davis 1940 - extreme social isolation of a child

7/16/2019 Davis 1940 - Extreme Social Isolation of a Child

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/davis-1940-extreme-social-isolation-of-a-child 1/12

(;75(0( 62&,$/,62/$7,212)$&+,/',.,1*6/(< '$9,6

$%675$&7

$JLUORIPRUHWKDQILYH\HDUVZDVGLVFRYHUHGQFDUFHUDWHGQDQXSVWDLUVRRP6KHKDGDSSDUHQWO\HHQWKHUHLQFHEDE\KRRGDQGZDVSK\VLFDOO\PDOQRXULVKHGQGDSDWKHWLFVZHOODVPHQWDOO\ODQN7DNHQILUVWRDFRXQW\KRPHWKHQWRDIRVWHUKRPHDQGILQDOO\RDVFKRROIRUGHIHFWLYHKLOGUHQKHLPSURYHGYHU\VORZO\6KHLVVWLOODYLUWXDOO\QVRFLDOL]HGUHDWXUHPDQLIHVWLQJDQ\SDUDOOHOVZLWKRWKHUDVHVRIVRODWHGFKLOGUHQQGEHDULQJXWWKH&RROH\0HDG'HZH\)DULVKHRU\IVRFLDOL]DWLRQ

7KHSUHVHQWSDSHUGHDOLQJZLWKDQLQFDUFHUDWHGKLOGVRIWKH

QDWXUHRIDSURJUHVVHSRUW7KHJLUOWGHVFULEHVVVWLOOXQGHUREVHUYDWLRQDQGLVOLNHO\WRUHPDLQVRIRUPDQ\\HDUV+HQFHWKH

SUHVHQWUHVXOWVUHQHFHVVDULO\QFRQFOXVLYH$FFRUGLQJRWKH1HZ<RUN7LPHVRU)HEUXDU\, DJLUORI

PRUHWKDQILYH\HDUVKDGEHHQIRXQGWLHGWRDQROGFKDLULQ DVWRUDJHURRPRQWKHVHFRQGIORRURIDIDUPKRPHVHYHQWHHQPLOHVIURPVPDOO3HQQV\OYDQLDFLW\7KHFKLOGDLGWKHUHSRUW

ZDVZHGJHGQWRKHKDLUKLFKDVLOWHGDFNZDUGVRUHVWQDFRDOEXFNHWKHUSLQGO\UPVLHGERYHKHUKHDG6KHZDVXQDEOHRWDONRUPRYH7KHFKLOGZDVGUHVVHGQDGLUW\KLUWQGQDSNLQKHRIILFHUDLG+HU

KDQGVUPVQGHJVZHUHXVWERQHVZLWKNLQUDZQYHUKHPRIUDLOKHFRXOGQWVHWKHPKHQHYHUDGHQRXJKRXULVKPHQWKHQHYHUUHZRUPDOO\QGWKHFKDLUQZKLFKKHD\KDOIHFOLQLQJQGKDOILWWLQJDVVRVPDOOKHKLOGDGWRGRXEOHHUHJVSDUWO\QGHUHU

7KHUHDVRQIRUWKLVVLWXDWLRQZDVWKDWWKHFKLOG$QQDZDVLOOHJLWLPDWH6KHZDVWKHVHFRQGLOOHJLWLPDWHKLOGWKHPRWKHUKDGERUQHQGVLQFHWKHPRWKHUHVLGHGZLWKKHUIDWKHUQGRWKHUUHODWLYHVQWKHSDWHUQDOKRPHVWHDGKHIRXQGKHUIDWKHURDQJU\KDWKHZDVDYHUVHHYHQWRVHHLQJWKLVVHFRQGFKLOG+HQFHVKHNHSWLWLQDQRXWRIWKHZD\RRP

8SRQUHDGLQJWKLVUHSRUWWKHZULWHUDQGD VWXGHQWDVVLVWDQW5LFKDUG*'DYLVZHQWWRVHHWKHFKLOG/DWHUVXEVHTXHQWWULSV

,&RQGHQVHGIURPSDSHUUHDGDWWKHDQQXDOPHHWLQJIWKH$PHULFDQRFLRORJLFDO6RFLHW\LQ'HWURLW,

2XWRIUHJDUGIRUWKHSDUWLHVFRQFHUQHGRUUHFWQDPHVRISHUVRQVQGSODFHVDUHQRWJLYHQ



(;75(0(62&,$/,62/$7,212)$&+,/'

ZHUHPDGHDQGEHWZHHQLVLWVUHSRUWVURPDULRXVSHUVRQVRQQHFWHGZLWKKHFKLOGZHUHHFHLYHG\PDLO2XUUHFRUGVRZHHP

UHDVRQDEO\RPSOHWHQGFRQILUPKHVDOLHQWDFWVQWKH7LPHVFFRXQW%\WKHWLPHZHDUULYHGQWKHFHQHHEUXDU\$QQDKDGEHHQ

LQKHUQHZDERGHWKHFRXQW\RPHRUQO\KUHHD\V%XWVKHZDVDOUHDG\EHJLQQLQJRFKDQJH:KHQILUVWURXJKWRWKHFRXQW\KRPHVKHKDGEHHQFRPSOHWHO\SDWKHWLFKDGODLQLQDOLPSXSLQHSRVLWLRQPPRELOH[SUHVVLRQOHVVQGLIIHUHQWRHYHU\WKLQJHUIODFFLGHHWDGIDOOHQRUZDUGDNLQJOPRVWVWUDLJKWLQHZLWKKHVNHOHWRQOLNHHJVQGLFDWLQJKDWKHKLOGKDGRQJDLQRQKHUDFNWRWKHSRLQWRIH[KDXVWLRQQGDWURSK\IKHUIRRWPXVFOHVKH

