diary section 3 [pdf 0.14mb, 15 pages]

The Clerk to the Patents Court Web Site http://www.justice.gov.uk

ARCHIVE OF COMPLETED OR SETTLED PATENTS COURT TRIALS

JANUARY 2011 TO DECEMBER 2013 TRIALS FROM 2011

08/10/2015 15:45

Case Ref: HC09C04031 CAT Gedeon Richter Plc v Bayer Schering Pharma AG

Representatives Claimants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Joe Delaney (3 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: L Brazell Defendants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Hinchliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons Ref: M Döring Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 3-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 21.02.2011 FIXED ON 11/2009 Judgment reserved on 01.03.2011 Judgment given on 17.03.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 583 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C00883 CAT H. Lundbeck A.S v Norpharma SpA

Representatives

Claimants Dr. Justin Turner QC & Dominic Hughes, 3 New Square Howrey LLP Ref: P. Inman Defendants Andrew Lykiardopoulos, 8 New Square Cumberland Ellis Ref: QJML INF 3 1 Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 6 days WINDOW (5 days) 14.03.2011 FIXED ON 05.05.2010 Judgment reserved on 24.03.2011 Judgment given on 14.04.2011 NCN [2011] EWHC 907 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC06C03050 CAT Les Laboratories Servier v Apotex

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Antony Watson QC & Simon Salzedo (3 New Square & Brick Court Chambers) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: Mr S Cohen Defendants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Andrew Lykiadopoulos (11 South Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 453/B/09360 0041 Heard by: Arnold J

Reading time: Sitting time: 3-4 days WINDOW (5 days) 14.03.2011 FIXED ON 05.11.2010 Judgment reserved on 16.03.2011 Judgment given on 29.03.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 730 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC09C04064 Hospira, Inc. & anr v Amgen Inc.

SETTLED

HC10C01233 CAT Nokia OYJ (Nokia Corporation) v IPCom GmbH & Co. KG

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & James Abrahams (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: J Mutimear Defendants Counsel: Henry Carr QC & Brian Nicholson (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Miles Jelf Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 3-4 days WINDOW (5 days) 11.04.2011 FIXED ON 08.07.2010 Judgment reserved on 20.04.2011 Judgment given on 16.06.2011

NCN: [2011] EWHC 1470 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC09C04770 CAT Medimmune Ltd v Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Tom Mitcheson (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: L3940/MG/WJ Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC with Justin Turner QC & Joe Delaney (3 New Square) Solicitors: Allen & Overy Ref: Nicola Dagg Heard by: Arnold J

Reading time: 4 days Sitting time: 15 days WINDOW (5 days) 02.05.2011 FIXED ON 12.03.2010 Judgment reserved on 27.05.2011 Judgment given on 05.07.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 1669 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C02910 CAT Cephalon Inc. & ors v Orchid Europe Ltd & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Henry Carr QC & Piers Acland QC (11 South Square) Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons Ref: 1496-26/RBF/BXXH Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC & Adrian Speck (8 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing LLP & Latham Watkins Ref: JMM/KFM Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 5-6 days WINDOW (5 days) 09.05.2011 FIXED ON 19.11.2010 Judgment reserved on 13.05.2011 Judgment given on 24.06.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 1591 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C00879 Janssen-Cilag NV v Bayer Corporation

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C03103 CAT Ranbaxy (UK) Ltd v Astrazeneca AB

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: John Baldwin QC & Mark Chacksfield (8 New Square) Solicitors: SJ Berwin Ref: 1555/R21261.14/3614241.1CJAT Defendants Counsel: Henry Carr QC with Tom Mitcheson & Miles Copeland (11 South Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 245/SAF/10281 0006 Heard by: Kitchin J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 3-4 days WINDOW (5 days) 07.06.2011 FIXED ON 19.11.2010 Judgment reserved on 10.06.2011 Judgment given on 15.07.2011 NCN: [2011] EWCH 1831 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC09C04080 CAT Select Healthcare (UK) Ltd v Cromptons Healthcare Ltd & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Ashley Roughton (Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Gowings LLP Ref: B000059 Defendants Counsel: Heather Lawrence (11 South Square) Solicitors: Williams Powell

