chase bank time 45

8/12/2019 Chase Bank Time 45

1/23

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

EASTERN DISTRICT

JP MORGAN CHASE

v.Tanuja Murray, JD, MBAT!"#$y Pa#r%& Murray

'(( S Va))*y R"a+ Pa") PA -(F)!S#u+"/0C)"u+.%"!

A11*)an#*/

Ca/* N"2 '3(445-

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are

citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or

enforce any law which shall abridge the priileges or immunities of citizens of the United States!nor shall any State deprie any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law!

nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the eual protection of the laws.' Amendment XIV

NOTICE OF ERROR

6* r*%*n#)y 7)*+ an a11*a) 8#$ #$* Su1*r"r C"ur# n #$* !a##*r "7 JP MORGAN CHASE v MURRAY, n C$*/#*rC"un#y 8#$ Ju+9* Gr77#$.

6* ju/# n"#%*+ a7#*r 1)*a+n9/ 8* /*n# #" y"u ++ n"# /$"8 u1 "n #$* +"%&*# #$a# #$*r* / a !aj"r *rr"r.

6$a# / #$* *rr"r: T$* +"%&*# nu!;*r )/#*+ / '


2/23

T$an& y"u.

Da#*+ #$/ #$* 4#$ +ay "7 F*; '(@.

Tanuja Murray T!"#$y Murray

EXHIBIT

VARIOUS MOTIONS FILED FOR YOUR INFORMATION

_________________________________________________________

IN THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA

SUPERIOR COURT EASTERN DISTRICT

JP MORGAN CHASE )P!"nt"##$ )%& ) )

C!e N(& *+,-../0T!n12! M133!4 )T"m(t54 M133!4 )


3/23

CIVILDe#end!nt& )

)EMERGENCY MOTION

MOTION FOR EMERGENCY STAY INJUNCTION RELIEF

Unde3 Penn4%!n"! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e *.7*8!)$ ! 6(13t m!4 "1e ! 93e"m"n!34 (3 9e6"! "n21n6t"(n (n4!#te3 :3"tten n(t"6e !nd ! 5e!3"n; P!& R&C&P& *.7*8!)&

At5(1;5 te3m !nd Stee C"t4G3(19 %& G(=! On"ne D"3e6t$ In6&$ +--@ U&S& D"t& LEXIS @7*$ !t .,@ 8&D& P!& N(%& 7-$ +--@)& E!te3nD"t3"6t (# Penn4%!n"! L(6! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e /&*8;)&

De#end!nt 5!%e 5e3e=4 dem(nt3!ted t5e e?"ten6e (# PROOF OF FRAUD !nd PROOF CHASE SOLD THEIR

STANDING 8(:ne35"9) "n +--.$ ! :e ! ;3( d1e 93(6e #!"13e& T5ee !3e t:( 6(m9e"n; #!6t(3 :5"65:!33!nt 3e6(n"de3!t"(n (# ! t!4$ 3em(%! (3 ! TRO 1nde3 E!te3n D"t3"6t (# Penn4%!n"! L(6! R1e (# C"%"P3(6ed13e /&*8;)&

T5e4 !3e 8*) t5e 93een6e (# !dd"t"(n! #!6t :5"65 :e3e n(t !%!"!=e :5en t5e 6(13t #"3t 6(n"de3ed t5e TRO !nd8+) t( 93e%ent m!n"#et "n21t"6e&

ADDITIONAL FACTORS

J1d;e G3"##"t5 " t5e 21d;e #(3 m4 =3(t5e3' #(3e6(13e !nd 5e ente3ed ! 1mm!34 21d;ment :5"65 :! 3e6ent43e%e3ed =4 !99e!& T5e =!" St!nd"n; (# C5!e "n t5e"3 6!e ! :e&

St!nd"n; t( 1e " 63"t"6! t( t5e 93(9e3 #1n6t"(n"n; (# t5e 21d"6"! 4tem& It " ! t53e5(d "1e& I# t!nd"n; "

den"ed$ t5e 9!t5:!4 t( t5e 6(13t5(1e " =(6ed& T5e 9!"nt"## :5( 5! t!nd"n;$ 5(:e%e3$ m!4 63( t5e t53e5(d!nd ee 21d"6"! 3ed3e&Saratoga #ounty #hamber of #ommerce, $nc. %ataki, &'' N()d *'& *&)

+)''-, cert denied /' US &'&0 +)''-1.

T5e 9"3"t (# t!nd"n; !(: (n4 !;;3"e%ed 9e3(n t( =3"n; 1"t& St!nd"n; t( 1e dem!nd t5!t ! 9!"nt"## " n(t"n%(%ed "n ! ;en1"ne 6(nt3(%e34$ !nd ! "m9e 4(;"m t!e 1 #3(m t5e3e t( ! 213"d"6t"(n! d"m"! 8*) t5e6(13t 5!%e 213"d"6t"(n (n4 (%e3 6(nt3(%e3"e 8+) ! 9!"nt"## #(1nd t( !6 t!nd"n; " n(t "n%(%ed "n !6(nt3(%e34 !nd 7) t5e 6(13t t5e3e#(3e 5!%e n( 213"d"6t"(n (# t5e 6!e :5en 165 ! 9!"nt"## 9139(3t t( =3"n; "t&

I# 9!"nt"## !6 t!nd"n; t( 1e$ 9!"nt"## m!4 n(t 93(6eed "n t5e !6t"(n& St!3 % G(d=e3;$ +0/ AD+d +-7 *t De9t+--+)

In C!m9!";n % B!3=! 8+7 AD7d 7+/ +d De9t +--.)$ "nt316ted t5!t t( et!="5 ! 93"m! #!6"e 6!e "n !n !6t"(nt( #(3e6(e ! m(3t;!;e$ t5e 9!"nt"## m1t et!="5 t5e e?"ten6e (# t5e m(3t;!;e !nd t5e m(3t;!;e n(te$ (:ne35"9

(# t5e m(3t;!;e$ !nd t5e de#end!nt de#!1t "n 9!4ment& 2See 3itelson 4amaica 5states 6olding #orp.

$, /' A7d )*/ +&st 7ept )''0-! 6ousehold 8inance 9ealty #orp. of New (ork 3ynn, &:

A7d / +)d 7ept )''-! Sears ;ortgage #orp. (ahhobi, &: A7d /') +)d 7ept )''-!

rust Nat. Ass?n

>rustee =utti, &@ A7d /'* +)d 7ept )''-! 8irst Union ;ortgage #orp. 8ern, ):* A7)d

/:' +)d 7ept )'')-! illage =ank 3ild


4/23

A";nment (# m(3t;!;e !nd n(te !3e m!de =4 e"t5e3 :3"tten "nt31ment (3 t5e !";n(3 954"6!4 de"%e3"n; t5em(3t;!;e !nd n(te t( !";nee& N( 165 e%"den6e :! !tt!65ed t( 6(m9!"nt& T5e 65!"n (# t"te " :(e#141nn(:n&St!nd"n; t( 1e 3eK1"3e !n "nte3et "n t5e 6!"m !t "1e "n t5e !:1"t t5!t t5e !: :" 3e6(;n"e !

1##"6"ent 93ed"6!te #(3 dete3m"n"n; t5e "1e !t "t";!nt 3eK1et& #aprer Nussbaum 2@ A7d &0@, &*&

+)d 7e1.

REMANDING OR REMOVAL !nd OTHER ACTIONS

e 5!%e !99e! 9end"n; =e#(3e t5e S19e3"(3 C(13t (# PA$ !nd :e !3e #""n; "n t5" Fede3! 213"d"6t"(n ! !:1"t!;!"nt C5!e !nd P5e!n #(3 #3!1d$ RICO !nd 1134$ ! :e ! #""n; ! PRIVATE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT!;!"nt J!"me D"m(n$ CEO (# C5!e& T5e !6 (# d1e 93(6e$ t5e ne: e%"den6e :e 21t d"6(%e3ed 8! "t :!3e6ent4 #"ed :"t5(1t n(t"6e) !nd 9end"n; !6t"(n!99e! 63e!te ! "t1!t"(n :5e3e=4 5!%"n; ! !e 1nde3 1656(nd"t"(n :(1d #13t5e3 6(1d t5e t"te$ e%e3e4 "n213e 1 8:5"e n(t !##e6t"n; C5!e (ne "(t!) !nd !##"3m :5!t "!3e!d4 ! !365et49e (# m!n"#et "n21t"6e&

T5e 9139(e (# 165 ! 5e!3"n; :(1d =e t( !n!4e !nd d"e6t t5e 6133ent e%"den6e 93(##e3ed =4 C5!e 8n(ne) !ndt5e ne: "n#(3m!t"(n !nd 6(n#"3m t5e %e3!6"t4 (# (13 !e;!t"(n (# #3!1d !nd m"t!e !3e t5e 3((t 6!1!t"(n (# !m!tte3 t5!t ! t!4 :(1d "m94 3emed4 1nt" 93(9e3 d1e 93(6e 6!n =e !99"ed&

5ene%e3 !n !6t"(n " 3em(%ed #3(m t!te 6(13t t( ! d"t3"6t 6(13t$

M!? Se!#((d %& 1"nte3($ */@ F&7d @@0$ @// 87d C"3& *000)&

A 9!3t4 need (n4 5(: (ne (# t5e !=(%e ;3(1nd t( et!="5 t5!t 3em(%! (3 3e6(n"de3!t"(n " !993(93"!te& Id&C(mm:& e? 3e& C(t!$ +/+ A&+d !t 0-0&

OUR BURDEN OF PROOF HAS BEEN MET

e 5!%e et!="5ed t5e #(1nd!t"(n #(3 #!6t(3 3eK1"3ed t( =e ;3!nted ! TRO "n (13 #!%(3$ :e =e"e%e&

I# ! t3"! 6(13t "1e !n e? 9!3te


5/23

De#end!nt 3e9e6t#14 1=m"t t( t5e m(t H(n(3!=e C(13t t5" MOTION TO STAY SHERIFF SALE ! "t :!ente3ed "m93(9e34 ! 9e3 PA !:$ !nd ! t"me4 Pet"t"(n t( O9en :! 9!"d #(3 :"t5 !n An:e3 !tt!65ed !nd ! Ne:M!tte3 C(1nte36!"m 6(m9(nent ! :e$ =1t "t :! n(t ;3!nted n(3 den"ed =1t IGNORED =4 t5e 6(13t$ 21t ! !MOTION TO STRIQE :! ";n(3ed$ ! MOTION TO STAY SHERIFF SALE :! ";n(3ed$ ! MOTION FORRELIEF FROM ERRORS :! ";n(3ed$ !(n; :"t5 6e3t"#"ed m!"ed MEMORANDUM OF MISTAQES AND

