@>AB8RO! J,"0<B+1&,C! 4]XLYC! Lg\bJKhO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKKdOLKOKdJ!

0GD>GC!)OC!`!/D;>8C!.O!+O!XJKLKYO!&>EDS>AI!DF!F98E@BD8!B8!;9Q<8:]!EDA@BE<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8!<8P!H;<AQ<EDGDRBE<G! @A><@Q>8@:!<F@>A!:@AD?>O!J,"0<.$<*<&A'<@';$/,1/,C!5aXJYC!Jd\bJhLO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8UPOJKKgOKhOKJe!

0DWC!1O!$OC!`!&<BE;G>C!1O!%O!XJKKeYO!'HD8@<8>D9:!FG9E@9<@BD8:!B8!UA<B8!<E@BSB@I!DU:>AS>P!TB@;! F98E@BD8<G! Q<R8>@BE! A>:D8<8E>! BQ<RB8RO! J1#"0,' 0,C$,(/' J,"0</2$,%2,C! ^XgYC!eKKbeLLO!PDB]LKOLK\fc8A8JJKL!

0AB@:E;C!5OC!&>B:C!MOC!1<A@B8DTBE;C!7OC!'E;<QUA<C!2O!1OC!MBC!3OC!/D;>8C!.O!+OC!`!.9C!5O!XJKLKYO!$BA>E@! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8!HADQD@>:!5$#04P>H>8P>8@! :I8<H@BE!HG<:@BEB@I]!HD@>8@B<G!BQHGBE<@BD8:! FDA! QD@DA! G><A8B8RO! J,"0<%C! \\XJYC! LgfbJKdO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9AD8OJKLKOK\OK\h!

+<G><C! MO! 1OC! =<[Z9>[C! )OC! -<:ABE;<C! #OC! ,AU<8! P>! sBSAIC! MO4MOC! `! />G8B?C! -O! XJKLKYO!

84 !

$B::DEB<@B8R! @;>! &DG>:! DF! @;>! />A>U>GG9Q! <8P! 1D@DA! /DA@>W! P9AB8R! )P<H@BS>!.><A8B8R]!(;>!1D@DA!/DA@>W!&>@<B8:!6;<@! @;>!/>A>U>GG9Q!.><A8:O!8,0,.01*'8<0#,NO!PDB]LKOLKg\cE>AEDAcU;ZJdi!

+<8PBR<C!-O!/OC!29QQ>GC!0O!/OC!`!/D;>8C!.O!+O!XJKKiYO!(A<8:EA<8B<G!$/!:@BQ9G<@BD8!X@$/'Y]!<!@DDG!FDA!PD9UG>4UGB8P!:;<Q4ED8@ADGG>P!EGB8BE<G!:@9PB>:!B8!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!8*$%$21*'%,"0<!)A/$<*<&A' U' <@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),' B%#,0%1#$<%1*' :,;,01#$<%' <@' 8*$%$21*'J,"0<!)A/$<*<&AC!33aXdYC!fdhbfhKO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOEGB8H;OJKKhOLJOKK\!

+>8@BGBC! &O! MOC! 5A<PU>AAIC! (O! MOC! 2<@FB>GPC! 5O! $OC! `! /D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC! MO! .O! XJKKgYO! 5A<B8!UBDQ<A?>A:! DF! QD@DA! <P<H@<@BD8! 9:B8R! H;<:>! :I8E;AD8B[<@BD8O! 8<%@,0,%2,'!0<2,,;$%&/'U'MMM'-%%"1*'B%#,0%1#$<%1*'8<%@,0,%2,'<@'#),'BIII'I%&$%,,0$%&'$%'>,;$2$%,'1%;'7$<*<&A'G<2$,#AM' BIII'I%&$%,,0$%&' $%'>,;$2$%,'1%;'7$<*<&A'G<2$,#AM'8<%@,0,%2,C!4[[VC!hg\Kbhg\\O!PDB]LKOLLKgc*%15'OJKKgOh\\ded\!

