csss value of the at 2017 · 2014 fall 2014 spring 2015 fall 2015 spring 2016 ... key takeaways •...

59
The Value of the Athletic Trainer: the Dollars, the Lives, the Difference Robert Huggins PhD, ATC Vice President of Research Vice President of Athlete Performance & Safety Yuri Hosokawa PhD, ATC Vice President of Education Vice President of Communication

Upload: others

Post on 02-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

TheValueoftheAthleticTrainer:theDollars,theLives,theDifference

RobertHugginsPhD,ATCVicePresidentofResearch

VicePresidentofAthletePerformance&Safety

YuriHosokawaPhD,ATCVicePresidentofEducation

VicePresidentofCommunication

Page 2: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

“Whatisthemostcriticalthingthatweneedtokeepyouth

athletessafe?”

Page 3: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present
Page 4: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

ProgressingTheValueofTheATTimeline

Spring 2014

Fall 2014

Spring 2015

Fall 2015

Spring 2016

Fall 2016

��

KSI & NFL Meet

KSI and NFL meet. Question is asked“How do we as a nation improvehealth and safety in sport and getAthletic Trainers into schools?”

Insurance Data ObtainedCompanies provide KSIwith claims and injurydata

Value of ATs: Insurance PerspectiveDo ATs help reduce excessliability and medical costs?

NFL Hosts Optimization of Services MeetingAdditional companiesprovide data to KSI

Presence of AT ResultsATs not present during62% of deaths in thesecondary school setting

Value of ATs: Presence of the ATWhat medical coverage ispresent at the time ofsudden death?

NATA Financial SupportBuy in from NATA tosupport insurance project

School districts with Fulltime Ats have 4x lessclaims and 2.5x less $

Preliminary Insurance Results

Page 5: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

TheLivesIsthereanydatathatwecanobtainthatwouldhelptoshowthatAthleticTrainersinHighSchoolssavelives?

Page 6: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

PresenceofAthleticTrainers,EmergencyActionPlans,andEmergencyTrainingattheTimeofSuddenDeathinSecondarySchoolAthletics

• Background:• Currentbestpracticesforthepreventionofsuddendeath(SD)duringsecondaryschoolathleticssuggest:• appropriateon-sitemedicalservices(e.g.athletictrainer)• venue-specificemergencyactionplans(vEAP)• basicemergencytrainingforcoaches

• NocomprehensiveretrospectiveanalysisofSDcasesinthissettinghasinvestigatedifappropriateon-sitemedicalserviceswereprovided,ifvEAPwerepresentandfollowed,orifcoachesutilizedtheiremergencytraining.

Page 7: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Purpose&Methods• Purpose:ToexaminecasesofSDduringsportatthesecondaryschoollevelanddescribeappropriatemedicalservices,emergencyplanning,andemergencytrainingatthetimeofthedeath.

• PatientorOtherParticipants:• Secondaryschoolswhoexperiencedasport-relatedSDduringatrainingorcompetitionsession

• NationalCenterforCatastrophicSportInjuryResearchdatabasefrom8/1/2000-7/31/2013.

• Representativesemployedatthetimeofdeathorwithextensiveknowledgeofthedeathwereaskedtoparticipate.

Page 8: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

SecondarySchoolsfromNCCSIRDatabasefrom2000-2013

(n=279)

SecondarySchoolsResponding(n=134)

RefusaltoParticipate(n=16,12%)

Noknowledgeoftheevent(n=42,31%)

SecondarySchoolsIncluded(n=76,57%)

AthleticDirectors(n=67)

Principals(n=3)

Coaches(n=3)

AthleticTrainers(n=2)

Secretary(n=1)

ParticipationBreakdown

Page 9: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AppropriateMedicalPersonnelAreNotPresentAtAMajorityOfSuddenDeaths

• 62%(n=42)ofthesuddendeathsatthesecondaryschoolsdidNOThaveathletictrainingservices.

• Nomedicalservicesofanykindwerepresentat42% (n=32) ofthedeaths.