ERRORS m!"ed t( t5e J1d;e$ P3(t5(n(t!34$ C(13t Adm"n"t3!t(3$ S5e3"##$ B(!3d (# JP M(3;!n C5!e !nd 6(1ne#(3 P!"nt"##& N( (ne d"d !n4t5"n;, e?6e9t t5e 6(1ne #(3 P!"nt"##, t5e4 ASQED FOR *-- m(3e m(ne4 !#te321d;ment$ !nd #"ed 8K1"et4$ ( K1"et4) ! 5(3t 6(%e3"n; 3e6(3d (# ! +--. !";nment n(t TO C5!e =1t FROMC5!e "n t5e EXACT AMOUNT (# 6(n"de3!t"(n t5!t Deed :! 6(n%e4ed t( 1 "n +-- !t t"me (# !e&

THIS COURT SHOULD ALLO MOTION FOR EMERGENCY INJUNCTIVE RELIEF$ A STAY OFSHERIFFS SALE !nd "# needed SCHEDULING OF AN EVIDENTIARY HEARING ON THE VALIDITY OFJUDGMENT AND REMEDY OF SHERIFFS SALE UNTIL THE ADJUDICATION AND DETERMINATION OFAPPEAL$ PETITION TO OPEN AND OUR FEDERAL ACTION AS PLAINTIFF BASED ON NE EVIDENCEOF FRAUD&

T5" In21n6t"%e Re"e# (n t5e =!" t5!t t5e de#e6t (# t5e 6(m9!"nt "n et!="5"n; t!nd"n; t( #(3e6(13e " !t t5e%e34 5e!3t (# :5!t " 1n6(nt"t1t"(n! ! "t "n#3"n;ement 19(n$ de";ned !nd "m9emented t( %"(!te 8*) t5e

6(nt"t1t"(n! 93(5"="t"(n (n "m9!"3ment (# t5e (=";!t"(n 8!nd 3";5t) (# 6(nt3!6t$ 8+) t5e 6(nt"t1t"(n!93(5"="t"(n (n "m9!"3ment (# t5e 3";5t t( 9et"t"(n #(3 3ed3e (# ;3"e%!n6e$ 87) t5e t!t1t(34 3";5t e613ed =4 +U&S&C& *0*$ *0+$ 3e!t"n; t( t5e !6K1""t"(n$ m!"nten!n6e$ 1e$ !nd en2(4ment (# 3e! !nd 9e3(n! 93(9e3t4$e9e6"!4 =4 !nd t53(1;5 eK1! !66e t( 6(13t$ 8) t5e 3";5t t( =e #3ee #3(m t5e et!="5ment (# !n4 t"te (#n(=""t4 (3 t5e 63e!t"(n =4 t!te !: (# !n4 6!e (# 6"t"en 5!%"n; 93"%"e;e !nd "mm1n"t"e 19e3"(3 t( !nd93e"d"n; !=(%e ! (t5e3 8165 ! B!n$ M(3t;!;e F(3e6(13e Se3%"6e3$ !nd t5e"3 Att(3ne4 1nde3 %!3"(1 93(6ed13! 93"%"e;e)

In St(ee %& Ame3"6!n H(me$ 7@+ Se& 7.-$ !nd *00 N&E& /0 8*07.)$ t5e 6(13t 31ed !nd dete3m"ned t5!t$


6/23

See Ne(n %& C(?$@@ N&M& 70/&T5" m(t"(n ee !t e!t (=t!"n ! t!4 !nd :e 65!en;e 213"d"6t"(n !nd m(t"(n (n ne: e%"den6e t( 5!%e t5"m!tte3 d"m"ed&

T5e 4e(: #3"n;e !3(1nd t5e 1neen 6(13t3((m :e :e3e den"ed !n4 5e!3"n; :"t5"n 5! t5e !dm"3!t4 6(13t #!;:5"65 6(n#e3 n(t 6(13t (# 6(mm(n !: (3 eK1"t4 213"d"6t"(n =1t (n4 !dm"3!t4 m!tte3$ " t5!t n(t 6(33e6t

B(t5 t5e N(te !nd M(3t;!;e " n(t 6(1nte3";ned$ ( 5(: :! "t e?e61ted$ 5(: " "t en#(36e!=e !nd :5e3e " t5e6(nt3!6t

5e3e " t5e 6(nt3!6t :5e3e"n I n(:"n;4 !nd :""n;4$ :"t5 #1 d"6(13e$ 6(nented (3 (t5e3:"e !;3eed t( =et3e!ted t5" :!4

I =e"e%e t3"! 6(13t !6 213"d"6t"(n& I :!nt t( ee t5e 199(ed 213"d"6t"(n t5!t :! d14 9!6ed "nt( e%"den6e&

JURISDICTION AND VENUE

e !%e3 9!"nt"## !nd !tt(3ne4 m"6(nd16t !nd #3!1d 6(m9(1nded =4 21d"6"! ne;";en6e !nd !=1e (# d"63et"(n$R((e3 Fedm!n 5(1d n(t =e !99"ed "n t5e 3e2e6t"(n (# t5" M(t"(n&

A !3t"61!ted =4 t5e Un"ted St!te S193eme C(13t "n G3een:((d %& Pe!6(6

Unde3 *7 8*)$ t5e %"nd"6!t"(n (# t5e de#end!nt' #ede3! 3";5t " e#t t( t5e t!te 6(13t e?6e9t "n t5e 3!3e"t1!t"(n :5e3e "t 6!n =e 6e!34 93ed"6ted =4 3e!(n (# t5e (9e3!t"(n (# ! 9e3%!"%e !nd e?9"6"t t!te (3 #ede3! !:t5!t t5(e 3";5t :" "ne%"t!=4 =e den"ed =4 t5e %e34 !6t (# =3"n;"n; t5e de#end!nt t( t3"! "n t5e t!te 6(13t&Ge(3;"! %& R!65e$ 7 U&S& !t /,/0+ St3!1de3 %& et V"3;"n"!$ *-- U&S& 7-7& 7 U&S& - !t +& @ S&Ct& *--!t **+&

de63"=e !nd m!nd!te ! FACTUAL !nd !n!4" (# t!te 6(13t !99"6!t"(n (# t!te8(3 Fede3!) !: ! ! M(t"(n #(3 Eme3;en64 In21n6t"%e Re"e# !nd Tem9(3!34 St!4 (# S5e3"## S!e&

T5e S193eme C(13t !(: 1 t( "n%(e t5e 3";5t t( 3em(%e 1nde3 + U&S&C& *78*) !nd :e 93(%"de3 5e3e"n :5!t" 3eK1"3ed =4 t5e #!"13e (# t5e t3"! 6(13t t( 5(d ! 5e!3"n;$ m!n!;e d"6(%e34$ end t5e"3 (3de3 t( t5e 3";5t !dd3e$e3%e 1 !t t5e 3";5t !dd3e$ 3e6(n6"e t5" 6!e :"t5 S5en"n' MOOT (3de3$ ";n(3e (13 Pet"t"(n t( O9en$ ";n(3et5e"3 #!1t4 de#!1t 21d;ment !nd #"n!4 ";n(3e t5e e%"den6e :e 93eent 5e3e"n ! t5e m("n; ;1n :5e3e=4t!nd"n; " PROVEN t( n(t "e :"t5"n t5e 3";5t (# C5!e :5( (d t5em "n +--. t( ! t31t m!n!;ed =4 "m"n;t(nT31t !nd (d ! d(en t"me t5e3e!#te3$ 6(m9"e "n t5e !;;3e;!te t5e ne6e!34 6(n61"%e 5(:"n; t5!t


7/23

*-7+@+$ 7, 8E&D& P!& De6& */$ +--)&

T5e #ede3!4 ;1!3!nteed$ m!nd!ted$ !nd e?93e4 e613ed 3";5t 19(n :5"65 C!& C"%& C(de +0+ et eK& "n#3"n;e$:5"65 #ede3! 3";5t 6!nn(t =e en#(36ed "n t5e PA C(13t$ !3e t5(e e?93e4 e613ed 8!nd 953!ed$ 5(:e%e3"33ee%!nt4$ "n te3m (# 3!6"! "nK1!"t4) !3e t5(e (1t"ned "n + U&S&C& *0*,*0+

8!) St!tement (# eK1! 3";5t

A 9e3(n :"t5"n t5e 213"d"6t"(n (# t5e Un"ted St!te 5! 5!%e t5e !me 3";5t "n e%e34 St!te !nd Te33"t(34 t( m!e!nd en#(36e 6(nt3!6t$ t( 1e$ =e 9!3t"e$ ;"%e e%"den6e$ !nd t( t5e #1 !nd eK1! =ene#"t (# ! !: !nd 93(6eed"n;#(3 t5e e613"t4 (# 9e3(n !nd 93(9e3t4 ! " en2(4ed =4 :5"te 6"t"en$ !nd 5! =e 1=2e6t t( "e 91n"5ment$9!"n$ 9en!t"e$ t!?e$ "6ene$ !nd e?!6t"(n (# e%e34 "nd$ !nd t( n( (t5e3&

8=) de#"ned

F(3 9139(e (# t5" e6t"(n$ t5e te3m "n61de t5e m!"n;$ 9e3#(3m!n6e$ m(d"#"6!t"(n$!nd te3m"n!t"(n (# 6(nt3!6t$ !nd t5e en2(4ment (# ! =ene#"t$ 93"%"e;e$ te3m$ !nd 6(nd"t"(n (# t5e 6(nt3!6t1!3e!t"(n5"9&

86) P3(te6t"(n !;!"nt "m9!"3ment

T5e 3";5t 93(te6ted =4 t5" e6t"(n !3e 93(te6ted !;!"nt "m9!"3ment =4 n(n;(%e3nment! d"63"m"n!t"(n !nd"m9!"3ment 1nde3 6((3 (# St!te&

