data for 305 completed trials with mta · data for 305 completed trials with mta . no. trial number...

1

Data for 305 Completed Trials with MTA

No. Trial Number Parties Patent

Number Petition

Filed Termination

Date Termination Type

Motion to Amend Substituting Claims

Granted or Granted-in-part (Y, N, N/A)

Statutory or Solely

Procedural Denial (S, P,

N/A) 1 CBM2013-00002 Liberty Mutual Insurance v.

Progressive Casualty 7877269 10/2/2012 2/24/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation

only N/A

2 CBM2013-00005 Bloomberg v. Market-Alerts Pty Ltd

7941357 10/15/2012 3/26/2014 FWD N S

3 CBM2013-00017 Volusion v. Versata Development

6834282 4/23/2013 6/17/2014 Settled N/A N/A

4 CBM2013-00018 Volusion v. Versata Development

7426481 4/23/2013 6/17/2014 Settled N/A N/A

5 CBM2013-00024 salesforce.com, Inc. v. VirtualAgility

8095413 5/24/2013 9/16/2014 FWD N S

6 CBM2013-00027 Chicago Mercantile v. 5th Market, Inc.

6418419 6/18/2013 12/17/2014 FWD Y, Grant-in-part S

7 CBM2013-00037 Search America v. TransUnion Intelligence

7333937 7/29/2013 2/3/2015 FWD N S

8 CBM2013-00044 Groupon v. Blue Calypso 8452646 8/16/2013 12/17/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A

9 CBM2013-00049 International Securities Exchange v. Chicago Board Options Exchange Inc.

7356498 9/6/2013 3/2/2015 FWD N S


7980457 9/6/2013 3/2/2015 FWD N S


8266044 9/6/2013 3/2/2015 FWD N S

12 CBM2014-00001 American Express v. MetaSearch

8326924 10/1/2013 3/13/2015 FWD N S

13 CBM2014-00031 PNC Financial Services Group v. Intellectual Ventures

6182894 11/12/2013 8/18/2014 Request for Adverse Judgment

N/A N/A

2


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 14 CBM2014-00050 American Express v.

Harvey Lunenfeld 8239451 12/19/2013 5/22/2015 FWD N S

15 CBM2014-00060 MotionPoint v. TransPerfect Global

6857022 1/23/2014 7/15/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

16 CBM2014-00062 CoreSource v. Quality Healthcare


N/A N/A

17 CBM2014-00063 CoreSource v. Quality Healthcare


N/A N/A

18 CBM2016-00081 SAP America v. Lakshmi Arunachalam

7340506 5/18/2016 12/21/2017 FWD N S

19 CBM2014-00119 The Jewelry Channel v. America's Collectibles Network

8370211 4/18/2014 10/16/2015 FWD N S

20 CBM2014-00159 Square Inc. v. Think Computer Corp.

8396808 7/21/2014 11/27/2015 FWD N S

21 CBM2014-00171 Mitchell International v. Audatex North America

7912740 8/11/2014 2/19/2016 FWD N S


8468038 8/12/2014 2/19/2016 FWD N S


8200513 8/11/2014 2/19/2016 FWD N S

24 CBM2014-00182 Square Inc. v. Protegrity Corp.

8402281 8/29/2014 3/2/2016 FWD N S

25 CBM2014-00186 Travelers Lloyds of Texas v. Integrated Claims Systems

7346768 9/17/2014 3/30/2016 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A

26 CBM2014-00187 Travelers Lloyds of Texas v. Integrated Claims Systems


N/A

27 CBM2015-00006 Epicor Software Corp. v. Protegrity Corp.

8402281 10/7/2014 4/18/2016 FWD N S

28 CBM2015-00010 Informatica Corporation v. Protegrity Corporation

8402281 10/14/2014 5/9/2016 FWD N S

3


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 29 CBM2015-00040 Google Inc. v.

ContentGuard Holdings, Inc.

7774280 12/9/2014 6/21/2016 FWD Y N/A, full grant of

MTA 30 CBM2015-00061 Chicago Mercantile v. Fifth

Market 7024387 1/14/2015 3/10/2016 Request for

Adverse Judgment N/A N/A

31 CBM2015-00145 Global Tel*Link Corp. v. Securus Technologies, Inc.

7860222 5/19/2015 11/15/2016 Dismissed N/A N/A

32 CBM2016-00039 Interactive Brokers LLC v. Chart Trading Development, LLC

8380611 2/19/2016 8/8/2017 FWD N S

33 CBM2016-00046 CQG, Inc. v. Chart Trading Development, LLC

7890416 3/18/2016 9/1/2017 FWD N S


8041626 3/18/2016 9/1/2017 FWD N S


8060435 3/18/2016 9/1/2017 FWD N S

36 IPR2012-00001 Garmin International, Inc. v. Cuozzo Speed Technologies LLC

6778074 9/16/2012 11/13/2013 FWD N S

37 IPR2012-00005 Nichia Corporation v. Emcore Corporation

6653215 9/16/2012 2/11/2014 FWD N S

38 IPR2012-00006 Illumina, Inc. v. National Science Foundation

7713698 9/16/2012 3/6/2014 FWD N S


7790869 9/16/2012 3/6/2014 FWD N S

40 IPR2012-00018 Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC v. Xilinx, Inc.

7566960 9/17/2012 2/10/2014 FWD N S


8062968 9/17/2012 2/10/2014 FWD N S

4


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 42 IPR2012-00020 Intellectual Ventures

Management, LLC v. Xilinx, Inc.