Reading time: ½ day Sitting time: 3 days WINDOW (5 days) 20.06.2011 FIXED ON 22.07.2010 Judgment reserved on 22.06.2011 Judgment given on

Ref: J Excell Heard by: Kitchin J

15.07.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 1830 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC08C00391 Leo Pharma v Sandoz

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C03618 CAT Convatec Ltd & ors v Smith & Nephew Healthcare Ltd & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Piers Acland QC with Brian Nicholson & Geoffrey Pritchard (11 South Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Latham & Watkins Ref: LC/IB 1st & 2nd Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Miles Copeland (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 393/PGW/10403 0019 3rd Defendants Counsel: Justin Turner QC & Mark Chacksfield (3 New Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Slaughter & May Ref: SXXM/RAZD/JMD 4th Defendants Counsel: Andrew Norris (Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Kingsley Napley Heard by: HHJ Birss QC (Sitting as a judge of the High Court)


Case Ref: HC09C02361 Atrium Medical Corporation & anr v DSB Invest Holding SA

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C00864 Kohler Mira Ltd v Norcoss Group Ltd

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C04610 Actavis UK Ltd v Novartis

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC09C03989 Elmo-Tech Ltd & anr v Guidance Ltd & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C01095 Kuka Systems & Thompson Friction Welding Ltd v Mike Dorsett & Magna International

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C02854 Astrazeneca AB v Krka

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC08C00958 CAT Fabio Perini SpA v LPC Group PLC & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Justin Turner QC & Miles Copeland (3 New Square) Solicitors: Collyer Bristow Ref: J Cohen 2nd Defendants Counsel: Anthony Watson QC & Tom Hinchcliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing LLP Ref: 4th Defendants Counsel: Anthony Watson QC & Tom Hinchcliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Harvey Ingram LLP Ref: P McAleer Heard by: Norris J

Reading time: 1½ days Sitting time: 8 days WINDOW (5 days) 03.10.2011 FIXED ON 29.07.2010 Judgment reserved on 19.10.2011 Judgment given on 04.04.2012 NCN: [2012] EWHC 911 (Ch)

TRIALS FROM 2012 Case Ref: HC11C00127, HC11C00131 CAT Bayer Schering Pharma AG v Genentech (to be heard with Regeneron action)

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons Ref: Ms M. Noor Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: Mr M. Gilbert Claimant in Regeneron Action Counsel: Richard Meade QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Mr P. Kelleher Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 5-6 days WINDOW (5 days) 11.01.2012 FIXED ON 16.03.2011 Judgment reserved on 25.01.2012 Judgment given on 22.03.2012 NCN: [2012] EWHC 657 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C04779, HC11C0553 & HC11C01095 CAT Teva UK Ltd & anr v Astrazeneca AB Inatas Pharmaceuticals Ltd & anr v Astrazeneca AB Hexal AG & anr v Astrazeneca AB

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 3-4 days WINDOW (5 days)

Representatives

Claimants (4779) Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Tom Mitcheson (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Pinsent Masons Ref: J Singer – 641975.07043 Claimants (553 & 1095) Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Adrian Speck (8 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: SCC/MZS/CWH Defendants Counsel: Piers Acland QC & Mark Chacksfield (11 South Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: S Field - 324/SAF/10281003 Heard by: Arnold J

20.02.2012 FIXED ON 17.02.2011 Judgment reserved on 27.02.2012 Judgment given on 22.03.2012 NCN: [2012] EWHC 655 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C01989 CAT Wagner International AG & ors v Earlex Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Davis (Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse Ref: DMK Defendants Counsel: Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Redd Ref: Sara Ashby Heard by: Floyd J


Case Ref: HC10C04270 Shire Pharmaceutical Contracts Ltd v Mount Sinai School of Medicine of New York University

