decision makers needs workshop report - oct 2013

8/13/2019 Decision Makers Needs Workshop Report - Oct 2013

1/51

FIELD-BASED

DECISION

MAKERS

INFORMATION

NEEDS

REPORT FROM THE WORKSHOP ON

in Sudden Onset Disasters

DM N

October 2013


2/51

Community

DM N

AUTHORS:

Erica Gralla ([email protected])George Washington University

Jarrod Goentzel ([email protected])Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Bartel Van de Walle ([email protected])Tilburg University

WORKSHOP ORGANISERS:

Lars Peter Nissen([email protected])

Assessments Capacities Project

Andrej Verity ([email protected] | @andrejverity)United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs

DESIGNER:Ana Macau ([email protected])

M.D. 13 Universidade Lusfona de Humanidades e Tecnologias

This framework was developed through ACAPS and UN-OCHAs support to the

Decision Makers Needs Community of Interest

http://digitalhumanitarians.com/communities/decision-makers-needs

Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported


3/51

CONTENTS

FOREWORD

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

1. INTRODUCTION

MOTIVATION

OBJECTIVE

SCOPE

ORGANIZATION, SUPPORT, AND FACILITATION

SUMMARY OF WORKSHOP PROGRAM

INTRODUCTION TO RESULTS

2. DECISIONSDETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DECISIONS EXERCISE

GROUP RESULTS FOR DECISIONS EXERCISE

CONSOLIDATED RESULTS OF DECISIONS EXERCISE

POTENTIAL DECISION FRAMEWORKS BASED ON THE

CONSOLIDATED RESULTS

3. INFORMATION

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INFORMATIONEXERCISE

GROUP RESULTS FOR INFORMATION EXERCISE

SURVEY ON INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS

CONSOLIDATED RESULTS

4. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION

Appendix A: Workshop Program and Participants

Appendix B: List of Tables and Figures

3

5

9

9

9

10

10

11

11

1212

13

24

25

27

27

28

35

39

45

47

50


4/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

56 78

!"#$%"#&

%9:; :; < =>?@=A >F A@ GE@D :E A9> H:=;A D>>G; @H < F:;=I %:O>F A@ FI .E A9> ?D P> O@MCEA>>= K9E:KFMP ;9@DE A9> ?@A>EA: A9> HCMM ?@A>EA:

JC:F>F BP < KM>=;A F>K:;:@EW>EL>EA;I %9> :;;C>

9>E =F =>?>FMP BP A9> RS%3 K@LLCE:AP :A;>MHI '@= >XN :E YZ[[N A9> 4E:A>F

- H@= A9> 3@@=F:E


5/51


6/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

b6 78

$($)*+,-$ .*//0#1

%9> F>O>M@?L>EA D A>K9E@M@JP :EA>=E>A 9E>F < E>D D@=MF @H

?@;;:B:M:A:>; A@ J= F

R@MCEA>>= K9E:K; QR%3T :E =>K>EA K=:;>;I )@D>O>=N :A :; E@A KM> A@ L A9> B>;A ?@;;:BM> F>K:;:@E;I 2; < =>;CMAN :A :;

F:HH:KCMA H@= A9> R%3;N =;N A@ K@MM>KA E @E;>A F:;=N BF @E

:EA>= :E?CA H=@L H:>MFWBF F>K:;:@E L=;I %9> H=D@=G L>EA; ;9@CMF HAA>= ;C??@=A AA>= F>K:;:@EWL?@=A F>;K=:B>; A9> ]*@=G;9@? @E ':>MFW1F 0>K:;:@EW(=;` .EH@=L>F; :E

,CFF>E $E;>A 0:;=;N_ ; < F>AF F>;K=:?A:@E @H :A; ?=@K>;; ;CMA;I %9:;

