d4uyx^r im mf xycyqoiac i - university of michigan · 2006-07-12 · z. c vwiac w_wab g g b...

23

Upload: others

Post on 18-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

������������ �������� �������� ���� � �!�"�"�#�$ �%���&(')�"�+* ��,���!�-�!�.�0/1��2�.3 ��4���

�5�3�3��6 �����7�-�98:�!�.�4���9�; ��4�<���=&> ����&

?A@AB�CED;FHG�B�IKJMLONQPSR

T>U IAVWN T VQXYNWC�VWNWR=Z.X\[]X^RSX^@_Ca`Kb�ced$f�g�h=i T ijikJlNQRkm�NWR-NnIAP-VoBpG�NQC�qSNWPQg�ra@As�N)qSqkt�X^NWuYv�g�G�i�wAbyx_f_c]z

{ @AB�C#|.J~}>VWNQC�IANAF�IAP-VAF�C�IAR�I]F��_@�[

D4uYX^R�IM�MF�����XYCyqoIAC�I

T]U IAVQN T VWX^NWC�VQN~Z.X\[]X^RSX^@_C�`Kb�c�df�g�hki T i�ikJlNQR=m=NQRSNnIKPSVoBpG�NQCyq�NWPQgOr�@AsONQqSqkt�X^NWu^v6g�G�i�wAbyxAfyc

IAC�vaZ.N U IKP-q�J�NWCyq�@A���4B�}>R-XYVWRQgH�kC�X\[_NWP-RSX\q$}�@A��r�XYVoB�X^�yIAC6g�i�C�Cai�P-LO@_PQg#r���b_����x_w�z

NQ����XYCyqoIKC#|.NWR-qSPSNQuYu�IKRWF�IAPSVKF�C�IKR�I�F��_@�[

rEIAP-qSXYCa?�F#Z.��C�VnIAC

Z.N U IAP!q�J�NWCyq=@A���2By}>RSX^VWRQg��.��NQNWC6��Rk�kC�X\[_NWP-RSX\q$}_gH��XYC��_R!q�@_C�g���hj���K��f_hk��g#G�IAC�IKv�I�z

v���C�VnIAC�|�IKR-q�P-@�F��>��NWNWC�RS�6F�VnI

?_IAVo��?�F#��X^RSRSIA��NWP

T]U IAVQN T VQXYNQC�VWN�Z.X^[>X^RSXY@AC�`Kb�ced$f�g�h=i T iji�J�NWR=m�NWR-NnIAP-VoBpG�NWCyqSNWPWgOr�@Ks�N)qSqkt�XYNQuYv6g�G�i�wAbyx_fyc>z

{ uYX^RSRSIA��NWP�|.PSXYC��_RSX^v�NAF�IAPSVKF�C�IAR�I�F��_@�[

m�NWVQNWX^[ANWv z IAVQVWN U q�NWv

Page 2: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ` �

�������������

1N v�NWP-X^[_N IKC�v q�NQR-q�q���@aC�N�� R-}>J U uYNWV)q�X^V~XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P.IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J�RWg#RS��X\qoIAL�uYN�� @APR!q���v�}>X^C�� U uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}�IKVWVWP-NQqSXY@_C X^ClL�XYC�IAP!}�R-qoIKP�R-}>R!q�NWJ�RWF��;B�N�IAuY�A@_PSX\q�B�J�R4XYC�VQ@_P U @_PSIKq�NqSB�N B�XYNQP�IAP-VoB�XYVWIAu4C�IKqS��PSN @A��R-qoIKL�uYN U uYIAC�N)qoIAP!}p@_PSL�X^q�R�X^C1L�XYC�IAP!} R!qoIAP�R-}>R!q�NWJ�RWF �$C@_C�N~VnIKRSNAg U u�IKC�NQqSR�@_P-L�X^qkI R-XYC��_u^N�R-qoIKPWg U NQP-q���PSLHNWvpLy}�I v�XYR!qoIACyqkVW@_J U IAC�XY@_C6zHXYCaq�B�NR-NWVW@AC�v VnIKRSNAg U u�IKC�NQqSR�@_P-L�X^q2LH@AqSB L�X^C�IAP-}MJlNQJMLONQPSRQF2D"IKVoB IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�NWR"VWu^@_RSNNQC�VW@_��C�qSNWP-RkLHNQq���NWNQC U u�IKC�NQqSR=R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYVWIAuYu\}���RSX^C�� I By}>L�PSX^v�R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV�R-VoB�NWJ�NAF

�������������! "�$#&%('*),+.-0/ VQNWuYNQR-qSX�IAu"JlNQVoB�IAC�X^VWRQg4R-q�NQuYuYIAP�v]}]C�IAJlX^VWR�15J�NQq�B�@]v�R�2 C]d$LH@]v]}R-XYJM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R�15J�NQq�B�@]v�R�2�C���J�NWP-XYVnIKu

Page 3: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� f �

��� ������� ������������

h�d LO@>v�} R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV JlI U�U XYC���q�NQVoB�C�XY����NQR IAPSN�q�B�Nlq�@>@_u2@A��VoB�@_X^VWNl� @AP~JlIACy} U PS@_L�u^NWJ�Rq�B�IKqMP-NW����XYP-N B�X^�_B�R U NQNWv6g2J�@]v�NQP�IKqSNWu\} IAVWVQ��P�IKqSN���d LO@>v�}1XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�XY@AC�RWF �;B�NWR-N�IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J�R� IKuYRS@lPSN)� NWPSP-NWv qS@�IAR�J�X��]NQv]d [KIAP-X�IAL�u^N�R-}>J U uYNWV)q�X^V�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�@APSRWg�IK� q�NQP T IKB�I IAC�v � P-NWJlIAXYC�N���w_w_`����NWPSN X^C�qSPS@>v���VQNWvpLy} 5X^RSv�@_J IAC�v��=@_uYJlIAC � ��w_w���kIAC�v ��X^C�@_RSB�X^qoI ��� #���� � ��w_w���)F �;B�N)}pB�In[_NRSX^C�VWN�LONQNWCp��R-NWvEqS@ qoIKVo�>u^NMI ��XYv�N�[AIKPSXYN)q$}a@A� U P-@_L�uYNQJlR=XYC T @_uYIAP T }>R-q�NQJ v�}>C�IKJlX^VWRWg U uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}IAC�v RSIKq�NQuYuYX\q�N IKVWVWP-NQqSXY@_C6g�IKC�v N �>q�PSIARS@_uYIAP U uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}ER-}>R-qSNWJ�R � ��� +!� g��3NQ[>XYR-@_C#" Z.��C�VWIAC ��w_wAb�gG�B�IAJ~LONQPSR$" 1NQq�B�NWPSX^uYu ��w_w_��g�G�IAC�� U ��� #���� �nw_w_w�g�m�X^[ANWPSI%" �3XYRSRSIA��NQP�`Kx_x_x!� FT }>J U uYNQVQq�X^V=IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J�R�B�In[_N=q���@ML�XY��IAv�[KIACyqoIA�ANWR"@e[ANWP�@Aq�B�NQP�J�NQqSB�@>v�RWF4t XYPSR!qng_� @_P U P-@_L�uYNQJlR

XYCy[A@_u^[>XYC��MI�v�@_JlX^C�IACyq�VWNWCyqSP�IAuOJ IAR-RWg�q�B�N.��N U uYNQPSXYIAClJ�@AqSXY@_C�@A�3q�B�N�R�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NWR"IALH@_��q�q�B�N U PSX^J IKP-}XYR'&-L���XYu\q�XYC)(�F�i�R�I�P-NWRS��u^qng#J�@_R-q=@A��q�B�N�VW@_J U ��q�IKq�X^@_C�IAu�NQsO@_P-qkXYR�v�N)[_@AqSNWvEqS@lq�B�N U NWP!q���P-L�IKq�X^@_C�RLHNQq���NWNWC�q�B�N�R�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NWRQg���B�X^VoB�JlIA�ANQRkX\q U @_RSR-XYL�u^N.q�@���RSN�uY@_C��Mq�XYJ�NWR!q�N U R ��X^q�BaJlIACy} � N���NWP�� @_PSVQNNQ[KIAu^��IKqSXY@_C�R�qSB�IAC�VW@_Cy[_NQCyq�XY@AC�IAu IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J�R�RS��VoB IAR+*���uYX^PSRSVoB>d T qS@]NQP � T q�@>NWPkIAC�v,*���u^XYPSR-VoB1�nw_�_x!�@_P�m�i.Z�i�� � D�[ANWPSB�IAP-q���w_�_c��)F�i�R�I P-��uYNM@K�"qSB���JML6g6qSB�XYR.�AX^[_NQR.q�B�N R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�JlRkIR U NWNQvEIKv�[KIACyqoIA�_N�@A� IALO@A��q�IAC�@_P-v�NWP�@K� JlIA�_C�X^q���v�Nk� @_P U PS@_L�uYNWJ�R�qSB�IKq;v�@ C�@Kq;PSNQ�>��XYPSN.[ANWP!}�B�XY�ABIAVQVW��PSIAVQ}�R-@_uY�]q�XY@AC�RWF �;B�N�R-NWVW@AC�v IAv][AIKC�q�IA�_N�@A� R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV�RSVoB�NWJ�NWR=XYR�q�B�IKq;q�B�N)}�N ��IAV)q�u\} � @_uYu^@ �q�B�N~NQ[A@_uY�]q�XY@ACE@A�2I'��IAJ�XYu\q�@_C�X�IAC�R!}]R!q�NQJ�g�IAuYLHNWX\q�@_C�N�qSB�IKqkXYR=C�@AqkN ��IAV)q�u^}�qSB�N~RSIAJlN~IAR�q�B�N�PSNnIKuR-}>R!q�NWJaF �;B�XYR�J�NnIKC�R�q�B�IKqngON �]VWN U q�� @_P�C���J�NWP-XYVnIKu�PS@A��C�v�@As1NWP-PS@_PQg�q�B�NQ} N-�]B�XYL�X\q.C�@�u^@_C��Kd q�NQPSJL���X^uYv�� U XYC�NQC�NWP-�A}�NWP-PS@_PQFm�NWVWNQCyq�u^}Ag�Z.��C�VWIAC ��� #���� � ��w_w_�!�"IAC�v�G�B�IAJMLHNWPSR � ��w_wAw!�"B�In[AN.v�NWR-VWP-XYLHNWv�B�@ �5q�@MJ�@]v�X^� } q�B�N

L�IAR-XYV�R-}>J U uYNWV)q�X^V�R-VoB�NWJ�N~q�@ VW@ U N ��X\q�B R-X^q���IKq�X^@_C�R�XYC ��B�XYVoB U NWP!q���P-L�IKq�X^@_C�R=LON)q���NQNWC R�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NWRIAP-NMC�@�uY@AC��_NWPkRSJlIAuYu�VW@AJ U IKPSNWv qS@ q�B�N�� @_PSVQNMv���NMqS@ q�B�N U PSXYJlIAP!}_F �;B�X^R.J IK�ANWR�X\q U @_RSR-XYL�u^N�qS@XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NMVQuY@_R-NMNWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSR�LHNQq���NWNWC LH@]v�X^NWRQg3IAC�vpq�@�J�@>v�NWu U u�IKC�NQq�IAP-}�@_P.RSIKq�NQuYuYX\q�N~IAVWVQPSNQqSXY@_C�F�;B�N q���@�Jl@>v�X�.�NWv IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�R.v�X\s�NQP�XYC v�NWR-XY�_C�g�L���qMI U�U NWIAP�q�@a�_X^[AN VW@_J U IAPSIAL�uYN P-NWR-��u^qSR�X^CU PSIAVQqSXYVWNKg#IAC�v�NnIKVoBEPSN)qoIAX^C�R�q�B�N�IKv�[KIACyqoIA�_NQR�@A� qSB�N�@_PSX^�_XYC�IAu�J�NQqSB�@]v�F

��@�v�I q�NAg3@AC�N U PS@_L�uYNWJ ��B�XYVoB B�IAR�C�@Kq�LONQNWC N ��IAJ�XYC�NQv ��RSXYC��aR!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_PSR�X^RU uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}�IAVQVWP-NQq�X^@_CpXYCEL�XYC�IKP-}aR-q�IAP.R-}>R!q�NWJ�RWF �;B�N v�XYRSVQ@�[_NWP!} @A�2N-�>q�P�IKRS@_uYIAP U uYIAC�NQqSR�X^C L�XYC�IAP-}R-}>R!q�NWJ�R � ��� +!� g�G�@>VoB�P�IAC ���!#���� �nw_wy��� g�IAC�vpq�B�N � IAV)q�q�B�I q�Jl@_R!q�R-q�IAPSR�XYC qSB�N �yIAuYI/�>}pIAP-N U IAP-q@A�4R-��VoBpR-}>R!q�NWJ�RWg�J IA�KNWR=q�B�X^R.I ��@_P!q�B&��B�XYu^N U P-@_L�u^NWJ � @_P=R-qS��v�}_Fki�q+.�P-R-q�RSXY�AB�qWgOR!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYVWIAuYu\}XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^C�� U u�IAC�NQqoIKP-}�@_P-L�X^qSR�XYCaL�XYC�IKP-}�R!}]R!q�NQJlR U PSNQRSNWCyqSR�I U PS@_L�u^NWJ R-XYC�VQN�qSB�N���RS��IKu�PSIKq�X^@_C�IAu^N� @_P;R!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYV�J�NQq�B�@]v�R;X^R�L�IARSNQvE@_C�qSB�N�� IKVQq;q�B�IKqkI R!}>R-q�NQJ VW@_CyqoIKXYC�R=I RSXYC��_uYN.v�@_JlX^C�IACyq�LH@]v�}IAC�v C�@Kq�q���@�F0�=@ ��N)[_NWPQg�IKuYu�u^@_C��Kd uYX\[_NWv U u�IAC�NQqoIKP-} R!}>R-q�NQJlR�X^C�[A@_u^[>X^C���L�XYC�IAP-}ER-qoIKPSR�IAP-N�u^XY�KNWu^}q�@�LHN B�X^NWP�IKPSVoB�X^VnIAu 15NWX\q�B�NQP=qSB�N U uYIAC�NQqSR�@_PSL�X^q�qSB�N VWNQCyq�NWP�@A�"JlIARSR�@K��I U IAXYP.@K��R!qoIAP-R�@A�"RSJlIAuYuRSN U IAPSIKq�X^@_C6z�@AP�q�B�N U uYIAC�N)q�R�@_P-L�X^q�@_C�N�R-q�IAPWg�IAC�v q�B�N�RSNWVQ@_C�vaR-q�IAP;@_PSL�X^q�R�IKq�I VW@_C�RSXYv�NWP�IKL�u^}lu�IAP-�_NWPv�X^R-qoIKC�VWNKF �;B�N�B�XYNQP�IAP-VoB�XYVWIAu C�IKq���P-N~@A��q�B�NQRSNMR!}]R!q�NQJlR�JlIA�ANQR�X\q U @_RSR-XYL�u^N�qS@ J�@]v�X\� } q�B�N~NnIKPSuYX^NWPR-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV RSVoB�NWJ�NWRWg ��B�X^uYNMR!q�XYu^u U NWP-JlX\qSqSXYC�� VQuY@_R-N NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSRQg X^Cp@_PSv�NQP.q�@ U NWP-� @APSJ P-NnIAu^XYR!q�XYVU uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}�IAVQVWP-NQq�X^@_CpRSX^JM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R�XYC L�XYC�IAP!}aR-qoIKP.R-}>R-qSNWJ�RWF��$C q�B�XYR U I U NQP!��N v�NWR-VWPSX^LON~B�@ � qS@J�@]v�X\� }�q�B�N21 � 3����43-5 By}>L�PSX^v]d$R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�J @A��G�B�IAJMLHNWP-R � ��w_wAw!�)g3L��]q ��N C�@AqSNMq�B�I qRSX^JlX^u�IAP=J�@]v�X�.�VnI q�XY@AC�R.VW@A��uYv LHN�NWIARSX^u^} I U�U u^XYNWv qS@�q�B�N T }�r,*�i0IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J @A��Z.��C�VWIAC ���!#����� �nw_w_�!� F

