department of computing and technology school of science and technology a.a.s. in computer aided...

Department of Computing and Technology

School of Science and Technology

A.A.S. in Computer Aided Design Drafting (CADD)

CIP Code 480105

1Program Quality Improvement Report

2009-2010

Program Actions Since Last Assessment Presentation

• Create a baseline of clearly defined program outcomes based on Bloom’s Taxonomy to better establish student learning objectives.

• For each of the expanded and focused program outcomes, a careful analysis has been performed and we are implementing a plan to measure effectiveness of student learning for each outcome which will be utilized in future assessments so that trend data may be obtained.

• Continue to utilize the Industrial Advisory Council membership and include their input in the assessment process.

Program Quality Improvement Report 2009-2010 2

Program Actions Since Last Assessment Presentation (Continued)

• For faculty assessment of student capstone portfolios, a rubric has been developed for direct measurement.

• It is also planned to utilize opinionaires from industry professionals as an indirect measurement of student capstone portfolios.

• Sponsor and promote various activities of the CADD Club to promote positive student retention. CADD Club activities will be assessed with indirect measurements of student learning outcomes.


Student-Learning or Service Outcomes

General Student Learning Outcomes

• PO-1: Students will have an understanding of Computer Aided Drafting Design (CADD) techniques and practices by using various CAD software tools.

• PO-2: Students will be capable of solving basic mathematical and design problems in the capacity of technical supervisors for a design drafting industry.

• PO-3: Students must possess the ability to communicate effectively using oral, written, and multimedia techniques.

4Program Quality Improvement Report 2009-2010

Student-Learning or Service Outcomes(Continued)

Specific Student Learning Outcomes• LO-1: Students will be able to solve 2D and 3D drafting problems involving

points, lines, planes and contoured surfaces in addition to producing these solutions based on industrial standards.

• LO-2 - Students will demonstrate their capability to design manufacturing tools such as jigs and fixtures and produce these drawings by examining parametric design procedures related to data structures and Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM).

• LO-3: Students will solve applied mathematical problems related to Surveying, Statics, Materials and Strength, Motion analysis, and basic electricity.


Alignment of Outcomes

The A.A.S in CAD program, as well as all programs in the CaT Dept., support the University Mission in the Cameron University Plan 2013 as stated below…

“Cameron University provides a diverse and dynamic student body access to quality educational opportunities; foster a student-centered academic environment that combines innovative classroom teaching with experiential learning; prepare students for professional success, responsible citizenship, life-long learning, and meaningful contributions to a rapidly changing world; and is a driven force in the cultural life and economic development of the region.”


Alignment of Outcomes

• Outcomes PO-1, PO-2, PO-3, LO-1, LO-2, LO-3 experiential learning• Outcomes PO-1 PO-2, PO-3, LO-1, LO-2, LO-3 professional success • Outcome PO-1, PO-2, PO-3, LO-2, LO-3 meaningful contributions to a

rapidly changing world


Measures of Learning and Service Outcomes

• Sample project drawings, class assignments and laboratory exams will be evaluated by faculty for quality and proper usage of industrial standards. This also includes pretest-posttest assessment.

• A sample of these assignments/project drawings/exams will be maintained in a portfolio for evaluation (on a rubric scale based on the program objectives) by the advisory council members.

• The prototype of a manufacturing tool will be checked for feasibility in production using CAM procedures. This assessment will be in a form of a random sampling of course projects.


Student-learning or service outcome and measurements

PROGRAM OUTCOME

CURRICULUM AREA OR TARGET AUDIENCE

MEASUREMENTS OF STUDENT LEARNING OR SERVICE OUTCOME

Measurements

Methods used to determine validity of measurement instruments

Methods used to determine reliability of measurements

Schedule for measurements

Students will be able to solve 2D and 3D drafting problems involving points, lines, planes and contoured surfaces in addition to producing these solutions based on industrial standards.

Example:CAD 1013, CAD 1023, CAD 1073, CAD 2603, CAD 2123

Locally developed test (direct)

Norm-referenced scores

A rubric will be applied to these samples and graded for the following: CAD 1013, CAD 1073, CAD 1023

Once a year during the Advisory Council Meeting

Annually , Fall Semester


Display of assessment dataA locally developed test was administered in a posttest format for students in CAD1013: Computer Aided Drafting. 70 questions were given on the final exam, and out of those questions were underlying Student Outcomes concerning the Programs Objectives for the AAS Computer Aided Design and Drafting Degree. The test was administered in Fall 2009 semester, the results for which are as shown below.


CAD 1013 : Computer Aided Drafting : Fall 2009

(9 students took Final Exam)

Question Number

Number Correct Final Exam Percent

2

9

9/9

100%

5 9 9/9 100% 6 9 9/9 100% 7 9 9/9 100% 8 9

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 20 28 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 66 67 68 69 70

8 8 9 9 9 8 8 8 7 8 7 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9

8/9 8/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 8/9 8/9 8/9 7/9 8/9 7/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9 9/9

89% 89% 100% 100% 100% 89% 89% 89% 78% 89% 78% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Analysis of assessment data


The questions for this assessment came from the outcomes that are associated with ADDA accreditation in the area of Introduction to CAD. It appears from the results of this exam that students fared well and:

• All of the students are close to mastering CAD software with enough skill to be known as a novice Draftsman

• There were 2 areas at which students placed lower than 80% • There were 6 areas at which students placed only 80%.

