critical thinking faculty development workshop (feb 2014)
TRANSCRIPT
CT Course Faculty Development WorkshopFebruary 22, 2014
Center for Teaching and Learning
•what’s your 60-second pitch?
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
Introductions
What our students see . . . When they hear the words public health, psychology, math, history
What we see in our mind’s eye. . .
So how do we help our students getfrom HERE to HERE?
•recall
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
important concepts, course topics, ideas, facts, theories, arguments
•use
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
post-it notes and personal “white board” to test conceptual framework
•explain
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
conceptual framework to someone else
•analyze
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
partner’s map for inconsistency b/w explanation & representation
•assess
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
how effectively the map represents & integrates course content
•integrate
With regard to your upcoming CT course . . .
a visual metaphor that clarifies & amplifies the overall structure of knowledge in the course
But why?
Students who become cognizant of the
conceptual structure of their courses are more
likely to employ appropriate discipline-specific
learning strategies. (Saroyen, Amundsen, &
Donald, 2004)
Neo and Co. in the Matrix
Neo outsideof the Matrix
BREAK TIME
Purpose of Core I
• We all teach and encourage critical thinking in some form or another. So what’s new about CT courses?– Connections: Helping our students situate critical
thinking within a discipline, especially in lower division courses, so they can make connections to other disciplines
– Early Immersion: Capitalizing on opportunities to practice critical thinking through active rather than passive learning, where students have opportunities to DO as well as to OBSERVE
For our students
expertise often means
to study
which equals a way of KNOWING
For professionals in the field
expertise often means
to study
which equals a way of KNOWING
BUT . . .
AND . . .
For professionals in the field
expertise often means
to cultivate a certain habit of mind
which equals a way of SEEING
AND . . .
For professionals in the field
expertise often means
to acquire a certain set of practices
which equals a way of DOING
Seeing . . .
the discipline as a structure of knowledge
then backing up further to see
the deep structures of inquiry
that connect the disciplines
Salvador Dali, 1976Gala looking at the Mediterranean Sea which at a distance of 20 meters is transformed into the portrait of Abraham Lincoln (Homage to Rothko)
The Meta View of General Education
• Peruse the maps of your colleagues
• Look for deep structures of inquiry and
knowledge making that may link or
permeate more than one concept
map
• Jot down your observations
Teaching Habits of Mind
using . . .
discipline-specific concept maps
& integrative inquiry maps
– Instructional strategies? TLA = T + L + A
Teaching Habits of Mind
using . . .
objects as themselves
& objects as metaphor
Changing contexts of “production”
1998, anthology1981, pamphlet1981, toilet paper
Changing contexts of
“production”
JUXTAPOSITION of form and content
• A literary “narrative” is not real.
(It’s fiction!)
• A literary narrative is not unreal.
(It’s material--made of ink, glue,
paper.)
Teaching Habits of Mind
using . . .
objects as themselves
atoms, books, photons, words, children,
terrain, cells, geological formations,
shards, families, kidneys, ideas.
– Instructional strategies? TLA = T + L + A
Teaching Habits of Mind
using . . .
objects as metaphors
– Instructional strategies? TLA = T + L + A
Doing. . .
the work of the discipline as a “professional”
then backing up further to see
where the skills in a gen ed discipline
connect to the major
Doing. . .
The Big Secret
Teaching a Set of Practices
What discipline-specific performance
tasks do professionals in your field
regularly engage in?
Teaching a Set of Practices
using . . .
performance tasks in the classroom
• CLA in the Classroom
• Problem Based Learning
• Case Based Learning
• Gaming
• Service Learning
Teaching a Set of Practices
using . . .
instructor modeling
student doing
Reading Like a Literary Scholar:Secondary TextsArmstrong, Nancy. Fiction in the Age of Photography: The Legacy of British Realism. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1999.