+>8@BGBC! &O! MOC! 5A<PU>AAIC! (O! MOC! ,;C! 2OC! 2<@FB>GPC! 5O! $OC! `! =BP<GC! MO! .O! /O! XJKLLYO! />A>UA<G!EDA@BE<G! PI8<QBE:! P9AB8R! SB:9DQD@DA! @A<8:FDAQ<@BD8]! <P<H@<@BD8! @D! <! EDR8B@BS>4QD@DA! >W>E9@BS>! E;<GG>8R>O!O/A2)<!)A/$<*<&AC!6^XiYC! fL\bfJdO! PDB]LKOLLLLcVOLdig4fgfiOJKLKOKLLd\OW!

+A>BEB9:C!1O!$OC!`!1>8D8C!=O!XJKKdYO!$>F<9G@4QDP>!<E@BSB@I!P9AB8R!<!H<::BS>!:>8:DAI!@<:?]!98ED9HG>P! FADQ! P><E@BS<@BD8! U9@! BQH<E@B8R! <E@BS<@BD8O! W<"0%1*' <@' 2<&%$#$C,'%,"0</2$,%2,C!3\XgYC!LdfdbLdgJO!PDB]LKOLLiJcKfgfgJgKdJhifh\J!

2<PBHD9A4#B?@<A<:;C!)OC!.>>C!/O!7OC!$>:QD8PC!MO!%OC!`!';<PQ>;AC!&O!XJKKeYO!*QH<BAQ>8@!DF!A>@>8@BD8! U9@! 8D@! <EZ9B:B@BD8! DF! <! SB:9DQD@DA! :?BGG! @;AD9R;! @BQ>4P>H>8P>8@!PB:A9H@BD8!DF!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>WO!K),'W<"0%1*'<@'%,"0</2$,%2,'U'#),'<@@$2$1*'X<"0%1*'<@' #),' G<2$,#A' @<0' J,"0</2$,%2,C! 4aXdgYC! L\dL\bL\dLgO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*OJheK4KeOJKKe!

2B?D:<?<C! ,OC! #<?<Q9A<C! 7OC! '<?<BC! 7OC! `! #<?<;<A<C! 2O! XJKKJYO! />8@A<G! Q>E;<8B:Q:! DF!QD@DA!:?BGG!G><A8B8RO!8"00,%#'<!$%$<%'$%'%,"0<.$<*<&AC!34XJYC!JLebJJJO!

29<8RC!=O!'OC!2<B@;C!)OC!1<[[D8BC!-OC!`!7A<?<9>AC!MO!6O!XJKLLYO!&>@;B8?B8R!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!<8P! :<SB8R:! B8! <P<H@<@BD8! H<A<PBRQ:]! QDP>G4FA>>! Q>QDAI! FDA! :9EE>::F9G! <E@BD8:!EDQUB8>:! TB@;! B8@>A8<G! QDP>G:O! J,"0<%C! a[XdYC! efebfKLO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9AD8OJKLLOKdOKLJ!

29QQ>GC!0O!/OC!`!/D;>8C!.O!+O!XJKKiYO!#D84B8S<:BS>!UA<B8!:@BQ9G<@BD8]!<!8>T!:@A<@>RI!@D!BQHADS>! 8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8! <F@>A! :@AD?>Ç! P1%2,#' %,"0<*<&AC! ]XfYC! eKfbeLJO!PDB]LKOLKLic'Lded4ddJJXKiYeKhJh4e!

29QQ>GC! 0O! /OC! 2>B:>C! 7OC! />G8B?C! -OC! 0GD>GC! )OC! +>AGDFFC! /OC! `! /D;>8C! .O! +O! XJKLKYO!0<EBGB@<@B8R!:?BGG>P!ABR;@!;<8P!QD@DA!F98E@BD8!B8!DGP>A!:9UV>E@:!UI!<8DP<G!HDG<AB[<@BD8!DS>A! @;>! G>F@! HABQ<AI! QD@DA! EDA@>WO! J,"0<.$<*<&A' <@' 1&$%&C! 53XLJYC! JLiKbJLifO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADUBDG<RB8ROJKKfOLJOKKf!

