child & adult care food program serious deficiency process & provider appeals

60
Child & Adult Care Child & Adult Care Food Program Food Program Serious Deficiency Serious Deficiency Process Process & Provider Appeals & Provider Appeals

Upload: don

Post on 25-Feb-2016

34 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals. Overview. Federal law (ARPA) mandated changes for providers Established serious deficiency process for providers Suspension for health or safety violations Provider appeals. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

Child & Adult Care Child & Adult Care Food ProgramFood Program

Serious Deficiency Serious Deficiency ProcessProcess& Provider Appeals& Provider Appeals

Page 2: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

2

OverviewOverviewFederal law (ARPA) mandated changes for providers

Established serious deficiency process for providers

Suspension for health or safety violations

Provider appeals

Page 3: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

3

Why do we need provider Why do we need provider appeal rights?appeal rights?• Problem of non-compliant providers

switching sponsors• Federal law requires USDA to

maintain a National Disqualified List of terminated providers

• Importance of protecting provider rights

Page 4: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

4

Termination for cause or for Termination for cause or for convenienceconvenience

• Violation of agreement = termination for cause

Initiated by the Sponsor

• Termination for convenience = non-performance issues

Initiated by the provider or the Sponsor

Page 5: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

5

A rose by any other nameA rose by any other name

• Fair hearing = administrative review = appeal

• Administrative review official = hearing official = hearing officer = appeal officer

Page 6: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

6

What can be appealed?What can be appealed?• Proposed termination for cause and

proposed disqualification

• Suspension for health or safety violations

Page 7: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

7

What cannot be appealed?What cannot be appealed?

Anything else

Page 8: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

8

WhenWhen is an action is an action appealable?appealable?

• Sponsor issues a Notice of Proposed Termination for Cause and Proposed Disqualification

• Sponsor issues a Suspension Notice

A provider may request an appeal when:

Page 9: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

9

How will providers know How will providers know about their appeal rights?about their appeal rights?• Language in the agreement between

the sponsor and the provider• Sponsor gives a copy of the appeal

procedures to the provider– Annually– When any appealable action is taken– Upon request

Page 10: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

10

Minimum appeal Minimum appeal proceduresprocedures• Uniformity

• Representation

• Review of record and opposition

• In-person hearing not required

Page 11: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

11

Minimum appeal Minimum appeal procedures (cont.)procedures (cont.)

• Basis for decision

• Timeframes for issuing a decision

• Final administrative decision

Page 12: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

12

Supplemental proceduresSupplemental procedures

• Must be consistent with minimum procedures

• Examples– Timeframe for appeal decision– Deadline for requesting an appeal– Deadline for submitting additional

written documentation

Page 13: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

13

Supplemental proceduresSupplemental procedures(cont.)(cont.)

• More examples – In-person hearing

– Additional appealable actions

• State agency approval required

Page 14: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

14

Ensuring complianceEnsuring compliance• State agency must ensure sponsors

properly implement provider appeal process

– Part of state agency review of sponsors

– Improper implementation of a provider appeal process = Seriously Deficient

Page 15: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

15

Serious deficienciesSerious deficiencies

• Submission of false information

• Submission of false claims

• Simultaneous participation under more than 1 sponsor

• Meal pattern non-compliance

Page 16: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

16

Serious deficienciesSerious deficiencies• Failure to keep required records

• Imminent threat to health or safety

• Conviction indicating lack of business integrity during the past 7 years

• Any other circumstance related to non-performance under agreement

Page 17: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

17

Convictions indicating a Convictions indicating a lack of business integritylack of business integrity

• Past 7 years 

• Criminal convictions only

Page 18: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

18

Sponsor discretionSponsor discretion • Distinguish between:

– Occasional errors and systemic errors

– Minor errors and major errors

• Improper use of termination for convenience = serious deficiency

Page 19: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

19

Error or serious deficiencyError or serious deficiencyFactors to consider:

– Frequency of the error– Severity of the error– Length of program experience– Literacy level or English proficiency

Provider must move to full compliance ASAP

Page 20: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

20

Serious Deficiency Serious Deficiency Process for ProvidersProcess for Providers

Page 21: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

21

Steps in the processSteps in the process• Serious deficiency determination

• Serious deficiency notice

• Opportunity for corrective action

• Proposed termination/disqualification

• Appeal

Page 22: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

22

Seriously Deficient noticeSeriously Deficient notice Notice must be in writing and contain

certain information: Fully describe the serious deficiency Specify the corrective action required

to resolve the serious deficiency & deadline

State that serious deficiency determination is not subject to appeal

Page 23: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

23

Seriously Deficient noticeSeriously Deficient notice Must state that failure to fully and

permanently correct the serious deficiency by the deadline will result in:

• proposed termination of the provider’s agreement for cause, and

• proposed disqualification of the provider.

Page 24: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

24

Seriously Deficient noticeSeriously Deficient notice • Must inform provider if she/he will

receive CACFP payments during the period of corrective action

• Must state that if the provider voluntarily terminates her/his agreement after receiving the notice, the sponsor will still proceed with the proposed disqualification.

