DHOs REVIEW MEETING27/04/2015

STAR RATING OF FACILITIES

CRITERIA FIXED BY GOI, MOHFW FOR STAR RATING OF CHC BASED ON HMIS

DATAPresented by MOHFW in NPCC

APRIL 2014 – DEC 2014

DEMOGRAPHY AND EVALUATION CELL, BANGALORE

METHODOLOGY

• District wise each CHC in Karnataka was analyzed and a rating provided i.e 5 Star, 4 Star, 3 Star, 2 Star, 1 Star, Not Eligible for star rating.

• 20 indicators from HMIS were considered for analysis. The indicators were categorized as:– Human Resource (3 indicators)

– Infrastructure (3 indicators)

– Drugs and supplies (3 indicators)

– Service availability (3 indicators)

– Client orientation (3 indicators)

– Service utilization (5 indicators)

Format Section Line Item Indicator Criteria Star

HMIS Infrastructure

Format

Human Resource

2.1+2.2+2.3+2.4+2.5+2.7+2.9

Doctors including specialists >=2

2.13.a+2.13.b+ 2.13.c

Nurse and ANM >=6

2.16 Laboratory Technician >=1

Infrastructure4.8

Separate public utilities for males and females Available

4.18.a Operation Theatre available Available4.29.c Stand by facility (generator) Available

Drugs and supplies

9 2 month supply of essential drugs Available

102 month supply of essential vaccines Available

112 month supply of essential contraceptives Available

Service availability

1.2.e 24 - hour delivery services including normal and assisted deliveries

Yes

1.2.h Emergency care of sick children Yes

1.2.l Essential Laboratory Services (Specify the type of lab tests conducted)

Yes

Client orientation

4.43.iPublicly displayed mechanism, whereby a complaint/grievance can be registered

Yes

8.1 Citizen's charter Yes

8.4External monitoring /Gradation by PRI (Zila Parishad)/ RKS

Yes

HMIS Monthly Format

Service Utilization

9 C -Section deliveries performed at facility>=5 / month

25 Number of new IUCD Insertions at facility>=3 / month

33.12Infant 0-11 months who received Measles >=10 / month

57.3In-Patient Head Count at midnight >=450 / month

58.1OPD attendance >=750 / month

Note : 1. Star rating of facilities has been done based on the criteria fixed by GOI, MOHFW

CRITERIA FIXED BY GOI : CHC

KEY FINDINGS

Abstract on star rating of facilities (CHCs)Sl. No. District No. of CHC Facilities

EligibleNot applicable for Star Rating Not Eligible

Total NE = Not Eligible + Not

applicable% of not eligible

1 Bagalkote 8 1 2 5 7 87.50%2 Bangalore Rural 2 1 1 1 50.00%3 Bangalore Urban 5 2 3 3 60.00%4 Belgaum 16 4 1 11 12 75.00%5 Bellary 11 3 8 8 72.73%6 Bidar 8 0 8 8 100.00%7 Bijapur 9 1 4 4 8 88.89%8 Chamrajnagar 3 2 1 1 33.33%9 Chikkaballapur 2 0 1 1 2 100.00%

10 Chikmagalur 5 2 3 3 60.00%11 Chitradurga 11 6 5 5 45.45%12 Dakshina Kannada 8 3 5 5 62.50%13 Davanagere 6 1 5 5 83.33%14 Gadag 2 2 0 0 0.00%15 Gulbarga 16 2 14 14 87.50%16 Hassan 15 7 8 8 53.33%17 Haveri 5 1 4 4 80.00%18 Kodagu 7 3 4 4 57.14%19 Kolar 2 0 2 2 100.00%20 Koppal 9 1 8 8 88.89%21 Mandya 6 3 1 2 3 50.00%22 Mysore 10 3 3 4 7 70.00%23 Raichur 6 1 5 5 83.33%24 Ramanagar 4 3 1 1 25.00%25 Shimoga 7 1 6 6 85.71%26 Tumkur 4 1 3 3 75.00%27 Udupi 6 4 2 2 33.33%28 Uttara Kannada 3 0 1 2 3 100.00%29 Yadgir 6 0 1 5 6 100.00%

