did panasonic make a contractor-proof bath fan ?
DESCRIPTION
Did Panasonic Make a Contractor-Proof Bath Fan ?. Ben Hannas -- [email protected] Jonathan Coulter -- [email protected] Bruce Manclark -- [email protected] Data, Not Dogma - July 18-19, 2011 - Goldendale, WA. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Did Panasonic Make a Contractor-Proof Bath Fan?
Ben Hannas -- [email protected] Coulter -- [email protected]
Bruce Manclark -- [email protected]
Data, Not Dogma - July 18-19, 2011 - Goldendale, WA
Measuring Air Flow, Energy Use, and Static Pressure in a Variety of As-Installed Conditions
The Test Setup
Panasonic Whisper GreenFan Controls
• Dial-in CFM• Timer not visible to homeowner
Metering
Variables
• Duct type (metal flex, sheet metal)• Elbow placement (immediate, 2-3’)• Flap (open, screwed shut)• Termination (forced passive, duct roof vent)• Grille (with, without)• Installation type (perfect, small oops, they
probably won’t catch this mistake)
Baseline and Ideal
• Baseline– No duct, open flap, with grille– 136 CFM, 1.5 Pa, 10 Watt
• Ideal– 2 feet straight before elbow, 5 feet
up to roof duct vent termination– 143 CFM, 45 Pa, 19.8 Watt
Duct Type
• No change between metal flex and sheet metal in ideal setup– 141 CFM, 22-24 Pa, 15 Watt
Changing the Termination
• Passive attic vent used as duct termination– Shove it in and seal it– 142 CFM, 22.2 Pa, 14.8 Watt
• Duct roof vent– Meets code– 143 CFM, 45.0 Pa, 19.8 Watt– As a note, running fan 24/7 at this rate is
<$20/year
Real-world Duct Run
• We have a ladder and a phantom truss in the way!– CFM increased
slightly (5 CFM)– Static pressure
doubled to 46 Pa– Energy increased
slightly, up to 21 Watt
Damper
• With the same realistically awkward duct run, now tape the damper shut (but that never happens in real life)– CFM dropped almost in half, but still pulled 87
CFM– Static pressure jumped
from 46 Pa to 128 Pa– Watts increased slightly,
from 21 to 23 Watts
Calibrated Crush
• The “small oops” scenario– Damper open, but complex duct run– No change in CFM– Static increases from
46 Pa to 60 Pa– Watts increase from
21 to 24
Maybe They Won’t Notice
Maybe They Won’t Notice
• Still pulled 57 CFM• 140 Pa• Only 20 Watt