derrida - violence and metaphysics - an essay on the thought of emmanuel levinas

37
g=;E€ii;;i'ri|? E ;.gi;€E*::*;; :c+zi|4;*c t ; E * i : 27Ei ; i E; : : rE{gi:ii€i;gi E+:a ai::E;: gE3 3Fri;;; i;F;: F,lgi ?:s€: Ee;€;A: g Ig1; l: E E :;: ;?: q5: ; i: : 3;i i E: ggE ;: i€: gi i {}ii?Eg: Ei BE E : ii s glE!:i='.8 1:,o 1i: iCE:se€€ EE#i E 3g€ i€ gi 31 ! ;! ga! E i?:sEai ; €A-i "w A?o \? 6 ,L Y - ;. I c; == 1 . , t s J Y =tEiz;E,:=i: fi 8.: =ti 5 !n=: =:;E:!;:AE: z v Z = E ,I *: i s 7Ee E;i-E i:- = E=3'===;S;i:: ;g:33;;g?ii ig-;4.t=?ei,-8i fte + s l'-l = q .: :: u : a< S.F+ S t P'i.e s a< \ 3€ \ : llq \ .: oo qJ C\i! \\ "-:g B o-= h S f s H t, n EE FE 4 F t .:Q ;G o.l n\ -^qil;v 6 -= $3 - d C \-S 0)c:E<! 31gg rio v\ NU il: cr tg v +!'t! x sr vla '-LU>v = =,3! ='i TE E? i E. cv oo 'Pl r.Xe-\J\ :5 e + b= EE:f rt v + s v ts V^> - V V a > TiYP t s Ita- .3\ r€Ei i\. = 3 - ; St :()c\o v+\nl (J''L X X T \ g r\* v grii: liiiiiE t iii ;?i li E : 1z FigiFFi iiE;FEii iI isg?; : ii :::"; !ieti lE e: fI€ii= ;- = E€ . €; i i li f, i g ie E ; ? g f3 g i i*i;3 i :!Eig: t;;eglf -:€= I; i iE : E $E tii iE gii i.E I Ji:174 ! i E : :i E: E N:,ZEE : a=, E E ! : i gi; i: i€ ii ; 3iFgi! :;i 111 qJ L F co c-

Upload: charlie-jewell

Post on 08-Nov-2014

64 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

g=;E€ii;;i'ri|? E ;.g i;€E*::*;;:c+zi|4;*c t ; E * i : 27Ei ; i E; : :rE{gi:ii€i;gi E+:a ai::E;: gE33Fri;;; i;F;: F,lgi ?:s€: Ee;€;A:g Ig1; l: E E :;: ;?: q5: ; i: : 3;i i E:ggE ;: i€: gi i {}ii?Eg: Ei BE E : ii sglE!:i='.8 1:,o 1i: iCE:se€€ EE#i E3g€ i€ gi 31 ! ;! ga! E i?:sEai ; €A-i

"w

A?o\?

6

, L Y - ; .I c ; = = 1 . , t s

J Y

=tEiz;E,:=i :f i 8 . : = t i 5 ! n = :

=:;E:! ; :AE:z v Z = E , I * : i s7Ee E ; i -E i : - =E = 3 ' = = = ; S ; i : :;g:33;;g?i ii g - ; 4 . t = ? e i , - 8 i

f te + sl ' - l = q . :

: : u : a<S.F+ S tP ' i . e s a <\ 3 € \: l l q \. : o o q J

C \ i !\ \" - : g Bo - = h S

f s H t ,n EE FE4 F t . : Q; G o . l n \- ^ q i l ; v

6 - = $ 3- d C \ - S

0 ) c : E < !3 1 g g r i o

v \N U

i l : c r t gv

+ ! ' t !x s rv l a' - L U > v

= = , 3 ! = ' iTE E? i E.c v o o ' P lr . X e - \ J \

:5 e + b=EE:f r t

v+ s v ts

V ^ > -V V a >

TiYP t sI t a - . 3 \

r€Ei i \ .= 3 - ; S t: ( ) c \ ov + \ n l( J ' ' L X X

T \

g r \ *v

grii: liiiiiE t iii ;?i li E : 1zFigiFFi iiE;FEii iI isg?; : ii: ::"; !ieti lE e: f I €ii= ;- = E€ .€; i i li f, i g ie E ; ? g f3 g i i*i;3 i:!Eig: t;;eglf -:€= I;i iE : € E $E tii iE gii i.E I Ji:174! i E : :i E: E N:,ZEE : € a=, E E! : i gi; i: i€ ii ; 3iFgi! :;i 111

qJ

L

F

coc-

Page 2: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

Etii ?ggiitEl E+''iE E ;;tqliEEa: !ii i!ill;+iii;iii!EiiliEi,i:iigggliE?ii:;iitli;E!:*iii g ai;EEiib EEiai:?ri'€11i AliiElii:iiEligi!gii?Eiis iigE€€EisE:I$3 EE;gi aasi; i+aii€a9i?i iiii !iliil!l!;!iilgi1g €l i:! i;giigiliet is? igi,A!;s: €{;, :; s:; ! r : rE;i*! 1!i ' Erii ; *?fiit+EEg?:13=ilgE; i€ i : i;Es €'E; ;*€; E; ai LEr: aE:; E*! t"3Et;:i?n g;gi;i;sE;i;ea:At iv=uEE E ;€:o::;:# EF: 27EEt E;; ;; - ; g s" i.:i€

Esg l

{ ) c g

E ;5>

2 = e = I e=, . _ - t q _' t ) > , r r = Y s

s g €€ F r E; 6 F r ; 8 X- ( ) 2 E 9 . h

: :s# l * ; -B3Ea: j e . i =E *r E qE i1€ ! H € H E> € E r a = ' X - E

* a r & 9 - a El + x E ( k C l : 3

E: P E *g -og ^ F €

6 l v' E : g F ; p . r . co - t c E ? 0 . 9= + ' = t 9 c ' lu S : F 3 3a!Ht8z+= a ? - o . = . n c )i =s '9=F€A R 2 o ' ! F :E " ! 2 s c ) - . * ; v' i r € . = b =

- c y o . =c ! -

- € A - r F

: i ' - . ^ - . ( ) E C. E = = l t € . = ' =p . - r O 6 - ; = - + - F

E* tgE * 5 E! = E E ! E ! & -

;: ?; g*: E! ? = ( ) ( ) o =5 P : ' - o F . o ' Yi= . e v E 3 : Ee = ' :=z=? F" t rE=-= t r- -J J - r L v J . -

; L L 2 e e g.g E E g € b g s € E : $ E : r $ E A H;€ p ei. ;Etr; i e:; E;Z;; ! t E;9H€,1€b aE a:-[;€; gai A Ez,ziE; E t* EE ri 5e l E E g 3 ; *;.; F F ; b r; E s 5 7 s b +=

giE is f ai E ! t; l iai: fE €:: aiE EE a* : : g 5E E" tE€,E Eu iE :: EE A€ :€ia€i " oE i It!g;t €rg:€; i E€";A?4€ E € $$ !€ i€ E e !i s E s * e; s e =f : i ijE€ E a! F 35 sE;*ii$s€i*Et€;i;;:iets+;t t E I Ea;$s€*qts e i ;€i: a B ab i i i € i i i I E rE E ; ; g i € a+ ;;E= TE s'A=f *E;;i 33: EF E;E:i ie: i*#E€;= ii g; *E i8E tti $€; Ej;s 6 eEsl is el g;gE*;€€ FE€ E A H: E

ig t iit [i gil ii ;; isgigt i i g; ag:;:ci; t:€;;€Et€E sEiE: +E *i?ssi q F.E€ E: E F;= i;: i = r'€;7i?',E s;= +E +d +s +FE g;E; f e g€ E gEiS

= >. -o >.': t) '= c)

E = = = ' - E

; Ei { : 9 F + = =

. = X : = . Y . 2 7 o

€ F ,Z 3 E p €3 o g . x g ^ > ' F

EiI : ; ; iE. : d = ( g > ' . : . = =C ) 6 r r = . = t r ^ q

b S o c € ' = = + c li ? - : c S = E t s €€ 9 2 g E t r - , *: jEIF3e3,

. Y > . { O t r ' J - r r -A E€ 8<ET 'Ee 'E ;5 I *E =+FE e i * I F" f r g i : ! : : t r€€E iEEgS:E i3+ ; :<

