criminal law bar examination q

Upload: vhal-bomes

Post on 07-Apr-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    1/119

    723,,,7,23,943"41

    $#$%#

    %"&$%$

    ###%!

    723,,,7,23,943"%84783493903/0/1478,047.42207.0%84781700,7092,-01700.450/,3//897-:90/98572,73903/0/147,94804/087094,;0,/00507:3/0789,3/3419088:0894:.0/-90!5530,7,23,9438,3/989703/98850.,3903/0/147,89:/0398174290574;3.08 4 ;0741903 ,70 70.50398 41 /0-07,90 /894790/ 34908 1742 4907 :38.7:5:4:8 ,8.448,3/89:/0398$,7094490789847,3/4:-07.70,7/0/-4/30,;0398,84;0744/,72,0 4:/ 0 94 800 90 3/:03.0 41 90 70,/07 147 8420 ,7 ":089438 . ,70 2574507.,8810/:3/07, 945.,3/1478420945.8.,70257450747347,3957,80/147 90,:9478,70 :89 ,7 #0;0008 4 ,;0 5705,70/ 9847 0 70;03 147 90 ,7 ,28:3/07 920

    .43897,398,3/93907290/340/041 90,04:/0948009070,/0783/:03.0147,49419547,5.,07747839847%0:9478:&5/,90/-:723,,,7,23,943"

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    2/119

    %,-0414390398#!#!$0307,!73.508$.4484194:93723,,0307,!73.508%077947,90307,!73.508%077947,9:78/.9434;07'0880&8041,8080340/

    $43857,.43857,.;4/,3.04170,907;43857,.443857,94743857,.422430434:8!:7548043857,.42507209#,5043857,.994;,/055700384343857,.994;,/055700384343857,.250/43857,.43857,.250/43857,.110.98

    723,,-90897:.9;07843723,,-90434:8.941$.,73723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80723,,-925488-07208723,,-90434:8.941$.,73723,,-90434:8.941$.,73723,,-90434:8.9220/,90,:80723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80

    723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80723,,-925488-0720723,,-925488-07208723,,-925488-07208/3,553,,3$0;8,,!74-9,,,3$0;8,,!74-9,,,3$0;8,,!74-9,,,3$0;8,,!74-9,,,

    !74-9,.9:,3:7#06:70/,:23$0;8,:2!74-9:249;0;83903949;0;83903949;0;83903949;0!74419070414988039,43;.943

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    3/119

    &$%!%#&$%$025937.:289,3.084;07,0025937.:289,3.08347902593347978/-803.0418.0732039:8913;8025937.:289,3.08

    :8913010380414347#06:8908:891301038041$97,307:8913:1203941:9#06:8908:8913$010380414347#06:8908:8913010380414347020398:8913$01038041!745079#06:8908:8913$01038041!745079#06:8908723,,,7,23,943" 41":,1302039841,720%%#&$%$

    9,9343394.,9439,93!0,41:99,93!0,41:9#06:89089,93!0,41:9'4:39,7$:7703/079,93'4:39,7$:7703/079,93'4:39,7$:7703/07020398#'%#&$%$7,;,937.:289,3.087,;,937.:289,3.0803078;8":,137,;,937.:289,3.083/8

    !03,9087,;,937:09#0,943857,;,93:89-0,00/39031472,9437,;,939920,3/7,;,93#0./;827,;,93#0./;82;8":,8#0./;827,;,93%70,.07&3,1:397%#%'#&$%$9073,9;07.:289,3.08394.,943!#$$##$3903.3,03.33903.3,03.3;8%01947#4--073903.3,03.3020398723,,-9..088470803.0723,,-943025943,8..08847723,,-9!73.5,-70.9!,79.5,9434!73.5,-3/85038,-044507,943723,,-9!73.5,-3/:.02039723,,-9!73.5,3/:.02039!,79.5,943

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    4/119

    0897:.9;07843!%$4250720;84254:3/7204250720;8$50.,4250720;80944393:,/44250720-077,94.9:8;8077473507843,0

    4250720-077,94.9:877473!07843,0!7,09073903943024250720-077,94.9:89902590/:7/07942./042507204.973041-077,94.9:84955.,-0425072084:5/09,970-04380/94342507208090723,943419072042507208,9:70!03,93;4;0/425072087/3,74250720;8$50.,42507204393:3110380;80944393:,/40,9!03,90,9!03,9":,10/#,50#06:8908,-9:,036:03.

    #0./;823/090723,90$03903.0,3/090723,90$03903.0,3/090723,90$03903.0,3/090723,90$03903.0,3/090723,90$03903.0,3/090723,90$03903.0,.0594383/090723,90$03903.0,.059438723,,,7,23,943" 41!03,90830472578432039;8$:-8/,72578432039!03,908!0.:3,7!03,908;8!0.:3,7

    ,-908!03,90842507204189,1,!03,908,.947894438/07!03,90842./04/137.:289,3.0!03,9089,937.:289,3.084:97,;,937.:289,3.0!03,908!,77./09,937.:289,3.0!03,908!70;039;02578432039!03,908#0.:843!07509:,#4!03,908#0.:843!07509:,;8102578432039!03,908#0.:843!07509:,;8102578432039!74-,943,!74507!074/!74-,943,,770/-550,!74-,943,,770/-550,!74-,943,,2:2%072;8%49,%072!74-,943,7/07033!74-,94349550,,-0!74-,943,!074/4;070/!74-,943,#9,770/-550,!74-,943,#9,770/-550,$:850384341$03903.0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    5/119

    /:983478$:850384341$03903.03478$:850384341$03903.04:91:1103/07%%#%23089;8!230897208

    4;070/93.943723,;,-908110.980,941,..:80/503/3,550,93.943723,;,-908110.980,9411103/0/!,79!,7/43;823089!,7/43110.9;3907/.943!,7/43110.9#0389,902039!708.75943417208,2!708.7594341720842203.02039!708.7594341720842203.02039!708.7594341720843.:-3,0!708.75943417208,80%089243

    !708.75943417208$250$,3/07'%;,-9110.941.6:99,;,-9110.941.6:99,;,-9$:-8/,7254078;,-903,3/,947723,,-9,2,0842./0%02507,90,2,08#$$%%$%%%$!7,.390$0,8":,10/!7,.#$$%%&%%$%%

    '4,9434142.0;8%7085,889403#$$%!#79#0-043!49.,49;,90/422990/-!02-078794:5/09,9#,507:897,90/794:5/09,9794:5/09,9070,728,7943857,.944229#0-043723,,,7,23,943" 417970.988,:9;8#0889,3.084-0/03.07970.988,:9%0,.078!74108847879!0784383:9479039841!0784383:9479790;0741!78430781742,79;,84341$07;.041$03903.079#0-043;84:5/09,9425072070.988,:992:7/07#$$%!&%#$%,8049080,!48808843,80%089243

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    6/119

    ,81.,943!708:2594341,81.,9434707,81.,9437,;0$.,3/,!07:7

    !07:7!07:7#$%%!$7-07477:594341!:-.11.,70.97-0731/09390:894/414.:20398:78/.943250,.,-0!:-.11.078,;078,943,;078,943,;078,943

    ,;078,943,;078,943,;078,943;889,1,,;078,943!74507908:894/,08,;078,943%0.3.,,;078,943!:-.11.078/013943!:-.11.07831/093:894/41!7843078!:-.11.07831/093:894/41!7843078#$$%!#$$425072042./088,:9:9479

    4250720!,77./0:33903943,,-47943723,,-908#,5042./0%0194723,,-9%:2:94:8117,723,,-9%:2:9:4:8117,0,9:3/07.05943,7.:289,3.080,9:3/07.05943,7.:289,3.0842./07,:897,90/!8.,3:70831,39./0:7/07$0.#4:7/07:7/07013943020398:7/07;/039!7020/9,943:7/0742./031,39./0!,77./0:7/07#0.08257:/03.0:7/07%70,.07:7/07&80410,70,728!,77./0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    7/119

    !,77./0!,77./0:950!,77./042./0#,50#,50-803.04147.0392/,943

    #,5039#,50,41723,,,7,23,943" 41#,5039#,50,41#,504380390/-/:.943#,50110.911/,;9410889,3.0#,50,0'.92#,50:950#,50847.-0-/:.943#,50!74507!,79#,50$9,9:947#,50039,#09,7/,90'.92#$$%!#$#%$%

    7-97,7090394302039874:3/87,;0407.437,;0407.43;8,970,9203941!7843070,0903943;87,;0407.43/3,553/3,553/3,55342./0/3,553110.98'4:39,7#00,80/3,5530,09039433479/3,553!74548,94/3,5

    /3,553$074:80,0903943%7085,889403!7;,90!078438%70885,889403#:041-8475943&3:89'0,943;8.9841,8.;4:83088#$$%!#!#%78430897:.9;0784378430897:.9;07843784307843,!0247,3/:20.!0247,3/:20.!!708:2594341340/089,1,%7:89#0.059,89,1,89,1,;8!89,1,;8!

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    8/119

    89,1,;8430,709!,.0203989,1,;8%01989,1,02039889,1,,81.,9434142207.,4.:203989,1,,81.,94341

    42207.,4.:2039889,1,$3/3#4--07#4--07:3/07#!#4--07:3/07#!#4--07;8,#4--07#4--07147.0:543938#4--0742./0#4#4--0742./0#4--0742./0

    #4--0742./0#4--0742./0$50.,4250720#4--07392/,943;8%019#4--07#,50#4--07#,5043857,.#4--0742./07843#4--07#,50%019%019

    723,,,7,23,943" 41%019":,10/%019%019 ":,10/%019%019":,10/%019%019$9,08410.:943%019$9,08410.:943&8:75,94341#0,#98#$$%$%%.9841,8.;4:83088;8&3:89'0,943/:90743.:-3,043.:-3,0&3:89'0,943;8.941,8.;4:83088#$$%%'$%%&$!#$$,2,2

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    9/119

    ,2,2!708.759;0!074/$2:,9434179/%7,11.3

    #$$%#-0-0-0$,3/07$,3/07$,3/07-00/;8,970,92039$,3/07;8723,43;078,943$&$

    475:80.9475:80.9013943020398397,52039;8389,943397,52039;8389,943$!!$39,73,553.9,73,55342./0397,19477:59!7,.9.08#39,3,#&$#/-:80#,3074:87:.9!0,,7,33

    ,3074:87:8.9,3074:87:8.9,3074:87:8.9,70/430,3074:87:8.9!0,,7,33,3074:87:8.9438:22,94341$,0,3074:87:8.9723,3903994!48808,3074:87:8.9!0,,7,33,#4--070,83!0,!488088434170,728#0,!488088434170,72822:39438!#3/70.97-07!!723,,,7,23,943" 41!:3/07:3/07#!708.759;0!074/

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    10/119

    #439430,:3/073.9#,!70;039;0$:8503843#!70;039;0$:8503843#!:-.11.07#,

    4;07,0#.4342.$,-49,00,#0.7:92039#/549,943

    723,,,7,23,943"#!#!$0307,!73.508$.4484194:93723,,

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    11/119

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

    4:80,3/89,--0/7,39490897009-:9,8-4.0/-147.329410094,7/8,34907/70.943220/,90,1907,/89,--0/,8489,--0/4,8;893%070,190700/1742904:80,3/9409079,3/709:730/9490,939,.,-,3/249470/,,/0/8:7;;0/4,70,-014790/0,941,3/9058.,3:70841$&$%$#,43084:/-00/,-014790/0,941%04-0.94190.43857,.41,3/,89443$3.0,3///34934419089,--341-90.,3349-00/.723,907014790/7;07.,3349-0,840/,-014790/0,94183.090147207,8.425090:3,,70418,/3723,,,7,23,943"479058.,3:70841,3/84:/-00/,-090701470;0319,8434

    ,.9:,89,--0/,3/.,:80/58.,3:70894,3/,70343090088,-0147.4385739,3/147.4397-:935489;0,.98.0/949070,,94341,.42243.723,390395489430/2801,8,444:90-4.0/808.,5040;07,94:5,794190.43857,..,3349-00/,-0-0.,:800019908.030-01470.4:/03907904:800709089,--34..:770/94:0,80,7075,794190.43857,.0//349507843,5,79.5,9039000.:9434190.720-,.98./70.9903/0/94,7/908,2003/!0450;8%4247409,!3908,20-70,990/7;07.,3349-0,840/,-01479031.9434158.,3:708:543-0.,:8090708348439,90,/340/041905,39443857,.;4/,3.04170,907;,3/-49,720/93;08,99,.0/%%0;.928843$%:543800390,99,./708:3-:9,8570;0390/17428449390,99,.078-47,550/921475488088434190

    :3%/0/17423104:3/8,3/070.,70/92:7/0738/0103803;40/90:8913.7.:289,3.041,;4/,3.04170,9070;473:7.43903/39,9-570;0393$%174284493,3/02070,;4/0/,70,9070;8/0103805748507#0,843-701$&$%$#48/0103803495748507-0.,:804-;4:89070,8,.43857,.,243,3/8:.9,990573.509,90390708,.43857,.90,.941430890,.941,8,4;073%0,.941$%90;.928843,550,7894-0,092,90/0103804170,9;0803.0:8910/,8,/0103804181,907

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    12/119

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

    .43857,.90,.941430890,.941,79:749070147084:/-0,-0,8,.4.43857,947-:990503,94322,-09,941,3,..425.043!0450;8077,$#!0450:80/7,34$#-0.,:800,8349,-094,.9:,5,79.5,90390844934140,;3-003,557003/0/-0147070,.3905,.007090.720,8.422990/%#%'$#79:748349,-0-0.,:800,8349,-0945,79.5,903903414043857,.980183495:38,-0:3088057088574;/0/-,,3/98834997:0390.,8041:7/07.4.43857,9472:895071472,34;079,.95:78:,399490.43857,.43857,.422430434:8!:754809,-4:93900;033034,3/#,11070,3,43!,/70,:7,$97009,3,433

    99029,74.3:7334,990-,.#,11,5574,.0/34-:98://034--$90;0,33,3/4348:774:3/0/90/:4%034--89,--0/34$90;0,33434,3/4330594399334,3/#,11974.88,708:934/0/4--$90;0,33434,3/433070.,70/942./089070.43857,.398.,80$&$%$#0890708.43857,.,2439041103/078,82,310890/-907.43.0790/,.9438,,38990;.928/0243897,93,.4224310434:85:7548041,88,:9390;.928%008903.04190.43857,..,3-0310770/47/0/:.0/1742902,33079041103/078,.90/3.42243,99,.334,3/#,11974.89070-/0243897,93,:3941.723,/0839431.9,7243907;.92843857,.42507209#,504804234,344,3/073,3/4,720/9-448,9,-4:94304.4.3902473374--0/,

    4:80,9,/084,905,.0070,34810,3/9700/,:9078070;309014:7070390574.088417,38,.3,3484:80073,3/4349.39,943041,348/,:9078,89739409,,7,3,190707,3/13,.,:9:59073,9.098420,9/89,391742904:80073,3/4-01470-733-,.90/,:90794904:807,50/071789%070,19079014:7.,790/,,90-0433841,34,3/81,2,,9.720//4804234,344,3/073,3/4.42295,3723,,,7,23,943"-$:55480,19079074--079014:79449:73837,53909700/,:907841,3438/090,990784:80-:9-0147090019900/90401,294570;039/0391.,943,9.720//90

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    13/119

    14:7.42295,3$&$%$#,4804234,3/,344.422990/#4--070073,3/4.422990/.4250.72041#4--079#,5043857,..,3-0310770/1742902,33079041103/078.422990/9074--07-:9907,50,8.422990/-073,3/4,9,5,.0/89,391742904:800709074--07,8.422990/349390570803.041904907.43857,947803.0073,3/4,43084:/,3807147907,50703/0732,-014790850.,.4250.720!0450;8,39:7,09,#:30

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    14/119

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

    50714720/8723,,,7,23,943"0.:5,94743857,.9474-,3/8349507805:38,-0%0/0889,3.0300/349-0,.9:,90/-70247804744/249;098034:9,990/8.4393:,3.0.42081742905078434,8-0:390.42288434190.720-:9-01470,,.984100.:943,7050714720/5078434,8-0,390.422884341,.720-:9/08890/8,-84;0/1742.723,,-9,8,70,7/944304,;380914494390;07041.72000/890.,418.438.03.0,3/709:73894905,9417904:8308843857,.250/43857,.

