computational journalism at columbia, fall 2013, lecture 9: drawing conclusions from data

8/14/2019 Computational Journalism at Columbia, Fall 2013, Lecture 9: Drawing Conclusions from Data

1/71

!"#$%&"' #)

*#+,-./%#$/0 1#-"$/02'+

*#0-+32/ 1#-"$/02'+ 456##0

7&&8 9: ;"/


2/71

F&5.-"& 9: ;"/


3/71

;/./ I#&'$M. ',&/8 )#" 2.'&0)


4/71

G$.&","&%$= ;/./

;/./ N *#$.&O. PQ R&/$2$=


5/71

G+,#"./$. $#.&

S6&"& +/T 3& +#"& .6/$ #$& I&)&$'230&

2$.&","&./%#$ #) / I/./ '&.U

V-" =#/0 2$ .62' 50/'' 2' .# "-0& #-. !"#$%$"&!'($

2$.&","&./%#$'U


6/71

W#- '&& / '.#"T 2$ .6& I/./G' 2. "&/00T .6&"&X


7/71

76T


8/71

[#<


9/71

G$.&$%#$/0 #" -$2$.&$%#$/0 ,"#30&+'


10/71

76/.

I#&'$M. /

S


11/71

>W*

,#,-0/%#$

5#0#"&I 3T

2$5#+&


12/71

G$.&"?2&< .6& ;/./

76&"& I# .6&'& $-+3&"' 5#+& )"#+X 76# "&5#"I&I .6&+X [#


13/71

_I?&$.-"&' 2$ !2&0I ;&J$2%#$'

BCC` L0&5%#$A 2$ !0#"2I/A "&5#-$.&I 3T R/Y 7/2.& 2$ )*"#(!"+-*.* *'/0. 1*2$ *"# 3.4"!2!.56

S6&"&


14/71

F&5.-"& 9: ;"/


15/71

76/. './.' 8$#


16/71

76256 #$& 2' "/$I#+X


17/71

V$& './" ,&" 3#O e $#. "/$I#+


18/71


19/71


20/71

76/.M' .6& ,"#3/3202.T #) "#002$= / @X

fg@h P Di@

_0'#: fgDh P Di@A fgBh P Di@A fgEh P Di@A fg`h P Di@A fgjh P Di@


21/71

G' .62' I2& 0#/I&IX


22/71


23/71


24/71


25/71

_"& .6&'& .


26/71

S


27/71


28/71

S


29/71

G' '#+&.62$= 5/-'2$= 5/$5&"X

*/$5&" "/.& ,&" 5#-$.TU ;/"8&" P ="&/.&" 2$52I&$5& #) 5/$5&"U


30/71

76256 #) .6&'& 2' "&/0 I/./X


31/71

l0#3/0 .&+,&"/.-"& "&5#"I

[#< 028&0T 2' 2. .6/. .6& .&+,&"/.-"& 7/"8.2$5"&/'& #?&" $&O. I&5/I&X


32/71

!"#+ 94$ :!+"*( *"# .4$ ;/!&$A >/.& 420?&"


33/71

G. 2' 5#$5&2?/30& .6/. .6& D` &0I&"0T ,,0&


34/71

_''-+2$= .6/. /3#-. `C ,&"5&$. #) &0I&"0T _+&"25/$'


35/71

S6& ,"#3/3202%&' #) ,#002$=

G) H#+$&T 2' .


36/71

l2?&$:

H P `9rA VP`ar

RVLgHh P RVLgVh P sjUjr

[#< 028&0T 2' 2. .6/. V3/+/ 2' /5.-/00T /6&/IX

F&. ; P HdV P BrU S62' 2' /$ #3'&"?&I ?/0-&A /$I 2)


37/71

4.IU I&? #) ; u RVLg;hiDU9@ /' RVL 2' \-#.&I /' 9jr 5#$JI&$5& 2$.&"?/0

P sjUjrU

wd'5#"& #) d; P dBrijUjr P dCUE@

fgZtdCUEjh P CUE@A '# E@r 56/$5& / H#+$&T 2' $#. /6&/IA #" /3#-. D 2$ EU

fgV3/+/ /6&/Ih fgH#+$&T /6&/Ih


38/71

H/$I#+ [/,,&$'

xv$028&0T .# 6/,,&$ 3T 56/$5&x 2' #$0T / =##I

/"=-+&$. 2) T#-M?& &'%+/.&I .6& 56/$5&U

_0'#: /B*>C20(*> 5#2$52I&$5& +/T 3& "/"&A 3-. &/@$5#2$52I&$5& '#+&


39/71

F&5.-"& 9: ;"/


40/71

K&02&)

x76/. T#- 3&02&?&x #" x


41/71

K&02&):

,"#3/3202.T I2'."23-%#$ #?&" 6T,#.6&'&'

LU=U G' .6& >Wf; ./"=&%$= +#'\-&' )#" '.#,d/$Id)"2'8X

D

C

[C [D [B

>&?&" H#-%$&0TV$5& #" .