298@>AC!(OC!'<EEDC!-OC!#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!`!(9A8>AC!$O!.O!XJKKgYO!1DP9G<@BD8!DF!B8@>A8<G!QDP>G!FDAQ<@BD8! P9AB8R! FDAE>! FB>GP4B8P9E>P!QD@DA! G><A8B8R! UI! <8DP<G! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DF!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>WO!K),'W<"0%1*'<@'O)A/$<*<&AC!]^aX-@!LJYC!JgdgbJgiLO!PDB]LKOLLL\cVH;I:BDGOJKKgOLigJfd!

7A<?<9>AC! MO!6OC!`!1<[[D8BC!-O! XJKLLYO!29Q<8!:>8:DABQD@DA! G><A8B8R]!<P<H@<@BD8C! :?BGGC!<8P!U>ID8PO!8"00,%#'<!$%$<%'$%'%,"0<.$<*<&AO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOED8UOJKLLOKiOKLJ!

7A<?<9>AC! MO!6OC!+;BG<APBC!1O40OC!1>8@B:C!1OC!5<A8>:C!)OC!=>I@:Q<8C!1OC!%BP>GU>ARC!$OC!`!

85 !

+;>[C!/O!XJKKdYO!$BFF>A>8@B<G!EDA@BE<G!<8P!:9UEDA@BE<G!<E@BS<@BD8:!B8!G><A8B8R!AD@<@BD8:!<8P! R<B8:! FDA! A><E;B8R]! <! -%(! :@9PIO! W<"0%1*' <@' J,"0<!)A/$<*<&AC! V3XJYC! gJdbg\\O!PDB]LKOLLhJcV8OKKiehOJKK\!

7TD8C!3O!2OC!7DC!1O42OC!);8C!'O!2OC!7BQC!3O42OC!'D8RC!MO!/OC!.>>C!/O42OC!/;<8RC!1O!/OC!>@!<GO!XJKKfYO!-ABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>W!<E@BS<@BD8!UI!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!B8!@;>! ;9Q<8! UA<B8O! J,"0</2$,%2,' *,##,0/C! 65]XLYC! hibhgO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9G>@OJKKfOKJOKLJ!

.<8RC!#OC!'B>U8>AC!2O!&OC!6<APC!#O!'OC!.>>C!.OC!#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!-<9G9:C!6OC!&D@;T>GGC!MO!/OC!>@!<GO! XJKKhYO!2DT!PD>:!@A<8:EA<8B<G!$/!:@BQ9G<@BD8!DF!@;>!HABQ<AI!QD@DA!EDA@>W!<G@>A!A>RBD8<G! 8>9AD8<G! <E@BSB@I! B8! @;>! ;9Q<8! UA<B8Ç! K),' I"0<!,1%' X<"0%1*' <@'%,"0</2$,%2,C!44XJYC!dghbhKdO!PDB]LKOLLLLcVOLdiK4ghifOJKKhOKdJ\\OW!

.>TB:C!/O!1OC!5<GP<::<AA>C!)OC!/DQQB@@>ABC!+OC! .9E<!&DQ<8BC!+OC!`!/DAU>@@<C!1O! XJKKgYO!.><A8B8R!:E9GH@:!@;>!:HD8@<8>D9:!<E@BSB@I!DF!@;>!A>:@B8R!;9Q<8!UA<B8O!O0<2,,;$%&/'<@'#),'J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A'<@'G2$,%2,/'<@'#),'Z%$#,;'G#1#,/'<@'-+,0$21C!3[\XdLYC!LehhfbLehi\O!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKgKJdhhLKi!