    ,9890/4.973041250/.43857,.($&$%$#%0/4.973041250/.43857,.4/89447247050784385,79.5,93390.422884341,.720.40.9;07085438-0,3/,-0,8.4.43857,9478,94:,-8039,3,7002039949,90110.90390,.93.43.079/0243897,93:3941.723,39039,3/,.422435:75480474-0.9;0%008903.041,.43857,.8,-0310770/47/0/:.0/1742907.723,5,79.5,94335:78:390.720,3/9:890,.9414308,-0/0020/90,.941,43857,.250/43857,.110.98$9,9090.43.05941250/.43857,.,3/;0980,0110.98$&$%$#3!$!#8430.843310770/47/0/:.0/1742902,3307905,79.5,398390.422884341.720.,770/4:99800.:9430709041103/078,.90/3.43.079390.42288434190.72020,339,9907,.98,70.447/3,90/4783.7430/3,,3/.,9;09,9

    90,705:78:3,.42243.723,4-0.9;0908,-0/0020/94-0,.933.43857,.,3/907.723,,-98,-0.40.9;03493/;/:,%00,0110.9841,3250/.43857,.,70,49,94804,705708039,9908.0304190.720-0.438/070/.43857,9478-3948045,79.5,90/-.723,,.98390.42288434190.720-0.438/070/,8.4.43857,9478,3/.070,.6:08.03.09447,5574;,4190.42288434190.72094:9,3,.941.723,5,79.5,9438,349703/07430.723,,-0,8.4.43857,947723,,-90897:.9;07843

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    15/119

    ,3/,,720/9,72,908574.00/0/94904:8041,30-47414,55030/94-05,883-54390/949014:7.:57989074429,94..:50/%014:7.:57985055070/9074429-:098&38,9810/0;03970,,3/703,/09,9949,/089740/8744240;07:3343949014:7.:5798,834938/0907442,3/34-4/,89473:70//:73903./03970,3/,-0147,3.7205,341$&$%$#08,3/,70,-0147/0897:.9;0,7843-0.,:804190/0897:.9434190744241990:8041,30548;090,3/703,/0,-9147,325488-0.720894-025480/43190,.9.422990/4:/349.43899:90,34907.720:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/094:901,.983;4;0/,705,7,09490.,8041394/;84:7941550,8$#0709,87:0/9,990,-9419041103/07,8147,325488-0.72034,3/703,/0,8:80/38,/.,80..43899:908,24708074:8.72094:/11070391742,9,83903/0/723,,-90434:8.941$.,730,3/07,308.,50/.43;.97,3,2:.43-4,7/,$:507308:8-4:3/147,3,1742.4,3/

    0/9035078438%07710/-903./039,74,3/03,234,705,88030784190-:8:250/4:941903/4,3/03:3.438.4:8,1907993905,;02039419074,/0707,34;07,3/.7:80/94/0,9-,1,8924;3080794-:89,390$:507308:8,30,3/07-00/,-014790/0,941,74,3/03,23,94:0,8.425090:3,,709,99094:250/4:94190-:85,3$&$%$#080,3/07.,3-00/,-014790/0,941,74,3/03,23-0.,:804110434:8,.9417:333,8905742,90.,:804190;.928/0,9%07:089,903,507843-,10434:8,.90307,90839023/41,34907,8038041223039/,307574259390,99079408.,50174247,;4/8:./,307,3/390574.0888:89,383:70847/0890507843.4229939010434:8,.987085438-0

    1478:.3:70847/0,9&$;8',/0!!0450;857,$#723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80'.0390,.0/3,.0949,-44-:990,9907,8,-0945,77998,3/.,:83:5432,943.4:3/438795,2'.0390,8349,-094,.3,.0941:7907-0.,:80970054.0203,77;0/,3/970,9030/948449'.039010//349/7458-44'.0390,8,..47/3.,70/-9054.0,99057480.:9478411.0147,9902590/42./0%0391;0/,8,90709057023,73;089,943,8357470883,.094,87:80/94904859,-0.,:8041825942841909,3:8310.9434390943.4:3/31.90/-'.03903,.094/0/901443/,,3'.0390-00;039:,.,70/942./014790/0,9413,.0945,3$&$%$#

    08'.03902,-0.,70/4142./014790/0,9413,.094:308890909,3:8310.943./0;0450/90391;0/,8,907,8-74:9,-4:9-,3011.0398:507;033.,:80'.0390810434:8,.941.,:83,943.4:3/433,.0948795,22,89-070,7/0/,8905742,90.,:804190,99078/0,9-0.,:8094:98:.4:3/34909,3:8310.943.4://0;045174290;.928795,2,3/94:9723,,,7,23,943"8:.909,3:8310.94390;.924:/349,;0/0/99723,,-925488-07208,98,325488-0.720

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    16/119

    8,325488-0.72070,,.720$&$%$#325488-0.7208,3,.9.4:/-0,34110380,,38950784347574507907013491479030703925488-94198,..425820394743,..4:39419002542039413,/06:,904730110.9:,20,38795,7#!4,325488-0.720834970,,.720984384.,0/-0.,:8090,.9;0878094.723,,-9:9,.9:,3410438.422990/%0,..:80/894-05:380/1478.723,903/03.4757450389,94:34.720,8.422990/723,,-90434:8.941$.,73,7,30,/948:9478050,3/08,7$0//3494503840757010703.0-:943944..,8438,..0590/08,783;9,94394.43.0798-#030,3/!458050,8,47389:/039,3/.4:/43,8,794800,24;0.,8/0.30/05010938:90/,3/2,/05,3894090;03908,7-8.,7324118420430/,0039070/08,7874423907-4,7/34:80,3/5,.0/,7:--0783,0.,550,70/94-070,308,78-,.5,.0.,:8008,7,/,0,0,7908:11070/,0,79,99,.:543450338-,.5,.,3/80039083,008,7/0/94:970,33.438.4:83088%054.03;089,943708:90/35354393050,890.:579,3/0,8.,70/942./0147

    08,78/0,938/010380050.,20/9,90//34934,-4:908,780,0,79,3/9,90433903/0/945,,57,.9.,404308,78050,-014790/0,94108,7478/0103805748507

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    17/119

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

    4/0723,,,7,23,943"94:/0/410,79,99,.908,/,99,.,80307,90/-810434:8,.94199307981898$:.10434:8,.9,890220/,90.,:8041900,79,99,.,;32,907,.4397-:90/94,3/,89030/8/0,9;0394:2,,;0,.90/94:93903994810,.418:.39039841342420390390;.92/0840;072,-0;039029,93.7.:289,3.041,;3,.90/94:9390394394.4229847,;0,743,89,9.422990/795,7#0;80/!03,4/0723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:8000450/9$.499070:543081,907#4-3,3/-74907#:894203994$.49984:80&54370,.3904:80#:894236:70/1742$.499,-4:98889078070,-4:980#4-384:90/,3/970,9030/94$.499%0,9907903039/4389,78-:9#:89420/8$.4998,890,30

    ;0900/078890741$.499.,773079424394/./,5574,.0/#:8942,3/$.499945,.1902;0,9902590/947024;0#:89428,3/1742$.4998,89:9#:89425:0/;08,3/.,:8307941,4;0707-,-%0-,-903/0/2420398,9078#:8942.723,,-014790/0,94190./$&$%$#08#:89428.723,,-014790/0,94190./-0.,:80810434:8,.9,8905742,90.,:80418:./0,99,8#:89428,.9415:3;08,3/..,:80/90,9907941,4307-,-,/9349-0031478,/,.941#:8942.8:3/4:-90/10434:8,90,8989.407.439070,834.,:80147;0941,4;0707-,-38479#:8942810434:8,.9890.,:8041900;.,:80/350784350714723,10434:8,.98.723,,-014790/70.93,9:7,,3/4.,.43806:03.0907041

    ,94:/11070391742,903903/0/795,7#!0450;8!:,09,#44;723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80090.7041,890,2075705,70/947,80,3.47,990!,8#;070;/03925,903999057470884147-0,394:80,-:8;0,3:,0,,389902034304190202-0784190.7070243897,90/8,39,990.4:/47-08919007034938:90/9448,999:/0,8,/85,4138:-47/3,943,3/7833,7,024;0/94,7/80/3,-310,3/970,90339489,-990389,3903,843,101009174290,9907,55,7039-00;3280194-0370,9,3/220/,90507970280139490,907/8,550,70/-030,9908:71,.0,3//7430/,-0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    18/119

    0/.723,,-014790/0,941$&$%$#08.,3-00/.723,,-014790/0,94179.04190#0;80/!03,4/0574;/0835,799,9.723,,-98,-03.:770/-,3507843.422993,1043,94:907431:,.9/430-0/110703917429,9.03903/0/3&$;8',/0!07090;.924,8970,9030/-90,..:80/9,310:250/394907;07-:9-0.,:8041419089743.:7703947-0.,:800//34934494820/7430/90$:570204:79,11720/90.43;.94314742./04190,..:80/-0.,:801,507843,,38942,.723,,88,:98/70.90/-00;08280194-03/,30741/0,94770,9-4/,72,3/347/079408.,50:25839490,9072500/-903893.941801570807;,94390,88,,3987085438-01479042./03.,80/0,9708:98-/7433723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80:739074--073,/034:804304190.:5798,55030/941708:3:5,7/390.0394:920,3394,3430%0430741904:804,8/39070,9,89,3/0/,8,708:9%0/01038090470/9,9903,8,2070,../039,3/,83495075097,90/3.4330.943947

    1475:754808419074--074:8:89,390/010380$&$%$#43498:89,390/010380%0,.9-0310434:8,3/905742,90.,:804190;.928/0,99041103/078,-090701470,94:92,349-03903/0/47/11070391742,903903/0/%041103/078,-057480.:90/14790.4254890.7204174--07942./00907903,83903943,47,../039,,843,8903,8434..,843419074--07723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:80:87:,8/005:7903841107414;0,8700.90/-871703/,7;0,430,19073443030;890/07030019074:800,0/,810,88005,3842:.849,9,9003,083,9.07,8,-0947,-8.05430,3/10094:9-03.,80/-:8990309#%89,9430

    -4,7/0/4304190.4,.08-4:3/147,.,7,3080,90/0,55030/9470,/,3085,507019439080,9,3/349.0/9,9900,/308070,-4:9908334190$:50707704398,940-:00394;0790894128835,880307840705708:20//0,/,3/.,20,.7488903,204187,3/1,9074,/7,80/21742./44/,19070,8475,30/0,884.0/,3/823/039-,3147,1023:908,1907.07,3,2:.,3/:838-,84389,790/89,--3,9905,880307849038.,25070/,,9970041902:2534:9419097,3,3/,3/3439074,/-049097005,8803078/0/,907419073:708,9904859,8:8,-014790/0,9419097005,88030784:250/4:9419024;397,3$9,904:770,8438$&$%$#

    08:88,-0147907/0,98-0.,:800,8.422993,104303089,790/89,--3,9905,8803078,3/8:.7431:,.9,8905742,90.,:80418,/5,8803078:2534:9419097,303.0907/0,98723,,,7,23,943"&3/0779.0#0;80/!03,4/0,3507843.422993,10438,3.:7.723,,-9,94:907431:,.9/430-0/110703917429,9.03903/0/398.,8090/0,9419097005,8803078,890/70.93,9:7,,3/4.,.43806:03.041:810434:8,.9..70,90/,3220/,908038041/,30739023/8418,/5,88030784970/94,;4/4708.,5017429-:2534:9419097,3!0450;875,$#&$;8',/0!