N/A

43 IPR2012-00022 Ariosa Diagnostics v. Isis Innovation Limited

6258540 9/20/2012 9/2/2014 FWD N P


7994609 9/17/2012 2/11/2014 FWD N S

45 IPR2012-00026 Microsoft v. Proxyconn Inc. 6757717 9/18/2012 2/19/2014 FWD N S 46 IPR2012-00027 IDLE Free Systems, Inc. v.

Bergstrom, Inc. 7591303 9/18/2012 1/7/2014 FWD N P

47 IPR2012-00042 Synopsys v. Mentor Graphics

6240376 9/26/2012 2/19/2014 FWD N S


8088575 10/3/2012 3/6/2014 FWD N S

49 IPR2013-00016 RIM v. Mobile Media Ideas 6441828 10/12/2012 2/25/2014 FWD N S 50 IPR2013-00020 LKQ Corp v. Clearlamp 7297364 10/17/2012 3/27/2014 FWD N S 51 IPR2013-00028 Chimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)

v. Semiconductor Energy Laboratory

6404480 10/19/2012 12/11/2013 Settled N/A N/A

52 IPR2013-00029 Xilinx, Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures

5632545 10/19/2012 3/10/2014 FWD N S

53 IPR2013-00033 CBS Interactive v. Helferich Patent Licensing

7155241 10/25/2012 3/3/2014 FWD N P

54 IPR2013-00038 Chimei Innolux Corp. (CMI) v. Semiconductor Energy Laboratory

7956978 11/6/2012 12/11/2013 Settled N/A N/A

55 IPR2013-00043 Corning, Inc. v. DSM IP Assets B.V.

7171103 11/15/2012 5/1/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


6961508 11/15/2012 5/1/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

5


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 57 IPR2013-00045 Corning, Inc. v. DSM IP

Assets B.V. 6339666 11/15/2012 5/9/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


6110593 11/15/2012 5/1/2014 FWD N P


6298189 11/15/2012 5/9/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


6298189 11/15/2012 5/9/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


6323255 11/15/2012 5/1/2014 FWD N S


7697102 11/19/2012 12/11/2013 Settled N/A N/A


7876413 11/28/2012 12/11/2013 Settled N/A N/A

64 IPR2013-00067 Adidas AG v. Nike, Inc. 7347011 11/28/2012 4/28/2014 FWD N S 65 IPR2013-00068 Chimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)

v. Semiconductor Energy Laboratory

8068204 11/29/2012 12/11/2013 Settled N/A N/A

66 IPR2013-00071 Avaya Inc. v. Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc.

6218930 12/5/2012 5/22/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

67 IPR2013-00072 Muchkin and Toys "R" Us, Inc. v. Luv N' Care, Ltd.

D617465 12/5/2012 4/21/2014 FWD N S

68 IPR2013-00073 Oracle v. Clouding IP, LLC 6738799 12/8/2012 7/22/2013 Settled N/A N/A 69 IPR2013-00075 Oracle v. Clouding IP, LLC 6925481 12/10/2012 7/22/2013 Settled N/A N/A 70 IPR2013-00093 Motorola Solutions, Inc. v.

Mobile Scanning Technologies

6065880 12/20/2012 4/24/2014 FWD N S

71 IPR2013-00097 Smith & Nephew v. Convatec Inc.

6669981 12/21/2012 5/29/2014 FWD N S

6


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 72 IPR2013-00099 Oracle v. Clouding IP, LLC 7065637 12/21/2012 7/22/2013 Settled N/A N/A 73 IPR2013-00102 Smith & Nephew v.