Grand Total 202 58 14 130 144 71.29%

Districts >80% of CHC Not Eligible for Star Rating

Sl. No. District No. of

CHCFacilities Eligible

Not applicable

for Star Rating

Not Eligible

Total NE = Not

Eligible + Not

applicable

% of not eligible

1 Bidar 8 0 8 8 100.00%2 Chikkaballapur 2 0 1 1 2 100.00%3 Kolar 2 0 2 2 100.00%4 Uttara Kannada 3 0 1 2 3 100.00%5 Yadgir 6 0 1 5 6 100.00%6 Bijapur 9 1 4 4 8 88.89%7 Koppal 9 1 8 8 88.89%8 Bagalkote 8 1 2 5 7 87.50%9 Gulbarga 16 2 14 14 87.50%

10 Shimoga 7 1 6 6 85.71%11 Davanagere 6 1 5 5 83.33%12 Raichur 6 1 5 5 83.33%13 Haveri 5 1 4 4 80.00%

Performance of Facilities During 2014-15

Source : HMIS data

FACILITY TYPE No. of facilities DELIVERY POINTS

SC>=3 DELIVERIES 9308 19

PHC>=10 DELIVERIES (Non 24x7 PHC) 1337 9

24x7 PHC >= 10 DELIVERIES 953 469

CHC >= 20 DELIVERIES 202 95

TLH>= 20 DELIVERIES 146 137

DH>= 50 DELIVERIES(includes major hospitals)

37 37

Delivery Points

Reporting of Deliveries in PHCs

Sl No District

PHCs Nil Reporting PHCs

NON 24X7 24x7 Total

Total Nil Reporting

PHCs

Percentage of Nil reporting

PHCs24X7 PHCs

1 Udupi 53 7 60 57 95.00% 6

2 Dakshina Kannada 55 9 64 46 71.88% 1

3 Uttara Kannada 68 14 82 57 69.51% 04 Hassan 109 26 135 90 66.67% 15 Ramanagar 47 14 61 39 63.93% 1

6 Bangalore Urban 76 20 96 61 63.54% 0

7 Mysore 123 27 150 94 62.67% 38 Bangalore Rural 32 16 48 29 60.42% 09 Chikmagalur 67 22 89 50 56.18% 0

10 Mandya 90 29 119 66 55.46% 311 Shimoga 83 22 105 58 55.24% 012 Tumkur 96 48 144 74 51.39% 113 Chamrajnagar 33 27 60 25 41.67% 214 Chitradurga 47 33 80 32 40.00% 115 Davanagere 57 41 98 37 37.76% 0

Reporting of Deliveries in PHCs

Sl No District

PHCs Nil Reporting PHCs

NON 24X7 24x7 Total

Total Nil Reporting

PHCs

Percentage of Nil reporting

PHCs24X7 PHCs

16 Chikkaballapur 36 19 55 20 36.36% 117 Kodagu 20 9 29 10 34.48% 018 Bijapur 31 34 65 20 30.77% 019 Haveri 30 38 68 19 27.94% 020 Bidar 31 25 56 15 26.79% 021 Bellary 21 52 73 19 26.03% 022 Belgaum 60 90 150 38 25.33% 023 Gadag 15 24 39 9 23.08% 024 Kolar 17 44 61 13 21.31% 025 Dharwad 13 20 33 6 18.18% 026 Bagalkote 9 39 48 6 12.50% 027 Raichur 4 46 50 3 6.00% 028 Gulbarga 10 75 85 5 5.88% 029 Koppal 4 42 46 2 4.35% 030 Yadgir 0 41 41 1 2.44% 1

Grand Total 1337 953 2290 1001 43.71% 21

Nil reporting of Deliveries in PHCsSL.NO. DISTRICT TALUK FACILITY

1 Chamrajnagar Chamaraja Nagar ALURU (24X7)2 Chamrajnagar Chamaraja Nagar KOTTALAVADI (24X7)3 Chikkaballapur Gowribidanur ALLIPUR 24X74 Chitradurga Molakalumur ASHOKA SIDDAPURA 24X75 Dakshina Kannada Bantwal MANI (24X7)6 Hassan Channarayapatna ANATHI (24X7)7 Mandya Krishnarajpet SHEELANERE 24X78 Mandya Mandya HOLALU (24X7)9 Mandya Mandya KEELARA 24X7