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    19/119

    723,,-90434:8.9!742,90,:8038,4201742411.074/03,00530$:-806:039-4,7/0/908,2000530&54370,.3,80.:/0/85493"5:0/4:9,703,/017428-,,3/,334:3.0/,4/:5094/948:7703/078,9.,09,3/.054300,73147810:250/4:94190;0.0:9,801080,/9905,;02039.,:838389,39/0,98,-01478/0,95,3-701$&$%$#088,-01478/0,9-0.,:808,.98415:34:9,703,/0,3/,334:3.3,4/:5.4:50/9,/02,3/14790,9.,09,3/.0543041810434:8,3/8:.10434:8,.9,8905742,90.,:80418:2534:9419000530708:93390,99078/0,9$9,90/49078090/0,941,890/70.93,9:7,,3/4.,.43806:03.041810434:8,.9..70,90/,3220/,908038041/,30739023/414970/94,;4/8:./,307-:2534:9419000530!0450;75,$#723,,-925488-0720,3/070-49.4:793907.4025400$&0.,:8041907-99077;,7/0./0/94097/41-548433254:70/,8:-89,3.03948.411009339,8,7803.99:730/4:99,9908:-89,3.0,8908:,78:-899:90343,86:,493,55030/94,19070/7,390

    .41100,9.723,,-9//3.:71,35,3-701$&$%$#3.:770/.723,,-9147,325488-0.720412:7/07723,,-98,-03.:770/-,350784350714723,3,.9.4:/-0,34110380,,389507843847574507907093491479030703925488-94198,..425820394743,..4:39419002542039413,/06:,904730110.9:,20,38795,7#390574-02;039025488-941,..4258390.720412:7/07,.720,,3895078438,8/:09490025420394130110.9:,20,38.94:9,854843%0,25:908.723,,-9949041103/07,94:34.720708:90/43948:5570888.723,57450389-0.,:808:-0.9;008,.723,94:4-0.9;034.720,8.422990/723,,-925488-0720841

    !708,3/#,3/,5,330/948,,708/03941,7,3,!:,,:70,9,3,8%0,80/90,8889,3.041,481,2,79905,.0357,9,-4:93900;033!708,3/#,3/,,,720/9,:942,9.0,543803994,7,3,!:,,-0390:/0/70.90/07.425,3438949074423904:80418,070:543!708,3/#,3/,170/907:38,9077442479:3,908,,8349,74:3/,880,9903/0/,57,07200939,90;0333,34907-,7,3,3,:70!09,070.,70/,3/.43;.90/41,9902590/2:7/07-90#043,%7,4:79,9%,3,:,3,9,3,83,550,94904:7941550,8,90,..:80/,8.7-0/949097,.4:7990840077474113/3902:941,9902590/2:7/0714:07090543039044:/0./090,550,$&$%$#1070905430390809,8/090:/2039.43;.9390,..:80/41,9902590/2:7/07,3/3890,/

    13/902:94125488-0.720:3/07795,7#!370,9439479#!,-914725488-0.720,780834943039025488-980,-:908003981,.9:,4758.,25488-9,8390.,80,9-,78,8,-803.01742904:808,58.,25488-9.703/07890.7203903/0/3070393.,5,-041,..42582039%4.43;.990,..:80/41,9902590/2:7/074:/2,0795,757,.9.,:80088,8,.7.:289,3.08.570;0390/90.438:22,94341904110380-0970,90/,8,33./0393/0503/0394190,.9478.8,300203941,9902590/4717:897,90/1043394/;8$#723,,-925488-07208

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    20/119

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

    8074:858.,3:708147.,:83904859,,943,3/20/.,,9903/,3.0147/,894:3%07,.94123990144/0,903-:3902,9907.706:70/8:.20/.,,9903/,3.0.422990/9.723,39039703/078902,-014790708:933:7723,,-925488-07208/3,553,7,0,784/,8/3,550/-376:09097..0/7;075,/-075,7039894-73,3/109.0794,3/17428.44376:07490,7,38423490/02,3/3!1742,7,85,7039830.,30147,7,81700/42376:08039907,38423490-2,40;07-01470907,38423490,870.0;0/-,7,85,70398376:08/04:9,8/8.4;070/-9054.0,7,,8708.:0/0376:0,8,770890/,3/3.,7.07,90/438/0739,9907,38423490,834970.0;0/-,7,85,7039890

    3;089,9357480.:947207010/,.,804125488-0720944229/3,553,,389376:089057480.:947.4770.9$&$%$#49057480.:9478349.4770.9313,.,8014725488-0.72094.4229/3,553,,389376:025488-0.7208,70290/4394,.98.0350714720/4:/-0,.720,,38950784384757450798/3,5538,.720,,389507843,80.:79,3/349,,3895078438475745079376:0.4:/349,;03.:770/,325488-0.72094.4229/3,553%07089:83425488-0.72041/3,553,,3$0;8,,!74-9,893:8-09003.72082,,380,3/.72082,,574-9,,,3,.9-02,:2380,3/-0,9908,209202,:2574-9:2$&$%$#

    72082,,380,7010434:8,.98.422990/-/4447.:5,,8/0130/390#0;80/!03,4/0,.41.723,390398,;,//0103800.0590390.720708:981742.723,3003.03904907,3/.72082,,574-9,,709480.438/070/74343-0.,:8090,70574-90/-89,9:90%0.43899:90;4,94384120707:0841.43;0303.0/0830/9480.:70,247047/0770:,9434190,11,784184.09$&$%$#08,3,.92,-02,:2380,3/2,:2574-9:2,9908,209203!0450;$:3.409,

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    21/119

    9,80/9,990428843471,:704100.9433850.9478,3/54.078943.:/0,;490783,2039041708978941;49078874350780-0.,:809/80317,3.808,;49074187994;49039870,7/98.438/070/,82,:2380$3.0985:380/:3/07,850.,,$0.,3/#0;80/0.9434/098.438/070/2,:2574-9:2,,3$0;8,,!74-9,893:82,,38017422,,574-9,$&$%$#32,,38090,.98.43899:9390.7208,703070390;-,/47743,3/03.03;4;0890247,97,98419041103/07032,,574-9,90,.98.43899:9390.7208,70349307039-,/0;47743-:9574-90/,3/2,/05:38,-0431475:-.44/3/-0.,:8090247,97,9419041103/0783;4;0/32,,3804/13.7.:289,3.089041103/07809039415,79.5,943390.720,3/90/070041,..425820394190.720,709,03394,..4:3932548390503,99080,703498432,,574-9,070.723,,-9,7808430390,.98,70.438:22,90/,,3$0;8,,!74-9,70189,90,9088039,/893:808,.7202,,574-9,1742,.7202,,380$&$%$#

    3.72082,,574-9,90,.98,70349-3,9:707430;47-,/%0,705:380/43-0.,:8090708,,574-939021475:-.44/,3/9:844/1,947,.41.723,390393/4390574-90/,.98349,/0103803.72082,,38090,.98,70-3,9:707430;47-,/,3/840307,.43/0230/%0247,97,9419041103/0783;4;0/9:844/1,947,.41.723,3903943905,79419041103/078,/010380:308890.720890708:941.723,3003.047708543/324/13.7.:289,3.08,70.438/070/35:3839041103/07,,3$0;8,,!74-9,893:8390770850.9;0.43.0598,3/0,25.,9438-09003.72082,,380,3/.72082,,574-98$&$%$#

    3.43.05972082,,380,70948007090,.98474288438503,0/,70307039-,/0;477439,990,70,2489:3;078,.43/0230/72082,,574-9,,70948007090,.98503,0/,70349307039-,/0;47743-:9574-90/-,1475:-.44/5:-.01,70473907089,3/40;07;4,90890574-943,70503,0/30,25.,94383.72082,,38044/1,947,.41.723,390393003.08,/01038003.72082,,574-9,44/1,947,.41.723,39039472,.08349,/01038098034:9,990574-943,8;4:39,7;4,90/723,,,7,23,943"84.723,,-980307,3.:770/3.72082,,3800;030390.720843,9902590/4717:897,90/03.72082,,574-9,.723,,-980307,3.:770/430390.7208.438:22,90/

    843.72082,,38029,93,3/,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08,70,5570.,90/32548390503,90803.72082,,574-9,8:..7.:289,3.08,70349,5570.,90/:308890850.,,,8,/4590/908.020478.,041503,908:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/0,,!74-9,.9:,3:7#06:70/7,748,-8,.:89428:,7/,3/7#.494,57;,903/;/:,0399490411.04170907.:,794,.:89428-7407,3/7057080390/90280;08,8,039841443442207.,%7,/3,3254790741./7038.4908,3/9487,-8,3/79403,0/7.:,794945705,70

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    22/119

    ,3/10990:70,:41:894289030.088,725479397,3/39073,#0;03:00.,7,943.4;073443488520397,-8,3/7948:-2990/947.:,794,5,.389,.42207.,3;4.0,-41,/3,3/,$47325479:90.,7,943./0.,70/90852039,8./7038948909,08,3//:90841.070.425:90/,9!7.:,79410/90,14702039430//4.:20398990,3,39073,943,439,307!47940;07-0147090852039,8700,80/,8549.0.,8.43/:.90/-:89428$0347039,208,3//44/8.4;070/9,990.43903984190;,3852039070349./7038948,8/0.,70/3908553/4.:20398-:9:39841;/04.,88099070.47/07899,08,3//:908.425:90/,9!4/47/07,3/,77,394180:70,3//090394307090388:0/-90897.940.94741:89428:79073;089,943840/9,94434834308903943806:0397,-8,3/794070.,70/9,3/.43;.90/147;4,94341$0.943041#.2,089:3,1:,243490781475:-.411.07894.,:80,3:3/:03:794,35,793.:/3904;0732039390/8.,7041411.,1:3.9438974:2,310895,79,90;/039-,/1,947748830.:8,-03003.039072494314770.438/07,94390,..:80/,00/

    9,990/0.843,80774304:8-0.,:8090.720,8349.438:22,90/-:9,843,9,3,9902590/89,0,3/9,931,.9904;0732039//3498:1107,3:3/:03:7,890.4390394341-49,..:80/.4770.95,3-88:239,990,9902590/4717:897,90/89,04190;4,943.,70/83495:38,-02,90,..:80/-030;0790088.43;.90/147,341103805:380/-90#0;80/!03,4/0:3/07901,.984190.,805,3$&$%$#0890.439039434190,..:80/9,990.720,8349.438:22,90/8.4770.9#8,850.,,5:383,.982,,574-9,8,7:0,9902590/41;4,94341,850.,,83495:380/.9:,3:78706:70/08-49,70,-0147,9902590/

    089,1,97:1,81.,94341.42207.,/4.:20398,.4250.720,:23$0;8,:2!74-9:2893:82,:238017422,:2574-9:2$&$%$#3.72082,:2380,3,.98-3,9:707430;47-,/,3/840307,.43/0230/%0247,97,9419041103/0783;4;0/9:844/1,947,.41.723,3903943905,79419041103/078,/010380:308890.720890708:941.723,3003.047708543/324/13.7.:289,3.08,70.438/070/35:3839041103/073.72082,,574-9:2,3,.98349-3,9:707430;47-,/09985:380/-0.,:8090708,,574-939021475:-.44/,3/9:844/1,947,.41.723,390393/4390574-90/

    ,.98349,/01038049;0;839039893:8390391742249;03723,,,.720-0.422990/94:9.723,39039$&$%$#49;089024;35407.250843094,.943147,/01390708:9070,8390398905:7548094:80,5,79.:,720,38940110.98:.708:9849;08349,3088039,00203941,1043,3/300/349-0574;0/1475:7548041.43;.9430390398,3088039,00203941104308-/4408,.7202,-0.422990/94:9.723,3903918:.8,.:5,-010430703390398

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    23/119

    8:-899:90/-3003.047257:/03.0,3/,843,2,:2574-9:2471,3,.985:38,-0-850.,,49;0;839039893:8249;0174239039038249;0700;,3994574;0,.,80038934930.088,794-0089,-80/5,3$&$%$#49;089024;35407.2508,50784394/4,3,.9147,/01390708:90390398905:75480147:83,5,79.:,720,3894-73,-4:9,/0870/708:949;08349,300203941,.720-:9390398,3002039413903943,.720849;01,9903/3,.720,,8570.0/0903903949;08700;,3994574;0,.,800390708/4:-9,89490/0399419041103/07470390,.9.422990/;0878094;,7,39.7208,3/9070890300/94/090723090574507.72094-025:90/949041103/07723,,,7,23,943"9834930.088,794574;0249;0039041103/0785489;0/03910/4790.723,,.9//349;078094;,7,39.720849;0;839039893:8.0,7-:9-701-0900339039,3/249;0390.422884341,34110380$&$%$#

    390398905:75480147:83,5,79.:,720,3894,.0;090/0870/708:90249;089024;35407.2508,50784394,.9147,/01390708:9390398,3370/03941/44472,.0,3/9:8,300203941/0-07,901043080249;08349,300203941,.720-:943.438/070/0390/0399419041103/0783/4:-949;0!74419070414988039,43;.94349;08088039,390/090723,9434190.422884341,.720,3/90,-90841905075097,9478,9,7090389,3.080705744141249;08349088039,47706:70/94:891.43;.94341,3,..:80/;0,90,89389,3.08$&$%$#0390708,30093088475489;0/0391.,9434190,..:80/0390,..:80/,/2990/47.4310880/9490.42288434190.7203.72082,,574-9,3/70.9,88,:90390;.9248,5078433,:947947,03941,5078433,:9479,8

    ,99,.0/390,.9:,5071472,3.0418/:979#0;80/!03,4/03.7208.422990/974:70.088257:/03.0&$%!%#&$%$025937.:289,3.084;07,0-7490741990390394341,;3,394:9981703/894490.4.43:980.8-03:80/-,8,-,3147.438174238/09074.0/.,-309:83907.4224304799-74090.4.43:9804:98/041907420390570803.04181703/8,9890.723,,-9411,35,38002590/1742.723,,-9:3/0779.04190#0;80/!03,4/0147-03,-74907415,3$&$%$#,8.723,,-0147#4--079147.0:543938-48349002591742.723,,-9:3/0779-0.,:808,/79.0,550843949019

    83/3472,.4:828.0107090.720.422990/874--0741025937.:289,3.08347943,3090,74/-48143/41,9.390900;8435747,204#,3078300;03300,80374880/,9.381,;4790900;84384!097,,2,/.,30/90.,3309403,-00794,9.4204390#08%8037,0/4344981,907870;4;07,3/94:9,733849!097,,990-,.41070,/.,:8307389,39,304:8/0,9843.723,,-0($&$%$#4438349.723,,-01473!097,-0.,:8008430,784/030.422990/90