Convatec Inc. 7267828 12/22/2012 5/29/2014 FWD N S

74 IPR2013-00110 Scotts v. Encap 6209259 1/10/2013 6/24/2014 FWD N P 75 IPR2013-00111 SATA GmbH v. KANEKO 6494387 1/11/2013 5/20/2014 FWD N S 76 IPR2013-00112 Xilinx, Inc. v. Intellectual

Ventures 5779334 1/15/2013 6/26/2014 FWD N S

77 IPR2013-00116 Gnosis v. Merck 5997915 1/23/2013 6/20/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A


N/A


N/A


N/A

81 IPR2013-00120 LaRose v. Capriola 7731558 1/23/2013 6/26/2014 FWD N S 82 IPR2013-00122 InVue Security v.

Mechandising Tech. 7909641 1/24/2013 3/21/2014 Request for

Adverse Judgment N/A N/A

83 IPR2013-00124 IFF v. US Dept. of Agriculture


84 IPR2013-00128 Intelligent Bio-Systems v. Illumina, Inc.

7057026 1/29/2013 7/25/2014 FWD N S

85 IPR2013-00131 Dynamic v. National Graphics

6635196 2/1/2013 9/12/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

86 IPR2013-00136 ZTE v. ContentGuard Holdings


N/A N/A

87 IPR2013-00141 Veeam v. Symantec 6931558 2/13/2013 7/29/2014 FWD N S 88 IPR2013-00142 Veeam v. Symantec 6931558 2/13/2013 7/29/2014 FWD N S 89 IPR2013-00143 Veeam v. Symantec 7191299 2/13/2013 7/29/2014 FWD N S 90 IPR2013-00150 Veeam v. Symantec 7093086 2/14/2013 7/29/2014 FWD N S

7


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 91 IPR2013-00155 Ecowater Systems v.

Culligan International 8180489 2/21/2013 6/24/2014 FWD N S

92 IPR2013-00156 Zynga v. Personalized Media Comm.

7860131 2/22/2013 2/10/2014 Settled N/A N/A

93 IPR2013-00159 Zodiac Pool Systems v. Aqua Products Inc

8273183 2/25/2013 8/22/2014 FWD N S

94 IPR2013-00167 Athena Automation Ltd. v. Husky Injection Molding Sys

5620723 2/26/2013 7/23/2014 FWD N S


5624695 2/26/2013 7/23/2014 FWD N S

96 IPR2013-00175 BAE Systems v. Cheetah Omni

7633673 3/4/2013 6/19/2014 FWD N S

97 IPR2013-00178 Syntroleum v. Neste Oil 8212094 3/8/2013 8/29/2014 FWD N S 98 IPR2013-00179 ScentAir Tech. v. Prolitec 7712683 3/7/2013 6/26/2014 FWD N P 99 IPR2013-00191 Google/Apple v. Jongerious

Panoramic Tech 7785334 3/15/2013 8/12/2014 FWD N S

100 IPR2013-00194 SAP America v. Pi-Net Int'l 8108492 3/18/2013 9/18/2014 FWD N S 101 IPR2013-00195 SAP America v. Pi-Net Int'l 5987500 3/18/2013 9/18/2014 FWD N S 102 IPR2013-00226 SAS Institute v.

ComplementSoft, LLC 7110936 3/29/2013 8/6/2014 FWD N S

103 IPR2013-00241 InvenSense v. STMicroelectronics

6370954 4/8/2013 3/31/2014 Settled N/A N/A

104 IPR2013-00248 Rackspace Hosting v. Rotatable Technologies

6326978 4/12/2013 9/19/2014 FWD N S

105 IPR2013-00254 InvenSense v. STMicroelectronics

6034419 4/24/2013 3/31/2014 Settled N/A N/A

106 IPR2013-00266 Intelligent Bio-Systems v. Illumina, Inc.

8158346 5/4/2013 10/28/2014 FWD N S

8


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 107 IPR2013-00268 MotivePower v. Cutsforth 7141906 5/6/2013 10/30/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation

only N/A

108 IPR2013-00270 MotivePower v. Cutsforth 7417354 5/6/2013 10/30/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A

109 IPR2013-00272 MotivePower v. Cutsforth 8179014 5/8/2013 10/30/2014 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A


7670536 5/20/2013 10/23/2014 FWD N S

111 IPR2013-00292 Microsoft v. SurfCast 6724403 5/22/2013 10/14/2014 FWD N S 112 IPR2013-00318 JDS Unlphase Corp v. Fiber,

LLC 7095917 6/4/2013 12/5/2014 FWD N S

113 IPR2013-00322 Respironics v. Zoll Medical Corp.

6681003 5/31/2013 9/17/2014 FWD N P

114 IPR2013-00333 Tandus Flooring, Inc. v. Interface, Inc.

8381473 6/7/2013 12/8/2014 FWD N S

115 IPR2013-00336 JDS Uniphas Corp. v. Fiber, LLC

6430332 6/7/2013 12/5/2014 FWD N P

116 IPR2013-00357 Spectra Logic Corp v. Overland Storage

6328766 6/14/2013 11/7/2014 FWD N S

117 IPR2013-00369 Palo Alto Networks, Inc. v. Juniper Networks

7107612 6/20/2013 6/4/2014 Settled N/A N/A

118 IPR2013-00400 General Growth Properties, Inc v. George Peschke

6397143 7/2/2013 4/9/2014 Settled N/A N/A

119 IPR2013-00402 Riverbed Tech v. Silver Peak System


120 IPR2013-00403 Riverbed Tech v. Silver Peak System


121 IPR2013-00415 Toyota Motor v. American Vehicular Sciences

7650210 7/8/2013 11/12/2014 FWD N/A, Withdrawn N/A

9


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 122 IPR2013-00416 Toyota Motor v. American