10 Mysore Hunsur MULLURU (24X7)11 Mysore Krishnarajanagara HAMPAPURA (24X7)12 Mysore Krishnarajanagara HANASOGE (24X7)13 Ramanagar Kanakapur DOMBARADODDI (24X7)14 Tumkur Madugiri MARUVEKERE (24X7)15 Udupi Karkal AJEKAR (24X7)16 Udupi Karkal BAILOOR (24X7)17 Udupi Kundapura BELVE (24X7)18 Udupi Kundapura KANDLOR 24X719 Udupi Kundapura NADA (24X7)20 Udupi Udupi PADUBIDRI (24X7)21 Yadgir Surapur HEMANOOR (24X7)

Nil reporting of Deliveries in CHCs

SL. NO. DISTRICT TALUK FACILITY

1 Bangalore Urban Bangalore South KENGERI

2 Dakshina Kannada Belthangadi DHARMASTHALA

3 Hassan Holenarasipura DODDAKUNCHE

4 Mandya Krishnarajpet BOOKANAKERE

5 Tumkur Gubbi M N KOTE

6 Udupi Udupi BRAHMAVARA

7 Udupi Udupi SHIRUVA

8 Uttara Kannada Mundgod PALA

Taluk Level Hospitals with < 20 Deliveries / month

Sl.No DISTRICT TALUK FACILITY

TOTAL DELIVERIES IN

YEARAVERAGE PER

MONTH

1 Chamrajnagar Yelandur (FRU) YELANDUR 48 4

2 Chikmagalur Kadur (FRU) KADUR 5 0

3 Chikmagalur Mudigere (FRU) MUDIGERE 218 18

4 Hassan Alur (FRU) ALUR 135 11

5 Kodagu Somwarpet (FRU) SOMVARPET 129 11

6 Mandya Sriranagapatna (FRU) SRIRANGAPATNA 16 1

7 Uttara Kannada Ankola (FRU) ANKOLA 70 6

8 Uttara Kannada Supa (FRU) SUPA 88 7

CHCs with <10 deliveries during 2014-15SL. NO. DISTRICT TALUK FACILITY

Deliveries conducted /

year

1 Bangalore Urban Bangalore South CHANDRAPPA CIRCLE 5

2 Chikkaballapur Bagepalli GULURU 7

3 Dakshina Kannada Bantwal VAMADAPADAV 3

4 Hassan Channarayapatna NUGGEHALLI 6

5 Hassan Holenarasipura PADUVALAHIPPE 4

6 Mysore Heggadadevankote SARAGUR 1

7 Mysore Mysore ASHOKAPURAM UCHC 2

8 Shimoga Sagar (FRU) ANADAPURAM 3

9 Shimoga Thirthahalli KANNANGI 2

10 Udupi Karkal HEBRI 7

11 Udupi Karkal NITTE 1

12 Udupi Kundapura BAINDOOR 2

13 Uttara Kannada Bhatkal SHIRALI 4

Districtwise Nil reporting of IPD in PHCsSl No District Total No. of Facilities Facilities with Nil IPD % of facilities with nil

IPD1 Dakshina Kannada 64 49 76.56%2 Bangalore Urban 96 72 75.00%3 Hassan 135 101 74.81%4 Mysore 150 96 64.00%5 Bangalore Rural 48 30 62.50%6 Tumkur 144 84 58.33%7 Chikmagalur 89 48 53.93%8 Uttara Kannada 82 44 53.66%9 Ramanagar 61 31 50.82%

10 Chikkaballapur 55 23 41.82%11 Kodagu 29 10 34.48%12 Mandya 119 36 30.25%13 Kolar 61 15 24.59%14 Shimoga 105 25 23.81%15 Chitradurga 80 19 23.75%16 Bellary 73 15 20.55%17 Chamrajnagar 60 12 20.00%18 Bidar 56 11 19.64%19 Davanagere 98 17 17.35%20 Gadag 39 5 12.82%21 Bijapur 65 8 12.31%22 Gulbarga 85 10 11.76%23 Belgaum 150 16 10.67%24 Haveri 68 6 8.82%25 Bagalkote 48 3 6.25%26 Dharwad 33 2 6.06%27 Koppal 46 2 4.35%28 Raichur 50 2 4.00%29 Yadgir 41 1 2.44%30 Udupi 60 1 1.67%