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC09C04478 Orasure v D D D Ltd & others

SETTLED

Case Ref: GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals v Novartis AG

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C03433 Syngenta Ltd & ors v Chemsource Ltd & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C02358 CAT Danisco A/S v Novozymes A/S

Representatives Claimants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Arnold & Porter Ref: DCLP/CMS Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Miles Copeland (3 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: MM/EP Heard by:

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 6 days WINDOW (5 days) 19.03.2012 FIXED ON 01.10.2010 PATENT REVOKED BEFORE TRIAL see [2013] EWHC 155 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C02983 Nuance v Vlingo

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C01111 SanDisk IL Ltd & anr v Kingston Technology Europe Ltd & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C04177 Vision Critical Limited v Future Route Limited

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC09C03755 CAT Molnlycke Healthcare v BSN Medical

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Anna Edwards-Stuart (11 South Square) Solicitors: Charles Russell LLP Ref: IW Defendants Counsel: Richard Meade QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert LLP Ref: Tim Powell Heard by: Floyd J

Reading time: 1½ days Sitting time: 5-6 days WINDOW (5 days) 08.10.2012 FIXED ON 05.07.2011 Judgment reserved on 18.10.2012 Judgment given on 09.11.2012 NCN: [2012] EWHC 3157 (Pat)

Case Ref: Mylan v Viiv Healthcare

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC10C02897 Preston Innovations Limited v Ultimate Angling Limited

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C02180 CAT Samsung Electronics Co Limited v Apple Retail UK (726 & 675) (404)

Representatives

Claimants (726 & 675) Counsel: Henry Carr QC (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bristows

Reading time: Sitting time: 12-15 days WINDOW (5 days) 26.11.2012 FIXED ON 26.10.2011

Ref: Myles Jelf Defendants (726 & 675) Counsel: Guy Burkill QC & Tom Hinchliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer Ref: Justin Watts Claimants (404) Counsel: Mark Vanhegan QC & Brian Nicholson (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Myles Jelf Defendants (404) Counsel: Simon Thorley QC with Guy Burkill QC & Joe Delaney (3 New Square) Solicitors: Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer Ref: Justin Watts Heard by: Floyd J

Judgment reserved on (726 & 675) 06.12.2012 (404) 17.12.2012 Judgment given on (726 & 675) 07.03.2013 (404) 07.03.2013 NCN: (726 & 675) [2013] EWHC 467 (Pat) (404) [2013] EWHC 468 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC10C01969 Environmental Polymer Recycling Technologies Ltd v Protomax Plastics Ltd & ors

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12C01465 HTC Europe Co Ltd v Apple Inc

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C04536 CAT Microsoft Corporation v Motorola Mobility Inc

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & James Abrahams (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: ACW/HEP/MPH/MICCP.0005 Defendants Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert Ref: Tim Whitfield Heard by: Arnold J


TRIALS FROM 2013 Case Ref: HC12E02314 & HC12A2137 CAT Glenmark Generics Ltd v The Wellcome Foundation

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Piers Acland QC & Tom Alkin (11 South Square)

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 4-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 21.01.2013 FIXED ON

Solicitors: HGF Law Ref: Martyn Fish Defendants Counsel: Justin Turner & Tom Hinchcliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Rouse Legal Ref: Heard by: Arnold J

30.07.2012 Judgment reserved on 28.01.2013 Judgment given on 07.02.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 148 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC11C00516 Basf v Makhteshim-Agan UK Ltd

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C04491, HC12C02558 CAT 3-4 Hospira v Novartis

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Tom Mitcheson 3 New Square Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: Mr Nigel Stoate Defendants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Miles Copeland (3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Mr Brian Cordery Heard by: Arnold J


Case Ref: HC12 D02673 CAT 3 Nestec & ors v Dualit & Ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Benet Brandreth (3 New Square & 11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Claire Chapman Defendants Counsel: Mark Vanhegan QC & Anna Edward-Stuart (11 South Square) Solicitors: Jensen & son Ref: David Moore