• ATswereemployedin61%(n=46)oftheschools,butnotpresentfor27%(n=17)ofthedeaths.

Page 10: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

VenueSpecificEAPs(vEAPs)• OverallvEAP Presence

• 66%(n=50)ofschoolshadvEAPs inplace• 44%(n=26)ofschoolsdidNOThavevEAPs inplace

• OfschoolswithAthleticTrainingservices(n=46)• vEAPs werepresentin74%(n=34)oftheschools• vEAPs werenotpresentin26%(n=12)oftheschools

• WhenvenuespecificEAPswereinplace,itwasfollowed100%ofthetime!• ThosewithoutvEAPs inplace(n=26),38%(10/26)remaintodaywithoutavEAP!

Page 11: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

EmergencyTraining

• Insuddendeathcases78%(n=59)ofcoachesreceivedemergencytraining

• Thistrainingwasappliedin58%(n=34)ofdeaths

Page 12: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

KeyTakeaways• 62%ofthedeathsdidnothaveappropriateon-siteathletictrainingservicespresent.• Medicalserviceswerenotpresentin42%ofSDcases.• WhenvEAP wereinplace,theywerefollowed.• AlthoughmedicalpersonnelandvEAP werepresentin~60%ofcases,thedeathwasnotprevented.• Detailedcase-specificinformationtoidentifyunderlyingmedicalcauseofdeathandopportunitiesforimprovingpreventionandcareproceduresareneeded.

Page 13: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

TheDifferenceWhatpercentageofschoolshaveATs?HowareAthleticTrainingservicesimprovingthroughoutthecountry?Wherecanwemakeadifference?

Page 14: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present
Page 15: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

November2016 March2017

Page 16: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present
Page 17: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present
Page 18: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Purpose(s):

1. Createareal-timedatabaseofathletictrainingservicesinsecondaryschools

2. Createadirectoryforeachstate’sathletictrainingassociationandhighschoolathleticsassociation

3. Assiststatesinmovingtowardfull-timeathletictrainingservices4. Provideusefuldatatoeachstate’sathletictrainingassociationandhigh

schoolathleticassociation5. Identifycommonfactorsassociatedwithincreasedathletictraining

servicesacrossthecountry.6. Improvethedeliveryofhealthcareservicesviaimprovedcommunication

betweensecondaryschools

Page 19: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

DataAcquisitionProcess

ATLASMasterDatabase

1.NATABenchmark StudyDatabase

• Originaldatabase• Called 24,000schoolspublic&private• ~50%responseratenationwide• Upto4yrs old

2.NationalCenterforEducationStatisticsDatabase

• FederalReporting• Title1,students,teacher:student ratio• Locale:urban,suburban

3.IndividualStateData• ProvidedbySSCChair• StatefilesarerefinedwithhelpfromSSCmembers

• Mergedwithmasterdata

4. ATLASSurvey• Marketing• Twitter,Facebook,NATAROM,NATANews

• WordofMouth• DistrictMeetings• PhoneCallswithStateLeaders• ProgramDirectors• EmailstoAT StatePresidents

Mergedwith

PastProcess

CurrentProcess

Mergedwith

Page 20: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

ATLASProjectWebofConnectivity

NATASSC•StrategicInitiatives

•ATValueModel•SafeSportSchools

StateATAssoc.

•Legislative•Healthcare•Communication

StateHighSchoolAthAssoc.

• SafetyPolicies• Improvemedservices

NATA&NFL

InsuranceProject•ATServices

AnalysisStatePolicyJustification

AssistotherAssociations• AMSSM• StateHSAssoc• NFHS

AT ServicesInNeedBasedAreas• Title1Schools

MarketingCompanies• Gatorade• J&J

ATLASProvides:1. ComprehensiveListofAT

Services2. Evidencetosupportbest

practiceimplementation(EAPs)

3. Sportscovered4. Physiciansupervision5. Physiciancredentials6. ATcredentials/licensure7. AThiringtrends(overtime)8. ThresholdsforFTandPT9. ComparisonsbetweenFT&