Page 4: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� b �

�;B�N�PSNWR!q.@A� q�B�X^R U I U NQPkX^R�@_PS�yIKC�X��QNWv IKR=� @_u^uY@ ��RWF T NWV)q�XY@AC ` VW@_CyqoIKXYC�RkIlL�P-XYN)��PSN)[>XYN��j@K��q�B�Nq�B�NW@_P!} @A��R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_PSRQg IKC�v qSB�NWX^P�Jl@>v�X .�VnIKqSXY@_CEqS@�X^C�VWu^��v�N VQuY@_R-N�NQC�VW@A��Cyq�NWP-RWFl�$CT NQVQq�X^@_C f]g ��NMv�NQRSVWP-XYLHN~B�@ � qSB�NMIAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�JlR;VWIAC LHNMIAv�I U q�NQvEq�@�� @_uYu^@ � @_PSL�X^q�R=XYC�NnIAVoB�q$} U N~@K�B�X^NWP�IKPSVoB�X^VnIAu3L�X^C�IAP!}�R-}>R-qSNWJ�RWF;t XYC�IAu^u^}Ag T NQVQq�X^@_CEb�v�NQRSVWP-XYLHNWR�q�NQR-q�R ��N�B�In[_N�J IKv�N���RSX^C���qSB�N�C�N��RSVoB�NWJ�NWRWF

� � ��������� ����� �2� � � �� ��� ����� � ��� � � �������� � ��� � �� � � �t�@_P=I'�kIAJ�XYu^qS@_C�XYIAC R!}]R!q�NQJ @A� � LH@>v�XYNQR ��X^q�B ��IKJlX^u^q�@AC�X�IAC���g�q�B�N�P�I q�N�@A��VoB�IAC��_N�@A�4IACy}

����IACyq�X\q$}�� VnIKCaLHN�N � U P-NWRSR-NWvp��R-XYC��� �� �"! #%$&' (�)*,+ �+.- ' + �+ / '10 + �+ / ' + �+�- '32 !54 �76 � ��

��B�NQPSN 4 XYR=I v�X^sONWP-NWCyq�XYIAu3@ U NWP�I q�@_PQg�IAC�v �98 ' 6 � ' �;IAPSN�q�B�N�VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�NQR�IAC�vaJl@_J�NWCyq�I @K��LH@]v�}�:SF�;B�X^R=NQ����IKq�X^@_C�B�IAR=IM� @_PSJlIAu6R-@_uY�]q�XY@AC

� �9; � !=<?>A@ � � x�� ! *�CB ; 4 B ;.D 4 D

` B5EFEFE 2 � � x!�G6 � `��

��B�NQPSN ; X^R�I RSB�@_P!q=XYCyq�NQP-[KIAu6@A��q�X^JlNKF�$CEVQNWu^NWR-qSX�IAu�J�NWVoB�IKC�XYVQR U P-@_L�u^NWJ�RWgH� VWIAC @A� qSNWC�LON�R U u^X^q�X^C�qS@lq���@ @_P=J�@_PSN U X^NWVWNQRWgHRS@ qSB�IKq

NnIKVoB U IAP!q.@A��qSB�N U PS@_L�u^NWJ VWIAC LHN~RS@Au^[_NQv NnIKRSXYu\}�XYCaq�B�N~IAL�R-NWC�VQNM@A��qSB�N~@AqSB�NWPQF�t�@_P=N ��IAJ U u^NAg#X^�� XYR=R U u^X^q�XYCyqS@lq���@ U X^NWVWNQRWg��"I1IKC�vJ�LK4g"��N�VnIACEIARSR-@]VQX�IKqSN�NWIAVoB U X^NWVQN ��X^qSBEI�C�N��jv�X^sONWPSNQCyq�X�IKu@ U NWPSIKq�@_PQg.M�IAC�vON g�Ly}aIAC�IKuY@_�A} ��X^qSB 4 F4�$C�q�B�X^R;VnIAR-NAg�q�B�N�R-@_uY�]q�XY@AC � @_PP�MLHNWVW@AJlNQR� �9; � !Q<?>?R I.S�KUT � � x��3V � f��

T }>J U uYNQVQq�X^V�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_PSR=VnIACELON�v�NWR-XY�_C�NWv Ly}�PSN U u�IAVQXYC�� q�B�N�N � U @_C�NWCyqSX�IAu�q�NQPSJ IALH@e[AN ��X\q�BIlR-NWP-XYNWRk@A��qSNWPSJ�R�X^C�N-� U ; M IAC�vEN � U ; N gORS��VoB qSB�IKq=q�B�NQXYP U PS@>v���V)q.XYRkI U�U PS@ �]XYJlIKq�NQu^}�NQ�>��IAu�qS@N � U ; � MWBXN � F�t�@_P;N-��IAJ U uYNAg]q�B�N U @ U ��uYIAP�RSNQVW@_C�v]d$@_P-v�NWP &-u^NnI U � P-@_��( X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�@AP�XYR;�_X\[_NQC�Ly}

<?> KHY D <?> I <?> KUY D � � x!� ! � �9; �ZBX[ �9; # �3V � b!�� � ��N q�B�X^C��E@K� ; IAR.qSB�N R-q�N U RSX\�WN�@A�2q�B�N u^NnI U � P-@_��XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_PQg6q�B�NQC1@AC�NMq�X^JlNQR-q�N U VW@_C�R-XYR!q�R�@A�VnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXYC��MqSB�N�N)[_@_u^��q�X^@_C�@A��qSB�N�XYC�X\q�X�IKuOVQ@_C�v�X\q�XY@AC�R;��C�v�NQP]�LK � @APkI q�X^JlN ;�^ `]g�qSB�NWCEIAv�[KIAC�VQXYC��q�B�N~PSNQRS��u\q�X^C�� R!}]R!q�NQJ ��C�v�NWP]�"I � @_PkI�q�X^JlN ; gOq�B�NWC IAv�[KIAC�VWXYC��lq�B�N~PSNQRS��u\q���C�v�NWP]�_K�� @AP=qSXYJ�N;U^ `]F �;B�N�NWC�v U PS@>v���V)q�X^RkNQ�>��X^[KIAuYNQCyq=qS@lqSB�N�N)[_@_u^��q�X^@_Ca@A�`� XYC�q�B�N�P-NnIAu U P-@_L�uYNQJ ��X^qSB IACaNWP-PS@_PU P-@ U @AP-q�X^@_C�IAuHq�@ ; # F2�3NWI U � PS@A��X^R�I uY@ � @APSv�NQP=X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_PWg]JlNWIAC�XYC��Mq�B�IKq�X^C��_NWC�NQP�IAu�IM[ANWP-}�R-B�@_P!qR-qSN U R-X��QN�X^R;PSNW����X^PSNQvaqS@��AX^[_N�IAVQVW��PSIKq�N�P-NWRS��u^q�RQF

�;B�N��_PSNWIKq=R U NWNWv IAv�[KIACyqoIA�AN�@K��R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV�IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J�R�VW@AJlNQR=� P-@_J VoB�@>@_RSX^C��a�"I IAC�vJ�LKRS@ q�B�IKq�q�B�N�u�IKq-q�NQP;XYR�JM��VoB�RSJlIAuYu^NWP�qSB�IAC�q�B�N�� @_PSJ�NWP;Ly}aI � IAVQqS@_P1bdc �AF��$Caq�B�X^R;VnIAR-N�q�B�N�NQPSP-@_P

Page 5: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� c �

U NWPkqSXYJ�NWR!q�N U LONQVW@_J�NWR [ � b ; # � g6IAC�v�q�B���R�I�JM��VoBpu�IKPS�_NQPkR!q�N U RSX��QNMVnIKC LON���RSNQv q�@�IKVoB�XYN)[_N~qSB�NR�IKJlN�uYNQ[ANWu @A�2IAVQVW��PSIAVQ} IARkqSB�NM�_NQC�NWPSIAu VWIARSNKF �;B�NM��RS��IAu ��In}aq�B�X^R�X^R�v�@_C�NMXYR�q�@�IKRSRS@>VWXYIKq�N �"I��X^qSB�qSB�N~��N U uYNQPSX�IKC�J�@Aq�X^@_C�@A��RSIKq�NQuYu^X^q�NQR=IALO@A��qkqSB�N U PSX^J IAP!}_g#IAC�vJ�LK ��X^qSBaqSB�N~JM�]q���IAu6� @APSVWNQRLHNQq���NWNWC R�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NWRkIAC�vp@Kq�B�NQP.RSJlIAuYu U NWP-qS��PSL�IKq�X^@_C�RWF.t#@AP�B�X^NWP�IKPSVoB�X^VnIAu R-}>R-qSNWJ�R�XYC ��B�X^VoBpVWu^@_RSNNWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSR�v�@~C�@Aq;@>VWVQ��P � ��� +!� qSB�N U uYIAC�N)q�R�X^C q�B�N T @_u�IKP T }>R!q�NWJ �)g 5XYRSv�@_J�IAC�v �k@AuYJlIAC � ��w_w����PSNQVW@_J�J�NWC�v ��RSX^C��E?_IAVW@_L�X"VQ@]@APSv�X^C�IKq�NQRWg�XYC ��B�X^VoB�R�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NWR�IKPSN @_PSv�NWPSNQv IAVQVW@_P-v�XYC��aqS@aqSB�NWX^Pv�X^R-qoIKC�VWN�� PS@_J q�B�N U PSX^J IKP-}_g�IKC�vlVQ@]@APSv�X^C�IKq�NQR"IAPSN�J�NnIAR-��PSNQv PSNQu�IKqSX^[AN�qS@�qSB�N=VWNWCyqSNWP�@K�6JlIARSR2@A�6IAuYuLH@]v�X^NWR ��X\q�B R-J IKuYuYNQP�X^C�v�X^VWNWRQF4i�v�[KIAC�VWXYC��L�LIEIAC�v �LK ��RSX^C�� ?_IAVQ@_L�X6VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�NQR�XYR�IMRS@_J�N���B�I qVW@AJ U u^XYVWIKq�NQv�L���RSX^C�NWR-RWg#L���q�qSB�N�JlN)q�B�@>v�XYR;v�NQRSVWP-XYLHNWvaXYC�v�N)qoIAX^u6XYC T IAB�I�IKC�v ��PSNQJ IKXYC�N � ��w_wAb � FG�uY@ARSN=NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSR�LHNQq���NWNQC�R�IKqSNWu^uYX^qSNWR U @_RSNkI U PS@_L�u^NWJ LHNWVWIA��R-N�v���P-XYC���IAC�NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQP�X\q�X^R2C�@

uY@AC��_NWP�q�PS��N.q�B�IKq1�LK c �"I�F �=NWC�VQN b�X^C�VWP-NnIAR-NWRQg#IAC�v�q�B�N�NQPSPS@AP U NQP�q�X^JlNQR-q�N U VnIAC�LHNWVW@AJlN�uYIAPS�_NNWC�@_���_Bpq�@ PSNWC�v�NWP�IACpX^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_CE��RSNWu^NWR-R���C�uYNQRSR.q�B�N~q�X^JlNQR-q�N U XYR.X^C�X^qSX�IAu^u^} VoB�@_RSNQC qS@ LHNM[_NWP!}RSJlIAu^u � ��B�X^VoB @A��VW@_��P-RSN�v�NQ� NWIKq�R�q�B�N�R U NWNQv IAv�[KIACyq�IA�_N�@A��q�B�N�R!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYV�IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�R � F"Z.��C�VnIKC��� #���� � ��wAw_�!��IKC�vaG�B�IAJMLHNWP-R � �nw_w_w!�2v�NWR-VWPSX^LONkq���@ ��I�}>R�qS@ @e[ANWP-VW@_J�N�q�B�XYR U P-@_L�u^NWJag]L��]q;XYC NWIAVoBVnIKRSN ?_IKVW@_L�X�VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�NQR�qS��PSC�@_��q=q�@�LON�IAC�XYC�N � VQXYNQC�qkVoB�@_X^VWNKF *�@Aq�BaRSN)q�Rk@A�2IA��qSB�@_P-R�IAv][_@>VnIKqSN��R-XYC�����B�I q�q�B�NM� @_P-JlNQP.B�In[_N VWIAuYu^NWv &-v�NWJ�@]VQP�IKqSXYV~B�NWuYX^@]VQNWCyq�P-XYV ( � Z �+�kVW@>@_PSv�XYC�IKqSNWRQg6XYC ��B�X^VoBR�I q�NWu^uYX\q�N U @_R-X^qSXY@_C�R�IAPSN~JlNWIARS��P-NWv ��X^qSB PSNQR U NWV)q�qS@ q�B�N U PSX^J IAP!}_g���B�XYu^NMR�I q�NWu^uYX\q�N�[_NWu^@]VQX^qSXYNWR�IAPSNJ�NnIAR-��PSNQv ��X\q�B�PSNQR U NWVQq=q�@ qSB�N�VWNWCyqSNWP=@A��JlIAR-R=@K� qSB�N ��B�@_uYN�R!}>R-q�NQJ�F�kR-XYC���Z �<VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�NQRWg�q�B�N �kIAJ�XYu^qS@_C�XYIAC�� @AP�I�R!}]R!q�NQJ @A� �7RSIKq�NQuYuYX\q�NQR�@_PSL�X^q�X^C�� I U PSX^J IKP-}

XYR;�AX^[_NQC�Ly} � ! �"ILBW�LK�BX����g ��B�NWP-N�"I ! $&' (�)

*J/ D'`��

'C0�� ���'

�'�

2 6�LK ! 0 � $&' (�)

$&� ( ' S ) �

'� ��'�

6��� ! �

` �������

$& ' (�) �' �����D 6 � c��

��B�NQPSN XYC�v�N � x PSNQ� NQPSR.qS@ q�B�N U P-XYJlIAP-}AF �kNQPSNAg��"I1XYR�qSB�N RS��J @A�2q�B�N ��N U uYNQP.Jl@Kq�XY@AC�R�@A�2NWIAVoBR�I q�NWu^uYX\q�NAg �_K:XYR.qSB�N RS��J9@K��qSB�N v�XYP-NWVQq�X^C�qSNWPSIAVQqSXY@_C�R�LON)q���NQNWC RSIKq�NQuYuYX\q�NQRWg3IAC�v���� XYR�I�RSN)q�@K�XYC�v�XYP-NWVQq�VW@_P-PSNQVQq�X^@_CEqSNWPSJ�RWF��$C q�B�N IKL�RSNQC�VWN @A�"VQuY@_R-N~NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSRQg3LO@Kq�B �LK IAC�v ��� IAP-NMRSJlIAuYuVW@AJ U IKPSNWv qS@O�LI�F *�NWVWIA��RSN_� C�@ � VW@_C�RSXYR!q�R�@A��f U X^NWVWNQRWg6qSB�N uYNWI U � PS@A��XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqS@_P�@K��D4�#F � b!�LHNWVW@AJlNQR <?> KUY D <?> � Y D <?> I <?> � Y D <?> KUY D � � x!� ! � �9; �ZBW[ � ; # �G6 � �����B�NQPSN�� XYR�I C�N�� v�X^sONWP-NWCyq�XYIAu6@ U NWPSIKq�@AP�IARSR-@]VQX�IKqSNWv���X^qSB ����FG�B�IAJ~LONQPSR � ��w_wAw!��RS@_u\[_NQR=qSB�N�VQuY@_R-N)d NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQP U P-@_L�uYNQJ Ly} U IAP!q�X^qSXY@_C�XYC��MNWIAVoBE@K��q�B�N�qSNWPSJ�R

XYCO�LK1LHNQq���NWNQCJ�"IpIAC�v �LK�g�RS��VoB�q�B�IKq;q�B�N U IKP-q�XYCO�LK1X^R�IAu ��In}>R=R-J IKuYu g ��B�X^uYN�qSB�N U IAP-q�X^CO�LI�_@>NWR;q�@L�QNWPS@�N �]VQN U qkv���P-XYC���I VWu^@_RSN�NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWP02

�"I ! $& ' (�)* / D'` �

' 0 � ���'