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    24/119

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

    !42538;0,94:8,.9417050,90/5:3075439,3490747/8903:7,8,../039,-%0,9903/,39.7.:289,3.08.2,-0.438/070/,7034794190,..:80/,8,3002593.7.:289,3.0:3/0779.05,7,7,5#0;!03,4/0070808,-0002591742.723,,-9:30889,8574;0/9,980,.90/9/8.0732039$0840;07.;,-0114:3/.723,,-090234794190,..:80/,8,57;00/29,93.7.:289,3.0/8.70943,7503,9407-,90,8994723,,,7,23,943"/070089,39,95708.7-0/14790.720.422990/8,-025480/3,..47/,3.0979.05,7,7,5#0;!03,4/0%0803903.040;0784:/,:942,9.,-08:8503/0/3,..47/,3.09$0.943,41#05.94490780343,890,24:798.941

    84114:3/.723,,-09047/3,729,93.7.:289,3.0413493903/394.4229847,;0,743,89,9.422990/:3/0779.05,7,7,5#0;!03,4/0,3/%047/3,729,93.7.:289,3.0418:11.039574;4.,94343905,79419041103/0/5,79220/,90570.0/0/90,.9:8913;8025937.:289,3.08893:8.0,7-:9-70109003:8913,3/002593.7.:289,3.083.723,,$&$%$#:8913.7.:289,3.0,110.9890,.934990,.9470002593.7.:289,3.0,110.9890,.94734990,.93:8913.7.:289,3.034.723,,3/0307,34.;,-983.:770/03002593.7.:289,3.0.;,-980307,3.:770/,94:9070834.723,,-9:8913;8025937.:289,3.08893:8-09003:8913,3/002593.7.:289,3.08($&$%$#

    3:89137.:289,3.08%0.7.:289,3.0,110.9890,.934990,.947

    %0,.98/430930,-4:3/803.0.438/070/,8349,.720$3.090,.98349,.7209070834.723,%070-0334.720347.723,9070834.723,347.;,-9070,83,3025937.:289,3.08%0.7.:289,3.0,110.9890,.94734990,.9%0,.9810434:8,3/03.0,.720-:990,.947,.90/94:9;4:39,7308894:90708,.7209070834.723,-0.,:8090,.947870,7/0/43,8,33897:20394190.720

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    25/119

    %070-03,743/430-:934.723,:8913010380414347#06:890803,77;0/420014:3/7,538/,:907&54380037,3,,9448:3,3/84932,70/942./0.,20/0,.90/3/010380418/,:907843478.4770.91349.,3.,290-0301941,329,93.7.:289,3.047.7.:289,3.08$&$%$#4.,3349;,/3;40/010380418/,:907843473,;30/83.0907,50,8,70,/.438:22,90/24704;07,70,/7,3,,03.09070,834,70884394/0103/,,389,3/34/01038094850,41412,40;073;4090-03019419029,93.7.:289,3.041,;3,.90/3220/,90;3/.,94341,7,;0411038094,/08.03/,398/,:907:3/075,779.04190#0;80/!03,4/0,8,203/0/:891301038041$97,307.,3.0/:54397002034070,99,.39189-484304190203,8,-4:99489,-9,310493439,9,8,.9:,90,708847-0.,:800,/0,707.,030/90970020394,19849,890,9907,8,-4:99489,-,3;4090/01038041,897,307,8,:8913.7.:289,3.0381,;47

    $&$%$#082,3;4090:8913.7.:289,3.041/01038041897,30783.00,83493;4;0/39019,3/08490390,9907,8,-4:99489,-%070-03343/.,9439,9,83/:.0/-70;030708039203947,349070;249;03844938,.98:8910/:3/075,779.04190#0;80/!03,4/0,8,203/0/:8913:1203941:9#06:8908:.708,,894704307,874--0/4107-7,.009307420%01443/,,9,-4:94.4.390,19073443,30-470,74/:3:34,/,3:38,;47705:9,943.,2094078947094-:-4990841-007:.708,349.0/07-7,.0094:3/,74:3/9079,7241:3:388443,890,9907019:.708,03994,30,7-54.089,943,3/84:9900541,54.02,343/:9!,90

    #00800399:.708,94904:8041:3:394.431743990,9907!,9#0083974/:.0/2801,8,54.02,3,3/970/94094/41:3:34708890/,3/7,3,,!,9#008.,80/2,3/170/94,7338498390,7:3:3.4393:0/947:3,3/030,8,-4:9209078,,!,9#0088492390790:3:3,89,3/010/43-:90.7,0/94,7/8,103.03903/3945,88974:,345033:3/0730,903!,9#008,8,-4:9209078,,0170/,34907849,9:3:39932,990794075!,9#008-74:9:3:394904859,-:9-0.,:80415741:80-00/300;039:,/0/!,9#008,88:-806:039.,70/942./0:739097,!,9#0087,80/90/010380-,4104307,9439,90,.90/3901:1203941,/:9890/010380903,-05,3

    $&$%$#490/01038041!,9#0088349903,-0%0/01038041,;3,.90/3901:1203941,/:9706:708,8,.43/9433907,,9,9903:7474110380.422990/-090:3,;4/,-04730.088,7.43806:03.04190/:05071472,3.04190/:9!0450;8,3809,!98349034:9,990,..:80/,.90/31:1203941,/:91907:3:3,8849390790,3/,8,70,/.7,39070,834300/147!,9#00894844921:79070,7!,9#008,.90/-043/90.,41/:9.-74:9,-4:990.,:8041/0,94190;.92

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    26/119

    723,,,7,23,943"41:8913$010380414347#06:89083039&3,,4:32,770/42,3,884:3/,8005307-0/74420380109,2,3439454107%339,807:8-,3/%944.,20420,/,0,717428-:83088975&3,092,;080907190790,.9902,38,/4504:0340/9,82:.,8//4970.43390;4.09/,30/:5433,9,9902,3,8349%9407:8-,3/:74:8&3,9444:9%948:3,3/849902,3,70/942./0&3,/0308.:5,-9439074:3/41/010380414347807.,2903,-0($&$%$#4&3,8.,29,980,.90/3/0103804143478349903,-0-0.,:8090:3,1:,70884343074347,/,70,/.0,80/010380414347,83.:/0/3801/0103802:89,;0-003/43094570;039477050,3:3,1:,708843%070834/01038094850,4107090:3,1:,7088433443070898:89130103804143470203988,3,2,770/42,33070,7903908,88005343,-,3439014474190735,:9-08/0

    9080,84700380,8,,030/-90,.941,2,324:39307%339,99,807:8-,3/,7/44,/709:730/174218339080,8,3.4393:0/078005-:9,40/902,34,8,.9:,90730-47:494,;080:,3907.4:7809071907:48,9810/280108,/$,,2,98,3,809:730/940,;03903//8,370,09,9902,3,834907:8-,3/37,0/8,37,--0/,-,843174290,,3/89,--0/:494/0,903970/14742./08,3.,20//010380414347$4:/90.,2-08:89,30/$&$%$#48,38.,241/01038041434784:/349-08:89,30/-0.,:8090,70884343074347,/.0,80/038089,--0/90,7088473/01038041798:3/075,7,7,5794190#!98706:70/3907,,9,99070-0:3,1:,708843,3/70,843,-030.0889419020,3802540/94570;0394770509%0:3,1:,7088432:89-0.4393:30390,708847,8

    3:70/47/8,-0/-905078432,3,/010380:9190,7088439,9,8-0:3-903:70/47/8,-0/5,79,70,/.0,80/940890390,..:80/,99,.0/2,8390.,80,9-,790,99,.2,/08,709,,943,3/349,/010380!,7,7,579.041904/0/4083494;07303.08,38,.94189,--3:494/0,9,19079080:,3907.4:780,81380/8349/010380414347-:9,3220/,90;3/.,94341,7,;04110380.422990/,,38907.84329,93:8913$01038041!745079#06:890880.:79:,7/:5438003,2,38.,090,41,1,.947.4254:3/.0,8:,7/3849,3/0/90,9907&5433;089,943-9054.049070,1907,77;0/,9908.0304190844939,8/8.4;070/9,990;.92,8:3,720/0357480.:90/14742./09080.:79:,7/.,20/9,9

    02070,.90/3801/010380415745079,3/3905071472,3.0418/:9,8,80.:79:,7/14:07090:/04:/4:.43;.924142./05,3$&$%$#084:/.43;.99080.:79:,7/14742./0107090:/0-0.,:808.,241,;3,.90/3/010380415745079,3/35071472,3.041,/:9.,33491:-0:8910/;03,88:239,990;.92,88.,390,41901,.947.4254:3/94.4229,.72038/0908,20844932830;07

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    27/119

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

    47574507979/408349:89190,.941173,:3,9,-:7,7:30889010,3/2-4190,..:80/8,70,/3223039,3/220/,90/,30794:90,..:80/,.90/4:941,28,55700384341901,.9808349,-84;0/1742.723,,-9%#%'$#438/07390;03.7.:289,3.083,20901706:03974--070839030-4744/90920,85,892/39,3/90;.92,550,70/94-0,3,720/-:7,7390/,7,3/38/084:8090,..:80/.4:/,;0039079,30/,343089-0019,9810,3/2-4794804181,2,70,70,/3220/,90,3/223039/,30703.092,-070,843,-094,..0599,90,.90/4:941,343089289,0411,.9,3/9070147094:9.723,39039343089289,0411,.930,9;08.723,39039,3/9:8

    ,-84;0890,..:80/1742.723,,-9723,,,7,23,943"":,1302039841,720034:/6:,13.7.:289,3.08-0/0020/1,9,002039841,.720$&$%$#6:,13.7.:289,3.04:/-0/0020/,300203941,.720039.,308903,9:704190.720-733,-4:9,24708074:8.720,3/,0,;07503,998088039,9490.7203;4;0/49078084204907.7208.422990/,3/98850.1.,,00/39031472,943,3/574;03/:739097,%#%'$#6:,13.7.:289,3.08/0020/,300203941,.7200398850.1.,89,90/-,,83.:/0/

    390/01394341,.7200970,.07390.720412:7/07%%#&$%$9,9343394.,94308590902,88;0,/;07983.,25,3320/,,,389170.7,.078,3/:3173/:739000,78.00-7,943843,8,3/,,-4:9903-408418:50744,3/5,5,34.,:0:,.,3014702/39410.02-0743,8,3/,,89,790/907.00-7,943-,;3,/73385700,943,85,.0-054/390754070/170.7,.078390730-4744/390.4:78041907.43;078,94343,8.431/0/94,,9,90,8-0030053,439207:/0,,389830-470543;04190,99078701:8,9403/2842024300:3/079031:03.0416:4743,8

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    28/119

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

    41,43,8,3/,,.,3-0.,70/990.4250.72041,9902590/2:7/07942./0-0.,:80,830,.9.,:80/,0887,;0,3/,7,;0104379#!-107043,8,3/,,8,07:80901443/0103808%,990,..:80/,/34390394394.4229847,;0,743,89,9.422990/,89020703903/0/9417903054%,943,8.422990/90.7203,89,9041394.,9439070-25,738540747.,5,.994:3/0789,3/907431:3088418,.9433903943,394.,9438,29,93.7.:289,3.0!0450:8479.$#79#!9,93!0,41:93,..:80/.,70/990.7204142./050,/0/349:9/:739057023,73;089,943-0147090:3.5,4:79&5439000;,9434190.,809490#043,%7,4:79904:7941

    .42509039:78/.943050,/0/:91700,3/;4:39,7:543,77,32039,3850,41:9-0147090#%-0.438/070/85439,304:8,3/9:8039902949029,93.7.:289,3.04185439,304:850,41:9:3/0779#!$&$%$#08850,41:9-0147090#043,%7,4:79.,3-0.438/070/85439,304:8147.0803990/949029,93.7.:289,3.04150,41:9850,41349:9-0147090:3.5,4:79822,907,,89,82,/0/:7357023,73;089,94343,3/-01470,.4:79349.4250903994703/07:/20399,93!0,41:9#06:8908347/079,99050,41:92,-029,93,9706:89082:89-0.4250/9$&$%$#4750,41:994-029,9390706:8908,70

    %,990,..:80/85439,304:850,/0/:99490.720.,70/%,98:.50,,82,/0-0147090.4:79.42509039949790.,80,3/703/07:/2039,3/%,98:.50,,82,/0574794905708039,943410;/03.01479057480.:9439,93!0,41:9'4:39,7$:7703/071907390;.9290,..:80/,-8.43/0/08:..00/0/30:/39054.0:3908:71,.0/,3/8:7703/070/9490,:947908,-4:9940,78,907,70/92:7/07050,/0/349:9-:9,19079057480.:943,/57080390/94930880825.,9329490.7200.,30/850,949,941:9$4:/9029,93.7.:289,3.0841;4:39,78:7703/07,3/50,41:9-0.438/070/31,;474190,..:80/

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    29/119

    $&$%$#'4:39,78:7703/0784:/-0.438/070/,8,29,93.7.:289,3.01907940,789054.007089:3,,704190070,-4:984190,..:80/,3/90,9907723,,,7,23,943".4:/,;0.4393:0/940:/0,77089..47/3908:7703/074190,..:80/84:/-0.438/070/29,93-0.,:809,8/43085439,304:83/.,9;04190702478047705039,3.043905,79418,/,..:80/,3/90701470-88:7703/0790,..:80/8,;0/904;073203905038080114798,3/920%#%'$#'4:39,78:7703/072,349-0,5570.,90/31,;474190,..:80/%40,78894443,92094.438/07908:7703/07,885439,304:8!0450:8-,4$#478:70904;0732039,/,70,/3.:770/.438/07,-00114798,3/0503808344314790,..:80/!0,41:9.,3344307-0,5570.,90/,8,29,93.7.:289,3.0-0.,:809057480.:943,/,70,/89,790/9905708039,94341980;/03.0795,7#0;80/!03,4/09,93'4:39,7$:7703/07,74:5438003884303,0/3,8.:1109#03089,--0/,3/0/90,990719079089,--30-74:98843420%00141!4.04190943,..425,30/-80;07,54.020303994,7484:80,74:543800390,5574,.354.0203.,20/43174284:80942009902,3/;4:39,703999029490!4.0$9,94394-03;089,90/3.4330.943990303

    0;039:,.,70/9,3/.43;.90/4142./0,7443,550,1,:90/9097,.4:79147349,5570.,93381,;479029,93.7.:289,3.041;4:39,78:7703/078003990/948:.,29,93.7.:289,3.05,3$&$%$#08,74803990/949029,93.7.:289,3.041;4:39,78:7703/07%0.7:419088:080907901,.99,9,74039420,1907903./039-:9.,20/43,3/2099054.0411.078,3/03999028.438/070/'4:39,78:7703/07%0;4:39,73088418:7703/07890890/1908,20885439,304:884390390394190,..:80/948:-292801:3.43/943,9490,:947908%82:89-00907,-0.,:800,.340/088:947--0.,:800808948,;090290974:-0,3/050380830.088,73.:770/3880,7.,3/.,59:70#008422039,7085%:890,.94190