>X>KCA:O> ;CLL; ;@L> @H A9> G>P =>;CMA; =;A

?=@K>;; BP D9:K9 A9>;> =>;CMA; D>=> O>FN ?M> =>H>= A@ A9> LEAI .E B=:>HN

? F A@ B=K:;:@E; L>EA;N A9>E F:;KC;;

A9> =>;CMA;I

%9> D@=G;9@? H@KC;>F @E < ;:EJM> A:L>H= c A9> :E:A:E @E;>A F:;= c

F J=@C? @H F>K:;:@EWL=; c A9> :EA>=E K@LLCE:API 2 B=@A @H

F>K:;:@E; D>=> K@E;:F>=>FN ;?=EKPN :EA>=WKMC;A>=N KMC;A>= ;CMA; @CAM:E:EJ A9> AP?>; @H F>K:;:@E; L :E < =>;?@E;> J:O>E B>M@D :E % [

QA9> ; =>?@=ATN D9:K9 M:;A; ;>O>E F:L>E;:@E; K:;:@E; L:J9A

B> G>P =>;CMA; @CAM:E:EJ A9> :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; H@= =>;?@E;> J:O>E

B>M@D :E ':JC=> [ QA9> ;


7/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

e6 78

f:O>E A9> >XA>E;:O> >X?>=:>EK> @H A9> F>K:;:@E L=; LBM>F H@= A9> D@=G;9@?N A9>

=>;CMA; @HH>= EA;I

'>>FB?@=A E HC=A9>= =>H:E>L>EA

:L?@=A @H A9> H=D@=G; F>;K=:B>F :E A9:; =>?@=AI

$E> J@>= K9E:K; QR%3T A@

CEF>=;A :EH@=LMF F>K:;:@EWL=; =>VC:=> A@ L A9> B>;A ?@;;:BM> F>K:;:@E;I

%9>;> =>;CMA; M

MFWBF F>K:;:@EWL=;N QYT KJ@=:>; ; @H F>K:;:@E;

L BP F>K:;:@EWL=;N A @H B=F F>K:;:@E; H=@L D@=G;9@?

?G:EJ A@ ;C??@=A 9CL


8/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

86 78

&,/$2.,"2 )0+$3"#,$.

%.("'!2(" [I ':=;A F


9/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

d6 78

5+364% '( 7+*2-4+"$ 86//"49 -: ;.:-4/"2+-. ,2)&> ,2 -$-> -&4 @+ A--(% )1( 5?)1% " 0$ $-40 ?04 )% =1&-$1 )? $-%501 %- 5 ?)1

3&)&7% 0" )""-4&-(: (#%5?)4-(> -&4@ =1&-$1)? 4)5)4#&*> %&$74&7$-

G01&-H& C %2-?&-$> ,)&-$> -&4@+ C440/5?#%2/-1&%

I04)% 0" 1--(% L-)%7$#16 )1( 07&57&%

A--(% 0" %7FJ6$075%: (#%5?)4-(>


10/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

i6 78

45.-%!$043%.$-

%9:; =>?@=A F>;K=:B>; A9> ]*@=G;9@? @E ':>MFW1F 0>K:;:@EW(=;` .EH@=L>F; :E

,CFF>E $E;>A 0:;=;N_ ; < F>AF F>;K=:?A:@E @H :A; ?=@K>;; ;CMA;I ':=;AN

A9:; :EA=@FCKA:@E F>;K=:B>; A9> L@A:OKA:O>N ;K@?>N ;; @H A9> D@=G;9@?N ; A9> G>P =>;CMA;I ->XAN A9> =>;CMA; ?=>;>EA>F :E AD@ ;>KA:@E;N H@KC;:EJ @E F>K:;:@E;

Q,>KA:@E YT =>?@=A ?=@O:F>; F>AF =>;CMA; E@A @EMP :E H:EF: ;A;N :EKMCF:EJ A9> =>;CMA; H=@L A9> :E:A:=K:;>;

D:A9:E A9> D@=G;9@?