42/71

L?2I&$5&

G$)#"+/%#$ .6/. z-'%J&' / 3&02&)U

f"&'&$.&I


43/71

4."&$=.6 #) L?2I&$5&

G' 5#-=62$= '."#$= #"


44/71

;#$M. "&?&"'& ,"#3/3202%&'}

G$ =&$&"/0 fg_|Kh ~ fgK|_h

fg5#-=62$=|5#0Ih u CU9

fg5#0I|5#-=62$=h u CUE

K/T&'M .6"&+ =2?&' .6& "&0/%#$'62,

fg_|Kh P fgK|_h fg_h i fgKh


45/71

-/$%J&I '-,,#". )#" 6T,#.6&'&'

[#< 028&0T 2' / 6T,#.6&'2' [A =2?&$ &?2I&$5& LX

V"A


46/71

K/T&' .6"&+:

0&/"$2$= )"#+ &?2I&$5&

f"g[|Lh P f"gL|[h f"g[h i f"gLh

#"

fg[|Lh P f"gL|[hif"gLh y f"g[h

!"#$%"&''(

[#< 028&0T 2' [

=2?&$ &?2I&$5& LX

*+"'+

[#< 028&0T


47/71

_025& 2' 5#-=62$=U ;#&' '6& 6/?& / 5#0IX

[T,#.6&'2' [ P _025& 6/' / 5#0I

L?2I&$5& L P


48/71

_025& 2' 5#-=62$=U ;#&' '6& 6/?& / 5#0IX

[T,#.6&'2' [ P _025& 6/' / 5#0I

L?2I&$5& L P


49/71

_025& 2' 5#-=62$=U ;#&' '6& 6/?& / 5#0IX

fg[|Lh P fgL|[hfg[hifgLh

P CU9 y CUCj i CUD

P CU`j

G) T#- 3&02&?& T#-" 2$2%/0 ,"#3/3202.T &'%+/.&'A T#-

'6#-0I $#< 3&02&?& .6&"&M' / `jr 56/$5& '6& 6/' /

5#0IU


50/71

K2/'

_ &5&.$@*C2.&$I&$5T .# ,"#I-5& /$ 2$5#""&5.

/$'


51/71

*#=$2%?& 32/'&'

_?/20/3202.T 6&-"2'%5:


52/71

*#$J"+/%#$ 32/'

*#+&' 2$ +/$T )#"+'U

UUU-$5#$'52#-'0T J0.&"2$= 2$)#"+/%#$ .6/. I#&'$M. J.

&O,&5./%#$'U

UUU$#. 0##82$= )#" 5#$."/"T 2$)#"+/%#$U

UUU$#. 2+/=2$2$= .6& /0.&"$/%?&'U


53/71

S6& .62$= /3#-. &?2I&$5&UUU

_' .6& /+#-$. #) 2$)#"+/%#$ 2$5"&/'&'A 2. =&.'

+#"& 028&0T .6/. '#+& 2$)#"+/%#$ '#+&


54/71

R&.6#I #) 5#+,&%$= 6T,#.6&'&'

4./". gH&+&+3&"A 2) T#- 5/$M. 2+/=2$& 2.A T#- 5/$M. 5#$50-I& 2.}h

l# 0##82$= )#" 2$)#"+/%#$ .6/. =2?&' T#- .6& 3&'./3202.T .# ("01+"2"345$3&.


55/71


56/71

_ =##I +#I&0 6/' / .6"T #) .6&


57/71

F&5.-"& 9: ;"/


58/71

76 . 2 x % xX


59/71

76/. 2' x5/-'/%#$xX

W

{

#3'&"?/30& .62$=

.62$= 2$ .6&


60/71


61/71


62/71

l I J 6 2 2I X


63/71

l-$' /$I J"&/"+ 6#+252I&'X

W{

2) T#- 6/?& / =-$A T#-M"& =#2$= .# -'& 2.

W{

2) 2.M' / I/$=&"#-' $&2=63#"6##IA T#-M00 3-T / =-$

W{

.6& 5#""&0/%#$ 2' I-& .# 56/$5&


64/71

K&/-.T /$I "&',#$'&'


65/71

K&/-.T /$I "&',#$'&'

W{

.&002$= /


66/71

,

2$.&"?&$& 2$ / $&.


67/71

,,0& .# '6/"& 02$8'X


68/71

_ I2m5-0. &O/+,0&

>Wf; ,&")#"+' @CCACCC '."&&. '.#, /$I )"2'8'

,&" T&/"U

76/. '#".' #) 5#$50-'2#$' 5#-0I


69/71


70/71

4.#, /$I !"2'8 */-'/%#$


71/71

4.#, /$I !"2'8 */-'/%#$

4-,,#'& T#- ./8& .6& /II"&'' #) &?&"T +#'\-&

2$ >W*A /$I I2'5#?&" .6/. .6&"& /"& Djr +#"&

'.#,d/$Id)"2'8'

computational journalism at columbia, fall 2013, lecture 9: drawing conclusions from data

Documents