coolidge vs new hampshire

8/13/2019 Coolidge vs New Hampshire

1/23

!"#" #%&'()( *+%',

!""#$%&' )* +', -./01-$2'3 456 7*1* 446 89:;9^ !"#"


3/23

b( 7'( 07..(B %&+2 /2 ,5/4 074( ,+ B(0/B( /44%(4 %2B(' ,5( I+%',5 72B I+%',((2,5L)(2B)(2,4 7'/4/2E /2 ,5( 0+2,(R, +D 7 4,7,( 0'/)/27. ,'/7. D+' ,5( 0+))/44/+2 +D 7&7',/0%.7'.8 A'%,7. )%'B('" L4 /2 (K('8 074(; +%' 4/2E.( B%,8 /4 ,+ B(,(')/2( ,5( /44%(4&'(4(2,(B /2 700+'B 1/,5 ,5( *+24,/,%,/+2 72B ,5( .71"

-7)(.7 _74+2; 7


4/23

+2.8 17''72, ,57, 0+20('24 %4 5('(; 4,7,(B ,57, ,5( 7DD/72, W574 &'+A7A.( 07%4( ,+4%4&(0, 72B A(./(K(; 72B B+(4 4%4&(0, 72B A(./(K(; 72B 5('(1/,5 +DD('4 47,/4D70,+'8(K/B(20(; ,57, ,5('( 7'( 0(',7/2 +AQ(0,4 72B ,5/2E4 %4(B /2 ,5( *+))/44/+2 +D 47/B+DD(24(; 2+1 G(&,; 72B 0+20(7.(B /2 +' %&+2 7 0(',7/2 K(5/0.(; ,+ 1/,U


5/23

J5( &(,/,/+2('34 D/'4, 0.7/) /4 ,57, ,5( 17''72, 7%,5+'/V/2E ,5( 4(/V%'( 72B 4%A4(@%(2,4(7'05 +D 5/4


6/23

_720%4/ K" `(I+',(; X=9 !"#" X>?; X^< " L4 D+' ,5( &'+&+4/,/+2 ,57, ,5( (R/4,(20( +D&'+A7A.( 07%4( '(2B('4 2+20+)&./720( 1/,5 ,5( 17''72, &'+0(B%'( 72 /''(.(K720(; [?YX!"#" ??X; ?Z


7/23

WJ5( b/,2(44U i(4" *7&,7/2 *+%,%'( 72B *7&,7/2 #5(7 72B *7&,7/2 e+K('(2 7'( 6" -"34"

WJ5( *+%',U b(..; .(, )( 74G 8+%; *5/(D; 8+%' 7241(' /4 ,+ ,5( (DD(0, ,57, 8+% 2(K(' E++%, +D ,5( B(&7',)(2, D+' ,5( 6%4,/0( +D ,5( -(70(j

WJ5( b/,2(44U C, 57423, A((2 +%' H &+./08 ,+ E+ +%, +D ,5( B(&7',)(2,"

Wk" c/E5," i+%' &+./08 72B (R&('/(20(; /4 ,+ 57K( 7 D(..+1 &+./0( +DD/0(' ,7G( ,5( 17''72,/2 ,5( 07&70/,8 +D 6%4,/0( +D ,5( -(70(j

WL" J57, 574 A((2 +%' &'70,/0("W [?YX !"#" ??X; ?ZX\

d%, /, /4 ,++ &.7/2 D+' (R,(24/K( B/40%44/+2 ,57, ,5/4 2+1 7A72B+2(B a(1 T7)&45/'()(,5+B +D /44%/2E W4(7'05 17''72,4W K/+.7,(B 7 D%2B7)(2,7. &'()/4( +D A+,5 ,5( I+%',572B I+%',((2,5 L)(2B)(2,4 H 7 &'()/4( D%..8 B(K(.+&(B 72B 7',/0%.7,(B .+2E A(D+'(,5/4 *+%',34 B(0/4/+24 /2 f(' K" *7./D+'2/7; 4%&'7; 72B _7&& K" M5/+; X>^ !"#" >?X " L4 _'"6%4,/0( I'72GD%',(' &%, /, /2 b+.D K" *+.+'7B+; XX: !"#" 9Z; 9^ H9:U

WJ5( 4(0%'/,8 +D +2(34 &'/K708 7E7/24, 7'A/,'7'8 /2,'%4/+2 A8 ,5( &+./0( H 15/05 /4 7, ,5(0+'( +D ,5( I+%',5 L)(2B)(2, H /4 A74/0 ,+ 7 D'(( 4+0/(,8" C, /4 ,5('(D+'( /)&./0/, /2 h,5(0+20(&, +D +'B('(B ./A(',83 72B 74 4%05 (2D+'0(7A.( 7E7/24, ,5( #,7,(4 ,5'+%E5 ,5( `%(-'+0(44 *.7%4(" J5( G2+0G 7, ,5( B++'; 15(,5(' A8 B78 +' A8 2/E5,; 74 7 &'(.%B( ,+ 74(7'05; 1/,5+%, 7%,5+'/,8 +D .71 A%, 4+.(.8 +2 ,5( 7%,5+'/,8 +D ,5( &+./0(; B/B 2+, 2((B,5( 0+))(2,7'8 +D '(0(2, 5/4,+'8 ,+ A( 0+2B()2(B " " " "W

b( D/2B 2+ (407&( D'+) ,5( 0+20.%4/+2 ,57, ,5( 4(/V%'( 72B 4(7'05 +D ,5( -+2,/707%,+)+A/.( 0722+, 0+24,/,%,/+27..8 '(4, %&+2 ,5( 17''72, /44%(B A8 ,5( 4,7,( +DD/0/7.15+ 174 ,5( 05/(D /2K(4,/E7,+' 72B &'+4(0%,+' /2 ,5/4 074(" #/20( 5( 174 2+, ,5( 2(%,'7.

