clicsgate - lokblok toy system versus clics analysis

58
1 (als intro) Het belang van ‘een detail’; het rode stiksel hier is ‘een knop aannaaien, maar zonder knop’. Wel, op deze manier zal je niet zo vlug uw portefeuille verliezen, en je maakt de Pick- Pocket zijn leven wat zuurder…

Upload: eric-parein

Post on 20-Jan-2015

104 views

Category:

Engineering


3 download

DESCRIPTION

The LOKBLOK one-block toy building system has lost most of its merrits to falsifications. The analysis follows here (in Dutch and English...)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

1

(als intro)

Het belang van ‘een detail’; het rode stiksel hier is ‘een knop aannaaien, maar zonder knop’.

Wel, op deze manier zal je niet zo vlug uw portefeuille verliezen, en je maakt de Pick-Pocket zijn leven wat zuurder…

Page 2: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

2

Door Eric Parein besproken op 30 november 2010 voor

de volle aula van de Academie van Antwerpen - ARTESIS

Page 3: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

3

AnalyseHet LOKBLOK

speelgoedelementversus

het CLICS element

Page 4: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

4

AUTEURSRECHTEn, wat zijn persoonlijkheidsrechten?

http://www.auteursrecht.nl/auteursrecht/pagina.asp?pagnaam=faq

Persoonlijkheidsrechten of morele rechten beschermen de band tussen de maker en zijn werk. De maker heeft bijvoorbeeld het recht zich te verzetten

tegen gebruik van zijn werk onder een andere naam dan de zijne, tegen een wijziging van het werk (tenzij verzet daartegen niet redelijk zou zijn) en tegen aantasting van zijn werk, die nadeel zou kunnen toebrengen aan zijn

eer, naam of waarde.

OKTROOIENOp naam van Eric Parein,

voor SPEELGOEDELEMENTwww.espacenet.com , enter:

‘Resilient hinge connection and CD holder box or photograph frame utilizing the same’

Page 5: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

5

Eerste octrooi: ‘SPEELGOEDELEMENT’ 1010833A6 dd. 2 februari 1997 op naam van Eric Parein

TM

Page 6: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

6

Then…the PLAYCUPSdebacle

• EP’s LOKBLOK-licensee came into trouble with his own product, due to related safety concerns. The ill-conceived spoons were life threatening.

• The Licensee responded very inadequately to it as a toy manufacturer, and finally was forced to a total market recall. But, he didn’t…

• Therefore, Eric terminated the LOKBLOK-license under the ‘grave shortcoming’ clause, Art.5.5 of the license.

• PLAYCUPS went bankrupt.

Page 7: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

7

Eric Parein donneerde uit voorzorg zijn LOKBLOK R&D aan het Speelgoedmuseum te Mechelen. Aanvaard door Conservator Marc Wellens (document onder).

Page 8: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

8LOKBLOK archived at the world renown toy museumSPEELGOEDMUSEUM, Mechelen - Belgium. Since 1998

Page 9: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

9

1. Robot LOKBLOK

Page 10: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

10

2. Huisje - LOKBLOK

Page 11: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

11

3. Jeep - LOKBLOK

Page 12: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

124. Tank - LOKBLOK

Page 13: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

13

5. PeriscoopLOKBLOK

Page 14: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

14

6. Tenniser - LOKBLOK

Page 15: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

157. 1-2-3-… LOKBLOK

Page 16: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

16

8. Koe (milkbar) - LOKBLOK

Page 17: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

17

9. Kubus - LOKBLOK

Page 18: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

18

10. Zetel - LOKBLOK

Page 19: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

19

Extra: LOKBLOK‘Lettering’

Page 20: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

20Extra LOKBLOK R&D

Page 21: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

21

LOKBLOK R&D 1998

Page 22: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

22

LOKBLOK R&D 1998

Page 23: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

23

LOKBLOK Technical Properties

Page 24: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

24

LOKBLOK Central Positioning

Page 25: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

25

LOKBLOK Accessories

Or as a container

Page 26: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

26

LOKBLOK Technical Performances, or

Utility for e.g. Characters

Page 27: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

27

LOKBLOK R&D 1998

The Sky is the Limit!

Page 28: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

28

LOKBLOK cardboard

Cheap but sound stuff

Page 29: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

29

LOKBLOK Central fortification option

Page 30: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

30

LOKBLOK Conduit option

Page 31: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

31

LOKBLOK ‘Ghetto Blaster’Indeed, the sky is the limit…

Page 32: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

32

www.clicstoys.com

Check following 11 modifications

Page 33: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

33

One /11 Four enlarged through cylinders To recuperate a tool from a previous fiasco molding axles (under red)

LOKBLOK CLICS

Page 34: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

34

The space underneath the cylinder is almost completely gone. Limiting the usefulness of the cylinder from the outside. Excluding the use of the LOKBLOK-tool (patent claim)

LOKBLOK CLICS

Page 35: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

35

Two /11 Four swivel connecting points

This great LOKBLOK feature is gone; gravely limiting its play value.Like a car with four flat tires…

Page 36: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

36

Hi ! Yes,I’m blue

‘I have become so useless…’

Page 37: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

37

LOKBLOK DOUBLE CONNECTOR

ITS POTENTIAL

Page 38: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

38This simple feature greatly determines Play Value. Imagine those guys without those ‘hands’…

Page 39: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

39This simple feature greatly determines Play Value. Imagine those guys also without those ‘hands’…

Page 40: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

40

LOKBLOK DOUBLE CONNECTOR

See?