T( 1t!"n 3em(%! (# t5ee 93(e61t"(n t( ! #ede3! 6(13t 19(n t5e !e;!t"(n (# t5e 9et"t"(n "n t5" 6!e :(1dt5e3e#(3e m!3 ! 6(m9ete de9!3t13e #3(m t5e te3m (# t5e 3em(%! t!t1te$ :5"65 !(: 3em(%! (n4 :5en ! 9e3(n" den"ed (3 6!nn(t en#(36e ! 9e6"#"ed #ede3! 3";5t "n t5e 6(13t (# t5e St!te$ !nd ! 6(m9ete de9!3t13e ! :e#3(m t5e #"nd"n; (# St3!1de3 %& et V"3;"n"!$ *-- U&S& 7-7$ t( Qent164 %& P(:e3$ +-* U&S& *&

T5(e 6!e ! t!nd #(3 !t e!t (ne =!"6 93(9("t"(n It " n(t en(1;5 t( 199(3t 3em(%! 1nde3 *7 8*) t(!e;e (3 5(: t5!t t5e de#end!nt' #ede3! eK1! 6"%" 3";5t 5!%e =een "e;!4 !nd 6(3319t4 den"ed =4 t!te

!dm"n"t3!t"%e (##"6"! "n !d%!n6e (# t3"!$ t5!t t5e 65!3;e !;!"nt t5e de#end!nt !3e #!e$ (3 t5!t t5e de#end!nt "1n!=e t( (=t!"n ! #!"3 t3"! "n ! 9!3t"61!3 t!te 6(13t& T5e m(t"%e (# t5e (##"6e3 =3"n;"n; t5e 65!3;e m!4 =e6(3319t$ =1t t5!t d(e n(t 5(: t5!t t5e t!te t3"! 6(13t :" #"nd t5e de#end!nt ;1"t4 "# 5e " "nn(6ent$ (3 t5!t "n !n4(t5e3 m!nne3 t5e de#end!nt :" =e den"ed (3 6!nn(t en#(36e "n t5e 6(13t (# t5e St!te !n4 3";5t 1nde3 ! #ede3! !:93(%"d"n; #(3 eK1! 6"%" 3";5t& 7 U&S& - !t +@,+ @ S&Ct& *-- !t **+$ *@ L&Ed&+d 0 !. 0.@,/&

FACTS

C5!e 5! #"ed t53ee !6t"(n !;!"nt 1 "n C5ete3 C(1nt4 #(3 !e;ed de#!1t$ d"m""n; t5e !t (ne t:( 4e!3 !;(de9"te ! 3e6ent 6(nt3!d"6t(34 31"n; =4 TO 21d;e "n C5ete3& J1d;e S5en"n 31ed "n Se9tem=e3 +-*+ t5!t !#""n; !nd 9e!d"n; 3e;!3d"n; t5" 6!1e (# !6t"(n !3e MOOT !#te3 +-*- !nd J1d;e G3"##"t5$ t5e 6133ent 21d;e$ :e!%e3 5! NO JURISDICTION& A 9e3 C5ete3 C(1nt4 (6! 31e$ 5(1d "m94 5!%e =een 3e%"%ed& B1t "t :! n(t$! "t 6(nt!"ned "n t5e 3e6(3d "n63"m"n!t"n; e%"den6e !;!"nt C5!e$ :5( !( #!"ed t( 3e#e3en6e "t (n t5e 6(%e3 9!;e

(# t5" !6t"(n& A#te3 (13 m!n4 93e"m"n!34 3e9(n"%e 9e!d"n; "n J1ne (# +-*+ e?9!"n"n; t5e 9!3!d(? !nd 5(:C5!e 5(1d =e et(99ed #(3 6!"m 93e61"(n ! :e ! 3e 21d"t6!$ t5e t3"! C(13t :!"ted 1nt" T5!n;"%"n; t(den4 (13 m(t"(n$ 4et m!"ed (3de3 t( t5e :3(n; !dd3e "n M!%e3n$ n(t P!("$ :5e3e e3%"6e :! !( :3(n;4e?e61ted t5e3e!#te3 8ee d(6et !nd e?5"="t)&A#te3 t5e "n"t"! #""n;$ C5!e #!"ed t( 3e94 (3 #"e !n4 9e!d"n; #(3 *-m(nt5& T5e4 d"d n(t m!n!;e t5e 6!e "n ;((d #!"t5 !nd 6(nd16t d"6(%e34 de9"te ! t3"! n(t"6e ent t( =(t5 (# 1&

And 4et t5e 93(t5(n(t!34 ente3ed de#!1t 21d;ment #(3 P!"nt"## (n */ :"t5(1t *) !n4 *- d!4 n(t"6e !tt!65ed !nd +)!"n; #(3 ne!34 ! m""(n d(!3 :"t5(1t ! 53ed (# 199(3t"n; d(61ment!t"(n& e$ 6(nt3!t$ #"ed 93!e6"9e #(3de#!1t 21d;ment ITH THE *- DAY NOTICE ATTACHED !nd 6!"med - !nd t!ted :e :(1d ! #(3 ! d!m!;e!ement 5e!3"n;& e FEDEXED t5" !t :ee !nd t5e 93(t5(n(t!34 ";n(3ed "t& T5e4 d(6eted (13 #ee #(3 t5e


8/23


9/23

"ne?9"6!=4 ";n(3ed 0- d!4 91 (d t"me4 #"ed 9et"t"(n t( (9en t5!t ne;e6t "n dete3m"n!t"(n 9!6ed 1 "n e3"(12e(9!3d4 t( (e (13 5(me "n e t5!n 7- d!4& A ! 3e1t$ :e !99e! 5e3e t( t5" C(13t #(3 3e"e#$ ! :e 5!%ee?5!1ted (:e3 6(13t 3emed"e !nd :"t5 Pet"t"(n !nd M(t"(n =e"n; ";n(3ed 8e%en t5(e :e 9!"d **0 #ee #(3)&

T5!t " =1t (ne (# m!n4 93(=em$ e33(3$ (m""(n !nd %"(!t"(n (# d1e 93(6e t5!t 6(m9e ! t!4 !nd6(nt"n1!n6e (# n(t (n4 t5e 65ed1ed 5e3"## !e (n *.*7$ =1t ! :5(e!e "nte3%ent"(n t( d"m" t5" =!ed

19(n ne: e%"den6e t5!t 93(%e t5e P!"nt"## C5!e 5! n(t t5e (:ne35"9 ;( t5e N(te n(3 t5e 3";5t t( t5e M(3t;!;e$!nd t5e3e#(3e :e !( 5!%e ne: e%"den6e 93(%"n; ! F3!1d U9(n T5e C(13t$ !nd =4 t5e ent34 (# ! de#!1t 21d;ment:"t5(1t t5e 3eK1""te !tt!65ment (# ! *- d!4 n(t"6e t5!t :! 5(net4 1n!tt!65ed ! "t :! ne%e3 m!"ed t( 1 8ee t5e3e6(3d #(3 &*/&*7 9e!d"n;) 4et t5e 93(t5(n(t!34 ";ned !nd #"e ! eK1"t!=e 3e"e# de#!1t 21d;ment (# ne!34 !m""(n d(!3 :5"65 " 93(5"="ted =4 !: ! (n4 ! C(13t m!4 d( (&

H(:e%e3$ "n ! 6!"6 e?!m9e (# ! 93( e d"63"m"n!t"(n t5!t !m(1nt t( ne;";en6e !nd !=1e (# 93(6e =4 t5eC(1nt4$ t5e P3(t5(n(t!34 3e2e6ted (13 93!e6"9e #(3 de#!1t 21d;ment #(3 1n!n:e3ed 6(1nte36!"m #"ed :"t5 !n:e3!nd ne: m!tte3 !(n; :"t5 t5e t"me4 #"ed Pet"t"(n t( O9en (n &+&*7&

PARTIES

A (ne (# 1 " ! #(3me3 !tt(3ne4 :"t5 !n MBA :5( 93!6t"6ed "n t:( t!te ! :e ! :"t5"n t5e Fede3! 213"d"6t"(n$

:e !3e 5(6ed !nd !99!ed t5!t 21t"6e 5! 6(me t( t5" 9!t5et"6 9("nt "n (13 5"t(34 :5e3e ! 6(3319t !nd 1n21t#"n!n6"! 4tem 5! e"t5e3 me3;ed$ e?t(3ted$ =3"=ed (3 6(1ded :"t5 !n "nd"##e3ent (%e3:5emed !nd !9!t5et"6 e;!4tem t5!t en2(4 "mm1n"t4 #3(m "!=""t4 "n ! m!et3(m 63e!t"n; ! 9e3#e6t t(3m :5e3e=4 #!m""e (e t5e"3 5(me:"t5(1t d1e 93(6e :"t5"n 7- d!4 "n (me 6!e&

T5" " 6"%" 6!9"t! 91n"5ment !nd t5e Ame3"6!n 5(1"n; 5((6(1t&

STANDARD FOR REVIE

In Penn4%!n"!$ t5e t!nd!3d #(3 ;3!nt"n; ! 1nde3 Penn4%!n"! !:& V";"!nte$ +--0 U&S& D"t& LEXIS *+7+$ !t *-Stee C"t4 G3(19$ +--@ U&S& D"t& LEXIS @7*$ !t .,@&

Penn4%!n"! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e *.7*8!)$ :5"65 et #(3t5 t5e 93(6ed13e ;(%e3n"n; 93e"m"n!34 !nd m!4 =e ;3!nted "n t5e !=en6e (# ! 5e!3"n;$ =1t (n419(n ! dem(nt3!t"(n =4 t5e m(%"n; 9!3t4 t5!t