ZDVEHOLHYHGREHGHDIQGSRVVLEO\OLQG+HUXULQHFFRUGLQJRWKHQXUVHDGEHHQH[WUHPHO\RQFHQWUDWHGQGKHUVWRPDFK[FHHGLQJO\ORDWHGWZDVWKRXJKWKDWKHKDGVXIIHUHGWRQHWLPHIURPLFNHWVKRXJKDWHUPHGLFDOSLQLRQKDQJHGKHGLDJQRVLVWRVLPSOHPDOQXWULWLRQHUEORRGFRXQWKDGEHHQYHU\RZLQKDHPRJORELQRVLJQIGLVHDVHKDGEHHQGLVFRYHUHG8SRQRXUDUULYDOKUHHD\VIWHUKHZDVEURXJKWRWKHFRXQW\

KRPHPRVWIWKHVHRQGLWLRQVWLOOUHYDLOHGXWKHUWRPDFKDGUHWUDFWHGOLWWOHQGVKHKDGEHFRPHDLUO\FWLYHHLQJEOHWRVLW

XSLISODFHGQDVLWWLQJRVLWLRQQGWRPRYHKHUKDQGVUPVKHDGH\HVDQGPRXWKXLWHIUHHO\KHVHFKDQJHVKDGUHVXOWHGIURPKLJKYLWDPLQLHWPDVVDJHQGDWWHQWLRQQVSLWHRIKHUSK\VLFDORQGLWLRQKHKDGDQDWWUDFWLYHDFLDOSSHDUDQFHLWKQRGLVFHUQLEOHWLJPDWD+HUFRPSOH[LRQHDWXUHVDUJHOXHH\HVQGHYHQHHWKLQJRRGKDSHKRXJKRWTXLWHQRUPDOQVL]HJDYHKHUDIDYRUDEOHSSHDUDQFH6LQFH$QQDWXUQHGHUKHDGVORZO\RZDUGORXGWLFNLQJORFN

KHOGQHDUKHUZHFRQFOXGHGKDWKHFRXOGKHDU2WKHUWWHPSWVR

WLVGRXEWIXOKDWWKHFKLOGVKDQGVDWWKHWLPHRIGLVFRYHU\ZHUHWLHG,WLVPRUHOLNHO\KDWVKHZDVFRQILQHGRKHUFULEQWKHILUVWHULRGRILIHQGDWDOOWLPHVNHSWORFNHGQKHUURRPWRNHHSKHUIURPDOOLQJRZQWKHVWHHSVWDLUVHDGLQJPPHGLDWHO\IURPKHGRRUDQGWRNHHSWKHJUDQGIDWKHUURPHHLQJKHU,WLVGRXEWIXOIWKHFKLOGZDVHYHUNHSWQWKHDWWLFDVWKHUHSRUWOVRVWDWHG

6KHUHPDLQHGQWKHKRPHPRUHWKDQQLQHPRQWKVHLQJUHPRYHGQ1RYHPEHULWRDIRVWHUKRPHKHLQVWLWXWLRQVSULPDULO\RUWKHDJHGDQGLQILUPQWKHFRXQW\ZKHUH$QQDLYHGEXWFRQWDLQVDVHVRIQHDUO\OOW\SHV



7+($0(5,&$1-2851$/2)62&,2/2*<

PDNHKHUQRWLFHRXQGVXFKVFODSSLQJDQGVUVSHDNLQJRKHUHOLFLWHGRUHVSRQVHHWZKHQKHGRRUZDVRSHQHGXGGHQO\KH

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

OD\RQKHUEDFNWRWDNHW6KHFRXOGQRWFKHZUGULQNURPFXSEXWKDGWREHIHGIURPERWWOHUVSRRQWKLVQVSLWHIWKHIDFWWKDWVKHFRXOGJUDVSQGPDQLSXODWHEMHFWVZLWKKHUKDQGV7RZDUGQXPHURXVR\VJLYHQKHUE\ZHOOZLVKHUVOORYHUWKHFRXQWU\VKHVKRZHGQRUHDFWLRQ7KH\ZHUHLPSO\EMHFWVREHKDQGOHGLQDGLVWUDFWHGPDQQHUKHUHZDVQRHOHPHQWISOD\6KHOLNHGKDYLQJHUKDLUFRPEHG:KHQSK\VLFDOO\HVWUDLQHGKHH[KLELWHGFRQVLGHUDEOHHPSHUKHGLGQRWPLOH[FHSWZKHQRD[HGQGGLG

QRWFU\6KHKDGWKXVPDGHVRPHSURJUHVVXULQJHUWKUHHD\VQWKHFRXQW\RPH6XEVHTXHQWO\HUSURJUHVVQWKHKRPHZDVVORZHU%XWEHIRUHHDOLQJZLWKKHUDWHUKLVWRU\HWXVILUVWHYLHZPRUHFRPSOHWHO\KHEDFNJURXQGDFWVQWKHFDVH$QQDZDVERUQ0DUFK LQDSULYDWHXUVHVRPH6KRUWO\

WKHUHDIWHUKHZDVWDNHQRDFKLOGUHQVRPH)RUDWLPHKHZDVERDUGHGZLWKSUDFWLFDOXUVH7RWKRVHZKRDZDQGFDUHGRUHUVKHVHHPHGQHQWLUHO\RUPDODE\LQGHHGEHDXWLIXOKLOGV

PRUHKDQQHZLWQHVVDVDVVHUWHG$WWKH

JHRIVL[WRWHQPRQWKV

VKHZDVWDNHQDFNWRKHUPRWKHUVRPHHFDXVHQRRXWVLGHJHQF\ZLVKHGKHILQDQFLDOHVSRQVLELOLW\IFDULQJRUHUQKHUPRWKHUVKRPHKHZDVSHUSHWXDOO\RQILQHGQRQHURRPQGKHUHKHVRRQEHJDQRVXIIHUURPPDOQXWULWLRQLYLQJROHO\QDGLHWIPLONQGJHWWLQJRVXQVKLQHKHGHYHORSHGPSHWLJRKHGRFWRUFFRUGLQJWRWKHPRWKHUUHVFULEHGRPHH[WHUQDOPHGLFLQHKLFKPDGHWKH



