complaint to tga: the ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......complaint to tga: the ongoing and...

54
Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 1 of 10 I submit that this is a "high priority" complaint because the sponsors (&/or other advertisers) are recalcitrant, this class of products have had numerous upheld complaints and the sponsors (&/or others) continue to make claims that I allege breach the Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code 2017. This clearly impacts on consumers ability to appropriately use these goods. Background Ear candling is a widely promoted alternative medical practice that involves inserting and lighting a hollow candle in the ear canal. There are at least 15 ear candles currently included on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Products (ARTG) as “other” therapeutic goods. 1 There are also seven Class I medical device entries in the ARTG that appear to be ear candles. 2 As with listed medicines, there is no pre-market evaluation by the TGA of these goods. In theory, the listing application process for ear candles should ensure that the presentation, claims and labelling for these products are appropriate and that the product is safe. In practice, sponsors can, and do, say whatever they like in their promotion and on the ARTG public summary document. The only check is the complaint system and rare post-marketing reviews by the TGA. There have been at least 20 complaints about ear candles upheld by the TGACRP on various grounds, such as claims that candling removes wax (which it does not) and statements that the product has “TGA approval” (which is not allowed). 3 It is also claimed (without evidence) that candling may assist with tinnitus (ringing in the ears), headaches, sinusitis, swimmers ear, migraines, glue ear and bacterial infections such as tonsillitis (see screen shots below). In fact, ear candles (and candling) are ineffective and dangerous. They do not remove wax from the ear and have caused injury from burns, ear canal occlusions, ear drum perforations and secondary ear canal infections with temporary hearing loss. 4,5 Neither the promotion of these products, nor their ARTG Public Summary documents point out these dangers. Given the lack of effective sanctions against upheld complaints more definitive regulatory action has been requested. The U.S. FDA and Health Canada have acted against manufacturers of ear candles by providing public warnings, import alerts, seizures, injunctions, and warning letters. 6 A recent TGA consultation asked for submissions on options for reform. 2 Nine of 451 public submissions discussed ear candles (the rest were mainly concerned about homeopathy). These submissions can be found in appendix I. Option 1 (continue to be regulated as Therapeutic Goods by TGA) was supported by 5 bodies: NICM, FSM (Harvey), ASMI, ATMS and the ACCC (but with caveats). Option 3 (excluded from Therapeutic Goods framework) was supported by 4 bodies: PSA, MTAA, Australian Skeptics, Victorian Skeptics. 1 http://tga-search.clients.funnelback.com/s/search.html?query=candles&collection=tga-artg 2 https://tga.gov.au/consultation/consultation-options-future-regulation-low-risk-products 3 http://www.tgacrp.com.au/complaint-register/?_search=ear%20candles 4 http://www.audiology.org/news/ear-candles-and-candling-ineffective-and-dangerous 5 https://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/candling.html 6 https://www.fda.gov/forconsumers/consumerupdates/ucm200277.htm

Upload: others

Post on 21-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 1 of 10

I submit that this is a "high priority" complaint because the sponsors (&/or other advertisers) are

recalcitrant, this class of products have had numerous upheld complaints and the sponsors (&/or

others) continue to make claims that I allege breach the Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code

2017. This clearly impacts on consumers ability to appropriately use these goods.

Background

Ear candling is a widely promoted alternative medical practice that involves inserting and lighting a

hollow candle in the ear canal. There are at least 15 ear candles currently included on the Australian

Register of Therapeutic Products (ARTG) as “other” therapeutic goods.1 There are also seven Class I

medical device entries in the ARTG that appear to be ear candles.2

As with listed medicines, there is no pre-market evaluation by the TGA of these goods. In theory, the

listing application process for ear candles should ensure that the presentation, claims and labelling

for these products are appropriate and that the product is safe.

In practice, sponsors can, and do, say whatever they like in their promotion and on the ARTG public

summary document. The only check is the complaint system and rare post-marketing reviews by the

TGA.

There have been at least 20 complaints about ear candles upheld by the TGACRP on various grounds,

such as claims that candling removes wax (which it does not) and statements that the product has

“TGA approval” (which is not allowed).3 It is also claimed (without evidence) that candling may assist

with tinnitus (ringing in the ears), headaches, sinusitis, swimmers ear, migraines, glue ear and

bacterial infections such as tonsillitis (see screen shots below).

In fact, ear candles (and candling) are ineffective and dangerous. They do not remove wax from the

ear and have caused injury from burns, ear canal occlusions, ear drum perforations and secondary

ear canal infections with temporary hearing loss.4,5

Neither the promotion of these products, nor their ARTG Public Summary documents point out

these dangers.

Given the lack of effective sanctions against upheld complaints more definitive regulatory action has

been requested. The U.S. FDA and Health Canada have acted against manufacturers of ear candles

by providing public warnings, import alerts, seizures, injunctions, and warning letters.6

A recent TGA consultation asked for submissions on options for reform.2 Nine of 451 public

submissions discussed ear candles (the rest were mainly concerned about homeopathy). These

submissions can be found in appendix I.

• Option 1 (continue to be regulated as Therapeutic Goods by TGA) was supported by 5

bodies: NICM, FSM (Harvey), ASMI, ATMS and the ACCC (but with caveats).

• Option 3 (excluded from Therapeutic Goods framework) was supported by 4 bodies: PSA,

MTAA, Australian Skeptics, Victorian Skeptics.

1 http://tga-search.clients.funnelback.com/s/search.html?query=candles&collection=tga-artg 2 https://tga.gov.au/consultation/consultation-options-future-regulation-low-risk-products 3 http://www.tgacrp.com.au/complaint-register/?_search=ear%20candles 4 http://www.audiology.org/news/ear-candles-and-candling-ineffective-and-dangerous 5 https://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/candling.html 6 https://www.fda.gov/forconsumers/consumerupdates/ucm200277.htm

Page 2: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 2 of 10

Regardless, on 21 June 2018, without providing any analysis of these submissions, or giving any

reason for its decision, the TGA / Government decided that ear candles will be excluded from the

Therapeutic Goods framework. Friends of Science in Medicine (FSM) has written to Minister Hunt

concerned about the decision-making that led to this result and the impact on consumer safety.

I can find no evidence that ear candles, as yet, have been added to the Therapeutic Goods (Excluded

Goods) Order No 1 of 2011.7 Meanwhile, misleading and deceptive promotion of these potentially

dangerous goods continues, as does similar misleading statements on ARTG Public Summary

Documents. The following is a representative sample.

I allege that the following promotion breaches the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989, s.41ML and the

Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code 2015, s.4(1)(b), 4(2)(a), 4(2)(b), 4(2)(c), 4(2)(d), 4(2)(i), 4(7) &

5(2). In addition, the failure of the TGA to act on this matter has encouraged many natural therapists

to repeat these misleading and deceptive claims and offer this discredited therapy to the potential

detriment of their customers (appendix II).

The promotion

1. https://www.chemistwarehouse.com.au/buy/60465/Bio-Sun-Ear-Candles-1-Pair

ARTG 197479 Biosun In Australia Pty Ltd Applicator, ear, single use. Medical Device Class 1. Intended purpose: Intended to be used to promote relaxation and a feeling of wellbeing, when lit, warmth travels down it to the ear, providing a relaxing sensation, aiding wellness and also assisting in cleansing the ear of wax and impurities.