Vehicular Sciences 8019501 7/8/2013 12/5/2014 FWD N/A, Withdrawn N/A

123 IPR2013-00417 Toyota Motor v. American Vehicular Sciences


N/A

124 IPR2013-00453 Atlanta Gas Light v. Bennett

5810029 7/18/2013 1/6/2015 Dismissed N/A N/A

125 IPR2013-00463 Johnson Health Tech v. ICON Health & Fitness

6702719 7/23/2013 1/29/2015 FWD N P

126 IPR2013-00480 Facebook v. Software Rights


N/A

127 IPR2013-00493 Trivascular v. Shaun Samuels

6007575 8/5/2013 12/3/2014 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

128 IPR2013-00512 Apex Medical Corp. v. RESMED Limited

7487772 8/16/2013 9/12/2014 Settled N/A N/A

129 IPR2013-00527 Tandus Flooring, Inc. v. Interface, Inc.

8434282 8/23/2013 2/12/2015 FWD N S

130 IPR2013-00531 Target v. Destination Maternity

RE43563 8/27/2013 5/8/2015 Request for Adverse Judgment

N/A N/A

131 IPR2013-00575 DeLaval International AB v. Daritech

6443094 9/6/2013 2/20/2015 FWD N S

132 IPR2013-00578 Neste Oil v. Syntroleum 8231804 9/10/2013 3/12/2015 FWD N S 133 IPR2013-00586 Unified Patents, Inc. v.

Clouding 6738799 9/16/2013 3/18/2015 FWD N P

134 IPR2013-00597 Yamaha v. Black Hills Media 8230099 9/19/2013 3/18/2015 FWD N/A, Cancellation only

N/A

135 IPR2013-00602 Broadcom Corp v. Ericsson 6466568 9/20/2013 3/6/2015 FWD N S 136 IPR2013-00636 Broadcom Corp v. Ericsson 6424625 9/30/2013 3/6/2015 FWD N S 137 IPR2014-00038 Google v. B.E. Technology 6628314 10/8/2013 3/31/2015 FWD N P 138 IPR2014-00039 Microsoft v. B.E.

Technology 6628314 10/9/2013 3/31/2015 FWD N P

10


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 139 IPR2014-00041 GEA Process Engineering v.

Steuben Foods, Inc. 6945013 10/9/2013 12/23/2014 Dismissed N/A N/A

140 IPR2014-00042 Guangdong Xinbao v. Adrian Rivera

8291812 10/9/2013 2/6/2015 FWD N S

141 IPR2014-00047 Crocus Technology v. New York University


N/A

142 IPR2014-00052 Facebook v. B.E. Technology

6628314 10/9/2013 3/31/2015 FWD N P

143 IPR2014-00053 Facebook v. B.E. Technology

6628314 10/9/2013 3/31/2015 FWD N P

144 IPR2014-00054 GEA Process Engineering v. Steuben Foods, Inc.

6481468 10/10/2013 12/23/2014 Dismissed N/A N/A

145 IPR2014-00088 Veeam Software Corp v. Symantec

7480822 10/22/2013 3/20/2015 FWD N P

146 IPR2014-00090 Veeam Software Corp v. Symantec

7024527 10/22/2013 4/23/2015 FWD N P

147 IPR2014-00098 International Securities Exchange v. Chicago Board Options Exchange

7980457 11/12/2013 3/2/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

148 IPR2014-00110 Medtronic, Inc. v. Troy R. Norred

6482228 10/31/2013 4/23/2015 FWD N S

149 IPR2014-00111 Medtronic, Inc. v. Troy R. Norred

6482228 10/31/2013 4/23/2015 FWD N S

150 IPR2014-00128 Silver Peak Systems, Inc v. Riverbed Tech


N/A N/A

151 IPR2014-00149 Silver Peak Systems, Inc v. Riverbed Tech


N/A N/A

152 IPR2014-00167 Micro Motion, Inc. v. Invensys Systems

7505854 11/19/2013 3/31/2015 Settled N/A N/A

153 IPR2014-00178 Micro Motion, Inc. v. Invensys Systems

7136761 11/19/2013 4/1/2015 Settled N/A N/A

11


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 154 IPR2014-00179 Micro Motion, Inc. v.