10/23

*& Penn4%!n"! C(13t :e";5 :5et5e3 8*) !n "n21n6t"(n " ne6e!34 t( 93e%ent "mmed"!te !nd "33e9!3!=e 5!3m8+) ;3e!te3 "n2134 :(1d 3e1t #3(m 3e#1"n; !n "n21n6t"(n t5!n #3(m ;3!nt"n; "t 87) !n "n21n6t"(n :(1d 93(9e343et(3e t5e 9!3t"e t( t5e"3 t!t1 "mmed"!te4 93"(3 t( t5e !e;ed :3(n;#1 6(nd16t 8) t5e m(%!nt " "e4 t(93e%!" (n t5e me3"t (# t5e !6t"(n 8.) t5e 3eK1eted "n21n6t"(n " 3e!(n!=4 1"ted t( !=!te t5e (##end"n; !6t"%"t4!nd 8@) !n "n21n6t"(n :(1d !d%e3e4 !##e6t t5e 91="6 "nte3et& V";"!nte$ +--0 U&S& D"t& LEXIS *+7+$ !t 0,*-ee !( S1mm"t T(:n Cent3e$ In6& %& S5(e S5(: (# R(64 M(1nt$ In6&$ + A&+d 00.$ *--* 8P!& +--7)& B(t5 9!3t"e

5!%e !e3ted t5!t "33e9!3!=e 5!3m :" 3e1t #3(m t5e C(13t 31"n; (n t5e TRO$ :5"65e%e3 :!4 t5e C(13t 31e&

T5e3e#(3e$ t5e !99"6!t"(n (# t5e #"3t #!6t(3 " K1"te !99"6!=e 5e3e, t5e4 8=";;et =!n "n Ame3"6!) "te3!4 (en(t5"n; =4 :!"t"n; #(3 3e%"e:!99"6!t"(n (# d1e 93(6e$ !nd :e$ "# :e :e3e t( "n #!6t (e (13 5(me$ :(1d =e9e3m!nent4 6!33ed !nd #!6e 5(meene$ d"%(36e !nd end!n;e3 (13 t:( 65"d3en&

+& T5e e6(nd #!6t(3 :5"65 m1t =e 6(n"de3ed =4 t5e C(13t " :5et5e3 ;3e!te3 "n2134 :(1d 3e1t #3(m 3e#1"n; !n"n21n6t"(n t5!n #3(m ;3!nt"n; "t& V";"!nte$ +--0 U&S& D"t& LEXIS *+7+$ !t 0&

On t5e #!6t1! 3e6(3d 5e3e$ "t 6!nn(t =e dete3m"ned "# ;3e!te3 "n2134 :(1d 3e1t #3(m d"(%"n; t5e TRO$ (3!(:"n; "t t( 3em!"n "n 9!6e& B(t5 9!3t"e 6(ntend t5!t t5e "1!n6e (3 t5e !=en6e (# t5e TRO :(1d d3!m!t"6!4en5!n6e (3 det3(4 t5e"3 #"n!n6"! 9(t13e& Be6!1e P!"nt"##$ ! t5e m(%"n; 9!3t4$ 5! t5e =13den t( 93(%e t5!t;3e!te3 5!3m :(1d 3e1t #3(m d"(%"n; t5e "n21n6t"(n$ !nd "t d(e n(t d( ($ t5" #!6t(3 :e";5 "n #!%(3 (#d"(1t"(n&

Unde3 Penn4%!n"! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e *.7*8!)$ P!& R&C&P& *.7*8!)& Unde3 t5" R1e


11/23

!t =e5et (# C5!e&

T5e (e =!" (# d!m!;e #(3 e?!m9e :! 91ed (1t (# t5"n !"3$ "te3!4, :"t5(1t !n4 !66(1nt"n;& T5e4 :e3e"e;!4 !eed =4 PHELAN n(t t5e C(13t =4 ! 5e!3"n; !nd !3e =!ed 19(n t5e %!1e (# !n !993!"!& T5" eement" e4, n(t (n4 " 21d;ment "m93(9e3$ =1t ! P3(t5(n(t!34 6!nn(t ";n (## (n eK1"t!=e 3e"e#&

T51$ t5e "n!6613!te$ 1n!66(1nted #(3 !nd (1t3!;e(1 !e;!t"(n 6(nt!"ned "n P!"nt"## 9e!d"n;& N( d(61ment (3(t5e3 e%"den6e :! 93(%"ded& "t5(1t ! 5e!3"n; n( d!m!;e 6!n =e ;3!nted =4 :3"t !nd !e&

T5e de#!1t 21d;ment !nd t5e n(t"6e (# 5e3"## !e :! ;3!nted :"t5(1t 1##"6"ent n(t"6e t( De#end!nt 8e3%ed t( !d"!=ed m!n) !nd :"t5(1t ! 93(9e3 5e!3"n; 8de9"te (13 dem!nd)&

.& "t5 3e9e6t t( t5e #"#t5 #!6t(3$ :e 6e!34 e?9!"n 5e3e"n :5!t (##end"n; !6t"%"t4 need t( =e !=!ted& 1!d e3!tdem(nt3!t1m, t5e 1m (# t5e !dded :e";5t (# t5e #"%e #!6t(3 6(m9e t5!t t5e TRO =e ;3!nted$ (3 !t e!t t5e !et!4ed$ !nd ( t5e C(13t need n(t dete3m"ne :5et5e3 ! "?t5 #!6t(3 :(1d !994 5e3e& IF DENIED E FACEINJURY OR FORCED FILING OF BANQRUPTCY TO OBTAIN A STAY&

CONCLUSION

FOR THE RECORD$ :e 5e3e=4 3e,#"e t5e n1me3(1 m(t"(n :e FILED IN MAY :5"65 t5e 93(t5(n(t!34$ :eJUST DISCOVERED$ d"d NOT FILE ! t5e4 !e3ted "n d(6et t5!t t5e4 :e3e UNSIGNED :5"65 :e d( n(t t5"n" t31e, =1t e%en "# "t :!, :e 5(1d 5!%e =een !##(3ded t5e 65!n6e t( !mend t5em (3 t5e n(t"#"6!t"(n (# t5e93(=em, "nte!d :e :e3e 21t ";n(3ed$ !;!"n&

T5e PREJUDICE " 3e! "n t5" 6(1nt4 93(t5(n(t!34' (##"6e ! t5e4 SIGN JUDGMENTS #3(m !tt(3ne4 !nd =";=!n :"t5(1t ne6e!34 n(t"6e !nd 199(3t"n; !ement e%"den6e$ !nd t5en ";n(3e, "te3!4 d( n(t e%en n(te t5eFedE? "n t5e d(6et, #(3 93( e #"e3&

T5e 3";5t en53"ned =4 U&S& T"te + U&S&C& *0*,*0+ :(1d !99e!3 t( =e (e4 e6(n(m"6 3";5t$ =1t t5e4 d(n(t me3e4 "m9ement t5e 6(nt"t1t"(n! 93(%""(n 93(te6t"n; t5e (=";!t"(n !nd 3";5t (# 6(nt3!6t #3(m !n4"m9!"3ment =4 t5e t!te (3 #ede3! ;(%e3nment& T"te + U&S&C& *0*,*0+ !( e##e6t1!te t5e m(3e m1nd!ne$93!6t"6!$ =1t 193eme4 "m9(3t!nt !9e6t !nd eement (# t5e F"3t Amendment R";5t t( Pet"t"(n #(3 Red3e (#G3"e%!n6e$ "n t5e 93(te6t (# 6(nt3!6t1! 3";5t t( !6K1"3e$ ee9$ 1e$ !nd en2(4 93"%!te 93(9e3t4&

e #"e t5" :"t5"n d!4 (# ("n; (13 5(me, !nd :"t5"n ! #(3tn";5t (# t5e ent34 (# ! 93e"m"n!34 "n21n6t"(n !;!"nt#(3e6(13e =4 (ne (# t5e n!t"(n 8!nd :(3d) !3;et =!n "n t5e USA&

S1=m"tted =4

_________________________________ _______________________________________________________

TANUJA SINGH MURRAY$ J&D&$ MBA TIMOTHY PATRICQ MURRAYPRO SE DEFENDANTS

DATE


12/23

IN THE UNITED STATES FEDERAL COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

THIRD CIRCUIT COURT

CHASE%& C!e *+,-../0M133!4 C5ete3 G3"##"t5

MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM JUDGMENT

T5e C5ete3 C(1nt4 93(t5(n(t!34 ente3ed de#!1t 21d;ment #(3 P!"nt"## (n */ :"t5(1t !) !n4 *- d!4 n(t"6e!tt!65ed !nd =- !"n; #(3 ne!34 ! m""(n d(!3 :"t5(1t ( m165 ! ! 53ed (# 199(3t"n; d(61ment!t"(n&

e$ 6(nt3!t$ #"ed (13 93!e6"9e #(3 de#!1t 21d;ment ITH THE *- DAY NOTICE ATTACHED !nd 6!"med - !:e t!ted :e :(1d ! #(3 ! d!m!;e !ement 5e!3"n;&

e FEDEXED t5" !t :ee !nd t5e 93(t5(n(t!34 ";n(3ed "t&

T5e4 d(6eted (13 #ee #(3 t5e !99e! 5(:e%e3&

L!t4$ FOR THE RECORD$ :e 5e3e=4 3e,#"e t5e n1me3(1 m(t"(n :e FILED IN MAY :5"65 t5e 93(t5(n(t!34$:e JUST DISCOVERED$ d"d NOT FILE ! t5e4 !e3ted "n d(6et t5!t t5e4 :e3e UNSIGNED :5"65 :e d( n(tt5"n " t31e, =1t e%en "# "t :!, :e 5(1d 5!%e =een !##(3ded t5e 65!n6e t( !mend t5em (3 t5e n(t"#"6!t"(n (# t5e93(=em, "nte!d :e :e3e 21t ";n(3ed$ !;!"n&

T5e PREJUDICE " 3e! "n t5" 6(1nt4 93(t5(n(t!34' (##"6e ! t5e4 SIGN JUDGMENTS #3(m !tt(3ne4 !nd =";=!n :"t5(1t ne6e!34 n(t"6e !nd 199(3t"n; !ement e%"den6e$ !nd t5en ";n(3e, "te3!4 d( n(t e%en n(te t5eFedE? "n t5e d(6et, #(3 93( e #"e3&

e$ I 5!%e ! JD 21t "e t5e 21d;e$ !nd !n MBA !nd !n en;"nee3"n; de;3ee, !nd m4 t!? d(!3 9!4 ALL OFYOUR SALARIES, ( t( t5e e?tent t5!t :e !3e !(:ed =4 !:$ :e "ntend t( =3"n; 1"t !;!"nt t5" 6(1nt4 #(33e9e!ted %"(!t"(n (# (13 3";5t$ n(t "m"ted t( d"63"m"n!t"(n !nd eK1! 93(te6t"(n %"(!t"(n$ ne;";en6e !nd !=1e(# 93(6ed"63et"(n&

