HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA

COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS

( 2017-2018 )

(EIGHTH REPORT)

REPORT

on

Various Petitions/Representations received by

the Committee

(Presented to the House on 15th March, 2018)

HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA SECRETARIATCHANDIGARH

2018

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page No.

Composition of Committee on Petitions iii

Introduction v

Sr. Petition Received fromNo.

1. SH. NARESH KUMAR, RAMESH KUMAR AND SURINDER 1-11

KUMAR S/O SH. LAKHMIRA SINGH R/O VILL. MANDOLE

GAGAD, TEHSIL CHHACHROLI, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR.

2. SHRI RAJENDER KUMAR AND PREET SINGH, BOTH ART 11-20

MASTER, GOVT. ARTS SCHOOL, SECTOR 6, I.T.I CAMPUS,

ROHTAK.

3. SHRI. ROOP CHAND VERMA, H.NO. 638, SECTOR 17, HUDA, 20-23

JAGADHARI.

4. SHRI SHAMSHER SINGH S/O SH. HARNAM SINGH R/O 23-38

VILL KAMRI, TEHSIL & DISTT. HISAR.

5. SHRI KANT SHARMA, JUNIOR SCALE STENO TYPIST, 38-40

HARYANA POLICE HOUSING CORPN., K.NO. 7, PTC,

SUNARIA (ROHTAK).

6. SHRI VIJAY PAL S/O SH. MAHENDER SINGH R/O V.P.O. TIKLI, 41-42

TEHSIL AND DISTT. GURUGRAM.

7. DR. PRADEEP, MEDICAL OFFICER, CIVILHOSPITAL. BHIWANI. 42-46

8. SMT. BHUPENDER KAUR D/o SH. GURSHRAN SINGH, VILL. 47-50

SALEMPUR BAN GAR P.O. CHACHHROLl, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR.

9. SHRI MAN ISH SAINI, MD, KAY KAY GLOBAL SUPPLIERS, 50-57

AMBALA CANTT.

10. SMT. MONIKA MEHTA W/o SH. YOGESH MEHTA, R/O B-801. 57-80

APEX APARTMENT, SECTOR 45, GURGAON.

11. SHRI SANJAY KUMAR S/o SH. OM PARKASH R/O VILLAGE 80-85

GHORON PIPLI, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR.

12. SHRI BASVANANAD S/O SH. DEVIDUTT, #1047, FIRST FLOOR, 85-87

SECTOR 19, PANCHKULA.

13. SMT. USHA DEVI W /0 SH. MANOl KUMAR, H.NO. 646, 87-89

SECTOR 9, JIND.

14. DR. P.K. BAJPAYEE, PRINCIPAL, MAHARAJA AGRASEN 89-92

MAHAVIDYALAYA, JAGADHRI.

15. SMT. SANTRO DEVI W /0 LATE SH. RATAN SINGH, 92-100

VILL. NIMANBAD, TEHSIL SAFIDON, DISTT. JIND.

COMPOSITION OF THE COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS

(2017-2018)

CHAIRPERSON

1. Shri Ghanshyam Dass, MLA

MEMBERS

2. Smt. Geeta Bhukkal, MLA Member

3. Shri Zakir Hussain, MLA Member

4. Smt. Shakuntla Khatak, MLA Member

*****5. Shri Umesh Aggarwal, MLA Member

****6. Shri Jai Prakash, MLA Member

7. Shri Anoop Dhanak, MLA Member

8. Shri Jasbir Deswal, MLA Member

SPECIAL INVITEE

*9. Shir Ved Narang, MLA Special Invitee

**10. Shri Jagbir Malik, MLA Special Invitee

***11. Shri Sri Krishan, MLA Special Invitee

* Shri Ved Narang, MLA was nominated vide Notification No. HVS/Petitions/1/2017-18/55, dated 25th May, 2017.

** Shri Jagbir Malik, MLA was nominated vide Notification No. HVS/Petitions/1/2017-18/55, dated 25th May, 2017.

*** Shri Sri Krishan, MLA was nominated vide Notification No. H V S /Petitions/1/2017-18/55, dated 25th May, 2017.

**** Shri Jai Prakash, MLA was nominated vide Notification No. HVS/Petitions/1/2017-18/64, dated 8th June, 2017.

***** Shri Umesh Aggarwal, MLA was resigned vide Notification No. HVS/

Petitions/1/2017-18/65, dated 8th June, 2017.

SECRETARIAT

1. Shri R.K. Nandal, Secretary

2. Shri Vishnu Dev, Under Secretary

(iii)

INTRODUCTION

1. I, Ghanshyam Dass, Chairperson of the Committee on Petitions having

been authorized by the Committee in this behalf, present this Eighth Report of the

Committee on Petitions on the various Petitions/representations received by the

Committee.

2. The Committee considered all the Petitions/representations as per the details

given in the Report and examined the concerned Government Officers. The

Committee made its observations and has tried its level best to redress the grievances

of the Petitioners to the maximum extent.

3. The Committee considered and approved this report at their sitting held

on 1st March, 2018.

4. A Brief record of the proceedings of the meetings of the Committee has

been kept in the Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat.

5. The Committee would like to express their thanks to the Government Officers

and other representatives of various departments who appeared for oral evidence

before them for the cooperation in giving information to the Committee.

6. The Committee is also thankful to the Secretary and other Officer/Officials

of Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat for their whole hearted cooperation and

assistance given by them to the Committee.

Chandigarh (GHANSHYAM DASS)The 1st March, 2018 CHAIRPERSON

(v)

REPORT

The Committee on Petitions for the year 2017-18 consisting of

seven Members was nominated by the Hon’ble Speaker, Haryana Vidhan Sabha on

25th April, 2017 under Rule 268 of the Amended Rules of the Rules of Procedure &

Conduct of Business in the House. Shri Ghanshyam Dass, MLA was nominated as

Chairperson of the Committee by the Hon’ble Speaker. Three special invitee were

also nominated by the Hon’ble Speaker to serve on this Committee.

The Committee held 51 sittings during the year 2017-18 (till finalization of

the Report).

(vii)

1. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SH. NARESH

KUMAR, RAMESH KUMAR AND SURINDER KUMAR S/OSH. LAKHMIRA SINGH R/O VILL. MANDOLE GAGAD, TEHSILCHHACHROLI, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR REGARDING COMPLAINTAGAINST REVENUE DEPARTMENT, TEHSIL GHAURANDA,DISTT. KARNAL.

The Petition received from Sh. Naresh Kumar, Ramesh Kumar and

Surinder Kumar, is reads as under:-

lsok esa]

ekuuh; pS;jesu iSfV’ku desVh]gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk p.Mhx<+A

fo"k;%& nj[kkLr ckcr rglhy ?kjkS.Mk] ftyk djuky ds jktLo foHkkx esa feyhHkdr djdsizkFkhZx.k dh tehu fdlh vU; O;fDr ds uke djus ckjsA

Jheku th]

izkFkhZx.k vkils fuosnu djrs gS fd%&

1- ;g fd izkFkhZx.k Jh lhrk jke iq= Jh nhuk fuoklh xkao nsohiqj] rglhy ?kjkS.Mk] ftykdjuky ds okfjlku gSA

2- ;g fd lhrk jke iq= Jh nhuk us jdck rknknh 32 djuky 18 ejys [kljk uaå 392]417] 157@@1] 2] 3] 4] 5@1] dLVksfM;u foHkkx ls fnukad 21-08-1965 dks [kjhnfd;k FkkA tks dsUnzh; ljdkj us [kqyh uhykeh esa cspk FkkA lhrk jke us lcls vf/kdcksyh nsdj iSlk tek djk;k FkkA ftl ckcr lsy lVhZfQdsV Hkh ljdkj }kjk tkjh fd;kFkkA bl ckcr bUrdky uaå 697 eUtqj gks x;k FkkA tkfd ;g bUnzkt tekcUnh lky1966&1967 esa vey njken gks x;k Fkk vkSj 1971&1972 dh tekcUnh esa Hkh bUnzktlhrk jke ds uke pyrk jgk gSA ysfdu joSU;w fjdkMZ ds gYdk iVokjh us bUrdky uaå944 ekydku ds uke ls ’kkeykr nsg esa rcnhy djus ckjs bUrdky ntZ dj fn;kAysfdu og bUrdky eUtwj uk gqvkA rglhynkj us og [kkfjt dj fn;k Fkk vkSj blhizdkj bUrdky uaå 945&946 Hkh dHkh eUtwj uk gqvk gS vkSj bUrdky ntZ djus ckjsdksbZ lwpuk lhrk jke dks uk nh xbZ FkhA ysfdu mlds ckn tekcUnh esa bUrdky eUtqjgq;s fcuk gh vey njkeUn dj fn;k x;k gSA

3- ;g fd lhrk jke dh e`R;q gks pqdh gSA mudh e`R;q ds ckn muds pkj csVs gfjiky]j?kqchj] pUnkjke o egkchj o rhu csfV;ka j?kchjh] djs’kuh mQZ djseks o Hkxrh mudsdkuwuh okfjl cus gSA gfjiky dh e`R;q gks pqdh gS vkSj gfjiky dh e`R;q ds ckn mudknRrd iq= cyfoUnz gS vkSj j?kchj dh Hkh eR;q gks pqdh gS vkSj mUkdh eR;q ds ckn mldsrhu csVs d`"k.kiky] lqjsUnz o izohu dqekj gS o pkj csfV;k jktoarh] dkUrh] feFkys’k odeys’k gS vkSj Hkxrh nsoh dh Hkh eR;q gks pqdh gS vkSj mudh eR;q gks pqdh gS vkSj mudhe`R;q ds ckn rhu yM+ds izkFkhZx.k ujs’k] jes’k o lfyUnz o ,d csVh yyrs’k gS tksfd

2

Jhefr Hkxrh nsoh ds dkuwuh okfjlku gksus ds ukrs mijksDr Hkwfe ds 1@7 fgLlk dsekfyd gSA

4- ;g fd Hkwfe dHkh Hkh ’kkeykr nsg uk jgh gS tc ljdkj us Loa; gh uhykeh djds Hkwfedks cspk FkkA ml le; og tehu fcuk fdlh uksfVl ds fdlh ds uke bUrdky ntZdjuk xSj dkuwuh gSA

5- ;g fd izkFkhZx.k bl ckjs igys Hkh dbZ vf/kdkfj;ksa dks nj[kkLrs ns pqds gS vkSj gj txgls nj[kkLrs ekØ gksdj rglhynkj egksn; ?kjkS.Mk ds uke tkrh gSA tc izkFkhZx.krglhynkj ?kjks.Mk ls feyrs gS rks og dgrk gS fd 32 duky 18 ejys tehu eSa rqeyksxks ds uke Ýh esa FkksMh uk uke dj nwaxkA bl Hkwfe dh ftruh dher gS ml fglkcls eq>s Hkh fgLlk nks eSa rHkh QnZ cnj cukdj Bhd dj nwaxkA bl izdkj ls rglhynkjeq>ls fj’or dh ekax djrk gSA rglhynkj dgrk gS fd vkidh tehu bUrdky uaå944 dh :g ls ’kkeykr ds uke pyh xbZ gSA tcfd bUrdky uaå 944 dHkh eUtwjuk gqvk gSA bl ckcr tc fjdkMZ:e ls udy ysus ds fy, nj[kkLr nh rks mlijfjdkMZ dhij us fjiksVZ dh fd bUrdky uaå 944 tekcUnh lky 1976&77 ds LkkFk fjdkMZtek uk gqvk gSA tksfd bl Hkwfe ckjs fdlh izdkj dk dksbZ dsl fdlh Hkh vnkyr esafopkjk/khu uk gSA

6- ;g fd rglhynkj tks O;fDr mldks iSls ns nsrk gS muds uke nq:Lrh dj nsrk gS tksfj’or ugh nsrk mldh nq:Lrh ugh gksrh gSA bl izdkj ls ge dkuwu esa fo’okl j[krsgS vkSj ge izkFkhZx.k fj’or nsus okys esa ls uk gSA

blfy, vkils fuosnu gS fd mijksDr rF;ksa dks /;ku esa j[krs gq,s izkFkhZx.k dk fojklrdk bardky ntZ djus o fjdkWMZ nq:Lr djok;k tk,sA vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

/kU;oknA

fnukad%& izkFkhZx.k gLrk@&ujs’k dqekj] jes’k dqekj olfyUnz dqekj iq=ku Jh y[kehjk flag]fuoklhx.k xkao e.MkSyh xx<+]rglhy NNjkSyh] ftyk ;equkuxjA

The petition was place before the Committee in its meeting held on

22.12.2015 and the Committee considered the same and decided that said petition

be sent to the concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of

15 days. The Committee does not receive any reply from the department. Reminders

was sent to the department on 10.02.2016 and 11.05.2016. Thereafter, Committee

orally examine Deputy Commissioner, Karnal, Tehsildar, Ghauranda, Distt. Karnal

and Petitioners in its meeting held on 06.06.2016 and 28.06.2016. The Committee

3

directed the petitioner to submit a new application along with the all the important

documents and proof of thumb impression to Deputy Commissioner within 7 days.

Thereafter, Deputy Commissioner will take necessary action and submit his report

to the Committee within a month.

Thereafter, The Deputy Commissioner, Karnal submit his report vide his

letter No. 2065/SK, dated 30.08.2016, which reads as under:-

izs"kd]

Jh eanhi flag cjkM] vkbZ- ,- ,l-]mik;qDr] djukyA

lsok esa]

Principal Secretary,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha,

Secretariat, Chandigarh.

Øekad 2065/SK fnukad 30&08&16

fo"k;% Extract of the Proceedings of the meetings of the committee on

Petitions held on 06-06-2016.

;knh %

v kid s dk;k Zy; d s ; kn h Øå HVS/Petition/466/16-17/11419

fnukad 28-06-2016 ds lUnHkZ esaA

mijksDr fo"k; ij gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk desVh }kjk fy;s x, fu.kZ; vuqlkjlacaf/kr dsl dh tkap iMrky djus ds fy, mie.My vf/kdkjh] ¼ukå½ djuky dks vf/kdr fd;kx;kA bl dk;Zy; ds ;knh Øå 1433@l-d- fnukad 6-7-2016 }kjk mie.My vf/kdkjh] ¼ukå½djuky ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;k fd og lacaf/kr lHkh i{kksa dks lquus mijkUr fjdkMZ dks /;ku esa j[krsgq, viuh foLr`r fjiksVZ bl dk;kZy; esa 18-7-2016 rd fHktokuk lqfuf’pr djsA mie.Myvf/kdkjh] ¼ukå½ djuky us vius dk;kZy; ds ;knh Øå 29@LVSuks fnukad 22-7-2016 }kjk foLr`rfjiksVZ Hkst nh gSA

mie.My vf/kdkjh] ¼ukå½ djuky us lacf/kr fjdkMZ dk voyksdu mijkUr rF;ksa dsvk/kkj ij viuh foLrr fjiksVZ izsf"kr dh gSA mie.My vf/kdkjh] ¼ukå½ djuky dh fjiksVZ dh ,dizfr vkidh lsok esa vkxkeh vko’;d dk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

lyaXu & tkap fjiksVZA

¼gLrkå½d`rs% mik;qDr djukyA

4

izs"kd]mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼ukå½]djukyA

lsok esa]mi;kqDr egksn;,

djukyA

Øekad 29/LVsuks fnukad 22&07&2016

fo"k;% Extract of the Proceedings of the meetings of the committee on Petitions

held on 06-06-2016.

;knh

mijksDr fo"k; ij vkids dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad 1433@ld fnukad06-04-2016 ds lanHkZ esaA

fo"k;k/khu ekeys esa Jh ujs’k dqekj iq= y[kehjk flag fuoklh xkao xxM eMkSyh rglhyNNjksyh ftyk ;equkuxj dk f’kdk;r i= mik;qDr djuky ds ek/;e ls cjk;s tkap bldk;kZy; esa izkIr gqvk gSA f’kdk;rdrkZ dk eq[;r% vkjksi gS fd mlds ukuk lhrk iq= nhuk dh32 duky 18 ejys Hkwfe xkao x<hHkyy rglhy ?kjkSaMk esa fLFkr gSA tksfd izkFkhZ ds ukuk usrglhynkj lsYl djuky ls [kqyh cksyh esa j?kchjk] vehpan] uxhuk] xksih vkfn ds lkFk [kjhnhFkh vkSj ftldk bardky uå 697 eky fjdkMZ esa 24 ch?ks ntZ gS tkfd bLrseky ds ckn bardkyuå 742 jdck 32 duky 18 ejys ntZ gqvk vkSj fQj mlds ckn bardky uå 804 ntZ gqvkftldk vey tekcanh lky 1971&72 esa crkSj ekfyd vk;kA izkFkhZ us rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk dksvuqjks/k fd;k fd mlds ukuk dh eR;q gks pqdh gS blfy, mlds ukuk ds okjlkuks ds bardky ntZo rlnhd fd, tkosA ysfdu gYdk iVokjh o dkuwuxks us rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk dks xqejkg djrs gq,fjIkksVZ nh fd mDr tehu vuqlkj bardky uå 944&945&946 vU; fdlh O;fDr ds uke pyhxbZ gSA blfy, bldk bardky lhrk ds okjlkuks ds uke ugha gks ldrkA tc izkFkhZ }kjk bl ekeysesa Nkuchu dh xbZ rks irk pyk fd bardky uå 944&945&946 QthZ gS rFkk bu bardkyks lslEcaf/kr dkxtkr rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk dks fn[kk, ysfdu rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk }kjk mldh leL;k dklek/kku u fd;kA izkFkhZ us izkFkZuk dh gS fd mldk o vU; lkfFk;ks dk fjdkMZ nq:Lr djokdjbardky btZ djok;k tk;s rFkk nks"khx.k ds f[kykQ dkuwuh dk;Zokgh dh tkosA

mijksDr f’kdk;r ds laca/k esa lHkh lEcaf/kr dks lquk x;k rFkk muds c;ku dyec}fd, x,A

Jh ujs’k iq= y[kehkj mez yxHkx 50 lky fuoklh xkao euMksyh xxM rglhy NNjksyhftyk ;qeukuxj us C;ku fd;k fd o"kZ 1965 esa esjs ukuk lhrk iq= ohuk us 24 chxs 0 chLok Hkwferglhynkj lsYl djuky ls 2000 # esa [kjhnh FkhA ftldk bardky uå 697 eky fjdkMZ esa ntZ

5

gSA mlds ckn pdcanh ds fy, bardky uå 741 ntZ gqvk o pdcanh ds ckn fely gfd;r uå742 rdlhe ntZ gqvkA tksfd Hkwfe fLFkr xkao x<hHkyy eqjCck uå 17 fdyk uå 11@2¼0&18½]12 ¼8&0½] 19 ¼8&0½] 20 ¼8&0½ dqy jdck 32 djuky 18 ejys eky fjdkMZ esa ntZ gqvkA mldsckn bardky uå 804 ntZ gqvk ftlesa gesa Hkwfe fLFkr xkao x<hHkyy eqjCck uå 157 fdyk uå1 ¼8&0½] 2 ¼8&0½] 3 ¼8&0½ 4 ¼7&18½] 5 ¼1&0½ dqy jdck 32 duky 18 ejys lhrk dks feykAtksfd tekcanh o"kZ 1971&72 esa ntZ gqvkA bl tekcanh esa dqN jiV fy[kh gqbZ gS tSls fd jiVjkstukepk uå 68 bardky uå 1003 945 cS;] 946 cS; fy[kk gqvk gS ;g bUnzkt xyr gS D;ksafdtc bardky uå 944 dk gh dksbZ vfLrRo u gS rks bardky uå 945&946&1003 dSls gks ldrsgS tksfd bardky uå 944 dh :g ls fd, x, gSA bardky uå 944 dHkh eatwj u gqvk vkSj ekyfjdkMZ esa Økl dk fu’kku gqvk gS D;ksafd blesa ntZ bUVªh rcknys gdqQ ckgqde vnkyr le ttntkZ 1 ikuhir dsl uå 97 frfFk 18-12-1970 QthZ gS vkSj blds vykok bardky uå 945 Hkh QthZgS D;ksafd bardky uå 944 1973 esa ntZ gqvk rks ekMk oxSjg 1971 esa dSls 99 o"kZ dk iVVk djldrs gS blfy, bl bardky uå 945 dks Hkh lEcaf/kr rglhynkj us dHkh eatwj u fd;k gS vkSj;fn bardky uå 945 dks lgh eku fy;k tk;s tkfd ekMk oxSjg ds 99 o"kZ ds iVVs ij vk/kkfjrgS rks ekMk oxSjg us mijksDr Hkwfe dk 99 o"kZ ds fy, iVVk dj fn;k rk ml iVVk djus ds lkFkgh mldk lEca/k ml Hkwfe ls LkekIr gks tkrk gS vkSj ;g laca/k lekIr gksus ds mijkar Hkh og vxysfnu bardky uå 946 esa ntZ cSukek dSls cS; jftLVªh dj ldrs gS blfy, bardky uå 946 dksHkh fdlh rglhynkj us dHkh eatwj u fd;kA vr% tc bardky uå 944&945&946 gh xSj dkuwuhgS vkSj budk dksbZ vfLrRo u gS rks bardky uå 1003 dh Hkh dksbZ oS/krk ugha jgrhA bl Hkwfe dksesjs iwoZtks us dHkh fdlh O;fDr] laLFkk ;k ljdkj dks jgu] cS; oXkSjg }kjk u cspk gS vkSj u gh;g jdck gekjs iwoZtks ls dHkh dSflay gqvk gS vkSj u gh bl Hkwfe ds cnys eydh;r Hkwfe fdlhvU; xkao ;k cygsMk esa ugha feyh gS vkSj u gh fdlh Hkwfe dk bl Hkwfe ds cnys gekjs iwoZtks dsuke bardky ntZ gS vkSj u gh xkao cygsMk dh tehu ls lhrk iq= nhuk dk dksbZ ysuk nsuk gSAesjk iwoZt lhrk iq= nhuk vui< FkkA ekStwnk tehu tks bardky uå 804 esa ntZ gS vkSj ftls xyrrjhds ls ljdkjh vf/kdkfj;ks }kjk [knqZcqnZ fd;k x;k gS ml Hkwfe dks <q<rs&<q<rs lkjh mez xqtkjnh vkSj ej x;k vksj esjh Hkh vk/kh ls T;knk mez fudy xbZA ysfdu lQyrk rc feyh tc esjsekek ds yMds d`"k.k iky dh vihy fdlh vU; tehu ls lEcaf/kr fnukad 19-12-2013 dkseydh;r u gksus dh otg ls [kkfjt dj nh vkSj mlus tc vkjVhvkbZ ,DV ds rgr rglhynkjls lwpuk ekaxh rks fnukad 26-08-2014 dks rglhynkj us tks lwpuk nh rc bardky uå 804 dkgesa irk pykA ;g fd gesa vius iwoZt lhrk jke ls ;g Hkh irk pyk fd lhrkjke ls dkxtks ijvaxwBk yxokus ckjs dbZ ckj iqfyl ls fiVok;k x;k Fkk o csbZTtrh djokbZ xbZA fQj gerglhynkj ?kjkSaMk ls feys vkSj mUgsa nj[kkLr nsdj vuqjks/k fd;k fd lhrk iq= nhuk dh tehudk bardky mlds dkuwuh okjlks ds uke ntZ dj fy;k tkos rks rglhynkj lkgc us igys gkadj nh ckn esa badkj dj fn;k vkSj mlus bardky ntZ djus ds fy, 30 yk[k : dh fj’or ekaxhvkSj iSls u nsus ij gekjk bardky ntZ u fd;kA

Jh jes’k flaxyk] rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk us C;ku fd;k fd mlds }kjk mDr ekeys esa foLrrfjiksVZ Øekad 291@vksds fnukad 22-06-2016 ftyk jktLo vf/kdkjh djuky dks Hksth xbZ Fkh mlh

6

dks mlds C;ku le>s tkosA rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk }kjk fcUnqokj foLrr fjiksVZ ftyk jkTkLo vf/kdkjh]djuky dks izLrqr dh xbZ Fkh fuEu izdkj ls gS]

1- bUrdky u 697]741]803] dk fgUnh dk vuqokn djokdj lkFk lyXu gSA rFkk944]945]946]1003 dh LkR;kfir izfr lkFk lyaXu gSA

2- xkao x<hHkyy dh jiV u 442 fnukad 10&07&1968 dk jkspukepk miyC/k ugha gqvkAiVokjh gYdk x<hHkyy dbZ ckj jkstukepk ysus ds fy, ikuhir x;k ysfdu dkQhryk’k djus ds ckn Hkh jkspukepk 1968 izkIr ugha gqvk ;g xkao x<hHkyy gYdk cjkukds lkFk layXu Fkk tks vc ftyk ikuhir esa gSA

3- xkao x<hHky esa jiV u 68 frfFk 01&11&1972 dk voyksdu fd;k x;k voyksdumijkUr ik;k x;k fd ftu 12 vykfV;ku dk jDck jÌ fd;k x;k Fkk mä vykVhekStqnk fjdkZM esa uk rks ekfyd gS u gh ekSdk ij dCtk gS vkSj uk gh eqtkjs gSA ekSdkij ekfyd o dCtk ckjs rS;kj dh xbZ lqfp ;[k) xkao x<hHkyy lkFk layXu gSA

4- fQYM LVkQ rglhy ?kjkS.Mk ls xkao cygsMk ckjs fjdkZM eky o ekSdk fjiksZV yh xbZrFkk fjdkZM voyksdu djus mikjUr ik;k x;k fd xkao cygsMk esa jiV u 10 fnukad10&09&1972 ds rgr tks jDck 12 vykfV;ks dks vykV fd;k x;k Fkk mu esa ls xksihiq= NTtq] ekaxk iq= [ktku] fxjoj iq= mejk o UkRFkq iq= jketh yky ds ukerglhynkj lSYl }kjk cS; dh jftLVªh dh xbZ gS o lhrk iq= nhuk xSj e:lh jDck32&18 dk lky 2002 rd bl jDck ij dkfct jgk bl ds ckn gkfll iq= eqU’kh½ oftlku lkfnj] ;kdqc] ;kuqt] jkfln iq=ku tXxk ds uke fxjnkojh xSj e:lhrRdkyhu iVokjh gYdk }kjk dh xbZ blds ckn mä 32&18 ejys dh fxjnkojh jivu 57 fnukad 31&10&05 ds rgr Ae-IInd Grade, Gharaunda }kjk cÙkkSj fgLlsnkjrcnhy dh xbZ ckfd vykfV;ks dk ekSdk ij bl le; dCtk ugh gSA ds uke mu [kljkuEcjku ij ekStqnk fjdkZM esa mä vykVh uk rks ekfyd gS u gh eqtkjs gS vkSj u ghekSdk ij dCtk gS fjdkZM vuqlkj ekfyd o ekSdk fLFkrh ij dCtk ckjs lwph ;d) xkaocygsMk lkFk layXu gSA

5- dsl uaa0 939 fnukad 19&09&2005 ds ewy QkbZy dh lHkh dkxtkr lfgr Nk;k izfrA

6- Nk;k izfr jiV u 57 frfFk 03&10&05 ckcr n:Lrh fxjnkojhA

7- flfoy dksVZ esa bu bUrdkykr ls lEcfU/kr ,d dsl U;k;kyl Jh xxu nhi feÙkyts0Mh0 djuky ds U;k;ky; }kjk fnukad 14&09&2011 dks ,d QSlyk vk;k Fkkftldh vihy ekuuh; vfrfjDr lS'ku tt djuky ds U;k;ky; ls 19-12-2013 dksQSlyk gqvk tks vihy [kkfjt dh xbZ dh Nk;k izfr lkFk layXu gSA bldh vfrfjä,d flfoy lqV bUgh bUrdky ckjs d".k iky cuke gfj;k.kk ljdkj flfoy U;k;ky;esa fnukad 13&7&16 ds fy, yfEcr gSA ftldk tokc nkok nk;j fd;k tkuk gS ftldhNk;k izfr lkFk lyaXu gSA

;gka ;g Hkh Li"V fd;k tkuk mfpr gksxk fd f’kdk;r drkZ ujs’k vkfn us tks Hkwfe lhrkiq= nhuk ckjs ekax dh gS og Hkwfe xkao x<hHkyy ls rglhynkj lSYl ds vuqlkj cnydj xkao

7

cygsMk esa nh xbZ Fkh ftldk dCtk Hkh ns fn;k x;k Fkk jiV 68 ij lhrk iq= nhuk ds dCtk izkIrdjus ckjs gLrk{kj Hkh gSA

Jh jkefuokl rglhynkj lsYl djuky us C;ku fd;k fd cLrh nsohiqj nk[kyh ekStkx<h Hkjy ds dqN ifjokjks us fnukad 01-01-62 dks mik;qDr djuky dks vkosnu i= fn;k fd budheydhr; jdck teuk unh esa cqnZ gks x;k gs vkSj muds xqtkjks fd fy, ekStk x<h Hkjy esa 20lky ds iVVs ij Hkwfe nh tkosA mik;qDr djuky us bl vkosnu i= ij vkns’k fn;k fd izfrO;fDr dks 5 ,dM osLV ys.M nh tk;s o iqfyl }kjk dCtk fnyok;k tk;sA bl vkns’k dh ikyukesa bu ifjokjks dks jIkV jkstukepk 499 frfFk 30-06-62 ij dCtk fn;k x;k ckn esa ea=h ifj"kn¼Council of Ministers½ us ;g QSlyk fd;k fd bu izR;sd ifjokjks dks 5 ,dM Hkwfe fu/kkZfjrewY;@dher ij nh tkos tks og gksxh tks iquZokl foHkkx esa eqdjj dh gqbZ gSA bl fu.kZ; ds vuqlkjizR;sd ifjokj dks 5 ,dM Hkwfe ftldh fdLe lsyku Fkh vkSj ftldk ewY; 2000 nh xbZA ml le;bl fdLe dh Hkwfe dh dher 400 : izfr ,dM fu/kkZfjr FkhA 2000 #- dh jkf’k esa ls 500 #-izfr dqVqEc us Loa; vnk fd, vkSj 'ks"k 1500 : izfr dqVqEc crkSj dtkZ ljdkj dh vksj ls fn;kx;kA bl izdkj reke jkf’k olwy dh xbZA bl jdck dh jftLVªh gj ifjokj dks ns nh xbZA cknesa 21 dqUcks us vkosnu i= fn;k fd tks [kljk uå mudks fn, x, gS og bu [kljk uEcjku lsfHkUu gS tks muds dCtk esa gS vkSj mUgsa [kljk uå fn, tk;s tks muds dCts esa Fks ;k pdcanhesa muds dCtk esa tks uEcj gS ogha fn, tk;sA tkap iMrky ds ckn bu dqucks dks dkcy dk’rHkwfe nsus dk izLrko ljdkj dks Hkstk x;kA iquZokl foHkkx us vius Kkiu fnukad 01-04-67 }kjk6 dqucks dks igys nh xbZ tehu cgky j[kh] rhu dqucks dh vykV’kqnk tehu esa dqN rcnhyhdh vksj 'ks"k 12 dqucks dk igys jdcs ds cnys esa u, [kljk uEcjku vykV fd, x,A ysfdubudk vey njken pdcanh esa u gks ldkA ckn esa iMrky ds ckn ;g fjiksVZ Hksth xbZ fd 13dqucks dks tks jdck mudk vkjaHk esa vykV gqvk Fkk mldh tks dher pdcanh esa yxh ds cjkcjcnys esa jdck fn;k tkosA cUnkscLr vf/kdkjh] fcØh ds vkns’k fnukad 20-07-67 dh ikyuk esa bu12 ifjokjks dks cnys esa jdck fn;k x;kA dk’rk jdck dk n[ky ekydkuk vkSj Qly dk’rkdk eqvkotk rtoht ¼assess½ fd;k x;kA bu dqucks us vkosnu i= fn;k fd oks eqvkotk Qlynkf[ky ugha dj ldrs vkSj mudks Qly mBus ds ckn [kkyh jdcs dk n[ky fn;k tk;sA dqNyksdy eqtkjks us vnkyr nhokuh ikuhir esa tks jdck bu dqucks dks vykV fd;k x;k Fkk lscsn[kyh ds f[kykQ nkok nk;j fd;kA ftlesa ;g Hkh loky mBk;k x;k fd ;g jdck yksdyekydku dk gS vkSj ;g evacuee Hkwfe ugha gSA ftlesa rglhynkj fcØh dks Hkh Qjhd cuk;k x;kFkk ysfdu ckn esa mls Mªki dj fn;k x;kA vnkyr nhokuh us QSlyk fnukad 18-12-1970 dksnkosnkjks ds gd esa fd;k ftlds f[kykQ bu dqucks us vfrfjDr ftyk ,oa ls’ku tt djukydh vnkyr esa vihy nk;j dh ysfdu og [kkfjt gks xbZ d;ksafd bu dqucks us nkosnkjksa ds lkFkle>kSrk dj fy;kA

vnkyr nhokuh ikuhir ds QSlys ds ckn bu 13 dqucks us eqrckny ¼exchanged½jdck nsus ds fy, HkwriwoZ jktLo ea=h rFkk iquZokl foHkkx dks vkosnu i= fn, vkSj rglhynkjfcØh djuky ds dk;kZy; ls bl laca/k esa bl dk;kZy; iw.kZ fjiksVZ ekaxh tks fnukad 04-05-71 dksHkst nh xbZA bu dqucksa us xkao cygsMk esa eqrckny jdck ¼exchanged land½ nsus ds fy, vkosnu

8

i= fn;k FkkA ftl jdcs dh rtoht ¼proposal½ Hksth xbZ Fkh mlesa vf/kdrj jdck og Fkk tksigys lhfer cksyh esa gjhtuks dks uhyke fd;k x;k Fkk tks fd’rs vnk u djus ds dkj.k okfilys fy; x;k Fkk vkSj C;kuk dh jde tCr dj yh xbZ FkhA ckn esa ;g jdck uhykeh esa j[kk x;kysfdu bl ij Hkh fdlh igys [kjhnnkj us ftlls okfil Hkwfe yh xbZ Fkh u rks nksckjk cksyh nhxbZ vkSj u gh fd’r vnk djus ds fy, vkosnu i= fn;kA ckn esa muls iwNrkN Hkh dh xbZA ysfdufdlh us fd’rs vnk ugha dhA ftl ckjs iw.kZ fjiksVZ voj lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj iquZokl foHkkx]paMhx< dks Hksth xbZA iquZokl foHkkx us vius Kkiu uå t&1 ¼151½@9634 dated 02-08-1972 }kjklwfpr fd;k fd ljdkj us bl dk;Zy; dks vuqefr iznku dj nh gS vkSj vkxkeh dk;Zokgh iquZoklfoHkkx ds fu;ekuqlkj dh tkosA bl vkns’k ds vuqlkj bu dqucks dks ;g jdck ftldk lq>koHkstk x;k Fkk mudks vykV dj fn;k x;k vkSj iVokjh gYdk dks budk dCtk fu;ekuqlkj nsusdk vkns’k fn;k x;kA bl laca/k esa ;g Hkh o.kZu fd;k tkuk mfpr gksxk fd bu 12 dqucks esa ls6 dqucks us fQj vkosnu i= fd;k fd tks jdck mudks fn;k x;k gS oks fudEeh gS o dkfcys dk’ru gS vkSj mUgsa cnys esa nwljk jdck fn;k tk;sA bl laca/k esa iquZokl foHkkx us fjiksVZ ekaxh vkSjrRdkyhu rglhynkj fcØh }kjk i= Øekad 2630@Vh,lds fnukad 12-12-72 }kjk fjiksVZ vojlfpo] foHkkx gfj;k.kk ljdkj dks Hkst nhA ftl ij tkap djus mijkar voj lfpo gfj;k.kkljdkj paMhx< ds i= Øekad th&1@¼151½@63@10332 fnukad 09-07-173 loZJh 1- veh paniq= eaxr jke 2- :Mk iq= ukscr 3- :Mk iq= ghjk 4- :fy;k iq= ekejkt 5- ekaxk iq= jkeLo:i6- eq[fr;kjk iq= gtkjh fuoklh nsohiqj dks tksa Hkwfe vykV dh Fkh ds cnys esa Hkwfe nwljs LFkkuij vykV dh tkos vkSj Hkwfe tks muds dCts esa gS mls uhyke fd;k tkos ftl ckjs rRdkyhurglhynkj fcØh }kjk vkns’k ikfjr dj fn, x,A vly QkbZy esa nLrkost mnwZ esa fy[ks gq, gSftldk fgUnh vuqokj mnwZ tkuus okys ls djok;k x;k gS tks layXu gSA

Jh okftn vyh iq= Jh lykeqnhu fuoklh xkao cygsMk us C;ku fd;k fd gjhiky]egkojh o pUnk iq= Jh lhrk jke iq= Jh nhuk jke ;g tehu eqrutk 32 duky 18 ejys tksfdbu rhuks ds firk ds uke Fkh tks ;g tehu mUgksus vlhe iq= eqU’kh iq= rqaxy cygsMk 1@2 Hkkxo thlku lkfcj lquql ;kdqc jk’khn leh lHkh 1@2 Hkkx fuoklhx.k xkao eq.Mhx<h dks fnukad26-03-2002 dks csp nh Fkh og ekSds ij fxjnkojh buds uke djokus ckjs gYQukek fn;k Fkk ftldhQksVksizfr lkFk layXu dj nhA mlds ckn g’khe oXkSjg us ;g tehu cjk;s bdjkjukek frfFk09-11-2002 dks ;qlqQ vyh iq= vykcD’k iq= lDdq xkao cygsMk dks csp nh FkhA vusDlj&ch bldsckn ;qlqQ vyh iq= vukcD’k us ;g tehu 23-03-2005 dks bljku iq= eqU’kh iq= vYykcD’kfuoklh xkao cygsMk dks csp nh Fkh ftldk C;ku gYQh vusDlj lh gSA blds ckn bljku iq=eqU’kh us ;g tehu lk[kk iq= lkcqnh dks csp nhA

lEcaf/kr O;fDr;ks ds c;kuks o tkap ds nkSjku izLrqr fd, x, nLrkostks o QkbZy dsvoyksdu ls ik;k tkrk gS fd rglhynkj lsYl }kjk izLrqr fd, x, fjdkMZ o C;ku ls Li"Vgksrk gS fd cLrh nsohiqj nk[kyh ekStk x<h Hkjy ds dqN ifjokjks us fnukad 01-01-62 dks mik;qDrdjuky dks vkosnu i= fn;k fd budh eydh;r jdck teuk unh esa cqnZ gks x;k gS vkSj mudsxqtkjs ds fy, ekStk x<h Hkjy esa 20 lky ds iVVs ij Hkwfe nh tkosA mik;qDr djuky us blvkosnu i= ij vkns’k fn, fd izfr O;fEr dks 5&5 ,dM osLV ys.M nh tk;s o iqfyl }kjk dCtk