Invensys Systems 7124646 11/19/2013 4/1/2015 Settled N/A N/A

155 IPR2014-00183 Autel U.S. Inc. v. Service Solution

6904796 11/21/2013 5/5/2015 FWD N S

156 IPR2014-00185 Organik Kimya San. ve Tic. A.S. v. Rohm and Haas

6020435 11/21/2013 5/27/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

157 IPR2014-00192 Syntroleum Corp v. Neste Oil


MTA 158 IPR2014-00204 Toshiba Corp v. LG

Electronic 6477126 12/2/2013 3/31/2015 FWD N P

159 IPR2014-00216 Greene's Energy Group v. Oil States Energy

6179053 12/3/2013 5/1/2015 FWD N P

160 IPR2014-00242 Facebook v. EveryMD 8499047 12/6/2013 5/12/2015 FWD N S 161 IPR2014-00245 Riverbed Tech v. Silver

Peak System 8392684 12/11/2013 6/9/2015 FWD N S

162 IPR2014-00252 NetFlix, Inc. v. OpenTV 8107786 12/16/2013 1/26/2015 Settled N/A N/A 163 IPR2014-00272 Ford Motor Com. v. TMC

Fuel Injection 7318414 12/19/2013 6/22/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

164 IPR2014-00350 Organik Kimya San. ve Tic. A.S. v. Rohm and Haas

6252004 1/14/2014 6/26/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

165 IPR2014-00351 Euro-Pro Operating v. Acorne Enterprises

6515262 1/14/2014 7/9/2015 FWD N S

166 IPR2014-00352 Euro-Pro Operating v. Acorne Enterprises

6624392 1/14/2014 7/9/2015 FWD N S

167 IPR2014-00360 Amneal Pharmaceuticals v. Endo Pharmaceuticals

8329216 1/16/2014 7/22/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

168 IPR2014-00393 Micro Motion, Inc. v. Invensys systems

7571062 1/31/2014 3/31/2015 Settled N/A N/A

169 IPR2014-00395 Micro Motion, Inc. v. Invensys systems

6482228 1/31/2014 6/25/2015 FWD N S

12


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 170 IPR2014-00513 Oxford Nanopore v. UAB &

University of Washington 8673550 3/18/2014 2/26/2016 FWD N/A, Cancellation

only N/A

171 IPR2014-00532 Google v. Micrografx 5959633 3/24/2014 7/21/2015 FWD N S 172 IPR2014-00583 Edmund Optics v. Semrock 7068430 4/4/2014 9/9/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A 173 IPR2014-00599 Edmund Optics v. Semrock 7119960 4/9/2014 9/16/2015 FWD N/A, Moot N/A 174 IPR2014-00714 U.S. Dept. of Homeland

Security v. Larry Golden RE43990 4/30/2014 10/1/2015 FWD N S

175 IPR2014-00718 Samsung Electronics v. Black Hills Media


N/A N/A

176 IPR2014-00721 Samsung Electronics v. Black Hills Media


N/A N/A

177 IPR2014-00784 Torrent Pharm v. Novartis AG

8324283 5/27/2014 9/24/2015 FWD N S

178 IPR2014-00814 Churchill Drilling v. Schoeller-Bleckmann


179 IPR2014-01121 Broad Ocean Motor LLC v. Nidec Motor Corp.

7626349 7/3/2014 5/9/2016 FWD N S

180 IPR2014-01154 HTC Corp v. Advanced Audio Devices

6587403 7/11/2014 12/29/2015 FWD N P

181 IPR2014-01157 HTC Corp v. Advanced Audio Devices

7933171 7/11/2014 1/22/2016 FWD N P

182 IPR2014-01244 Geox SpA v. Outdry Technologies

6855171 8/4/2014 12/18/2015 FWD N S

183 IPR2014-01246 AAC Technologies Pte. v. MEMSMART Semiconductor

7829364 8/5/2014 1/4/2016 Settled N/A N/A

184 IPR2014-01262 Tech 21 UK v. Zagg 8567596 8/8/2014 1/27/2016 FWD N S 185 IPR2014-01278 Global Tel*Link Corp v.

Securus Tech 7860222 8/12/2014 1/21/2016 FWD N P

186 IPR2014-01282 Global Tel*Link Corp v. Securus Tech

7860222 8/12/2014 1/21/2016 FWD N P

13


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 187 IPR2014-01292 VMware v. Clouding 7032089 8/14/2014 12/3/2015 FWD N S 188 IPR2014-01361 AVX Corp. v. Greatbatch 6687117 8/21/2014 12/30/2015 FWD N S 189 IPR2014-01439 Toshiba Corp. v. Optical

