d - noufors book ufo files/1950s/1957...project 10073 record -----~-----~-----r---·~ i. da 'te •...

12
. .. . . . . . . . PROJECT 10073 RECORD I. DA 'TE • TIWE GROUP 2. LOCATION 31 December 57 Ol/.043PZ . .- , 3. SOURCE Civilian •· NUMBER OF OBJECTS 10. CONCLUSION D , .._ . . . .. ,, . . J .,. "" IU' . • .• 4\ .L \. One 5. LENGTH OF OBSERVATION 3 - 5 J.at\utes 6. TYPE OF OBSERVATION Ground-Visual 7. COURSE N/ A 8. PH01"0S · - 0 v., )t(No 'r . • .. 9. PHYSICAL EVIDENCE c Yea lt(No 'OAM 11. BRIEF SUMMARY A"O ANAL n 1s The sightil\$ t oc l: · · ·. 1957 and has just hP.en reported the Air Force. ;,j . :. .. 1t· t.oo old to investigate and infonnat.ion p:· ·;: .- .. .·. l ·. ,lsufficient for evalt&ation. •• . . ' . FTO SEP 63 0·329 (TOE) PN•Ioue ••llUOfto of U.ll fora ••v b. u•••l. . I

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jan-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • • •

    . .. . . . . . . . • • PROJECT 10073 RECORD

    ----------------------~------------------------~------------------------------r---·~ I. DA 'TE • TIWE GROUP 2. LOCATION 31 December 57 Ol/.043PZ DulL~ . .- , l· :i n:H~sota

    ~------------------~--~-------------------- · -· 3. SOURCE

    Civilian

    •· NUMBER OF OBJECTS

    10. CONCLUSION

    INSUFFIC~T D ,.._ . . . .. ,, . . J .,. ""IU'l · . • .• -~ 4\ .L \.

    One r---------------------~~--------------------- ------------------------------------~ 5. LENGTH OF OBSERVATION

    3 - 5 J.at\utes 6. TYPE OF OBSERVATION

    Ground-Visual

    7. COURSE

    N/A 8. PH01"0S · -

    0 v., )t(No

    • • 'r . • • ..

    • •

    • • • • 9. PHYSICAL EVIDENCE

    c Yea lt(No

    'OAM

    • • • • •

    11. BRIEF SUMMARY A"O ANAL n 1s

    • •

    The sightil\$ t ocl: · · ·. ~u 1957 and has just hP.en reported +~ the Air Force. ;,j . :. ~ .. 1t· :~s t.oo old to investigate and infonnat.ion p:· ·;: .-.. . ·. l ~- ~ ·.,lsufficient for evalt&ation.

    • •

    • •

    . . ' . •

    FTO SEP 63 0·329 (TOE) PN•Ioue ••llUOfto of U.ll fora ••v b. u•••l. . •

    I

  • • •

    • •

    No Case (Information Only)

    ..

    30 December 1957 Drakestown, N~w Jersey

    ~ther New Jers&Little-man Case, Drakestown., December 30; Jules, hope~ \to qh~k up; soilids proiliis ; little men said to be luminous, and greenl '- ;) - 1

    ~

    • I •

    • •

    • • •

    • •

  • ••

    ••

    • •

    • •

    • • •

    HO r; ...... ,., . .) . • • • HJ}.~ ~ ·:·rn,y .. ,~,· t; .. · · · .... • ~1 r ·, r :.· ' . ....,_ -. .. ' CRAFT Jl .. (~ 1?57

    • •

    8'!0CXir06JC. ~"~'a - .31 t. .. c~~- ·~7 ••• ' ~~~ ~1 • Sredtas =rttc~ ct • ah~iaa cbjeet tra~l1~ on a ap1r•l OG'~- ~~ tM 11oft wa un-dar ex..faastoe at 3wa4e~'•

    · ~- :· ., ,u• he.£iq\U r .-t.:-11 :ic;l.;!a l • · :)• • '=-· &U•¥• ..., f u- aea:;3

    t~ ~. th•t 1t ~i~ht haTe ~~•tb!~~ t o do w :~~ ~r.s ··s

    ' J

  • Jen 1-~ 2 2 2 2 2 ' 2 2 2 3 ~ .., ., -., -'J .J

    4 I.

    I . .:.t-· l. ~

    c: ;

    6 • ,-~

    7 I

    --~ • -~

    \ ;

    ~ ...