(;75(0( 62&,$/ ,62/$7,21 2)$&+,/'

FKLOGORRNLNHDQLJJHUQGZKLFKKHPRWKHUHDVHGWRXVHIRUWKDWUHDVRQ7KHPRWKHUODUJHZRPDQIWZHQW\VHYHQOOHJHV

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

EHHQH[WUDRUGLQDULO\LUW\QGFRQWDLQHGGRXEOHHGRQZKLFKKHPRWKHUQGVRQVOHSWZKLOH$QQDUHFOLQHGQDEURNHQKDLU7KHPRWKHUDUULHGSDQGIHGR$QQDKXJHXDQWLWLHVIPLON7RZDUG$QQDVILIWKLUWKGD\KHPRWKHUSSDUHQWO\QDGYLFHHJDQIHHGLQJKHUWKLQDWPHDOZLWKVSRRQEXW$QQDQHYHUHDUQHGRHDW

VROLGIRRG$QQDVRFLDORQWDFWVLWKWKHUVHUHKHQWDPLQLPXP:KDW

IHZKHGLGKDYHZHUHIDSHUIXQFWRU\URSHQO\QWDJRQLVWLFLQGDOORZLQJRRSSRUWXQLW\RU*HPHLQVFKDIWRGHYHORS6KHDIIRUGVWKHUHIRUHQH[FHOOHQWXEMHFWIRUWXG\LQJKHHIIHFWVIH[WUHPHVRFLDOVRODWLRQ7HQGD\VDIWHUXUILUVWLVLW$QQDVKRZHGRPHPSURYHPHQW

6KHZDVPRUHOHUWDGPRUHELOLW\RIL[HUWWHQWLRQDGPRUHH[SUHVVLRQDQGOHGKHUVHOIHWWHURRNHGKHDOWKLHU0RUHRYHUKH

7KHPRWKHUZDVUHSRUWHGRKDYHWKHPHQWDOLW\IDFKLOGRIWHQ:HGLGQRWLQWHUYLHZKHSHUVRQVZKRJDYHWKHLQWHOOLJHQFHHVWEXWGLGLQWHUYLHZKHPRWKHUKHUVHOI6KHVHHPVSUREDEO\XEQRUPDOQGWKLVVWKHRSLQLRQRIPRVWSHRSOHZKRNQRZKHU%XWLWVGRXEWIXOIKHUWDWXVVDQ\RZHUKDQWKDWRIDKLJKJUDGHPRURQDQGVKHPD\EHPHUHO\GXOOQRUPDO$QQDVIDWKHUFFRUGLQJRRQHVWRU\VDZHDOWK\DUPHULYLQJQWKHVDPHUXUDO

VHFWLRQVWKHPRWKHULVWDQWO\LQWRKHU$QRWKHUWRU\DVLWKRZHYHUKDWDV\SKLOLWLFPDUULHGPDQLQWKHQHDUE\RZQVWKHIDWKHU



7+( $0(5,&$1 -2851$/2) 62&,2/2*<

KDGIRXQGHURQJXHLQSK\VLFDOHQVH:KHUHDVWKDGIRUPHUO\ODLQQDFWLYHDFNQKHUPRXWKKHQRZWXFNWRXWIUHTXHQWO\QG

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

PDQLIHVWDQWVRFKHZUWRFRQWUROHUHOLPLQDWLRQQO\RQHVRFLDEOHWXQWKDGVKHEHJXQROHDUQUXEELQJRUHKHDGVLWKKHQXUVHVSRUWIZKLFKKHDWHUEHFDPHYHU\IRQG2QWKHRWKHUKDQGKHUULWXDOLVWLFDQGSOD\QRWLFHDEOHUDLWWWKLVLPHZDVHQWLUHO\VRFLDO2QWKLVHFRQGYLVLWZHWRRNDORQJDFOLQLFDOV\FKRORJLVWG

ZDUG&DUU+HEHJDQE\FKHFNLQJKHUHIOH[HVLQGLQJRQHWKDW

ZHUHGHIHFWLYHHWKHQJDYH$QQDDWKUHHILJXUHRUPRDUGWHVWXVHGQWKH)RUP/5HYLVLRQIWKH6WDQIRUG%LQHWQQDZDVXQDEOHWRSODFHWKHEORFNVQWKHDSSURSULDWHO\KDSHGKROHVKRXJKDSSDUHQWO\\FKDQFHKHGLGRQFHSODFHWKHURXQGLHFHVDWLVIDFWRULO\KHPRUHUHDGLO\HPRYHGKHEORFNVIURPKHERDUGDQGSOD\HGZLWKKHPGO\IRUWLPH:KHQ0U&DUUILUVWWWHPSWHGE\SDQWRPLPHRJHWKHURSODFHWKHEORFNVKHVHHPHGRFRQFHQWUDWHXWRQO\PRPHQWDULO\QGWKLVFRQFHQWUDWLRQROLPLWHGQUHVXOWVSSDUHQWO\LUHGHURRJUHDWO\RUXUWKHUIIRUWV