Devices RE42913 9/3/2014 3/8/2016 FWD N S

190 IPR2014-01441 Toshiba Corp. v. Optical Devices

RE43681 9/3/2014 3/8/2016 FWD N S

191 IPR2014-01443 Toshiba Corp. v. Optical Devices

RE40927 9/3/2014 3/8/2016 FWD N S

192 IPR2014-01500 Ford Motor v. Empire IP 7389198 9/15/2014 7/28/2015 Settled N/A N/A 193 IPR2014-01528 Amazon.com v.

Personalized Media Communications

7783252 9/22/2014 3/23/2016 FWD N S

194 IPR2014-01530 Amazon.com v. Personalized Media Communications

7864956 9/22/2014 3/24/2016 FWD N S


7801304 9/22/2014 3/29/2016 FWD N S


7805749 9/22/2014 3/8/2016 FWD N S


7827587 9/22/2014 3/22/2016 FWD N S

198 IPR2015-00013 Edmit Industries, Inc. v. SMARTDOOR HOLDINGS, INC.

6484784 10/3/2014 3/29/2016 FWD N S

199 IPR2015-00040 MasterImage 3D, Inc. v. REALD INC.

8220934 10/7/2014 4/14/2016 FWD N S

200 IPR2015-00101 AVX Corp. v. Greatbatch, Ltd.

6219222 10/21/2014 5/2/2016 FWD N S

14


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 201 IPR2015-00158 Sony Mobile

Communications (USA) Inc. v. Memory Integrity, LLC

7296121 11/4/2014 5/19/2016 FWD N S

202 IPR2015-00159 Apple Inc. v. Memory Integrity, LLC

7296121 10/28/2014 6/21/2016 FWD N S

203 IPR2015-00163 Apple Inc. v. Memory Integrity, LLC

7296121 10/28/2014 6/21/2016 FWD N S

204 IPR2015-00208 Shinn Fu Company of America, Inc. v. The Tire Hanger Corporation


MTA 205 IPR2015-00430 Epic Lift Systems, LLC v.

Integrated Production Services

6719060 12/15/2014 10/19/2015 Settled N/A N/A

206 IPR2015-00465 Zhongshan Broad-Ocean Motor Co., Ltd. v. Nidec Motor Corp.

8049459 12/19/2014 6/22/2016 FWD N S

207 IPR2015-00556 Alcohol Monitoring Systems, Inc. v. Soberlink, Inc.

8381573 1/12/2015 5/3/2016 FWD N S

208 IPR2015-00630 Mako Surgical Corp. v. Carnegie Mellon University

6205411 1/28/2015 8/1/2016 FWD N S

209 IPR2015-00636 CaptionCall, L.L.C. v. Ultratec, Inc.

8917822 1/29/2015 9/7/2016 FWD N S


8908838 1/29/2015 9/7/2016 FWD N S

211 IPR2015-00754 Array Biopharma Inc. v. Takeda Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd.

8592454 2/17/2015 8/12/2016 FWD N S

212 IPR2015-00765 Blue Belt Technologies, Inc. v. All-of-Innovation GmbH

7346417 2/19/2015 7/26/2016 FWD N S

15


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 213 IPR2015-00841 Baby Trend, Inc. v.

Wonderland Nurserygoods Co., Ltd.

RE43919 3/4/2015 6/27/2016 FWD N S

214 IPR2015-00842 Baby Trend, Inc. v. Wonderland Nurserygoods Co., Ltd.

RE43920 3/4/2015 6/27/2016 FWD N S

215 IPR2015-00872 Luv N' Care, Ltd. v. Munchkin, Inc.

8739993 3/11/2015 9/15/2016 FWD N S

216 IPR2015-00908 AVX Corp. v. Greatbatch, Ltd.

7035076 3/20/2015 9/20/2016 FWD N S

217 IPR2015-00998 Ameriforge Group Inc. v. Worldwide Oilfield Machine, Inc.

6684897 4/3/2015 9/19/2016 FWD N S

218 IPR2015-01028 Samsung Electronics v. NVIDIA Corp.

6198488 4/9/2015 8/3/2016 Settled N/A N/A


6992667 4/9/2015 8/3/2016 Settled N/A N/A

220 IPR2015-01057 Anatomage, Inc. v. Sirona Dental Systems GmbH

6319006 4/15/2015 10/19/2016 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

221 IPR2015-01060 Brunswick Corp. v. Cobalt Boats, LLC

8375880 4/16/2015 9/28/2016 FWD N S

222 IPR2015-01079 American Megatrends, Inc. v. Kinglite Holdings Inc.

6373498 4/22/2015 10/27/2016 FWD N S

223 IPR2015-01094 American Megatrends, Inc. v. Kinglite Holdings Inc.

6401202 4/24/2015 11/4/2016 FWD N S

224 IPR2015-01190 Institut Straumann AG v. Sirona Dental Systems GmbH

6319006 5/11/2015 11/15/2016 FWD N S


7015913 5/12/2015 8/15/2016 Settled N/A N/A

16


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 226 IPR2015-01219 Global Tel*Link Corp. v.

