designing effective professional development: linking ... · designing effective professional...

31
Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, BSCS 18 June 2011 Presented at Road Map for Education in the Geographical Sciences Project National Geographic Society Washington, DC

Upload: duongthuy

Post on 14-Jun-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction

Janet Carlson, BSCS

18 June 2011

Presented at Road Map for Education in the Geographical Sciences Project National Geographic Society

Washington, DC

Page 2: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

BSCS

•  Full name: Biological Sciences Curriculum Study (emphasis on the curriculum study)

•  Established in 1958 •  Non-profit based in Colorado •  Focused on inspiring science literacy by

transforming teaching and learning –  Our work is theory-based research and development

projects resulting in curriculum materials, professional development programs, evaluation reports, and empirical studies

•  40 staff, 90 projects à funded by government grants, contracts, and royalties

Page 3: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Professional Development Paradigm Shift

Old Paradigm •  Private/individual •  One-shot •  Unrelated topics •  External expert •  Passive learning •  Skill development •  Atheoretical •  Quick fix •  Training

New Paradigm •  Shared process •  Sustained •  School-related issues •  Internal expertise •  Active learning •  “Why” & “how” of teaching •  Research-based •  Lasting change = slow

process •  Learning

Page 4: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Professional Learning

Additive Learning -- the addition of new skills to an existing repertoire

AND Transformative Learning -- substantial changes

in deeply held beliefs, knowledge, and habits of practice Thompson & Zeuli, 1999

Page 5: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Requirements for TRANSFORMATIVE Professional Development

1. Create cognitive dissonance. 2. Provide opportunities to resolve

dissonance. 3. Connect 1 and 2 to teacher’s students. 4. Develop a repertoire of practice to support

new understanding. 5. Support for cycling back through #1-4.

Thompson, Charles; and Zeuli, John. The Frame and the Tapestry (in Sykes, G. & Darling-Hammond, L. (1999) Teaching as the Learning Profession. San Francisco: Jossey Bass)

Page 6: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Creating Cognitive Dissonance Requires PD Providers to Consider

How People Learn

Page 7: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Some Premises to Consider

•  Teacher knowledge and beliefs impact teacher action.

•  The more consistent the actions are with research on learning, the more likely it is that learners (of any age) will learn.

Page 8: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Principles: Learners and Learning

•  What learners already know influences their learning. •  Learners acquire new knowledge by constructing it for

themselves. •  The construction of knowledge is a process of change

that requires addition, creation, modification, refinement, restructuring, and rejection.

•  Learning happens through diverse experiences. •  All learners, regardless of age, race, culture, and

gender are capable of understanding and doing science and mathematics.

(Loucks-Horsley et al., p. 33-34)

Page 9: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Principles: Teachers and Teaching

•  The purpose of teaching is to facilitate learning.

•  Teaching is a profession requiring specialized knowledge.

•  The practice of teaching is complex and demanding.

(Loucks-Horsley et al., p. 38)

Page 10: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

So what does Professional Development that accounts for all these ideas look like?

Page 11: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

An Example: Project PRIME

•  Promoting Reform through Instructional Materials that Educate

•  Collaborative project BSCS, Center for Science Teaching and Learning at Northern Arizona University, and AZ biology teachers

•  Funded by NSF in 2004 through the Teacher Professional Continuum (TPC) program

•  Goal: Study the impact of educative curriculum materials combined with transformative PD on teacher understanding and practice

Page 12: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

PRIME Time Line

Time line for Cohort A

Summer 05 (2 wks)

Spring 05 School Year 05-06 (2 CLS & ASTA)

Summer 06 (3 wks)

School Year 06-07 (3 CLS & ASTA)

Time line for Cohort B

Summer 06 (2 wks)

Spring 06 School Year 06-07 (2 CLS & ASTA)

Summer 07 (3 wks)

School Year 07-08 (3 CLS & ASTA)

40 HS biology teachers in Arizona

Page 13: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

PRIME Program

Program Selection

1 week

Curriculum Analysis ASTA and 2 Lesson Study Cycles

2 weeks

Teach a

Fall Analyze Student Work Plan y

Spring Analyze Student Work

ASTA Teach b

Curriculum Analysis ASTA and 3 Lesson Study Cycles

3 weeks

Teach c

Fall Analyze Student Work Plan d

Spring Analyze Student Work

Winter Analyze Student Work Plan e ASTA Teach d Teach e

Analyze Units a,b

Analyze Units c,d,e

Y1

Y2

Page 14: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Major Components of the Professional Development Plan

1.  Curriculum selection process 2.  Emphasis on educative curriculum

materials 3.  Extensive summer professional

development program 4.  Collaborative lesson study sessions 5.  Research on Pedagogical Content

Knowledge (PCK)

Page 15: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Component 1: Curriculum Selection Process

1.  Coherence –  An organizational structure that

deliberately promotes student understanding,

–  Explicit links between facts and concepts that will facilitate the retrieval and application of those facts

–  Builds from and extends concepts previously developed

–  Explicit connections between the key concepts and an overarching framework about biology

2.  Focus –  Inclusion of a limited number of

key concepts –  Development of concepts in-

depth at an appropriate level for an introductory college course

–  Intellectual requirement that the reader apply and demonstrate their understanding in multiple ways

–  Articulated text that helps the reader build from and extend concepts that were developed previously

Selection process included looking for evidence of

Page 16: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Teachers' Voices

How did choosing a curriculum using the AIM process differ from what you had experienced before? •  Before: matched curriculum with state standards •  Before: selected curriculum with the best

ancillaries •  AIM: careful examination for relevance, rigor,

coherence, focus •  Applied AIM process after Project PRIME in new

district project

Page 17: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Component 2: Understanding Educative Curriculum Materials

Educative curriculum materials are those that promote teacher learning as well as student learning.