    ,..:80/3/3,1907.42288434190.720-:9;4:39,703999054.02034,/430948/35,.0943;089,90,80/94-029,93.7.:289,3.0!0450;8,79.90/3#008422039,70859,93'4:39,7$:7703/070203980388:7703/07-,3,..:80/.438/070/;4:39,7,3/.43899:9;0419029,93.7.:289,3.041;4:39,78:7703/07$&$%$#8:7703/07-,341103/078.438/070/;4:39,7039885439,304:83/.,9;041,339039948:-29:3.43/943,9490,:947908%4-029,93908:7703/072:89-04185439,304:803/.,9;041,.340/203941:9,3/349147.43;0303.0347.43/943,

    2,/0-01470904;07320393.:780503808920,3/011479397,.3/439041103/078070,-4:98,3/2,/094,5078433,:94794790,99078,0398#'%#&$%$7,;,937.:289,3.084804234,344,3/073,3/4,720/9-448,9,-4:94304.4.3902473374--0/,4:80,9,/084,905,.0070,34810,3/9700/,:9078070;309014:7070390574.088417,38,.3,3484:80073,3/4349.39,943041,348/,:9078,89739409,,7,3,190707,3/13,.,:9:59073,9.098420,9/89,391742904:80

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    30/119

    073,3/4-01470-733-,.90/,:90794904:807,50/071789%070,19079014:7.,790/,,90-0433841,34,3/81,2,9.720//4804234,344,3/073,3/4.42295,3$:55480,19079074--079014:79449:73837,53909700/,:907841,3438/090,990784:80-:9-0147090019900/90401,294570;039/0391.,943,9.720//9014:7.42295,3&3/07901,.984190.,80,9,7,;,93.7.:289,3.082,-0,5570.,90/,,3899014:75,3$&$%$#,4804234,3/,344.422990/#4--070073,3/4.422990/.4250.72041#4--079#,50-%0.7204:/-0#4--07942./0-0.,:809038070-70,84394570;039/0391.,943,3/43904..,843419074--07%02:9507,508.422990/,3/901,.99,980;07,50784380700/42./04:/-0.438/070/,8,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08%07,508,70834324:893423,3/90,//943,3834324:89.7:09!0450;8$48$#!0450;8!,,$#.%0,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08.2,-0.438/070/3905702808,70,3/-0.,:80,9014:741103/078,70,720/4.9:29-0.,:800;/0399041103/078944,/;,39,04139920

    /03,3/&33,-90/5,.0-0.,:80904:8007090.7208070.422990/,8,9,/084,905,.0,3/4-;4:89041103/078944,/;,39,04198.7.:289,3.03.42299390.720723,,,7,23,943"7,;,937.:289,3.0803078;8":,13893:80307.,7,;,93.7.:289,3.017426:,13,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0$&$%$#0307.7,;,937.:289,3.08,110.98439025489434190503,95708.7-0/-:9349903,9:704190.720.422990/.,3-0411809-47/3,729,93.7.:289,3.08300/349-0,00/39031472,943,843,8574;03/:739097,908,208,-0.438/070/32548390803903.0":,137,;,937.:289,3.08

    2:89-0,00/39031472,943,3/574;03/:7397,.,3349-0411809-29,93.7.:289,3.08,110.98903,9:704190.72047-738,-4:9,503,9073/07009,39,947/3,75708.7-0/7,;,937.:289,3.083/8!03,908,209014:73/841,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08,3/89,909070110.94390503,941.7208,3/3,9:70907041$&$%$#%014:73/841,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08,70##'%4794809,9.,30307,,5594,.7208,3/.,3-0411809-29,93.7.:289,3.08-:913494118094:/,110.943902,2:24190503,95708.7-0/-,$!#'%4794809,9,5543945,79.:,7.7208,3/.,3349-0411809-29,93.7.:289,3.08

    "&$%$4794809,9.,30903,9:704190.72094,7,;0743047-738,-4:9,503,9309073/0700,3/.,3349-0411809-29,93.7.:289,3.08#%#'%4794809,9088039,,..425,390.42288434190.720,3//408349,110.990503,9,9840;077,;,937:09#0,9438503,/407/7;03--089,/0870540/,:3438/,:90703147.-:3/70880/07,3/90/07089490-0/0,84-:730/071,.09,90/.,770900,2,/2,30,:0/07,5307,9,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08,705708039398.,80$&$%$#

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    31/119

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

    -003,00/39031472,943946:,1903942:7/076:,13.7.:289,3.02:89-0,00/39031472,943,3/574;03-043/70,843,-0/4:-9/:739097,94-0,5570.,90/,88:.7,;,939920,3/9,-4:93900;033034,3/#,11070,3,43!,/70,:7,$97009,3,43399029,74.3:7334,990-,.#,11,5574,.0/34-:98://034--$90;0,33,3/4348:774:3/0/90/:4%034--89,--0/34$90;0,33434,3/4330594399334,3/#,11974.88,708:934/0/4--$90;0,33434,3/433070.,70/942./0,390.4:79,5570.,9090,7,;,93.7.:289,3.084139920,3/-,3/$&$%$#439920.,3349-0,5570.,90/,8,3,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0-0.,:8090708343/.,9439,99041103/078/0-07,9084:990.4;0741/,73088941,.9,9090.42288434190.720479,990

    944,/;,39,04139920!0450;8048#008$#08/08:/.,349.0.,3-09,0341901,.99,9!,/70,:7,$970098090/40;07-,3/84:/-0.438/070/,890.720,8.422990/-24709,39700,720/2,01,.94783,70.039$:570204:79/0.8438943084774.8,70.438/070//0,/0,54387,;,93#0./;82:,3/0,8974,70,/,/9700570;4:8.43;.9438-13,:/20391479019030,814:3/:941#4--07942./0390,89.,809097,:/0.438/070/,,38990,..:80/-4970./;82,3/,-9:,/036:03.%0,..:80/,550,0/,3/.43903/0/9,938,89.43;.9439097,.4:79.,3349.438/07,,3892,13/34170./;82,3/723,,,7,23,943",,341,-9:,/036:03.890,550,2079474:85,3

    $&$%$#490,550,83492079474:8#0./;82,3/,-9:,/036:03.,70.4770.9.438/070/398.,80-0.,:8090-,884170./;828/110703917429,941,-9:,/036:03.:,38,70./;89-0.,:800,/-003570;4:8.43;.90/-13,:/20391479019,3/,,314:3/:9147#4--07942./0.,70-49.7208,,389574507902-7,.0/:3/07908,20%90%90%0344%4(4190#0;80/!03,4/0%025.,94389,908850.,3390.422884341.7208,,389574507903.0,7,;,93390.43;.943147#4--07942./0,-9:,/036:03..-738,-4:9,3,//943,503,903,341103/078.43;.90/,97/920472470147850.10/.72088.4770.9.438/070/

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    32/119

    7,;,93#0./;82;8":,8#0./;82893:8-0900370./;82,3/6:,870./;82($&$%$#370./;82%0.43;.9438419041103/07,70147.720802-7,.0/3908,20%904190#0;80/!03,4/0,3/%8.7.:289,3.080307.,7,;,93,3/90701470.,3-00110.9-,347/3,729,93.7.:289,3.0070,836:,870./;82%0.43;.9438,70349147.720802-7,.0/3908,20%904190#0;80/!03,4/0574;/0/9,998,10439,9,8.422990/-9041103/07-01470807;3803903.0-13,:/2039147,34907.720470807;3803903.0147,34907.720,3/%8.7.:289,3.08,850.,,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0..,3349-0411809-,329,93.7.:289,3.07,;,93%70,.07&3,1:397%0,..:80/,3/90;.924..:50/,/,.039,5,79203980,.-03,805,7,90/03:3941430-4:80%0,..:80/8:850.90/81041,;3,3.970,943990;.9230,1907344308,90;.92,3/81094090743-4,7/,;0.03900;033419,9/,90,..:80/03994-0/

    0,7,3/970/948005-:9-0384,3340/4;07908:850.90/70,943-09003810,3/90;.920.4:/3498005,9073903907084;0/94;.92074801742-0/,3/9444/41,3100039070/90,5,7920394190;.92974:,3:34.0/3/438/008,90;.9284:3/,800509070:54389,--0/90;.9231.9380;07,4:3/8..,:80/8/0,993,104:78414:/4:8,9,9903,8,9903/0/-906:,1347,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08410;/03957020/9,943970,.0739920,3/:3,1:0397$&$%$#;/03957020/9,943.,3349-0.438/070/,,38990,..:80/-0.,:8007084;0/9490;.92,90739039,3/9070,8348:11.039,58041920-0900390/090723,943,3/00.:94394,48.438.03.0944;07.420907084:943418

    %##2,-05708039-0.,:8090,..:80/89,--0/90;.92090,9907,884:3/,8005..47/3002540/20,38,3/2094/8./70.9,3/850.,38:70/9000.:9434190,.994:9782801,783174290/010380.90;.9229,;02,/0!0450;806:3,!!0450;87,3/,09,9!9920.,3349-0,5570.,90/-0.,:8090708348439,990,..:80//0-07,9084:947,;,0/41399209438:70908:..088418,.9%0390394394.422990.720,8.43.0;0/8479-0147098.4228843!0450;8!,7/4!4704;07399208,-847-0/3970,.07&&%#2,-0,5570.,90/,8,3,7,;,93.7.:289,3.03,82:.,890,..:80/039070/9074424190;.92974:903/4.8349905745075,.01470397,3.0394904:80795,7#0;80/!03,4/0!0450;8,7:,!

    %#%'#&$%$9073,9;07.:289,3.08394.,943,83;90/94,/73385700-1703/81907,;3,/,/739442,3,3/,/,0,90/,7:2039/:73.89,--0/8,708:98:11070/8074:858.,3:708,90394.,94341-0.438/070/,7,;,934729,93$&$%$#%0394.,943412,-0572,1,.0.438/070/29,9383.09,820703./039,9490.42288434190.72092,349-0.438/070/,7,;,93,89070834.0,73/.,9431742901,.984190.,809,99,8,-9:,473903943,43905,79417,;,93.7.:289,3.08,7034994-0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    33/119

    5708:20/9084:/-0574;0/-043/70,843,-0/4:-9!#$$723,,-0147$3903.3,03.347,4,803,0/3905:7.,80,3/8,041007,857480.:90/14790;4,94341!490780343,8903903.3,147,;3-00314:3/94-035488088434170.03989403007;,:0/,9!,907007845,9,5490723,,,7,23,943"#4,/,8!3,80974,3,$0908910//:739097,9,9802070-4:9908,2017424303,20/0.34,3/0;03574/:.0/,70.059.4;073908,00.343905,89:80/94/0;079407007081478,0-:9857080393407094-014:3/43;.90/-9097,.4:79147;4,94341903903.3,80,7:0/4707,.6:99,43,550,.43903/39,99057480.:9431,0/94574;09,980304784:/,;03439,9900070870.4;070/17420707090574.00/84190.7204174--07479019$&$%$#447,8/010380834909,03-0.,:80207054880884341,3,79.041;,:0.,8-003908:-0.94190194774--078,-0572,1,.00;/03.041103.3!4%0-:7/038:54390

    ,..:80/94574;09,980,.6:70/90007092,9007/01038041,;3-4:99000717428420430480070,-4:988:3343/4083494;07.420905708:2594341103.3,,38907!,239:,3;8!0450#::3507843,57450795:9890-:0743.,;0,9-0.,:80419057,8089,9084:/,;0343474:994349,99890574.00/174274--0747901908/088084:/,;01440/90,/23897,9;0574.0/:70:3/0790/0.7009,9410993,.0,7,3.0174290,:9479083.,8090/0,078:3.0380/347/079408.,50,-93903.3,03.3;8%01947#4--07,9890/110703.0-09003,103.0,3/,3,..088479490194774--075,389070,382,79-09003902$&$%$#30/110703.0-09003,103.0,3/,3,..088479490194774--07890503,93;4;0/,103.08

    5:380/,8,573.5,:3/07!4,3/90503,9807070,8,3,..088479474--07479019:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/085:380/94/070084079,390573.5,:30880-4:947574190/174290574.00/84190194774--07,783174274--073!5530,8:3/07!4070085:380/,8,3,..425.003.090503,98430/070040784103.38,2,:2574-9:2,3/907014709070834300/94574;0.723,390394190,..:80/988349843;4,943841#0;80/!03,4/0$&$%$#0890708,82,79390803809,9,90,.984143048,3,..088479490.72084174--07479019,703.:/0/390,.98/0130/,8103.331,.990,..08847390.72084174--07479019

    .4:/-057480.:90/,88:.:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/047,8,103.0:3/07!443!,239:,3;8!0450$#(3903.3,03.3020398,9,7090002039841103.3$&$%$#%0002039841103.3,70,,.7204174--07479019,8-003.422990/41,..:80/48349,573.5,47,..425.0390.720-:870.0;085488088080058,.6:708.43.0,847/85480847-:8,3/808473,32,3307/0,83,3,79.09024-0.947,39341

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    34/119

    ;,:0.,8-003/07;0/174290574.00/8418,/.72090,..:80/3484784:/,;03439,98,/,79.09024-0.947,39341;,:0,8-003/07;0/174290174290574.00/84190.7204174--07479019,3/9070843905,794190,..:80/3903994,3147280147147,34907723,,-9..088470803.0303994904:8041,:7,4,8,430,:7,411070/2,/73,3/,1907.438:239700-4990841-00732,/0,/;,3.089407,3/9147.0,3/;403.07,;80/07%0330/,:7,,3/9440700742338,/4590/-749070,730/,-4:9903./039003994,:7,84:80/07-4/.0,30/0;0793,3/,80/90-44/89,3838/0907442,9073,;04808092,90-7490743050.041007-043394,:7,480309,990007,89,031742,:7,-:9343090088084/9147!,9.72047.7208//3423,3/480.42298.:88907.723,,-908($&$%$#3.422990/90.4254890.72041#,50942./0,8,8303/;8-04110380349,.4250.720,3/%0194238,.98,;3-003/4309340/04190.42288434190.720,3/4-;4:894.43.0,90-4/4190.72094570;03998/8.4;072,082,3,..088479490.720417,50942./0:3/07795,74190#0;!03,4/0-:908002591742.723,,-99070147:3/0779.0