    ~ '"' , ""l ., -.:.~ , ...

    • _.__ 1"' -..1

    • 10 -"' • --. ... I .......

    - . -~ - ·- ... .!,

    rJ "": •• -

    • •

    r:Q , J

    • •

    • • • •• •

    Urut:;u~.)-

    R1vet· For~ s · , Il11no1,s untsv11le, Alabema

    • •

    · Sco t 7 A~~, Centralia, Illinois ; illsbor o, Illinois Te chikava, ·rokota, Japan

    . t-roodri'=l.ge, Englanc1 Yosemite, Kentucky N o~ few Orl~ans, Louisiana Boi.:3e, Ida:.o · Housto:1, Texas ·

    • •

    .. . . . .. ·-. •

    ·-of

    · I-:.Dz t.:.~:e .~ r - 1 Jsp~:. - l ' I ' -- -, ., '!'1.. • • ,- '--" "" ~ .:. .. ..- t..:;. - .~ .' • ) .'1 ..L .J:""t; t '":: ., -. ~ ~ •'• r. :'l

    l·:ulti

    :·~111 tar.:: · ( ::is & RADAR) ~-Ulitarj

    Ot'·er (i-1ISI ~"'"mRPFB\A'i ION) i Astro ( 1FJ:t~NUS) · , Insu~ficier-t Data Aircraft Astro ( r-.-i.l1,~d:OR ) Astra ( tvl.~EOR) Insuffic ient Data Astra ( t·sr:'EOH) Insuf!"icient Da1:a

    - ·-

    Ot~:er ( tf.'i'ReLIABU RJ;PORl' ) Ealloon Insufficient Dat.a Aircra: t

    I • ' • I • • ' I I

    ! :i li t at· · '

  • • •

    ' ~ . "!"---" ~ --- ' ' ... - "-=I ) ~' ..:( 'I ( 7 : , ·. 1 ·~ •

    j~-),·1 L~· _ '/z.:-·1~ · >' ··-·-: . ;; ... . ~,,,:} . f_ 1, r· ,..) ,1 1 / I . • • ' • . I 1. ·: ; ' ·: '} 1 9 . . (.. ., :'.' l . l

    . - I_ 7 • VI ·' 'J 1 '17 (' ' I " ~· 1 \ • . ~ ... 1' a ..,:; , ../ ., ) r ·) J~ ' · .,

    :7 , ... ?7~1 ~,.,.: /. y 7,')' qft~ . > • , b1 ., ) 7 ~? ') 7 ...,_ J I

    ' ) "l , I r- ·-' 1 . n .. ~ 'l , - \ rt .

    ( (

    .

    ,I ( /

    / / I

    [ ..

    (

    / ____ .. --

    . t 1 '7 ~; • • ... --- ···-........--- /' ... - -,

    - .... ' • •

    /~ I .. , _..... - . .I

    \ ., •• •

    I

    . t.-1 f rJ ~'V. 'c.J.f·: '17 ~ • .• .,~ ,.,(> \"1:7' .... 1 j A 'f1 .7

    • • · ' • - ,. .J ' .., .. ~ '1 '( ·.' (., I ~.....- ( -, -,•] '1 r-. - . l .. __L..f ! •

    . _c; 't ~· ,_,., 7 ' , 'l ,) .J ':/ • ., "1 :J .., .... 7 I u ·lt I . u '0 ~ 7 .• .i>) . , I ~? }_.~ · 1 !.:J., !?· 1' ~~~7 ;~ , "1 iJ 7 .... ,. ?/_ { I l { 'd ' i!:t b . '\:.) - !. . r; I I /1., '., , ..

    . I 1 -- - -.. . .CJ r.-. ..... t:J . - . i - , ,.., , ... " ' 1 • ., .., ;'\ 1 ; J ~ l . . . .,I .. ; I .. 1 . ., t . . r :,

    tf:. -: ~ ' ' 1' . i' 1 ,., .?9- ~:"1 rQ' , / ' iJ 'f'( 11 .3? 1. ' , , "'-:> 1/.. • . ./ ' · .•

    t.. ,9 b I I' / 7 . ) ·I I . ' . I J·. (7 ( j(V''l'u~ . ~ .) ) ~. • ); 11 ... 1-,l )., ..., .,, , ·1 ' , . ) · ·

    ' •.J.',r. . , . • . - . ·, y ·· I -• !' f/ , ' ' 7 f/ /. J ' I ,• ; . ,... I I 1· ~ . ) ,' 1. 1 , .