7 https://tga.gov.au/excluded-goods-orders

Page 3: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 3 of 10

2. https://www.buyorganicsonline.com.au/ear-candles/

ARTG: 137617 Graeme Leishman T/A Byron Bay Ear Candles - Byron Bay Ear Candles - Applicator,

ear, single use. Other Therapeutic Good. The intended purpose for using the ear candles is for

general relaxation and a feeling of wellbeing.

Page 4: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 4 of 10

ARTG: 159195 Honeycone Naturals, Honeycone Ear Candles - Applicator, ear, single use. Other

Therapeutic Good. Intended purpose to support general well-being and relaxation.

The “Happy ears” candles advertised are not on the ARTG. These are also promoted at:

3. http://www.itzallgoodfood.com.au/happy-ears-ear-candles-100-natural-cone-2-pack/

4. https://australianorganicproducts.com.au/products/wise-ears-2-ear-candles-100-natural

Page 5: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 5 of 10

Not found on ARTG.

5. http://audacioushealth.com.au/Products.html

ARTG 197479 Biosun In Australia Pty Ltd Applicator, ear, single use. Medical Device Class 1. Intended purpose: Intended to be used to promote relaxation and a feeling of wellbeing, when lit,

Page 6: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 6 of 10

warmth travels down it to the ear, providing a relaxing sensation, aiding wellness and also assisting in cleansing the ear of wax and impurities.

6. https://naturalcity.com.au/prod-hopi-ear-candles-6-candles-by-biosun-22061.aspx

ARTG 197479 Biosun In Australia Pty Ltd Applicator, ear, single use. Medical Device Class 1. Intended purpose: Intended to be used to promote relaxation and a feeling of wellbeing, when lit, warmth travels down it to the ear, providing a relaxing sensation, aiding wellness and also assisting in cleansing the ear of wax and impurities.

Page 7: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 7 of 10

7. https://www.luvinlife.com.au/ear-candles

Luvin Life Ear Candles are not on the ARTG.

8. http://www.thecuthut.com.au/wholesale/beauty/tools-disposables/ear-candles

These ear candles are also not on the ARTG.

Page 8: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 8 of 10

9. https://www.naturalcandleshop.com.au/products/ear-candles

These ear candles were not found on the ARTG.

10. http://www.shiatsuman.com/ear_candles.html

11. https://aperfectblend.com.au/our-therapies/ear-candling/

These ear candles were not found on the ARTG.

Page 9: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 9 of 10

12. http://wisdomforlivingcentre.com.au/shop/ear-candles-three-pack/

Page 10: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles

Page 10 of 10

I insist on an immediate response to me as to the priority allocated to this complaint, the

measures taken by the TGA to achieve compliance and the final outcome.

Sincerely, Ken --- Dr Ken Harvey MBBS, FRCPA, AM Associate Professor Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine

School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine

Monash University Alfred Campus 553 St Kilda Rd Melbourne VIC 3004 Mobile: +61 419181910 Email: [email protected] WWW: www.medreach.com.au 5 January 2019

Page 11: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Appendix I - TGA Consultation: Options for the future regulation of 'low risk'

products: Public Submission on Ear Candles

Summary

Only nine of 451 public submissions mentioned ear candles (the rest were mainly concerned about

homeopathy).

• Option 1 (continue to be regulated as Therapeutic Goods by TGA) was supported by 5

bodies: NICM, FSM (Harvey), ASMI, ATMS, ACCC.

• Option 3 (excluded from Therapeutic Goods framework) was supported by 4 bodies: PSA,

MTAA, Australian Skeptics, Victorian Skeptics

Regardless, the government decided that ear candles will be excluded from the Therapeutic Goods

framework (handballed to the ACCC).

The details follow:

1. Pharmaceutical Society of Australia. The PSA believes ear candles should be removed from

the therapeutic goods regulatory framework (Option 3). Given the lack of evidence of

therapeutic benefit and the potential to cause serious injury (and actual reports of injury)

these products should not be making therapeutic claims and should be removed from

consideration as therapeutic goods.

2. The National Institute of Complementary Medicine. NICM recommends Ear Candles

continue to be regulated by the TGA as “Other Therapeutic Goods” (Option 1 – Maintain the

status quo regulation). However, NICM further recommends that the TGA formally review

ear candles to assess if they should continue to maintain low risk status.

It appears the scientific evidence suggests that ear candles do not work; that the residue left

after burning which is used as evidence of effectiveness is in fact an artefact; and that the

use of ear candles is associated with the potential for harm.

On this basis, Health Canada recommends to Canadians they avoid ear candling considering

it dangerous and without proven medical benefits. It regulates ear candles as a medical

device and has not issued any licences. They state that selling ear candles for medical

reasons in Canada is illegal; and both Canada and the United States have banned the

importing of ear candles.

NICM recommends that the low risk status of ear candles be reviewed.

3. Medical Technology Association of Australia. MTAA noted ear candles are currently

included in the ARTG as Class I medical devices. In a recent BBC program, ENT surgeon Dr

Gabriel Weston stated: “Research has shown that not only is ear candling ineffective at

removing earwax, but it can be dangerous. It can burn the face and ear, it can leave wax in

the canal, and it can also puncture the ear drum.” (Dr Gabriel Weston, 2017).

The MTAA does not support the inclusion in the ARTG of substandard products that could be

supplied to consumers with inappropriate therapeutic representations.

Therefore, we recommend Option 3 – Exclude ear candles from the regulatory framework

(this approach is aligned with US and Canada; both countries have banned the importation

of ear candles). This will result in ear candles no longer being considered therapeutic goods

and removing the perceived ‘approved by the TGA’ legitimising of ear candles.

Ear candles would hence be regulated as consumer goods under the jurisdiction of ACCC.

Page 12: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Appendix I - TGA Consultation: Options for the future regulation of 'low risk'

products: Public Submission on Ear Candles

4. Friends of Science in Medicine (Harvey, et al.) Noted ear candling is an alternative medical

practice (often practiced by naturopaths) that involves inserting and lighting a hollow candle

in the ear canal. As with listed medicines, there is no pre-market evaluation by the TGA of

Class 1 medical devices.

In theory, the listing application process for ear candles should ensure that the presentation,

claims and labelling for these products are appropriate and that the product is safe. In

practice, sponsors can, and do, say whatever they like in their promotion and on the ARTG

public summary document subject. The only check is the complaint system and rare post-

marketing reviews by the TGA.

It is often claimed that ear candles remove excess wax from the ears and promote relaxation

and general wellbeing. Additional claims state that candling may assist with tinnitus (ringing

in the ears), headaches, sinusitis, swimmers ear, migraines, glue ear and bacterial infections

such as tonsillitis and that certain candles are “TGA approved”.

In fact, ear candles (and candling) are ineffective and dangerous. They do not remove wax

from the ear and have caused injury from burns, ear canal occlusions, ear drum perforations

and secondary ear canal infections with temporary hearing loss.

Neither the current promotion of these products, nor their ARTG Public Summary

documents point out these dangers. There have been at least 20 complaints about ear

candles upheld by the TGACRP on various grounds, such as claims that candling removes

wax could not be substantiated, and statement that products have “TGA approval” is not

allowed.

Given the lack of effective sanctions against upheld complaints more definitive regulatory

action has been suggested. The U.S. FDA and Health Canada have acted against

manufacturers of ear candles by providing public warnings, import alerts, seizures,

injunctions, and warning letters.

