chris newton university hospital birmingham nhs foundation trust pbr for renal services trust...
TRANSCRIPT
Chris NewtonUniversity Hospital Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust
PbR for Renal Services
Trust Dialysis Reference Cost Comparisons Project – Workshop 2
Renal Clinical Directors Forum – 7th March 2008
Project Background
• RAG response to the DoH consultation on “The Future of Payment by Results”
• More robust costing data required for renal services – wide variation appears to exist
• Project group established to examine dialysis costs and their construction
Dialysis Project Summary
• 16 participant Trusts representing 41% of adult HD and 35% of adult PD nationally
• A standard cost template to identify cost components and categories for dialysis
• Based on 2006/07 Reference Costs (June 2007) using HRG Version 4 definitions
• Data based on second cut incorporating costing and activity adjustments from some Trusts
HRG Version 4 – Adult Dialysis
LC01A Haemodialysis/Filtration on patient with Hepatitis B 19 years and over
LC02A Haemodialysis/Filtration 19 years and over
LC03A Peritoneal Dialysis on patient with Hepatitis B 19 years and over
LC04A Peritoneal Dialysis 19 years and over
Project Issues
• Reconciliation with June 2007 Ref Cost data– Service labels – HD/PD with/without HepB– Activity data, particularly PD therapy days vs
exchanges
• Allocation of costs to service components– Limitations of costing models– Primary cost data collection– IS satellite costs
2006/07 All Haemodialysis: Adult - Average Unit Cost
104
210
153
0
50
100
150
200
250
1 2 11 7 6 14 3
Proje
ct Ave
rage 17 8 9 16 13 15 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Ref Cost
£24k per year therapy cost
Market Forces Factor by Trust
1
1.05
1.1
1.15
1.2
1.25
1.3
1.35
1.4
Trust
3
Trust
10
Trust
16
Trust
13
Trust
2
Trust
15
Trust
11
Trust
12
Trust
9
Trust
17
Trust
4
Trust
14
Trust
6
Trust
8
Trust
7
Trust
1
MF
F A
dju
stm
ent
Fac
tor
2006/07 All Haemodialysis: Adult - MFF Adjusted Average Unit Cost
130
97
178
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
2 11 3 1 7 6 14 16 9
Projec
t Ave
rage 17 13 15 8 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Total Adult HD by Cost Category
0
50
100
150
200
250
1 2 11 7 6 14 3 17 8 9 16 13 15 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
£
CC & OHs
Facilities
Non Clin
Clin Support
Non Pay
Staff
2006/07 Total Adult HD - Average Staff Costs per Dialysis
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
1 2 11 7 6 14 3 17 8 9 16 13 15 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
2006/07 Total Adult HD - Average Non Pay per Dialysis
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
1 2 11 7 6 14 3 17 8 9 16 13 15 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Total Adult HD - Capital Charges & Overheads per Dialysis
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
1 2 11 7 6 14 3 17 8 9 16 13 15 4 12 10
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Hospital Haemodialysis: Adult - Average Unit Cost
104
288
185
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
1 14 7 2 4 8 6 11
Projec
t Ave
rage 3 9 17 16 12 15 13 10
Un
it C
os
t £
2005/06 Ref Cost
2006/07 Ref Cost
£29k per year therapy cost
2006/07 Hospital Haemodialysis: Adult - MFF Adjusted Average Unit Cost
97
210
159
0
50
100
150
200
250
1 14 2 3 11 4 16 7
Projec
t Ave
rage 6 9 8 17 12 15 13 10
Un
it C
os
t £
2007/08 Indicative Tariff - £159
2006/07 Satellite Haemodialysis: Adult - Average Unit Cost
193
86
142
0
50
100
150
200
250
1 11 2 7 13
Projec
t Ave
rage 3 17 6 16 9 15 8 14 12 10 4
Un
it C
os
t £
2006/07 Ref Cost
2005/06 Ref Cost
£22k per year therapy cost
2006/07 Home Haemodialysis: Adult - Average Unit Cost
33
189
83
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
11 15 8 3 10 16 13
Projec
t Ave
rage 7 1 9 2 12 4 14 6 17
Un
it C
os
t £
2005/06 Ref Cost
2006/07 Ref Cost
£17k per year therapy cost
2006/07 Hospital HepB Haemodialysis - Average Unit Cost
210202
175
112
197
0
50
100
150
200
250
7 8 Project Average 17 10
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Ref Cost
2006/07 Satellite HepB Haemodialysis: Adult - Average Unit Cost
139
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
11
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Total PD: Adult - Average Unit Cost
36
104
57
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
10 16 11 8 17
Proje
ct Ave
rage 9 13 15 14 3 12 2 6 1 4 7
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Ref Cost
£21k per year therapy cost
2006/07 CAPD: Adult - Average Unit Cost
52
30
104
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
10 16 11 9 17 8
Proje
ct Ave
rage 15 14 3 12 2 1 6 7 13 4
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Ref Cost
2005/06 Ref Cost
£19k per year therapy cost
2006/07 APD: Adult - Average Unit Cost
104
36
60
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
10 16 4 8 11 13 17
Proje
ct Ave
rage 6 15 3 14 12 9 7 1 2
Un
it C
ost
£
2006/07 Ref Cost
2005/06 Ref Cost
£22k per year therapy cost
• Improving 2008 Reference Cost collection– Activity measures– Costing models– Tariff exclusions
• HRGV4 Tariff Structure– Hospital/Satellite/Home vs HepB/non-HepB?– PD with HepB?
• Links with other Renal tariff development
Issues for Consideration