    41904/0-03,3,/4590/-749074190573.5,4803.:78.723,,-90907,8,3,..088479490.720419019.422990/-347,8103.094:08,092,90-74907413900025943:3/0779.0/4083493.:/0905,79.5,9430//-0.,:800574190/1742900110.98418:.9019-803900073439,9908,20,89,031742,:7,74802,-057480.:90/147103.3:3/07903903.3,41!483.090007,890574.00/8419019,3/93903994,3070.0;0/917423,3/84/9723,,-943025943,8..0884790/,:907418940900,773841,897,3075,30/900,77389%!,3845,8,50/0147!4,3:739097,7,80/90/0103809,9-0390249074180.,3349-0723,,,7,23,943"

    0/,-0,8,3,..088478/0103805748507#0,843-701$&$%$#48/0103803495748507-0.,:809000259431742.723,,-941,3,..08847-;79:04170,94385990573.5,/408349.4;07,..0884708490280;08574190/174247,88890/9041103/079457419-900110.9847574.00/84190.720%8343002594341,3,..0884794:70,90/9490573.5,4190.7208057088574;/0/3794190#0;80/!03,4/0723,,-9!73.5,-70.9!,79.5,9434!73.5,-3/85038,-044507,94308590902,88;0,/;07983.,25,3320/,,,389170.7,.078,3/:3173/:739000,78.00-7,943843,8,3/,,-4:9903-408418:50744,3/5,5,34.,:0:,.,3014702/39410.02-0743,8,3/,,89,790/907.00-7,943-,;3,/73385700,9

    43,85,.0-054/390754070/170.7,.078390730-4744/390.4:78041907.43;078,94343,8.431/0/94,,9,90,8-0030053,439207:/0,,389830-470543;04190,99078701:8,9403/2842024300:3/079031:03.0416:4743,889,790/974390/8:50744838/00548103.094779,902,3/908,20054/0/38/090,99078,7/&5433439,990974341908:50744,8/0-07,90054-0.,201:74:8,3/89073,730/43,894894582,.4:8,.94704:/09,90,390/0,90/,7:2039-0900343,8,3/054038:0/-:9,,970/94.,2/4381703/92/3943,8.43;3.0/,,9403/28.,-075894849,90.4:/:8099434./43054,3/9403/8,774,3.043,8

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    35/119

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

    $&$%$#44:/349-0,-0,8,573.5,-3/:.02039-0.,:809070,7/0574280/834990840250370,843.2,/094%4-73,-4:9.723,,-941,.4573.5,903/:.020392,/0-903/:.072:89-090840.438/07,943..,:80/905078433/:.0/94.422990.720,3/94:9.90.7204:/349,;0-003.422990/%01,.984190.,803/.,909,990078:55480/3/:.0/-,/84370,843944:941,4389,3/37:/0723,,-9!73.5,3/:.02039!,79.5,943%,9,438,970089470-:/34.,90/,94077,3$97009!,.4,3,$0,390/94.43897:.9,30-:/3-:9,/3424309413,3.090.43897:.943$48038:70/90-:/3147!$0903:70/4-4,3/43814724309,7.438/07,94394-:7307-:/38480.4:/.40.9

    9038:7,3.0574.00/84-4,3/438-:730/908,/-:/3708:939498949,488,9890770850.9;0.723,,-9$&$%$#%,9,8,573.5,-3/:.02039-0.,:8080/70.93/:.0/4-4,3/438147,57.04724309,7.438/07,94394.4229,7843.90,99074:/349,;0.422990/07093491478:.70,8434-4,3/438,70573.5,8-/70.95,79.5,943795,78,3/#!0897:.9;07843%,9,438,970089470-:/34.,90/,94077,3$97009!,.4,3,$0,390/94.43897:.9,30-:/3-:9,/3424309413,3.090.43897:.943$48038:70/90-:/3147!

    $0903:70/4-4,3/43814724309,7.438/07,94394-:7307-:/38480.4:/.40.99038:7,3.0574.00/84-4,3/438-:730/908,/-:/3708:939498949,488,9.720//%,9,4-4,3/438.4229$&$%$#%,9,4-4,3/438.422990/90.72041/0897:.9;0,7843-0.,:8090.40.9;0.,:80/90/0897:.943415745079-20,3841170:3/0790.7.:289,3.08.05480/94/,30790104757450794149078795,7#!,8,203/0/-#4!%$4250720;84254:3/720

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    36/119

    893:8.0,7-:9-70109003.4254:3/,3/.4250.7208,8.43.0598390!03,4/0$&$%$#!$708:9039041103/07.422990/43,83010434:8,.91742.9447723,,,7,23,943"2470.7208708:90/%88574;/0/147324/10/147239017895,794179.0#0;80/!03,4/029390708:93.720894437,;0,3/470887,;010430803.09104308,700.:/0/0;0394:708:931742908,20830,.9!#$708:9039041103/07,894.4229,34110380,8,30.088,720,38147.422993,349074110380343031472,9438,-010/,3/1574;0390503,91479024708074:8.7208,-025480/4250720;8$50.,4250720;80944393:,/4893:890144317420,.4907$&$%$#3##!#82,/0:54194472470.7208-035:380/3/893.9574;84384190#0;80/!03,4/0-:9,00/343031472,9430907-0.,:8090070-74:9,-4:9-,83010434:8,.947-0.,:8043041103808,30.088,720,38147.42299390490741103804741103808%0,70,00/343031472,943849,943430503,98,-025480/894503,90847/3,7.4250.72090503,91479024898074:8.7208,-025480/,3/3982,2:25074/$!!#43904907,3/82,/0:54194472470.7208.,70

    .438/070/43,8.42543039841,8303/;8-04110380-035:380/3430574;8434190#0;80/!03,4/0894503,908850.,.4250.72043430503,98850.1.,5708.7-0/147,90.42543039.7208.,7070,7/0/,84303/;8-04110380%0.42543039.7208,7034970,7/0/,8/893.9.7208,3/8490503,91479024898074:8.720834990503,994-025480/3473982,2:25074/9890503,9850.1.,574;/0/14790850.,.4250.7209,98,-0,550/,..47/394907:084325489434190503,9%%&47%&&$#8,9072:80/94/03490,843430.720,807084110434:8,.98,7831742,830.723,7084:9433498:8.059-041/;843.,70.,770/4:93908,205,.0,3/,9,-4:9908,20920,3/;4,93430,3/908,20503,574;843%0,.98/4302:89-02500/-430.723,39039475:754808:.9,90,.,.92070.43899:908,5,79,00.:94341,5,79.:,7.720;4,93430,3/908,20503,574;84393;4;08,.43.:7703.04110434:8,.98;4,93,.4224379,.42243503,574;843,3/2500/-,830.723,

    25:80!0450;80/082,$#4250720-077,94.9:8;8077473507843,0893:8,-077,94.9:81742077473507843,0$&$%$#41-077,94.9:847289,0390-44..:7803,10434:8,.92880/90507843,,389429,8/70.90/,3/93890,/8420-4/4,8349903903/0/;.9277473507843,047289,03/03994..:78039010434:8,.9,8/70.90/,9905078433903/0/-:949:730/4:994-08420-4/080-077,94.9:8-738,-4:9,90,899410434:8.43806:03.0090,9902590/104343903903/0/;.924,83499,3/9010434390:33903/0/;.924,89.4250.720419017891472:3/0779#!0307,708:93077473507843,043430.7208.422990/

    4250720-077,94.9:877473!07843,0!7,0907390394302,9/44::3/0789,3/-,-077,94.9:8077473507843,0,3/57,0907390394302490,90790.723,,-941,3,..:80/5,3$&$%$###%%&$47289,0390-44..:78039041103/07/0;070/90-4,983903/0/;.92-:92880/,3/3890,/8:.-4,3/0/43,3:33903/0/;.92%089:,9430307,-738,-4:9.4250.72080701742,830,.9944724707,;0470887,;0104308708:90/3,2090,990259,,389903903/0/;.92,3/90.43806:03.04390:33903/0/;.928.4250.7208

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    37/119

    90503,91479024708074:8.7208,-09043025480/,3/3902,2:25074/98430390708:93104308,704399,9.4250.7208/4349708:9,3/90503,908,7094-025480//893.91470,.708:93.720###!#$47289,03/03994..:78039041103/07,.9:,990507843944290-4,8/70.90/-:99:730/4:994-0/11070391742,3/34990;.923903/0/%0.723,,-9419041103/078349,110.90/:308890289,03/0399708:90/94,.720/11070391742,99041103/073903/0/94.42293..,809008807503,9-0900390.7203903/0/,3/90.720.422990/8,-025480/-:93902,2:25074/79#!#%#%%4707090.43806:03.0039-043/9,93903/0/47050.90/%88,29,93.7.:289,3.0795,7#!0390708,349474:8/85,79-0900390,.94720,3802540/-9041103/07,3/90708:931043090708:931043.4:/349-070,843,-,39.5,90/4714708003-9041103/07174290,.94720,3802540/-24250720-077,94.9:89902590/:7/07942./008590902,88;0,/;07983.,25,3320/,,,389170.7,.078,3/:3173/:739000,78.00-7,943843,8,3/,,-4:9903-408418:50744,3/5,5,34.,:0:,.,3014702/39410.02-0743,8,3/,,89,790/907723,,,7,23,943"

    .00-7,943-,;3,/73385700,943,85,.0-054/390754070/170.7,.078390730-4744/390.4:78041907.43;078,94343,8.431/0/94,,9,90,8-0030053,439207:/0,,389830-470543;04190,99078701:8,9403/2842024300:3/079031:03.0416:4743,889,790/974390/8:50744838/00548103.094779,902,3/908,20054/0/38/090,99078,7/&5433439,990974341908:50744,8/0-07,90054-0.,201:74:8,3/89073,730/43,894894582,.4:8,.94704:/09,90,390/0,90/,7:2039-0900343,8,3/054038:0/-:9,,970/94.,2/4381703/92/3943,8.43;3.0/,,9403/28.,-075894849,90.4:/:8099434./43054,3/9403/

    8,774,3.043,894:99,9,1907,05484380700;07070,3/34-4/4:/3448490541907,,0398170,729443,890,9907,,389,790/974390/8:507448,3/5,5,8,90548,7/347/0794574;402849,904:/.4204:94184:8003054.,204:943,8220/,9084929,,8.,-07:3-:92880/89,7093890,/90-:09905481;00,74/8434,81443-03/2390-4389,39,304:8,,9.72047.7208.,343,8,3/,,-0.,70/95,3$&$%$#43,8,3/,,.,3-0.,70/990.4250.72041,9902590/2:7/07942./0-0.,:80,830,.9.,:80/,0887,;0,3/,7,;0104379#!

    9902590/2:7/078,0887,;010430.438:22,90/42./08,7,;01043-49,705:38,-0-,11.9;0503,90842507204.973041-077,94.9:84955.,-09900941,3,907.,943!0/794849!,:4-:92880/993%-:7.43890,/708:93390/0,94190,9907!0/7943;4390/4.973041,-077,94.9:8.,2800259431742.723,,-914:07090:/044:/4:/0./090.,80$&$%$#107090:/0.43;.9!0/794,3/13/2:94190.4250.7204142./099902590/42./0%0830,.941173,9!,:4708:90/390.42288434194104308430

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    38/119

    7,;042./0,3/9049070887,;0,9902590/42./09:81,386:,70:3/0779#!03.090503,94:/-01479024708074:8.72042./0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    39/119

    503,99070147$&$%$#.4250.7208.43899:90/03,830,.9.,:80/944724707,;0470887,;01043084703,341103808.422990/,8,30.088,720,3894.4229,34907411038079#!90,8994.7208,703;4;0/3,.4250.7200907944724707,;0470887,;0104308708:90/1742,830,.947,341103808.422990/,8,30.088,720,38147.422993,34907%0503,91479024708074:8.7208,-025480/,3/3982,2:25074/79#!425072087/3,74250720;8$50.,4250720893:8-09003,347/3,7.4250.720,3/,850.,.4250.720,894907.43.0598,3/,89490254894341503,908$&$%$#!%3##!#82,/0:54194472470.7208-035:380/3/893.9574;84384190#0;80/!03,4/0-:9,00/343031472,9430907-0.,:8090070-74:9,-4:9-,83010434:8,.947-0.,:8043041103808,30.088,720,38147.42299390490741103804741103808%0,70,00/343031472,943849,943430503,98,-025480/$!!#43904907,3/82,/0:54194472470.7208.,70.438/070/43,8.42543039841,8303/;8-04110380-035:380/3430574;8434190

    #0;80/!03,4/0$%!%$3##!#90503,91479024898074:8.7208,-025480/,3/3982,2:25074/3$!!#43430503,98850.1.,5708.7-0/147,90.42543039.7208.,7070,7/0/,84303/;8-04110380%0.42543039.7208,7034970,7/0/,8/893.9.7208,3/8490503,91479024898074:8.720834990503,994-025480/3473982,2:25074/984190503,9850.1.,574;/0/14790850.,.4250.7209,98,-0,550/,..47/394907:084325489434190503,94393:3110380;80944393:,/41107039,90/094.4393:,/41742,.4393:34110380

    $&$%$#%%&47%&&$#8,9072:80/94/03490,843430.720,807084110434:8,.98,7831742,830.723,7084:9433498:8.059-041/;843.,70.,770/4:93908,205,.0,3/,9,-4:9908,20920,3/;4,93430,3/908,20503,574;843%0,.98/4302:89-02500/-430.723,39039475:754808:.9,90,.,.92070.43899:908,5,79,00.:94341,5,79.:,7.720;4,93430,3/908,20503,574;84393;4;08,.43.:7703.04110434:8,.98;4,93,.4224379,.42243503,574;843,3/2500/-,830.723,25:80!0450;80/082,$#3904907,3/,%&$8430480088039,370/03989445,.0324709,34302:3.5,947.9842:.849,990.723,57480.:9432,-03899:90/,3/90.,80970/390.42509039.4:7941,3430418:.2:3.5,947.9