Harvey advocated:

• The TGA as a specialist regulator should retain responsibility for these listed

products (option 1) BUT ensure that a prominent warning is provided on their ARTG

Public Summary documents, product packaging, labelling and promotion, for

example, Warning: these products do NOT remove wax or other impurities from the

ear and have been associated with INJURY including burns, ear drum perforations

and ear canal infections.

• The TGA should conduct a targeted post-marketing review on these products to

ensure that the above warning is complied with.

• The TGA should provide a public warning about these products on their web site like

that provided by the U.S. FDA. The TGA should convey this warning to the

organisations listed in Schedule 1. Part 2 of the Therapeutic Goods Regulations

19906 and ask them to pass it on to all their members

5. Australian Traditional Medicine Society ATMS noted that ear candles are therapeutic

devices and should be regulated as such (option 1). No other option allows for this.

6. Australian Skeptics (Victorian Branch) Inc advocated excluding ear candles from the

regulatory framework.

Page 13: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Appendix I - TGA Consultation: Options for the future regulation of 'low risk'

products: Public Submission on Ear Candles

The claim is frequently made that ear candles can remove toxins or earwax by lowering the

pressure in the aural cavity. However, there is nothing to suggest that detritus found in the

remains of a burnt ear candle is extracted from the subject of the procedure.

As ear candles offer no therapeutic benefit, they are better regarded as a fraudulent parlour

trick than a therapeutic good. By excluding them from the regulatory framework (Option 3)

the TGA is giving a clear signal to alternative practitioners that there is no tacit endorsement

or recognition of this crypto-medical performance.

The ACCC is an ideal body to deal with dishonest advertising of them or to consider product

recalls or category wide ban on these goods owing to the dangers that they pose.

7. Australian Skeptics Inc. Ear candles have been shown to have potentially very dangerous

impacts on users, even if used as directed. These dangers include damage to the inner and

outer ear through the application or misapplication of hot wax. The US Food & Drug

Administration warns that “ear candles can cause serious injuries, even when used in

accordance to manufacturers’ directions. ‘Also,’ says Mann [Eric Mann, MD, PhD, clinical

deputy director of FDA's Division of Ophthalmic, Neurological, and Ear, Nose, and Throat

Devices], ‘FDA believes that there is no valid scientific evidence for any medical benefit from

their use.’” - https://www.fda.gov/forconsumers/consumerupdates/ucm200277.htm

Classifying ear candles as “very low risk” is a misrepresentation of the serious dangers these

products represent. The fact that these products are listed in the ARTG “with therapeutic

claims to the effect of ‘for relaxation’, ‘general wellbeing’ and ‘ear wax cleaning’” indicates

that the TGA listing for these products is ineffective and misleading.

Thus, we would recommend Option 3 – “Exclude ear candles from the regulatory

framework”.

8. Australian Self Medication Industry ASMI questioned the inclusion of ear candles in the

“very low” category. We suggest that any product that involves a naked flame in close

proximity to the head of a prone patient should at least be considered to be a “low” risk. We

also suggest that consideration needs to be given to how these products are marketed (e.g.

for chronic ear infections, glue ear, etc.) which are conditions that may require different

forms of treatment.

Option 1- Maintain the status quo regulation of ear candled is supported

Where a product is represented in any way to be for therapeutic use (or is likely to be taken

to be for therapeutic use) then the product should be on the public register (the ARTG) and

should be regulated by the TGA.

The consultation paper raises the possibility that the TGA's continued regulation of these

products could be viewed as "legitimising" them. ASMI does not support this proposition. If

the products are not legitimate then the TGA should take action against the sponsors and

advertisers.

The legitimacy or otherwise of a group of products should have no bearing on whether the

TGA (or some other agency) regulates them. If they are therapeutic goods, they are the

TGA's responsibility. If they are not legitimate goods, then the TGA has an obligation to take

action.

Page 14: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Appendix I - TGA Consultation: Options for the future regulation of 'low risk'

products: Public Submission on Ear Candles

Handing responsibility on to another agency is not an appropriate solution.

9. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission ACCC noted the advertising & claims

made for these products can be problematic and if there is a lack of enforcement then these

problems can be made worse.

The ACCC is concerned that by excluding the following “low risk” products from the TGA

regulatory framework there is an expectation that the ACCC would provide the same level of

regulatory oversight. The ACCC’s consumer protection role does not extend to assessing the

efficacy of medical treatments such as ear candling. As an agency it does not hold the

specialist knowledge required to evaluate this type of practice or associated health claim.

Option 1 implied.

Page 15: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

Friends of Science in Medicine

Images from 50+ websites making false and misleading claims for Ear Candles

(Images from practitioner websites)

Compiled July 2018

Page 16: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

2

Websites promoting Ear Candles

On-line stores ..................................................................................................................................................... 4

E-Tailer World Pty Ltd (Buy Organics Online) ................................................................................................ 4

Itz all good food - Summer Soliman-Gardner ................................................................................................ 5

Australian Organic Products + more– Peter .................................................................................................. 6

Audacious Health – Catherine Jenkins ........................................................................................................... 7

The Natural City .............................................................................................................................................. 7

Luvin Life......................................................................................................................................................... 7

Cut Price Pharmacy ........................................................................................................................................ 8

Practitioners ....................................................................................................................................................... 9

The Shiatsu Man - Klaus Rennebarth ............................................................................................................ 9

Centre of Wellbeing - Ros Wilson ............................................................................................................... 10

A Perfect Blend - Lisa McDonald ................................................................................................................. 11

Wisdom for Living – Barbara Elkins .............................................................................................................. 11

True Health – Adam Raponi & Siobhan Gilligan ........................................................................................... 12

Your Sanctuary Day Spa – Robyne Armstrong ............................................................................................. 12

Alternative Body Works - Chanette Routlege .............................................................................................. 13

Viive Skin & Body Care ................................................................................................................................. 14

ReNew Reflexology & Massage – Esther Sheppard ..................................................................................... 14

Yatan Holistic Ayurvedic Centre – Raman Das Mahatyagi ........................................................................... 15

Olive Homeopathy Healing Group – Sally Moore ........................................................................................ 16

Feeling Healthy - Rosanna Mosca & Merril Bowater ................................................................................... 16

The Wings of Angels - Adele Johnson .......................................................................................................... 17

Sage Beauty – Junia Kerr .............................................................................................................................. 18

Liebe Wellness .............................................................................................................................................. 19

Zen Chi Natural Therapy & Wellness Centre ................................................................................................ 20

Bings Natural Health - Bing Qian .................................................................................................................. 21

Tarot in Action - Ruanna Sega ...................................................................................................................... 21

K.O Beauty Zone – Enza Caio ........................................................................................................................ 22

HRT Acupuncture & Massage Centre – Hong Ren Tang .............................................................................. 23

Laurimar Health & Wellbeing Centre - Karlie Jewitt .................................................................................... 24

So Natural Reflexology – Sandy Vanrenen ................................................................................................... 25

Page 17: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

3

Sapphire Coast Wellness Centre – Trish Howard ......................................................................................... 26

Brunswick Health – Sara Canney & Josephine Cabrall ................................................................................. 27

Pam Allen Reflexology & Indian Head Massage – Pam Allen ...................................................................... 27

Mystic Universe – Sue Kelly.......................................................................................................................... 28

Capital Complementary Therapies Centre - Dennis Yu ................................................................................ 29

Gently Does It – Lyn Wood ........................................................................................................................... 30

Back in Harmony – Ross Swadling ................................................................................................................ 30