72B B(,705(B )7E/4,'7,( '(@%/'(B A8 ,5( *+24,/,%,/+2; ,5( 4(7'05 4,72B4 +2 2+ D/')('E'+%2B ,572 /D ,5('( 57B A((2 2+ 17''72, 7, 7.." CD ,5( 4(/V%'( 72B 4(7'05 7'( ,+ A( Q%4,/D/(B; ,5(8 )%4,; ,5('(D+'(; A( Q%4,/D/(B +2 4+)( +,5(' ,5(+'8"

$$

J5( #,7,( &'+&+4(4 ,5'(( B/4,/20, ,5(+'/(4 ,+ A'/2E ,5( D70,4 +D ,5/4 074( 1/,5/2 +2( +'72+,5(' +D ,5( (R0(&,/+24 ,+ ,5( 17''72, '(@%/'()(2," C2 0+24/B('/2E ,5(); 1( )%4,2+, .+4( 4/E5, +D ,5( I+%',5 L)(2B)(2,34 D%2B7)(2,7. E%7'72,((" _'" 6%4,/0( d'7B.(8347B)+2/,/+2 /2 5/4 +&/2/+2 D+' ,5( *+%', 7.)+4, 7 0(2,%'8 7E+ /2 d+8B [?YX !"#" ??X;?Z?\ K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; ; >XZ ; /4 1+',5 '(&(7,/2E 5('(U

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


8/23

0+24/4,(B )+'( /2 4+%2B ,572 /2 4%A4,720(" C, /4 ,5( B%,8 +D 0+%',4 ,+ A( 17,05D%. D+' ,5(0+24,/,%,/+27. '/E5,4 +D ,5( 0/,/V(2; 72B 7E7/24, 728 4,(7.,58 (20'+705)(2,4 ,5('(+2"W ?

J5%4 ,5( )+4, A74/0 0+24,/,%,/+27. '%.( /2 ,5/4 7'(7 /4 ,57, W4(7'05(4 0+2B%0,(B +%,4/B(,5( Q%B/0/7. &'+0(44; 1/,5+%, &'/+' 7&&'+K7. A8 Q%BE( +' )7E/4,'7,(; 7'( &(' 4( [?YX !"#"

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d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


9/23

LE2(..+ K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 9>= !"#"; 7, XY HX^ !"#"


10/23

W7 2(0(447'8 B/DD('(20( A(,1((2 7 4(7'05 +D 7 4,+'(; B1(../2E 5+%4( +' +,5(' 4,'%0,%'(/2 '(4&(0, +D 15/05 7 &'+&(' +DD/0/7. 17''72, '(7B/.8 )78 A( +A,7/2(B; 72B 7 4(7'05 +D 745/&; )+,+' A+7,; 17E+2 +' 7%,+)+A/.(; [?YX !"#" ??X; ?>Y\ D+' 0+2,'7A72B E++B4;15('( /, /4 2+, &'70,/07A.( ,+ 4(0%'( 7 17''72, A(07%4( ,5( K(5/0.( 072 A( @%/0G.8 )+K(B+%, +D ,5( .+07./,8 +' Q%'/4B/0,/+2 /2 15/05 ,5( 17''72, )%4, A( 4+%E5,"W 9>^ !"#"; 7,


11/23

,5( W7%,+)+A/.( (R0(&,/+2;W B(4&/,( /,4 .7A(.; /4 4/)&.8 /''(.(K72," X\

#/20( *7''+.. 1+%.B 2+, 57K( Q%4,/D/(B 7 17''72,.(44 4(7'05 +D ,5( -+2,/70 7, ,5( ,/)(*++./BE( 174 7''(4,(B; ,5( .7,(' 4(7'05 7, ,5( 4,7,/+2 5+%4( 174 &.7/2.8 /..(E7.; 7, .(74,

4+ D7' 74 ,5( 7%,+)+A/.( (R0(&,/+2 /4 0+20('2(B" *57)A('4; 4%&'7; /4 +D 2+ 5(.& ,+ ,5(#,7,(; 4/20( ,57, 074( 5(.B +2.8 ,57,; 15('( ,5( &+./0( )78 4,+& 72B 4(7'05 727%,+)+A/.( %2B(' *7''+..; ,5(8 )78 7.4+ 4(/V( /, 72B 4(7'05 /, .7,(' 7, ,5( &+./0(4,7,/+2" 9Y c7,5('; ,5/4 074( /4 0+2,'+..(B A8 `8G( K" J78.+' C)&.()(2, _DE" *+"; 4%&'7"J5('( ,5( &+./0( .70G(B &'+A7A.( 07%4( ,+ 4(/V( +' 4(7'05 ,5( B(D(2B72,34 7%,+)+A/.( 7,,5( ,/)( +D 5/4 [?YX !"#" ??X; ?>?\ 7''(4,; 72B ,5/4 174 (2+%E5 A8 /,4(.D ,+ 0+2B()2 ,5(4%A4(@%(2, 4(7'05 7, ,5( 4,7,/+2 5+%4(" T('( ,5('( 174 &'+A7A.( 07%4(; A%, 2+ (R/E(2,0/'0%)4,720(4 Q%4,/D/(B ,5( &+./0( /2 &'+0((B/2E 1/,5+%, 7 17''72," L4 /2 `8G(; ,5( .7,('4(7'05 7, ,5( 4,7,/+2 5+%4( 174 ,5('(D+'( /..(E7." 9 !"#" Z: ; /4 47/B ,+ 4%&&+',7 4%A4(@%(2, 17''72,.(44 4(7'05 7, ,5( 4,7,/+2 5+%4(; 1/,5 +' 1/,5+%, &'+A7A.( 07%4("MD 0+%'4(; ,5( B/4,/20,/+2 A(,1((2 72 W/24,'%)(2,7./,8 +D 0'/)(W 72B W)('( (K/B(20(W174 B+2( 7178 1/,5 A8 b7'B(2 K" T78B(2; X:^ !"#" 9=? ; 72B 1( )78 744%)( ,57, ,5(&+./0( 57B &'+A7A.( 07%4( ,+ 4(/V( ,5( 7%,+)+A/.(" 99 d%,; D+' ,5( '(74+24 ,57, D+..+1;1( 5+.B ,57, ,5( W&.7/2 K/(1W (R0(&,/+2 ,+ ,5( 17''72, '(@%/'()(2, /4 /27&&./07A.( ,+,5/4 074(" #/20( ,5( 4(/V%'( 174 ,5('(D+'( [?YX !"#" ??X; ?>Z\ /..(E7.; /, /4 %22(0(447'8 ,+0+24/B(' ,5( 7&&./07A/./,8 +D *++&('; 4%&'7; ,+ ,5( 4%A4(@%(2, 4(7'05" 9X

C, /4 1(.. (4,7A./45(B ,57, %2B(' 0(',7/2 0/'0%)4,720(4 ,5( &+./0( )78 4(/V( (K/B(20( /2&.7/2 K/(1 1/,5+%, 7 17''72," d%, /, /4 /)&+',72, ,+ G((& /2 )/2B ,57,; /2 ,5( K74,)7Q+'/,8 +D 074(4; 728 (K/B(20( 4(/V(B A8 ,5( &+./0( 1/.. A( /2 &.7/2 K/(1; 7, .(74, 7, ,5()+)(2, +D 4(/V%'(" J5( &'+A.() 1/,5 ,5( W&.7/2 K/(1W B+0,'/2( 574 A((2 ,+ /B(2,/D8 ,5(0/'0%)4,720(4 /2 15/05 &.7/2 K/(1 574 .(E7. 4/E2/D/0720( '7,5(' ,572 A(/2E 4/)&.8 ,5(2+')7. 0+20+)/,72, +D 728 4(7'05; .(E7. +' /..(E7."

