council of indian medicine new delhiccimindia.org/meeting_file/pdf/pdf/ec_10082010.pdf1159ec council...

1159ec

COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE

NEW DELHI

MINUTES OF 159TH MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

HELD ON 10.8.2010 AND ADJOURNED MEETING HELD ON 18.08.2010 AT NEW DELHI.

PRESENT

1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma, President, CCIM Chairman 2. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurved) Member

3. Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefthullah, Vice-President(Unani) Member 4. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member

5. Dr. PK Jain Member

6. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member 7. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member

8. Dr. D Ramanathan Member 9. Dr. V Arunachalam Member

10. Dr. Rashidullah Khan Member Dr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM

Following could not attend the meeting:-

1. Dr. Khalid Siddqui Member

Agenda Items No. 1 Confirmation of the minutes 158th

meeting of Executive Committee

held on 28.6.2010 .

It was noted that 158th meeting of Executive Committee was held on 28.6.2010 at New Delhi. The minutes of the same were placed before the

Central Council in its meeting held on 30.6.2010 for consideration and ratification. After considering the same, the minutes were ratified by the

CCIM.

Executive Committee confirmed the same.

Agenda Item No.2 Acquiring of Guest House.

It was noted that as per decision of Executive Committee in its meeting

held on 20.01.2010 regarding to hire the accommodation as Guest House

an advertisement was issued in the news paper namely Nav Bharat Times and Hindustan Time dated 3.4.2010. In response of the same 5

2159ec

quotation were received. However, following two landlord mentioned the

rate.

S.No. Details of the accommodation Rent

1.

Naresh Chand Meena,

Flat No.238, Sector 18-B, Dwarka, New Delhi

Rs. 32,000/-

2. OP Goel, House No.D1 A/A-8 Janakpuri, New Delhi

Rs. 55,0000/-

As per instructions of President, CCIM the committee constituted by President, CCIM consisting of following members made a spot verification

for availability of furniture, fixture and other requirement of both the flats.

1. Dr. PK Jain 2. Dr. VP Tyagi

3. Dr. Rashidullah Khan

The committee verified the availability of the same in flat of Mr. Naresh Chand Meena and same has been hired from 1st August, 2010 for 05

years @ 32,000/- PM as rent in advance form alongwith charges of electricity and water charges etc. The same has been informed to all

the members of CCIM also

Executive Committee ratified to the same.

Agenda Item No.3 Engagement of Legal Consultant

It was noted that the Executive Committee in its 149th meeting held on decided to engage one Legal Consultant for the office of the Council.

In view of the above, an advertisement was issued to engage Legal

Consultant in newspaper and after receipt of the applications the interview was held on 28.6.10 and the Selection Committee consisting of

following members decided as under:-

1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma President, CCIM

2. Dr. Jaya Prakash Narayan Vice-President, (Ayurved) 3. Prof. Hakim Syed Khallefathullah Vice-President (Unani)

4. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha)

“The Committee agreed to engage Sh. KN Subduhi temporarily for legal work on consolidated salary of Rs.20,000/- PM for a period of three

months initially.

3159ec

Accordingly, Sh. KN Subduhi joined the office on 01.7.10.

Executive Committee noted the same.

Agenda Item No.4 Reporting of Consultant (R.T.I.)

It was noted that it was reported in the Executive Committee dated

28.6.10 that Mr. GP Chand was engaged as Consultant (R.T.I.). Accordingly, an offer of engagement was issued to Mr. GP Chand. He

joined the office w.e.f. 15.7.10 and tendered his resignation on 22.7.10 (forenoon). He was relieved and thereafter, the second choice Sh. Vijay

Kumar Joshi was asked to join the office. Accordingly, he has joined the office on 30.7.10.


Agenda Item No.5 Engagement of Sh. Lal Babu Mahto,

Ex-UDC It was noted that as per decision of 158th meeting of Executive

Committee dated 28.6.10, it was decided to engage Sh. Lal Babu Mahto, Ex-UDC for preparation and maintenance of Central Register of

Indian Medicine. Sh. Lal Babu Mahto, Ex-UDC has been engaged on consolidated salary of Rs.12,000/- PM for six months in the first instance.

In response of the same he has joined he service w.e.f. 05.7.10.


Agenda Item No.6 Ratification of the Action Taken by President, CCIM.

1. Om Ayurved College Betul

It was noted that after receipt of various complaints of students in respect of Om Ayurved College, Betul regarding non-availability of

teaching staff and infrastructure etc. to verify the same the visitation was conducted on 27.7.2010 by the visitors of the CCIM and the verification

report has been sent to Government of India for taking into consideration at the time of disposal of the case for the session 2010-11.

Executive Committee ratified the same.

4159ec

2. Reporting regarding Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Chalakari Village, Mahe, Pudduchery.

It was noted that after receipt of the proposal from the Government of India, the proposed college was visited on 12 & 13th July, 2010 by the

visitors of the CCIM for examination of the Scheme. After assessment of the visitation report in view of the criteria adopted by Executive

Committee in its meeting held on 28.6.2010 the recommendation to Government of India for granting permission for establishment an

Ayurved College as proposed by Government of Puducherry was sent.

Executive Committee agreed to the same.

3. Consideration of verification Report of Sri Sri College of

Ayurvedic Medicine & Research, Bangalore

It was noted that to verify the revised data of OPD and IPD and the physical

verification of newly appointed teachers as per the compliance received from Sri Sri College of Ayurvedic Science and Research, Bangalore, the college was

visited by the verification team consisting of following visitors on 05.07.2010.

i. Dr. PK Jain ii. Dr.KC Ballal

iii. Dr. Vaishali Mali, Ayurveda Expert

After assessment of the verification report the same observations were sent to Government of India with the relevant record.


4. Consideration of verification Report of Sri Sai Ram Ayurved

College, Chennai.

It was noted that Government of India vide letter No. R.17011/189/2009-EP dated 28.07.2010 forwarded the documents

submitted by the college namely Shri Sai Ram Ayurved College, Chennai at the time of hearing for verification and genuineness of the records

received from Govt. of India regarding to the grant of permission to Sri Sairam Ayurved Medical College, Chennai

After examination of the record as provided by the college, the bed

occupancy has been informed to the Government of India.


5159ec

Agenda Items No. 7 Special allowances to Expert of

Ayurved, Unani and Siddha.

It was noted that considering the observations of the President, CCIM that Experts of the Ayurved, Unani and Siddha have put their best effort

to complete the entrusted work of assessment of visitation report of 252 Ayuved, 41 Unani and 9 Siddha college to maintain the transparency and

considering that they have worked more than the Regular Employee of the CCIM by contributing a lot in respect of examination of teaching

experience, duplicity of teachers etc., therefore, special allowance to the experts may be paid on similarity to Regular Employees.


Agenda Items No. 8 Reporting of the decision in respect of

document forwarding by the Govt. of India submitted by the Unani College.

It was noted that Govt. of India has forwarded the document submitted

by the college at the time of hearing in respect of following Unani Colleges. The details are as under:-

S. No. Name of the

College

Letter received from

ministry alongwith documents to examine and verify the matter

and to furnish the comment of CCIM

regarding eligibility of teachers etc…

Comments of CCIM Decision

of Govt. of India

1. Mohsine Millat Unani Medical College, Raipur

(CG)

To examine and verify these documents in regards to the eligibility of

teachers.

All the Readers (Sr. No. 1-5) appointed by the College have more than 5

years teaching gap since they last taught and as

per policy adopted by CCIM to assess the

eligibility of teacher, more than 3 years gap in teaching is not

acceptable. Therefore, all new appointed teachers

as Reader can not considered eligible for re-employment as teacher.

Permitted

2. Anjuman-I-Islam’s Dr. Ishaq

Jam Khanwala

The representative of the College submitted that they

have 31 teachers including

1. As representatives have submitted that

there are 31 teachers

Pending

6159ec

Tibbia Unani Medical College,

Mumbai (MS)

12 higher faculty in the college and submitted

documents (6 pages) in support of their claim in

regard to the higher faculty, and these papers are being sent to the

Council in original to examine and verify these

documents in original and return with Council’s views and comments within 07

days.

including 12 higher faculties, whereas, as per

visitation report of 2010-11, there were 31

teachers including 11 higher faculties and after further scrutiny, it was

observed that one Professor had submitted

fake experience certificate. Therefore he was not considered as

eligible teacher. 2. Regarding

promotion of one Lecturer to Reader, it has been observed that the

lecturer was appointed on 18.10.2005 and

promoted to the post of Reader on 2.1.2010

without completing 5 years teaching experience as per norms

of the CCIM. Therefore, teacher in question can

not be treated a reader. Therefore, the previous observations of 30

teachers including 10 higher faculty of CCIM

remain same.

