communication of debate aspects to different audiences - da

24
Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences Brian Plüss Knowledge Media Institute The Open University, UK [email protected] edv-project.net hloss Dagstuhl, 17 December 2015

Upload: edv-project

Post on 14-Feb-2017

186 views

Category:

Data & Analytics


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences

Brian PlüssKnowledge Media InstituteThe Open University, [email protected]

edv-project.netSchloss Dagstuhl, 17 December 2015

Page 2: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Context and Motivation

edv-project.net

The Election Debate Visualisation project

• Aim: to improve democratic citizenship by making political media events more accessible and engaging, and by giving viewers tools to make sense of complex political argumentation and debate.

• Political communication, computational linguistics, collective intelligence and design brought together to provide enhanced, interactive online debate replays.

Page 3: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Context and Motivation

edv-project.net

Page 4: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Context and Motivation

edv-project.net

Page 5: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Context and Motivation

edv-project.net

Page 6: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Embedded visualisations

edv-project.net

Page 7: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Embedded visualisations

Page 8: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Interactive Visualisations

edv-project.net

Page 9: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Dialogue Rule Compliance and Fair Play

+

Manual Annotation of Dialogue Act Functions and

Content Features

Rules of Engagement(76 in 2010; 28 in 2015)

Page 10: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Dialogue Rule Compliance and Fair Play

• Instances of violations of the rules Static: performance of forbidden dialogue acts Dynamic: failure to discharge discourse obligations

• Aggregated normalised scores per speaker

+

Manual Annotation of Dialogue Act Functions and

Content Features

Rules of Engagement(76 in 2010; 28 in 2015)

Page 11: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Dialogue Rule Compliance and Fair Play

• Instances of violations of the rules Static: performance of forbidden dialogue acts Dynamic: failure to discharge discourse obligations

• Aggregated normalised scores per speaker

Fair Play Summary

+

Manual Annotation of Dialogue Act Functions and

Content Features

Rules of Engagement(76 in 2010; 28 in 2015)

Page 12: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Dialogue Rule Compliance and Fair Play

+

Manual Annotation of Dialogue Act Functions and

Content Features

Rules of Engagement(76 in 2010; 28 in 2015)

• Instances of violations of the rules Static: performance of forbidden dialogue acts Dynamic: failure to discharge discourse obligations

• Aggregated normalised scores per speaker

Page 13: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Instant Audience Feedback

Page 14: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Instant Audience Feedback

Page 15: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Instant Audience Feedback

Page 16: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Instant Audience Feedback

Page 17: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Instant Audience Feedback

Page 18: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

“Argument” Mapping

Page 19: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

“Argument” Mapping

Page 20: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

“Argument” Mapping

Page 21: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

“Argument” Mapping

Page 22: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

“Argument” Mapping

Page 23: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

edv-project.net

Widget Dashboard

Page 24: Communication of Debate Aspects to Different Audiences - Da

Thank you!

Brian Plüss Knowledge Media InstituteThe Open University, [email protected]

edv-project.net