11/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[Z6 78

.)"8$

%:L>H=k .E:A:E @E;>A F:;=I %9> D@=G;9@? H@KC;>F @E F>H:E:EJ Q[T A9>

:EH@=LVC:=>F H@= L :E:A:K:;:@E;N MM :EH@=LVC>EA F>K:;:@E; A9L>EA>FN ?>=9 @H A9:; :E:A:K:;:@E;N ;:EK> A9>=> K

;A=@EJ F>?>EF>EK> L Q>IJI ;k .EA>=E K@LLCE:API .E A9:; :E:A: F:F E@A ;?>K:H:KEA:EJ F>K:;:@EWL=; :E A9> 9@;A J@O>=EL>EA E@= A9>

KA>F ?@?CM:= F>K:;:@EWLVC:=>L>EA; D>=> K@E;:F>=>F :E F:;KC;;:@E;I

"#302,90+,"2: .*88"#+: 02& !0),;,+0+,"2

%9> D@=G;9@? D=>;A H@KC;>F

@E 0>K:;:@EW(= ->>F;N EF A9=@CJ9 A9> ;C??@=A @H A9> 4E:A>F - H@=

A9> 3@@=F:E


12/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[[6 78

A9> ].EH@=L=K:;>I_ $E 0

F

A9> =>;CMA; H=@L >;> A9=>> >X>=K:;>;N K@L?M>A>F < ;C=O>P A@ ?=@O:F> HC=A9>= F>AL>EA;N F @O>=;CMA; XA ;A>?;I %9> HCMM D@=G;9@?

?=@J=F :E A9> 2??>EF:XN AF F>;K=:?A:@E; @H A9> >X>=K:;>; ?=@O:F>F :E

A9> ;>KA:@E; B>M@DN =>;CMA; H=@L > [ZI %9>

H:JC=> ;CLL; :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; ;?@E;>I % [Y M:;A; ;>O>E KJ@=:>; @H :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; :E L@=> F>A F>K:;:@E;N F>AF M:;A; @H @A9>= FVC:=>L>EA; @HH>= >O:F>EK> H@= F>O>M@?L>EA @H

L>EA; H@= :EH@=LK9E@M@JP

F>O>M@?>=;I


13/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[Y6 78

>50"3.,.$-,

%9:; ;>KA:@E KE;I 2 HXN == A9L BP A:L>N

A9>P L:J9A B> KJ@=:U>F BP K=:A:KI 2JF A@ HM:? K9= A9> K@L?M>A:@E @H A9> >X>=K:;>N A9> ;>?=> B=@CJ9A BA9>=N HMP =>?@=A>F :A; =>;CMA; A@ A9> >EA:=> D@=G;9@?I


14/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[56 78

G1;8;AB8 >E>F

%9> H@MM@D:EJ ;CBW;>KA:@E; ?=>;>EA A9> =>;CMA; @H > A9=>> J=@C?;` ;>;;:@E;I

f!$4# 2/#)2

f=@C? 2M?9< F>H:E>F A9> A:L> F:L>E;:@E; BP >O>EA; A9L=:@F; M:G> 9@C=; =:@F; :E D9:K9 A9>;> ?9; AP?:K


15/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[76 78

:EA>=E>AT

Y5I 3MC;A>=;^ 2KA:O^

Y7I .; < E>D K@@=F:E =>VC:=>F^ Q:I>I KMC;A>=;T

YbI !>;?@E;> ?MK:;:@EI ,K@?>gK@EK>?A @H @?>=O>M @H HCEF:EJ

Y8I .E:A:=WEKP K@@=F:E=F; ;;L>EA

5[I 0>K:F> ;;L>EA L>A9@F@M@JP

5YI .; < E>>F; ;;L>EA =>VC:=>F^ )@D B:J^ %@ D9>=>^

55I jC:KGMP 9@D B:JI %>MM =>J:@E n )jI #>@?M>N < KA>F

57I 0=EC> H@= @?>=EA @H @HH:K>g;A=H:EJg>O;?@EF :LL>F:MP A@ ;;:BM> =` ?:KAC=>

@H E>>F;^

eI *9 J= A9> J>@J= =O>EA:@E

8I ,?>K:F E>>F; ;;L>EA A@@M;

dI

(>>A:EJ ?ME A@ K= L>>A:EJ; c 9@D @HA>E :; A@@ @HA>E^

[ZI 'CMM LKA@=;

