7/21/2019 Digest Manning vs Nlrc

1/2

Civil ProcedureAngelo A. de LeonSeptember 11, 2013

G.R. No. 83018March 13, 1991

MANNING INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION

FACTS:Frac!sco B""#!c$o % a.&.a. La'aro B""#!c$o !s a $r(c& #r!v"r ! R!)a#h, Sa(#!

Ara*!a h!r"# *) a +or"! -r, A*#(/as!s Moha"# A. A/oa!h Co., $hr( !$s Ph!/!22!"r"2r"s"$a$!v", Ma! I$"ra$!oa/ Cor2ora$!o. +or$(a$"/) B""#!c$o 4as !vo/v"# !a v"h!c(/ar acc!#"$ a# as a cos"5("c" 4as !(r"# a# /os$ *o$h h!s /"s, h" s$a)"# ! ahos2!$a/ ! Sa(#! Ara*!a +or so" $!" *($ 4as /a$"r o r"2a$r!a$"# $o $h" Ph!/!22!"s.

Ev"$(a//) B""#!c$o -/"# a co2/a!$ 4!$h $h" Ph!/!22!" Ov"rs"as E2/o)"$A#!!s$ra$!o 6POEA7 +or $h" r"cov"r) o+ h!s sa/ar) +or $h" ("2!r"# 2or$!o o+ h!s co$rac$,!s(rac" *""-$s a# 2ro"c$"# cos$ o+ "#!ca/ "2"s"s ao($! $o P,000.00.;"s2!$" #(" s"rv!c" o+ s(os a# s"v"ra/ s(*s"5("$ o$!c"s, o a22"arac" 4as"$"r"#, a# o "v!#"c" 2r"s"$"#, ! *"ha/+ o+ $h" !2/"a#"# r"s2o#"$s, B""#!c$o

7/21/2019 Digest Manning vs Nlrc

2/2

Civil ProcedureAngelo A. de LeonSeptember 11, 2013

vo!# ! a) as2"c$. I$ !s ! $r($h $h" ="4 (#"$= o+ $h" NLRC $ha$ !s vo!# ab initio,.!so+ar as !$ a$$"2$s $o var) $h" #!s2os!$!o o+ $h" -a/ a# ""c($or) #"c!s!o o+ $h" POEA#!!s$ra$or. Sa!# ="4 (#"$= !s ($$"r/) !"@cac!o(s $o 4or& a) cha" ! $h"A#!!s$ra$or