9

fnyok;k tk;sA bu vkns’kksa dh ikyuk esa bu ifjokjks dks jiV jkstukepk 449 frfFk 30-06-62 ijdCtk fn;k x;kA ckn esa ea=h ifj"kn us ;g QSlyk fd;k fd bu izR;sd dks 5&5 ,dM Hkwfefu/kkZfjr ewY;@dher ij nh tkos] dher og gksxh tks iquZokl foHkkx }kjk eqdjj dh gqbZ gSA blfu.kZ; ds vuqlkj izR;sd ifjokj dks 5&5 ,dM+ Hkwfe ftldh fdLe lSykc Fkh vkSj ftldh dher2000 nh xbZA 2000 : dh jkf’k esa ls 500 : izfe dqVqEc us Loa; vnk fd, vkSj 'ks"k 1500 :izfe dqVqEc crkSj dtkZ ljdkj dh vksj ls fn;k x;kA bl izdkj reke jkf’k olwy dh xbZA bljdck dh jftLVªh gj ifjokj dks ns nh xbZA ckn esa 21 dqUcks us vkosnu i= fn;k fd tks [kljkuå mudks fn, x, gS og bu [kljk uEcjku ls fHkUu gS tks muds dCtk esa gS vkSj mUgsa os [kljkuå fn, tk;s tks muds dCts esa Fks ;k pdcanh esa muds dCtk esa tks uEcj gS ogha fn, tk;sAtkap iMrky ds ckn bu dqucks dks dkcy dk’r Hkwfe nsus dh rtoht ljdkj dks Hksth xbZAiquZokl foHkkx us vius Kkiu fnukad 01-04-67 }kjk 6 dqucks dks igys nh xbZ tehu cgky j[kh]rhu dqucks dh vykV’kqnk tehu esa dqN rcnhyh dhs vksj 'ks"k 12 dqucks dks igys jdcs dseqrckny ¼inexchange½ u, [kljk uEcjku vykV fd, x,A ysfdu budk vey njken pdcanhesa u gks ldkA ckn esa iMrky ds ckn ;g fjiksVZ Hksth xbZ fd 12 dqucks dks tks jdck mudks vkjaHkesa vykV gqvk Fkk mldh tks dher pdcanh esa yxh ds cjkcj eqrckny jdck fn;k tkosA cUnkscLrvf/kdkjh fcØh ds vkns’k fnukad 20-07-67 dh ikyuk esa bu 13 ifjokjks dks eqrckny jdck fn;kx;kA dk’rk jdck ekydkuk vkSj Qly dk’rk dk eqvkotk rtoht fd;k x;kA bu dqucks usvkosnu i= fn;k fd oks eqvkotk Qly nkf[ky ugha dj ldrs vkSj mudks Qly mBus ds ckn[kkyh jdcs dk n[ky fn;k tk;sA dqN yksdy eqtkjks us vnkyr nhokuh ikuhir esa tks jdckbu dqucks dks vykV fd;k x;k Fkk ls csn[kyh ds f[kykQ nkok fd;k ftlesa ;g Hkh loky mBk;kx;k fd ;g jdck yksdy ekydku dk vkSj evacuee Hkwfe ugha gSA ftlesa rglhynkj fcØh dksHkh Qjhd cuk;k x;k Fkk ysfdu ckn esa mls Mªki dj fn;k x;kA vnkyr nhokuh us QSlyk nkosnkjksds gd esa fd;k ftlds f[kykQ bu dqucks us vfrfjDr ftyk ,oa las’ku tt djuky dh vnkyresa vihy nk;j dh ysfdu og [kkfjt gks xbZ D;ksafd bu dqucks us nkosnkjks ds lkFk le>kSrk djfy;kA ;gka ;g mYys[k djuk vko’;d gS fd mDr nhokuh dsl esa f’kdk;rdrkZ dk ukuk ewyvykVh Jh lhrk cdk;nk i{k cuk;k x;k FkkA U;k;ky;ks ds QSlys ds mijkar rcknyk’kqnk jdck¼Exchanged Land½ dk vkosnu HkwriwoZ jktLo ea=h dks bl vk/kkj ij fn;k fd tks jdCkk mUgsafn;k x;k gS og cgqr ?kfV;k fdLe dk gS rFkk mUgsa vPNk jdck fn;k tk;sA bl vkosnu esa izkFkhZdk ukuk Jh lhrk Hkh ’kkfey FkkA ljdkj }kjk mudk vuqjks/k Lohdkj djrs gq, bu dqucks dk iqu%jdck vykV djus dh vuqefr nh vkSj mudks xkao cygsMk esa igys jdcs ds cnys esa nwljk jdcknsus dh eatwjh nh xbZA ewy i=ks dh izfr;k QkbZy ij gSA

rglhynkj ?kjkSaMk }kjk viuh fyf[kr C;ku ds ek/;e ls fLFkfr Li"V dh xbZ gS fdewy vykVh Jh lhrk dks vykV dh xbZ Hkwfe xkao x<hHkjy esa rglhynk lsYl ds vuqlkj cnydjxkao cygsMk esa nh xbZ Fkh vkSj mldk dCtk Hkh lhrk us izkIr dj fy;k Fkk vkSj eqrkfcd fxjnkojh;g jdck tks xkao cygsMk esa fLFkr Fkk og izkFkhZ ds okjlks }kjk o"kZ 2002 esa 26-03-2002 dks ,dC;ku gYQh nsdj viuh lgefr izdV djrs gq, mDr Hkwfe dh fxjnkojh loZJh gkf’ke iq= eqU’kh1@2 Hkkx tks’kku vkfn 1@2 Hkkx ds gd esa rCnhy djokbZA blds mijkar gkf’ke] tks’kku vkfn

10

ds uke ls bl Hkwfe dh fxjnkojh o"kZ 2003 esa ;qlqQ iq= vYykcD’k ds uke crkSj xSj ekS:lhrCnhy gksuh ikbZ xbZ gSA bl Hkwfe ij 12 vykfV;ks ftuesa lhrk iq= nhuk ¼f’kdk;rdrkZ dk ukuk½Hkh ’kkfey gS o"kZ 2002 rd eqrkfcd jktLo fjdkMZ 32 duky 18 ejyk ij dkfct jgs vkSj bljdck dh fxjnkojh jiV uå 57 fnukad 31-10-2005 ds rgr rRdkyhu lgk;d dysDVj f}rh;Js.kh ?kjkSaMk }kjk rCnhy dh xbZA f’kdk;rdrkZ dk eq[; vkjksi gS fd tks Hkwfe rcknyk djds xkaocygsMk esa mlds ukuk Jh lhrk dks vU; 11 dqUcks ds lkFk nh xbZ Fkh og lkjh dk;Zokgh QthZ gStcfd bl laca/k esa ewy fjdkMZ tks rglhynkj fcØh }kjk izLrqr fd;k x;k gS ls ik;k tkrk gSfd ljdkj }kjk mDr rcknys dh eatwjh fof/kor iznku dh gqbZ gS rFkk ewy fjdkMZ rglhynkjlsy ds dk;kZy; esa miyC/k gS ftldk voyksdu fd;k x;k gS rFkk mldh izfr;ka Hkh QkbZy ijmiyC/k djokbZ xbZ gSA vr% f’kdk;rdrkZ dk ;g vkjksi fujk/kkj gSA tgka rd f’kdk;rdrkZ dk;g vkjksi gS fd bardky uå 944 dHkh eatwj u gqvk gS blfy, mlds vk/kkj ij fd, x, bardky945 o 946 xyr gS bl ckjs Li"V fd;k tkrk gS fd bardky uå 944 esa n’kkZ;k x;k jdck mlhfLFkfr vuqlkj dysDVj egksn; djuky ds vkns’k fnukad 25-12-75 tks flfoy U;k;ky; ikuhirds vkns’k fnukad 18-12-70 ds vk/kkj ij ikfjr fd;k x;k Fkk] dh ikyuk esa bardky uå 1003Lohd`r gks pqdk gS ftldh izfr fjdkMZ ij gSA vr% ;g vkjksi Hkh fujk/kkj ik;k x;k gSA ;gka ;gHkh mYYks[k djuk mfpr gS fd bardky dh dk;Zokgh o fxjnkojh dh dk;Zokgh jktLo foHkkx dh,d yxkrkj izfØ;k gS vkSj ;fn dksbZ O;fDr lgk;d dysDVj ds }kjk ikfjr vkns’kks ls vlarq"Vgks rks og fu;ekuqlkj vihy l{ke jktLo U;k;ky; esa djds mlesa nq:Lrh fof/kor rjhds lsdjok ldrk gSA vr% bl laca/k esa f’kdk;rdrkZ }kjk dksbZ izkFkZuk i= ;k vihylEcaf/kr jktLo U;k;ky;@vf/kdkjh ds lEeq[k izLrqr u dh gSA tks ,d U;kf;d izfØ;k dk HkkxgSA fu;eks ds vuqlkj jktLo fjdkMZ esa ;fn dksbZ rduhdh ;k fyfid =qfV jg tkrh gS rks mlesanq:Lrh djus dh ’kfDr;ka jktLo vf/kdkjhx.k ds ikl gS ijarq orZeku dsl esa leLr izfØ;kgfj;k.kk ljdkj dh Lohdfr ds mijkar dh xbZ gS vkSj jkTkLo fjdkMZ ds ckjs esa dHkh dksbZ f’kdk;rizkIr u gqbZ gS rFkk mijksDr rF;ks ds voyksdu ls Hkh ik;k tkrk gS fd jktLo fjdkMZ esa fdlhizdkj dh dksbZ xyrh ugha gqbZ gS ftldh nq:Lrh dh vko’;drk gksA mijksDr rF;ks ds n`f"Vxrf’kdk;r i= fujk/kkj ik;k x;k gS rFkk bls nkf[ky n¶Rkj fd;k tkuk mfpr gksxkA fjiksVZ vkidhlsok esa vkxkeh dk;Zogh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

¼gLrkå½mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼uk0½

djukyA

The Committee orally examined the Deputy Commissioner, Karnal,

Tehsildar, Ghauranda, Distt. Karnal and Petitioners and discussed the petition in

brief in its meeting held on 10.01.2017. The Committee give its observation on its

meeting held on 16.05.2017, which reads as under: -

11

The Committee considered the Petition of Sh. Naresh Kumar and others

in its meeting held on 22.12.2015. The Committee also orally examined the D. C.,

Karnal, DRO, Karnal and Tehsildar, Gharaunda, Distt. Karnal in respect of petition

submitted by Sh. Naresh Kumar, Ramesh Kumar and Salinder Kumar S/o Sh.

Lakhmira Singh R.o Vill Mandoli Gagad, Tehsil Chhachhraouli, Distt. Yamunanagar,

regarding complaint against Revenue Department in its meetings held on 06.06.2016,

28.06.2016 and 03.10.2016. The Committee observed that the case is very old. The

Committee is not in position to examine such a case where the title of a land is to

be decided. The matter falls under the jusrisdiction of Civil Court. The aggrieved

party can seek remedy through Court of Law. Therefore, the Committee decided to

dispose-of the petition accordingly.

————————

2. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SHRI RAJENDER

KUMAR AND PREET SINGH, BOTH ART MASTER, GOVT. ARTSSCHOOL, SECTOR 6, I.T.I CAMPUS, ROHTAK, REGARDING GRADEPAY OF ARTS MASTER.

The Petition/ Representation received form Shri Rajender Kumar and Preet singh,

reads as under:-

lsok esa

ps;jeSuPetition Committee

fo/kku lHkk] gfj;k.kk]lSDVj&1] p.Mhx<+A

fo"k;%& vf/kdkjh Js.kh&I dh Degree ij Roll No. vafdr u gksus dkj.k Degree dh rgdhdkrdjus ckjs] o Rs. 4800/- Pay Band esa Hkjs in izfr esjk vkosnu u Hkstus dkj.kinksUufr nsus@fnyokus ckjs] ¼izkFkZuk i=½A

ekU;oj egksn;]

fuosnu gS fd M.D. University, Rohtak us R.T.I Act-05 esa izkIr Degree ij Roll

No. vafdr u gksus dkj.k Fair/Fresh & visible Photocopy ds fy, Advise fd;k gSA ¼Degree

o M.D.V dk i= layXu½A

1- nwljh ckj foKkfir in izfr HPSC ds i= Øå RG.88/375 fnukad 20-4-1990 vuqlkjesjh ;ksX;rk dks Ignore djds ;g in Hkjk x;k FkkA bu fu;qDr vf/kdkjh dk vkosnui= foHkkx esa u feyus dkj.k F.I.R. lSDVj&17 p.Mhx<+ esa 3@2015 dks gqbZgS&lwpukFkZ gSA

12

v/;{k egksn; fo/kku lHkk gfj;k.kk] p.Mhx< us Hkh esjs i=ks dk voyksdu djdsinksUufr ckjs ßeq[; ea=h egksn;] eq[; lfpo] ea=h egksn;] foÙkk;qDr ,oa iz/kku lfpo]funs’kd dks 1@2015 dks fy[kk@dk;Zokgh vHkh Hkh v/kwjh gSA

2- fnukad 25-1-2013 dks foHkkx us eq>s inksUufr ckjs vkQ’k i= nsus mijkUr 13-9-2013dks iqu% foKkfir in Rs. 4800/- Pay Band esa gksus ij vkosnu le; ij dj fn;kFkk tksfd Govt. Art School, Rohtak Ind.Trg.Deptt. ds Dispach No. 499 o 500ij vafdr gS o eSus Hkh R.T.I Act-05 ds vUrZxr izkIr fd;k gSAmijksDr gqbZ o"kZ 1991 dh fu;qfDr o Rs. 4800/- Pay Band dk Hkjk vkosnu i= dkse/;Uktj j[krs gq, eq>s inksUufr in bu Pay Band esa nsus@fnyokus dh d`ik@d"VdjsaA

l/kU;oknfrfFk 1-7-2015uksV%&uksV%&uksV%&uksV%&uksV%& lEcfU/kr of.kZr i= igys gh dbZ ckj foHkkx dks Hksts tk pqds gSA

izkFkhZRajinder Kumar,

Preet Singh H.No. 490/5, Gobindgarh farm,

# L-11 New Kailash Nagar Jagadhari (YNR) Haryana.

Model Town, Ambala city

The Petition/representation was place before the Committee in its meeting

held on 18.02.2015, the Committee considered the same and desired that the

comments of the concerned department may be obtained witin a period of 15 days.

The Haryana Industrial Training Directorate, has sent their reply/comments vide

their letter No. KC/TP/4/Pay Anomaly/Art Master/128, dated 18.03.2015 which reads

as under:-

To

The Principal Secretary,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat,

Sector-1, Chandigarh 160001.

Memo No: KC/TP/4/Pay Anomaly/Art Master/128 Dated: 18/3/15

Subject:Regarding Grade Pay of Arts Teacher.

Kindly refer to your office letter No. HVS/Petition/14-15/2757 dated

23.2.2015 on the subject cited above.

As desired, the Comments of this office on the petition submitted by Sh.

Rajender Kumar and Preet Singh Art Master, Govt. Art School, Sector-5, I.T.I.

Campus, Rothak are enclosed herewith.

(Sd.)…,

Assistant Director (Planning)

for Director General, Industrial Traning Department,

Haryana.

13

Sr. Points raised in petiton Comments of the departmentNo.

1 The Pay Band of Rs. 3600/- has • The petitioners have mentioned Pay Band of

been granted to instructors w.e.f. Rs. 3600/- whereas it is Grade pay.

12.12.2011 by the department and • The Grade Pay of Instructor in Technical

Finance Department whereas the Education Department is also Rs. 3600/-

qualification and designation was which is similar to the Grade Pay of Instructors

similar to the instructors posted in posted in Industrial Training Department.

Technical Education Department, • The qualification of Instructor in Technical

Haryana. Education Department is lower than ITI

Department.

• The petitioner are Group-C employees and are

equivalent to Instructors in ITI Department.

2 One department has provided • The Pay Scale of Art Master posted in

equality while following the other Industrial Training Department and Education

department but the Pay Band of Department was Rs.1400-2600 from the year

Rs. 4800/- has not been granted 1986 to 1995, Rs. 5000-7850 form the year 1996

by the Industrial Training Department to 2005.

whereas qualification and • The designation is not same in ITI Department

designation of Art Master is similar and Education Department. It is Art Master in ITI

to the instructors posted in Department and It is TGT Art in Education

Education Department. Department.

• The Pay Band and Grade Pay of TGT Art is

Rs. 9300-34800+4600 in Haryana School

Education Deptt.

3. The Industrial training Department • The pau band Grade Pay of Principal Art

is running Govt. Arts School, Rohtak School Rohtak and Principal ITIs Group-B is

(Non-Technical) in which the designation Rs. 9300-34800+4200. The Art Master is

and qualification of Art Master have subordinate to the Principal and as such Pay

been kept similar to the Education band higher to senior post i.e. Principal, cannot

Department. be granted to post of Art Master.

• The designation is not same in ITI Department

and Education Department. It is Art Master in ITI

department and it is TGT Art in Education

Department.

• The qualification for the post are not similar as

compared below:

Qualification of TGT Art in Education Qualification of Art Master in Industrial

Department in 2012 Rules Training Department in 2013 Rules

1. B.F.A./B.A. and 2 year Diploma in 1. Bachelor in Fine Arts degree in

Elementary Education: OR Palnting or Masterin Fine Arts in

B.F.A./B.A. with at least 50% marks Painting from recognized university/

and 1 year Bachelor in education institution;

(B.ed,); OR 2. Hindi/Sanskriti upto Matric Standard

B.F.A./B.A. with at least 45% marks or higher education; Note: Preference

and 1 year Bachelor in Education shall be given to candidates prossessing

(B.ed) in accordance with the NCTE additional qualification of two years

(Recognition Norms and Procedure) course in Art &Craft teacher training

Regulation issued time to time in this from institute recognized by

regar: OR Industrial Training Department, Haryana.

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent)

14

with at least 50% marks and 4 year

Bachelor in Elementary Education

(B.EI.Ed.); OR

Senior Secondary (or its equlvalent)

with at least 50% marks and 4 year

BA ED.; OR

B.F.A./B.A. with at least 50% marks

and 1 year B.Ed.(Special Education);

2. In case of B.A. Arts, at least 50%

marks in Fine Art as an Elective Subject.

3. In Case of B.Ed, Fine Art as a

teaching subject from a recognized

University.

4. Certificate of having qualified

Haryana Teacher Eligibility Test (HTET)

/School Teachers Eligibility Test(STET);

5. Matric with Hindi/Sanskrit or 10+2/

B.A./M.A. with Hindi as one of the Subject.

4. The Art Master posted in this department • The Pay Scale/Pay Band has been not

are getting the same Pay Band which downgraded in previous pay commissions

they were getting before 26 years. and granted in corresponding Slabs.

• There is no disparity or anomaly at present.

5 As the instructors posted in • The demand is not based on facts due to

Polytechnics have been provided the following

same designations and qualifications, o The designation is not same in ITI Department

similarly it is requested to grant the Pay and Education Department it is Art Master

Band of Rs. 4800/- havig same in ITI department and it is TGT Art in

designation and qualification, while Education Department.

adopting the system of Education o The qualification for the posts are also

Department. In this regard, they request not similar.

has been earlier also in 2011 and 2012. o The Pay Band and Grade pay of Principal Art

School Rohtak and Vice Principal ITI Group-B

is Rs. 9300-34800+4200. The Art Master is

subordinate to the Principal and as such Pay

band higher to senior post i.e. Principal,

cannot be granted to Art Master.

o The matter of upgradation of Pay Scales of

various posts in ITi Department has been

examined earlier and the proposal was

returned by FD on 20.10.2014 with the

remarks that the proposal may be sent to

Pay Anomaly Commission when the

applications/ proposal will be invited by the

Pay Anomaly Commission.

15

The Committee orally examined the Departmental representatives and

the petitioner in its various meetings held on 13.05.2015, 29.07.2015, 10.05.2016,

12.07.2016, 03.10.2016, 25.10.2016, 14.12.2016 and 17.01.2017 and also sought

legal opinion from Advocate General, Haryana, which reas as under:-

LEGAL OPINION

Subject: Petition submitted by Sh. Rajinder Kumar and Sh. Preet Singh both

Art Master, Govt. Art School Rohtak.

After going through the file, it transpires that Sh. Rajender Kumar and Sh.

Preet Singh were appointed as Drawing Master in ITI (Women Wing). A perusal of

the file further show that the above said employees possesses qualification of degree

in technology. There was no rules framed at the time of their appointment, however,

on the basis of draft rules, appointments were made. It transpires that the rules

governing the service condition of Drawing Masters were notified in the year 1988,

as per the above said rules, a degree holder working on the post of Drawing Master

were eligible for promotion to the post of Technician-cum-Designer which is a class-

III Post, as per the above said rules, Technician-cum-Designer were further eligible

for promotion to the post of Principal. In the year 2001, 1998 Rules were amended

and as per the amended Rules, there was no further channel for promotion from the

post of Designer-cum- Technician. In view, the above said amendment, there was

stagnation at the level of the post of Designer-cum-Technician, as a consequence

of this Drawing Master were not considered for promotion to the post of Technician-

cum-Designer.

That the perusal of the file further would show that there was restructuring

done in ITIs in the State of Haryana. After the restructuring, the nomenclature of

post of Drawing Master was changed to Art Master. It is relevant to mention here

that the pay of Art Master in Education Department was fixed in the pay band of

Rs.4800/- however pay of Art Masters in ITI were fixed in the pay band of Rs.3600/-.

It is further relevant to state here that in fact the nature of duties and responsibilities

performed by Art masters in Education Department and in Women Wing in ITI was

similar. That the perusal of the file would further show that in the year 2010, post of

Art Master in ITI (Women Wing) was abolished and as a consequence of this, Sh.

Rajender Kumar and Sh. Preet Singh were adjusted in ITI i.e. Government Art

School, Rohtak. It further transpires that the courses in Art School in Rohtak was

stopped in the year 2005 and as a consequence of this, the above said employees

were appointed afresh on the post of Painter instructor in ITI. It is further relevant to

mention here that Sh. Rajender Kumar was appointed at ITI Barala and Sh. Preet

Singh was appointed at ITI Panchkula. It transpires that a perusal of the condition

of appointment letter issued in favour of above said employees would show that

above said appointment was fresh and previous service rendered by above said

employees in ITI (Woman Wing) was not to be taken into consideration for any

16

purpose except protection of their pay.. The above said appellant filed a representation

to the Committee of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha. A copy of the petition is already

attached in the file. A perusal of the petition filed by the above said employees

would show that case has been set up by the above said employees is that in fact

their fresh appointments are totally arbitrary and unreasonable. Apart from this, it is

also the case of above said employees that they should be granted same pay-band

which are given to the similar situated persons working on the same post in the

Education Department.

That the above said representation was duly considered by the Committee

and it is being observed by the Committee that the opinion should be sought from

the Ld. Advocate General Haryana. The above said Committee has marked the file

to the undersigned for rendering opinion in regard to the petition filed by Sh. Rajender

Kumar and Sh. Preet Singh.

Now, the file has been sent to undersigned for opinion as sought by the

Committee. In regard to the opinion as sought by the Committee is concerned, a

perusal of the facts mentioned above would show that in fact Sh. Rajender Kumar

and Preet Singh were appointed a Drawing Master in the year 1988 inspite of the

fact, the above said employees have approximately rendered service of almost

more than three decades, they are not to be even considered for promotion till date.

A perusal of the above said facts would show that in fact above said employees has

suffered a lot. It is relevant to mention here that the employee who joins the service

in the Government always has an expectation of getting at least one promotion in

his/her service career. In fact the above said employees have been offered fresh

appointment in the month of July, 2015 on the post of Painter Instructor. As fresh

appointment has been offered to the above said employees, the previous service

rendered by the above said employees is not to be taken into consideration for any

purpose except protection of pay, meaning thereby that the seniority of the above

said employees has to be reckoned from the date of appointment on the post of

Painter Instructor w.e.f 7th July, 2015. As the seniority has to be fixed w.e.f July,

2015, the above said employees are the junior most employees in the cadre of

Painter Instructor and cannot be considered for further promotion for the simple

reason that in fact there are many. Painter Instructor who are senior to above said

employees. Apart from this, the above said employees are also going to be retired

in the year 2019-2020. A perusal of the above said facts would show that inspite of

fact that the above said employees have almost 26 years of service in their credit

yet they are now junior most in the cadre of Painter Instructor, Painter Instructors

who have some years of service are now senior to the above said employees in the

cadre of Painter Instructor.

Taking into consideration, the above said facts, the action of department

in appointing, the above said employees a fresh on the post of Painter Instructor in

ITI is totally unreasonable and arbitrary and also violate article 14 and 16 of the

Constitution of India. In my view, department should make endeavour by way of

necessary modifications/amendment in the letter of appointment/rules in the case

of above said employees so that the previous service rendered by the above said

17

employees may be taken into consideration for the purpose of seniority so that the

above said employees may have a chance to be considered for promotion and are

also entitled for other benefits.

Sd/-

PARVINDER CHAUHAN,

Addl, Advocate General, Haryana.

During the course of oral examination the Committee received various

applications/representations from the petitioners and their counter reply from the

Department. Department has resolved various grievances of the Petitioner. A reply

received from the Principal Secretary to Govt., Haryana, Industrial Training

Department, Haryana, vide their letter No. KC/TI/Rajender & Preet Singh/Admn-II/

1438, dated 15.09.2015, which reads under:—

izs"kd]

iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj]vkS/kksfxd izf’k{k.k foHkkx gfj;k.kkA

lsok esa]

ps;jeSu] fo/kku lHkk]iSVh’ku desVh]gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk lfpoky;A

;knh Øå- dslh@VhbZ@jktsUnz o izhr flag@iz’kk&kk@1438fnukad% 15@9@15

fo"k;%& Meeting of the Committee on Petitions.

mijksDr fo"k; ij vkids i= ;kfn Øekad HVS/Petitions/2/2015-16/11304-13

fnukad 22-7-2015 o bl funs’kky; ds ;kfn Øekad dslh@VhbZ@jktsUnz o izhr flag@iz’kklu&kk@1352fnukad 21-8-2015 ds lanHkZ esaA

lwfpr fd;k tkrk gS fd Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag] dyk v/;kid] jktdh; dykLdwy] jksgrd vc isUVj vuqns’kd }kjk ps;jeSu iSVh’ku desVh fo/kkulHkk] gfj;k.kk dks nh xbZiSVh’ku ckjs bu nksuksa deZpkfj;ksa dk fnukad 25-8-2015 dks iz/kku lfpo egksn; }kjk futh :Ikls lquk x;kA futh lquokbZ ds nkSjku mUgksaus crk;k fd og VSDuhdy es vkrs gSa D;ksafd mudhfMxzh esa baftfu;fjax ds fo"k; Hkh gksrs gSaA mudh fMxzh VSDuhdy vkSj uku VSDuhdy nksuks txg

18

dke djrh gS tcfd baftfu;fjax dh fMxzh dsoy ,d txg gh dke djrh gSA mudh iz/kkukpk;Zds in ij inksUufr dk fu;eksa esa izko/kku Fkk tks ckn esa cny fn;k x;kA 27 o"kZ dh lsok esa mudhdsoy ,d ekl dh ofj"Brk gS vkSj muds i<k, fo/kkFkhZ muls ofj"B gks x;s crkrs gq, vUr esadgk fd mu }kjk tks iSVh’ku dh gqbZ gS ml ij dk;Zokgh djrs gq, iz/kkukpk;Z ds in ij inksUurdjus dk vuqjks/k fd;kA iz/kku lfpo egksn; }kjk bu nksuks deZpkfj;ksa o foHkkx nksuks dk i{k lquusmijkUr mu }kjk viuh iSVh’ku o futh lquokbZ ds nkSjku mBk, x, fcUnqvksa ckjs dsl dk fujh{k.kfd;k x;kA fujh{k.k mijkUr fcUnqckj lwpuk fuEu izdkj ls gS%&

1- Jh jktsUnz dqekj o izhr flag ds orZeku osru ckjsA

Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag ds in dk osrueku 9300&34800$3600 xzsM is gS vkSjbUgsa fnukad 11-06-2015 ds vkns’kksa ls fnukad 01-01-2015 ls r‘rh; ,0lh0ih0 osru cS.M9300&34800$4200 xzsM is ns fn;k x;k gS ¼izfr layXu½

2- Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag dks xzsM is 4800 nsus ckjsA

bl foHkkx ds LkHkh vuqns’kdks dk osru cs.M 9300&34800$3600 xzsM is gS vkSj foHkkx}kjk vkVZ ekLVjksa lfgr LkHkh vuqns’kd ftudk osrueku 9300&34800$3600 xzsM is gS mu lHkhinksa dk osrueku fuEu izdkj ls c<kus gsrq ekeyk is vukseyh desVh dks ;kfn Øekad Vhih@4@isvukseyh@izfrosnu@928 fnukad 11-04-2015 ¼izfr layXu½A }kjk Hkstk gqvk gS%&

Entry Level PB-II 9300-34800+4600 G.P.

ACP after 5 years GP Rs. 4800

After 11 years : Rs. 5400

After 17 years : Rs. 6000

Fixed Workshop Allowance per month 2000/-

3. Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag dh in laKk isUVj vuqns’kd dh ctk;s isUVj ckjsA

bu deZpkfj;ksa dh inlaKk isUVj u gksdj isUVj vuqns’kd gS vkSj lek;kstu vkns’kksaesa VkbZfiax pwd ls isUVj vafDr gks x;k Fkk tks isUVj vuqns’kd vafdr djrs gq, fnukad03-07-2015 dks la’kksf/kr vkns’k tkjh dj fn;s x;s gS ¼izfr layXu½

4- Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag dks iz/kkukpk;Z oxZ d^ ds in ij inksUur djus ckjsA

Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag us Øe’k% fnukad 13-01-1988 o fnukad 14-01-1988dks rnFkZ vk/kkj dyk v/;kid ds in ij dk;Zxzg.k fd;k Fkk vkSj bUgsa eq[; lfpo] gfj;k.kkljdkj }kjk tkjh uhfr vuqlkj fnukad 01-01-1991 ls osrueku 1400&2600 esa fu;fer fd;k x;kFkkA budh fu;qfDr efgyk foax dkMj es Fkh vkSj gfj;k.kk vkS|ksfxd izf’k{k.k ,oa O;olkf;d f’k{kkfoHkkx {ks=h; dk;kZy; xzqi ^x^ lsokfu;e] 1998 fnukad 12-2-1998 dks vf/klwfpr gq;s Fks ftuesefgyk foax dkMj ds MªkbZax ekLVj dk inksUufr dk pSuy fuEu izdkj ls Fkk%&

19

¼d½ iz/kkukpk;Z dh n’kk esa]& iz/kkukpk;Z dk ;g in oxZ x] fnukad 1-1-2006 ls osrucS.M9300&34800$3600 xzsM is Fkk ftls fnukad 12-12-2011 dks osrucS.M 9300&34800$4200 xzsM isesa vixzsM fd;k x;k gS½

(i) 75 izfr’kr eq[;k/;kfidk] rduhdh v/;kfidk] f’kYi vuqnsf’kdk] rduhf’k;u,oa fMtkbZuj esa ls inksUufr }kjk vkSj

(ii) 25 izfr’kr lh/kh HkrhZ }kjk ;k

(iii) fdlh jkT; jdkj ;k Hkkjr ljdkj dh lsok esa igys ls gh yxs fdlh deZpkjhds LFkkukUrj.k ;k izfrfu;qfDr }kjkA

¼[k½ rduhf’k;u ,oa fMtkbZuj dh n’kk esa]&

(i) MªkbZax ekLVj esa ls inksUukfr }kjk ;k

(ii) fdlh jkT; ljdkj ;k Hkkjr ljdkj dh lsok esa igys ls gh yxs fdlh deZpkjhds LFkkukUrj.k ;k izfrfu;qfDr }kjkA

¼x½ MªkbZax ekLVj] dfu"B v/;kfidk ¼dVkbZ flykbZ] d<kbZ RkFkk lwbZ dk dk;Z] MªSl esafdx]fufVax fon e’khu rFkk gs;j ,.M Ldhu ds;j½ dh n’kk esa]&

(i) lh/kh HkrhZ }kjk ;k

(ii) fdlh jkT; ljdkj ;k Hkkjr ljdkj dh lsok esa igys ls gh yxs fdlh deZpkjhds LFkkukUrj.k ;k izfrfu;qfDr }kjkA

ljdkj }kjk bu fu;eksa esa 28-02-2003 dks la’kks/ku djrs gq, iz/kkukpk;Z oxZ x^ ds in ij inksUurgksus okys inksa esa ls rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj 'kCn dks gvk fn;k x;k ¼izfr layXu½ ysfdu MªkbZaxeklVj ds in ls rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj ds in ij inksUufr dk izko/kku Fkk ¼izfr layXu½vkSj bu fu;ekuqlkj MªkbZax ekLVjksa dh rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj ds in ij inksUufr;ka gksrh jghysfdu fnukad 2-9-2009 dks tkjh LFkkbZ ofj"Brk lwph ¼izfr layXu½ vuqlkj Jh jktsUnz dqekj oJh izhr flag dh rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj ds in ij inksUufr gsrq ckjh ugh vkbZ vkSj ;fn mlle; ofj"Brk vuqlkj budh inksUufr ds fy, ckjh vkrh rks bUgs rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj dsin ij inksUur dj fn;k tkrkA bu deZpkfj;ksa ds ewy vkbZ-Vh-vkbZ efgyk foax dkMj esa iz/kkukpk;Z dk in oxZ x^ dk gS vkSj ml dkMj esa iz/kkukpk;Z oxZ d^ dk dksbZ in Lohd`r ugh gSAdyk v/;kidksa ds in lEcfU/kr laLFkkuksa esa lekIr gksus ds dkj.k bu dyk v/;kidksa dks jktdh;-dyk- Ldwy- jksgrd esa dyk v/;kidksa ds fjDr inks ds izfr fnukad 28-9-2010 dks lek;ksftrdj fn;k x;k ysfdu jk- dyk- Ldwy- jksgrd Hkh cUn dj fn, tkus ds dkj.k bu deZpkfj;ksa dksvkbZ-Vh-vkbZ- dkMj esa fnukad 3-7-2015 dks isaVj vuqns’kd ds in ds izfr lek;kstr dj fn;k x;kgSA

tgka rd fu;eksa esa la’kks/ku dk ekeyk gS rks ljdkj foHkkx dh vko’;drk vuqlkj fdlh HkhfoHkkxh; vf/klwfpr lsokfu;eksa esa dSfcusV ls vuqeksnu mijkUr la’kks/ku dj ldrh gS vkSj blfoHkkx }kjk o"kZ 2003 esa la’kks/ku djds iz/kkukpk;Z oxZ x^ dk in ftu inksa esa ls inksuufr }kjk

20

Hkjs tkus dk izko/kku Fkk] mu inksa esa ls rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj dk in gVk;k x;k gSA bufu;eksa ds vf/klwfpr gksus ls iwoZ tks deZpkjh iz/kkukpk;Z oxZ ^x^ ds in ij inksUur gks pqds Fksmudh lsokvksa ij bu fu;eksa dk dksbZ izHkko ugh iMk tcfd Jh jktsUnz dqekj o Jh izhr flag dkin dyk v/;kid dk Fkk vkSj mudh inksUufr dk vxyk in rduhf’k;u de fMtkbZuj dk Fkkftuesa dksbZ la’kks/ku ugh fd;k x;kA ls deZpkjh vc vkbZ-Vh-vkbZ- dkMj esa isaVj vuqns’kd ds inij dk;Zjr gS vkSj bl dkMj ds deZpkfj;ksa ds fy, inksUufr gsrq fu;eksa esa izko/kku fd;k gqvkgSA

foHkkx@ljdkj bu deZpkfj;ksa dk foHkkxh; vf/klwfpr lsokfu;eks o ljdkj dhfgnk;rksa ds vUrxZr tks ykHk ns ldrh Fkh] og ykHk ns fn, x, gSA bu deZpkfj;ksa dks vius dkMjesa Qkyrw gksus ds dkj.k budh lsok,a cpkus ds fy, nwljs dkMj esa lek;ksftr fd;k x;k gSA vr%,Slh fLFkfr esa ;g foHkkx@ljdkj bu deZpkfj;ksa dks bl le; fdlh Hkh in ij inksUur djusvFkok bUgs inksUur djus ds fy, fu;eksa esa dksbZ Hkh izko/kku djokus esa vleFkZ gSA

Sd/-

layXu% mijksDr vuqlkj v/kh{kd] ¼vkS|kså izf’kå½d`rs% iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj] vkS|ksfxd izf’k{k.k foHkkxA

The Committee again orally examined the departmental representatives

and the petitioner in its meeting held on 22.08.2017, in which departmental

representatives informed the Committee that maximum benefits were given to the

petitioner which petitioners are entitled and requested the Committee to dispose

the petition.

The Committee considered the department request and recommend the

department to withdraw the charge sheet issued to petitioner and consider petitioners

grievances sympataticaly and Committee disposed of the petition accordingly.

————————

3. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SHRI. ROOP CHANDVERMA, H.NO. 638, SECTOR 17, HUDA, JAGADHARI, REGARDINGRELEASING OF PAY FROM SEPTEMBER, 2014 TO 29TH JULY, 2015OF HIS DAUGHTER-IN-LAW.

The Petition/Representation received from Room Chand Verma, read as under:-

To

The Chairmain

Petitions Committee

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

21

Sub:- The on road period pay of my daughter in law Ritika Nirmal LecturerPol.Sc.G.S.S.S Sohana Distt. Gurgaon from Sep. 2014 to July 2015.

R/Sir,

It is requested that the Director Secondary Education office is harassing

my family by not releasing the salary of my daughter in law Ritika Nirmal Lecturer

Pol.Sc.G.S.S.S Sohana Distt. Gurgaon EID 94809 for the last about two years.