L2 (R7)&.( +D ,5( 7&&./07A/./,8 +D ,5( W&.7/2 K/(1W B+0,'/2( /4 ,5( 4/,%7,/+2 /2 15/05 ,5(&+./0( 57K( 7 17''72, ,+ 4(7'05 7 E/K(2 7'(7 D+' 4&(0/D/(B +AQ(0,4; 72B /2 ,5( 0+%'4( +D

,5( 4(7'05 0+)( 70'+44 4+)( +,5(' 7',/0.( +D /20'/)/27,/2E 057'70,('" *D" N+Hd7',C)&+',/2E *+" K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 9:9 !"#" X??; XZ: F !2/,(B #,7,(4 K" e(DG+1/,V; 9:Z !"#"?Z9; ?>Z F #,((.( K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 9>^ !"#" ?=: F #,72.(8 K" N(+'E/7; X=? !"#" ZZ^;Z^


12/23

4%4&(0," b7'B(2 K" T78B(2; 4%&'7F 0D" T(4,(' K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 9>Z !"#" Z^ " L2B 72+AQ(0, ,57, 0+)(4 /2,+ K/(1 B%'/2E 7 4(7'05 /20/B(2, ,+ 7''(4, ,57, /4 7&&'+&'/7,(.8./)/,(B /2 40+&( %2B(' (R/4,/2E .71 )78 A( 4(/V(B 1/,5+%, 7 17''72," 9? *5/)(. K"*7./D+'2/7; X=Z -7E( ?>> !"#"; 7, ^>9 H^>X" I/27..8; ,5( W&.7/2 K/(1W B+0,'/2( 574 A((27&&./(B 15('( 7 &+./0( +DD/0(' /4 2+, 4(7'05/2E D+' (K/B(20( 7E7/24, ,5( 700%4(B; A%,

2+2(,5(.(44 /27BK(',(2,.8 0+)(4 70'+44 72 /20'/)/27,/2E +AQ(0," T7''/4 K" !2/,(B#,7,(4; X=Y !"#" 9X? F I'7V/(' K" *%&&; X=? !"#" ^X< F f(' K" *7./D+'2/7; X^? !"#"; 7, ?X " *D"e(1/4 K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; X:Z !"#" 9Y> "

b57, ,5( W&.7/2 K/(1W 074(4 57K( /2 0+))+2 /4 ,57, ,5( &+./0( +DD/0(' /2 (705 +D ,5()57B 7 &'/+' Q%4,/D/07,/+2 D+' 72 /2,'%4/+2 /2 ,5( 0+%'4( +D 15/05 5( 07)( /27BK(',(2,.870'+44 7 &/(0( +D (K/B(20( /20'/)/27,/2E ,5( 700%4(B" J5( B+0,'/2( 4('K(4 ,+ 4%&&.()(2,,5( &'/+' Q%4,/D/07,/+2 H 15(,5(' /, A( 7 17''72, D+' 72+,5(' +AQ(0,; 5+, &%'4%/,; 4(7'05/20/B(2, ,+ .71D%. 7''(4,; +' 4+)( +,5(' .(E/,/)7,( '(74+2 D+' A(/2E &'(4(2,%20+22(0,(B 1/,5 7 4(7'05 B/'(0,(B 7E7/24, ,5( 700%4(B H 72B &(')/,4 ,5( 17''72,.(444(/V%'(" MD 0+%'4(; ,5( (R,(24/+2 +D ,5( +'/E/27. Q%4,/D/07,/+2 /4 .(E/,/)7,( +2.8 15('( /, /4/))(B/7,(.8 7&&7'(2, ,+ ,5( &+./0( ,57, ,5(8 57K( (K/B(20( A(D+'( ,5()F ,5( W&.7/2K/(1W B+0,'/2( )78 2+, A( %4(B ,+ (R,(2B 7 E(2('7. (R&.+'7,+'8 4(7'05 D'+) +2( +AQ(0,,+ 72+,5(' %2,/. 4+)(,5/2E /20'/)/27,/2E 7, .74, ()('E(4" [?YX !"#" ??X; ?>^\ *D"#,72.(8 K" N(+'E/7; 4%&'7; 7, Z^


13/23

2((B.(44 /20+2K(2/(20(; 72B 4+)(,/)(4 B72E('+%4 H ,+ ,5( (K/B(20( +' ,+ ,5( &+./0(,5()4(.K(4 H ,+ '(@%/'( ,5() ,+ /E2+'( /, %2,/. ,5(8 57K( +A,7/2(B 7 17''72, &7',/0%.7'.8B(40'/A/2E /,"

J5( ./)/,4 +2 ,5( B+0,'/2( 7'( /)&./0/, /2 ,5( 4,7,()(2, +D /,4 '7,/+27.(" J5( D/'4, +D ,5(4(

/4 ,57, &.7/2 K/(1 7.+2( /4 2(K(' (2+%E5 ,+ Q%4,/D8 ,5( 17''72,.(44 4(/V%'( +D (K/B(20("J5/4 /4 4/)&.8 7 0+'+..7'8 +D ,5( D7)/./7' &'/20/&.( B/40%44(B 7A+K(; ,57, 2+ 7)+%2, +D&'+A7A.( 07%4( 072 Q%4,/D8 7 17''72,.(44 4(7'05 +' 4(/V%'( 7A4(2, W(R/E(2,0/'0%)4,720(4"W C20+2,'+K(',/A.( ,(4,/)+28 +D ,5( 4(24(4 ,57, 72 /20'/)/27,/2E +AQ(0, /4+2 &'()/4(4 A(.+2E/2E ,+ 7 0'/)/27. 4%4&(0, )78 (4,7A./45 ,5( D%..(4, &+44/A.( )(74%'(+D &'+A7A.( 07%4(" d%, (K(2 15('( ,5( +AQ(0, /4 0+2,'7A72B; ,5/4 *+%', 574 '(&(7,(B.84,7,(B 72B (2D+'0(B ,5( A74/0 '%.( ,57, ,5( &+./0( )78 2+, (2,(' 72B )7G( 7 17''72,.(444(/V%'(" J78.+' K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 9:> !"#" < F 6+524+2 K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; XXX !"#" == " 9Z [?YX !"#" ??X; ?>=\