^ ( . ) 6 l n ' -

>a.E.U€-Ee ' 'z -- = c - o . - € f ;7=E '- ; : AEE = . ! - ! x ' o = F

5 r:E; l+e q- Y

. e i j f b ' = F c> \ * = J ) ' =t - I : d f i n r a r d EI E 9 i€ : u -3 E S g c 9- ' - . = ' = 4 7 ' -

x E 9 EF - -o E =; H ! E ] b n ' ii j C 5 o ' O - - C O' = t r 2 = I D - o .F . ' ; F ;E3 .F t r- . = - ^= ; i 4 ; l0 9 3 0 : J _ . : ' g 1 9 c

-Y ' i r ' * a = '= = ' t )- - . - + -oo

Page 3: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

't-

Fi$ l iiF I FF F1ft iii i'i lgiig iii iggFiEiiiigi i rn$6;p1FF;;1iE;IgrF igfi rr* gE i*€ gFF+l$$=[Ef +[19i}[$fu ssiE FIFgI5 l;lgl* i5 s iF$'FEEFii$gigigllf36;gggg g3F1;f; a: i ilsiiel;s'e[eH s; r; i i F * F; Fi!f FEl siFf I$$EfiFf Fie;EgFFIiE;€ F # i 3

rFgi*[ri IilE- *sgi : gr€*iiFi; iigr;gl*c iissl*rlirgg+"ssrfaifFagll;gggaeiiiglgag=e sE = 1;

gFig$5*Ff ffiH iigEii ?t r;r F FaeH r;r3 $*.nB *re s-F@

3 Sg g

g 8

gli;!gF: 11+i e;. 3$ I aE ?ElE 1i= r; 1 '*EF$ **lFEaig i 1?llaiilaiat lail?tl il a?alE,? IlagatlEglEela 1??EElEElliEilg1liE lgll 1 aAlF'?Eg1EEiiEg;gE?EliiIiE:EI?AF1E 1EFIg Ib*A B?A

Page 4: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

?i1:ffiiii li!sEi;;gta;l s; l: * i ,i!isEi€!3iliii;g;3t ;t H g;iiEiE?Eg€3:#11;{i!:: i!Fs iss s;E:

i; e r; E! i;r *E'* i ig;i!1lita3E}iil€;ii*=*?iE;!s-:cEu$Ei

i!3,|!ff ii siil?i|ia;i : iE

lii:iiiiiE :;i iiiliiig!ii3il iiiii i islig ilig lag; i a;

E , J

s iO f i: :t >

v-)@

- r -. l !

** E +Ei E ez g

d

* : A q eF :8 b t rF E LE ;- t - c . i

dc! OOE (Jc E = C ) E

B9 9 E 3-g J ,E v E

* t / t r? C C ) u )

r = * ^A Sf " ;EEi 'egee g. - g€ , E

td a r - c .h

( i | tc* o) c l t

z E o . ? :; E $+d! : ' = 6 vt , - v : -

l v L

: v C ) o ' -t s o - E E

9 f i e -

E g FtFe +# €";: ; 5 + E o; J y 3 2 ' 7

E€E5i? 9 t 9 :- - . -3 ; 5 > \ 3

i - -

; g ' r a X Uc ; ( . ) Y i< . - *

. : ?\ ( . t r

* c )

: ( g. u3S 't)' -C !

0.) c.)

d . ) ' -

* ( )s., o

>. 'i(.) c0 i k

9 : -:! ;q) '4

3 Q6 J \ J

o \q)

9 . :v c

( * S

9 r c

= >- o -c l } . . :

r < <

ooIqr

q)q,

c)

. ' a E - dE re ! €e * rye 5^4EU€= Y E O 6

r - , d

v L L - -L

E ' - ; 6 3; e 6 k o; r € o . j ,- , .3 0 B b f; .? ; i iH= PgJ

& . 4 . 4 Vn ; ; r < 0 J €

T H +E 9. = - E L og 3 9 3 T= F F - 9= Y O J t s3 g € : 9

3E:E;C ) ( J ; 6 3

t s - E ( l ) I { . ). o Q 6 ' ; :E E E.E T9 O u )

! v € . - d

? ; = € i

a! E t I= 92 0 > , . :: = - ' i i b 0

J f , I

= ^ L

o - = 6 ' =A n d

* v

v

E Fo g a'3a n * = I dc - E ' = Ec

- i ^ t -

X = c X t rH t J

O U Y = c h

: Fi * : A iE : sF;; E g ! i F€ : :E * E;$g?E E i:giEiEH gii E{Eii EEii: F 3l;ii Ft;i;€E€ E :;sE;€ ; ;:E g€ r;i * :€ =ge i;;; ii s E r= € E:$H* f,q;;;s€; tilE€ ;Ei $:;s!t; i : € € rE ; *; s € : +€ ; € E i $t r : e**€ gFai ui *i**i! +; i:si;t;:iZA* e =i '=69"; ir E !: A'fr =EE;qit eEiEi::i;EiE;€i9g f !;itgiigEat;t;g:tli€ t:i; ;;:: * E;€ :BIE$.FEi€ i : ; g FP;€ zZeEs!r :;: $;t Fai s; aE € €,€ a! ?l ii i ! €; ;: I4:; r;* Ii:5g g;; r* g;:I:€;i= Exr€ E:*a*9Efi: tHgi-E:ti€E€E

I

x F

s@

Page 5: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

=' = '-"ri; ==!='iE ;gi ilii!tZ'---igi;i1ig g*3p;i;I V

> r + , - { 5 ( D : ;

a g rIE€ i

i E g 1 I g I l5;*1'Eaiii q i i E ; i E s 3?E* ry g I i I g E ; ; ' 11ais: ai; i:- {i1a+;i aEs;? ;igE3:eai11 i51gi3lla s s I E + lE $ $ a ;: iFllliE I I l1 1i;a3i1.

;Ftiit:grir i; ='Eai*iiiiEi gillEliEii Ii$!FF13 aEEEtiliillaEE1ligiiiEl i:llgi**iaii \€Eg3:FgleifArar ++ F E i;ris iESFlE13gEEliFFlIEgEgsEEii I i l'? I l*i ; ri E?;1 I lE 1 lIgEE IEilge

oo-J

3 Sg sD , ( l

€ i ;O r .

8e

FFiEEEglEiEllig ft $;l$E EaFEBtE rgil€ 1EillIlitg;Ei.-€ a ii-igii*Eiql lEll l1AE iI,iEEigI[Eggla agal aaia* 1{ [!!g }gfi-rl1! fgg 19IaE I aar i *Erise i6 le I 1 aFi ;: I I EE f ag tTtAiE ?Flg? lFii Illg: itla: I I alEEEs?:E 11 lg 1

r l*: I gig iqAlgg * u = *,

iii iE' li lilti ? liEE Ii ir liiiilFi iiiiElFEti

Page 6: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

@@

@

t|'lt

- =iE 3 il E ? E i3 =E ; iIgi *E 5tieIi IiiEF [g a;ge s iF FFE- ) r : # . ( D - F ' l

;Ii€ 1 I 19[EEi [F lgB$FFlE [3Eg lil ?EE1[ 1E+?EEl IF;11i iIgg3EIFg*H Ii; ;a Igi*aIiF H itE:$FElEFEEg[ *i rgF liF: I I 1 tiiit {{F*#t 1*: ig E ;egE[ 11E I F;rFEE.iil$EFE ;ffi ABIE tll[l?* s *ai $F + t*Ei E'.* -E s H i€ n Fe at =s 1;rl $E*g*+ett:'i *:iFFiF*e :I*iIa eH aa,rrBsi;ig[1ff $ilEggIi+Ei1$ti4aE?fiFlEFA a +tiiir;9;i,, un 3i +ss; iiE H 1*;la*iiliigtg is$g iaIEgigggggiiiiiiraIlill*t*l1g*glie IgEl5 g;E'; g.in?*Et; ;FE[:.i ag**Ec:raE'Bi ifigI =;eg

i ' : i =D ' t D

€ ; iC s

c;' A

r a qF $ r 1g;el: g lt lagiell*gg llg[3 l'g lEg *ElI I Iglrgfa'

ill lisgliiiillEsiEEiEii}lEiiis iigiiliiIia-1 i'IgIFIIiIIFia;gIlecltllEl* E1FEi€EEAii+1 At l