6KHZRXOGKROGRQHKDQGLQIURQWIKHUZLWKWKHLWWOHILQJHUUHVVHGJDLQVWWKHSDOPWKHRWKHUKUHH LQJHUVORVHWRJHWKHUQGVWUDLJKWXWDQGZRXOGWKHQPDQLSXODWHWKHKDQGVKDSHGLQWKLVZD\FORVHWRKHUH\HV2IWHQZKHQGRLQJWKLVVKHZRXOGKROGDILQJHUIKHURWKHUKDQGQKHUDU7KHVHDFWLRQVJDYHKHUQLGLRWLFSSHDUDQFH6KHVKRZHGPRUHNLOOQEHQGLQJKHILQJHUVKDQDQ\RIXVFRXOGH[KLELW

0U&DUUZKRUHSUHVHQWHGKH3V\FKRHGXFDWLRQDOOLQLFDW3HQQV\OYDQLDWDWH&ROOHJHIRXQGWKDW$QQDVKRZHGDFFRPPRGDWLRQIRUERWKOLJKWDQGGLVWDQFHWKDWVKHZLQNHGZKHQDSHQFLOZDVVXGGHQO\KRYHGWRZDUGKHUH\HVDQGZKHQDWXPEOHU



(;75(0( 62&,$/ ,62/$7,21 2)$&+,/'

7KHQH[WYLVLWQ0DUFK UHYHDOHGLWWOHKDQJH[FHSWRUVOLJKWK\VLFDOPSURYHPHQWKHFRXOGLIWKHUKLSVIURPKHEHG

WKHQXUVHKDGLQGXFHGKHUWRODXJKRXWULJKW\WLFNOLQJHUDQGODXJKLQJSURDULRXVO\HUVHOIQGWKHQXUVHEHOLHYHGKDW$QQDUHFRJQL]HGHU7KHGRFWRUKDGFKDQJHGLVHDUO\SWLPLVWLFSLQLRQKHQRZEHOLHYHGKHFKLOGZDVFRQJHQLWDOO\HILFLHQW$IWHUQRWKHUPRQWK$QQDZDVILYHRXQGVKHDYLHUPRUHQHU

JHWLFLYHQRDXJKLQJJRRGGHDOQGFUHGLWHGLWKKDYLQJPDGHDVRXQGLNHGD %XWWKDWZDVDOO2Q-XQHDQRWKHUPRQWKDWHUKHKDGVFDUFHO\PSURYHGQ

DQ\UHVSHFW:KHQHVWHG\WKHZULWHUFFRUGLQJRWKHWHPVIKH

*HVHOOFKHGXOHKHVHHPHGRUDQNZLWKRQH\HDUROGUEHWWHULQPRWRUFWLYLWLHVQYROYLQJDQGVDQGH\HV%XWZLWKUHJDUGROLQJXLVWLFQGSXUSRVLYHHKDYLRUKHODJJHGEHKLQGIDQ\HVWLPDWHZHUHPDGHWFRXOGEHVDLGWKDWKHGHILQLWHO\DQNHGHORZWKHRQH\HDUROGKLOG%\$XJXVW VKHZDVVWLOOPSURYLQJK\VLFDOO\HUOHJVKDG

FDOYHVLQWKHPQGVKHOLNHGWRH[KLELWKHUVWUHQJWKQURXJKKRXVLQJKHZRXOGDXJKKHDUWLO\IWHQPDNHDWVKDWVKDWVKDVRXQGZLWKKHULSVRQFHRUWZLFHPDNLQJYHUEDO\SHIVRXQG

WKRXJKPHDQLQJOHVV:KHQKHOGE\VRPHRQHKHFRXOGZDONE\SXWWLQJQHIRRWQIURQWIWKHRWKHUQRVWHQWDWLRXVWHSV+HULQWHUHVWQRWKHUHUVRQVDGEHFRPHPRUHEYLRXVKHUUHVSRQVHVPRUHHILQLWHQGGLVFULPLQDWLQJ

ZDVVWUXFNZLWKVSRRQXVWEHKLQGKHUHDUDQGWKDWWKHSDWHOODUQGSODQWDUUHIOH[HVZHUHSUHVHQW,WEHLQJPSRVVLEOHRDGPLQLVWHUQ\VWDQGDUGL]HGHVWVQYROYLQJDQJXDJHKHH[DPLQHGKHUZLWKUHIHUHQFHRWKHPRWRUEHKDYLRUWHPVQ*HVHOOVGHYHORSPHQWDOVFDOH7KHLWHPVSDVVHGLQFOXGHGWKHIROORZLQJUHVLVWLQJHDGSUHVVXUHDSSHDUVQRUPDOO\WIRXUPRQWKVLIWLQJHDGZKLOHLQSURQHSRVLWLRQVL[PRQWKVVLWWLQJSQLQHPRQWKVODVSLQJFXEHVVL[PRQWKVSLFNLQJXSFXEHVL[PRQWKV

VFULEEOLQJHLJKWHHQPRQWKVEXWWKLVVFULEEOLQJSSHDUHGWRXVWREHDQDFFLGHQW$QQDKDGIRUZHHNVEHHQZLWKRXWQ\SOD\PDWHVQKHUURRP$VDWHVWDOLWWOH

ER\DJHILYHZDVEURXJKWQ:HDOOOHIWWKHURRPDQGSHHUHGEDFN$QQDWRRNDGHILQLWHQWHUHVWQKLP6KHWULHGKHUWULFNIRRNLQJKDUGQWRKLVH\HVDQGPRYLQJKHUKHDGQHDUKLVWRUXEIRUHKHDGV6KHFODSSHGKHUKDQGVPDQLIHVWLQJRUHQWHUHVWLQKLPWKDQKHLQKHU

7KHQXUVHDLGWKDW$QQDKDGSOD\HGZLWKNLWWHQVIHZGD\VSUHYLRXVO\\VZLQJLQJWKHPE\WKHLUDLOV:HVHFXUHGWZRNLWWHQVQGSXWWKHPQKHUEHG7KLVWLPHKH