1<8@B8BC! $OC! ->AA9EEBC! 1O! +OC! P>G! +A<@@<C! /OC! &DQ<8BC! +O! .OC! `! /DAU>@@<C! 1O! XJKKeYO!%G>E@ADH;I:BDGDRBE<G! :BR8<@9A>:! DF! A>:@B8R! :@<@>! 8>@TDA?:! B8! @;>! ;9Q<8! UA<B8O!O0<2,,;$%&/'<@' #),'J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A'<@' G2$,%2,/'<@' #),'Z%$#,;'G#1#,/'<@'-+,0$21C!3[6X\JYC!L\LeKbL\LehO!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKeKKiifLKd!

1<@:98<R<C!7OC!#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!(:9VBC!'OC!`!&D@;T>GGC!MO!/O!XJKKdYO!%FF>E@!DF!@A<8:EA<8B<G!$/!:>8:DABQD@DA! EDA@>W! :@BQ9G<@BD8! D8! :DQ<@D:>8:DAI! >SD?>P! HD@>8@B<G:! B8! ;9Q<8:O!8*$%$21*'%,"0<!)A/$<*<&A' U'<@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*'<@' #),' B%#,0%1#$<%1*' :,;,01#$<%'<@'8*$%$21*'J,"0<!)A/$<*<&AC!33]XJYC!dhibdiKO!

1<I?<C! 1O! )OC! /DAED:C! $O! 1OC! .>9AR<8:C! 'O! %OC! `! =<BGG<8ED9A@C! $O! %O! XJKKiYO! (;A>>4PBQ>8:BD8<G!GDE<@BD8:!<8P!UD98P<AB>:!DF!QD@DA!<8P!HA>QD@DA!EDA@BE>:!<:!P>FB8>P!UI!F98E@BD8<G! UA<B8! BQ<RB8R]! <! Q>@<4<8<GI:B:O! J,"0<B+1&,C! 53XdYC! Ldh\bLdedO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKKiOKJOKKd!

1E*8@D:;C!)O!&OC!`!.DU<9R;C!#O!MO!XJKKdYO!-<A@B<G! G><:@!:Z9<A>:!<8<GI:B:!DF!8>9ADBQ<RB8R!P<@<]! <HHGBE<@BD8:! <8P! <PS<8E>:O! J,"0<B+1&,C! 45' G"!!*' 3C! 'JhKbi\O!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKKdOKeOKJK!

1B8B9::BC!/OC!/<HH<C!'O!0OC!/D;>8C!.O!+OC!0GD>GC!)OC!0A>R8BC!0OC!#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!,GBS>ABC!1OC!>@!<GO!XJKKfYO!%FFBE<EI!DF!A>H>@B@BS>!@A<8:EA<8B<G!Q<R8>@BE!:@BQ9G<@BD8c@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! B8! EDR8B@BS>! 8>9ADA>;<UBGB@<@BD8O! 701$%' G#$+"*1#$<%C! 3XdYC! \Jib\\iO!PDB]LKOLKLicVOUA:OJKKfOKeOKKJ!

1DA<@@BC! 'OC! '<9R<AC! /OC! `! '@A<8R>C! 5O! )O! XJKLLYO! -A>FAD8@<G4DEEBHB@DH<AB>@<G! ED9HGB8R!98P>AGB>:! G<@>! G<@>8EI! ;9Q<8! 8>9AD8<G! A>:HD8:>:! @D! >QD@BD8O! K),' W<"0%1*' <@'%,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),' <@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),' G<2$,#A' @<0' J,"0</2$,%2,C!53XdeYC! LeJefbLeJfiO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*OJgLe4LLOJKLL!

#<E;>SC!-OC!7>88<APC!/OC!`!29:<B8C!1O!XJKKfYO!098E@BD8<G!ADG>!DF!@;>!:9HHG>Q>8@<AI!<8P!HA>4:9HHG>Q>8@<AI! QD@DA! <A><:O! J1#"0,' 0,C$,(/' J,"0</2$,%2,C! VXLLYC! fhibfigO!PDB]LKOLK\fc8A8Jdef!