Elf aEiiiFaE;iigE iEEEilFiillii liEitlEili$Eg 1[31g!11i rlll eiF€i;Ei;*e s*F;'$ =-iisE* 3EFFIE'IiiF;1 lg*1il-?ES

Page 7: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

F * r * #; : r i sF a i i s a E $c, i 1 - i : A i ; if i 3 f i [ 1 [ $ff i $ $ i- .n ; ''ui;l' i-F*:iFil;1:*lEir**sFi *iiF;

I

; ' 5 < A O 3 ,

Fsti*ii

lg*F 1 $FfgEEiia i* i; :; F lFlg * r s r i€r iIEE*9 *F:,iE BE*arEg*iillliilil3ii;EFgElgillg[$fiiig1f EaFgi FiEgEis; s€ rgE ifi;:e iiFE l*isgllE []iF1[g Ig[[$iigg;3i[i*EF F -t€$11Fg1*s i11Ei1[[iF;1 FElEgIgEEfFiilii€ **lirlis'iliil$ti:s*lEg;tg$ilsg$ii$s iE;[E l+lEa[laEi *[1;lg$iiIii,sirr*$i*siFq: s s !s

7 <g gs ( !

€ i i

cz

gE A6 iiit i 1,Vac r ??*r= I 31[31 r ?t € qa sr * 3 r;+ i *c's

ilBE laEEi 1 Ig lli? IEilAa;:gigga liaai l al liigg1i1i 1i igii lE a ig tgi ilE il 1 I a I I i lgeitg rggggsaaHfagg- ss1igI7z!1 Il; tfFi sgiiii?iEal?EiIliElgEa1lggE I 1 lgEiiai il lilEatt ilaE:iEig lliE lE legigi; aE g ic ;? 3 i'eE ; i5 3 i 3i A€1 1 g =[ 7i71€[ggaEgEa;€ 1 FIalEii I 1a:1lFi11 lt?Eg 1le1Elg

Page 8: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

lg

(/J

if[g1fggEr€g gigg1iat Es1lf$:Il lexEFti=+ElEllfg!iEin a*Eiagigfi

'Fal; ia:T€EF+*giggIi e ; * E a s : 3 r * * * f g 3 *: u A t F FE 3 t 5 l 6g[ f ag s ; a ;

iE:EIEilEIIEEI*ggEEi iE.FigiEggEgElfliaEgE-;i=igaIg,egIfgfilg$:giit3;3Bllgg'--i[lgE 3rlE$i gE

EgiEagglgi 1a**$gitiEF IgggrIai;a*arl$Fi F

3 Sl ; =D t D

€ i ;a a -

, ; &

;Fgi $1g 11EEEF3g I rg igs iil EEEE I l;gl I i [ liE lgg: I liaE liE iliEEgiEiFE iii lE lg E FL+i Ii I * li iil3 i3 ; *ls=; ?: larn 5gi ig IFt i jtiil€i; $iF $r= F'

*' r*iE'*'*='ggigg1i q;1[1i|gg;lffil; lriiig ila irE -igag;ltggEii i i iill;E lq lgEli lligE1i 1g1$E IilrrE?iErgE *e glli1l;iFEfil Ersi€slE 1;tl =€e€'r:Ft*Es iFaigigEiBFEfEr ililF

Page 9: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

i

a iai ?n?iiullir1lEiiEEEE i*:rri= 'Eii*'iii'I iiiEE+*gziziEEiceEEEciiai*EEi*EElFEgEg[$iEiEEsli IEAiliFgilg-aITaiEggI gEiEigEEEEFE a?eag;sEiieglf i?iiE €s;fai:;f iE::s+tiFFaiaE;a[?FFlii: ii lagi* EsaiiF?ie EEffegaiEiEieiEfi:lEi3lEiie;iiE asagilEfF iiifeF$i*rri';I e r * tii; E ia F g iFE ? E€ i ieEE aaE iEE a aE aa i a iraii ii e s s e e a i i i i I{g1}5 g ? i i e? i ? ? ? E ? i g3 i g e A a i i a i ? ?*Hll l1r*laqt lltle11lil?Aal:ialEi aaiE ae?l ?* ? F g s i, r,; i :??i eEg? g iE? iiE gg?i? ? SaEEaiaiE;€ iUE i iE e:ii i a re ; iu: r sI s ; igaAg€ i[ E ?g E. EA€ig i;a i ; gi? iie I iE *eE +e iiE :E ? =' iagEEE ii ieFg F igiE

3 S9 g

€ i {

Page 10: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

aeiF ire*eila$!E11i1;fii$1l;iI*lggg1g31ggi3 E F s * F{

llilai $t1g9lgil: iiliiE{;i;;r i ? rii*$iFa,E i$?*F$EFiEIiE gBg g€ i iE[lF F 1gi IgiE E *' g H'-'+FE.gi'E{ a +* E ;EgIEe*!.gIi +1311[|gl:i z? +iAiillt ffie15 ' e d E .B i

FFfEFgtFEgglagEiBiEElg$EFiaFHE EfgIlgFgFgEi€. il$*E[e;es1{i[}issaiFr1|Fg3 l3p;16li;;$-t 1 ua lcr*lit r * i i* =E;*fgElgEEg liEgiig1l'*3.i ge F

$g gi[sg*[iEililgg i*Elg+ililEE tg lirg?a? rs

3 Sg g9 r t !

.Z i;

8 1

g; 1gg iF *€ r r aig$ rE F€EgE fi 1'Tiieifia fi I I ilE$ t

i 1l I [ 1la iggaEg 3i lil[qiE*i [iiEE I * s'*, isr; r Fa f I gEgF F I l;F lgi rFg fii 1 rgEEi [ Fg i i;El I flgtrsg;13 sn ' iiE€ : i f gE:iAir r s' E i; €.;; a i - : $+i$$+ e: E- x - d 3 == + ifs 1FEEiEFIEIEi lEi lgiii lEi F liEI1$iiFlgEE; A: sg

T!1; 1Fi g E{tEEiE :gg li f F-g 1 r i ! Fs; e ? *: E. * $ } E r e

-J

Page 11: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

&

tE ltFAl. $EgE igg ? li[ gg ra. is ; a le€E +E';i tg ffi 3 r i FgIEgl il ilEE IE AE 1 1 1 A*gigl?E lag lEiagEigii lEga i i $ I * l€ : I I f FlzEt 1g Etg* i i i lg';E 16 $ l$F *g 1E: i l 3 c P q ' -t -F-rFi iiiiE ?FtEiEq gl}lliaEffi llgiiEEBllggfr ilFl}s; ealE li!lg[E iEies+ i1$ggqESEEEE*aE gi iEg?EFiIl1liIiiEE EiEEiiiiE*lFliligElEE 1t ;a ;*iEsll3glsi*;* E[ElgiI;;l+: lEgl*aAg;1

3 S; + =

€ . t

u &

+ r 1 rea 1; ig ig |3,,l{g!l: 1 ll I l{iE +; iF lEl I [;[ f|f.llllg11igilli ati ifitl iEiiiaig;*lgii;s ?zif e f, 1 ; il i I e{ tv /,zliu 3: r = * : =Et=€ i r 1 i g g i i E, * * rEe*E:ggig1tller1fl{*,{|lg1*,iirsltEiiF:ll€

ir1*sFiiili?s :lEE i?71 iglalTil lsE;:gE'i,t, a r ?i iiiiili ? ?te;s +s I V++r ts r€*t'E lif EllEt€g;1ggiae:tIlfi lilgggiiFg1ig$g'l*-i aa*ffi airE ag =:ElgiliE 3ii1**F;i;11i+a asaa; l:l lg*

J= . = - * =

FF*fai

Page 12: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

FEg lg *g 1ggE I g i gEg;s gg*+tlFgti:a ;gg 3 iisgg 1Sron+; q {i+s[ [; ii*#g i Eri FiiElasal 1l€ :,=lg* ;gl{ eEeii r:sE gi lF$ 1l li [FFilgliEEFi Ei1l i lilFEB1lqi*let*t;+t1*gllE Etic llti iii ElFg€silgiias*r;i l3lgfgggg lg$1 s+e' *iil1gi ig I Elia, :E i*g*u€;;Es= *E H'F- =b ; p 113[iFiFfig €1[ui**isiEiiEilggsrtFir*glgli sEriapg'E*€ lilFiEE ilfFE1i+igg li $lEB' ile;i i$[i€E;Efif rI+glEi ii*;atlEEligg3116 reiaa rila:flg li1 a$rir,+'$ri i€ [isin,e *;,;3 ireq BF[gS aE iigaig lii lElEtalilf

? <5 =

€ ; ;( , e .