She filed her request Ref. No. 1736 Dt. 3-8-2015 to the director. Copy enclosed as

P.C. Thereafter I approached every hook and corner for getting This work done but

of no use. I do not remember last how may times to visted the office of DSE and

met director and Additional Director-HRC and all of no use.

After about one year on dt. 1-8-2016, I requested the Hon'ble CM all through

CM Window vide Grevience No. 2016/055104. Copy enclosed-P-2 wrote another

reminder to CM Window on dt 27-9-16 Vide Grievence

No. 2016/77486 Copy-P-3, but of no use Lasfly it was decided by the Commissioner

last such cases are not dealt on CM Window. The Decision of the Commissioner

was so painful that can’t be described because if not through CM Window my

complaint should have delt n routine manner because the complaint was with The

Commissioner.

Then again on dt. 25/11/2016 I wrote a registered letter to Hon'ble CM and

Secretary Education Haryana to release this salary copy of concern receipt P-4

Since there I have visiting DSE office about every fortnight and visited The

Commissioner office twice but of no use. Moreover it is shocking that the pay file

was returned by the Director six times by levelling different objections everytime.

The objections levelled by director proves that the office is not seen by rules but

deny by will of director.

The most painful was the second week of April 2017 when the Additional

Director misbehaved with me when I visited his office to know the status of this file.

I could not understand how the DSE office is working and what they aspect from

public by not solving their problems.

Therefore it is requested that a through enquiry the ordered into the laps of

posting order of my dauther-in-law from 21-8-2014 to 27-7-2015. Which caused a

on road period of 11 month and thereafter the non-payment of salary of these 11

months form sept. 2014 to july 2015 during the last about two year

Lastly I applied for an information of on road lecturer under-RTI on

01-08-2016 but the DSE office has not supplied this information in spile of clear

orders of its apleate authority and the information Commissoner Haryana copies

enclosed on P-6 and P-7

22

This all show the problems faced by the general public in dealing with this

office so you are requested to get the salary of my daughter-in-law released at the

earliest

I shall be highly thankful to you

Dt. 02-05-2017. Your Sincerley,

Sd/-

Roop Chand Verma,

H.no. 638, Sector-17

HUDA JAGADHARI.

The Petition/representation was placed before the Committee in its meeting

held on 09.05.2017, the Committee considered the same and desired that the

comments of the concerned department may be obtained within a period of 15

days. The representation was sent to the concerned department on 16.05.2017. As

no reply was received within the stipulated period from the Department. The

Committee called the Additional Chief Secretary to Govt., Haryana, Education

Department, Director, School Education Department, Haryana and the Petitioner in

its meeting held on 08.08.2017 and 02.01.2018, in which Additional chief Secretary

to Govt., Haryana, Education Department, has brought in the notice of the Committee

that due to non given of posting to the dauther-in-law of the petitioner she was on

road for 11 months, due to this she has not given salary of 11 months and power to

condone the waiting period is with Finance Department. In addition to it he has also

informed the Committee that he will fix accountability and a disciplinary action also

be taken against the officials who sent the wrong proposal of the daughter-in-law of

the petitioner. Thereafter, Committee received the order dated 01.01.2018, which

reads as under:-

HARYANA GOVERNMENT

SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

Order

The 1st January, 2018

Order No.2/365-2014 PGT-II(1).— The on-road period of Smt. Ritika Nirmal(094809),

PGT Political Science, Govt.Sr. Secondary School Sohna (Gurugram) from

10.09.2014 to 25.07.2015 is hereby treated as duty period spent for all intents and

purposes as provided under Rule 82, Chapter-VI Part-I, of Haryana Civil Services

Rules, 2016.

K. K. KHENDELWAL,

Additional Chief Secretary to Govt. of Haryana,

School Education Department, Chandigarh.

23

As the grievances of the petitioner has been settled. Hence, the petition

is disposed off in its meeting held on 23-2-18.

4. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SHRI SHAMSHERSINGH S/O SH. HARNAM SINGH R/O VILL KAMRI, TEHSIL & DISTT.HISAR, REGARDING ENQUIRY OF POWER ATTORNEY

The Petition/Representation received from Shri Shamsher Singh, reads as under:-

lsok esa]

ps;jeSu]

iVh’ku desVh gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk]

p.Mhx<+A

fo"k;% QthZ ikoj vkWQ vVksuhZ dh tkap djokus ckjsA

Jheku~ th]

izkFkhZ fuEufyf[kr vtZ djrk gS%&

1- izkFkhZ xkao dSejh rglhy o ftyk fglkj dk LFkkbZ fuoklh gSA

2- izkFkhZ dh xkao fcykliqj ftyk xqM+xkao rglhy ekuslj esa yxHkx 21 duky tehu gStks izkFkhZ ds uke gSA

3- ;g fd nks"kh d`".k yky iq= Jh nsoh yky gky fuoklh edku ua0 215] lSDVj&14]xqM+xkao] gfj;k.kk tksfd orZeku esa ftyk fHkokuh crkSj pdCkUnh vf/kdkjh ds inb ijdk;Zjr gSA

4- ;g fd mDr nks"kh us rglhy csjh ftyk >Ttj esa crkSj rglhynkj ds in ij jgrsgq, izkFkhZ dh mDr tehu dk o"kZ 2003 esa QthZ eq[kR;kjukek vius uke cukdj tksfdLo;a }kjk gLrk{kfjr gSA

5- ;g fd o"kZ 2008 esa mDr tehu dh nks ckj jftLVjh mijksDr eq[kR;kjukek dsvk/kkj ij Athuk Hotel PVT LTD ds uke djokbZ xbZ] mDr QeZ] ftldk ekfyd]nks"kh d`".k yky dk iq= fodkl gSA

6- ;g fd mDr nks"kh }kjk /kks[kk/kM+h djus ckcr pkSdh csjh esa nks ckj nj[kkLr nh xbZ]ysfdu fQj Hkh nks"kh ds f[kykQ dksbZ dkuwuh dk;Zokgh ugha dh xbZA nj[kkLr dkua0 30&,lMh@22&7&2014 gSA

7- ;g fd izkFkhZ us iqfyl v/kh{kd egksn;] ftyk >Ttj dks Hkh mDr ekeys ckjs nj[kkLrfy[kh] ftlesa iqfyl v/kh{kd egksn; Economic Cell dks tkap ds fy, nj[kkLrua0 1311 fnukad 06@08@2014 ds rgr Hksth xbZ] ftl ij Hkh dksbZ dk;Zokgh uk gqbZAtkap ds fy, bZdksuksfed lSy vf/kdkjh us fnukad 21-10-2014 dks izFkhZ ds gLrk{kjfeyku ckjs gLrk{kj fy, tks e/kqcu esa fjiksVZ ds fy, Hksts x,] ysfdu vktrd mDrgLrk{kj dh fjiksVZ Hkh ugha vkbZA

24

8- ;g fd ,d nj[kkLr iqfyl egkfujh{k egksn;] jksgrd dks Hkh fy[kh ftl ij dk;Zokghdjrs gq, Mh,lih /khjt dqekj us izkFkhZ ds C;ku fy;s vkSj izkFkhZ dh nj[kkLr [kkfjtdj nh vkSj izkFkhZ ds gLrk{kj feyku Hkh ugha djok,A

9- ;g gS fd izkFkhZ us ftyk Lrj ds vf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk mDr ekeys esa dksbZ dk;Zokgh uk djusds ckn ekuuh; eq[;eU=h egksn; dks fnukad 30@12@2014 dks mDr ekeys dh tkap]Mh,lih /khjt dqekj }kjk C;ku ysdj nj[kkLr dks [kkfjt djus o izkFkhZ ds gLrk{kjdk feyku u djus ckcr ,d nj[kkLr fy[kh] ftldk uEcj CMOFF/N/2014/

02671 gS] ftl ij izkFkhZ us nks"khx.k ds f[kykQ dkuwuh dk;Zokgh dk bUrtkj Fkk] ysfduizkFkhZ dh mDr nj[kkLr dk dksbZ tokc ugha feykA

10- ;g gS fd izkFkhZ us fnukad 02@03@2015 dks nksckjk ekuuh; eq[;eU=h egksn; dks ,dnj[kkLr mDr ekeys ckjs fy[kh] ftldk UkEcj CMOFF/N/2015/27856 gS ftlesaizFkhZ dh nj[kkLr ij dk;Zogh djrs gq, mik;qDr >Ttj us izkFkhZ dh nj[kkLrrglhynkj >Ttj dks Hksth] rglhynkj us mDr nj[kkLr dh dk;Zokgh djrs gq, fy[kkfd izkFkhZ dh nj[kkLr dk fcUnw 3 ls 10 rd voyksdu dj fy;k gSA izkFkhZ dks fgnk;rnh fd ;g mfpr gksxk fd rglhynkj ds fo:) ;fn dksbZ ekeyk ntZ o tkap iM+rkydjokuk pkgrk gS rks og l{ke U;k;ky; o lEcfU/kr foHkkx esa pkjk tksbZ djsA

11- ;g gS fd izkFkhZ us nksckjk fnukad 16@03@2016 dks ,d nj[kkLr Jhuku mik;qDregksn; ftyk >Ttj ds uke mDr ekeys ckjs fy[kh] ftl ij mik;qDr egksn; usekeys dh tkap nksckjk djus ckjs mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼uk0½] csjh dks HksthA mie.Myvf/kdkjh ¼uk0½] csjh us izkFkhZ ds gLrk{kj feyku ds fy, gLrk{kj fy, o lEcfU/krO;fDr;ksa ¼rglhynkj] uk;kc rglhynkj] nks xokg o olhdk uohl½ ds C;ku fy;s Amie.My vf/kdkj ¼uk0½] lat; jk;] csjh }kjk izkFkhZ ds gLrk{kj feyku ds fy,QksjSfUld ySc] e/kqcu esa dsoy QksVksdkih Hksth] tcfd ySc vf/kdkjh vly gLrk{kjdh ekax djrs gSA

12- ;g gS fd QksjSfUld ySc] e/kqcu vf/kdkjhx.kksa us mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼uk0½] csjh dks i=fy[kdj izkFkhZ dh tehu dk tks eq[R;kjukek cuk;k x;k Fkk] mldh vly dkih o izkFkhZds gLrk{kjksa dh vly dkih dh ekax dh xbZ Fkh] ysfdu mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼uk0½] csjhus nks"kh d`".k yky ds cpko ds fy, mlls lktckt gksdj rFkk ekeys dks jQknQkdjus ds fy, dsoy mDr eq[R;kjukek o gLrk{kjksa dh Nk;kizfr gh Hksth] tcfd vlynLrkost Hksts tkus pkfg, Fks] ftlls dh nks"kh dh vlfy;r lkeus vk tkrh o nks"kh}kjk dh xbZ /kks[kk/kM+h dk inkZQk’k gks ldrk FkkA

13- ;g gS fd izkFkhZ dks viuh nj[kkLr ij dksbZ dk;Zokgh gksrh utj ugha vk jgh FkhAblfy, izkFkhZ us fnukad 06@05@2016 dks iqfyl v/kh{kd >Ttj o mik;qDr egksn;]>Ttj dks nksckjk ekeys dh tkap ckjs fy[kh] ftlesa iqfyl v/kh{kd egksn; usEconomic Cell dks nksckj tkap ds fy, Hkstk vkSj mik;qDr egksn;] >Ttj usmie.My ¼uk0½ csjh dks nksckjk tkap ds fy, Hkstk tks fd ;g dk;Zokgh bUgh vf/kdkfj;ksa}kjk iwoZ esa gks pqdh gS] ysfdu dksbZ fu"d"kZ ugha fudykA

25

14- ;g gS fd nks"kh d".k yky tks fd iz’kklfud vf/kdkjh gS vkSj mPp izHkko okyk gS] ftllsdk;Zokgh esa ftyk Lrj ds vf/kdkjh nks"kh ds f[kykQ dk;Zokgh djus esa vkudkuh djjgs gSa vkSj nks"kh dk cpko dj jgs gSaA

vr% vki ekU;oj ls nj[kkLr nsdj xqtkfj’k gS fd nks"kh ds f[kykQ rqjUr izHkko ls dkuwuhdk;Zokgh djsa nks"kh }kjk in dk nq:Ik;ksx djus ok izFkhZ dh tehu dks /kks[k/kM+h ls gM+iusckcr eqdnek ntZ djds nks"kh dks inP;qr fd;k tkos vkSj izkFkhZ dh tehu okfilfnyokbZ tkosA

izkFkhZ lnSo vkidk vkHkkjh jgsxkA

fnukad% 9&5&2017 izkFkhZSd/-

'ke’ksj flag iq= Jh gjuke flagfuoklh xkao dSejh] rglhy o ftyk fglkjA

The Petition/representation was placed before the Committee in its meeting

held on 16.05.2017, the Committee considered the same and desired that

the comments of the concerned department may be obtained within a

period of 15 days. The representation was sent to the concerned department

on 24.05.2017. The Deputy Commissioner, Haryana, has sent their reply

along with the enquiry report vide their letter No. 1936/E.B, dated

07.08.2017, which reads as under:-

izs"kdmik;qä] >TtjA

izsf"kr

lfpo]gfj;k.kk fo/kku LkHkk] lfpoky;]p.Mhx<+AØekad 1936@E.B fnukad 7&8&2017

fo"k;%& Regarding enquiry of Power attorney.

————————

Mijksä fo"k; ij vkids dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad HVS/Petition/532/17-18/11122

fnukad 24@05@2017 ds lUnHkZ esaA

lanfHkZr ekeys dh tkap mie.My vf/kdkjh¼uk0½] csjh ls djokbZ xbZA tkap vf/kdkjh}kjk izLrqr tkap fjiksVZ vuqlkj Qkjasfld lkabZl ykbZczsjh e/kqcu djuky }kjk eq[kR;kjukek vke u- 4@50 fnukad 18@02@2003 ij Jh 'ke’ksj flag iq= Jh gjuke flagfuoklh 388&,@2Mh-,y-,Q- xqM+xkao fd, x, gLrk{kjksa o ml }kjk fn, x, gLrk{kjuewuksa dk feyku djokus ij mä gLrk{kjksa dk feyku ugh gqvk gSA rRdkyhurglhynkj] csjh Jh d".k yky ftlds gd esa eq[kR;kj ukek fn;k x;k gS rFkk eq[kR;kj

26

ukek vke iaftd`r djus okys Jh jks’ku yky uk;c rglhynkj] csjh rRdkyhu gkyrglhynkj ¼lsok fuo`r½ }kjk vius in dk nq:Ik;ksx fd;k x;k gSAvr% tkap fjiksVZ dh Nk;k izfr vuqyXudksa dh Nk;k izfr lfgr tkap fjiksVZ ls lgergksrs gq, vkidh lsok esa vkxkeh vko’;d dk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

layXu%& mijksä

¼gLrkå½ d`rs% mik;qä] >TtjA

izs"kdmie.My vf/kdkjh ¼uk0½csjhA

izsf"krmik;qDr egksn;] >TtjAØekad 533@jhMj fnukad 4&8&2017

fo"k;%& For including the enquiry against Krishan Lal and others pending with

SDO (C), Jhajjar.

mijksDr fo"k; ij vkids i= Øekad 1951@bZ0ch0 fnukad 02-06-2016 rFkk Lej.k i=Øekad 177@,p0vkj0lh0 fnukad 24-05-2017 ds lanHkZ esa vuqjks/k gS fd v/kksgLrk{kjh us bldk;kZy; esa frfFk 06-10-2016 dks dk;Zxzg.k fd;k FkkA fo"k;k/khu tkap ckjs v/kksgLrk{kjh us rqjUrdk;Zokgh djrs gq, vkids Lej.k i= fnukad 24-05-2017 ls iwoZ gh bl dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad83@jhMj fnukad 25-04-2017 }kjk vkils ewy th0ih0,0 Øekad 50 fnukad 18-02-2003 ckjs vuwjks/k fd;k Fkk fd ;g ewy izfr vkids dk;kZy; dh ,p0vkj0,0 ’kk[kk esa nkf[ky gks pqdh gSA blewy izfr dks Hkstus ds vkns’k ikfjr djus dk d"V djsaA blds Ik’pkr bl dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad199@LVSuksa fnukad 13-06-2017 }kjk iqu% vuwjks/k fd;k x;k Fkk f'kdewy th0ih0,0 Øekad 50fnukad 18-02-2003 dks Mk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZl ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu] djuky dks tkap gsrw Hksth tkuhgSA blfy, bl th0ih0,0 ls lEcfU/kr ewy cgh Mk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZl ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu]djuky ls ikorh ysdj ewy cgh lEcfU/kr foHkkx esa j[kus dk d"V djsA vkids dk;kZy; ds i=Øekad 252@,p0vkj0,0 fnukad 16-06-2017 }kjk fy[kk x;k gS fd jftLVªS’ku ,DV esa dgh HkhfjdkMZ dks fdlh tkap ,tsUlh esa tek djkus dk izok/kku ugh gSA vr% fgnk;r dh tkrh gS fdfjdkMZ dks tek fd, fcuk vko’;drkuqlkj tkap ,tsUlh dks izLrqr djs o lkFk gh deZpkjh dksfgnk;r dh tkrh gS fd og viuh gkftjh esa fjdkMZ dh tkap djok;sa rFkk fjdkMZ okfil ykdjlEcfU/kr dk;kZy; eas tek djs rkfd fjdkMZ ds lkFk NsM+[kkuh uk gks ldsA mijksDr i= dh ikyukesa v/kksgLrk{kjh }kjk bl dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad 342@jhMj fnukad 04-07-2017 }kjk Jh lat;

27

dqekj] fyfid rglhy dk;kZy; csjh dks fgnk;r dh xbZ fd og vkids dk;kZy; ls vly ftYnizkIr djds viuh gkftjh esa fjdkMZ dh tkap djus mijkUr vly ftYn dks okfil ykdj vkidsdk;kZy; esa tek djok;sxkA lEcfU/kr fyfid }kjk ;g vly ftYn vkids dk;kZy; ls IkzkIr djdsMk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZl ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu] djuky ds dk;kZy; esa tkap mijkUr okfil izkIrdjds iqu% vkids dk;kZy; esa tek djok nh FkhA blds i’pkr bl dk;kZy; }kjk ;g tkap fjiksVZMk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZal ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu] djuky ds dk;kZy; ls nLrh ykus ckjs fy[kk x;kAokafNr fjiksVZ bl dk;kZy; esa izkIr gks pqdh gSA

;gka ;g Li"V djuk vfr vfuok;Z gS fd ;g tkap bl dk;kZy; esa igys ls yfEcrFkhA ftlesa igys gh lEcfU/kr vf/kdkfj;ksa ,oa xokgksa ds C;ku dyeca) fd, tk pqds FksA ysfdufnukad 19-02-2016 dks dk;kZy; esa vkxtuh ds dkj.k ;g vly tkap QkbZy u"V gks xbZ FkhAiwoZ esa dyeca) fd, x, C;kukr ftudh lR;kfir izfr dh QksVksizfr tkap QkbZy esa miyC/k gSAmuds ewykfcd Jh jfoUnz izdk’k 'kekZ] ofldk uoh’k csjh us frfFk 22-06-2015 dks C;ku dyeca)djok, Fks] mlus C;kuksa esa dgk fd ,d eq[r;kjukek vke fnukad 18-02-2003 dks 'ke’ksj flag iq=gjuke flag fuoklh 388&,@2] Mh0,y0,Q0] xqM+xkao Jh d`".k yky iq= nsohyky fuoklh215@14] xqM+xkao ds gd esa fn;k Fkk tks fd esjs jftLVj ds Øekad 82 fnukad 18-02-2003 dksntZ gSA ftl ij 'ke’ksj flag fu'iknd ds gLrk{kj gS bldh iqf"V yEcjnkj cztyky csjh o Xokgthr flag iq= vej flag us dh FkhA ;g nLrkost eSus MªkQV fd;k FkkA eSa 'ke’ksj flag fu'iknddks tkfr rkSj ij ugh tkrk gSA ftuds gd esa eq[;rkjukek fd;k Fkk oks Jh d".k yky rglhynkj]csjh dk;Zjr FksA

Jh thr flag iq= Jh vej flag] ikuk fgUn;ku] csjh xokg us vius C;kuksa esa dgk fdtks eq[r;kjukek vke ofldk uohl us jftLVj is’k fd;k gS] ns[k fy;k gSA ml ij cSrksj esjsgLrk{kj gSA eS 'ke’ksj flag tkfr rkSj ij ugh tkurkA Jh d`".k yky ml le; ;kfu 2003 esacSrksj rglhynkj csjh dk;Zjr FksA mUgksus eq> ls dgk Fkk fd 'ke’ksj esjk ppsjk HkkbZ gSA ;gth0ih0,0 mlus esjs uke fd;k gSA vki bl ij cSrksj xokg vius lkbZu dj nksA eSu muds dgusls vius gLrk{kj dj fn, FksA

Jh jks’ku yky] rRdkfyu uk;c rglhynkj] csjh gky fjVk;MZ rglhynkj us viusC;kuksa esa dgk fd eS o"kZ 2003 cSrksj uk;c rglhynkj] csjh yxk gqvk FkkA ml le; Jh d`".kyky] rglhynkj csjh yxs gq, FksA fnukad 18-02-2003 dks eq[Rk;kjukek ua0 4@50 'ke’ksj flagiq= gjuke flag us Jh d`".k yky rglhynkj csjh ds gd esa iathd`r djok;k FkkA 'ke’ksj flagrglhynkj d`".k yky dh cqgk ds yM+ds gSa ftldh 'kuk[r cztyky uEcjnkj csjh o thr flagiq= vej flag fuoklh csjh us dh FkhA lHkh esjs lEeq[k is’k gq, Fks vkSj d`".k yky us 'ke’ksj flagds QksVks mDr eq[r;kjuke ij yxs gq, Fks rFkk lHkh QjhdSu o xokgksa us esjs lkeus gLrk{kj@vaxqBkfd, FksA

Jh d`".k yky] rglhynkj] csjh us gky cankscLr vf/kdkjh] fHkokuh fuoklh edku ua0215] lSDVj&14 xqM+xkao us vius C;kuksa esa dgk fd fnukad 18-03-2003 dks eS rglhynkj] csjh yxkgqvk FkkA ml le; Jh 'ke’ksj flag iq= gjuke flag] dkSe fc’kuksbZ] fuoklh 388&vkj0@2]Mh0,y0,Q0] xqM+xkao tks fd esjh lxh cqgk dk yM+dk gS ftldks eS tkfr rkSj ij tkurk gqaA mlds

28

uke yxHkx 21 duky jdck fcykliqj ftyk xqM+xkao esa Fkk ftUgksaus Lo;a fnukad 18-03-2003 dksrglhy csjh esa vkdj mijksDr tehu dk eq[r;kjukek iaftd`r esjs uke djok;k Fkk ftldhluk[kr cztyky uEcjnkj csjh o thr iq= vijflag csjh us dh Fkh vkSj LkHkh us lc jftLVªkj dslEeq[k gLrk{kj@vaxqBs fd, FksA ;g eq[r;kjukek Jh vkj0ih0 'kekZ ofldk uohl csjh ds jftLVjesa Øekad 82 ij ntZ gSA ;g eq[r;kjukek fu;ekuqlkj iaftd`r fd;k FkkA eSus bl eq[r;kjukesds }kjk ofldk ua0 9899 fnukad 17-07-2008 o ofldk ua0 11409 fnukad 06-08-2008 dks fodklfc’kuksbZ ds uke ij iathd`r djokbZA lc jftLVªkj] xqM+xkao ds dk;kZy; esa gqbZA ;fn eq>s blckcr dksbZ /kks[kk/kM+h ;k tkylkth djuh rks eS yxHkx 5 o"kZ rd bUrtkj ugh djrkA ;g dk;ZokghrqjUr dh tk ldrh FkhA mijksDr jdck fcykliqj ftyk xqM+xkao esa yxHkx bruk jdck esjs lxsHkkbZ jktdqekj ds uke Fkk ftlesa mldh jftLVªh ,Fksfud gksVy] izkbZosV fyfeVsM ds uke ofldkua0 12474 fnukad 20-08-2008 o ofldk ua0 9580 fnukad 16-08-2008 dks iaftd`r djok nh xbZFkhA blesa esjs iq= fodkl fc’kuksbZ ds uke ij tks bl dEiuh esa Mk;jsDVj Fks le;&le; ij >wBhnj[kkLrs nsdj ijs’ku djrk jgk FkkA tks tkap ds ckn lHkh [kkfjt gks pqdh gSA ftldh izfr is’kdj jgk gqaA izkFkhZ us viuh nj[kkLr esa tks fHkUu&fHkUu nj[kkLrksa dks gokyk fn;k gS mu lHkh dhtkap gks pqdh gSA 'ke’ksj us tks nj[kkLr 19-06-2014 dks csjh Fkkus esa nh Fkh ftldh tkap 14-08-2014 dks gks pqdh gSA nwljh nj[kkLr 06-08-2014 dks ,l0ih0 >Ttj dks nh bldh tkap bapktZbDuksfeDl lSy }kjk 06-11-2014 dks dh tk pqdh gSA ,d nj[kkLr fnukad 15-09-2014 dksvkbZ0th0 egksn; jksgrd dks nh ftldh tkap ,l0ih0 >Ttj fnukad 12-12-2014 dks dh tk pqdhgSA mijksDr rhuksa tkapks esa 'ke’ksj flag 'kkfey gqvk Fkk vkSj mlus vius C;ku Hkh dyeca) cjok,FksA rhuksa tkapksa dh Nk;kizfr izLrqr djrk gqaA 'ke’ksj flag us blh tehu ls lEcfU/kr 17-11-1998dks ,d vU; eq[r;kjukek Hkh iaftdr djok;k FkkA tgka rd izkFkhZ dks /kedh nsus dh ckr gSA eSusdksbZ /kedh ugh nh vkSj uk gh dksbZ vU; dk;Zokgh dh gSA ;g vkjksi ljklj >wB gSA ikfjokfjderHksn gksus ds dkj.k yxHkx 13 o"kZ ckn esjs vkSj esjs ifjokj ds f[kykQ ckj&ckj >wBh nj[kkLrsnsdj ijs’kku dj jgk gSA f’kdk;rdrkZ }kjk mi iqfyl v/kh{kd }kjk tkap esa ;g dgk gS fd ;gtehu esjs firk th us [kjhn dh gqbZ FkhA og ckn esa esjs uke dh tks dh ljklj xyr gSA ;gtehu 'kq: ls gh 'ke’ksj flag ds uke vkbZ gqbZ gSA vyx&vyx tkap esa fHkUu C;ku nsus ls izrhrgksrk gS fd f’kdk;rdrkZ ljklj >wB cksy jgk gSA vr% f’kdk;rdrkZ dh nj[kkLr dks nkf[kynQrj fd, tkus dks vuwjks/k fd;k tkrk gSA

uLrh ij vk, dkxtkr ,oa C;kukr dk voyksdu djus ls ik;k tkrk gS fd frfFk18-02-2003 dks Jh d`".k yky cSrksj rglhynkj csjh rFkk Jh jks’kuyky cSrksj uk;c rglhynkjcsjh dk;Zjr FksA jkT; tu lwpuk vf/kdkjh ,oa jktLo vf/kdkjh] >Ttj ds i= Øekad418@,p0vkj0,0 fnukad 19-07-2017 ls bl rF; ls Hkh iqf"V gksrh gS fd frfFk 18-02-2003 dksrglhy csjh es lkr nLrkost iathd`r gq, FksA ftles ls 6 bLrkost dEI;wVjkbZt gq, Fkk RkFkk ,dnLrkost eSuqoy iathd`r fd;k x;k gSA fnukad 18-02-2003 dks eSuwoy djus ds lEcU/k Lohd`friznku djus dh ckcr laizs"k.k jftLVj dk fnukad 18-02-2003 ls iwoZ dk voyksdu fd;k x;k ijUrqlaizs"k.k jftLVj esa eSuqoy iathd`r djus dh Lohd`fr iznku djus ckcr dqN ugh Ikk;k tkrk gSAJh thr flag xokg us Hkh vius C;ku esa Li"V rkSj ls dgk gS fd og 'ke’ksj flag dks tkfr rkSjij ugh tkurkA mlus d".k yky rglhynkj ds dgus ij cSrksj xokg gLrk{kj fd, FksA ;g fl)

29

gksrk gS fd d`".k yky rRdkyhu rglhynkj csjh rFkk Jh jks’kuyky rRdkyhu uk;c rglhynkjcsjh us vius in dk nq:Ik;ksx fd;k gSA

Mk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZl ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu] djuky dh fjiksVZ dk voyksdu djus lsHkh bl rF; dh iqf"V gksrh gS fd eq[r;kjukek vke Øekad 4@50 tks fnukad 18-02-2003 dksiathd`r fd;k x;k gS] ml ij tks gLrk{kj fd, gq, gS os gLrk{kj f’kdk;rdrkZ 'ke’ksj flag dsgLrk{kj ls esy ugh [kkrsA Mk;jsDVj] Qkjsafld lkbZl ykbZczsjh] e/kqcu] djuky ls izkIr fjiksVZvkidh lsok esa vkxkeh vko’;d dk;Zogh gsrw izsf"kr gs tks layXu gSA

¼gLrkå½&mie.My vf/kdkjh ¼ukå½

csjhA

The Committee orally examined the Deputy commissioner, Jhajjar, District

Revenue Officer, Jhajjar and the petitioner in its meeting held on 08.08.2017 and

discussed the case. During the proceedings of the case Sh. Roshan Lal S/o

Sh. Phool Chand R/o H.No. 688, ward No. 9, Mohalla Haripura, Distt. Jhajjar who is

retired as Tehsidar from Tehsil Beri Distt. Jhajjar, submit a representation to the

Committee to provide an opportunity of hearing him and request the Committee to

stay the observations of the Committee dated 08.08.2017. The Committee accepted

the same. The application of Sh. Roshan Lal, is reads as under:-

Before Sh. Ghanshyam Dass M.L.A. Chair Person Committee on petition Haryana

Vidhan Sabha Chandigarh

R/Sir

The application submits as under:-

1. That application Roshan Lal S/o Sh. Phool Chand is R/o House No. 688 ward

No. 9 Mohalla Haripura Jhajjar Distt Jhajjar who has retired as Tehsildar on

31/12/2012 from Tehsil Beri Distt Jhajjar.

2. That one Shamsher Singh S/o Harnam Singh R/o Village Kamri Tehsil and Distt

Hissar has made a complaint to you stating that he never executed any GPA on

18/2/2003 in favour of Krishan Kumar S/o Sh. Devi lal H.no. 215 Sector 14 Gurgaon.

He has further alleged that some other person had appeared as Shamsher Singh

and Krishan Kumar above mentioned got a false G.P.A. registered in his favour

incollusion with Sh. Roshan lal (Applicant) the then Naib Tehsildar cum joint

Sub Registrar Beri on 18/2/2003.

3. That your Honour has directed an inquiry into the above mentioned matter and

finally has directed Deputy commissioner Jhajjar to lodge an FIR vide order

dt. 8/8/2017 and in pursuance of that the proceeding for lodging FIR are in

progress in the office of Deputy Commissioner Jhajjar.

4. That applicant has no fault in doing registration of G.P.A. dt. 18/2/2003 because

the applicant had followed the procedure as mentioned in Section 35 of the

30

Registration Act, and as per Registration Act Sh. Brijlal Numberdar had identitifed

and Sh. Jeet Singh witness had identified Shamsher singh executants so there is

a no fault of applicant. It is also stated that since 2003 Shamsher Singh has not

challenged the validity of the G.P.A. in any civil court upto date.

5. That before passing the order by you the applicant was never given any

opportunity of hearing nor he was given any chance to explain his position. In

this way your honour it is stated that the applicant be also provided an

opportunity of hearing and upto the time the applicant is provided opportunity

of hearing the implementation of order dt. 8/8/2017 be stayed.

Applicant

Sd/-

Roshan Lal S/o Sh. Phool Chand

R/o House No. 688, Ward No. 9

Mohalla Haripur, Jhajjar

Distt. Jhajjar

The Committee orally examined the Departmental representatives, Sh. Shamsher

Singh and Sh. Roshan lal, in its meeting held on 04.10.2017, and give its recommendations

as under :-

desVh dh fjde.Ms'ku

xyr <ax ls dh xbZ th-ih-,- ds bl dsl esa iwoZ esa lfefr }kjk nksf"k;ksa ds f[kykQbaDokW;jh djus o ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZ djus ds funsZ'k ij ,l-Mh-,e- csjh }kjk bDokW;jh dh xbZ vkSjbl bDokW;jh esa mUgksaus jftLVªs'ku vFkkWfjVh] csfufQ'kjh vFkkZr ftlds i{k esa th-ih-,- gqbZ rFkkrlnhddrkZ vFkkZr uEcjnkj dks nks"kh ekukA

Jh jks'ku yky] uk;c rglhynkj ¼lsokfuo`r½ ¼ftlus th-ih-,- dh Fkh½ dks tc ;glaKku gqvk fd gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk dh ;kfpdk lfefr }kjk xyr <ax ls dh xbZ th-ih-,- ds ekeysesa baDokW;jh djus o nksf"k;ksa ds f[kykQ ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZ djus ds funsZ'k fn, x, gSa vkSj tcbudks vkHkkl gqvk fd D;ksafd ;g ml le; tcfd th-ih-,- dh xbZ Fkh] Lo;a jftLVªs'ku vFkkWfjVhFks bl 'kadk ds en~nsutj dh dgha buds f[kykQ Hkh ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZ u gks tk;s] blh vans'ksds /;kukFkZ Jh jks'ku yky us lacaf/kr ekeys esa mudk Lo;a dk i{k lquus ds fy, ,d fyf[kr izkFkZuki= ds ek/;e ls lfefr ds le{k xqgkj yxkbZ vkSj lfefr us Mh-vkj-vks-, >TTkj dh mifLFkfresa jh jks'ku yky] lsokfuo`Rr uk;c rglhynkj dk i{k lqukA nksuksa i{kksa dks lquus ds i'pkr rFkkjftLVªs'ku eSuqvy dks Hkh /;ku esa j[krs gq, ;g lfefr laLrqfr izLrqr djrh gS fd xyr <ax lsdh xbZ th-ih-,- ds bl ekeys esa jftLVªs'ku vFkkWfjVh dk dksbZ nks"k ugha gS cfYd okLro esa vlyhnks"k rks csfufQ'kjh ¼ftlds i{k esa th-ih-,- gqbZ gS½ rFkk rlnhddrkZ uEcjnkj ¼ftlus rlnhd dhgS½ dk gh gSA vr% ;g lfefr iwoZ esa lHkh nks"kh i{kksa ds f[kykQ ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- nTkZ djus ds lfefrds funsZ'k esa lq/kkj djrs gq, iqu funsZ'k tkjh djrh gS fd jftLVªs'ku vFkkWfjVh pwafd nks"k eqDr gS]vr% mlds f[kykQ ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZ u dh tk;s cfYd nks vU; i{k vFkkZr csfufQ'kjh o

31

rlnhddrkZ ds f[kykQ gh ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZ dh tk;s vkSj bl ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- dh ,d izfrlacaf/kr ekeys dh izksflfMax izkIr gksus dh frfFk ls ,d lIrkg dh le;kof/k ds vUnj vUnj lfefrdks izLrqr dh tk;sA

;kfpdkdrkZ dh vihy ij fd mudh bl tehu ij fd, tk jgs fuekZ.k dk;Z dks jksdktk;s] ij ;g lfefr ;g Hkh vuq'kalk izLrqr djrh gS fd ;kfpdkdrkZ dh tehu ij fd, tk jgsfuekZ.k dk;Z dks jksdus ds fy, lacaf/kr Mh-lh- ds ek/;e ls Vkmu ,aM daVªh fMikVZeSaV dks Hkh fy[kktk;sA

Thereafter, Sh. Krishan Lal Bishnoi, DRO (Retd.), H.No. 215, Sector 14, Gurgaon

has filed an application before the Committee with the request he may also be heard,

Committee perused his application. The application/representation filed by Sh. Krishan Lal

Bishnoi reads as under :

Application of Krishan Lal Bishnoi, Before the Hon’ble Committee on Petitions,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat, Chandigarh

In the matter of Chairman Sh. Ghanshyam Dass Ji M.L.A. Y. Nager in recomplaint

submitted by Sh. Shamsher Singh s/o Sh. Harnam Singh resident of Village Kaimri, Tehsil

and District Hisar.

Sir,

The instant representation is being filed before the Hon ‘ble committee on

petitions on account of the orders that had been passed by the by the committee in its

meeting held on August 8, 2017 and the subsequent hearings on the petition submitted by

Sh. Shamsher Singh slo Sh. Harnam Singh resident of Village Kaimri, Tehsil and District

Hisar regarding Inquiry of forged power of attorney. The Hon’ble committee has directed

the authorities to get FIR registered against the applicant without appreciating that the

applicant has not been granted any opportunity of hearing and that vital facts that required

to be before the Hon’ble committee have not been disclosed. Apart therefrom, various

issues pertaining to the civil rights have been determined with such determination has to

be done as per the process of law by approaching the competent court of original

jurisdiction .

Thus, the necessity to approach the Hon’ble committee so as to apprise it of the

necessary facts and to request that the order passed by the committee be recalled.

Facts as alleged:-

Sh. Shamsher Singh slo Sh. Harnam Singh resident of Village Kaimri, Tehsil and

District Hisar submitted a complaint to the committee on petitions alleging that the land

owned by him has been sold off by the applicant on the basis of the general power of

attorney allegedly executed by the complainant. During the course of proceedings held

on August 8, 2017, reliance was placed on the report of the handwriting expert wherein the

signatures are alleged to have not been found matching. The Hon’ble committee directed

that case be got registered and the furnished to the complainant so that by placing reliance

on the same, the complainant may get the sale deed cancelled and transferred in his own

name.