J5( 4(0+2B ./)/,7,/+2 /4 ,57, ,5( B/40+K('8 +D (K/B(20( /2 &.7/2 K/(1 )%4, A(/27BK(',(2," 9> J5( '7,/+27.( +D ,5( (R0(&,/+2 ,+ ,5( 17''72, '(@%/'()(2,; 74 Q%4,4,7,(B; [?YX !"#" ??X; ?^Y\ /4 ,57, 7 &.7/2HK/(1 4(/V%'( 1/.. 2+, ,%'2 72 /2/,/7..8 K7./B O72B,5('(D+'( ./)/,(BP 4(7'05 /2,+ 7 WE(2('7.W +2(; 15/.( ,5( /20+2K(2/(20( +D &'+0%'/2E 717''72, ,+ 0+K(' 72 /27BK(',(2, B/40+K('8 /4 E'(7," d%, 15('( ,5( B/40+K('8 /472,/0/&7,(B; 15('( ,5( &+./0( G2+1 /2 7BK720( ,5( .+07,/+2 +D ,5( (K/B(20( 72B /2,(2B,+ 4(/V( /,; ,5( 4/,%7,/+2 /4 7.,+E(,5(' B/DD('(2," J5( '(@%/'()(2, +D 7 17''72, ,+ 4(/V(/)&+4(4 2+ /20+2K(2/(20( 157,(K('; +' 7, .(74, 2+2( 15/05 /4 0+24,/,%,/+27..80+E2/V7A.( /2 7 .(E7. 484,() ,57, '(E7'B4 17''72,.(44 4(7'05(4 74 W&(' 4( [?YX !"#" ??X;?^


14/23

J5( 4(/V%'( 174 ,5('(D+'( %20+24,/,%,/+27.; 72B 4+ 174 ,5( 4%A4(@%(2, 4(7'05 7, ,5(4,7,/+2 5+%4(" #/20( (K/B(20( +A,7/2(B /2 ,5( 0+%'4( +D ,5( 4(7'05 174 7B)/,,(B 7,*++./BE(34 ,'/7.; ,5( Q%BE)(2, )%4, A( '(K('4(B 72B ,5( 074( '()72B(B ,+ ,5( a(1T7)&45/'( #%&'()( *+%'," _7&& K" M5/+; X>^ !"#" >?X "

%C2 5/4 B/44(2,/2E +&/2/+2 ,+B78; _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ] )7'457.4 ,5( 7'E%)(2,4 ,57, 072 A()7B( 7E7/24, +%' /2,('&'(,7,/+2 +D ,5( W7%,+)+A/.(W 72B W&.7/2 K/(1W (R0(&,/+24 ,+ ,5(17''72, '(@%/'()(2," d(8+2B ,5( [?YX !"#" ??X; ?^?\ %24,7',./2E &'+&+4/,/+2 ,57,15(2 7 ./2( /4 B'712 ,5('( /4 +D,(2 2+, 7 E'(7, B(7. +D B/DD('(20( A(,1((2 ,5( 4/,%7,/+240.+4(4, ,+ /, +2 (/,5(' 4/B(; ,5('( /4 7 4/2E.( ,5()( ,57, '%24 ,5'+%E5 157, 5( 574 ,+ 4787A+%, ,5( ,1+ (R0(&,/+24" #/20( ,57, ,5()( /4 7 '(0%''/2E +2( /2 0+2,'+K('4/(4 +K(' ,5(&'+&(' )(72/2E 72B 40+&( +D ,5( I+%',5 L)(2B)(2,; /, 4(()4 7&&'+&'/7,( ,+ ,'(7, 5/4K/(14 /2 ,5/4 4(&7'7,( 4(0,/+2; '7,5(' ,572 &/(0()(7."

_%05 ,5( )+4, /)&+',72, &7', +D ,5( 0+2D./0, ,57, 574 A((2 4+ 2+,7A.( /2 ,5/4 *+%',347,,()&,4 +K(' 7 5%2B'(B 8(7'4 ,+ B(K(.+& 7 0+5('(2, A+B8 +D I+%',5 L)(2B)(2, .71574 A((2 07%4(B A8 B/47E'(()(2, +K(' ,5( /)&+',720( +D '(@%/'/2E .71 (2D+'0()(2,+DD/0('4 ,+ 4(0%'( 17''72,4" #+)( 57K( 7'E%(B ,57, 7 B(,(')/27,/+2 A8 7 )7E/4,'7,( +D&'+A7A.( 07%4( 74 7 &'(0+2B/,/+2 +D 728 4(7'05 +' 4(/V%'( /4 4+ (44(2,/7. ,57, ,5( I+%',5L)(2B)(2, /4 K/+.7,(B 15(2(K(' ,5( &+./0( )/E5, '(74+27A.8 57K( +A,7/2(B 7 17''72,A%, D7/.(B ,+ B+ 4+" M,5('4 57K( 7'E%(B 1/,5 (@%7. D+'0( ,57, 7 ,(4, +D '(74+27A.(2(44;7&&./(B 7D,(' ,5( D70, +D 4(7'05 +' 4(/V%'( 15(2 ,5( &+./0( 7,,()&, ,+ /2,'+B%0( ,5(D'%/,4 /2 (K/B(20(; 7DD+'B4 7)&.( 47D(E%7'B D+' ,5( '/E5,4 /2 @%(4,/+2; 4+ ,57, W[,\5('(.(K72, ,(4, /4 2+, 15(,5(' /, /4 '(74+27A.( ,+ &'+0%'( 7 4(7'05 17''72,; A%, 15(,5(',5( 4(7'05 174 '(74+27A.("W 9=

d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

J5( 47)( 0+2D./0, 7'/4(4 /2 ,5/4 074(" #/20( ,5( &+./0( G2(1 +D ,5( &'(4(20( +D ,5(7%,+)+A/.( 72B &.722(B 7.. 7.+2E ,+ 4(/V( /,; ,5('( 174 2+ W(R/E(2, 0/'0%)4,720(W ,+ Q%4,/D8 ,5(/' D7/.%'( ,+ +A,7/2 7 17''72," J5( 7&&./07,/+2 +D ,5( A74/0 '%.( +D I+%',5L)(2B)(2, .71 ,5('(D+'( '(@%/'(4 ,57, ,5( D'%/,4 +D ,5( 17''72,.(44 4(/V%'( A(4%&&'(44(B" _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ]34 B/44(2,/2E +&/2/+2; 5+1(K('; 7'E%(4 +20( 7E7/2 ,57,4+ .+2E 74 ,5( &+./0( 0+%.B '(74+27A.8 )7G( 7 17''72,.(44 2/E5,,/)( (2,'8 +2,+*++./BE(34 &'+&(',8 /2 +'B(' ,+ 7''(4, 5/); 1/,5 2+ 45+1/2E 7, 7.. +D 72 ()('E(208; ,5(2/, /4 7A4%'B ,+ &'(K(2, ,5() D'+) 4(/V/2E 5/4 7%,+)+A/.( 74 (K/B(20( +D ,5( 0'/)("