[[I $=J :EKMCF>F :E A9> KMC;A>=^ .E>X?>=:>EK>F

.-f$;^ 1F EK:>;^

[7I 4;> @H ;@HAD A>K9E@M@JP

[bI 4;> >X:;A:EJ 0!( ?M? H@= >X:;A:EJ ;A


16/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[b6 78

[8I / A>K9 J=@C? J:@E

[dI $?>E:EJ @H ;>EA A@ D9:K9 M@KO>MT

)5

'.!,% ($-%) %)!$4f)

0$-$! 3$-'"!"-3" Q[W5

($-%), #$,%W0.,2,%"!T

[I 0>O>M@?L>EA @H K@EA:EJ>EKP ?MK:F> ;P;A>L H@= FKC=:AP M>O>M @H :A

5I $?>E:EJ C? < E>D @HH:K>I *9>E =>^

7I 0>;:JE H@=L H@= FKA:@E ; QVC>;A:@E; A@ :EKMCF> @= E@AT

bI '@KC; @E Q@DET F>K:;:@E L@J==E=N

J@O>=EL>EAN )3% F>K:;:@E

!"#$% I( G4-6J ?$JK" L)%*+,+-., >M%4*+,%L( 0%*+,+-. #4"+.,2-4/+.3 4%,6$2,

2HA>= ?@;A:EJ := F>K:;:@E :F> A:L> ?9 KJ@=:>;N A9> J=@C? ;?>EA ;@L>

A:L> K@L:EJ C? D:A9


17/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[e6 78

':EE K@E;:F>=:EJ A9> ;K@?> @H F>K:;:@E;N A9> F:;KC;;:@E @HA>E =>H>==>F A@ A9> ?>=;@E @=

J=@C? L F>K:;:@E =J>EKP !>M:>H 3@@=F:E


18/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[86 78

f!$4# 1!2R$

f=@C? 1=:= B= H@MM@D:EJ KJ@=:>;k 2J>EKPN 3MC;A>=N

.EA>=WKMC;A>=N =I Q%9>;> KJ@=:>; KAMP D:A9 f=@C? 2M?9E;:@E @H ],K@?> @H 0>K:;:@EI_T f=@C? 1=; D:A9 E @E ?@;AW:A;

?=>;>EA>F :E % 7I

)0+$3"#1 &$),.,"2. ?6#0,2.+"#/,23 #$.*;+. 0#$ 2*/6$#$& !"#

#$!$#$2)$: 2"+ 8#,"#,+1@

05

2f"-3h

[I QJ=@C?:EJT

o

)@D LCK9 L@E>P M:G>MP A@ J>A r ;A=JP r ;A^ )@D LCK9 E>>F; A@ B> F@E>^ *9>=>

:; :A E>>F>F^

YI 0>K:F> @E E>>F; H@= => A@ ;M>>?

o %F:< @= E@A

o *9=; A@ F:HH>=>EA A :EA>= EKP K@@=F:E ?MK:F> D9@ D:MM F@ D9IJI @CAM:E> M@J;N K@@=F:E

M@KK:F> ?=@J==E>A r ;C??@=A A>LB>=;

dI 2KA:O >L@? Q:LL>F: HCEF:EJ L>K9


19/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[d6 78

[ZI *9>=> :; P@C= K@@=F:EEA>=^

[[I )@D K ;AP KC=:AP H@= P@C= A> :L?@=A=EL>EA A@

L>>A^

[5I 0>A>=L:E> D9>A9>= F => E

[7I /:H>;O;gE@

[bI !>K@O>=P ;A=JP

65

3/4,%"!