PT10. DirectoryforATs

Page 21: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

SummaryPoints(30,000ft view)

• 2016-2017PrimaryGoals• Removeallunknownschools(blackdots)ineachstateontheATLASmaps• Getto8,000surveysbyJune2017

• ATLAS“Mapping”isshowinggreatprogress:• June=14,888àDec=11,752àMar=15,973• Overall%Mapped:June=44%à Dec=53%àMar=71%

• ATLASSurveycontinuestoshowgreatprogress:• June2016(5Ksurveys)àDec2016(6,600Ksurveys)àMarch2017(7,000surveys)

• ThesuccessofATLASProjecthingesupon:• completionofthesurveys• assistancewithmappingbykeyleadersatthestateanddistrictlevel

• KSIhasreachedouttoeachstate’sSSCmemberforassistance

Page 22: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

ATLASResultsAsOf6:45amToday• 71%ofthenation’shighschoolsaremapped(n=15,973/22,589)

• 43%ofschoolswithATserviceshavecompletedthein-depthATLASsurvey(n=4,828/11,282)

• 50%ofschoolshaveathletictrainingservices(n=11,282/22,589)

Overall:• 27%ofschoolshaveFullTimeservices(n=6,022/22,982)• 23%ofschoolshavePartTimeservices(n=5,260/22,982)• 21%ofschoolshaveathleticswithNOATservices(n=4,770/22,982)• 29%ofschoolremainunknown(n=6,509/22,589)

Page 23: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

HowareAthleticTrainershiredNationally?

NATAAbstract2017EmploymentofAthleticTrainersInSecondarySchools:TheATLASProject

Objective:ToquantifycurrentemploymentprovidersofATservicesinthesecondaryschoolsettingnationwide.

Results:27%EmployedSchoolDistrictEmployee16%SchoolDistrictEmployeeTeacher51%Medical/UniversityEmployee6%IndependentlyContracted

Page 24: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

• Background• Previousresearchofsecondaryschooladministratorshasdeterminedthat:

• 70%ofpublicschoolshaveaccesstoanAT• 58%ofprivateschoolsnationwidehaveaccesstoanathletictrainer.• 37%ofpublicreportedhavingfulltimeATservices• 28%ofprivateschooladministratorsreportedhavingfulltimeATservices.

• Howeverspecificinformationreportedfromathletictrainersregardingtheirspecificemployerhasnotbeendocumented.

Page 25: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Methods• Objective:ToquantifycurrentemploymentprovidersofATservicesinthesecondaryschoolsettingnationwide.• Design: Longitudinal,survey-basedquestionnaire.• Setting: Public,private,charter,magnet,specialeducationandalternativesecondaryschoolsintheUnitedStates.• Participants:Secondaryschool certified athletictrainers.• Interventions: SecondaryschoolATscompletedanonlinequestionnairefromJune2015toNovember2016.

Page 26: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

FullTimevs.PartTime• Full-timeservicesweredefinedasallofthefollowing:

• ATservicesprovidedtoonly1school• ³5daysperweek• ³30hoursperweek• ³10monthsperyear.

• Part-timeservicesweredefinedasanythinglessthanFT.• Athletictraineremploymentstatuswascollectedandsplitintofourcategories:• schooldistrictemployees(SDE)• schooldistrictemployeeswithteachingresponsibilities(SDET)• medicaloruniversityfacilityemployees(MUE)• independentcontractors(IC).

Page 27: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Results• Athletictrainers(n=3836)from50statesandoneprovincerespondedtothesurvey.• 81%(n=3136/3836)workedinpublicschools• 16.69%(n=627/3836)inprivateschools• 1.9%(n=73/3836)incharter,magnet,specialeducationandalternativeschoolscombined.

Employer• 27%(n=1052/3836)ofathletictrainersareSDE• 16%(n=630/3896)areSDET• 51%(n=1965/3836)areMUE• 5%(n=189/3836)areIC.