32

Brief factual Matrix:

The complainant became owner of land measuring 9 Kanal 16 Marla

situated in the revenue estate of village Bilaspur, District Gurgaon (now

Gurugram) by virtue of 3 different sale deeds registered in his favour. The

details of the same are as under :

a. Sale deed No. 14697 dated January 17, 1997 for an area measuring 4 kanal-12

marla situated in the revenue estate of Village Bilaspur, Tehsil and District Gurgaon

(Now Gurugram). Annexure-I.

b. Sale deed No. 14699 dated January 17, 1997 for an area measuring 4kanal-4marla

situated in the revenue estate of Village Bilaspur, Tehsil and District Gurgaon

(Now Gurugram). Annexure-II.

c. Sale deed No. 5454 dated July 21, 1997 for an area measuring

1 kanal situated in the revenue estate of Village Bilaspur, Tehsil and District

Gurgaon (Now Gurugram). Annexure-III.

Mutation with respect to the properties in question was duly sanctioned in favour of the

complainant.

That apart from the aforesaid 3 sale deeds for which mutations were duly recorded,

the complainant also became owner to the extent of 11 Kanal of land situated in the

revenue estate of village Bilaspur, District Gurgaon by virtue of an arbitration award dated

December 12, 1998. The said arbitration award became role of the court in civil suit No. 457

of 1998 titled Shamsher Singh son of Sh. Hamam Singh resident of 388 - Al2 DLF colony,

sector 14, Gurgaon versus Smt. Vedo widow of Sh. Amar Singh resident of village Bilaspur,

District Gurgaon. By virtue of the decree passed in the aforesaid civil suit on December 19,

1998 by the court of Ms Madhu Khanna, Civil Judge (Jr Division), Gurgaon, the award

passed by the arbitrator was made rule of the court. As well as the decree passed by the

civil courts are attached as Annexures-IV and V respectively. Resultantly, a total land

measuring 21 Kanal - 1 Marla got mutated in favour of the complainant. The details of the

land mutated in favour of the complainant are as under :

a. Mutation number 1665 Mustil no. 24/10 (8 - 0), 24111 (8 - 0), 201112 (0 - 11), total 16

Kanal 11 Marla - 2/5 share: 6 Kanal 12 Marla.

b. Mutation number 1668 Mustil no. 2411 0 (8 - 0), 24111 (8 - 0), 20/1/2 (0 - 11), total

16 Kanal 11 Marla - 2/5 share: 3 Kanal 19 Marla.

c. Mutation number 1796 Khewat no. 26/41 min 43 and Mustil no. 6/125//2 (5 - 4),

252/7/2 (7 - 1), 2411 (8 - 0), 25//412/212 (3 - 3), 7/12, 7/21 (8-0), total 39 Kanal- 220/780

share: 11 Kanal.

Copies of the mutations are however not being appended. The same may be verified by

the Hon’ble committee in case it is so desired.

The General Power of Attorney :

The complainant thereafter executed a registered general power of attorney on 18th of

February 2003 in favour of the applicant with respect to the entire property as aforesaid i.e.

33

21 Kanal 1 Marla in favour of the applicant. A copy of the said general power of attorney

registered vide vasika number 4/50 dated 18.2.2003 is attached as Annexure VI. Some of

the essential recitals of the said general power of attorney are as under:

“9. To enter into agreement for the sale of the said properties with any person/

S and to receive consideration amount in full and final from the intending purchaser in his

own name in cashlby check/bank draft or acknowledge the same.

10. To sell, mortgage, transfer or dispose of my property/ies to any personls

and to execute the sale deed, mortgage deed, transfer deed and to get it registered with the

office of sub registrar and to receive the consideration amount.”

Thus, a perusal of the powers vested upon the applicant on the strength of the

aforesaid power of attorney establishes beyond realm of any doubt that the applicants

was fully authorised to alienate the property in question and was also within his authority

to receive the sale consideration in his own name.

Subsequent Events:

The applicant also initiated proceedings for seeking partition of the

land in question. After the aforesaid proceedings had been finalised, registered sale deed

with respect to the property in question was executed by the applicant in favour of Ethnic

Hotel Private Limited on July 17, 2008. The alienation of the said land was. done toseparate

sale deeds for an area measuring 10 Kanal 13 Marla and 10 kanals are attached as Annexure-

VII and VIII respectively. After the execution of the sale deed, mutation of the property in

favour of the purchaser was entered in the revenue record in the year 2008 itself.

PREVIOUS COMPLAINTS:

Despite the sale deed having been executed on July 17,2008, there was no

complaint of any nature whatsoever by the executed of the general power of attorney viz

the complainant herein. Before filing of the instant complaint to the Hon’ble Committee on

Petitions, the following complaints were made by the complainant which all found the

complaint to be baseless and unworthy of any merit. The details of the same are stated as

under : -

1. A complaint dated 29th of June 2014 which was received in the police station on

22nd of July 2014 was submitted by the complainant levelling said allegation about the

Power of Attorney being forced and that the sale deed having already been got executed

on the strength of the said forged our of attorney.An enquiry to the knowledge of the

applicant was conducted by the police at the relevant point of time and after coming to a

conclusion that the complaint was baseless and that’s the general power of attorney had

actually been executed by the complainant himself, the said complaint was confined to

record. Having concluded that the complaint was unsubstantiated and that no cognizable

offence was made out upon verification of the averments contained in the complaint, the

same was consigned. A copy of the said complaint is attached as Annexure-IX.

2. A complaint dated September 15, 2014 was also sent to the Inspector General of

police, Rohtak Range Rohtak. Upon receipt of the said complaint that had all the allegations

which had previously been conveyed to the SHO, the office of the Inspector General of

34

police marked the said complaint to the Superintendent Of Police Jhajjar to get an enquiry

conducted through the Economic Offences Wing. An enquiry into the allegations was

conducted by the Economic Offences Wing and the statement of the complainant as well

as other witnesses and accused persons was also recorded. After conducting the enquiry,

a report was submitted no criminal case was made out and that the dispute, if any, was civil

in nature. Vide letter dated December 13, 2014, information in this regard was conveyed by

the office of Supt of Police to the Inspector General Of Police. A copy of the said complaint

along with the statements of witnesses recorded by the Economic Offences Wing and

letter sent by the Supt of Police to the Inspector General are attached as Annexure-X

(colly).

3. That having come to know of the report forwarded by the Superintendent of

Police to the Inspector General dated 13.12.2014, instead of taking recourse to the remedy

available to him in law, the complainant filed a fresh complaint to the worthy Chief Secretary

Haryana on December 15,2014. A copy of the said complaint is attached as Annexure-XI.

The aforesaid complaint received by the Chief secretary to government of Haryana was

forwarded to the office of Additional Chief Secretary and FCR Haryana.

4. The complainant however submitted that another complaints to the

Hon’ble Chief Minister of Haryana on January 13, 2015 on the same set of allegations. The

copy of the said complaint is attached as Annexure-XII. the said complaint was forwarded

to the Director General of Police from where it was sent to the Superintendent of Police

Jhajjar who got the enquiry conducted from Sh. Dheeraj Kumar HPS, Dy.S.P. The enquiry

officer again recorded the statements of all the witnesses and furnishes report to the

Superintendent of Police Jhajjar who vide his letter number 343-P dated 19.2.2015 forwarded

his report to the Inspector General of Police. In the said report it was specifically conveyed

that the allegations levelled were found to be bereft of truth and merit and

that’s the same was baseless. The copies of the statements recorded by the Deputy

Superintendent of Police are attached as Annexure XIII and the report forwarded by the

Superintendent of Police Jhajjar is attached as Annexure-XlV.

Perusal of the aforesaid sequence of previous complaints establishes beyond any doubt

that the complainant had been taking recourse to submitting complaints to various

authorities that had been independently enquired into. Now the authorities found any

substance in a complaint so levelled and decided to consign the said complaints to record

as being without any merit. All the aforesaid facts had been concealed by the complainant

while submitting the complaint to the Hon’ble Committee on Petitions.

The worthy committee, without issuing any notice to the applicant and having

been kept uninformed of the same by the authorities associated, issued orders for

registration of case against the applicant so that the sale deed could be got cancelled.

Necessity has thus reason for the applicant to make the instant representation and to

apprise the Hon’ble committee and to request it to recall its order severely prejudices the

applicants apart from in violation of the statutory mandate and the powers conferred upon

the committee.

Grounds for seeking recall :

a. The complainant is concealed vital information from the Hon’ble committee

thus rendering the order to have been passed on the basis of conjectures. The only

35

premise for passing the said order is the report of the handwriting expert. Needless to

mention that report of handwriting expert is a very weak evidence apart from the fact that

the purported report pertains to comparison of the signatures that had been fixed in the

year 2003 vis-a-vis the signatures that may have been sent for comparison in the year

2015. The possibility of the signatures that have been appended over a gap of more than

a decade to match negligible.

b. The matter had already been enquired into on as many as 4 occassions by the

administrator authorities as well as by the police. All the authorities had not only concluded

that the complainant had miserably failed to bring any evidence to substantiate or to

support the allegations but also concluded that no criminal case of any nature was made

out. The said record was never produced before the Hon’ble committee.

c. The Hon’ble committee has directed registration of case against the applicant

without associating the applicant in the proceedings and without granting any hearing.

The aforesaid order thus having been passed at the back of the applicant deserves to be

recalled.

d. That it is further well established Cardinal principle of law and no person should

be condemned unheard. Since the order passed by the committee had the effect of vitally

affecting the rights and liberties of the applicant, hearing or to have been extended to the

applicant before passing any such order as is prejudicial to the rights and liberties of the

applicant.

e. That by means of securing the aforesaid order on account of concealment of

vital facts, the complainant is wanting to revive a dead horse. Even if all the contentions

of the complainant are accepted. as per the averments of the complainant himself, he had

acquired knowledge of the said sale deeds in the month of June 2014/complaint was

submitted to the police in July 2014. Thus, knowledge with respect to the sale deed had

been acquired and as such, the time limit prescribed for the purposes of raising a

challenge is 3 years from the date of knowledge. Hence, the complainant could have at the

most filed a civil suit till July 2017. As per the law of limitation, the complainant has no

remedy in law. Once the; right to challenge the sale deed has been lost, no such

right can be conferred by the orders of the Hon’ble committee.

f. That the order so passed by the Hon’ble committee amounts to

substituting the satisfaction of the investigating agency and exercising it power that is

not conferred upon it under the Criminal Procedure Code. The satisfaction as regards

existence of any cognizable offence is to be that of the investigating agency and once the

said investigating agency has concluded more than once that no cognizable offence is

made out and only a civil dispute, if any, exists, no such directives could have been issued

by the Hon’ble committee. The remedy if any, which was available to the complainant was

to have approached the concerned competent court of jurisdiction for the purposes of

raising a dispute to the decisions of the investigating agency and to pursue the private

complaints. The committee cannot vest what is prohibited by law.

g. That the authorities have also failed to consider that the executed under the

generalpower of attorney had duly appeared before the sub registrar and it was only

thereafter that the photographs had been appended as a mark of verification and

36

authentication. No challenge has been made to the general power of attorney and the

same has not been got cancelled by the complainant. Thus, the document which has come

into being by operation of law is being sought to be annulled without taking recourse to

the remedy available in law. No cogent reason or explanation is being offered

by the complainant as to why he ought not take recourse to the remedy which is available

as per law.

h. That the provisions of the Specific Relief Act As Well as the Limitation Act had

been specifically examined so as to verify the remedies that are available to any agreed

person as per law and within what specified timeframe, such a remedy can be invoked.

The law is well settled that any action initiated after the expiry of the period of limitation

prescribed in law is unsustainable and liable to be ignored. Despite being conscious and

aware of alleged wrong, no steps have been taken by the complainant to take

anappropriateremedy before the court of law. The said act is a deliberateandmischievous

act on the complainant was all along well aware of the fact that whatever he was contending

was not only incorrect but was alsofraudulent in nature. Thus, fearing adverse order

being passed by the court, the complainant deliberately chose not to take recourse to the

appropriate remedy.

i. That the vesting of powers is a statutory function and only the authority which

has been vested with the specific power can exercise the same. No other authority can

direct such authority to exercise its powers in any specific manner. The substitution of

satisfaction of the competent authority is not a domain of any other authority. Whenever

any such substitution is effected, the same vitiates the action.

j. That determination of civil rights is not within the domain of Committee on

Petitions and all such declarations can only be given by Court of law.

k. That the Hon’ble committee has already amended its order in relation to the

concerned sub registrar and has directed that no such case be registered against him.

Once the registering authority is protected the allegation itself falls flat since the entire

gist of allegations pertains to the registration of the GP A.

I. That the complainant has opted to dispute be GP A at his convenience. No

challenge is raised to the partition proceedings that have been initiated on the strength of

the said attorney. Once the complainant accepts the partition proceedings to be valid, all

other subsequent proceedings on the basis of the said GP A too have to be accepted and

acknowledged.

m. That the authorities have also failed to appreciate that what is prohibited directly

cannot be permitted to be done indirectly. Since the sale deeds in question could not have

been disputed or be got annulled directly by taking recourse to appropriate proceedings

in annulled directly by taking recourse to appropriate proceedings in law, the present

indirect methodology has been adopted by the complainant.

n. That the complainant has also deliberately not conveyed that he is a cousin to

the applicant and that considering the relationship, it is seemingly impossible that the

complainant was not aware of having executed the GPA in the year 2003. The very fact that

the complainant chose to remain silent for a period of nearly 1] years since the execution

of the GP A in itself suggestive of the fallacy of the allegations.

37

o. That the authorities have issued the directions on the basis of conjectures and

presumptions as regards the alleged misconduct without seeking a report from the

concerned quarters to whom the complaints had been submitted earlier.

p. That the settled actual and legal rights are being sought to be unsettled by

means of the aforesaid order calling for recall of the same.

It is therefore respectfully prayed that the order dated August 8, 2017 be recalled in the

facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of Justice and fair play.

Regards.

Yours sincerely

Sd/-

Krishan Lal Bishnoi (Retd. D.R.O.)

R/o 215, Sec.-14 ,Gurugram.

To

The Secretary

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh

Subject : In re Complaint submitted by Sh. Shamshcr Singh s/o Sh. Harnam Singh

resident of Village Kaimri, Tehsil and District Hisar.

In reference to the subject mentioned above, the applicant wants to submit the

aforesaid representation to the worthy Committee on Petitions against the order dated

8.8.2017and all other proceedings arising therefrom since the order has been passed

condemning the applicant unheard.

You are requested to kindly put up the matter before the Hon’ble Committee on

petitions and to intimate the date of personal hearing to the applicant to present his case

with necessary proof.

Regards.

Sd/-

(Krishan Lal Bishnoi)

The Committee orally examined the Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar, District

Revenue Officer, Jhajjar, Sh. Shamsher Singh, Sh. Roshan Lal and Shri Krishan Lal Bishnoi,

in its meeting held on 02.01.2018, and discussed the matter in detail. After hearing all the

parties Committee made following observation :-

lfefr dh vuq'kalk

lfefr us bl ekeys esa igys dsoy ek= dEiysuSaV dks gh lqudj ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- ntZdjokus ds vkns'k fn;s FksA desVh dh vkt dh ehfVax esa bl ekeys ls lEcaf/kr lHkh i{kksa dks lqukx;k ftlds i'pkr~ bl ekeys ls tqM+s cgqr ls rF; lfefr ds lkeus vk;s blfy, bl ekeysij iqufoZpkj djrs gq, lfefr us ;g fu.kZ; fy;k gS fd bl ekeys esa desVh us tks blls igysfu.kZ; fn;s Fks desVh vius mu lHkh fu.kZ;ksa dks okfil ysrh gSA

vc bl ekeys ij foLrkjiwoZd fopkj&foe"kZ djus ds mijkar desVh us ;g vkWCtoZfd;k gS fd bl ekeys esa igys gh dkQh baDokW;jht gks pqdh gSa tks fd ijLij fojks/kkHkklh gSaA bldslkFk gh lkFk desVh ds uksfVl esa ;g rF; Hkh vk;k gS fd ;g ekeyk ,d ikfjokfjd ekeyk gSA

38

bu rF;ksa dks /;ku esa j[krs gq, desVh ;g vuq'kalk djrh gS fd bl ekeys ls lEcaf/kr nksuksa i{kvius Lrj ij gh bl ekeys dk fuiVkjk dj ysaA

ps;jilZu % bl iSVh'ku dks fMLikst vkWQ fd;k tkrk gSA

The petition is disposed of accordingly on 02.01.2018.

————————

5. PETITION RECEIVED FROM SHRI KANT SHARMA, JUNIOR SCALE

STENO TYPIST, HARYANA POLICE HOUSING CORPN., K.NO. 7, PTC,

SUNARIA (ROHTAK). REGARDING CORRECTION IN DATE OF

REGULARIZATION OF SERVICES TO THE POST OF STENO TYPIST

To

The Chairman

Petition Committee

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Subject : Correction in date at Regularization of services to the Post of Steno typist w.e.f.

01.10.2003 as per Haryana Govt. Notification.

Hon'ble Sir,

With due regards it is kindly submitted as under :-

1. That I was appointed as a Steno typist in Haryana Police Housing Corporation

Divisional office on 01.08.1995 against sanction accorded vide M.D. HPHC Panchkula

office letter No. 5122 dt. 04.07.1995 on D.C. rate.

2. As per Haryana Govt. Notification No. G.S.R. 24/Const/Art 309/2003 Dated

01.10.2003 the services of adhoc/contract employees who have completed three years

service on 30.9.2003 and were in service on that date snould be made regular w.e.f. 1.10.2003.

3. My services were regularzed vide M.D. HPHC Panchkula order No. HPHC/Estt

05/3762 dated 28.04.2005 and my date of joining have been considered on 3.05.2005 whereas

my joining was to be considered on 1.10.2003 as per above Haryana Govt. Notification.

4. The other Corporation officials Sh. Lalit Nanda & Kamal Kishore. J.Es who were

working on adhoc basis were regularized by HPSC in compliance of same Haryana Govt.

Notification mentioned above w.e.f. 1.10.2003 vide order No. HPHC/Estt/05/HPHC/11488

dated 12.12.2005.

5. I have represented to Managing Director Haryana Police Housing Corporation

Panchkula in the year 2005 to 2011 but no action have been taken. The representations were

also sent through proper channel through XEN, HPHC, Madnuban vide memo No. HPHC/

MBN/12/3995 dt 20.7.12 3422 dt. 20.8.13 & 5044 dt. 1.10.2014 but till date no action have

been taken.

39

6. By ignoring my date of joining on 1.10.2003 my juniors Smt. Sushil Kumari &

Parveen Arora were promoted as Junior Scale Stenographer vide order No. 12800 13 dt.

8.11.12.

7. I am suffering loss financially for the last 13 years.

In view of above it is requested that my date of regularization may be corrected/

considered w.e.f. 01.10.2003.

I shall be very thankful to you.

Sincerely yours

Sd/-

DA as above (Shri Kant Sharma)

Junior Scale Stenotypist.

Haryana Police Housing Corpn

K.No. 7 PTC Sunana (Rohtak)

The Petion was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 20.08.2016

and the Committee considered the same and decided that said petition may be sent to the

concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15 days. The Committee

received the reply from Chairman and Managing Director, Haryana Police Housing

Corporation, Plot No. C-10, Sector-6, Panchkula vide their letter No. 11959, dated 19.09.2016,

as under-

HARYANA POLICE HOUSING CORPORATION

(A Haryana Government Undertaking)

Plot No. C-10, Sector-6, Panchkula-134109

Ref. : 11959 Dated : 19.9.16

To,

The Principal Secretary

Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat,

Sector-1, Chandigarh.

Subject :-Regarding correction in date of regularization of services to the post of steno

typist.

Kindly refer to your office letter No. HVS/Petition/501/16-17/20045 dated 08.09.2016

on the above noted subject.

2. Sh. Shrikant Sharma was appointed on daily wages fixed by DC Hisar doing

7/1995. He had earlier submitted requests to Head office for regularization of his services,

the same were not considered by the then MD since he had filed an appeal in the cout of

District Judge, Hisar against regularization of his services and matter was sub-judice. Since,

he had given an assurance at that time regarding withdrawal of all court cases hence the

then MD had considered his request and regularized his services as Steno-typist with

immediate effect vide orders dated 28.04.2005(Copy enclosed). Accordingly, Sh. Shri Kant

40

Sharma had submitted his joinining as Steno-typist on 03.05.2005 FN (Copy enclosed). At

the time of joining. he did not represent against regularization of his services w.e.f. 01.10.2003

instead of immediate effect.

3. During 2013 i.e. after a lapse of 08 years of his regularization, he had represented

first time in Head Office vide his request dated 20.08.2013(copy enclosed) regarding

regularization of his services w.e.f. 01.10.2003 instead of 03.05.2005. However, his request

was considered at length and rejected by the undersigned, being time barred.

4. Now, Sh. ShriKant Sharma has been promoted as Junior Scale Stenographer on

12.09.2014(Copy enclosed). Even though, he is representing time and again through his

requests dated 01.10.2014, 01.01.2015, 16.07.2015, and 10.09.2015(Copies enclosed) regarding

the reqularization of his services as Steno-typist w.e.f. 01.10.2003 instead of 03.05.2005 as

per Govt. policy along with all consequential benefits. The same were also considered and

rejected being time barred.

5. It will not be out of place to mention here that in case he is considered for

rregularization of his services w.e.f. 01.10.2003. instead of 03.05.2005 then the seniority of

Steno-typists, existed at that time will be disturbed. Since, two more Steno-typists who

were absorbed from fisheries department on 31.10.2003 were senior to him. Now, on date,

out of these two senior steno-typists, one steno-typist is in the cadre of Senior Scale Steno

and another is in the cadre of Junior Scale Steno. Thus it will be higly discriminatory to

supersede already promoted Steno-typists by granting Sh. ShriKant Sharma the

regularization w.e.f. 01.10.2003. This will also lead to unnecessary litigations.

6. Further, on his request, the case of Sh. Shrikant Sharma was also placed before

Departmental Level Grievance Redressal Committee under State Litigation Policy-2010 of

this Corporation.

The Committee observed that Sh. Shrikant Sharma neither submitted any

representation on the issue during 2005 to 2013 nor he could submit any evidence/

documentary proof of the same during hearing, Hence, the committee was of the view that

the request of Sh. ShriKant Sharma cannot be accepted at this stage being time barred and

may be filed.''

7. In view of above circumstances, the appeal of Sh. Shrikant Sharma regarding

regularization of services w.e.f. 01.10.2003 instead of 03.05.2005 alongwith all consequential

benefits was considered and filed by the undersigned being time barred. Acordingly, he

was also informed vide this office letter No. 11268 dated 26.08.2015(Copy enclosed).

Sd/-

Chairman and Managing Director

Haryana Police Housing Corporation

Panchkula.

The Committee considered the same in its meeting held on 12-01-2018 and

Committee was satisfied with the reply hence decided to dispose-of the said petition.

————————

41

6. PETITION RECEIVED FROM SHRI VIJAY PAL S/O SH. MAHENDER SINGH

R/O V.P.O. TIKLI, TEHSIL AND DISTT. GURUGRAM, REGARDING NOT

GRANTING OF NOC.

The Petition received from Shri Vijay Pal, reads as under :-

To

The Chairman

Petition Committee,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

fo"k; %& ,u-vks-lh- ugha nsus ckjsA

Jheku th]

fuosnu ;g fd t; izdk'k&lat;&fot;iky&egs'k iq=ku Loå Jh egsUnz flag fuoklh xkaoo Mkdå Vhdyh lc rglhy ckn'kkgiqj o ftyk xq:xzke] gfj;k.kk ds jgus okys gSA fuosnu ;ggS fd geus vius fgLls vuqlkj jdck 00 fc?kk 01 fcLok 14 fcLokalh okadk ekStk xkao Vhdyh lcrglhy ckn'kkgiqj o ftyk xq:xzke dks Jhefr vfurk /keZiRuh Jh ns'kjkt fuoklh xkao o MkdåVhdyh lc rglhy ckn'kkgiqj ftyk xq:xzke dks c; djus dh ckcr ,d ,u-vks-lh- fnukad11&04&2017 dks Mh-Vh-ih-¼,uQkslZeasV½ dk;kZy;] xq:xzke esa yxkbZ gqbZ gSA tksfd gesa vHkh rdugha feyh gS foHkkx ds pDdj dkV&dkV dj ge Fkd pqds gSA ,u-vks-lh- ugha feyus ds dkj.kge uk gh jftLVjh djk ik jgs vkSj uk gh mijksDr jdcs dks cspus dh ckcr feyh gqbZ jde lsdksbZ tehu [kjhn ik jgs gSA Mh-Vh-ih-¼,uQkslZesaV½ dk;kZy;] xq:xzke ls tehu cspus ds fy;sljdkjh fu;eksa vuqlkj ,u-vks-lh- ysuk vko';d gS tksfd lHkh lEcfU/kr nLrkostks ds lkFk Mh-Vh-ih-¼,uQkslZesaV½ dk;kZy;] xq:xzke esa fnukad 11&04&2017 ls tek gSA blh Mh-Vh-ih- vf/kdkjh}kjk iwoZ esa Hkh bl izdkj dh dbZ ,u-vks-lh- tkjh dh tk pqdh gS ysfdu gesa gekjs }kjk yxkbZxbZ ,u-vks-lh- ysus ds fy;s ckj ckj pDdj dVok jgk gSA

vr% tukc ls vuqjks/k gS fd gesa tYn ls tYn ,u-vks-lh- fnyokus dk d"V djs rkfd gejftLVjh djk lds vkSj dksbZ nwljh tehu [kjhn ldsA vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

/kU;okn lfgr

Hkonh;Sd/-

fnukad%& 08&05&2017 fot;iky ,oa egs'k iq= Lo0 Jh egsUnz flag fuoklh xkaoo Mkd0 Vhdyh rglhy o ftyk xq:xzke] gfj;k.kk

The Petition was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 16.05.2017 and

the Committee considered the same and decided the same and decided that said petition

may be sent to the concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15

42

days. The Committee did not received any reply from the Department. Therefore, the

Committee orally examine the Director General, Town and Country Planning, Haryana,

District Town Planner (Enforcement), Gurugram, Haryana and the Petitioner in its meeting

held on 29.08.2017, and discussed the matter with the departmental representatives and the

Director General, Town and Country Planning, Haryana, assured the Committee that matter

in question would be is resoived within 24 hrs.

Shri Vijay Pal, submitted application that his grievances were resolved and her

case may be disposed off Application submitted by Shri Vijay Pal, reads as

under :-

To

The Chairman

Petition Committee,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

Sub :- Thanks for the Hon'ble Chairman, all petition committee members and Staff.

R/Sir,

With due respect I would like to state I have made a complaint against DTP

(Enforcement) Gurugram, Mr. Rajender T. Sharma for not issue the NOC in respect of

registration of sale deed of land measuring 01 Biswa 14 Biswansi of Village-Teekli, Sub-

Tehsil-Badshahpur, Gurugram, Haryana.

In this regard the committee had taken up the issue on dated 29-08-2017 of

NOC very seriously, results the NOC has been issued.

Now I want to thanks the Hon'ble Chairman, whole committee and staff for

solve my grievance.

Thanks

With Regards

Sd/-

(VIJAY PAL)

S/o Late Sh. Mahender Singh

R/o V.P.O.-Teekli, Gurugram

The petition is disposed off/accordingly on 12-01-2018

————————

7. PETITION RECEIVED FROM DR. PRADEEP, MEDICAL OFFICER,

CIVILHOSPITAL. BHIWANI, REGARDING PAY PROTECTION OF

PREVIOUS SERVICE

The Petition received from Dr. Pradeep, reads as under :-

43

To

The Chairman

Petitions Committee

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

Subject:- Grievances Redressal.

R/Sir,

It is humbly requested that I am posted as Medical officer in Civil Hospital,

Bhiwani since 15-09-2015. Before this appointment I remained posted at PGIMS Rohtak on

regular basis from 15-10-2010 to 14-09-2015. I applied HCMS cadre through proper channel.

I requested to the Director General Health Services Haryana through Principal

Medical Officer ,Civil Hospital, Bhiwani vide E- I/CHV2513 dated 10-05-2016 for pay

protection for previous serevice.

Director General Health Services Haryana raised objection vide letter no 78/

P(-)-7E2-2016/7097 dated 23-08-2016 which was removed and case was resend to the

Director General Health Services Haryana vide letter no . E-I/CHl3010 dated 30-09-2016.

I again reminded on dated 31-01-2017 bye-mail and the same through Principal

Medical Officer, Civil Hospital, Bhiwani vide letter no . E-I/CH/133 dated 09-02-2017.

But even after my case is still pending resulting into my following due

benefits are still pending due to non protection of pay and I am facing hard ship.

1- Pay Protection

2- ACP due w.e.f 01-01-2016.

3- Pay in ih pay commission.

4- LTC

You are requested to kindly direct to the authorities concerned to release the

due benefits at the earliest to avoid further financial loss.

Dated :-20-02-2017

Sd/-

Dr.Pradeep

Medical Officer

Civil Hospital, Bhiwani

The Petition was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 21.02.2017,

the Committee considered the same and decided that the said petition may be sent to the

concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15 days. The

Committee did not received any reply from the Department. Thereafter, Committee orally

examined Additional Chief Secretary to Govt., Haryana, Health Department, Director General,

44

Health Services, Haryana and the Petitioner in its meeting held on 30.05.2017 and discussed

the matter in detail in which ACS, Health Department informed the Committee that matter

regarding pay protection is pending with the Finance Department and they will pursue it

positively. Additional Chief Secretary to Govt., Haryana, Health Department has also sent

their reply vide their letter No. 32/02/2017-6HV, dated 08/12/.06.2017 and letter No. 32/02/

2017-6HB, dated 01.08.2017 which are reads as under -

izs"kd]

iz/kku lfpo gfj;k.kk ljdkjLokLF; foHkkxA

lsok esa

lfpo]gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk] lfpoky;A;knh Øekad 32@02@2017&6,p0ch0kfnukad] p.Mhx<+ 8 twu] 2017

fo"k; %& Meeting of the Committee on petitions-Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat-

regarding pay protection of previous service of PGIMS Rohtak Dr. Pardeep

Kumar, Medical Officer, Civil Hospital, Bhiwani.

mijksDRk fo"k; ij vkids dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad HVS/Petitions/2/2017-18/12256-

65, fnukad 6-6-2017 ds lanHkZ esaA

2- fo"k;ksDr ekeys esa voxr djok;k tkrk gS fd Mk0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh]flfoy gLirky] fHkokuh }kjk ih0th0vkbZ0,e0,l0 jksgrd esa mu }kjk iwoZ esa dh xbZ lsok vuqlkjosru fu;e@fu/kkZfjr djus dk vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA

LokLF; funs'kky; ls muds dk;kZy; ds i= fnukad 17-2-2017¼irkdk&d½ }kjkMk0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh flfoy gLirky] fHkokuh dk mu }kjk ih0th0vkbZ0,e0,l0jksgrd esa iwoZ esa dh xbZ lsok vuqlkj osru fu;e@fu/kkZfjr djus dk vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA

rnkuqlkj bl dk;kZy; }kjk ekeyk foRr foHkkx dks bl dk;kZy; ds vksu&ykbZupkyku Øekad 6914] fnukad 22-5-2017 ¼irk[kk&[k½ }kjk vf/kdkjh dh lsokiqfLrdk Hkstrsgq, osru&fu;r djus gsrw vko';d ea=.kk@lgefr iznku djus dk vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA

foR R k fo H k kx }kj k fnuk ad mud s dk;k Zy; d s v' k k0 Øek ad1@102@2012&1ih0vkj0¼,Q0Mh0½] fnukad 1-6-2017 ¼irkdk&x½ }kjk Mk0 iznhidqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh] flfoy gLirky fHkokuh ds osru fu;r ekeys esa [ksn@vlgefr izdVdh gSA rnkuqlkj dk;kZy; ds i= 7@8-6-2017 ¼irkdk&?k½ }kjk foHkkx@lEcfU/kr vf/kdkjh dks lwfpr dj fn;k x;k gSA

45

mijksDRk of.kZr fLFkfr vuqlkj Mk0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh] flfoy gLirky]fHkokuh ds osru&fu;r ds lEcU/k esa iVh'ku desVh dks ekeyk lwpukFkZ ,oa vkxkeh vko';ddk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

lyaXu mijksDrkuqlkj

Sd/-

vfrfjDr lfpo] LokLF;d`rs iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj]

LokLF; foHkkxA

izs"kd]

iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkjLokLF; foHkkxA

lsok esa

lfpo]gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk] lfpoky;A

;knh Øekad 32@02@2017&6 ,p0ch0fnukad] p.Mhx<+ 25 tqykbZ] 2017

fo"k; %& Meeting of the Committee on petitions-Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat-

regarding pay protection of previous service of PGIMS Rohtak Dr. Pardeep Kumar,

Medical Officer, Civil Hospital, Bhiwani.

*****

mijksDr fo"k; ij ljdkj ds i= lela[;d fnukad 08-06-2017 o vkids dk;kZy; dsi= Øekad HVS/Petitions/2/2017-18/15378-87, fnukad 18-07-2017 ds lanHkZ esaA

2- fo"k;ksDr ekeys esa voxr djok;k tkrk gS fd Mk0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh]flfoy gLirky] fHkokuh }kjk ih0th0vkbZ0,e0,l0 jksgrd esa mu }kjk iwoZ esa dh xbZlsok vuqlkj osru fu;e@fu/kkZfjr djus ds lEcU/k esa foRr foHkkx us muds dk;kZy;ds i= Øekad 1@102@2012&1ih0vkj0¼,Q0Mh0½ fnukad 21-07-2017 }kjk fuEuea=.kk nh gS&~

1. ''AO of the Department has advised in a very causal manner because, the

pay on subsequent appointment from one department to another

department only is protected as per Rules. Hence, Finance department is

unable to accept the AD’s proposal.

2. State Government has not adopted the instruction dated 30.03.2010 issued by

the GOI.

46

3. Finance Department cannot accept such type of cases and if only single case

is considered in favour of the incumbent, it may invite litigation and it will be

ultra virus of the Article 14 of the Constitution in the eyes of Hon’ble Court.

4. AD has referred the case of pay protection of Dr. Pardeep, Medical Officer, who

was initially appointed in the University of Health Science on 15.10.2010, in

terms of Rule 10 of HCS (PAY) Rules, 2016.

5. As per Act 26 of 2008 issued vide Government Not.f!ication No. S.O.74/HA.26/

2008/S.1/2008 dated 18.08.2008 passed by the State Assembly; it is a

maintained institute/autonomous body.

6. Rule 10 of HCS (PAl) Rules, 2016 provides the pay protection on subsequent

appointment from one department to another department only and does not

provide for protection of pay of the university/autonomous body on subsequent

appointment in the Government Department.

7. Moreover, CSR Vol-I Part-I is applicable at the time of subsequent appointment

i.e. 16.09.2015, there is no provision in these rules also to protect the pay of

the university/autonomous body.

Therefore, keeping in view of the above facts, the case of the pay protection is

neither covered under Rule 10 of HCS (PAY) Rules, 2016 nore under the provision of

CSR Vol-I Part-I, as such, Finance Department Is not agreed with the proposal of AD.“

foRr foHkkx ls izkIr mDr ea=.kk vuqlkj Mk0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh dk mu}kjk ih0th0 vkbZ0,e0,l0] jksgrd esa dh xbZ lsok vuqlkj osru fu/kkZfjr ugha fd;k tk ldrkAfoRr foHkkx ls izkIr mDr i= dh izfr lyaXu gSA

mijksDr of.kZr fLFkfr vuqlkj MkW0 iznhi dqekj] fpfdRlk vf/kdkjh] flfoy gLirky]fHkokuh ds osru&fu;r ds lEcU/k esa iVh'ku desVh dks ekeyk lwpukFkZ ,oa vkxkeh vko';ddk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

v/kh{kd] LokLF;&kd`rs iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj]

LokLF; foHkkxA

v'kk0 Øekad 32@02@2017&6,p0ch01 fnukad] p.Mhx<+ 25 tqykbZ] 2017

bldh ,d izfr egkfuns'kd] LokLF; lsok,a] gfj;k.kk] iapdwyk dks lwpukFkZ ,oeavko';d dk;Zokgh gsrw Hksth tkrh gSA

Sd/-

v/kh{kd] LokLF;&kd`rs iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk ljdkj]

LokLF; foHkkxA

The committee considered the reply received from the department in its meeting

held on 12-01-2018 and felt satisfied and decided to dispose of the petition accordingly.

47

8. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SMT.

BHUPENDER KAUR D/o SH. GURSHRAN SINGH, VILL. SALEMPUR

BAN GAR P.O. CHACHHROLl, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR, REGARDING

ALLOTMENT OF PLOT IN OUSTEES OUOTA.

The Petition/Representation received from Smt. Bhupender Kaur, reads as

under :-

lsok esa

ifV'ku desVhgfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkkA

fo"k; %& xzke jSyh ¼lSDVj 12&,½ iapdwyk esa Questess Queta esa IykV vykV gksusckjsA

Jheku th]

lfou; izkFkZuk gSa fd esjs firk th Jh xqj'kj.k flag iq= Jh /;ku flag th dh xzke jSyhlSDVj&12, iapdwyk esa 81 duky ds yxHkx Hkwfe vftZr gqbZ FkhA esjs firk th us Questess Queta

esa IykV vykV djokus ds fy, jkf'k tek djokbZ FkhA ;g fd esjs firk Jh xqj'kj.k flag th cqtqxZFks rFkk pyus fQjus esa vleFkZ FksA ;g fd fot; /kou iq= Jh jkepUnz fuoklh iapdwyk us esjsfirk dk s cgyk Qqlyk dj ikoj vkQ vVkjuh vius uke djok yh vk Sjxqj'kj.k flag th ls [kpsZ ds iSls ysrk jgkA ;g fd fnukad 15-04-2006 dks esjs firk th dk LoXkZoklgks x;k Fkk rFkk muds ejus ds ckn ikoj vkWQ vVkjuh [kRe gks xbZA ;g fd esjs firk ds LoxZoklds i'pkr ml iykV ij vc esjk gd gSa ijUrq fot; /kou iq= Jh jkepUnz fuoklh iapdwyk eq>s/kedh nsrk gSa fd gqMMk esa esjh lSafVax gSa vkSj ;g IYkkWV eSa rqEgkjs uke ij fudyus ugha nwaxk vkSjgesa iSlksa dh vkQj djrk gSa rFkk ge 10 lky ls bl Nkuchu esa yxs gq, gSa rFkk gesa dqN Hkh izkIrugha gqvkA

vr% tukc ls izkFkZuk gS fd ;g 10&10 ejysa ds nks IYkkWV esjs uke ij fd;k tk, ftldsge gdnkj curs gSa A D;ksafd ml nkSjku ds lHkh IYkkWV fd;s tk pqds gSa vkSj ge iwjh jkf'k vnkdj pqds gSaA vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

/kU;okn lfgrA

fnukad %& 19-07-2016

Sd/-

izkFkhZx.kHkwfiUnz dkSj liq=h Jh xqj'kj.k flag/keZiRuh Jh ijethr flag fuoklhxzke lyseiqj ckaxj] Mk0 NNjkSyh]

ftyk ;equkuxj

48

The petition/representation was placed before the committee in its meeting held

on 02-08-2016, The committee considered the same and desired that the comments of the

concerned departments may be obtained within a period of 15 days . The representation

was sent to the concerned department on 04-08-2016, the Chief Administator Haryana,

HUDA, Haryana has sent their reply vide their letter No. 66516, dt. 09-09-2016 vide their

reply they stated.