(Ball & Cohen, 1996; Davis & Krajcik, 2005)

See this link: http://www.bscs.org/pdf/prensentationhighschoolbiotext06.pdf for a summary of the review of biology curriculum materials.

Page 18: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Component 2: Educative Curriculum Materials

(Davis & Krajcik, 2005)

Thoughtfully designed instructional materials can help teachers develop:

Content Knowledge – e.g., content information in the teacher materials

Pedagogical Knowledge – e.g., support materials for using the instructional model

Contextual Knowledge – e.g., information on common student misconceptions and related strategies

Page 19: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Teachers’ Voices

Donna: •  Previous textbooks were used as a resource only, this one is our

guide to learning •  This program interconnects concepts so it all flows together •  This program emphasizes problem solving, critical thinking,

relevance

Erin: •  This one scaffolds experimental skills and the curriculum for

students •  This program includes student-led activities

As you used the educative materials you selected, how were they the same or different from other materials you’ve used?

Page 20: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Component 3: Extensive Summer PD Program

•  2 weeks summer 1; 3 weeks in summer 2 (40 hour weeks)

•  Participants switched between a teacher hat and a student hat.

•  Emphasis on understanding the curriculum features that supported student understanding of concepts

•  Emphasis on the educative features of the curriculum and teacher craft knowledge

•  Participants taught selected activities to their colleagues •  1 content deepening experience per unit – usually a

university researcher describing his/her research; later participants made connections between the lecture and the curriculum

Page 21: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance
Page 22: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Teachers’ Voices

Donna: •  First reaction: not fun!

Colleagues reactions about the same

•  Second year: recognized that CFGs helped see program as a whole & how chapters flow together

•  More recently: used CFGs in PD with new teachers

Erin: •  Made sense of the curriculum

progression •  Helped me determine what

lessons could be skipped if necessary

•  Helped me see links between big ideas in science

•  Got to hear viewpoints of other teachers and could hear about their experiences related to the material

What was your reaction to the development of Conceptual Flow Graphics?

Page 23: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Component 4: Collaborative Lesson Study Sessions

•  Participants worked in small groups to choose one lesson that they agreed to teach in a similar way, video record, and collect student work from

•  Planning was done during the summer. •  CLS sessions were held twice during each

school year.

Page 24: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

CLS Planning Document Program Name: Unit Name and Number Activity Name:

Focus Question:

Expected Student Learning Outcomes

Ways that students can communicate understanding of the concept(s)…

Description of a High Quality

Student Work Product

Description of a Medium Quality Student Work

Product

Description of a Low Quality

Student Work Product

Connecting to the Conceptual Flow Graphic:

Page 25: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Teachers’ Voices

Erin: •  Sharing video and student

work with other teachers •  (Summer 2) was great—I saw:

–  other methods of teaching to try –  questioning techniques different

than mine –  classroom arrangements that

were successful for the assignments

•  It was great because two or three amazing teachers could put their brains together and develop a great lesson.

Donna: •  My school is very secluded

from others and in a different culture, so it was great to compare student work with others

•  CLS helped me see my teaching style

•  I gained a PLC—I was able to discuss teaching with others in my group via email and phone calls

What was the value of the Collaborative Lesson Study component?

Page 26: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Teachers’ Voices

Donna: •  Before: stand & deliver •  Now: a facilitator •  Before: students

expected to get it “right or wrong”

•  Now, students create labs, think critically & learn the process of science

Erin: •  Learning about

metacognition helped me plan better plan lessons and ask better questions

•  Hearing other teachers’ ideas increased my efficiency as a teacher

•  Seeing the CFGs helped me understand how the lessons are related

How did participating in Project PRIME change you as a teacher?

Page 27: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Empirically Tested Theoretical Path of Influence

Page 28: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

A Closing Thought on the Importance of Effective Professional Development

The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn, and relearn.

Alvin Toffler

Page 29: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Acknowledgements

PRIME teachers •  Donna Savill, Douglas

High School, AZ •  Erin Stuart, Deer

Valley High School, AZ

PRIME researchers •  April Gardner, BSCS •  Julie Gess-Newsome,

Northern Arizona University

Page 30: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

References

Thompson, C. and J. Zeuli (1999). The Frame and the Tapestry Standards-Based Reform and Professional Development. Teaching as the Learning Profession: Handbook of Policy and Practice. L. Darling-Hammond and G. Sykes, Jossey-Bass Publishers.

Davis, E. and J. Krajcik (2005). "Designing educative curriculum materials to promote teacher learning." Eduactional Researcher 34(3): 3-14.

Ball, D. L.. & Cohen, D. K. (1996). Reform by the book: what is – or might be – the role of curriculum materials in teacher learning and instructional reform? Educational Researcher, 25, 6 - 8, 14.

Loucks-Horsley, S., P. W. Hewson, et al. (2003). Designing professional development for teachers of science and mathematics. Thousand Oaks, CA, Corwin Press.

Page 31: Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking ... · Designing Effective Professional Development: Linking Curriculum & Instruction Janet Carlson, ... Create cognitive dissonance

Thank you

BSCS 5415 Mark Dabling Blvd.

Colorado Springs, CO 80918 719.531.5550 www.bscs.org