Page 28: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Results• 43%employedbytheschooldistrict(SDE+SDET)• 57%whileamajorityofathletictrainerswerenotemployedbytheschooldistrict(MUE+IC)• 76%(n=2918/3836)ofathletictrainersreportedworkingFT.

• OftheFTathletictrainers,31%(n=908/2918)wereSDE,• 18%(n=515/2918)wereSDET• 48%(n=1389/2918)wereMUE• 3%(n=97/2918)wereIC.

• 24%oftheathletictrainersreportedworkingPT• 16%(n=144/917)wereSDE• 12%(n=115/917)wereSDET• 62%(n=576/917)wereMUE• 10%(n=92/917)wereIC

Page 29: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

KeyFindings• AthletictrainersemployedbyamedicaloruniversityfacilitytoprovideATservicestothesecondaryschoolwasthemostcommon,followedbyemploymentthroughtheschooldistrictwithoutteaching,schooldistrictwithteachingresponsibility,andindependent.• Nationally,itismorecommonforanATtobehiredfromanoutsidesource(MUE+IC)thanbytheschooldistrict(SDE+SDET).• Thesedatawillenhanceknowledgeofandidentifycurrentemploymentmethodsforschooldistricts/organizationslookingtohigheranATinthehighschoolsetting.

Page 30: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

TheDollarsWhatisthevalueoftheathletictrainerfromtheinsuranceperspective?

Page 31: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Entity State&SchoolDistrict Parent InsuranceProviderAssociatedCosts

• CatastrophicPremium(StateCost)

• LiabilityPremium(SchoolDistrict)

• ExcessMedicalPremium(SchoolDistrict)

• Co-pays• %ofmedicalcarecostfor

specialist• %ofmedicationcost

• %ofclaims(Dependingonplan)

• Operating/processingclaimscost

Goals&Expectations

• Reducepremiumcost• Decreasespending• Minimizeliability• Improvesafety• Reducecostto

parent/community

• Reduceout-of-pocketspending.• Haveschooltopayif

liable• SafeEnvironmentfor

children

• Providecoveragebasedonexpectedmedicalcosts/risk

• Reducenumberofclaimspaidout

• Claimsnottoexceedpremium/limitsofcoverage

PositiveBenefitsofanAthleticTrainer

• Reducepremiumcostfor• LiabilityInsurance?• ExcessMedical?• Catastrophic?

• Decreasedschoolliability• Improvedsafety&athlete

care• Compliancewithleague

recommendations• Decreasedcosttoparent

• Decreasedunnecessarycostsfor:

• VisitstoER• Emergencytransport• Rehabilitativecostsfor:

• PreandPostsurgery

• Decreasednumberofunnecessaryclaimsfor:Excessmedical,catastrophic,liability?

• Decreasedlevelofriskatschool=lesslikelytohavepreventablecatastrophicclaim?

Page 32: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Goals

SchoolDistrict

Reducepremiumcost

Decreasespending

Minimizeliability

Improvesafety

Reducecost toparentandcommunity

Parent

Reduceout-of-pocketspending

Haveschoolpaythecost,ifliable

Safeenvironmentforchildren

InsuranceProvider

Providecoveragebasedonexpectedmedicalcostandrisk

Reducenumberofclaimspaidout

Claimsnottoexceedpremiumorlimitsofcoverage

Page 33: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Hypothesis

• Preventable(unnecessary)numberofsecondaryinsuranceclaimsareobservedinschoolswithnoathletictrainingservice.• Anydifferencebetweenfulltimevs.parttimevs.noservice?

