dementia improving hospital environments -...

55
Improving hospital environments for people with dementia: Listening event report Yates-Bolton, NJ, Yates, KA, Williamson, T, Newton, RA and Codinhoto, R Title Improving hospital environments for people with dementia: Listening event report Authors Yates-Bolton, NJ, Yates, KA, Williamson, T, Newton, RA and Codinhoto, R Type Monograph URL This version is available at: http://usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/ Published Date 2012 USIR is a digital collection of the research output of the University of Salford. Where copyright permits, full text material held in the repository is made freely available online and can be read, downloaded and copied for non-commercial private study or research purposes. Please check the manuscript for any further copyright restrictions. For more information, including our policy and submission procedure, please contact the Repository Team at: [email protected] .

Upload: truongcong

Post on 10-Sep-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

Improving hospital environments for people with dementia: Listening event 

reportYates­Bolton, NJ, Yates, KA, Williamson, T, Newton, RA and Codinhoto, R

Title Improving hospital environments for people with dementia: Listening event report

Authors Yates­Bolton, NJ, Yates, KA, Williamson, T, Newton, RA and Codinhoto, R

Type Monograph

URL This version is available at: http://usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/

Published Date 2012

USIR is a digital collection of the research output of the University of Salford. Where copyright permits, full text material held in the repository is made freely available online and can be read, downloaded and copied for non­commercial private study or research purposes. Please check the manuscript for any further copyright restrictions.

For more information, including our policy and submission procedure, pleasecontact the Repository Team at: [email protected].

Page 2: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening Event ReportNatalie Yates-BoltonKathryn YatesTracey WilliamsonRita NewtonRicardo Codinhoto

www.salford.ac.uk

Page 3: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!"#$%&'()*+%,#'-./*0(&'$%("1(-,*2%$*

31%#/1*4'-5*61"1(-'.*

#$%&'($()"'*'(&"+',-+&"

."/',&'01'+"2342"."

"

7.-./'1*8.-1,*9%/-%(5"#'6&7+'+"$("87+%$()5"/69--:"-;"87+%$()5"<$=>$;'+?"@(="/-6$@:"A-+B5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="."8EF@&'%.G-:&-(H%@:;-+=E@6E7B"

:.-5$;(*8.-1,5"I'%'@+69"J'::->5"K'@:&9"@(="L@+'"M(;+@%&+76&7+'"I'%'@+69"@(="M((-*@&$-("L'(&+'"NK@LMIMLO5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="."PEQEF@&'%H%@:;-+=E@6E7B"

<$.=1;*>'//'.",%(5"I'%'@+69"J'::->5"D%'+"M(*-:*'0'(&RS71:$6"T()@)'0'(&"$("I'%'@+695"/69--:"-;"87+%$()5"<$=>$;'+?"@(="/-6$@:"A-+B5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+=".CEA$::$@0%-(H%@:;-+=E@6E7B"

?'-.*714-%(5"<'01'+"-;"/DIJQLT"M(6:7%$*'"U'%$)("I'%'@+69"L'(&+'5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="."IE8'>&-(H%@:;-+=E@6E7B"

?'=.$@%*A%@'(5%-%5"U$+'6&-+"-;"G/6"NK-(%O"Q+69$&'6&7+@:"U'%$)("@(="C'69(-:-)?5"/69--:"-;"&9'"G7$:&"T(*$+-(0'(&5"K@LMIML"M(*'%&$)@&-+5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="."IEL-=$(9-&-H%@:;-+=E@6E7B"

"

"

C9$%"+',-+&"6@("1'"+';'+'(6'="@%"F@&'%.G-:&-(5"8V"F@&'%5"PV"A$::$@0%-(5"CV"8'>&-(5"I"@(="

L-=$(9-&-5"I"N2342O"M0,+-*$()"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"#$%&'($()"

'*'(&"+',-+&5"C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+=5"/@:;-+=5"DPE"

T:'6&+-($6"6-,$'%"-;"&9$%"+',-+&"6@("1'"*$'>'="-("&9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+=W%"=@&@1@%'"-;"

'X,'+&$%'"@&"9&&,YRR7%$+E%@:;-+=E@6E7BR2ZZ[\R"

ISBN: 978-1-907842-35-1"

Page 4: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2"

B9C<?BA<*

Q$0Y"C9$%"+',-+&",+-*$='%";''=1@6B"-("@"#$%&'($()"T*'(&"9':="-("/',&'01'+"44&9"2344"&9@&"

'X,:-+'="$%%7'%"$("+':@&$-("&-"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'"17$:&"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&E"""

G@6B)+-7(=Y"M("&9'":@%&"='6@='"'%,'6$@::?5"&9'+'"9@%"1''("@")+->$()"$(&'+'%&"$("'(9@(6$()"

9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'"=':$*'+?"'(*$+-(0'(&%"$(6:7=$()"9-%,$&@:%5"(7+%$()"@(="+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"

9-0'%E"C9$%"$%",@+&:?"$("+'%,-(%'"&-"+'6-)($&$-("&9@&"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$(">9$69"6@+'"$%"

=':$*'+'="6@("9@*'"@"%$)($;$6@(&"';;'6&"-(",@&$'(&"@(="%&@;;"'X,'+$'(6'5",@&$'(&">'::1'$()"@(="

7:&$0@&':?"+'6-*'+?"-+"@,,+-,+$@&'"'(="-;":$;'"6@+'E"M("&9'"DP5"&9'+'"9@%"1''("+@,$=")+->&9"$("

='*':-,0'(&"-;"('>.17$:="6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%"@%">'::"@%"@=@,&@&$-(%"-;"'X$%&$()"6@+'";@6$:$&$'%"

>$&9"*@+?$()"%766'%%"@&"0''&$()"&9'"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9-%'">9-"6@+'";-+"

&9'0E""

C9'"+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"1@%'"$("%7,,-+&"-;"='*':-,0'(&%"$("&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&";-+"

='0'(&$@"6@+'"$%")+->$()5"?'&"+'0@$(%",@&69?"@(="$(6-0,:'&'E"]&9'+"*@:7@1:'"'*$='(6'"$("

&9'";-+0"-;"*$'>%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"&9'$+";@0$:$'%"@(="&9-%'"$("@("$(;-+0@:"-+",@$="

6@+'"+-:'5"9@*'"(-&"@:>@?%"1''("&@B'("$(&-"@66-7(&">9'("='%$)($()"9'@:&9"6@+'"+':@&'="

17$:=$()%E"A9$:%&"&9'+'"$%"0769"@66',&'=")--="='%$)(",+@6&$6'"'*$='(&5"&9'+'"+'0@$("

69@::'()'%5"&'(%$-(%"@(="7(0'&"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"$("+':@&$-("&-"&9'"17$:&"

'(*$+-(0'(&5"&9@&"&9'"#$%&'($()"T*'(&"%-7)9&"&-"'X,:-+'E"""

Q,,+-@69Y"C9'"#$%&'($()"T*'(&"1+-7)9&"&-)'&9'+"@">$='"+@()'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"@("$(&'+'%&"-+"

=$+'6&"'X,'+$'(6'"-;"='0'(&$@E"C9'%'"$(6:7='=",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"&9'$+";@0$:?"0'01'+%5"

$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%5",@$="6@+'">-+B'+%5"+',+'%'(&@&$*'%"-;"-+)@($%@&$-(%"&9@&">-+B">$&9",'-,:'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="@6@='0$6"%&@;;">$&9"@("$(&'+'%&"@(="'X,'+&$%'"$("='0'(&$@"6@+'"$(6:7=$()"

(7+%'%5"@+69$&'6&%"@(="%-6$@:">-+B'+%E"M("@">-+B%9-,"'(*$+-(0'(&5",@+&$6$,@(&W%"*$'>%">'+'"

7(6-*'+'="7%$()"@"+@()'"-;"&'69($^7'%"$(6:7=$()"=$%67%%$-("-;",9-&-)+@,9%"-;"@66',&'=")--="

,+@6&$6'"$("='0'(&$@"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%"@(=";@6$:$&@&'="=$%67%%$-(")+-7,%"-("@"69-$6'"-;"

&-,$6%"-;"$0,-+&@(6'"&-",@+&$6$,@(&%E"M%%7'%"-;"$(&'+'%&"@(="6-(6'+(">'+'",+$-+$&$%'=E"_--="

,+@6&$6'">@%"9$)9:$)9&'="@(="@%,'6&%"-;"='0'(&$@"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%"$("(''="-;"

$0,+-*'0'(&">'+'"=$%67%%'=E"/-:7&$-(%">'+'"%7))'%&'="1?",@+&$6$,@(&%"@(=";7&7+'"+'%'@+69"

-,,-+&7($&$'%"$='(&$;$'=E"Q::">-+B%9-,"@6&$*$&$'%">'+'"@7=$-.+'6-+='="@(="'X&'(%$*'"(-&'%"

Page 5: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z"

0@='"&-"'(@1:'"&9-+-7)9";''=1@6B"&-"1'")$*'("&-",@+&$6$,@(&%"@(="-&9'+%">$&9"@("$(&'+'%&"$("

&9'",+-6'%%"@(="-7&6-0'%"-;"&9'"'*'(&E"A9$:%&"(-&"@"+'%'@+69"@6&$*$&?"$&%':;5"&9'"'*'(&"9@%"

1''("@"*@:7@1:'"6-007($&?"'()@)'0'(&"@6&$*$&?"@$0'="@&"$='(&$;?$()";7&7+'"+'%'@+69"@(="

$((-*@&$-("&-,$6%"@(=",+$-+$&$'%5"@(="6+'@&$()"&9'"1')$(($()%"-;"@("-()-$()"+':@&$-(%9$,">$&9"

>$::$()",@+&$6$,@(&%"&-"&@B'"$='@%";-+>@+=E"

U$%67%%$-(Y"TX@0$(@&$-("-;"=$%67%%$-("6-(&'(&"+'*'@:'="["6-+'"&9'0'%"-;"$0,-+&@(6'"&-"

,@+&$6$,@(&%E"C9'";$+%&"`"-;"&9'%'"+'%-(@&'">$&9"&9'"67++'(&"@(="+':'*@(&"+'%'@+69":$&'+@&7+'E"

C9'":@&&'+"Z"&9'0'%"$(=$6@&'"%-0'&9$()":'%%"+',-+&'="-("@(="$("(''="-;";7+&9'+"'X,:-+@&$-(E"

C9'"["&9'0'%"@+'Y""

• J@1+$6"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&""

• Q01$'(6'"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"

• S%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"

• /-6$-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"

S:7%5"

• J7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&$'%"@(="%@;'&?"

• M(;-+0@&$-("@(="6-007($6@&$-("

• Q,,+-@69'%"&-"6@+'"

A$&9$("&9'%'"&9'0'%5"%'*'+@:"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%">'+'"@,,@+'(&"&9@&"@+'"@:%-"+',-+&'="-(E"

C9'%'"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"$::7%&+@&'"%-0'"-;"&9'"69@::'()'%"$("6+'@&$()"&9'"1'%&",-%%$1:'"17$:&"

'(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"='0'(&$@"6@+'"@(="&9'"+'@:$&$'%"$("=':$*'+$()"='0'(&$@"6@+'">$&9$("&9'0E"

C9'"'*'(&"7(6-*'+'="*@:7@1:'";''=1@6B"@1-7&"&9'",+';'+'(6'%";-+";7&7+'"+'%'@+69"$(&-"

='0'(&$@"6@+'"@(="&9'"17$:&"9'@:&9"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&E""

L-(6:7%$-(%Y"L:'@+"0'%%@)'%";+-0",@+&$6$,@(&%"$(=$6@&'="@"(''=";-+";7+&9'+"@(="0-+'"

;-67%'="+'%'@+69"$(&-"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"17$:&"9-%,$&@:"@(="9'@:&9"+':@&'="6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&"

-("&9'"6@+'"@(="'X,'+$'(6'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">':6-0'="&9'"07:&$.

%&@B'9-:='+"@,,+-@69"&-"'X,:-+$()"$%%7'%"-;"%9@+'="6-(6'+("@(="1'$()")$*'("@("-,,-+&7($&?"

&-"*-$6'"&9'$+"*$'>%"@(="$0,-+&@(&:?"9@*'"&9-%'"*$'>%":$%&'('="&-">$&9"&9'"'X,'6&@&$-("-;"

&9'0"1'$()"@6&'="7,-(E"C9$%"+',-+&")-'%"%-0'">@?"$("%9@+$()"&9'":'@+($()";+-0"&9$%"

$0,-+&@(&"&-,$6"@+'@"@(="6@&@:?%$()";7&7+'"@6&$-("&-"0@B'"='%$)("-;"='0'(&$@"6@+'"17$:=$()%"

@+'";$&";-+",7+,-%'E"

Page 6: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`"

DE?0>E?6*

C9'";-+'>-+="$("&9$%"+',-+&"$%"+',+'%'(&%"07:&$,:'",'+%,'6&$*'%";+-0":'@='+%">$&9$("@6@='0$65",+-;'%%$-(@:"@(=",-:$&$6@:"@+'(@%E"C9'"6-00-("&9+'@="@0-()%&"&9'%'"*$'>,-$(&%"+':@&'%"&-"9->"='0'(&$@"9@%"$0,@6&'="=$+'6&:?"-+"$(=$+'6&:?"$("&9'$+":$*'%E"

B=.@1"'=*F'14*

C-"0-*'")--="$='@%";+-0"&9'-+?"&-",+@6&$6'"&@B'%"0-+'"&9@("a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

Q&":'@%&"&>-"$0,-+&@(&"=$0'(%$-(%"-;"&9$%"+',-+&"='%'+*'",@+&$67:@+"@&&'(&$-(E"

J$+%&5"$&"$%"1'6-0$()"$(6+'@%$():?"6:'@+"&9@&"&9'"(701'+"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%")+->$()"@(="&9@&",9@+0@6'7&$6@:"&+'@&0'(&"+'%'@+69"$%"1@()$()"7,"@)@$(%&"@"1+$6B">@::b@&":'@%&";-+"&9'",+'%'(&E"M&"$%"1'6-0$()"$(6+'@%$():?"6:'@+"@%">'::5"@%"&9$%"+',-+&"+';:'6&%5"&9@&"&9'"1'%&"&9$()"&-"=-";-+",'-,:'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"@&",+'%'(&"$%"&-"$0,+-*'"&9'$+":$*'%">$&9"(-(.,9@+0@6-:-)$6@:b'6-,%?69-%-6$@:b$(&'+*'(&$-(%E""C9'"0-%&"1@%$6"-;"&9'%'"$%"@",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"@=@,&'="&-"&9'"(''=%"-;"@::"$&%"7%'+%5"$("&9$%"6@%'"$(6:7=$()",'+%-(%">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'",'-,:'">9-":-*'"@(="6@+'";-+"&9'0E"

/'6-(=5"@(="&9$%"0$)9&"1'"'*'("0-+'"$0,-+&@(&5"$%"&9@&"&9$%":$%&'($()"'X'+6$%'">@%"@$0'="@&"1'&&'+"7(='+%&@(=$()"&9'"'X,'+$'(6'"@(="(''=%"-;",'+%-(%":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"$("9-%,$&@:%b$("@"17$:=$()"&?,'",+$0@+$:?"7%'="1?"-&9'+%">$&9-7&"='0'(&$@E""M&">-7:="(-&"9@*'"1''("+'0@+B@1:'5"9@="&9'")+-7,"1''("%&7=?$()"^7'%&$-(%"-;"'*$='(6'.1@%'="='%$)("@,,:$'="&-"@"='=$6@&'="6@+'"9-0'"-+"@"0'0-+?"6@+'"6:$($6"1'6@7%'"&9-%'"-,'+@&'"-(:?";-+"&9$%")+-7,"-;"7%'+%E"G7&"&9'?"=$="(-&E"

Q%"&9$%"+',-+&"'X'0,:$;$'%5"&-"@69$'*'"&+7'"c7($*'+%@:"='%$)(d"-;"-7+",71:$6"%,@6'%"@(=",71:$6"17$:=$()%b%769"@%"9-%,$&@:%b>'"07%&"6@++?"-7&"+'%'@+69"-("@(="$(6:7='"&9'"(''=%"@(=">$%9'%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'",@+&('+%"&-"0@B'"';;'6&$*'"'*$='(6'.1@%'="='%$)("='6$%$-(%"$("%769"%'&&$()%E"

S+-;'%%-+"G%5(*H1',1/"S+'%$='(&"@(="6-.;-7(='+"-;"K'@+&9%&-('"Q:e9'$0'+"L@+'5"#&=E"

Q7&9-+"-;"Mf0"/&$::"K'+'Y"Q"8'>"S9$:-%-,9?"-;"Q:e9'$0'+f%"L@+'5"233g5"S$@&B7%"

Page 7: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"h"

3$%21,,'%(./*F'14*

C9'+'"6@("1'";'>",'-,:'"&9@&"@+'"(-&"@>@+'"-;"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"='0'(&$@E"K->'*'+5"$&"9@%"1''("@(="%&$::"$%5"&-"%-0'"=')+''5"%-0'&9$()"&9@&"$%",7%9'="1'9$(="@"67+&@$(E"

<?"67++'(&"'X,'+$'(6'"$%"&9@&"M"9@*'"&>-"0@:'";+$'(=%"$("&9'$+"'@+:?"\3%">9-"@+'"@;;'6&'="1?"='0'(&$@"&-"=$;;'+'(&"=')+''%E"G-&9"'X&+'0':?"%766'%%;7:"17%$('%%0'(5"-('"$%"(->"6-0,:'&':?"$(6@,@1:'"-;"@(?";-+0"-;"$(=','(='(&":$*$()"@(="&9'"-&9'+"9@%":-%&"&9'"@1$:$&?"&-"0@B'"='6$%$-(%"@(="-+)@($%'"9$%"@6&$*$&$'%E"C9'"6@+'"-;"1-&9"$%"&9'"+'%,-(%$1$:$&?"-;"&9'$+"+'%,'6&$*'">$*'%">9-5":$*$()"$("=$;;'+'(&",@+&%"-;"T():@(=5"9@*'"1''("@1:'"&-"@66'%%"*'+?"=$;;'+'(&":'*':%"-;"6:$($6@:"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'";-+"&9'$+",@+&('+%"@(="('):$)$1:'"%7,,-+&";-+"&9'0%':*'%"@%"6@+'+%E"

M";$(="&9@&"0?"'X,'+$'(6'"$%"0$++-+'=">9'("M"+@$%'"&9'"$%%7'">$&9"0?";+$'(=%"@+-7(="&9'"6-7(&+?"@(="'*'("0-+'"%-">9'("M"&@:B"&-"0?"-:='+"+':@&$*'%"@(=";+$'(=%">9-"@::"9@*'"@":')$-("-;"%&-+$'%"@1-7&"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"6-(=$&$-("-("&9'",'-,:'"&9'?"B(->5"-+"9@*'"B(->(5"@(="&9'"$(&-:'+@1:'"17+='("-("&9'"6@+'+%E"

#--B$()"1@6B"&-"0?"+-:'"@%"@"9-%,$&@:"0@(@)'+"@(="=7&?"=$+'6&-+"+'%,-(%$1:'";-+"@("8K/"9-%,$&@:"$("&9'"4gg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

U@*$="L@0'+-(5"&9'"S+$0'"<$($%&'+"@(="&9'":'@='+%"-;"8K/"@(="/-6$@:"L@+'"9@*'"+'6-)($%'="&9@&"69@()'"$%"(''='=E"U'6$%$-(%">$::"9@*'"&-"1'"0@='"-(">9@&"%9-7:="69@()'"&-"1@:@(6'"&9'"(''=%"-;"$(=$*$=7@:",@&$'(&%"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%"&-)'&9'+">$&9"&9'"+'^7$+'0'(&"&-"=':$*'+"9-%,$&@:"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'"$("%@;'5"*@:7'";-+"0-('?">@?%"&9@&"('6'%%@+$:?"0'@("7%$()"$((-*@&$*'"('>",+-6'%%'%"@(=",+-6'=7+'%E"C9'"69@()'%"&9@&">$::"1'"$(&+-=76'="%9-7:="1'"1@%'="-("%-7(=">'::.+'%'@+69'="$(;-+0@&$-("@(="7(='+%&@(=$()E"M&"$%"@("@+'@"&9@&"$%"7(='+"+'%'@+69'=5">9'+'"$&"$%"'%&$0@&'="&9@&"\3i"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@+'"7(=$@)(-%'=5"@(="0@(?",'-,:'"%7,,+'%%"-,'("@6B(->:'=)'0'(&"-;"&9'"6-(=$&$-(E"

A'"07%&"@::"6-00$&"&-"&9'"69@::'()'5"&9'"%6-,'"-;">9$69"$%"%&$::"'0'+)$()5"&-"$0,+-*'"&9'":$*'%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"&9'"6@+'+%"@(="&9'",+-;'%%$-(@:"%&@;;">9-"%7,,-+&"&9'0E"A'"07%&"7(='+&@B'"$(*'%&$)@&$-(%"@(="+'%'@+69"&9@&"+'6-)($%'"&9'"6-0,:'X"@(="6-0,'&$()"='0@(=%"&-",+-=76'"'*$='(6'"-(">9$69"&-"1@%'"='6$%$-(%"&9@&"@+'"(''='="&-"$0,+-*'"&9'"^7@:$&?"-;"&9'":$*'%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

C9$%"+',-+&"cM0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@d")$*'%"*@:7@1:'"$(%$)9&%"$(&-"&9'";7+&9'+">-+B"&9@&"$%"(''='=E*

?%I*C"'-5*j$%$&$()"S+-;'%%-+5"/]GTb/69--:"-;"&9'"G7$:&"T(*$+-(0'(&5"/@:;-+="D($*'+%$&?"

I'&$+'="U$+E"T%&@&'%"@(="J@6$:$&$'%"-;"8K/"$("T():@(="@(="S+'%$='(&";-+"&9'"KTJ<Q"

Page 8: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"\"

3%/'-'=./*F'14*

M"@0"=':$)9&'="&-"9@*'"1''("@%B'="&-">+$&'"&9'";-+'>-+="&-"&9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+=W%"$0,-+&@(&"cM0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@d"+',-+&E"U'0'(&$@"$%"@("$%%7'"&9@&"&-769'%"&9'":$*'%"-;"'*'+?";@0$:?"$("G+$&@$("@(="$%"+$)9&:?"@"0@a-+"6-(6'+("(-&"a7%&";-+"&9'"8K/5"17&";-+",71:$6"%'+*$6'%"@%"@">9-:'E"#$B'"0-%&",'-,:'"M")-&"$(*-:*'="1'6@7%'"%-0'-('"M":-*'"9@%"='0'(&$@"k"0?"<70"k"@(="-*'+"&9'",@%&";$*'"?'@+%"M"9@*'"%''("@(="'X,'+$'(6'="&9'"$0,@6&"-("9'+"@(="0?"U@=">9-5"@&"&9'"@)'"-;"lh5"$%"%&$::"9'+";7::.&$0'"6@+'+E"

L@+$()";-+"&9-%'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%"@"0@%%$*'"69@::'()'";-+"7%"@::5"@(=",+'%%7+'";+-0"&9'",71:$6"@(="@6@='0$6%"9@%"9':,'="&-";-67%"&9'"0$(=%"-;",-:$&$6$@(%"@(=",+@6&$&$-('+%"-(">9@&"6@("@(="%9-7:="1'"=-('"&-"%7,,-+&"&9-%'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"&9'$+";@0$:$'%"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%E""

I'.'X@0$($()"&9'">@?"&9@&">'"6@+'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%"%-"$0,-+&@(&"1'6@7%'"-;"&9'"%6@:'"@(="&9'"6-%&E"C9'"233g"8@&$-(@:"U'0'(&$@"/&+@&')?",7&"&9'"&-&@:"6-%&"-;"='0'(&$@"&-"&9'"DP"'6-(-0?"@&"m4["1$::$-(",'+"?'@+"k">$&9"@("@)'$()",-,7:@&$-("&9$%"$%"'%&$0@&'="&-"&+$,:'"-*'+"&9'"('X&"Z3"?'@+%E""

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

G?":--B$()"@&"@">$='"+@()'"-;"*@+$@1:'%";+-0"6:$($6@:"@%,'6&%"%769"@%"9'@:&95"9?)$'('"@(="$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:5"&-"'(*$+-(0'(&@:";@6&-+%"%769"@%"@6-7%&$6%5"6-:-7+"@(="6:7&&'+5"&9'"+',-+&",+-*$='%"@"6-0,+'9'(%$*'"7(='+%&@(=$()"-;"&9'"=$;;'+'(&">@?%"&9@&"@"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@("1'"$0,+-*'="&-"%7,,-+&",'-,:'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

L+76$@::?"&9$%"+',-+&"@6B(->:'=)'%"&9'"(''=";-+"@("$(&')+@&$-("-;",9?%$6@:"@(="0'(&@:"9'@:&9"%'+*$6'%"$(%&'@="-;"9@*$()"&9'0"@%"=$%&$(6&"@(="%',@+@&'E"C9$%"$%"@("$0,-+&@(&"%&',"&->@+=%"6+'@&$()"@"6-0,+'9'(%$*'"6@+'",@6B@)'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(=",:@(($()"@"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&"$%"%,'6$;$6@::?"='%$)('=";-+"&9'$+"(''=%E""M&"%9->%"&9@&"&9'+'"$%"@")+'@&'+"7(='+%&@(=$()"-;"&9'"7($^7'"6$+670%&@(6'%"&9@&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@";@6'E""

Q%"='0'(&$@")@$(%"@")+'@&'+"(@&$-(@:",+-;$:'"$&"$%"$0,-+&@(&"&9@&"@::",-%%$1:'"@*'(7'%"-;"&+'@&0'(&"@(=">@?%"&-"$0,+-*'"&9'"^7@:$&?"-;":$;'"-;"&9-%'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@+'"'X,:-+'=E"MW0"&9'+';-+'"=':$)9&'="&9@&"&9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="9@%",+-=76'="&9$%"$((-*@&$*'"+',-+&5"@(="M":--B";-+>@+="&-"6-(&$(7$()"0?"6:-%'">-+B">$&9"&9'"D($*'+%$&?"@(=">-+B$()"$("S@+:$@0'(&"&-"'(%7+'"&9@&"='0'(&$@"6@+'"$%")$*'("&9'"$0,-+&@(&"@&&'(&$-("$&"='%'+*'%E"

I&"K-("+.J1/*9/1.$,Y"<ESE"j$6'"L9@$+"-;"&9'"Q::.S@+&?"S@+:$@0'(&@+?"_+-7,"-("U'0'(&$@"NQSS_O

Page 9: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"["

"

"

BA:7E>K06L0M07<C*

C9'"6-0,$:@&$-("-;"&9$%"+',-+&">@%"&9'"+'%7:&"-;"@"6-::@1-+@&$*'"';;-+&"1'&>''("@"&'@0";+-0"

&9'"/69--:"-;"87+%$()5"<$=>$;'+?"@(="/-6$@:"A-+B"@(="&9'"/69--:"-;"&9'"G7$:&"T(*$+-(0'(&E""

C9$%"$($&$@&$*'">-7:="(-&"9@*'"1''(",-%%$1:'"$;">'"=$="(-&"9@*'"&9'"%7,,-+&"-;"-7+"K'@=%"-;"

/69--:"NS+-;'%%-+"C-(?"A@+('"$("&9'"/69--:"-;"87+%$()5"<$=>$;'+?"@(="/-6$@:"A-+B"@(="

S+-;'%%-+"<$B'"P@)$-):-7"$("&9'"/69--:"-;"&9'"G7$:&"T(*$+-(0'(&OE""

A'"07%&";$+%&"&9@(B"&9-%'",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@">9-"6-(&+$17&'=">$&9"&9'$+"*$'>%E"Q:%-5"&-"

&9'";-+0@:"-+"$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%"@(=",+-;'%%$-(@:%">9-"0@='"&$0'"@*@$:@1:'";-+"&9$%"'*'(&E"A'"

07%&"@6B(->:'=)'"&9'"*-:7(&@+?">-+B"=-('"1?"<@+$@"]W/7::$*@(5"T:$e@1'&9"L-::$'+5"Q:$%-("

L@*@(@)95"n@%-("D(='+>--=5"L:'0'(&$(@9"I--B'5"<@+67%"]+0'+-=5"P@+'("A'%&5"o''%9@("

Qe$e"@(="K@(('B'"j@("U$aB">9-"%7,,-+&'="=@&@")@&9'+$()"@(=";@6$:$&@&$-("-;"&9'"'*'(&E"];"

,@+&$67:@+"(-&'"$%"S+-;'%%-+"M@("L--,'+"NjS"@&"/]GTO"$("&9'",+',@+@&$-("@(=";@6$:$&@&$-("-;"&9'"

:$%&'($()"'*'(&"@(="S+-;'%%-+"I-1"/0$&9"NjS"@&"/]GTO">9-"+'*$'>'="&9'"+',-+&"@(="

9$)9:$)9&'="+':'*@(&"0'%%@)'%"'0'+)$()";+-0"$&E"

"

Page 10: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"l"

AE7<07<C*

N! !(-$%@O=-'%(*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*Q!

