decision system planning systems nepa process. agency administrative decision making id roadless...

12
Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process

Upload: paulina-price

Post on 04-Jan-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Decision System

Planning Systems

NEPA Process

Page 2: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Agency Administrative Decision Making

ID Roadless Rule

Page 3: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

DISCLOSURE ENGAGEMENT Procedural & Legal

Compliance Bilinear Mechanization Explicit Knowledge Codification Closed System Narrow Scope –

exclusive Standardization

Decision Making & Public Involvement

Iterative Professionalization Tacit Knowledge Personalization Open System Inclusive – Relationship

oriented Customization &

Innovation

Page 4: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Simple Hard Complex Wicked

Page 5: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Portfolio of Problems

SimpleHardComplexWicked

Page 6: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule
Page 7: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Stages of the structured decision making process (after Hammond et al. 1999; in Marcot et al. 2012)

Page 8: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule
Page 9: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Findings

What decision

criteria do we need to meet?

What is the purpose? (objectives)

Why are we doing this project? (need)

Page 10: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule

Ultimate Conclusion

Basic Conclusions

Evidence

Significance threshold

Design criteria, assumptions

Rationale for ultimate conclusion

Finding

Page 11: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule
Page 12: Decision System Planning Systems NEPA Process. Agency Administrative Decision Making ID Roadless Rule