Mind & Body Health ..................................................................................................................................... 31

Absolute Wellbeing – Suzie Kerkin ............................................................................................................... 31

Wayne Massage – Wayne Zheng ................................................................................................................. 32

Chameyli Wellbeing Sanctuary - Catherine Glover ...................................................................................... 33

Aialu Massage - Anna-Linda Jelliff ................................................................................................................ 34

Natures Wisdom ........................................................................................................................................... 34

BodiBeautilicious - Jennifer Sheldon ............................................................................................................ 35

Yan Acupuncture & Massage - Ning Lu ........................................................................................................ 36

Zen Chinese Medicine .................................................................................................................................. 36

Body in Tune - Mirium Bunder ..................................................................................................................... 36

Timeless Skin Laser & Beauty Spa ................................................................................................................ 37

Happy Healing Australia ............................................................................................................................... 37

Anakien Natural Therapies – Carole Hoffin.................................................................................................. 38

Lyn Craven Corporate Health ....................................................................................................................... 38

Harmony within Health – Manuela Picinich................................................................................................. 39

The Rose Health - Maree .............................................................................................................................. 39

Page 18: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

4

On-line stores

E-Tailer World Pty Ltd (Buy Organics Online)

Address: PO Box 8506, Carrum Downs VIC 3201 Phone: 1300 360 023 Email: [email protected] https://www.buyorganicsonline.com.au/ear-candles/

Website claims:

What are ear candles? :Ear candles are a natural remedy used by those looking to clear their earcanals in a safe manner. They work by extracting ear wax and debris out of the ear canal with theassistance of smoke or a burning wick. Proponents of this method claim that the smoke creates avacuum that safely helps to remove wax and other debris from the ear.

How do ear candles work?: Many people ask how do ear candles work? Well, the treatmentmethod is quite simple and non-invasive. The treatment begins by placing a long candle into theear. The external end of the candle is then lit which results in the whole ear becoming coated inbeeswax. This creates a vacuum in the ear canal and, as the beeswax is being removed, excess earwax is drawn out with it.

The potential benefits of ear candles: As a form of alternative medicine there are both proponentsand critics of the potential benefits of ear candles as a form of treatment. With that said, those whoare advocates of the herbal and natural treatment method outline the following benefits of use:

It clears earwax build-up. Although earwax serves a purpose in protecting the inner ear fromunwanted particles, problems arise due to excess build-up. Traditional treatments such aswater pumping or the insertion of sharp implements can be invasive and uncomfortable. Usingear candles is an alternative that is free from discomfort.

Can reduce the impact of earaches. Earaches generally occur due to inflammation within theear canal. Those looking for a treatment method that does not involve the use of prescribedmedication may find that ear candling provides an effective alternative. This is because thewarmth inside the ear can ensure bacteria does not have the space to reside.

Can provide sufferers of swimmer’s ear with effective relief. When water gets trapped in theear canal, germs present in the liquid can cause an infection. This often is reported as severelyuncomfortable. When ear candles are used, the warmth provided can remove the water build-up therefore reducing the chance for germs to survive.

It can help reduce the pain experienced by tinnitus sufferers. Tinnitus is an incurable afflictionmore commonly known as that annoying ringing feeling that some members of societyexperience daily. Ear candle treatment provides temporary relief from the ringing due to theexpansion of the ear canal because of the heat provided. While it will not heal tinnitus, it willhelp provide welcomed temporary relief when applied.

Page 19: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

5

Itz all good food - Summer Soliman-Gardner

Address: 11/76 Bayview Street. Runaway Bay, QLD 4216 Phone: 0413 692 972 Email: [email protected] http://www.itzallgoodfood.com.au/happy-ears-ear-candles-100-natural-cone-2-pack/

Website claims:

Ear candling may be beneficial in cases of:

Excessive wax build up

Impaired hearing

Fungal infections

Sinus pain & irritation

Toxic residue from medication

Tinnitus,

Meniere's Syndrome

Foggy head

Poor lymphatic circulation

Migraines

Poor balance,

Vertigo

Glue ear or swim ear

Children's ear problem

Page 20: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

6

Australian Organic Products + more– Peter Address: Chealsea, VIC, 3196. Phone: (03) 8759 0380 Email: [email protected] https://australianorganicproducts.com.au/products/wise-ears-2-ear-candles-100-natural

Page 21: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

7

Audacious Health – Catherine Jenkins

Address: 72 Myla Road Landsborough Qld 4550 Phone: 0432 127 997 Email: [email protected] http://www.audacioushealth.com.au/Products.html

Website claims:

Biosun Hopi Ear Candles A “chimney-like” device that looks like a “candle”. Assists with sinus,headaches and issues with the ears eg excess ear wax, swimmers ear, tinnitus, blocked ears etc.

The Natural City

Address: Shop 45, DFO 16 Amazon Place Jindalee Qld 4074 Phone: (07) 3376 0003 Email: [email protected] https://www.naturalcity.com.au/prod-hopi-ear-candles-6-candles-by-biosun-22061.aspx

Website claims:

Biosun Earcandles are a safe choice because they contain the exclusive cross-shaped barrier whichprevents any liquid wax or excess condensate from entering the ear. This barrier is eco-friendly,being made from environmentally compatible PE. Biosun Earcandles are excellent in the treatmentof nose and throat congestion,sinusitis, headaches, T.M.J. pain, tinnitus, and otitis external/tropicalear. Ideal relaxation treatment for stress or anxiety related symptoms. Softens earwax for easyremoval.

Luvin Life

Address: 38 Kayleigh Drive, Maroochydore, QLD, 4558 Phone: (07) 5452 7546 Email: [email protected] https://www.luvinlife.com.au/ear-candles

Website claims:

Page 22: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

8

Heat produced from the candle helps to draw out excess ear wax and other debris which may be present in the ear canal.

Other benefits may include:

Relief from tinnitus (ringing in the ears)

Relieve sinus pain and pressure

Removing excess wax build up

Assisting with relieving Swimmers' ear

Relief from headaches

Relieving severely itchy ears (often caused by yeast, mould or dairy allergies)

Helping to unplug ears (often due to illness)

Cut Price Pharmacy Address: Shop 4 & 6 175-181 Oxford St, Bondi Junction, NSW, 2022 Phone: (02) 9387 7957 Email: [email protected] https://www.cutpricepharmacy.com.au/products/wise_ears___ear_candles_2s Website claims:

Ear candling may be beneficial in cases of: Excessive wax build up Impaired hearing Fungal infections Sinus pain & irritation Toxic residue from medication Tinnitus, Meniere's Syndrome Foggy head Poor lymphatic circulation Migraines Poor balance, vertigo Glue ear or swim ear Children's ear problems

Page 23: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

9

Practitioners

The Shiatsu Man - Klaus Rennebarth Address: Clinic Address 21 Morry Street, Hill End, Queensland 4101 Phone: (07) 3844 6988 Email: [email protected] http://www.shiatsuman.com/ear_candles.html

Website claims:

Under “Indications” the website states:

Irritations in the ears or sinus

Soothing effect in cases of over-irritability and stress-related symptoms

Noises in the ears (such as, for example, ringing in the ears)

Energetic revitalization in cases of hearing impairments

Pressure regulation in cases of headaches, migraines, sinusitis and rhinitis

Circulatory disturbances of the ear

Local activation of the lymph and the metabolic process

Stimulation of the energy-flow circulation

Page 24: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

10

Under “Range of Application” the website claims:

Ear candles can be used for all head ailments caused by disorders in the area of the lymphatic tonsillar ring, for sore throats, tonsilitis, disorders of the sinuses, beginning colds, flu, pressure in the head, pressure in the ears, ringing in the ears, poor hearing, lymphatic edema as well as poor resistance to infection in general.