Page 34: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Methods

• Datafromtwosecondaryathleticsinsurancecompanies• Claimsdatawithdetailsonthemedicalserviceprovided• CompanyA:August,2010- July,2015(i.e.,4academicyears)• CompanyB:August,2012- July,2014(i.e.,2academicyears)

• AthletictrainingservicedatafromATLAS• DatafromwhatwasreportedbyJanuary,2017

Page 35: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Sampling• Datafrom476insurancepolicyholders• 22states

• 32%ofthedataarefromPennsylvania• 26%ofthedataarefromNewJersey

• CompanyA• Fulltime:233• Parttime:83• None:111

• CompanyB(alldatafromPennsylvania)• Fulltime:44• Parttime:6

Table1.SampleDemographics

FullTime PartTime NoneAR 5 1 8CT 13 36 2DE 5 2 0FL 1 0 4GA 2 3 5IN 1 0 0KS 1 0 0KY 3 2 14LA 2 10 1MA 4 2 8MO 0 0 1MS 0 1 11NC 0 2 3NJ 109 2 12NY 0 0 1OH 0 0 2PA 112 18 21SC 14 7 13TN 0 1 1TX 4 2 1VA 0 0 2WV 0 0 1Total 276 89 111

AthleticTrainingServiceNumberofPolicyHolders

Page 36: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Overview• Ambulance

• Anesthesia

• Dentalinjury

• Diagnostic/image/labtests

• Emergencyroom

• Equipment/supplies

• Injection

• Prescription

• Outpatient

• Physician

• Rehabilitation/treatment

• Specialistconsultation

• Surgery

AverageNumberofServiceClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

AverageCostPaidperPolicyHolder

FullTime 498.42 $78,027.06PartTime 532.28 $72,090.55None 629.24 $104,403.69

AverageNumberofServiceClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

AverageCostPaidperPolicyHolder

FullTime 54.32 $39,063.13PartTime 161.667 $38,829.45

CompanyB:2academicyearscumulative

CompanyA:4academicyearscumulative

Page 37: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:CompanyA• Ambulance

• Anesthesia

• Dentalinjury

• Diagnostic/image/labtests

• Emergencyroom

• Equipment/supplies

• Injection

• Prescription

• Outpatient

• Physician

• Rehabilitation/treatment

• Specialistconsultation

• Surgery

• Ambulance

• Emergencyroom

• Diagnostic/image/labtests

• Rehabilitation/treatment

• Anesthesia

• Injection

• Surgery

• Dentalinjury

• Equipment/supplies

• Prescription

• Outpatient

• Physician

• Specialistconsultation

ACUTECARE

SURGICALPROCEDURE

DIAGNOSISANDMANAGEMENT

PHYSICIANANDSPECIALISTVISIT

Page 38: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:AcuteCare

Ambulance,1.8

Ambulance,1.8

Ambulance,1.7

EmergencyRoom,8.34

EmergencyRoom,6.29

EmergencyRoom,10.11

0 5 10 15

None

PartTime

FullTime

AverageNumberofAcuteCareClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 39: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:AcuteCare

Ambulance$142.08

Ambulance$186.68

Ambulance$235.88

EmergencyRoom$118.86

EmergencyRoom$84.31

EmergencyRoom$100.00

$0.00

$50.00

$100.00

$150.00

$200.00

$250.00

FullTime PartTime None

MedianClaimCost

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 40: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:SurgicalProcedure

Anesthesia 10.83

Anesthesia 10.17

Anesthesia 7.85

Injection 3.06

Injection 3.46

Injection 2.38

Surgery 45.31

Surgery 41.88

Surgery 32.3

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

None

PartTime

FullTime

AverageNumberofSurgicalProcedureClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 41: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:SurgicalProcedure

Anesthesia$131.76 Anesthesia

$115.74

Anesthesia$135.52

Injection$17.77 Injection

$7.32

Injection$21.97

Surgery$205.00

Surgery$167.00

Surgery$176.99

$0.00

$50.00

$100.00

$150.00

$200.00

$250.00

FullTime PartTime None

MedianClaimCost

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 42: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:DiagnosisandManagement

Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,81.85

Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,69.51

Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,60.85

RehabilitationandTreatment,280.4

RehabilitationandTreatment,209.46

RehabilitationandTreatment,201.56

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

None

PartTime

FullTime

AverageNumberofDiagnosisandManagementClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 43: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:DiagnosisandManagement

Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,$36.00 Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,