?z**1f ? =s E*s E is a= E=;sl #a;ii i = :su -u t sTs€r I i

e I a }; f 1? $EEglggiElgfii liEEiFi liEi lE lii +i}EgEi lii ii 1' I IEliEsiEi;FiiaiF:EE!iigI lii *i lEilE r*s t i 3 I i igaggias g I I li a;g 1leEg Fil I la l IF1 EIFEi lEE3gEBIlEiiE[EFigEagiilIEi[IlEllai *'' 1i igIgElEligillgEgFis*s;lr *l 11li +iE: ;1 E*: i;;E 3aa ra i#Fri+ulrEa*ia+ 1[{ia;Ai

Page 13: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

FJ'is s^721 ;1f I1'F?s= TEsieiB*f teiii:E:$€ 1l11liE3 llga lgiig iiL,l I I I I I g lE [ IgiEF 1i I ?'F ' rE rng 1

iEil IEiEBI Fl illE l$aiii I llE iiiiF I I lii l[ l 1Bgr = = l . a R illalFilE IfgEl1?E'Ei *r ++ss{i:g1g i qE sa r: iiiBg?iEl g: ?E ;E, *;, i +z!11ggi+l;taEs}Eg$g![;liE lli3A lli l1lii i I lEil Ig litEE lEErgEii lga Ia +E i ia ; * i s i :=;:+?- tc l+Bi f 13E l;g?g g ;tEg+ u3is

.,

3 S; =l | ; r i

,: .i

d 7

i l? El3tiiF;i lti Fal ffi il I $E1i +?EEgiFg lgl li 1 I[ r iEE s e * T E : i EFEE I A ig t*F I +$ 1g iF i i1 I [1 €ri; Ig 'qE I t+gili l {z+1g i'' i; i[E lilii ill [FEiIi? fg Ir* i l

EglFi iiig*:l?rE iE€sFli g ialiEsigi?+FaE iEEgi*g eFlit;A?E g*gilEi;ii lEs?*i[: ;€taa= :i

,tt

Page 14: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

,?t

Fl

s=sE e=F $ s F f aiigE.iqg[gi+FsefE€FliFf :ilatEEqi1giiFi1*1eT 1+= i:F r *: rg 3; i B ,,r r i F;;i$i i; 5 r 3esii a rti; 3*€ iei[:i igElglE*1F$Ea1r1Ei11i1ilEFs:: AEit - *gt '$ ila[1g e:gi:EE F;E3 F tilE 114 1E [[1 lilEE* s i3#€sE a : 3i;$i!.gIile [;i;:; ri{si a iF V;EtF;ss3:6-f : t I

-li l iisgll Ili*i r 3isll;Eg€ 1:I F IEFEFT igs '+F:f * r=*s rlrt; +€.; i i3: ;= *i;s *;E€ iEFEFg +E[$il iiiiiiIl ;;T: ri; Ei;r; e;e€ F* f {iti$EigiEFgE+:E1'Fsser [gt1$iEsliElEFg i[ *E+1 lil1ES3BBE EEg:[l;1$€.iE;E*ig* u's# s*r Eu; $}1[r13: is* +q:ini

(-rl

3 Sg s! 9 ( D

g 86 A

E3 li lEgE 11 ii. I 1 ig?g i ffiEFtEi ; l lgEli* ffiqi lF:E ;i i *sE:El t igA lF3i +glEg$i :F* E ; s ! +;*ilgllE $: ^ . p E 9 . I i3 :3 :F r +;ri;*xg 1pE;: Fgg ;iE eF: gtigsi3tiil*c3g iE Egg}iai1 lg l + [i€E i i i 'Ei fsF ] liiEFiE* i*iE f;r ; :a,a;*E $[Flag; ]iliiili : FEFFIgFE$]$l FEE InaagSi

i;i+gE?; -;F +=:li*iiisi€$3F il:a 3iE s:Eilu,E;I ? F iEa I 1E I iiEsi s t *g: g1 I11 [i li;gpiii f} lilE; ; =ii:ii $r+IiI1;Eg $g i$sr*ii i I I il i i i I I + ;' i + ;' I i Ia i ?; a l E : ;i ]i; i 3[ I l;,

Page 15: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

IZil lE 1 IgEil;Ei liii 1 i l;giilEEE 1 $i lFl iili $#'€ F F; i

*; igfFigaali ;FiErE Fatggi;i*iElg{.fEIFigiI $- 's*$rl i-:*lgifiil$gigiifigiIEgI[;g[1[f;gi *lrs i e sa$*eleci llgglfgt iglEigFFiEFEEal[;srFFi F aF i'3 3*-l*i ilaiEEElEE'* uiE,9Ei ?*3 =iFf I*1[Fgg-E e= *;s*$E Il[Eltrliqli,igg€*EFFfgg;$lsFElH o * = i ' .

F+ gEagi igiiliaiE a;ri;;Ef*s3 $rF:.EIfe?=+ *;e =l$airs=3EiF F *= ;i ;s=;[€ a;1[aIliEta3

-J

z <: i : -D ' t ?

d: id

? 1lg a + lg *sg: ii IEtiE lgig?Ea iglgi lg I lE 1 aiil gl*g[i iIliigiisl' iE l i si* s r- i 1a E i ; l iiE lii*a1

i E31E; il?c;;lE :li i*-il-l{6[!gIigilgl1;iF3 lglilllgllall i1g1lliiliili?iglll:lglF;a

Page 16: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

m

g iiiE IEi iEEgE IEIiIIiEi lE IEi? i 1 ii;iigi 1 AiEE IEE iiEEiEi lEEEE iE i gEe F 1 lEii lIiiIiEE?i IEE lEEEE i eig i e+ + IE r -i i i rE ii iag iE i ie i ii ii i i I $ [ iE 5;€s$*}i;5FiiEA Ei:irilt*ii;arEE iEirF$iii*;r;r

3 - . <= =D t o

€ i "

A r *

gliE+nEEii?iieg;F;r;iii *?;s $+i;eriili+EEE?ilggiilEiie?iEiEE,+ilEEaif;i;E$i?iif*ili F$ EFi iiFE =iii$*;iiiiatS€i$?iiAi;iiiFFi;Frgr=lsr-sIaaaaaiEieeiI}giiIigFiiEEEI-'i1,EE

Page 17: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

i$s i rE v:!a gl€l{ rEigf EEliIiSi*EE FF 5 rF if 13r€ElFiEiii iEFi liF i* ii iEii 1 i iE IiE lii ErE 1 lE iiZtElgEEi r ;E i 1 tgggg IrgSE i a ig g I I i i: agg E?IFg Ie*+I r *n€.eigc*g$I+}gg$Eiifli*l ii ii ++a;; Ilgc Ifllll 1$ ;i$[*iLi* ,1rl'*3 fsiisiH=;iFe;Ft ':+:arEiEr; lI.*1s rEs*iF1i rx:,,,*- ; u; a - i a +€ i- i* iii *lui lgiiF'igiE li I iEg Igl lE*€ tEsI 1g{ I ii *gg g 1g*r$€B*altIriggl*lfl *