�'�

2 0 � $&' (�)$&

� ( ' S ) �'� ��'�� � 0�� � �

'� ��� 6

Page 6: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� � �

�LK ! 0 � $& ' (�)$&

� ( ' S ) �'� ��'�� � �

'� �36

��� ! �`���

�����

$&' (�) �' �����D V � ���

ijRS��X\qoIAL�uYN�VoB�@_X^VWN�� @_P � � � ��X^RkIM� ��C�VQq�X^@_C�q�B�I qkRSIKq�X^R .�NQR ��� x ��B�NQC � � x�g�IAC�v � ! ���B�NQC� X^R;C�@Aq=RSJlIAuYu F�kR-XYC���q�B�X^R U IKP-q�X\q�X^@_C�XYC���g�b�P-NWJlIAXYC�R�R-J IAu^u g#IAC�vEq�B�N�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�@_PQ��RkIAVWVQ��P�IKVQ}�XYR=C�@AqkRSNQ[ANWP-NWu^}

v�NQ�_P�IAv�NWvEv���PSX^C��lVQuY@_R-N�NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSRWF �=@ ��N)[_NWPQg�R-@_JlN�@A� q�B�N�q�NQPSJ�RkX^CO�LI IAP-N�C�@lu^@_C��_NQP�RS@_u^��L�uYNIAC�IKu^}�q�X^VnIAu^u^} v���P-XYC�� IAC NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQP � ��B�NWC:RS@AJlN @K�=qSB�N � � �

'� ��IAPSN C�@_C �WNWP-@ �)g"IAC�v qSB�NWR-N

q�NQPSJ�R�B�In[_N q�@�LHN XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NQvpC>��JlNQPSXYVWIAuYu\}�q�@�B�X^�_B IAVWVQ��P�IKVQ}_F �;B�XYR�VWIAC LON IKVoB�XYN)[_NWv ��R-XYC���IVW@AC�[ANWCyq�X^@_C�IAu�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�@AP;RS��VoBEIAR$*���uYX^PSR-VoB]d T qS@]NQPWg�IKC�va� @AP�q�B�X^R;PSNnIKRS@_C�q�B�N�IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J X^R=P-NQ� NQPSPSNQvq�@�IKR�I &-By}]L�PSXYvpR!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV (�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�@_PQg3IAu^qSB�@_���AB X^q�R!q�X^uYu�PSNQq�IAXYC�R�q�B�N U PS@ U NWP!q�XYNQR�IAR-RS@>VWX�I q�NWv��X^qSB�@Aq�B�NQP�R-}>J U uYNWV)q�X^V�RSVoB�NQJlNQRWF

� � ��������� ����� �2� � � �� ��� ������� �� � � ���)� � � � � � �7� ���NWR-q U IAP!q�XYVQuYN�@_P-L�X^qSRkX^C�L�X^C�IAP!}�R-}>R-qSNWJ�R.VnIAC�LON�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�NWv ��X^qSB�q�B�N�R!qoIAC�v�IAPSv R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV

JlI U�U X^C�� q�NWVoB�C�XY����N���RSX^C�� ?_IKVW@_L�X�VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�NQR � ��� +!� g" 5XYNQ�_NWP!q�IKC�v,�=@_uYJlIAC ��w_w_�]g��k@_u^J IKC�IAC�v 5XYNQ�_NWP!q���w_w_w!� F �k@ ��N)[_NQPWgOqSB�XYR�J�NQqSB�@]v�C�@luY@_C��_NWP ��@_PS��R ��B�NWCEVWuY@ARSN�NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSRkVnIAC�@]VQVW��PQg�RS@��N�C�NWNQv�qS@ .�C�vaI~C�N�� JlN)q�B�@>v ��B�X^VoBaVWIAC�XYC�VW@_P U @_PSIKq�N�q�B�N�R U NWVWXYIAu�VQuY@_R-N)d NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQP U PS@>VWNQv���PSNQR��R-NWv�Ly} Z.��C�VnIAC ����#���� � ��wAw_�!�4@_P�G�B�IAJMLHNWPSR � ��w_wAw!�)F �;B�NWP-N�IAPSN=q���@ U @_R-RSXYL�uYN=VW@_C .��_��P�I q�XY@AC�R"� @APU uYIAC�NQq�IAP-} @APSL�X\q�R"XYC�L�XYC�IKP-} R-q�IAP�R!}>R-q�NQJlR�2�q�B�N U u�IKC�NQqSR�VWIAC @_P-L�X^q"NWX\q�B�NQP�@AC�N�@_P"LH@Aq�BlJlNQJMLONQPSR"@A�q�B�N.L�XYC�IAP-}AF4D2IAVoB�VW@_C .��_��PSIKq�X^@_C VnIKC q�PSNWIKq�NQv ��R-XYC�� IMJ�@>v�X .�NQv R!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYVkRSVoB�NQJlNKg�L���q�q�B�N�q���@RSVoB�NWJ�NWRkIAPSN�v�X\s�NQPSNWCyqWg#IAC�v���N�VW@AC�RSX^v�NWP;q�B�N�q���@�VnIAR-NWR=RSN U IAP�IKqSNWu\}�XYC�q�B�N�� @AuYuY@ ��X^C��MRSNQVQqSXY@_C�RQF

� � � � � � � � � � ���)� ��$C1I ��X^v�N L�XYC�IKP-}_g3q���@ER!qoIAP-R�J�@�[_N�@_C ��XYv�NQu^} R-N U IKP�IKqSNWv�@APSL�X\q�RWg�IAC�v1X^C JlIACy}pVWIARSNQR~X^q

XYR U @_R-RSXYL�uYNM� @_P�u^@_C��Kd uYX^[ANWv U uYIAC�N)qoIAP!} @_P-L�X^qSR.q�@aN �]XYR!q~IKPS@_��C�v @AC�N @A��qSB�N R-qoIKPSR � �=@_uYJlIAC IAC�v 5XYNQ�_NWP!q���w_w_w��)F �;B�N ��IKJlX^u^q�@AC�X�IAC�� @_P�I R-}>R-qSNWJ VW@AC�q�IAXYC�XYC��0� U uYIAC�NQqSR�XYR

� ! / DI`���I B / D K

`�� K B $& ' (�)/ D'` �

' 0 � ��I � K� I.K 0 � ��I $&' (�) �

'�' I0 � � K $& ' (�) �

'�' K 0 � $&' (�) &��� ' �

'� ��'�

6 � ���

Page 7: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� � �

A

Wide Binary Close Binary

B

A

B

t�X^��F��_F 1 � @_R-RSX^L�uYN=VW@_C .��_��PSIKq�X^@_C�R2@A�3u^@_C��Kd uYX^[ANWv U uYIAC�N)qoIAP!} @_PSL�X\q�R2XYC�L�X^C�IAP-} R!qoIAP"R-}>R!q�NWJ�RWg,��B�NWP-N&-i (lIKC�v & * ( XYC�v�X^VnIKqSN.q�B�N�q���@lR!qoIAP-R�XYC�NnIAVoBaVnIKRSNAF

��B�NQPSN,M XYR�q�B�NMVQNWCyq�PSIAu�R-qoIKP.IAP-@_��C�v ��B�XYVoB q�B�N U uYIAC�NQqSR�@_P-L�X^qWgHN XYR�q�B�N~v�XYR!qoIACyqkR-qoIKPWg6IKC�vEq�B�NU uYIAC�NQqSRkB�I�[ANMXYC�v�XYVQNWR=PS��C�C�XYC���� PS@_J ��qS@2� � RSNQNMt�X^�_��P-Nl��� F�hk@AqSN�qSB�IKq=q�B�NQPSN~X^RkC�@ PSNQR-q�P-XYV)q�XY@AC@_C�q�B�N�P-NWuYIKq�X\[_N�JlIARSR-NWR=@A� qSB�N�q���@�R-q�IAPSRQFrEIA��X^C�� ��R-N~@A� q�B�N�B�X^NWP�IKPSVoB�X^VnIAu�IAP-P�IAC��ANWJ�NWCyq�@K��q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP!}�R-}>R-qSNWJag ��N~v�N .�C�N I C�N��jRSNQq

@A� VW@>@_PSv�XYC�IKqSNWR � IAR;� @_u^uY@ ��R02

� I ! * ��I � ILB�� K � K B�� � � � � ��������

2 6�' ! �

' 0 � I�6� K ! � K 0 * ��I � I"B�� � � � � �

��I_B�� � � �2 6 � w��

��B�NQPSN ����� ! ��I B � K�B � � � � XYR�q�B�N�q�@KqoIAu�JlIARSR=@A��qSB�N~R!}]R!q�NQJ�gOIAC�vEqSB�N�RS��J�J I q�XY@AC�R�PS��C� PS@AJ9��q�@'�1F��kRSX^C�� q�B�NQRSN�VW@>@_PSv�X^C�IKqSNWRWg�qSB�N U @ARSX^qSXY@_C�@K��NnIKVoB U uYIAC�NQq�X^R�JlNWIARS��P-NWv ��X^qSB�P-NWR U NWV)qq�@ X^q�R U PSX^J IKP-}�R-q�IAPWg ��B�XYu^N�qSB�N U @_RSX\q�X^@_CE@A��q�B�NMv�XYR-q�IACyq.R!qoIAP.X^R�J�NnIAR-��PSNQv ��X^qSB PSNQR U NWV)q�q�@ qSB�NVWNQCyq�NWP=@A� J IKRSR�@A��IAuYuHq�B�N�@AqSB�NWP�@_L { NQVQqSRWF

Page 8: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� � �

�;B�N�VW@_C { ���yIKqSN�Jl@_J�NWCyq�I�� @A� qSB�NWR-N�VQ@]@APSv�X^C�IKq�NQR�IAPSN

� I ! � I_B � KaB $&� (�) � � 6

�' ! � ' 0 � ' * � I_B � � � �

��I_B�� � � �2 6

� K ! � K 0 � K * � I_B � K�B � � � ���� ���

2 6 � ��x!�

��B�NQPSN�q�B�N�RS��JlJlIKq�X^@_C�R;IK�yIAXYC�P-��C�� PS@_J ��qS@ � FD � U PSNQRSRSNQv XYC�qSNWPSJ�R�@A��q�B�N�C�N��<VW@>@_P-v�XYC�I q�NWRQg�q�B�N �kIAJlX^u^qS@_C�X�IKClLHNWVQ@_JlNQR� ! ������� BX��� �HBX���� ���� 6 � �_���

��B�NQPSN

������� ! *�� DK`�������

0 � ���������������]K 2 B $& ' (�)

*�� D'`��

' 0 � ��I � '�' 2 6

��� � ! 0 $& ' (�) &��� ' � �'� �

�'�

B � � K ��I * �� K 0 �

� � KaB � �2

B � � K $& ' (�) �' * �

� K 0 �� � K 0 �

' B � �2 6

���� ���� ! � � $' (�) � '� D

`���I 6 � �e`��

��B�NQPSN������� ! � ��I"B � �'� � K ^ ��� ���"X^R�q�B�N�PSNWv���VWNQvEJlIARSR;@A��qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP-} R-}>R-qSNWJ � X^C�VWu^��v�X^C��~q�B�N

JlIARSR�@A��q�B�N U uYIAC�N)q�R � g�IAC�v� ! � $' (�) � '

�'

��ILB�� $' (�) � � ��f!�

hk@Kq�N�q�B�I q�XYC�v�NWP-X^[>XYC�� qSB�NWR-N�NQ����IKq�X^@_C�RQg���N�B�In[_N�IAv�v�NWv�IAC�vaRS��L�qSP�IAV)q�NQv�q�NQPSJ�R U PS@ U @_P!q�XY@AC�IAu#q�@� ^ � K ��B�NQCER U uYX^q-q�X^C��~q�B�N U XYNWVQNWR�@A��q�B�N �kIAJlX^u^qS@_C�X�IKC6F

�;B�N�q�NQPSJ�RMXYC ��������VW@APSPSNQR U @_C�v q�@ qSB�N���N U u^NWP-X�IAC J�@AqSXY@_C @K�=qSB�N�L�X^C�IAP-}1R-q�IAP @_P-L�X^q� X^C�VWu^��v�X^C��Mq�B�N�JlIARSR-NWR�@A��q�B�N U uYIAC�NQqSR � g�IAC�v�q�B�N���N U uYNWP-X�IAC�J�@AqSXY@_C�R;@K� qSB�N U u�IAC�NQq�R�IKLO@_�]q=qSB�NWX^PVWNQCyq�P�IKuOR!qoIAPQF �;B�NkqSNWP-JlR"XYC ��� ��IAP-N=qSB�NkX^Cyq�NWPSIAVQqSXY@_C�R�LHNQq���NWNQC U u�IAC�NQq�RQg>IAC�vlqSXYv�IKu U NQP-q���PSL�IKqSXY@_C�R@_C qSB�N U uYIAC�NQqSR�v���NMq�@ qSB�NMv�X^R-qoIKC�q.R-qoIKPWF�t�X^C�IAuYu\}_gH���� ����MVQ@_CyqoIAX^C�R�X^C�v�XYP-NWV)q.VW@APSPSNQVQqSXY@_C qSNWPSJ�RWF 5B�NQC ���� �����X^R.I U�U uYXYNQv6g�q�B�N�[_NQuY@>VWX^qSXYNQR=@K��q�B�N U u�IKC�NQqSR�PSNQJ IKXYCaVW@_C�R!qoIACyqWg�L���qkq�B�N�VW@>@_PSv�XYC�IKqSNWR@A� NnIAVoBEIAPSN�v�XYR U u�IAVQNWvaL�}�I R-J IKuYu3IAJ�@_��Cyq ��B�X^VoB�X^R U PS@ U @_P!q�X^@_C�IAuHq�@ q�B�N�[ANWuY@>VWX\q$}�@A��q�B�N�VQNWCyq�PSIAuR-q�IAPWFhk@Kq�N q�B�IKqWg�XYC q�B�N�IAL�R-NWC�VQN @A��VWu^@_RSN�NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSRQg�IAu^u�q�B�N q�NQPSJ�R�X^C ���� �kIAC�v����� �����IAPSN

RSJlIAu^u4VW@_J U IAP-NWv1qS@J�������_F��$C IKv�v�X^qSXY@_C�g�NWIAVoB U X^NWVQNl@A��q�B�N ��IAJ�XYu\q�@_C�XYIAC VWIAC LHN IAv][AIKC�VWNQv

Page 9: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� w �

N � VQXYNWCyqSu^}a��RSX^C���IAC�IAu^}�q�X^V�RS@_u^��q�X^@_C�RWFkG�u^@_RSN�NWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSR�LHNQq���NWNWC U uYIAC�N)q�R=VnIAC LHN~X^C�VW@AP U @_P�IKqSNWvXYC I R-qSP�IAX^�_ByqS� @_P ��IAP-v ��I�}ELy} U IAP!q�X\q�XY@AC�XYC�� qSB�N U uYIAC�NQq!d$X^C�qSNWPSIAVQqSXY@_C�R�q�NQPSJ�R.LHNQq���NWNWC ������� IAC�v��� ��IKR;XYCaD4�HFO�]F�$Ca�_NWC�NQP�IAu g�@_C�N�R!q�N U @A� q�B�N ��XYv�N)d$L�XYC�IAP!} X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_P;VW@_C�RSXYR!q�R�@A��c R-��L�R!q�N U R02

� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��� �2� @_P ;U^ `>g ��B�NWP-N ; XYR�qSB�N�q�X^JlNQR-q�N U F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ���� ������ @_P ;�^ `]F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��������� @_P ; F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ���� ������ @_P ;�^ `]F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��� �2� @_P ;U^ `>Fhk@Kq�N�qSB�IKq=q�B�N .�PSR!q�IAC�v u�IAR!q�R-��L�R!q�N U R.VnIACELON�VW@_JML�XYC�NQvEXYCyqS@ IlR-XYC��AuYN�RS��L�R!q�N U N �]VWN U q�IKq

q�B�N�LHNW�AXYC�C�X^C�� @A��q�B�N�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�@_P ��B�NQCE@_�]q U ��q=X^R;PSNW����X^PSNQv6F