Reading time: Sitting time: 5 days WINDOW (5 days) 11.03.2013 FIXED ON 31.07.2012 Judgment reserved on 27.03. 2013 Judgment given on 22.04.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 923 (Pat)

Heard by: Arnold J Case Ref: HC11 C03400 Eli Lilly & Company v Biogen IDEC MA Inc

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C01602 CAT 3 Swarovski-Optik AG v Leica Camera AG

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Fasken Martineau LLP Ref: RPC/269759.00011 Defendants Counsel: Michael Hicks (Hogarth) Solicitors: Redd Solicitors LLP Ref: Sara Ashby Heard by: Vos J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 4 days WINDOW (5 days) 08.04.2013 FIXED ON 23.02.2012 Judgment reserved on 23.04.2013 Judgment given on 10.05.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 1227 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC11C03400 CAT 5 Eli Lilly Inc v Janssen Alzheimer Immunotherapy

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse Ref: Mr M Hodgson Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Charlotte May (3 New Square) Solicitors: Linklaters Ref: Mr N Jones Heard By: Arnold J


Case Ref: HC11C01177 & HC11C01178 CAT 5 HTC Corporation v Gemalto

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC & Ben Longstaff (8 New Square & Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert LLP Ref:

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 8-9 days WINDOW (5 days) 22.04.2013 FIXED ON 21.11.2011 Judgment reserved on 10.05.2013

Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC with Guy Burkhill QC & Miles Copeland (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: S J Berwin LLP Ref: 290/290/G25770.1 Heard By: Birss J

Judgment given on 10.07.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 1876 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC11C01371 Hellermanntyton Data Ltd v Tyco Electronics & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC 11C01605 Intercase UK Ltd and I-desk Solutions Ltd v Ergo Computing Ltd

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12C00541 Merck Sharp & Dohme v Bristol Myers Squibb

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Justin Turner QC (3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells Ref: Mr D Brook Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Mark Chacksfield (3 New Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Winston & Strawn Ref: Heard By: Birss J


Case Ref: Hospira UK Limited and The Mathilda v Terrence Kennedy Institute of Rheumatology Trust

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12C02319 CAT 1 Collingwood Lighting Ltd v Aurora Ltd RE: UK Patents 2 475 649

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Mark Vanhegan QC & Tom Alkin (11 South Square) Solicitors: EMW Law Ref: Mark Finn Defendants Counsel: Michael Edenborough QC & Tom St. Quintin (Serle Court & Hogarth Chambers ) Solicitors: Lewis Silkin Ref: Simon Chapman

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 2-3 days WINDOW (5 days) 22.07.2013 FIXED ON 05.11.2012 Judgment reserved on 26.07.2013 Judgment given on 10.02.2014 NCN:

Heard by: [2014] EWHC 228 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC11C02009 CAT 3 AGA Medical Corporation v Occlutech (UK) Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC Tom Hinchliffe (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells LLP Ref: CM3PJB Defendants Counsel: Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk LLP Ref: GG/GL/L4790 Heard by: Roth J

Reading time: 1-2 days Sitting time: 5 days WINDOW (5 days) 01.10.2013 FIXED ON 28.06.2012 Judgment reserved on 15.10.2013 Judgment given on NCN:

Case Ref: HC12A02048, HC12F02047, HC12C02909 CAT 4 HTC v Nokia (RF Case)

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Guy Burkill QC with Brian Nicholson & Alexander Milner (3 New Square, 11 South Square & Fountain Court Chambers) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Jane Mutimear Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC with Nicholas Saunders & Miles Copeland (8 New Square, Brick Court Chambers & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells Ref: Paul Brown Heard by: Arnold J


Case Ref: HC11C04102 CAT 4 Adaptive Spectrum & Signal Alignment Inc v British Telecommunications Plc

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Joe Delaney (11 South Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Wragge and Co Ref: D. Barron Defendants