R! 61"1(-'.S*E&1$&'14*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*NT!2E4! D(='+%&@(=$()"U'0'(&$@"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"43!2E2! U'0'(&$@"@(="&9'"S9?%$6@:"T(*$+-(0'(&"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"43!

!"!"#! $%&'()*+,-."""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""".##!!"!"!! /0123&%4.5,63)*,78,9.%,-.:878,93%."""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""".#!!!"!";! <*,23-8)3,(.563-8,&8.=)*7.>823-8,93%4.<%)8.?8993,(2@.""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""".#A!!"!"A! 5,63)*,78,9%4./21&0*4*(1.B.C08*)893&%4.D-8%2.""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""".#E!

2EZ! U$%67%%$-("EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"4g!

U! <51*K',-1('()*0&1(-*B##$%.=5*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*RT!ZE4! U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("]('"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"24!ZE2! U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("C>-"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"22!ZEZ! U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("C9+''"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2Z!ZE`! Q(@:?%$%"Q,,+-@69"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2`!

V! CO"".$;*%2*D'(@'(),*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*RW!`E4! J@1+$6"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2\!`E2! Q01$'(6'"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2[!`EZ! S%?69-:-)$6@:"M0,@6&"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2g!`E`! /-6$-:-)$6@:"M0,@6&"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"2g!`Eh! J7(6&$-(@:"Q6&$*$&?"@(="/@;'&?"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"Z3!`E\! M(;-+0@&$-("@(="L-007($6@&$-("EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"ZZ!`E[! Q,,+-@69'%"&-"L@+'"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"Z`!`El! L-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"Np&+@='"-;;%WO"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"Z\!`Eg! L-:-7+'="U-&%"TX'+6$%'"EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"Zl!`E43! U$%67%%$-("EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"̀ 3!

X! A%(=/O,'%(*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*VR!

W! ?121$1(=1,*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*VW!

Y! B##1(@'=1,*PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP*XN!

Page 11: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"g"

N !7<?E6ZA<!E7*

M("/',&'01'+"23445">'"7(='+&--B"@("$((-*@&$*'"6-007($&?"'()@)'0'(&"@6&$*$&?"B(->("@%"@"

p#$%&'($()"T*'(&W"&-"'X,:-+'"*$'>%"@1-7&"9-%,$&@:"='%$)("$("+':@&$-("&-",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

M("&9$%"+',-+&">'"%9@+'">9@&">'"9'@+=">9'(">'":$%&'('="&-"&9-%'">9-"@+'"=$+'6&:?"@(="

$(=$+'6&:?"$0,@6&'="1?"='0'(&$@E"A'"@66-7(&";-+"&9'"$%%7'%"&9@&">'+'"+@$%'="$("+':@&$-("&-"

&9'"@='^7@6?"-;"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+";-+0@:"@(="

$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%E"C-",+-*$='"&9'"1@6B)+-7(="@(="@("-*'+*$'>"@1-7&"='%$)(";-+"='0'(&$@5"&9$%"

+',-+&"$%"%&+76&7+'="@%";-::->%E"

/'6&$-("&>-",+'%'(&%"@")'('+@:"-*'+*$'>"$("&'+0%"-;"&+'(=%"+':@&'="&-"&9'"DP",-,7:@&$-("@(="

='0'(&$@E"M&"@:%-"1+$';:?"=$%67%%'%">9@&"='0'(&$@"$%"@(="&9'"@6@='0$6"+'%'@+69"&9@&"9@%"

1''("=-('"&-"$(*'%&$)@&'"9->"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@("$0,@6&",-%$&$*':?"@(="(')@&$*':?"-("

='0'(&$@"6@+'"@(="'X,'+$'(6'E"/'6&$-("&9+''"='%6+$1'%"&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&"@,,+-@69"@(="&9'"

0'&9-="7%'="&-"6-::'6&"@(="@(@:?%'"$(;-+0@&$-(";+-0",@+&$6$,@(&%E"/'6&$-(";-7+",+'%'(&%"&9'"

;$(=$()%"-;"&9'"'*'(&5"$(6:7=$()",-&'(&$@:",+-1:'0%"@(=",-%%$1:'"%-:7&$-(%5"@%">'::"@%"%-0'"

6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"&9@&"'0'+)'=5"M&"@:%-"$(6:7='%"&9'",+$-+$&?"$%%7'%";-+";7&7+'"'X,:-+@&$-(5"

;+-0"&9'",'+%,'6&$*'"-;"&9-%'">9-"@&&'(='="&9'"'*'(&E"J$(@::?5"%'6&$-(";$*'",+'%'(&%"&9'"

6-(6:7%$-(%"@(="+'6-00'(=@&$-(%";-+"$0,+-*'0'(&E"

Page 12: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"43"

""

R 60M07<!BS*EF0?F!0>*

RPN Z(@1$,-.(@'()*61"1(-'.*

c:878,93%.32.*,8.*=.908.7*29.37F*)9%,9.322+82.G8.=%&8.%2.908.F*F+4%93*,.%(82d"NU',@+&0'(&"

-;"K'@:&95"2343OE"M&"$%"1':$'*'="&9@&"&9'+'"@+'"@,,+-X$0@&':?"l335"333",'-,:'"$("&9'"DP":$*$()"

>$&9"U'0'(&$@" NQ:e9'$0'+W%"/-6$'&?5"2342O5"-(:?" :'%%" &9@("9@:;"-;" &9'%'5"@+-7(="`3i5"9@*'"

1''(" =$@)(-%'=" NQ::" S@+&?" S@+:$@0'(&@+?"_+-7,5" 2344OE" cC08. ,+7H8). *=. F8*F48. 4363,(.G390.

-878,93%.32.F)*I8&98-.9*.3,&)8%28.H1.*68).EJK.3,.5,(4%,-.H89G88,.!J#J.%,-.!J;Jd"Nj'+('"89.

%45"2344OE"

U'0'(&$@"$%"&9'"+'%7:&"-;"=$;;'+'(&"=$%'@%'%"@(="6-(=$&$-(%"&9@&"6@7%'"@":-%%"-;"1+@$(";7(6&$-("

&9@&"6@("+'%7:&"$("0'0-+?":-%%5"0--="69@()'%5",+-1:'0%">$&9"6-007($6@&$-("@(="+'@%-($()"

@(="@"='6+'@%'" $("&9'"@1$:$&?"@(="%B$::" $("6@++?$()"-7&"=@$:?"@6&$*$&$'%"'E)E">@%9$()5"=+'%%$()5"

6--B$()"@(="6@+$()";-+"%':;"NQ:e9'$0'+W%"/-6$'&?5"2342"@(="U'0'(&$@"DP5"2342OE""

M0,+-*$()"&9'"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&"&-"'(%7+'"&9@&"$&"$%"%7$&@1:'";-+",'-,:'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"

6@("9':,"$0,+-*'"-7&6-0'%";-+"$(=$*$=7@:%"@(="+'=76'"&9'"+$%B"-;"@*-$=@1:'"='&'+$-+@&$-("$("

@1$:$&$'%"@(="@%%-6$@&'="6-%&%"NQSS_5"2344OE"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"'*$='(6'"%9->%"&9@&"&9'",9?%$6@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&"6@("=$+'6&:?"$0,@6&"-("@",'+%-(W%";7(6&$-(@:"@1$:$&?"@(="$(=','(='(6'E"C9'+'"$%"

,-&'(&$@:";-+"$0,+-*'0'(&%"&-"1-&9"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;"&9-%'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&-"&9'"

6-%&"';;'6&$*'('%%"-;"6@+'"&9+-7)9"6@+';7:",:@(($()"@(="='%$)("-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"NQSS_5"

2344OE"C9$%"$%"&9'"%71a'6&"@==+'%%'="$("&9$%"+',-+&E"

RPR 61"1(-'.*.(@*-51*35;,'=./*0(&'$%("1(-*

/$(6'"&9'"4gl3%"&9'+'"9@%"1''("@"%&'@=?"$(6+'@%'"$("&9'",+-;'%%$-(@:"@(="@6@='0$6":$&'+@&7+'"

:$(B$()"='%$)("-;"&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="='0'(&$@"@(="='0'(&$@"6@+'"NU@?5"2333OE"C9'"

@=@,&@&$-("-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@("0@B'"&9'":$;'"-;"@",'+%-(":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"'@%$'+V"(-&"

=-$()"%-"6@("+'%7:&"$("7(('6'%%@+?"=$%&+'%%"@(="+'=76'="^7@:$&?"-;":$;'"NS@+%-(%5"2334OE"

Page 13: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"44"

Q=@,&@&$-("-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&";-+"&9-%'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%"%&$::"@"+':@&$*':?"('>"'X'+6$%'5"

%,'6$;$6@::?"$("&9'"6@%'"-;"&9'"@67&'"6@+'"%'6&-+"NU'0'(&$@"/'+*$6'%"U'*':-,0'(&"L'(&+'5"

2342OE""

S+-)+'%%"$%"1'$()"0@='"&-"+@$%'"@>@+'('%%"-;"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"-("&9-%'":$*$()"

>$&9"='0'(&$@5"%769"@%"&9'"6-00$&0'(&"&-"&9'"6@+'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$(")'('+@:"

9-%,$&@:%"1?"&9'"I-?@:"L-::')'"-;"87+%$()"NIL85"2342OE""I'%-7+6'%"%769"@%"&9'"U'0'(&$@"

/7,,-+&$*'"T(*$+-(0'(&"Q7=$&"C--:%"='*':-,'="1?"&9'"U'0'(&$@"/'+*$6'%"U'*':-,0'(&"

L'(&+'"NU/UL5"2342O"@(="&9'"P$()W%"J7(=",+-a'6&"T(9@(6$()"&9'"K'@:$()"T(*$+-(0'(&"NP$()W%"

J7(=5"2342O"9@*'"1''("$(&+-=76'="&-"9':,",:@(('+%5"@+69$&'6&%"@(="9-%,$&@:"%&@;;">$&9"&9'"

='%$)("-;"&9'"@67&'"6@+'"%'&&$()E""

RPRPN 9.=[)$%O(@*

C9'"(''="&-"6-(%$='+"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"-("&9'"'X,'+$'(6'5"9'@:&9"@(="

>'::.1'$()"-;",@&$'(&%">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@"$%"@("$0,-+&@(&"6-(%$='+@&$-(";-+"@+69$&'6&%5"

(7+%'%5"='%$)('+%"@(="9-%,$&@:"0@(@)'+%5"@0-()%&"-&9'+%E"K@*$()"@("-,&$070"='%$)("6@("

+'%7:&"$("1'&&'+"6@+'5">$&9"@"0-+'",-%$&$*'"'X,'+$'(6'";-+",@&$'(&%"@(="%&@;;V">9$:%&"@:%-"

6-(&+$17&$()"&-"%@*$()%"$("6-%&%"NU/UL5"2342OE"M&"$%"'%&$0@&'="&9@&"@&"@(?")$*'("&$0'"2h.`3i"-;"

&9'",@&$'(&%"$("&9'"@67&'"9-%,$&@:">@+="@(="@66$='(&"@(="'0'+)'(6?"%'&&$()%"9@*'"='0'(&$@"

NU/UL5"2342OE"<-+'"&9@("g3i"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@+'"B(->("&-"'X,'+$'(6'"1'9@*$-7+@:"

@(=",%?69-:-)$6@:"%?0,&-0%">9$69"6@("6@7%'"%&+'%%";-+"&9'"$(=$*$=7@:5"&9'$+";@0$:?"@(="%&@;;"

6@+$()";-+"&9'0"NI-1'+&"89.%45"233hOE"/-0'"-;"&9'%'"%?0,&-0%"%769"@%"=$%-+$'(&@&$-(5"

6-(;7%$-(5"0'0-+?":-%%"+$)$=$&?5":-%%"-;"0-*'0'(&5"9@::76$(@&$-(%"N1-&9"*$%7@:"@(="@7=$-O5"

6@("@;;'6&"9->"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%"@1:'"&-"7(='+&@B'"=@?.&-.=@?"@6&$*$&$'%"@(="$%"@1:'"

&-"+'@6&"@(=")'&"@+-7(="&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"NS@+%-(%5"2334OE"C9'%'"%?0,&-0%"@+'"

-;&'("'X@6'+1@&'="=7+$()"&$0'%"-;"%&+'%%">$&9"@"B'?"&+$))'+"-;"%&+'%%"1'$()"@&&'(=@(6'"@&"

9-%,$&@:E"C9$%"6@("7:&$0@&':?"+'%7:&"$("=@0@)$()"%9-+&"@(=":-()"&'+0"$0,@6&%"7,-("&9'"

,9?%$6@:"@(=",%?69-:-)$6@:"9'@:&9"-;"&9'",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"N8K/"L-(;'='+@&$-(5"2343OE"M&"

6@("@:%-"-;&'(":'@="&-"@":-()'+"%&@?"$("9-%,$&@:">9$69"$(6+'@%'%"6-%&%";-+"&9'"8K/"NU/UL5"

2342OE"

Page 14: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"42"

RPRPR 35;,'=./*0(&'$%("1(-*.(@*61"1(-'.*

A9'("6-(%$='+$()"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"-("&9'">'::.1'$()"-;",@&$'(&%">9-"9@*'"

='0'(&$@"$&"$%"$0,-+&@(&"&-"6-(%$='+"&9'"$(&'++':@&$-(%9$,"1'&>''("&9'",'+%-(@:"6-0,'&'(6'"

-;"@("$(=$*$=7@:">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"='0@(=%"&9'?"'X,'+$'(6'"N_--=@::5"

233\OE"C9$%"$(&'++':@&$-(%9$,"$%"@:%-"@==+'%%'="1?"o'$%':"89.%4"N233ZO">9-"%7))'%&"&9@&"c@"

1@:@(6'="6-01$(@&$-("-;",9@+0@6-:-)$65"1'9@*$-7+@:"@(="'(*$+-(0'(&@:"@,,+-@69'%L.$%"

0-%&":$B':?"&-"1'"';;'6&$*'"$("$0,+-*$()"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

<769"-;"&9'"'*$='(6'"-("&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(=",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"+':@&'%"&-"

+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"%'&&$()%"@(="(-&"9-%,$&@:%E"K->'*'+5"&9'%'"%'&&$()%"@+'"*'+?"=$;;'+'(&E"

K-%,$&@:%"@+'"6:$($6@:"%'&&$()%">9'+'"&9'"@$0"$%"&-"&+'@&",@&$'(&%";-+"9'@:&96@+'"$%%7'%"@(="&-"

9@*'"@%"%9-+&"@",@&$'(&"%&@?"@%",-%%$1:'E"A9'+'@%"+'%$='(&$@:"%'&&$()%"-;&'(",+-*$='"6@+'"-("@"

:-().&'+0"1@%$%5">$&9"@("'0,9@%$%"-(",+-*$=$()"%-6$@:"6@+'"@(=",'+9@,%"%-0'"9'@:&9"6@+'";-+"

+'%$='(&%E"C9'+'"@+'",-&'(&$@::?"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%">9'("6@+$()";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"$("

@("@67&'"%'&&$()"&9@&"=-"(-&"'X$%&">$&9$("@"+'%$='(&$@:"%'&&$()E"J-+"'X@0,:'";@0$:$@+$&?"$%"

$0,-+&@(&"&-"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"?'&"&9$%"$%"=$;;$67:&"$("@("@67&'"%'&&$()">9'+'"%&@?%"@+'"

$(&'(='="&-"1'"%9-+&"NU/UL5"2342OE"""

C9'"$(&')+@&$-("-;"=$;;'+'(&"@%,'6&%"-;"='0'(&$@"6@+'5">9$69"$(6:7='%"@&&'(&$-("&-"@(="7%'"-;"

&9'"&9'+@,'7&$6"'(*$+-(0'(&"@+'"%700@+$%'="1?"&9'"IL8"@(="&9'"UK"N2344O">9-"9@*'"

$%%7'=";$*'",+$(6$,:'%"@%",@+&"-;"@"6-00$&0'(&"&-"&9'"6@+'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$("

9-%,$&@:%E"C9'",+$(6$,:'"&9@&";-67%'%"-("&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$(6:7='%"+'6-00'(=@&$-(%"&9@&"

@==+'%%"&9'"7%'"-;Y""

• Q,,+-,+$@&'":$)9&$()""

• J:--+"6-*'+$()%""

• Q$=%"&-"%7,,-+&"-+$'(&@&$-("@(="*$%7@:"%&$07:@&$-(""

• S'+%-(@:$%$()"-;"&9'"1'="@+'@"@(="@='^7@&'"%,@6'""

• I'%-7+6'%"&-"%7,,-+&"@6&$*$&?"@(="%&$07:@&$-(""

Q"+'%-7+6'"&9@&"%7))'%&%"&9'";'@&7+'%"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&"$0,@6&"-("&9'">'::.

1'$()"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%"&9'"+'6'(&:?",71:$%9'="'(*$+-(0'(&"@%%'%%0'(&"&--:"B$&"

NP$()W%"J7(=5"2342O"='*':-,'="@%",@+&"-;"&9'"T(9@(6$()"&9'"K'@:$()"T(*$+-(0'(&"

Page 15: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4Z"

,+-)+@00'E"C9'"@%%'%%0'(&"&--:"@==+'%%'%"9->"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&",+-0-&'%"%'*'(";'@&7+'%"

-;"&9'",@&$'(&W%"'X,'+$'(6'Y"

• <'@($();7:"$(&'+@6&$-("1'&>''(",@&$'(&%5"&9'$+";@0$:$'%"@(="%&@;;"

• A'::.1'$()"

• T@&$()"@(="=+$(B$()"

• <-1$:$&?"

• L-(&$('(6'"@(="$(=','(='(6'"

• ]+$'(&@&$-("

• L@:0('%%"@(="%'67+$&?"

U$%-+$'(&@&$-("@(="&9'+';-+'"%&+'%%";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"1'"+':$'*'="&9+-7)9"

='%$)("%-:7&$-(%5">9$69"=-"(-&"(''="&-"1'"'X,'(%$*'"-+"6-0,:$6@&'=E"/-0'"-;"&9'%'"%-:7&$-(%"

$(6:7='"%-6$@:"@+'@%5"'@%?"&-"+'@="$(;-+0@&$-("@(="6:'@+'+">@?.;$(=$()"@(="%$)(@)'"N8K/"

L-(;'='+@&$-(5"2343OE"A@?.;$(=$()"6@("1'"0@='"'@%$'+"&-"7(='+%&@(="&9+-7)9"&9'"7%'"-;"

,$6&-+$@:"%$)(%"-+"6-:-7+"6-='%E"M(6-(&$('(6'"6-7,:'=">$&9"=$%-+$'(&@&$-("6@("0@B'"&9'":$;'"-;"

@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"%&+'%%;7:E"Q("'X@0,:'"-;"@"='%$)("%-:7&$-("&-"&9$%"%$&7@&$-("$%"&-"

6-:-7+"&9'"&-$:'&"=--+%"=$;;'+'(&:?"&-"-&9'+"=--+%"%-"&9@&"&9'?"@+'"'@%$:?";-7(="@(="=$%&$(6&"

;+-0"&9'">@::%"@(="-&9'+"=--+%"NU'%$)("L-7(6$:5"2344OE"

M("@"+'6'(&"+',-+&",71:$%9'="1?"&9'"U'0'(&$@"/'+*$6'%"U'*':-,0'(&"L'(&+'"NU/UL5"2342O5"

/&'+:$()"D($*'+%$&?"$='(&$;$'%"4\"pB'?"='%$)(";'@&7+'%W5"\"pB'?";'@&7+'%"-;"%,'6$;$6"+--0%W"@(="Z"

p-7&%$='W";'@&7+'%"&9@&"%9-7:="1'"6-(%$='+'="$("&9'"='%$)(5",:@(($()"@(="17$:=$()"-;"@"

9-%,$&@:E"C9'%'"@+'"*'+?"%$0$:@+"&-"&9-%'">9$69"9@*'"1''(",+'*$-7%:?"$='(&$;$'="@%"

+'6-00'(=@&$-(%"@(=R-+"6-(%$='+@&$-(%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$("+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"

%'&&$()%E""C9'?"@+'Y"

• P'?"='%$)("""• J:--+%"• L:-6B%"@(="6@:'(=@+%"• #$)9&$()"• /-7(="• J7+($&7+'"• <$++-+%"• T(@1:$()"+':@&$*'%"@(=";+$'(=%"&-"+'0@$(">$&9"&9'",@&$'(&"• /&-+@)'"

Page 16: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4`"

• 87+%'"6@::"%?%&'0"• 87+%'%W"%&@&$-(%"• T%%'(&$@:"(-&$6'%"@(=":'@;:'&"+@6B%"

• P'?";'@&7+'%"-;"%,'6$;$6"+--0%"• A@$&$()"+--0%""• S9?%$-&9'+@,?"@(="-667,@&$-(@:"+--0%"• C-$:'&%"• G@&9+--0%R%9->'+"+--0%"• G'=+--0"@+'@%"• U@?"+--0%"

• ]7&%$='"• #--B$()"-7&%$='"• _'&&$()"-7&%$='"• G'$()"-7&%$='"

RPRPU A%(,'@1$'()*0&'@1(=1*2$%"*?1,'@1(-'./*A.$1*C1--'(),S*

M("&9'"8@&$-(@:"M(%&$&7&'";-+"L:$($6@:"TX6'::'(6'")7$=@(6'"-("%7,,-+&$()",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"

@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%"$("9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'"N8MLT5"2344O"$&"$%"+',-+&'="&9@&",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@(=";-+0@:"@(="$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@",+';'+"@(="$(&'+@6&"1'&&'+"

$("@"(-(.$(%&$&7&$-(@:"%'&&$()E"C9$%",+'%'(&%"@"='%$)("69@::'()'";-+"9-%,$&@:%"&-"1'"='%$)('="

@(=";7(6&$-("@,,+-,+$@&':?"@%":'%%"$(%&$&7&$-(@:$%'="%'&&$()%E"Q(-&9'+"69@::'()'"$%"&9@&"&9$%"

@,,+-@69"$%"=$;;$67:&"&-"+'@:$%'"=7'"&-"&9'"-;;$6$@:"%?%&'0%"@(="+')7:@&$-(%"&9@&"@+'"@:+'@=?"$("

,:@6'">$&9$("&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"N<--+"89.%4"5"2333OE"I'%'@+69";$(=$()%"+':@&'="&-"%$():'"

+--0%"@(="&9'"6+'@&$-("-;"p9-0':$('%%W"0@?"(-&"1'"&+@(%;'+@1:'"&-"&9'"9-%,$&@:"%'&&$()"@%"

7(:$B'"$("+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"&9'"%$():'"+--0"6-7:="1'"&9'"-(:?"+--0"$(">9$69"&9'",'+%-(">$&9"

='0'(&$@"0@?"%,'(="&9'$+"&$0'E"M(":-().&'+0"6@+'"%'&&$()%5"=@?"+--0%"@(="=$($()"+--0%"

>-7:="@:%-"1'"@66'%%$1:'"?'&"&9'%'"&?,'%"-;"+--0%"@+'":'%%",+'*@:'(&"$("0-='+("9-%,$&@:%"

NJ:'0$()"q"S7+@(&@+'5"2343OE"C9'")-@:"-;"9-0':$('%%";-+"&9'">9-:'"-;"@"9-%,$&@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&5">9$69"9@%"@",+$0@+$:?"6:$($6@:";7(6&$-(5"0@?"@:%-"1'"$(@,,+-,+$@&'E"K->'*'+5"

&9'"$(6:7%$-("-;"9-0':$B'5",'+%-(@:"1':-()$()%"$("@",@&$'(&W%"$00'=$@&'",'+%-(@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&"6-7:="1'"@"+'@:$%&$6"6-0,+-0$%'E"

J+-0"@",+@6&$6@:"*$'>,-$(&5"D&&-("N233\V"233gO"@(="P'++"N233[O",+-*$='"'X@0,:'%"-;"

'(*$+-(0'(&%"@(="9->"&9'?"'(@1:'"@(="=$%@1:'",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"G-&9"@7&9-+%"

='%6+$1'"&9'";7(6&$-(@:$&$'%"@(="6-(%&+@$(&%"+':@&'="&-"&9'"%,@6'"='%$)('=";-+",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@%">'::"@%"$='@%"&9@&"%7,,-+&"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"P'++"N233[O"

Page 17: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4h"

)-'%";7+&9'+"@(="='%6+$1'%"h"='%$)(",+$(6$,:'%"&9@&"%7,,-+&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@Y"6@:0"@(="

%&+'%%.;+''V",+'=$6&@1:'"@(="0@B'"%'(%'V";@0$:$@+V"%7$&@1:?"%&$07:@&$()"@(="%@;'E"

C9'"&'+0"p17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&W"'(6-0,@%%'%"&9'"%7++-7(=$()%"-+"6-(=$&$-(%5"6+'@&'="@(="17$:&"

&9+-7)9"970@("$(&'+*'(&$-(5">9'+'"@",'+%-(5"@($0@:"-+",:@(&":$*'%"-+"-,'+@&'"NL-=$(9-&-"89.