� �\� � , H� � � � ���)� ��$CpI VQuY@_R-N~L�X^C�IAP!}_g#q���@�R!qoIAP-R.@_PSL�X^q ��X^qSBpI RSN U IAPSIKq�X^@_C ��B�X^VoBpXYR=@A�4q�B�N~R�IKJlN�@_PSv�NQP.IAR=q�B�N

U By}>RSX^VnIAu�v�XYIAJlN)q�NQPSR�@A��qSB�N�R-q�IAPSRQF��$CaqSB�XYR�VWIARSNKgHqSB�NWP-N�X^R=��C�uYX^�ANWu\} qS@lLHN�P-@]@AJ0� @_P�R-q�IAL�u^N U u�IAC�N)q�Rq�@�@_P-L�X^q;@AC�u^}�@AC�N�JlNQJMLONQP;@A��qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP-}AF �=@ ��N)[_NWPQg U uYIAC�N)qoIAP!} @_P-L�X^qSRkIKPS@_��C�vaqSB�N U IAXYP;@K��R!qoIAP-RVnIKC LON�R-qoIKL�uYN � �=@_uYJlIAC IKC�v 5XYNQ�_NWP!q��nw_w_w!� F �;B�N �kIAJlX^u^qS@_C�X�IKCM� @_P � U u�IAC�NQq�R�XYC R-��VoB�I~R!}]R!q�NQJXYR�qSB�NlRSIAJ�NlIKR~D4�#F���g N-�]VWN U q~q�B�IKq�C�@ � M IKC�v�N PSN)� NWP�q�@aq���@�R-qoIKPSR�u^}>XYC���X^C�qSNWP-XY@_P.qS@aqSB�NU uYIAC�NQq�IAP-} @_PSL�X^q�RQF�kR-XYC��lq�B�NMB�XYNWPSIAPSVoB�XYVnIKu C�I q���P-N~@A�4qSB�NMR-}>R!q�NWJag ��NMv�N .�C�N I C�N���RSNQq.@A�2VW@>@_PSv�XYC�IKqSNWR � IAR

� @_u^uY@ ��R

��� ! ��I � ILB � � � � � B � K � K�������

6��� ! �

' 0�� ��I � ILB � K � K� ���� � 6

��� ! � K 0 � I 6 � �nb �

��B�NQPSN � ���� ! ��ILB � K�X^R�q�B�N�JlIARSR;@A� q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP!}_g �������"XYR�q�B�N�qS@AqoIAu�J IAR-R�@A� qSB�N�R-}>R-qSNWJagHIAC�vq�B�NMRS��J�JlIKq�X^@_C�R=PS��CE� P-@_J �~q�@�� F��kR-XYC��lq�B�NQRSN VW@>@_P-v�XYC�I q�NWRQgOqSB�N U @_RSX\q�XY@AC�@A�2NWIAVoB U uYIAC�NQq�XYRJ�NnIAR-��PSNQv ��X^q�BEPSNWR U NQVQq�qS@ q�B�N~VWNWCyqSNWP.@A�2JlIAR-R.@A�4q�B�N�q���@�R-qoIKPSRWg ��B�XYu^N�]K �_X\[_NWRkq�B�NMP-NWuYIKq�X\[_NU @_RSX\q�XY@AC�@A� qSB�N�R-q�IAPSR�XYC�qSB�N�L�XYC�IKP-}_F

Page 10: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ��x �

�;B�N�VW@_C { ���yIKqSN�Jl@_J�NWCyq�I � @A� qSB�NWR-N�VQ@]@APSv�X^C�IKq�NQR�IAPSN

� I ! � ILB � KaB $&� (�) � � 6

�' ! � ' 0 � ' * � ILB � K�B � � � �

��� ���2 6

� K ! � � 0 � K � � I_B � K� ���� � 6 � �ec��

��B�NQPSN�q�B�N�RS��JlJlIKq�X^@_C X^C�v�XYVQNWR�PS��C�� P-@_J9��q�@%� FD � U PSNQRSRSNQv XYC�qSNWPSJ�R�@A��q�B�N�C�N��<VW@>@_P-v�XYC�I q�NWRQg�q�B�N �kIAJlX^u^qS@_C�X�IKClLHNWVQ@_JlNQR� ! ������� BX��� �HBX���� ���� 6 � ���!�

��B�NQPSN

������� ! � � DK`�������

0�� � ���� �������]K � B $& ' (�)

� � D'`��

'C0�� � ���� �'

�' � 6

��� � ! � � ����$&' (�) �

' � ��' 0 ��I

� � ���� �' B � K � K � 0 � K

� � ���� �' 0 ��I � K � � 60 $& ' (�) &� � ' � �

'� �

�'����� ���� ! � � $' (�) � '

� D` � ���� 6 � �e���

��B�NQPSN ������ ! ��I � K ^)� ��ILB�� K��;X^R�q�B�N�P-NWv���VQNWv�J IAR-R�@A� qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP-} R-qoIKPWF�;B�N~qSNWP-JlR=XYC ��������VW@_P-PSNQR U @_C�v q�@�q�B�N~��N U u^NWPSXYIACaJl@AqSXY@_Ca@A��qSB�N~L�XYC�IAP!}�R-q�IAPSR�IALO@A��q�@AC�N

IAC�@Kq�B�NQPWgOIAC�v @A��q�B�N U u�IAC�NQq�RkIALH@_��q=q�B�N�VWNQC�qSNWP.@K�4J IKRSR�@K��q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP-}AF �;B�N~q�NQPSJ�RkX^CJ��� �;IAP-Nq�B�N�X^C�qSNWPSIAVQqSXY@_C�R�LHNQq���NWNQC U u�IKC�NQqSRWgHIAC�v U NQP-qS��PSL�I q�XY@AC�R�@_C�qSB�N U u�IAC�N)q�R�v���N�q�@ q�B�N�B�X^�_B�NQP=@APSv�NQPJ�@_JlNQCyq�R;@A��q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP!}O��R U @Kq�NWCyqSX�IAu F4t�XYC�IAuYu\}_g ���� �����VQ@_CyqoIAX^C�R;XYC�v�XYP-NWVQq�VQ@_PSP-NWV)q�XY@AC�qSNWP-JlRQF�$C�q�B�N�IAL�RSNWC�VWN�@A��VWuY@ARSN�NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSRQg�IKuYuOqSB�N.q�NQPSJ�R;XYCO��� �2IAC�vO���� �����IAPSN�R-J IKuYu�VQ@_J U IAPSNQv

q�@ �������ygHIAC�vENWIAVoB U IAP-qk@A��qSB�N ��IAJ�XYu\q�@_C�XYIAC VWIACELHN~IKv�[KIAC�VWNQv IAC�IAu^}�q�X^VnIAu^u^}AF�G�u^@_RSN�NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSRLHNQq���NWNWC U uYIAC�NQqSR�VnIKCaLHN.X^C�VW@_P U @AP�IKqSNWv�IAR�LHNQ� @APSN.Ly} U IKP-q�X\q�X^@_C�XYC���qSB�N U uYIAC�NQq!d$X^C�qSNWPSIAVQqSXY@_C�R"q�NQPSJ�RLHNQq���NWNWCJ��������IAC�vO��� ��IAR�XYC�D4�#F��>F�$C �_NWC�NQP�IAu g3@_C�N R-qSN U @A��qSB�N VWu^@_RSN d$L�X^C�IAP!} XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P�VQ@_C�R-XYR-qSR�@A�;c R-��L�R-qSN U RQg�R-XYJ�XYu�IKPkq�@

q�B�@_RSN � @_P.q�B�N ��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}pX^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_PWF0�=@ ��NQ[ANWPQg�XYCpq�B�XYR�VnIAR-N�qSB�N q�X^JlNQR-q�N U J~��R-q�LHN�R-J IKuYuXYCp@APSv�NQP.q�@�XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NMqSB�N @_PSL�X^q.@K��qSB�N L�XYC�IAP-}�R-q�IAPWF�i Jl@_P-NMN � VQXYNWCyq�RSVoB�NWJ�N�X^R�q�@�IKRSRSX^�_C IRSN U IAPSIKq�N�RSJlIAuYu3q�X^JlNQR-qSN U ;�^ � ����~q�@�q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP-}�R!qoIAPQg ��B�X^uYN�VoB�@]@ARSXYC�� IluYIAPS�ANWP=�_uY@_L�IAu6q�X^JlNQR-q�N U; qS@ XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�N�q�B�N U u�IAC�NQq�RQF � �;B�XYR U PS@>VWNQv���P-NMXYRkRSXYJ�XYuYIAP�qS@ q�B�I q.��R-NWvpLy} T IAB�I IKC�v ��PSNWJlIAX^C�N��w_wKb�F ���$C U PSIAVQqSXYVWNKg ��NMv�@lq�B�X^R�Ly}ER U uYX\qSqSXYC��_������� XYCyq�@ I U X^NWVQN"��� ��� ��q�B�I q.XYCy[A@_u^[ANWRkqSNWP-JlRkXYC

Page 11: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� �_� �

� KpIAC�v � KpIAC�v�I U X^NWVWN]��� ������q�B�IKq�v�@>NWR�C�@AqnF T XYJ�XYuYIAPSu\}_g(��N.R U uYX^q ��� ��XYCyqS@ `�C�N�� U IAP-qSRd��� �� �IAC�v ��� �� ��F

��� ����� ! � DK`�������

0 � � ���� � ����� K 6

��� ����� ! $& ' (�)� � D'`��

' 0 � � ���� �'

�' � 6

��� �� � ! � � ����$&' (�) �

' � ��' 0 ��I

� � ���� �' B � K � K � 0 � K

� � ���� �' 0 ��I � K � � 6

������ � ! 0 $& ' (�) &��� ' � �'� �

�'�

V � ���!�

�.C�N�q�X^JlNQR-q�N U @A� qSB�N�VWu^@_RSN d$L�X^C�IAP-} XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�@_P;C�@ � uY@>@_��R;uYXY�KN(2

� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��� �� �2� @_P ;�^ `]g ��B�NQPSN ; X^R�q�B�N�qSXYJ�NWR-qSN U F� m�N U NnIKq�qSB�N�� @_uYu^@ ��X^C�� �������q�X^JlNQR02

�ikv�[KIAC�VQN ��� �� �2� @_P ;U^)� `�� ������)F

�ikv�[KIAC�VQN ��� ������� @_P ;U^)� `�� ������)F

� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ���� ������ @_P ;�^ `]F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��� ������� @_P ; F� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ���� ������ @_P ;�^ `]F� m�N U NnIKq�qSB�N�� @_uYu^@ ��X^C�� �������q�X^JlNQR02

�ikv�[KIAC�VQN ��� ������� @_P ;U^)� `�� ������)F

�ikv�[KIAC�VQN ��� �� �2� @_P ;U^)� `�� ������)F

� ikv�[KIAC�VWN ��� �� �2� @_P ;�^ `]F�$Cp@_��P=XYJ U u^NWJ�NWCyqoIKqSXY@_C�g ��NMJlIA�KN � ����MI U�U P-@ ��X^J I q�NWu\}�NW����IAu�q�@�q�B�NMPSIKq�X^@l@K�4q�B�NM@APSL�X\qoIAu

U NWPSX^@]v�@A� q�B�N�X^C�C�NWP-Jl@AR-q U uYIAC�NQq�qS@�qSB�IKq=@A��q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP-}Ag#IAu^qSB�@_���_B�qSB�XYR;JlIn}�C�@Aq=LHN�qSB�N�@ U q�X^J IKuVoB�@_X^VWNKF�h=@Aq�N�q�B�IKq!��N�VW@_��uYvpIAu^RS@���RSN~XYC�v�N U NQC�v�NQC�q�q�XYJ�NWR!q�N U Rk� @_P�q�B�N~L�X^C�IAP-}aIKC�vEq�B�N U uYIAC�NQqSRXYC�qSB�N��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}�IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�J0v�NWRSVQPSX^LONQvEXYC T NQVQqSXY@_C�f�F\�_F �=@ ��N)[_NWPQg�X^C�qSB�XYR�VWIARSN�q�B�N�IAJ�@_��Cyq=@A�VW@AJ U �]q�NWP"q�X^JlN=R�In[_NQv���@_��uYv LHN�J�@]v�NWR-q�RSX^C�VWNkJl@_R!q�@A��q�B�N.N-� U NQC�RSN�X^R�P-NW����XYP-NWv qS@MVnIAu^VW��uYIKq�N�q�B�Nv�X^PSNWV)q U NWP!q���P-L�IKqSXY@_C�R�LHNQq���NWNQC q�B�N U u�IKC�NQqSRWgOIAC�v�qSB�N�L�IARSX^V~IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�J IKuYPSNWIAv�}���R-NWR�IACE@ U q�XYJlIAuq�X^JlNQR-qSN U � @_P�q�B�XYRWF

Page 12: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� �e` �

� � � � � �F��$C q�B�X^R RSNWV)q�X^@_C ��Nav�NWR-VWPSX^LON�R-@_JlN�qSNWR-qSR ��NaB�In[_NaJ IKv�N���RSX^C�� q�B�N�C�N�� R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV

IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�RWF

��� � � ��� � ��� � ���� � ����� ��U� � �� � �F� � �i�R�I'.�P-R-q�qSNWR!q.@A��qSB�N~C�N���IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�R ��NMN ��IAJ�XYC�NQv�qSB�N~P-NWR-qSPSX^VQq�NQvEq�B�PSNWN d$LH@]v]} U PS@_L�u^NWJaF

1N�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSNWv q�B�N�@_PSL�X^q�R�@K��q�NQR-q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR�Jl@�[>XYC���X^C qSB�N�@_PSL�X\qoIAu U u�IKC�N @A��q���@�R!qoIAP-R��X\q�BJlIARSR-NWR ��I IKC�v � K2F �;B�N�R-qoIKPSR�qSB�NWJ�RSNQu^[_NQR�Jl@�[_NQv�@_C�VWX^PSVQ��u�IAP�@_PSL�X^q�R�IALO@A��q�@_C�N�IAC�@AqSB�NWPQF �;B�NPSNQR-qSPSXYV)q�NQv U P-@_L�u^NWJ B�IAR=IAC�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IAu6@K� qSB�N�Jl@AqSXY@_C�g]q�B�N~?_IKVW@_L�X�VW@_C�R!qoIACyq ��g��AX^[_NQC�L�}

� ! �` ���- D B �� D � 0�� ��I� I 0�� � K

� K 0 � - �� 0 � �- �36 � ��w!�

��B�NQPSN � IAC�v��� IAPSN=q�B�NkL�IAP!}]VQNWCyq�P-XYVkVW@>@_PSv�X^C�IKqSNWR�IAC�v [ANWuY@>VWX\q�X^NWR2@A�6qSB�NkqSNWR-q U IAP-qSXYVQuYNAg � IaIAC�v � KIAP-N�qSB�N~v�X^R-q�IAC�VWNQR�@A��q�B�N U IAP-qSXYVQuYN�� PS@_J qSB�N�q���@ R!qoIAP-R�PSNQR U NWV)q�X^[ANWu\} IAC�v D� # ! � � ��I_B � K��)g��B�NQPSN XYR�qSB�N�RSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P�I/�]X^R;@A� qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP-}�@APSL�X\qnF