7+($0(5,&$1-2851$/2)62&,2/2*<

8QWLOUHPRYHGURPKHFRXQW\KRPHRQ1RYHPEHUL WKHUHZHUHIHZGGLWLRQDOKDQJHV%\WKLVWLPHKHFRXOGEDUHO\WDQG

ZKLOHKROGLQJRVRPHWKLQJKHQSXWRQDFDUSHWKHFRXOGFRRWEXWQRWFUDZO6KHYLVLEO\LNHGSHRSOHVPDQLIHVWHG\VPLOLQJURXJKKRXVLQJQGKDLUSXOOLQJXWVKHZDVVWLOOQXQVRFLDOL]HGLQGLYLGXDORUKHKDGHDUQHGUDFWLFDOO\RWKLQJ,IZHDVNZK\KHKDGHDUQHGRLWWOHQRWYHQRFKHZUGULQN

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

QRWKDYHWKHQLPDOVQKHUHQWO\UJDQL]HGWUXFWXUHQGKHQFHHPDLQHGQDPRUHDVVLYHQDGHTXDWHWDWH2QRXUYLVLWI'HFHPEHUDVXUSULVHZDLWHGXVIRU$QQDKDG

XQGHUJRQHKDWZDVIRUKHUUHPDUNDEOHUDQVIRUPDWLRQVKHDGEHJXQRHDUQ1RWWKDWKHFRXOGSHDNEXWVKHFRXOGGRVHYHUDOWKLQJVRUPHUO\RQVLGHUHGPSRVVLEOHKHFRXOGGHVFHQGKHWDLUVE\VLWWLQJXFFHVVLYHO\QHDFKRQHFRXOGKROGDGRXJKQXWQKHU

EHFDPHSDUDO\]HGZLWKIULJKWKHPDGHOLWWOHQRLVHH[FHSWVWLIOHGHOORQFHRUWZLFHDQGVKHPDGHQRHIIRUWRJHWDZD\RUSXVKWKHNLWWHQVII7KLVSDUDO\]HGW\SHRIUHDFWLRQZDVFKDUDFWHULVWLFQLWLDWLYHVHHPHGYLUWXDOO\P

SRVVLEOHIRUKHU$WHPSHUWDQWUXPSUHYLRXVO\H[KLELWHGKDGWKLVFKDUDFWHU6KHZDYHGKHUKHDGIURPLGHWRVLGHDQGIOLSSHGHUKDQGVXSDQGGRZQD QHUYRXVXWLOHVRUWRIWDQWUXPHKDYLRUWZDVDVLIVKHKDGQRFKDQQHOVIH[SUHVVLRQUDFWLRQQRPRGHRIGHDOLQJZLWKWKHHQYLURQPHQW$VVRRQDVWKHNLWWHQVZHUHRXWRIVLJKWKHIRUJRWERXWWKHPEXWWKHIULJKWH

WXUQHGZKHQHYHUKH\ZHUHSODFHGLQKHUSUHVHQFH'XULQJKHUIULJKWKHEURNHQWRWKHILUVWU\LQJSHOOWKHZULWHUDGZLWQHVVHGWZDVDUHDOFKLOGVFU\



(;75(0( 62&,$/ ,62/$7,21 2)$&+,/' ,

KDQGQGHDWWPXQFKLQJLNHQRUPDOKLOGRXOGJUDVSJODVVRIRPDWRXLFHQGGULQNWE\KHUVHOIRXOGDNHVWHSUWZRZKLOH

KROGLQJRVRPHWKLQJQGFRXOGIHHGKHUVHOILWKVSRRQ7KHVHDFFRPSOLVKPHQWVPDOOQGHHGIRUFKLOGRIVHYHQHSUHVHQWHGWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ[SODLQDEOHRGRXEW\KHUUDQVIHUHQFHURPKHFRXQW\RPHRDSULYDWHDPLO\KHUHKHZDVWKHVROHREMHFWRIRQHZRPDQVVVLGXRXVDUH$QQDKDGEHHQQWKHIRVWHUKRPHHVVWKDQPRQWKXWWKHUH

VXOWVZHUHODLQWRVHH+HUQHZJXDUGLDQDVXVLQJKHDPHFRPPRQVHQVHHWKRGV\ZKLFKPRWKHUVURPLPHPPHPRULDODYHVRFLDOL]HGKHLUQIDQWVXQUHPLWWLQJWWHQWLRQHSHWLWLYHRUUHFWLRQQGFRXQWOHVVPDOOUHZDUGVQGSXQLVKPHQWVL[HGOZD\VZLWK\PSDWKHWLFQWHUHVWQGKRYHULQJK\VLFDOUHVHQFHKHVH$QQDZDVJHWWLQJRUKHILUVWLPHQKHULIH2QHWKLQJHHPHGQRWLFHDEOH$QQDZDVPRUHLNHRQH\HDUROG

EDE\KDQKHKDGEHHQEHIRUHKHZDVUHVSRQVLYHQWKHXQWXWRUHGUDQGRPQHUJHWLFD\RIDEDE\:KHQRQHEHFNRQHGQGFDOOHGKHUKHZRXOGPDNHDQHIIRUWRFRPHPLOLQJQGJRLQJKURXJKH[FLWHG[WUDPRWLRQV$PRQWKDWHUPRUHPSURYHPHQWORQJKHDPHLQHVZDVQRWHG