Owing to their excellent relaxative effect, ear candles are extremely suitable for treating mental and vegetative disorders.

Centre of Wellbeing - Ros Wilson Address: 77 Anne Road, Knoxfield, VIC 3180 Phone: (03) 9763 0033 Email: [email protected] http://www.centreofwellbeing.com.au/ear-candling.html

Website claims:

Under “Ear Candles” the website states: BIOSUN Hopi EARcandles for adults and children – may be beneficial in the temporary relief of the symptoms of :

Sinus problems, ear ache, glue ears, swimmers ear, some chronic headaches, ringing in the ears (tinnitus), hearing difficulties, headache, irritations in the ear, sore throat and allergies.

Will aid removal of excess wax.

May also help to relieve pressure after flying, deep sea diving or whenever an imbalance of pressure had occurred. i.e. caused by altitude, the consequences of cold, headphones, telephones etc. May also help to relax and calm, relieving symptoms of stress and anxiety.

Page 25: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

11

A Perfect Blend - Lisa McDonald

Address: Shop 19. Centrepoint Marketplace. 50 Bulcock St. Caloundra Phone: (07) 5438 0688 Email: [email protected] https://www.aperfectblend.com.au/our-therapies/ear-candling/

Website claims:

Under “Ear Candles” the website states:

Ear Candling is a painless way of relieving many ear complaintsBenefits of Ear Candling Therapy Below is a small list of conditions that Ear Candles can benefit.

swimmer’s ear

tinnitus

otitis or tropical ear

blocked ears following flying

over secretion of earwax

How does Ear Candling work?

Ear Candling is a natural way to clean out accumulated wax from the ears

Wisdom for Living – Barbara Elkins

Address: Post Office Box 890, Terrigal, New South Wales, 2260 Phone: (02) 4334 6868 Email: [email protected] Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/WisdomForLivingCentre/ http://www.wisdomforlivingcentre.com.au/shop/ear-candles-three-pack/:

Page 26: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

12

Website Claims:

Wise Ear candles – pack of three $35.00

This ancient remedy for removing toxins and excess wax from the ear canal has been tried and trusted for centuries.

This procedure is completely painless and is a great option for dealing with children’s ear problems.

True Health – Adam Raponi & Siobhan Gilligan Address: 569 North Road, Ormond, Victoria, Australia 3204 Phone: (03) 9578 4912 Email: [email protected] http://www.truehealth.net.au/services/ear-candling/

Website claims:

Under “Ear Candling”:

Does your body produce excessive ear wax? Do you have difficulty hearing? Do you suffer from persistent earaches, middle ear infections, ringing in the ears (tinnitus) or Swimmer’s ear?

Ear candling could provide you with some relief.

Your Sanctuary Day Spa – Robyne Armstrong Address: 38 Saunders St, Pyrmont, Sydney, NSW Phone: 0418 445 469 Email: [email protected] http://www.yoursanctuary.com.au/beauty/ear-candling/

Page 27: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

13

Website claims:

Under “Ear Candling”:

Ear Candling is safe, non invasive, and natural, it will gently clear excess earwax from the ears and will assist with earache, runny nose, tinnitus, migraine, and blocked ears associated with air travel.

To create a vacuum in the ear, drawing out old wax residues. Ear candling is non invasive and completely painless. This treatment may assist with the following conditions:

Excessive Wax build-up (minor hearing loss)

Sinus irritation, and Vertigo

To clear the head before or after air travel

Alternative Body Works - Chanette Routlege Address: Suite 3, 53 Ross Smith Avenue, Parap, NT, 0820. Phone: (08) 8941 0810 Email: [email protected] https://alternativebodyworks.com.au/massage-therapies-darwin/ear-candling-darwin/ Website claims:

Who should have the treatment?

As long as you do not have any contraindications then the treatment is a relaxing experience for all, however it may be especially useful for the following conditions:

Sinusitis

Hayfever

Migraines and headaches

Excessive or compacted ear wax

Snoring

Tinnitus

Loss or reduction of smell

Page 28: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

14

Viive Skin & Body Care Address: 1/34 Melbourne St, Kilmore VIC 3764 Phone: (03) 5781 1150 Email: [email protected] https://alternativebodyworks.com.au/massage-therapies-darwin/ear-candling-darwin/ Website claims:

An ancient natural therapy originated by Indians. Hopi ear candles will aid removal of excess ear wax, may also help relieve sinus problems, headaches, ear aches, tinnitus or a sore throat.

ReNew Reflexology & Massage – Esther Sheppard Address: 5 Sage Close, Point Cook, Vic, 3030

Phone: 0425 718 104 Email: [email protected] http://www.renewreflexology.com.au/http---www-renewreflexology-com-au---ear Website claims:

Ear Candling

Do You Suffer From…

Excess earwax?

Tinnitus (ears ringing)?

Sinus congestion?

l offer ear candling

Conditions Ear Candling can help with.....

Sinus congestion

Colds

Sore throat

Compacted or excessive ear wax

Ear ache

Page 29: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

15

Prevention of ear infections

Glue ear (if no grommets in place)

Tinnitus

Lymphatic congestion

Snoring

Vertigo/balance

Headaches

Allergy symptoms

Pain or pressure when flying

Scuba diving pressure problems

Rhinitis – medical or allergy based

Meniere’s disease

Yatan Holistic Ayurvedic Centre – Raman Das Mahatyagi Address: Suite 28, 924 Pacific Highway, Gordon NSW 2072

Phone: 1300 552 260 Email: [email protected] https://www.yatan-ayur.com.au/the-benefits-of-ear-candling/ Website claims:

Page 30: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

16

When used correctly ear candling Is a safe and gentle method of removing excess wax and toxins from inside the ears and eustachian tubes.

to the value of the practice, not only in the treatment of ear problems such as excess wax, glue ear and tinnitus, but a wide variety of other problems such as sinus irritations, rhinitis, colds, flu, headaches and migraines.

Olive Homeopathy Healing Group – Sally Moore Address: 135 Pearce St Sawyers Valley, Perth, WA, 6074 Phone: (08) 9295 6782 Email: [email protected] http://www.olivehomoeopathic.com.au/ear-candling-perth-hills-holistic-health/ Website claims:

This technique aids removal of wax build up and debris that may have accumulated in the ear.

Ear candling aids improvement in hearing and balance. It also supports a reduction in frequency and severity of ear infections, ear aches, sinusitis headaches, tinnitus and regulates ear pressure, especially when associated with air travel.

Feeling Healthy - Rosanna Mosca & Merril Bowater Address: 69 Anderson Street Yarraville VIC 3013 Phone: (03) 9687 5333 Email: [email protected] https://feelinghealthy.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Ear candling can help to relax and calm whilst also relieving symptoms of

Sinus problems and discomfort

Ear ache

Page 31: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

17

Glue ear

Swimmers Ear

Some chronic headaches

Ringing in the ears (Tinnitus)

Hearing Difficulties

Headache

Sore Throat

Allergies

Irritaions and itching in the ear

Vertigo

Stress and Anxiety

The candles gently draw from the ear, sinuses, lymph glands, dental area , throat and more.