  • • • -, ; JL"' (

    \

    fJ~ .

    )t. :l: t ,1: i '/c. ·-

    . ') .c., .t• I~ l < I

    . I. I~ · -·;J t r ·• I t ,J. ' ,. 4 ~/

    ' ,

    .. ,/.. ."· .. (' '' ./il .. ~/ .. t 1/

    ·--. it., L) F , l - • / I I

    '

    • .

    • •

    • •

  • • •

    '

    I •

    • I t

    "

    • •

    • • • .. I I I

    ' t

    ' \ .

    • I ''

    • •

    •I

    ..

    I

    • • • •

    I

    • ..

    ' I

    ' n • •

    ·~ "··

    I • t I i • • • •

    •• • ( I :

    • •

    • • • I

    \ z .. '

    • ,I •

    • - .. . . ... ' .A

    •• . -• • • -;· ·.J ~ ; I (l ••

    • ..

    ' I

    • •

    0 ' I

    I I I

    • • 1 .. .. . I .. I '• I

    I• -·

    • • •' • • r •

    o • I .. • I

    \ .

    h •

    brilliant

    I

    • •

    • I

    • •

    t I ·I ft

    ' tl a ' . 'II . • ltlt oi l ,. lrl oil'

    ~ ,.:r' '· t•-! ••

    l • I\ ' j

    • I .\lol l

    \I,. r 'lt .~t .. ••

    ! ' · ' '~-'''. \ I ' I • 1t1W ,; 1 d · t.

    ' I ' I

    I I

    ,. I I

    ·~ i

    ' . •

    ' •

    I ' ,

    '

    \ I

    ..... ,.

    ·• r

    . '

    ~

    as ..Jtar •

    that

    I • , ·· ,

    \ .

    ' \ • j .I

    .. ~.

    • I "

    I

    .. , .. •

    '

    '"'',. \ .. t I ~ .. . til. I I I '

    j •• I ' I • 1. \ ...... ' ' .

    ' . •• I'

    . ' " . ' . • I 0 • '' .. '

    . ' & I t • '' I • • • ' • t • • ..

    I ' .. ,, ·. hcstt l,. ... , .. , ... , •

    ' u I • t "'* ••• • u , ••••

    "' ' .. ,,.,. ,, • ·:"' t'll l ,·1 1\t

    It '11! ' · 1 IK . put•' .•• .111• .1 .• r•' ' '-' · ' tt ' " ·' • •• , r. , , -''"'•- •ur u ... ,. : '"' ' }t (' : l l•• u• ,.,. , , f \' a~ ' · '" ' l arcar . .. , ·" -..'' ' ' , . ._ , . .\ •• v .. ,, •. I I' I' \'

    I ~ .~ ,,. I ,,. ! ,, . , •• 1·· l , H Ill ·i ( ·. d tb II I . •ht< 1\1• • • II

    1'1 1 .1~' l'll ' " ' I• • • I'':'\ ~.I• \.~ :'r'"''" .

    II IC o tll't , Vl'''

  • • •

    I

    ' I

    : . f

    • 1 ;

    ~

    -' •

    t

    i

    j

    f •

    ..

    'l • .

    I •

    • . . ... . - . • • •

    • • • I

    . ,c tl~ l!o• '- ·H. :: . 1 .. ) II•J !•11hr nl H't Mil n r c 1 .o- p . IU. ~.,.,n f.trt11C'k. ~ • .._c: l ~: d•" l ~. ,, . 11 :llunu u .• ..-, }l, lttt" ~un . .o .lwt one rniiNo.