Securus Technologies, Inc. 8626118 5/19/2015 12/9/2016 FWD N S

227 IPR2015-01221 Global Tel*Link Corp. v. Securus Technologies, Inc.





8135115 5/19/2015 12/21/2016 FWD N S

230 IPR2015-01490 Pharmacosmos A/S v. Luitpold Pharmaceuticals, Inc.

7754702 6/24/2015 1/4/2017 FWD N S

231 IPR2015-01493 Pharmacosmos A/S v. Luitpold Pharmaceuticals, Inc.

8431549 6/24/2015 12/28/2016 FWD N S

232 IPR2015-01516 Creative Consumer Concepts, Inc. v. Kid Stuff Marketing, Inc.

8783548 7/6/2015 10/7/2016 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

233 IPR2015-01835 Coalition for Affordable Drugs VIII, LLC v. The Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania

8618135 8/28/2015 3/6/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

234 IPR2015-01836 Coalition for Affordable Drugs VIII, LLC v. The Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania

7932268 8/28/2015 3/6/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

235 IPR2015-01855 McAfee, Inc. v. CAP Co., Ltd.

RE42196 9/2/2015 3/2/2017 FWD N S


9131045 9/9/2015 3/8/2017 FWD N S

237 IPR2015-01920 Repro-Med Systems, Inc. v. EMED Technologies Corp.

8961476 9/17/2015 1/12/2017 FWD N S

17


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 238 IPR2015-01951 Activision Blizzard, Inc. v.

Acceleration Bay, LLC 6714966 9/24/2015 3/23/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

239 IPR2015-01953 Activision Blizzard, Inc. v. Acceleration Bay, LLC



6829634 9/28/2015 3/29/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


6701344 9/25/2015 3/23/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A





244 IPR2015-02009 Amerigen Pharmaceuticals Limited v. Shire LLC

RE42096 10/1/2015 3/31/2017 FWD Y N/A, full grant of

MTA 245 IPR2016-00012 Zimmer Biomet Holdings,

Inc. v. Four Mile Bay, LLC 8821582 10/2/2015 3/10/2017 FWD N/A, Withdrawn N/A

246 IPR2016-00043 MRSI Systems, LLC v. Palomar Technologies, Inc.

6776327 10/13/2015 3/29/2017 FWD N S

247 IPR2016-00076 Aceto Agricultural Chemicals Corp. v. Gowan Company, LLC

8791049 10/23/2015 4/28/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

248 IPR2016-00125 Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. West View Research, LLC


N/A, Withdrawn N/A

249 IPR2016-00156 Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. West View Research, LLC


N/A, Withdrawn N/A



N/A N/A

18


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 251 IPR2016-00212 Google Inc. v. Vedanti

Systems Limited 7974339 11/18/2015 5/7/2017 FWD N S



N/A N/A

253 IPR2016-00266 McWane, Inc. v. Tom Waugh

RE45329 11/25/2015 5/23/2017 FWD N S

254 IPR2016-00341 Elekta Inc. v. Varian Medical Systems, Inc.


N/A N/A

255 IPR2016-00360 Twilio Inc. v. Telesign Corporation

7945034 12/16/2015 6/26/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A



N/A

257 IPR2016-00458 Eli Lilly & Co. v. The Trustees of the Univ. of Penn.

7625558 1/14/2016 7/13/2017 FWD N S



N/A

259 IPR2016-00481 3Shape Medical A/S v. Sirona Dental Systems GmbH

6319006 1/20/2016 6/21/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

260 IPR2016-00502 Valeo North America, Inc. v. Shaeffler Technologies AG & Co. KG


261 IPR2016-00528 General Electric Co. v. Rolls-Royce PLC

8715809 1/29/2016 7/26/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A



N/A N/A

263 IPR2016-00615 Tex. Ass'n of Realtors v. IP3, Series 100 of Allied Security Trust I

8510045 2/11/2016 8/4/2017 FWD N S

19


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 264 IPR2016-00712 Mylan Labs. Ltd. v. Aventis

Pharma S.A. 8927592 3/15/2016 9/21/2017 FWD N S

265 IPR2016-00753 Apple Inc. v. Personalized Media Communications, LLC

7752649 3/14/2016 4/29/2017 Settled N/A N/A


8559635 3/14/2016 9/19/2017 FWD N S


8191091 3/14/2016 9/19/2017 FWD N S

268 IPR2016-00792 Vision Indus. Grp. v. Mighton Prods. Ltd.

8881461 3/23/2016 9/20/2017 FWD N S

269 IPR2016-00806 Legend3D, Inc. v. Prime Focus Creative Serv. Canada Inc.

8922628 3/28/2016 9/18/2017 FWD N S

270 IPR2016-00868 Minerva Surgical, Inc. v. Hologic, Inc.

6872183 4/11/2016 12/15/2017 FWD N S

271 IPR2016-00906 Curt G. Joa, Inc. v. Fameccanica Data S.P.A.


272 IPR2016-01033 Mylan Pharms. Inc. v. Shire Labs. Inc. & Shire LLC

RE42096 5/12/2016 8/4/2017 Dismissed N/A N/A

273 IPR2016-01069 Valve Corporation v. Treehouse Avatar LLC


N/A N/A

274 IPR2016-01186 Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Mayne Pharma Int'l Pty Ltd.


N/A

275 IPR2016-01197 Bear Archery, Inc. v. James Kempf

7328693 6/14/2016 5/11/2017 Settled N/A N/A

20


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 276 IPR2016-01243 Prime Focus Creative Serv.