3. Calcutta Unani

Medical College, Kolkata (WB)

To examine and verify the

documents of newly appointed teaching staff in regard to the eligibility of

teachers.

1. College has appointed

three higher faculties (one Professor-cum-Principal, one Professor

and one Reader). Out of three new higher

faculties, two Professors were found to be eligible as per norm of CCIM;

however, teaching eligibility of new

appointed Reader can not be considered due to three times break of

various duration (6 months to 3 years) from

continuous teaching, in previous three institutions where he

taught.

Permitted

7159ec

2. Four Lecturers have been promoted to the

Reader in concerned subjects as per CCIM

norms and hence may be treated eligible for the post of Reader.

In view of above, the college has a total 33

eligible teaching staff including 14 higher faculties.

4. Mohammadia Tibbia College.

Malegaon (MS)

The representative of the College submitted that they

have 41 teachers including 19 higher faculty and 180

beds are available in the college, they also informed that after CCIM visit they

have appointed 4 teachers and submitted documents

in support of their claim in regard to the teaching faculty and hospital, and

these papers (44 pages in original) are being sent to

you Council examine and verify the documents and

return in original with Council’s views and comments within 07 days.

1. College did not submit the affidavits and UG &

PG degrees of newly appointed teachers and

in absence of the same, the newly appointed teachers can not be

considered as eligible. Further, no copy of

promotion order enclosed for Dr. Alisha Ansari Mohd. Suleman (Sr. No.

21) which is shown as Reader since 01.12.2009

in new list of teaching staff submitted to the

Govt. of India by the college while she is a lecturer in visitation

report of 2010-11.

Therefore, the previous observation of CCIM about teaching staff

remains same i.e. 37 teaching staff including

18 higher faculty. 2. Sr. No. 14 (Dr.

Rahmani Shaheda) is MD Ilmul Advia (Jamia

Hamdard) as per copy of degree certificate not MD Amraz –e-Niswan (Jamia

Hamdard) which seems to be a typing error.

3. College claim of having 180 beds against

150 beds furnished by

----

8159ec

the college in visitation report of 2010-11

supported with the documents (letters of

University of Pune, Govt. of Maharashtra, previous visitation report of CCIM

etc.) can not be taken into consideration as

college itself has written 150 beds in the visitation report

which has been verified by the

visitors.


Agenda Item No.9 Consideration of visitation Report of H.A.H. Unani College, Dewas- Reg.

It was noted that H.A.H. Unani College was not permitted by the Govt. of

India for the session 2008-09 on the recommendation of the CCIM. The student admitted in the year 2008-09 filed the case in the Hon’ble Court

at Jabalpur. The Hon’ble Court stayed the order of Govt. of India for not granting permission for the session 2008-09 and asked the CCIM to

verify the fulfillment of shortcomings as per Regulations. Accordingly college was visited on 23rd January, 2010 and visitation report was

forwarded to Govt. of India. The Govt. of India did not grant the permission vide order No. 17012/19/2009-EP dated 15.6.2010,

Government of India did not grant permission for the session 2009-10 also vide letter No.17012/19/2009-EP dated 3.8.2009. To verify the

compliance of the shortcomings the college has been visited again on

17.7.2010. The visitation report is placed below for consideration.

Executive Committee decided that as college is not fulfilling the criteria as per decided policy of Government of India so the

college is not recommended. Accordingly the decision may be communicated to Government of India.

Agenda Item No.10 Reporting of decision in respect of

document forwarded by Govt. of India submitted by the college at the time of

hearing.

It was noted that Govt. of India has forwarded the document of the following Siddha Colleges submitted by the college at the time of

hearing. After examination following decisions have been taken.

9159ec

S.No. Name of the

college

Letter received from

GOI along with documents for

verification and comments of CCIM regarding eligibility of

teachers etc.

Comments of CCIM

1. Sri Sairam

Siddha Medical College,

Poonthandalam, West

Tambaram,

Chennai-44, (TN)

College has been

claimed that 6 new teachers are appointed

as Readers

Affidavits and related

documents are not received with the

Letter from the GOI therefore the same

have been requested

from the college under intimation to

GOI.

2. Velumailu

Siddha Medical College,

Sriperumbudur, Kanchipuram-

602105 (TN)

College has been

claimed that 9 new teachers are appointed

as Professors - 7

Readers - 2 and Lecturer Promoted to

Reader - 1

After examination of

affidavits and related documents submitted

by the college it has been found that all

the new 9 teachers and the promoted

teacher are eligible as

per qualifications and experiences

prescribed by CCIM.

In view of the above, the Velumailu Siddha

Medical College, Sriperumbudur,

Kanchipuram (TN) is 100% fulfilling the

requirements of teaching staff.

Executive Committee noted that affidavit and relevant documents

is in the office within stipulated time, therefore, after examination the recommendations may be sent to Government of

India.

10159ec

Agenda Item No.11 Reporting of decision of Govt. of India

in respect of Ayurved, Unani and Siddha colleges permitted/not

permitted by Govt. of India for the session 2010-11.

It was noted that Govt. of India has conveyed the decision in respect of

following Ayurved, Unani and Siddha college permitted/not permitted by Govt. of India for the session 2010-11 so far in response of the

recommendation of the CCIM.

Ayurved

S.No College Name Decision of the

Govt. of India

Recommendation

of the CCIM

1 College of Ayurveda & Research Centre,

Akurdi

UG-60.seat. PG-

Rachana Shrir 04 Kachikitsa- 04

Kriya Sharir- 02 RogaNidan- 02

Swasthavritta- 02 Shalya- 02

Recommended

2 Vasant Kusum Rural Yoga

& Ayurved Sansthan Siddhakala Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Sangamner

UG-60

PG Prasuti & Stri Roga -02

Bal Roga -02

Recommended

3 *JJ Magadum Ayurved Medical College,

Kolhapur

UG-40 Not Recommended

4 Padamshri Dr. DY Patil

College of Ayurved &

Research Institute, Narul, Navi Mumbai

UG-100 Recommended

5 Yashwant Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Kodoli

UG-65 PG

Roga Nidan -02 Agad Tantra - 02

Shalakya -02

Recommended

6 *Hanuman Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Kolhapur


11159ec

7 Shushrutha Ayurved

College, Bangalore

UG-50 Recommended

8 Cap. Kedari Redekar Ayurved College,

Kolhapur

UG-50 Recommended

9 *Bapuji Ayurvedic

Medical College, Shimoga (Karnataka)


10 *Pt. Khushilal Sharma Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

Sansthan, Bhopal


11 Yagya Dutt Sharma Ayurved College,

Khurza

UG-40 Recommended

12 Mai Bhago Ayurvedic

College for Women Muktsar

UG-50 Recommended

13 Shri Vijay Mahenthesh

Ayurvedic Medical College, Ilkal,

(Karnataka)

UG-50 Recommended

14 Gaur Brahmin Ayurved

College & Hospital, Distt. ROHTAK Haryana

UG-70 Recommended

15 Shri Basaveshwar

Vidya Vardhak Sangha Ayurved College,

Bagalkot


16 Dr. DY Patil Pratishtan

Ayurved College,

Pimpri, Pune (MS).

UG-50 PG (i)

Ayurveda Samhita-4

(ii) Rachna Sharir-4

Recommended

17 Sangam Sevabhavi

Trust’s Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Sangamner

UG-50 Recommended

18 Annasaheb Dange Ayurved College,

Sangali

UG-50 PG (i) Rachna Shair-2

Recommended

19 Nalasopara Ayurved College, Vasai, Thane

UG-40 Recommended

20 JR Tatia’s

Shriganganagar College of Ayurvedic Sciences,

Shriganganagar

UG-50 Recommended

12159ec

21 Shri JG Cooperative

Hospital Ayurved Medical Collegeg,

Ghataprabha

UG-40

PG- Dravyaguna- 02

Shaya- 02

Not Recommended

22 Shri Kalabhairaveshwara

Swami Ayurved College, Bangalore

UG-60 Recommended

23 Bhau Saheb Maulak

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nagpur

UG-60 Recommended

24 Government Ayurved College, Jabalpur


25 Parul Institute of

Ayurved, Limda, Vadodra


26 Shaheed Kartar Singh Sarabha Ayurved

College & Hospital, Ludhiana


27 JS Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Nadiad


28 Govindbhai Jorabhai

Patil Ayurved Medical College, Gujarat


29 Dada Saheb

Surupsingh Naik Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Nangaon, Dhule


30 Bharat Ayurvedic

Medical College, Muzaffarnagar (UP)