[I 'M


20/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

[i6 78

8I 0>K:F> @E G>P K@E;A==L:E> ;>KC=:AP E>>F;

iI 0>K:F> @E D9@ A@ K@EAA =O:>D @H A9> ;:ACA>=L:E> G>P @Ba>KA:O>; @H A9> @?>=O>M

[[I 0>A>=L:E> :H KMC;A>=; E>>F>F n D9:K9 @E>;

[YI 0>K:F> A@ >XA= :; L>>A:EJ

E>>F;I !>;:M:>EK>T #9 5n

&5

$%)"!

[I 3@EFCKA =


21/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

YZ6 78

f!$4# 3)2!/."

f=@C? 39 H:=;A B=F < ECLB>= @H F>K:;:@E; C;:EJ A9> A:L> KJ@=:>; ;CJJ>;A>F BP

A9> HO>== KJ@=:UL>;I " :; @=JF E;:@E Q;CK9 N ;K@?>N >AKIT ; KJ@=:>;

D:A9:E A9> F:L>E;:@E Q;CK9 >G;N >AKITI 2HA>= :F>EA:HP:EJ < M

;>A @H F:L>E;:@E; D:A9 ;N A9>P L@O>F ;@L> @H A9>:= ?@;AW:A; H=@L A9>

@=:J:EWBF HM:? K9 E>D @E>N A@ ?=@O:F> >X; @H A9> AP?>; @H F>K:;:@E;

B>M@EJ:EJ A@ >E;:@EI %9>=>H@=>N A9> A@AA @H B=F F>K:;:@E; :; J:O>E :E .01

'$##%+%-. .)2&%3B>M@DN BF @E A9> H:E


22/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Y[6 78

65

8Y )$4!, c

Y *""+,

[I .E M:E> D:A9 =@M> ;?@E;:B:M:A:>; A@ F>K:F> k =>;@C=K>;N M>O>M @H

:EA>=O>EA:@EN =>VC>;A H@= ;C??@=AN M@KE A>= K>F; A@ ?=;

8I %@@M; A@ C;>

dI 0:HH>=>EA EF:EJ @E ?9N =>;@C=K>;N K


23/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

YY6 78

&,/$2.,"2 )0+$3"#,$. &$),.,"2 $(0/8;$. 61 &,/$2.,"2: 2"+ 61 )0+$3"#1

?2*/6$#$& !"# #$!$#$2)$@

,5

%.("

2I ':=;A 8Y 9@C=;

1I 8Y 9@C=; c Y

D>>G;

3I 1>P@EF Y D>>G;

QM:;A>F :E % eT

,,5

,32/" S ,3$#"

2I />O>M [

1I />O>M Y

3I />O>M 5

[I .E A9> KA>F ?@?CM^

QL@;A OCME>=T

YI )@D L@?M> F@ D> L@;A C=J>EAMP E>>F>F :A>L;^

7I f>@J=@?M>^ Q#=:@=:A:U> M@K;; EK:>; ->>F; O;I 0>L D> J@:EJ A@ =>;?@EF^

5I f=


24/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Y56 78

1AB8A@;)?!>) 8H@!8 A5 D)>1;8;AB8 >E>F

%9> H@MM@D:EJ KJ@=:>;N J:O>E :E % dN D>=> K@E;@M:FF ;>EA>F BP A9> H =E DN == A9 ;>A @H F>K:;:@E; ?= ?

>X>=K:;>I

&,/$2.,"2 )0+$3"#,$.