$33.98Diagnosis,Image,LabTests,

$34.39

RehabilitationandTreatment,$31.03

RehabilitationandTreatment,$30.00

RehabilitationandTreatment,$40.00

$0.00

$10.00

$20.00

$30.00

$40.00

$50.00

FullTime PartTime None

MedianClaimCost

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 44: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:PhysicianandSpecialistVisit

DentalInjury4.02

DentalInjury4.59

DentalInjury3.78

EquipmentandSupplies,28.77

EquipmentandSupplies,29.1

EquipmentandSupplies,24.61

Prescription5.79

Prescription3.53

Prescription3.08

Outpatient,27.5

Outpatient,25.49

Outpatient,30.57

Physician,125.48

Physician,123.98

Physician,110.2

SpecialistConsultation0.95

SpecialistConsultation0.45

SpecialistConsultation2.33

0 50 100 150 200

None

PartTime

FullTime

AverageNumberofPhysicianandSpecialistVisitClaimsSubmittedperPolicyHolder

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 45: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:PhysicianandSpecialistVisit

DentalInjury$93.50

DentalInjury$92.00

DentalInjury$75.04

EquipmentandSupplies$45.23 EquipmentandSupplies

$40.00

EquipmentandSupplies$41.37

Prescription$10.00

Prescription$10.00

Prescription$14.99

Outpatient$120.00

Outpatient$220.61

Outpatient$217.55

Physician$44.00

Physician$40.00

Physician$43.25

SpecialistConsultation$101.97

SpecialistConsultation$45.00

SpecialistConsultation$152.42

$0.00

$50.00

$100.00

$150.00

$200.00

$250.00

FullTime PartTime None

MedianClaimCost

FULLTIME:233PARTTIME:83NONE:111

Page 46: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Limitations

• Notalltypesofinjurieshappenatconstantrateforallschools• Ouranalysisistheaverageoffouracademicyears

• Noinformationonprimaryinsuranceclaims• Analysisperpolicyholder(schooldistrict)notbyindividualschool

Page 47: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Conclusions• Four-yeardataoninsurancedatademonstratedthatthenumberofclaimsandaveragecostwerehighestinschoolswithnoathletictrainer.

• Frequenciesofaverageserviceclaimswerelowestinfulltimewhentheserviceswererelatedto(1)surgicalprocedure,(2)diagnosisandmanagement,(3) physicianandspecialistvisit.

• Highestnumberwasobservedinfulltimeforacutecarerelatedserviceclaims,probablyduetotheenhancedrecognitionofinjuriesthatwarrantfurthercare.

Page 48: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Ambulance

Exertionalillness30%

Concussion22%

Dehydration22%

Fracture11%

Anaphylaxis3%

Asthma3%

Dentalinjury3%

Headtrauma3% Laceration

3%

FULLTIME

359/395casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion43%

Dehydration29%

Dentalinjury9%

Exertionalillness14%

Other5%

PARTTIME

129/150casesunknowndiagnosis

Exertionalillness43%

Concussion28%

Fracture29%

NONE

182/196casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 49: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Anesthesia

Fracture48%

ACLtear21%

Dentalinjury11%

Pain

5%

FULLTIME

1790/1827casesunknowndiagnosis

Dentalinjury27%

ACLtear20%

Fracture20%

Dislocation13%

Concussion6%

Fracuture7%

Subluxation7%

PARTTIME

829/844casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture34%

ACLtear13%Dentalinjury

13%

Dislocation13%

Exertionalillness13%

Concussion7% Meniscus

tear7%

NONE

1187/1202casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 50: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

Fracture30%

Concussion28%

ACLtear15%

Dentalinjury6%

PARTTIME

Concussion37%

Fracture21%

Dentalinjury12%

Sprain/strain9%

Exertionalillness8%

NONE

AnalysisbyService:Diagnostic/Image/LabTests

Fracture35%

Concussion32%

Sprain/strain5%

FULLTIME

13807/14174casesunknowndiagnosis 5632/5769casesunknowndiagnosis 8969/9085casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 51: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:EmergencyRoom