7KRXJKUDYHLPLWDWLRQVHPDLQHGQQDZDVGHILQLWHO\HFRPLQJ

PRUHIDKXPDQHLQJ6WLOODWHUQ0DUFK , KHUFFRPSOLVKPHQWVHUHKHIRO

ORZLQJKHZDVDEOHWRZDONDORQHIRUIHZWHSVZLWKRXWDOOLQJVKHZDVUHVSRQVLYHRWKHYHUEDORPPDQGVIKHUIRVWHUPRWKHUVHHPLQJRXQGHUVWDQGQDYDJXHRUWIZD\ZKDWKHDWWHUZDQWHGKHUWRGRVKHGHILQLWHO\HFRJQL]HGKHVRFLDOZRUNHUKRWRRNKHUZHHNO\RWKHGRFWRUQGZKRKHUHIRUH\PEROL]HGRKHUKHSOHDVXUHRIDQDXWRPRELOHLGHVKHH[SUHVVHG\DQ[LRXVRGLO\PRYHPHQWVHUGHVLUHRJRRXWIRUULGHKHVHHPHGQPLVWDNDEO\R

VHHNDQGWRLNHWWHQWLRQKRXJKKHGLGQRWXONZKHQHIWORQHVKHZDVDEOHWRSXVKGROOFDUULDJHQIURQWIKHUQGWRVKRZRPHVNLOOQPDQLSXODWLQJW6KHZDVIXUWKHUPRUHXFKPSURYHGK\VLFDOO\HLQJOPRVWDWZLWKKXEE\UPVQGHJVQGKDYLQJPRUHHQHUJ\QGDOHUWQHVVQWKHYLVLWSULRURWKLVQHVKHKDGVKRZQWKDWKHRXOGXLFNO\LQGQGHDWFDQG\ZKLFKKHDZSODFHGHKLQGDSLOORZRXOGSHUIRUPNQHHEHQGLQJ[HUFLVHRXOGXVHRUGLQDU\



7+($0(5,&$1-2851$/2)62&,2/2*<

XWHQVLOVQHDWLQJHJRXOGRQYH\LTXLGRKHUPRXWKQDVSRRQFRXOGPDQLIHVWVHQVHIQHDWQHVVE\SXWWLQJUHDGEDFNRQDSODWHDIWHUDNLQJELWHIURPW/LPLWDWLRQVWLOOUHPDLQLQJRZHYHU

ZHUHVIROORZVKHVDLGQRWKLQJFRXOGRWHYHQEHWDXJKWRVD\E\HE\HKHKDGWREHZDWFKHGRWHOOZKHQHOLPLQDWLRQDVLPPLQHQWKHKDUGO\OD\HGZKHQORQHVKHKDGOLWWOHXULRVLW\OLWWOHQLWLDWLYHWVHHPHGWLOOPSRVVLEOHRHVWDEOLVKQ\FRPPXQLFDWLYHRQWDFWZLWKKHU2Q$XJXVW , $QQDZDVWDNHQIURPKHIRVWHUKRPHQG

PRYHGRDVPDOOFKRRORUHIHFWLYHKLOGUHQEVHUYDWLRQVDGHDWWKLVWLPHKRZHGKHUWRKDYHEHFRPHIDWJLUOZHQW\RXQGVRYHUZHLJKWRUHUJH<HWVKHFRXOGZDONEHWWHUQGFRXOGOPRVW

UXQ+HUWRLOHWKDELWVKRZHGKDWKHXQGHUVWRRGKHZKROHSURFHGXUHKHPDQLIHVWHGQREYLRXVRPSUHKHQVLRQIPDQ\YHUEDOLQVWUXFWLRQVKRXJKKHFRXOGQRWSHDN&RPSDULVRQI$QQDZLWKWKHUDVHVRIVRODWHGKLOGUHQHYHDOV

VHYHUDOQWHUHVWLQJDUDOOHOVRWKQWKHLULVWRULHVQGQWKHQWHUSUHWDWLRQIWKHP)LUVWIDOOZHQRWHKHOPRVWQLYHUVDODLOXUHWROHDUQRWDONZLWKQ\IDFLOLW\QGKHQFHKHIDLOXUHRPDVWHUPXFKIWKHFXOWXUDOHULWDJHHFRQGZHQRWHKHQHDUO\QLYHUVDOSUHVHQFHIVHQVRU\EQRUPDOLWLHVLQDOO\ZHQRWHQGDOVRTXHVWLRQKHXVXDOQWHUSUHWDWLRQIWKHVHHFXUUHQWDFWVQDPHO\KDWWKH\UHGXHWRFRQJHQLWDOHHEOHPLQGHGQHVV7KRXJK$QQDDWSUHVHQWDQQRWSHDNVKHVQRWDQXQXVXDOPHP

EHURIKHUSHFXOLDUODVV7KHIHUDOKLOG.DPDODIRXQGWWKHDJHRIHLJKWZDVDEOHWRXWWHUQO\IRUW\RUGVIWHUL[\HDUVIWXWRULQJQGVRPHZKDWLPLODUORZQHVVVHQFRXQWHUHGQRWKHUDVHV,3 & 6TXLUHV:ROI &KLOGUHQRI,QGLD$PHULFDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJ\

;;;9,,,,,,,26DQLFKDURXQGWDERXWWKHDJHRIVHYHQFRXOGQRWVSHDNHYHQDVDJURZQPDQ

+HPHUHO\XWWHUHGQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHRXQGV*&)HUULVDQLFKDUWKH:ROI%R\I,QGLD>1HZ<RUN3XEOLVKHGE\WKH$XWKRU SS37KHJLUORI6RQJLGLV

FRYHUHGWDERXWWHQ\HDUVRIDJHOHDUQHGIWHUHYHUDO\HDUVWRVSHDNEXWDSSDUHQWO\QRWYHU\ZHOO0DGDP+HFTXHW7KH+LVWRU\ID6DYDJH*LUO/RQGRQ'XUVOH\'DYLVRQ0DXVRQ%ODQG-RQHV@SDQGL &DVSDU+DXVHUZKRPLJKWVHHPDQH[FHSWLRQRWKHUXOHDFWXDOO\UHPDLQHGRWKHODVWDZNZDUGQODQJXDJH$QVHOPYRQ)HXHUEDFK&DVSDU+DXVHUWUDQVIURP*HUPDQGHG%RVWRQ$OOHQ7LFNQRU+LVFDVHLVQRWFOHDUKRZHYHURUWDSSHDUVKHFRXOGSURQRXQFHVRPHZRUGVZKHQILUVWLVFRYHUHGLELGSS 2WKHUQVWDQFHVIVSHHFKGLIILFXOWLHVVHHPDVQXPHURXVVWKHFDVHVRIVRODWHGFKLOGUHQKRXJKKHHYLGHQFHVVFDQW\QGGXELRXV