Canada Inc. v. Legend3D, Inc.

7907793 6/21/2016 12/18/2017 FWD N S

277 IPR2016-01249 Taiwan Semiconductor Mfg. Co., Ltd. v. Godo Kaisha IP Bridge 1


278 IPR2016-01257 Cisco Sys., Inc. v. Focal IP, LLC

8457113 6/23/2016 12/27/2017 FWD N S

279 IPR2016-01258 Ymax Corp. v. Focal IP, LLC 7764777 6/23/2016 12/28/2017 FWD N S 280 IPR2016-01260 Ymax Corp. v. Focal IP, LLC 8457113 6/23/2016 12/27/2017 FWD N S 281 IPR2016-01261 WideOpenWest Fin., LLC v.

Focal IP, LLC 8457113 6/24/2016 12/28/2017 FWD N S

282 IPR2016-01262 WideOpenWest Fin., LLC v. Focal IP, LLC

7764777 6/24/2016 12/28/2017 FWD N S

283 IPR2016-01264 Taiwan Semiconductor Mfg. Co., Ltd. v. Godo Kaisha IP Bridge 1

6538324 6/24/2016 12/20/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

284 IPR2016-01398 Intel Corp. v. Future Link Sys., LLC

7743257 7/8/2016 8/17/2017 Settled N/A N/A

285 IPR2016-01402 Intel Corp. v. Future Link Sys., LLC

7685439 7/8/2016 8/17/2017 Settled N/A N/A

286 IPR2016-01428 Fluke Corp. v. Ametek Denmark A/S

8342742 7/13/2016 12/13/2017 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


8559635 7/30/2016 2/15/2018 FWD N S

288 IPR2016-01550 Parrot S.A. v. QFO Labs, Inc. 7931239 8/8/2016 2/15/2018 FWD N S 289 IPR2016-01559 Parrot S.A. v. QFO Labs, Inc. 9073532 8/8/2016 2/15/2018 FWD N S 290 IPR2016-01589 Semiconductor

Components Indus., LLC 6249876 8/11/2016 2/14/2018 FWD N S

21


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) d/b/a ON Semiconductor v. Power Integrations, Inc.

291 IPR2016-01600 Semiconductor Components Indus., LLC d/b/a ON Semiconductor v. Power Integrations, Inc.

7834605 8/11/2016 2/14/2018 FWD N S

292 IPR2016-01610 Polygroup Ltd. (MCO) v. Willis Electric Co., Ltd.

8454186 9/2/2016 2/26/2018 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


8454187 8/26/2016 2/26/2018 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


9044056 9/1/2016 2/26/2018 FWD Y, Grant-in-part


8936379 9/2/2016 2/26/2018 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


8936379 9/13/2016 2/26/2018 FWD N/A, Moot N/A


8936379 9/2/2016 2/26/2018 FWD N/A, Moot N/A

298 IPR2016-01622 Kingston Tech. Co., Inc. v. Polaris Innovations Ltd.

6850414 8/16/2016 2/5/2018 FWD N S

299 IPR2016-01737 Apple Inc. v. Realtime Data, LLC d/b/a IXO

8880862 9/9/2016 3/13/2018 FWD Y N/A

300 IPR2016-01738 Apple Inc. v. Realtime Data, LLC d/b/a IXO

8880862 9/9/2016 3/16/2018 FWD Y N/A

301 IPR2016-01763 Kapsch TrafficCom IVHS Inc. v. Neology, Inc.

8944337 9/9/2016 3/20/2018 FWD N S

302 IPR2017-00962 Boydstun Equip. Mfg., LLC v. Cottrell, Inc.

7585140 2/21/2017 3/14/2018 Settled N/A N/A

22


Number Petition

Filed Termination




Statutory or Solely


N/A) 303 PGR2015-00003 American Simmental

Association v. Leachman Cattle of Colorado, LLC

8660888 11/21/2014 6/13/2016 FWD N S

304 PGR2015-00005 American Simmental Association v. Leachman Cattle of Colorado, LLC

8725557 1/30/2015 6/13/2016 FWD N S

305 PGR2017-00005 Securus Techs. Inc. v. Global Tel*Link Corp.

9307386 11/17/2016 12/7/2017 Settled N/A N/A

data for 305 completed trials with mta · data for 305 completed trials with mta . no. trial number...

Documents