UG-50 Recommended

31 Manjara Ayurved College & Hospital,

Latur

UG-50 Recommended

32 Smt. KC Ajmera Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Dhule

Not permitted Not Recommended

33 Rani Dhullaiya Ayurved

College & Hospital, Bhopal

UG-50 Recommended

34 Loknete Rajarambapu

Patil Ayurved College, Sangli

UG-50 Recommended

13159ec

35 Jammu Institute of

Ayurved & Research, Jammu Tawi

UG-90

PG- Kriya Sharir-05

Kayachikitsa-05 Shalya-05

Recommended

36 Bhagvan Mahavir Jain Ayurved College,

Gajendergarh, Gadag

UG-40 Recommended

37 Govt. Ayurved College,

Junagarh


38 Mahila Utkarsh Ayurved College, Hospital &

Research Centre, Washim


40 Shri Saptashrungi Ayurved College,

Nasik

UG-50 Recommended

41 Vaidyaratnam Ayurved College, Ollur, Trichur


42 Guru Nanak Ayurved College & Research

Institute, Ludhiana


43 Shri Maru Singh Memorial Mahila

Ayurved Degree College, Sonepat


44 Shri Hingulambika

Education Society Ayurved College,

Gulbarga


45 Shikhawati Ayurved

Medical College, Pillani

UG-50 Recommended

46 SS Ayurvedic Medical

College, Haveri, Karnataka


47 Shri Shivayogeshwar

Rural Ayurvedic Medical College, Inchal

UG-40 Recommended

48 Major SD Singh Ayurved Medical

College & Hospital, Farrukhabad


49 Uttaranchal Ayurved

College , Dehradun


50 Rama Krishna Ayurved

College, Bangalore


14159ec

51 PN Panicker Sauhruda

Ayurved Medical College, Kasaragod


52 Government Gurukul

Ayurved College, Haridwar


53 Shri Gulab Kunverba


Jamnagar


54 Pt. Shivshaktilal

Sharma Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Ratlam

UG-50 Recommended

55 Rajiv Lochan Ayurved

Chikitsa Mahavidyalaya, Durg


56 Acharya Desh Bhushan Ayurved Medical

College, Bedkihal, Belgaon


Unani

1 Sham-e- Ghausia

Minority, Ghazipur (UP)

UG-40 Recommended

2 Iqra Society's Unani Medical College,

Jalgaon


3 Yunus Fazlani Unani

Medical College, Aurangabad

UG-50 Recommended

4 Dr. Abdul Haq Unani

Medical College, Kurnool


5 Aligarh Unani Medical College & CAN Hospital,

Aligarh UP)

UG-40 Recommended

6 Deoband Unani Medical College, Hospital and

Research Centre, Deoband, Saharanpur

(UP)


7 Allama Iqbal Unani

Medical College &

Hospital, Muzaffar Nagar (UP)


15159ec

8 Dr. Abdul Ali Tibbia

College, Lucknow


9 Rajasthan Unani

Medical College, Jaipur (Raj.)


10 Farooq Unani Tibbia

College, Indore


11 Luqman Unani Medical

College, Bijapur


12 Salfia Unani Medical

College & Hospital, Darbhanga


13 Ibn-e- Sina Tibbia

College, Azamgarh


14 Culcutta Unani Medical

College and Hospital, Kolkata, West Bengal


15 Tipu Sultan Shaheed

Educational Trust Unani Medical College,

Gulbarga- 2008-09


16 Mohsin-e-Millat Unani

Medical College, Raipur (Chhatisgarh)


Siddha

1 Akila Thiruvithamcore Sidhha Vaidya Sangam

Sidhha Maruthuva

Kalloory & Hospital, Kanyakumari

Permitted Not Recommended

Executive Committee noted that Government of India has granted

permission to some colleges against the recommendations of the CCIM. Executive Committee decided to obtained the legal opinion

in the matter whether Government of India may grant the permission against the recommendations of the CCIM or not.

Agenda Item No.12 Revision of draft Proposed PG Regulations

It was noted that draft proposed Regulation namely “Indian Medicine

Central Council (Post-graduate Education (Amendment) Regulations ___ were considered in the meeting of Sub Committee held on 27.7.2010

16159ec

constituted by Ayurveda Committee in its meeting held on 29.6.2010

under additional agenda item No.3. Finalized draft of the above said proposed PG Regulations was considered by Executive Committee.

Executive Committee decided to send the above said Regulations

to State Government for their comment as required under Section of 22 (2) of IMCC Act, 1970.

Addl.Agenda Item No.1. Minutes of screening Committee constituted by President, CCIM

held on 9.8.2010 at New Delhi

It was noted that the minutes of Sub Committee constituted by President, CCIM to examine the documents submitted by the college at

the time of hearing and forwarded to Government of India to CCIM for

verification and comments held on 09.8.2010.

The following members were present:-

1. Dr. PK Jain 2. Dr. VP Tyagi

3. Dr. NS Tyagi 4. Dr. D Ramanathan

After considering the recommendation of screening committee, Executive

Committee decided as under:-

S.No. Name of the College Decision of Executive Committee

1. Babe Ke Ayurved College &

Hospital, Moga

After going through the

recommendations of screening committee and

other all the relevant records, it was decided to

recommend to Government of India for

issuing the Letter of Permission for the year

2010-11.

2. Mahadeorao Shivankar Ayurved College & Research Institute,

Gondia

After going through the recommendations of

screening committee and other all the relevant

records, it was decided to recommend to

Government of India for

17159ec

issuing the Letter of

Permission for the year 2010-11.

3. SS Ayurvedic Medical College, Haveri, Karnataka




Government of India for issuing the Letter of

Permission for the year

2010-11.

4. Ramrao Patil Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya & Rugnalaya, Purna, Parbhani







5. Chaitanya Ayurved Mahavidyala, Bhusawal, Jalgaon





Permission for the year

2010-11.

6. Shri Gulab Kunverba Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Jamnagar




not to recommend to Government of India for



7. Belley Sankerpur Rajiv Gandhi Memorial Ayurved College &

Hospital, 24, Pargnas (N) 743129



18159ec

records, it was decided to



2010-11.

8. Swami Raghwendracharya Tridandi

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Gaya




not to recommend to



9. Shri Radha Krishna Toshniwal Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Akola






2010-11.

10. Gramin Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Patur




not to recommend to



11. Kisan Dnyanoday Mandal Gudhe’s Ayurved College, Chalisgaon,

Jalgaon






2010-11.

19159ec

12. Ayurved College, Coimbatore After going through the





2010-11.

13. Sri Nrusinghnath Ayurved College

& Research Institute, PAIKMAL


recommendations of


records, it was decided to not to recommend to



14. Shri Motisingh Jageshwari Ay.

College & Hospital, Chhapra




have a surprise visit of the institution.

15. Vidarbha Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Amrawati






2010-11.

16. Bharteeya Sanskrit Prabodhini

Gomantak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya & Research Centre, South Goa



other all the relevant




20159ec

17. Lt.Sunil Ramshingji Chunawale

Ayurved College, Chikhli, Buldana






2010-11.

18. Acharya Desh Bhushan Ayurved

Medical College, Bedkihal, Belgaon


recommendations of





19. Smt. Urmila Devi Ayurvedic

College & Hospital, Hoshiarpur






2010-11.

20. Govt. Ayurved College , Tuija Pur

Road, Madhuban, Osmanabad


recommendations of


records, it was decided to not to recommend to



As Government of India has forwarded the complaint against Shri

Motisingh Jageshwari Ayurved College & Hospital, Chhapra, Executive Committee decided to make a surprise visit of the said

college.

21159ec

Addl.Agenda Item No.2. Action taken by CBI.

It was noted that it is understood from the media (printing and electronic) that some of the Ayurved and Unani colleges have been

raided at various places in the Country by CBI. Executive Committee decided to obtain the legal opinion of Senior Legal Counsel.

If necessary, President, CCIM is authorize to take legal action after

obtaining legal opinion of senior advocate initiate if any required to protect the interest of CCIM and clarify the position of the CCIM before

the appropriate authority.

President, CCIM adjorned the meeting for 18th August, 2010 for

remaining Agenda items.

Minutes of 159th meeting of Executive Committee (10.8.2010) Adjourned meeting of held on 18th August, 2010 at New Delhi

PRESENT

1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma, President, CCIM Chairman

2. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurved) Member 3. Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefthullah, Vice-President(Unani) Member

4. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member 5. Dr. PK Jain Member

6. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member 7. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member

8. Dr. D Ramanathan Member

9. Dr. V Arunachalam Member 10. Rashidullah Khan Member

Dr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM

Following could not attend the meeting:-

1. Dr. Khalid Siddqui Member

Addl.Agenda Item No.3. Minutes of screening Committee constituted by President, CCIM held on

17.8.2010 at New Delhi

It was noted that a Screening Committee was constituted by President, CCIM to examine the documents submitted by the college at the time of

hearing and forwarded to Government of India to CCIM for verification

22159ec

and comments. The meeting was convened on 17.8.2010 and following

members were present:-

1. Dr. PK Jain

2. Dr. VP Tyagi 3. Dr. NS Tyagi

4. Dr. D Ramanathan

After considering the recommendation of screening committee, Executive Committee decided as under:-

S.No. Name of the College Decision of Executive

Committee

1. Taluka Shikshana Prasaraka Sahakara Mandal Ayurvedic

College SINDHAGI Bijapur

After going through the recommendations of screening

committee and other all the relevant records, it was

decided to not to recommend to Government

of India for issuing the Letter of Permission for the year

2010-11.