3 Si ; =D 9 | l

€ i t

u ' d

: 1 agE riE; * lg IEila lge ffig l*? iaE la lail I lEttt IlEF: lglEiFi E tga11 l?HiEE iiE tn: F3 $rF+? iF3s?Er IE1' ilg*iii:nE' IsE lllaii'EAet 1ii3 ;-

iiEsgllE? FliliEqlE fl lEllaEaEffii EEllgEi EE7{,{IEggal rtd iil9li lllaryl?}lliEiiiEiE EE?I31,al E I a ?E?l!zaf-1 I a I g I i 7??r i E I i I i i .,sis;Fs a ?E r*=i!;e itE llEllElEEglEi[gllEl 1i= E I * - , = .r

r + a * + i J

Page 18: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

N)

lg1€ E li;lEgEEi$g[$EsEIEIit* i6;s$ragsrq ; ;rglsgiiIiggfEgsi;i=a; ;err lg;=at ails1[l*[ 1[I$ig.3 1i [gi3g3ig3ilge;lllar,! $Eiie;l1gga ' i=t * +E F jF$ s i,: i3s$s;qElgEgaFigigiFiiiaigEi 1[1gI g€E s e [ [€ ii?aEs++'a*;as'l*ii li; 1f Il€iE€ $lilEFlfEs Frt Ir[E lgtlgiEFFigiiEE liiE:FElall; rgiilig Egiiiri'ci}*EreIg1E1gs ii'iiIiFi1i-*Filf It E1ig: a : :F s$1;; a ilffa*u*e;=a;ieai; ssrgF[*i $a7iE'n **i ll lillgE f 1* iEg;iu€gi [a i IElg€ I lg; *E- J A +

= 5 a ' 5 i Z g r

3 S5 =a r l l

€ i dO r .

u a

l=1+;Ii :e E eFE : 5 i5 i = 3E g ii r li:EE +fi :;E E9 s ** *;iElelgrE?igl11l l*gE ;iEir rd;;g i lEF ; i s * I ; i s;l?EllgiF1EE*[ I g g FEEE I lElEilEE I 1 Fg?gl tE ilEEE H E ig! Igg ls igFgigllgiEg [E liaii lEgl lg [i** : ieg? 1;g igEgElg€El [1 ligFEiili I lE:Er;:E i 1: ?.igE ifti? I3 + r $sgqE ia: er E F aFl * FlEI lB? I I:iil [ ilEi lgiiiqFr-=:E iE$E;:igq ii ?;+a;;ar iia +ilnialt g=.;. =

1 [EiEEgE }EaEE} * 1FEE lF lii lE lgEl I 1 i F r*i ligli

Page 19: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

> E+ E eFi$al.c r; -a;llgil1gEga}g3*fig$iE}i= " -E '=? r jI g I E E€r

ffiiF;rlgElrllgFff lliailgltgs ilir$gl'Ei s€i1* 1:glgggllr;c r;criigi 1[ega $1ttaEg FH {iEEiliElii3ElllElilEEgFiliEEgi ig$ErE+3rs:igElt gEg rggFEls;lEgIgg;i+Eg *tIilgiiEFFl1'=iIi€FEiFlEBEliiliilEii[iEg ii$iiFgiiiEEe c*ga;3a[[gAeIg3;fi€ si3 igE$ EiB* n*a*s ;,*

(i

? <; i =! 9 t t

g EO a -

az

I lgg 1 lli IiE 1 i?iiiEiEgaEiiiiElE[iii 1 li Ililli??1iEll?l llEiEEiF?iiigiii?EEiliEiEIqi Iii?i1 'it=*F ilEiEEl?i?1lEi1l1lilau ?ea ?'r iiiiliii?3ii 1iEiEF Eit lrii=€;;r:e= iE'z* ;5E+i?airrii?i 3i;; i* i azr;ir: ;E 5g F:1 +i;i;" 7 &is$*E,li:El lEEilEE zlE iFl*aesa; i*t*? *i i?lE 1 [ i ; ii lE E rgtiiE€ ;ll1Fl I I lis iggE g afi i aE E

Page 20: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

q

- - 1E lf}l€aE;g+igr:rf iFEr€ sE*E€ F:=i *r4* A * d

n;*€6: si

* *}gEi lg lE ig }gFB; I lglg l: igl I lalagi* 1g I * [Eg 6ii: rx ?:F;ig aH;;E 3 if gre igiFsrge;;frr I g ?." e3 F F i + ; g 3€ i + igE Iq? : E iA q E B -dg ji :E i3: i=- s 3 L s= 9 - ' " g . P f i

r a: gF;€3e F rE s+r:a1= :.iiF;iitlFr i€rF F; t r- =g; n:F$F+segqgFEfi€r1ifB;' Eq3lfS€ElIiig *Fgi; a ts T iss $ i s ri$6E flggs;;i iF 3; fr 3 i tE ri iH iI : E r€ *H . E #**'gE+e$igfgllgggi:lg1gi$gi 1tFnF;s;;triEggagXEEiigAEfilg*FiFFiFl$Etg a =F€ +*g€c ;;ais;FE:Si'Fi*BscF F5? ;e[? s *ar; * g=Es a: ;: ifigrFFEEFig{g*EEEEFg1iE3igil[iE $ i:; +as *rterEEEEg3E; iiFriggiig$lig$EIi€E ig]( ' ) = a = g c j tH'E s-s i E iSfran;Cfia*ei'reEts5s6

!

3 S; : =D G

.: id

6 e

E $F'I iaE€ tEaH *'i Eg aE 6E rsxut ???iEE irfiE Hit fE l?ES iruar:ixEI i$i[16$FIii+if i3 : *E r6 +;s n Ii, r, s*?ei15iFi:i;i s; z=iA: i::; arasia r ;; ni* a, ri eiE I a i n Eg {iii 1liiiii lgigElgElE giii I**e?EEi;ilgllrl3i l€ iFi' t+5 1;E iiisi$ EH : g r: lEiE ;;lE;Eg:!'slgE[iEEEiiF 1g r 1r lEi * liEi Ii ig t F i fr ; ii i ic 3 e g i ; g; i i I 1 i : : ; =; l: t * i a ; e.? IE3EEg i i5' ! t + 3is€s ig1i 1i liE, i lF1F: it 3[* [F igE +a *llEIl' 1: ag5iis i ?: EaFe ii I ig +IiEgFgg IH gegigi: i raig € sr i ir ;a a; r;; r 1*: a ii4f l€ i i F4ir:FB€EigF+i;;qs*it itF+EgE;ieii:il: nF Fs r;aqT n iE:+E:t;+$B;E"3*r3;€ ii n=s *erF;x+;ii *

Page 21: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

@

t

-= !a'f p rr ? sE s i3EE gI; r1 ?C,i]g 1gi119fiE.t [$37 , S ' H = = s3 g J € x l . ;

?lsFtgrsis ii 'li:E i+;;iil= fi= i +qiIi; ?i 53riai n +$: IiatEgle 6i$]FEE lriFgE;1is gFEai;*r;ii: if f gi* cr :: aE[; ii'tigE ii1 ':Elui:€lesuigiae*:r re=:tt!1*g[FlftE riars3$ri:* *?sEEt-* iiiaaF;ltiF$e,iF ?EE-Es-u'is Ei??El ;} ir; lSgk€ir;$Fr;s F;nEEsiiLr

111[E:giIF1[iFEriieF:11igIa:1iEFiIfr i g $€ E: :FsEgEirl FIleggIl ssgE=g}f*IFE+lEi aFE $Fer$;2t;39 feFEi3gi [ifE 9+at&aasggEFgEgIEEf[3ii;lgiiEiFFi[tFgEiif,

3 Sg gt r G

€ i dU) ^r

, ; a

F: =;€ r?i fif 7?7?iliseS H itrgy+- I 1^H iB ; r;FiF:E

5gF ugq il li:3 I ligE IlEglEl; l IaFg iggg ilgie I *s;'i x=?gi 1i;lgf ig: re*: FuFire*'iigiaEg*1lgiE li FEiEg l IZiI I liiFl? 1 i E ig;FEFEFEEEg iEiai;t t;jE i i € ii lgg z!;iiza r llal l* isi}E 1g [ag1 i 1iggi igE3; rgiii'ElE91rlEIEEiEgEi1;EEEBFE fll[iEIlqEa 1 E;tl I lFF ?1=i I lgE [gAE ig lE:E 1' i 1 $ lEE iE a s