    '' ,I f IJ brt~t t-t •nll tht nppu.at,. h.& It dark. .:~ . 1 1 ' 1 ll·"'· ~DlM "' ft.t:t 4U.utf'f · . L ~ 1 1 1 •-~ J h ~u hfuc( orw )lour lc r l ST, ·wo h.,.,,.. 1uc } .• \af .-,pn n ~"' u (JUr uc:~un , e tun. ~i5TI ~ ffw• fw ~1· '

    .1 •da the enure bn•ht hemtoq»llett NtDCCl - ·laue •• , '-' 11 111: 1 ,,., u. ltR l • • .. ttf\w11ds. Sin\.e then at haa l~n mt~\int ~e• , • • _ _ ...:__ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1 .a.\d u now 1 clfnin,_ bcr~m die e-Jt tD a"'' (' · · '"" · Thua. ut-ln , ,f i tj ,unlit htfTHAf'htrr. ;, • 1rned ,;w~y, Uhi "~ twve a n~cnt phal('.

    On Jan. ~8 11 Will be. nr-.H I}', .tirec•i~ t l-et-~ u~ Uhl ch~ u.n, and this will. ( ~unapotad to M~ moon. Af~n th-at i t w&ll t l'la:Cme 1 cr~cm apul, Vt.\ihlc tn tbc ( murul' m

    1·_LI. «aky br-tot'~ •uavria.

    1 J

    · II .. e C nH~ltl, t'D~ tS a W!\yt !0 1. (u 3W11' at uuly rilrn~aJrh ;a tel(')o.·~ ~~re • its pili .. .,i.&blc.

    Tlv paa u nf \'tnw t.htler from th~ of t • . " ·' tbt nKal in U)Ut._ taped. . .

    • Tb1t whv • r is ~'' '-"'"""' wtw:tl • cru.

    cmL Alth•IUifll It: ~ tb.~n halt .>t the bt11ht : • ,icJe i1 ,., .. bk UJ '"· ttl!. prvll!mt•~· mme rhAlt aukta up iur tbi.i. Uk.t •.he part we • • ..:an ter tiUt 'tit' l ar~• u~ nc Uw \ky.

    ...

    fhrfl ir i. ~ tt.-: Il~l'lf:$t. br1thanu.. t· ....._ Atelv•

    On~. ~ I tk ~Jn, "'·bi:1• r.o~< .1op:arr nrlv ~n tn.eiinjl .110\HJl•~rd ID t.,~ .J&y U OCt' 'na hnw. rc..< nN ,,., J~M~rhalL'TH~ poinL n,. ia the "inu to lbtk.'t • thr ~c•nntna c~ "'iaeu in the Nonhuu Hanupncr~and u t.:r.un ar 9 :.f'J p. a, £ST •

    .\t ~t mMllenl cht tu11 will h~ clirecdy • wc:r 1 PJ5•1 "''' fhe ea"'l'n :'die ot the "-Dillin. .,hM:b is ia A u.

  • . '

    • • •

    No Case (Information Only)

    _, ... , : .. . : ·. l· · ··,·

    1~8 . T A L E 0 F • I .

    T W 0

    • ' ,. • I . • 0 , • • • •• •

    • • • 1 ~ . .

    • . . ' . - 7 -

    • I . . . .. : ~ .

    D I S C S

    • • .

    16 December 1957 Sao Marcos,

    0 • • • • • I

    • • . • • . 0 !• • t : l . . . 0 . . .. . . . . •

    • • ' • 0 •

    ~ •. . .· . ,. . . . ... ~ . . -.

    • • • • • • • • • . ! . ...

    • • • • . . .

    , .,) no··· remember Dever gas,. that scoutmaster who lived a stra

    Ruppelt wr venture with a

    bout him in Report flying , ·back in 1952? ., . . . . .

    Do you· .. remember what on UF01 s

    ManY passed by since the strange in Florida and it is possi-ble that you recollect all ' details. Some were very strange indeed and no satisfactory · tion has ever been gi ther by Project Blue B~~~ 9.r any

    d:.l·.w~().ffiqial_ . agency, intervi.ewed the ;so ter and .. .inv.es:tiga.ted tha·:.sp.ot where ·---a;· w ird-·maciiirl'~·hiia hov discovering . ~· t the roots of the vegetation on that bl~2~:J,aAfcuJ.~--&~J·.~e~e unacc obly c • Unable to crush the story as told by De-~ . , verges, Ruppel t destroyed the 1 s reputati~on and the whole affair was dis-:,.< missed by official and unoffio stigators as a hoax. The whole story is worth

    reading. The book written by · full of reticences and dubious meanings and . o•.l•'•'\" ' def:L.l.~ .. ..,wi.d~ly a la Ruppel t .. ~ ; ~.~ I. • ..c .. e~ : ~~~~~ ~~ac:t~~~)~roje~t_..Blue Book. ·:: ·· ·:: :: ~~.~· ;.~r:t;· i~o·s~.i ~~.e .. :t ·o :· .. ~~-~ . · lli~ .b~.C?~: ~.'!~ .. 8