2. Veenavadini Ayurved College & Hospital, Bhopal





2010-11.

3. Shri Shivayogeshwar Rural Ayurvedic Medical College,

Inchal





2010-11.

4. SSMD Ayurved Medical College, Moga




23159ec

of India for issuing the Letter

of Permission for the year 2010-11.

5. Shri OH Nazar Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Surat





2010-11.

6. Padamshri Dr. Vitthal Rao Vikhl Patil Foundation Ayurved

College Shevgaon, Ahmednagar



decided to recommend to Government of India for

issuing the Letter of Permission for the year 2010-

11.

7. Karnataka Liberal Education Society Shri Karnataka B.M.

Kankanwadi Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Belgaum

it was noted that college has not been recommended to

take admission in PG Course on account of shortfall of bed

occupancy i.e. 50% for the session 2010-11.

It was also noted that

Government of India has forwarded the letter of the

college clarifying that by the

college that bed strength of hospital was 150 upto 31st

October, 2009 and thereafter 281

Screening Committee was of

the view that clarification has been submitted without any

supporting documents, therefore, on account of

shortfall of bed occupancy below 50%.

Executive Committee decided

in absence of supporting

24159ec

documents it is not possible to

furnish the recommendation to Government of India.

8. Veerpulikeshi Vidyavardhak Samasth’s Rural Ayurved

College & Research Centre, Badami, Bagalkot





2010-11.

9. Uttaranchal Ayurved College , Dehradun





2010-11.

10. Subh Deep Ayurved College, Indore





2010-11.

11. Sri Siddharameshwar Ayurved

Medical College, Hospital, Bidar


recommendations of screening committee and other all the

relevant records, it was decided to not to

recommend to Government of India for issuing the Letter


12. Ashvin Rural Ayurved College Manchi Hill, Ashvi B.K.,

Ahmednagar




25159ec



13. Dayanand Ayurved College,

Jallandhar City





of Permission for the year

2010-11.

14. Govt. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Baroda



relevant records, it was decided to recommend to


Permission for the year 2010-

11.

15. Govt. Ayurved College, Raipur After going through the


relevant records, it was decided to recommend UG

but not to recommend PG course to Government of

India for issuing the Letter of Permission for the year 2010-

11.

16. Seth Chandanmal Mutha Aryangla Vaidyak

Mahavidyalaya, Satara





2010-11.

17. Vishnu Ayurved College, Shoranur, Palkkad




26159ec



18. Shri JG Cooperative Hospital Ayurved Medical College,

Ghataprabha





11.

19. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Old Hubli

As per previous visitation report there were 160 beds

whereas as per requirement 185 bed were required.

College has submitted the bill. The committee did not agree

to take decision on the basis of bill without verification for

prepare as 30 cots to enhance

the beds from 160 to 190.

In view of the above, without verification it is not possible to

make any recommendation in the matter.

20. Shri Raghvendra Ayurved

Medical College, Malladihalli, Chitradurga



relevant records, it was



2010-11.

21. Chaudhary Devilal College of Ayurveda, Jagadhari

It was noted that in absence of name of resigned teacher

Screening Committee did not

take any decision.

As per Screening Committee, the desired information i.e. list

of resigned teachers was asked from the college and

27159ec

after receipt of the and same

and after going through the recommendations of screening

committee and all other the relevant records, it was



2010-11.

22. RJVS Bhaisaheb Sawant


Sawantwadi


recommendations of screening




11.

23. Shri Jayendra Saraswati

Ayurved College, Naszarapet






24. Santhagiri Ayurved Medical College, Shanthagirir


committee and other all the




25. Dhawantry Ayurved Medical College, Siddhapur


committee and other all the




28159ec

26. Vaghdevi Ayurved Medical

College, Warangal






27. Dhanwantry Ayurved Medical College, Nipani

It was noted that college has submitted the list of 41

teachers by adding 06 new

teachers and deleting 01 teacher. It was also noted

that original affidavit in respect of 06 newly appointed

teachers have not been submitted. In absence of the

same, it is not possible to furnish the recommendation to

the Government of India.

Therefore, it is not recommended to the

Government of India for granting permission for the

session 2010-11.

28. Bharti Veedyapeeth, Pune It was noted that 06 new teachers have been appointed

and 04 Lecturer have been promoted as Reader. But

after overall assessment of the teaching staff it has been

observed that even then college does not fulfill the

requirement of teaching staff

for the remaining subjects for which it was not recommended

earlier.

The recommendation of the CCIM remains same.

29. TMAE Society’s Ayurved Medical College, Nidgi



decided to not to

29159ec

recommend to Government


2010-11.

30. Amrita Ayurved Medical College,

Kollam

It was noted that college has

submitted the list of 39 teachers by adding 02 new

teachers and deleting 02 teachers alongwith with the

OPD record from 6th March 2010 to 15th June 2010. After

assessment it was observed

that there are 38 eligible teachers and 05 are ineligible.

However, as daily average attendance of patients in OPD

was 93.68 per day. On the basis of information from 1st

January, 2009 to December, 2009 whereas college has

submitted the information from 6th March, 2010 to 15th

June 2010, therefore, it is not possible to make the

recommendations in the matter.

31. SGV Ayurved College Bailhongal After going through the





UNANI

As per instructions of the President, CCIM, Dr. Rashidullah Khan, Member, EC was requested to visit the office on 17.8.2010 to examine

the documents forwarded by Government of India submitted by the

colleges at the time of hearing of same. The same has also been examined by Dr. Rashidullah Khan, Member, EC.

30159ec

Executive Committee decided as under:-

S. No.

Name of the College

Letter received from Ministry alongwith documents to examine the matter and to furnish the comments of CCIM regarding eligibility of teachers etc.----

Comments of CCIM Decision of Executive Committee

1. State Unani Medical College, Allahabad (UP)

Govt. of India has forwarded the documents submitted by the college during hearing for examination and requested to furnish the Council’s comments on the same.

The documents have been examined and following observations have been made:- 1. The supporting documents in favour of Professors at serial No. 1 & 2 (Prof. Ghulam Jeelani & Prof. Saad Usmani) are not enclosed, therefore, they will be treated as Reader as per information furnished by the college itself in the latest visitation report. Similarly, in absence of supporting documents, Sr. No. 7 Dr. Mohd. Hasan will be treated as lecturer (as per latest Visitation Report) not Reader.

2. Sr. No. 8-12 are Medical Officers and deputed in the College vide State Govt. order dated 03.11.2009 (for Sr. No. 8) and 16.12.2009 (Sr. No. 9-12). They have been deputed as lecturers around 7-8 months ago and now shown as Reader. These Medical Officers can not be treated as eligible teachers as reported earlier.

After going

through the recommendations

of screening committee and

other all the relevant records,

it was decided to not to

recommend to Government of

India for issuing

the Letter of Permission for

the year 2010-11.

31159ec

3. Similarly, Lecturers from Sr. No. 20-31 can not be treated as eligible lecturers as reported earlier because all of them are Medical Officers transferred to the college on various dates.

In view of above, there are only 14 teaching faculty including 6 higher faculty (Readers) in the college.

Further, OPD & IPD information of pervious 6 months submitted by the college can not be verified without supporting documents.

2.

State Takmil-ut-Tib College, Lucknow (UP)

Govt. of India has forwarded the documents of State Takmil-ut-Tib College, Lucknow submitted by the college during hearing for examination and to furnish the opinion of CCIM in the matter related to grant permission to the college for admission to the BUMS course for 2010-11.

The documents have been examined and following observations have been made- 1- Regarding Eligible Teaching Staff: College has submitted department wise list of teaching staff of 34 including one Principal. Among them, 14 are Medical officers transferred to the college by Sate Govt. order on various dates. The Department of these Medical officers shown in new list is different from what has been furnished by the college during recent visitation report and which has duly been verified by the visitors also. Their designation has also been changed from lecturer to Reader or Professor in a short span (against the norms). The

After going

through the recommendations

of screening committee and

other all the relevant records,

it was decided to not to

recommend to Government of

India for issuing the Letter of

Permission for the year 2010-

11.