“That the report was collected from Estate Office who has submitted that the

application of Sh. Gursharan Singh 5/0 Sh. Dhian Singh had applied for 2 Nos. 10 maria

plots in Sector 12-A, Panchkula. As per report of LAO, Panchkula, the applicant

Sh.Gursharan Singh 5/0 Sh. Dhina Singh and his mother Smt. Kartar Kaur were the cosharer.

Total land measuring 81 kanal was acquired. The applicant along with the co-sharer is

found eligible for two plots of 10 maria each (copy of proceeding attached).

As per record available in Estate Office, Sh. Gursharan Singh had expired on

15.4.2016 and he executed un-registered will on 29.8.2003 in favour of Sh. Vijay Kumar 5/0

Sh. Ram Chand R/o H.No. 134, Village Maheshpur, Panchkula. The will if out of family.

Vide representation dated 19.7.2016 (received from Hon’ble Petition Committee

on 18.8.2016), the applicant Smt. Bhupinder Kaur is claiming to be legal heir of deceased

Sh. Gursharan Singh and she wants that she should be considered under oustees quota

being legal heir. As per record available in our office, Smt. Bhuipinder Kaur never applied

for any oustee plot earlier nor on the basis of said decision of Screening Committee, any

plot was allotted to anyone.

In compliant of the decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in Sandeep’s case and

Bhagwan Singh case, the Headquarter has issued a latest policy on the oustees dated

11.8.2016. Now this office submits that, the balance plot for oustees of Urban Estate,

Panchkula, are being advertised and the oustees may apply against this advertisement

along with the documents as mentioned in the latest oustees policy dated 11.8.2016.

The latest oustee policy dated 11.8.2016 is available on official website of HUDA

(www.huda.gov.in) and other details on vacant plots, their size and rates etc. are likely to

be hosted soon. The copy is also attached.

Ms. Bhupinder Kaur may apply against this advertisement after fulfilling the

formalities and her claim will be settled as per law.”

The Committee orally examined the Departmental representatives and the

petitioner in its meeting held on 24.09.2015 in which Committee desired that department

provide all the documents related to this case to the Committee and the petitioner after

examining this Committee will proceed further in this case. The Chief Administrator, HUDA,

Panchkula, has submit his-reply vide their letter No. UB.A.7- 2016/129238, dated 09.12.2016,

in which he has stated as under:-

“The Estate Officer, HUDA, Panchkula has intimated that as per condition no.15

of policy issued vide no. UBI A- 5/2016/46608-09, dated 11.08.2016 (copy enclosed ) an

oustees who has made an application for allotment of plot under oustees policy on any

previous occasion and said application either is pending for decision or was rejected on

any ground and said rejection order was impugned before any court of law or Aurhority or

forum of any nature and matter has been remanded back to the Authority for fresh decision,

shall be informed of the decision in Bhagwan Singh’s case and Sandeep’s case and may be

advised to apply for allotment of plot in fresh advertisement which will be issued after

determination of reservation and their earnest money may be refunded alongwith interest

49

@5.5 % per annum from date of deposit till date of payment. However, litigation is pending

then the court of law of authority of forum where litigation is pending may be informed of

the aforesaid decision and efforts may be made to get the litigation disposed off in terms

specified herein.

The Estate Officer, HUDA, Panchkula has intimated that he has already requested

to Smt. Bhupiner Kaur W/o Sh. Paramjeet Singh D/o Sh. GursharanSingh R/o Village

Salempur Bangar, Post Office Chhachhroli, Distt. Yamunanagar to submit no Objection of

other legal heirs for refund of earnest money against 2 No. Plots applied under oustees

quota amounting to Rs.1,99,972/- vide memo no. 8681, dated 06.09.2016, but till date no

documents has been received from the petitioner/applicant in his office.”

The Committee considered the reply and discussed the matter in its meeting

held on 14.12.2016, in which departmental representatives informed the Committee that a

new oustee policy has been enforced and the petitioner has to apply according to new

policy and department will consider her claim when she will apply according to the new

policy of oustees. The Committee satisfied with the reply of department and disposed off

the petition.

Thereafter, Petitioner Smt. Bhupinder Kaur, has submit new representation/

petition dated 12.01.2017, before the Committee, which reads as under:-

PAS TE new Petition dated 12.01.2017

lsok esa

ekuuh; iSfV'ku desVh]gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk p.Mhx<+A

fo"k; %& nj[kkLr ckcr izkFkhZ;k dks IykVl iqjkuh iksfylh ds rgr nsus ckjsA

&&&&&&&

Jheku th]

izkFkhZ;k vkils fuosnu djrh gS fd %&

1- ;g fd izkFkhZ;k HkwisUnz dkSj iq+=h Jh xqjlj.k flag fuoklh xkao lyseiqj ckaxj] Mkd[kkukNNjkSYkh] rglhy NNjkSyh] ftyk ;equkuxj dh jgus okyh gSA

2- ;g fd izkFkhZ;k us iqjkuh iksfylh gkmlVht dksVk ds rgr IykVl ds fy, vkosnu fd;kFkk ysfdu gqMk foHkkx iapdwyk IykVl }kjk vc izkFkhZ;k dks ubZ iksfylh ds rgr vkosnu djusds fy, dgk tk jgk gS ysfdu izkFkhZ;k us rks iqjkuh ikWfylh ds rgr 2003 esa IykVl ds fy, vkosnufd;k Fkk vkSj izkFkhZ;k dh tehu Hkh iqjkuh ikWfylh ds rgr vf/kd`r dh xbZ FkhA

3- ;g fd vkt ds le; esa gqMMk IykVksa dh dher foHkkx esa iqjkuh ikWfylh ds fglkc lscgqr vf/kd c<+ gks pqdh gS ysfdu tc izkFkhZ;k dh tehu vf/kd`r gqbZ Fkh rks ml le; tehudh dher cgqr de Fkh vkSj mlh dher ;kfu jkf'k ds fglkc ls eq> izkFkhZ;k us IykVl ds fy,vkosnu fd;k FkkA tks fd ubZ ikWfylh vc fnlEcj 2016 esa ykxq dh xbZ gS tks fd izkFkhZ;k ds mijykxq ugha gksrhA

50

4- ;g fd izkFkhZ;k 14 lkyksa ls /kDds [kk jgh gS vkSj izkFkhZ;k ckj ckj gqMMk foHkkx ds pDdjyxkk jgh gS vkSj gqMk foHkkx ds deZpkjh izkFkhZ;k dks ;g dgrs gS fd vius iSls okfil ys yks vkSjtc Hkh ubZ ikWfylh vk;sxh mlds rgr gh nksckjk ls vkosnu dj nsukA tc izkFkhZ;k us igys gh2003 esa vkosnu fd;k gqvk gS vkSj ml le; ds fglkc ls Qhl vnk dh gqbZ gS rks nksckjk ls vkosnudjus dk rks dksbZ vkSfpR; gh ugha curkA

5- ;g fd ;gka crkus ;ksX; ckr ;g gS fd ftu O;fDr;ksa us izkFkhZ;k ds lkFk iqjkuh ikWfylhds rgr vkosnu fd;s Fks mu lHkh dks iqjkuh ikWfylh ds rgr IykV Hkh fey pqds gS ysfdu eq>izkFkhZ;k dks vkt rd Hkh IykV uk feyk gS vkSj tks ubZ ikWfylh vkbZ gS izkFkhZ;k viuh lkjh tehucspdj Hkh mldh Qhl vnk ugha dj ldrhA

blfy, vkils fuosnu gS fd mijksDr rF;ksa dks /;ku esa j[krs gq;s izkFkhZ;k dks iqjkuhikWfylh ds fglkc ls IykWVl fn;s tk;sA

vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

fnukad %& 12@01@2017 izkFkhZ;k

Sd/-

HkqisUnz dkSj iq=h Jh xqjlj.k flagfuoklh xkao lyseiqj ckaxj]Mkd[kkuk NNjkSyh] rglhyNNjkSyh] ftyk ;equkuxjA

The Committee orally examined the departmental representatives and the

petitioner in its meeting held on 17.01.2017and 25.07.2017 in which committee discussed

the matter and considered the petitioner request and desired that petitioner may be given

the plot on the rates which were existed on date of her entitlement the same after following

all the procedure and approval of the Govt.

The petition was disposed of by the Committee in its meeting held on 23-2-2018.

———————

9. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SHRI MAN ISH SAINI,

MD, KAY KAY GLOBAL SUPPLIERS, AMBALA CANTT., REGARDING

COMPLAINT /RE-SAMPLING IN TENDER NO. l0261.

The Petition/Representation received from Shri Manish Saini, reads as under:-

Add. : 3171, 12 Cross Road, Ambala Cantt. Haryana, INDIA (133001) TIN

06031045259

51

To,

The Chairman,

Petition Committee,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

Subect:- Request for Re-Sampling in Tender No. 10261 for supply of supply of Science

Lab Kits for Education Department opened on 04.02.2016 by Department of

Supplies & Disposals.

Respected Sir,

I am to invite a reference to Tender No.10261 floated by the Director General of

Supplies & Disposals Department inviting supply of Science Lab kits on behalf of Haryana

School Siksha Pariyojna Parishad (HSSPP) opened on 04.02.2016. In the process of opening

of tender following shortcomings/omissions were noticed and pointed out to The Director

General, Supplies & Disposals (DS&D) and The Director, Haryana School Siksha Pariyojna

Parishad (HSSPP) by me but no satisfactory reply has been received so far. I, therefore,

bring to your kind notice the Omissions noticed in the process of opening/Checking of

Samples dtd : 22/03/2016.

(a) As enunciated in note 7 of the terms & conditions of the tender” In case of

Evidence of cartel formation by the bidders, the EMD is liable to be forfeited along with

other actions as are permissible to Goverment”. But it was noticed and pointed out that

the following firms formed the CARTEL

(i) Laboratory Instruments & Chemical

(ii) Ahuja Scientific & Sports Works

(iii) Sachdeva Instruments Co.

(iv) Mediworld India.

Clear Proofs of formation of CARTEL by these companies were on the record as

all these companies had provided Sample items similar to each other. They have also given

bid for Similar Chemical in the brand name of ALPHA CHEM which is Health Hazardous

for the students. This is a clear cut proof of formation of CARTEL and despite sufficient

proof of Cartel the finance bid has been opened and tender is likely to be allotted to the

CARTEL.

(b) The ALPHA CHEM brand chemicals are registered at the address of MIS APLHA

CHEM, 341, Industrial Growth Centre, Saha (Ambala) which is merely a plot size of 450 Sq.

Meters. No Chemical industry can be set up in such a small land and is against the

prescribed norms.

(c) Formation of Cartel benefited these firms and they quoted overprice of items

which may be a loss to the Education Department.

52

(d) Close discussions of these firms with Sh. Rajeev Vats, consultant HSSPP, Haryana

were noticed during the process of sampling. The Entire Sample selection team was closely

monitored and directed by him to follow his instructions scrupulously.

(e) Some of our Samples were straight away rejected by the team of Sh. Rajeev Vats

without assigning any reason.

(f) As per financial Rules the tender may be allotted to the lower priced person and

in case of non allotment of tender to lower priced tenderer reason may be recorded in

writing. But it seems that this formality has also not met with.

(g) There were about 30-40 Different written complaints related to the above

mentioned CARTEL from various other companies were forwarded to both the departments.

And it was clearly highlighted that the terms & conditions of this Tenderwere made

Specifically favourable only to this Cartel.

The above omissions and facts were pointed out to the Director General of

Supplies & Disposals Haryana and The State Director, Haryana School Siksha Pariyojna

Parishad Haryana and an Inquiry Committe was formed and headed by the same person

who was appointed to open and check the specifications of the Tender and Tender Sample

Items respectively and who was fully helpful to the CARTEL formed by above four firms.

As per various judgments of the Supreme Court the appointment of a person as

Inquiry Officer who originally headed the work is against the rules as he cannot provide

justice in the same matter having bias mind.

I shall be highly thankful to you if you could kindly intervene in the matter and

arrange to expedite the Re-Sampling by an independent body that has no links with the

bidders or CARTEL. In addition to this the above facts may also be got examined by that

independent body and suitable action may be taken against the erring officers.

Yours faithfully,

(MANIS SAINI, M.D.)

KAY KAY GLOBAL SUPPLIERS

AMBALA CANTT

Dtd : 12.08.2016

The Petition/representation was placed before the Committee in its meeting held

on 20.08.2016, the Committee considered the same and desired that the comments of the

concerned department may be obtained within a period of 15 days. The representation

was sent to the concerned department on 08.09.2016. The State Project Director, HSSPP,

Panchkula has sent the reply vide thier letter no. SSA/PO/2016/21708, dated. 05.10.2016,

which reads as under:-

53

HARYANA SCHOOL SHIKSHA PARIYOJNA PARISHAD

(Regd Under Societies Registration Act, 1860)

Shiksha Sadan, 3rd & 4th Floor, Sector-5, Panchkula-134109

Tel: 0172-2590505, 2586026(F) I E-mail:................I Website: www.hsspp.in

Ref. No: SSA/PO/2016/21708 Dated: 5.10.2016

To

The Principal Secretary,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Secretariat, Chandigarh

Subject:- Regarding complaint/re-sampling in Tender no. 10261

Please refer to your office letter no. HVS/Petition/503/ 16-17/20046

dated 8.10.2016 on the subject cited above.

It is stated that a committee has been formed to verify the procedure and to

submit the fact finding report soon.

After examining the report the reply would be sent accordingly.

State Project Director

HSSPP, Panchkula

Encl :-

Copy of Committee members

HARYANA SCHOOL SHIKSHA PARIYOJNA PARISHAD

(Regd. Under Societies Registration Act, 1860)

Shiksha Sadan, 3rd & 4lh Floor, Sector-S, Panchkula-134109

Tel: 0172·2590505, 2586026(F) I [-mail: ...........•....... I Website: www.hsspp.in

Ref. No: Dated :

To

The Accounts Officer

0/0 The Principal Secretary

Haryana Vidhan Sabha.

Chandigarh

Subject: - Regarding complaint/re-sampling in Tender No. 10261

Please refer your letter no. HVS/Petition/503/20046 dated 14.9.2016.

At the outset it is submitted that the allegations made in the complaint are

frivolous. baseless and devoid of substance and any merit which arc also not supported

with any material proofs.

The entire process of callingof online bids for tender No.10261. supply of Science

Items and opening of bids by the appointed committee was done at the level of Director.

Supplies and Disposal. The Parishad had no role in any way or at any stage to influence

the rate contract. Infact, there was complete transparency and fair play adopted by the

54

Director, Supplies and Disposal and HPPC selected only the eligible companies who fulfill

the laid down norms as per the tender.

Further. HSSPP had also received a similar complaint which was examined by a

appointed committee. The appointed committee checked and verified the procedure

adopted during the finalization or the tender. The committee did not find any irregularity in

finalizing or the successful bidder. A photocopy of the written report submitted by the

appointed committee is attached as Annexure for your ready reference please.

A similar complaint received by Director. Supplies & Disposal Haryana was

brought before the HPPC which was headed by the Finance Minister Haryana and other

complaints in this matter was apprised by the Hon’ble Chief Minister. Thereafter, after

considering all facts the High Power Purchase Committee finalized the tender.

Delay submission of reply is highly regretted.

Sd/-

State roject Director

HSSPP, Panchkula

COMMITTEE MEMBERS

1. Sh. Dilbag Singh, Joint Director % District Elementary Education

2. Smt. Kamlesh Kumari, Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Badgodam, Panchkula

3. Sh. Surender Kumar, DSS % District Education Officer, Kurukshetra

4. Dr. Ashok Kumar, Lect. In Chemistry, Govt. Sr. Sec. School, Murtzapur,

Krukshertra

5. Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Mehta, Account Officer % District Programme Coordinator,

SSA/RMSA, Ambala

From

DilbagSingh, Joint Director

Shiksha Sadan, Sector-5,Panchkula.

To

Procurement Officer

For State Project Director

HSSPP~ Panchkula

Memo. SPL-I

Dated:25.10.20 16

Subject:- Regarding to verify the procedure and put up a fact finding report of Tender

No.10261 for purchase of Lab. Equipment (physics, Chemistry and Biology

Labs).

On the subject cited above, report submitted to you for-further necessary actions.

Attachment:-

1. 1 to 4 pages

(Dilbag Singh)

Joint Director Masters

0/0 Director Elementary Education

Panchkula.Haryana

55

Subject:- Regarding to verify the procedure and put up a fact finding report of Tender

No.10261 for purchase of Lab. Equipment (physics, Chemistry and Biology

Labs).

*****

That in reference to letter no. PO/SSA/ RMSA/20 16-17/21714 a committee was

constituted on dated 06.10.2016 namely Sh. Dilbag Singh, Joint Director O/o Directorate of

Elementary Education, Panchkula- Chairman, Smt, Kamlesh Kumari, Principal, GSSS,

Badgodam, Panchkula-Member-I, Sh. Surinder Singh, DSS 0/0 District Education Officer,

Kurkshetra- Member-2, Dr. Ashok Kumar, Lect. In Chemistry, GSSS, Murtzapur, Kurukshetra-

Member-3, Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Mehta, Account Officer O/o District Programme Coordinator,

Ambala- Member-4 to verify the procedure and put up a fact finding report of Rate Contract

for Lab Equipments (physics, Chemistry & Biology) for HSSPP and Secondary Education

as finalized by Director Supply & Disposal, Haryana through the High Power Purchase

Committee CHPPC) for 1163 Science Labs in various schools of State. In this context as

per the record provided by the HSSPP to the committee it is submitted as under:-

1. That Tender No. 10261 on dated 16.10.2015 was floated by the Director General

Supplies & Disposal through the e-tendering inviting science lab equipments on behalf of

HSSPP with date of opening of technical bid being 18.11.2015 with brief intimation in the

news paper which was further extended upto 31.12.2015. In the mean time on dated 28.12.2015

the HSSPP vide its memo no. 36606/PC/science/SSA requested for the withdrawal of the

above composite tender.

2. That ‘afterwards HSSPP Panchkula submitted fresh indent for the purchase of

Laboratory items i.e. Physics, Chemistry & Biology amounting approximately for Rs.13.63

Crores.

3. That tender was published on web portal https:/haryanaeprocurement.gov.in

with brief intimation in the news paper and as well as emails to manufacturers and’ technical

bids were opened on 04.02.2016 by Technical Committee Comprising-

(1) Sh. Vikas Gupta, lAS, Director, Supplies and Disposals, Haryana

(II) Sh. Sudhir Rana, Deputy Director, Supplies and Disposals, Haryana

(llI) Sh. Rajeev Vats, HSSPP, Panchkula

(IV) Sh. Amit Sharma, HSSPP, Panchkula

(V) Sh. Vivek, HSSPP, Panchkula

(VI) Sh. Omveer Malik, Govt. Q.M.C.(plastic) Faridabad

(Vll) Sh. Surender Singh, Inspector, State Vigilance Bureau, Haryana

(VllI) Sh. Subhash Garg, Subject Specialist Physics % SCERT Gurgaon

(IX) Smt, Poonam Yadav, Subject Specialist Biology % SCERT Gurgaon

(X) Sh. Gurdeep Gulati, Lect. Chemistry, % DEO Ambala

56

(XI) Sh. Rakesh Kumar, Lect. Chemistry, % DEO Ambala

(XII) Sh. Ashish Aggarwal, Lect. In Physics,O/o DEO Ambala

(XllI) Sh. Ram Sharan, Lect. In Physics, % DEO Ambala

4 . That in response to tender following 8 no. of firms submitted their bids namely

M/s Lab.oratury Instruments & Chemical, (LINCO), -M/s-Kay-Kay-Global

Suppliers, M/s Mediworld India, M/s Sachdeva Instruments Co, M/s Ahuja

Scientific and sports works, M/s Quality Industrial Corporation, M/s Jain

Scientific Glass Works & M/s Abom Exports.

5. That after scrutiny of technical bids by technical committee two firms namely

M/s Jain Scientific Glass Works & M/s Abom Exports were not found eligible as per NIT.

6. That in the samples testing report Technical Committee finalized samples

submitted by M/s Laboratory Instruments & Chemical (LINCO), Mis Sachdeva Instruments

Co, M/s Mediworld India, M/s Ahuja Scientific and sports works have been observed to

be as per NIT specifications vise by the sample testing committee, so, their samples are to

be considered as per NIT.

7. That financial bids of technically qualified bidders were opened on 03.05.2016

on the basis of reasonable rates offered by bidders. The Committee decided to arrange the

annual rate contact with firms as under-

Sr. Description of Rate Name of the firm Quantity No.

No. Store allocation

l. Physics Lab Item 32,8001- Ahuja Scientific and 100%

sports works, Ambala

2. Chemistry Lab 40,000/- Sachdeva Instruments 60%

Item Co., Ambala

Laboratory Instruments 40%

& Chemical (LINCO),

Ambala

3. Biology Lab Item 23,750/- Laboratory Instruments 100%

& Chemical (lNCO),

Ambala

The terms and conditions would be as per NIT. On asking of the firms, it was

clarified by the representatives of the indenting department that the supply orders would

preferably be placed by the Head Offices in collective manner.

8. That various representations/complaints namely Rapposns Laboratory Services,

Jain Laboratory Glassware Co., Kay Kay Global Suppliers, M/s Anil Scientific, M/s The

Laboratory Glassware CO., M/s Gupta Scientific Industries received regarding this tender

has already been decided on merits by higher authorities and hence needs no comments.

It is further submitted that the sample testing was done by the concerns subject experts

and needs no comments.

57

9. Reasonability of Rates:- As per standing decision of High Power Purchase

Committee (HPPC) the indenting deptt. is required to bring rates of at least three adjoining

states so as to assess Reasonability of Rates in the meeting otHPPC. In this context it is

submitted that the rates submitted by HSSPP vide their letter dated 10.05.2016 (Annexure-

6) is of Rajasthan & Punjab in which reasonability of rates is relied upon the letters/

demand from Principal/ Headmaster Adarsh Sr. Sec.School Balwada, Block Sayala Jalore

(Rajasthan) and Principal Govt. Higher Secondary School Jaswantpura, Jalore (Rajasthan)

has ordered to supply the Science equipments goods to M/s Shree Enterprises Ambala

Cantt. On dated 20.03.2015 and 17.03.2015 respectively. In case of Punjab- Punjab School

Shiksha Board complex, 4th Floor, “E” Block, Phase-8 Ajitgarh has ordered to M/s M.S.

Sachdeva enterprises company Ambala Cantt, to supply of Science Equipments/ goods

on dated 30.03.2016 and vide tender dated 16.07.2014.

It is pertinent to mention that the reasonability of rates has been verified

from the office record i.e page No. 450 to 467 and 468 to 478 of two states.

To

Procurement Officer

For State Project Director

HSSPP, Panchkula

l. Sh. Dilbag Singh - Chairman

2. Smt.Kamlesh Kumari-Member-l

3. Sh. Surinder Singh -Member-2

4. Dr. Ashok Kumar - Member-3

5. Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Mehta -Member-4

The Committee orally examined the Additional Chief Secretary to Govt., Haryana,

School Education Department, Haryana, Director, Haryana School Siksha Pariyojna

Parishad and the petitioner in its meeting held on 14.03.2017 and 06.06.2017 and desired

that Additional Chief Secretary to Govt., Haryana, School Education Department, Haryana

will give personal hearing to the Petitioner and Petitioner will submit all his fact to them.

The Committee disposed of the petition in its meeting held on 23-2-2018.

10. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SMT. MONIKA

MEHTA W/o SH. YOGESH MEHTA, R/O B-801. APEX APARTMENT,

SECTOR 45, GURGAON, REGARDING CRIMINAL COMPLAINT AGAINST

RAM SHANTI SHANTI COOP. GROUP HOUSING SOCIETY LTD.

The Petition/representatioin received from Smt. Monika Mehta,

reads as under :-

58

To

The Chairman Date: 7/09/15

Petition Committee

Haryana Vidhan Sabha

Chandigarh.

Sub:- Criminal complaint against (1) Sh. Randip Singh resident of B-503, Aralias

DLF Golf Course Road, Gurgaon (2) Vijay Tehlani R/o CGHS Plot No. 19,

Sector-52, Gurgaon,Haryana and (3) other unknown accomplices of serial

numbers 1 to 2, for committing criminal conspiracy, misappropriation, breach

of trust, cheating, forgery, and document manipulation with the motive of

deriving wrongful gain for themselves and by causing corresponding wrongful

loss to the complainant.

Sir,

The complainant most respectfully submits as under.-

1. That the complainant has purchased a flat in The Ram Shanti Coop. Group

Housing Society Ltd. Plot No. 19, Sector-52, Gurgaon, Haryana in April, 2013, share

certificate/membership certificate No. 144 given after purchase is attached with this

complaint. The accused no. 1 is Vice President, accused no. 2 is Secretary of above said

society.

2. That the complainant has purchase the flat for a total sale consideration of Rs.

102.75 lacs. Out of which 31.601acs has been paid to society and recipt of same is attached

with complaint.52 lacs were given to Mr. Randip through Mr. Himanshu Maggaon who is

a witness of our case and rs.0.75lacs were paid towards transfer of falt to Mr. Randip in his

office:Farm house no 1 near Ghitorni Metro station, New’ Delhi in presence of Mr. Himanshu

Maggon.

3. The said flat has been purchased by the complainant from Mr. Randip. The

membership was confirmed by accused no. 1 vide Welcome letter which is attached herewith.

The accused no.1 also demanded Rs. 31.60 lacs to be deposited in the account of society

which was deposited and recipt is attached herewith. That the complainant had made

initial payment of Rs. 31.60 lacs vide cheque no. 730519,730520 of Rs. 25lac and 6.60lacs

respectively dt. 07-05- 2013, drawn on OBC, S.LOK-1,GURGAON . That after some time

the complainant has come to know that the affairs of the above mentioned society are not

carried out as per provisions of the law. No meeting was ever conveyed by the managing

committee nor any information regarding the construction of flat have ever been given to

the complainant and other members. The complainant time and again visited the office of

society and met with the accused persons, but no satisfactory reply was given to the

complainant.

4. That the complainant has not received neither transfer letter nor

name of member resigned from society whose flat will be allotted to complainant from

society till time and till date. So they are liable to be prosecuted for the offence of cheating

by impersonation, misappropriation and criminal breach of trust.

59

5. Since all the record of the society are in the custody of accused persons and the

account of the society is being operated by them, and the complainant has no access to

them, so he is not able to unearth the fraud committed by the accused persons.

6. The complainant has also learnt that several other complaints of serious nature

for same or similar type of offence are pending against the accused persons. It is evident

from the foregoing that in pursuance of their nefarious and sinister design,’ the accused

persons, their accomplices and cohorts subjected the complainant to several serious

criminal offences, which-to our understanding of law- prima facie attract the provisions of

403, 406, 420, IPC against the aforesaid accused persons and other unknown accomplices

who may be involved in the entire conspiracy and may have jointly and severally committed

the aforesaid offences. It is therefore requested that an FIR may be registered to investigate

the matter and to unearth the truth, so as to bring the guilty to justice.

Your Sincerely Monika Mehta W /0 Yogesh Mehta R/o B-801, Apex Apartment,

Sec-45 Gurgaon-122003

Enclosures :-

1. The Ram Shanti Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. Membership Certificate

No. 144 dated 03-05-2013.

2. Letter from the Vice President, The Ram Shanti Cooperative Group Housing

Society Ltd. Confirming Membership to the Society along with the details of Flat booking.

3. Receipts of payment of Rs. 31.60 lacs to the society.

4. Copy of mails exchanged with Mr.Randip for Transfer of flat.

5. Police Copy attached/Police complant.

The Petition/representation was placed before the Committee in its meeting

held on 14.09.2015, the Committee desired that comments of the concerned

department may be obtained within a 15 days. As no reply was received within

astipulated period, reminders were issued on 14.10.2015. After that the Committee

received reply from Commissioner of Police, Gurgaon, vide their letter No. 46476/

CC, dated 20.10.2015, which reads as under:-

izs"kd

iqfyl vk;qDrxqM+xkaoA

lsok esa

iz/kku lfpo]gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk lfpoky;]lSDVj&1] p.Mhx<+A

Øekad % 46476@lh0lh0 fnukad 20&10&15

60

fo"k; % Complaint of Monika Mehta was Yogesh Mehta r/o B-801, Apex Apartment,

Sec-45, Gurgaon and others.

;kfn

d`i;k vkids dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad HVS /Petition/15-1614665-67 fnukad15-09-15 o Lej.k i= Øekad HVS /Petition/15-16/16002 fnukad 14-10-15 ds lUnHkZ esaA

2- mijksDr fo"k;k/khu ifjokn dh tkap iqfyl mik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao ds ek/;e ls bUpktZvkfFkZd mijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ] xqM+xkao }kjk djkbZ xbZA nkSjkus tkap ifjoknhx.k dks 'kkfey tkap djdsmuds dFku vafdr fd;s x;s o jke 'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh] lSDVj&52]xqM+xkao rFkk lgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls fjdkMZ fy;kA lkslk;Vh }kjk cryk;k x;k fd lfefrdk iz/kku /keZohj eXxq] mldk HkkbZ vejthr eXxq] mlds fj'rsnkj jkeizdk'k fexykuh] cgu dqlqexqy'ku o nks vU; lnL; Fks] tks lkslk;Vh NksMdj Hkkx x;s gS] blfy, lgk;d jftLVªkjdks&vkijsfVo lkslk;Vh us lfefr Hkax dj nh gSA lgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls tkudkjh yh xbZftUgksaus fyf[kr esa cryk;k fd ifjoknh Jh jtr dY;ky o Jh foey ,u tsBk igys lfefr dslnL; Fks] ysfdu vc ugha gS rFkk Jhefr eksfudk esgrk Hkh lnL; ugha gSaA ifjoknhx.k Jh jtrdY;ky }kjk 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s] Jh foey ,u tsBk }kjk 20 yk[k #i;s o Jhefr eksfudkesgrk }kjk 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;s lfefr esa tek djk;k x;k gS] ysfdu fjdkMZ ds eqrkfcdifjoknhx.k dh lnL;rk lfefr esa ugha gSA iqfyl mik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao }kjk bUpkTkZ vkfFkZdvijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ] xqM+xkao dh tkap fjiksVZ ds vk/kkj ij ifjokn ij /kkjk 406]420 Hkk0n0l0 ds rgrFkkuk lq'kkUr yksd] xqM+xkao esa vfHk;ksx vafdr djus dh flQkfj'k dh xbZA ekeys ckjs vfHk;ksxvafdr djds vkxkeh dk;Zokgh vey esa ykbZ tk;sxhA iqfyl mik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao o vkfFkZd vijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ] xqM+xkao ls izkIr fjiksVZ dh Nk;kizfr voyksdukFkZ layXu gSA

layXu&;FkksijhALVkQ vkfQlj&k

d`rs% iqfyl vk;qDr]

xqM+xkoA

The Committee orally examined the departmental representatives in its meetings

held on 09.01.2016, 02.02.2016 and 20.05.2016. During oral examinations Registrar,

Cooperative Societies, Commissioner of Police, Gurgaon and Ex-Hon. President of Ram

Shanti CGHS, Gurgaon, vide their letter No. 4660, dt.19.05.2016, letter No. 620- PD,

dt.01.06.2016 and letter dt.20.05.2016 respectively

Øekad % 4660@ vkj-ds-k@ljl@ fnukad 19&05&2016

izsf"kr

lgk;d jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka] xqM+xkaoA

61

lsok esa

jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka] gfj;k.kkiapdwykA

fo"k; % nh jke 'kkfUr lgdkjh xzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkao dk ekStwnk la{ksifooj.k o dk;Zokgh

nh jke 'kkfUr lgdkjh xzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkao esa fnukad 25-05-2003 dksjftLVMZ gqbZ gSA lfefr dk xr pquko fnukad 30-06-2010 dks gqvk FkkA lfefr dh izCkU/kd desVhdk dk;Zdky fnukad 29-06-2015 dks lekIr gks x;k gSA lfefr dk dk;Z lqpk: :i ls pykus dsfy, bl dk;kZy; }kjk fnukad 17-07-2015 dks iz'kkld e.My dh fu;qfDr dh xbZA lfefr esaiz'kkld e.My ds }kjk lfefr dk fjdkMZ dCts esa ysus ds fy, lfefr dh HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVhdks fHkUu&2 frfFk;ksa ij i=kpkj fd;k x;k ijUrq HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh ds }kjk dksbZ Hkh fjdkMZiz'kkld e.My dks miyC/k ugha djk;k x;kA iz'kkld e.My }kjk dk;kZy; esa miyC/k fjdkMZlfefr jftLVªs'ku QkbZy o vkfMV fjiksVZ ls lfefr dk pquko djkus gsrw lEHkkfor lwfp fnukad26-10-2015 dks tkjh dh xbZA bl lEcU/k esa iz'kkld e.My }kjk nks jk"Vªh; lekpkj i= esafoKkiu izdkf'kr djok;k x;k fd vxj fdlh lfefr lnL; dks bl lEHkkfor lwfp ij fdlh izdkjdh dksbZ vkIifr gS rks ,d efgus ds vUnj&2 viuk ,srjkt nkf[ky djsaA rRi'pkr lnL;ksa ds}kjk iz'kkld e.My esa lgk;d jftLVªkj lgdkjh lfefr;k] xqM+xkao ds lEeq[k ,srjkt nkf[kyfd, x,A iz'kkld e.My }kjk 9 ,srjktksa dh lquokbZ djrs gq, fnukad 15&01&2016 dks QSlykdj fn;k x;kA iz'kkld e.My }kjk 9 ,srjktksa dh lquokbZ djrs gq, fnukad 15&01&2016 dksQSlyk dj fn;k x;kA iz'kkld e.My dh vof/k 15-01-2016 dks lekIr gks xbZ FkhA iz'kklde.My dh vof/k esa lfefr dk pquko u gksus ds dkj.k iz'kkld e.My dh vof/k c<kus ckjs bldk;kZy; ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA bl dk;kZy; }kjk iz'kkld e.My dh vof/k c<kus dk dsl ljdkjds ikl Hkstk x;kA ljdkj }kjk fnukad 29&03&2016 dks iz'kkld e.My dh vof/k fnukad 15-01-2016 ls vxys N% ekg@lfefr dk pquko gksus rd tks Hkh igys gks rd c<k nh xbZA bldk;kZy; esa lfefr lnL;ksa ds dqy 23 ,srjkt izkIr gq,A ftudh lquokbZ gsrw lacaf/kr dks uksfVltkjh dj lquokbZ dh xbZA lquokbZ ds le; HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh dh rjQ ls dksbZ Hkh lnL;gkftj ugha gqvkA dk;kZy; esa miyC/k fjdkMZ ds vk/kkj ij o ,rjktdrkZvksa }kjk miyC/k djk,x, nLrkostksa ds vk/kkj ij 23 ,srjktksa esa ls 5 ,srjktksa ij QSlyk dj fn;k x;kA blh nkSjkuiwoZ izcU/kd desVh ds lnL;ksa Jh fot; rgykuh o vU; ds }kjk ekuuh; iatkc ,oa gfj;k.kkmPp U;k;ky; esa CWP no 2392/2016 ;kfpdk nk;j dh xbZ fd lgk;d jftLVªkj] lgdkjhlfefr;ka xqM+xkao }kjk mUgsaa lquokbZ dk ekSdk fn;k tk,A rRi'pkr bl dk;kZy; }kjk HkwriwoZ izcu/kd desVh lnL;ksa ekSdk nsrs gq, ,srjktksa ij lquokbZ gsrw uksfVl tkjh fd, x,A blds QyLo:i13 dsl bl dk;kZy; }kjk fuiVku dj fn;s x,A bl izdkj dk;kZy; }kjk dqy 18 dslksa dkfuiVku dj fn;k x;kA 'ks"k 5 dslksa dk fuiVkjk tYn gh dj fn;k tk,xkA blds ckn pqukoizfØ;k vkjEHk dj nh tk,xh o ubZ izca/kd desVh dk xBu dj fn;k tk,xkA