1N�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�NQvE� q�NQR-q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR;XYC�I�VQuY@_R-N)d$L�XYC�IAP!} R!}]R!q�NQJ IAC�vEIAC�@Aq�B�NQP�� XYCaI ��XYv�N d$L�X^C�IAP!}R-}>R!q�NWJag ��X^qSB ��I ! � K ! �ar��+XYC NWIAVoB VnIAR-NAF�ikuYu"@A��q�B�N qSNWR!q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQRMXYC�X\q�XYIAuYu\} B�IAvRSNQJlX d$JlI { @_PkI/�]NWR�@A�������4g6IAC�vpVWX^PSVQ��u�IAPk@_PSL�X^q�RQF �;B�N XYC�X^q�XYIAu3uY@AC��_X^qS��v�NQR�@A�2q�B�N U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR!��NWPSNR U IAVWNQv IKq�X^C�qSNWP![AIKuYR�@A��b�c��WF �;B�N�VWu^@_RSN L�XYC�IAP!}pR-q�IAP�B�IAv ! x V `_c���� IKC�v�I U NWPSX^@]vp@K��fy`>F fv�In}>RWg���B�XYu^N.q�B�N ��XYv�N�L�XYC�IAP!}�R-}>R!q�NWJ B�IKv ! b���� IAC�v�I U NQPSXY@>v�@A�2`Kxy�Ax v�In}>RWF �;B�N U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQRXYC q�B�NWRSN�R-}>R!q�NWJ�R~B�I�[AN @_P-L�X^qSR�q�B�IKq�I U�U NWIAP�q�@aLON�R-q�IAL�uYNKg L���q�q�B�N)}1u^XYN VQuY@_R-N qS@aqSB�N�VWPSX\q�X^VnIAuRSNQJlX d$JlI { @_PkI/�]XYR�IKq ��B�X^VoB qSB�NQ} ��@_��uYvpLHNM��C�R-qoIKL�uYNKF�;B�N XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_C�R���R-NWv I q�X^JlNQR-q�N U @A���v�In}>RWg���X^qSB,������ ! � � @_P;q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP-}�R!qoIAP=XYC�q�B�N�VQuY@_R-N�L�XYC�IAP!}�R-}>R!q�NWJaF�D2IAVoB X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�u�IKR-q�NQv� @_P���J�XYuYu^XY@_C }_NWIAPSRQFt�X^�_��PSN `�R-B�@ ��R�qSB�N PSNQu�IKqSX^[_N~NWPSP-@_P�XYCpqSB�Nl?_IAVW@_L�X�VW@_C�R-qoIKC�q�� @_P.q���@�q$} U XYVnIKu U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR�XYC

NnIKVoB1X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6F��$C NnIAVoB VnIKRSNAg3qSB�N PSNWuYIKq�X\[_NMNQPSP-@_P�@_RSVQXYu^u�IKqSNWR!��X\q�B IAC IAJ U u^X^q���v�N~@A�"@_P-v�NWP �U IAP!q=XYC ��x_x_xAx�g ��X^qSBaqSB�N�VWuY@ARSN)d L�XYC�IAP-}�IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�J0R-uYX^�_Byq�u^}lJ�@_PSN�IAVQVW��PSIKq�N�q�B�IKCaqSB�N��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}@_C�NKF��$C IAv�v�X^q�X^@_C6g3q�B�NWPSN�XYR�C�@�RSNWVQ��u�IKP�qSPSNWC�v XYC q�B�N�NWP-PS@_P-R ��X\q�B q�XYJ�NAg ��B�X^VoB�XYR�q$} U XYVWIAu2@A�R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV J�NQqSB�@>v�RWFpt�@_P�VW@_J U IAP-XYR-@_C6g qSB�N q���@pPSX^�_Byq�J�@_R-q U IAC�NQuYRM@K�=t�XY�_��PSN `�RSB�@ ��q�B�NPSNQRS��u\q�@K��XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^C�� q�B�N ��XYv�N d$L�X^C�IAP!}�R-}>R-qSNWJ ��RSX^C�� I R-q�IAC�v�IKPSv By}>L�PSX^vER!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYV�XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P� G�B�IAJMLHNWPSR �nw_w_w!� ��X\q�B I q�X^JlNQR-qSN U @A��� v�In}>RWF �;B�X^R�IAuY�_@APSX^qSB�J XYR�C�@Aq�v�NQRSXY�AC�NWv � @_P.R!}]R!q�NQJlRVW@AC�q�IAXYC�XYC�� q���@�[_NQP-}pJlIARSR-X^[ANMLO@>v�X^NWRWg6IAC�v q�B�N NWPSP-@_PSR�XYC q�B�N U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQRW�3?_IKVW@_L�X VW@_C�R-qoIKC�qSR�IAPSNu�IKPS�_NQP�Ly}aIAC�@_PSv�NQP�@A��JlIA�_C�X^q���v�NAF

Page 13: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ��f �

t�X^��F�`]F 1 m�NWu�I q�X^[AN NQPSPS@AP�@A�;qSB�N�?_IKVW@_L�X�VW@_C�R-qoIKC�q�� @_P U IAP-qSXYVWu^NWR�@_PSL�X^q�X^C���I ��XYv�NlL�XYC�IAP-} IAC�v I

VWu^@_RSN L�XYC�IAP!}_g6��RSXYC�� q�B�N IAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�JlR=v�NWR-VWP-XYLHNWv XYC qSB�XYR U I U NQPWF�i�u^RS@�RSB�@ ��C XYR.IAC XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_C�@A�

q�B�N ��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-} R-}>R-qSNWJ ��R-XYC��lI B�}>L�P-XYvaR-}>J U uYNQVQq�X^V�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�@_PQF

� �\� � � � � � � � �)���� � �� ��� ����� ��� � �� � ���F� � � � 5XYNQ�_NWP!q�IAC�v �=@_uYJlIAC � ��w_wy���=JlIAv�N I v�N)qoIAX^uYNQvpRS��P![_NQ} @A�2q�B�N R!qoIAL�X^uYX\q$}�@A�2q�NWR!q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR

@_P-L�X^qSXYC�� qSB�N � G�NWCyq�IA��PSX4L�XYC�IAP!} R!qoIAP�R!}]R!q�NQJ�F �;B�X^R�R-}>R-qSNWJ7VQ@_CyqoIAX^C�R.q���@aR-q�IAPSR�@A�"JlIARSR �AF^�IAC�v�x�F�w���r��:Jl@�[>XYC���@_C�IAC�@APSL�X\q��X\q�B1RSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P�I/�]XYR~`Af�F�b����4g�IAC�v NQVWVQNWCyq�P-XYVWX\q$}1x�F cA`]F�;B�N IA�]q�B�@_P-R.��R-NWv q�B�NMR!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV~XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqS@_P�@K� 5X^RSv�@AJ IAC�v��k@_u^J IAC � ��w_w]����qS@ v�NQqSNWP-JlX^C�Nq�B�N�JlI/�]XYJ~��J R-NWJ�X\d J I { @AP�I/�]XYRQg ���� � ��LONQuY@ � ��B�XYVoB�IAuYu @_PSL�X\q�R�IAP-@_��C�v q�B�N U PSXYJlIAP!}ER!qoIAP�IAP-NR-q�IAL�u^NAg#IARkI � ��C�VQqSXY@_C�@A� q�B�N U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQRW��X^C�VWu^XYC�IKqSXY@_C�g :Sg�P-NWuYIKq�X\[_N�q�@ q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP!}�@_PSL�X^qnF"�$C�q�B�N �WNQPS@XYC�VWuYX^C�IKqSXY@_C VnIKRSNAg ���� � ��X^R�IALH@_��q�x�F^�kq�XYJ�NWR2q�B�N.L�XYC�IAP-}�RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P"I/�]XYRQF �;B�N�IA�]q�B�@_P-R�� @_��C�v q�B�I q ���� � ��XYR.IlR-q�P-@_C�� � ��C�VQqSXY@_C @K�4q�B�N~qSNWR!q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQRW�HXYC�VQuYXYC�IKq�X^@_C6g�PSNWIAVoB�X^C���I J�XYC�X^JM��J @A�2VQuY@_R-N�qS@�WNQPS@ � @_PP: ! w_x � F

�kNQPSNKg ��N�B�I�[AN�PSN U PS@>v���VWNQv:qSB�XYRMqSNWR!ql��RSXYC�� qSB�N���XYv�N)d$L�XYC�IAP!} X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C IAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�Jv�NQRSVWP-XYLHNWv�IALO@�[ANAF �N X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�NQv �nf�R-NQqSR�@A��cAx�q�NQR-q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR ��X^q�B X^C�X^qSX�IAu^u^}�VWX^PSVQ��u�IAP�@_PSL�X\q�RIALH@_��qkq�B�N U PSXYJlIAP!}�R!qoIAPQg ��X\q�BpRSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P=I/�]NWR�x V `Af �_� V c ����gOR U IAVQNWv IKq�XYCyq�NQP-[KIAuYRk@A�

Page 14: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� �nb �

t�X^��F.f�F 1 � U�U NWP02kRS��P![>X^[KIAu�q�XYJ�N~@K� U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWRk@_PSL�X^q�X^C�� q�B�N U PSXYJlIAP!}�@K�4q�B�N � G�NWC6F�L�X^C�IAP!}EIKR�I

� ��C�V)q�X^@_CE@A��q�B�NQXYP=XYC�X\q�X�IKu�RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P=I/�]XYR � �QNWP-@Kd$X^C�VWu^XYC�IKqSXY@_C�VWIARSN �)Fk�3@ ��NWP�2=G�PSX\q�XYVWIAu3RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_PI/�]XYR�� @AP;RS��VoB U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWR�IKRkIM� ��C�VQq�X^@_C�@A��q�B�NQXYP;XYC�X^q�XYIAuHXYC�VQuYXYC�IKq�X^@_C6F

x�F `Af ���4F2D2IAVoB�R-NQq�@A� U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR�LHNW�yIKC ��X^qSB I~v�X\s�NQPSNQC�q�XYC�X\q�XYIAu�XYC�VWuYX^C�IKqSXY@_C PSNQu�IKqSX^[AN=qS@~q�B�NkL�XYC�IAP-}@_P-L�X^qWF �N�N-��IAJlX^C�NWv�VWIARSNQR ��X\q�B�P-NWu�I q�X^[AN�XYC�VQuYX^C�IKq�X^@_C�R�x : �n�_x � g�R U IAVQNWv�IKq�XYCyq�NQP-[KIAu^R�@A�"�ec � F�$CpNnIKVoB X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C6gHq�B�N~RSNWVQ@_C�v�IKP-}pR!qoIAP ��IAR�R!qoIAP!q�NWv IKq.I U @yIAR-qSPS@_C�g6@_C q�B�NM@ U�U @_RSX\q�NMR-XYv�N~@A�q�B�N U P-XYJlIAP-}�� P-@_J q�B�N�q�NWR!q U IKP-q�X^VWu^NWRWF �;B�NMX^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C�R�uYIAR-qSNWvE� @_P�`]F clJ�XYuYu^XY@_Cl}_NnIKPSRWg6IAC�vEqSB�NXYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P���R-NWvEIlR-qSN U R-X��QN�@A�4`�v�In}>RWF�� IAP-qSXYVQuYNWR ��NWP-N~v�NQNWJ�NWv�qS@lLHN���C�R-q�IAL�u^N�X\� qSB�NWX^P=v�XYR-q�IAC�VQN� PS@AJ qSB�N U P-XYJlIAP-} LHNWVWIAJ�N��_P-NnIKqSNWP�qSB�IAC qSB�N�R-NWJ�X\d$JlI { @_P"I/�]X^R�@A�6qSB�N.L�X^C�IAP-}�@_P�uYNQRSR�qSB�IAC�x�F�xy`AfKb����F

�;B�N � U�U NQP U IAC�NQu�@A��t�X^��FHf RSB�@ ��R�q�B�N~uYX^� N)q�X^JlN�@A� U IKP-q�X^VWu^NWR.X^CEq�B�N �WNWP-@Kd$X^C�VWu^XYC�I q�XY@AC�VWIARSNIAR~Ia� ��C�V)q�X^@_C�@A��q�B�NQXYP�XYC�X\q�X�IKu�RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P�I/�]XYR F ��NWR!q U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR ��X^q�B � � ��� LONQVnIAJ�N��C�R!qoIAL�uYN IAu^[email protected]^JlJ�NWv�X�IKqSNWu^}�IK� q�NQP�q�B�N R!qoIAP!q�@A�2q�B�NMXYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�XY@AC6F���IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR ��X^qSB f�� � ���� R-��P-[>X\[_NWv1uY@_C��_NWPQg�L���q���u^qSXYJlIKq�NQu^}aLONQVnIAJ�N ��C�R!qoIAL�u^NAg���X^qSB qSB�N q�X^JlNMP-NW����X^PSNWv q�@�LHNWVW@AJlN��C�R!qoIAL�uYN��_NWC�NQP�IAu^u^} XYC�VQPSNnIKRSXYC�� IAR v�NQVWP-NnIAR-NWv6F;�$Caq�B�X^R=R-XYJM��u�IKqSXY@_C6g�IAuYu U IAP-qSXYVWu^NWR ��X\q�B ` V �A�

Page 15: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� �ec �

t�X^��F�b�F 1 G�P-X^qSXYVnIKuHR-NWJ�X\d J I { @AP2I/�]XYR�� @AP U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR�@APSL�X\q�XYC��~LH@Aq�B J�NWJ~LONQPSR�@K�6q�B�N � G�NWC�F4L�XYC�IKP-}_gIAR=IM� ��C�V)q�XY@ACa@K� qSB�NWX^P;XYC�X\q�X�IKuOX^C�VWu^XYC�IKqSXY@_C�F

��� PSNWJlIAX^C�NWvpR!qoIAL�u^NMq�B�P-@_���_B�@_��q.qSB�N XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_C�g ��B�X^VoB�IA�APSNWNQR ��X^qSB qSB�N PSNQRS��u\q�@A� 5XYNW�ANWP-qIAC�v �k@AuYJlIAC � ��wAwy���)F �;B�XYR�XYR;X^C�v�XYVWIKq�NQv�L�}�qSB�N�uYX^C�N�u�IALHNWu^uYNQv �� � � �"XYC�q�B�N�� U�U NQP U IAC�NQu�@K��t�X^��F�f]F�k@ ��NQ[ANWPWg���N�C�@Kq�N�q�B�I qkR-@_J�N�@A��qSB�N U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWR ��X\q�B �5` V �A�����1JlIn} U P-@�[_N�q�@�LON���C�R!qoIAL�uYN�@_CuY@AC��_NWP�qSXYJ�NWR-VnIAu^NWRWF

�;B�N uY@ ��NWP U IKC�NWu4@A��t�X^��F�f�R-B�@ ��R�qSB�N VWP-X^q�X^VnIAu RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P.I���X^R�IAR�I � ��C�V)q�XY@ACp@A��X^C�X^qSX�IAuXYC�VWuYX^C�IKqSXY@_C6g�X^C @_��P�XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_C�R�IAC�v q�B�@_R-N @A� 5XYNQ�_NWP!q�IAC�v��k@_u^J IAC � ��wAwy���)F��$Cp�_NWC�NQP�IAu gOqSB�NIA�_P-NWNQJlNQC�q=X^R=�A@]@>v6g�IAu\q�B�@A���_B�XYCaRS@_J�N�VnIKRSNWRQg U IAP-qSXYVWu^NWR�IAP-N�� @A��C�v�q�@�LON���C�R!qoIAL�uYN�XYCa@_C�N�@A� q�B�NRSX^JM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R;L���q�C�@Aq=q�B�N�@Aq�B�NWPWF 1N~R-���_�_NQR-q.qSB�IKq=q�B�NQRSN U IKP-q�X^VWu^NWR ��XYu^u���u^q�X^J I q�NWu\} U PS@�[_N~qS@ LHN��C�R!qoIAL�uYN.��R-XYC�� LH@AqSB�XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_Clq�NWVoB�C�XY����NQR=X\��XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�NWv � @AP�uY@_C��MNWC�@A���_B6F �k@ ��NQ[ANWPWg�qSB�N�q�X^JlNPSNQ����XYP-NWvE� @_PkI U IAP-qSXYVW��u�IAP U IKP-q�X^VWu^N�qS@ LHNWVQ@_JlN���C�R!qoIAL�u^N~I U�U NWIAPSR=q�@lv�N U NWC�vpR-NWC�R-X^qSX^[_NQu^}�@_C�q�B�NXYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P���RSNQv6F �;B�N � IAVQq�qSB�IKq�qSB�N PSNQRS��u\q�R�IAP-N�R-XYJ�XYuYIAP���RSX^C���q�B�NMq���@EIKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�JlRQg ��X\q�BpC�@R-}>R!q�NWJlIKqSXYV�v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQNWRQgH�AX^[_NQR���R�VW@_C .�v�NWC�VQN�qSB�IKq=@_��P;C�N��jIAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�J ��@_P-�>RQF