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 10 days WINDOW (5 days) 21.10.2013 FIXED ON 07.11.2012 Judgment reserved on 05.11.2013

Counsel: Roger Wyand QC & Hugo Cuddigan (Hogarth Chambers & 11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: CHRD/MPH/BRITT.0707 Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HC10C02854 CAT 1 Astrazeneca AB & anr v KRKA, d.d. Novo Mesto & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Innovate Legal Ref: Duncan Curley Defendants Counsel: Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Jeremy Blum Heard by: Sales J


Case Ref: HC10C02785 & HP13B00085 CAT 4 Smith & Nephew v Convatec Technologies Inc & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Charlotte May (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 392/EJC/10403.0016 Defendants Counsel: Piers Acland QC & Tom Alkin (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird and Bird Ref: Mark Hilton Heard by: Birss J

Reading time: ½ day Sitting time: 3-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 06.11.2013 FIXED ON 18.04.2012 Judgment reserved on 26.11.2013 Judgment given on 12.12.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 3955 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12C04455 Resolution Chemicals Ltd v H. Lundbeck A/S

SETTLED

HP13E03325 CAT 1-2 Blue Gentian, LLC & anr v Tristar Products (UK) Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Denise Mcfarland (3 New Square) Solicitors: DWF LLP Ref: MFM/N01117-1 Defendants Counsel: Roger Wyand QC & Jonathan Hill (Hogarth Chambers & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse Ref: David Knight/James Martin Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HC12D01783 CAT 3 Rovi Solutions Corporation & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Henry Ward (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert Ref: AL Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: WC Heard by: Mann J


Case Ref: Studer Professional Audio GmbH v Calrec Audio Ltd RE: EP 1 665 593 B1

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C02959 Corma Inc. & ors v Hegler Plastik GMBH & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12C02319 CAT 1 Collingwood Lighting Ltd v Aurora Ltd RE: UK Patents 2 475 649

Representatives

Claimants

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 2-3 days WINDOW (5 days) 22.07.2013

Counsel: Mark Vanhegan QC & Tom Alkin (11 South Square) Solicitors: EMW Law Ref: Mark Finn Defendants Counsel: Michael Edenborough QC & Tom St. Quintin (Serle Court & Hogarth Chambers ) Solicitors: Lewis Silkin Ref: Simon Chapman Heard by:

FIXED ON 05.11.2012 Judgment reserved on 26.07.2013 Judgment given on 10.02.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 228 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC11C02009 CAT 3 AGA Medical Corporation v Occlutech (UK) Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Tom Hinchliffe (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells LLP Ref: CM3PJB Defendants Counsel: Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk LLP Ref: GG/GL/L4790 Heard by: Roth J

Reading time: 1-2 days Sitting time: 5 days WINDOW (5 days) 01.10.2013 FIXED ON 28.06.2012 Judgment reserved on 15.10.2013 Judgment given on 22.07.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 2506 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12A02048, HC12F02047, HC12C02909 CAT 4 HTC v Nokia (RF Case)

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Guy Burkill QC with Brian Nicholson & Alexander Milner (3 New Square, 11 South Square & Fountain Court Chambers) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Jane Mutimear Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC with Nicholas Saunders & Miles Copeland (8 New Square, Brick Court Chambers & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells Ref: Paul Brown Heard by: Arnold J


Case Ref: HC11C04102 CAT 4 Adaptive Spectrum & Signal Alignment Inc v British Telecommunications Plc

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Joe Delaney (11 South Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Wragge and Co Ref: D. Barron Defendants Counsel: Roger Wyand QC & Hugo Cuddigan (Hogarth Chambers & 11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: CHRD/MPH/BRITT.0707 Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HC10C02854 CAT 1 Astrazeneca AB & anr v KRKA, d.d. Novo Mesto & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Tom Mitcheson (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Defendants Counsel: Bernard Livesey QC & Andrew Lykiardopoulos (Hailsham Chambers & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Innovate Legal Ref: Heard by: Sales J