During the treatment old earwax and toxins are drawn up the candle, which has been lit and placed gently in the ear using a plastic cone for protection

The Wings of Angels - Adele Johnson Address: Mill Point Rd, South Perth WA 6151 Phone: 043 835 530 Email: [email protected]

Page 32: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

18

http://www.thewingsofangels.com.au/pages/Ear-Candling.html

Website claims:

The process of ear candling involves the use of custom made, hollow candles that are coated withbeeswax. They are hollow in nature and once lit and inserted gently into the ear, they create avacuum in the ear canal, drawing out excess wax, resides of past infection and fungus, clearing andopening up the sinuses by drawing away impurities. Ear candling is completely painless and non-invasive.

Ear Candling is said to of benefit for; Excessive wax build up, Sinusitis, Headaches, Enhancinghearing, Clear head before a flight, Ear infections( in conjunction with other medical treatment),Glue ear, Pressure pain/blockage, Tinnitus and swimmers ear.

Sage Beauty – Junia Kerr (updated 05/01/2019)

Address: 292 Campbell Parade, North Bondi NSW 2026 Phone: (02) 9130 7064 Email: [email protected] https://sagebeauty.com.au/catalog/ear-candling/

Website claims:

What are Ear Candles used for?

Excessive or compacted wax in the ears / glue ear

Irritation in ears and sinuses

Pressure regulation in cases of sinusitis / rhinitis / colds / flu

Relaxing and calming effect in cases of stress

Noises in the ears, ringing, tinnitus

Sore throats and hay fever

Headache and migraine

Catarrh and asthma

Vertigo

Meniere’s Disease

Neuralgia

Page 33: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

19

Liebe Wellness Address: 258 Maribyrnong Road, Moonee Ponds, Vic, 3039 Phone: (03) 9956 8804 Email: [email protected] http://liebewellness.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Ear Candling

For sinus, tinnitus, ringing in ears, hearing, stress.

Ear candling is a gentle, relaxing treatment to clear the ear canals of accumulated debris and stimulate the flow of energy to the entire head area. It’s an excellent therapy for relieving conditions affecting the head and ear area such as:

Sinus Congestion

Glue Ear / Swimmers Ear Ringing In The Ears (Tinnitus)

Hearing Problems

Age Related Deafness

Flying Discomfort

Excessive Ear Wax

The ear candles are lit, creating a suction effect drawing and removing toxins and excess wax from the ear canal

Page 34: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

20

Zen Chi Natural Therapy & Wellness Centre Address: Shop 11/12-18 Discovery Dr, North Lakes QLD 4509 Phone: (07) 3482 2549 Email: [email protected] http://www.zen-chi.net.au/ear-candling.html Website claims:

The candles are simple to use, are safe and very effective.

BENEFITS OF EAR CANDLING? Though results may vary from patient to patient, some clients have reported the candles to be helpful with;

Sinus problems

Ear aches

Noises in the ears,

ringing,

tinnitus

Headaches

Sore Throats

Allergies

Colds and Flus

Swimmers Ear

Excessive Ear Wax

Relaxing and calming effect in cases of stress

Page 35: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

21

Bings Natural Health - Bing Qian

Address: Level 1, 265 Coventry Street South Melbourne, VIC 3205 Phone: (03) 9699 5333 Email: [email protected] https://bingsnaturalhealth.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Ear candling is helpful for drawing dead cells, bacteria, pollen, yeast, dust, fungus, mould, parasites, pollution and other toxic debris out of the ears.

It can be of assistance with conditions such as ear aches, sinus problems, tinnitus, headaches and swimmer’s ear. Results may vary for different recipients.

Tarot in Action - Ruanna Sega Address: 165 Pascoe Vale Rd, Moonee Ponds, VIC 3039 Melbourne, Australia Phone: 0418 388 712 Email: [email protected] https://www.tarotinaction.com.au/healings/healings-ear-candling Website claims: Ear Candling may be used for:

Headaches

Tinnitus (Ringing in the ears)

Sinus problems

Glue Ear

Hearing difficulties

Page 36: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

22

Sore throat and allergies

Hayfever and rhinitis

Will aid in the removal of excessive ear wax

Clear toxins build up

General hearing loss

Colds

Tension headaches

Travel sickness

May also help to relieve pressure after flying, deep sea diving or whenever an imbalance ofpressure has occured by altitude

Meniere's disease

Allergies

Swimmers ear

Puffingness around the eyes

Aids in blood circulation of the lymph glands

May also help to relax and calm by relieving symptoms of stess and anxiety

Will aid in the removal of excessive ear wax

K.O Beauty Zone – Enza Caio

Address: 2 Landells Road Pascoe Vale, VIC 3044 Phone: (03) 9354 5574

Page 37: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

23

Email: [email protected] https://www.kobeautyzone.com.au/ear-candling Website claims:

Ear candling is used primarily for cleaning the ears and to promote a healthy atmosphere for the ear, inner ear, sinus cavities, Eustachian tubes, glands and throat. There are however several other benefits. The process can regulate pressure, assist with nasal drip, sinusitis, catarrh, migraines, some forms of hearing loss, restoration of equilibrium, relieving tinnitus, vertigo, swimmers ear and the list goes on.

HRT Acupuncture & Massage Centre – Hong Ren Tang Address: Shop 3-4 Sunnybank Plaza, Sunnybank,QLD 4109 Phone: (07) 3344 2858 Email: [email protected] http://www.acupuncturefitness.com.au/health-services/other-services/ear-candling-2/ Website claims:

Due to its gentle procedure it is a suitable method for children.

Benefits:

Reduced stress

Improved sense of taste

Improved sense of smell

Equalized pressure in the ear

Ear candling is a non-intrusive technique that may help with: • Sinusitis • Tinnitus • Tension headaches • Snoring • Swimmer’s ear • Vertigo

Page 38: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

24

Laurimar Health & Wellbeing Centre - Karlie Jewitt

Address: Suite 7, Level 1, 101 Hazel Glen Drive, Doreen, VIC, 3754 Phone: (03) 9717 1130 Email: [email protected] http://laurimarhealth.com.au/ear-candling-session/ Website claims:

Benefits of ear candling include:

Effectively loosens ear wax – Note that the candles will not “suck” all the wax out of your ear in a single sitting, but rather, the effects will be cumulative over time with multiple treatments.

May help to prevent ear infections – Ear candling may help to draw moisture and debris out of the ear canal.

Relieving tinnitus – Tinnitus, or ringing in the ears, may be helped with ear candling according to many, particularly if it is caused by buildup of wax and other materials in the ear.

Reduces headaches – Ear candling may be a wonderful way to relieve tension headaches caused by stress, as it provides you with an opportunity to rest and relax.

Sinus pain and pressure relief – Many people also claim that ear candling can help to relieve sinus pain and pressure, as well as relieving symptoms of swimmers’ ear.

Improved lymphatic fluid flow through the body – Ear candling helps to stimulate peripheral blood circulation in the body.

Clearer mind and emotions – Ear candling can produce a strong calming and relaxing effect on the body, and it’s the perfect way to clear your mind of worry, and relax and unwind after a long stressful day.

Page 39: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

25

So Natural Reflexology – Sandy Vanrenen

Address: 277 Wollaston Road, Warrnambool, Vic, 3280 Phone: 0409 185 066 Email: [email protected] http://in2reflexology.com.au/ear-candling/

Website claims:

induces a pleasant feeling of warmth and a balance of pressure in the ears, forehead and sinuses.

a soothing, pressure and pain relieving sensation, mainly in the ear and head area.