%4M.233lOE"Q"+'*$'>"-;"+'%'@+69"%&7=$'%"&9@&"'X,:-+'"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&";-+"

&9'"='%$)("-;":-().&'+0"'(*$+-(0'(&%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"6-(6:7='="&9@&"='%$)('+%"

0@?"6-(r='(&:?"7%'"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"='%$)(";'@&7+'%"&-"'(9@(6'"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;",'-,:'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@"NJ:'0$()"q"S7+@(&@+'5"2343OE"C9'%'"$(6:7='"7(-1&+7%$*'"%@;'&?"0'@%7+'%V"

*@+$@&$-("$("@01$'(6'V"%$e'"@(="%9@,'"-;"%,@6'%V",+-*$%$-("-;"%$():'"+--0%V"0@X$0$%@&$-("-;"

*$%7@:"@66'%%V"@(="6-(&+-::'=":'*':%"-;"%&$07:@&$-(E"M("&9'":-().&'+0"6@+'"%'&&$()"&9'?";-7(="

&9@&"&9'+'"$%":'%%"@)+''0'(&"-("&9'"7%';7:('%%"-;"%$)(@)'V"9-0':$('%%V",+-*$%$-(";-+"

'()@)'0'(&"$("-+=$(@+?"@6&$*$&$'%V"%0@::"%$e'"-;"-7&%$='"%,@6'%"@(="&9'":@6B"-;"$&%",+-*$%$-(E""

U@?"89.%4"N2333O"7(='+&--B"@"+'*$'>"-;"'0,$+$6@:"+'%'@+69"-(")7$=':$('%"-(",9?%$6@:"='%$)("-;"

+'%$='(&$@:"%'&&$()%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"C9'?";-7(="&9@&"='%$)("+'6-00'(=@&$-(%"

>'+'")+-7,'="$(&-";-7+"0@$("@+'@%Y",:@(($()",+$(6$,:'%V")'('+@:"@&&+$17&'%V"='%$)("

-+)@($%@&$-("@(="%,'6$;$6"+--0%"@(="@6&$*$&?"%,@6'%E"M("&'+0%"-;",:@(($()",+$(6$,:'%5",:@(($()"

%9-7:="@,,+-,+$@&':?"@66-00-=@&'"&9'">9-:'"%,'6&+70"-;"$::('%%'%"@(="6@+'"(''='=">9'("

='*':-,$()"@"='0'(&$@"6@+'";@6$:$&?E"C9'"@++@()'0'(&"-;"%,@6'%">$&9$("&9'"6@+'";@6$:$&?"

%9-7:="%7,,-+&"$(=$*$=7@:W%"%'(%'"-;"-+$'(&@&$-(E"C9'"='%$)("-;",@+&$67:@+"+--0%"%769"@%"

1@&9+--0%"%9-7:=",+'%'+*'"+'%$='(&W%"=$)($&?"@(=",+$*@6?E"

M("@==$&$-(5"o'$%':"89.%4.N233ZO";-7(="&9@&"6'+&@$("'(*$+-(0'(&@:"@&&+$17&'%"$("+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"

%'&&$()%"+'%7:&'="$("='6+'@%'=":'*':%"-;"@(X$'&?5"=',+'%%$-(5"%-6$@:">$&9=+@>@:"@(="@))+'%%$-("

@0-()%&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"T(*$+-(0'(&%"&9@&"9@="@",-%$&$*'"';;'6&"-("&9'">'::.1'$()"-;"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@",+-*$='="@"%'(%'"-;",+$*@6?"@(=",'+%-(@:$%@&$-(5",+-*$='="6-(&+-::'="

%'(%-+?"$(,7&5"@66'%%$1$:$&?"&-"=$;;'+'(&"&?,'%"-;"+--0%"@(="7%'="+'%&+$6&$-(%"-("'X$&"&9@&"

>'+'"6-*'+&"+@&9'+"&9@("-*'+&E""

A9'("6-(%$='+$()"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"7,-("0'(&@:"9'@:&9"@(=">'::.

1'$()5";-7+"%,'6$;$6";'@&7+'%"%9-7:="1'"&@B'("$(&-"@66-7(&Y"&9'";@1+$6"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&V"&9'"

@01$'(6'"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&V"&9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"@(="&9'"%-6$-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"

Page 18: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4\"

'(*$+-(0'(&"NL--,'+"89.%45"233lOE"C9$%";+@0'>-+B">@%")'('+@&'="1?"&9'%'"@7&9-+%"&9+-7)9"

@"%?%&'0@&$6"6-0,$:@&$-("-;"0-+'"&9@("Z33",$'6'%"-;"'*$='(6'";+-0"=$;;'+'(&"&?,'%"-;"

'(*$+-(0'(&%E"

M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"&9'";@1+$6"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$(6:7='%"&9'"='%$)("@(="6-(%&+76&$-("-;"

17$:=$()%"N'E)E";:--+%5">@::%5"=--+%5"6'$:$()%5">$(=->%O"@(="&9'"%,@6'%"1'&>''("17$:=$()%"

N)@+='(%OE"L-(%$='+@&$-("%9-7:="1'")$*'("&-"&9'"7%'"-;"6-:-7+"N'E)E"+'=5"1:7'5"?'::->OV"&'X&7+'"

N'E)E"+-7)95"%0--&95"%$:B?OV",@&&'+("N'E)E"69'6B'=5"%&+$,'%5";:'6B%OV"0@&'+$@:"N'E)E">--=5"0'&@:5"

+711'+O"@(="%&+76&7+'"N'E)E"9@+=5"%-;&5";$+0OE"

C9'"@01$'(6'"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&",'+&@$(%"&-"&9'"%7++-7(=$()"69@+@6&'+"@(="@&0-%,9'+'"-;"

&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&E"C9$%"$(6:7='%"(-$%'"N1@6B)+-7(=5">9$&'.(-$%'5"%$:'(&5":-7=5"6-(%&@(&OV"

:$)9&$()"N9@+%95"%&@+B5"0'::->5"1+$)9&5"=$0OV"&'0,'+@&7+'"N6-:=5"9-&5"0$:=OV"6-:-7+"N>@+05"6--:5"

69''+;7:5"(@&7+@:5"%71=7'=OV"@$+"^7@:$&?"@(="*'(&$:@&$-("N6:'@+5",-::7&'=5"=$+&?5";+'%9OV"970$=$&?"

N=@0,5"=+?O"@(="*$'>%"-;"(@&7+'"N(@&7+@:"%7(:$)9&OE""

C9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&%"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@+'"&9'",'+6',&$-(%"-;"&9'",9?%$6@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="$&%"$0,@6&"7,-("$(=$*$=7@:%"%769"@%"='(%$&?"N'E)E"6+->=$()5"='%-:@&'OV"%'(%'"

-;"%@;'&?"-+";'@+V">@?.;$(=$()"N'E)E"'@%?5"9@+=5"6-(;7%$()OV"@66'%%$1$:$&?"N'E)E"=$;;$67:&5"=$+'6&5"

'@%?5"-;;",7&&$()O"@(="$='(&$&?"N'E)E"9-0':?5"6:$($6@:5"$(%&$&7&$-(@:5"&+@=$&$-(@:"-+"0-='+(OE"

C9'"%-6$-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$%"&9'"%-6$@:"%$)($;$6@(6'"-;"17$:=$()%"@(="&9'$+"

'(*$+-(0'(&%"$("+':@&$-("&-"%?01-:$6"*@:7'%"@(="0'@($()%5";-+"'X@0,:'")+-7,$()"N'E)E"

?-7()R-:=5",-:$&$6@:R+':$)$-7%5"%&@;;R,@&$'(&5"0@:'R;'0@:'5"7($%'X"%,@6'R%$():'"%'X"%,@6'5"

,71:$65",+$*@&'"@(="6-007(@:"%,@6'%";-+"%-6$@:$%$()5"6@+'5">-+B5":'$%7+'5"+';:'6&$-(O"@0-()%&"

-&9'+%E"

C9'"-7&%$='"%,@6'"$%"@:%-"-;")+'@&"$0,-+&@(6'"$("&9'"@+'@"-;"6@+'"@(=">'::.1'$()";-+"@",'+%-("

>$&9"='0'(&$@E"A$&9"0-+'"@(="0-+'"'*$='(6'"6:@$0$()"&9@&"-7&=--+"'X'+6$%'"$%"1'(';$6$@:"

1-&9",9?%$6@::?"@(="0'(&@::?"N/7%&@$(@1:'"U'*':-,0'(&"L-00$%%$-(5"233lV"<$(=5"233[V"

J7B7B@>@"89.%4M"233`V"Q11-&&"89.%4M"233`V"D:+$695"233`V"@(="#@+%-("89.%4M"233\O5"='%$)('+%"@+'"

,:@6$()"a7%&"@%"0769"$0,-+&@(6'"-("&9'":-6@&$-("@(="-7&=--+"%,@6'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@%"&9'"17$:=$()%"&9'0%':*'%E""

Page 19: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4["

RPRPV 0(&'$%("1(-./*3,;=5%/%);*\*<51%$1-'=./*!@1.,**

C9'+'"@+'"0@(?"&9'-+$'%"'X,:@$($()"9->"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@;;'6&%"970@(":$;'"@(="

1'9@*$-7+E"C9'"$(&'(&$-("-;"&9$%"+',-+&"$%"(-&"&-"6-*'+"@::"-;"&9'0"17&"+@&9'+"&-")$*'"@"1+$';"

@66-7(&"&-"'X,:@$("&9'"=$;;'+'(&"':'0'(&%"&9@&"@+'"1':$'*'="&-"'X,:@$("&9'"+':@&$-(%9$,"

1'&>''("&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="9'@:&9"+':@&'="-7&6-0'%E"/7(=%&+-0.89.%4M"N4gg\O"

%7))'%&"&9@&"%$X"&9'-+$'%"9@*'"1''("0-+'"$(;:7'(&$@:"&9@("-&9'+%"$("+'6'(&"+'%'@+69"

='*':-,0'(&%">$&9$("&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&@:",%?69-:-)?";$':=E"C9'%'"@+'"='%6+$1'="1':->Y"

• Q+-7%@:"&9'-+?",+'=$6&%"-,&$070",'+;-+0@(6'"@(="%@&$%;@6&$-("7(='+"6-(=$&$-(%"-;"

0-='+@&'"@+-7%@:">9'("&+$))'+'="1?"'(*$+-(0'(&@:";'@&7+'%"%769"@%"%-7(=5"&'0,'+@&7+'"

@(=":$)9&"NC9@?'+5"4glgV"G$('+"89.%45"4glgV"Q(='+%-(5"4glgV"G'::5"4gg2OE"

• T(*$+-(0'(&@:":-@="&9'-+?",+'=$6&%"&9@&"970@(%"9@*'"@";$($&'"6@,@6$&?";-+",+-6'%%$()"

%&$07:$"@(="$(;-+0@&$-("@(="&9@&">'"6-,'">$&9"%'(%-+?"-+"$(;-+0@&$-("-*'+:-@="&9+-7)9"

%':'6&$*'"@&&'(&$-("-;"9$)9.,+$-+$&?"$(,7&%"@(="$)(-+$()":->.,+$-+$&?"$(,7&%E"j'$&69"N4gg3O5"

/0$&9"N4gg4O"@(="#-'>'("@(="/7'=;':="N4gg2O"@+'"'X@0,:'%"-;"+'%'@+69'+%">9-"9@*'"

&'%&'="&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&@:":-@="&9'-+?E"

• /&+'%%"@(="@=@,&@&$-("&9'-+?"'X,:@$(%"&9@&"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"'X&+'0'%"%769"@%"&'0,'+@&7+'5"

%-7(=5"@(="-&9'+"*@+$@1:'%"&+$))'+",9?%$-:-)$6@:"@(=",%?69-:-)$6@:"%&+'%%5"@%">'::"@%"&9'"

='*':-,0'(&"-;"6-,$()"@(="@=@,&$*'"1'9@*$-7+%"&9@&"0$&$)@&'"%&+'%%E"TX@0,:'%"-;"

+'%'@+69'+%"&'%&$()"&9$%"9?,-&9'%$%"$(6:7='"K'=)'"N4glgO5"G@70"89.%4"N4gg3O5"K-1;-::"

N4gg4O5"I71-($%"@(="G$6B0@("N4gg4O"@(="G@70"@(="J:'0$()"N4ggZOE"

• S+$*@6?.+')7:@&$-("&9'-+?"+':@&'%",+$*@6?5"%,@&$@:"1'9@*$-7+"N$E'E"9->"@("$(=$*$=7@:"-+"

)+-7,"+'@6&"&-"&9'"$00'=$@&'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="$&%"-667,@(&%O5"6+->=$()5"@(="

&'++$&-+$@:$&?">$&9"@"970@("&'(='(6?"&-"%''B"-,&$070"%-6$@:"$(&'+@6&$-(5",@+&:?"&9+-7)9"

7%'"-;"&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"NQ:&0@(5"4ggZOE"M&"@:%-"%7))'%&%"&9@&"&9'"6@7%'"-;"%&+'%%"

@:%-"&+$))'+%"&9'"0$&$)@&$-("-;"$&E"I'%'@+69"$("&9$%"@+'@"$(6:7='%"&9@&"1?"G:-6B"@(="_@+('&&"

N4glgO5"K@))@+="@(="A'+('+"N4gg3O"@(="G+->("N4gg2OE""

• C9'"'6-:-)$6@:",%?69-:-)?"@(="1'9@*$-7+"%'&&$()"&9'-+?"*$'>%"'(*$+-(0'(&%"$("&'+0%"-;"

1'9@*$-7+"%'&&$()%">9$69"@+'"=';$('="@%"c27%44.2&%48.2*&3%4.2129872.&*7F*28-.*=.F8*F48.

%,-.F0123&%4.*HI8&92.&*,=3(+)8-.3,.2+&0.%.G%1.%2.9*.&%))1.*+9.%.N)*+93,328-O.F)*()%7.*=.

%&93639382.G390.2F8&3=3%H48.9378.%,-.F4%&8.H*+,-%)382d"NA$6B'+5"4gg2OE"C9$%"9?,-&9'%$%"$%"

Page 20: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4l"

$(*'%&$)@&'="$("&9'">-+B"='*':-,'="1?"/69-))'("N4glgO5"/-00'+"@(="A$6B'+"N4gg4O5"

A$6B'+"N4gg2O"@(="A$6B'+"@(="Q7)7%&"N4gghOE""

• C+@(%@6&$-(@:"@,,+-@69"$%"+':@&'="&-",+$*@6?"+')7:@&$-("&9'-+?"N/7(=%&+-0.89.%4M"4gg\OE"

Q66-+=$()"&-"G+->("89.%45"N4gg2O5"A'+('+"89.%4MN4gg2O"@(="Q:&0@("N4ggZO"&9'",9?%$6@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&",+-*$='%"6-(&'X&";-+"%-6$@:"$(&'+@6&$-("&9@&"6@("%7,,-+&5"6-(%&+@$(5"

%?01-:$%'5"@(="6-(;'+"0'@($()"7,-("*@+$-7%"@%,'6&%"-;"%-6$@:"+':@&$-(%9$,%E"

• S+-X'0$6%"&9'-+?"+':@&'%",'-,:'%f"7%'"-;"&9'$+",'+6',&7@:"@,,@+@&7%"$("=$;;'+'(&"

'0-&$-(@:"%&@&'%"=7+$()"=$;;'+'(&"@6&$*$&$'%5"$("=$;;'+'(&"+':@&$-(%9$,%5"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"

%'&&$()%5"@(="6-(&'X&%"NK@::5"4g\lV"L--B5"4g[3V"I@?1'6B5"4gg4OE""

• C9'":@()7@)'"-;"%,@6'"&9'-+?",+'=$6&%"&9@&"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"9@%"%$)(%"@(="%,'6$;$6"

69@+@6&'+$%&$6%"&9@&"6@("1'"p+'@=W"1?"$&%"7%'+%5"&9'+';-+'"$(;:7'(6$()"970@("1'9@*$-7+"

N#@>%-(5"2334OE"#@>%-("N2334O"+'6-)($%'%"&9@&"&9'":@()7@)'"-;"%,@6'"0-=':"$%"%$0,:$%&$65"

@(="$&"=-'%"(-&"$(6:7='"@::"&?,'%"-;"1'9@*$-7+"%769"@%"&9-%'"&+$))'+'="1?"%-6$@:"

,9'(-0'(@"@%"='%6+$1'="1?"S+-%9@(%B?.89.%4"N4g[\O"$("#@>%-("N2334OE""

Q==$&$-(@::?5"+'%'@+69"@1-7&"&9'"='%$)("@(="7%'"-;"9'@:&96@+'";@6$:$&$'%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"

0'(&@:"9'@:&9"(''=%"N'E)E"#@>&-(5"2334O"9@%"1''("6-(=76&'="1?"%,'6$@:$%&"9'@:&96@+'"

='%$)('+%5"9'@:&9",+-;'%%$-(@:%"@(="&9'"8K/"T%&@&'%"N'E)E"8K/"T%&@&'%5"4gg\OE"C9'%'"+'*$'>%"

@$0"&-"6:@+$;?"@"1+-@="%'&"-;"$%%7'%"+':@&'="&-"0'(&@:"$::('%%"@(="$&%"6-(('6&$-(">$&9"&9'"

,9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&E"C9'?"@==+'%%5";-+"$(%&@(6'5"&9'":@6B"-;"6-(%'(%7%"@0-()%&"6@(=$=@&'"

&9'-+$'%"@(="9->"B(->:'=)'"6@("1'")@$('=";+-0"+'%'@+69"%&7=$'%E"

C-"%700@+$%'5"&9'",9'(-0'(@"7(='+"$(*'%&$)@&$-(5"$E'E"69@()'%"$("970@(%W"+'@6&$-(%"=7'"&-"

&9'"%&$07:7%"6@7%'="1?"69@+@6&'+$%&$6%"-+"=$;;'+'(&"6-(;$)7+@&$-(%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&5"

6@("1'"'X,:@$('="$("=$;;'+'(&">@?%"@66-+=$()"&-"&9'"-1%'+*'="-7&6-0'E"J+-0"&9'",+'%'(&'="

&9'-+$'%"$&"6@("1'"%@$="&9@&Y"

• "C9'"17$:&"@(="%-6$@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@((-&"1'"6-(%$='+'="@%"%',@+@&'"'(*$+-(0'(&%""

• C9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"$%",'+6'$*'="&9+-7)9"&9'"7%'"-;"-7+"%'(%'%5">9$69"%&$07:@&'"-7+"

6-)($&$-("$("&9'";$+%&",:@6'"

• L-)($&$-("6@("1'"%&$07:@&'=">9'("&9'"p(@&7+@:W"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"1@:@(6'"$%"=$%&7+1'=5"

&9+-7)9"&9'"p+'@=@1$:$&?W"-;"&9'";'@&7+'%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"-+"&9+-7)9"970@(%W"

Page 21: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"4g"

,+$-+$&$'%E"K->'*'+5"&9'",@+@0'&'+%">9$69"'%&@1:$%9"1@:@(6'5"+'@=@1$:$&?5"@(=",+$-+$&$'%"

@(=">9'&9'+"&9'?"*@+?";+-0",'+%-("&-",'+%-(">'+'"(-&"$='(&$;$'="$("&9'":$&'+@&7+'"

• C9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&%"6@7%'="1?"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"0@?":'@="&-"%71%'^7'(&"

,9?%$6@:"-+",9?%$-:-)$6@:"6-(%'^7'(6'%"

• J'@&7+'%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"&+$))'+$()"(')@&$*'"';;'6&%"@:%-"6@7%'"&9'"='*':-,0'(&"

-;"6-,$()"0'69@($%0%"

RPU 6',=O,,'%(**

C9'+'"$%"&9'"(''=";-+"+'%'@+69"&-"1'"7(='+&@B'("&9@&"$(*'%&$)@&'%"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&"-("&9'"'X,'+$'(6'"@(=">'::.1'$()"-;",@&$'(&%">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@E"M("&9'"

@1%'(6'"-;"@"%$)($;$6@(&"1-=?"-;"+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"&9@&"%,'6$;$6@::?";-67%'%"-("&9'"='%$)("@(="

7%'"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"$&"$%"('6'%%@+?"&-"=+@>"7,-("

+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"&9@&"$(*'%&$)@&'%"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&"-("

,'-,:'">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@E"C9'"%@0'"$%%7'%"%769"@%"6-(;7%$-(5">@(='+$()5"=$%-+$'(&@&$-("

@(="@)$&@&$-("0@?"@;;'6&"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'">@?"&9'?"(@*$)@&'"@(="+'%,-(="&-"

&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$("1-&9"+'%$='(&$@:"@(="@67&'"6@+'"%'&&$()%E"/-0'"-;"&9'"%-:7&$-(%"&9@&"@+'"

7%'="$("+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"%'&&$()%"@+'"&+@(%;'+@1:'"&-"@67&'"6@+'"%'&&$()%5";-+"'X@0,:'"&9'"7%'"

-;"=$;;'+'(&";:--+"6-:-7+%"&-"9$)9:$)9&"&9'"&+@(%$&$-(";+-0"-('"@+'@"&-"@(-&9'+"N_7&0@(5"

233hOE""

T*$='(6'"1@%'=",+@6&$6'"+'^7$+'%"&9'"$(&')+@&$-("-;"&9'"1'%&"@*@$:@1:'"+'%'@+69";$(=$()%5"&9'"

,@&$'(&%W"'X,'+$'(6'"@(="&9'",+@6&$&$-('+%W"'X,'+&$%'"N/@6B'&&5"2333OE"M&"0@?"1'"('6'%%@+?"&-"

$(&')+@&'"+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'";+-0"%&7=$'%"-;"&9'"+'%$='(&$@:"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&">$&9"'*$='(6'"

;+-0",@&$'(&%W"N@(="&9'$+";@0$:?O"@(=",+@6&$&$-('+%"&-")'('+@&'"&9'"'*$='(6'"1@%'";-+"&9'"

='%$)("-;"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%"7(&$:"@">$='+"1-=?"-;"9-%,$&@:";-67%'="+'%'@+69";$(=$()%"@+'"

@*@$:@1:'E"C9'"7%'"-;"p:$%&'($()"'*'(&%W"@&&'(='="1?",'-,:'">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@5"&9'$+"

;@0$:$'%5"@(="$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%5"9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'">-+B'+%5"@+69$&'6&%"@(="='%$)('+%"

@0-()%&"-&9'+"%&@B'9-:='+%5"$%"@("@,,+-@69"&9@&"6@("6@,&7+'"&9'"'X,'+$'(6'"@(="'X,'+&$%'"

-;",@&$'(&%"@(=",+@6&$&$-('+%"@:$B'E"C9'"'*$='(6'"6-::@&'=";+-0"%769"'*'(&%5"6@("&9'("1'"7%'="

&-"$(;-+0"a7=)'0'(&%"@1-7&"&9'"&+@(%;'+@1$:$&?"-;"+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"1'&>''("6@+'"%'&&$()%E"

C9'"+'0@$(='+"-;"&9$%"+',-+&"='&@$:%"&9'"7(='+&@B$()"@(=";$(=$()%";+-0"%769"@":$%&'($()"'*'(&"

@%"@"0'@(%"-;"%9@+$()"$(%$)9&%"@(="$(;-+0$()";7&7+'"+'%'@+69"@(="@6&$-("$("&9'";$':="-;"

='0'(&$@"6@+'">$&9$("&9'"17$:&"9'@:&96@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&E"

Page 22: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"23"

""

U <+0*K!C<07!7L*0F07<*B33?EBA+*

C9'"-('.=@?"'*'(&"6-0,+$%'="@"+@()'"-;"&'69($^7'%"&-"'()@)'",@+&$6$,@(&%"$("$(;-+0@:5"

;@6$:$&@&'="@6&$*$&$'%"&-",+-0,&"=$%67%%$-("-("&-,$6%"-;"$0,-+&@(6'"&-"&9'0"@(="&9'"'*'(&"

;@6$:$&@&-+%E"A9$:%&"(-&"+'%'@+695"&9'"'*'(&"=$="@::->"7%"&-")@&9'+"@"+@()'"-;"$(;-+0@&$-(5"

;''=1@6B5",'+%-(@:"'X,'+$'(6'%"@(="$(%$)9&%";+-0",@+&$6$,@(&%E"M("&-&@:5"%'*'(&?"%'*'(",'-,:'"

&--B",@+&"$("&9'"'*'(&"$(6:7=$()"&9'";@6$:$&@&-+%"@(="(-&'"&@B'+%E""

J-+"&9'",7+,-%'%"-;"-+)@($%$()"&9'"=@?5"@::",@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"6@&')-+$%'="@%"+',+'%'(&$()"

;-7+"6-+'"%&@B'9-:='+")+-7,%Y",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"6@+'+%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"9'@:&9"

@(="%-6$@:"6@+'",+-;'%%$-(@:%"@(="='%$)('+%E"M("+'@:$&?5"&9'%'"6@&')-+$'%">'+'"-*'+:@,,$()"@%"

0@(?",@+&$6$,@(&%"%,@(('="0-+'"&9@("-('"'E)E"='%$)('+%"@(="9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'"

,+-;'%%$-(@:%">'+'"@:%-"6@+'+%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"_+-7,$()",@+&$6$,@(&%"$("&9$%">@?"