Karnataka 2290 794 34.67%

Nil reporting of IPD in CHCs

Sl. No. DISTRICT SUBDISTRICT FACILITY TYPE FACILITY NAME

1 BANGALORE URBAN BANGALORE SOUTH CHC KENGERI

2 DAKSHINA KANNADA BELTHANGADI CHC DHARMASTHALA

3 MANDYA KRISHNARAJPET CHC BOOKANAKERE

4 MYSORE HEGGADADEVANKOTE CHC SARAGUR

5 MYSORE NANJANGUDU CHC HULLHALLI

6 TUMKUR GUBBI CHC M N KOTE

7 UTTARA KANNADA MUNDGOD CHC PALA

Nil reporting of OPD in PHCsSl. NO. DISTRICT SUBDISTRICT FACILITY NAME

1 BELGAUM BELGAUM CANTONMENT UPHC2 BELGAUM BELGAUM SES TILAKWADI UPHC3 BELGAUM BELGAUM SHIVAJINAGAR UPHC4 BELLARY BELLARY BELAGAL5 BELLARY HADAGALI MAILAR6 BELLARY HADAGALI UTTANGHI7 BELLARY SANDUR VITTALAPURA8 BIJAPUR SINDAGI NAGAVI.B.K.9 CHAMRAJNAGAR KOLLEGALA MEENYAM

10 CHIKKABALLAPUR SHIDALAGHATTA Y. HUNASENAHALLI11 GADAG RON YAVAGAL12 GADAG SHIRAHATTI BALEHOSUR13 GULBARGA AFZALPUR BADADAAL14 HASSAN HASSAN DODDABEEKANAHALLI15 HASSAN HASSAN GODANAHALLI16 HASSAN HOLENARASIPURA NAGARANAHALLI17 HASSAN HOLENARASIPURA VALAMBIGE18 HAVERI HAVERI MEVUNDI19 KOPPAL KUSHTAGI MALAGATTI20 KOPPAL YELBURGA SHIRUR21 MYSORE HEGGADADEVANKOTE H.D.KOTE22 MYSORE HUNSUR HUNSUR TRIBAL23 MYSORE MYSORE K.R.KENDRA UPHC24 SHIMOGA SAGAR TADAGALALE25 SHIMOGA SORABA BETTADAKURLI26 SHIMOGA SORABA HARISHI27 TUMKUR PAVAGADA C.K.PURA28 TUMKUR PAVAGADA DODDAHALLI29 UTTARA KANNADA SUPA DIGGI

CHCs with <5,000 OPDs / year

Sl. No. DISTRICT SUBDISTRICT FACILITY NAME

OPD attendance

(All)

1 BELLARY BELLARY ROOPANAGUDI 5030

2 HASSAN HOLENARASIPURA HALLI MYSORE 4821

3 HASSAN HOLENARASIPURA DODDAKUNCHE 4600

4 BELGAUM CHIKKODI EXAMBA 3493

5 HASSAN HOLENARASIPURA PADUVALAHIPPE 3167

Taluk Hospitals with <40,000 OPDs / year

Sl. No. DISTRICT SUBDISTRICT FACILITY NAME

OPD attendance

(All)

1 CHIKMAGALUR NARASIMHARAJAPURA (FRU) NARASIMHARAJAPURA 39146

2 UTTARA KANNADA YELLAPUR (FRU) YELLAPURA 38101

3 BELGAUM BAILAHONGALA (FRU) BAILHONGAL 36542

4 YADGIR SHAHPUR (FRU) SHAHPUR 36462

5 UTTARA KANNADA ANKOLA (FRU) ANKOLA 29149

6 GADAG SHIRAHATTI (FRU) SHIRAHATTI 29092

7 UTTARA KANNADA SUPA (FRU) SUPA 20149

8 BAGALKOTE BAGALKOT BAGALKOTE 3882

District Hospitals with <1,00,000 OPDs / yearSl. No. DISTRICT SUBDISTRICT FACILITY NAME OPD attendance

(All)