EMERGENCY PRAYER FOR RELIEF

e 93!4 t5" C(13t$ =4 (3de3 (# ! t!4 (# 5e3"## !e (3 =4 (9en"n;t3""n; 21d;ment (# &*/&*7$ 93e%ent t5!t !e#3(m t!"n; 9!6e !nd "mmed"!te4 gra nt a stay pending appeal. Ate3n!t"%e4$ :e ! #(3 t5e C(13t t( compel adetermination of or Petition to Open !y "rial Cort#(3 ! 21d;ment t5!t :! "n5e3ent4 de#e6t"%e "n #(3m !nde3%"6e$ !nd !n6t"(n C5!e #(3 #3!1d& e !3e t3!%e"n; #(3 :(3 =1t !3e !%!"!=e #(3 tee95(n"6 5e!3"n; "# "t " (


13/23

de"3ed& A($ :e :" 9!4 !n4 #ee 3eK1"3ed 19(n t5e #""n; (# t5" M(t"(n, :e !3e 1n!=e t( dete3m"ne #ee ! t5e3e "n( !99e! d(6et 4et&

HEREFORE$ De#end!nt !$ m(%e$ !nd 3eK1et t5!t t5" C(13t t!4 !e$ "1e ! TRO$ 3em(%e "1e t( #ede3!6(13t$ 3em!nd t( t3"! :"t5 ! ne: 21d;e (3 d"m" ! 9e3 ne: e%"den6e&

S1=m"tted =4

_________________________________ _______________________________________________________

TANUJA SINGH MURRAY$ J&D&$ MBA TIMOTHY PATRICQ MURRAYPRO SE DEFENDANTS

DATE

FEDERAL RELIEF MOTION

De#end!nt 5e3e=4 3e9e6t#14 m(%e t5e 6(13t #(3 t5e ent34 (# !n O3de3 T( D"m" t5e C(m9!"nt (n t5e #((:"n;;3(1nd

*& T5e C(m9!"nt " ! 6"%" !6t"(n "n 3em$ ee"n; 3emed4 #(3 !n !e;ed de#!1t (n 3e9!4ment (n ! 93(m"(34 n(te&De#end!nt !e3t t5!t 165 !n !6t"(n 6!n !nd 5(1d (n4 =e 9e3m"tted =4 t5e 6(13t t( =e #"ed !nd 93(6eed :"t5me3"t =!ed (n ! 166e#1 "n 9e3(n!m 21d;ment #(3 =3e!65 (# 6(nt3!6t$ t51 et!="5"n; t5e 3";5t (# 3emed4(1;5t "n t5e #(3e6(13e !6t"(n t5!t "$ 3e9(e"(n (# t5e 1nde34"n; 6(!te3!& B4 n(t d("n; ($ t5e P!"nt"## " "ne##e6t 93e1m"n; de#!1t !nd$ "n een6e$ ee"n;


14/23

7-.$ *@ P& +-7 8*0*) !nd M""en %& Me4e3$ 7** U&S& ./$ @* S&Ct& 770$ . L&Ed& +d +/ 8*0-)&

A %("d 21d;ment :5"65 "n61de 21d;ment ente3ed =4 ! 6(13t :5"65 !6 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 t5e 9!3t"e (3 t5e 1=2e6tm!tte3$ (3 !6 "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t( ente3 t5e 9!3t"61!3 21d;ment$ (3 !n (3de3 93(613ed =4 #3!1d$ 6!n =e !tt!6ed !t!n4 t"me$ "n !n4 6(13t$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (3 6(!te3!4$ 93(%"ded t5!t 9!3t4 " 93(9e34 =e#(3e t5e 6(13t$ L(n; %&S5(3e=!n De%e(9ment C(39&$ *+ F&7d . 8 C&A& / I& *000)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 #3(m t5e =e;"nn"n; :! 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t !n4 e;! e##e6t$ H(== %& U&S&O##"6e (# Pe3(nne M!n!;ement$ . F&S199& .@ 8M&D& F!& *0-)& V("d 21d;ment " (ne t5!t$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n$" 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t$ H(te"n %& C"t4 (# C5"6!;($ -7 F&S199& +-.$ 3e6(n"de3!t"(n den"ed*0 F&R&D& */$ !##"3med +0 F&7d **. 8N&D& I *00+)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne :5e3e 6(13t !6ed 9e3(n! (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n (3 ent34 (# (3de3 %"(!ted d1e93(6e$ U&S&C&A& C(nt& Amend& . T3"!d Ene3;4 C(39& %& M6Ne **- F&R&D& 7+ 8S&D&N&Y& *0@)&

J1d;ment " ! %("d 21d;ment "# 6(13t t5!t 3ende3ed 21d;ment !6ed 213"d"6t"(n (# t5e 1=2e6t m!tte3$ (3 (# t5e9!3t"e$ (3 !6ted "n ! m!nne3 "n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e 93(6e$ Fed& R1e C"%& P3(6&$ R1e @-8=)8)$ + U&S&C&A&U&S&C&A& C(nt& Amend& . Q1;5 %& U&S&$ @+- F&S199& 0+ 8D&S&C& *0.)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n$ :!$ :! ! 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t$ R1="n %&J(5n$ *-0 F&R&D& */ 8D& V"3;"n I!nd *0.)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n$ :! ! 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t$ L1==en %&See%t"%e Se3%"6e S4tem L(6! Bd& N(& +/$ .7 F&+d @.$ * A&L&R& Fed& +0 8C&A& * M!& *0/+)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n$ " !nd #(3e%e3 6(nt"n1e t( =e !=(1te4 n1$ :"t5(1t e;!e##"6!64$ "ne##e6t1! t( ="nd t5e 9!3t"e (3 t( 199(3t ! 3";5t$ (# n( e;! #(36e !nd e##e6t :5!te%e3$ !nd "n6!9!=e (#en#(36ement "n !n4 m!nne3 (3 t( !n4 de;3ee L(4d %& D"3e6t(3$ De9t& (# P1="6 S!#et4$ - S(& +d .// 8A!& C"%&A99& *0.)&

A 21d;ment 5(:n =4 e%"den6e t( =e "n%!"d #(3 :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n " ! %("d 21d;ment (3 !t ! e%ent 5! !

!tt3"=1te (# ! %("d 21d;ment$ C"t4 (# L( An;ee %& M(3;!n$ +7 P&+d 7*0 8C!&A99& + D"t& *0.*)& V("d 21d;ment:5"65 " 1=2e6t t( 6(!te3! !tt!6$ " "m1!ted 21d;ment de%("d (# !n4 9(ten64 =e6!1e (# 213"d"6t"(n! de#e6t$!3d %& Te33"e3e$ 7@ P&+d 7.+ 8C((& *0@7)&

A %("d 21d;ment " ! "m1!ted 21d;ment de%("d (# !n4 9(ten64 =e6!1e (# 213"d"6t"(n! de#e6t (n4$ "n t5e 6(13t3ende3"n; "t !nd de#e6t (# 213"d"6t"(n m!4 3e!te t( ! 9!3t4 (3 9!3t"e$ t5e 1=2e6t m!tte3$ t5e 6!1e (# !6t"(n$ t5eK1et"(n t( =e dete3m"ned$ (3 3e"e# t( =e ;3!nted$ D!%"d(n C5e%3(et$ In6& %& C"t4 !nd C(1nt4 (# Den%e3$ 77- P&+d***@$ 6e3t"(3!3" den"ed /0 S&Ct& @-0$ 7.0 U&S& 0+@$ 7 L&Ed& +d @+0 8C((& *0.)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne ente3ed =4 6(13t :"t5(1t 213"d"6t"(n (# 9!3t"e (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 t5!t !6 "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t(m!e (3 ente3 9!3t"61!3 (3de3 "n%(%ed !nd 165 ! 21d;ment m!4 =e !tt!6ed !t !n4 t"me$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (36(!te3!4$ Pe(9e %& !de$ .-@ N&&+d 0. 8I& *0/)& V("d 21d;ment m!4 =e de#"ned ! (ne "n :5"65 3ende3"n;6(13t !6ed 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n$ !6ed 9e3(n! 213"d"6t"(n (3 !6ted "n m!nne3 "n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e

93(6e (# !: E6e %& M!6Ne!$ @+ N&E& +d /* 8I& A99& D"t& *007)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne ente3ed =4 6(13t :"t5(1t 213"d"6t"(n (# 9!3t"e (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 t5!t !6 "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t(m!e (3 ente3 9!3t"61!3 (3de3 "n%(%ed 165 21d;ment m!4 =e !tt!6ed !t !n4 t"me$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (3 6(!te3!4

Pe(9e %& S!e$ ..* N&E&+d *7.0 8I&A99& + D"t& *00-)& Re 21d"6!t! 6(neK1en6e :" n(t =e !99"ed t( ! %("d21d;ment :5"65 " (ne :5"65$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n$ " ! 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t$ A6(6 %& A6(67/ N&E& +d 70+ 8I& A99& 7 D"t& *0+)&V("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65$ #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n " 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t In 3e M!33"!;e (# P!3$


15/23

@7- N&E& +d .-0 8I&A99& . D"t& *00)& V("d 21d;ment " (ne ente3ed =4 6(13t t5!t !6 t5e "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t(m!e (3 ente3 t5e 9!3t"61!3 (3de3 "n%(%ed$ !nd "t m!4 =e !tt!6ed !t !n4 t"me$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (3 6(!te3!4 165 !