%$0,:?"'(@1:'="7%"&-"1'"6-(;$='(&"&9@&"@"+@()'"-;"=$;;'+'(&",'+%,'6&$*'%">-7:="1'")@$('="

@(="&9@&"(-"-('")+-7,$()">@%"7(='+.+',+'%'(&'="-+"p)$*'(":'%%"-;"@"*-$6'WE"j$'>%">'+'"

)@$('=";+-0"&9'"[[",'-,:'"&9@&"@&&'(='="&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&"@%"='%6+$1'="1':->E"

• `",'-,:'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"

• 43"$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"N'E)E";@0$:?"0'01'+%O"

• `3"9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'",+-;'%%$-(@:%"$(*-:*'="$("=':$*'+$()"6@+'"%'+*$6'%";-+",'-,:'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@"

• Z",'-,:'"$(*-:*'="$("='%$)($()"%,@6'%";-+"&9-%'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"

• 23"@6@='0$6%"$(*'%&$)@&$()"%-0'"@%,'6&"-;"='0'(&$@"6@+'"N[",@+&$6$,@&'="@%"(-&'"&@B'+%5"

["@%";@6$:$&@&-+%5"4"@%"'*'(&"L9@$+"@(="h",@+&$6$,@&'="$("&9'"='1@&'OE"

_+-7,"=$%67%%$-(%">'+'"-+)@($%'="$(&-"&9+''"6-(%'67&$*'"%'%%$-(%E"T@69"&@1:'"9@="@"

;@6$:$&@&-+">9-"9@="1''(",+',@+'=";-+"&9'"+-:'"$("@=*@(6'5"@(=">9-"'(%7+'="&9@&"'@69"

,@+&$6$,@(&"9@="@"69@(6'"&-"6-(&+$17&'"$;"&9'?">$%9'=E"Q::"&@1:'%">'+'"'^7$,,'=">$&9"@"=$)$&@:"

@7=$-.+'6-+='+5";-7+"6-:-7+%"-;",-%&.$&"(-&'%5";:$,.69@+&%",@=%"@(=",'(%E"Q("$(=$*$=7@:">@%"

@:%-",+'%'(&">9-"9@="1''(",+',@+'=",+$-+"&-"&9'"'*'(&"&-"@6&"@%"@"(-&'"&@B'+5">$&9"

Page 23: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"24"

$(%&+76&$-("&-"1'"@%"='&@$:'="@%",-%%$1:'"&-"'(@1:'"6:@+$&?"-;"0'@($()"&-"1'")+@%,'="@;&'+"&9'"

'*'(&E"/700@+?"(-&'%"-;"&9$%"B$(="6@("-;&'(":@6B"0'@($()"@;&'+"@("'*'(&"@(="%-"'@69"

=$%67%%$-(">@%"@:%-"@7=$-.+'6-+='=">$&9",'+0$%%$-("-;"&9-%'",+'%'(&5"%$0,:?"&-"'(@1:'"0-+'"

@667+@&'"+',-+&$()E""

S+$-+"&-"=$%67%%$-(%5"@%"@">@+0.7,"'X'+6$%'5",@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'")$*'("@"23"0$(7&'%"-*'+*$'>"

-;"&9'",7+,-%'"-;"&9'"=@?"@(="$&%";-+0@&E"T@69"=$%67%%$-("%'%%$-("$%";7+&9'+"='%6+$1'="1':->E"

UPN 6',=O,,'%(*C1,,'%(*E(1*

M("&9'";$+%&"=$%67%%$-(")+-7,",@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'",+'%'(&'=">$&9"@",+$(&'="%'&"-;"43"

,9-&-)+@,9%"=',$6&$()"=$;;'+'(&"@+'@%"-;"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"C9'",9-&-)+@,9%">'+'"-;"

&+@=$&$-(@:"9-%,$&@:"%'&&$()%"@%">'::"@%"0-='+(5"@>@+=">$(($()"='%$)(%E"S$6&7+'%">'+'"%9->("

&-"%&$07:@&'"=$%67%%$-("@(=")@7)'",@+&$6$,@(&"+'@6&$-(%"@1-7&">9@&";@6&-+%"&9'?";':&">-+B'="

>'::"@(=":'%%">'::"$("&9-%'"'(*$+-(0'(&%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5";+-0"&9'$+"=$;;'+'(&"

,'+%,'6&$*'%E""

S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"@::-6@&'="@"6-:-7+'=5"@=9'%$*'.1@6B'="=-&"&-"+',+'%'(&"&9'"%&@B'9-:='+"

)+-7,"&9'?"1':-()'="&-"@(="=$+'6&'="&-"@"&@1:'";-+0'="1?"@"0$X"-;"=$;;'+'(&"%&@B'9-:='+%E"

C9'?">'+'"@%B'="&-"6-(%$='+">9'&9'+"&9'",9-&-)+@,9%"=',$6&'="%'&&$()%"&9@&"&9'?"1':$'*'="

>-7:="9':,"-+"9$(='+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"C9'?">'+'"@:%-"@%B'="&-"=$%67%%"@(="%9@+'"

$%%7'%">$&9"-&9'+%"@1-7&"&9'$+"'X,'+$'(6'%"-;"6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"@%B'="&-"

$(=$*$=7@::?">+$&'"&9'$+",-%$&$*'"'X,'+$'(6'%"-(")+''(",-%&.$&"(-&'%"@(="(')@&$*'"-('%"-(",$(B"

-('%E""

Q==$&$-(@:"'X,'+$'(6'%"@(="$%%7'%"+@$%'="&9@&">'+'"(-&"=$+'6&:?"+':@&'="&-"&9'",9-&-)+@,9%"

>'+'"6@,&7+'="-("1:7'",-%&.$&"(-&'%"@(=",:@6'="-(&-"@"%9''&"-;";:$,"69@+&",@,'+"@&"&9'"'(="-;"

&9'"=$%67%%$-("%'%%$-(E""

T@69")+-7,"$='(&$;$'="&9'"&>-"0-%&"$0,-+&@(&"$%%7'%"&9@&"&9'?">$%9'="&-"%9@+'">$&9"&9'"

0@$("@7=$'(6'5">9$69">@%"=-('"1?">+$&$()"&9'%'"-(";7+&9'+",-%&.$&"(-&'%"@(="=$%,:@?$()"

&9'0"6-::'6&$*':?"-("-('">@::"-;"&9'"+--0E""

Page 24: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"22"

U7'"&-"&9'"*$%7@:"(@&7+'"-;"&9$%"@6&$*$&?5"=$%67%%$-(%">'+'"*$='-.&@,'="@%">'::"@%"@7=$-.&@,'="

;-+"@667+@&'"+',-+&$()E""

]('"-;"&9'"'*'(&":'@=%"&9'("&9'0'="&9'%'",+$-+$&?"$%%7'%"$(&-"'$)9&"B'?",@$+%"&9@&">'+'"&9'("

=$%&+$17&'="&-",@+&$6$,@(&%"&-";-67%"-("$("&9'"('X&"%'&"-;"=$%67%%$-(%E"C9'"&-,$6%"&9@&"'0'+)'="

$("&9'";$+%&"%'%%$-("&9@&">'+'"6-(%$='+'="@%"@",+$-+$&?"@(="=$%67%%'="$("/'%%$-("2">'+'Y"

4E K->"=-"M";$(="0?">@?s"

2E /&@;;"@(=",'+%-(@:"'()@)'0'(&"N$(6:7='%"6@+'"+':@&'="$%%7'%"@%"-,,-%'="&-"G7$:&"

T(*$+-(0'(&O""

ZE K->"6@("M";'':"%@;'s"

`E K'@:&9R"9?)$'('R"$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:""

hE I--0">$&9"@"*$'>"

\E M&W%"&--"(-$%?""

[E D%$()"6-:-7+"

lE C--"0769"6:7&&'+"

gE ]&9'+",+$-+$&$'%"."6-01$('="%'+*$6'%"N$(6:7='"0'(&@:"9'@:&9O5"6@+'+"$(*-:*'0'(&"$("6@+'5"

6-%&"';;'6&$*'('%%"

UPR 6',=O,,'%(*C1,,'%(*<4%*

M("&9$%"%'%%$-(5",@+&$6$,@(&%"6-7:="69--%'">9'+'"&9'?"%@&"@(="%-",'+%,'6&$*'%">'+'"0$X'=E"

S@+&$6$,@(&%"%':'6&'=">9$69"-;"&9'"&-,$6%"='+$*'=";+-0"U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("45"&9@&"&9'?">$%9'="

&-"=$%67%%"$(")+'@&'+"=',&9E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"@:%-"@%B'="9->"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%"6-7:="

1'"$0,+-*'=";-+",'-,:'">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@E"C9'";-67%"-;"'@69"=$%67%%$-(">@%"-("$='(&$;?$()"

>9@&"6-7:="1'"=-('"&-",+-*$='"2*4+93*,2.*).37F)*6878,92"&-"&9'"$%%7'%"$='(&$;$'="$("

U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("4E""

C-",+-0,&"=$%67%%$-(5"@";7+&9'+"%'&"-;"-(:?"@>@+=">$(($()"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"

,9-&-)+@,9%">@%")$*'("&-"'@69")+-7,E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'",+-0,&'="&-"6-(%$='+">9'&9'+"&9'"

9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%"=',$6&'="$("&9'",9-&-)+@,9%">-7:="9':,"-+"9$(='+",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@E""

Page 25: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2Z"

C9'+'">@%";7+&9'+"=$%67%%$-("@1-7&"&9'$+"->("@(="@('6=-&@:"'X,'+$'(6'%"-;"6@+'"

'(*$+-(0'(&%E"S@+&$6$,@(&%"a-&&'="&9'$+",-%$&$*'"'X,'+$'(6'%"-(")+''(",-%&.$&"(-&'%"@(="

(')@&$*'"-('%"-(",$(B"-('%E"/-:7&$-(%"-+"$0,+-*'0'(&%"&9@&">'+'",+-,-%'="17&"(-&"+':@&'="

&-"&9'",9-&-)+@,9%">'+'"6@,&7+'="-("1:7'",-%&.$&"(-&'%"@(="@&&@69'="&-"@"%9''&"-;";:$,"69@+&"

,@,'+E""

T@69")+-7,">@%"@%B'="&-"@)+''"@0-()%&"&9'05"&9'$+"&>-"0-%&"$0,-+&@(&"=$%67%%$-(",-$(&%E"

C9'%'">'+'"@)@$("6-::@&'=";+-0"@::"&@1:'%"%-"&9@&"@::",@+&$6$,@(&%"6-7:=":--B"@&"&9'%'">9'("

=$%,:@?'="-("@"%$():'">@::"$("&9'"+--0E"Q"*'+1@:"%700@+?">@%")$*'("1?"&9'"'*'(&"L9@$+"@&"&9'"

'(="-;"&9'"%'%%$-(E""

P'?"$%%7'%"@(=",+-1:'0%"$='(&$;$'="$("U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("45"@%">'::"@%"B'?"%-:7&$-(%"$='(&$;$'="

$("U$%67%%$-("/'%%$-("25">'+'"=$%,:@?'="-(";:$,.69@+&%"@(=",@+&$6$,@(&%"@%B'="&-"$='(&$;?"&9'"Z"

0-%&"+':'*@(&"-('%E"J-+"&9$%",7+,-%'5"@("@+1$&+@+?"0'@(%"-;"$='(&$;?$()">9$69"$%%7'%">'+'"-;"

0-%&"6-(6'+(">@%"7(='+&@B'(">9'+'1?",@+&$6$,@(&%",:@6'="&9'$+"@::-6@&$-("-;"h"6-:-7+'="

%':;.@=9'%$*'"=-&%"@)@$(%&"&9'"$%%7'"-;"&9'$+"69-$6'E"C9'?"6-7:=",7&"-('"-+"@::"-;"&9'$+"%&$6B'+%"

-("@("$%%7'E"C9$%">@%";-::->'="1?"@"%$0,:'"6-7(&$()"'X'+6$%'"&-"%''">9'+'",@+&$6$,@(&%"9@="

,:@6'="&9'$+"h"%&$6B'+%E"C9'"6-:-7+"6-=$()"@:%-"'(@1:'="&9'"%,+'@="-;"6-(6'+(%"-;"=$;;'+'(&"

%&@B'9-:='+")+-7,%"&-"1'"$='(&$;$'=E"

UPU 6',=O,,'%(*C1,,'%(*<5$11*

C9$%"=$%67%%$-("%'%%$-(";-::->'="@"%$0$:@+",+-6'%%"&-"&9'"-&9'+"&>-"%'%%$-(%"@(=";-67%'="-("

$='(&$;?$()">9@&"6-7:="1'":'@+(&";+-0"&9'"9-0'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="(-(.9-%,$&@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&%E"C9+''"&9'0'%">'+'"$(&+-=76'="1?"&9'"'*'(&";@6$:$&@&-+%"&-";-67%"=$%67%%$-(Y"@O"

$(=','(='(&":$*$()"@&"9-0'V"1O"&9'"-7&=--+"'(*$+-(0'(&V"@(="6O"@%%$%&$*'"&'69(-:-)?E"

S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"@%B'="&-"a-$("@"&@1:'"&-,$6"&9@&"&9'?";':&"1'%&"@1:'"&-"6-(&+$17&'"&-"-+"9@="@"

,'+%-(@:"$(&'+'%&"$(E"S@+&$6$,@(&%"=$%67%%'="&9'"$%%7'%5",+-1:'0%"@(="%-:7&$-(%"-;"&9'"9-0'"

'(*$+-(0'(&5"@66-+=$()"&-"&9'%'"&9+''"&9'0'%"@(="9->"&9'?"6-7:="1'"7%'=R@=@,&'="$("

9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"@)@$("'(6-7+@)'="&-"%9@+'"&9'$+"->("'X,'+$'(6'%"

@(="$(%$)9&%E"S@+&$6$,@(&W%"$(=$*$=7@:",-%$&$*'"'X,'+$'(6'%">'+'"a-&&'="-(&-")+''(",-%&.$&"

(-&'%"@(="(')@&$*'"-('%"-(",$(B"-('%E"T@69")+-7,">@%"@%B'="&-"@)+''"&9'"&>-"0-%&"

Page 26: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2`"

$0,-+&@(&"$%%7'%"@(=R-+"%-:7&$-(%"&9@&"&9'?"9@="=$%67%%'=E"C9'%'">'+'"&9'("%9@+'=">$&9"&9'"

0@$("@7=$'(6'"@&"&9'"'(="-;"&9'"%'%%$-(E"

UPV B(./;,',*B##$%.=5*

Q"07:&$.=$%6$,:$(@+?"&'@0"6-0,+$%$()"&>-"@6@='0$6%";+-0"&9'"/69--:"-;"87+%$()5"<$=>$;'+?"

@(="/-6$@:"A-+B"@(="&>-"@6@='0$6%"@(="@"+'%'@+69'+";+-0"&9'"/69--:"-;"&9'"G7$:&"

T(*$+-(0'(&"@&"&9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="7(='+&--B"@(@:?%$%"-;"'*'(&"=$%67%%$-(%E""C9'"

@(@:?%$%">@%"6@++$'="-7&">$&9"@";-67%"-("6@,&7+$()"&9'"6-(&'(&"-;">9@&",'-,:'"&-:="7%"@(="

'%&@1:$%9$()"&9'",@+&$6$,@(&%W"%'(%'"-;",+$-+$&?E"""

C9'"@(@:?%$%"1')@("1?":$%&$()"&9'"$='(&$;$'="$%%7'%5",+-1:'0%"@(="%-:7&$-(%"$='(&$;$'="1?"

,@+&$6$,@(&%E"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"@(@:?%$%"7%'="@("@=@,&'="*'+%$-("-;"&9'"p$0,@6&%"-;"&9'",9?%$6@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&"-("0'(&@:">'::.1'$()W";+@0'>-+B"@%"='*$%'="1?"L--,'+"89.%4M"N233lOE"C9$%"

;+@0'>-+B"$%"='%6+$1'="$("&9'":$&'+@&7+'"+'*$'>"%'6&$-("-;"&9$%"+',-+&E"M("@==$&$-("&-"&9'";-7+"

&9'0'%"$='(&$;$'="1?"L--,'+"89.%4"N233lO5"&9+''"('>"&9'0'%"'0'+)'=";+-0"&9'":$%&'($()"

'*'(&E"

C9'0'%"$='(&$;$'="1?"L--,'+"89.%4"N233lOY"

• J@1+$6"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&""

• Q01$'(6'"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"

• S%?69-:-)$6@:"M0,@6&"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"

• /-6$-:-)$6@:"M0,@6&"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&"

8'>"@==$&$-(@:"&9'0'%"$='(&$;$'=";+-0":$%&'($()"'*'(&Y"

• J7(6&$-(@:"Q6&$*$&$'%"@(="/@;'&?"

• M(;-+0@&$-("@(="L-007($6@&$-("

• Q,,+-@69'%"&-"L@+'"

K'+'"$%"@("-*'+*$'>"-;"&9'"6-0,-%$&$-("-;"&9'"&9+''"('>"&9'0'%Y"

M(;-+0@&$-("@(="L-007($6@&$-(Y*C9$%"&9'0'">@%"@1-7&")$*$()"@(="+'6'$*$()"$(;-+0@&$-(5"

%$)(@)'5"@%%'%%0'(&5"*$%7@:"67'$()E"C9'"&@+)'&"@7=$'(6'"-;"$(;-+0@&$-("@(="6-007($6@&$-("

Page 27: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2h"

0@?"1'";-+",@&$'(&%5"*$%$&-+%"-+"%&@;;E""M(;-+0@&$-("@(="6-007($6@&$-("0@?"1'"@1-7&",7+,-%'"

-;"+--0%5"%,@6'5"$(%&+76&$-(%";-+"6@+'5",'+%-(@:",+';'+'(6'%5"9'@:&9"@(="%@;'&?5"=$+'6&$-(%E"

M(;-+0@&$-("@(="6-007($6@&$-("0@?"1'"*$%7@:5">+$&&'("-+"@7+@:E"C9'"(@&7+'"-;"$(;-+0@&$-("

@(="6-007($6@&$-("0@?"1'"6-(;$='(&$@:"-+"-,'("@66'%%"@(="+'^7$+'="1?"@::"7%'+%"-;"9-%,$&@:"

'(*$+-(0'(&%E"

J7(6&$-(@:"Q6&$*$&$'%"@(="/@;'&?Y*C9$%"&9'0'">@%"@1-7&"&9'"=@?.&-.=@?"@6&$*$&$'%"-;",'-,:'"

>9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@Y"'@&$()5"=+$(B$()5"7%$()"&-$:'&%5"9?)$'('5">@:B$()"@(="+'6+'@&$-(@:"

@6&$*$&$'%E"J7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&?"-;",'-,:'">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@"0@?"1'"+'=76'="1?"*$%7@:5"

9'@+$()5"07%67:@+.%B':'&@:"@(="('7+-:-)$6@:"$0,@$+0'(&%E"C9'"&9'0'"$(6:7='%"+':@&'="

@++@()'0'(&%"@(="@6&$*$&$'%"&9@&"0$($0$%'"+$%B"-;"9@+0"&-",@&$'(&%5"%&@;;"@(="*$%$&-+%E"M&"

$(6:7='%"&9'"@66',&'=":'*':"-;"+$%B"%&@&'="$("9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'",-:$6?5":@>"-+"@)+''="1?"

6-(%'(%7%"-;"%&@;;E"M&"$(6:7='%"@++@()'0'(&%"@(="@6&$*$&$'%"&9@&"0@$(&@$("&9'",9?%$6@:5"

'0-&$-(@:5",%?69-:-)$6@:"@(="%-6$-:-)$6@:">'::.1'$()"-;",@&$'(&%E"

"Q,,+-@69'%"&-"L@+'Y*C9$%"&9'0'"'X,:-+'%"@"+@()'"-;"$%%7'%",'+&$('(&"&-"&9'",+-*$%$-("-;"6@+'"

$(6:7=$()"%&+@&')$'%5"6@+'"$(&'+*'(&$-(%5"@%%$%&$*'"&'69(-:-)?5"(7+%'"'=76@&$-(5"=$)($&?5"

,+$*@6?"@(="6-(;$='(&$@:$&?">$&9"+')@+=%"&-"6@+'"-;",@&$'(&%">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@E"*

J+-0"&9'"=$%67%%$-("=@&@5"&9'"&'@0",-,7:@&'="&9'"["-*'+@+69$()"&9'0'%",+'*$-7%:?"

$='(&$;$'=">$&9$("&9'":$&'+@&7+'"@(=";+-0"&9'$+"->("=':$1'+@&$-(%E"M(&'+,+'&@&$-(%">'+'"

6-0,@+'="@(="6-(&+@%&'=";+-0"@"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="9'@:&9"6@+'",'+%,'6&$*'E"C9'%'"@+'"

&9'0'%"@+'",+'%'(&'="$("/'6&$-("`E""

U7+$()"@(@:?%$%"@"(701'+"-;"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%">'+'"$='(&$;$'="1'&>''("&9'"+'^7$+'0'(&%"-;"@"

,'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(=">9@&">@%"=''0'="@%"%7$&@1:'";-+"@("@67&'"6@+'"%'&&$()E"J-+"

$(%&@(6'"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?">@(&"$(=','(='(6'"@(=";+''=-0"9->'*'+"$("@("@67&'"

6@+'"%'&&$()"&9$%"6@(",-%'"=@()'+%"@(="%-"&9$%"+@$%'%"+$%B"@(="%@;'&?"$%%7'%E"Q":$%&"@(="

='%6+$,&$-("-;"&9'%'"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"6@("1'";-7(="$("/'6&$-("`EgE"

Page 28: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2\"

""

V CZMMB?8*ED*D!76!7LC*

C9$%"%'6&$-(",+'%'(&%"@"%700@+?"-;"&9'"$%%7'%"&9@&"@+-%'"=7+$()"=$%67%%$-("/'%%$-(%"4"@(="2E"

L-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"@+'"@:%-",+'%'(&'="&->@+=%"&9'"'(="-;"'@69"%'6&$-(">9'+'"+':'*@(&E""

VPN D.I$'=*%2*-51*0(&'$%("1(-*

M("+')@+=%"&-"&9'";@1+$6"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&5"%'*'+@:"$%%7'%">'+'"+@$%'="$(6:7=$()"&9'"7%'"-;"

-7&=--+"%,@6'%5"&9'"7%'"-;"@='^7@&'"6-:-7+"%69'0'%5",@&&'+(%"-;">@::%"@(=";:--+$()5"

>@?;$(=$()5"@66'%%$1$:$&?5"$(=$*$=7@:",+';'+'(6'"@(="-667,@&$-(E"

C9'"=$%67%%$-(%"+':@&'="&-"-7&=--+"%,@6'"N0-%&:?"@1-7&")@+='(%O"$(=$6@&'="&9@&"&9$%"$%"

,'+6'$*'="@%"9@*$()"&9'+@,'7&$6"^7@:$&$'%E"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"9@*$()"@66'%%"&-"&9'"-7&=--+%"@(="

@",:'@%@(&"*$'>"$%"*'+?"$0,-+&@(&";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"@%"@"%-7+6'"-;"+':@X@&$-(E"

U'%,$&'"$&%",'+6'$*'=",-%$&$*'"$0,@6&5"&9'+'"@+'"$%%7'%"+':@&'="&-"@66'%%"$("&'+0%"-;"">9'&9'+"

-+"(-&"@66'%%"(''=%"&-"1'"0-($&-+'=5"&97%"+'*'@:$()"6-(;:$6&$()"%@;'&?"@(="$(=','(='(6'"

+'^7$+'0'(&%E"

L-:-7+">@%"@("$%%7'"0'(&$-('="0@(?"&$0'%"&9+-7)9-7&"&9$%"'X'+6$%'E"C9'"p>+-()W"7%'"-;"

6-:-7+"$%",'+6'$*'="@%"@"6@7%'";-+"6-(;7%$-(5";@::%"@(="=$%-+$'(&@&$-(E"C9'"p6-++'6&W"7%'"6@("

9':,">$&9">@?;$(=$()"@(="'0-&$-(%E"C9'+'">@%"6-(%'(%7%"&9@&"&9'"7%'"-;"$(6+'@%'="

p6-(&+@%&W"%''0%"&-",+-*$='"%7,,-+&"&-",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"I':@&'="&-"6-:-7+5",@&&'+(%"

>'+'"$("&9'"0@$("%''("@%"@"(')@&$*'";'@&7+'";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@5">9'&9'+"&9'?"@+'"

-("&9'";:--+5"67+&@$(%"-+"6'$:$()E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">9-"9@="='0'(&$@"6-00'(&'="&9@&"6-:-7+"@(="

,@&&'+("&9@&"&9'?"6-(%$='+'="&-"1'":$B'"&9@&";-7(="$("p(@&7+'W">'+'",+';'+@1:'"&-">9@&"&9'?"

6-(%$='+'="@%"1'$()"p@+&$;$6$@:WE""

J7+&9'+0-+'5">@?;$(=$()">@%"0'(&$-('="@%"-('"B'?"6-(&+$17&-+"&-"%&+'%%E"S@+&$6$,@(&%"9@*'"

='6:@+'="&9@&">@?;$(=$()"(''=%"&-"1'"6:'@+"@(="%$0,:'"."(-&"&--"0769"$(;-+0@&$-(5"@&"&9'"

+$)9&":'*':"N'?'"%$)9&O"@(="(-&"&--"0@(?"6-:-7+%E"M("&9$%"'X'+6$%'5"$&">@%"(-&",-%%$1:'"&-")@&9'+"

Page 29: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2["

@"0'@($();7:"0'@%7+'";-+"&9'"+$)9&"@0-7(&"-;"$(;-+0@&$-(5":'*':"-+"&9'"(701'+"-;"6-:-7+%E"M("

&9$%"+'%,'6&5",@+&$6$,@(&%W"-,$($-(">@%"=$*$='="@%"&-">9'&9'+"6-:-7+"6-=$()">@%"@",-%$&$*'"-+"

@"(')@&$*'";'@&7+'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E""

Q==$&$-(@:"$%%7'%">'+'"@:%-"=$%67%%'="$("+':@&$-("&-"@66'%%$1$:$&?"@(=",+';'+'(6'E"Q66'%%$1$:$&?"

&-";@6$:$&$'%">$&9$("&9'"9-%,$&@:"%769"@%"&9'"&-$:'&"@(="-7&=--+"%,@6'"(''=%"&-"1'"'@%?5"

@66-+=$()"&-",@+&$6$,@(&%E"T@%?"@66'%%";-+",@+&$6$,@(&%">@%"+':@&'="&-">@?;$(=$()"@(=",+-,'+"

%$)(@)'5"17&"@:%-"&-"@7&9-+$%@&$-("-;"@66'%%E"J-+"$(%&@(6'5"%-0'",@+&$6$,@(&%"0'(&$-('="&9@&"

%-0'"6@+'";@6$:$&$'%"-;;'+")@+='(%";-+"%&@;;"17&"(-&",@&$'(&%E"C9$%"%71a'6&"&+$))'+'="=$%67%%$-(%"

+')@+=$()"$(=$*$=7@:",+';'+'(6'%E"C9'"=$%67%%$-("1+-7)9&"&-":$)9&"&9@&"&9'"='%$)("-;"

9'@:&96@+'";@6$:$&$'%"(''=%"&-"'(%7+'"&9'?"@+'";7(6&$-(@:5"6:$($6@:5"%@;'"@(="@6B(->:'=)'"&9@&"

$&"$%"(-&",-%%$1:'"&-"6@&'+"&-"6'+&@$("$(=$*$=7@:",+';'+'(6'%"N'E)E"6-0;-+&5"%&?:'O5"@%"c-('"%$e'"

=-'%"(-&";$&"@::dE"C9'"6-7(&'+"@+)70'(&">@%"&9@&"(-&"@&&'(=$()"&-",'-,:'W%",+';'+'(6'%"0@?"