#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!&D@;C!)OC!79DC!1O40OC!0B:E;>AC!)O!7OC!.B>U>@<8[C!$OC!.<8RC!#OC!(>AR<9C!0OC!>@!<GO! XJKKeYO! (BQB8R4P>H>8P>8@! QDP9G<@BD8! DF! <::DEB<@BS>! HG<:@BEB@I! UI! R>8>A<G!8>@TDA?!>WEB@<UBGB@I! B8! @;>!;9Q<8!QD@DA! EDA@>WO!K),' W<"0%1*'<@'%,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),'

86 !

<@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),' G<2$,#A' @<0' J,"0</2$,%2,C! 4aXLdYC! \fKeb\fLJO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*Oh\df4KiOJKKe!

#B@:E;>C!1O!)OC!'E;<9>8U9ARC!)OC!.<8RC!#OC!.B>U>@<8[C!$OC!%W8>AC!/OC!-<9G9:C!6OC!`!(>AR<9C!0O!XJKK\YO!0<EBGB@<@BD8!DF!BQHGBEB@!QD@DA!G><A8B8R!UI!T><?!@A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8! DF! @;>! HABQ<AI! QD@DA! EDA@>W! B8! @;>! ;9Q<8O! W<"0%1*' <@' 2<&%$#$C,'%,"0</2$,%2,C!3]XdYC!iLgbiJiO!PDB]LKOLLiJcKfgfgJgK\\JLiiJggd!

#B@:E;>C! 1OC! /D;>8C! .OC! 6<::>AQ<88C! %OC! -ABDABC! )OC! .<8RC! #OC! )8@<GC! )OC! -<9G9:C! 6OC!29QQ>GC!0OC!5DRRBDC!-OC!`!0A>R8BC!0O!XJKKf<YO!(A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8]!'@<@>!DF!@;>!<A@!JKKfO!701$%'G#$+"*1#$<%C!3X\YC!JKibJJ\O!

#B@:E;>C! 1OC! /D;>8C! .OC! 6<::>AQ<88C! %OC! -ABDABC! )OC! .<8RC! #OC! )8@<GC! )OC! -<9G9:C! 6OC!29QQ>GC!0OC!5DRRBDC!-OC!`!0A>R8BC!0O!XJKKfUYO!(A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8]!'@<@>!DF!@;>!<A@!JKKfO!701$%'G#$+"*1#$<%C!3X\YC!JKibJJ\O!

,o';><C! MOC! MD;<8:>845>ARC! 2OC! (AB>FC! $OC! +pU>GC! 'OC! `! &9:;TDA@;C! 1O! 0O! 'O! XJKKeYO!098E@BD8<GGI!:H>EBFBE!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!B8!;9Q<8!HA>QD@DA!EDA@>WO!J,"0<%C!]6X\YC!degbdgKO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9AD8OJKKeOKdOKJL!

-DG<8n<C! &OC! #B@:E;>C! 1O! )OC! `! -<9G9:C! 6O! XJKLKYO! 1DP9G<@B8R! F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@I!H<@@>A8:! <8P! @DHDGDRBE<G! F98E@BD8<G! DAR<8B[<@BD8! DF! @;>! ;9Q<8! UA<B8! TB@;!@A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8O! Q"+1%' 701$%' >1!!$%&O!PDB]LKOLKKJc;UQOJLLKd!

-DG<8n<C!&OC!-<9G9:C!6OC!)8@<GC!)OC!`!#B@:E;>C!1O!)O! XJKLLYO! *8@ADP9EB8R!RA<H;!@;>DAI!@D!@A<E?! FDA! 8>9ADHG<:@BE! <G@>A<@BD8:! B8! @;>! A>:@B8R! ;9Q<8!UA<B8]! <! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@!E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8! :@9PIO! J,"0<B+1&,C! ]6X\YC! JJfebJJgiO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKLKOKgOKfh!