5XYNQ�_NWP!q�IAC�v#�k@_u^J IKC � ��w_w_���.IAuYR-@�uY@>@_�ANQv�I q�q�NWR!q U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWR�@APSL�X\q�XYC���LO@AqSB JlNQJMLONQPSR�@A�q�B�N � G�NWC�F L�XYC�IAP-}Ag�IAC�v ��N B�In[AN PSN U PS@>v���VQNWv q�B�IKq�q�NQR-q���RSX^C���q�B�N�VWu^@_RSN d$L�X^C�IAP-} IAuY�A@_PSX\q�B�Jv�NQRSVWP-XYLHNWv XYC T NQVQq�X^@_C f�F `]F 1N�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSNWv ��f�RSN)q�R�@A� U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWR ��X\q�B XYC�X^q�XYIAuYu\}�VWX^PSVQ��u�IAP�@_PSL�X\q�R

Page 16: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ��� �

IALH@_��q=q�B�N�L�IAP!}]VQNWCyq�NQP�@A��qSB�N~L�X^C�IAP!}_Fk��IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR ��X\q�B�X^CENnIKVoB RSN)q�LONQ�yIAC ��X\q�B�RSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P�I/�]NWRfyc V\� � � �_�e� ����g�R U IAVWNQv IKq�X^C�qSNWP![AIKuYR;@A��`]F�fAb ����F2D"IKVoB�R-NQqk@A� U IAP-qSXYVWu^NWR�LHNW�_IAC ��X\q�BaI RSX^C��_uYNXYC�VWuYX^C�IKqSXY@_C P-NWuYIKq�X\[_N.q�@ qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP!}_g���X\q�B�x� : j���_x � � @_P;v�X\s�NQPSNQC�q=R-NQq�RQg#R U IAVQNWvpI q�XYCyq�NQP-[KIAuYR;@K��ec��QF��$CENWIAVoB X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6g�qSB�N�RSNWVQ@_C�v�IKP-}aR-q�IAP ��IARkR-q�IAP-qSNWv I q�I U @yIKR-q�P-@_C6g�@_Caq�B�N�@ U�U @_R-X^q�N�R-XYv�N@A��qSB�N U PSX^J IAP!} q�@ q�B�N�q�NQR-q U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQRWF �;B�N�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�XY@AC�R�u�IAR!q�NWva� @_P�`]F c J�XYuYu^XY@_Cl}_NnIKPSRWgO��RSX^C��lIACXYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�@_P;R!q�N U RSX\�WN�@A���nx_x v�In}]R ��X^qSB,������ ! `]F"��IKP-q�X^VWu^NWR ��NWPSN�PSNQJl@�[_NQv�X\� qSB�NWX^P;v�XYR!qoIAC�VWN�� PS@_Jq�B�N U PSXYJlIAP!} LHNWVWIAJlN�u^NWRSR;qSB�IAC�`Af�F�b ���1@_P;J�@_PSN.qSB�IAC�`Ax_xAx_x�����Ft�X^�_��PSN b�R-B�@ ��R�qSB�N VWPSX\q�X^VnIAu RSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P.I/�]X^R ���� � �;� @_P.q�B�NWRSN R-XYJM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R�IAR�I�� ��C�VQqSXY@_C

@A�2q�B�N XYC�X\q�X�IKu�X^C�VWu^XYC�I q�XY@AC6F �kNQPSN���N�v�N .�C�N ���� � ��q�@�LHNMq�B�N J�XYC�X^JM��J R-NWJ�X\d$JlI { @_P�I/�]XYR�IKLO@�[_N��B�X^VoB IAuYu3q�B�N U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR�I U�U NWIAPkqS@ LHN~R-q�IAL�u^NAF �;B�N .��_��P-N IAu^RS@ R-B�@ ��R�q�B�NMPSNQRS��u\q�R�@AL�qoIAX^C�NWvEL�} 5XYNQ�_NWP!q=IAC�v �k@AuYJlIAC � �nw_wy��� F �N�C�@Kq�N.q�B�IKqng�X^C�VW@_J�J�@_C���X^qSB� 5XYNW�ANWP-q=IKC�v �k@_u^J IAC�g ��N�B�I�[ANv�NQRSVWP-XYLHNWv1I U IAP-qSXYVQuYN IAR &-��C�R-q�IAL�uYN (�X^�"X^qSR.q�XYJ�N)d$In[_NWPSIA�_NQv R-NWJ�X\d J I { @AP.I/�]XYR�v�X^sONWPSNQv1Ly}pJ�@_P-Nq�B�IACac � � PS@_J X^qSR�XYC�X^q�XYIAu�[KIAuY��NAF �;B�NQRSN U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR�IAP-N.uYX^�ANQu^} q�@MLHN.P-NWJ�@e[ANWv�Ly}�IMVQuY@_R-N�NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWP@_P;N { NWVQqSXY@_C�@_C�qSXYJ�NWRSVWIAuYNQR�uY@AC��_NWP�q�B�IACa@_��P;X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C6F �;B�N�PSNQRS��u\q�R�XYC�t�X^��F�b ��R-XYC�� qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP-}VW@>v�N�IAPSN�IKuYJ�@_R-q"XYv�NWCyq�X^VnIAu�q�@�q�B�@_R-N.@A� 5X^NW�_NQP-q�IAC�v��=@_uYJlIAC � ��w_wy���)g&��X^qSB �� � � � v�X^sONWP-XYC��~IKq�@AC�u^}@_C�N�[KIAu^��N�@A�:SF

� � � � H� � � � � � �)� � ��� �?� U��$v�I ��� #���� � `AxAx_x!��B�In[_N X^C�[ANWR!q�XY�_IKq�NQv�q�B�N NQsONWVQq~@A�;q�B�N U IAR-R�IA�AN @A��IER!qoIAP�@_C I�C�NnIAP-u^}

U IAPSIALH@_uYX^V�@_PSL�X\q U IARSR-XYC�� { ��R-q�@_��qSRSXYv�N�qSB�N U P-XYJ�@_PSv�X�IAu3D4v��AN���@_P-qSB]d����X U NQPkLHNWu\qnF �;B�NQRSN IA�]q�B�@_P-R� @_��C�vEq�B�I q�q�B�N~v�NQ�_PSNQN~q�@ ��B�XYVoBEqSB�N~@_P-L�X^qSR�@A��@_L { NWV)q�R.X^C�qSB�NMLHNWu^q ��NWPSN U NQP-q���PSLHNWvpv�N U NQC�v�NWvR-qSPS@_C��_u^} @_CEIKCa@AL { NWV)qn��RkR-NWJ�X\d$JlI { @_P�I/�]XYR�XYC���C�X^q�R;@K� qSB�N�R-qoIKPW��R U NWP-XYB�NQuYX^@_C�v�XYR!qoIAC�VWNAF

1NkB�In[ANkP-N U P-@]v���VWNWvl@_C�N�@A�Oq�B�NQXYP2VnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_C�R���RSXYC���qSB�N ��XYv�N d$L�X^C�IAP-}MIAuY�A@_PSX\q�B�J�v�NWR-VWP-XYLHNWvXYC T NQVQqSXY@_C�f�F\�_F �N�XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NQv �A�Ax qSNWR!q U IKP-q�X^VWu^NWRWg ��X^q�B�X^C�X^qSX�IAu^u^} VWX^PSVQ��u�IAPQg�VW@ U u�IAC�IAP;@_PSL�X^q�RQg�IAC�vRSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P�I/�]NWR~c � � �_x ����g3� @_P�`Ax_xAx_x }_NnIKPSRWF �;B�N U IAP!q�XYVQuYNQR�LONQ�yIAC @_PSL�X^q�X^C���Ip� r �R-q�IAPWg ��B�XYuYN�I RSNQVW@_C�v �Mr � R!qoIAP�J�@e[ANWv�@_CEI U IAPSIALH@_uYX^V.@_PSL�X^qng�XYC�VQuYXYC�NWvaIKq=f_x � g���X\q�BaI U NQPSX�I U RSNv�X^R-qoIKC�VWN @A�k��x_x����4g U IARSR-XYC���q�B�PS@_���AB U NWP-X�I U RSN J�XYv���In}Eq�B�PS@_���AB qSB�N XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6F�;B�N q�NWR!qU IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR ��NWP-NM�_P-@_� U NWv X^C�qS@lL�IKq�VoB�NQR�@A�;��x]gONWIAVoB L�IKqSVoBpB�In[>XYC���q�B�N�R�IAJ�N~X^C�X^qSX�IAu gHR U IKVWNWv I qXYCyqSNWP-[KIAu^R;@A��� ���4F 5X\q�B�X^C�NnIAVoBaL�IKqSVoB6g�q�B�N�XYC�X^q�XYIAu#uY@_C��_X^qS��v�NWR ��NWP-N�R U IAVQNWv I q�XYCyq�NQP-[KIAuYR;@K��f_� � Ft�X^�_��PSN~c�R-B�@ ��R�q�B�N .�C�IKu�v�XYR-qSPSX^L���q�X^@_C�R�@A� < IKC�v :"� @_P=qSB�N�qSNWR!q U IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR�IKR�I � ��C�VQqSXY@_C�@A�

q�B�N .�C�IAu�[KIAuY��NWR�@K� g ��B�NWP-N XYR�J�NnIKRS��P-NWv X^C ��C�X\q�R�@K��q�B�N~L�XYC�IKP-} U NQPSXYI U RSN�v�XYR!qoIAC�VWN,�>F �;B�Nv�X^R-q�P-XYL��]q�XY@AC�R�IKPSN~v�X^[>XYv�NQv XYCyqS@lq���@�PSNW�AXYJ�NWRWF�t�@_PkR-J IKuYu3[KIAuY��NQR�@A� gHq�B�N�v�NW�_P-NWNM@K�2N �]VWX\qoIKqSXY@_C@A� < IAC�v�:kXYR�I U @ ��NQP!d$uYI�� � ��C�V)q�XY@AC�@A��q�B�NlRSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P�I/�]XYRQF��$C�q�B�X^R�P-NW�_X^JlNKg < IAC�v�:kIAP-NI U�U PS@ �]XYJlIKq�NQu^} U PS@ U @_P-qSXY@_C�IAu�q�@ � ^ ����� Y D IAC�v � ^ ��� # Y D PSNWR U NQVQqSX^[_NQu^}AF�i�q�uYIAPS�ANWP�[KIAuY��NWR�@A� g�q�B�Nv�NQ�_PSNQN�@K��N-��VQX^q�IKq�X^@_CpXYR�uYIAPS�_NQPWg3IKC�v�IKuYRS@�v�N U NWC�v�R�@_Cpq�B�N�X^C�X^qSX�IAu�u^@_C��_X\q���v�NQR�@A�2q�B�N U IKP-q�X^VWu^NWRv���N�q�@ qSB�NMNQsONWV)q�@A�2J�NnIAC>d$J�@Aq�X^@_C�P-NWR-@_C�IAC�VQNWRQF�;B�NWRSN VoB�IAP�IAV)q�NQPSXYR!q�X^VWRWg�IAC�v qSB�NMv�X^R-q�P-XYL��]q�XY@AC�Rq�B�NWJ�RSNWu\[_NQR�IAP-N�NWR-RSNWCyqSX�IAu^u^}�X^v�NWCyq�X^VnIAuHq�@ q�B�@ARSN�@A��t�XY��F�`KLa@A���$v�I ��� #���� � `Ax_x_x��)F

Page 17: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� �e� �

t�X^��F�c]F 1 t�XYC�IKu4NWVWVQNWCyq�P-XYVQX^q$} < IAC�v1XYC�VQuYXYC�IKq�X^@_C :=[ANWP-RS��R .�C�IAu2RSNWJ�X\d J I { @_P�I/�]XYR � @_P~�_cAx�q�NWR!qU IAP!q�X^VWuYNQR.� @_uYu^@ ��XYC�� qSB�N U IARSRSIA�_N�@A��I � r�� R!qoIAP�@_C1I U IAP�IALH@_u^XYVM@_P-L�X^q ��X\q�B : ! f_x � Fl�$C�X\q�XYIAuYu\}<]! : ! xM� @_P�IAuYu U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWRQz X^R;XYC���C�X\q�R�@A��q�B�N�R!qoIAPQ��R U NWPSX^B�NWu^XY@_C v�XYR!qoIAC�VQNAg�:2XYR;X^C�P�IAv�XYIAC�RQF

� � � � � �� � ���� � � � ��� � � �7� �������)� � � � � � �F��;B�N�q�NWR!q�Rkv�NWR-VWPSX^LONQv IALH@�[_N�B�In[_NMIKuYu6X^C�[A@_u^[ANWv�J IAR-RSu^NWRSR�q�NQR-q U IAP-qSXYVQuYNWRQF��$Caq�B�X^R=R-NWV)q�XY@AC6g"��N

v�NQRSVWP-XYLHN�I~q�NWR!q=XYCy[_@_u\[>XYC�� I R!}]R!q�NQJ @A��JlIAR-RSX^[AN�LO@>v�X^NWRWF �;B�N�R-}>R-qSNWJ VW@AC�RSX^R-q�R�@A� f �_XYIACyq U u�IKC�NQqSR��X^qSBEX^C�X^qSX�IAu6@APSL�X\q�R=XYv�NQC�qSXYVWIAu3q�@lqSB�@_R-N~@A�"?A� U X^qSNWPWg T IKqS��PSC IAC�v �=P�IAC���RQg ��X\q�BEqSB�N~JlIARSR-NWRk@A�2IAu^uf U u�IAC�N)q�R=RSN)q.NW����IKu�qS@lq�B�IKq�@K�"?A� U X\q�NWPQF �N�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�NWvaq�B�X^RkR!}>R-q�NQJ ��R-XYC��lLO@Kq�BE@K��q�B�N~L�X^C�IAP-}IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�R.IKC�v IAuYR-@�I�R!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYV VQ@]v�NMqSB�IKq�XYC�VWuY��v�NWv I�R-}>J U uYNQVQq�X^V VW@_P-PSNQVQq�@AP � 5XYR-v�@_J ���#���� ��wAw_�!�)Fkt�@_P�q�B�N�VWuY@ARSN)d L�XYC�IAP-}�VQ@]v�NKg ��NMv�NQRSXY�AC�IKq�NQv T ��C IAC�v ?A� U X^q�NQP.IAR=q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP-}aR-}>R!q�NWJ@_P-L�X^qSNWv�Ly} q�B�N�@Kq�B�NQP=` U u�IAC�N)q�RQF2t#@AP�q�B�N ��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IKP-}lVnIAR-NAg�q�B�N�JlIAR-R!d$NQC�B�IAC�VWNWv��kPSIAC���R U u�In}ANWvq�B�N~PS@AuYN�@A�2Ilv�XYR-q�IACyq.L�X^C�IAP!}�VW@_J U IAC�X^@_C�IAC�vEqSB�N~@AqSB�NWP.` U uYIAC�N)q�R!��NWP-N IAR-RS��J�NWvEqS@ @_P-L�X^q=q�B�NT ��C�F.D2IAVoB @A��q�B�NQRSN I U�U PS@ �]XYJlIKq�X^@_C�R�XYRkPSNWIARS@_C�IAL�uYNKg�IKu^q�B�@_���_BEI�q�P-��N~B�XYNWPSIAPSVoB�XYVnIKu�R!}>R-q�NQJ X^R�ILHNQqSqSNWPkI U�U P-@ ��X^J I q�XY@AC�R-q�X^uYu F�t�@_P;qSB�XYR�PSNWIARS@AC ��N�VQ@_J U IAPSNQv�q�B�N�P-NWRS��u^q�R=��R-XYC�� q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP-} VW@>v�NWR

Page 18: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ��� �

t�X^��F ��F 1 m=NQu�IKqSX^[_NpNQPSP-@_P�@_C+q�B�N RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P I���NQR�@K� ?A� U X^q�NQPaIAC�v hkN U q���C�N XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NQv5� @AP`AxaJlX^uYuYX^@_C }_NWIAPSR~��RSX^C���qSB�N VQuY@_R-N IAC�v ��XYv�N d$L�X^C�IAP-} IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�JlRQF i�u^RS@ R-B�@ ��C XYR�q�B�Nlv�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN

LHNQq���NWNWC ` X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C�R���RSX^C���I R!qoIAC�v�IAPSvaRSVoB�NWJ�N � XYC�VQuY��v�X^C�� I R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV�VW@APSPSNQVQqS@_P ��XYC���B�XYVoB

q�B�N�X^C�C�NQPSJ�@_R-q U uYIAC�N)q ��IAR�X^C�X^qSX�IAu^u^} v�X^R U uYIAVWNQvaLy}p�nx�� ) � ���4F��X^qSBpIlP-NQ� NQPSNWC�VWN XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C ��B�XYVoBp��R-NWv I VQ@_Cy[_NWCyqSXY@_C�IKu�R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV�XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqS@_P=��RSX^C���?_IAVQ@_L�XVW@>@_P-v�XYC�I q�NWRQF �;B�XYR�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqS@_P�IAuYR-@�XYC�VQuY��v�NWv1I�R-XYJ U uYN~R-}>J U uYNWV)q�X^V VW@_P-PSNWV)q�@_P�qS@aX^C�VWP-NnIAR-N q�B�NIAVQVW��PSIAVQ}�@A�6qSB�N=PSNQ� NQPSNQC�VWN.VWIAuYVQ��u�I q�XY@AC6F�h=@Aq�N�q�B�IKq�NWIAVoB @A�Oq�B�NkVnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_C�R4X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�NQvlqSB�NkRSIAJ�NR-}>R!q�NWJ @A� b LO@>v�X^NWRWF �;B�N�@AC�u^} v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN�X^R;XYC�q�B�N�J�NQqSB�@]v�@A� XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6F

�;B�N VnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�R�P�IACp� @_PM�nx_x�JlX^uYuYX^@_C�}_NnIKPSR���RSX^C��aI�R-q�N U RSX\�WN @A��cAx�v�In}>R � ��x_x�v�In}>R�� @_Pq�B�N VWuY@ARSN L�X^C�IAP-}EIAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�Jag���X^q�B������� ! `�� F��$C�X^q�XYIAu�v�IKqoI � @_Pkq�B�N U uYIAC�N)q�R ��NWPSN q�IA�ANQC � P-@_J?_�2� N U B�NWJ�NWP-XYR�Z�D"`Ax_x]F�t XY�_��P-N � RSB�@ ��R�q�B�N PSNWuYIKq�X\[_N�NWPSP-@_P�@_C qSB�N�?_IAVW@AL�X�RSNQJlX d$JlI { @_P�I/�]NWR@A��?A� U X^q�NQP.IAC�vp�kPSIAC���R�� @_P=q�B�N .�PSR-q�`AxlJ�XYu^uYXY@AC }_NnIKPSR�@A�4qSB�N~X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�R � qSB�NMPSNQJ IKXYC�v�NQPSRk@A�q�B�N�R-XYJM��u�IKqSXY@_C�R.IAPSN RSX^JlX^u�IAP �)F t�@_P�NWIAVoB�@K��qSB�NlL�XYC�IAP!} VQ@]v�NQRWg�q�B�N NWP-PS@_P-R�IAPSN VnIKuYVW��u�IKqSNWv L�}VW@AJ U IKPSXYC�� q�B�N PSNQRS��u\q�R ��X^qSBpq�B�N PSN)� NWP-NWC�VQNlX^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6F �;B�NluYIKqSqSNWP.B�IAv�IKC NQC�NWP-�A} NWP-PS@_P�@K�IALH@_��q�� U IAP-q=X^C1��x ) � IKq�qSB�N�NQC�vE@K��q�B�N�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6g]VW@_J U IAP-NWv�qS@ IKLO@_�]q�� U IAP!q=XYC ��x��;� @_P;q�B�NL�X^C�IAP-}aVQ@]v�NQRWF!�;B�XYRkv�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN~XYRkv���N�Jl@_R!q�u\}�q�@ qSB�N~X^C�VW@_P U @AP�IKqSXY@_Ca@A�2I R!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV�VW@APSPSNQVQqS@_P

Page 19: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� ��w �

XYC qSB�N R-q�IAC�v�IKPSv VW@>v�NAF � h=@Aq�NMqSB�IKq�I VW@APSPSNQVQqS@_P�VW@_��uYvpLHN I U�U u^XYNWv qS@ q�B�N L�XYC�IAP!}pIAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�JlRQgL���q~@_��P U ��P U @_R-N B�NQPSNlXYR�q�@EVQ@_J U IAPSN q�B�NlL�IKRSXYVlL�XYC�IAP-} IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�JlR ��X\q�B�I�J�@_PSNlIAVWVQ��P�I q�NXYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6F �

�;B�NlPSNWuYIKq�X\[_N NWP-PS@_P-R�X^C IAPSN q$} U XYVWIAuYu\}pIALH@_��q�@_C�N U IAP!q�X^C �nx_x_x�� @_P�LO@AqSB ?A� U X^qSNWP�IAC�v�kPSIAC���RWg�VWNWCyqSNWPSNQv @_C �QNWPS@�g ��X^qSB�C�@�RSNQVW��uYIAP�qSPSNWC�v�q�@ ��IAPSv�R�u�IAP-�_NWP�@_P�RSJlIAu^uYNWP�[KIAu^��NWR�@A� F�$Cpq�B�N~NnIAVoB VnIAR-NAg6qSB�N PSNQu�IKqSX^[_N~NWPSP-@_P.N-��B�XYL�X\q�R.B�X^�_BE� P-NW����NWC�VQ} @_R-VWXYu^u�IKqSXY@_C�RWg#L���q�qSB�N NWCy[_NQuY@ U NNWC�VW@_J U IAR-RSXYC�� q�B�NQRSN @_R-VWXYu^u�IKqSXY@_C�R=v�@]NQR.C�@Aq��APS@ � ��X^q�B�q�XYJ�NAF �;B�NWR-N U PS@ U NWP!q�XYNQR.IAP-N~q$} U XYVWIAu�@K�R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV IAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�JlRQF �;B�N NWP-PS@_P-R�IAPSN VQ@_J U IAP�IKL�uYN�q�@ q�B�NMq$} U XYVnIKu�PSNQu�IKqSX^[ANMVoB�IAC��AN XYC � @_PNWX\q�B�NQP U u�IAC�NQq�@_C�q�X^JlNQRSVnIKuYNWR;@K��IACa@_P-L�X^q�IAu U NWP-XY@>v6g���B�X^VoB�R-���_�_NQR-q�R�q�B�IKq�q�B�N�v�X\s�NQPSNWC�VWNWRkIAP-N�v���Nq�@ NQPSPS@APSR�XYC�q�B�N U B�IARSNQRkPSIKq�B�NWP;q�B�IKC�qSB�N�IAVQqSXY@_C�RWFi�R�IAC IKv�v�X^qSXY@_C�IAu�q�NQR-qWg ��N~P-NWP�IKC�q�B�N~PSN)� NWP-NWC�VQNMVnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_C�v�X^R U uYIAVWX^C���qSB�N�XYC�X\q�X�IKu�@_P-L�X^q=@A�

q�B�NMXYC�C�NWPSJ�@_R!q U uYIAC�NQq�Ly} ��x � ) � ����F �;B�N v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQNMLHNQq���NWNWC q�B�N `lPSN)� NWP-NWC�VQN�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C�R=XYRRSB�@ ��C XYC qSB�N PSX^�_Byq�J�@_R-q U IAC�NQuYR�@A��t�X^��FO��F �;B�NWRSN X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�R.v�X^[_NQPS�_NQv P�I U X^v�u^}Ag�R-���_�_NQR-q�X^C��q�B�IKqkqSB�XYR�R!}]R!q�NQJ X^R=B�XY�_B�u\}�VoB�IA@Kq�XYV ��X^qSBEIl�6}yI U ��C�@�[aqSXYJ�N�� cAx 6ox_x_xM}_NWIAPSRQF�ik� q�NQP��AF c JlX^uYu^XY@_C}_NWIAPSRQgHqSB�N�v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN�LHNQq���NWNQC q�B�N�P-NQ� NWP-NWC�VQN~VWIAuYVQ��u�IKqSXY@_C�R ��IKR�VW@AJ U IKP�IAL�u^N�q�@ q�B�N�v�X\s�NQPSNQC�VWN�@A�NWX\q�B�NQP=� P-@_J qSB�N�L�XYC�IAP!}�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�XY@AC�R;RS���A�_NWR!q�XYC��lq�B�IKq�q�B�N�L�XYC�IKP-}�IAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�JlR�v�@ I �_@]@>v { @_L�@K�� @_u^uY@ ��XYC���q�B�N�NQ[A@_uY�]q�XY@ACa@K��R!}]R!q�NQJlR=XYCy[_@Au^[>XYC�� JlIAR-RSX^[AN�LO@>v�XYNQR;@_C�uY@_C�� qSXYJ�NWR-VnIAu^NWRWF

����� � � � � � �F� � � � �!��� � ���� �i�R I,.�C�IAu�qSNWR-q @K�=qSB�N���XYv�N)d$L�XYC�IAP!} IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�J�g ��N U PSNWR-NWCyq�RS@_J�N�h�d LO@>v�}�IAVWVQPSN)q�XY@AC

VnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�R;v�NWRSX^�_C�NQv�q�@lRSX^JM��u�I q�N.q�B�N .�C�IAu�R-qoIK�_N�@K��q�B�N�� @_P-J I q�XY@ACa@K��q�B�N�qSNWPSP-NWR!q�PSXYIAu U u�IKC�NQqSRWF�;B�NQRSNaVnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_C�R�XYC�VQuY��v�N�JlIACy} VQuY@_R-N NWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSRQg;IAC�v R-@ qSB�NQ} U PS@�[>XYv�N�IpqSNWR!q @A�kqSB�NVW@AJML�XYC�IKq�X^@_C @A��q�B�N�L�XYC�IAP!} VQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�N.R!}>R-q�NQJ ��X^qSB�qSB�N�By}>L�PSX^v�J�NQqSB�@]v � @AP;v�NnIAu^XYC�� ��X^q�B�VQuY@_R-NNWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSRQF�.��P.P-NQ� NWP-NWC�VQN VnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_C ��IAR�IKC IAVWVQPSNQqSXY@_CpX^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_CaqoIA�KNWCp� PS@_J G�B�IKJMLONQPSR � `Ax_x���� g

��B�X^VoBp��RSNQv I By}]L�PSXYvpR!}>J U u^NWV)q�XYV�XYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�@_PQF �;B�NMR-XYJM��u�IKqSXY@_C�LHNW�yIAC ��X\q�B ��cKb NQJML�P-}A@_R ��X\q�BXYC�X^q�XYIAu�R-NWJ�X\d J I { @AP�I/�]NWR x V�f � ��` V x ����g NQVWVQNWCyq�P-XYVWX\q�X^NWRMx � < � x V�x�� IAC�v�X^C�VWu^XYC�I q�XY@AC�Rx ��: � x V c � F�t#@A��P-qSNWNWC�@A�#q�B�N=NQJML�P!}_@_R2LHNW�yIAC ��X^qSB I�J IAR-R2RSXYJ�XYuYIAP3q�@�rEIAP-RWg>IAC�v q�B�N;PSNWJlIAX^C�XYC���nbyx�B�IAv JlIAR-RSNWRkVW@_J U IAPSIAL�u^N�qS@lq�B�N r�@>@_C6F�G�@_uYu^XYR-XY@_C�R;LHNQq���NWNQC U IAXYP-Rk@K�4LO@>v�X^NWR�P-NWR-��u^qSNWv X^C IRSX^J U uYNMJ�NWP-�_NWPQg3VW@_C�R-NWP![]X^C��aJ IAR-R�IAC�v J�@_JlNQCyq���JaF �;B�N�XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_CpIAu^RS@�XYC�VQuY��v�NWv ?A� U X\q�NQPWgR-q�IAP-qSXYC�� ��X\q�B�X^qSR;VW��P-PSNWCyqkJ IKRSR�IAC�va@_P-L�X^q�IAu�NQuYNWJ�NWCyqSRWF

1NMPSNQv�XYvEqSB�XYR�VnIAu^VW��uYIKq�X^@_Caq���X^VWNM��RSXYC�� q�B�N ��XYv�N d$L�X^C�IAP-}�IAu^�_@_P-X^q�B�J�g ��X\q�B ?A� U X^q�NQP�IAR=q�B�Nv�X^R-qoIKC�qkL�X^C�IAP-} JlNQJMLONQPWF��.C�N�VnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C � m���C1����LONQ�yIAC ��X\q�B�XYv�NQC�qSXYVWIAu3XYC�X\q�XYIAu�VQ@_C�v�X\q�XY@AC�R;q�@q�B�IKq=@A�"G�B�IAJ~LONQPSR � `Ax_x]���)F"�$C�qSB�N�R-NWVQ@_C�v VWIAuYVQ��u�IKqSXY@_C � m=��Cp`�� g ��N�Jl@�[_NQv�qSB�N�X^C�X^qSX�IAu U @ARSX^qSXY@_C@A��@_C�N�@A��qSB�N�RSJlIAuYu^NWP�NQJML�P!}_@_R=Ly} ��J�NQqSNWP=IAuY@AC�� X^q�R;@APSL�X\qng�u^NnIn[>XYC���IAu^u6@Aq�B�NWP=XYC�X\q�X�IKuOVQ@_C�v�X\q�XY@AC�R��C�VoB�IAC��_NQv6F�h�d LO@>v�} U uYIAC�NQq�IAP-}pIAVWVQPSNQqSXY@_C1RSX^JM��u�I q�XY@AC�R�IAP-Nl��C�@ ��C�qS@�LHNlB�XY�_B�u\} R!q�@>VoB�IAR-qSXYV� ��� +!� g G�B�IKJMLONQPSR�IAC�v 1NQq�B�NWPSX^uYu��nw_w_�!� g�R-@ ��NlIACyq�XYVQX U I q�NWvpqSB�IKq�q�B�N q���@EX^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�R.��RSXYC��q�B�N ��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}EVW@>v�N ��@_��uYv v�X^[ANWPS�ANlIKC�v1�AX^[_N v�X\s�NQPSNQC�q�P-NWRS��u^q�RQF r�IA��XYC���q���@EVnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�R

Page 20: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� `Ax �

t�X^��F:�]F 1 hk��JMLHNWP @A�kRS��P-[>X^[>XYC�� NQJML�P!}_@_R [_NQPSRS��Rlq�X^JlN � @AP h�d$LH@>v�} IAVQVWP-NQq�X^@_C:XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_C�RM@A�

�ecKb U u�IAC�N)qoIAP!}�NQJML�P!}_@_RQg U u^��R ?A� U X^q�NQPWg2XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�NQv ��RSX^C�� q�B�N���X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}1VW@>v�N�IAC�v IpBy}>L�PSX^v

R-}>J U uYNQVQqSXYV.VQ@]v�NKF2m=��Ca`~XYR�X^v�NWCyq�X^VnIAu#q�@ m���Cp��N-��VQN U q�qSB�IKq;@_C�N.NWJML�P-}_@ ��IAR;XYC�X^q�XYIAuYu\}Mv�X^R U uYIAVWNQvLy}p��JlN)q�NWPQF

��X^qSB IAuYJ�@_R!q.XYv�NWCyq�X^VnIAu XYC�X\q�X�IKu�VQ@_C�v�X\q�X^@_C�R�IAu^uY@ ��R.��R.qS@�VW@_J U IAP-N v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQNWR�VnIK��RSNQv1Ly} ��RSXYC��v�X\s�NQPSNWCyqkXYCyq�NQ�_P�I q�XY@AC�IKuY�_@_P-X^qSB�JlR ��X^q�B�q�B�@_RSN�VnIA��RSNWvEL�}�qSB�N�X^C�B�NQPSNWCyqSu^}�VoB�IA@Kq�XYV�C�I q���P-N�@A��RS��VoBVnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�RQFt�X^�_��PSN�� RSB�@ ��R=q�B�N�C���JMLHNWP=@A��P-NWJlIAXYC�X^C�� NWJ~L�P-}A@_R+�7[_NQPSR-��R�q�X^JlN�X^CaqSB�N�f�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�RQF