_c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ] ,7G(4 7 A74/07..8 4/)/.7' 7&&'+705 ,+ ,5( @%(4,/+2 15(,5(' ,5(4(7'05 +D ,5( 7%,+)+A/.( /2 [?YX !"#" ??X; ?^=\ ,5/4 074( 072 A( Q%4,/D/(B %2B(' *7''+..K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 4%&'7; 72B *57)A('4 K" _7'+2(8; 4%&'7" *7''+..; +2 /,4 D70(; 7&&(7'4 ,+

A( 7 0.744/0 (R7)&.( +D ,5( B+0,'/2( ,57, 17''72,.(44 4(7'05(4 7'( &(' 4( %2'(74+27A.(/2 ,5( 7A4(20( +D (R/E(2, 0/'0%)4,720(4" ]K('8 1+'B /2 ,5( +&/2/+2 /2B/07,(4 ,5( *+%',347B5('(20( ,+ ,5( %2B('.8/2E '%.( 72B /,4 07'( /2 B(./2(7,/2E 7 ./)/,(B (R0(&,/+2" c(7B,5%4; ,5( 074( @%/,( (K/B(2,.8 B+(4 2+, (R,(2B ,+ ,5( 4/,%7,/+2 7, A7'" i(, /D 1( ,7G( ,5(K/(1&+/2, +D 7 Q%BE( 07..(B +2 +2.8 ,+ B(0/B( /2 ,5( 7A4,'70,; 7D,(' ,5( D70,; 15(,5(' ,5(&+./0( 57K( A(57K(B W'(74+27A.8W %2B(' 7.. ,5( 0/'0%)4,720(4 H /2 45+', /D 1( 4/)&.8/E2+'( ,5( 17''72, '(@%/'()(2, H *7''+.. 0+)(4 ,+ 4,72B D+' 4+)(,5/2E )+'(" J5(4,+&&/2E +D 7 K(5/0.( +2 ,5( +&(2 5/E5178 72B 7 4%A4(@%(2, 4(7'05 7)+%2, ,+ 7 )7Q+'


17/23

/2,('D('(20( /2 ,5( ./K(4 +D ,5( +00%&72,4" *7''+.. 5(.B 4%05 72 /2,('D('(20( ,+ A('(74+27A.( 1/,5+%, 7 17''72,; E/K(2 &'+A7A.( 07%4(" C, )78 A( ,5+%E5, ,+ D+..+1 7D+',/+'/ ,57, ,5( 4(/V%'( 72B 4(7'05 5('( H 15('( ,5('( 174 2+ 4,+&&/2E 72B ,5( K(5/0.(174 %2+00%&/(B H 1('( 7.4+ '(74+27A.(; 4/20( ,5( /2,'%4/+2 174 .(44 4%A4,72,/7.;7.,5+%E5 ,5('( 1('( 2+ (R/E(2, 0/'0%)4,720(4 157,(K('" !4/2E '(74+2/2E +D ,5/4 4+',; /,

/4 A%, 7 45+', 4,(& ,+ ,5( &+4/,/+2 ,57, /, /4 2(K(' 2(0(447'8 D+' ,5( &+./0( ,+ +A,7/2 717''72, A(D+'( 4(7'05/2E 72B 4(/V/2E 72 7%,+)+A/.(; &'+K/B(B ,57, ,5(8 57K( &'+A7A.(07%4(" L2B _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ] 7&&(7'4 ,+ 7B+&, (R70,.8 ,5/4 K/(1 15(2 5( &'+&+4(4,57, ,5( *+%', 45+%.B W,'(7, 4(7'05(4 +D 7%,+)+A/.(4 74 1( B+ ,5( 7''(4, +D 7 &('4+2"W

CD 1( 1('( ,+ 700(&, _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ]3# K/(1 ,57, 17''72,.(44 (2,'8 D+' &%'&+4(4 +D7''(4, 72B 17''72,.(44 4(/V%'( 72B 4(7'05 +D 7%,+)+A/.(4 7'( &(' 4( '(74+27A.(; 4+ .+2E74 ,5( &+./0( 57K( &'+A7A.( 07%4(; /, 1+%.B A( B/DD/0%., ,+ 4(( ,5( A74/4 D+' B/4,/2E%/45/2E4(7'05(4 +D 5+%4(4 72B 4(/V%'(4 +D (DD(0,4" CD /, /4 '(74+27A.( D+' ,5( &+./0( ,+ )7G( 717''72,.(44 2/E5,,/)( (2,'8 D+' ,5( &%'&+4( [?YX !"#" ??X; ?:Y\ +D 7''(4,/2E 7 &('4+2 /25/4 A(B; ,5(2 4%'(.8 /, )%4, A( '(74+27A.( 74 1(.. ,+ )7G( 7 17''72,.(44 (2,'8 ,+ 4(7'05D+' 72B 4(/V( K/,7. (K/B(20( +D 7 4('/+%4 0'/)(" CD ,5( &+./0( )78; 1/,5+%, 7 17''72,; 4(/V(72B 4(7'05 72 %2+00%&/(B K(5/0.( &7'G(B +2 ,5( +12('34 &'/K7,( &'+&(',8; 2+, A(/2E%4(B D+' 728 /..(E7. &%'&+4(; ,5(2 /, /4 57'B ,+ 4(( 158 ,5(8 2((B 7 17''72, ,+ 4(/V( 72B4(7'05 7 4%/,074(; 7 ,'%2G; 7 45+&&/2E A7E; +' 728 +,5(' &+',7A.( 0+2,7/2(' /2 7 5+%4(;E7'7E(; +' A70G 87'B"