32159ec

details of such Medical officers are as under:-

Name of Medical Deptt. Designation Deptt. shown in Designation Officer Visitation report in V.R. 1- Dr. Ahsan Ulah Kulliyat Reader Ilmul Advia MO 2- Dr. Hussain Ahmad Munafe-ul Professor Moalajat MO Azmi Aza 3- Dr. Iftikhar Ahmad --Do-- Reader Hifzane Sehat MO 4- Dr. Shahla Hifzane Sehat Reader Niswan wa Atfal MO Yasmeen 5-Dr. Dil Mohd. Advia Lecturer Kulliyat MO Azmi 6-Dr. Mohd. Ashfaq Moalajat Reader Moalajat Khusoosi MO 7- Dr. Shameem Nafsiyat Reader Advia MO Ahmad Further, eligibility of Dr. Syed Munawwar Hussain Kazmi, Lecturer, Deptt. of Tashreeh can not be ascertained in absence of appointment order and other supporting documents. Therefore taking into the consideration two new appointment of lecturers (one in Moalajat Khusoosi and another one in Hifzane Sehat) as per proper channel, there are only 19 eligible teaching staff i.e. 2 Professors, 5 Readers (as reported earlier) and 12 lectures in the College. 2- Constructed Area of the College and Hospital: College itself has furnished the constructed area on Page -3 of visitation report which has been verified by the visitors also. Now College submit the sum of constructed area of two lands in the name of college and similarly the sum of constructed area of two lands in the name of Hospital and that comes at par with the norm. It has also been observed that college and Hospital are running at 4 places.

3. OPD and IPD: The record of 2009 for OPD and IPD was furnished by the college itself and which has been verified by the visitors also. However as per 5 months OPD and IPD record (Jan to

33159ec

May 2010) submitted by the College, OPD is about 185/day and IPD is near about 50%. In view of the above, college may not be

recommend for granting permission for the session 2010-11.

SIDDHA

It was noted that documents submitted by the Sri Sairam Siddha Medical

College, Poonthandalam, West Tambaram, Chennai were examined and it has been observed that college has not submitted the desired documents

to examine the matter, therefore, it is not possible to arrived at suitable decision, therefore, it may not be recommended for the permission for

the session 2010-11.

After going through the recommendations of screening committee and other all the relevant records, Executive

Committee decided to recommend to Government of India for issuing the Letter of Permission for the year 2010-11.

Addl.Agenda Items No.5 Ratification of action taken by

President, CCIM

It was noted that WPNo.33/2009 was filed by KB Nagur V/s Government of India, the Government of India asked the CCIM to defend the case on

behalf of Government of India. Accordingly affidavit was filed.

It was further noted that Retainer of CCIM and Advocate of Supreme Court of India desired to engage the Senior Advocate for strengthening

our legal defense in the Court as writ petition was challenging certain statutory provisions of IMCC Act, 1970. Accordingly, Mr. Harish Salve

was appointed and Rs.3.20 lakh for the same has been paid to Shri Rakesh Upadhyaya for the same on account to engage the senior

advocate. The case was heard on 30.7.2010 and Hon’ble Court passed an order.


Addl.Agenda Item No.6 Reporting of decision of Govt. of India in respect of Ayurved, Unani and

Siddha colleges permitted/not permitted by Govt. of India for the

session 2010-11.

34159ec

It was noted that Govt. of India has conveyed the decision in respect of following Ayurved, Unani and Siddha colleges permitted/not permitted by

Govt. of India for the session 2010-11 so far in response of the recommendation of the CCIM.

S.No. Name of the college Decision of CCIM

Decision of GOI

1. Babe Ke Ayurved College & Hospital, Moga

Not Recommended

UG-50

2. Mahatma Gandhi Ayurved College, Hospital &

Research Centre, Wardha

Not Recommended

UG-50

3. Lt.Sunil Ramshingji

Chunawale Ayurved College, Chikhli, Buldana

Recommended

UG-40

UG-40

4. Vasant Dada Patil Ayurved College, Sangli

Not Recommended

Not permitted

5. Govt. Ayurved College & Hospital, Rewa

Not Recommended

UG-40

6. Bharteeya Sanskrit Prabodhini Gomantak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya &

Research Centre, South Goa.

Not Recommended

UG-40

7. *Patanjali Ayurved Medical College, Roorki, Haridwar

Not Recommended

UG-50

8. Karmvir Vyanketrao Tanaji Randhir Ayurved College,

Dhule

Not Recommended

UG-30

9. Karnataka Ayurved

College, Mangalore

Not

Recommended

UG-50

10. Yerala Medical Trust &

Ayurved College, Mumbai

Recommended

UG -60 & PG Drvyaguna- 04

Rasashastra-04, Kayachikitsa04,

Shalakya-04, Bhashajya Kalpana-

-04

Permitted

UG -60 PG Drvyaguna- 04

Rasashastra-04, Kayachikitsa 04,

Shalakya- 04, Bhashajya Kalpana -04

11. Padamshri Dr. Vitthal Rao Vikhl Patil Foundation

Ayurved College Shevgaon, Ahmednagar

Not Recommended

UG-50

12. Shri Gajanan Maharaj Sansthan Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Pusad

Recommended UG-50 seat

UG-50

35159ec

13. Shri Dhanwantry Ayurved Medical College, Mathura

(U.P.)

Not Recommended

Not permitted

14. CB Guttal Ayurved Medical

College, Dharwad

Not

Recommended

UG-50

15. Govt. Taranath Ayurved

College, Ballary

Not

Recommended

UG-40

Rasashastra-07

16. National Institute of

Ayurved, Jaipur

Recommended-

UG-92 seat PG- Not

Recommended ( All Subject)

UG-92

PG- All subject Maulik Siddhant- 8 Rachan Sharir-07

Kriya Sharir-07 Dravyaguna-08

Rasashastra-07 Kaumarbhritya-05

Kayachikitsa-08 Swasthavritta-05 Roganidan-08

Shalya-08 Panchkarma-05

Shalakya-03 Prasuti & Striroga-05 Agad Tantra-05

17. Shri Krishna Govt. Ayurved College, Kurukshetra

Not Recommended

UG-50

18. Surya Mukhi Dinesh Ayurved College &

Hospital, Booty, RANCHI

Not Recommended

UG-40

19. ALN Rao Memorial Ayurved

Mahavidyalya, Koppa

Recommended

UG - 60-50 Seat PG –

Dravyaguna- 06 Kayachikitsa

05 Bhaishayjakalpna-

05

UG-60

PG in Dravyaguna-06

Kayachikitsa-05 Bhaishjya Kalpana-05

UNANI

20. Unani Medical College,

Institute of Asian Medical Science, Srinagar.

Not

Recommended

UG-40

21. Ajnuman-I-Islam's Dr. Ishaq Jam Khanwala Tibbia Unani Medical College,

Mumbai

Not Recommended

UG-50

22. Saifia Hamidia Unani Tibbia

College & Hospital, Burhanpur

Not

Recommended UG-50

36159ec

23. HMS Unani Medical College, Tumkur

Not Recommended

UG-40

24. Govt. Unani Medical

College, Chennai

Not

Recommended UG-26

25. Zulfequar Haider Unani

Medical College & Hospital, Siwan, Bihar

Not

Recommended UG-50

26. Allama Iqbal Unani Medical College & Hospital, Muzaffar

Nagar (UP)

Not Recommended

UG-40

Siddha

27. Velumailu Siddha Medical

College, Kancheepuram

Not

recommended

Permitted


Addl. Agenda Item No.7 Consideration of proposals received

from Government of India under section 13A of IMCC Act, 1970 in the

year 2010-11 for starting PG course and increasing intake capacity in UG &

PG Course.

It was noted that following proposals as per details given below have been received from the Government of India for recommendation to

issue the letter of Intent or not at first instance.

Executive Committee while considering the matter noted the following

points-

i. As per Regulations namely IMCC (Post-graduate Ayurved Education) Regulations, 2005 the Post Graduate Education Centre

shall satisfy the entire minimum requirements of UG training as prescribed by CCIM alongwith the other requirement.

ii. Government of India has conditionally permitted all colleges for the session 2010-11. CCIM itself has felt that if 100% norms are

followed 50-60% college will not be in position to get the permission.

iii. Applicant college should be recognised by CCIM for running UG or PG Course in Ayurveda, Unani and Unani Tibb at least 5-1/2 years

and 03 years respectively.

iv. Following colleges have applied last year also. The decision of the Government of India in the matter are still awaited.

1. Anantha Laxmi Ayurved College, Warangal 2. DGM Ayurved College, Gadag

37159ec

3. KLE Society’s Shri BM Kankanwadi Ayurveda Medical College

Belgaum. 4. SDM Ayurved College, Hassan

5. Cap. Kedari Redekar Ayurved College, Kolhapur 6. Rani Dullahiya Ayurved College, Bhopal

7. Desh Bhagat Ayurved College, Mandi Govindgarh 8. Yashwant Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Kodoli

v. Executive Committee in its meeting held on 28.5.2010 was also

decided that proposal of those colleges have not been recommended for granting the permission to the Government of

India be returned to Government of India for onward transmission.