It has been known to help with ear wax removal and to assist with conditions such as sinusitis,headaches, ear noise, tinnitus, headache, TMJ pain, nose and throat congestion.

Candling also offers an ideal relaxing session to assist stress or anxiety related symptoms

Page 40: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

26

Sapphire Coast Wellness Centre – Trish Howard Address: Bega Valley Natural Healing Centre, 61 Parker St, Bega NSW 2550 Phone: (02) 6492 2222 Email: http://trishhoward.com.au/ear-candling-bega-merimbula/ Website claims:

Ear Candling can be very beneficial for a variety of ailments. Some of these include:

Excessive wax build up

Fungal infections, parasites, including Candida

Sinus pain and irritation (sinusitis, rhinitis)

Colds and other head congestions

Some sore throats and congestion

Toxins, including toxic residue from medications

Some allergies

Glue ear, swimmers ear

Tinnitus

Foggy head

Vertigo, other inner ear problems

Migraines, headaches

Some hearing impairments Relief of ‘stuck pressure’ after flying, diving TMJ pain

Page 41: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

27

Brunswick Health – Sara Canney & Josephine Cabrall Address: 68 Melville Road, Brunswick, Vic, 3056 Phone: (03) 9380 8099 Email: [email protected] https://brunswickhealth.com.au/acupuncture-melbourne/what-is-ear-candling.html Website claims:

For removing ear wax, ear candling is the most recommended for its simplicity, delicacy and low risk.

Following are several of the health advantages of cleaning the car canals using ear candles – they may not apply to everyone but those who have used the method testify by it.

Many ailments such as tinnitus, sinus pain, feeling of head pressure, swimmer ear, general ear complications, dizziness, itchy ears and several other symptoms may be reduced by using ear candles.

Ear candles may also assist in enhancing lymphatic fluid flow, improve colour perception and some individuals have reported improved sense of taste.

In addition to the reduced pressure (initially caused by wax buildup in the ears), ear candling greatly reduces the chance of an infection developing in the ear canal. The most important reason for the procedure is that it will help clear wax and debris from the ear canal, consequently ensuring a heightened feeling of personal hygiene.

Pam Allen Reflexology & Indian Head Massage – Pam Allen

Address: 44 Highmont Drive, Belmont, Vic 3216 Phone: 0417 357 030 Email: https://pamallen.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Page 42: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

28

How can Ear Candling help me? The treatment can be very beneficial for you if you have recurrent ear infections, tinnitus, swimmer’s ear, sinusitis, hay fever, some types of headaches, or regularly have blocked ears.

It is also valuable pre-flight for people who experience ear pain on aeroplanes. If you work in an environment with floating particles in the air that can get inside the ear, (eg. builders, plasterers, bakers, animal groomers, hairdressers, etc) you may also benefit.

If you are looking for general detoxification processes as part of a cleansing program, this will also be beneficial.

Mystic Universe – Sue Kelly Address: Suite 5, 80 Sixth Ave, Maroochydore Qld 4558 Phone: 0422 893269 Email: https://mysticuniverse.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Ear Candling is a gentle yet very effective ancient natural therapy. It is safe, pain free and may be used for many types of ear disorders.

HOW CAN EAR CANDLES BENEFIT ME?

Ear candles may be of benefit in various cases of:

Cleanse ear canal

Deep sea diving pressure buildup

Diminished hearing

Excessive wax build up

Foggy head

Fungal infections

Glue ear or swimmers ear

Improve hearing

Pressure after flying

Relieves sinus pressure & pain

Subscribe Past Issues

Stress & anxiety

Toxic residue from medication

Tinnitus (Ringing in the ears)

In some cases it is beneficial for vertigo, headaches and sore throats.

Ear candling is ancient method that has been used by the Chinese for thousands of years. The process involves using a hollow candle which is held gently on the edge of the ear. The candle is lit which creates a vacuum in the ear, drawing out old wax and other residues such as fungus and infections. Candling is also said to stimulate the immune system and peripheral blood circulation.

The process is not invasive and is completely painless. The benefits of ear candling may reduce excessive wax build-up, assist with sinus irritation , help with chronic ear infections and fungal problems as well assist in clearing the head before or after a flight.

Page 43: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

29

Capital Complementary Therapies Centre - Dennis Yu Address: Unit 69, Level 1, 10 Lonsdale St, Braddon, Canberra, ACT, 2612 Phone: (02) 6174 1834 Email: [email protected] https://cctcentre.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

What can it treat?

Ear Candling can help to promote an improved state of health. The treatment may relieve conditions troubling the ear, such as:

Earaches

Tinnitus

Excessive earwax

Glue ear

It may also benefit other conditions that affect the head area such as:

Colds

Hay fever

Headaches

Sinus problems

Snoring

Page 44: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

30

Gently Does It – Lyn Wood Address: Phone: Email: http://www.gently-does-it.com.au/ear-candling-3 Website claims:

Ear Candling can be effective in the case of allergies, tinnitus, headache, snoring, hearing difficulties, excess wax and can help to remove viruses and toxins.

Back in Harmony – Ross Swadling Address: 4/23 Wyong Rd, Tumbi Umbi, NSW, 2261 Phone: 0448 890 903 Email: [email protected] http://www.backinharmony.net.au/ear%20candling.html Website claims:

Ear candles provide harmony of Body-Soul-Spirit, they are used to treat swimmers or glue ear, sinus problems, vertigo and tinnitus can be eased.

They aid with insomnia and boost the immune system or for relaxation in general.

Page 45: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

31

Mind & Body Health Address: 82 Kilmorey St Carindale, Qld, 4152 Phone: (07) 3398 1100 Email: [email protected] http://www.mindandbodyhealth.com.au/ear-candling-cupping/

Website claims:

The Benefits:

Ear candling loosens and removes excess wax from the ear canal and by doing so, effectively treats a number of common conditions such as headaches, migraines, sinusitis and tinnitus.

Ear candling can help with ringing in the ear and hearing loss.

Relief from vertigo and balancing of the ear fluids.

Absolute Wellbeing – Suzie Kerkin Address: 18 Dehlsen Ave, West Pennant Hills NSW 2125 Phone: 02 8677 0421 Email: [email protected] http://absolutewellbeing.ntpages.com.au/ear_candling/absolute_wellbing_ear_candling Website claims:

Biosun Ear Candles may be beneficial in the temporary relief of the following symptoms:

Sinus issues

Glue Ear

Swimmers ear

Headaches

Tinnitus

Hearing difficulties

Aids clearer meditation

excessive wax buildup

Imbalance

Earaches and Pain

Page 46: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

32

Wayne Massage – Wayne Zheng Address: 78A Darlinghurst Rd, Potts Point, NSW, 2011

Phone: 0410 878 827 Email: [email protected] http://waynemassage.com.au/service.php Website Claims:

Ear Candling Helps Relieve

Ear Aches

Sore Throat

Itchy Ear

Candida

Tinnitus

Glue Ear

Vertigo

Ear Infections

Sinus Problems

Excess Ear Wax

Headaches

Surfers Ear

Vertigo

Relieves Pressure From Diving

Relieves Pressure From Flying

Page 47: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

33

Chameyli Wellbeing Sanctuary - Catherine Glover Address Falvey St, Ripley, Qld, 4306 Phone: 0418 340 652 Email: http://www.chameyli.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