:'@="&-"@66$='(&%5"%769"@%";@::$()"6@7%'="1?"&9'"p$(6-++'6&W"7%'"-;"6-:-7+5"0@&'+$@:5",@&&'+("

@(=":$)9&$()">9$69"6@("$("&7+(":'@="&-"0-+'"%'+$-7%"9'@:&9",+-1:'0%E""""

Q"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'"&9@&"'0'+)'="=7+$()"=$%67%%$-(%">@%"+':@&'="&-"+'^7$+'0'(&%";-+"@"0-+'"

@'%&9'&$6@::?",:'@%$()"'(*$+-(0'(&"68)2+2"@("'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&"%7,,-+&%"'@%?"$(;'6&$-("

6-(&+-:E"]("&9'"-('"9@(=5",@&$'(&%"@(="6@+'+%";':&"&9@&"@"0-+'"+':@X$()"'(*$+-(0'(&"$%"-('"

&9@&"+'%'01:'%"&9'"9-0'"'(*$+-(0'(&E"]("&9'"-&9'+"9@(=5"6:$($6@:"%&@;;"@+)7'="&9@&"@("

'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&"$%"6:7&&'+'=">$&9",'+%-(@:"&9$()%"$(",7+%7$&"-;"6+'@&$()"p9-0':$('%%W5"6@("1'"

9@e@+=-7%"@(="0@B'"$&"=$;;$67:&"&-"$0,:'0'(&"$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:"0'@%7+'%E"

VPR B"I'1(=1*%2*-51*0(&'$%("1(-**

M("+':@&$-("&-"&9'"@01$'(6'"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&5"%$0$:@+"$%%7'%"'0'+)'="=7+$()"&9'"=$%67%%$-("

%'%%$-(%E"L:7&&'+5";-+"$(%&@(6'5">9$69"6@("1'"$("@"&-$:'&5"-("@"1'=%$='"&@1:'5"$("@"6-++$=-+5"-("@"

;:--+"-+"$("@")@+='(5">@%",'+6'$*'="@%"@==$()"&-"&9'"6-(;7%$-("-;"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@5"

>9$69"6@(":'@="&-";@::%"@(="%&+'%%E"

#$)9&$()">@%"@(-&9'+"69@+@6&'+$%&$6"0'(&$-('="@0-()%&",@+&$6$,@(&%E"M&">@%"=$%67%%'="&9@&"

:$)9&$()"(''=%"&-"1'"@&"&9'"+$)9&":'*':";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"@%"'$&9'+"'X&+'0'"N&--"

0769"-+"&--":$&&:'O"6@("6@7%'"=$%-+$'(&@&$-(5">9$69"@)@$("6@(":'@="&-";@::%E"_:@+'5"$(",@+&$67:@+"

Page 30: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2l"

>@%"0'(&$-('="@%"@"&+$))'+"-;"(')@&$*'"';;'6&%E"8@&7+@:":$)9&$()"%9-7:="@:%-"1'"6-(%$='+'="$("

&9'"='%$)("-;"9'@:&96@+'";@6$:$&$'%E"A'::.:$&"6-++$=-+%"@(="1'=+--0%">'+'"6-(%$='+'="

$0,-+&@(&"$("%&$07:@&$()",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"&-">@:B"@(="'()@)'"$(",9?%$6@:"@(="%-6$@:"

@6&$*$&?E"

8-$%'">@%"@"69@+@6&'+$%&$6"&9@&"'0'+)'="@%"+':'*@(&";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"#-7="(-$%'5"

6-(&$(7@:"(-$%'"-+"a7%&")'('+@:"p97%&:'"@(="17%&:'W">@%"%7))'%&'="@%"1'$()"@"%-7+6'"-;")+'@&"

@)$&@&$-("&-"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"/-0'"%-:7&$-(%"%7))'%&'="&-"+'=76'"(-$%'":'*':%5"

+':@&'="&-"&9'"='%$)("-;";7+($&7+'"@(="='*$6'%"@(="7%'"-;";@1+$6"$("@">@?"&-"@1%-+1"(-$%'E"

L-:-7+">@%"@("$%%7'"$("1-&9"&9$%"&9'0'"@(="$("J@1+$6"-;"&9'"T(*$+-(0'(&E"M("&9'"67++'(&"

&9'0'5"7%'"-;"$&"+':@&'%"&-"$&%"$(6-++'6&"7%'5":'@=$()"&-";@::%"@(="=$%-+$'(&@&$-(E"C9$%"=$%67%%$-("

;-67%'="7,-("&9'"$0,@6&"-;"6-:-7+"-("'0-&$-(%"@(="9->"&9'?"6@("@))+@*@&'"-+"%--&9'E"M&"

>@%";7+&9'+",'+6'$*'="&9@&"6:$($6@:"@+'@%"6@("1'"p>@+0'=W"1?"6-:-7+5">$&9-7&"6-0,+-0$%$()"

9'@:&9"@(="%@;'&?E"8@&7+@:"6-:-7+%">'+'";@*-7+'="-*'+"@+&$;$6$@:"6-:-7+%E"C9'+'">@%"@"*$'>"

&9@&"9-%,$&@:%"(''="&-"0@B'")+'@&'+"7%'"-;"67++'(&"+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"-("&9'"&9'+@,'7&$6"7%'"

-;"6-:-7+E"

]7&=--+"%,@6'"$%"B(->(";-+"$&%"&9'+@,'7&$6"^7@:$&$'%E"M&">@%"@)@$("+@$%'="&9@&"9@*$()"@66'%%"&-"

@"*$'>"$%"*'+?"$0,-+&@(&";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"T0,9@%$%">@%",:@6'="-(";'':$()"@(="

%0'::$()"&9'"6-(&'(&"@(="%7++-7(=$()%"$("-7&=--+"%,@6'%E"""

Q(-&9'+";'@&7+'"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&">@%"=$%67%%'="$%"@+&E"Q+&">@%"*$'>'="@%"9@*$()"

,-%$&$*'"&9'+@,'7&$6"';;'6&%"-(",'-,:'E"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"-(:?"@"(@++->'+"6-(6',&"-;"@+&">@%"

6-(%$='+'="@(="0-%&:?"+':@&'="&-"9@*$()"@+&>-+B"N,$6&7+'%5"%67:,&7+'%5"07%$6O"@%"

6-0,:'0'(&$()"&9'"@01$'(6'E"K->'*'+5"@+&">@%"@:%-"N6-O"+':@&'="&-"$(=$*$=7@:",+';'+'(6'%"

+@&9'+"6-::'6&$*'"-('%E"M("+'%,'6&"&-"@66'%%"&-")@+='(%5"&9'"7%'"-;"=$)$&@:"$0@)'%">@%"

%7))'%&'=">9'+'"&9'+'"@+'":$0$&@&$-(%"+')@+=$()"@66'%%"&-"+'@:"-('%E""

L-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%"@+$%$()";+-0"&9'"=$%67%%$-(%">'+'"&9'"%@0'"@%"$("&9'",+'*$-7%"%'6&$-(E"

M%%7'%"@+-7(="@'%&9'&$6"6-0,-%$&$-("-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"N9$)9:$)9&'="1?",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%O"%''0'="6-(&+@=$6&-+?"&-";7(6&$-(@:$&?"$%%7'%"+@$%'="1?"6:$($6@:"

%&@;;E"Q:%-5"$%%7'%"+':@&'="&-"1@:@(6$()"+'%,'6&";-+"&9'"$(=','(='(6'"-;"$(=$*$=7@:%"@(="%@;'&?"

0'@%7+'%"&-",+-&'6&"&9'0E"

Page 31: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"2g"

VPU 3,;=5%/%)'=./*!"#.=-*%2*-51*0(&'$%("1(-**

C9'"(''=";-+"=$;;'+'(&"&?,'%"-;"%,@6'">@%"=$%67%%'="0@(?"&$0'%"=7+$()"&9'"=$%67%%$-("

%'%%$-(%E"T0,9@%$%">@%")$*'("&-"&9'"(''=";-+"1-&9"@"^7$'&"%,@6'"@(="@"%,@6'";-+"%-6$@:$%$()E"

M("+'%,'6&"-;"&9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&5"%,@6'%";-+"%-6$@:$%$()">'+'"%''("

@%"'%%'(&$@:"&-",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"K->'*'+5"&9+-7)9-7&"%-6$@:"$(&'+@6&$-(%"&9'",'+%-("

>$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"(''="^7$'&"%,@6'"&-"p='1+$';W"-+"+':@X"$;"&9'"%-6$@:"$(&'+@6&$-("9@%"6@7%'="

%-0'":'*':"-;"@(X$'&?"-+"@(-&9'+"(')@&$*'";'':$()E"

<-+'-*'+5"$&">@%"=$%67%%'="&9@&"%-0'"='%$)(";'@&7+'%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"0@?":'@="&-"

,'-,:'";'':$()"$0,+$%-('=E"M&">@%"+',-+&'="&9@&"6'+&@$("69@+@6&'+$%&$6%5"%769"@%"&9'"N$("

)'('+@:5"=@+BO"6-:-7+"@(=":$)9&$()5"@%">'::"@%"1@+%"-(">$(=->%"6@("&+$))'+";'':$()%"-;"

$0,+$%-(0'(&E""#$*$()"$(=','(='(&:?5"$&"'0'+)'=5"6-(&+$17&'%"&-"9$)9"%':;.'%&''0",7%9$()"

@>@?"&9'"%':;.@>@+'('%%"-;":$*$()">$&9"@"6-(=$&$-("N$E'E"='0'(&$@OE"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5">'"

$(&'+,+'&'="&9@&"@"%71&:'"%&$)0@"'X$%&%"&9@&"$%"+':@&'="&-"9@*$()"='0'(&$@"@(="=','(=$()"-("

-&9'+%"&-",'+;-+0"=@$:?"=-0'%&$6"&@%B%"N+$%B$()":'@+('="9':,:'%%('%%OE""

#@%&:?5"&9'"$%%7'"+':@&'="&-"9-0':$('%%">@%"6-(%$='+'=">$&9$("&9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@6&%"-;"

&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&E"C9'+'">@%"6-(%'(%7%"@+-7(="&9'";@6&"&9@&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"

='0-(%&+@&'":'%%"%&+'%%"$;"&9'?";'':":$B'"&9'?"@+'"p@&"9-0'WE"C9$%"='1@&'"&+$))'+'="=$%67%%$-(%"

@+-7(="9->"&-"$(6+'@%'"&9'"9-0':$('%%"-;"9'@:&96@+'";@6$:$&$'%">9'("&9'?"6-0,+$%'"

7(;@0$:$@+"%7++-7(=$()%";$::'=">$&9"%&+@()'+%E"

VPV C%='%/%)'=./*!"#.=-*%2*-51*0(&'$%("1(-**

"C9'"0@$("$%%7'%">$&9$("&9$%"&9'0'">'+'"@+-7(=",'+%-(@:$%@&$-("@(=";@0$:$@+$&?">$&9"&9'"

'(*$+-(0'(&E"S'+%-(@:$%@&$-("@(=";@0$:$@+$&?"-;"&9'",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@W%"%,@6'"N'E)E"

&9+-7)9"7%$()",9-&-%"@(=",'+%-(@:",-%%'%%$-(%O">@%"9$)9:$)9&'="@%"$0,-+&@(&"$("&9'"

@::'*$@&$-("-;"@)$&@&$-(E"U'%,$&'"$&%",-%$&$*'"$0,@6&%5"&9'"=$%67%%$-(%"&7+('="&-"&9'"=$;;$67:&$'%"

-;"9@*$()"$(,@&$'(&%"1+$()",'+%-(@:"$&'0%"&-"@"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&E"M%%7'%"+@$%'=">'+'"

;-67%'="-("&9'":$0$&"-;"$&'0%"&9@&"6-7:="1'"1+-7)9&"$("=$;;'+'(&"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%5"

6:7&&'+"@(="&9'"%'67+$&?"-;"%769"$&'0%E"

Page 32: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z3"

Q%"9$)9:$)9&'=",+'*$-7%:?5"^7$'&"@%">'::"@%"6-007(@:"%,@6'%">'+'"@:%-"*$'>'="@%"('6'%%@+?"

;'@&7+'%E"S@&$'(&%5">9'&9'+"&9'?"9@*'"='0'(&$@"-+"(-&5">'+'"'X,'6&'="&-"+'^7$+'"1-&9"@"

^7$'&"%,@6'">9'+'"&9'?"6@(")'&"@>@?";+-0"&9'"(-$%'"@(="17%?('%%"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:5"@%">'::"@%"

%,@6'">9'+'"&9'?"6@("%-6$@:$%'"@(="$(&'+@6&">$&9"-&9'+%E"G-&9"%,@6'%">'+'"6-(%$='+'="

'^7@::?"$0,-+&@(&E"C9$%"='1@&'"+@$%'="@";'>"$%%7'%"@1-7&"%&@;;",+@6&$6'%"N7(('6'%%@+?"

&@:B$()R69@&&'+$()O"+@&9'+"&9@("a7%&"&9'"17$:=$()%"&9'0%':*'%5"@(="&9'"(''=";-+"$(&'+.

,+-;'%%$-(@:"6-::@1-+@&$-("@0-()%&"9'@:&9"6@+'"%&@;;"@(="='%$)('+%",:7%",71:$6"@(=",@&$'(&"

$(*-:*'0'(&E"C9$%">@%"%-5"%'+*$6'%"@(="17$:=$()"='%$)("='6$%$-(%">'+'"$(;-+0'="1?"&9-%'"

>9-"7%'"9-%,$&@:%"+@&9'+"&9@("@"+':$@(6'"-(",-%&"$(,@&$'(&"'*@:7@&$-(E""

VPX DO(=-'%(./*B=-'&'-;*.(@*C.21-;*

C9'"=$%67%%$-(%"-(">9@&"@%,'6&%"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:">-+B">'::";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="

>9$69"@%,'6&%"6-7:="1'"'(9@(6'=5"$='(&$;$'="&9'"(''=";-+"@("p'(@1:$()W"'(*$+-(0'(&E"C9$%"

+':@&'="&-"1-&9"&9'"$00'=$@&'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@+-7(="1'="%,@6'";-+"$(.,@&$'(&%"@(=">$='+"

'(*$+-(0'(&"-;"9-%,$&@:">@+=%5"=',@+&0'(&%5"6-++$=-+%"@(="6-007(@:"%,@6'%5"$(&'+(@:"@(="

'X&'+(@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"

/'*'+@:"@%,'6&%"-;"&9'"$00'=$@&'"1'="%,@6'"%7++-7(=$()"@",@&$'(&">'+'"9$)9:$)9&'=E"M&">@%"

%7))'%&'="&9@&"@&&'(&$-("1?"='%$)('+%"@(="9'@:&9"6@+'"%&@;;"%9-7:=";-67%"-("'(%7+$()"&9'"

$(6:7%$-("-;"'(@1:$()";'@&7+'%"-;"&9$%"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&",+-0-&'"@(="%7,,-+&";7(6&$-(@:"

@6&$*$&$'%"%769"@%"'@&$()5"=+$(B$()5">@:B$()5"'()@)$()"*$'>%"@(="&9'"@1$:$&?"&-"+'&7+("&-"&9'"

6-++'6&"1'="%,@6'E"

M("&9'">$='+">@+="@+'"%,'6$;$6"+';'+'(6'">@%"0@='"&-"&9'"='%$)("@(="'(*$+-(0'(&@:";'@&7+'%"

-;"&-$:'&%5"$(6:7=$()"&9'"$0,-+&@(6'"-;"9@*$()"=--+%"&9@&"6:'@+:?"$(=$6@&'",7+,-%'"-;"+--0"

@(=""-;""&-$:'&";:7%9"9@(=:'%"(''=$()"&-":--B":$B'";:7%9"9@(=:'%"+@&9'+"&9@("1'$()"-;"@("7:&+@.

0-='+("(-("&-769"='%$)(E"C9'"1'(';$&"-;"(-("&-769"='%$)("-;";:7%9"9@(=:'%";+-0"@("

$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:",'+%,'6&$*'"@+'"@6B(->:'=)'="17&"&9'"(''="&-",+-0-&'"&9'"$(=','(='(6'"

-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$("=@?.&-.=@?":$*$()"07%&"@:%-"1'"&@B'("$(&-"6-(%$='+@&$-(E""

C9$%"+@$%'%"&9'"69@::'()'"$("0@(?"-;"&9'"$%%7'%"=$%67%%'=5"-;"&9'"(''="&-"1@:@(6'"-('"

$0,-+&@(&"@%,'6&"-;",@&$'(&"6@+'">$&9"'^7@::?"$0,-+&@(&"17&"-,,-%$()"=7&$'%"-;"6@+'E"J-+"

Page 33: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z4"

'X@0,:'5"&9'"(''="&-"1@:@(6'",@&$'(&%"(''=";-+";+''=-0"-;"0-*'0'(&">$&9"&9'",+-0-&$-("

-;"%@;'&?E"

M(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:"$%"@("$0,-+&@(&"@%,'6&"-;"6@+'"@(="%$0,:'"0'&9-=%"%769"@%"9@(=">@%9$()"

1?"%&@;;"@(=",@&$'(&%"@+'"B'?"&-",+-0-&$()"&9$%"@%,'6&"-;"%@;'&?"@(=">'::.1'$()E"M;"&@,%"7%'="

;-+"9@(=">@%9$()"@+'"-;"@"0-='+("='%$)(5"&9@&"=-"(-&"1'@+"@"+'%'01:@(6'"&-"&+@=$&$-(@:"&@,%5"

&9$%"0@?"1'"@"1@++$'+"&-",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"1'$()"@1:'"&-"0@$(&@$(")--="9?)$'('",+@6&$6'%"

%769"@%"9@(=">@%9$()E"

<@(?"$%%7'%"$='(&$;$'="@%"+':@&$()"&-"%@;'&?5"@:%-"+':@&'="&-";7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&?E"M%%7'%"+@$%'="

+':@&'="&-"9->"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&">@%"*$'>'="&-"6-(&+$17&'"&-"&9'"%@;'&?"-;",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@5"9$)9:$)9&$()"&9'"1@:@(6'"&9@&"$%"+'^7$+'="1'&>''("+$%B"&@B$()5";+''=-05"

$(=','(='(6'"@(="=7&?"-;"6@+'E"]('"=$0'(%$-(";+'^7'(&:?"9$)9:$)9&'=">@%"&9'"@6&$*$&?"-;"

>@:B$()"@+-7(="&9'"$00'=$@&'"'(*$+-(0'(&5"&9'"+$%B"-;";@::$()5"&9'"+$%B"-;")'&&$()":-%&"@(="

&9'",+-0-&$-("-;"$(=','(='(6'E"

/7))'%&$-(%";-+"@==+'%%$()"6-(6'+(%"$("+':@&$-("&-">@:B$()"$(6:7='=Y"

]M.(.)'()*$',[*%2*2.//'()*.(@*)1--'()*/%,-^*.(@*]3$%"%-'%(*%2*4./['()*.(@*'(@1#1(@1(=1^*

6',)O',1*@%%$,*-5.-*#.-'1(-,*4%O/@*(%-*(11@*-%*O,1*1P)P*-%*=/'('=./*.$1.,*%$*,/O'=1_*I;*#.'(-'()*-51*,."1*=%/%O$*.,*-51*,O$$%O(@'()*4.//*

Z,1*%2*5.(@*$.'/,*.(@*/1.(*$.'/,*'(*.//*5%,#'-./*4.$@,*.(@*=%$$'@%$,_*-%*2.='/'-.-1*,.21*4./['()*

Z,1*%2*@',#/.;*=.I'(1-*I;*1.=5*I1@*-%*5%/@*#1$,%(.//;*,')('2'=.(-*'-1",*-5.-*4%O/@*.,,',-*4'-5*'@1(-'2'=.-'%(*I;*.*#1$,%(*4'-5*@1"1(-'.*%2*-51'$*#1$,%(./*I1@*,#.=1*

Z,1*%2*=%/%O$*=%@1@*4.//,*-%*@',-'()O',5*I1-411(*@'221$1(-*.$1.,*%2*4.$@,*.(@*@'221$1(-*.$1.,*%2*-51*5%,#'-./*

A/1.$*.(@*51/#2O/*,')(.)1*`.,*@',=O,,1@*'(*-51*]!(2%$".-'%(*.(@*A%""O('=.-'%(^*,1=-'%(*%2*$1#%$-a*

J'@&7+'%"&9@&"@+'";-7(="$("='0'(&$@"%,'6$@:$%&"7($&%"(''="&-"1'"$(6:7='="$(")'('+@:"@(="-&9'+"

%,'6$@:$%&">@+=%"@(="=',@+&0'(&%"'E)E":'@("+@$:%5"@,,+-,+$@&'";:--+$()5"6-:-7+'="=--+%"

Page 34: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z2"

C9'"1@:@(6'"1'&>''(";7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&?"@(="%@;'&?"@:%-"@,,'@+%"&-"$0,@6&"-("&9'"

,%?69-:-)$6@:"%@;'&?"-;",@&$'(&%">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="+','@&'="+';'+'(6'">@%"0@='"&-"&9'"

p,+$%-(":$B'";'@&7+'%W"-;"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"Q("'X@0,:'"-;"%769";'@&7+'%">@%"@";$+%&";:--+"

9-%,$&@:">@+=">9$69"9@=">$(=->%"&9@&",+-*$='="@",:'@%@(&"-7&=--+"*$'>"?'&">'+'"-1%67+'="

1?"1@+%"&9@&",+-0-&'="%@;'&?E"

S%?69-:-)$6@:">'::.1'$()">@%"-;&'("=$%67%%'="@%"1'$()",-%$&$*':?"$(;:7'(6'="1?"&9'"^7@:$&?"-;"

&9'"*$'>"@*@$:@1:'"&-"&9'",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"'E)E";+-0"&9'"1'="%,@6'E"A9'+'"*$'>%"-;"&9'"

-7&%$='5"(@&7+'5")@+='(%"@(=",'-,:'">'+'"@*@$:@1:'"&9$%">@%"%7))'%&'="@%"1'$()",+';'+@1:'"

&-"*$'>%"-;">@::%"@(="6-++$=-+%E"

C9'"$%%7'"-;"1@:@(6$()"&9'"%@;'&?"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'"(''="&-"9@*'"

'^7$,0'(&";-+"&9'",+-*$%$-("-;"6@+'">@%"9$)9:$)9&'="$("=$%67%%$-(%"-;"'^7$,0'(&"&9@&"0$)9&"

1'"=@()'+-7%"$;"$(6-++'6&:?"-+"$(@,,+-,+$@&':?"7%'="'E)E"'0'+)'(6?"&+-::'?%5">9'':"69@$+%5"

$(&+@*'(-7%"$(;7%$-(",70,%E"/769"'^7$,0'(&"6-7:="@:%-"6-(&+$17&'"&-"@"6:7&&'+'="

'(*$+-(0'(&">9$69"0@?"1'"6-(;7%$()"&-"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

Q66'%%"&-"-7&=--+"%,@6'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@">@%"+@$%'="@%"@",-%$&$*'";'@&7+'"-;"

9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%5"@:&9-7)9"7%'"-;"%769"%,@6'"0@?"+'^7$+'"+':'*@(&"%7,,-+&"1?"6@+'+%"-+"

%&@;;E"/@;'5"'(6:-%'="&9'+@,'7&$6")@+='(%">'+'"%7))'%&'="@%"&9'"$='@:"-7&=--+"%,@6'"&-"1'"

@66'%%'=E"/-0'"9-%,$&@:%5"%769"@%"A?&9'(%9@>'"K-%,$&@:"$("<@(69'%&'+5"9@*'"@"%,'6$;$6"

p)+''(W"-+)@($%@&$-("$='(&$&?"&9@&"$%"'*$='(&"$("&9'"6+'@&$-("-;"0@(?")@+='("%,@6'%E"M&">@%";':&"

&9@&"%-0'"-;"&9'%'"%,@6'%"6-7:="1'";7+&9'+"='*':-,'="&-"1'"='0'(&$@";+$'(=:?5"1?"

6-(%$='+$()">9$69";'@&7+'%"6-7:="1'"'(9@(6'="&-",+-0-&'"&9'"%@;'"7%'"-;"&9'%'"%,@6'%"1?"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

Q:&9-7)9"=$%6+'&'"$(;-+0@&$-("%&+@&')$'%"%769"@%"&9'"G7&&'+;:?"/69'0'"9@*'"1''("='%$)('="

&-",+-0-&'"@,,+-,+$@&'"6@+'"@(="%@;'&?"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"N1?"7%'"-;"@"17&&'+;:?"

%&$6B'+"&-"$='(&$;?",@&$'(&%">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@O5"%769"@,,+-@69'%"+$%B"1+'@69$()"

6-(;$='(&$@:$&?"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"(-&"@>@+'"-;"@(?"-&9'+",@&$'(&"

)+-7,"&9@&"9@%"@",71:$6@::?"*$'>@1:'"%?01-:"-+":@1':"$='(&$;?$()"&9'$+"$::('%%"-("*$'>E"M&">@%"

@+)7'="&9@&",+-;'%%$-(@:"6-007($6@&$-("&9@&"0@$(&@$(%"6-(;$='(&$@:$&?"$%"@,,+-,+$@&'";-+"@::"

,@&$'(&%E"C9'"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@">9-"@:%-"9@*'"@"%'(%-+?"=';$6$&">'+'"

Page 35: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"ZZ"

9$)9:$)9&'=";-+"6-(%$='+@&$-(E"M("@==$&$-("&-"&9'"$%%7'%"$='(&$;$'=5";7+&9'+"&9-7)9&">@%"

$(=$6@&'="+')@+=$()"9->"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"6-7:="1'"'(9@(6'="&-"1'"'(@1:$()";-+",@&$'(&%"

>9-"@:%-"9@*'"*$%7@:"@(="9'@+$()"$0,@$+0'(&%E"

VPW !(2%$".-'%(*.(@*A%""O('=.-'%(*

M("&'+0%"-;"$(;-+0@&$-("%H*+9.,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5",@+&$6$,@(&%"%,-B'"@1-7&"&9'"

$0,-+&@(6'"-;"6-007($6@&$()"&9-%'",'-,:'W%"(''=%"@(="&9'"7%'"-;"%?01-:%"%769"@%"&9'"

@;-+'0'(&$-('="G7&&'+;:?"/69'0'E"C9$%"+@$%'="^7'%&$-(%"@%"&-"9->"6@+'"%'+*$6'",+-*$='+%"

67++'(&:?"%9@+'"$(;-+0@&$-("@1-7&",@&$'(&%"@(=">9'&9'+"&9$%"6-7:="1'"=-('"$("@"0-+'"

=$)($;$'="@(=",+$*@&'">@?E"

_'('+@::?"&9'+'">@%"@"%9@+'="*$'>"&9@&"@"6-01$(@&$-("-;">-+=%"@(=",$6&7+'%R$0@)'%">@%"&9'"

$='@:"@,,+-@69"$(",+-*$=$()"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"$(;-+0@&$-("=*)",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"C9'%'"

>'+'"$("&'+0%"-;"=@?.&-.=@?"(@*$)@&$-("&-"+'@69";@6$:$&$'%"%769"@%"&-$:'&%5"=$($()"%,@6'%"@(="

'X$&%E"C--"0769"&'X&"@(="*$%7@:"$(;-+0@&$-(">@%"6-(%$='+'=":$B':?"&-"p1-01@+=W"@",'+%-(">$&9"

='0'(&$@E"Q(?"*$%7@::?",+'%'(&'="0@&'+$@:"(''='="&-"1'"*$%$1:'"&-"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"

>9-"0@?"9@*'"*$%7@:"$0,@$+0'(&E"C9'+'">@%"%-0'"=$%67%%$-("@1-7&">9'&9'+"%$)(@)'"

(''='="&-"1'"=$;;'+'(&";-+",'-,:'">9-"=$="-+"=$="(-&"9@*'"='0'(&$@5"?'&"(-"@)+''0'(&">@%"

+'@69'=E"C9'+'">@%"@:%-"@"1':$';"&9@&"0@(?",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@":--B"=->("@":-&"@(="0@?"

(-&"(-&$6'"%$)(%"@1-*'"@"6'+&@$("9'$)9&E"M&">@%"^7'%&$-('=">9'&9'+"6:'@+:?",+'%'(&'=">+$&&'("

@(="*$%7@:"$(;-+0@&$-(">-7:="1'"6-0,+'9'(='="1?"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"C9'%'"$%%7'%"

%7))'%&"&9@&"&9'"'*$='(6'"1@%'"-("*$%7@:"$0,@$+0'(&"@(=",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"1'"

>-+&9"'X@0$($()";7+&9'+E"I':@&'="&-"&9'%'"$%%7'%">@%"&9'"@,,+-,+$@&'('%%"-;"%-0'"-1a'6&%"

@(=">9'&9'+"&9'?">'+'"'@%$:?"$='(&$;$@1:'"1?"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"'E)E"(-(.&-769"&@,%"

>9$69"@+'"&+$))'+'="1?"@"9@(="%'(%-+E"A9$:%&"7%'"-;"6-:-7+">@%"@:%-"6-(%$='+'="$("+':@&$-("&-"

e-($()"-;"17$:=$()%"-+"&9'";7(6&$-("-;"@+'@%5"$&">@%"^7$6B:?"6-7(&'+'=">$&9"&9'"=$;;$67:&?"-;"

'X,:@$($()"&9'"0'@($()"-;"&9'"=$;;'+'(&"6-:-7+%"&-",'-,:'"'E)E";:--+$()5"=--+%5"@(="e-('%E"M&"

>@%"@6B(->:'=)'="&9@&":$)9&$()"(''='="&-"1'"%7;;$6$'(&";-+",'-,:'"&-"1'"@1:'"&-"%''"%$)(@)'"

@(="*$%7@:"67'%"6:'@+:?E""

S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'":'%%"$("@)+''0'(&"@%"&-">9'&9'+"@+&';@6&%"+',+'%'(&$()"@",'+%-(">$&9"

='0'(&$@W%",+'*$-7%"9-0'"-+"&9'$+"@6&7@:",'+%-(@:"1':-()$()%"%9-7:="1'"7%'="&-";-%&'+"@"

Page 36: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z`"

%'(%'"-;";@0$:$@+$&?"&9@&"0@?"9':,"-+$'(&@&'"&9'0"'E)E"@"B'&&:'E"S@+&$6$,@(&%">'+'"*'+?"@>@+'"

&9@&"%&?:'%"-;"9-7%'9-:=")--=%"@(=";$X&7+'%"*@+$'="=+@0@&$6@::?"@6+-%%",'-,:'W%":$;'"6-7+%'"

@(="0-='+("=@?"&':',9-('%";-+"'X@0,:'"0@?"1'"9@+="&-"$='(&$;?"@%"1'$()"%769"@"='*$6'E"Q"

+@()'"-;"%&+@&')$'%">'+'"@=*-6@&'="%769"@%"7%'"-;"p0'0-+?"1-X'%W5">@::,@,'+">$&9"@"

1--B%9':;"07+@:"-("$&"&-"=$%6-7+@)'"6-()+')@&$()"$("=--+>@?%"-+"=$%)7$%'"&9'"=--+%"

&9'0%':*'%5",+-0,&"6@+=%"%&@&$()"c?-7"@+'"$("9-%,$&@:"."?-7+";@0$:?"B(->%">9'+'"?-7"@+'d5"

@(="@"*'+%$-("-;"&9'"Q:e9'$0'+W%"/-6$'&?"p)'&"&-"B(->"0'W"%?%&'0">9'+'1?"@"6@+="+'6-+=%"

$(=$*$=7@:W%",+';'+'(6'%"%769"@%"(@0'5";--=5",@%&$0'%"@(="%-"-(E"""

"Q&"&$0'%",@+&$6$,@(&%"+'6-)($%'="&9@&"$(;-+0@&$-("$%">@(&'="=$+'6&:?"=)*7.,'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"%769"@%">9'("&9'?">@(&"@%%$%&@(6'E"M("*@+$-7%"6@+'"%'&&$()%"&9$%"0@?"$(*-:*'""(-$%?"