J5( D%2B7)(2,7. +AQ(0,/+2; ,5(2; ,+ ,5( ./2( +D 7'E%)(2, 7B+&,(B A8 _c" 6!#JC*]bTCJ] /2 5/4 B/44(2, /2 ,5/4 074( 72B /2 *5/)(. K" *7./D+'2/7; 4%&'7; /4 ,57, /, &'+K(4 ,++)%05" CD 1( 1('( ,+ 7E'(( 1/,5 _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ] ,57, ,5( &+./0( )78; 15(2(K(' ,5(857K( &'+A7A.( 07%4(; )7G( 7 17''72,.(44 (2,'8 D+' ,5( &%'&+4( +D )7G/2E 72 7''(4,; 72B,57, 4(/V%'(4 72B 4(7'05(4 +D 7%,+)+A/.(4 7'( ./G(1/4( &(' 4( '(74+27A.( E/K(2 &'+A7A.(07%4(; ,5(2 A8 ,5( 47)( .+E/0 728 4(7'05 +' 4(/V%'( 0+%.B A( 07''/(B +%, 1/,5+%, 717''72,; 72B 1( 1+%.B 4/)&.8 57K( '(7B ,5( I+%',5 L)(2B)(2, +%, +D ,5(*+24,/,%,/+2" C2B((B; /D _c" 6!#JC*] b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

a+2( +D ,5( 074(4 0/,(B A8 _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ] B/4&+4(4 +D ,5/4 WE'7K( 0+24,/,%,/+27.@%(4,/+2"W J5( 074( +D b7'B(2 K" T78B(2; 4%&'7; 15('( ,5( *+%', (.7A+'7,(B [?YX !"#"??X; ?:


18/23

%272/)+%4.8 '(705(B ,5( 47)( 0+20.%4/+2" X> d%, 1( D/2B /, %22(0(447'8 ,+ B(0/B( ,5(@%(4,/+2 /2 ,5/4 074(" J5( '%.( ,57, W4(7'05(4 0+2B%0,(B +%,4/B( ,5( Q%B/0/7. &'+0(44;1/,5+%, &'/+' 7&&'+K7. A8 Q%BE( +' )7E/4,'7,(; 7'( &(' 4( %2'(74+27A.( %2B(' ,5(I+%',5 L)(2B)(2, H 4%AQ(0, +2.8 ,+ 7 D(1 4&(0/D/07..8 (4,7A./45(B 72B 1(..HB(./2(7,(B(R0(&,/+24;W X^ /4 2+, 4+ D'7/. ,57, /,4 0+2,/2%/2E K/,7./,8 B(&(2B4 +2 ,5( D7,( +D 7

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c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

I/27..8; 7 1+'B 7A+%, J'%&/72+ K" !2/,(B #,7,(4; 4%&'7" M%' B/40%44/+2 +D W&.7/2 K/(1W /2-7', * 7A+K( 0+''(4&+2B4 1/,5 ,57, E/K(2 /2 J'%&/72+" T('(; 74 /2 J'%&/72+; ,5(B(,(')/2/2E D70,+'4 7'( 7BK720( &+./0( G2+1.(BE( +D ,5( (R/4,(20( 72B .+07,/+2 +D ,5(

(K/B(20(; &+./0( /2,(2,/+2 ,+ 4(/V( /,; 72B ,5( 7)&.( +&&+',%2/,8 D+' +A,7/2/2E 7 17''72,"#(( XX? !"#"; 7, ^Y^ H^Y: 72B 2" 9^; 4%&'7" T+1(K('; 1( B+ 2+, W'(/24,7,(W J'%&/72+;4/20( 1( 0722+, 7B+&, 7.. /,4 /)&./07,/+24" J+ A(E/2 1/,5; /2 *5/)(. K" *7./D+'2/7; 4%&'7;1( 5(.B ,57, 7 4(7'05 +D ,5( &('4+2 +D 72 7''(4,(( 72B +D ,5( 7'(7 %2B(' 5/4 /))(B/7,(0+2,'+. 0+%.B A( 07''/(B +%, 1/,5+%, 7 17''72," b( B/B 2+, /2B/07,( ,5('(; 72B B+ 2+,4%EE(4, 5('(; ,57, ,5( &+./0( )%4, +A,7/2 7 17''72, /D ,5(8 72,/0/&7,( ,57, ,5(8 1/.. D/2B4&(0/D/0 (K/B(20( B%'/2E ,5( 0+%'4( +D 4%05 7 4(7'05" #(( 2" 9?; 4%&'7" L2B 74 ,+ ,5(7%,+)+A/.( (R0(&,/+2; 1( B+ 2+, @%(4,/+2 ,5( B(0/4/+24 +D ,5( *+%', /2 *++&(' K"*7./D+'2/7; X:> !"#" Z: ; 72B *57)A('4 K" _7'+2(8; 4%&'7; 7.,5+%E5 A+,5 7'( 7'E%7A.8/20+24/4,(2, 1/,5 J'%&/72+"

_c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ]3# B/44(2, 057'70,('/V(4 ,5( 0+(R/4,(20( +D *5/)(.; *++&(';*57)A('4; 72B ,5/4 074( 74 W&%2/,/K(;W W(R,'7K7E72,;W W/20+24/4,(2,;W W1/,5+%, 7&&7'(2,'(74+2;W W%2(R&.7/2(B;W 72B W/2(R&./07A.("W -+4,; 7, Z


19/23

5/4 &'+&+47. ,57, 1( ,'(7, (2,'8 D+' &%'&+4(4 +D 7''(4, 72B 4(/V%'( +D 72 7%,+)+A/.(7./G( 74 &(' 4( '(74+27A.( +2 &'+A7A.( 07%4(" #%05 72 7&&'+705 )/E5, B/4&+4( +D ,5/4074( 0.(7'.8 72B 0(',7/2.8 (2+%E5; A%,; 74 1( 57K( ,'/(B ,+ 45+1 7A+K(; /, 1+%.B 074,/2,+ ./)A+ ,5( 15+.( 2+,/+2 +D 7 I+%',5 L)(2B)(2, 17''72, '(@%/'()(2," L2B /, /4B/DD/0%., ,+ ,7G( 4('/+%4.8 _c" 6!#JC*] bTCJ]3# 7.,('27,/K( 4%EE(4,/+2 ,57, 0.7'/,8 72B

0(',7/2,8; 74 1(.. 74 0+5('(20( 72B 0'(B/A/./,8; )/E5, 7.4+ A( 705/(K(B A8 )+B/D8/2E*5/)(. 72B +K(''%./2E *57)A('4 72B *++&('" #%'(.8; @%/,( 7&7', D'+) 5/4 4,'+2EB/47E'(()(2, +2 ,5( )('/,4; 5( 1+%.B ,7G( K(5()(2, (R0(&,/+2 ,+ 728 4%05 07K7./(','(7,)(2, +D ,5/4 *+%',34 B(0/4/+24"