21d;ment :(1d =e ! n1"t4 Pe(9e %& R(!nd .* N&E&+d 0-/$ 8I&A99& D"t& *00*)&

V("d 21d;ment 1nde3 #ede3! !: " (ne "n :5"65 3ende3"n; 6(13t !6ed 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 d"91te (3213"d"6t"(n (%e3 9!3t"e$ (3 !6ted "n m!nne3 "n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e 93(6e (# !: (3 (t5e3:"e !6ted

1n6(nt"t1t"(n!4 "n ente3"n; 21d;ment$ U&S&C&A& C(nt& Amed& .$ H!4 %& L(1""!n! D(6 C(&$ .+ n&e&+D *778I& A99& . D"t& *07)&

A %("d 21d;ment 5! n( e##e6t :5!t(e%e3 !nd " "n6!9!=e (# 6(n#"3m!t"(n (3 3!t"#"6!t"(n$ L16! %& Et!te (# St!%($@-0 N& E& +d ***$ 3e5e!3"n; den"ed$ !nd t3!n#e3 den"ed 8Ind& A99& * d"t& *007)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne t5!t #3(m "t "n6e9t"(n " ! 6(m9ete n1"t4 !nd :"t5(1t e;! e##e6t St"d5!m V& 5e65e$ @0N&E&+d **.+ 8Ind& *00)&

Re"e# #(3m %("d 21d;ment " !%!"!=e :5en t3"! 6(13t !6ed e"t5e3 9e3(n! (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n$D1en=e334 %& D1en=e334$ @+. N&E& +d . 8Ind&A99& * D"t& *007)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne 3ende3ed =4 6(13t :5"65 !6ed 9e3(n! (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n (3 !6ted "n m!nne3

"n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e 93(6e$ U&S&C&A& C(nt& Amend& .$ * M!tte3 (# M!33"!;e (# H!m95"3e$ @0 P&+d . 8 Q!n&*00/)&

J1d;ment " %("d "# 6(13t t5!t 3ende3ed "t !6ed 9e3(n! (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n %("d 21d;ment " n1"t4 !ndm!4 =e %!6!ted !t !n4 t"me$ M!tte3 (# M!33"!;e (# e"%e3$ @0 P&+d @.7 8Q!n& *00)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne 3ende3ed =4 ! 6(13t :5"65 !6ed 9e3(n! (3 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n (3 !6ted "n ! m!nne3"n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e 93(6e In 3e Et!te (# e$ 07 P&+d +/0$ 8Q!n& A99& *000)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne 3ende3ed "n !=en6e (# 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 9!3t"e 7*- N&& +d .-+$ 8M"nn&*0*)& A %("d 21d;ment " (ne 3ende3ed "n !=en6e (# 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 9!3t"e$ L!n;e %& J(5n(n$+- N&&+d +-. 8M"nn& *0/7)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5! me3e4 em=!n6e$ :"t5(1t (me eent"! eement$ ! :5en 6(13t 9139(3t"n; t(3ende3 " 5! n( 213"d"6t"(n$ M" %& R"65!3d(n$ * S&E& +d -0$ 8N&C& *0.)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5! ! me3e em=!n6e$ =1t " !6"n; "n (me (# t5e eent"! eement :5"65 :(1d!1t5(3"e t5e 6(13t t( 93(6eed t( 21d;ment$ Hende3(n %& Hende3(n$ .0 S&E& +d ++/$ 8N&C& *0.-)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne ente3ed =4 6(13t :"t5(1t 213"d"6t"(n t( ente3 165 21d;ment$ St!te %& B!nen5"9 @/. N&E&+d *7-7$ 8O5"( A99& 0 D"t& *00@)&

V("d 21d;ment$ m!4 =e %!6!ted !t !n4 t"me " (ne :5(e "n%!"d"t4 !99e!3 (n #!6e (# 21d;ment 3($ G3!## %& Qe4$* P&+d 0 8O& *00*)& A %("d 21d;ment " (ne t5!t " %("d (n #!6e (# 21d;ment 3($ C!9"t! Fede3! S!%"n;B!n %& Be:e4$ /0. P&+d *-.* 8O& *00-)&

5e3e 6(nd"t"(n (# =!" =(nd :! t5!t de#end!nt :(1d !99e!3 !t 93eent te3m (# 6(13t$ 21d;ment #(3#e"t"n; =(nd #(3de#end!nt =!" t( !99e!3 !t 1=eK1ent te3m :! ! %("d 21d;ment :"t5"n 31e t5!t !65e d(e n(t 31n !;!"nt ! %("d

21d;ment C(m& V& M"e3$ *.- A&+d .. 8P!& S19e3& *0.0)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5(: 19(n #!6e (# 3e6(3d ! :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n "n 6(13t !1m"n; t( 3ende3 t5e21d;ment$ Unde3:((d %& B3(:n$ + S&& +d *@ 8Tenn& *0.*)&

A V("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5(: 19(n #!6e (# 3e6(3d :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n "n 6(13t !1m"n; t( 3ende3 21d;ment$


16/23

!nd :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n m!4 =e e"t5e3 (# 9e3(n$ 1=2e6t m!tte3 ;ene3!4$ 9!3t"61!3 K1et"(n t( =e de6"ded (3 3e"e#!1med t( =e ;"%en$ St!te e? 3e& D!:(n %& B(m!3$ 7. S&& +d /@7$ 6e3t"(3!3" den"ed$ 8Tenn& *0@+)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne "n :5"65 t5e 21d;ment " #!6"!4 "n%!"d =e6!1e t5e 6(13t !6ed 213"d"6t"(n (3 !1t5(3"t4 t(3ende3 t5e 21d;ment$ St!te %& R"65"e$ +- S&&7d @+ 8Tenn& +---)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5(: (n #!6e (# 3e6(3d t5e :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n "n 6(13t !1m"n; t( 3ende321d;ment$ :5"65 :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n m!4 =e e"t5e3 (# t5e 9e3(n$ (3 (# t5e 1=2e6t m!tte3 ;ene3!4$ (3 (# t5e9!3t"61!3 K1et"(n !ttem9ted t( de6"ded (3 3e"e# !1med t( =e ;"%en$ R"65!3d(n %& M"t65e$ +7/ S&& +d .//$8Tenn&Ct& A99& *0.-)&

V("d 21d;ment " (ne :5"65 5! n( e;! #(36e (3 e##e6t :5!te%e3$ "t " !n !=(1te n1"t4$ "t "n%!"d"t4 m!4 =e!e3ted =4 !n4 9e3(n :5(e 3";5t !3e !##e6ted !t !n4 t"me !nd !t !n4 9!6e !nd "t need n(t =e !tt!6ed d"3e6t4 =1tm!4 =e !tt!6ed 6(!te3!4 :5ene%e3 !nd :5e3e%e3 "t " "nte39(ed$ C"t4 (# L1#"n %& M6V"6e3$ .*- S&& +d **8Te?& C"%& A99& Be!1m(nt *0/7)&

A %("d 21d;ment$ "n(#!3 ! "t 9139(3t t( =e 93(n(1n6ement (# 6(13t$ " !n !=(1te n1"t4$ T5(m9(n %&T5(m9(n$ +7 S&&+d +* 8Te?&C"%&A99& !6( *0.*)&

A %("d 21d;ment " (ne t5!t 5! =een 93(613ed =4 e?t3"n"6 (3 6(!te3! #3!1d (3 ente3ed =4 ! 6(13t t5!t d"d n(t 5!%e213"d"6t"(n (%e3 t5e 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 t5e 9!3t"e& R(( %& R(($ +77 V!& 0+$ 0.$ 7.7 S&E&+d /.@$ /. 8*0/)

A %("d 21d;ment " ! 21d;ment$ de63ee$ (3 (3de3 ente3ed =4 ! 6(13t :5"65 !6 213"d"6t"(n (# t5e 9!3t"e (3 (# t5e1=2e6t m!tte3$ (3 :5"65 !6 t5e "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t( m!e (3 ente3 t5e 9!3t"61!3 (3de3 "n%(%ed$ St!te e? 3e& T13ne3%& B3";;$ 0/* P&+d .* 8!5& A99& D"%& *000)&

A %("d 21d;ment (3 (3de3 " (ne t5!t " ente3ed =4 ! 6(13t !6"n; 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 t5e 9!3t"e (3 t5e 1=2e6t m!tte3$(3 !6"n; t5e "n5e3ent 9(:e3 t( ente3 t5e 9!3t"61!3 (3de3 (3 21d;ment$ (3 :5e3e t5e (3de3 :! 93(613ed =4 #3!1d$ In3e Ad(9t"(n (# E&L&$ /77 N&E&+d @$ 8I&A99& * D"t& +---)& V("d 21d;ment !3e t5(e 3ende3ed =4 6(13t :5"65!6ed 213"d"6t"(n$ e"t5e3 (# 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 9!3t"e$ C(6e35!m %& "3!t65$ @*0 P&+d /70 8A3"& *0-)&

V("d 21d;ment ;ene3!4 #! "nt( t:( 6!"#"6!t"(n$ t5!t "$ 21d;ment :5e3e t5e3e " :!nt (# 213"d"6t"(n (#9e3(n (3 1=2e6t m!tte3$ !nd 21d;ment 93(613ed t53(1;5 #3!1d$ !nd 165 21d;ment m!4 =e !tt!6ed d"3e6t4 (36(!te3!4$ I3%"n; %& R(d3"K1e$ *@0 N&E&+d *.$ 8I&!99& + D"t& *0@-)& In%!"d"t4 need t( !99e!3 (n #!6e (#

21d;ment !(ne t5!t 21d;ment (3 (3de3 m!4 =e !"d t( =e "nt3"n"6!4 %("d (3 %("d (n "t #!6e$ "# !6 (# 213"d"6t"(n!99e!3 #3(m t5e 3e6(3d$ C3(6ett O" C(& %& E##"e$ 7/ S&&+d *. 8 M(&A99& *0@)&

De6""(n " %("d (n t5e #!6e (# t5e 21d;ment 3( :5en #3(m #(13 6(3ne3 (# t5!t 3($ "t m!4 =e dete3m"ned t5!t !te!t (ne (# t53ee eement (# 213"d"6t"(n :! !=ent 8*) 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 9!3t"e$ 8+) 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 1=2e6tm!tte3$ (3 87) 213"d"6t"(n! 9(:e3 t( 93(n(1n6e 9!3t"61!3 21d;ment 5!t :! 3ende3ed$ B W C In%etment$ In6& %& FW M N!t& B!n W T31t$ 0-7 P&+d 770 8O!& A99& D"%& 7$ *00.)& V("d (3de3 m!4 =e !tt!6ed$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (36(!te3!4$ !t !n4 t"me$ In 3e Et!te (# Ste"n#"ed$ @7- N&E&+d -*$ 6e3t"(3!3" den"ed$ See !( Ste"n#ed %& H(dd"6$.*7 U&S& -0$ 8I& *00)&