6@::"%?%&'0%"-+";:@%9$()":$)9&%E"C9'"@*@$:@1$:$&?"@(="'*$='(6'"1@%'";-+"%?%&'0%"@(="='*$6'%"&-"

0@(@)'"@7=$&-+?"@(="*$%7@:"(7$%@(6'R@%%$%&@(6'"@(="(7+%'"6@::R@:@+0"%?%&'0%"@(="%-"-(5"

>@%"6-(%$='+'="$("(''="-;";7+&9'+"'X,:-+@&$-(E"C9'"@=*@(&@)'%"@(="=$%@=*@(&@)'%"-;"

&'69(-:-)$'%"&9@&"$(;-+0"0-($&-+$()",'+%-((':"@1-7&"&9'"%&@&7%"@(=">'::.1'$()"-;",'-,:'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@5"%769"@%"=--+"@:@+0%"@(="0-*'0'(&"%'(%-+%">'+'"=$%67%%'=E"C9'"(''=";-+"

1@:@(6$()",+$*@6?"@(="%@;'&?">@%"@)@$("+@$%'=">$&9"+')@+=%"&-"&9'%'E""

A9$:%&"0'(&$-('=",+'*$-7%:?5"@("$0,-+&@(&"0'%%@)'"&-"1'"6-007($6@&'=">@%">9'+'",'-,:'"

>'+'",9?%$6@::?":-6@&'=E"Q"6-(%$%&'(&"*$'>"@1-7&"%-0'"0-='+("9'@:&96@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%"

>@%"&9@&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@">-7:="%&+7)):'"&-"$='(&$;?">9'+'"&9'?">'+'5"@%"0@(?"%769"

,:@6'%"=$="(-&":--B":$B'"&+@=$&$-(@:"9-%,$&@:%"-;",@%&"='6@='%E"C9$%"*$'>">@%"+'$(;-+6'="1?"

%'*'+@:",@+&$6$,@(&%">9-"'X,:@$('="9->",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"=+@>"9'@*$:?"-(":-()"

&'+0"+@&9'+"&9@("%9-+&"&'+0"0'0-+?"$("0@B$()"%'(%'"-;"&9'$+"%7++-7(=$()%E""

VPY B##$%.=51,*-%*A.$1*

Q"+@()'"-;"$(%$)9&%">@%"%9@+'="@1-7&"&9'"6@+'"@,,+-@69'%"&9@&"9'@:&9"6@+'"%&@;;"@=-,&'="$("

+':@&$-("&-",'-,:'">$&9"'X,'+$'(6'"-;"='0'(&$@E"Q",@+&$67:@+"69@::'()'"6-(6'+('="&9'"7%'"-;"

&9'"&'+0"p,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@W"@%"$&"+$%B'="17(69$()",'-,:'"&-)'&9'+"@%"@")+-7,">$&9":-%%"

-;"&9'$+"$(=$*$=7@:"$='(&$&$'%E"C9$%",+-0,&'=";7+&9'+"=$%67%%$-("@1-7&"&9'";@6&"&9@&"@67&'"

9'@:&9"6@+'"%'&&$()%"$(",@+&$67:@+"@+'"7%'="1?":@+)'"(701'+%"-;",'-,:'">9-"9@*'"='0'(&$@E"

C9'+'">'+'"0$X'="*$'>%"1@%'="-(",'+6'$*'="@=*@(&@)'%"@(="=$%@=*@(&@)'%"@1-7&">9'&9'+"

Page 37: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Zh"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"+':@&'="(''=%"%9-7:="1'"6@+'=";-+"$("='=$6@&'="%'&&$()%"-+"$("%'&&$()%"

;-+"&9'")'('+@:"@=7:&"9-%,$&@:",-,7:@&$-(E"J-+"'X@0,:'5"@",+';'+'(6'";-+"$(&')+@&$-("-;"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@6+-%%"6@+'"%'&&$()%">@%"6-7(&'+'="1?"@"(''=";-+"%769"&9$()%"@%"+'%&"

@0-()%&",@&$'(&%"$("@"6@+=$@6"6@+'"%'&&$()">9-"0@?"1'"=$%&7+1'="1?"%-0'-('">9-">@%"

@)$&@&'="=7'"&-"='0'(&$@E"K'@:&96@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%">'+'"6-00-(:?",'+6'$*'="1?"

,@+&$6$,@(&%"@%":'%%"&9@("%?0,@&9'&$6"&-"&9'"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

<@(?"%7))'%&$-(%">'+'"0@='"1?",@+&$6$,@(&%"@%"&-"&9'"%7$&@1$:$&?"-;"%&@(=@+="9-%,$&@:"

'^7$,0'(&"$::7%&+@&'="$(",9-&-)+@,9%"&9'?">'+'"%9->(E"<@(?"$&'0%"-;"'^7$,0'(&"%769"@%"

1'=",'=@:%">'+'"*$'>'="@%":$B':?"&-"@&&+@6&"@&&'(&$-("-;"%-0'1-=?">9-">@%"6-(;7%'="-+"

+'%&:'%%">9-"0@?"&9'(";$=)'&">$&9"&9'0E"C9$%"+@$%'="%-0'"=$%67%%$-("@1-7&"9->"&-"1'%&"

-667,?",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"&-"%'&&:'"&9'0E"/'*'+@:"6-00'(&%"%9->'="9->"=$;;'+'(&"6@+'"

%'&&$()%">'+'"B(->("&-"9@*'"+'%,-(='="1?"9@*$()"'^7$,0'(&";$&&'="&-"@$=",'-,:'">9-"0@?"

1'"B''("&-">@:B"'E)E":'()&9?"@(="697(B?"9@(="+@$:%"&-">@:B"@:-()E"]&9'+"@+'@%"9@="%''0$():?"

)$*'(":$&&:'"&9-7)9&"&-"&9$%"@(="&9'+'">@%"@":@6B"-;"%769"@$=%"@(="@=@,&@&$-(%E""

C9'+'">@%"@")'('+@:"6-(%'(%7%"&9@&"p-('"%$e'">-(W&";$&"@::W"@(="&9@&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"

%9-7:="(-&"9@*'"&9'$+"(''=%"-*'+:--B'="$("@"%'@"-;"-&9'+",@&$'(&%E"J$(=$()"@"0$==:'")+-7(="

>@%"%''("@%"@"0@a-+"69@::'()'E"/-0'",-%$&$*'"@,,+-@69'%">'+'"$='(&$;$'="$(6:7=$()"%9@+'="

1'=+--0%";-+"%-0'",'-,:'">9-"0@?"1'":'%%":-(':?">9'("6@+'=";-+"&9@&">@?5">9'+'@%"-&9'+%"

0@?",+';'+"@"%$():'"+--0E"C9'"$0,-+&@(6'"-;"%7$&@1:'"%&@;;"$(&'+@6&$-(">$&9"@",'+%-(">$&9"

='0'(&$@">@%"%&+'%%'="@%">'::"@%"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$(">9$69"&9'?"@+'"6@+'=";-+E"C9'"&>-">'+'"

*$'>'="@%"$(%',@+@1:'E"C9'+'">@%"@")'('+@:",:'@";-+"%&@;;"&-"1'"%,'6$;$6@::?"&+@$('="$("

='0'(&$@"6@+'"@(=";-+"@%%'%%0'(&%"-;"('>"@=0$%%$-(%"&-"9-%,$&@:"&-"1'"0@='"1?"%&@;;">9-"

@+'"='0'(&$@"@>@+'"@:%-E"Q%">'::"@%"@='^7@&'"%&@;;$()"(701'+%"&9'+'">@%"6-(6'+("@1-7&"

6@:$1+'"-;"@*@$:@1:'"%&@;;E"C9'+';-+'5"&+@$($()",+-*$%$-(";-+"@::"%&@;;")+-7,%"@1-7&"='0'(&$@"

6@+'">@%"9$)9:$)9&'="1?"0@(?",@+&$6$,@(&%E""

C9'+'">@%"+'6-)($&$-("-;"%-0'",+@6&$6'%"*$'>'="@%",-%$&$*'"$("&9'"6@+'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"'%,'6$@::?E"J-+"'X@0,:'"&9'",+-*$%$-("-;"@"&9'+@,?"%,@6'";-+"@+-0@&9'+@,?"-+"

p^7$'&"&$0'W">@%"+@$%'="%'*'+@:"&$0'%5"@%">@%"&9'"(''=";-+",+$*@&'"6-(%7:&@&$-("%,@6'";-+"

=$%67%%$-(%">$&9"9'@:&9"6@+'"%&@;;E"C9'",+-*$%$-("-;"9'@+$().:--,'="+--0%"&-"9':,"&9-%'">$&9"

9'@+$()"$0,@$+0'(&">@%"@=*-6@&'="@%"%&@(=@+=",+@6&$6'E"Q*-$=@(6'"-;"%-0'",+@6&$6'%">@%"

Page 38: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z\"

9$)9:$)9&'="%769"@%"&9'"6@++?$()"-;"pa@():?W">@+="B'?%E"Q)@$("&'69(-:-)$'%"%769"@%"=--+"

@:@+0%">'+'"@:%-"+@$%'="@%"@"0'@(%"-;"@%%$%&$()"&9'"%&@;;"&-"6@+'";-+":@+)'"(701'+%"-;",'-,:'"

17&"(-&"@&"&9'"6-%&"-;"6@+'"^7@:$&?E"#'%%"$(&+7%$*'"&'69(-:-)?"%769"@%"&9-%'"&-":-6@&'",@&$'(&%"

>9-"9@="p>@(='+'=W"@>@?">'+'";@*-7+'="1?"%-0'",@+&$6$,@(&%"@:&9-7)9"&9'?"+'6-)($%'="

&9'?">-7:="(''="%@;')7@+=%"$(",:@6'"&-",+-&'6&",+$*@6?"@(="%-"-(E""

]('"@,,+-@69"*$'>'="@%",@+&$67:@+:?"';;'6&$*'">@%">9'+'")'('+@:"9-%,$&@:"6@+'"

'(*$+-(0'(&%"9@*'"'@%?"@66'%%"&-"$(,7&";+-0"0'(&@:"9'@:&9"(7+%'%"&-"%7,,-+&"&9'"6@+'"-;"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"Q"B'?"0'%%@)'">@%"&9@&"^7@:$&?"-;"6@+'">@%";@+"0-+'"$0,-+&@(&"&9@("

&9'",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"$&">@%"=':$*'+'="$(E"S@+&$6$,@(&%"@:%-"+'0$(='="'@69"-&9'+"&9@&"

='0'(&$@"@;;'6&'=",'-,:'"@6+-%%"@">$='"@)'"+@()'"$(6:7=$()"6-(%$='+@1:'"(701'+%"-;",'-,:'"

$("&9'$+";-+&$'%"@(=";$;&$'%E"

A9$:%&",'+%-(@:$%'="6@+'">@%"0'(&$-('=";+'^7'(&:?5"&9'+'">@%"@:%-"+'6-)($&$-("&9@&"&9'"

(''=%"-;"$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"%769"@%";@0$:?"0'01'+%5"@+'"$0,-+&@(&"&-"

0''&"&--E"C9'",+';'+'(6'";-+"%-0'"$(;-+0@:"6@+'+%"&-"1'"$(*-:*'="$("6@+'"@6&$*$&$'%"%769"@%"

'@&$()"@&"0'@:&$0'%">'+'"6-(%$='+'="$0,-+&@(&E"M("@==$&$-("&-"0'@:&$0'%5"-&9'+"%-6$@:"

)@&9'+$()"-,,-+&7($&$'%">'+'"9$)9:$)9&'="@%"*@:7@1:'5"%769"@%")@+='($()"@(="'*'("9@*$()"@"

%$()$()"%'%%$-(">9$:%&")@+='($()"9@="1''(";-7(="&-"1'"1'(';$6$@:E"

VPb A%(2/'=-'()*',,O1,*`]-$.@1*%22,^a*

C9$%"%'6&$-("%'&%"-7&"&9'"6-(;:$6&$()"$%%7'%5"6-(&+@=$6&$-(%"@(="p&+@='.-;;%W"$='(&$;$'="=7+$()"

=$%67%%$-(%"@&"&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&E"C9'%'";7+&9'+"9$)9:$)9&"%-0'"-;"&9'")@,%"@(="

$(6-(%$%&'(6$'%"$("&9'"'*$='(6'"1@%'"6-(6'+($()"&9'"(''=%"@(=",+';'+'(6'%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@5"@(=">9@&"$%"67++'(&:?"1':$'*'="-+"@66',&'=")--=",+@6&$6'"$("9'@:&9"+':@&'="6@+'"

%'&&$()%E""

• !(21=-'%(*=%(-$%/"68)2+2",5.$1@*,#.=1,"N,'+%-(@:",+';'+'(6'O"

• /$():'"+--0%"(-&"$='@:"N17&"0@?"1'"@",'+%-(@:"69-$6'O"@(="(''='="@&"&$0'%";-+"$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:"

• C.21-;"68)2+2"2$11@%""N$(=','(='(6'"$%%7'%O"

Page 39: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Z["

• G@:@(6'"-;"1'(';$&"-;"0-*$()"@(=";+''">$::"68)2+2"+$%B"-;";@::$()5")'&&$()":-%&"• I$)9&"&-"@66'%%"-7&%$='"17&"%@;'&?"$0,:$6@&$-(%"• /'(%'"-;"%@;'&?"@(="6@:0"68)2+2"+$%B"-;"9@+0"@(="@6&7@:"$(a7+?"

• K')5-'()"2%$*=/'('=./*,-.22"68)2+2"/')5-'()*2%$*#1$,%(*4'-5*@1"1(-'."

• 3$'&.=;"N6-(;$='(&$@:$&?O"68)2+2"@O-;*%2*=.$1E"#@1'::$()"-;",@&$'(&%"N%?01-:%"='(-&$()"

='0'(&$@"=$@)(-%$%O"."1+'@69"-;"6-(;$='(&$@:$&?"

• B##/'.(=1,*2."'/'.$*-%*#.-'1(-,"68)2+2""%@1$(*-1=5(%/%)'1,"

• M.c%$'-;*#$121$1(=1"N67%&-0$%@&$-(O"68)2+2"#1$,%(./*#$121$1(=1"N$(=$*$=7@:"

+'^7$+'0'(&%O"

• B1,-51-'=,"68)2+2"#$.=-'=./'-'1,d2O(=-'%(./'-;d'(21=-'%(*=%(-$%/"

• /-0'"17$:=$()"='%$)(%"0@?":--B"@'%&9'&$6@::?",:'@%$()"'E)E"9$)9"6'$:$()%"17&"&9'%'"@+'"(-&"('6'%%@+$:?"&9'"1'%&"69-$6'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"6@+'"(''=%"

• S'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"68)2+2"='%$)(";-+"-&9'+%">$&9-7&"@"='0'(&$@"=$@)(-%$%"

• 31$,%(./',.-'%(*68)2+2"'(21=-'%(*=%(-$%/"

• B&%'@.(=1*%2*=/O--1$*>9$:%&"7%$()"6+'@&$*'">@?%"-;"@66-00-=@&$()",'+%-(@:"&-769'%"

• !(21=-'%(*=%(-$%/"68)2+2",%='./*'(-1)$.-'%(""

• /?%&'0%"@(="'(*$+-(0'(&"%9-7:="1'"@=@,&$*'"&-"&9'",@&$'(&W%"(''=%""• /-6$@:",+-*$%$-("$("@"6:$($6@:"%'&&$()"

• C-.22*41//\I1'()"68)2+2"#1$,%(*4'-5*@1"1(-'.^,*41//\I1'()"

• <%%*"O=5*'(2%$".-'%("68)2+2.(%-*1(%O)5"

• U-71:'"%$)(@)'";@*-7+'=5"&9'"7%'"-;"=$;;'+'(&"0'&9-=%"-;"6-007($6@&$()"&9'"%@0'"0'%%@)'"N'E)E"@"&-$:'&"%?01-:"@(=">-+="p&-$:'&WOE"C--"0769"$(;-+0@&$-(":--B%"6:7&&'+'="@(="6@("6@7%'"6-(;7%$-("

• C1)$1).-'%("68)2+2"'(-1)$.-'%("

• S'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"6@+'=";-+"-("%,'6$@:$%&"7($&%"-+"-(")'('+@:"6@+'">@+=%s"• I'%&:'%%('%%"-;",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"='&+@6&";+-0">'::.1'$()"-;"-&9'+",@&$'(&%"• K-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&"$%"%7$&@1:'";-+"@",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"0@?"@:%-"1'"%7$&@1:'"

;-+"&9-%'">$&9-7&"='0'(&$@"

• 0(%O)5*,-'"O/.-'%("68)2+2"-%%*"O=5*,-'"O/.-'%("

• 3$',%(*.(./%);5"+'%7:&"-;"$(&'(&$-("&-"B'',",9?%$6@::?"%@;'"17&"0@?"1'",%?69-:-)$6@::?"@(="

%-6$@::?"='&+$0'(&@:"

Page 40: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Zl"

• C#.=1*-%*$1,-"68)2+2",#.=1*-%*,%='./',1"

• t7$'&"%,@6'">9'+'",'-,:'"6@(")'&"@>@?";+-0"(-$%'"@(="17%?('%%"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"@%">'::"@%"6-007(@:"%,@6'"&-"%-6$@:$%'"@(="$(&'+@6&">$&9"-&9'+%"

• 6')('-;_*=%(2'@1(-'./'-;"$%%7'%5"+'%&+$6&'="1?",9?%$6@:"+'%-7+6'%R:@?-7&"-;">@+=%"@(="&$0'"

@*@$:@1:'"

• A%/%O$*=%@'()"-;"B'?"@%,'6&%"-;"'(*$+-(0'(&"?'&"&9$%"=-'%"(-&"+';:'6&",'-,:'W%"9-0'"

'(*$+-(0'(&%""

• L9@::'()'%"-;"(''="&-"=.//*2%$*.,,',-.(=1"6-(&+$17&$()"&-">@+="(-$%'"

• <1=5(%/%);"@%"@"9':,"-+"9$(=+@(6'"

• C#1='./',-*$%/1,"$("='0'(&$@"6@+'"@(=")'('+@:"&+@$($()";-+"@::"%&@;;V"+')@+=$()"6@+'")$*'("$("

&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"

VPQ A%/%O$1@*6%-,*0e1$=',1**

C9$+&?.;-7+",@+&$6$,@(&%"+'0@$('=";-+"&9'"-,&$-(@:"@;&'+(--("%'%%$-(">9'+'"&9'?"7(='+&--B"

&9'"p,+$-+$&$%$()"-;"$%%7'%W"'X'+6$%'"7%$()"%':;.@=9'%$*'"%&$6B'+%E"C9$%"6-:-7+'="=-&"'X'+6$%'"

7&$:$%'="@"=$;;'+'(&"6-:-7+"&-"+',+'%'(&"'@69"%&@B'9-:='+")+-7,E"C9'"(701'+"-;"%&$6B'+%"'@69"

%&@B'9-:='+")+-7,"9@=">$&9">9$69"&-"*-&'";-+"&9'$+",+$-+$&?"$%%7'%">@%",+-,-+&$-(@&'"&-"&9'$+"

@&&'(=@(6'";$)7+'%"@&"&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&E"""

S+$-+$&$%@&$-("1?"&9'",@+&$6$,@(&%"-;"%-0'"-;"&9'"$%%7'%"%7))'%&'="@%"1'$()"%$)($;$6@(&"$("&9'"

9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"9$)9:$)9&'="&9@&"&9'"7%'"-;"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"$%"@("$0,-+&@(&"

6-(%$='+@&$-(E"pK->"=-"M";$(="0?">@?W"+';:'6&%"&9'"$0,-+&@(6'"-;"$(=','(='(6'"@%"@"+'%7:&"-;"

>@?;$(=$()5"%$)(@)'"@(="6-007($6@&$-(E"

C@1:'"4"%9->%"&9@&"@":@+)'"(701'+"-;",@+&$6$,@(&%")@*'",+$-+$&?";-+">@?;$(=$()"$%%7'%5"&9'"

%&@;;"@(=",'+%-(@:"'()@)'0'(&"&9@&"-667++'="$("&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(=";'':$()%"-;"%@;'&?E"

J$)7+'"4"%9->%"&9'"1+'@B=->("-;"6@%&"*-&'%",'+",@+&$6$,@(&%W"6@&')-+?E"M&"$%"'*$='(&"&9@&"&9'"

,+$-+$&?"$%%7'%"$='(&$;$'="1?"&9'",@+&$6$,@(&%"@+'"6-(6'(&+@&'="@+-7(=">@?";$(=$()5"

'()@)'0'(&"1'&>''("%&@;;"@(=",@&$'(&"@(="$%%7'%"+':@&'="&-"0@$(&@$($()"&9'"%@;'&?"-;"&9'"

,'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"J$)7+'"2"%9->%"@",+-,-+&$-(@:"*$'>"6-(%$='+$()"&9'"(701'+"-;"

,@+&$6$,@(&%",'+")+-7,"6@&')-+?E""J+-0"&9'")+@,95"$&"6@("1'"%''("&9@&"&9'+'"$%"@)+''0'(&"

Page 41: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Zg"

+':@&'="&-"&9'"$0,-+&@(6'"-;">@?.;$(=$()5"17&":'%%"%-"$("+':@&$-("&-"%&@;;"@(=",@&$'(&"

'()@)'0'(&E"M("&9$%"+'%,'6&5"&9'"='%$)(")+-7,")@*'",+$-+$&?"&-"$%%7'%";-+"'@69"&9'?"6@("

$(&'+*'('"%769"@%",+-*$=$()"@"+--0">$&9"@"*$'>E"

C@1:'"4"k"L-:-7+'="=-&"'X'+6$%'"+'%7:&%"

!,,O1*

f*3>6*%$*A.

$1$*

&%-1,*

f*3$.=-'-'%(1

$,^*

&%-1,*`7+Ca*

f*3$.=-'-'%(1

$,^*

&%-1,*`7%(

\7+Ca*

f*61,')(1

$,*&%-1,*

f*>

1')5

-1@*&%

-1*

+%4*@%*!*2'(@*";*4.;* 23" 4[El" Z\E[" 2ZE4" RX*C-.22*.(@*#1$,%(./*1().)1"1(-* 2hE[" 2hEh" 23E3" [E[" RT*+%4*=.(*!*211/*,.21** 4[E4" 4[El" 43E3" 4hE`" NX*+1./-5d*5;)'1(1d*'(21=-'%(*=%(-$%/** 2Eg" [El" 4ZEZ" 4hE`" NT*?%%"*4'-5*.*&'14* 2Eg" \E[" \E[" 2ZE4" NT*!-^,*-%%*(%',;** hE[" ZEZ" 3E3" 4hE`" W*Z,'()*=%/%O$* hE[" 2E2" 43E3" 3E3" X*<%%*"O=5*=/O--1$* 3" hE\" 3E3" 3E3" N*E-51$*#$'%$'-'1,* 23" ZEZ" ZEZ" 3E3" b*

<%-./* NTTf* NTTf* NTTf* NTTf* NTTf*

"SAU"k"S'+%-(">$&9"U'0'(&$@"

"

!" #" $"%" %" &" &"

!"

%$"

&'"

%$"

!" $" '" &" ("

%&"

%%"

$"

'"

)"&"

'"

%"

'"%"

&"

&"'"

&"

!"

#"

$!"

$#"

%!"

%#"

&!"

&#"

'!"

'#"

()*"+)","-.+"/0"*10"

2314"1.+"5678).19"6.:1:6/6.3"

()*";1.","<669"81<6""

(6193=>"=0:?6.6>"?.<6;@).";).37)9""

A))/"*?3="1"B?6*"

,3C8"3))".)?80""

D8?.:";)9)E7"

F))"/

E;=";9EG67"

H3=67"57?)7?@68"

I68?:.678"

J71;@@).678"KL).ML(2N"

J71;@@).678"KL(2N"

JOI")7"P1767QQ"

"

J$)7+'"4"k"L-:-7+'="=-&"'X'+6$%'Y"+@>";$)7+'%"

Page 42: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`3"

!"#""$% !&#'($%('#()$%

!#*+$% !#*+$% &#'($% &#'($%!"#""$%

('#'*$%

!&#&+$%

('#'*$%

'#'*$% +#+'$% ,#,,$% !#!!$%&#&+$%

(,#,,$%

,+#+'$%!"#""$%

("#""$%

(,#,,$%+#+'$% ("#""$%

,#,,$%

!,#"*$%

'#+-$%

(&#,*$%

(&#,*$%!,#"*$%

(&#,*$%

!"!!#$

%!"!!#$

&!"!!#$

'!"!!#$

(!"!!#$

)!"!!#$

*!"!!#$

+!"!!#$

,!"!!#$

-!"!!#$

%!!"!!#$

./0$1/$2$341$56$076$

897:$741$;<=>/47?$<4@7@<5<49$

./0$A74$2$B<<?$>7B<$$

.<7?9CD$C6@E<4<D$E4B<AF/4$A/49=/?$$

G//5$0E9C$7$HE<0$

29I>$9//$4/E>6$$

J>E4@$A/?/K=$

L//$5

KAC$A?KM<=$

N9C<=$;=E/=EF<>$

#$O<>E@4<=>$

#$P=7AFF/4<=>$QR/4SR.8T$

#$P=7AFF/4<=>$QR.8T$

#$PUO$/=$V7=<=WW$

"

J$)7+'"2"k"L-:-7+'="=-&"'X'+6$%'Y",+-,-+&$-(@:"*$'>"

VPNT 6',=O,,'%(*

U$%67%%$-(%"9':="1'&>''("&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&";@6$:$&@&-+%"@;&'+"&9'"'*'(&":'="&9'0"$='(&$;?"@"

%'&"-;"69@+@6&'+$%&$6%">$&9$("&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"&9@&">'+'""=$%&$(6&:?",-%%$1:'"&+$))'+%"-;"

,-%$&$*'"@(="(')@&$*'"-7&6-0'%"$(",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"A'"@+)7'"&9@&"&9'";'':$()%"&9@&"

@+'"&+$))'+'="1?"'X,'+$'(6$()"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@+'"+':@&'="&-"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;"&9'"

,'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@E"A'"7(='+%&@(="&9@&"&9'"6-007($6@&$-("p69@((':W"&9@&"$%"7%'="1?"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%"$%"(-&"+':@&'="&-"0'@%7+'%"-;"9'@:&95"%769"@%"%&+'%%5"

1:--=",+'%%7+'"-+"@(?"-&9'+",9?%$-:-)$6@:"9'@:&9"-7&6-0'%E"I@&9'+5"&9-%'";'':$()%"-;"%'67+$&?"