  • • •

    • •

    • • • •

    - 8-•

    of 3,5 motors (10 foet) boing on tho oaet sido.

    bctwoon tho highest and lowost edgo of tho ring, tho highest

    . . •l ... .., • • . . .. 0., · · ··~ , •• ,. r ' • # I ' •

    ... . .· . :. . . . 0 \ • • 0 • • • • ~

    .

    .. . . . . . • • • • • • • .. . .

    • • • • • • I •.

    • . . .. .. . ... . ........ ··-. . .. .. . .. . .... . • - · - ••• • • - • 0 •• • ,. •

    ; • • • .. • 0 • • • • • .. • • • • ' • f \ .. . . . .. , " . . .. - ,. .

    ( J .. .. - · I ·' . . :\ . .. . . .. ' ""!• '""· •• . \ .. . . . .. i ~. . . 0 • • • • ' • : o o I '• o . . . , ,· . .~ · . ... ,,, ... , : . ·: 0 • • • • • • • • • • • 0 1" o ' '' J '" ' o I .., . . . . :. . • ~ I ' • • 0 • • • · : ! . ' . . . .. ' . · - ···~- ........ .. ... . - . . . .. · 0 • • • • .. • • • 0 • '

    • • [

    0 • . . .. • • • • • • ,. • • . ,. . .. ~ . . . . . :. .. . . . . . : . . 1 °' 0 • 1' (' # 'o 0 o 0 0 ° o t l' 0 I o ' I ," , l' . .. .··. . , ..

    • f •u ,1 • • 0 .. . J • •• ... "" • ... • . . .. .... .. ~ - • '

    • I I • " • • , • I• ' • • ... ; • • ,., ,._. f r ;, • t ' •• ,,.. '{I• l •. • I ;.-• ' • I • • . . • . . • V \ • • • • .., . .. . .. ~ . · .·~ ·· . , ·· . .

    • • II

    • •

    • • • ... . .

    • • , t , · • • • • . .

    t .... . . . . . . .. ' , .

    . . . • • • t' · ~ ·~ . ., . .. .

    .... • • 0 '\ ' 0 • •

    . l , .. , J. • . . ·• . . ' .. . . . I

    • a. • • : , . • t .. .... ' • ''. • • ~. • J .,. .• ' · '- • ' . J

    I ..... . : . ' . .

    • 0 ... • • ..... .... ... .. .. . . .. : I ' t f 00 \ 0 ,.. f 0 0 . . . . .. . .

    l . . .! • . .. ; • • • • .. • ., • . • ~ ' .• • • : • t : • • • . • ... ... . ··~ •• • • • • .'\ •• :·· . •• . ' •. • •• .•J • • t ~ -: .••• .

    . . . . ...

    , •

  • No Case (Information OnJy) 16 December 1957 Old Saybrook, Connecticut

    . .... .... One of the most unusual s1ght1ngs related to the Two-State UFO

    Study Group for Adults was an encounter in December, 1957 by a retired school teacher, Mrs. l~ary Starr of Old Saybrook, Conn., who reported a closeup sighting of a oigar-shaoed object, having lights, ~indows, and at least four passengers, nhich hovered near her home on this close encounter. Her story, though 'fantaaticT, seems to ring of truth.

    . -.-~

    Little ~en in ~lying Cig~r: That's· Wl1at Teacher Saw

    • By Ralph Chapman Phenomena In Wash ington: t.nd

    Miss Isabel Davis. a member of OLD SAYBROQK. Conn .• Clviltan saucer Intelligence in

    Apr. 26.-Mrs. Mary Starr is a New York school teacher llvini here in NICAP, · as it ts known, Is semi-retirement. She has a dedicated to the idea that the bachelor's derre~ from Mld~le· Alr Force is not giving the bury, a masters degree f1 om public all the lnforma tion it Yale. She has_ta.ught in China should hAVe on "flying saueel's.':'. and Japan as well as the United technically known as "unidentl-States. has traveled widely and ned .ftying objects." Civilian