%.("'!2(" [I ':=;A F


25/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Y76 78

'4-3%.$- [I f@OAg0@E@= !>MF:MM;;

8I !>;@C=K> 2MM@KB!;?@ )>1;8;AB 5


26/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Yb6 78

5+364% N( )%*+,+-. 54"/%V-4[( 8*-J%U 14+2+*"$+29U ".0 ;.:-4/"2+-. G"J

5+364% O( )%*+,+-. 54"/%V-4[( !+/% ".0 56.*2+-.

!"#$%&'")*+!),-#".*$!)

!"#$%&'$!/.*$!),)*%!)

%)01/#- 21#%/*-

.$/#-,%)01/#-3

"*4#-$5#$/316!-#7 !%/.*$1

58998:; 2

1:? -89@ !"#$$%&' ()*+",- #/"%0#"%1&

)8A


27/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Ye6 78

5I .-'$!(2%.$-

%9:; ;>KA:@E K


28/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Y86 78

GF

%9> H@MM@D:EJ ;CBW;>KA:@E; ?=>;>EA A9> =>;CMA; @H > A9=>> J=@C?;` ;>;;:@E;I !>;CMA;

9 B>>E K@E;@M:FF F:A>F @EMP H@= KM =>?>A:A:@EI

f!$4# 2/#)2

f=@C? 2M?9< KJ@=:U>F A9>:= :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; BF @E B@A9 A9> A@?:K @H A9>

:EH@=LN KA>F ?@?CM=K>?A:@EN M@EJWA>=L =>;@MCA:@E E>>F;T D

:EH@=L C;>F Q=>;?@E;> ?MVC:=>L>EA;N => M>;> KJ@=:>;N ;>O>=;A:@E;N @=

:EH@=LVC:=>L>EA;N :EKMCF>FI % i M:;A; A9> KJ@=:>; L>EA;I

3#"*8 0;8=0

60.$;,2$

o *9 ;:AC^

o *9^

0!!$)+$& 8"8*;0+,"2

o *9@J=


29/51


30/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

Yi6 78

o *9L A9VC:=>; H@MM@DWC? Q>IJI HCEF:EJT^ 2=> A9>=> M:G>MP E>>F; @= >H :A>L; 9 B>>E =>K>:O>F^

;"23B+$#/ #$.";*+,"2 2$$&.

o *9 M@EJWA>=L EM@?L>EA ;A=J:>;^

o *9 E>>F; =P^

!"#$% \( G4-6J ?$JK" D;.:-4/"2+-. >M%4*+,%F( #4"+.,2-4/%0 +.:-4/"2+-. 4%=6+4%/%.2,

f!$4# 1!2R$

f=@C? 1=F A9> :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; :E A>=L; @H A9> G:EF @H :EH@=LVC:=>FN :EKMCF:EJ A9> A:L>H= :E D9:K9 :A K@CMF B> K@MM>KA>F Q?=>W=>;?@E;>N FC=:EJ

@?>=L; F KA:EJ HH@=A;N A9=>> J=@C?;I % [Z M:;A; A9> KJ@=:>; L>EA;I

3#"*8 6#0-"

-0;*$ A*$.+,"2.