1 KODAGU MADIKERI KODAGU DISTRICT HOSPITAL 94231

2 BAGALKOTE BAGALKOT BAGALKOTE DISTRICT HOSPITAL 86327

3 YADGIR YADGIR YADGIR DISTRICT HOSPITAL 86211

4 BELLARY BELLARY BELLARY DISTRICT HOSPITAL 83703

5 CHIKKABALLAPUR

CHIKKABALLAPUR

CHIKKABALLAPUR DISTRICT HOSPITAL 81809

6 MYSORE MYSORE KR HOSPITAL MYSORE DH 63465

7 DAVANAGERE DAVANGERE DAVANGERE WOMEN AND CHILDREN DH 53525

8 DAKSHINA KANNADA MANGALORE LADY GOSHAN HOSPITAL

MANGALORE DH 34124

Mother &

Child

Tracking System

PREGNANT WOMAN REGISTRATION IN MCTS V/S HMIS

Bangalore Rura

l

Ramanagar

Mandya

KodaguUdupi

Chitradurg

a

Chamrajnagar

Koppal

Dakshina Kannada

Yadgir

Gadag

Haveri

Chikmagalur

Uttara Kannada

Bangalore U

rban

Hassan

Chikkaballapur

Dharwad

Tumkur

DavanagereBidar

Myso

re

Belgaum

Bijapur

Karnata

ka

Shimoga

Gulbarga

Raichur

Bellary

Kolar

BagalkoteBBM

P0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

120.0098

.60

93.4

334

.71

102.

1192

.62

98.2

054

.33

49.1

110

1.83

47.2

150

.66

52.5

090

.32

81.5

887

.82 95

.17

88.4

2 97.8

397

.66

80.3

994

.47

68.8

739

.36

46.0

5 58.7

274

.82

74.1

626

.53

25.2

888

.35

86.9

70.

00

CHILDERN REGISTRATION IN MCTS V/S HMIS

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

120.00

140.0012

9.73

122.

5410

5.69

103.

9199

.08

94.4

392

.66

92.6

291

.33

88.2

287

.17

86.5

085

.04

82.6

680

.62

80.2

479

.35

78.2

576

.33

76.2

875

.95

72.8

671

.79

70.1

368

.94

66.4

465

.95

59.0

150

.91

47.6

742

.20

0.00

REGISTRATION OF CHILDRENS IN DISTRICT HOSPITALSSl No District Child registered

1 Bagalkot 892 Belgaum 833 Bellary 434 Bidar 2865 Bijapur 406 Chamarajanagar 667 Chikkaballapura 1468 Chikmagalur 1429 Chitradurga 595

10 Dakshina Kannada 35211 Davanagere 11612 Dharwad 15613 Gadag 5214 Gulbarga 14715 Hassan 54116 Haveri 13917 Kodagu 11218 Kolar 11219 Koppal 6620 Mandya 21121 Mysore 767

22 Raichur 023 Ramanagara 4324 Shimoga 28325 Tumkur 35226 Udupi 15627 UK 6828 Yadgir 57

March 2015

Taluk Hospitals where deliveries are not registered in MCTS

Sl No District Facility Name

1 Bagalkot BADAMI TH

2 Bagalkot MUDHOL TH

3 Bangalore Rural NELAMANGALA TH

4 Bangalore (U) ANEKAL TH

5 Belgaum CHIKODI TH

6 Belgaum KHANAPUR TH

7 Belgaum BAILHONGAL TH

8 Bellary HADAGALI TH

9 Bellary SIRAGPPA TH

10 Bijapur INDI TH

11 Chikkaballapura GOURIBIDANUR TH

12 Chikkaballapura BAGEPALLI TH

13 Chikmagalur MUDIGERE TH

14 Davanagere CHANNAGIRI TH

Sl No District Facility Name

15 Gulbarga ALAND TH

16 Gulbarga CHINCHOLI TH

17 Gulbarga CHITAPUR TH

18 Hassan ALUR TH

19 Haveri HIREKERUR TH

20 Kolar BANGARPET TH

21 Kolar MALUR TH

22 Kolar MULBAGAL TH

23 Mysore HUNSUR TH

24 Mysore KRISHNARAJANAGARA TH

25 Raichur MANVI TH

26 Raichur SINDHANOOR TH

27 Udupi KARKALA TH

28 Yadgir SHAHPUR TH

March 2015