&>B:C!MOC!'E;<QUA<C!2O!1OC!/D;>8C!.O!+OC!59E;C!%O!&OC!0AB@:E;C!5OC!Ä<A<;8C!%OC!/>G8B?C!-O!)OC!>@!<GO! XJKKgYO! #D8B8S<:BS>! EDA@BE<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8! >8;<8E>:! QD@DA! :?BGG! <EZ9B:B@BD8! DS>A!Q9G@BHG>! P<I:! @;AD9R;! <8! >FF>E@! D8! ED8:DGBP<@BD8O! O0<2,,;$%&/' <@' #),' J1#$<%1*'-21;,+A' <@' G2$,%2,/' <@' #),' Z%$#,;' G#1#,/' <@' -+,0$21C! 3[\XhYC! LhgKbLhghO!PDB]LKOLKe\cH8<:OKfKhdL\LKi!

&DT>C! MO! 5O! XJKLKYO! /D88>E@BSB@I! )8<GI:B:! B:! %::>8@B<G! @D! "8P>A:@<8P! #>9ADGDRBE<G!$B:DAP>A:O!:0<%#$,0/'$%'GA/#,+/'J,"0</2$,%2,C!6O!PDB]LKO\\fgcF8:I:OJKLKOKKLdd!

&DT>C! MOC! '@>H;<8C!7O!%OC! 0AB:@D8C!7OC! 0A<E?DTB<?C!&OC! .>>:C!)OC!`!-<::B8R;<QC!&O! XJKKJYO!)@@>8@BD8! @D! <E@BD8! B8! -<A?B8:D8o:! PB:><:>]! BQH<BA>P! >FF>E@BS>! ED88>E@BSB@I! <QD8R!FAD8@<G!EDA@BE<G!A>RBD8:O!701$%C!34]X-@!JYC!JeibJfgO!

&9@@>AC! .OC! /<AS>AC! 0O! 6OC! 2DGADIPC! (OC! #<P<AC! 'O! &OC! 1B@E;>GG40A<8EB:C! MOC! )H9PC! MOC!6>B8U>AR>AC!$O!&OC!>@!<GO!XJKKgYO!1<R8>@D>8E>H;<GDRA<H;BE!R<QQ<!HDT>A!A>P9E@BD8!B8! H<@B>8@:! TB@;! :E;B[DH;A>8B<! P9AB8R! A>:@B8R! ED8PB@BD8O! Q"+1%' 701$%' >1!!$%&C!5[XLKYC!\Jhdb\JidO!PDB]LKOLKKJc;UQOJKedi!

'E;G<9RC!+OC!&>8R<C!=OC!`!#<BAC!$O!XJKKfYO!(A<8:EA<8B<G!PBA>E@!E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!B8!:@AD?>!A>EDS>AIO! -02)$C,/' <@' %,"0<*<&AC! \]XLJYC! LheLbLheiO!PDB]LKOLKKLc<AE;8>9AOihOLJOLheL!

'>BPG>AC! &O! $O! XJKLKYO! #>9A<G! EDAA>G<@>:! DF! QD@DA! G><A8B8RC! @A<8:F>A! DF! G><A8B8RC! <8P!G><A8B8R! @D! G><A8O! IN,02$/,' 1%;' /!<0#' /2$,%2,/' 0,C$,(/C! 5^XLYC! \bgO!PDB]LKOLKgecM%'OKUKL\>\LfLEhEE>e!

'>BPG>AC!&O!$OC!`!#DGGC!$O!/O!XJKKfYO!#>9AD<8<@DQBE<G!EDAA>G<@>:!DF!QD@DA!<EZ9B:B@BD8!<8P!

87 !

QD@DA! @A<8:F>AO! W<"0%1*' <@' J,"0<!)A/$<*<&AC! VVXdYC! Lf\ibLfdhO!PDB]LKOLLhJcV8OKLLfeOJKKe!

'>V8DT:?BC! (O! MOC! `! -<9G:>8C! ,O! XJKKiYO! #>@TDA?! D:EBGG<@BD8:]! >Q>ARB8R! EDQH9@<@BD8<G!HAB8EBHG>:O! K),' W<"0%1*' <@' %,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),' <@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),' G<2$,#A' @<0'J,"0</2$,%2,C!4\XiYC!Lie\bLieiO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*O\e\e4KhPOJKKi!