o *9 A@ :EHMC>EK> A9> :EH@=LK>:O>^

o *9=L:E> A9> O


31/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5Z6 78

o *9 J>E>=;?@E;>N :EKMCF:EJ M@KF^

o )@D L@?M> D> ;>=O:EJ^

o *:A9 D9@L F@ D> E>>F A@ D@=G^

o .; A9> ;:ACMP A@ K9^ .E D9>F >XA>=EL;T =O:K>; Q;A


32/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5[6 78

! )@D L@?M> 9 B>>E KA>FN KA >HH>KA; L>=J>EKP^ ECLB>= @H 9@C;>; KA>F ?>@?M> N F:;?ML>EAN OCME>= J=@C?;N >AKI

! .; >F>F^

! ) J@O>=EL>EA F H@= :EA>=E


33/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5Y6 78

! .EH@=LK:H:K >M>L>EA; @H :EH@=LKA@=;N ;CK9 MA>=N H@@FN >AK^

! *9 J


34/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

556 78

.-%"!#!"%2%.$- $' %)" %)!"" f!$4# !",4/%,

*9:M> A9> J=@C?; KJ@=:U>F A9>:= :EH@=L=>EA D=> D=MK:H:K ]A9:EJ;_ >M>L>EA; F A9> K@EA>XA @H A9> F:;=N A9> DFN A9> =>;CMA:EJ E>>F; @H KA>F ?@?CM K=F; B@A9 H@= ?=@J==;N ;@C=K>; ;CK9 =>;A>F :E 9@D A@ L> O= A@ M:EG :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; A@ A9> F>K:;:@E; A9>P ;C??@=AN @E 0

P KJ@=:U:EJ :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; K:;:@E

F:L>E;:@E;I %9> =>;CMA; H@MM@DI '>>FB ? = ]A9:EJ; D> D= @H :L?@=AI

'>>FBP D>=> =EKPI

0:;KC;;:@Ek ':JC=> b ;9@D; A9> =N L:E:LCLN =>;?@EF>EA =F >O>=PA9:EJ ][_

QL@;A :L?@=A ?M@A ] L:E:LCL =

=>;?@EF>EA;I 0>;?:A> A9> F:HH:KCMAP @H =;> :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA;N :A D=> K@E;:F>=>F L@=> :L?@=AE>=XAN E>>F;N ;?@E;>

?M=> K@E;:F>=>F L@;A :L?@=A


35/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

576 78

5+364% R( ?Q%4"3%U /"MU ".0 /+. 4".[+.3, :-4 %"*K +.:-4/"2+-. *"2%3-49

jYk #M> KM D H@MM@D:EJ KJ@=:>;I 0@ D> E>>F A@

GE@D A9>L ;A H:=;A F>G;N @= M=^

'>>FBF A9=@CJ9@CAN BCA A9>F>?A9 @H :EH@=LVC:=>F K9; @O>= A:L>I .E ?L>EA; @H A9> KJ@=:>; Q>IJI ;>KC=:AP >;A @H KJ@=P M=TI

0:;KC;;:@Ek 0>;?:A> A9> F BP ?>FB =>;CMA; KM>F A9> :L?@=A @H K>=AN E>>F;N =E;?@EF>= =>VC:=>L>EA;I 2 ;>K@EF ;>A @H :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; DEAMP

=F >F>F :E A9> H:=;A F>G;k =>;?@E;> ?M 8 K


36/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5b6 78

5+364% S( YK%. 0- V% :+4,2 .%%0 +.:-4/"2+-.

5+364% T( )%*+,+-. :4"/%V-4[U V+2K +.:-4/"2+-. .%%0%0 +. %"*K 2+/%:4"/%

j5k #M> KM D H@MM@D:EJ KJ@=:>;I ,9@CMF A9>P B>

C?FF >GMPN ;; H=>VC>EAMP^

'>>FB ?L>EA; @H KJ@=:>; @O>= A:L> Q>IJI ;>KC=:AP L@=>

@HA>E A9= >O>EA; :E A9> ; KJ@=:>;TI .E ; @O>= A:L>N

:EH@=LVC:=>F M>;; H=>VC>EAMPI

!

"

#

$

%

&!