After considering the same Executive Committee considered the matter and took decision in respect of each colleges as mentioned against them.

S.No. Name of the College Observation and Decision of CCIM

1. JS Ayurved College,

Nadiad for starting PG course in (i)

Rasashastra, (ii) Kayachikitsa

Not recommended by CCIM on the basis of

31 teaching staff and 11 higher faculty.

However, Government of India has conditionally permitted for 50 seats in UG

for the year 2010-11.

As Government of India has granted the permission as per their own norms,

therefore, it is not feasible to consider the

proposal for additional course at the moment.

As college is not fulfilling the 100%

requirement of UG course, therefore, Executive Committee did not agree for

visitation.

2. National Institute of

Ayurved, Jaipur

To increase intake

capacity in all subjects (13 seats) to meet the

27% OBC (only 13 seats)

PG was not recommended by CCIM on

account of 221 beds against 320.

Bed occupancy 47.31%.

68 eligible teachers against 79 teaching staff. The same has been informed to

Government of India.

It was noted that Government of India has granted the permission for 92 UG and for all

PGs for the session 2010-11.

As proposal has been forwarded by the

38159ec

Government of India for 27% reservation of

OBC which is constitutional obligation.

Executive Committee decided that Institute should not be proposed for

visitation. However, as per latest letter of Government of India, matter be put

up on the basis of following criteria to consider the proposal further-

i) Total number of teachers ii) Bed strength iii) Bed occupancy

3. Anantha Laxmi Ayurved

Medical College, Warangal to start PG

course in Kaumarbhritya,

Swasthavritta and Panchkarma 6 seats in

each

Not recommended by CCIM for UG on

following reason –

a) Account of Bed Occupancy 35.15% against 40%.

b) Area of the hospital is 8000 Sq.ft. against 20,000 Sq.ft.

c) 18 teachers against 35.

Beds have not been mentioned. As per previous report there is 58 beds whereas

150 beds are required.

However, as college has not been

recommended by CCIM for granting permission for the session 2010-11,

therefore, it is not feasible at the moment to consider the proposal for starting PG

Course in various specialities, whereas college is not fulfilling the criteria of

permission for existing course.

As college is not fulfilling the 100% requirement of UG course, therefore,

Executive Committee did not agree for visitation.

4. Bhau Saheb Mulak

Ayurved College, Nagpur

Samhita 04

Dravyaguna 01 Kayachikitsa 01

Balroga 02

Colleges has furnished the NOC of

Government of Maharashtra is of 2005.

Consent for affiliation of the University is of 2005 of Sant Tukaram Nagpur University,

Nagpur instead of MUHS, Nashik.

Government of India permitted on the

39159ec

Rachna Sharir 03

Kriya Sharir 03 Rasashastra 04

Swasthavritta 03 Agadtantra 03

recommendation of CCIM for 60 seats in UG

for the year 2010-11.

As Government of India has permitted the college on the basis of as per their own

norms not as a whole therefore it is not feasible to consider the proposal for

additional course at the moment. Moreover, as college has not submitted the consent of

affiliation of MUHS, therefore, proposal may also not be considered.



visitation.

5. Govt. Ayurved College, Guwahati

To start PG: 1. Shalya 2. Prasuti & Striroga 3. Roganidan

4. Rachana Sharir 3- each

37 eligible teachers against 38. Not a single teacher in the department of of Dravyaguna

and Shalakya.

Bed occupancy 46.73% against 50%. 150 beds against 180.

As college is not fulfilling the criteria of

permission for existing courses, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for

additional course at the moment.



visitation.

6. Jammu Institute of

Ayurved & Research, Jammu

1. Agadtantra 2. Rasashastra

3. Dravyaguna 4. Swasthavaritta

10 each

Recommended as per previous year but not

in Kayachikitsa because there was one teacher in Kayachikitsa.

Government of India permitted for 90 seats in UG & PG 05 Kriya Sharir, 05 Kayachikitsa

and 05 Shalya for the year 2010-11.

As permission has been granted by the Government of India as per their own

criteria,, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for starting additional

course at the member.


40159ec

requirement of UG course, therefore,


7. Govt. Ayurved College, Raipur

Dravyaguna-06 Roganidan- 06

In increase Intake Capacity in 55-100.

Not recommended by CCIM on following reasons:-

48 eligible teachers against 49.

150 beds against 190 beds. Bed occupancy 16.168% against 50% for

PG centre and 40% for UG centre.

As college is not fulfilling the criteria for

granting permission for conducting existing course, therefore, it is not feasible to

consider the proposal for additional course at the moment.



visitation.

8. Govt. Rishikul Ayurved College, Haridwar

TO Start PG Dravyaguna

Samhita Siddhant Kayachikitsa

Kaumarbhritya Prasuti & Striroga

Shalakya- Netra Rachana Sharir

4 seats in each

UG Recommended

PG is not recommended by CCIM on following reason-

There is no minimum number of beds i.e.

154 beds against 200 beds and bed occupancy i.e. 43.94% against the 50%.

In view of the above, as college is not

fulfilling the criteria for conducting PG Course, therefore, it is not feasible to




visitation.

9. Pt. Khushilal Sharma

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Sansthan, Bhopal

PG in Rachana Sharir

Roga Nidan Swasthavritta

Not recommended by CCIM on following

reasons:-

33 teachers against 35. 17 higher faculty against 20.

However, as per latest visitation report.

Bed occupancy 46.55 %

41159ec

Number of beds 150.

Government of India has permitted for 50

seats in UG for the year 2010-11.

As Government of India has permitted the college for conducting existing Course as

per their own norms, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for



Executive Committee did not agree for visitation on above said reasons.

10. Ashvin Ayurved

College, Manchi, Hill For strating PG course

Rasashastra-06 Shalya-06

Kayachikitsa-06

Not recommended after examination of

documents submitted at the time of hearing by CCIM on following reason:-

26 eligible teachers against 32 teaching

staff. As college is not fulfilling the criteria for




Executive Committee did not agree for visitation. However, matter be put up

on the basis of documents submitted at the time of hearing.

11. Yashwant Ayurved College, Kodoli

Increase in PG Course-

Roga Nidan- 2-4 Shalakya- 2-6

Agad Tantra- 2-6

UG Recommended

PG in 02 Roganidan

02 Agadtantra & Vyavhar Ayurveda 02 Shalakya

Government of India permitted 65 seats in

UG and PG

02 Roganidan 02 Agadtantra

02 Shalakya for the year 2010-11.

42159ec

The proposal for starting PG course was

submitted the college during 2009-10 for starting PG course in following subject-

Ayurved Samhita-06 Kayachikitsa-06

Rasashastra-06 Rachana Sharir-06

Swasthavritta-06 Prasuti & Striroga-06

Kaumarbhritya-06 Shalya-06

Initially CCIM recommended for LOI further

LOP has been recommended except the Swasthavritta.

The decision of Govt. of India is still awaited.

Executive Committee decided that if

college fulfills the criteria in respect of teaching staff for existing as well as in

subject in which LOP has been recommended by the CCIM on the

proposal received last year, thereafter, the decision will be taken for visitation

by CCIM.

12. SVM Ayurved College, Ilkal

To start New PG Course Prasuti & Striroga

Recommended for UG for 50 seats.

Government of India permitted for 50 seats in UG for the year 2010-11.

The Proposal for starting PG course in

following subjects was received during 2009-10

Kayachikitsa-05 Panchakarma-05

Prasuti-05 Shalya-05

Initially it was recommended to the Govt. of

India to issue the LOI as above but LOP has

not been recommended by CCIM.


43159ec

Moreover, as Government of India has

permitted the college for conducting existing Course as per their own norms,

therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for additional course at the

moment.


Executive Committee did not agree for visitation by CCIM.

13. Govt. Ayurved College,

Patna For starting PG course

i. Kayachikitsa ii. Rachana Sharir

iii. Samhita & Maulik Siddhant

iv. Shalya v. Shalakya

With 5 seats each


reasons:-

13 Higher faculty against 15. Bed occupancy 13.589% against 50%.






visitation by CCIM.

14. Govt. Ayurved College, Bolangir

For starting PG course i. Bhaishajya

Kalpana ii. Dravyaguna

iii. Roga Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan

iv. Ayurved Siddhant

4 seats in each


Area of the college is 13,957 Sq.ft. against

20,000 Sq.ft.

11 eligible teachers against 35 teaching staff.