';<PQ>;AC!&OC!`!6B:>C! 'O! -O! XJKKhYO!K),' 8<+!"#1#$<%1*' J,"0<.$<*<&A' <@' _,12)$%&' 1%;'O<$%#$%&U'-':<"%;1#$<%'@<0'><#<0'P,10%$%&O!

';<AQ<C! #OC! 5<AD8C! MO4/OC! `! &DT>C! MO! 5O! XJKKgYO! 1D@DA! BQ<R>AI! <F@>A! :@AD?>]! A>G<@B8R!D9@EDQ>! @D! QD@DA! 8>@TDA?! ED88>E@BSB@IO! -%%1*/' <@' J,"0<*<&AC! \\XhYC! iKdbiLiO!PDB]LKOLKKJc<8<OJLfLK!

'QB@;C! 1O! )OC! +;<[B[<P>;C! )OC! `! ';<PQ>;AC! &O! XJKKiYO! *8@>A<E@B8R! <P<H@BS>! HADE>::>:!TB@;! PBFF>A>8@! @BQ>:E<G>:! 98P>AGB>! :;DA@4@>AQ! QD@DA! G><A8B8RO! OP<G' .$<*<&AC! 6XiYC!>LegO!PDB]LKOL\eLcVD9A8<GOHUBDOKKdKLeg!

'H<AB8RC! &OC! (;BQQC! 1OC! 2>::>C! 1O! $OC! 7r:@C! MOC! 7<AU>C! 2OC! `! 0B8?C! +O! &O! XJKKgYO!5BPBA>E@BD8<G! <G@>A<@BD8:! DF! B8@>A;>QB:H;>ABE! H<AB>@<G! U<G<8E>! UI! 8D84B8S<:BS>!EDA@BE<G!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!701$%C!354X-@!LLYC!\KLLb\KJKO!PDB]LKOLKg\cUA<B8c<THLhd!

'@<RRC! /O! MOC! `! #B@:E;>C!1O! )O! XJKLLYO! -;I:BDGDRBE<G! U<:B:! DF! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8O!K),'J,"0</2$,%#$/#' U'1'0,C$,('X<"0%1*'.0$%&$%&'%,"0<.$<*<&AE'%,"0<*<&A'1%;'!/A2)$1#0AC!3aXLYC!\ebh\O!PDB]LKOLLeecLKe\fhfdLK\fiiLd!

'@<RRC!/O!MOC!5<E;@B<AC!=OC!`!MD;<8:>845>ARC!2O!XJKLLYO!(;>!&DG>!DF!+)5)!B8!29Q<8!1D@DA!.><A8B8RO!8"00,%#'.$<*<&A'U'87O!PDB]LKOLKLicVOE9UOJKLLOKLOKig!

'@<RRC! /O! MOC! 5>:@C! MO! +OC! '@>H;>8:D8C! 1O! /OC! ,o';><C! MOC! 6IG>[B8:?<C! 1OC! 7B8E:>:C! ÄO! (OC!1DAAB:C! -O! +OC! >@! <GO! XJKKgYO! -DG<AB@I4:>8:B@BS>! QDP9G<@BD8! DF! EDA@BE<G!8>9AD@A<8:QB@@>A:! UI! @A<8:EA<8B<G! :@BQ9G<@BD8O! K),' W<"0%1*' <@' %,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),'<@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),' G<2$,#A' @<0' J,"0</2$,%2,C! 4VXLiYC! hJKJbhJKiO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*Odd\J4KfOJKKg!