Page 22: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

t J= E 5 E E E E F + ? l: a iA f eE i f : : c g€ i I =E i 5[c. i [5 i9 9p gg*r 3 i i + i" . . Y 1E ii ;EE 1i =3iilI$E!fI i1$;lqpglgil?r|*?t . = - F . F l :

! aEAIF;;;E rRE F r iE iFF i; s rt i;${ iSE;$EE i5; r*irs A5i F3 riFFsl 7?:e€ sa +a a: $;;: e n i iilEEiifai;E iei5iii$E IiE IfFil i r*t 11*$r;r*aa;'l i*g i $*s€3 F[$ ? i[ga€iE lg[Eiii1Eif lgi IF[agI I l?g [i!ii lii [E 1 [giF *i lgi i liE lgiiEiEiiEigE: g i i i * a r r e *: = E 5 g = a ; g tg i fi ? i+*i$F;as*l*lsa *i s;iFE eis ??;3H '11g*iE3lEFElies*se; E r*+*13i t$gii=Eii$Eii1Li'.+;eir irg+;H;e *€;g;3i*=Fs ;iaAg*3g;eg8$FgArEF ec; E * HF

3 S5 =A : O

€ i d

6 a

€€FE€ Fgg= giEit' *aqg s3E =aEr*:g;g =Fi€I

TaSEFE

ll$FirEfiiE[iilr UEFEailiiFiiFlFiiEi aF*llEEgaaage l?tEgilge lg : g *gl lEg? lgaigEi IaE 1?gaq'slei{iHiriF3gqFFllgEgiEFiBElEiil[1i; s e F€ i3l fi qr;

e ggi*g*:t lagE- [;t i iiii **:,a,ia raEi ii; ;ere i?i giigggAltst [ {i; *s ?= riglgaiieiaIfgi11F*s i*i;?1[*tir $i1i $lIliiA+Er 1;: a;EiiastaSi13g+EF igigllil= *i'i4q ?+a'Fi*u i; r;srsFE;i raiai 1* * a;,rF1;€ Al;l e+$giFl19

Page 23: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

NJN)

11

.t

iFE; aiF g: igil ;gl'gll:gsalrf$gEigeEl*lglEffig s,F n,; $fEFErEsl $Eli11[F1[Fl 19' 1ligi?g[lEsiiAEiElE+Psg E IB€x = i: ; r€ 3r€sr€ 3; HiE*[ tgE1+ia*gg[igFIf lEsa*rrge:rF;€g $;;+E[=ifi;g9i€a1l iec ITF-'':'a3gE ielFiagE+:$lgiilEEE I ii ggE ?EEg l*EEilEi iEi lEiili$gEEgiEgiiE IF€ s; + a

g*gilEl aiiigligiglglgi liggigallggsaEailg*gg Tr;a Ii,e5iiEiEEFi;; $s a; +ss+*:lu; s [;*,

*: sc = sF iis r?si ii*eiqEEH?E t$l?9iEgEEEl[[EEgiIrEIEilEEEtE.1i1FE a'EEiEE'T[: IFsg gg iaEa ?E[1 a la igl1 1 11 li liEE lql?1li?l??AElEg lEig?e = i' I i7lElg?lli [lAlea ai, llaaFEE il*' ; } u € ir ie* =s;Til

1 1 i A: 1 li{:,',|i F? i? lE g i? EE FE 1 ilE 1 I?E E 11 1: gEE:r' s 'F;lgEigEe z?u i, iEEE1*g11ii *11{la*lgE lEEtaaiE lE ?lEi€lE[ffilgiEFFEFltg EEaFi ?llEB1

N)(,1

? <; i =D r ( t

€ ; dC r -

Page 24: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

N)5s [ *Ei i t; rg 1EEEEFE I if iiEEu i 3 f

, I iE I $ 41EEFgi

FgsiFilFiFEiE;EEFfEE igliiEFi gEfi lsgEiiEFp3iiEgIiEfg+i;eErsF s*ii€iil 1rfingErn ; $:'i +ff sEs,s:fiFEEl$cE $E ri€irf [5i iEIa3BfgFggiEigFgEEgEIEiEiiiEBEEEiEB FEEIEEgIFSaa ;:t3 F35ssii5i$EEFEisErrEi EEgE=E€iEEgi

t\.)(.rl

3 Sg gD I D

.: id( ^ .6 - d

3 r* * i i +e i '5* i:E [: IiF l iE*g i f gt i F i i lgeg egF r;i;g a; i ffi f+i a u ne * + ng iE iE i + i: {E iqi ls sEi$ aiaEEEES i;gr Ii; iiiglgFEi iEE lgF liiE; iEgEEB[e€iiqeiigf3i: i; iig€E' i;iifE[i{;i$€i€EE€E rii+,re-Fi n:;f;[f [E}[ i;i$iiiiiEiijliE:EiliE;EirliEEFE; *1i€BEi FF*E*iiaE3i:giaiEai

Page 25: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

N)

i i€ IEEg'gEa iE is ii $ iE iE ia i iE i 3E i I I igF iBi 1 i

Eiililg liliEg:;lilggggllgEEiliEligg iasgiiigggg iE;iEEi;cEg;gEi;lElII:gEEIla llgEEiFsiEE EiFffi$$EsFi$ltgEi$[?fl€Agi3ii cigs

t J-l

3 S; i =D i ( l

.: id

u a

i s$=igeE I g + + i ; s ia + l€ +ri *c[ *?E r i i iE *iiE i? l

EiliEEFlEii1iEiigiEEiiElEEEiF1lEEa iEigEtElEialiEEEi? gEEE?iliiiiiEFAErEEIA iiiElEIIEiEIaEEE?g Eig?aiilisitEElE*: iii aiilEa

Page 26: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

t\)ooil$ *gE gEl gFE,[itgri?iei iiFE u ss i =,'7F eilssegsgalltgIllgiglgEggrlElilEEaglgg liggiiigaE l5ii i+i3+:r;i;i5i5 +Ff,?r+siEjF3 sg +3 i:='+eai€ +ri; a: gif;gtfiE ielYI iSsi slrti ASgi€=' E

aEe T e Zi*Fq gg€.cqa +E f *ire Fasi 5E;€ F ;i,E;;E a =

[gFliiiigiilFEilgagai lgagFFiaial iEa iglg l^ H = = ' 7 ; - i

+g; *i:fr r*r;qr Ii * iu ?=sHF*;cusi€;i laI[aigiIlt rlsgiglatfei*gEggell+ggiEiBgg EgsiglEiF1[ teirlF*[gEi [EE11s* gH ii;i rEg r; FlrlieaF" - .=dE E +F f e E 3 X g 5 E^E q b 2 : t ' + f .e P E F€ - l X & = F A 3 ?=?-+FF +!EIlc;.il[iIE.BIf,iIeI*;i[]BEE[1 niIEF;ia

|.J

3 Ss gD . D

+ E< . D

,;' -d

erE *g 1s a i g: + i i i Ir 1; f g i i i F 5F $ ili e e r t: I 1i F 1 Iie € iF+aAi:i11Ets:ia;a-= il€ili$iFIiF$iBfgffi i*lEg$lilsf lEE1 I*li s*lEF3f [E*ggFiFl$giEi EiElii[g lgi€gF 11?F FF F iFE3 ig IEFIBEiFgFiga t iliisFEiElll!aitll;1lgillgalaiillffgi[; EFFg lt+F1ltq$liiFgiEl lEiiifE[1€[1gliBlE; illit gitF[11ilE1+;ii*EF+Fi,F-+*irEliirFi ;is*i€fl;'lEit *r= *i€ i a{1€ iE1ftgil$E ifs

Page 27: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

(,

Et

ra= +=aiEf ;€ei=a-: H*[[sli1lfr1[ig: a|[s[!f +1t?=iry?;! *E'.3[fri:E *ga$*+;u,6: gE E =FE iyz;r**,i I i lciE i'ixi;.l;.gigi1[fg.i=E 1E ?F*u$?$* [*strE rE iBESrEFg lE[iiF iii€igiliEiiigilg illi€; +aEjqI iEileEgfigEigltglSei**la11ru;e ?rr ;,,,) - . F . j

- v !