Case Ref: HC10C02785 & HP13B00085 CAT 4 Smith & Nephew v Convatec Technologies Inc & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Charlotte May (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows

Reading time: ½ day Sitting time: 3-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 06.11.2013 FIXED ON 18.04.2012

Ref: 392/EJC/10403.0016 Defendants Counsel: Piers Acland QC & Tom Alkin (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird and Bird Ref: Mark Hilton Heard by: Birss J

Judgment reserved on 26.11.2013 Judgment given on 12.12.2013 NCN: [2013] EWHC 3955 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12C04455 Resolution Chemicals Ltd v H. Lundbeck A/S

SETTLED

HP13E03325 CAT 1-2 Blue Gentian, LLC & anr v Tristar Products (UK) Ltd

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Denise Mcfarland (3 New Square) Solicitors: DWF LLP Ref: MFM/N01117-1 Defendants Counsel: Roger Wyand QC & Jonathan Hill (Hogarth Chambers & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse Ref: David Knight/James Martin Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HC12D01783 CAT 3 Rovi Solutions Corporation & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Henry Ward (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert Ref: AL Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Andrew Lykiardopoulos (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: WC Heard by: Mann J


TRIALS FROM 2014

Case Ref: Studer Professional Audio GmbH v Calrec Audio Ltd RE: EP 1 665 593 B1

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C02959 Corma Inc. & ors v Hegler Plastik GMBH & anr

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12B01709 CAT 3-4 Kennametal Inc v Pramet Tools S.R.O. & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Alastair Wilson QC & Richard Davis (Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Browne Jacobson Ref: Mr Roberts Defendants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Kathryn Pickard (11 South Square) Solicitors: Charles Russell Ref: Ian Wood Heard by: Henry Carr QC

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 4 days WINDOW (5 Days) 27.01.2014 FIXED 14.01.2013 Judgment Reserved on 03.02.2014 Judgment given on 05.03.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 565 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12A03904 CAT 2Jarden Consumer Solutions (Europe) Ltd (formerly Pulse Home Products Ltd) v SEB S.A & anr

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Andrew Lykiardopoulos QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: GBH/CTM/PUL1/1 Defendants Counsel: Benet Brandreth (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Helen Conlan Heard by: Arnold J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 4-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 03.02.2014 FIXED ON 11.02.2013 Judgment reserved on 10.02.2014 Judgment given on 28.02.2014 NCN: 2014 EWHC 445 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12F04972 & HC13A00233 HTC Corporation v Access Company Ltd and LG Electronics v Access Company Ltd

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC09C04664 Aga Rangemaster Group Plc & anr v Glass Finishing Ltd & ors

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC11C04556 & HC12D01783 CAT 3 Starsight Telecast Inc & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors and Rovi Solutions Corporation & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC with James Abrahams & Isabel Jamal (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert Ref: AL Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC & James Whyte (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: WC Heard by: Arnold J

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 8 days WINDOW (5 days) 24.02.2014 FIXED ON 16.11.2012 Judgment reserved on 11.03.2014 Judgment given on 26.03.2014 NCN: 2014 EWHC 828 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12C03487 CAT 4 Hospira UK Ltd v Genentech Inc

Representatives Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC with Tom Mitcheson QC and Jeremy Heald (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: NMS/MCR/KLO/HOS8.U6 Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC & Mark Chacksfield (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: Mike Gilbert Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HC12D04157 Polymer Logistics v D S Smith (the Polymer Proceedings) Case Ref: HC12C04589 D S Smith v Polymer Logistics (the D S Smith Proceedings)

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12D02916 HTC v Nokia (Proxy Case)

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12C01722 CAT 3 Baillie & ors v Bromhead & Co & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Roger Stewart QC & Richard Davis (4 New Square & Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse Ref: Nicola Sewell Defendants Counsel: John Wardell QC & Jeremy Reed (Wilberforce Chambers & Hogarth Chambers) Solicitors: Hewitsons Ref: Mark Elmslie Heard by: Birss J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 8-10 days WINDOW ( Days) 24.03.2014 FIXED ON 25.11.2013 Judgment Reserved on 11.04.2014 Judgment given on 02.07.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 2149 (Ch)