(;75(0( 62&,$/ ,62/$7,21 2)$&+,/'

,QDELOLW\RZDONUUXQQGSURQRXQFHGHFXOLDULWLHVIJDLWUHDOVRH[FHHGLQJO\KDUDFWHULVWLFQGVRPHVRUWRIDEQRUPDOLW\IWKHVHQVHVLWKHUVDFXWHQHVVRUGXOQHVVSSHDUVLQQHDUO\YHU\LQVWDQFH,,

,QYLHZRIWKHVHLPLODULWLHVWLVQRWVXUSULVLQJKDWDVWDQGDUGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQDVEHHQDSSOLHGRSUDFWLFDOO\YHU\DVHQDPHO\WKDWKHFKLOGZDVLQQDWHO\HHEOHPLQGHGLQHOGHFODUHGKH:LOG%R\RI$YH\URQREHDIDNHVWRZLOGQHVVQGDQLQFXUDEOHGLRWVWRPHQWDOLW\QG,WDUGDIWHULYH\HDUVIH[DVSHUDWLQJIIRUWOWLPDWHO\GPLWWHGKDWWKHER\PD\KDYHEHHQPHQWDOO\HILFLHQWIURPKHVWDUWKRXJKHVWLOODWWULEXWHGUHDWPSRUWDQFHRKLVORQJVRODWLRQ3RSXODUQWHUHVWQIHHEOHPLQGHGQHVVQGQELRORJL

FDOGHWHUPLQLVPHGWRJHQHUDOJUHHPHQWLWK3LQHOVYHUGLFWXWUHFHQWO\FLHQWLILFSLQLRQDVEHHQFKDQJLQJ6)UHHPDQQDXWKRULW\QLQGLYLGXDOLIIHUHQFHVHOLHYHVKDWWKH$YH\URQR\VVWXSLGLW\DVGXHWRKLVRQJSHULRGIVRFLDOVRODWLRQ(YHQIWLVJUDQWHGKDWKHER\ZDVTXLWHGXOOWREHJLQZLWKWVKRXOG

KDYHEHHQSRVVLEOH RDFKLHYHPXFKPRUHZLWKKLPWKDQZDVWKHFDVHXQOHVVRQHDOORZVIRUKHSHFXOLDURQGLWLRQVQGHUZKLFKKHOLYHGQGIRUKHIL[LQJSURFHVVUHVXOWLQJURPKHVHFRQGLWLRQV ,WDUGVUHSRUWVUHVHQWKHFDVHRIDQLQGLYLGXDOZKRVHHDUO\LIHRVKDSHGKLVEHKDYLRUQGIL[HGKLVDELOLWLHVWKDWHYHQILYH\HDUVRISDLQVWDNLQJHYRWHGQGLQWHOOLJHQWQVWUXFWLRQHUH

LQDGHTXDWHWRSURGXFHKHPHQWDOPDQLIHVWDWLRQVIHYHQDORZJUDGHPRURQ;,, .DPDODSRVVHVVHGH[WUHPHO\FXWHKHDULQJZKHQGLVFRYHUHGQGDQDQLPDOOLNH

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

,WDUGSFLWSYLLDQG,2,

,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV1HZ<RUN+HQU\ROW&R S,,



7+( $0(5,&$1 -2851$/2) 62&,2/2*<

6LPLODUO\1.HOORJUJXHVRUKHQQDWHRUPDOLW\IWKLVQGRWKHUHUDOKLOGUHQHDVVXPHVKDWWKH\SUREDEO\RVVHVVHGQ

HQWLUHO\RUPDOTXLSPHQWRWKHUZLVHXUYLYDOQDKDUVKQYLURQPHQWZRXOGKDYHEHHQPSRVVLEOHKH\GHYHORSHGHVSRQVHVXLWDEOHWRWKHLUXUURXQGLQJVHQFHKHLUXEVHTXHQWQDELOLW\RHDUQLVDWWULEXWDEOHRWKHGLIILFXOW\IXSURRWLQJXQGDPHQWDODVLFDOO\LQWUHQFKHGDELWVRUPHG\HDUOLHU[SHULHQFH,7KHUHVRQHDFWXDOFDVHLQZKLFKKHK\SRWKHVLVDVGLVSURYHG

7KLVZDVWKHDVHRI(GLWK5LOH\ZKRIWHUQFDUFHUDWLRQQDFORVHWIRURPH\HDUVZDVVDLGDWWZHOYHREHIHHEOHPLQGHGKHUHFRYHUHGRPSOHWHRUPDOLW\LWKLQZR\HDUV,

&21&/86,216

L &RPSDULQJQQDZLWKWKHUVRODWHGKLOGUHQHDULQJQPLQGWKDWKHHHPHGRUPDOQQIDQF\QGQRWLQJHUSURJUHVVRGDWHRQHFDQPDLQWDLQKDWWKRXJKKHVVWLOOWWKHGLRWHYHOQPHQWDOLW\KLVIDFWVODUJHO\KHUHVXOWIRFLDOVRODWLRQ%XWLIWKHWULNLQJDUDOOHOZLWKWKHUQRZQDVHVGLPLQLVKHV