MD 0+%'4(; /, 1+%.B A( 2+24(24( ,+ &'(,(2B ,57, +%' B(0/4/+2 ,+B78 '(B%0(4 I+%',5L)(2B)(2, .71 ,+ 0+)&.(,( +'B(' 72B 57')+28" J5( B(0/4/+24 +D ,5( *+%', +K(' ,5(8(7'4 &+/2, /2 B/DD('/2E B/'(0,/+24 72B B/DD(' /2 ()&574/4" a+ ,'/0G +D .+E/0 1/.. )7G( ,5()7.. &('D(0,.8 0+24/4,(2," d%, /, /4 2+ .(44 2+24(24( ,+ 4%EE(4,; 74 B+(4 _c" 6!#JC*]bTCJ]; &+4,; 7, Z9


20/23

I(A'%7'8 9; ?; 15/.( 5( 174 A(/2E /2,(''+E7,(B 7, ,5( &+./0( 4,7,/+2; ,5(8 (2E7E(B /27 4(7'05 72B 4(/V%'( K/+.7,/K( +D ,5( *+24,/,%,/+2" C2 +'B(' ,+ [?YX !"#" ??X;?:Z\ %2B('4,72B ,5/4 0+2,(2,/+2; /, /4 2(0(447'8 ,+ '(K/(1 /2 4+)( B(,7/. ,5(0/'0%)4,720(4 +D ,5( I(A'%7'8 9 (&/4+B("

.J5( ./(HB(,(0,+' ,(4, 7B)/2/4,('(B ,+ *++./BE( /2 *+20+'B +2 ,5( 7D,('2++2 +D ,5( 9B174 /20+20.%4/K( 74 ,+ 5/4 70,/K/,/(4 +2 ,5( 2/E5, +D -7)(.7 _74+234 B/47&&(7'720(; A%,B%'/2E ,5( 0+%'4( +D ,5( ,(4, *++./BE( 0+2D(44(B ,+ 4,(7./2E lX^Z D'+) 5/4 ()&.+8('"LD,(' ,5( E'+%& '(,%'2(B D'+) *+20+'B ,+ _7205(4,('; ,5( /2,(''+E7,/+2 7A+%,*++./BE(34 )+K()(2,4 +2 ,5( 2/E5, +D ,5( B/47&&(7'720( 0+2,/2%(B; 72B *++./BE(7&&7'(2,.8 )7B( 7 2%)A(' +D 4,7,()(2,4 15/05 ,5( &+./0( /))(B/7,(.8 05(0G(B +%, 74A(4, ,5(8 0+%.B" J5( B(0/4/+2 ,+ 4(2B ,1+ +DD/0('4 ,+ ,5( *++./BE( 5+%4( ,+ 4&(7G 1/,5_'4" *++./BE( 174 7&&7'(2,.8 )+,/K7,(B /2 &7', A8 7 B(4/'( ,+ 05(0G 5/4 4,+'8 7E7/24,157,(K(' 45( )/E5, 478; 72B /2 &7', A8 ,5( 2((B D+' 4+)( 0+''+A+'7,/+2 +D 5/4

7B)/44/+2 ,+ ,5( ,5(D, D'+) 5/4 ()&.+8('" J5( ,'/7. Q%BE( D+%2B 74 7 D70,; 72B ,5( '(0+'B4%&&+',4 5/); ,57, 7, ,5( ,/)( +D ,5( K/4/, ,5( &+./0( G2(1 K('8 ./,,.( 7A+%, ,5( 1(7&+2,57, 57B G/..(B -7)(.7 _74+2" J5( A%..(, ,57, 57B A((2 '(,'/(K(B 174 +D 4)7.. 07./A(';A%, ,5( &+./0( 1('( %24%'( 15(,5(' ,5( 1(7&+2 174 7 '/D.( +' 7 &/4,+." `%'/2E ,5((R,(24/K( /2K(4,/E7,/+2 D+..+1/2E ,5( B/40+K('8 +D ,5( A+B8; ,5( &+./0( 57B )7B( /, 7&'70,/0( ,+ 74G 7.. ,5+4( @%(4,/+2(B 15(,5(' ,5(8 +12(B 728 E%24; 72B ,+ 74G ,5(+12('4 D+' &(')/44/+2 ,+ '%2 ,(4,4 +2 ,5+4( ,57, )(, ,5( K('8 E(2('7. B(40'/&,/+2 +D ,5()%'B(' 1(7&+2" J5( ,'/7. Q%BE( D+%2B 74 7 D70, ,57, 15(2 ,5( &+./0( K/4/,(B _'4"*++./BE( +2 ,5( 2/E5, +D ,5( 9B; ,5(8 1('( %2717'( +D ,5( &'(K/+%4 K/4/, B%'/2E 15/05*++./BE( 57B 45+12 +,5(' +DD/0('4 ,5'(( E%24; 72B ,57, ,5(8 1('( 2+, )+,/K7,(B A8 7B(4/'( ,+ D/2B ,5( )%'B(' 1(7&+2" [?YX !"#" ??X; ?:>\

J5( ,1+ &.7/20.+,5(4)(2 74G(B _'4" *++./BE( 15(,5(' 5(' 5%4A72B 57B A((2 7, 5+)(+2 ,5( 2/E5, +D ,5( )%'B(' K/0,/)34 B/47&&(7'720(; 72B 45( '(&./(B ,57, 5( 57B 2+,"J5(8 ,5(2 74G(B 5(' /D 5(' 5%4A72B +12(B 728 E%24" L00+'B/2E ,+ 5(' ,(4,/)+28 7, ,5(&'(,'/7. 4%&&'(44/+2 5(7'/2E; 45( '(&./(B; Wi(4; C 1/.. E(, ,5() /2 ,5( A(B'++)"W M2( +D,5( +DD/0('4 '(&./(B; Wb( 1/.. 0+)( 1/,5 8+%"W J5( ,5'(( 1(2, /2,+ ,5( A(B'++) 15('(_'4" *++./BE( ,++G 7.. D+%' E%24 +%, +D ,5( 0.+4(," T(' 700+%2, 0+2,/2%(BU

WL" C A(./(K( C 74G(B /D ,5(8 172,(B ,5( E%24" M2( E(2,.()72 47/B; ha+3F ,5(2 ,5( +,5('E(2,.()72 ,%'2(B 7'+%2B 72B 47/B; hb( )/E5, 74 1(.. ,7G( ,5()"3 C 47/B; hCD 8+% 1+%.B./G( ,5(); 8+% )78 ,7G( ,5()"3

Wk" `/B 8+% E+ D%',5(' 72B 478; hb( 57K( 2+,5/2E ,+ 5/B("3j

WL" C 0723, '(07.. /D C 47/B ,57, ,5(2 +' A(D+'(" C B+23, '(07.."