@(=";@0$:$@+$&?"%''0"&-"1'">9@&"+'=76'%"&9'"7%'"-;"@=@,&$*'"1'9@*$-7+"@(="0@?"6-(&+$17&'"

&-"@::'*$@&$-("-;"%&+'%%5"=',+'%%$-("@(="1'9@*$-7+@:"69@::'()'%E"

G':->"NJ$)7+'"ZO5">'",+'%'(&"@("-,'("0@,">9'+'"&9'"'%&@1:$%9'="69@+@6&'+$%&$6%"-;"&9'"17$:&"

'(*$+-(0'(&"@+'"$(",@+@::':">$&9"&9'";'':$()%"&9@&"9@*'"1''("'X,+'%%'="$("&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&E"

M&"%''0%"&9@&"%-0'"69@+@6&'+$%&$6%"@+'":$(B'="0-+'"&-"-('"-+"-&9'+";'':$()"&9@("-&9'+%E"

A$&9-7&"@"%-:$="1@%$%"-;"'*$='(6'5">'"6@((-&"6-(;$+0"&9-%'":$(B%"&9@&"+'0@$("$("(''="-;"

;7+&9'+"'X,:-+@&$-(E"C9'"&'X&7+'"$("&9'"0$==:'"-;"&9'"$0@)'"+',+'%'(&%"-7+":@6B"-;"B(->:'=)'"

+')@+=$()"6@7%'.';;'6&"0'69@($%0%E"

Page 43: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`4"

!"#$%&'()#*+

(,-(

%&.+/#0$&'()#*+

(,-(

%&1$-2#3#$#%4&

5*60(#708+(&

9:-;"0%-&<+0:&

!0**#-*7&

=+(#(6&

>+(%*07%&

?<04+"%&@&>$"A-*B&

?C+#7-@&)#7"0$7@&%-,D-*0%"*-B&

?7+/#0$&@&$-#7"*-&@&#(:#)#:"0$B&

.-*)#/-&?'2D-*#-(/-B&

?E-*7+(0$&7%"F@&0:G"7%03$-B&

?30*7&@&:++*7&@&H#(:+H7B&

10,#$#0*#%4&

.0I-%4&

E*#)0/4&

J(:-D-(:-(/4&

J,D*#7+(,-(%&

>0$,(-77&

.+/#0$&J(/$"7#+(&

K#6(#%4&

E-*7+(

&H#%L

&K-,

-(80

&&M&&N

-$$M3

-#(6&

*

J$)7+'"Z"k"G7$:&"T(*$+-(0'(&RJ'':$()%"<@,"

Page 44: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`2"

""

X AE7AKZC!E7*

U'0'(&$@"$%"@"6-(=$&$-("&9@&"@;;'6&%"@":@+)'"@(="$(6+'@%$()"(701'+"-;",'-,:'"$("&9'"DPE"

L'+&@$("@%,'6&%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@("'(9@(6'"-+"='&+@6&";+-0"&9'">'::.1'$()"-;"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E""

]+$)$(@::?5"@"07:&$.,'+%,'6&$*'"7(='+%&@(=$()"-;"&9'"$%%7'%"@+-7(="&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="$&%"

$0,@6&"-(",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%">@%"%-7)9&E""J-+"&9$%",7+,-%'5"@":$%&'($()"

'*'(&">@%"-+)@($%'="$("/',&'01'+"2344"@&"&9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="&9@&"1+-7)9&"&-)'&9'+"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@5"&9'$+"6@+'+%5"9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'"%&@;;"@(="@6@='0$6%E"C9$%"'*'(&"

>@%"(-&"='%$)('="&-"1'"@"+'%'@+69"%&7=?V"+@&9'+"$&">@%"7%'="@%"@("$(%&+70'(&"&-"%&$07:@&'"

=$%67%%$-(%"@(="':$6$&"&9'"&'%&$0-(?"-;"&9-%'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"-+"%7,,-+&$()"&9-%'":$*$()"

>$&9"='0'(&$@E"

S+',@+@&$-(";-+"p:$%&'($()W"$(*-:*'="&9'"6-(=76&$-("-;"@":$&'+@&7+'"+'*$'>"@1-7&"&9'"B(->("

$0,@6&%"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"-(",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'"'X@0$(@&$-("-;"@("

'X$%&$()";+@0'>-+B"6-(&@$($()";'@&7+'%"&9@&":$(B%",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"

'(*$+-(0'(&%E"C9'%'";'@&7+'%">'+'"&9'";@1+$65"&9'"@01$'(6'5"&9'",%?69-:-)$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"

@(="&9'"%-6$-:-)$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&E"J7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&?"@(="%@;'&?5"$(;-+0@&$-("@(="

6-007($6@&$-("@(="@,,+-@69'%"&-"6@+'">'+'"@=='="&-"&9'";+@0'>-+BE"C9$%"@=@,&'="

;+@0'>-+B"9@%"$("-7+"*$'>"1''("%&+'()&9'('="1?"&9'"6-00'(&%"@(="-,$($-(%"-;"&9'"[["

,@+&$6$,@(&%"-;"&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&"@(="$%"-;;'+'="&-"+'@='+%"&-"6+$&$6@::?"6-(%$='+"@(="9':,"7%"

='*':-,";7+&9'+"@%"@"p+7=='+W";-+"'X,:-+$()"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'"9'@:&96@+'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"

;7+&9'+E"""

p/&@;;"@(=",'+%-(@:"'()@)'0'(&W">@%"&9'";-67%"-;"%'*'+@:"-;"&9'")+-7,"=$%67%%$-(%5">9$69"$%"@"

7%';7:"+'0$(='+"-;"9->"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"(''=%"&-"-,&$0$%'",@&$'(&"@(="%&@;;"

$(&'+@6&$-(E"Q==$&$-(@:"$%%7'%">'+'"%7))'%&'="@%"1'$()"-;"$0,-+&@(6'"$(6:7=$()"&9'"1'(';$&"-;"

$(&')+@&$()",9?%$6@:"@(="0'(&@:"9'@:&9"%'+*$6'%"+@&9'+"&9@("%',@+@&$()"&9'0"@(="&9'"

$0,-+&@(6'"-;"$(*-:*$()"6@+'+%"$("&9'"6@+'"='6$%$-(%"@(="6@+'",+-*$%$-(E"C9'"$(6:7%$-("-;"

Page 45: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`Z"

&9'%'"$%%7'%"+'$(;-+6'%"&9'"(''=";-+"$(6:7%$*'"='%$)("$(*-:*$()"@+69$&'6&%5",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%"@(="%&@;;"$("&9'",:@(($()"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&E""

Q%"9-%,$&@:%"6@("1'"@("@:$'("'(*$+-(0'(&5"&9$%"$%%7'"-;"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"

-("p9->"6@("M";'':"%@;'W"+'$(;-+6'%"&9'",%?69-%-6$@:"@%,'6&%"-;"&9'",@&$'(&"'X,'+$'(6'E"/769"

(''=%"@%"&9'%'">'+'"6@,&7+'="$("&9'",+';'+'(6'";-+"@"p+--0">$&9"@"*$'>WE"L:$($6@:"$%%7'%"-;"

,+-0-&$()"p9'@:&95"9?)$'('5"@(="$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:W"@+'"@"+'0$(='+"-;"&9'";-67%"-;"&9'"%'+*$6'"

,+-*$='="$("&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="&9'"(''=";-+"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"&-"%7,,-+&"&9'%'"

@%,'6&%"-;"&9'"6@+'",+-*$='=E"C9'"$%%7'"-;"&9'"@6-7%&$6%"-;"&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"9$)9:$)9&"

&9'"+-:'"&9@&"&9'"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&"6@(",:@?"$("0-=$;?$()"&9'"$0,@6&"-;"&9'"%-7(=")'('+@&'="

&9+-7)9"&9'"7(@*-$=@1:'"@6&$*$&$'%"&9@&"-667+"$("@"9-%,$&@:E"Q>@+'('%%"-;"&9'"7%'"-;"6-:-7+"

@(="&9'",+'%'(6'"-;"6:7&&'+">'+'"@:%-"9$)9:$)9&'="@%"1'$()"$%%7'%";-+"6-(%$='+@&$-(">9'("

'(9@(6$()"&9'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&"&-"$0,+-*'"&9'"'X,'+$'(6'"-;",'-,:'">9-"9@*'"

='0'(&$@E"

C9'"@69$'*'="-7&6-0'%"-;"&9$%"$($&$@&$*'")-"1'?-(="@6@='0$6";$(=$()%E"C-":$%&'("&-"&9-%'"

:$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@"-+"6@+$()";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"9@%")$*'("7%"@"1+-@='+",'+%,'6&$*'"

-("='0'(&$@"='%$)("@(=">'::.1'$()E""M&"1+-7)9&"@"=$;;'+'(&"=$0'(%$-("-;"$(&'+,+'&@&$-("&-"&9'"

+'%7:&%";-7(="$("%6$'(&$;$6"+',-+&%E"A'"9@*'"$='(&$;$'="&9+-7)9"&9$%"'X'+6$%'"&9@&"0@(?"

9'@:&96@+'"%'&&$()%5"@%"67++'(&:?"6-(;$)7+'=5"&+$))'+"(')@&$*'";'':$()%"%769"@%"%&+'%%"$("&9-%'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@E"C9$%"%@0'"(')@&$*$&?"$%"@==+'%%'="$("%6$'(&$;$6"+',-+&%"&9@&"6-(&+$17&'"

+'%'@+69"'*$='(6'"@1-7&"&9'"'(*$+-(0'(&"@(="$&%"$0,@6&%"-(",'-,:'":$*$()">$&9"='0'(&$@E"

]*'+@::5">'"%7))'%&"@+'@%"$("(''="-;";7+&9'+"+'%'@+69"@%"1'$()Y"

• C9'"$%%7'%"-;";7(6&$-(@:"@6&$*$&?"@(="%@;'&?"9$)9:$)9&'="$("&9'":$%&'($()"'*'(&"='0-(%&+@&'"

&9'"(''=";-+"$(&'+.,+-;'%%$-(@:"6-::@1-+@&$-("-("='%$)(V"-667,@&$-(@:"&9'+@,$%&%5"

@+69$&'6&%5"(7+%'%5";7+($&7+'"@(="'^7$,0'(&"='%$)('+%5"@6-7%&$6"='%$)('+%5":$)9&$()"

='%$)('+%5",@$(&"@(="6-:-7+"'X,'+&%5",9?%$-&9'+@,$%&%"@(="%-"-(5"@%">'::"@%"%71%&@(&$*'"

,71:$6"$(*-:*'0'(&"

• U'6$%$-(%"@1-7&"&9'"='%$)("@(="7%'"-;"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%"(''="&-"1@:@(6'"&9'"(''=%"

-;"@::"&9-%'">9-"7%'"&9'"%,@6'E"U'%$)("@(="6@+'"='6$%$-(%"(''="&-",+-0-&'"&9'"

$(=','(='(6'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(=",+-0-&'"&9'$+"%@;'&?E"C9'"69@::'()'"$%"&-"

Page 46: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"``"

,+-*$='"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%"@(="6@+'"&9@&"6@("0''&"&9'%'"@&"&$0'%"-;"6-(;:$6&$()"

='0@(=%"

• C9'"'*$='(6'"1@%'";-+">9@&"6-007($6@&$-("@,,+-@69'%">-+B";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"

@%">'::"@%"-&9'+%5"$("&'+0%"-;"$(&'+.,'+%-(@:"6-007($6@&$-(",+@6&$6'%"1?"%&@;;5"

&'69(-:-)$'%"@(="6@+'"'(*$+-(0'(&%"$%"$("(''="-;"+'*$'>"@(="='*':-,0'(&E"C9$%"0@?"1'"

7(='+,$(('="-+"6-0,:'0'(&'="1?"@"%?%&'0@&$6@::?"7(='+&@B'("+'*$'>"-;"&'69($^7'%"@(="

,+@6&$6'%"@(="&9'"&9'-+$'%"7(='+,$(($()"6-007($6@&$-("@,,+-@69'%"@(="&9'$+"

@,,:$6@&$-("$("9'@:&9"6@+'"+':@&'="%'&&$()%E"C9$%"$%"'%,'6$@::?"&9'"6@%'";-+"%'&&$()%"&9@&">$::"

@66-00-=@&'",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"

• C9@&"&9'"(''=%"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="6-007($6@&$-("$0,@$+0'(&"%769"@%"*$%7@:"

@(="9'@+$()"=$;;$67:&$'%"1'";7+&9'+"'X,:-+'="

• C9@&"%&@(=@+=%"-;"'=76@&$-("@(=",+',@+@&$-("-;"9'@:&9"6@+'"+':@&'="%&@;;"&-">-+B">$&9"

,'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+";@0$:$'%5"1'"'X,:-+'=""

• C9@&"&9'"'*$='(6'"1@%'";-+"%,'6$@:$%&"-+"$(&')+@&'="6@+'";@6$:$&$'%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"

='0'(&$@"@(="$0,@6&"-("6@+'"-7&6-0'%"N;-+"&9-%'">$&9"@(=">$&9-7&"='0'(&$@O5"$(6:7=$()"

,@&$'(&"@(="6@+'+"+',-+&'="-7&6-0'%5"$%"='*':-,'=""

• C9@&"p-667,@&$-(W"N9->"&$0'"$%"%,'(&"=@?.&-.=@?O"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$%";7+&9'+"

'X@0$('="

• C9@&"&9'"$0,@6&"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"'X,'+$'(6$()"6-(;7%$-("$%"6-(%$='+'="$("+':@&$-("

&-"6@+'"%&@;;5",@&$'(&%"@(="&9'",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"

• C9@&"0'@(%"-;",+-0-&$()"'X'+6$%'"%769"@%"%@;'">@:B$()"@%"@"0'@(%"-;"9':,$()",'-,:'"

>$&9"='0'(&$@"&-":$*'"@6&$*':?5"1'"'X,:-+'="

• C9@&",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@+'";@6$:$&@&'="@(="%7,,-+&'="&-"9@*'"0-+'"-;"@"%@?"$("&9'"

='*':-,0'(&"-;"&'69(-:-)$'%"@$0'="@&"'(9@(6$()"&9'$+"6@+'"@(="0@(@)'0'(&""

M("@==$&$-("&-"&9'"='%6+$1'="-7&6-0'%5"@("'X&'(='="('&>-+B"-;",'-,:'"@(="-+)@($%@&$-(%"

9@%"1''(";-+0'="@%"@"+'%7:&"-;"&9$%"$($&$@&$*'E"A$&9$("/@:;-+="@(="&9'"%7++-7(=$()"@+'@5"$&"

1+-7)9&"&-)'&9'+"Z2"@6@='0$6%E"8@&$-(@::?5"$&"+'@69'="'%&@1:$%9'=")+-7,%"@(="-+)@($%@&$-(%"

>$::$()"&-"%9@+'"&9'$+"'X,'+$'(6'"@(="B(->:'=)'"@+-7(="%769"@("'0'+)$()"&-,$6E"J$(@::?5"$&"

9@%"9':,'="&-"%'&"@"1'&&'+.$(;-+0'="=$+'6&$-(";-+"@"6-::@1-+@&$*'"+'%'@+69"@)'(=@E"

Page 47: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`h"

U'%,$&'"$&%",-%$&$*'"+'%7:&%5">'"@6B(->:'=)'"&9'":$0$&@&$-(%"-;"-7+"@,,+-@69E""C9$%"+',-+&"

%9-7:="(-&"1'"6-(%$='+'="N@(="$&">@%"(-&"$(&'(='="&-"1'O"@%"@"+'%'@+69"+',-+&E"C9'"0'&9-="

7%'=">@%"(-&"%6$'(&$;$6@::?"='%$)('="@(="@%"%769"$&"=-'%"(-&",+-*$='"%6$'(&$;$6"'*$='(6'5"17&"

+@&9'+"&'%&$0-(?E"A'"@:%-"7(='+%&@(=5"&9@&"&9'+'">@%"@("$01@:@(6'"+':@&'="&-"&9'"(701'+"

@(="'X,'+$'(6'"-;"-7+",@+&$6$,@(&%E"J-+"&9$%"+'@%-(">'"@+'"&@B$()"&9'">-+B";-+>@+="$("@"

(701'+"-;">@?%"$(6:7=$()"&9'":@7(69"-;"&9$%"+',-+&"@&"@"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+=":'="='0'(&$@"

6-(;'+'(6'"$("/',&'01'+"2342E"Q&"&9$%"%@0'"'*'(&">'">$::"1'";-+0@::?"@((-7(6$()"-7+"

$00$('(&",:@(%"&-"%'&"7,"@("$(&'+(@&$-(@:"='0'(&$@"='%$)("('&>-+BE""

J-+"&9-%'">$::$()"&-";-::->"&9'"%@0'"@,,+-@695"0769"0-+'"6@("1'"%9@+'="&9@&"9@%"(-&"1''("

+',-+&'="9'+'E"<-%&:?"$("+':@&$-("&-"&9'"6@,&7+'"-;"$(;-+0@&$-(5"&9@&"$("&9$%"6@%'">@%"

='%$)('="$("@"6-0,:'X">@?E"<769">@%":'@+(&"&9@&"6-7:="%7,,-+&"&9'",+',@+@&$-("-;"%6$'(&$;$6"

+'%'@+69"@(=">'">':6-0'";7+&9'+"a-$(&">-+B$()"=+@>$()"-("-7+"%,'6$;$6"'X,'+&$%'"@+-7(="

17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&5"='0'(&$@"6@+'5"$(6:7%$*'"='%$)("@(=",71:$6"@(="6-007($&?"'()@)'0'(&"

@(="$(*-:*'0'(&E""

"

Page 48: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`\"

W ?0D0?07A0C*

Q11-&&5"IE5"A9$&'5"#E5"I-%%5"AE5"<@%@B$5"PE5"L7+15"UE"@(="S'&+-*$&695"KE"N233`O"A@:B$()"@(="='0'(&$@"$(",9?%$6@::?"6@,@1:'"':='+:?"0'(E"n-7+(@:"-;"&9'"Q0'+$6@("<'=$6@:"Q%%-6$@&$-(5"2g2Y"4``[.4`hZ"

Q:&0@(5"ME"N4ggZOE"U$@:'6&$6%5",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&%5"@(=",'+%-(@:"+':@&$-(%9$,%E"L-007($6@&$-("<-(-)+@,9%"\3Y"2\kZ`E"

Q:e9'$0'+W%"/-6$'&?"N2342O"A9@&"$%"='0'(&$@s"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&"9&&,YRR>>>E@:e9'$0'+%E-+)E7BR%$&'R%6+$,&%R=-670'(&%E,9,s6@&')-+?MUu233Z\3"N@66'%%'="/',&"2342OE"

Q(='+%-(5"LE"QE"N4glgOE"C'0,'+@&7+'"@(="@))+'%%$-(Y"71$^7$&-7%"';;'6&%"-;"9'@&"-("-667++'(6'"-;"970@("*$-:'(6'E"S%?69-:-)$6@:"G7::'&$("43\Y"[`kg\E"

QSS_"NQ::"S@+&?"S@+:$@0'(&@+?"_+-7,O"N2344O"C9'"m23"G$::$-("^7'%&$-(5"K-7%'"-;"L-00-(%"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&">>>E=9E)-*E7B"N@66'%%'="n@(7@+?"2342O"

G@705"QE"@(="ME"J:'0$()"N4ggZOE"M0,:$6@&$-(%"-;",%?69-:-)$6@:"+'%'@+69"-("%&+'%%"@(="&'69(-:-)$6@:"@66$='(&%E"Q0'+$6@("S%?69-:-)$%&"`lY"\\hk\[E"

G@705"QE5"'&"@:E"N4gg3OE"Q67&'"%&+'%%-+%"@(="69+-($6"+'%,-(%'Y"&9'"6@%'"-;"&+@70@&$6"%&+'%%E"n-7+(@:"-;"Q,,:$'="/-6$@:"S%?69-:-)?"23Y"4\`Zkh`E"

G'::5"SE"QE"N4gg2OE"M("=';'(6'"-;"&9'"(')@&$*'"@;;'6&"'%6@,'"0-=':"-;"9'@&"@(="@))+'%%$-(E"S%?69-:-)$6@:"G7::'&$("444Y"Z`2k`\E"

G$('+5"SE5"'&"@:E"N4glgOE"Q("@+-7%@:"-,&$0$e@&$-("0-=':"-;":$)9&$()":'*':",+';'+'(6'%Y"@("$(&'+@6&$-("-;"%-6$@:"%$&7@&$-("@(="&@%B"='0@(=%E"T(*$+-(0'(&"@(="G'9@*$-+"24Y"Zk4\E"

G:-6B5"#E"@(="/E"_@+('&&"N4glgOE"S'+;-+0@(6'"@(="%@&$%;@6&$-("$(",+$*@&'"*'+%7%"(-(",+$*@&'">-+B"%'&&$()%E"T(*$+-(0'(&"@(="G'9@*$-+"24Y"2[[kg[E"

G-&&$))$5"PE5"L9@()5"nE5"/690$&&5"JE5"Q*$%-(5"<E5"<--&--+5"FE5"8@&95"QE"@(="G'+)'+5"nE"N233[O"C9'"KMj"U'0'(&$@"/6@:'Y"S+'=$6&$*'",->'+"$("0$:="='0'(&$@"@(="KQQIC5"n-7+(@:"-;"&9'"8'7+-:-)$6@:"/6$'(6'%"2\3Y"44.4h"

G+->(5"GE"GE"N4gg2OE"C9'"'6-:-)?"-;",+$*@6?"@(="0--="$("@"%9@+'=":$*$()")+-7,E"n-7+(@:"-;"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"S%?69-:-)?"42Y"hk23E"

G+->(5"GE"GE5"'&"@:E"N4gg2OE"L:-%'"+':@&$-(%9$,%"$("&9'",9?%$6@:"@(="%-6$@:">-+:=Y"=$@:'6&$6"@(="&+@(%@6&$-(@:"@(@:?%'%E"L-007($6@&$-("F'@+1--BE"/E"U''&eE"8'>17+?"S@+B5"LQ5"/@)'Y"h3gk22E"

G7+?5"<E"N4gg4O"C9'"/-6$-:-)?"-;"69+-($6"$::('%%Y"@"+'*$'>"-;"+'%'@+69"@(=",+-%,'6&%5"/-6$-:-)?"-;"9'@:&9"@(="$::('%%5"4ZY"`h4.`\l"

L@(&:'?5"LE"N'=EO"N2334O"Q"K@(=1--B"-;"U'0'(&$@"L@+'5"G76B$()9@05"],'("D($*'+%$&?"S+'%%E""

L--B5"<E"N4g[3O"TX,'+$0'(&%"-("-+$'(&@&$-("@(=",+-X'0$6%E"K70@("I':@&$-(%5"2ZY"\4.[\"

L--,'+5"IE5"G-?B-5"LE"@(="L-=$(9-&-5"IE"N233lO"/&@&'.-;./6$'(6'"I'*$'>Y"C9'"T;;'6&"-;"&9'"S9?%$6@:"T(*$+-(0'(&"-("<'(&@:"A'::1'$()E"J-+'%$)9&"<'(&@:"L@,$&@:"@(="A'::1'$()Y"

Page 49: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`["

<@B$()"&9'"0-%&"-;"-7+%':*'%"$("&9'"24%&"6'(&7+?E"_-*'+(0'(&"];;$6'";-+"/6$'(6'5"#-(=-(E"

U@?5"PE5"L@++'-(5"UE"@(="/&70,5"LE"N2333O"C9'"C9'+@,'7&$6"U'%$)("-;"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'"A$&9"U'0'(&$@5"C9'"_'+-(&-:-)$%&"`3N`OY"Zg[.`4\"

U'0'(&$@"/'+*$6'%"U'*':-,0'(&"L'(&+'"N2342O"U'%$)(";'@&7+'%"&-"@%%$%&",@&$'(&%">$&9"='0'(&$@"$(")'('+@:"9-%,$&@:%5"U/UL5"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/&$+:$()5"DP"

U'0'(&$@"DP"N2342O"N-(:$('O"A9@&"$%"='0'(&$@s"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&Y"9&&,YRR>>>E='0'(&$@7BE-+)R$(;-+0@&$-(.%7,,-+&R@1-7&.='0'(&$@Rv2"N@66'%%'="/',&"2342O"

U',@+&0'(&"-;"K'@:&9"N2343O"t7@:$&?"-7&6-0'%";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@Y"17$:=$()"-("&9'">-+B"-;"&9'"8@&$-(@:"U'0'(&$@"/&+@&')?"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&">>>E=9E)-*E7BR,71:$6@&$-(%"

U'%$)("L-7(6$:"N2344O"/$)(@)'"%?%&'0"N-(:$('O"9&&,YRR>>>E='%$)(6-7(6$:E-+)E7BRL@%'.%&7=$'%RU'%$)(.;-+.S@&$'(&.U$)($&?R/$)(@)'./?%&'0R"N@66'%%'="Q7)7%&"2344O"

J:'0$()"IE5"@(="S7+@(=@+'"8EN2343O"#-().&'+0"6@+'";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@Y"'(*$+-(0'(&@:"='%$)(")7$=':$('%5"M(&"S%?69-)'+$@&+E"22N[OY"43l`.g\E""

J7B7B@>@5"FE5"8@B@%9$(@5"8E5"Q(=-5"JE"@(="/9$0-B@&@5"KE"N233`O"Q)'"=$;;'+'(6'%"$("&9'"';;'6&"-;",9?%$6@:"@6&$*$&?"-("=',+'%%$*'"%?0,&-0%5"S%?69-:-)?"@(="Q)$()5"4gY"Z`\.Zh4"

_--=@::5"UE"N233\O"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"L9@()'%"M(6+'@%'"K-%,$&@:"/@;'&?";-+"U'0'(&$@"S@&$'(&%5"K-:$%&$6"87+%$()"S+@6&$6'5"23"N2OY"l3.l`"

_7&0@(5"_E"N233hO"L+$&$6@:"':'0'(&%"-;"&9'",9?%$6@:";'@&7+'%"-;"@("':='+:?";+$'(=:?"@67&'"6@+'"9-%,$&@:"'(*$+-(0'(&Y"Q":$&'+@&7+'"+'*$'>"7(='+&@B'(";-+"J+@%'+"K'@:&9E"j@(6-7*'+5"GLY"/$0-("J+@%'+"D($*'+%$&?5"_'+-(&-:-)?"I'%'@+69"L'(&'+E"

K@))@+=5"#E"<E"@(="LE"<E"A'+('+"N4gg3OE"w/$&7@&$-(@:"%7,,-+&5",+$*@6?"+')7:@&$-(5"@(="%&+'%%E"G@%$6"@(="Q,,:$'="/-6$@:"S%?69-:-)?"44Y"Z4ZkZ[E"

K@::5"TECE"N4g\lO"S+-X'0$6%E"L7++'(&"Q(&9+-,-:-)?"g"N2RZO5"Q,+$:Rn7('"4g\l"

K'=)'5"QE"N4glgOE"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"6-(=$&$-(%"@(="9'@:&9"$("-;;$6'%E"M(&'+(@&$-(@:"I'*$'>%"-;"T+)-(-0$6%"ZY"l[k443E"

K-1;-::5"/E"TE"N4gg4OE"C+@70@&$6"%&+'%%Y"@"&9'-+?"1@%'="-("+@,$=":-%%"-;"+'%-7+6'%E"Q(X$'&?"I'%'@+69"`Y"4l[kg[E"