07 higher faculty against 20.


permission, therefore, it is not feasible to consider for starting PG Course whereas as

there is no facilities of teaching and practical training for UG Course.



visitation.

44159ec

15. Sangam Seva Bhavi

Trust Ayurved College, Sangamner

For starting PG course i. Prasuti & Striroga

ii. Kayachikitsa iii. Shalya (Samanya)

iv. Shalakya-Shiro-Nasa- Karna avum

Kantha Roga For 5 seats in each

Recommended for 50 seats.

Government of India permitted for 50 seats

in UG for the year 2010-11.






16. BVVS Ayurved College,

Bagalkot PG

i. Shalya ii. Rasashastra

No seats are mentioned


reasons:-




As Government of India has permitted the

college for conducting existing Course as

per norms, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for additional course

at the moment.



17. Hanuman Shikshan

Prasark Mandal Ayurved College, Peth VAdgaon

For starting PG i. Kriya Sharir

ii. Roga Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan

iii. Kayachikitsa 6 seats in each


reasons:-

32 teachers against 35 teaching staff. 13 higher faculty against 20.




per their own norms, therefore, it is not

45159ec

feasible to consider the proposal for




18. Rajiv Gandhi Ayurved College, Bhopal

For starting PG course i. Ayurved

Siddhant- 06

ii. Kriya sharer- 06

Not recommended by CCIM on following reasons

32 teachers against 35 teachers.

As college is not fulfilling even the criteria of permission, therefore, it is not feasible to




visitation.

19. Ayurved College, Coimbatore

PG i. Rasashastra

ii. Ayurved Siddhant iii. Shalya

iv. Rog Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan

v. Kayachikitsa vi. Dravyaguna

5 seats in each


27 teachers against 35 teaching staff.


As college is not fulfilling the criteria for granting permission of UG Course,

therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal for starting PG Course at the

moment.


Executive Committee did not agree for

visitation.

20. Maharshtra Arogya

Mandal, Sumatibhai Shah Ayurved College,

Hadapsar Increasing seats in PG

i. Kriya Sharir ii. Rachana Sharir

iii. Rasashastra iv. Prasuti & Striroga

v. Kayachikitsa

UG recommended with 60 seats

02 Kriya Sharir

03 Rachna Sharir 03 Prasuti & Striroga

03 Shalya 03 Kayachikitsa

Rasashastra not recommended on account

of shortfall of teaching staff.

46159ec

vi. Shalya 3 to 6 seats

Moreover, as college is not fulfilling the

criteria of permission, therefore, it is not feasible to consider for starting PG Course

in additional subjects at the moment.

College applied for PG in 2009-10 for following subject

1. Agad Tantra-03 2. Ayurved Siddhant-03 3. Dravyaguna-03 4. Roga Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan-03

After visitation it was recommended

to Govt. of India for issuing Letter of Intent as above also.

Letter of permission also recommended as

under- 1. Agad Tantra-03 2. Ayurved Siddhant-03 3. Dravyaguna -03

4. Roga NIdan & Vikriti Vigyan-03

Decision of Govt. of India for the proposal submitted 2009-10 and permission for

2010-11 is still pending.

Executive Committee decided that if college fulfills the criteria in respect of

teaching staff for existing As well as in subject in which LOP has been

recommended by the CCIM on the


by CCIM.

21. Desh Bhagat Ayurved

College, Mandi Govindgarh

New PG i. Rachana Sharir-

05 ii. Rasashastra-05

iii. Kayachikitsa- 05

UG seats

60-100

Not recommended by CCIM on account of

shortfall of teaching staff.



The proposal for starting PG course in in the

same as well as for increasing intake capacity for 60-100 was received during

2009-10 and it was not recommended to the Govt. of India to issue the LOI.

However, college has been permitted by

47159ec

Govt. of India for increasing intake capacity

from 40-60 during 2008-09. After hearing Govt. of India also forwarded the

documents submitted by the college at the time of hearing to CCIM. after examination

again LOI was not recommended.

Moreover, as college is not fulfilling even the criteria of permission, therefore, it is not

feasible to consider for starting PG Course whereas as there is no facilities of teaching

and practical training for UG Course.



visitation.

22. Shubhdeep Ayurved

College, Indore For starting PG

i. Kayachikitsa ii. Samhita Siddhant

iii. Rasashastra iv. Bhaishajya

Kalpana 5 seats in each

Seats increasing in UG 50-75

Not recommended after examination of

documents submitted at the time of hearing by CCIM on following reason:-


The proposal was received during 2009-10

but later on college withdrawal the proposal.

As college is not fulfilling the criteria of permission, therefore, it is not feasible to


Executive Committee decided that after

assessment of paper submitted by the college at the time of hearing decision

for visitation will be taken.

23. Late Kedari Redekar Ayurved College,

Kolhapur PG

Samhita 04 Kayachikitsa-06

Shalakya-06



The college submitted proposal during

2009-10 for starting PG course as under-

Roganidan & Vikriti Vigyan-04 Rasashastra & Bhaishjya Kalpana-05

Shalya-05

48159ec

Initially it was recommended to Govt. of

India for issuing the LOI as above. Accordingly Govt. of India issued LOI and

now CCIM has recommended to issue the LOP as under-

Roganidan & Vikriti Vigyan-04

Rasashastra & Bhaishjya Kalpana-05

But not recommended in Shalya.



college for conducting existing Course as





24. Rani Dulliya Ayurved College, Bhopal

PG

Panchakarma Shalya

05 seats in each




The college submitted the proposal for starting PG in following subjects during

2009-10

1. Basic Principle-05 2. Rachana Sharir-05

3. Swasthavritta-05 4. Agadtantra-05 5. Kaumarbhritya-05

It was recommended to issuing Letter of Intent for the same.

Letter of permission has been recommended

for Swasthavritta with seats Not recommended

Basic Principle-05 Rachana Sharir-05

Agad Tantra-05

49159ec

Kaumarbhritya-05

Decision of Govt. of India is still awaited.


college for conducting existing Course as per their own norms, therefore, it is not

feasible to consider the proposal for additional course at the moment.



visitation.

25. Chaitanya Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Bhsawal PG

Kayachikitsa-03

Recommended to Government of India.

As college is fulfilling the criteria of permission not as a whole, therefore, it is

not feasible to consider the proposal for additional course at the moment.



visitation.

26. Veenavadini Ayurved College Bhopal

PG Kayachikitsa 10

Samhita 10 Dravyaguna 10

seats in each 10 8




As college is not fulfilling the criteria of permission for UG course, therefore, it is

not feasible to consider the proposal for additional course at this moment.



27. Chhatrapati Shahuji Maharaj Ayurved

College, Aurangabad PG

Prasuti & Striroga Shalya

Kaumarbhritya

Recommended for 100 UG seats. PG in

04 kayachikitsa Rachna Sharir not recommended on account

of shortfall for teaching staff.

As college is fulfilling the criteria of

50159ec

permission for UG course.


college fulfills the criteria of 13 C than only visitation may be carried out.

28. Uttaranchal Ayurved College, Dehradun

PG Maulik Siddhant

Swasthvaritta Dravyaguna

Agadtantra

5 seats in each

Not recommended by CCIM on following reasons










29. Loknete Rajarambabu

Patil Ayurved College, Islampur

PG Starting Bhaishajya Kalpana

Roganidan Swasthavritta

Agadtantra Kaumarbhritya

Shalakya Panchkarma

06 seats in each




College has applied for starting PG course as under-

Kayachikitsa-06 Shalya-06

Prasuti & Striroga-06

It was recommended for issuing Letter of

intent for the same. But has been recommended to issue letter of permission

for starting PG in Shalya 02, Prasuti & Striroga-03 and not recommended for

Kayachikitsa.




51159ec




college fulfills the criteria in respect of teaching staff for existing As well as in

subject in which LOP has been recommended by the CCIM on the


by CCIM. 30. Dr. DY Patil Ayurved

College, Navi Mumbai

PG Rachana Sharir

Kriya Sharir Samhita

Swasthavritta Roganidan

Rasashastra Shalya

3 seats in each


Government of India has permitted the college the year 2010-11.


college in view of the norms of the CCIM, therefore, college may be visited for LOI.

Executive Committee decided to visit

the college.

31. Vaidya Yagya Dutta Sharma Ayurved

College, Khirza Starting PG

Kayachikitsa, Kaumarbhritya, Prasuti

& Striroga, Shalakya with 5 seats

Recommended for 40 UG seats.


College has applied for starting PG course in

2009-10 as under from 40-75 and PG Kriya Sharir-05

Shalya-05

After visitation it was recommended to

Govt. of India for issuing letter of Intent. Further Letter of permission has also been

recommended to Letter of permission same.

Final decision of Govt. of India is still awaited 2010-11. College has been

recommended for 40 seats on the basis of 90% + 40%. Govt. of India has also issued

permission letter for the same. As Government of India has permitted the college for conducting existing Course as



52159ec




visitation.

