defendants. ) this matter is beforethe courton two setsof ......v. ) caseno. 1:14-cv-01043-gbl.idd)...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
ALEXANDRIA DIVISION
PRO-FOOTBALL, INC., )
)Plaintiff, )
)V. ) Case No. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD
)AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )
)Defendants. )
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
THIS MATTER is before the Court on two sets of cross-motions for summary judgment.
First, Plaintiff Pro-Football, Inc. ("PFI"), Defendants Amanda Blackhorse, Marcus Briggs-
Cloud, Phillip Cover, Jillian Pappan, and Courtney Tsotigh ("Blackhorse Defendants"), and the
United States of America filed cross-motions for summary judgment on PFI's claims challenging
the constitutionality of Section 2(a) of the Lanham Act (Counts III-VI) (Docs. 54, 105, and 108).
Second, Blackhorse Defendants and PFI filed cross-motions for summary judgment on PFI's
claims contesting the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board's ("TTAB") Order cancelling the
registrations of six of PFI's trademarks on the grounds that they consisted of matter that "may
disparage" Native Americans and bring them into contempt or disrepute, and that the defense of
laches does not bar the claims (Counts I, II, and VII) (Docs. 69 and 79). This case concerns
Blackhorse Defendants' petition to cancel the registration of six trademarks owned by PFI on the
grounds that the marks consisted of matter that "may disparage" a substantial composite of
Native Americans and bring them into contempt or disrepute under Section 2(a) of the Lanham
Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1052(a), at the time of their registrations (1967, 1974, 1978, and 1990).
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 1 of 70 PageID# 6097
![Page 2: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 2 of 70 PageID# 6098
![Page 3: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 3 of 70 PageID# 6099
![Page 4: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 4 of 70 PageID# 6100
![Page 5: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 5 of 70 PageID# 6101
![Page 6: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 6 of 70 PageID# 6102
![Page 7: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 7 of 70 PageID# 6103
![Page 8: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 8 of 70 PageID# 6104
![Page 9: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 9 of 70 PageID# 6105
![Page 10: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 10 of 70 PageID# 6106
![Page 11: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 11 of 70 PageID# 6107
![Page 12: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 12 of 70 PageID# 6108
![Page 13: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 13 of 70 PageID# 6109
![Page 14: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 14 of 70 PageID# 6110
![Page 15: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 15 of 70 PageID# 6111
![Page 16: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 16 of 70 PageID# 6112
![Page 17: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 17 of 70 PageID# 6113
![Page 18: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 18 of 70 PageID# 6114
![Page 19: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 19 of 70 PageID# 6115
![Page 20: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 20 of 70 PageID# 6116
![Page 21: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 21 of 70 PageID# 6117
![Page 22: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 22 of 70 PageID# 6118
![Page 23: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 23 of 70 PageID# 6119
![Page 24: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 24 of 70 PageID# 6120
![Page 25: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 25 of 70 PageID# 6121
![Page 26: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 26 of 70 PageID# 6122
![Page 27: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 27 of 70 PageID# 6123
![Page 28: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 28 of 70 PageID# 6124
![Page 29: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 29 of 70 PageID# 6125
![Page 30: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 30 of 70 PageID# 6126
![Page 31: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 31 of 70 PageID# 6127
![Page 32: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 32 of 70 PageID# 6128
![Page 33: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 33 of 70 PageID# 6129
![Page 34: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 34 of 70 PageID# 6130
![Page 35: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 35 of 70 PageID# 6131
![Page 36: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 36 of 70 PageID# 6132
![Page 37: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 37 of 70 PageID# 6133
![Page 38: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 38 of 70 PageID# 6134
![Page 39: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 39 of 70 PageID# 6135
![Page 40: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 40 of 70 PageID# 6136
![Page 41: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 41 of 70 PageID# 6137
![Page 42: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 42 of 70 PageID# 6138
![Page 43: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 43 of 70 PageID# 6139
![Page 44: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 44 of 70 PageID# 6140
![Page 45: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 45 of 70 PageID# 6141
![Page 46: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 46 of 70 PageID# 6142
![Page 47: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 47 of 70 PageID# 6143
![Page 48: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 48 of 70 PageID# 6144
![Page 49: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 49 of 70 PageID# 6145
![Page 50: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 50 of 70 PageID# 6146
![Page 51: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 51 of 70 PageID# 6147
![Page 52: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 52 of 70 PageID# 6148
![Page 53: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 53 of 70 PageID# 6149
![Page 54: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 54 of 70 PageID# 6150
![Page 55: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 55 of 70 PageID# 6151
![Page 56: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 56 of 70 PageID# 6152
![Page 57: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 57 of 70 PageID# 6153
![Page 58: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 58 of 70 PageID# 6154
![Page 59: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 59 of 70 PageID# 6155
![Page 60: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 60 of 70 PageID# 6156
![Page 61: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 61 of 70 PageID# 6157
![Page 62: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 62 of 70 PageID# 6158
![Page 63: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 63 of 70 PageID# 6159
![Page 64: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 64 of 70 PageID# 6160
![Page 65: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 65 of 70 PageID# 6161
![Page 66: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 66 of 70 PageID# 6162
![Page 67: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 67 of 70 PageID# 6163
![Page 68: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 68 of 70 PageID# 6164
![Page 69: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 69 of 70 PageID# 6165
![Page 70: Defendants. ) THIS MATTER is beforethe Courton two setsof ......V. ) CaseNo. 1:14-cv-01043-GBL.IDD) AMANDA BLACKHORSE, et al., )) Defendants. ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER THIS MATTER](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050601/5fa8159a2505133677064302/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
Case 1:14-cv-01043-GBL-IDD Document 161 Filed 07/08/15 Page 70 of 70 PageID# 6166