9 7 ; ' 3 F ;gg igl+glgliiEiliiil;l1l[g[gliegE:ii Ilgiil iE fagaigii ag*lfgal:ig1Eg1ggr+eIlt i$1*;i e;i;l;gEalrEfi ei111rgr*1€ $FggliiFI IiEl

? <; : =l D t !

€ i d

lE= : r s: iti: a-1g11ii*-s i3t5g19;gfi ;96ggg;l13A Si =€ '

st t S rE F F i + ; f iEri i I aigii 1: ryEigg lEil iE€li ig iEigEE; lli 1g- ' 7 . + S _ T 3 '

agiSit *1:: a$a: ss*; : iSTt=i=i u; fi ug;+;i!? - -=lE1sE.E i;iell'=;u = - =r*1i+: lit le;g9llieg illa+tggitE i1l€ [F*ggdii liil[Esss i er qsl*E aa 1iig[i$iEal sii $FF ig i;llFl1a iE fif I aglllieFiEia 3 F* += 'aiE!Fr r€$ 6 =fi r1.Eani: A.?E +3€€[1gEi3:ix H A t * V( v J5:H F3 3 ?FFF9; a a+lgi*,i,EFi+F EE iI=Er = u*i=c'iiiFli F ii ;+i i€; i a ; E F i r:A *i itf; i 1; +iii=1=:3r;i3[S*3aI g; a;E *i"aistiss=::;33f ;31-r i u -''i-:t li- Ea 1*gf*llgl;l*;uuitglilt *i

Page 28: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

t .J

giiglilaaEEEiIiEEEEgiEEEiiIgIEIg lEiElEiii }Eggi€5iiigEiElElililEE$ laii IeEeg9*IEE;EESFi'$;[?*uii Ery eiiaEiiElEEi'EiEilF?BiiEglEiiigiiliF l€ =i*,,*i**E Ei$E *;E i i*r: i $r?,aEarcq+g g egE;Fi$+EgEf e;i1a;BFE{ i:gE;irt€FigEErsg$

(,(,

? <; i =1 9 t l

€ i ;

u - d

iFEE[;igii *i = HEsE;i ' I u-ll? lli lggglggggl rg; la a r aaeg 1 l;|;*g I igigi3 i1g F: E rerei i liae1ii}$ lg1 g*gi +; : s n 3e as *=lBgitE[iff lt€X F ' + 3 = c

i;EEgdrilgff FFEiggiiiIIggEEliF FIlEl*EgiE F

Page 29: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

5

li 1: F lg E 3 i i g lFg, i i ftF liii g ii ii I5 X c D 3 - i = " '

L

lEig}3,ariF s ?i.Ef ;gp;:": iez Igi+iFFa:riaryFgggl llg Egr*iiir€s3igi Ii g lFE ;+EF lE11i'E. 3c e 3 + i; irlFgg$3lEa3€Sf:aIir$i ?F +riEF1[A?ieEi]IiE 1gil$FigiIA[EEgR 5 i a 9 . = ' l

IggiagiEggFlfgi;;Eiig g1 [g'}gig;gglig iil Ef$i+FiilElE;ea$u,ii$* FilE' ***€*tI'i* 5gl $

3 Sg gI r ( D

€ i {

d ' d

i E ; a i eatgAt gli slgElg $lillgglg [i IEr iglEA5tEu3- i- s 1 ili lisc x li fi +i li$ I * 1 li * ilii iEig lE[ 1*r;a i: ii;lllriE€1i*:rr;++i11[1ilFl;g ?[ *B:i1FF:;,FlFsi += ;r*gggi?iul 3i;l I=lEg ;lFI€tElit€Eaiglli[:€ lB3lifiiF FFiu ' ?iiE ieFFEE Fi:isfl*Egglsi iE*giFlt; EE*iElll€ *;3*lFg iaeu iEiFEIE1EEqEIiElil; IEEl:?lg* Ei +--5'*FEii1 - - n r * ' <F+ev*i; iiE *.iiIri; iiiEaa;3l ;i!g[E lEa=rig-El1*' s:Fiifi'E$.' iiEliF*'e 1glElE1;'fg*

Page 30: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

rlt

F

[[[]i1[[5{g+ff 1$ n ri;+sFe ea ii ii1s Fg g1';.[1ii;: +*+E *c*: ri;a;i*i .g;*i:*Fiii;s a€ 5. p E 5:2 ?$+*sieir6iIg[5f 6;e; = *a[[iiEe€ iEt=;iiraEfi usa i

ig $ li i-a i t i :E;ifg tEliE1 lEgag.gllegFi0 0 5 ' 5 } { r : . ;= ) a ( D g e A c

: 1 J D + d w + !

llFIEi tiglgif3gEi iii EEEEE rilEBgEElilllEil! l 5 F . H c n (rgaE = 3 ; ;sr;* a?3rg i ts r€ii 5Ai€;iFEqftr;E' rsrig[r;; 1[qqFiFEiAI i; s rssa: ,72,,8-i'[?'$iIii;giiggEgrgigEg* i1 FE!gIgrEIllIrFgigFggFglr*EFSEF[FBEE$iII*F l$i[siiltlggEfil:ii fIiFg$s ;;e;F$aa9i+*;eF s +i;6 ieF eE$ $r as;5f*a[*tEF

(,{

3 - . <x =D | !

g B, ; a

t i IEAgg se lFEE l }9[ a f$1F 1gI iii f;ig 1 i;g f E.E + 1Eig Fs FIFiiESEiEEg I [illE;Egl l;ag IEEI 3gEglii:E Lz Pi

e I ii i[*''i I riag6iig 1glil{g3 I lggg';i*gi1ii Iiggg gii ggai rglar lgl llgliiiggigll: g *g + i; 1{ a31 Eii iT:;€$rgiFlili }lFilE?gFsiliFliEliE *1i'if l1i;FilgFFFirilEFFiFsiil:gr1iiia.iEliFg it ; **;E 13r1:ii[Ei1;3 li:;gF;FI iiggigF

Page 31: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

(,oo+ r: $ * g * t 3 3 ?: E iI3 I [.1 g* f F gf ?; i 3 e d i a r e i q 1i + +A$1${lill liEElrF Fi1r$fE *iElE.il:lF$lF;[1iilittllE liiEri${i f$$fl[$i3fligiEilii- q: iqr i;risEs itlFE1g;li lFirF r ;,{F3lFiilalifi3igil

I 1:Z+l:,i*;Eail 1i93,$g 1[Ei i# 3 i;e *;egre*rs: iii ltEi'i:-=i +? a 1; [i i tfg+Ffii ias;rr;e;r aia it {zi:=\',{Ez ; l e ti I I +g if gi6;;59 i 3 Fg iigry=i iE =i,EF: i=Eil i $i $ta lIp$[ iF:9fi e al; =***x€ aiEs$.!E+E;€F r;ie;i i*u E 4us3,i ;Ilgf +i1q*Xfl3;$a.u$isg ;€: 3,?t?+rri,z.iF I i i *e aqi'lla ; l ffiirr€E1 i;a: H s+E iiIgi'er' ; s;i$E *$i;iltr;51**E5r; i3+ M

* - l t L

? <: =s l !