32. SDM Ayurved Medical

College, Hassan To increase seats in

Kaumarbhritya 05-06, Swasthvaritta 04-06

Manas Roga 02-06

Panchakarma 04-06

For starting PG course Ayurved Siddhant

Rachana Sharir Dravyaguna

Bhaishajya Kalpana Agadtantra

Roga Nidan Shalya (Samanya)

Shalya (Kshar Karma avum Anushshastra

Karma) Shalakya (Shiro-Nasa-

Karna avum Kantha

Roga) Shalakya (Netra Roga)

6 seats in each

Recommended for 75 seats

PG 05 Shalya 05 Kaumarbhrittya 04 Swasthavritta

02 Manasroga

01 Panchkarma 04 Shalakya

College has submitted the proposal for

2009-10 for increasing intake capacity for 75-100 and PG in Ayurved Siddhant, Kriya

Shar-06, Kayachikitsa-06, Prasuti & Striroga-06 and for increasing intake

capacity from 02 to 05 in Manas Roga and it was recommended to issue the LOI was

issued by Government of India but CCIM has recommended to issue LOP as under

increasing intake capacity from 75 to 100.

Kriya Sharir 06

Kayachikitsa 06 Prasuti & Striroga 06

Increasing intake capacity 02-05

in Manasroga.

But not recommended for PG in Ayurved Samhita.

Decision of Govt. of India is still awaited.


college fulfills the criteria in respect of teaching staff for existing As well as in

subject in which LOP has been

recommended by the CCIM on the proposal received last year, thereafter,

the decision will be taken for visitation by CCIM.

53159ec

33. Shri Hingulambika

Education Society Ayurved College,

Gulbarga For starting PG course

Dravyaguna Rasashastra

Shalya Shalakya

5 seats in each

Not recommended on following reasons:-

31 eligible teachers against 35 teaching

staff. 04 higher faculty against 20.




college for conducting existing Course as per relaxed norms, therefore, it is not

feasible to consider the proposal for additional course at the moment.



visitation.

34. DGM Ayurved Medical College, Gadag

For starting PG course Kaumarbhritya

Swasthavritta Roganidan

Prasuti & Striroga Shalya

5 seats in each

Recommend for 50 UG and PG as under for the year 2010-11

05 Rasashastra 04 Dravyaguna

04 Panchkarma

1. Requisite of Rs.5.00 lakh is required. 2. College submitted the proposal las year

and after visitation it was recommended

to Government of India for issuing LOI for starting PG Course as follows:-

05 Kaumaryabhritta

05 Swasthavritta 05 Rognidan

05 Prasuti & Striroga 05 Shalya

But has not been recommended to issued

for LOP.



visitation.

35. KLE University, Shri BM

Kankanwadi Ayurveda Medical College

Belgaum, Karnataka Increase intake

capacity for existing PG

Recommended 75 seats for UG

PG not recommended on following ground:-

Bed occupancy is 40.75% against 50%.

54159ec

course

Kriya -06, Prasuti-06, Shalakya(Danta avum

Mukhroga) 06, Chhaya Avum Vikiran vigyan-

06, Basic Principles-02, Rachana-04,

Swasthavritta—03, Kayachikitsa-03,

Shalya(Samanya) 03, Dravyaguna- 02,

Rasashastra-01

The college has applied during 2009-10 for

starting PG course as under- 1. Kayachikitsa-03

2. Shalya-03 3. Agad Tantra-06 4. Bhaishjya Kalpana-06 5. Kaumarbhritya-06

6. Panchakarma-06 7. Sangyaharan-06

It was recommended to issue the Letter of

Intent. But Letter of permission has not been recommended on account of shortfall

of bed occupancy.

The decision of Govt. of India is still

awaited.



36. Ashwini Ayurveda Medical College,

Tumkur (Karnataka) Starting PG Course

Kayachikitsa,

Panchakarma, Swasthavritta,

Shalakya, Shalya, Kriya Sharir, Dravyaguna

5 seats in each

Increasing intake capacity from 50 to 75


Due to shortfaff of teaching staff



As college is not fulfilling the criteria for granting permission for conducting existing

course, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal at the moment.



visitation.

For increasing intake capacity in UG course

37. Gurunanak Ayurved

Medical College, Ludhiana for increasing

intake capacity from 40-50 (perhaps it is 50-

60).

Not recommended by CCIM on account of

area of the hospital is 15.916 Sq.ft. against 20,000 Sq.ft.



55159ec



consider the proposal at the moment.



38. Shri Bhanwar Lal Dugar Ayurved Vishwabharti,

Sardar Shehar

Intake Capacity from 40-50.


32 teachers against 35 eligible teaching staff.

13 higher faculty against 20. Bed occupancy is 34.13% against 40%.


granting permission for conducting existing

course, therefore, it is not feasible to consider the proposal at the moment.



visitation.

39. Sri Sri Nrusinghnath Ayurved College,

Paikmal

Increasing seats from 30-50





consider the proposal at the moment.



40. Bala Hanuman Ayurved

Medical College, Gandhinagar, Lodhra

Seats increasing in UG


reasons:-



permission for conducting existing seats in

56159ec

UG course, therefore, it is not feasible to

consider for increase intake capacity.



Addl.Agenda Item No.7 Visitation report of Mohammadia Unani Medical College, Nanded.

It was noted that a proposal of Marathwada Education Society for establishment of new college namely Mohammadia Unani Medical

College, Nanded (MS) was received through Government of India. After going through the recommendations of screening committee and other

all the relevant records, it was decided not to recommend to Government of India for issuing the Letter of Intent for the year 2010-11.

Executive Committee disapproved the scheme.

Addl.Agenda Item No.8 Enhancement of consolidated salary of Ayurveda, Unani &

Siddha Experts working in CCIM

it was brought to the notice of Executive Committee that Ayurveda,

Unani and Siddha Experts engaged under the scheme of TKDL are getting more consolidated salary from the CCIM.

However, Executive Committee decided that on the tuning of TKDL the

consolidated salary paid to Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Experts be

enhanced as follows:-

a. Experts who join the CCIM with one year experience 35,000/- pm b. Experts who join the CCIM without any experience 30,000/- pm

Addl.Agenda Item No.9 Regarding fake documents.

It was noted that as per observations of Hearing Committee held on 22nd,

23rd and 24th July, 2009 the letters in respect of 39 colleges submitted the false affidavit in respect of 57 teachers and 18 teachers were working

57159ec

in the two or three places among the 18 colleges were asked for

clarifications vice-versa.

The comments received from the colleges and teachers were tabulated. After going through the same only 26 colleges have responded but

except seven teachers have not submitted their comments.

However, the matter was placed before the Executive Committee in its

meeting held on 17-18.5.2010 and further Executive Committee discussed the issue and decided to prepare the details regarding duplicity

and false Experience/ Affidavit of last year and of this year and the same be placed before Executive Committee for consideration.

Executive Committee constituted a sub committee consisting of following

members to finalized the matter of fake documents submitted by the college or false affidavit submitted by the teacher. It was decided that

after scrutinize the documents, if Committee feels necessary, the hearing may be called of College as well as teachers as the case may be.

1. Dr. PK Jain

2. Dr VP Tyagi 3. Dr. NS Tyagi

4. Dr. D Ramanathan 5. Dr. Rashidullah Khan

i. If any college found guilty, FIR for submission of fake information may be lodged against the institution.

ii. If any teacher submitted the false experience, be black listed for

five years. iii. If any teacher who submit the false affidavit, FIR may be lodged

against the teacher and he will not treated as Teacher. iv. The list of Black Listed teacher should be circulated among the

college for non-appointment of blacklisted teachers. v. If any college appoints such teacher will not be considered as

teacher and list of Black Listed teaching staff will be displayed on the web site

It was further decided that the Sub Committee should chalk out the matter within 15 days and submit the action taken report to the ensuing

meeting Executive Committee.

58159ec

Addl.Agenda Item No.10 Services of Group ‘D’ being

procured on outsource basis –

regarding.

It was noted that agency is not providing the emoluments like bonus

etc., uniform and other benefits etc., as per settle terms and conditions therefore, Executive Committee decided to enquire the matter.

Executive Committee constituted a Sub Committee consisting of following members:-

1. Dr. VP Tyagi

2. Dr. Rashidullah Khan It was also decided that matter of Computer operator also be sort out by

this Sub Committee.

Executive Committee was of the opinion that next meeting of Executive Committee will be held at Trivandrum.

Meeting concluded with a vote thanks to the Chair.

***

***** *******

council of indian medicine new delhiccimindia.org/meeting_file/pdf/pdf/ec_10082010.pdf1159ec council...

Documents