    %09072%//094.4393:,/42,3/,9089,94343031472,94384:/-010/,,3899041103/07,94:,807084110434:8,.9807050714720/909072.4393:3.7208247050793039:80/97010703.09490;03:007090.723,,.9432,-03899:90/0,9!03,9%0/0,9503,9.,3349-031.90/:3/07.41901443.7.:289,3.080390:95078438,90,890,7841,0,9909204190.42288434190.7200390:9507843824709,30,7841,003:543,550,9447,:942,9.70;0-90$:570204:7990706:70/2,4791479025489434190/0,9503,983494-9,30/0390

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    40/119

    5078438.43;.90/41,.,59,.720-:9-0147000.:943-0.420838,300390,..:80/8,42,308085703,3947934300,7,1907/0;075,34:7,380747.4.0-701$&$%$#&3/0789,3/39047/31.90/9420,39025489434190/0,9503,93499800.:94390.7.:289,3.03.90/0,9503,9.,3349-031.90/8340390:9507843824709,30,7841,079#0;80/!03,4/03890,/90503,98,-0.422:90/9470.:843507509:,990,..08847503,908574;/0/379.0#3.7.:289,3.0340390:95078438,90,890,7841,0,9909204190.42288434190723,,,7,23,943".72090/0,9503,9.,3-025480/83.09041103/078,70,/410,,0030.422990/90.7207.:289,3.0343443074507,908.438/07390/0.8434190$:570204:793!0450;81703,904#:574;/3,3390720/,9070;01478:..,80807090503,925480/8/0,970.:843507509:,47102578432039-0147090,7000;,90/9490$:570204:793.7.:29,3.0834890/0,9503,9.,3-025480/15708.7-0/-90,;4,90/,94:9800.:9438,-08:8503/0/0390.43;.9-0.420838,30-014709.4:/-000.:90/,3/00

    838,3008090/0,9503,9.,3-025480/:543,42,3-:99800.:9438,-08:8503/0//:73075703,3.,3/1474300,7,190707/0;07%#%'$#%047/%814:3/4337994900110.99,990/0,9503,92,349-0%:543,5703,3942,38:.503,9894-08:8503/0/1%894-0.43897:0/,8&%9034890.4.00,9!03,9":,10/#,50#06:8908',8.43;.90/417,53%830.0,3/0,8803903.0/94/0,99,8,00/39031472,9439,990;.92,8,2347-0480;030,784/,3/0724907908910/9,980,84380,78

    ,3/903243984/.07,:39.4774-47,90/43909308889,3/%031472,943,84,00/9,990,..:80/,890;.928:3.0,1,.9574;0/-9057480.:9433,:942,9.70;0-0147090$:570204:79,..:80/,550,39.43903/89,9.,59,5:382039.4:/349-025480/432-0.,:8041903,/06:,.4190.,708,3/9038:11.03.41900;/03.094574;0,9000203984190034:8.720417,50-043/70,843,-0/4:-98,550,398.43903943.4770.9#0,843-701$&$%$#08,550,398.439039438.4770.93841,7,890,04190;.928.43.0730/%0,04190;.927,50/,8349-003574;0/-043/70,843,-0/4:-994.43899:9090.720,86:,10/7,50,3//0807;34190/0,9503,9%0:/03083,5570.,93,0,8,6:,13.7.:289,3.037,50.,808,;0

    349-003209949%0572,70;/03.04190,04190;.92807-79.0791.,90390,-803.04190-79.0791.,90,04190;.922,-0574;03-,:9039./4.:20398:.,8-,5982,.0791.,90,3/8.4470.47/8190,14708,//4.:20398,7084394,;0-00348947/089740/47490780:3,;,,-09090892431.0,7,3/.70/-04190;.9282490747,3202-0741901,2-.438,3:3947,1139486:,10/9490891432,9907870850.9350/7008:.,8900,.9,0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    41/119

    4147/,9041-79419041103/0/5,795:78:,3994$0.943#:04190#:0843;/03.08,-08:11.039-:943:3/07901443.7.:289,3.08,190;.928,00/94-0-040,7841,0,3/,9884:994-0574;0/89,98080889,30,784/-190;.928,00/94-0-040,7841,0,3/,9884:994-0574;0/89,98080889,30,784/.190;.928,00/94-0-040,7841,0,3/,9884:994-0574;0/89,98080889,30,784/390,-803.041,.0791.,9041;0-79,:9039./4.:2039479090892434190;.928249074770,9;08.43.073390;.928,0:3/0790.7.:289,3.08,-4;089,90/.425,3,3988409089243.,38:11.0574;/0/9,998057088,3/.0,7,/2990/-90,..:80/!0450:8!7:3,$#(,-9:,036:03.#0./;82:,3/0,8974,70,/,/9700570;4:8.43;.9438-13,:/20391479019030,814:3/:941#4--07942./0390,89.,809097,:/0.438/070/,,38990,..:80/-4970./;82,3/,-9:,/036:03.%0,..:80/,550,0/,3/.43903/0/9,938,89.43;.9439097,.4:79.,3349.438/07,,3892,13/34170./;82,3/,,341,-9:,/036:03.890,550,2079474:85,3$&$%$#490,550,83492079474:8#0./;82,3/,-9:,/036:03.,70.4770.9.438/070/398

    .,80-0.,:8090-,884170./;828/110703917429,941,-9:,/036:03.:,38,70./;89,-9:,/036:03..-738,-4:9,3,//943,503,903,341103/078.43;.90/,97/920472470147850.10/.72088.4770.9.438/070/-0.,:80:,3,/,70,/9700570;4:8.43;.9438-13,:/20391479019,3/,,3.43;.90/147#4--07942./03/90.7208850.10/,8-,88147,-9:,/036:03.3.:/083907,,9019,3/74--073/090723,90$03903.0,948,8.43;.90/41,34110380503,0/-,850.,,%0503,95708.7-0/83490889,380,78-:934924709,390;00,78424/13.7.:289,3.0,9903/0/90.42288434190.72014:07090:/04:,55903/090723,90$03903.0,18444:,559$&$%$#107090:/0,5590574;843841903/090723,90$03903.0,,890,89803903.041

    $0.943.9850.1.,574;/0890,55.,943907041147;4,943841850.,,8&3/07908,20574;84390232:22:89349-00889,390232:2574;/0/9070380,78,3/430/,,3/902,2:28,349-024709,390723,,,7,23,943"2,2:2574;/0/90703090;00,78!0450;8#48,3,#008$#3/090723,90$03903.0,3/7088.,70/9,34110380/0130/-,850.,,%0503,95708.7-0/14790411038082578432039413490889,31;00,78-:934924709,39030,78&543,77,320390039070/,50,41:939025489434190574507503,984:/903/090723,90$03903.0,-0,550/14:07090:/097390.,80,9503,94:/4:25480433/708

    $&$%$#08903/090723,90$03903.0,84:/-0,550/-0.,:8090232:22578432039824709,34300,7107090:/025480,33/090723,90803903.0902,2:241.8,3490.00/902,2:210/-,,3/90232:28,349-00889,390232:2503,95708.7-0/-908,20,;090/8.70943942548090503,993908,/232:2,3/2,2:23/090723,90$03903.0,,8.43;.90/410,5488088434170,80:38,3/94%4258438:-2,.30:385:38,-0:3/07904/,#4(925784320394117421;0949030,78%097,.4:79803903.0/

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    42/119

    90,..:80/948:11072578432039411;00,78,3/430/,890503,99:825480/.4770.95,3$&$%$#3/090723,90$03903.0,/408349,5594%0503,925480/-0343,897,9503,98349.4770.9-0.,:809/408349.4259903/090723,90$03903.0,.,55089498.,80$,/,706:7089,9190411038085:380/-,3,49079,390#0;80/!03,4/090.4:798,803903.090,..:80/94,33/090723,90803903.0902,2:2907241.8,3490.00/902,2:2503,910/-90,,3/90232:28,349-00889,390232:2503,95708.7-0/-908,203/090723,90$03903.0,4,70902,2:2,3/90232:29072841903/090723,90803903.0147411038085:38,-0:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/0/0907230/$&$%$#47.72085:380/:3/0790#0;80/!03,4/0902,2:2907241903/090723,90803903.08,-090503,95745072548,-0:3/07908,204/0,1907.438/07390,9903/329,93,3/47,7,;,93.7.:289,3.08,..47/39479418,/4/0%0232:2907241908,20803903.08,

    -010/93907,304190503,93094073/0700949,95708.7-0/14790.720:3/07908,/4/0&3/0790,,98905:7548014713902,2:2,3/90232:29072841903/090723,90803903.0$&$%$#41%05:754804190,31390232:290724190803903.0894809907,.05074/,9.90.43;.92,-0700,80/435,74017422578432039:3088-8.43/:.908349/0807;3415,740,3/9:808,.4393:0807;385784390723,-:9334.,80944-043/902,2:2907210/390803903.03/090723,90$03903.0,,74/,8.43;.90/41,.720/0130/,3/503,0/-,850.,503,,070902548,-0

    503,98174224398,8232:2940,78,82,2:2$9,90970,8438090790.4:792,.4770.925480901443503,908,,897,9503,94124398$&$%$#08-0.,:8090503,980889,34300,7,897,9503,92,-025480/!0450;70,34#4.94-07%#%'$#&3/07903/090723,90$03903.0,90232:22548,-0503,98,-025480/-:9902,2:28,3490.00/902,2:22548,-0-,-24398,8232:29424398,82,2:2$&$%$#

    4-0.,:803/090723,90$03903.0,/408349,550390503,925480/80889,34300,7$0.79,8,203/0/.,897,9503,9410,78$&$%$#4-0.,:80903/090723,90$03903.0,,550390232:24190503,90.00/84300,7%#%'$#190254894341897,9503,9..4388984190232:25074/4190503,95708.7-0/-,90392,-0,40/-0.,:8091,;47890,..:80/3/090723,90$03903.0,.059438

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    43/119

    &3/07,9.7.:289,3.088903/090723,90$03903.0,349,55.,-0$&$%$#!078438.43;.90/41411038085:380/9/0,9503,947102578432039%480.43;.90/41970,843.43857,.47574548,94.4229970,843%480.43;.90/41285784341970,84370-04380/9434708543,0%480.43;.90/4157,.%4804,70,-9:,/036:0398%48048,,;008.,50/1742.431302039470;,/0/803903.0%4804;4,90/909072841.43/943,5,7/437,390/94902-90010.:9;0%4804802,2:29072412578432039/4083490.00/4300,7723,,,7,23,943"%4804:54390,5574;,4190,0.02-07,/-003803903.0/-13,:/2039%480803903.0/9490503,941/0890774478:85038433/090723,90$03903.0,.059438034:/903/090723,90$03903.0,-03,55.,-0$&$%$#%03/090723,90$03903.0,8349,55.,-09494805078438.43;.90/41411038085:380/9/0,9503,9471025784320394770.:843507509:,9480.43;.90/41970,843.43857,.47574548,94.4229970,8439480.43;.90/41285784341

    970,84370-04380/9434708543,09480.43;.90/4157,.94804,70,-9:,/036:0398948048,,;008.,50/1742.431302039470;,/0/803903.094804,;3-0037,390/.43/943,5,7/43-90010.:9;08,,;0;4,90/909072890704194804802,2:29072412578432039/4083490.00/4300,79480,70,/803903.0/-13,:/2039,99092041,5574;,4198.9,3/9480480803903.0254808503,908./43493;4;025784320390/0890774!03,90830472578432039;8$:-8/,72578432039,3/,70.43;.90/41,503,,9,9254808,503,94113047257843203947-49130,3/2578432039%0:/0803903.0/902945,90130439,3/80;07,98:-8/,7

    25784320393.,8041384;03.890503,95745075,3$&$%$#%0503,98349574507%094,..:80/2:89805,7,905,90130.8907503,9$4/,7,-9,55084394.;,-908%#%'$#-0.,:803503,,039070,7080;07,41103/07890.4:79390007.804198/8.709438,/0907230,98,-0908,70410,.41103/07/0503/3:54390/0700415,79.5,943,8573.5,,..425.047,..088471930,..,884141103/079070,702470419028:.,824709,3430573.5,4724709,3430,..425.047,..0884790,-930,..,884141103/078,-08:-8/,7343041902,-0706:70/945,90.;,-95079,33948:.41103/0794:9570:/.09470.4;07174294804808,70,;0-0035,/-,34907,90:/025480,3,9073,9;0503,9411304725784320395,3

    $&$%$#414130090725480/,8,83047,8,3,9073,9;0503,984:/349,3/.,3349-070/:.0/47.43;0790/394,578439072%0708347:014797,382:9,9434190,24:3941,130394,9072412578432039!0450;,.:.:#4,!03,908!0.:3,7!03,908;8!0.:3,7,-908893:850.:3,7503,908174250.:3,7,-908$&$%$#!0.:3,7,-908/43493.:/070899:943-:93.:/0705,7,94341/,2,08.,:80/903/0231.,943147.43806:039,/,2,08,80,81308,3/.4894190574.00/38

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    44/119

    !0.:3,7503,9083.:/01308,3/.4894190574.00/38!03,90842507204189,1,,8.43;.90/4190.4250.72041089,1,974:1,81.,943415:-./4.:2039$3.090,24:393;4;0///3490.00/!90503,95708.7-0/-,147089,1,8,7708942,4739820/:2,3/2,2:25074/8%0503,95708.7-0/-,1471,81.,943415:-./4.:20398578432,475:8130349940.00/!254809057450757843503,9$&$%$#%0574507503,98#%57843.4770..43,824398,3/430/,9480,78,8&94#93578432,472,2:29030,78,3/430/,9490;00,78,8&%883,..47/,3.09!0450:843,08!0709,87:0/9,9147905:7548041/090723390503,93094073/070090503,99,984:/-0.438/070/,8,89,79354398904041578432,479-0390503,95708.7-0/-,,3/349578432,473982,2:25074/.84390503,9,.9:,,550/-0.,:804179.04190#0;80/!03,4/0%0503,93094073/07009070147857843.4770..43,,3/9893907,304198503,99,990232:284:/-09,03!03,908,.947894438/072,309,94:,70,:/0973,.,80,3/-,80/43900;/03.057080390/,3/90,55.,-0,4:

    ,;0/0./0/4390:94194,..:80/3/.,90901;0890584:4:/14494/0907230900,.9503,994-025480/$9,90//1107039,9,70901,.94784:2:89.438/0794,77;0,990.4770.9503,9$&$%$#90.720.422990/$9,04100.:943,3//0700415,79.5,943090723090503,9438/079024/13.7.:289,3.08090723009073/090723,90$03903.0,8,55.,-047349723,,,7,23,943"41!03,90842./04/137.:289,3.04207,8.43;.90/4142./0%097,.4:79,5570.,90/90144324/13.7.:289,3.0890,7,;,93.7.:289,3.04134.9:739,3/9029,93.7.:289,3.08415,8843,3/4-1:8.,94334

    3903994.4229847,;0,743907,.,3/;4:39,78:7703/07%02548,-0503,914742./0870.:843902547,907,3041.890;00,78,3/430/,9490390,78%,3394,..4:3990,9903/,39,7,;,93,3/29,93.7.:289,3.08,3/,553903/090723,90$03903.0,/090723090574507503,994-025480/4390,..:80/$&$%$#9,550,789,990708430,7,;,93.7.:289,3.034.9:739,3/14:729,93.7.:289,3.085,8843,3/4-1:8.,943343903994.4229847,;0,743,89,9.422990/,3/;4:39,78:7703/07!,77984:/-0,550/03.09070-0411809934124/13.7.:289,3.08.34708:93900.08841970029,93.7.:289,3.08%890701470:891370/:.390503,99490232:25074/%008903.041,3,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0,-099070,7014:7,7,;,93349:8919040734190503,99490309407/0700:3/075,7,7,5418,/79.0,8988,55.,-0

    431%#$#'%#&$%5708039$3.090.720.422990/842./0,3/90503,99070147870.:843902547,90&803903.0:3/07903/090723,90$03903.0,84:/-090232:24190503,9.80,78,3//,940,78,3/24398%0&503,99:8-090503,93094073/0700.8578432,473981:090390,78,3//,940,787490574507503,94:/-00,78,3//,,8232:2940,78,3//,,82,2:2-00;09,9-0.,:804190702,3329,93.7.:289,3.08,1907904118099394:/-0;074.,942548090232:24190&803903.0:3/0790$,3/90232:24190&803903.0

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    45/119

    !03,9089,937.:289,3.084:97,;,937.:289,3.088:20390570.0/3574-029,990700709429,93.7.:289,3.08,3/34,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0254809057450757843503,9$&$%$#%070-039429,93.7.:289,3.0894:9,3,7,;,93.7.:289,3.09057450757843503,98,7708942,473,341985074/807,3317424302439,3/430/,94824398,8&9457843.4770..43,3982,2:25074/14:70,789424398,3/430/,9480,78,8&&3/07795,74190#0;80/!03,4/003,503,9.439,3897005074/80,.43041.14728,5074/3,..47/,3.0979.0,3/41908,204/0,3/9070,709447247029,93.7.:289,3.08,3/34,7,;,93.7.:289,3.0890503,93094073/070084:/-025480/475:75480841903/090723,90$03903.0,90503,93094073/070084:/-0/0907230/94:970,7/,894090790-,8.503,9574;/0/-90#0;80/!03,4/084:/-0,550/3982,2:247232:25074/,8.7.:289,3.0824/13,-92,706:70%0503,93094073/07009457843.4770..43,%0701470,8570;4:889,90/90232:284:/-093907,3041,7708942,47,3/902,2:2893907,304157843.4770.943,3982,2:25074/!03,908!,77./09,937.:289,3.0,3/50,/0/:99490.720415,77./0%0.4:7914:3/970029,93.7.:289,3.083,20

    50,41:9,.413897:.943,3/,.413903994.4229847,;0,743,89,9.422990/%05708.7-0/503,91475,77./0870.:843507509:,94/0,92548090574507573.5,503,9$&$%$#%0574507503,9870.:843507509:,;0319070,709447247029,93.7.:289,3.08,.4:79.,334940790503,9-430/0700795,7#0;80/!03,4/0!0450;84724308!3&$;8#0,/47!07090.720.422990/,85,77./09909429,93.7.:289,3.0841907,.,3/,.41390394394.4229847,;0,743,3/934,7,;,93.7.:289,3.090$:570204:790/9,990574507503,994-025480/870.:843507509:,!03,908!70;039;025784320390389070570;039;0257843203903890,..:80/.70/90/9901:920418570;039;02578432039,3/0380.70/90/9907041$&$%$#

    %0708570;039;0257843203903,,341103/078/09,30/090.723,.,80,,38928-030,7/0907-0.,:8090.720.422990/8,.,59,4110380,3/349-,,-0470;03190.720.422990/,8-,,-09041103/07.4:/349548990706:70/-,1478574;843,-0793,..:80/8.70/90/9901:920418570;039;0257843203910;4:39,7,700/379394,-/0-907:0841903899:94325480/:5439857843078574;/0/9,9,90503,925480/43214790.720.422990/.43889841,/057;,94341-079-08349/86:,10/17428:..70/9147-03,70./;8947147,;3-003570;4:8.43;.90/14794472470920841,3.72047147,;31,0/948:7703/07;4:39,71479000.:9434190803903.0:543-0384

    8:22430/79#!723,,,7,23,943"07090,..:80/40;07//349,70004:/43-0.70/90/941909200,/:3/07430570;039;02578432039!03,908#0.:843!07509:,#4&3/0779.04190#0;80/!03,4/0,8,203/0/-#05:-..9#470.:843507509:,8,-017420,78,3//,940,784089820,39,970.:843507509:,834,/;8-0503,95,3$&$%$#

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    46/119

    4-0.,:8090$:570204:79,87050,90/.,0/90,9903943419003.,3/90,794901,.99,990503,9084170.:843507509:,,3/102578432039,70349834324:8,3/84:/-0,550/.4770.9,3/,82,-0850.10/-90,55.,-0,#0.:843507509:,,8,850.1./:7,943410,78,3//,940,7879,3/,..08847503,908790102578432039,834/01390907247,..08847503,9088410257843203982548,-043.72085:380/-850.,,8,3/349431043083904/0!0450;80:2,3#48,3!0450;88970,#4857!0450;8;074#4:30!0450;8,57484#40-800723,,43850.9:85,0(!03,908#0.:843!07509:,;81025784320391107039,9070.:843507509:,1742102578432039$&$%$##&$!#!%&89,9503,9574;/0/147390#0;80/!03,4/0147.7208/0130/3,3/503,0/907030.0591478420.7208/0130/-850.,,8.2548070.:843507509:,8:.,8;4,943841#05:-..9,8,203/0/-#05:-..94741!0

    !#$%8,503,9:8:,574;/0/1473850.,,8#0.:843507509:,,8,/:7,9434190390,78,3/430/,941479(0,78:3/07#05:-..90102578432039,834/:7,94370.:843507509:,2,-070/:.0/-4304794/0700870.:843507509:,908,..08847503,9080102578432039/408349,;0,3,..08847503,908!0450;8,:4$#!0450;8!,3048$#!03,908#0.:843!07509:,;8102578432039190797,:/0:,3,,4190,3,#%14:3/03,23,7.,:941:7/0790;.92,;38:89,30/80;07,-:094:3/838-4/849,90/0//0859020/.,,8889,3.0;03390859,3,3,0.,:80900,543:80/-03,23,8:3.0380/,3/906:,13.7.:289,3.041970,.07,814:3/94-05708039:/0,,703/070/8/0.843.43;.9303,23,3/803903.329470.:843507509:,47102578432039

    7070.:843507509:,,3/102578432039908,20,3/.,3-025480/3907.,30,-,8390147043803903.07,7090949,/1107039$9,904:770,843841$&$%$#%0503,94170.:843507509:,,3/90503,941102578432039,70949,/110703917420,.4907,3/9070147084:/349-0:80/3907.,30,-#0.:843507509:,8,503,95708.7-0/-90#0;80/!03,4/09,10//:7,94341257843203917420,78,3//,940,78,3/.,770899,..08847503,90810257843203943904907,3/8,503,95708.7-0/-850.,,893410//:7,943412578432039,3/94:9,3,..08847503,9!74-,943,!74507!074/,,3/,,8.,70/9;4,94341904:3.30.8,!5:38,-0-2578432039413490889,3/,8-:934924709,30,747,130413490889,3-:934924709,3/4:-090

    ,24:394190.0..1308,3490.00/!47-49%0.4:79.43;.90/074190.720,3/803903.0/07945,,13041!98:-8/,725784320393.,8041384;03.,3/945,9057;,90.425,3,3990,24:394190.0.,,3/,,8:3,-0945,90130-:910/,509943147574-,943%0.4:797,390/905099438:-0.99490.43/943,243490789,98084:/349.,3007708/03.094:990.4:7985747,5574;,,,98905745075074/41574-,943$&$%$#

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    47/119

    %05074/8,349-00889,39.090949,3:2-0741/,8418:-8/,72578432039&3/07.948:-8/,72578432039147;4,943841850.,,88,3490.00/24398,9907,9041430/,4125784320391470;0703.0905745075074/41574-,94384:/349-00889,32439834724709,324398$3.0!130824709,3902,2:28:-8/,725784320394124398,9!,/,-$:55483-01470907/07418.,70,888:0/-90.4:79-:9,190790,58041905074/41574-,943,,3/,97,3810770/708/03.094:95747,5574;,4190.4:79,90.4:7970;40907/0741!74-,943,3/47/070794807;0908:-8/,725784320395,3$&$%$#08%04:792,70;4007574-,943!74-,9438349.4907234:89985074/%0702:891789-088:0/-90.4:79,347/074113,/8.,70-,80/4390705479,3/70.42203/,9434190574-,943411.073903.,390.,804190574-,94307-090723,90/,,;,7930#4,3:,7.93$0.41!4!74-,943,,770/-550,30-7:,7#4-0794,8.43;.90/41,7843974:70.088257:/03.0,3/803903.0/945,,13041!98:-8/,725784320393.,8041384;03.-90#043,%7,4:7941":0439

    723,,,7,23,943"30-7:,70,550,0/94904:7941550,8$0;07,24398,907010/,24943949/7,90,550,439074:3/9,908,553147574-,9433,904:7941550,87,390/9024943,3/.438/070/90,550,9/7,33:309070.47/84190.,80070702,3/0/949097,.4:79#4-079410/,4943147!74-,94357,39,900.:943418803903.0-08:8503/0/,3/9,9,574-,943411.07-047/070/94.43/:.9,33;089,943,3/948:-29,705479438574-,943%0:/0/030/9024943439074:3/9,95:78:,3994!708/039,0.7004.9440110.943:34,55.,943147574-,9438,-0039079,30/477,390/190/0103/,39,850710.90/,3,550,174290:/203941.43;.943890/03,41#4-0794824943.4770.9$&$%$#

    08;031,990920418.43;.943#4-0794,86:,10/147574-,943-:99,9,990920418,55.,943147574-,943083443076:,10/0834903990/94574-,943%06:,1.,943147574-,9432:89-0/0907230/,8419092090,55.,943810/34:79073,7/4;8:/009,#44;/3/0,7:;8:/0,0409,$!57.93,2,/4;809,#4:30073,7/4:8:/0,,4909,#4;!74-,943,,770/-550,,8:-/;843/0;04507,8.43;.90/-90#%41,,91471,:709488:0908:-/;84399094,49-:07/085901:5,2039419049,3/803903.0/948:11074300,72578432039,550,0/90/0.8434190#%94904:7941550,8-:98,550,,8/82880/,89,55147574-,9435,3$&$%$#

    483443076:,10/94,55147574-,943,19070,550,0/174290:/203941.43;.943-90#%%0574-,943,!,8,203/0/-!34574;/089,934,55.,943147574-,9438,-0039079,30/477,390/190,..:80/,850710.90/,3,550,174290:/203941.43;.943$0.!!74-,943,,2:2%072;8%49,%072%0,..:80/,814:3/:9417,;047,/01,2,94338900331472,9438.070970/439,3/,8803903.0/3430/0.843948:110730,..,80,578439072414300,7,3/430/,944300,7,3/09243984157843.4770..43,93905074/94,550,010/,3

  • 8/3/2019 Criminal Law Bar Examination Q

    48/119

    ,55.,943147574-,943:3/0790!74-,943,41,8,203/0/4:/05488-6:,1147574-,943$&$%$#0837,3.8.4;84:7941550,8$#90$:570204:790/9,93.,8041430/0.843254832:950578439072890949,94190578439072884:/349-09,03394,..4:39147905:75480841/0907233900-94190,..:80/1479041574-,943%0,:8089047/2,2:29072,3/349949,907298034:9,90,.41905784390728/4083490.00/80,78%03:2-074141103808822,907,147,843,890503,90825480/039,033/;/:,,3/805,7,90,709390574-,943,-05074/!74-,943,7/07033!74-,94349550,,-0,8.,70/942./0190797,0,814:3/:9,3/803903.0/9480,78,3/430/,3578432,47,8232:29490;00,78,3/430/,4170.:843902547,,82,2:2!747948.43;.9430,/-00314:3/:941;,7,3.,3/2578430/147903/,841,7708942,347,3/130/11950848!800-0147574-,943$&$%$#40834903990/9490-0301984190!74-,943,!,8,203/0//4083490903/949480

    803903.0/94807;0,2,2:290724125784320394124709,380,78$0.,9841342420399,938570;4:8.43;.943,8;03,503,94143903/,841,7708942,47,3/,13041!,,574-,94307,550,174290/0.84370;43907,3941574-,9434724/139090728,3/.43/9438907041$&$%$#4&3/07$0.9434190!74-,943,,8,203/0/,347/077,39347/033574-,9438349,550,,-0!74-,943,!074/4;070/!,8.43;.90/,3/803903.0/94257843203941979/,8,3/,13041430:3/70/50848!70;4:8!,8.43;.90/41,34907.720147.90503,925480/432,8979/,8438!03990/94574-,9435,3-701$&$%$#

    08!2,,55147574-,9438570;4:8.43;.943147,34907.7209,503,941979/,82578432039473490.00/34302439/408349/86:,121742,553147574-,94390503,914785708039.43;.943/408349/86:,1209071742,553147574-,94383.0902578432039/4083490.00/80,78$0.!7080.7004!74-,943,#9,770/-550,3,.,80147;4,94341$0.#490780343,890,3074:87:8.9,..:80/'3.039,8;0390-03019419029,93.7.:289,3.0841;4:39,750,41:9,3//7:3033088349490780,-9:,0,8803903.0/948:1107,503,94180,78,3/