K70,9+$'%5"IE"@(="L7++?5"8E"N2344O"M(&')+@&$()"K'@:&9"@(="/-6$@:"L@+'Y"A9'+'"8'X&s"C9'"P$()%"J7(=5"#-(=-("

M(&'+(@&$-(@:"#-()'*$&?"L'(&+'"k"DP"N-(:$('O"N@66'%%'="Q,+$:"2344O"$:67BE-+)E7B"

n-9("K-,B$(%"<'=$6$('"N-(:$('ON@66'%%'="n7('"2344O"9&&,YRR>>>E9-,B$(%0'=$6$('E-+)R,@&$'(&!6@+'R,@?!1$::R$(%7+@(6'!;--&(-&'%E9&0:"

P'++5"UE"N233[O"D(='+%&@(=$()":'@+($()"=$%@1$:$&?"@(="='0'(&$@Y"U'*':-,$()"';;'6&$*'"$(&'+*'(&$-(%E""n'%%$6@"P$()%:'?"S71:$6@&$-(%5"DP"

P$()W%"J7(="N2342O"C9'"T(9@(6$()"&9'"K'@:$()"T(*$+-(0'(&"Q%%'%%0'(&"C--:"@(="U'*':-,$()"%7,,-+&$*'"='%$)(";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&"

Page 50: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`l"

9&&,YRR>>>EB$()%;7(=E-+)E7BR67++'(&!,+-a'6&%R'(9@(6$()!&9'!9'@:$()!'(*$+-(0'(&R'9'!='%$)(E9&0:"N@66'%%'="/',&"2342O"

#@()"@(="G7$%%-("N233lO"L@+'"-;"':='+:?",'-,:'Y"DP"0@+B'&"%7+*'?"233lE"#@$()"@(="G7$%%-(5"DP"

#@+%-(5"TE"A@()5"#E5"G->'(5"nE5"<6L-+0$6B5"AE5"C'+$5"#E5"L+@('5"SE"@(="P7B7::5"AE"N233\O"TX'+6$%'"$%"@%%-6$@&'=">$&9"+'=76'="+$%B";-+"$(6$='(&"='0'(&$@"@0-()",'+%-(%"\h"?'@+%"-;"@)'"@(="-:='+5"Q((@:%"-;"M(&'+(@:"<'=$6$('5"4``N2OY"[Z.l4"

#@>%-(5"GE"N2334OE"C9'":@()7@)'"-;"%,@6'E"]X;-+=5"T:%'*$'+E"

#'&-7+('@75"/E"N233gO"K'@:&9"#$(B"Q:1'+&@Y"Q"<-=':";-+"/766'%%;7:"K'@:&9"/'+*$6'"M(&')+@&$-("$("K'@:&96@+'"t7@+&'+:?5"NjE4Z5"/,O"

#-'>'(5"#E"@(="SE"/7'=;':="N4gg2OE"L-)($&$*'"@(="@+-7%@:"';;'6&%"-;"0@%B$()"-;;$6'"(-$%'E"T(*$+-(0'(&"@(="G'9@*$-+"2`Y"Zl4kghE"

#7'()-.J'+(@(='e5"IE5"#'@:5"nE"@(="_+@?5"QE"N2343O"U'0'(&$@"2343Y"C9'"'6-(-0$6"17+='("-;"='0'(&$@"@(="@%%-6$@&'="+'%'@+69";7(=$()"$("&9'"D($&'="P$()=-05"K'@:&9"T6-(-0$6%"I'%'@+69"L'(&+'5"D($*'+%$&?"-;"]X;-+="

<@%:$(.S+-&9'+-5"/E"@(="G'(($-(5"QE"N2343O"M(&')+@&'="C'@0"A-+B$()Y"Q"#$&'+@&7+'"I'*$'>"$("M(&'+(@&$-(@:"n-7+(@:"-;"M(&')+@&'="L@+'5"43"

<6L+@6B'("@(="J$&e>@&'+"N4glgO"C9'"+$)9&"'(*$+-(0'(&";-+"Q:e9'$0'+W%Y"A9$69"$%"1'&&'+.-,'("*'+%7%"6:-%'="7($&%s"K'+'W%"9->"&-"&@$:-+"&9'"@(%>'+"&-"&9'",@&$'(&E"_'+$@&+$6"87+%$()5"43Y"2gZ.2g`E"

<':e'+5"UE5"K-,B$(%5"/E5"S'(69'-(5"UE5"G+@?('5"LE"@(="A$::$@0%5"IE"N4gg2O"T,$='0$-:-)$6@::?"G@%'="8''=%"Q%%'%%0'(&Y"U'0'(&$@E"#-(=-("Y"8K/"<@(@)'0'(&"TX'67&$*'"$("L@(&:'?5"LE"N'=O"C9'"K@(=1--B"-;"U'0'(&$@"L@+'5"],'("D($*'+%$&?"S+'%%"

<$(="N233[O"T6-&9'+@,?Y"C9'")+''("@)'(=@";-+"0'(&@:"9'@:&95"<$(=>''B"+',-+&E"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'";+-0">>>E0$(=E-+)E7B"N@66'%%'="n@("2342O"

<--+'5"<E"nEV"o975"LE"AE"@(="L:$,,5"TE"LE"N2333O"M(;-+0@:"L-%&%"-;"U'0'(&$@"L@+'Y"T%&$0@&'%"J+-0"&9'"8@&$-(@:"#-()$&7=$(@:"L@+')$*'+"/&7=?E"C9'"n-7+(@:%"-;"_'+-(&-:-)?Y"/'+$'%"G"h\"N`OY"24g./22lE"

8@&$-(@:"M(%&$&7&'";-+"K'@:&9"@(="L:$($6@:"TX6'::'(6'"R/-6$@:"L@+'"M(%&$&7&'";-+"TX6'::'(6'"N8MLTR/LMTO"N2344O"Q"8MLTk/LMT"_7$=':$('"-("%7,,-+&$()",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"@(="&9'$+"6@+'+%"$("9'@:&9"@(="%-6$@:"6@+'Y"8@&$-(@:"L:$($6@:"S+@6&$6'"_7$=':$('"8701'+"`25C9'"G+$&$%9"S%?69-:-)$6@:"/-6$'&?"@(="_@%B'::5"DP"

8K/"L-(;'='+@&$-("N2343O"Q67&'"Q>@+'('%%Y"M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"L@+'";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@E"C9'"8K/"L-(;'='+@&$-(5"#-(=-(E""

8K/"T%&@&'%"N4gg\O"Q66-00-=@&$-(";-+",'-,:'">$&9"0'(&@:"$::('%%E"KG8"Zh"k"S@+&"4Y"C9'"Q67&'"D($&E"#-(=-(5"K</]E"

S@+%-(%5"<E"N2334O"Q"K@(=1--B"-;"U'0'(&$@"L@+'"N'=O"L@+-:$('"L@(&:'?5"],'("D($*'+%$&?"S+'%%"5DP"

S+-%9@(%B?5"KE"<E5"'&"@:E"N4g[\OE"T(*$+-(0'(&@:",%?69-:-)?"Y",'-,:'"@(="&9'$+",9?%$6@:"%'&&$()%E"#-(=-(5"8'>"F-+B5"K-:&5"I$('9@+&"@(="A$(%&-(E"

Page 51: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`g"

I@0'%95"IE"N2343O"_-*'+(0'(&"9@%";@$:'="-("$&%"='0'(&$@",+-0$%'%5"%@?%"%,'(=$()">@&69=-)5"C9'"_7@+=$@(5"9&&,YRR>>>E)7@+=$@(E6-E7BR%-6$'&?"R2343Ra@(R4`R)-*'+(0'(&.,+-0$%'%.='0'(&$@.(@&$-(@:.@7=$&.-;;$6'E"""

I@?1'6B5"UE"N4gg4OE"S+-X'0$6%"@(=",+$*@6?Y"<@(@)$()"&9'",+-1:'0%"-;":$;'"$("6-(;$('="'(*$+-(0'(&%E"M("QE"QE"K@++$%-(5"FE"QE"L:'@+>@&'+5"q"LE"SE"<6P@?"NT=%EO5"J+-0"Q(&@+6&$6@"&-"-7&'+"%,@6'Y"#$;'"$("6-(;$('="'(*$+-(0'(&%"N,,E"Z4[.ZZ3OE"8'>"F-+BY"/,+$()'+.j'+:@)E""

I'$%1'+)5"GE5"J'++$%5"/EKE5"='"#'-(5"<EnE5"@(="L+--B5"CE"N4gl2OE"_:-1@:"U'&'+$-+@&$-("/6@:'"N_U/O5"Q0'+$6@("n-7+(@:"-;"S%?69$@&+?5"4ZgY"44Z\.44ZgE"

I-1'+&5"SEKE"'&"@:"N233hO"_+-7,$()";-+"1'9@*$-7+@:"@(=",%?69-:-)$6@:"%?0,&-0%"$("='0'(&$@Y"6:$($6@:"@(="1$-:-)$6@:"@%,'6&%E"L-(%'(%7%",@,'+"-;"&9'"T7+-,'@("Q:e9'$0'+"U$%'@%'"L-(%-+&$70E"T7+-,'@("S%?69$@&+?V"23Y"`g3"k"`g\E"

I-?@:"L-::')'"-;"87+%$()"N2342O"L-00$&0'(&"&-"&9'"6@+'"-;",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@"$(")'('+@:"9-%,$&@:%"N-(:$('O"@*@$:@1:'"@&Y"9&&,YRR>>>E+6(E-+)E7BR='*':-,0'(&R,+@6&$6'R='0'(&$@R6-00$&0'(&!&-!&9'!6@+'!-;!,'-,:'!>$&9!='0'(&$@!$(!)'('+@:!9-%,$&@:%R6-00$&0'(&!&-!='0'(&$@"N@66'%%'="/',&"2342OE"

I71-($%5"QE"jE"@(="#E"G$6B0@("N4gg4OE"S%?69-:-)$6@:"$0,@$+0'(&"$("&9'">@B'"-;"=$%@%&'+E"S%?69-:-)$6@:"G7::'&$("N43gOY"Zl`kggE"

/@6B'&&5UE#E5"/&+@7%5"/ETE5I$69@+=%-(5"AE/E"@(="I-%'(1'+)"AE"N2333O"T*$='(6'.G@%'="<'=$6$('Y"K->"&-"S+@6&$6'"@(="C'@69"TG<5"L97+69$::"#$*$()%&-('5"DPE"

/69-))'(5"SE"N4glgOE"G'9@*$-+"/'&&$()%E"/&@(;-+=5"LQ5"/&@(;-+="D($*'+%$&?"S+'%%E"

/0$&95"QE"SE"N4gg4OE"8-$%'"@(="@%,'6&%"-;"@&&'(&$-(E"G+$&$%9"n-7+(@:"-;"S%?69-:-)?"l2Y"Z4Zk2`E"

/-00'+5"IE"@(="QE"AE"A$6B'+"N4gg4OE"_@%"%&@&$-(",%?69-:-)?Y"&9'"6@%'";-+"%,'6$@:$e@&$-("$("'6-:-)$6@:",%?69-:-)?E"T(*$+-(0'(&"@(="G'9@*$-+"2ZY"4Z4k`gE"

/7(=%&+-05"TE5"'&"@:E"N4gg\OE"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"S%?69-:-)?"4glg.4gg`E"Q((7@:"I'*$'>"S%?69-:-)?"`[Y"`lh.h42E"

/7%&@$(@1:'"='*':-,0'(&"6-00$%%$-("N233lO"K'@:&95"S:@6'"@(="8@&7+'Y"K->"-7&=--+"'(*$+-(0'(&%"$(;:7'(6'"9'@:&9"@(=">'::1'$()Y"@"B(->:'=)'"1@%'E"Q*@$:@1:'"@&Y"9&&,YRR>>>E%=.6-00$%%$-(E-+)E7BR=@&@R;$:'%R,71:$6@&$-(%R]7&=--+!'(*$+-(0'(&%!@(=!9'@:&9E,=;"

C'$%1'+)5"TE"N2344O"M0,+-*$()"j@:7'Y"K'@:&9"@(="L@+'"$("&9'"DP5"G7%$('%%"%&+@&')?"I'*$'>5"M%%7'"4E""

C9@?'+5"IE"TE"N4glgOE"C9'"G$-S%?69-:-)?"-;"<--="@(="Q+-7%@:E"8'>"F-+B5"]X;-+="D($*'+%$&?"S+'%%E"

D:+$695"IE5"x$@-1-5"tE5"o$0+$()5"LE5"n-%',95"QE5"L9-7=9@+?5"IE"N233`O"C9'"I-:'"-;"&9'"S9?%$6@:"T(*$+-(0'(&"$("&9'"K-%,$&@:"-;"&9'"24%&"L'(&7+?Y"Q"](6'.$(.@.#$;'&$0'"],,-+&7($&?5"I-1'+&"A--="n-9(%-("J-7(=@&$-(E"

D&&-(5"UE"N233\O"U'%$)($()"K-0'%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@E"K@>B'+"S71:$6@&$-(%5"DP"

Page 52: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"h3"

D&&-(5"UE"N233gO"C9'"='%$)("-;"9-7%$()";-+",'-,:'">$&9"='0'(&$@E"n-7+(@:"-;"L@+'"/'+*$6'%"<@(@)'0'(&5"Z"N`OY"Zl3.Zg3E"

j'$&695"nE"QE"N4gg3OE"];;$6'"(-$%'"@(="$::70$(@&$-("';;'6&%"-("+'@=$()"6-0,+'9'(%$-(E"n-7+(@:"-;"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"S%?69-:-)?"43Y"23gk4[E"

j'+('5"nE5"K@++$%5"/E"@(="K-5"UE"N2344O"U'0'(&$@R<'(&@:"L@,@6$&?"M%%7'%Y"8'>"$(%$)9&%"$(&-",:@6'"-;"='@&9";-+",'-,:'">$&9"Q:e9'$0'+f%"=$%'@%'5"='0'(&$@"@(="%'($:$&?5"G<n"/7,,-+&"S@::$@&"L@+'V"4Y4"

j$6&-+5"LE"IE"N2343O"Q)'$()5"K'@:&9"@(="L@+'5"C9'"S-:$6?"S+'%%5"DP"

j-("P-+;;5"<E5"_+70@(5"nE5"/69@';'+5"nE5"L7++?5"/E"@(="A@)('+5"TE"N4gg[O"L-::@1-+@&$*'"<@(@)'0'(&"-;"69+-($6"$::('%%5"Q((@:%"-;"$(&'+(@:"0'=$6$('5"42["N42OY"43g[.4432"

A'::%5"LE"N4g[lO"L9+-($6"1+@$("=$%'@%'Y"@("-*'+*$'>"$("Q0'+$6@("n-7+(@:"-;"S%?69$@&+EV"4ZhY"4.42"$("K7)9'%5"N4gl2O"Q"('>"6:$($6@:"%6@:'";-+"&9'"%&@)$()"-;"='0'(&$@5"C9'"G+$&$%9"n-7+(@:"-;"S%?69$@&+?5"4`3Y"h\\.h[2"

A'+('+5"LE"<E5"'&"@:E"N4gg2OE"wQ"&+@(%@6&$-(@:"@,,+-@69"&-"$(&'+,'+%-(@:"+':@&$-(%Y",9?%$6@:"'(*$+-(0'(&5"%-6$@:"6-(&'X&"@(="&'0,-+@:"^7@:$&$'%Ew"n-7+(@:"-;"/-6$@:"@(="S'+%-(@:"I':@&$-(%9$,%5"gY"2g[kZ2`E"

A$6B'+5"QE"AE"N4gg2OE"<@B$()"%'(%'"-;"'(*$+-(0'(&%E"S'+%-(.T(*$+-(0'(&"S%?69-:-)?Y"<-=':%"@(="S'+%,'6&$*'%E"AE"GE"A@:%95"PE"KE"L+@$B"@(="IE"KE"S+$6'5"K$::%=@:'Y"4h[kg2E"

A$6B'+5"QE"AE"@(="IE"QE"Q7)7%&"N4gghOE"K->";@+"%9-7:=">'")'('+@:$e's"C9'"6@%'"-;"@">-+B:-@="0-=':E"S%?69-:-)$6@:"/6$'(6'"\Y"Zgk``E"

F'++'::5"S"N233lO"_+''("_?0"(@&$-(@:"'*@:7@&$-("+',-+&Y"/700@+?"-;";$(=$()%"N-(:$('O"9&&,YRR>>>2E1&6*E-+)E7BR))!'*@:7@&$-(!3Z3lE,=;""

o'$%':5"nE"N233gO"MW0"/&$::"K'+'Y"Q"G+'@B&9+-7)9"@,,+-@69"&-"7(='+%&@(=$()"%-0'-('":$*$()">$&9"Q:e9'$0'+W%5"S$@&B7%5"DP"

o'$%':5"nE5"/$:*'+%&'$("58E<E5"K?='5"nE5"#'*B-;;5"/E5"#@>&-(5"<ESE5"K-:0'%5"AE"N233ZO"T(*$+-(0'(&@:"6-++':@&'%"&-"1'9@*$-+@:"9'@:&9"-7&6-0'%"$("Q:e9'$0'+f%"%,'6$@:"6@+'"7($&%E"_'+-(&-:-)$%&E"`ZNhOY"\g[.[44E"

"

"

"

"

"

"

Page 53: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

M0,+-*$()"K-%,$&@:"T(*$+-(0'(&%";-+"S'-,:'">$&9"U'0'(&$@"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"h4"

Y B33076!A0C*

B##1(@'e*NS*9$1.[@%4(*%2*=.,-1@*&%-1,*'(*-51*=%/%O$1@*@%-,*1e1$=',1**

Q==$&$-(@:"$(;-+0@&$-(Y"L-:-7+'="=-&%"'X'+6$%'"

• F'::->u"S'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@"-+"$(;-+0@:"6@+'+"u"Zh"=-&%"• G:7'u",+@6&$&$-('+"N8K/Ou"g3"=-&%"• I'=u",+@6&$&$-('+"N(-("8K/Ou"Z3"=-&%"• _+''(u"U'%$)('+u"4Z"=-&%"

T@69"9'@=$()"&-&@:"$("&@1:'"4"u">'$)9&'="*-&'"N&-&@:u"ZgZO"u"i"-;">'$)9&'="*-&'"N&-&@:"u"433"iOE"I'%7:&%Y"";+'^7'(6?"N@%",'+6'(&@)'"-;"'@69"6-:-7+u">'$)9&'="*-&'O*

C9'"1+'@B=->("-;"*-&'%";-+"'@69"6@&')-+?"$%",+'%'(&'="1':->E"C9'"(701'+%"$("1+@6B'&%"+',+'%'(&"&9'">'$)9&'=",'+6'(&@)'";-+"'@69"%&@B'9-:='+")+-7,E"J$)7+'"4"%9->%"&9'"+'%7:&%">$&9"&9'";7::"(701'+"-;"6@%&"*-&'%E*

• "K->"=-"M";$(="0?">@?"u"g`"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u"2ZEg2"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• Z="%$)(@)'.%$0,:$6$&?"-;"%$)(@)'.6-01$(@&$-("-;"&+$))'+%Y"\""N23O"+'=R"2"N4hO")+''(R"h"N4`O"?'::->R"42"N4ZO"1:7'"gXb*

• J+$'(=:?"@%%$%&@(6'Y"4"N4O"1:7'gN"• /$)(@)'",$6&7+'%.'?'":'*':%."@1$:$&?"&-",'+%-(@:$%'"'E)"&-$:'&%Y"Z"+'="N43OR"4"NlO")+''("R"2"

N\O"?'::->"R"4"N4O"1:7'"*gRW"• /$)(@)'."&--"0769"&'X&5">+-()"9'$)9&"N;-+"%&@;;"@(=",'+%-(">$&9"='0'(&$@O5"0-+'"7%'"

-;"%?01-:%5"6-:-7+"6-='Y"2"N[O+'=R"2"N2O"1:7'"gQ*

• /&@;;"@(=",'+%-(@:"'()@)'0'(&"u"l4N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"."N(-&'"[g,-$(&%";-+"6@+'"+':@&'="$%%7'"(-&"17$:&"'(*$+-(0'(&O"u"23E\4"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• M0,+-*'="6-007($6@&$-(.,'+%-(@:"6@+'",:@("@%"1'="%$='")7$='5"&+@$($()"-;"%&@;;Y"2Z"N2\O"1:7'R"4"NlO")+''(Rl"N2`O"?'::->R\"N23O"+'="gYb"

• S+$*@6?.">+-()":@?"-7&.:$&&:'"%,@6'."6:@7%&+-,9-1$6Y"4"NZO"?'::->"g*U*

• K->"6@("M";'':"%@;'"u"\4"N>'$)9&'="*-&'Ou"4hEh2"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• Q%%$%&$*'"&'69(-:-)?."@*-$=";@::"9@e@+=%5">@(='+$()"@1-7&"N%'(%-+%OY"2"N\O"?'::->"gW"• S'-,:'">$&9"B(->:'=)'"-;"='0'(&$@"6-(%7:&'="-("='%$)(5"-,'+@&$-(%"@(="+$%B"

@%%'%%0'(&Y"4\"N4lO"1:7'R`""N42O"?'::->R"Z"N43O"+'=R"2"N4hO")+''("gXX"• U'%$)("&-"='6+'@%'",'+6'$*'="%@;'&?"N*$%7@:"$0,@$+0'(&5",9?%$6@:":$0$&@&$-(%O"'E)"):@%%"

+@$:%"-("4%&";:--+":'*':."(''="&-"1'"-,@^7'"

• K'@:&9R"9?)$'('R"$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:"u"Zg"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"ugEg2"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• S@&$'(&"'X,'+$'(6'"-+"$(;'6&$-("6-(&+-:"&@+)'&%Y"4NZO"+'=R4"NlO")+''(R"4"N4O1:7'"gNR"• /9@+$()"B(->:'=)'"1'&>''(",+@6&$&$-('+%Y"4"NZO?'::->"gU"• J+''=-0."@67&'"9-%,$&@:%"6-7:=":'@+(";+-0"0'(&@:"9'@:&9"N$("?-7+"1'="-+"1'%$='"?-7+"

1'=OY"Z"N43O"+'=Y"`"N`O"1:7'"gNV"• K'@:&95"9?)$'('"@(="%@;'&?"*'+%7%";+''=-0"-;"6-(&+-:Y"4"NlO")+''(R"2"N2O"1:7'"gNT"

• I--0">$&9"@"*$'>"u"ZlN>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u"gE\["i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

Page 54: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

C9'"D($*'+%$&?"-;"/@:;-+="!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"h2"

• M(=--+"%,@6'%";-+"@+&R07+@:%R$(&'+@6&$*'")@=)'&%Y"4"NZO"+'=R"4"N4O"1:7'"gV"• j$+&7@:")+''("%,@6'%"-("1+$6B">@::%"N&9+-7)9">$(=->%"-+"$(=--+%O"`"N`O"1:7'RZ"N2ZO"

)+''(R"4"NZO"?'::->"gUT"• I'@:">-+:=")@+='(.*$'>%.>@&69$()">-+:=")-"1?Y"4"N4O"1:7'R4"NZO"+'="gV"

• M&W%"&--"(-$%?"u"2h"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u\EZ\"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• 8-$%'."&9'+'"$%"@"(''="&-"':$0$(@&'"%7++-7(=$()"(-$%'."@6-7%&$6",:@(($()Y"Z"1:7'"N`O"R"2"N4hO")+''(R2"N\O"?'::->"gRX"

• D%'"-;";@1+$6R%,@6'"='%$)("&-"0$($0$%'"'69-'%"@(="@==+'%%"@6-7%&$6"+':@&'="$%%7'%"• D(('6'%%@+?"(-$%'."6@::"17ee'+%.a7%&"7%'":$)9&%"-+"':'6&+-($6"0'@(%"'E)E",@)'%"

• D%$()"6-:-7+"u"4l"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u"`Ehl"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• 8@&7+@:",@:@&'";-+"1@6B)+-7(="6-:-7+%"+@&9'+"&9@("@+&$;$6$@:"6-:-7+%"'E)E"?'::->")--="69-$6'"N'X6',&">9'+'"$%"@"%,'6$;$6"=--+"-+":'@=$()"&-"@("$0,-+&@(&">@:B>@?OY"Z""N43O"+'=R"2"N\O"?'::->"gNW"

• S@&&'+(."-B"k7,"&-":'*':";-7(="$("(@&7+@:"0@&'+$@:%"+@&9'+"&9@("9'$)9&'('="@+&$;$6$@:",@&&'+("

• /$)(@)'"@(="6-:-7+"6-='%"@::">'::"@(=")--="17&"-;&'("%$)(%"@+'"9$)9"7,E"L-:-7+'=",@&9%"@+'"=$%&+@6&$()"@(=",'-,:'"(-&"@1:'"&-":'@+(R+'0'01'+"+-7&'%5"%-"(''="&-"='%$)("-7&"&9'"(''="&-"+'0'01'+Y"2""N2O"1:7'"gR"

• L-:-7+"-;"=--+%"@::"&9'"%@0'."&--"0769"%@0'('%%"k"=-(W&"B(->">9'+'"&9'?"@+'"

• C--"0769"6:7&&'+"u"\"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u4EhZ"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• #@6B"-;"6:7&&'+"&-"@*-$="@66$='(&%"-;",@&$'(&%"0-*$()";+-0"-('",-%$&$-("&-"@(-&9'+Y"h"N\O"1:7'"gW"

• L-(&'X&"-;"6@+'."%-0'"6:7&&'+"$%"*$&@:"&-"0@$(%&+'@0">@+="17&"$("%,'6$@:$%&"6@+'"6:7&&'+"9@%"&-"1'"0@(@)'="

• ]&9'+",+$-+$&$'%"u"Z4"N>'$)9&'="*-&'O"u"[Elg"i">'$)9&'="*-&'"

• L-.:-6@&$-("-;"0'=$6@:"@(="0'(&@:"9'@:&9V"`"N42O"?'::->R"4"N4O"1:7'"gNU"• <'@%7+$()"&9'"6-%&"-;"%-:7&$-(%"@)@$(%&"+'%-7+6'%"67++'(&:?"@*@$:@1:'Y"2"N2O"1:7'"gR"• M(6:7%$-("-;"6@+'+%"@&":'@%&"$(",:@(($()"@(="@:%-"$("6@++?$()"-7&"-;"6@+'",:@(E"J@6$:$&$'%"

&-"'(@1:'"&9$%.":@+)'+"1'="%,@6'5",+$*@&'"+--0%5"'X&+@"69@$+R1'=Y"2"1:7'"N2O"R"4"NZO"+'=R"2""N\O"?'::->"gNN"

• #$;'"%&-+?">-+BY"h"N\O"1:7'R"4"NZO"?'::->"gU"• <@B'"$&":--B":$B'">9@&"$&"$%."@"9-%,$&@:Y"2"N2O"1:7'gR"

Page 55: Dementia Improving Hospital Environments - …usir.salford.ac.uk/23376/1/Dementia_Improving_Hospital_Environme… · Improving hospital environments for People with dementia: Listening

The image on the front cover is a piece of art work developed by graphic designer John Rooney. His starting point was a scanned image of the blood flow through the brain of a person with dementia. The concave fold in the acrylic glass represents the two hemispheres of the brain and the holes represent the dementia related changes in the brain. The tilted acrylic glass sheet represents the need to consider the altered perceptions and experience that may result from dementia and the view of the sky represents the importance of maintaining a positive and appreciative view of the life experience of people living with dementia. The image created by John Rooney is now the logo for the International Dementia Design group hosted by the University of Salford.

University of SalfordSalford, M5 4WTt: +44 (0)161 295 5000www.salford.ac.uk ISBN: 978-1-907842-35-1