S<8!P>!=>8C!=O!+OC!0DAQB:<8DC!%OC!&pP>AC!/O!2OC!-AS9GDSBEC!$OC!5B@@8>AC!&O!)OC!$B>@[C!1O!+OC!29UGC! $OC! >@! <GO! XJKKhYO! (;>! :H<@BD@>QHDA<G! H<@@>A8! DF! <9PB@DAI! EDA@BE<G! A>:HD8:>:!P9AB8R! S>AU<G! ;<GG9EB8<@BD8:O! J,"0<B+1&,C! 4aX\YC! iddbihhO!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKKhOKdOKdL!

S<8!1>>AC!1O!-O!)OC!S<8!P>A!1<A>GC!7OC!6<8RC!7OC!,@@>C!6O!1OC!5D9<[<@BC!>GC!'OC!&D>GB8RC!(O!)O! -OC! =B>AR>S>AC! 1O! )OC! >@! <GO! XJKLKYO! &>EDS>AI! DF! :>8:DABQD@DA! F98E@BD8! <F@>A!>WH>ABQ>8@<G! :@AD?>! EDAA>G<@>:! TB@;! A>:@DA<@BD8! DF! A>:@B8R4:@<@>! B8@>A;>QB:H;>ABE!F98E@BD8<G! ED88>E@BSB@IO! K),' W<"0%1*' <@' %,"0</2$,%2,' U' #),' <@@$2$1*' X<"0%1*' <@' #),'G<2$,#A'@<0'J,"0</2$,%2,C!5[XLLYC!\gidb\geJO!PDB]LKOLhJ\cM#%"&,'/*OheKg4KgOJKLK!

=>8?<@<?AB:;8<8C! )OC! /D8@A>A<:4=BP<GC! MO! .OC! '<8PAB8BC! 1OC! `! /D;>8C! .O! +O! XJKLLYO!*8P>H>8P>8@! EDQHD8>8@! <8<GI:B:! DF! A>:@B8R! UA<B8! <E@BSB@I! A>S><G:! @A<8:B>8@!QDP9G<@BD8! DF! GDE<G! EDA@BE<G! HADE>::B8R! UI! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@! :@BQ9G<@BD8O!8<%@,0,%2,'!0<2,,;$%&/'U'MMM'-%%"1*'B%#,0%1#$<%1*'8<%@,0,%2,'<@'#),'BIII'I%&$%,,0$%&'$%'>,;$2$%,'1%;'7$<*<&A'G<2$,#AM' BIII'I%&$%,,0$%&' $%'>,;$2$%,'1%;'7$<*<&A'G<2$,#AM'8<%@,0,%2,C!4[33C!fLKJbfLKhO!PDB]LKOLLKgc*%15'OJKLLOiKgLggf!

=AU<C! MOC! `! &DUB8:D8C! 'O! %O! XJKKLYO! 'BR8<G! HADE>::B8R! B8! Q<R8>@D>8E>H;<GDRA<H;IO!>,#)<;/'DG1%'9$,&<E'81*$@M=C!4]XJYC!JdgbJeLO!PDB]LKOLKKicQ>@;OJKKLOLJ\f!

6<8RC! .OC! 39C! /OC! /;>8C! 2OC! ^B8C!6OC! 2>C! 3OC! 0<8C! 0OC! Ä;<8RC! 3OC! >@! <GO! XJKLKYO! $I8<QBE!

88 !

F98E@BD8<G!A>DAR<8B[<@BD8!DF!@;>!QD@DA!>W>E9@BD8!8>@TDA?!<F@>A!:@AD?>O!701$%C!355X-@!dYC!LJJdbLJ\fO!PDB]LKOLKg\cUA<B8c<TZKd\!

Ä;>8RC! sOC! )G:DHC! $O! /OC! `! 'E;G<9RC! +O! XJKLLYO! %FF>E@:! DF! @A<8:EA<8B<G! PBA>E@! E9AA>8@!:@BQ9G<@BD8!X@$/'Y!D8!;9Q<8!A>RBD8<G!E>A>UA<G!UGDDP!FGDTO!J,"0<B+1&,C!]^XLYC!Jib\\O!PDB]LKOLKLicVO8>9ADBQ<R>OJKLLOKiOKLf!

!