Action Items for this Assessment1. More emphasis on the items mentioned above will be made in CAD

1013 Introduction to CAD2. An additional assignment or project will be made in class to reinforce

the weak areas.



PROGRAM OUTCOME



Measurements




Students will demonstrate their capability to design manufacturing tools such as jigs and fixtures and produce these drawings by examining parametric design procedures related to data structures and Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM).

Example:EDT 2053, EDT 2173

The prototype of a manufacturing tool will be checked for feasibility in production using CAM procedures.

Random Sampling A rubric will be applied to these samples and graded for the following: EDT 2053, EDT 2173



Display of assessment data


EDT 2053 : Manufacturing Processes : Fall 2009

(5 students took Final Exam)

Question Number

Number Correct Final Exam Percent

2

5

5/5

100%

4 5 5/5 100% 5 5 5/5 100% 7 4 4/5 75% 8 9

10 11 12 13 14 15 17 20 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 68 69

4 4 5 5 4 4 2 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 5 5 4 5

4/5 4/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 4/5 2/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 5/5

75% 75% 100% 100% 75% 75% 50% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 75% 100% 100% 75% 100%

A locally developed test was administered in a posttest format for students in EDT 2053: Manufacturing Processes. 80 questions were given on the final exam, and out of those questions were underlying Student Outcomes concerning the Programs Objectives for the AAS Computer Aided Design and Drafting Degree. The test was administered in Fall 2009 semester, the results for which are as shown below.



The questions for this assessment came from the outcomes that are associated with ADDA accreditation in the area of manufacturing. It appears from the results of this exam that students fared well and:

• 80% of the students are close to mastering Manufacturing CAD/CAM software with enough skill to be employed at an entry level job as a Draftsman in Industry

• There were 7 areas at which students placed lower than 80% • There was 1 area at which students placed only 50%.

Action Items for this Assessment1. More emphasis on the items mentioned above will be made in EDT

2053 Manufacturing Processes.2. An additional assignment or project will be made in class to reinforce

the week areas.



PROGRAM OUTCOME



Measurements




Students will solve applied mathematical problems related to Surveying, Statics, Materials and Strength, Motion analysis, and basic electricity.

CAD 1023, CAD 2603, EDT 2103

Locally developed exit exam (capstone) will consist of a separte section in mathematical problem solving.

A topic in analytical solution to a problem will be included during the question answer session of the Advisory Council mock interviews.

Questions chosen by individual members of faculty and Advisory Council Members

A rubric will be applied to these samples and graded for the following: CAD 2603, EDT 2103



Display of assessment data


CAD 1023 : Descriptive Geometry : Fall 2009 : 10 students

Question Number

Number Correct

Final Exam

Percent

1

9

9/10

90%

2 10 10/10 100% 3 10 10/10 100% 4 9 9/10 90% 5 9 9/10 100% 6 10 10/10 100% 7 10 10/10 100% 8 10 10/10 100% 9 7 7/10 70% 10 12 15 26 27 28 31 32 47

9 9 7

10 8

10 7 8 9

9/10 9/10 7/10

10/10 8/10

10/10 7/10 8/10 9/10

90% 90% 70%

100% 80%

100% 70% 80% 90%

A locally developed test was administered in a posttest format for students in CAD 1023: Descriptive Geometry. 50 questions and a final drawing were given on the final exam, and out of those questions were underlying Student Outcomes concerning the Programs Objectives for the AAS Computer Aided Design and Drafting Degree. The test was administered in Fall 2009 semester, the results for which are as shown below.



The questions for this assessment came from the outcomes that are associated with ADDA accreditation in the area of descriptive geometry. It appears from the results of this exam that students fared well and:

• 80% of the students are close to mastering CAD software with enough skill to be employed at an entry level job as a Draftsman in Industry

• There were 3 areas at which students placed lower than 80% • There were 2 areas at which students placed only 80%.

Action Items for this Assessment1. More emphasis on the items mentioned above will be made in CAD

1023 Descriptive Geometry.2. An additional assignment or project will be made in class to reinforce

the week areas.

Action plan for Student-Learning or Service Outcomes

• Work toward obtaining ADDA accreditation for the A.A.S. in Computer Aided Design Drafting Degree program.

• Continue to sponsor and promote various activities of the CADD Club to promote positive student retention. CADD Club activities will be assessed with indirect measurements of student learning outcomes.

• Continue to utilize the Industrial Advisory Council membership and include their input in the assessment process.

Program Quality Improvement Report2009-2010 18

QUESTIONS??


department of computing and technology school of science and technology a.a.s. in computer aided...

Documents