    1speaks ~everal lan,u:~.ges . Saucer IntelUgence operates r. Th~ lS the story she tot~ as along similar lines but on a (We sa., before a t'rackllni fh e in smaller scale. Both organiza-th~ u,·mr room of her cottaae tions believe that many UFO

    1on Long Island S ound: "sightlna.s" are Interplanetary ' • "I w~! alone that night CDec. vehicles u·hich have approached ~6. , 19;, il so I .went to -nd or landed on the euth • e"_lh~. a~ut. 10 0 clock. Some· Ofncially, the Air Force has t•me b!t\111 een two and three in ne\'er admitted auch a pos· .the mo_ming_. I u·as ~wakened

    5ibillty.

    oy .a bngM l ight in .!"l~ room. 1 }.Jr. Hall put'fcd on a. pipe, loo...ted out the "mdow a nd stretched his legs toward the t i:ere -u·a.s what I n:·st though~ open ~re and charged the Air · \\a s a crippled airplane in m~ Fo:·ce with:

    back gar,~~~~t. Sh S 1. Failing to Investigate all 9... e aw UFO reports .

    . •·:aut "-·hen l got m; _eyes %. Being too supert\ciat 1 reallr open. I saw that it \\as a many cases where It d oes clga r-shaped obJect, brightly

    1 . ti t

    h r. and with square port holes, m es ga e. . bo\'erins abon my clotheN1ne. 3. Refusing to make ti11dmgs I could see three men inside. in specific cases available to An antenna poked up from what Independent investigators. even s~e:ned to be the tail ot this scientists. . ooject. There was no sound. 4. Publlshtng evalua ttons or

    ·'.After about ftve m inutes 1t ''sl~htings" v:hlch do not Jibe tumed at right angle and I with. the available facts. cc.u ld set that it was so shallow "l\nt lnqulry. b:r Conaress that the men could not have NICAP makes its own investl-been more than three .and a halt gations wherever possible and or four teet tall. It ilided out ot Insists that the s·esults are my ~rarden, rose almost ver· at wide variance from those Ucally and then disappeared." reported by the Air Force.

    Aicncles Given Report Immediate objective or the Mrs. Starr described the tn- organization is to get a full-

    cident with no n1ore emotion dress Congre~ional invesU.:-than if she had been telllna gation of the whole subjec~. about the vlslt of a friend. The Longer ra.nge objectives are story was acctpted in the aame "public education" and a t111ly manner by Richard Hall 11nfi sclentitlc atudy or UFOs. a Donald Neill, membel's of the proJect for which NICAP docs staff of the National Investlaa- not have the money at the tlons Committee on Aerial present time. .

    • •• ~ . •

    I I I I

    I

  • • •

    • •

    * * * * * X.~*~·-~~-~11'~~ **.it-~*'!'~··~-~-·-~·~-** **-if.*** -II:*****-~**~~-~ *****-*:*'**·*~··~·*~**:***.!.* _.!"_!0 9 ~=c. 21t 1957 PONTA PORANt BRAZIL (LORENZEN P 138) 6 WITNESSESOO _ _ AA.S . _.l_V.ONNE TORBES O.E ME.ISO.ONCA.t __ HER __ THREE .CHI LDeEN_L .HER . SEBVA~T- MJ ~S J3J:~\)NA t 0 _1_

    0 HER YOUNG. DRIVERt MARCtO GONCALVES • ~ERET 02 RAVELING S_Y _...IEEP __ fRQ~ .J:iE~ _ _EARM. TO THE V lLLAGE OF .J?ONTA PORAN~ IN_ PLACES TH_s_ 03 OAO RAN ALMOST PARALLEL TO THE FRONTIER OF PARAGUAY. LOW-HANGING CLOUDS 04

    - .-VERED_ T.H_E __ Sl(Y_ AND _ __ ~I Gtf.LtLAQ_ .. COM_E EARLY • SUDDENL '( _A_l _ 6 • 30 P_.M • FAR AWAY _ _ TO 05 HE SOUTH, MRS• ' MENDONCA SPOTTED A LARGE BALL OF LIGHT ABOUT THE SIZE OF THE 0~

    ·-~I_T APPEARED TO BE