WKHSUREDELOLW\IRQJHQLWDOHILFLHQF\WDOVRGLPLQLVKHVKHKDQFHRIDIDYRUDEOHXWFRPHRUWVHHPVOPRVWPSRVVLEOHRUQ\FKLOGWROHDUQRVSHDNKLQNQGDFWOLNHDQRUPDOHUVRQIWHUORQJ

SHULRGIDUO\VRODWLRQHW$QQDVQRQHUHVSHFWPDUJLQDODVHVKHZDVGLVFRYHUHGHIRUHKHKDGUHDFKHGL[\HDUVRIDJH7KLVLV\RXQJQRXJKRDOORZRURPHODVWLFLW\QIDFWKHKDVPDGHJRRGPDQ\GMXVWPHQWV

7KLVDJUHHVZLWKWKHJHQHUDOSLQLRQRQFHUQLQJKHPSRUWDQFHIWKHHDUO\\HDUVLQGHYHORSPHQW$ODUJHSHUFHQWDJHIFKLOGUHQUHYLRXVO\LDJQRVHGVIHHEOHPLQGHGKDYHEHHQSURYHQREHVRXQGQDOOUHVSHFWV[FHSWQ DFTXLUHGUHDFWLRQVIGLVFRYHUHGWDQHDUO\JHWKHLQKHULWHGHILFLHQFLHVIWKHVHQGLYLGXDOVKDYHEHHQVDWLVIDFWRULO\RUUHFWHGKURXJKSHFLDOL]HGHGXFDWLRQOWKRXJKWKLVKDVQRWEHHQSRVVLEOHLIWKH\KDYHSHUVLVWHGRRRQJQWKHLUULJLQDODELWV+XPDQL]LQJWKH$SH3V\FKR

ORJLFDO5HYLHZ;;;9,,, >,@ , 6LPLODUDUJXPHQWVUHFRQWDLQHGQ+XPSKUH\VQWURGXFWLRQR,WDUGVZRUNRSFLWSS[[L

,V1HZ<RUN7LPHV1RYHPEHU ,, VHFSDQG'HFHPEHU ,, VHFSL 1HZ<RUN'DLO\0LUURUPDJD]LQHHFWLRQ0DUFK ,S7KLVLVDQLQWHUHVWLQJDVHGLIIHULQJURPPRVWRIWKHRWKHUVQWKDWWKHFKLOGZDVLQFDUFHUDWHGWWKHODWHDJHRIHLJKW6KHORVWWKHFDSDFLW\IRUSHHFKDQGYLVLRQ%XWVLQFHVKHKDGRQFHDFTXLUHGWKHVHDELOLWLHVKHUHFRYHUHGKHPDJDLQIDLUO\DSLGO\



(;75(0( 62&,$/ ,62/$7,21 2)$&+,/'

7KHFRPSDUDWLYHDFWVHHPWRLQGLFDWHWKDWWKHVWDJHVRIVRFLDOL]DWLRQUHWRVRPHH[WHQWHFHVVDULO\HODWHGRWKHWDJHVI

RUJDQLFHYHORSPHQWIWKHGHOLFDWHRPSOH[QGORJLFDOO\ULRUVWDJHVIRFLDOL]DWLRQUHQRWFTXLUHGZKHQKHRUJDQLVPVSODVWLFWKH\ZLOOQHYHUEHDFTXLUHGQGWKHODWHUVWDJHVQHYHUFKLHYHGH[FHSWUXGHO\$QQDVKLVWRU\LNHRWKHUVHHPVRGHPRQVWUDWHKH&RROH\

0HDG'HZH\)DULVKHRU\ISHUVRQDOLW\QDPHO\KDWKXPDQDWXUHVGHWHUPLQHG\WKHFKLOGVRPPXQLFDWLYHRFLDOFRQWDFWVVPXFKDVE\KLVRUJDQLFTXLSPHQWQGWKDWWKHV\VWHPIFRPPXQLFDWLYH\PEROVVDKLJKO\RPSOH[XVLQHVVFTXLUHGDUO\QOLIHVWKHUHVXOWIRQJQGQWLPDWHUDLQLQJWLVQRWHQRXJKKDWRWKHUHUVRQVHPHUHO\UHVHQWKHVHRWKHUVPXVWKDYHDQLQWLPDWHULPDU\JURXSHODWLRQVKLSLWKKHFKLOG2WKHUKDQKLVRZHYHUKHWKHRULHVIRFLDOL]DWLRQUHJHQ

HUDOO\QHLWKHUZURQJQRUULJKWZLWKUHVSHFWR$QQDEXWVLPSO\LQDSSOLFDEOHKHSV\FKRDQDO\WLFKHRU\QVRIDUVLWDVVXPHVHUWDLQZLVKHVVJLYHQQKHUHQWO\QWKHRUJDQLVPQGUHVSRQVLEOHRUVHULHVIXEVHTXHQWHYHORSPHQWDOWDWHVHHPVZURQJXWQVRIDUDVLWWDONVQWHUPVIG\QDPLFPHFKDQLVPVXFKDVFRQIOLFWQGDQ[LHW\WVLPSO\RHVQRWSSO\EHFDXVHXFKPHFKDQLVPVVVXPH

WKDWRFLDOL]DWLRQDVDOUHDG\HJXQKDWKHQLWLDOWDJHVDYHEHHQWUDYHUVHGKHODWWHUKDUDFWHULVWLFHHPVQGHHGUXHIPRVWKHRULHVIRFLDOL]DWLRQKHFHQWUDOUREOHPIKRZKHRUJDQLVPLUVWDFTXLUHVVHOILUVWHJLQVKHRPPXQLFDWLYHURFHVVVVNLSSHGQGWDNHQRUUDQWHGKHWKHRU\RLQJQIURPKLVSRLQW

3(116</9$1,$67$7(&2//(*(

davis 1940 - extreme social isolation of a child

Documents