�;B�N�[KIAuY��NWR @A� � v�X^[ANWP-�_N�IAuYJ�@_R!qMXYJ�J�NWv�XYIKq�NQu^}_g�NWJ U B�IAR-X��WX^C��EqSB�N�v�NW�_P-NWN�q�@ ��B�XYVoB:RS��VoBVnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�RkIAP-N VoB�IA@AqSXYVAF �=@ ��NQ[ANWPQg � v�NQVWP-NnIAR-NWR�XYC I R-XYJ�XYu�IKP=JlIAC�C�NWP�� @_P�NnIAVoB XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C6gXYJ U u\}]X^C��lqSB�IKq�qSB�N IAVWVQPSN)q�XY@ACpP�IKqSNWR ��NQPSN RSX^JlX^u�IAPQF��$C U IAP-qSXYVQ��u�IAPQgOqSB�N v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN LON)q���NQNWC1qSB�NPSNQRS��u\q�R.@K�"qSB�N~q���@�RSXYJ~��u�IKqSXY@_C�R=��RSXYC�� q�B�N ��X^v�N)d L�XYC�IAP-}aVW@>v�NMX^R.VW@AJ U IKP�IAL�u^N�qS@ q�B�N~v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN@A�4NQX^qSB�NWP=RSX^JM��u�I q�XY@AC�� P-@_J q�B�N~PSNQRS��u\q�Rk��RSX^C��lqSB�N~By}>L�PSX^v VW@>v�NKF!�;B�X^R�R-���_�_NQR-q�R=q�B�I q�q�B�N~L�X^C�IAP-}IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J X^R ��@_PS��XYC�����NQuYu�X^CEq�B�XYR.VWIARSNKF �;B�NMq���@�RSX^JM��u�I q�XY@AC�Rk��RSXYC�� q�B�N L�XYC�IAP!}EVQ@]v�NMNWC�v�NWv��X^qSB ` IAC�v c%.�C�IKu U uYIAC�NQqSR�P-NWR U NWV)q�X\[_NWu\}_g ��B�XYuYN�q�B�NMBy}]L�PSXYv>d$VW@>v�N�RSXYJ~��u�IKqSXY@_C U P-@]v���VWNWvpb'.�C�IAuU uYIAC�NQqSRWF �;B�N~R-qSPSX^�>X^C���v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN~LHNQq���NWNWC qSB�N�L�XYC�IKP-}yd$VQ@]v�N�RSX^JM��uYIKq�X^@_C�RWg�v�NWR U X^qSN���R-XYC�� IAuYJ�@_R!q

Page 21: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� `]� �

t�X^��F���F 1 rEIKRSR!d ��NQXY�_ByqSNWvMJ�NnIAC�NWVQVWNQC�qSPSX^VWX^q$}�� @AP h;d$LH@]v]}�IAVWVQPSN)q�XY@AC�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�R�@A���ecKb U u�IKC�NQq�IAP-}

NWJ~L�P-}A@_RWg U u^��R=?A� U X\q�NQPWg�X^C�qSNW�_PSIKq�NQv���RSX^C�� q�B�N ��XYv�N)d$L�XYC�IAP!} VQ@]v�N�IAC�v�IMB�}>L�P-XYvaR-}>J U uYNQVQq�X^V�VW@>v�NAF

m���C `MX^R;XYv�NQC�qSXYVWIAu�q�@�m���C �_g�N �]VQN U q=q�B�I qk@AC�N�NWJML�P!}_@ ��IKR=X^C�X^qSX�IAu^u^} v�X^R U uYIAVWNQv�L�} ��J�NQqSNWPWF

XYv�NWCyq�X^VnIAu6X^C�X^qSX�IAuHVW@AC�v�X^qSXY@_C�RWg�NQJ U B�IARSX\�WNQR=qSB�N�VoB�IA@AqSXYV�C�IKqS��PSN�@A� RS��VoBEVnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�RQFt�X^�_��PSN��.RSB�@ ��R4q�B�N;JlIAR-R!d ��NWX^�_Byq�NQv�J�NnIKC NWVWVQNWCyq�P-XYVQX^q$}��< � @_P�R-��P-[>X^[>X^C���NWJML�P-}_@AR2[ANWP-RS��R4q�X^JlNXYClq�B�N�f�RSXYJ~��u�IKqSXY@_C�RWF �;B�N.NWJML�P-}_@AR;LONQ�yIAC���X^qSB C�NWIAPSu\}lVQXYP-VW��uYIAP�@_P-L�X^qSRWg]IAC�v qSB�NWX^P�NWVQVWNQC�qSPSX^VWX^qSXYNQR

q$} U XYVWIAuYu\} XYC�VQPSNWIARSNQva@�[ANWP�q�X^JlN=v���Nkq�@ VWu^@_RSNkNWC�VQ@_��Cyq�NQPSR=IAC�v�R-NWVQ��u�IAP U NQP-qS��PSL�I q�XY@AC�RWF �;B�N��AP�I U B�Rv�X\s�NQP�� P-@_J @_C�N�IAC�@Kq�B�NQP�IAu^Jl@AR-q;� PS@AJ q�B�N�R-q�IAP-qk@A��qSB�N~VWIAuYVQ��u�I q�XY@AC�RWF �k@ ��NQ[_NQPWg6X^C�NWIAVoB VWIARSNKg��<XYC�VWPSNWIARSNQv � @_PkqSB�N .�P-R-q �nx � }_NWIAPSR�@K��q�B�N~RSXYJ~��u�IKqSXY@_C�gHP-@_���_B�u^}�uYX^C�NnIKPSu^}�X^CEu^@_�lqSXYJ�NAg#q�@�Il[KIAu^��N@A�2P-@_���_B�u\}ax�F\�_F.i�q�qSB�XYR U @AXYCyqng#q�B�N~C>��JMLONQP.@A�2NQJML�P-}A@_R.P-NWJlIAXYC�X^C�� ��IAR��>��X^q�N�RSJlIAuYu gHIAC�v q�B�NRSX^JM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R�v�X^[ANWP-�_NWvp����IAu^X^q�IKq�X\[_NWu\}_g"��X^qSBEq�B�NMBy}]L�PSXYvpVWIARSN~u^}>XYC��lPS@_���_B�u^}aX^CELHNQq���NWNWC q�B�N~q���@RSX^JM��uYIKq�X^@_C�R���R-XYC��aq�B�NlL�XYC�IKP-} VW@>v�NKF �;B�N v�X\s�NQPSNWC�VWNWR�LON)q���NQNWC q�B�N XYCyqSNW�_PSIKq�X^@_C�R���RSX^C���qSB�NL�X^C�IAP-} VW@>v�N~IKPSN�IA�yIAX^C�VW@_J U IAPSIAL�uYN.qS@�qSB�N�v�X^sONWP-NWC�VQN�@A��NWX\q�B�NQP�� P-@_J qSB�N�X^Cyq�NW�AP�IKqSXY@_C���R-XYC�� q�B�NBy}>L�PSX^v6g ��B�XYVoBaRS���_�_NWR!q�R�q�B�I q;q�B�N�L�X^C�IAP-} VW@>v�N�XYR;RS��X^qoIKL�uYN�� @AP�IAVWVQPSNQqSXY@_CaVnIKuYVW��u�IKqSXY@_C�RQF

Page 22: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� `_` �

� � � � ��� �)� ��$C q�B�XYR U I U NQP ��N B�I�[AN v�NQ[>X^RSNWv IAC�v q�NWR!q�NQv q���@�C�N�� R!}]J U u^NWVQqSXYV�XYCyq�NQ�_P�IKqSXY@_CEIAuY�A@_PSX\q�B�J�R

I U�U PS@ U P-X�IKqSN�� @APMh�d LO@>v�} U P-@_L�uYNQJlR�XYC1L�XYC�IKP-} R-q�IAP~R!}]R!q�NQJlRQF �;B�N�C�N���VQ@]v�NQR~� @_u^uY@ � VQuY@_R-NNWC�VW@_��CyqSNWPSR�IAVQVW��PSIKq�NQu^}Ag6IAC�vpR-@ q�B�NQ} VWIAC LHNM��R-NWvpq�@ JlIA�KN h�d LO@>v�}aRSX^JM��u�I q�XY@AC�R�@A� U u�IKC�NQq�IAP-}IAVQVWPSN)q�X^@_C�X^C�L�XYC�IKP-}�R!}]R!q�NQJlRQF;D2IAVoBpIAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J���R-NWRkI�C�N��jRSN)q�@A� VW@>@_P-v�XYC�I q�NWR;qSB�IKq=PSN���NWV)q�RkqSB�NB�X^NWP�IKPSVoB�X^VnIAu#C�IKqS��PSN=@A�3R!qoIAL�uYN U u�IAC�NQqoIKP-} @_P-L�X^qSR"X^ClL�XYC�IAP!} R-q�IAP�R!}>R-q�NQJlRQg���X^qSB @_C�NkVQ@]@_P-v�XYC�IKq�N�RSN)qI U�U PS@ U P-X�IKqSN�� @_P U u�IAC�NQq�R;@APSL�X\q�XYC��MIMRSX^C��_u^N.R-q�IAPWg�IAC�v�q�B�N�@Kq�B�NQP;I U�U P-@ U P-X�IKqSN�� @_P U uYIAC�N)q�R�@_P-L�X^qSXYC��LH@Aq�BpR!qoIAP-RWFM� �"v�NQRSXYP-NWv6g6qSB�N J�NQq�B�@]vp��R-NWv q�@�v�NQPSX^[ANMq�B�NQRSN�IAu^�_@_PSX\q�B�J�R=VW@_��u^vpLON N-�>q�NWC�v�NWv q�@VW@AC�RSX^v�NWP U u�IAC�N)q�R.@APSL�X\q�XYC�� NnIKVoB @K�4q�B�NMR!qoIAP-R�XYCpIlL�XYC�IKP-}_g�@_P U uYIAC�N)qoIAP!}E@_P-L�X^qSR�X^C B�XYNQP�IAP-VoB�XYVWIAuJM��u\q�X U uYN d$R-q�IAP�R!}>R-q�NQJlRQF

?_D"G ��X^RSB�NQR�qS@ q�B�IAC��ph�m;G � @_P U P-XYJlIAP-}�RS� U�U @_P!qng�XYC IKv�v�X^qSXY@_C qS@aZ�D"h=�og3�2�Oi�m;G IAC�vT q�IAPSu^XYC��#F�r ?_Z X^R��_P�IKqSNQ� ��u6� @AP�qSB�N�VW@_Cyq�X^C���XYC�� .�C�IAC�VWXYIAu3RS� U�U @AP-qk@A� qSB�N�h�IKqSXY@_C�IKu T VWX^NWC�VQNWR�IAC�vD4C��_X^C�NWNQPSXYC���m�NWR-NnIAP-VoB G�@A��C�VWX^u4@A��G�IAC�IAv�I]F��;B�XYR ��@_PS� ��IAR�R-� U�U @_P-qSNWv�X^C U IAP!q�L�}phki T i~��R�.PSX^�_XYC�R�@A� T @_uYIAP T }>R!q�NWJ�R m�NWRSNWIAPSVoB �4PS@_�AP�IAJ q�B�P-@_���_B �AP�IACyq�hki���ced$w_�_�_x�IAC�v:Iphki T i��P�IAv���IKq�N T qS��v�NQC�q�m�NWRSNWIAPSVoB�NWPSR��4PS@_�_PSIAJ t�NQuYuY@ ��R-B�X U I���IAPSv�NQv�qS@lD��k�MF

Page 23: D4uYX^R IM MF XYCyqoIAC I - University of Michigan · 2006-07-12 · Z. C VWIAC w_wAb g G B IAJ~LONQPSR $" 1NQq B NWPSX^uYu w_w_ g G IAC U # nw_w_w g mX^[ANWPSI %" 3XYRSRSIA NQP`Kx_x_x!

� `Af �

� ��� � � � � � �

G�IAC�� U gHm�F r F^g#�3NQ[>X^RS@_C6g���F t�F�IAC�v T q�N���IKP-qng � F�m�F\g6��w_wAw�g�i�?�g3�A�e�]g��_xAfG�B�IAJ~LONQPSRWgH?�F�D;FH`Ax_x��Ag��$VnIAP-��RWg��ecA`]g#`Axyc

G�B�IAJ~LONQPSRWgH?�F�D;F3��w_w_w]g#rEh�m�i T g#f_xAb�g#�Kw_f

G�B�IAJ~LONQPSRWgH?�F�D;F#IAC�v �N)q�B�NQPSX^uYu g � F jF\g3��w_w_��g]�$VnIAP-��RWg���fA��g�f_xAb

G�@>VoB�P�IAC�g#ZMF G�F\g���IKq �WNQRWg#i~F�� F\g�*���qSuYNWPQg�m�F ��F#IAC�vErEIAPSV)}_g � F jF���w_wy�]g�i U ?�g�by�Af�g�b�c_�Z.��C�VWIAC6gHr1F ?�F\g#��N)[>XYRS@AC6g���F�t�F\g#IAC�va�3NWNAgOr1F ��F3�nw_w_��g�i.?�g6�_���]g#`Ax_�y�D�[_NQPSB�IAP!q�D�F\g���wA�yc]g6X^C G�IAPS��RSX�i�F^g6�"IAu^RSNQVWVoB�X � F *�F^g�NWv6F\g�Z�}>C�IAJ�XYVWR�@A��G�@_JlN)q�R�2 �;B�NQXYP��.PSX^�_XYC

IKC�vaD4[A@_uY�]q�XY@AC6F�m�NWXYv�NWu g U F6���yc

�k@AuYJlIACar1F ?�F#IAC�v 5XYNW�ANWP-q=��F�i�F3��w_w_w]F�i�?�g3�_���]g��y`>��$v�I i~F\g#��IAP ��@]@>v6g#?�F�IAC�v *���PS�KNWP!qng#i~F\g�i U ?�gHcA`A��g�fyc>���XYC�@ARSB�X\qoI�g ��F\g��"@_RSB�X^v�I�g ��F#IAC�vah�IK�KIKX g ��F3��w_w��_g�G�NWu FHr�NWVoB6FHZ�}>C6F�ikR-q�P-@_C6F\gHcAx�g#cKw�3NQ[>XYR-@_C6g���F t�F�IAC�v�Z.��C�VnIKC6gHr1F ?�F^g3��wAwAb�g��$VWIAPS��RQg���x_��gO���m�X^[_NQP�I�g�D�F ?�FHIAC�va�3XYR-R�IA��NQPWgH?�F ?�gH`Ax_x_x]g�i U ?�gHcKf_x�g�b�c b

T IAB�I���F#IAC�v � P-NWJlIAXYC�N T F^g3�nw_wy`]g]i�?�g3��xAb�g6���_f_f

T IAB�I���F#IAC�v � P-NWJlIAXYC�N T F^g3�nw_wAb�g]i�?�g3��x_�]g6��w_�y`

T qS@]NQP=?�F^g *���uYX^PSRSVoBam�F^g���w_�_x�g��$C�qSPS@>v���V)q�XY@AC�qS@ hk��J�NWP-XYVWIAu6i�C�IAu^}>RSX^RWF T]U PSX^C��_NQP!d �2NQPSuYIA��g�h=N����"@_PS�

5XYNQ�_NWP!qng���F�i�F#IAC�v �k@_u^J IKC6g�r1F ?�F3��w_w_�]g�i�?�g3�A��f�g6�nbAb�c 5XYR-v�@_Jag#?�F�IAC�v,�=@_uYJlIAC6g�r1F3��w_w��Ag�i�?�g3��x_`]g��ecA`A� 5XYR-v�@_Jag#?�F\g �k@_u^J IKC6g�r1F#IKC�v ��@_��JlI�g#?�F\g#t�X^NWuYv�R��$C�R-qWFOG�@_JlJaF\g���x�g�`]�e�

�;B�XYR;JlIAC���R-VWPSX U q ��IKR U PSN U IAPSNQv ��X^qSB�q�B�N�i�i T ��� � D�� J IAVQPS@_R�[>b�F�x�F