62

blds vykok fujh{kd] lgdkjh lfefr;k] xqM+xkao&k }kjk lfefr dk fjdkMZ izkIr djusgsrw bl dk;kZy; }kjk lpZ okjUV ukxk x;k FkkA bl dk;kZy; }kjk fnukad 03-03-2016 dks lpZokjUV tkjh dj fn;k x;k FkkA bl lanHkZ esa fufj{kd] lgdkjh lfefr;ka] xqM+xkao&k us fnukad 04-05-2016 dks fjiksVZ dh gS fd lfefr dk;kZy; esa fjdkMZ lpZ fd;k x;k o HkwriwoZ lfpo Jh fot;rgykuh HkwriwoZ Jh j.knhi flag mi iz/kku ls fjdkMZ izkIr djus gsrw dkQh iz;kl fd, x, ijUrqHkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh }kjk mls lfefr dk fjdkMZ miyC/k ugha djok;k x;kA fujh{kd us ;g HkhfjiksVZ dh gS fd HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh }kjk lfefr dk fjdkMZ miyC/k u djkuk ;g n'kkZrk gS fdHkwriwoZ izcU/kd ds f[kykQ iqfyl dk;Zokgh djus dh fLQkfj'k dh gSA lfefr ds fjdkMZ dks cjkendjkus gsrw dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad 4523 fnukad 05-05-16 ds }kjk ekuuh; iqfyl vk;qDr dks ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- djkus dh izkFkZuk ns nh xbZ gSA

lfefr dh HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh lnL; Jh /keZchj eXxq iz/kku] Jh j.knhi flag mi iz/kku Jh fot; rgykuh [ktkaph o Jh vejthr EkXxq desVh lnL; }kjk lfefr esa dkQh O;fDr;ksadks fgLlk izek.k i= ¼'ks;j lfVZfQdsV½ tkjh djus] lfefr esa dkQh vfu;ferrk, djus o xcugksus dk vUns'kk ckjs mDr lHkh ds fo:) fnukad 21-04-2016 dks vknj.kh; iqfyl vk;qDr dks izFkelwpuk fjiksVZ ntZ djus ds fy, fy[k fn;k x;k FkkA gfj;k.kk jkT; ds lHkh lgk;d jftLVªkj]lgdkjh lfefr;ka] lEink vf/kdkjh gqMk foHkkx o rglhynkjksa dks vkxkeh vkns'kksa rd budhlEifr dks vU; ds uke rcnhy u djus ckjs o lEifr dk C;kSjk nsus ckjs fy[k fn;k x;k gSA

lfefr esa fookn T;knk gksus ds dkj.k le; yx ldrk gS rFkk fookn fuiVkus ds iz;kltkjh gSa vksj fooknksa dk 'kh?kz fuiVku dj fn;k tk,xkA

lgk;d jftLVªkj]

lgdkjh lfefr;ka] xqM+xkao

Øekad % 4217@ vkj-ds-kk@ljl@ fnukad 29&04&2016

izs"kd

lgk;d jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka] xqM+xkaoA

lsok esa

vk;qDr iqfylxqM+xkaoA

fo"k; % nh jke 'kkfUr lgdkjh xzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkao ds HkwriwoZ desVhlnL;ksa ds fo:) izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ ntZ (FIR) djus ckjsA

63

;knh

mijksDRk fo"k; ds lEcU/k esa fn jke 'kkafr lgdkjh xqzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkaods izca/kd desVh lnL; HkwriwoZ iz/kku Jh /keZohj eXxq HkwriwoZ miiz/kku Jh j.knhi gqMMk HkwriwoZ[ktkaph Jh fot; rgykuh HkwriwoZ izca/kd desVh lnL; Jh vejthr eXxw }kjk lfefr esa dkQhlnL;ksa dks xyr rjhds ls fgLlk izek.k&i= ¼'ks;j lfVZfQdsV½ tkjh fd, o lfefr esa dkQhvu;ferrk, o xcu gksus dk vans'kk gSA vr% vkils vuqjks/k gS fd Jh /keZohj eXxw Jh j.knhi gqMMkJh fot; rgykuh o Jh vejthr eXxw ds fo:) izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ ntZ djus dh d`ik djsA

1- Jh /keZchj eXxq iwoZ iz/kku] edku ua0 Vh&05 ch] foMlj dksVZ] Mh-,y-,Q-Qsl&4]xqM+xkaoA

2- Jh j.knhi flag] iwoZ mi&iz/kku] edku ua0 ch&503] ,jkyh;kt] Mh-,y-,Q- xksYQ dkljksM xqM+xkaoA

3- Jh vejthr iwoZ desVh esEcj lnL;] edku ua0 2516 lSDVj&1 gqMMk jksgrd&124001

4- Jh fot; rgykuh] iwoZ desVh esEcj lnL;] Mh&12] lSDVj&47] uks;Mk&201301

lgk;d jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka] xqM+xkaoA

Øekad % 4523@ vkj-ds-kk@ljl@ fnukad 5&5&16

izs"kd

lgk;d jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka xqM+xkaoA

lsok esa

vk;qDr iqfylxqM+xkaoA

fo"k; % nh jke 'kkfUr lgdkjh xzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkao ds HkwriwoZ desVhlnL;ksa ds fo:) izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ ntZ (FIR) djus ckjsA

;knh

mijksDRk fo"k; ds lEcU/k esa fn jke 'kkafr lgdkjh xqzqi gkÅflax lfefr fy0 xqM+xkaodk fjdkMZ izkIr djus gsrw fujh{kd] lgdkjh lfefr;ka xqM+xkao&I ds vuqjks/k ij lpZ okjUV tkjhfd;s x, ijUrq izca/kd desVh lnL; HkwriwoZ iz/kku Jh /keZohj eXxw] HkwriwoZ miiz/kku Jh j.knhigqM~Mk] HkwriwoZ [ktkaph Jh fot; rgykuh HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh lnL; Jh vejthr eXxw ls lfefrdk fjdkMZ miyC/k ugha gks ldkA fujh{kd us HkwriwoZ izcU/kd desVh ds fo:) izFke lwpuk fjiksVZntZ djkus dh flQkfj'k dh gSA

64

vr% fujh{kd] lgdkjh lfefr;ka xqM+xkao&k dh flQkfj'k dks e/;utj j[krs vkilsvuqjks/k gS fd Jh /keZohj eXxw Jh j.knhi gqM~Mk Jh fot; rgykuh o Jh vejthr eXxw ds fo:)izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ ntZ djus dh d`ik djsa o fjdkMZ dCts esa ysdj bl dk;kZy; dks miyC/kdjokus dh d`ik djsA

1- Jh /keZchj eXxq iwoZ iz/kku] edku ua0 Vh&05 ch] foMlj dksVZ] Mh-,y-,Q-Qsl&4]xqM+xkaoA

2- Jh j.knhi flag] iwoZ mi&iz/kku] edku ua0 ch&503] ,jkyh;kt] Mh-,y-,Q- xksYQ dkljksM xqM+xkaoA

3- Jh vejthr iwoZ desVh esEcj lnL;] edku ua0 2516 lSDVj&1 gqMMk jksgrd&124001

4- Jh fot; rgykuh] iwoZ desVh esEcj lnL;] Mh&12] lSDVj&47] uks;Mk&201301

Sd/-

lgk;d jftLVªkjlgdkjh lfefr;ka xqM+xkaoA

To,

The Hon’ble Chairman, Dated- 20/05/2016

Petition committee,

Vidhan Sabha,Govt. of Haryana,

Chandigarh

Sub:- Complaint filed by Monika Mehta in respect of Ram Shanti CGHS, Gurgaon

Ref:- Notice dated 13/05/2016 vide its no. HVS/Petitions/2/2016-17 8702-08 Your

Excellency,

May I take this opportunity to present this supplication for kind consideration

of Your Excellency.

Though earlier I have appeared physically before your honour, but this time due

to bereavement in the extended family, I am unable to come and I am sending my submissions

through my Attorney (legal).

1. At the very outset it is stated that the Ram Shanti CGHS society is registered in

the year 2003 under Haryana Co- operative societies Act, 1984 bearing its no. 82G having

its registered office at Plot No. 19, Sector-52, Gurgaon.

2. A committee under Mr Dharam Vir Maggo was formed In 2010 and membership

increased from 42 to 96 and more than 100 memberships changed in hands by Mr

Mago,President of the society from 2010 to the end of his term in 2015. Society was

working regularly and the day to day business affairs was managing by the management

committee under the president ship of Mr. Dharamvir Maggo.

3. However, it was just an eye wash as the President Mr. Dharamvir Maggo had

kept three of his family members on the board/management committee, like his brother

Amarjit Maggon, and his brother-in law Ram Prakash Miglani ‘and his sister Kusum

65

Gulshan and two more members in the Society books, just to show diversity. The truth is

that his Family controlled and managed the business affairs of the said society without

giving any reference and knowledge to the other office bearers and other members of the

society.

4. Mr Mago ‘s term was autocratic as he had majority support in the committee

thorough his family and friends. This was accentuated also by the mutual greed of several

individuals (now members) who connived with Mr Maggo, ex- president to further

fortheirown interests. This was the reason due to which several deserving members did

not get their memberships and several others were kept as members in waiting or Non

members since 2010 and their contribution are visible in audited books of the Society.

Copy of the audited balance sheet is attached herewith for you kind perusal.

5. Mr Mago’s family (Amarjeet Mago; Ram Prakash etc are in connivance with

some members from so called core committee (e.g.Mr Rohit Arora who got a very favorable

deal illegally through Mr. Dhgr~vir Maggo and the members who exited still has all their

money stands outstanding with the society) Same goes for most other members of the

core committee. Mr Savinay Gupta who was a committee member and whose name was

objected by auditors had also been in connivance ( can be seen in the audited Balance

Sheet) . All these people are wanting to deny the legitimate claims of several non members

and members in waiting taking advantage of sentiments of members who have become

vulnerable due to the fact that previous President is absconding.

6. It is also pertinent to inform and intimate to your excellancy that the Ex-President,

Dharam Vir Maggo is intentionally and deliberately hiding himself from the process of law

and the same is in the knowledge of every public Authority for which the said society has

also published a public notice.

7. It is also informed that the term of the said management committee has also

expired and assistant Registrar, who is the appropriate local authority of CGHS as per Act,

has appointed an Administrator/body of administrators to look-

after the affairs of the society.

8. Ms Monika Mehta, who is the petitioner herein has come before your honour to

get her membership in the said society. In respect of the same, the Board of Administration

(under concerned Registrar, CGHS, Gurgaon) has been in- charge since last 10 months.

There are members with no payment and their membership may be transferred.

9. I was ex-Honorary Vice President in the said society, now I am not in any capacity

to help in this matter, although I have tried at my level best earlier when the said subject

was brought to my notice by the petitioner.

10. It is very pertinent to mention here that the petitioner lady herein had supposedly

bought membership through Mr. Himanshu Mago (former President's nephew). His uncle

(President Mr. Dharam Vir) and his father Amerjeet Mago and his uncle Mr. Ram Parkash

were sufficient quorum to transfer memberships so the answering respondent is totally

surprised why this could not be happened and why the petitioner did not approach them

and why I required to take care of that.

66

11. Supposedly one year after her supposed purchase of membership she contacted

me and after two years of supposed purchase she started alleging that she supposedly

puchased from me.

12. I want to state, I did not know her or any of her kin, I nerver solicited any sale of

apartment or membership to her. I was trying to held her only after she approached me with

her problem and I tried my level best to influence former President to help her, but was

unsuccessful. My personal friends and family have also been members-in waiting or non-

membership transferred, because I was a minority in the management committee. So, Maggo

family in trying to make Ms. Mehta petitioner herein approach me was a deliberate and a

calculated move to mislead her.

13. Her paryments to Society are reflecting in the accounts and according to me she

has a claim to membership as there are still people whose name feature but have not paid

a single penny.

14. I personally will also request this forum/ your honour to ask the present

administrators to look at the option of increasing the membership in light of increased

FAR and accommodate people like Ms Mehta, the petitioner, herein.

15. In this context it is also important to mention here that some members of the

society had approached Hon ‘ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana praying therein that

Concerned Authority(ARCS) be directed to consider the appointment of Arbitrator to

resolve the disputes arisen in the society. A direction to this effect was obtained (Copy

attached), however, we are surprised as to why the office of registrar and some members

are not in favour of having an independent arbitrator.

16. Your Excellency may kindly appreciate and direct the concerned authority to

hold an enquiry by independent authority, who is expert in society matters and / or appoint

oneexperienced arbitrator to resolve all these issues at hand. Having patiently waited all

these days for an opportunity to explain my case that the allegations are

baseless and there is no material and merit whatsoever in the representation submitted by

the petitioner against me before your Excellency, I earnestly request Your Excellency

to do the needful, so that, genuine grievance may kindly be redressed at the earliest and

justice be rendered to all of us expeditiously.

With kind regards,

Yours sincerely,

(Randip Singh)

Ex- Hon. Vice- President

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

CWP No. 2392 of 2016 (O&M)

Date of Decision :05.02.2016

67

Vijay Tahlani and another .... Petitionerts)

Versus

Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Haryana and others ... Respondcntrs)

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHESH GROVER

Present: Mr.Neeraj Sharma, Advocate for the petitioners

MAHESH GROVER, J.

The only prayer that is made in the instant petition is that the respondent No.1

be directed to refer the matter/dispute to the Arbitration in view of Section 102 as well as

103 ol Rules and Regulations of Haryana Cooperative Societies Act, 1984, regarding which

the petitioners have made representations (Annexure P-6 and P-l 0)

Having regard to the aforesaid limited prayer and without expressing any opinion

on the merits of the case, instant petition is disposed of with a direction to respondents to

consiler and decide the representations ( Annexures 6 and 10) made by the petitioners as

expeditiously as possible, from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.

February 05, 2016 (Mahesh Grover)

Rekha Judge

izs"kd

iqfyl mik;qDriwoZ] xqM+xkao

lsok esa

iz/kku lfpogfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky;lSDVj&1] p.Mhx<+A

Øekad % 620&PD@ vkj-ds-kk@ljl@ fnukad 01&06&16

fo"k; % ifjokn eksfudk eSgrk ch0&801 viSDl vikVZeSUV lSDVj 45] xqM+xkaoA

;kfn]

di;k vkids dk;kZy; ds i= HVS/Petitions/2/2016-17/8702-08 dated 15.05.2016

d lUnHkZ esa fnukad 20-05-16 dh xks"Bh esa fn, x, funsZ'ksa ds lEca/k esaA

Jheku Tkh]

mijksDRk fo"k; ds lEca/k esa fo'ks"k vuqla/kku Vhe bZpktZ ls fjiksZV izkIr dh ubZ tksvoyksdukFkZ lkFk layXu gSA fo'ks"k vuqla/kku Vhe dh fjiksZV ds vuqlkj vfHk;ksx la[;k 394fnukad 27-10-2015 /kkjk 408@420 Hkk0n0l0 Fkkuk&lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkaok esa ifjokn

68

lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky fnukad 31-08-15 eksfudk esgrk fnukad 17-09-15 o foey ,u tsBk fnukad 28-09-15 dh tkWp vkfFkZd vijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ xqM+xkaok }kjk tkWp mijkUr iathdr fd;k x;kA mijksDrifjoknhx.k dks 'kkfey tkWp djds muds dFku vafdr fd;s x;s o jke 'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzqigkmflax lkslk;Vh] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkao rFkk lgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls fjdkMZ fy;k x;kAlkslk;Vh }kjk cryk;k x;k fd lfefr dk iz/kku /keZohj eXxq] mldk HkkbZ vejthr eXxq] mldsfj'rsnkj jkeizdk'k fexykuh cgu dqlqe xqy'ku o nks vU; lnL; Fks] tks lkslk;Vh NksMdj Hkkxx;s gSa] blfy, lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vkijsfVo lkslk;Vh us lfefr Hkax dj nh gSaA lgk;djftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls tkudkjh yh xbZ ftUgksaus fyf[kr esa cryk;k fd ifjoknh Jh jtr dY;kyjftLVªkj o Jh foey ,u tsBk igys lfefr ds lnL; Fks] ysfdu vc ugha gS rFkk Jhefr eksfudkesagrk Hkh lnL; ugha gSa ifjoknhx.k Jh jtr dY;ky }kjk 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s] Jh foey,u tsBk }kjk 20 yk[k #i;s o Jh efr eksfudk esgrk }kjk 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;s lfefr esatek djk;k x;k gS] ysfdu fjdkMZ ds eqrkfcd ifjoknhx.k dh lnL;rk lfefr esa ugha gSaA iqfylmik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao }kjk bUpktZ vkfFkZd vijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ] xqM+xkao dh tkap fjiksVZ ds vk/kkj ijifjokn ij /kkjk 406-420 Hkk0n0l0 ds rgr Fkkuk lq'kkUr yksd] xMxkao esa vfHk;ksx vafdr djusdh flQkfj'k dh xbZA vfHk;ksx esa fuEufyf[kr inkf/kdkjh vkjksih cuk, x,A

1 /keZohj eXxq iza/kku oklh Vh&05] ch ohUMj dksVZ] Mh-,y-,Q- Qsl&4 xqM+xkaoA

2 junhi flag fuoklh ch&503 ,jkfyt Mh ,Y ,Q xksYQ dkslZ jksM] xqM+xkaoA

3 fot; rgykuh] lSDVjh jke'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM IykWVua0 19] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaoA

4 vejthr eXxq lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM] IykaVua0 19 lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaokA

5 jkeizdk'k fexykuh lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM]IykWV ua0 19 lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaokA

ihfMrksa ds fooj.k=6

Øålå ifjoknh dk uke o irk xcu jk'kh

1 lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky iq= ns'kjkt oklh 35-50-000@edku ua0 3030 lS0 37 Mh p.Mhx<+

2 eksfudk iRuh ;ksxs'k esgrk oklh ch&801, 31-60-000@viSDl vikVZesUV] lS0&45]xqM+xkao

3 foey ,u tsBk fuoklh gkml ua0 42] 20]00]000@clUr fogkj ubZ fnYyh

nkSjkus vuqla/kku 'kkfey gq, vU; ihfM+r

69

1 d`".k dqekj oklh edku uaå 752, lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkaokA 82-50000@#i;s

2 vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh eåuaå&121] lSDVj&7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks= 89-50000@#i;s

3 egkchj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] ubZ fnYyh 48]00000@#i;s

vfHk;ksx dh orZeku fLFkfr %& mijksDr jke'kkfURk dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh irkIykV uå th-,p- 19 lSDVj&52 xqM+xkaok o"kZ 2003 ls jftLVªj gSaA

1- ifjoknh lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky }kjk vius iq= jtr dR;ky ds uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2010esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 091 fnukad 12-12-12 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkAftlds }kjk dqy 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s lkslkbVh ds fjdkMZ esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk fnukad 18-04-14 dks ifjoknh ds csVs jtr dR;ky dh lnL;rk fdlhJh efr eUtwckyk ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khnsdCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

2- ifjokfn;k eksfudk esgrk us vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2013 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh}kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 144 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;slkslk;Vh ds cSad [kkrs esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA ysfdu vkjksihx.k lkslkbVh inkf/kdkfj;ks }kjkifjokfn;k dks lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZA ifjokfn;k dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrkuj'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSa o vkSj f'kdk;rdrkZ eksfudk esgrk dk dksbZ lnL;rk ckjsfjdkMZ lgk;d jftLVkj vkWfQl esa ugha feyk gSA ifjokfn;k dk vkjksi gS fd mlds }kjk lkslkbVhds lnL;rk izkIr djus gsrw vkjksih j.knhi dks /keZohj eXxw iz/kku lkslkbVh ds Hkrhts fgekUlq eXxqds ek/;e ls udn iSlk fn;k x;k Fkk ijUrq bl vk'k; dk dksbZ lk{; is'k ugha fd;k x;kAifjokfn;k o j.knhi ds chp bZ0&esy vknku iznku ds voyksdu ls fdlh izdkj ds Hkqxrku dklk{; ugha ik;k x;kA ftl ckjs vuqla/kku tkjh gSA

3- ifjoknh foey ,u tsBk vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 094 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 20 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tkpqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh dkUr ds uke dj nhxbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

4- ifjoknh d`".k dqekj oklh edku uå 752, lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkao ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 079 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 82 yk[k 50-000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa}kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh vadqj R;kxh ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;jlfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

5- vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh e0uå&121] lSDVj 7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks=k ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 113 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 89 yk[k 50]000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vhinkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh eueksgu 'kekZ ds uke dj nh xbZ ifjoknh dks

70

fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA tks lgk;djftLVªkj dkWijsfVo lkslkbVh xqM+xkao }kjk vuqiek xqIrk dks lnL;rk iznku dh tk pqdh gSaA

6- egkohj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] fnYyh ftlus vius uke lnL;rko"kZ 2015 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 039 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds}kjk dqy 48 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA ftlesa lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrs esa dsoy 8 yk[k#i;s fjdkMZ esa vk, gq, gS o 40 yk[k #i;s jktho 'kekZ izksiVhZ fMyj dks nsus ik, x, gSA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZ gSA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

vuqla/kku izxfr&

vuqla/kku gsrw fo'ks"k vuqla/kku Vhe xfBr dh xbZ gSA vkjksih lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esalkslkbVh dk lR;kfir fjdkMZ izkIr dj fy;k x;k gSaA jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrks dk fjdkMZdCtk iqfyl esafy;k tk pqdk gSA vfHk;ksx esa eq[; vkjksih jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds iz/kku /keZohjeXxw fons'k Hkx pqdk gSA tks vfHk;ksx ntZ ls igys gh Hkkxk gqvk gSA ftlds fo#) ,y-vks-lh-[kqyokbZ gqbZA

vfHk;ksx esa mi iz/kku jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh j.knhi flag dks 'kkfey rdrh'k fnukad 02-04-16] 04-04-16 05-04-16 fd;k tk pqdk gSA tks 'kkfey rQrh'k ij lkeus vk;k gS fd j.knhiflag ds QthZ gLrk{kj dk;Zokgh jftLVªkj esa bUnzkt djds ds vk/kkj ij ihfMr lnL;ksa dks lnL;rklekIr dh gqbZ gS o jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ys[kk tks[kk o vkWfMV fjdkMZ vuqlkj j.knhi flagmiiz/kku us lkslkbVh dks o"kZ 2010 ls 2012 rd yksu fn;k gqvk gSA ftlesa lkslkbVh us ,d djksM+5 yk[k #i;s vHkh Hkh mi iz/kku j.knhi dks okfil ugha ykSVk;s gS o miiz/kku j.knhi dks okfilugha ykSVk;s gS o miiz/kku j.knhi ls cSad [kkrksa o bZ&esy o lnL;ksa ds cnyko esa eUtwjh fyf[kresa ysus ckjs i=kpkj dk fjdkMZ dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSA miiz/kku j.knhi flag ds f[kykQeqdn~ek esa dksbZ lk{; ugha feys gSA fQj Hkh gj igyw ij vuqla/kku fd;k tk jgk gSA dCtk esafy;s x;s fjdkMZ dk ,Q-,l-,y- Hkstdj vkxkeh dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr dh tk;sxhA blds vfrfjDrj.knhi }kjk 14-12-12 dks gh bZ&esy }kjk lkslk;Vh ds lHkh inkf/kdkfj;ksa dks mldh fyf[krvuqefr ds fcuk ubZ lnL;rk iznku djus ds fy, euk fd;k gqvk gS o uk gh fdlh izdkj dkysu nsu djus ckjs fy[kk x;k gSA j.knhi ds vuqlkj izeq[k vkjksih /keZohj eExw }kjk fcuk mldsKku ds lnL;rk iznku dh xbZ gS o iSlk fy;k x;k gSA

eqdn~ek dh rQrh'k esa lgk;d jftLVªkj vkWfQl xqM+xkao esa fyf[kr esa fn;k gqvk gSfd lkslkbVh dk vly fjdkMZ ftlesa dk;Zokgh jftLVªkj bR;kfn iqjkuh eSausftax desVh ds ikl gSo lkslkbVh dk vkWfMV o"kZ 2010 ls ekpZ 2014 rd pkj ckj gks pqdk gSA tks vkWfMV fjiksVZ dsvuqlkj lkslkbVh dk ewy fjdkMZ iz/kku /keZohj eXxw jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ikl j[kk gqvk FkkA

jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esa fuEufyf[kr nks eqdn~esa vkSj ntZ fd;s x;s gS ftudkfooj.k bl izdkj gS%&

71

Øålå eqdn~ek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 98 23-03-16 406@420@467@468@120ch Hkkånålå lq'kkUr yksd

2 126 07-04-16 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkUr yksd

jke 'kkfUr lkslk;Vh ds iz/kku /keZohj eXXkw ds fo#) Lo.kZ t;Urh dkijsfVo lkslk;Vhesa /kks[kk /kM+h djus ckjs fuEufyf[kr rhu vfHk;ksx vU; ntZ gSA ftlesa vkjksih /keZohj eXxw dsfo#) igys gh ,y-vks-lh- tkjh djk;k gqvk gSA tks orZeku esa fons'k esa gSA vfHk;ksxksa dk fooj.kbl izdkj gSA

Øålå eqdn~ek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 202 10-06-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

2 254 08-07-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

3 255 09-07-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

uksV& mijksDRk lkslkbVh ds lnL;ksa }kjk fn;s x;s ifjokn ij fnukad 08-05-16 dks ekuuh;eq[;ea=h gfj;k.kk ljdkj dh v/;{krk esa gqbZ yksd ifjokn lfefr dh cSBd esa Hkh fopkj foe'kZgks pqdk gSA ftlesa ifjokn tkap gsrw lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh xqM+xkaok dks mfprfunsZ'k lfefr }kjk fn;s x;s gSA

vfHk;ksx esa vkjksih j.knhi 'kkfey rQrh'k gks pqdk gSA vkjksih fot; rgykuh gsrw'kkfey tkap gsrw uksfVl fn;k x;k ijUrq fot; rgykuh }kjk 'kkfey tkap u gksdj vfXkze tekurekuuh; l= U;k;ky; xqM+xkao esa nk;j dh FkhA tks fnukad 01-04-16 dks ekuuh; vnkyr ls[kkfjt gks pqdh gSA vU; vkjksih vejthr eXxw jkeizdk'k dks 'kfey rQrh'k djuk cdk;k gSaAvkjksih /keZohj eXxw ds fo#) miyC/k lk{;ksa ds vk/kkj ij fxjQrkjh okjaV izkIr djus gsrw l{keU;k;ky; ds le{k vkosnu fd;k tkuk gS o lgk;d jftLVªkj lkslkbVh dh tkap fjiksVZ izkIr gksusij vuqla/kku dks xfr iznku gksxhA

fjiksZV lsok esa izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

¼nhid lgkju½iqfyl mik;qDr

iwoZ] xqM+xkaoA

Øekad fnukad

mijksDr dh ,d izfr Jheku iqfyl vk;qDr] xqM+xkao dh lsok muds dk;kZy; ds i=Øekad 11641@lh0lh0 fnukad 27-05-16 ds lUnHkZ esa lwpukFkZ izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

¼nhid lgkju½iqfyl mik;qDr]

iwoZ] xqM+xkaoAiqfyl foHkkx ftyk xqM+xkao

72

izs"kd

lgk;d iqfyl vk;qDrMh0,y0,Q0 xqM+xkao

lsok esa

iqfyl vk;qDriwoZ xqM+xkaolSDVj&1] p.Mhx<+A

Øekad % 795@R fnukad 01&06&16

fo"k; % ifjokn eksfudk eSgrk ch0&801 viSDl vikVZeSUV lSDVj 45 xqM+xkaoA

Jheku th-

Jheku iqfyl vk;qDr xqM+xkao ds dk;kZy; ds i= 11641@lh0lh0 fnukad 27-5-16 ovkids dk;kZy; ds ifjokn Øekad 1576&tSM0 fnukad 28-5-16 mijksDr fo"k; ds lEcU/k esa Fkkuklq'kkUr ykSd xqM+xkao ls fjiksZV izkIr dh xbZ tks voyksdukFkZ lkFk lyXu gSA

izcU/kd Fkkuk lq'kkUr ykSd xqM+xkao ls izkIr fjiksZV vuqlkj vfHk;ksx la[;k 394fnukd 27-10-2015 /kkjk 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 Fkkuk&lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkao es ifjoknlqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky fnukad 31-08-15] eksfudk esgrk fnukad 17-09-15 o foey ,u tsBk fnukad28-09-15 dh tkap vkfFkZd vijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ xqM+xkaok }kjk tkWp mijkUr iathd`r fd;k x;kAmijksDr ifjoknhx.k dks 'kkfey tkWp djds muds dFku vafdr fd;s x;s o jke 'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkao rFkk lgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls fjdkMZfy;k z;kA lkslk;Vh }kjk cryk;k x;k fd lfefr dk iz/kku /keZohj eXxq] mldk HkkbZ vejthreXxq] mlds fj'rsnkj jkeizdk'k fexykuh] cgu dqlqe xqy'ku o nks vU; lnL; Fks] tks lkslk;VhNksM+dj Hkkx x;s gSa] blfy, lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vkijsfVo lkslk;Vh us lfefr Hkax dj nh gSaAlgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls tkudkjh yh xbZ ftUgksaus fyf[kr esa cryk;k fd ifjoknh Jh jtrdY;ky jftLVªkj o Jh foey ,u tsBk igys lfefr ds lnL; Fks ysfdu vc ugha gS rFkk Jh efreksfudk esgrk Hkh lnL; ugha gSa ifjoknhx.k Jh jtr dY;ky }kjk 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s] Jhfoey ,u tsBk }kjk 20 yk[k #i;s o Jh efr eksfudk esgrk }kjk 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;s lfefresa tek djk;k x;k gS] ysfdu fjdkMZ ds eqrkfcd ifjoknhx.k dh lnL;rk lfefr esa ugha gSaA iqfylmik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao dh tkap fjiksVZ ds vk/kkj ij ifjokn ij /kkjk 406]420 Hkk0n0l0 ds rgrFkkuk lq'kkUr yksd] xqM+xkao esa vfHk;ksx vafdr djus dh flQkfj'k dh xbZA vfHk;ksx esa fuEufyf[krinkf/kdkjh vkjksih cuk, x,A

1- /keZohj eXxq iz/kku oklh Vh&05] ch ohUMj dksVZ] Mh-,y-,Q- Qsl&4 xqM+xkaokA

2- junhi flag fuoklh ch&503 ,jkfyt Mh-,y-,Q- xksYQ dkslZ jksM] xqM+xkaok]

3- fot; rgykuh] lSDVjh jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM] IykWVuå 19] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaokA

73

4- vejthr eXxq lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM] IykWVuå 19] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaokA

5- jkeizdk'k fexykuh] lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM]IykWV uå 19] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaoA

ihfM+rksa ds fooj.k=6

Øålå ifjoknh dk uke o irk xcu jk'kh

1 lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky iq= ns'kjkt oklh edku uå 3030 35]50]000@lS0 37 Mh p.Mhx<+

2 eksfudk iRuh ;ksxs'k esgrk oklh ch&801, viSDl vikVZesUV] 31]60]000@lS0&45] xqM+xkao

3 foey ,au tsBk fuoklh gkml uå 42] clUr fogkj ubZ fnYyh 20]00]000@

nkSjkus vuqla/kku 'kkfey gq, vU; ihfMr

1 d`".k dqekj oklh edku uå 752 , lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkaokA 82]50000@ #i;s

2 vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh e0uå&121] lSDVj 7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks= 89]50000@ #i;s

3 egkchj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] fnYyh 48]00000@ #i;s

vfHk;ksx dh orZeku fLFkfr %&mijksDr jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh irk IykV uå th,019] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaok o"kZ 2003 ls jftLVªkj gSa

1- ifjoknh lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky }kjk vius iq= jtr dR;ky ds uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2010esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 091 fnukad 12-12-12 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkAftlds }kjk dqy 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s lkslkbVh ds fjdkMZ esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk fnukad 18-04-14 dks ifjoknh ds csVs jtr dR;ky dh lnL;rk fdlhJh efr eUtwckyk ds uke dj nh xbZ ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khnsdCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

2 ifjokfn;k eksfudk esgrk us vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2013 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh}kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 144 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;slkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrs esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSA ysfdu vkjksihx.k lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjkifjokfn;k dks lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZA ifjokfn;k dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrkuj'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSa o vkSj f'kdk;rdrkZ eksfudk esgrk dk dksbZ lnL;rk ckjsfjdkMZ lgk;d jftLVªkj vkWfQl esa ugha feyk gSA ifjokfn;k dk vkjksi gS fd mlds }kjk lkslkbVhds lnL;rk izkIr djus gsrw vkjksih j.knhi dks /keZohj eXxw iz/kku lkslkbVh ds Hkrhts fgekUlq eXxwds ek/;e ls udn iSlk fn;k x;k Fkk ijUrq bl vk'k; dk dksbZ lk{; is'k ugha fd;k x;kAifjokfn;k o j.knhi ds chp bZ&esy vknku iznku ds voyksdu ls fdlh izdkj ds Hkqxrku dk Lkk{;ugha ik;k x;kA ftl ckjs vuqla/kku tkjh gSA

3 ifjoknh foey ,u tsBk vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 094 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 20 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tk

74

pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh dkUr ds uke dj nhxbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

4 ifjoknh d`".k dqekj oklh edku uå 752 , lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkao ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 079 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 82 yk[k 50]000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa}kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh vadqj R;kxh ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;jlfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

5- vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh eå uå&121] lSDVj 7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks=k ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 113 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kj dqy 89 yk[k 50]000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;kas}kjk ifjoknh ds lnL;rk fdlh Jh eueksgu 'kekZ ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;jlfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA tks lgk;d jftLVªkj dkWijsfVolkslkbVh xqM+xkao }kjk vuqiek xqIrk dks lnL;rk iznku dh tk pqdh gSA

6- egkchj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] fnYyh ftlus vius uke lnL;rko"kZ 2015 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 039 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds}kjk dqy 48 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA ftlesa lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrs esa dsoy 8 yk[k#i;s fjdkMZ esa vk, gq, gS o 40 yk[k #i;s jktho 'kekZ izksiVh fMyj dks nsus ik, x, gSA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ks }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZ gSA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSA

vuqla/kku çxfr

vuqla/kku gsrw fo'ks"k vuqla/kku Vhe xfBr dh xbZ gSA vkjksih lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esalkslkbVh dk lR;kfir fjdkMZ izkIr dj fy;k x;k gSaA jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrksa dk fjdkMZdCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSA vfHk;ksx esa eq[; vkjksih jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh dsiz/kku /keZohj eXxw fons'k Hkkx pqdk gSA tks vfHk;ksx ntZ ls igys gh Hkkxk gqvk gSa ftlds fo#),y-vks-lh- [kqyokbZ gqbZ gSA

vfHk;ksx esa mi iz/kku jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh j.knhi flag dks 'kkfey rQrh'k fnukad02-04-16] 04-04-16] 05-04-16 fd;k tk pqdk gSA tks 'kkfey rQrh'k ij lkeus vk;k gS fd j.knhiflag o QthZ gLrk{kj dk;Zokgh jftLVªkj esa bUnzkt djds ds vk/kkj ij ihfMr lnL;ksa dks lnL;rklekIr dh gqbZ gS o jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ys[kk tks[kk o vkWfMV fjdkMZ vuqlkj j.knhi flag miiz/kku us lkslkbVh o o"kZ 2010 ls 2012 rd yksu fn;k gqvk gSA ftlesa lkslkbVh us ,d djksM 5yk[k #i;s vHkh Hkh mi iz/kku j.knhi dks okfil ugha ykSVk;s gS o miiz/kku j.knhi ls cSad [kkrksao bZ&esy o lnL;ksa ds cnyk esa eUtwjh fyf[kr esa ysus ckjs i=kpkj dk fjdkMZ dCtk iqfyl esafy;k tk pqdk gSA miiz/kku j.knhi flag ds f[kykQ eqdn~ek esa dksbZ lk{; ugha feys gSA fQj Hkhgj igyw ij vuqla/kku fd;k tk jgk gSA dCtk fy;s x;s fjdkMZ dk ,Q-,l-,y- Hkstdj vkxkehdk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr dh tk;sxhA blds vfrfjDr j.knhi }kjk 14-12-12 dks gh bZ esy }kjk lkslkbVhds lHkh inkf/kdkfj;ksa dks mldh fyf[kr vuqefr ds fcuk u lnL;rk iznku djus ds fy, euk

75

fd;k gqvk gS o uk gh fdlh izdkj dk ysu nsu djus ckjs fy[kk x;k gSA j.knhi ds vuqlkj izeq[kvkjksih /keZohj eXxw }kjk fcuk mlds Kku ds lnL;rk iznku dh xbZ gS iSlk fy;k x;k gSA

eqdn~ek dh rQrh'k esa lgk;d jftLVªkj vkWfQl xqM+xkao esa fyf[kr esa fn;k gqvk gSfd lkslkbVh dk vly fjdkMZ ftlesa dk;Zokgh jftLVªj bR;kfn iqjkuh eSausftax desVh ds ikl gSo lkslkbVh dk vkWfMV o"kZ 2010 ls ekpZ 2014 rd pkj ckj gks pqdk gSA tks vkWfMV fjiksVZ dsvuqlkj lkslkbVh dk ewy fjdkMZ iz/kku /keZohj eXxw jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ikl j[kk gqvk FkkA

jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esa fuEufyf[kr nks eqdn~esa vkSj ntZ fd;s x;s gS ftdkfooj.k bl izdkj gSa%&

Øålå eqdnek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 98 23-03-16 406@420@467@468@120ch Hkk0n0l0 lq'kkUr yksd

2 126 07-04-16 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 lq'kkUr yksd

jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds iz/kku /keZohj eXxw ds fo#) Lo'kZ t;Urh dkijsfVolkslk;Vh esa /kks[kk /kM+h djus ckjs fuEufyf[kr rhu vfHk;ksx vU; ntZ gSA ftlesa vkjksih /keZohj eXxw ds fo#) igys gh ,y-vks-lh- tkjh djk;k gqvk gSA tks orZeku esa fons'k esa gSAvfHk;ksx dk fooj.k bl izdkj gSA

Øålå eqdnek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 202 10-06-16 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 lq'kkUr yksd

2 254 08-07-15 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 lq'kkUr yksd

3 255 09-07-15 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 lq'kkUr yksd

uksV %& mijksDr lkslkbVh ds lnL;ksa }kjk fn;s x;s ifjokn ij fnukad 08-05-16 dks ekuuh;eq[;ea=h gfj;k.kk ljdkj dh v/;{krk esa gqbZ yksd ifjokn lfefr dh cSBd esa Hkh fopkj foe'kZgks pqdk gSA ftlesa ifjokn tkap gsrw lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh xqM+xkaok dks mfprfunsZ'k lfefr }kjk fn;s x;s gSA

vfHk;ksx esa vkjksih j.knhi 'kkfey rQrh'k gks pqdk gSA vkjksih fot; rgykuh gsrw'kkfey tkap gsrw uksfVl fn;k x;k ijUrq fot; rgykuh }kjk 'kkfey tkap u gksdj vfxze tekurekuuh; l= U;k;ky; xqM+xkao esa nk;j dh FkhA tks fnukad 01-04-16 dks ekuuh; vnkyr ls[kkfjt gks pqdh gSA vU; vkjksih vejthr eXxw] jkeizdk'k dks 'kkfey rQrh'k djuk cdk;k gSaAvkjksih /keZohj eXxw ds fo#) miyC/k lk{;ks ds vk/kkj ij fxjQrkjh okjaV izkIr djus gsrw l{keU;k;ky; ds le{k vkosnu fd;k tkuk gS o lgk;d jftLVªkj lkslkbVh dh tkap fjiksVZ izkIr gksusij vuqla/kku dks xfr iznku gksxhA

fjiksZV lsok esa izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

lgk;d iqfyl vk;qDrMh0,y0,Q0 xqM+xkaofnukad 1@6@16

76

Fkkuk lq'kkUr yksd ftyk xqM+xkao

fo"k; % vfHk;ksx la[;k 394 fnukad 27-10-2015 /kkjk 406@420 Hkk0n0l0 Fkkuk&lq'kkUryksd xqM+xkaok dh vuq'ka/kku çxfr fjiksVZA

