cross-language access to information and practical applications: the macs solution patrice landry
DESCRIPTION
Cross-Language Access to Information and Practical Applications: The MACS Solution Patrice Landry Head, Subject Indexing Swiss National Library. Outline. Various solutions for multilingual subject access What is MACS From Prototype to a Production database - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Cross-Language Access to Information and Practical Applications: The MACS
Solution
Patrice LandryHead, Subject IndexingSwiss National Library
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Outline
• Various solutions for multilingual subject access
• What is MACS• From Prototype to a Production database• Moving into production (or how to move an
international cooperative project into a library)• The (New) MACS Project
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Introduction• Goal of the presentation is to give an overview of
MACS (as one solution to multilingual subject access)• The MACS project as an international project and the
difficulties in moving to an operational phase• Moving from a theorical framework to a practical
application
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Solutions for multilingual subject access - Construction
approaches- Translation (RVM, MESH)- Satellite thesauri approach (linking various online
thesauri) – with a common search interface- Switching (Renardus)- Direct mapping (equivalences between terms in
different controlled vocabularies or between terms and classification numbers)
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Solutions for multilingual subject access – Methods used for link
storage and access
• Authority records (equivalences coded in a local or networked database): RVM, MSAC
• Links database: MACS• Semantic Network (organised structure where each
unit is linked to a cluster of equivalent terms): UMLS
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Why the MACS approach?
• In 1997, the need to find a « neutral » solution for linking SHLs forced libraries to find a solution not based on translation
• Approach to add value to existing data instead of creating new data (value added data)
• Linking work and management outside of each library’s authority files
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Short reminder: What is MACS
• A project that is developing a system that offers multilingual subject access using current subject headings languages (SHLs)
• A project that is based on a coordinated approach between national libraries
• A system that will permit users to search library catalogues in the language of their choice
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
MACS Basic principles
• Equality of languages and SHLs (no pivot) with autonomy of each SHL (only local, MACS is an external link database)
• Establishment of equivalences (no translation) between the SHLs involved (no new thesaurus)
• Equivalence links conceived as concept clustersMACS = mappings and numeric identifiers
• Consistency of results (goal = users retrieval)• Extensible to other SHLs
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Sachkatalogisierung und Schlagwortsuche in einer einsprachlichen Umgebung
Sachkatalogisierung und Schlagwortsuche in einer einsprachlichen Umgebung
Der Benutzer muss die Suche in deutscher Sprache durchführen
Dok. in Russisch
Dok. in Russisch
EnglischeSchlagwörter
EnglischeSchlagwörter
ItalienischeSchlagwörter
ItalienischeSchlagwörter
Dok. in Französisch
Dok. in Französisch
Dok. in Deutsch
Dok. in Deutsch
Dok. in Englisch
Dok. in Englisch
Französische Schlagwörter
Französische Schlagwörter
Indexierer deutschsprachi
g
Benutzer (englischsprachig) ?? ??
Deutsch Schlagwörter
Deutsch Schlagwörter
?
Der Indexierer vergibt deutsche Schlagwörter
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Sachkatalogisierung und Schlagwortsuche in einer mehrsprachlichen Umgebung
Sachkatalogisierung und Schlagwortsuche in einer mehrsprachlichen Umgebung
Der Indexierer vergibt deutsche SchlagwörterDer Benutzer kann die Suche in englischer Sprache durchführen
Dok. in Russisch
Dok. in Russisch
DeutscheSchlagwörter
DeutscheSchlagwörter
Italienische Schlagwörter
Italienische Schlagwörter
Dok. in Französisch
Dok. in Französisch
Dok. in Deutsch
Dok. in Deutsch
Dok. in Englisch
Dok. in Englisch
Französische Schlagwörter
Französische Schlagwörter
Indexierer deutschsprachig
Benutzer (englischsprachig)
Die Schlagwörter aus verschiedenen Sprachen sind untereinander durch Links verbunden
Englische Schlagwörter
Englische Schlagwörter
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Milestones
• Proposal & Feasibility study (1997-1999)• Prototype development (2000-2001)
• Specifications for developing the prototype in a productive system (LMI-II) (January-March 2002)
• Various releases and testing of the LMI-II (10 releases) (April 2002-March 2005)
• Formal letter acceptance of the LMI to Tilburg University (January 2005)
• New Project Proposal: June 2005
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
From Prototype to a Production LM database
• Feedback from guest users re-inforced the value of MACS approach
• Improvements based on prototype tests• MACS LM approach based on organisational
principles
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
MACS organisational principles• Partners share equal responsibility for link
authorisation: no central editor• Each partner is responsible for validating
links proposed to their own SHL• Partners may make proposals concerning any
other parts of the link (but must be confirmed by the responsible partner)
• All partners may comment links (annotations)
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Short overview of the Link management database and search
interface• The project has produced a Link Management
Database which presently contains:
- 30’000 RAMEAU-LCSH links and 3’000 RAMEAU / LCSH / SWD links
• A search Interface that was developed as part of the prototype and will be fully developed as part of the MACS development
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Moving into production (or how to move an international project into
a library)• The « project syndrome » is a common occurance in
international projects: succesful projects but difficulties in moving to production or applying results generally
• The MACS project accomplished many tasks with a lot of enthusiasm (and human resources, and a little money) but ….
• The longer a project exists, the more there is the risk of staff turnaround and the decrease of institutional committment to the project
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
The four MACS Project constraints
• Consortium agreement• Financing • Human resources• Strategic
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
The solution: A new project proposal
• A new project structure with roles and responsabilities (project and within each partner’s institution)
• A project manual with specific action plan• A strategic plan (operational and development)• To be discussed with partners at the end of
September 2005
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Current activities (SNL)
• Internal project to investigate:- link creation tactics & support for adding SWD headings by translation students from the Geneva University- drafting MACS linking manual for ensuring consistent linking approach
• Start of linking work process (adding and validating SWD terms) by staff of the Subject indexing service (September 2005)
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Future
• Investigate the possibility of integrating MACS in TEL as one of the multilingual options
• Possible funding in Germany for links creation• Cooperation with MSAC• Find new SHLs and partner• AND more importantly, implement action plan
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Topics for the workshop
• Explain the organisation and work process of the Link management database with linking examples
• Show how subject searches can be done in a library database (Helveticat database of the Swiss National Library
ODOK’05 - Workshop der VÖB-Kommission für Sacherschliessung
Bozen, September 13, 2005
Sc h
we i
z eri s
c he
L an d
e sb i
b li o
t hek
Contacts
• http://macs.cenl.org