complex systems, simple solutions? operationalizing diversity to understand technology adoption

1
Complex systems, simple solutions? Operationalizing diversity to understand technology adoption Utility A better understanding of farm and farmer diversity allows efficient targeting and a nuanced impact assessment of technologies (technical) and techniques (managerial). Introduction For Africa RISING (AR) we conducted an evaluation of the AR technology packages per farm type and per region. Farming systems are diverse and so are their pathways towards sustainable intensification. This document is licensed for use under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License November 2016 Who is the legacy product useful for? The approach is useful for development projects and businesses that want to test or promote new technologies or techniques among smallholder farmers. It also is a crucial element for successful upscaling. Results and outputs Key contacts Mirja Michalscheck; [email protected] Dr. ir. Jeroen Groot; [email protected] How does it work? Low Resource Endowed High Resource Endowed Intra-household differences: “Ask the male household head, his wife and the oldest son or daughter. They are like the three stones under a fire.” (social fundament) Model Result: Solution Cloud Model Result: Solution Cloud Modelled impact of individual packages Modelled impact of individual packages Evaluation by HH members A graphical impression A graphical impression 3. Personal evaluation of technology packages 1. Typologies 2. Impact assessment and exploration with whole-farm model Farm DESIGN AR intervention sites: Ghana Differentiate: Technologies vs. Techniques Inter and intra-household diversity e.g. What makes a package expensive ? Is it the extra labour for row planting? The improved seeds? The additional sprays? Farming Systems Ecology Group (WUR) Mirja Nitrogen flows (kg/ha) Statistical approach

Upload: africa-rising

Post on 14-Apr-2017

171 views

Category:

Science


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Complex systems, simple solutions? Operationalizing diversity to understand technology adoption

Complex systems, simple solutions?

Operationalizing diversity to understand technology adoption

UtilityA better understanding of farm and farmer diversity allows efficient targeting and a nuanced impact assessment of technologies (technical) and techniques (managerial).

Introduction

For Africa RISING (AR) we conducted an evaluation of the AR technology packages per farm type and per region. Farming systems are diverse and so are their pathways towards sustainable intensification.

This document is licensed for use under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International LicenseNovember 2016

Who is the legacy product useful for?

The approach is useful for development projects and businesses that

want to test or promote new technologies or techniques among

smallholder farmers. It also is a crucial element for successful

upscaling.

Results and outputs

Key contacts

Mirja Michalscheck; [email protected]. ir. Jeroen Groot; [email protected]

How does it work?

Low Resource Endowed High Resource Endowed

Intra-household differences: “Ask the male household head, his wife and the oldest son or daughter. They are like the three stones under a fire.” (social fundament)

Model Result: Solution Cloud

Model Result: Solution Cloud

Modelled impact of individual packages

Modelled impact of individual packages

Evaluation by HH members

A graphical impressionA graphical impression

3. Personal evaluation of technology packages

1. Typologies

2. Impact assessment and exploration with whole-farm model Farm DESIGN

AR intervention sites: Ghana

Differentiate: Technologies vs. Techniques

Inter and intra-household diversity

e.g.What makes a package expensive ?Is it the extra labour for row planting?The improved seeds? The additional sprays?

Farming Systems Ecology Group (WUR)

Mirja

Nitrogen flows (kg/ha)

Statistical approach