Jheku~ th]

d`I;k vkids dk;kZy; ds i= Øekad uå 1576&Z fnukad 28&5&16 fo"k; mijksDrds lEcU/k esa ekaxh xbZ vuqla/kku izxfr fjiksVZ bl izdkj gS %&

;g vfHk;ksx ifjokn lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky fnukad 31-08-15] eksfudk esgrk fnukad 17-09-15 o foey ,u tsBk fnukad 28-09-15 dh tkWp vkfFkZd vijk/k 'kk[kk iwoZ xqM+xkaok }kjk tkWpmijkUr iathdr fd;k x;kA mijksDr ifjoknhx.k dks 'kkfey tkWp djds muds dFku vafdr fd;sx;s o jke 'kkfUr dks&vkijsfVo xzi gkmflax lkslk;Vh] lSDVj&52] xMxkao rFkk lgk;d jftLVªkjdk;kZy; ls fjdkMZ fy;k x;kA lkslk;Vh }kjk cryk;k x;k fd lfefr dk iz/kku/keZohj eXxq] HkkbZ vejthr eXxq] mlds fj'rsnkj jkeizdk'k fexykuh] cgu dqlqe xqy'ku o nksvU; lnL; Fks] tks lkslk;Vh NksMdj Hkkx x;s gSa] blfy, lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vkijsfVolkslk;Vh us lfefr Hkax dj nh gSaA lgk;d jftLVªkj dk;kZy; ls tkudkjh yh xbZ ftUgksaus fyf[kresa cryk;k fd ifjoknh Jh jtr dY;ky jftLVªkj o Jh foey ,u tsBk igys lfefr ds lnL;Fks ysfdu vc ugha gS rFkk Jh efr eksfudk esgrk Hkh lnL; ugha gSa ifjoknhx.k Jh jtr dY;ky}kjk 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s] Jh foey ,u tsBk }kjk 20 yk[k #i;s o Jh efr eksfudk esgrk}kjk 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;s lfefr esa tek djk;k x;k gS] ysfdu fjdkMZ ds eqrkfcd ifjoknhx.kdh lnL;rk lfefr esa ugha gSaA iqfyl mik;qDr iwoZ] xqM+xkao }kjk bUpktZ vkfFkZd mijk/k 'kk[kkiwoZ] xMxkao dh tkap fjiksVZ ds vk/kkj ij ifjokn ij /kkjk 406]420 Hkk0n0l0 ds rgr Fkkuk lq'kkUryksd] xqM+xkao esa vfHk;ksx vafdr djus dh flQkfj'k dh xbZA vfHk;ksx esa fuEufyf[kr inkf/kdkjhvkjksih cuk, x,A

1- /keZohj eXxq iz/kku oklh Vh&05] ch ohUMj dksVZ] Mh-,y-,Q- Qsl&4 xqM+xkaokA

2 junhi flag fuoklh ch&503 ,jkfyt Mh-,y-,Q- xksYQ dkslZ jksM] xqM+xkaokA

3 fot; rgykuh] lSDVjh jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVMIykWV uå 19] lSDVj 52] xqM+xkaoA

4- vejthr eXxq lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfefVM]IykWV uå 19] lSDVj 52] xqM+xkaoA

5- jkeizdk'k fexykuh lnL; jke'kkfUr dks&vksijsfVo xzqi gkmflax lkslk;Vh fyfifVM]IykWV uå 19] lSDVj&52] xqM+xkaoA

77

ihfMrksa ds fooj.k=6

Øålå ifjoknh dk uke o irk xcu jk'kh

1 lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky iq= ns'kjkt oklh edku uå 3030 35]50]000@lSå 37 Mh p.Mhx<+

2 eksfudk iRuh ;ksxs'k esgrk oklh ch&801, viSDl vikVZesUV] 31]60]000@lSå&45] xqM+xkao

3 foey ,u tsBk fuoklh gkml uå clUr fogkj ubZ fnYyh 20]00]000@

nkSjkus vuqla/kku 'kkfey gq, vU; ihfM+r

1 d`".k dqekj oklh edku uå 752, lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkaokA 82]50000@#i;s

2 vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh eåuå&121] lSDVj 7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks= 89]50000@#i;s

3 egkchj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] fnYyh 48]00000@#i;s

vfHk;ksx dh orZeku fLFkfr %& mijksDr jke'kkfURk dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh irk IykV uåth,p 19 lSDVj&52 xqM+xkaok o"kZ 2003 ls jftLVªj gSaA

1- ifjoknh lqHkk"k pUnz dR;ky }kjk vius iq= jtr dR;ky ds uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2010esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 091 fnukad 12-12-12 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkAftlds }kjk dqy 35 yk[k 50 gtkj #i;s lkslkbVh ds fjdkMZ esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk fnukad 18-04-14 dks ifjoknh ds csVs jtr dR;ky dh lnL;rk fdlhJh efr eUtwckyk ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khnsdCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

2- ifjokfn;k eksfudk esgrk us vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2013 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh}kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 144 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 31 yk[k 60 gtkj #i;slkslk;Vh ds cSad [kkrs esa tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA ysfdu vkjksihx.k lkslkbVh inkf/kdkfj;ks }kjkifjokfn;k dks lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZA ifjokfn;k dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrkuj'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSa o vkSj f'kdk;rdrkZ eksfudk esgrk dk dksbZ lnL;rk ckjsfjdkMZ lgk;d jftLVkj vkWfQl esa ugha feyk gSA ifjokfn;k dk vkjksi gS fd mlds }kjk lkslkbVhds lnL;rk izkIr djus gsrw vkjksih j.knhi dks /keZohj eXxw iz/kku lkslkbVh ds Hkrhts fgekUlq eXxqds ek/;e ls udn iSlk fn;k x;k Fkk ijUrq bl vk'k; dk dksbZ lk{; is'k ugha fd;k x;kAifjokfn;k o j.knhi ds chp bZ0&esy vknku iznku ds voyksdu ls fdlh izdkj ds Hkqxrku dklk{; ugha ik;k x;kA ftl ckjs vuqla/kku tkjh gSA

3- ifjoknh foey ,u tsBk vius uke lnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 094 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 20 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tkpqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh dkUr ds uke dj nhxbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

78

4- ifjoknh d`".k dqekj oklh edku uå 752, lq'kkUr yksd xqM+xkao ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 079 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 82 yk[k 50-000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa}kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh vadqj R;kxh ds uke dj nh xbZA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k 'ks;jlfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

5- vuqiek xqIrk fuoklh e0uå&121] lSDVj 7] vjcu LVsV&dq#{ks=k ftlus vius ukelnL;rk o"kZ 2012 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 113 tkjh fd;k x;kFkkA ftlds }kjk dqy 89 yk[k 50]000 #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA vkjksih lkslk;Vhinkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk fdlh Jh eueksgu 'kekZ ds uke dj nh xbZ ifjoknh dksfn;k x;k 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA tks lgk;djftLVªkj dkWijsfVo lkslkbVh xqM+xkao }kjk vuqiek xqIrk dks lnL;rk iznku dh tk pqdh gSaA

6- egkohj lkguh fuoklh&bZ 46] v'kksd fogkj Qsl&1] fnYyh ftlus vius uke lnL;rko"kZ 2015 esa yh FkhA ftldks lkslk;Vh }kjk 'ks;j lfVZfQdsV uå 039 tkjh fd;k x;k FkkA ftlds}kjk dqy 48 yk[k #i;s tek djk;s tk pqds gSaA ftlesa lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrs esa dsoy 8 yk[k#i;s fjdkMZ esa vk, gq, gS o 40 yk[k #i;s jktho 'kekZ izksiVhZ fMyj dks nsus ik, x, gSA vkjksihlkslk;Vh inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk ifjoknh dh lnL;rk iznku ugha dh xbZ gSA ifjoknh dks fn;k x;k'ks;j lfVZfQdsV o Hkqxrku j'khns dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSaA

vuqla/kku çxfr&

vuqla/kku gsrw fo'ks"k vuqla/kku Vhe xfBr dh xbZ gSA vkjksih lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esalkslkbVh dk lR;kfir fjdkMZ izkIr dj fy;k x;k gSaA jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds cSad [kkrks dk fjdkMZdCtk iqfyl esafy;k tk pqdk gSA vfHk;ksx esa eq[; vkjksih jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds iz/kku /keZohjeXxw fons'k Hkx pqdk gSA tks vfHk;ksx ntZ ls igys gh Hkkxk gqvk gSA ftlds fo#) ,y-vks-lh-[kqyokbZ gqbZA

vfHk;ksx esa mi iz/kku jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh j.knhi flag dks 'kkfey rdrh'k fnukad 02-04-16] 04-04-16 05-04-16 fd;k tk pqdk gSA tks 'kkfey rQrh'k ij lkeus vk;k gS fd j.knhiflag ds QthZ gLrk{kj dk;Zokgh jftLVªkj esa bUnzkt djds ds vk/kkj ij ihfMr lnL;ksa dks lnL;rklekIr dh gqbZ gS o jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ys[kk tks[kk o vkWfMV fjdkMZ vuqlkj j.knhi flag miiz/kku us lkslkbVh dks o"kZ 2010 ls 2012 rd yksu fn;k gqvk gSA ftlesa lkslkbVh us ,d djksM 5yk[k #i;s vHkh Hkh mi iz/kku j.knhi dks okfil ugha ykSVk;s gS o miiz/kku j.knhi dks okfil ughaykSVk;s gS o miiz/kku j.knhi ls cSad [kkrksa o bZ&esy o lnL;ksa ds cnyko esa eUtwjh fyf[kr esaysus ckjs i=kpkj dk fjdkMZ dCtk iqfyl esa fy;k tk pqdk gSA miiz/kku j.knhi flag ds f[kykQeqdn~ek esa dksbZ lk{; ugha feys gSA fQj Hkh gj igyw ij vuqla/kku fd;k tk jgk gSA dCtk esafy;s x;s fjdkMZ dk ,Q-,l-,y- Hkstdj vkxkeh dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr dh tk;sxhA blds vfrfjDrj.knhi }kjk 14-12-12 dks gh bZ&esy }kjk lkslk;Vh ds lHkh inkf/kdkfj;ksa dks mldh fyf[krvuqefr ds fcuk ubZ lnL;rk iznku djus ds fy, euk fd;k gqvk gS o uk gh fdlh izdkj dkysu nsu djus ckjs fy[kk x;k gSA j.knhi ds vuqlkj izeq[k vkjksih /keZohj eExw }kjk fcuk mlds

79

Kku ds lnL;rk iznku dh xbZ gS o iSlk fy;k x;k gSA

eqdn~ek dh rQrh'k esa lgk;d jftLVªkj vkWfQl xqM+xkao esa fyf[kr esa fn;k gqvk gSfd lkslkbVh dk vly fjdkMZ ftlesa dk;Zokgh jftLVªkj bR;kfn iqjkuh eSausftax desVh ds ikl gSo lkslkbVh dk vkWfMV o"kZ 2010 ls ekpZ 2010 ls 2014 rd pkj ckj gks pqdk gSA tks vkWfMV fjiksVZds vuqlkj lkslkbVh dk ewy fjdkMZ iz/kku /keZohj eXxw jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds ikl j[kk gqvk FkkA

jke'kkfUr lkslkbVh ds lEca/k esa fuEufyf[kr nks eqdn~esa vkSj ntZ fd;s x;s gS ftudkfooj.k bl izdkj gS%&

Øålå eqdn~ek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 98 23-03-16 406@420@467@468@120ch Hkkånålå lq'kkUr yksd

2 126 07-04-16 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkUr yksd

jke 'kkfUr lkslk;Vh ds iz/kku /keZohj eXXkw ds fo#) Lo.kZ t;Urh dkijsfVo lkslk;Vhesa /kks[kk /kM+h djus ckjs fuEufyf[kr rhu vfHk;ksx vU; ntZ gSA ftlesa vkjksih /keZohj eXxw dsfo#) igys gh ,y-vks-lh- tkjh djk;k gqvk gSA tks orZeku esa fons'k esa gSA vfHk;ksxksa dk fooj.kbl izdkj gSA

Øålå eqdn~ek uå fnukad /kkjk Fkkuk

1 202 10-06-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

2 254 08-07-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

3 255 09-07-15 406@420@Hkkånålå lq'kkkUr yksd

uksV& mijksDRk lkslkbVh ds lnL;ksa }kjk fn;s x;s ifjokn ij fnukad 08-05-16 dks ekuuh;eq[;ea=h gfj;k.kk ljdkj dh v/;{krk esa gqbZ yksd ifjokn lfefr dh cSBd esa Hkh fopkj foe'kZgks pqdk gSA ftlesa ifjokn tkap gsrw lgk;d jftLVªkj dks&vksijsfVo lkslk;Vh xqM+xkaok dks mfprfunsZ'k lfefr }kjk fn;s x;s gSA

vfHk;ksx esa vkjksih j.knhi 'kkfey rQrh'k gks pqdk gSA vkjksih fot; rgykuh gsrw'kkfey tkap gsrw uksfVl fn;k x;k ijUrq fot; rgykuh }kjk 'kkfey tkap u gksdj vfXkze tekurekuuh; l= U;k;ky; xqM+xkao esa nk;j dh FkhA tks fnukad 01-04-16 dks ekuuh; vnkyr ls[kkfjt gks pqdh gSA vU; vkjksih vejthr eXxw jkeizdk'k dks 'kfey rQrh'k djuk cdk;k gSaAvkjksih /keZohj eXxw ds fo#) miyC/k lk{;ksa ds vk/kkj ij fxjQrkjh okjaV izkIr djus gsrw l{keU;k;ky; ds le{k vkosnu fd;k tkuk gS o lgk;d jftLVªkj lkslkbVh dh tkap fjiksVZ izkIr gksusij vuqla/kku dks xfr iznku gksxhA

Sd/-

Fkkuk lq'kkUr yksd]xqM+xkao

80

Thereafter, Committee received a mail dt. 27.02.2018 from Smt. Monika Mehta,

stating that her grievance is resolved, therefore, her petition may be disposed of. Mail

received from Smt. Monika Mehta is reads as under: ––

Dear Sir

This is to inform you that against above said petition for our membership in Ram

Shanti CGHS See-52 Gurgaon, in same context I would like to inform you that we have got

our membership in said society and is been approved by AR office gurgaon.

We have received our membership in place of Tajveer Yadav who has resigned

from his membership on 4.06.2017 in favour of Monika Mehta.

We are sending all the relevant documents pertaining to our membership through

registered post for your reference.

Copy of following documents are attached below resignation of Mr Tejveer in

favour of Monika Mehta is attached herewith 2. Membership letter from A.R office

Thanks and regards

Monika Mehta

The Committee perused the same and feel that since the grievance of Petitioner

is resolved. Therefore, the Petition of Smt. Monika Mehta was disposed of in its meeting

held on 01.03.2018.

Petition is disposed of accordingly.

————————

11. PETITION RECEIVED FROM SHRI SANJAY KUMAR S/o SH. OM

PARKASH R/O VILLAGE GHORON PIPLI, DISTT. YAMUNANAGAR,

REGARDING CUTTING OF TREES

The Petition received from Sh. Sanjay Kumar, reads as under :-

To,

The Chairman,

PetitionCommittee,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha,

Chandigarh

Sub. :- Application for directing the District

Forest Officer not to stop the Sir, applicant from cutting and removing thetrees

l. e. 295 Shisham treest, 47 poplar trees and 15 trees of khair standingover land comprising

Khasra No. 1//25 (3-6) , 7//5 (7-2), 6 (8-0) 7 (2-14) , 14 (5-4) total measuring 33K 05M which

is forming part of land measuring 66K-11M situated at Village Ghoron, H.B. No. 115, Tehsil

Jagadhri, District Yamuna Nagar.

Sir,

The applicant respectfully submits as under: -

1. That the applicant is permanent resident of Village Ghoron Pipli, Distt. Yamuna

Nagar and is agricul turist by profession having agriculture land at Village Ghoron.

81

2. That the land of forest department is abutting to the land of the applicant, so

there was a dispute In respect of the land. So, the applicant had filed a civil

suit no. 1128 of 2013 against State of Officer Officer Haryana, Range District

Forest

Forest for and permanent \ injunction restraining aforementioned defendants

not to interfere In his actual, physical and peaceful possession and not to cut

and’ remove the trees standingover the land which were detailed In the said suit.

The said suit was partly decreed by the court of Ms. Jasmine, Civil Judge (JR.

DIV.), Yamuna Nagar at Jagadhri vide judgement dt. 18- 11-2008 and the

defendants were restrained from interfering In the actual, physical and peaceful

possession of the plaintiffs over the land measuring comprlslng In Khewat No.

159/155, Khatauni No. 245 to 249, Khasra No. 1/ /25, 2/ / 11, 20 min, 7/ /5, 6, 7 , 14,

6/ /1, 2/ /20 rru.n , 7//15, 2/ /21, 2/ /22/1 si tuated at Village Ghoron. Against the

said judgment dt. 18-11-2008 no appeal was filed by the defendants as such the

said judgement attained finality.

3. That it is worth submitting here that out of the aforementioned land measuring

66K- 11M, over land measuring 33K-05M, 295 Shisham trees, 47 poplar trees and

15 trees of khair are standing over land comprising Khasra No. 1/ /25 (3-6), 7//5

(7-2), 6 (8-0), 7 (2-14), 14 (5-4) and this fact is very much clear from the si te plan

and the demarcation report dt. 05-04-2015 which was got conducted though

Retd. Tehsildar Sh. Mange Ram Verma.

4. That from the aforementioned report it is amply clear that the trees which are

detailed above are standing over the land which is in possession of applicant.

But the officials / employees of Forest Department without having any right,

title and concern with the trees standing over the said Khasra numbers, are

interfering In the possession of the applicant over the said trees despite the fact

that the forest department has no concern with the said trees. It is also worth

submitting here that the applicant had sought information under Right to

Information Act from the Forest Department in respect of the poplar trees planted

by the Forest Department. In the information supplied by the Forest Department,

there lS no mention that the Forest Department has ever planted any poplar

trees. Which mean that the forest department never planted any poplar tree. But

despite all this, the forest department is illegally claiming its right over the trees

standing on the land of applicant comprising Khasra No. 1/ /25 (3-6), 7//5 (7-2),

6 (8-0), 7 (2-14), 14 (5-4)total measurlng 33K-05M.

5. That despite repeated requests of applicant, the officials of Forest Department,

Yamuna Nagar are illegally interfering In the possession of the applicant over

the trees standing over the aforesaid land.

So, In view of the facts narrated above, it is respectfully prayed that the District

Forest Officer may kindly be directed not to stop the applicant from cutting and

removing the trees which are standing over land comprising Khasra No. 1//25

82

(3-6), 7//5 (7-2), 6 (8-0), 7 (2-14), 14 (5-4) total measuring 33K-05M which is

forming part of land measuring 66K-11M situated at Village Ghoron,’ H.B. No.

115, Tehsil Jagadhri, District Yamuna Nagar.

Yours faithfully

Sd/-

Sanjay Kumar s/o Sh. Om Parkash

r/o Village Ghoron Pipli,

Distt. Yamuna Nagar

COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS OF HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA

The Petition was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 06.05.2016,

the Committee considered the same and decided that the said petition may be sent to the

concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15 days. The

Committee did not received any reply from the Department. The Committee orally examined

the Principal Chief Conservator Forests, Haryana and the Petitioner in its

meeting held on 28.06.2016. The Committee discussed the matter with the departmental

represe:ntatives and the petitioner in detail and Committee direct the department to submit

their report within 15 days. The Committee received the reply from % Forest Department,

Haryana, vide their letter No. 967, dated 27.06.2016, which read as under––

ou foHkkx gfj;k.kk dk;kZy; % ou e.My vf/kdkjh] ;equkuxj ou e.My ;equkuxj

Øekad 967 fnukad 27@6@2016

lsok esa

iz/kku lfpo] gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky;p.Mhx<+A

fo"k;% Regarding Cutting of Tress

lanHkZ vkidk i= Øekad HVS/petition/479/16-17/8552 fnukad 12-05-2016 ¼iz/kku eq[; oulaj{kd gfj;k.kk dks lEcksf/kr½

–––––––––––––

mijksDr fo"k; ij lanHkZfdar i= ds lEcU/k esa vkidks voxr djok;k tkrk gS fd izkFkhZJh lat; dqekj ds firk th Jh vkse izdk'k xkao ?kksMks fiiyh ftyk ;equkuxj }kjk ,d dsl flfoyU;k;ky; txk/kjh esa fnukad 18-10-2003 @ 25-10-2005 dks QkbZy fd;k x;k FkkA ftldk fu.kZ;ekuuh; U;k;ky; }kjk fnukad 18-11-2008 ¼izfr layXu½ dks oknh ds fo:) fn;k zzzzx;k gSA fu.kZ;bl ls gS%&

“In view of my above findings on the aforesaid issues specifically discussed

under Issues No 1 to 3, suit of the plaintiff is partly decreed and defendants are restrained

from interfering in their actual , peaceful and physical possession of the plaintiff over the

suit land measuring 66K-ll comprising of Kewat No 159/155, Khatauni No 245 to 249,

Khasra 11/25, 2111, 20Min, 71/5,6,7,14, 61/1, 21120Min, 71115, 21/212, 21122/1, situated at

83

village Ghoron but the suit is dismissed in respect of 50 poplar trees, 6 dek and 20 Khair

trees which the plaintiffs have alleged that they are standing on their land since the

plaintiff have failed to prove the existence of the same over their land. Decree sheet be

prepared accordingly. File after needful be coinsigned to the record room.

mDr dsl esa fof/k ijkeZ'knkrk gfj;k.kk us vius i= Øekad 72445 fnukad 31-12-2008}kjk vius lq>ko esa Not Fit For Appeal fn;k gSA blds mijkUr okfn }kjk ,0Mh0ts0 txkk/kjhds U;k;ky; esa voekuuk ;kfpdk Mkyh xbZ ftldk fu.kZ; ekuuh; U;k;ky; }kjk 12-11-2013¼izfr layXu½ dks fn;k x;k ftldk fooj.k fuEu izdkj ls gS

“Learned counsel for the petitioner has made a statement that as the petitioner

has been died. Therefore, he does not want to persue the present petitioner. Same as

dismissed as withdrawn. In view of her statement, present petition is dismissed as

withdrawn. File, after due compliance be consigned to record room” .

blds mijkUr Jh lat; dqekj }kjk bl dk;kZy; esa izkFkZuk i= fu'kkunsgh dh QksVksizfr lfgr fn;k ftlesa vuqjks/k fd;k fd 295 isM+ 'kh'ke 47 isM+ ikiqyj rFkk 15 isM+ [kSjdsfu'kkunsgh esa okfn dh tehu esa [kMs fn[kk;s x;s gS mDr izkFkZuk i= ij dk;Zokgh djrs gq,fuEugLrk{kjh }kjk fnukad 15-06-2015 ¼izfr layXu½ dks txk/kjh jsat ds bl fu'kkunsgh ls lEcf/kar LVkQ dks e.My dk;kZy; esa cqyk;k rks mUgksaus fuEugLrk{kjh dks fy[k dj fn;k gS fd lsokfuo`r uk;c rglhynkj }kjk Hkw Lokfe dk i{k ysrs gq, ou foHkkx dh Hkwfe dks fdlh Hkh fcUnq lsiqjk ugha fd;k x;k gS tks isM+ fu'kkunsgh esa Hkw Lokfe ds fn[kk;s x;s gS og ljdkj ds gS o ekSdkij ou foHkkx ds ckmaMjh fiYyj yxs gq, gSAftldh ,d izfr Jh lat; dqekj dks bl dk;kZy;ds i= Øekad 1371 fnukad 19-6-2015 }kjk Hkst nh xgZ Fkh ¼izfr layXu½ ;g vkidks lwpukFkZ ,oavko';d dk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

ou e.My vf/kdkjh ;equkuxjA

i0Øekad fnukad

,d izfr iz/kku eq[; ou laj{kd gfj;k.kk iapdqyk dks muds i= Øekad F-W/166 dt.

02.06.2016 ds lanHkZ esa lwpukFkZ ,oa vko';d dk;Zokgh gsrw izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

ou e.My vf/kdkjh ;equkuxjA

The Committee again orally examined Principal Chief Conservator

Forests, Haryana and the Petitioner in its meeting held on 19.07.2017, in

which Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana submit their reply

vide their letter No. 1242 dated 19 07 2016 which reads as under:-

84

OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS

HARYANA, PANCHKULA

No .1242 Dated: 19-07-2016

To

The Chairman,

Committee on Petitions,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat,

Chandigarh.

Sub:- Petition submitted by Sh. Sanjay Kumar S/o Sh, Om Parkash RIo Village

Ghoron Pipli, Yamuna nagar.

*****

It is submitted that the Committee agreed for the demarcation of the forest land

and also the land of the petitioner, to find out the location of said trees. Sh. R.S.

Dhankhar,HFS, DFO Yamunanagar contacted the Tehsildar and also the Deputy

Commissioner, Yamunanagar for getting it done. Meanwhile raining season started and

also Sh. R.S. Dhankhar, HFS got transferred. Forest Department has already got the revenue

map of this area digitized from HARSAC Hisar. The HARSAC team has been contacted for

the demarcation of the whole area. Now this area has been affected by Yamuna waters and

hence it is not possible to get it demarcated till the water goes out from the forest land and

also the adjoining lands. Keeping in view the raining season and also the flood sensitivity

of the area, the petition may be adjourned for a month so that the forest and also the

adjoining land may be got demarcated properly. It is also clarified that after this demarcation

of the forest land and also the land of petitioner, if the trees are found standing on the land

of the petitioner then such trees will be handed over to the owner of the land. Accordingly

the petition may also be disposed off.

Sd/-

Principal Chief Conservator of Forests,

Haryana,Panchkula.

ou foHkkx gfj;k.kkdk;kZy; % mi ou laj{kd] ;equkuxj

Øekad@ fnukad---------------------

lsok esa

ou laj{kd mRrjh ifje.MyvEckyk 'kgjA

85

fo"k;%& fo/kku lHkk gfj;k;.kk esa Jh lat; dqekj iq= Jh vkSeizdk'k xkao ?kksMks ihiyh ftyk;equkuxj }kjk Mkyh xbZ iSVh'ku uå HVS/ iSVh'ku@2@2017&18@24566&75 esa fooknhr {ks=dh ekSdk vuqlkj dh xbZ fu'kkunsgh ij fnukad 2-1-2018 dh fo/kku lHkk ds fu.kZ; vuqlkj isMksadks lkSaidj vuqikyuk fjiksVZ dk HkstukA

mijksDr fo"k; ds lEcU/k esa fnukad 2-1-2018 dh fo/kku lHkk iSVh'ku desVh dh cSBdesa fy, x, fu.kZ; dh vuqikyuk esa chM Vkiw RF esa fu'kkunsgh esa tks Hkwfe oknh Jh lat; dqekjds ikl xbZ gSA ftlesa [kMs 'kh'ke ds isM tks ou foHkkx }kjk yxk, x, FksA 'kh'ke 30 isM okY;we2-38 ?ku eh0 ykV ua0 503-Y-YNR ou e.My vf/kdkjh mRiknu ;equkuxj dks dVkbZ gsrw lkSaifn;s x, gSA dCtk jlhn izkIr dj yh xbZ gSA ¼izfrlayXu½ blds vfrfjDr lkFkh Jh lat; dqekjdks iksiyj ds 48 isM lkSi fn, gS rFkk dCtk jlhn izkIr dj yh xbZ gS ¼izfrlayXu½A

fo/kkulHkk iSfV'ku desVh }kjk fd, x, fu.kZ; vuqlkj 30 isM+ 'kh'ke okWY;we 2-38 ?kueh0 ou e.My vf/kdkjh mRiknu e.My dks dVkbZ gsrq lkSi fn, x, gS isMks dh dVkbZ gks pqdhgS rFkk izkFkhZ Jh lat; dqekj iq= Jh vkSeizdk'k xkao ?kksMks ihiyh ftyk ;equkuxj us Hkh 48 isM+iksiyj ds dkV fy, gS vuqikyuk fjiksVZ vxkeh dk;Zokgh gsrq vkidh lsok esa izsf"kr gSA

lyaXu %& dCtk jlhn mRiknu e.My o izkFkhZ Jh lat; dqekj

Sd/-

mi ou laj{kd;equkuxjA

Øekad@1865 fnukad 28&2&18

,d izfr iz/kku eq[; ou laj{kd gfj;k.kk iapdwyk dks lwpukFkZ ,oa vko';d dk;Zokghgsrw izsf"kr gSA

Sd/-

mi ou laj{kd ;equkuxjA

————————

The Committee considered the reply of the Department 1.3.18 in its meeting held

on 1.3.18 and felt satisfied and decided to dispose of the petition accordingly.

12. PETITION RECIVED FROM SHRI BASVANANAD S/O SH. DEVIDUTT,

#1047, FIRST FLOOR, SECTOR 19, PANCHKULA, REGARDING

PROPER COMPENSATION AFTER DEATH OF MR. DEEPAK.

The Petition received from Shri Basvanand, reads as under :-

lsok esa] ekuuh; v/;{k egksn; th]iSVh'ku desVhgfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk] p.Mhx<+

86

fo"k; %& lSDVj&II&14 MhokfMax jksMz ij yxs fctyh ds [kEcs ¼LVªhV ykbZV dk iksy½ls djaV yxus ls gqbZ nhid dh e`R;q mijkUr mfpr eqvkotk nsus o uxjfuxe ds vf/kdkfj;ksa@deZpkfj;ksa ds fo#) dk;Zokgh djus ckjsA

Jheku th]

fuosnu ;g gS fd eSa cklokuUn iq= Jh nsohnRr fuoklh edku ua- 1047 igyh eaftylSDVj&19 iapdwyk esa ifjokj lfgr jgrk gwWaA tksfd eSa gqM~Mk foHkkx esa dk;Zjr gwa] fnukad16&06&2017dks esjk yM+dk nhid lSDVj&11 ls Mkal Dykl yxkdj yxHkx 8%30 o 9%00 cts jkf= dks okfil?kj vk jgk FkkA tc nhid lSDVj&11 o 14 chp dh lM+d dks ikj dj jgk Fkk rks ml nkSjkulVªhV ykbZV ds iksy ls djaV yx x;k dqN yksxksa }kjk nhid dks lkekU; vLirky lSDVj&6iapdwyk esa igqWapk z;k rks MkWDVjksa us nhid dks e`R;q ?kksf"kr dj fn;kA nhid esjk bdykSrk csVk Fkkftldh vk;q 16 o"kZ FkhA mlds mijkUr LVªhV ykbZV iksy dks pSd fd;k x;k rks mlesa djaV Fkk¼QksVks lkFk layXu gSW½A

vr% Jheku th vkils vuqjks/k gS fd esjs csVs dh e`R;q ds ftEesokj uxj fuxe dsvf/kdkfj;ksa@deZpkfj;ksa ds f[kykQ l[r dk;Zokgh dh tk;sa o eq>s mfpr eqvkotk fn;k tk, rkfdHkfo"; esa ,slh nq?kZVuk fdlh vkSj ds lkFk uk gksA vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

Sd/-

Hkonh;fnukad %& 27&07&2017 cklokuUn iq= Jh nsohnÙk

edku uaå 1047 igyh eaftylSDVj&19 iapdwykA

The Petition was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 05.08.2017

and the Committee considered the same and decided that said petition may be sent to the

concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15 days. The

Committee did not received any reply from the Department. Thereafter Committee orally

examined the Managing Director, HVPN, Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Panchkula

and Petitioner and discussed the matter. The Committee received the reply from Executive

Officer, Municipal Corporation, Panchkula, vide their letter No. 18582, dated 12.02.2018,

which read as under-

From

Executive Officer

Municipal Corporation

Panchkula.

To

The Secretary,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat

Memo No. 18582Dated : 12-2-2018

87

Subject: A copy of the Proceedings of the meeting of the Committee on Petitions held on

23.01.2018.

Kindly refer on the subject cited above.

In this connection the matter in question is pending in the Hon’ble court for

compensation. Since the matter in dispute involved subjudice, as and when matter is

decided the further action will be taken. This is for your information.

Sd/-

Executive Officer

Municipal Corporation

Panchkula’

The Committee considered the same in its meeting held on 1-3-2018 and

Committee felt as the matter is subjudice and it is not appropriate to interfere in the

subjudice matter at this stage. Hence decided to dispose-of the said petition.

13. PETITION RECEIVED FROM SMT. USHA DEVI W/O SH. MANOJ

KUMAR, H.NO. 646, SECTOR 9, JIND, REGARDING DA / ARREAR

AND CHILDREN EDUCATION ALLOWANCES

The Petition received from Smt. Usha Devi, reads as under :-

ekuuh;]

ps;jeSu gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk]iVh'ku desVh p.Mhx<+A

fo"k; % 2011&2016 dk D.A. Arrear to Children Education Allowance fudyokusckjsA

Jheku th]

esjs ifr Loå Jh eukst dqekj jk0 o0 ek0 fo0 x<+okyh[ksM+k ¼thUn½ esa SS v/;kid dsin ij Fks ftudk 22&04&2011 dks fu/ku gks x;k FkkA mlds ckn Ldwy ls feyus okys osru lsgj o"kZ tks D.A.o`f) gksrh gSA mldk tks Arrear curk gSA og vkt fnukad 20&01&2017 rddk cdk;k gSA tks 2011 ls tuojh 2017 rd ugha fudyok;k x;k vkSj esjs nks csfV;k gSA tks 7th

o 4th d{kk esa i<+rh gSA u gh budk f'k'kq HkÙkk fudkyk x;kA eSaus izk/kkukpk;Z ls ckj&2 izkFkZukHkh dh dHkh dgrh gS fd f'k'kq HkÙkk vkidk curk gh ugha] dHkh dgrh gS esjs dks irk ugha fyfidls iwNksA eSaus B.E.O. tqykuk o D.E.O. thUn ls Hkh f'kdk;r dh ysfdu dksbZ lek/kku ugha gqvkAesjh bu leL;kvksa dk lek/kku djok;k tk, o ;s Li"V fd;k tk, fd tks lqfo/kk,a tSls& osru]f'k'kq HkÙkk*] vU; lqfo/kk,¡ ljdkj }kjk ns; gksrh gSA mudh ftEesnkjh Ldwy iz/kkukpk;Z dh gksrhgS u fd esjh D;ksadh tc Hkh iz/kkukpk;Z ls tc Hkh ckr djrh gw¡ rks dgrh gS fd ;s rks vkidks irk

88

gksuk pkfg, fd dc D.A. of) gqbZ o vkidks f'k'kq HkÙkk feyrk ;k ughaA eSa fdl&2 dk irk d#xhAeSa fdl&2 ds fcy cuokÅaxhA vki vius vki irk yxkvksa fd ljdkj vkidks D;k nsrh gS D;kugha nsrh A bl ckjs fo"k; esa vki tgka tkuk pkgrs gS tk, ;k fdlh ls dksbZ Hkh f'kdk;r djuhgSA vki djsa eq>s blls dksbZ QdZ ugha iM+rkA vRk% vkils vuqjks/k gS fd vki esjh bu leL;k,adk lek/kku djokus dk d"V djs rkfd Hkfo"; esa eq>s ;s lHkh lqfo/kk,sa le; ij feyrh jgsA

Sd/-

izkFkhZm"kk nsoh W/o Lo0 eukst dqekje-u- 646 Sec.-9 Jind.

The Petition was placed before the Committee in its meeting held on 29.01.2017,

the Committee considered the same and decided that the said petition may be sent to the

concerned Department for sending their comments within a period of 15 days. The

Committee received the . reply from % Directorate Elementary Education, Haryana, vide

their letter No. 7/11-2017 PR(2), dated 10.04.2017, as under-

izs"kd

funs'kd ekSfyd f'k{kk gfj;k.kk]iapdwykA

lsok esa

ftyk ekSfyd f'k{kk vf/kdkjh]thUnA;knh Øekad 7@11&2017 PP (2)

fnukad] iapdwykA

fo"k;& Education Allowance and D.A. Arrear fudyokus ckjsA

*****

mijksDRk fo"k; ij funs'kky; ds ;knh Øekad 7@11&2017 iS0izk0 ¼2½]fnukad 10-04-2017 ds lanHkZ esaA

fo"k;kafdr ekeys esa vkils iqu% vuqjks/k gS fd e`rd deZpkjh Lo0 Jh eukst dqekj,l0,l0 ekLVj jk0o0ek0fo0] x<okyh [ksMk dh vkf{kr iRuh Jhefr m"kk nsoh }kjk fn, x,izfrosnu ij fu;ekuqlkj dk;Zokgh djds bl funs'kky; dks rqjUr voxr djok;s

Sd/-

v/kh{kd iSU'ku izkFkfed]d`rs % funs'kd ekSfyd f'k{kk gfj;k.kk] iapdwykA

89

i`"Bkdu Øa0 le fnukad] iapdwyk % 16&6&2017

bldh ,d izfr fuEufyf[kr dks vko';d dk;Zokgh@lwpukFkZ izsf"kr gS%&

1- lfpo] gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk] eSus lfpoky; lSDVj&1] p.Mhx<+A

2- izkpk;Z] jktdh; ofj"B ek/;fed fo|ky;] x<okyh [ksMk ¼thUn½

3- Jhefr m"kk nsoh iRuh Lo0 Jh eukst dqekj] edku ua0 646] lSDVj&9] thUnA

v/kh{kd iSU'ku izkFkfed]d`rs% funs'kd ekSfyd f'k{kk gfj;k.kkiapdwykA

The Committee satisfied with the reply of the department and accordingly

dispose-of the petition on in its meeting held on 1-3-2018.

14. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM DR. P.K. BAJPAYEE,

PRINCIPAL, MAHARAJA AGRASEN MAHAVIDYALAYA, JAGADHRI,

REGARDING NON PASSING OF COLLEGE SALARY BILLS FROM

JANUARY, 2017 BY HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT.

The Petition/Representation received from Dr. P.K. Bajpayee, reads as under :-

fnukad 25&05&2017

lsok esa]

v/;{k egksn;]isfVlu desVh] gfj;k.kkgfj;k.kk ljdkj] p.Mhx<+A

fo"k; %& tuojh 2017 ls mPprj] f'k{kk foHkkx }kjk dkWyst ds osru fcy u ikldjus ds lanHkZ esaA

egksn;]

fuosnu gS fd egkjktk vxzlSu egkfo|ky; txk/kjh jktdh; vuqnku izkIr ,d eq[;'kS{kf.kd laLFkku gS&

* ,d LFkkuh; odhy Jh th-Mh- xqIrk dh >wBh f'kdk;r ij rRdkyhu funs'kd }kjkdkWyst izcU/ku dks ebZ 2016 esa fof/k lEer mfpr dk;Zokgh djus ds fy, fy[kk FkkA

* dkWyst izcU/ku us mPprj f'k{kk funs'kd dks lwfpr djrs gq, ,d tkap vf/kdkjh dhfu;qfDr dj foLr`r tkap dk vkns'k tqykbZ&vxLr 2016 fn;k FkkA

* blls igys fd tkap vf/kdkjh viuh dksbZ fjiksVZ nsrs] funs'kky; mPprj f'k{kk ls ,di= 7 tuojh 2017 dks izkIr gqvk ftlesa fy[kk Fkk fd ,d lIrkg ds vUnj fjiksVZ u

90

nsus ij funs'kky; }kjk dkWyst ds lgk;rk vuqnku jksdus rFkk laLFkk dks tkjh NOC

dks withdraw djus dk;Zokgh dj yh tk;sxhA

* dkWyst esa bl i= ds izkfIr gksrs gh 7 tuojh 2017 dks ,d bZ&esy dj funs'kd egksn;dks tkap dh izxfr ls voxr x;k rFkk leqfpr tkap ds fy, dqN vkSj le; nsus dsfy, fy[kk x;k ftldh izfr MkWd }kjk Hkh mlh fnu Hksth x;hA

* rRi'pkr~ dkWyst dks funs'kky; mPprj f'k{kk dh vksj ls u rks dksbZ mRrj izkIr gqvkvkSj u gh gekjs i= ij fu.kZ; ls gh gesa voxr djk;k x;kA

* rnqijkUr dkWyst }kjk fnukad 07-02-2017 o fnukad 27-02-2017 o fnukad 10-04-2017dks Hkh dkWyst ds osru fcy ikl djus gsrw fuosnu i= izsf"kr fd, x, ij fdlh dkdksbZ mRrj funs'kky; dh rjQ ls izkIr ugha gqvkA

* fnukad 28 ekpZ 2017 dks izcU/ku lfefr ds inkf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk funs'kd egksn; lsO;fDrxr :i ls feydj tkap fjiksVZ lkSaih xbZ rFkk dkWyst ds tuojh ekg ls cdk;kosru fcy ikl djokus dk fuosnu fd;k x;kA

* blls iwoZ dkWyst izkpk;Z }kjk funs'kd egksn; ls O;fDrxr :i ls feydj fnukad21,24ekpZ 2017 rFkk 10 vizSy 2017 dks dkWyst ds tuojh ekg ls cdk;k osru fcy ikldjokus dk fuosnu fd;k x;kA

* mPprj f'k{kk funs'kd egksn; us fnukad 24 ekpZ 2017 dks lwfpr fd;k x;k fd dkWystds osru fcy ikl djus ds vkns'k ns fn;s x, gS ijUrq C-IV lsD'ku esa og QkbZy 17vizSy 2017 rd izkIr ugha gks ldhA

* fnukad 17 vizSy 2017 ds vijkUg tc dkWyst izkpk;Z us funs'kd egksn; ls ckr djusds fy, Qksu feyk;k rks muds lVkWQ us ;g tkudkjh nh fd lEcf/kr QkbZy fey xbZgS o osru fcy Hkstdj ikl djok ysaA

* dkWyst LVkWQ dks fcy ysdj Hkstus ij irk yxkk fd izkpk;Z dks NksMdj ckdh yksxksads osru fcy ikl djok ysa] blds fy, C-IV lsD'ku ds v/kh{kd us dksbZ dkj.k ughacrk;kA bl chp fnukad 18 vizSy 2017 dks funs'kd egksn; ls fuosnu djus ij Kkrgqvk fd tks vkns'k gksxsa oks QkbZy ij gksaxs] dkWyst dks lwpuk ns nh tk;sxhA lwpuk vHkhrd visf{kr gSA

* dkWyst LVkQ dh ijs'kkfu;ksa dks ns[krs gq, tc dkWyst ds izc/ku us fnukad 22-05-2017dks funs'kd mPprj f'k{kk ls eqykdkr dh rks mUgsa dgk x;k fd dkWyst izkpk;Z MkW- ih-ds-cktis;h dks NksM+dj ckdh lHkh ds osru fcy tuojh ekg ls vHkh rd ds ikl djkysaA

* dkWyst izc/ku }kjk ;g iwNus ij fd fQj pkj eghus rd leLr dkWyst ds osru fcyD;ksa jksds x;s funs'kd dh vksj ls bldk dksbZ lurks"ktud mRrj ugha izkIr gksldk funs'kd us dkWyst izkpk;Z MkW- ih-ds-cktis;h ds osru jksdus ds fu.kZ; dk Hkh dksbZlurks'ktud mRrj ugha fn;kA

91

* gfj;k.kk ,fQfy;sVsM dkWyst ¼flD;ksfjVh vkWQ lfoZl½ ,DV 1979¼fu;e 2006½ dsvuqlkj ,fQfy;sVsM dkWyst ds deZpkfj;ksa ds ij vuq'kklukRed dk;Zokgh gsrq dkWystizc/ku ghl{ke gSA dkWyst izcU/ku us O;kid tkap djk dj fjiksVZ 2 ekg igys ghfuns'kd mPprj f'k{kk dks Hkst nh gS rFkk funs'kd mPprj f'k{kk us fjiksVZ esa fdlh Hkh[kkeh ls dkWyst izcU/ku dks voxr ugha djk;k gS vkSj u gh mUgsa ,slk djus dk vf/kdkj gSA

* fcuk leqfpr dkj.k ds dkWyst ds lHkh dk;ZdÙkkZvksa dh ru[kkg 5 eghus rd jksds j[ukfuns'kd o mPprj f'k{kk funs'kky; ds vf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk vijkf/kd d`R; dh Js.kh esavkrk gS vr% muij fof/k lEer mfpr dk;Zokgh dh tk;saA

* MkW-ih-ds- cktis;h] izkpk;Z dk osru jksdus dk fu.kZ; euekuk o mUgsa izrkfM+r djus dkmnns'; ls fy;k x;k gSA 5 eghus rd dk;Z ds cnys osru ugha nsuk mudsekuokf/kdkj dk guu gS rFkk ;g ,d vkijkf/kd d`R; gS tks funs'kd mPprj f'k{kkegksn; Jh th-Mh- xqIrk ds nckc esa ys jgs gSaA

* dkWyst dk LVkWQ osru ds vHkko esa vU;Ur rdyhQ esa gS rFkk fiNys pkj ekg ls cgqrgh vf/kd dfBukbZ;ksa dk lkeuk djuk iM jgk gSA dkWyst deZpkfj;ksa ds cPpksa dk Ldwynkf[kyk] edku fdjk;k o lHkh izdkj ds nSfud o ekfld [kpZsa vkfn ogu djus esamudh fnDdrksa dk lkeuk djuk iM jgk gS o fiNys ekg esa lsokfoZr gq, deZpkjh dkProvident Fund dk Hkqxrku u gksus ds iSa'ku yxus esa nsjh gks jgh gSA

* ;g mPprj f'k{kk foHkkx ds dqN dEkZpkfj;ksa dh feyhHkxr ds dkj.k osru fcy ikldjus esa vojks/k mRiUu fd, tk jgs gSaA

vki ls fuosnu gS fd deZpkfj;ksa dh dfBukbZ;ksa dks ns[krs gq, mPprj f'k{kk foHkkxgfj;k.kk dh funsZ'k ns fd egkjktk vxzlSu egkfo|ky; ds dEkZpkfj;ksa dk osru tuojh ekg lstkjh djus ds lkFk gh izkpk;Z MkW- ih-ds- cktis;h dk Hkh osru Hkqxrku djkus dh di;k djsaA vkils;g Hkh fuosnu gS fd nks"kh vf/kdkfj;ksa ds f[kykQ mfpr iz'kklfud dk;Zokgh dh tk;s rFkk 5 ekgrd dkWyst izkpk;Z o leLr LVkWQ dks izrkfM+r djus ds fy, vkijkf/kd ekeyk ntZ dj eqdnekpyk;k tk;sA

Sd/-

Hkonh;]MkW-ih-ds-cktis;h izkpk;Z

The Petition/representation was considered by the Committee and Committee

directly orally examined the departmental representatives and the petitioner in its meeting

held on 04.07.2017, in which departmental representatives assured : the Committee that

they will release the salary, and also issued on letter No. 7/62-2017IV(1) Dated 8-8-17 in

this context.

92

Accordingly petition/representation was disposed of by the Committee in its

meeting held on 1-3-2018.

15. PETITION/REPRESENTATION RECEIVED FROM SMT. SANTRO

DEVI W /0 LATE SH. RATAN SINGH, VILL. NIMANBAD, TEHSIL SAFIDON,

DISTT. JIND, REGARDING.

The Petition/Representation received from Smt. Santro Devi, reads

as under :-

lsok esa]

pS;jeSu];kfpdk lfefrgfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk p.Mhx<+A

fo"k; % nj[kkLr ckcr Loå Jh jru flag ds LFkku ij ukSdjh nsus o e`rddeZpkjh ds lHkh izdkj ds cdk;ktkr dh vfr 'kh?kz vnk;xh djokus ckjsizkFkZuk i=A

Jheku th]

izkFkZuk fuEufyf[kr gS %&

1 ;g gS fd eSa lk;yk Jherh lUrjks nsoh iRuh Lo0 Jh jru flag iq= Jh cukjlh fuoklhxkao fueukckn] rglhy lQhnksa] ftyk thUn dh gw¡ vkSj esjs ifr Lo0 Jh jru flagvk;qDr] uxj fuxe Qjhnkckn ds v/khu Qjhnkckn esa crkSj lQkbZ deZpkjh ds LFkkbZin ij dk;Zjr Fks tks e0 u0 2 lh&5] ,u0vkbZ0Vh0 Qjhnkckn esa jgrs FksA

2 ;g gS fd esjs ifr mDr dh lfoZl le; nkSjku fcekj gksus ds dkj.k fnukad29@10@2014 dks ihthvkbZ,e,l jksgrd esa e`R;q gks xbZ FkhA

3 ;g gS fd esjs ifr dh e`R;q ds ckn gfj;k;.kk ljdkj ds fu;eksa ds rgr eSaus vkt rdmuds fdlh Hkh izdkj ds cdk;ktkr Q.M@ykHk dh vkn;xh dh xbZ gS rFkk uk ghihfM+r ifjokj ds fdlh Hkh lnL; dks ukSdjh nsus ckjsa dksbZ dkjokbZ dh xbZ gSaA

4 ;g gS fd esjs ikl 4 yM+fd;k o 2 yM+ds gS ftu esa ls nks yM+fd;k dh 'kknh dh tkpqdh gSa vkSj vc gky esa 4 cPpsa vfookfgr gSaA gekjs ikl esjs ifr dh ukSdjh gh ,s lkjsifjokj dh vkenuh dk Lkk/ku Fkk tks mudh e`R;q ds ckn [kRe gks tkus ds dkj.k eq>so esjs cPpksa dk Hkj.k iks"k.k Hkh ugha gks jgk gSaA ge xjhc o csjkstxkj gSa vLFkkbZ etnwjhHkh ugha fey jgh gSa ftlls gesa jksVh jksth ds ykys iM+s gq;s gSaA

vr% vki egkefge ekuuh; th ls esjh gkFk tksM+dj izkFkZuk gS fd esjs ifr dh e`R;q dsckn muds lHkh izdkj ds cdk;ktkr dh vfr 'kh?kz vnk;xh djokbZ tkosa rFkk gfj;k.kk

93

ljdkj ds fu;eksa ds rgr ifjokj ds ,d lnL; dks ukSdjh fnyokbZ tkosa rkfd eSa viusifjokj dk ykyu ikyu dj ldwaA 'kh?kz dkjokbZ ds fy;s vkidh vfr d`ik gksxhA

/kU;oknA

Sd/-

fnukad %& izkFkhZ;k]Jherh lUrjksa nsoh iRuhLoå Jh jru flag iq= Jh cukjlhfuoklh xkao feukckn] rglhy lQhnksa]ftyk thUnA

The Petition/representation was placed before the Committee in its meeting held

on 13.06.2017, the Committee considered the same and desired that the comments of the

concerned department may be obtained within a period of 15 days. The representation

was sent to the concerned department on 25.07.2017. As no reply was received within the

stipulated period from the Department. The Committee called the Commissioner, Municipal

Corporation, Faridabad and the Petitioner in its meeting held on 23.01.2018, in which

committee made following observations: -

desVh dh fjde.Ms'ku

,Mh'kuy dfe'uj] E;qfufliy dkjiksjs'ku] Qjhnkckn }kjk ;g Lohdkj fd;k x;k gSfd ekStwnk dsl ds ckcr fuxe ds ikVZ ij dkQh [kkfe;ka@dfe;ka gSa vkSj fuxe us tks mRrj HkstkgS og QkbZy ij yxs gq, MkWdweSaV~l ds lkFk esy ugha [kkrkA bl dsl esa ;g rF; lkeus vk;sgSa fd esfMdy cksMZ }kjk Jh jru flag dh vk;q izekf.kr dh xbZ gS rFkk ch-ds- gkWfLiVy }kjkesfMdy fQVuSl dk izek.k&i+= tkjh fd;k x;k gS] ftl ij xyrh ls flfoy ltZu ds dkaÅaVjlkbZ u ugha gSaA mijksDr rF;ksa dks /;ku esa j[krs gq, iSVh'ku desVh fuxe dks ;s fjde.Ms'ku nsrhgS fd ftrus Hkh izkFkhZ ds cSuhfQV curs gSa fuxe ,d eghus ds vanj mudk Hkqxrku dj ns vkSjdesVh dh vuq'kalk dh dEiyk;al fjiksVZ Hkh desVh dks tYnh ls tynh Hksth tk;sA blds vykokfuxe ds dfe'uj dks Hkh ;s vuq'kalk dh tkrh gS fd tks vf/kdkjh@deZpkjh iSVh'ku desVh dksxyr rF;@mRrj Hkstus ds fy, vkSj QSDV~l dks fNikus ds fy, ftEesnkj gSa muds f[kykQdk;Zokgh djds dEiyka;l fjiksVZ desVh dks HkstsaA

The Committee received compliance report from the Commissioner, Municipal

Corporation, Faridabad vide their Memo No. MCF/E-3/2018, dated 26.02.2018, which reads

as under:-

From

Commissioner,

Municipal Corporation,

Faridabad.

94

To

The Secretary,

Haryana Vidhan Sabha,

Chandigarh, .

Memo No. MCF/E/2018

Dated: 26-02-2018

Sub:- Compliance report on the recommendations/directions dated 23.01.2018 of

theCommittee on Petitions of Haryana Vidhan Sabha in respect of petition filed

by Smt. Santro Devi wife of Late Shri Rattan Singh, Village Namanbad, Tehsil

Safidon, Distt. Jind (Haryana)

Kindly refer to Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat letter No. HVS Petition 536A/

2017-18/2023, dated 6.2.2018 (received in the office of this Corporation on 12.02.2018) on

the subject cited as above.

In this connection, it is submitted for the kind information of COMMITTEE

ON PETITIONS of Haryana Vidhan Sabha that in pursuance to the directions/

recommendations dated 23.01.2018 made by the Committee, compliance have been made

by this Corporation. Action taken report/compliance report is submitted as under :-

1. The payment of Monthly financial assistance amounting to Rs. 554960/- (Rs,

Five Lacs Fifty Four Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty Only) Gratuity & Leave

encashment amounting to Rs.25883/- (Rs. Twenty Five Thousand Eight Hundred

Eighty Three Only), GIS amounting to Rs.5000/- (Rs. Five Thousand Only) has

been made to Smt. Santro Devi wife of Late Shri Rattan Singh - the petitioner. It

is further submitted that an amount of Rs. 25,000~- ( Rs. Twenty Five Thousand

Only) has already been ’Paid towards ex-gratia on 19.01.2018. A copy of the

report of Officer Incharge Accounts of this Corporation is attached herewith for

kind perusal, please.

2. The concerned official of this Corporation at fault namely Shri Ajay Dua, Senior

Clerk (now Inspector) has been charge-sheeted under rule 7 of Haryana Civil

Services (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 2016. A copy of the charge-sheet issued

to the said official is attached for kind perusal, please.

Sd/-

Commissioner

Municipal Corporation

Fridabad

Encl : As above

From

To

Officer In-Charge of Accounts

Municipal Corporation

Faridabad

95

To

The Establishment Officer

Municipal Corporation

Faridabad

Memo No. MCFIOIA/2018/429 Dated : 26-2-18

Subject:- Payment of dues to Smt. Santro Devi W/o Late Sh. Rattan Singh S/o

Sh. Banwad Employee Code No.4915.

Kindly refer to your office Endst. No. MCF/E-3/2018/435, dated 23.02.2018 on

the subject cited above. .

The payment of Monthly financial assistance amounting to Rs. 554960/-

(Rs. Five Lacs Fifty Four Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty’ Only) Gratuity & Leave

encashment amounting to RS.25883/- (Rs. Twenty Five Thousand Eight Hundred Eighty

Three Only), GIS amounting to Rs.5,000/- (Rs. Five Thousand Only) has been made to

Smt. Santro Devi wife of Late Shri Rattan Singh - the petitioner.

It is further submitted that an amount of Rs. 25,000/- ( Rs. Twenty Five

Thousand Only) has already been paid towards ex-gratia on 19.01.2018.

Sd/-

Officer In-Charge of Accounts

Øekad ,e0lh0,Q0@bZ&1@2008@44 fnukad % 26@2@18

vkjksi&i=

Jh vt; nqvk Jh lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ dks lwfprfd;k tkrk gS fd bl fuxe }kjk mlds fo:) gfj;k;.kk flfoy lsok,sa ¼n.M ,oa vihy½] fu;e]2016 ds fu;e&7 ds vUrxZr fooj.k esa fn;s x;s vkjksih ds vk/kkj ij dk;Zokgh djus dk izLrkofd;k x;k gSA

Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ fyf[kr :i esabl ;knh dh izkfIr ls 15 fnu ds vUnj&vUnj viuk izfrosnu@mÙkj izLrqr djs fd D;k ogvius fo#) LFkkfir vkjksiksa dh lR;rk dks Lohdkj djrk gS vkSj mldsd lEcU/k esa dqN dgukpkgrk gSA

Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ dks lwfpr fd;ktkrk gSfd og viuk fyf[kr mÙkj rS;kj djus ds fy, tkap lEcfU/kr dksbZ vfHkys[k ns[kus dhbPNk j[krk gS rks bu vfHkys[kksa dks LFkkiuk 'kk[kk esa l{ke vf/kdkjh ls iwoZ vuqefr ysdj ns[kldrk gSA mls ;g Hkh crkuk vko';d gS fd dsoy ogha vfHkys[k mls fn[kk;s tk;sxs tks l{kevf/kdkjh ds ikl miyC/k gksxsa vkSj ;fn dksbZ lEcfU/kr vfHkys[k tufgr esa fn[kkuk fuxe ds fgresa ugha le>k tk;sxk rks ,sls lEcfU/kr vfHkys[k dks fn[kkus ls euk Hkh fd;k tk ldrk gSA ;fnJh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ fdlh ,sls vfHkys[k dks ns[kukpkgrk gS tks bl fuxe ds ikl ugha gS rks og mls vius Lrj ij vU;= ns[k ldrk gSA mls ;g

96

Hkh Li"V fd;k tkrk gS fd mlds fo#) lEcfU/kr vfHkys[k ns[kus esa foQy jgus ij fyf[kr mÙkjds fu;r le; ds ckn v?kksgLrk{kjh dks nsjh ls izsf"kr djus esa foyEc dk dkj.k dksbZ dkuwuh vk/kkj ugha cusxk vkSj ;g le>k tk;sxk fd mlds ikl vius cpko i{k esa dksbZ izfrosnuk@mÙkjugha gSA ,slh voLFkk esa mlds fo:) fu;ekuqlkj vkxkeh ,d rjQk dk;Zokgh dj nh tk;sxhA

fyf[kr izfrosnuk@mÙkj v/kksgLrk{kjh dks izsf"kr fd;k tkuk pkfg,A

Sd/

vk;qDruxj fuxe Qjhnkckn

Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk]ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½uxj fuxe] QjhnkcknA

izfr % 1- la;qDr vk;qDr ¼Vh½2- vkfQlj bUpktZ ¼ys[kk½3- tkWap QkbZy@O;fDrxr QkbZyA

Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ ij yxk, x, vkjksiksdk fooj.k ftl ij vkjksi vk/kkfjr gS

1 LFkkiuk 'kk[kk esa miyC/k fjdkMZ vuqlkj Lo0 Jh jru flag lqiq= Jh cuokjh] lQkbZdeZpkjh] dksM u0 4915 ¼ftldk fnukad 29-10-2014 dks nsgkUr gks x;k Fkk½ dh iRuh Jherh lUrjksnsoh dks #i;s 25]000@& dh jkf'k crkSj] vuqxzgiwoZd foRrh; lgk;rk Lohd`r dh xbZ Fkh vkSjftldk Hkqxrku ys[kk 'kk[kk ds }kjk dj fn;k x;k gSA Haryana Compassisonate Assistance

to the Dependents of Deceased Government Employees Rules, 2006 esa fd;s x;s izok/kku dsvuqlkj e`rd deZpkjh ds vkfJrksa dks vuqxzgiwoZd foRrh; lgk;rk ds bykok Gratuity, GPG,

DCRG, Leave Encashment, GIS o monthly financial assistance vkfn dk Hkqxrku fd;k tkrkgSA ijUrq lEcfU/kr QkbZy esa Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½}kjk vafdr dh xbZ fVIi.kh tks fd uksfVx i`"B 1 ls 15 ij ekStwn gS] ds vuqlkj bl deZpkjhds vkfJrksa dks bu ykHkksa dks Hkqxrku blfy, ugha fd;k tk ldk] D;ksafd mDr deZpkjh us viuhe`R;q ls iwoZ dk;kZy; esa viuk medical fitness tek ugha djok;k FkkA

2 orZeku esa LFkkiuk 'kk[kk ds fMfyax deZpkjh Jh panu flag] fujh{kd us Jh fodkldUgS;k] v/kh{kd ds ek/;e ls fnukad 20-02-2018 dks izLrqr fjiksVZ ds vuqlkj fnukad 19-01-2018dks gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk] p.Mhx<+ dh COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS dh vksj ls bl ekeys esabl dk;kzy; dks uksfVl izkIr gksus ds ckn tc QkbZy dks search fd;k x;k rks ;g ik;k x;kfd QkbZy fnukad 11-10-2017 dks ys[kk 'kk[kk ds }kjk receive dh xbZ ys[kk 'kk[kk ls 19-01-2018dks QkbZy izkIr djus ds ckn tc QkbZy dks voyksdu fd;k x;k rks QkbZy esa e`rd deZpkjhds vk;q fu/kkZj.k lEcfU/kr dkxtkr ugha yxs gq;s Fks vkSj deZpkjh dh iRuh Jherh lUrjks nsoh ds}kjk fnukad 01-04-2015 dks bl dk;kZy; esa izLrqr B.K. Hospital dh medical examination

97

report dks entertain u djds uksfVax ist 1 ls ysdj 15 rd vusdksa txg ij Jh vt; nqvk lqiq=Lo- Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ us fofHkUu frfFk;ksa esa ;g fVIi.kh ntZ dhgqbZ gS fd medical fitness certificate izLrqr u fd;s tkus ds dkj.k deZpkjh dh iRuh JherhlUrjksa nsoh dks Post Death Benefits dk Hkqxrku ugha fd;k tk ldrkA rRdkyhu dealing hand

Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd o rRdkyhu LFkkiuklYkgdkj Jh cychj flag iaokj ds }kjk office noting esa ntZ mDr fVIi.kh;ksa vkSj QkbZy esa vk;qfu/kkZj.k izek.k i= u yxs gksus ds vk/kkj ij dk;kZy; ds }kjk rnkuqlkj fo/kku lHkk desVh dslEeq[k izLrqr dh tkuh okyh fjiksVZ rS;kj dj nh xbZA

3 mDr Jh panu flag] fujh{kd ¼tks fd fnukad 23-01-2018 dks gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk dhCOMMITTEE ON PETITIONS dh cSBd esa mifLFkr Fkk½ us viuh mDr fjiksVZ esa ;g Hkh fjiksVZdh gS fd fnukad 23-01-2018 dks gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk dh COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS dh cSBdesa uxj fuxe dh vksj ls committee ds lEeq[k mifLFkr gq, vfrfjDr vk;qDr us tc e`rddeZpkjh ds vkfJr ds }kjk age determination certificate izLrqr u djus dh ckr cSBd esa dghrks e`rd deZpkjh dh vkfJr iRuh us LFkkiuk 'kk[kk ds }kjk dk;kZy; ds ;knh i= Øekad,e0lh0,Q0@bZ&3@2015@1573 fnukad 25-05-2015 ds vuqlkj ys[kk 'kk[kk dks izsf"kr fd;s x;sage determination ls lEcfU/kr i= dh izfr izLrqr dj nh] ysfdu bldh izfr ml le; QkbZyesa miyC/k ugha Fkh] ftlds ifj.kkeLo:i u dsoy dk;kZy; ds }kjk fo/kku lHkk desVh ds lEeq[kxyr rF; izLrqr gq;s cfYd fuxe ds mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dks lfefr ds lEeq[k 'kfeZnxh Hkh mBkuhiM+hA ;fn Jh vt; nqvk ds }kjk bl i= dh izfr QkbZy esa yxkkbZ gksrh rks gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkkdh mDr desVh ds lEq[k fuxe dh Nfo /kwfey ugha gksrhA

4 gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky; ds i= Øekad HVS/Petition/536/2017-15/2023 fnukd06-02-2018 ds vuqlkj tkjh proceeding esa desVh us fuEu vuqlkj recommendation ddh gS %&

,Mh'kuy dfe'uj] E;qfufliy dkjiksjs'ku] Qjhnkckn }kjk ;g Lohdkj fd;k x;k gSfd ekStwnk dsl ds ckcr fuxe ds ikVZ ij dkQh [kkfe;ka@dfe;ka gS vkSj fuxe us tks mRrj HkstkgS og QkbZy ij yxs gq;s MkdweSaVl ds lkFk esy ugha [kkrkA bl dsl esa ;g rF; lkeus vk;sgS fd esfMdy cksMZ }kjk Jh jru flag dh vk;q izekf.kr dh xbZ rFkk ch-ds- gkWfLiVy }kjk esfMdyfQVuSl dk izek.k i= tkjh fd;k x;k gS] ftl ij xyrh ls flfoy ltZu ds dkamVj lkbZu ughagSA mijksDr rF;ksa dks /;ku esa j[krs gq;s iSVh'ku desVh fuxe dks ;s fjde.Ms'ku nsrh gS fd ftrusHkh izkFkhZ ds cSuhfQV curs gSa fuxe ,d eghus ds vUnj mudk Hkqxrku dj ns vkSj desVh dhvuq'kalk dh dEiyk;l fjiksVZ Hkh desVh dks tYnh ls tYnh Hksth tk;sA blds vykok fuxe dsdfe'uj dks Hkh ;s vuq'kalk dh tkrh gS fd tks vf/kdkjh@deZpkjh iSVh'ku desVh dks xyrrF;@mRrj Hkstus ds fy;s vkSj QSDV~l dks fNikus ds fy;s ftEesnkj gSA muds f[kykQ dk;Zokghdjds dEiyk;al fjiksVZ desVh esa HkstsaA

5 tgka rd desVh ds }kjk dh xbZ mijksDr recommendation dk lEcU/k gS] bl ckjs esacrk;k tkrk gS fd age determination lEcfU/kr LFkkiuk 'kk[kk ds }kjk gh tkjh fd;s x;s i=,e0lh0,Q0@bZ&3@2015@1573 fnukad 25-05-2015 dh izfr QkbZy esa u yxkus vkSj deZpkjh

98

dh vkfJr iRuh ds }kjk 01-04-2015 dks nh xbZ madical examination dh report dh QksVks izfrdk mYys[k uksfVax ist esa u djus ds fy;s Li"V :i ls Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk]ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ ftEesokj gSA ;fn mlus drZO;ghurk o ykijokgh djrs gq;s mDrdR; u fd;k gksrk rks u rks desVh ds lEeq[k uxj fuxe Qjhnkckn dh vksj ls rF;ghu ckrsa izLrqrdh tkrh vkSj u gh fuxe ds mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dks lfefr ds lEeq[k 'kfeZnxh mBkuh iM+rh gA

6 gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky; us vius i= Øekad HVS/Petition/536/2017-18/

15841fnukad 25-07-2017 ds vuqlkj bl dk;kZy; dks lwlpfr fd;k Fkk fd Jherh larjks nsoh/keZiRuh Lo0 Jh jru flag ds }kjk nk;j dh xbZ ;kfpdk dks gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk dh COMMITTEE

ON PETITIONS dh fnukad 13-06-217 dks gqbZ cSBd esa lfefr ds lEeq[k j[kk x;k] ftl ijfopkj djrs gq, desVh us iUæzg fnu esa fjiksVZ@mRrj izkIr dj desVh ds lEeq[k izLrqr djusds funsZ'k fn;s FksA ;g i= LFkkiuk 'kk[kk esa fnukad 2-08-2017 dks izkIr gqvkA dk;kZy; us viusi= ;knh Øekad MCF/E-3/2017/2039, fnukad 01-09-2017 ds vuqlkj ys[kk 'kk[kk ls fjiksVZ ekaxhAblds ckn LFkkiuk&'kk[kk dh vksj ls u rks dksbZ Lej.k i= Hkstk x;k vkSj u gh ys[kk ls fjiksVZizkIr djds gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky; dks Hkstus ds fy, dksbZ dk;Zokgh dh xbZA gfj;k.kkfo/kkulHkk dh mDr lfefr us fnukad 23-01-2018 dks gqbZ cSBd esa gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky;ds i= Øekad HVS/Petition/536-A/17-18/15841 fnukad 25-07-2017 ds vuqlkj ekaxh xbZ fjiksVZuxj fuxe ds }kjk u Hkstus ij ukjktxh trkbZ vkSj nks"kh vf/kdkjh dh vdkm.VfcfyVh fQDldj ,D'ku Vsdu fjiksVZ lfefr dks Hkstus ds vkns'k fn,A blds fy, Hkh fMfyax deZpkjh Jh vt;nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ Li"V :i ls ftEesnkj gSaA

vr% Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ dk mDrd`R; M;wVh ds izfr ?kksj ykijokgh ,oa xSj ftEesnkjh cjrus] vuq'kklughurk] drZO;ghurk] fu;eksadh mYy?kuk ,oa vuns[kh djus vkSj vius mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dks xqejkg djus dh ifjf/k esa vkrk gSAblds vfrfjDr bl deZpkjh ds mDr dR; ls bl ekeys esa gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk desVh ds lEeq[kfuxe dh Nfo Hkh /kwfey gqbZ gS ,oa mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa ds eku&lEeku dks Hkh Bsl igqaph gSA

Sd/

vk;qDruxj fuxe] Qjhnkckn

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION FARIDABAD

tSlk fd vkjksiksa ds fooj.k esa mYysf[kr gS] fd vk/kkj ij Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'knkl nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ ij fuEufyf[kr vkjksi LFkkfir fd;s tkrs gSa %&vkjksi %& 1- ;g fd mlus Loå Jh jru flag lqiq= Jh cuokjh] lQkbZ deZpkjh] dksM uå 4915

ftldk fnukad 29-10-2014 dks nsgkUr gks x;k Fkk] dh iRuh Jherh lUrjks nsoh dksHaryana Compassionate Assistanace to the Dependents of Deceased

Government Employees Rules, 2006 esa fd;s x;s izko/kku ds vuqlkj vuqxzgiwoZdfoRrh; lgk;rk ds bykok Gratuity, GPF, DCRG, Leave Encashment GIS omonthly financial assistance vkfn dk Hkqdrku bl vk/kkj ij uk djus ckjs vius

99

uksfVax esa izLrkfor fd;k fd lEcfU/kr deZpkjh us viuh e`R;q ls iwoZ dk;kZy; esaviuk medical fitness certificate tek ugha djok;k] tcfd QkbZy esa deZpkjh dsmedical examination report dh QksVksizfr Hkh miyC/k Fkh vkSj unsigned medical

fitness certificate dh QksVksizfr Hkh QkbZy esa miyC/k Fkh] tks fd deZpkjh dh iRuhJherh larjks nsoh us fnukad 01-04-2015 dks vius vkosnu i= ds lkFk dk;kZy;esa izLrqr dh FkhA ;fn Jh vt; nqvk us mDr mdedical examination report dkmYys[k uksfVax esa fd;k gksrk rks mppkf/kdkfj;ksa dks bl ij dksbZ fu.kZ; ysdjflfoy ltZu Qjhnkckn ls bl fjiksVZ ds vk/kkj ij medical fitness certificate

tkjh djok djds deZpkjh dh vkfJr iRuh dks Post death benefit dk Hkqdrkudj fn;k x;k gksrkA bl izdkj bl deZpkjh us fcuk fjdkMZ voyksfdr fd;s xyrrF; izLrqr djds uk dsoy e`rd deZpkjh ds vkfJrksa dk foŸkh; 'kks"k.k fd;kcfYd vius mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dks Hkh xqejkg fd;kA

2- ;g fd Jh vt; nqvk] ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ ds }kjk deZpkjh dh O;fDrxrQkbZy esa age determination lEcfU/kr LFkkiuk 'kk[kk ds }kjk gh tkjh fd;s x;si= ,eålhå,Qå@bZ&3@2015@1573 fnukad 25-05-2015 dh izfr dks u yxk,tkus ds dkj.k dk;kZy; us gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk dh COMMITTEE ON PETITION

dh fnukad 23-01-2018 dks cSBd esa fuxe dh vksj ls vfrfjDr vk;qDr us mRrjizLrqr fd;k fd deZpkjh us e`R;q ls iwoZ dk;kZy; esa medical fitness certificate

vkSj vk;q lEcfU/kr iz.kke i= izLrqr ugha fd;k ftlds vHkko esa deZpkjh dhvkfJr iRuh dks ;s ykHk vHkh rd ugha fn;s tk ldsA bl ij deZpkjh dh iRuhus LFkkiuk 'kk[kk ds }kjk gh tkjh fd;s x;s i= ,eålhå,Qå@bZ&3@2015@1573fnukad 25-05-2015 dh izfr lfefr ds lkeus izLrqr dj nh] ftlds ifj.kkeLo:ilfefr us xyr rF; izLrqr djus ij xgjh ukjktxh izdV dhA ;fn Jh vt;nqvk ds }kjk mDr i= QkbZy esa yxk fn;k tkrk rks fuxe ds mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dkslfefr ds lEeq[k 'kfeZanxh ugha mBkuh iM+rh] blds fy, Jh vt; nqvk Li"V :ils ftEesokj gaSA

3- gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky; us vius i= Øekad HVS/Petition/536-A/17-18/

15841 fnukad 25-07-2017 ds vuqlkj bl dk;kZy; dks lwfpr fd;k Fkk fd Jherhlarjks nsoh /keZiRuh Loå Jh jru flag ds }kjk nk;j dh xbZ ;kfpdk dks gfj;k.kkfo/kkulHkk dh COMMITTEE ON PETITION dh fnukad 13-06-2017 dks gqbZcSBd esa lfefr ds lEeq[k j[kk x;k] ftl ij fopkj djrs gq, desVh us iUnzgfnu esa fjiksVZ@mRrj izkIr dj desVh ds lEeq[k izLrqr djus ds funsZ'k fn;s FksA;g i= LFkkiuk 'kk[kk esa fnukad 02-08-2017 dks izkIr gqvkA dk;kZy; us vius i=;knh Øekad MCF/E-3/2017/2039, fnukad 01-09-2017 ds vuqlkj ys[kk 'kk[kk lsfjiksVZ ekaxhA blds ckn LFkkiuk 'kk[kk dh vksj ls u rks dksbZ Lej.k i= Hkstk x;kvkSj u gh ys[kk 'kk[kk ls fjiksVZ izkIr djds gfj;k.kk fo/kkulHkk lfpoky; dksHkstus ds fy, dksbZ dk;Zokgh dh xbZ] ftlds fy, fMfyax deZpkjh Jh vt; nqvk]ofj"B fyfid ¼vc fujh{kd½ Li"V :i ls ftEesokj gSaA

100

vr% Jh vt; nqvk lqiq= Jh x.ks'k nkl nqvk] ofj"V fyfid ¼vc fufj{kd½ dj mDrdR; M;wVh ds izfr ?kksj ykijokgh ,oa xSj ftEesnkjh cjrus] drZO;ghurk] fu;eksa dh mYya?kuk ,oalEcf/kr fjdkMZ dh vuns[kh djrs gq, xyr fjiksVZ o rF; izLrqr djus vkSj vius mPPkkf/kdkfj;ksadks xqejkg djus dh ifjf/k esa vkrk gSA blds vfrfjDr bl deZpkjh ds mDr d`R; ls bls ekeysesa gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk desVh ds lEeq[k fuxe dh Noh Hkh /kwfey gqbZ gS ,oa mPpkf/kdkfj;ksa dseku&lEeku dks Bsl igq¡ph gSA

Sd/

vk;qDruxj fuxe] Qjhnkckn

The Committee considered the same and feel that since the grivance of the petitioner

is resolved, accordingly petition is disposed of in its meeting held on 01.03.2018

56042—H.V.S.—H.G.P., Chd.