Page 41: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

41

LOKBLOKCharacter,

employing all four

connectors

Page 42: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

42

Three /11 The LOKBLOK tool This good looking handy and useful LOKBLOK-tool is gone;

It cannot be inserted into a CLICS block…Like a car without… door keys?

Page 43: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

43

Four /11 cardboard

rotating insertsThese CLICS are printed, limiting its use and/or usefulness.

Page 44: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

44

Five /11 Foreign wheels They even cannot revolve… Left, CLICS are commercialized with wheels from another toy;

They display the brand PLAYCUPS! They are stuck against the green protrusions…

Right, the LOKBLOK approach with a more adequate solution…

Page 45: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

45

Six /11 From 0,75mm to only 0,25 sticker in-depth

The LOKBLOK -sticker cavity is of 0.75mm. CLICS reduced it to 0.3mm.

Page 46: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

46

Seven /11 The ‘cut out’ !Comparing the solidity of both basis is simple: Like the sugar cube with or without a fault line… try it out!

LOKBLOK basisNo fault line

CLICS ‘basis’With middle fault line

Page 47: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

47

CLICS lies on internet: ‘They're made of tough polypropylene, so they can be chewed, jumped on and bashed around as much as the kids like - and they're just as good as they were before!’

Picture from official subpoena.

Page 48: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

48

Eight /11 Now it is swallow able

Besides exposing a dangerous sharp broken edge.

Page 49: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

49

Nine /11 Severe finger biting hazard

No CE-norm compliance

Picture from official subpoena

Picture from CLICS website

Page 50: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

50

http://www.safekids.co.uk/ChildDoorFingerTrapping.html

Left: Not just trapping is possibly involved between two CLICS toy elements, also a severe biting and/or cutting hazard is always present.

Right: Even relatively minor finger injuries can lead to some lasting loss of movement. If the nail bed is cut, it needs sutures to prevent a permanently deformed fingernail.

From CLICS website. Look at the tiny fingers!

Page 51: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

51

No CE-norm compliance for CLICS

Hinges nor Sharp Corners have been taken in consideration. Yet the four sides of each block are part of a potential hinge!

Two of the four edges on a CLICS block now has each two biting teeth.

Page 52: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

52

Google: 611 references for LOKBLOK

Google: 10.400.000 (…) references for CLICS

Ten /11 The Brand

Page 53: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

53

ATV… Antwerp local television

• CLICS nevertheless becomes an international best seller.• One day, Eric is asked by a friend of his: ‘Aren’t you the inventor of

the CLICS?!’ Well, the local TV-station ATV was airing a 20 min. documentary, titled ‘Antwerp Success Story’ about these great CLICS, and how it came about…

• CLICS had become their find, their development. About the real inventor not a word, whilst living in the same city!

• I had to certify friends, colleagues, business relations I wasn’t a liar!• My copyrights, personality and father rights are badly damaged.• I want CLICS (BBM nv) to completely withdraw from the market, to

pay damages accordingly for my loss of credibility as a designer.• ATV has to acknowledge their mistake and bring the real story.

They agreed upon, but have not yet executed their promise.

Page 54: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

54

CLICS on FOX 2 in the USA on http://www.clicstoys.com/b2b/clics (withdrawn now...)

Tim (FOX 2 in Detroit Reporter):”Now tell me how these things came about. Because it's kind of

a weird story how they came to be.”

Judith De Bie (CEO CLICS - USA):”Well, they actually have been around 5 years and they started

out, they wanted to, it was a design for windows, frame windows and doors. And that didn't really work, but the guy

(…) really loved the clicking sound. So they bought the pattern (patent) and they wanted to find something that they could do with it, because it was neat and they liked the clicking sound.

So they came up with this toy.”

Page 55: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

55

Hedwig Van Roy

CEO CLICS

‘A new sort of building

blocks, he came about it

after three years of thinking’

(...)

Page 56: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

56

Eleven /11 Extra central hole!The fault line has been improved with a central hole…

to ensure the faulting?!

Page 57: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

57

De CE -markering, die geen keurmerk is,

geeft aan dat het product voldoet aan de daarvoor

geldende regels.

Maar.De voorgelegde CLICS -stalen aan Intertek (links)

hadden geen CE-markering noch merk in het blokje

staan. (A = Absent)

Wat is hier voorgelegd

geweest?

CLICS was toen al jaren op de markt MET merk en CE.

Page 58: ClicsGate - LOKBLOK toy system versus CLICS analysis

58

No, I did NOT inventCLICS

Yes, I DID inventLOKBLOK

Yours truly,Eric Parein