V("d (3de3 :5"65 " (ne ente3ed =4 6(13t :5"65 !6 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 9!3t"e (3 1=2e6t m!tte3$ (3 !6 "n5e3ent9(:e3 t( ente3 21d;ment$ (3 (3de3 93(613ed =4 #3!1d$ 6!n =e !tt!6ed !t !n4 t"me$ "n !n4 6(13t$ e"t5e3 d"3e6t4 (36(!te3!4$ 93(%"ded t5!t 9!3t4 " 93(9e34 =e#(3e 6(13t$ Pe(9e e? 3e& B3"6! %& V"!;e (# L!e B!33"n;t(n$ @N&E&+d @@ 8I&A99& + D"t& *00)&

5"e %("d!=e (3de3 !3e 3e!d"4 !99e!!=e !nd m1t =e !tt!6ed d"3e6t4$ %("d (3de3 m!4 =e 6"361m%ented =46(!te3! !tt!6 (3 3emed"ed =4 m!nd!m1$ S!n65e %& Hete3$ 0** S&&+d */7$ 8Te?&A99& C(391 C53"t" *00.)&

A3"(n! 6(13t ;"%e ;3e!t :e";5t t( #ede3! 6(13t "nte393et!t"(n (# Fede3! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e ;(%e3n"n;


17/23

m(t"(n #(3 3e"e# #3(m 21d;ment "n "nte393et"n; "dent"6! te?t (# A3"(n! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e$ Et!te (# P!;e %&L"ten=13;$ .+ P&+d *+$ 3e%"e: den"ed 8A3"&A99& D"%& *$ *00)&

5en 31e 93(%"d"n; #(3 3e"e# #3(m %("d 21d;ment " !99"6!=e$ 3e"e# " n(t d"63et"(n!34 m!tte3$ =1t " m!nd!t(34$O3ne3 %& S5!!!$ 7- F&7d *7-/$ 8C((& *00)&

J1d;ment ente3ed :5e3e 6(13t !6ed e"t5e3 1=2e6t m!tte3 (3 9e3(n! 213"d"6t"(n$ (3 t5!t :e3e (t5e3:"e ente3ed"n %"(!t"(n (# d1e 93(6e (# !:$ m1t =e et !"de$ J!##e !nd A5e3 %& V!n B31nt$ S&D&N&Y&*00& *. F&R&D& +/&

A


18/23

T5e !: 3eK1"3e 93((# (# 213"d"6t"(n (n 3e6(3d (# !dm"n"t3!t"%e !;en64 !nd !dm"n"t3!t"%e 93(6eed"n;& H!;!n% L!%"ne *. US .77

T5(1;5 n(t 9e6"#"6!4 !e;ed$ de#end!nt' 65!en;e t( 1=2e6t m!tte3 213"d"6t"(n "m9"6"t4 3!"ed 6!"m t5!tde#!1t 21d;ment !;!"nt 5"m :! %("d !nd 3e"e# 5(1d =e ;3!nted 1nde3 R1e @-8=)8)& H(nne1 %& D(n(%!n$ 07F&R&D& 77$ 7@,7/ 8*0+)$ !##'d$ @0* F&+d * 8*t C"3& *0+)&

A 21d;ment " %("d "# 6(13t !6ted "n m!nne3 "n6(n"tent :"t5 d1e 93(6e !nd " ! n1"t4 !nd m!4 =e %!6!ted!n4t"me& +@* Q!n& !t @+

A 21d;ment (=t!"ned :"t5(1t 213"d"6t"(n (%e3 t5e de#end!nt " %("d& O%e3=4 %& O%e3=4 $ ./ S&&+d .* 8Tenn&*0/-)&

At5(1;5 R1e @-8=)8) " (ten"=4 1=2e6t t( t5e 3e!(n!=e t"me "m"t (# R1e @-8=)$ !t e!t (ne 6(13t 5! 5edt5!t n( t"me "m"t !99"e t( ! m(t"(n 1nde3 t5e R1e @-8=)8) =e6!1e ! %("d 21d;ment 6!n ne%e3 !6K1"3e %!"d"t4t53(1;5 !65e& See C3(=4 %& B3!dt3eet C(&$ 7*+ F&+d 7 8+nd C"3&) 6e3t& den"ed$ 7/7 U&S& 0**$ 7 S&Ct& *7--$ *-L&Ed&+d *+ 8*0@7) :5e3e t5e 6(13t %!6!ted ! 21d;ment ! %("d 7- 4e!3 !#te3 ent34& See !( M!3K1ette C(39& %&P3"ete3$ +7 F&S199& /00 8E&D&S&C&*0@) :5e3e t5e 6(13t e?93e4 5ed t5!t 6!1e R1e @-8=)8) 6!33"e n( 3e!t"me "m"t&

#. $rongfl Foreclosre !y a Non%older of t%e &eed of "rst

C5!e De6e9t"(n

*& T5e t3"! 6(13t 5! IGNORED ! t"me4 Pet"t"(n t( O9en& A($ de9"te ! t"me4 N(t"6e (# A99e!$ !nd t5e 9!4ment(# ! #ee$ t( d!te n( S19e3"(3 C(13t d(6et n1m=e3 5! =een !";ned& M!n4 (t5e3 9e!d"n; 5!%e =een !(";n(3ed "n t5" 6!e&

+& T5e3e#(3e$ ! :e 6!nn(t (=t!"n t5e !ttent"(n (# C(1nt4$ :e 93!4 #(3 3e"e#$ 5en6e t5e t"t"n;(# t5" m(t"(n ! !neme3;en64&

7& M133!4' 93(9e6t (# :"nn"n; !99e! !3e t3(n;$ ! NE EVIDENCE 5! 13#!6ed 8Att!65ed A";nment FROMC5!e t( T31tee ne%e3 d"61ed (3 d"6(ed =4 C5!e)

NE$ E'I&ENCE

(. $e %a)e disco)ered ne* e)idence *%ic% !lo*s t%is case *ide open and s%old not earn s a stay+ !t adismissal and damages in or Federal la*sit *e are filing.

S55 ASS$FN;5N>

NO &,E PROCE-- #EFORE &EPRI'A"ION OF PROPER"Y

*& T5e3e :! ne%e3 any cort process$ n( 6(13t (3de3, 21t !n "m93(9e3 de#!1t21d;ment ";ned =4 only a

Prot%onotary"n t5" #(3e6(13e&

+& E%en "#t5e n(te :! end(3ed t( !nd n(t #3(m C5!e 1nt" !#te3 t5e !:1"t :! #"ed$ t" C5!e 5! n( t!nd"n;!t t5e t"me t5e 6(m9!"nt :! #"ed$ "n :5"65 6!e t5e t3"! 6(13t 5(1d t3"e 21d;ment !nd :"t5 93e21d"6e d"m"!nd "m9(e !n6t"(n #(3 #3!1d 19(n C(13t$ 9e32134$ et6&

7& A 5e!3"n; " 3eK1"3ed t( !e d!m!;e 1n"!te3!4 !eed =4 P!"nt"## "e;!4$ ! :e ! "# t5e3e " d"91tede%"den6e (n !n "1e 8/0 S(& 7d */-$ */+,*/7) !nd C(1nt34 P!6e$ .* S(& 7d !t @**/0 8Be6!1e J&P& M(3;!n d"dn(t (:n (3 9(e t5e n(te !nd m(3t;!;e :5en "t t"ed "t !:1"t$ "t !6ed t!nd"n;&


19/23

& C5!e d"d !=(1te4 n(t5"n; t( !t"#4 t5" eement (# 93((# !t t5e n(n,t3"!, 4et :e 5!%e t5e 3e6(3d (# t5e93e6ed"n; SHENQIN 6!e :"t5 9ent4 (# e%"den6e&

.& e !%e3 t5e (:e3 6(13t e33ed =4 !(:"n; CHASEt( 1=m"t n( e%"den6e (# t!nd"n;$ de9"te t5e 3e6ent 3e=1e=4 t5e !99e! 6(13t 3e;!3d"n; t!nd"n;&

CA-ELAC/E& "E RE0,I-I"E -"AN&ING "O FORECLO-E -O I" E1EC,"E& AN IMPROPER#AC/ CANNEL &EFA,L" 2,&GMEN"

*& A #(3e6(13e 9!"nt"##' (=";!t"(n t( 93(%e "t t!nd"n; t( #(3e6(e !t t5e t"me "t #"ed "t !:1"t$ 9e3"(d&

+& T5e ne: e%"den6e 93(%e :5!t :e (n4 6(1d "n#e3 =4 (m""(n$ ! t5e 9!"nt"## m1t 93(%e t5!t "t 5!d t!nd"n; t(#(3e6(e :5en t5e 6(m9!"nt :! #"ed&

7& A 9e3 3e6ent 31"n; "n m4 =3(t5e3' 6!e$ CHASE %& FRANCIS X MURRAY "n PA S19e3"(3 C(13t$ "t " !#(3e6(13e 9!"nt"##' (=";!t"(n t( 93(%e "t t!nd"n; t( #(3e6(e !t t5e t"me "t #"ed "t !:1"t, ! #!6t t5!t 5! =eene?9!"ned =4 5" 3e6ent S19e3"(3 6(13t %"6t(34 !nd m!n46(13t "n 3e6ent 4e!3&

& In (t5e3 6"361"t$ M6Le!n %& J&P& M(3;!n C5!e B!n$ N&A&" ! ("d e?!m9e$ :5e3e t5e F(13t5 D"t3"6te?9!"nedT( 1mm!3"e$ t5e 9!"nt"## m1t 93(%e t5!t "t 5!d t!nd"n; t( #(3e6(e :5en t5e 6(m9!"nt :! #"ed&C(1nt4 P!6e Cmt%& A'n %& J&P& M(3;!n$ .* S(& 7d ** /@$ ** /0&Be6!1e J&P& M(3;!n d"d n(t (:n (3 9(e t5en(te !nd m(3t;!;e :5en "t t"ed "t !:1"t$ "t !6ed t!nd"n; t( m!"nt!"n t5e #(3e6(13e !6t"(n&)