&"

!"#$%&$'()"*% +,*- / 0%%1- 2%-*"#-% /

!,*,)3$4 ' 2%-*"#-%

56,##3#7

8#9":;,$3"#

!"":13#,$3"# '

8#-$3$


37/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5e6 78

)+,*6,,+-.(

':JC=> d ;9@D; A9> =>;CMA;N D9:K9 D>=> M>;; KM> ?=>O:@C; VC>;A:@E;N :E ?K @H A9> VC>;A:@EI .A DF; LC;A B> C?FF >GMPN EA C?F;I %9>

=>L; ;9@D>F < OAP @H =>;?@E;>;N ;CJJ>;A:EJ A9 C?F =>VC:=>L>EA;

O A9;> KJ@=:>; K@EAM>L>EA;

D:A9 F:HH>=>EA C?F =>VC:=>L>EA;N @= A9 C?F H=>VC>EKP F>?>EF; @E A9> >O@MCA:@E @H

A9> =>;?@E;> @O>= A:L>I

5+364% W( ;.:-4/"2+-. 6J0"2% :4%=6%.*9

!

"

#

$

%

&!

&"

!"#$%&$'()"*% +,*- / 0%%1- 2%-*"#-% /

!,*,)3$4 '2%-*"#-%

56,##3#7

8#9":;,$3"#

!"":13#,$3"# '

8#-$3$


38/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

586 78

j7k #M> KM D H@MM@D:EJ KJ@=:>;I 2=> A9>P E>>F>F

?=:L i ?M@A; A9> =>;CMA;I

5+364% \( @%Q%$ "2 VK+*K +.:-4/"2+-. +, .%%0%0

!

"

#

$

%

&!

&"

!"#$%&$'()"*% +,*- / 0%%1- 2%-*"#-% /

!,*,)3$4 '

2%-*"#-%

56,##3#7

8#9":;,$3"#

!"":13#,$3"# '

8#-$3$


39/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5d6 78

1AB8A@;)?!>) 8H@!8

2HA>= A9> D@=G;9@?N A9> H :EH@=LL;

B=F BP A>; 21.6KJ@=:>; K:H:K ]A9:EJ; D> DM@?>F BP A9> HK:H:K A@ < ?>E J>E>=F ;@L>D9IJI ]*9

?=@A>KA:@E E>>F;^_ 9>E ;CB;CL>F CEF>= ]*9 AP?>; @H E>>F;^_TI %9> :EA>EA:@E

@H A9:; M:;A D


40/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

5i6 78

! *9 M@KF =>;?@E;> @H A9> J@O>=EL>EA^ 2=> A9>=> =>;A=:KA:@E; @=

;>E;:A:O:A:>;^

! *9 A9> ?=>O:@C; =>;?@E;>; A@ F:;=;N K@?:EJ L>K9=K>?A:@E

! *9 ?CBM:K ?>=K>?A:@EN ;;N F:< =K>?A:@E;^

! *9 J>E>=;?@E;>N :EKMCF:EJ M@K


41/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7Z6 78

! M@K;

o $A9>=


42/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7[6 78

o 2KK>;;

! *9F ?@?CM= @B;A; A@ =>M:>H

@?>= =>F ?@?CMM:E> :EH@=L>E

=>K>:O>F^

o .EH@=L


43/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7Y6 78

o !>;?@EF>= O;

;""


44/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

756 78

,4((2!h 0.2f!2( $' 3$(#!")"-,.R" !",4/%,

':JC=> [Z K@EF>E;>; :EH@=LVC:=>L>EA; K


45/51


46/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7b6 78

A@ A9> M A@ H; @H F>K:;:@E;

L BP F>K:;:@EWL=;N A @H B=F F>K:;:@E; H=@L D@=G;9@?

?G:EJ A@ ;C??@=A 9CL


47/51


48/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

786 78

+*$.&01 >K .$8+$/6$#

[ZI

!>K


49/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7d6 78

80#+,),802+.

o

1@=:; 2=:;A:EN )>M?2J> .EA>=EE R


50/51

!"#$!% '!$( %)" *$!+,)$# $- '."/0 12,"0 0"3.,.$- (2+"!, .-'$!(2%.$- -""0,

.- ,400"- $-,"% 0.,2,%"!,

7i6 78

0DDEFGHI 6J/:;A @H %;


51/51

decision makers needs workshop report - oct 2013

Documents