€ ; t

, ; ' d

s.^8 g- . ig E:_f€ 33E E *=8 rra ^a rFig = 3 a R 3 Y: EF* $E= :"; r -. s = * t 1 5 33 lgE 3 g;1 gr ? sE;* ?g gg$lgi a 3cs a a'srF rr$ $ti ' *.*u i i iii Illilili1* ii{Fi IgEEFt fflEiEI IEliFEgEiiiE:iiiiEFiI EiiFgii ii;igEIElEFiFg.: i lgii lEEig:l iii li iEiii 1 iiFEF ag$ilgFifE i: iFi$1[lEEFligiii s: 1i FglE€EFg;iiilEssi qi gligigiiE13iiiig iiiiEEiiiiiiEiigiaE5 . ' l a :BB B-e- r

Page 32: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

E ni$= 1? :5; F =1gF€iEifli l5lrE;c?;i}[ElFlgFrAEFIE : ;S 8 ; ' ; a 3 i

lliEF$tElEF EEFiigFi *giliiiaiEilE$ii i+ElaiFiIEgiEEgEi iiEEigE lFgFi lllgiiF igilHEggE lEtsel*l*ea ra e++ieqeg13gl;6EE 1g*;*g**;.*1$i1;E i: Fsi+igF cEii; a[IFE 3 qE re?riira FiE*5*s 3 $E*ri'aiEgEg Erliigplgiiligglligiigs;iEi €E IIE E.EilEBEr E1ilIf,iF* i 3 F E r iBEgiiiBgRgl:.gEFF

3 Ss gA ' | D

€ i t

c;' 'd

i: i+? EisiEE=39++[giiisrE r?gg1gif ;[$iq€gr +ie =?: * s j

1 i; *g [E *;gEgu l;i I I i [1 lpi?iEEg?i I ge lg tlgIFgIFlFl1FFlFlE trglr:Filis ;7r;iaFg iFE;rilgEl: d J i t c D 'E $E *ill;gE gggiIiE[lEE:ligiEEEiEEiIiEiigBE $EE;b Fu*= * ;alE::EiliEir ; g 3: isE+i Ea i$e;alEillilpElEg €ErsE': lil ?t{gilliE, a s-*IEIgriEF1*EF FElEllgiElli;:lig*a rggglslplsa*i r+]ls:pfi g3;i;;gag f3lFligii i?c; iFa*{i*e; ar€it€EE *E'llri?iI Etl'glE;3 ;*i*fl'E=3

s

Page 33: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

]:I J1lll + i i I I g ?l,F€ gg igg i r rgFi *gi la I lg f q $ ?EilEigi?i1€Fgig li ; +€ E I I a ;F i r# a I 3 i r i isi Fis I 1E r F€

A 3 : B , a

aiFi g* 1ig1g fi- 1 3- l 11i'IF1EE ii it? rE-E I i; 11 iE - i ; € = a .

1; llil;lg;1llliliiigg ilaailggggllliEilliliqiil,a1g1lallglIi1lE9 13 fErEl*;:Fglrplleg;r * I H s-€

5',

z <5 Y -P G

a86 ' d

i?g11F;Et;,:, ii- *u *i ?1{Eilil''E:E 3l'E?Fli

Eg * i?iai 7?=E:gE iE $;l s 3: t€ $ ra i i;;* :E5;"

1EEEgilEa ?'sii lii[lt1 lEilglllEilliEE;13 i?1E H eEEeriEEF rIliElail [i?lE1laE1lgEtrl:liE1

Page 34: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

5A

€gas lEq llgElgi1Elg lg I [1 ai I I lglpg lggg li *lrgt;: i r i ? ;, ia e;i; i;$E *,en|r T;t iF ai iq iL2ar r a irg; f *lFetEilsA f illu*F s il = s a*$ 's 3l *E fF€€, lill5*$[f $E;?;f, Hil ii;aF'F s: ix 3 - r ' b *E 1€ sF: i +s sg:g.c H E $ I l':E€F 1g ll I 11IFf iiEilFfEl.EgEFE 1€iEIE$FEi.El Ii1[?l$iEggig[g[gaEggeIg *1a3 q g vs i

11i! $p[$i1fi;gg3ggIgF ri { ilF; e a=r +;rr;; a u i nggigig1gggg IgrEEEgEg iEi liili lEiEill*gil a$

5

3 - . <g gID ID

* z. j z , D9 . ra Q -

+ 1 1; I lEB [E lgii?i?3i?g; I I I?E;l *gi $i I ii iBi 1g1 fa?iEs $E IESEE 1s lEE I lEg lg lEi lF IEEEi IiEEF[E;gsgg I l lI ataiiig l lgi*Eiiig: illgiigiialiEigEE 1 }EEl il?tIi FElig??g

IiEiEiEi Il}E 1?E;F lgi?=- *a?, t ,

6fgl*EgigiiiEa ;igEs€l g illiE [F*E.: aE;i; iiisEqs =F' Fgia;ic= ?s?*s*F f3: ilIgeFg+gF?B $E ;giF- ' - ' - e = =

re i la?€

Page 35: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

F; H? sa+aas€ a?oir;aa.tiSlf FIEE *iF5ll13$Eifi lI

gE*+ 3Eg*s: Ei *3Esl$F.;iialg}Eiegi3ileir*= F :

igig EagiEli IgiilF igEi ii IE [iiEiEEiiiiiliBgli}i ?iElglg?gfiIgggAEiBEliliiliE EFgiIEg ilfiFf i*;eaF;FE* ii ;;;$$lFl*enri'i 9u1=i*; 's

+ e ?EE = ili Eaggta9q ll** * ueeq*I?al qIEEl*gglli5 ( D 2 4 O :

;tz\E Ei

*ti A l ? a ? 1 l t lE 1 i i ? r 1 l E? E s a E g I i a 1 ? a a q a g l I i lE+rsa? r= ;qEeisFrr t$i Fia; ie?*gAer3E *€ ;g;rislE 11 Fl1 iEElililAa:1il?g lliilEllii li?gfilEa{*LT'a?E ii I 1 e F lF 1 1 lE 1 I I liE ? lzgE 1 I? i Ei;?r?E 17El i 1 ? r17' TTTE i i i i + a E € r 1E'2=!; a i E i a r t lET*EE z:l tgalF il lilAliq[E? 1? i:IAE?E ?F;g;

5-J

z <) + =

+ ^( Z | r

0 a

Page 36: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

s@

11

r€ x Fi *5s:c isi i9gEEi,E 3 13 } [ [g SiiE iil!g11[Fi: ; aF $ +:* i i *ga *: a t + isggr [l l iiag;igiEgag li *. .

P V Y

g- , = E.E 8 . l

; i: ;sttitil*i iE1 I3$€ :EE i r; a: =; F *$iB *€E,:$iEiEFc lE: 1: E - E E gii i; ?; e E1F lFgFa lg lE.) v J -

3 - T 6 F ' 6

F3i;r; IiigFg;+ii,;;r Elrs i IEiEgFE stFiFiFilffi'iEE.tiilgiliE i r rlF s iFI 1E;EEiFBESE[g rEgEer:'':6 H .: n

ilggEE$ii iBlEgillg[; tl';iISiEF;EiEaEE ix i €E*€Ii*'E*i; ii*f l,Eil 11giE;Ef gIili's:Ern 3Ei[Ealr 'iSral*iigEal illg1iEgipiiglggg*+ar

? <; : =g 3

a 3 ? HE =t f a;gF gi:EglESg€ igei* a =ie *F€ E + i r ?f 77i q igg ?i: r q aE ii B ?s iac *Ei e *; la a iE i1i!16lli! fE i[!$[g il13lE11 i s FBi ; ' * ig eA I l31lSsiegi 3g lalig I lggEgls is1llt la l? I1;[i I ie a le 1 ffi 1i3i1ig a a 1g;1gg6'1 1*113ilE, = i * ,'i llg* i*llFir?:Egi gA: iac eE ? : +rgigilit;i lgliEisElii la'iiiaail lIE*+ $El: a {Ef illg.iEEEi?lEEsllaeii tz?;ll EFEiig +*u = * i; i *E:E ;5 a tl+iA=ig?E ?€EE s=pce Eg sFg g F i3 eH ais r;EE ;:isi*lg?1?li'gi€*i'g9 ?'g€f* 1si1116 6 ' = 6 T i Z

Page 37: Derrida - Violence and Metaphysics - An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas

' is aaiEiiE'usiEiE';Eli*Ea'?Ellcl*1EEE$lEiail1 iE1EEiEiEEEFiE*;iEE:iE::i€qg'sFi eas;EEggin

.liEeigii€ii1i€ fEEEiEg iig;BiaE5itEiEg

egiuE 'i*uiiEE*Eli;ligl*FillEiEFE''E*i'iEsErEu* aclilsri i€$FsF*asi:Eii5FEgsE;IEEEiEi

? <; i =D t !

d ; ;

t ; =

EgEiEEEeEI?EEEaE iE IEEiElgiEiE g1EElEiEgliiIeeEEi i 1 I'EaeeaElglllg? l[|EE lg[ ?!!{?li{i{E1{g"z+?{t!;

a i i i E t 111f ! ! !{ I * i i +ai Fi E:e * i F {Estlzia+igigiaEElitt{E*E;ai;rr'1,1u='tiE!t3i**'i