Dentalinjury29%

Concussion27%

Laceration16%

Fracture12%

Exertionalillness8%

FULLTIME

2242/2354casesunknowndiagnosis

Dentalinjury34%

Concussion24%

Exertionalillness12%

Fracture12%

Dehydration9%

PARTTIME

489/522casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion40%

Dentalinjury29%

Laceration12%

Fracture10%

Exertionalillness7%

NONE

884/926casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 52: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Equipment/Supplies

Fracture47%

ACLtear18%

Sprain/strain10%

Dislocation8%

Concussion6%

FULLTIME

5617/5733casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture46%

Concussion28%

ACLtear16%

PARTTIME

2365/2415casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture65%

Sprain/strain18%

Concussion5%

NONE

3171/3194casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 53: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Injection

Dentalinjury40%

ACLtear20%

Concussion20%

Dislocation20%

FULLTIME

550/555casesunknowndiagnosis

Menisuctear78%

Fracuture11%

Subluxation11%

PARTTIME

278/287casesunknowndiagnosis

Exertionalillness50%

Meniscustear50%

NONE

336/340casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 54: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Prescription

Concussion29%

Paralysis25%

Dentalinjury18%

Infection12%

Fracture10%

ACLtear6%

FULLTIME

666/717casesunknowndiagnosis

Dentalinjury62%

ACLtear15%

Internalbleeding15%

Concussion8%

PARTTIME

280/293casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture38%

Dentalinjury31%

Infection25%

Exertionalillness6%

NONE

627/643casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 55: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Outpatient

Concussion38%

Fracture22%

Dentalinjury7%

Laceration6%

Exertionalillness6%

Sprain/strain5%

FULLTIME

6858/7118casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion32%

Dentalinjury17%Exertional

illness10%

Fracture10%

Laceration9%

Sprain/strain8%

PARTTIME

2016/2116casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion32%

Dentalinjury14%

Laceration13%

Fracture10%

Exertionalillness7%

ACLtear5%

Overuse5%

Dehydration5%

NONE

2942/3052casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 56: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Physician

Concussion64%

Fracture10%

ACLtear5%

FULLTIME

24727/25665casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion59%

Fracture10%

ACLtear8%

Dentalinjury7%

PARTTIME

9977/10290casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion59%

Fracture7%

Sprain/strain7%

Dentalinjury6%

NONE

13647/13928casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 57: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Rehabilitation/Treatment

ACLtear31%

Sprain/strain21%

Concussion20%

Fracture9%

FULLTIME

46044/46958casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture25%

ACLtear21%

Concussion16%

Sprain/strain9%

Tendonitis7%

Separation7%

Dislocation5%

Meniscustear5%

PARTTIME

17052/17385casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion22%

Overuse21%

Fracture18%

Sprain/strain12%

Pain

6%

Dentalinjury6%

ACLtear5%

NONE

30940/31124casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 58: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:SpecialistConsultation

Concussion63%

Fracture11%

Laceration11%

Dentalinjury5%

Dislocation5%

Sprain/strain5%

FULLTIME

524/543casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion100%

PARTTIME

32/37casesunknowndiagnosis

Concussion100%

NONE

104/105casesunknowndiagnosis

Page 59: CSSS Value of the AT 2017 · 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2015 Fall 2015 Spring 2016 ... Key Takeaways • 62% of the deaths did not have appropriate on-site athletic training services present

AnalysisbyService:Surgery

Fracture45%

ACLtear13%

Dentalinjury11%

Sprain/strain9%

Laceration7%

Dislocation5%

FULLTIME

7359/7524casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture38%

ACLtear16%

Dentalinjury15%

Meniscustear9%

Concussion6%

Dislocation6%

Fracuture5%

PARTTIME

3395/3476casesunknowndiagnosis

Fracture36%

Dentalinjury20%

Overuse19%

Laceration10%

NONE

4952/5029casesunknowndiagnosis