cross-calibration results from observations of the ins rx ... · euve. vadim burwitz epic cal/ops,...

22
Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX J1856 RX J1856, and the WDs HZ 43 HZ 43 and Sirius B Sirius B Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS May 4-5 2006, MPE

Upload: others

Post on 16-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Cross-calibration results from observations of the

INS RX J1856RX J1856, and theWDs HZ 43HZ 43 and Sirius BSirius B

Vadim Burwitz

EPIC CAL/OPS May 4-5 2006, MPE

Page 2: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Overview Absolute Calibration Soft X­rays                                      dependant on model spectra of WDs                                          what models to use?, uncertainties?

 Analyse LETG + HRC­S data HZ 43A, Sirius B and RX J1856.5­3754                                       determine spectral parameters                                      improve effective area. 

 Compare obtained photon spectra with EUVE and ROSAT                                               and XMM (work by Frank Haberl)                

Page 3: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Overview

Page 4: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

NLTE pure H model spectrum of HZ43Different bound-free and free-free absorption coefficients

-- Seaton

-- Karzas & Latter

Page 5: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

NLTE pure H model spectrum of HZ43

Page 6: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

HZ43 temperature vs. gravity

Page 7: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

HZ43 temperature vs. gravity

Page 8: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

RX J1856-37 two temperature bb fit

Page 9: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

RX J1856-37 two temperature bb fit

Page 10: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Simultaneous fit to RXJ1856 and the WDs

Page 11: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Simultaneous fit to RXJ1856 and the WDs

Page 12: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

LETG + HRC-S effective areas

Page 13: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Parameters obtained from fit

Page 14: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Parameters obtained from fit

Page 15: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Comparison of photon spectra

EUVE

Page 16: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Comparison of photon spectra

EUVE

Page 17: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

RX J1856.5–3754: A `stable‘ neutron starIndividual fits with all param

eters free:Sim

ultaneous fits with N

H  linked:

Model:tbabs*bbody

from Frank Haberl

Page 18: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Summary

Page 19: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

HZ 43 residuals

Page 20: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Comparison Chandra LETGS and EUVE

Page 21: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

Comparison WD models with ROSAT

Page 22: Cross-calibration results from observations of the INS RX ... · EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Comparison of photon spectra EUVE. Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE

Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006 Vadim Burwitz EPIC CAL/OPS, MPE May 4, 2006

LETGS long-term lightcurve of HZ43