Page 25: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

25

Seriously Deficient noticeSeriously Deficient notice Sponsor must

continue to pay valid claims

Page 26: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

26

Timeframes for corrective Timeframes for corrective actionaction

• Deficiency must be corrected within 30 days

• Ensure prompt resolution

• No provision that allows sponsors to give providers additional time

Page 27: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

27

Opportunity for corrective Opportunity for corrective actionaction

Yes, but …

No corrective action allowed before suspension for imminent threat to health or safety

Page 28: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

28

False or Fraudulent False or Fraudulent ClaimsClaims • No provision to suspend provider

participation

• Opportunity to correct

Page 29: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

29

False or Fraudulent False or Fraudulent Claims (con’t)Claims (con’t)

• Declare the provider seriously deficient

• Opportunity for corrective action

Page 30: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

30

False or Fraudulent False or Fraudulent Claims (con’t)Claims (con’t) Deny the claim/recover payment

– Never reimburse providers for invalid claims

– Do not reimburse for invalid portion of claim

Page 31: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

31

An Example of False or An Example of False or Fraudulent ClaimsFraudulent Claims

• Four enrollment forms, three children in care.

• Claiming 5-7 children for 3 months

• No explanation

• Provider is declared Seriously Deficient

• While corrective action and appeal occur, the invalid portion of the provider’s claims must not be paid.

Page 32: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

32

Verifying Corrective Verifying Corrective ActionAction• Unannounced

follow-up review recommended 

• Refer to Nebraska Management Standards: Provider Serious Deficiencies & Corresponding Corrective Action Plan

Page 33: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

33

What Happens Next?What Happens Next?• If serious deficiency is corrected

– Notify provider & state agency

• If serious deficiency is not corrected– Notice of Proposed

Termination/placement on National Disqualified List is sent to provider & state agency

Page 34: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

34

Notice of Notice of Proposed Proposed Termination/DisqualificationTermination/Disqualification

• Propose to terminate agreement for cause

• Propose to disqualify provider• Basis for actions = inadequate

corrective action

Page 35: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

35

Notice of Notice of Proposed Proposed Termination/DisqualificationTermination/Disqualification• Procedures for appeal • Status of program payments• Voluntary termination =

disqualification

Page 36: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

36

Status of Program PaymentsStatus of Program Payments• General rule: Program participation,

including Program payments, continues during the serious deficient process

• One exception– Suspended providers

• Sponsors must always deny invalid claims

Page 37: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

37

Provider decides to Provider decides to appealappeal• Provider must submit request for

administrative review/hearing within time frame specified by sponsor

• Provider & sponsor submit documentation to hearing official

• Hearing official reviews the record or sets date for in-person hearing

Page 38: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

38

The hearing officialThe hearing official

• Hearing official must be:– Independent– Impartial

• Hearing official may be:– An employee or board member of the

sponsor– A contractor (e.g. sponsor

association)

Page 39: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

39

Role of the hearing officialRole of the hearing official• Review the evidence, documentation

and testimony

• Remain objective

• Determine if the sponsor complied with regulatory procedures

• Issue a decision based on the facts, not opinion or feelings

Page 40: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

40

Review of record or Review of record or hearinghearing

• Review all evidence and testimony• Issue decision in writing

– Decision sent to provider and sponsor at same time

Page 41: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

41

No place to set policyNo place to set policy• The hearing official is being

asked:Has the program requirement been

properly applied?

NOT

Do you agree with the requirement?

Page 42: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

42

In-person hearingsIn-person hearings• Allow both sides to present

their case, introduce evidence, call witnesses

• Keep proceedings on track• Maintain decorum

Page 43: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

43

In-person hearingsIn-person hearings• Remain objective• Tape record proceedings, if

desired• Don’t issue your decision at

the hearing

Page 44: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

44

Resources for hearing Resources for hearing officersofficers• Federal

Regulations 7 CFR 226

• Copy of sponsor/provider agreement

• Copy of sponsor’s appeal procedures

Page 45: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

45

Resources for hearing Resources for hearing officersofficers

• Copy of sponsor’s manual or handbook for providers

• Copies of sponsor’s administrative memos or other communication to providers

Page 46: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

46

Termination of the Termination of the AgreementAgreement

• Provider fails to appeal

• Hearing official rules in favor of sponsor

Page 47: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

47

Removal fromRemoval fromthe National Disqualified the National Disqualified ListList

• Generally removed after 7 years

• Two exceptions:– If SD is permanently corrected,

removal before 7 years– If provider still owes a debt after 7

years, will remain on list until repaid

Page 48: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

48

Applying after Applying after DisqualificationDisqualification

• What if a provider is on National Disqualified List?

• Sponsor is not required to:– Offer provider an appeal– Assist provider with removal from

National Disqualified List

Page 49: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

49

How Long?How Long?

• Provider is placed on the National Disqualified List or on a state agency list prior to July 29, 2002, will remain for 7 years

• Must remain on the list until July 29, 2009; longer if a debt is still owed

Page 50: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

50

AAQQ&&

Page 51: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

51

Question?Question? What if the provider wins the appeal?

Page 52: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

52

AnswerAnswer• Notify provider/state agency• Remove the seriously deficient

determination

Page 53: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

53

Wouldn’t it be simpler to allow the home to terminate for convenience after serious deficiency is declared?

Question?Question?

Page 54: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

54

AnswerAnswerEasier, but the provider could participate with another sponsor

Page 55: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

55

Who is the action taken against when the provider is incorporated—the provider or the corporation?

Question?Question?

Page 56: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

56

AnswerAnswerBoth

Page 57: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

57

Can a sponsor permit more than 30 days for corrective action?

Question?Question?

Page 58: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

58

AnswerAnswer

NO

Page 59: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

59

QuestionsQuestions• Will homes be notified they are off the

National Disqualified List after 7 years? – No. This is not required.

Page 60: Child & Adult Care Food Program Serious Deficiency Process & Provider Appeals

60

And justice for all . . .And justice for all . . .

Thank you for your contributions to maintaining integrity in the Child and Adult Care Food Program.