Case Ref: H12A00998 Knorr-Bremse v Juratek and First Link EP 1108155BRepresentatives

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12E02962 & HC12A03340 CAT 3 Actavis Group hf v Eli Lilly & Company Medis ehf v Eli Lilly & Company

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC with Thomas Raphael & Isabel Jamal (8 New Square, 20 Essex Street & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: EBW/MJH/ACTGR.0116 Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC with Tom Mitcheson QC & Stuart Baran (3 New Square) Solicitors: Hogan Lovells Ref: CM3/DCB/SDB/SW Heard by: Arnold J


Case Ref: HC12A04413 Bayer Pharma v Genentach

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC12E04759 CAT 4 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Nintendo of Europe GmbH

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Henry Carr QC & Tom Hinchliffe (11 South Square & 3 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: James Boon Defendants Counsel: Adrian Speck QC & Brian Nicholson (8 New Square & 11 South Square) Solicitors: Rouse Legal Ref: Arty Rajendra Heard by: Birss J


Case Ref: HP13B02148 CAT 2-3 Generics (UK) Ltd (t/a Mylan) v Richter Gedeon RT

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Piers Acland QC (11 South Square) Solicitors: Innovate Legal Ref: Duncan Curley Defendants Counsel: Michael Silverleaf QC & Lindsay Lane (11 South Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: Alan McBride Heard by: Sales J

Reading time: ½ day Sitting time: 2-3 days WINDOW (5 days) 06.05.2014 FIXED ON 10.10.2013 Judgment reserved on 08.05.2014 Judgment given on 22.05.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 1666 (Pat)

Case Ref: CH/2013/0414 CAT 3 Shanks v Unilever & ors

Representatives

Appellants Counsel: Patrick Green QC (Henderson Chambers) Solicitors: Beresford Ref: Respondents Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Jonathan Hill (8 New Square) Solicitors: Herbert Smith Freehills Ref: Heard by: Arnold J

Reading time: Sitting time: 2-3 days WINDOW (5 days) 06.05.2014 FIXED ON Judgment reserved on 15.05.2014 Judgment given on 23.05.2014 NCN: [2014] EWHC 1647 (Pat)

Case Ref: HC12D02118, HC12A02191, HC12C02915 HTC v Nokia (Tag Case)

SETTLED

Case Ref: HP13E01725 CAT 3 Teva UK Ltd v AstraZeneca BV

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Tom Hinchliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Pinsent Masons Ref: Tom Cahill Defendants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Kathryn Pickard (8 New Square & 11 South Square) Solicitors: Arnold & Porter Ref: Paul Abbott Heard by: Sales J

Reading time: 1 day Sitting time: 4-5 days WINDOW (5 days) 10.06.2014 FIXED ON 26.06.2013 Judgment reserved on 18.06.2014 Judgment given on NCN:

Case Ref: HC11C04556 & HC12D01783 Trial C CAT 3 Starsight Telecast Inc & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors and Rovi Solutions Corporation & anr v Virgin Media Ltd & ors

Representatives

Claimants Counsel: James Abrahams & Isabel Jamal (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert Ref: AL Defendants

Reading time: 2 days Sitting time: 5-6 days WINDOW (5 days) 23.06.2014 FIXED ON 13.02.2014 Judgment reserved on 02.07.2014

Counsel: James Mellor QC & Andrew Lykiardopoulos QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: WC Heard by: John Baldwin QC


Case Ref: HP13E01272 Swivelpole Group Pty Ltd v R&M Engineering Ltd and Industrial Lighting Systems Ltd

SETTLED

Case Ref: HC13A01063 Kingspan v Xtra-Them GB 2478228 GB 2436313

SETTLED

diary section 3 [pdf 0.14mb, 15 pages]

Documents