Wk" d%, 7, 4+)( ,/)( 8+% /2B/07,(B ,+ ,5() ,57, 74 D7' 74 8+% 1('( 0+20('2(B 8+% 57B2+,5/2E ,+ 5/B(; 72B ,5(8 )/E5, ,7G( 157, ,5(8 172,(Bj


21/23

WL" J57, 174 /,"

" " " " "

Wk" `/B 8+% D((. 7, ,57, ,/)( ,57, 8+% 57B 4+)(,5/2E ,+ 5/B(j

WL" a+"W

J5( ,1+ &+./0()(2 7.4+ 74G(B _'4" *++./BE( 157, 5(' 5%4A72B 57B A((2 1(7'/2E +2,5( 2/E5, +D ,5( B/47&&(7'720(" #5( ,5(2 &'+B%0(B D+%' &7/'4 +D ,'+%4('4 72B /2B/07,(B,57, 5(' 5%4A72B 57B &'+A7A.8 1+'2 (/,5(' +D ,1+ +D ,5() +2 ,57, (K(2/2E" #5( 7.4+A'+%E5, +%, 7 5%2,/2E Q70G(," J5( &+./0( E7K( 5(' 7 '(0(/&, D+' ,5( E%24 72B ,5( 0.+,5/2E;72B; 7D,(' 7 4(7'05 +D ,5( *++./BE( 07'4 2+, 5('( /2 /44%(; ,++G ,5( K7'/+%4 7',/0.(4 ,+ ,5(&+./0( 4,7,/+2" [?YX !"#" ??X; ?:^\

L

J5( D/'4, A'7205 +D ,5( &(,/,/+2('34 7'E%)(2, /4 ,57, 15(2 _'4" *++./BE( A'+%E5, +%, ,5(E%24 72B 0.+,5/2E; 72B ,5(2 572B(B ,5() +K(' ,+ ,5( &+./0(; 45( 174 70,/2E 74 72W/24,'%)(2,W +D ,5( +DD/0/7.4; 0+)&.8/2E 1/,5 7 WB()72BW )7B( A8 ,5()" *+24(@%(2,.8;/, /4 7'E%(B; *++./BE( 174 ,5( K/0,/) +D 7 4(7'05 72B 4(/V%'( 1/,5/2 ,5( 0+24,/,%,/+27.)(72/2E +D ,5+4( ,(')4" #/20( 1( 0722+, 700(&, ,5/4 /2,('&'(,7,/+2 +D ,5( D70,4; 1(2((B 2+, 0+24/B(' ,5( &(,/,/+2('34 D%',5(' 7'E%)(2, ,57, _'4" *++./BE( 0+%.B 2+, +' B/B2+, W17/K(W 5(' 5%4A72B34 0+24,/,%,/+27. &'+,(0,/+2 7E7/24, %2'(74+27A.( 4(7'05(4 72B4(/V%'(4"

T7B _'4" *++./BE(; 15+..8 +2 5(' +12 /2/,/7,/K(; 4+%E5, +%, 5(' 5%4A72B34 E%24 72B0.+,5/2E 72B ,5(2 ,7G(2 ,5() ,+ ,5( &+./0( 4,7,/+2 ,+ A( %4(B 74 (K/B(20( 7E7/24, 5/);

,5('( 072 A( 2+ B+%A, %2B(' (R/4,/2E .71 ,57, ,5( 7',/0.(4 1+%.B .7,(' 57K( A((27B)/44/A.( /2 (K/B(20(" *D" d%'B(7% K" _0`+1(..; 9Z> !"#" ?>Z " J5( @%(4,/+2 &'(4(2,(B5('( /4 15(,5(' ,5( 0+2B%0, +D ,5( &+./0( +DD/0('4 7, ,5( *++./BE( 5+%4( 174 4%05 74 ,+)7G( 5(' 70,/+24 ,5(/' 70,/+24 D+' &%'&+4(4 +D ,5( I+%',5 72B I+%',((2,5 L)(2B)(2,472B ,5(/' 7,,(2B72, (R0.%4/+27'8 '%.(4" J5( ,(4,; 74 ,5( &(,/,/+2('34 7'E%)(2, 4%EE(4,4;/4 15(,5(' _'4" *++./BE(; /2 ./E5, +D 7.. ,5( 0/'0%)4,720(4 +D ,5( 074(; )%4, A( '(E7'B(B74 57K/2E 70,(B 74 72 W/24,'%)(2,W +' 7E(2, +D ,5( 4,7,( 15(2 45( &'+B%0(B 5('5%4A72B34 A(.+2E/2E4" *D" !2/,(B #,7,(4 K" N+.BA('E; XXY I"9B XY O*LXP; 0('," B(2/(B; X^^!"#" =ZX O?PF -(+&.( K" J7'72,/2+; ?Z *7." 9B Z=Y; 9=Y -"9B ZYZ O


22/23

,7'E(, /4 +DD/0/7. )/40+2B%0," J5(8 7'( W,+ 0+)&(. '(4&(0, D+' ,5( 0+24,/,%,/+27. E%7'72,8/2 ,5( +2.8 (DD(0,/K(.8 7K7/.7A.( 178 H A8 '()+K/2E ,5( /20(2,/K( ,+ B/4'(E7'B /,"W ].G/24 K"!2/,(B #,7,(4; X>? !"#" 9Y>; 9


23/23

7E7/24, [?YX !"#" ??X; ?=Y\ ,5( 7BK('4( 0+24(@%(20(4 +D 7 4&+2,72(+%4; E++BHD7/,5(DD+', A8 5/4 1/D( ,+ 0.(7' 5/) +D 4%4&/0/+2" X=

=MD NCEBODHP KQ AD)DAQDE GHE PMD JGQD KQ ADOGHEDE P? PMD 1CRADOD !?CAP ?S +-GORQMKAD S?A SCAPMDA RA?JDDEKHBQ H?P KHJ?HQKQPDHP TKPM PMKQ ?RKHK?H*

$P KQ Q? ?AEDADE*

coolidge vs new hampshire

Documents