The Difference That Realism Makes
That Oliver Twist does not refer to a world in which truth takes a visual form is apparent in the protagonist’s
first view of the city:
A dirtier or more wretched place he had never seen. The street was very narrow and muddy; and the air was impregnated with
filthy odours. There were a good many small shops; but the only stock in trade appeared to be heaps of children, who, even at
that time of night, were crawling in and out at the doors, or screaming from the inside. The sole places that seemed to prosper,
amid the general blight of the place, were the public-houses; and in them the lowest orders of Irish were wrangling with might and
main. Covered ways and yards, which here and there diverged from the main street, disclosed little knots of houses, where
drunken men and women were positively wallowing in the filth; and from several of the doorways, great ill-looking fellows were
cautiously emerging: bound, to all appearance, on no very well-disposed or harmless errands. (49)
Everything in this city is identical to its type. Indeed, it is by means of the continuity ensured by
repetition of the type that things and people come to have identity as such, as Dickens here compresses the
kind of information available in treatises on the moral condition of the working classes for his reader’s
benefit. This passage offers as much auditory and olfactory information as visual description, as if one kind
of information (“filthy odours”) can do as well as any other (“heaps of children . . . crawling in and out at
the doors, or screaming from the inside”). This description is not, in other words, particularly visual.
Although he easily conjures up a picture, Dickens feels no inclination to supply colors, textures, or shades
of light and dark.
• A dirtier or more wretched place he had never seen. The street was very narrow and muddy; and the air was impregnated with filthy odours. There were a good many small shops; but the only stock in trade appeared to be heaps of children, who, even at that time of night, were crawling in and out at the doors, or screaming from the inside. The sole places that seemed to prosper, amid the general blight of the place, were the public-houses; and in them the lowest orders of Irish were wrangling with might and main. Covered ways and yards, which here and there diverged from the main street, disclosed little knots of houses, where drunken men and women were positively wallowing in the filth; and from several of the doorways, great ill-looking fellows were cautiously emerging: bound, to all appearance, on no very well-disposed or harmless errands. (49)
Reading Like a Literary Scholar:Primary Texts
Teaching a Set of Practices
using . . .
performance tasks
instructor modeling & student doing
• Instructional strategies? TLA = T + L + A
The Unbearable Lightness of “CT”-ness
• Integration of Gen Ed (connections)
• University Learning Outcomes
(authentic immersion)
Integration of Gen Ed: Core II
• Math
• Composition
• Communication
• Science
• Social Science
• Humanities
• Fine Arts
Integration of Gen Ed: Core II
• Introduce your students to the Core
Curriculum and situate your CT course
in the context of different disciplines
• Further developments/thoughts on
concept mapping?
• Other ideas?
University Learning Outcomes
• Communication Fluency
• Creative Thinking
• Ethical and Civic Thinking
• Information Literacy
• Inquiry Based Thinking
• Integrative Thinking
• Intercultural Thinking
• Metacognitive Thinking
• Quantitative Thinking
•recall
know
•use
apply
•explain
understand
•analyze
analyze
•assess
evaluate• integrate
create
University Learning Outcomes
Run a learning outcomes diagnostic
• the connections activities (anatomy
of the disciplines)
• the immersion activities (teacher-modeling and student-doing)
The Rubik’s Cube of Course Design
New in Box
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
Manipulating the Cube
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #1: First Look
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #1: Second Look
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #1: Third Look
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #2
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #3: Yay!! We’ve solved
it!
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion
Move #4
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question• Lecture
• Discussion• Field work• Hands-on
programming
Move #4: Second Look
Learning Outcomes
Teaching & Learning Activities
Assessments
• Basic knowledge of GIS terminology
• Skill in mapping local topography
• Exam: multiple ch. & simulation question
• Computer file of a GIS map
• Lecture• Discussion• Field work• Hands-on
programming
D. Fink, Creating Significant Learning Experiences, 2003.
From technique to strategy
Think globally about your course. How might you package and present these learning activities strategically?
– Over time?
– In a certain sequence?
– More than once?
Strategic goals:
– to demystify your discipline (knowing, seeing, doing)
– to help your students make connections between disciplines
Syllabus P’s and Q’s
The course title should be written like so:
SOC 200: Introduction to Sociology (CT)
The course description should indicate that this course is a critical thinking course and that it meets a Core I “CT” requirement. (If it meets a Core II requirement too, note that as well.)
Include a list of discipline-specific learning outcomes that you may already have, plus the CORE Learning Outcomes selected for your course.
Use the Master Syllabus Template.
“Completion” of the workshop
• Minor: Submission of draft syllabus
• Major: Submission of course
architecture (the invisible overlay that
drives the decisions you make about
outcomes, TLA’s, assessments, and the
order in which you proceed). See
emailed questionnaire.