Ear candling help alleviate a lot of symptoms such as:

Anxiety

Blocked ears caused by jetlag

Depression

Glue ear

Hearing problem

Head congestion

Insomnia

Migraines and headaches

Sinus related problems

Sleep apnoea

Tinnitus

Hay fever and other allergies

Sore throat

Swimmers ear

Snoring

Vertigo

Page 48: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

34

Aialu Massage - Anna-Linda Jelliff Address: 3a/77 Lilyfield Rd, Lilyfield NSW 2040 Phone: 0433 280 800 Email: [email protected] http://www.aialumassage.com/other.html Website claims:

Benefits:

Relief of excessive or compacted wax in the ears

Reduction of irritation in ears and sinuses

Pressure regulation in cases of: sinusitis, rhinitis, glue ear, colds, flu, headaches and migraine

Relaxing and calming effect in cases of stress

Reduction of noises in the ears including ringing and tinnitus

Natures Wisdom Address: Shop 71 Stockland, Townsville, 310 Ross River Rd, Aitkenvale QLD 4814 Phone: (07) 4725 7235 Email: [email protected] https://www.natureswisdom.com.au/other-services/ Website Claims:

It is often used by people with:

Tinnitus

Sinusitis

Glue ear

Hayfever and rhinitis

Excessive ear wax

Colds

Tension headaches

Stress

Page 49: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

35

BodiBeautilicious - Jennifer Sheldon Address: Shop 1/653 Old South Head Road, Rose Bay NSW 2029 Phone: (02) 9371 9939 Email: [email protected] https://www.bodibeauticious.com.au/portfolios/ear-candling/ Website claims:

‘Candle Powers’ Ear Candles are used in this very relaxing therapy that improves the immune system, enhances hearing, taste, smell, and intuition. Helpful in relieving many ailments such as headaches, sinus problems, allergies, excessive wax, ringing in the ears (Tinnitus), age-related deafness, sore throat, ear ache.

May help to relieve pressure after flying, deep sea diving or whenever an imbalance of pressure has occurred. May also relieve symptoms of stress and anxiety.

Generally two candles will be used for each ear as this has been found to be a very effective method.

Page 50: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

36

Yan Acupuncture & Massage - Ning Lu

Address: Shop 09, North Kellyville Square, 12-14 withers road, Kellyville, NSW, 2155 Phone: (02) 8883 0238 Email: [email protected] http://www.yanacupunctureandmassage.com.au/teamview_1383972.html

Website claims:

Ear Candling is a technique use to naturally cleanse the inside of the ears and head. As a non-intrusive procedure, it may help alleviate the painful effects of chronic headaches or sinusconditions, ear infections, allergies or vertigo, as well as minor hearing loss due to excessive earwaxbuild up.

Zen Chinese Medicine

Address: Sandy Bay Clinic: 10 Magnet Court, Sandy Bay, Tas, 7005 Phone: (03) 6245 3806 Email: http://zentcm.com.au/cupping-ear-candling-reiki.html

Website claims:

For removing ear wax, ear candling is the most recommended for its simplicity, delicacy and lowrisk. Following are several of the health advantages of cleaning the car canals using ear candles –they may not apply to everyone but those who have used the method testify by it.

Many ailments such as tinnitus, sinus pain, feeling of head pressure, swimmer ear, general earcomplications, dizziness, itchy ears and several other symptoms may be reduced by using earcandles. Ear candles may also assist in enhancing lymphatic fluid flow, improve colour perceptionand some individuals have reported improved sense of taste.

Body in Tune - Mirium Bunder

Page 51: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

37

Address: The Transformation Space, Level 1, Suite 101 54 Alexander St , Crows Nest, NSW 2065 Phone: 0412 683 188 Email: [email protected] http://bodyintune.com.au/shop.html

Website claims:

Ear Candles An extremely gentle and non-intrusive way to rid your ear of unneeded extra wax. They have known to help with chronic ear infections, swimmers ear, sore throat, tinnitus, sinusitis and chronic headaches.

Timeless Skin Laser & Beauty Spa Address: Ocean Grove Marketplace, Shell Road, Ocean Grove. Vic,, 3226 Phone: (03) 5255 3007 Email: https://www.timelessskin.com.au/ear-candling/ Website claims:

The benefits of ear candling may include: relieved sinus pressure and pain; reduced earaches and headaches; removal of excess wax buildup; reduced stress and tension, and ear candling may also improve your hearing.

Happy Healing Australia Phone: 0432 380 143 Email: [email protected] https://www.happyhealing.com.au/energy-healing-chakra-remedy Website claims:

Reported beneficial results may be obtained in the following areas:

Excessive wax build up

Sinus pain and irritation

Migraines

Tinnitus

Foggy Head

And more

Page 52: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

38

Anakien Natural Therapies – Carole Hoffin Address: Anakie Community House, 2115 Ballan Rd, Anakie, VIC 3213 Phone: 0425 731 295 Email: [email protected] http://anakienaturaltherapies.com.au/service-list/ Website claims:

Candling, coning, thermo-auricular therapy or Ototherapy; placing a lit, hollow beeswax candle over the entrance to the ear canal creates gentle warmth which soothes the eardrum and stimulates the lymphatic system.

Important body meridians and acupressure points are also treated during ear candling. People who suffer with tinnitus, vertigo and chronic sinusitis may benefit from regular candling: safe, gentle and relaxing.

A soothing and warming therapy that may assist in the management of chronic conditions of the ear and sinuses.

Lyn Craven Corporate Health Address: Sir Thomas Mitchell Road, Bondi Beach, Sydney, NSW Phone: 0403 231 804 Email: http://www.lyncravencorporatehealth-naturopath.com/page008.html Website claims:

Page 53: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

39

This is a safe, pain free and effective remedy can be used for many ear disorders from excess wax, infections, swimmers ear, glue ear, tinnitus etc. Also used for certain headaches, sinusitis and sore throats.

Harmony within Health – Manuela Picinich Address: 41 Tunstall Square East Doncaster VIC 3109. Phone: 0401 255 031 Email: https://www.harmonywithinhealth.com.au/ear-candeling Website claims:

Ear Candling is a gentle and relaxing technique which can help to promote an improved state of health. It has also been reported that those who partake in ear candling experience an improved sense of taste as well as reduced pressure, which may be present in the ears due to a wax build up or infection.

The treatment may relieve conditions troubling the ear, such as earaches, tinnitus, excessive earwax, and glue ear. It also benefits other conditions that affect the head area such as colds, hay fever, headaches, sinus problems and snoring and is an extremely relaxing treatment alongside a lymphatic facial drainage massage.

The Rose Health - Maree Address: Sandstone Way, Little Mountain Caloundra, QLD 4551 Phone: 0413 655 555 Email: [email protected] https://www.therose.net.au/services-fees/ Website claims:

Pure beeswax ear candles may be beneficial in the temporary relief of the symptoms of – sinus problems, ear ache, glue ear, swimmers ear, some chronic headaches, ringing in the ears (tinnitus), hearing difficulties, irritations in the ear. Will aid removal of excessive ear wax.

Page 54: Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ......Complaint to TGA: The ongoing and dangerous promotion of ear candles Page 6 of 10 warmth travels down it to the ear,

40

May also help to relieve pressure after flying, deep sea diving or whenever an imbalance of pressure has occurred. i.e. caused by altitude, the consequences of cold, headphones, telephones etc