.& C5!e d"d ment"(n t5e N(te "n t5"$ t5e"3 THIRD #(3e6(13e 6!e !;!"nt 1& T5e4 (# 6(13e n(t !tt!65 ! 6(94 (#t5e (3";"n! n(te t( "t 6(m9!"nt$

n(3 3e#e3en6ed t5e m("n; ;1n !e (# t5e m(3t;!;e ! 9e3 t5e ne: e%"den6e e?5"="t$ ! t5!t :(1d =e 5(net =1te#,de#e!t"n; !nd e?9(e #3!1d&

@& T5e 3e6(3d e%"den6e " "n1##"6"ent t( dem(nt3!te t5!t C5!e 5! t!nd"n; t( #(3e6(e !n4t"me !#te3 +--. (3 !t

t5e t"me t5e !:1"t :! #"ed&

3. "%e mortgage *as assigned not to C%ase !t FROM C%ase4

& T5e3e#(3e:e m(%e t5" C(13t #(3 ! t!4 9end"n; !99e! !nd #!"13e t( 31e 19(n (13 Pet"t"(n t( O9en t5e "m93(9e3ent34 (# ! De#!1t J1d;ment$ :5( " NOTT31tee (# SASCO XSM(3t;!;e P!,T53(1;5 Ce3t"#"6!te1nde3 t5eP(("n; !nd Se3%"6"n; A;3eement D!ted Fe= +--.8CHASE) !nd t5e3e#(3e n(t (n4 5(1d t5e !e =e t!4ed$ =1tt5e C(13t 5(1d d"m" "t ent"3e4 (3 dem!nd C5!e t( 5(: 6!1e$ !nd t5!n#14$ t5" C(13t d"d 21t t5!t "n !teJ14 +-*7&

A C5!e d"d n(t (:n t5e M(3t;!;e !nd P3(m"(34 N(te (n t5e d!te (# e?e61t"(n (# t5e A";nment !nd 5!d n(!1t5(3"t4 t( !";n t5em t( M(%!nt&B4 t5e te3m (# t5e t:( e613"t"ed t31t #(3 Le5m!n B3(t5e3 de";n!ted +--@,7 3e;"te3ed :"t5 t5e U&S& Se613"t"e

!nd E?65!n;e C(mm""(n$ n( !";nment (66133ed&

T5e A";nment :! e?e61ted !nd 3e6(3ded 9(t,9et"t"(n !nd m!4 6(nt"t1te ! %"(!t"(n (# t5e !1t(m!t"6 t!49131!nt t( ** U&S&C& Se6t"(n 7@+8!)8)&

& M(%!nt 5! n(t et!="5ed t5!t (n t5e Pet"t"(n D!te "t 5!d 954"6! 9(e"(n (# t5e (3";"n! P3(m"(34 N(te93(9e34 end(3ed "n "t #!%(3&

.& Le5m!n B3(t5e3 (3 !M1 !=""t4 t( en#(36e t5e P3(m"(34 N(te (3 M(3t;!;e :! e?t"n;1"5ed "n +--@ :5en"t :! 9!"d =4 t5e T31t #(3 t5e 9(( (# m(3t;!;e :5"65 #(3m t5e T31t 6(391&


20/23

@& T"te =et:een t5e P3(m"(34 N(te !nd M(3t;!;e :e3e ="#136!ted$ t5e3e=4 3ende3"n; t5e M(3t;!;e 1nen#(36e!=e&

T5e T31tee !e3t M(%!nt " !n 1ne613ed 63ed"t(3 !nd 5e 5! !1t5(3"t4 t( e t5e P3(9e3t4 #3ee !nd 6e!3 (#en61m=3!n6e #(3 t5e =ene#"t (# t5e et!te&

M(%!nt !e3t t5e N(te !nd M(3t;!;e !3e (:ned SASCO XS$ ! 93"%!te e613"t"ed t31t$ !nd ! t5e !e3ted (:ne3

!nd 5(de3 (# t5e N(te !nd M(3t;!;e$ 9e35!9 !nd !(ne 5! !1t5(3"t4 t( en#(36e t5e e613"t4 "nte3et "# t5" :! n(t3e,6(n%e4ed !nd(3 3e,549(t5e6!ted (3 9!"d (## =4 AIG (3 :3(te (## =4 =!n319t64 (3 (d t( P5e!n$ t5e 9139(3ted6(1ne #(3 93etend ende3 C5!e&

C5!e 1=m""(n !3e "n1##"6"ent t( et!="5 "t " t5e (:ne3 !nd 5(de3 (# t5e N(te !nd M(3t;!;e (3 " !1t5(3"edt( !6t #(3 :5(e%e3 5(d t5ee d(61ment& In 3e Re!$ N(& -0,+--@$ +--0 L .*0+@+$ !t . 8B!n3& D& 4(&De6& ++$ +--0) 8;3!nt"n; t!4 3e"e# :5e3e m(%!nt et!="5ed 9(e"(n (# n(te t53(1;5 tet"m(n4 (# :"tne :5(9e3(n!4 3et3"e%ed n(te #3(m m(%!nt %!1t) In 3e J!6(=(n$ -+ B&R& !t 7/- 8den4"n; m(%!nt t!4 3e"e# m(t"(nd1e t( m(%!nt #!"13e t( et!="5 "t :! 5(de3 (# n(te) In 3e H!4e$ 707 B&R& +.0$ +/- 8B!n3& D& M!& +--)8den4"n; m(%!nt t!4 3e"e# m(t"(n !nd 1t!"n"n; de=t(3 6!"m (=2e6t"(n d1e t( m(%!nt #!"13e t( et!="5 "t:! 5(de3 (# n(te)&

C5!e 5! n(t et!="5ed "t 5! t!nd"n; t( =3"n; t5e #(3e6(13e "n +--0 !nd +-*+ !nd t51 " d1e t( =e den"ed&

A66(3d"n;4$ "t 5(1d =e ORDERED$ ADJUDGED AND DECREED t5!t t5e P3(9e3t4 "n P!(" " n(t t( =e (d1nt" #"n! !d21d"6!t"(n (# ! e;! m!tte3&

B& St!nd!3d (# Re%"e: !nd D"61"(n

C(13t 5!%e d"63et"(n t( ;3!nt e?ten"(n :5e3e t5e m(%!nt 5(: t5e de!4 :! t5e 3e1t (# >e?61!=e ne;e6t&>In 3e Cend!nt C(39& P3"de L"t&$ *0 F&R&D& 7+*$ 7+7,7+ 8D&N&J& *000)&

Fede3! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e @8=)8+) t!te

5en =4 t5ee 31e (3 =4 n(t"6e ;"%en t5e3e1nde3 & & & !n !6t " 3eK1"3ed & & & t( =e d(ne !t (3 :"t5"n !9e6"#"ed t"me$ t5e 6(13t #(3 6!1e 5(:n m!4 !t !n4 t"me "n "t d"63et"(n & & & 19(n m(t"(n m!de !#te3 t5e e?9"3!t"(n

(# t5e 9e6"#"ed 9e3"(d 9e3m"t t5e !6t t( =e d(ne :5e3e t5e #!"13e t( !6t :! t5e 3e1t (# e?61!=e ne;e6t&

In dete3m"n"n; :5!t 6(nt"t1te e?61!=e ne;e6t$ 6(13t !3e t( 6(n"de3 ! 3ee%!nt 6"361mt!n6e 133(1nd"n; t5ede!4& In 3e Cend!nt C(39& P3"de L"t&$ *0 F&R&D& !t 7+ 86"t"n; P"(nee3 In%et& Se3%& C(& %& B31n:"6 A(6& Ltd&P!3tne35"9$ .-/ U&S& 7-$ 70. 8*007))&

Ree%!nt #!6t(3 "n61de t5e #((:"n; 8*) t5e d!n;e3 (# 93e21d"6e t( t5e n(n,m(%!nt 8+) t5e en;t5 (# t5e de!4 !nd"t 9(tent"! "m9!6t (n 21d"6"! 93(6eed"n; 87) t5e 3e!(n #(3 t5e de!4$ "n61d"n; :5et5e3 "t :! :"t5"n t5e3e!(n!=e 6(nt3( (# t5e m(%!nt$ !nd :5et5e3 m(%!nt !6ted "n ;((d #!"t5& Id& Ot5e3 #!6t(3 "n61de 8*) :5et5e3"n!d%e3ten6e 3e#e6ted 93(#e"(n! "n6(m9eten6e 165 ! ";n(3!n6e (# t5e 31e (# 93(6ed13e 8+) :5et5e3 !n!e3ted "n!d%e3ten6e 3e#e6t !n e!"4 m!n1#!6t13ed e?61e "n6!9!=e (# %e3"#"6!t"(n =4 t5e 6(13t$ !nd 87)6(m9ete !6 (# d"";en6e&Id& 86"t"n; D(m"n"6 %& He O" V&I& C(39&$ * F&+d .*7$ .*/ 87d C"3& *0)&

B& St!nd!3d O# Re%"e:

A m(t"(n t( d"m" 9131!nt t( Fede3! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e *+8=)8@) tet t5e e;! 1##"6"en64 (# t5e 6(m9!"nt&C(ne4 %& G"=(n$ 7.. U&S& *$ .,@ 8*0./)& A 6(13t m1t dete3m"ne :5et5e3 t5e 9!3t4 m!"n; t5e 6!"m :(1d =eent"ted t( 3e"e# 1nde3 !n4 et (# #!6t t5!t 6(1d =e et!="5ed "n 199(3t (# 5" (3 5e3 6!"m& H"5(n %& Q"n; WS9!d"n;$ /@ U&S& @0$ /7 8*0)86"t"n; C(ne4$ 7.. U&S& !t .,@) ee !( "n"e:" %& J(5n,M!n%"e C(39&$/.0 F&+d +/*$ +/* 87d C"3& *0.)& In 6(n"de3"n; ! m(t"(n t( d"m"$ ! !e;!t"(n "n t5e 6(m9!"nt m1t =e!66e9ted ! t31e !nd %"e:ed "n t5e ";5t m(t #!%(3!=e t( t5e n(n,m(%"n; 9!3t4& R(6 %& C"t4 (# P5"!de95"!$ @


21/23

F&+d @$ @. 87d C"3& *00)86"t!t"(n (m"tted)&

A=1e (# 93(6e

T5e t(3t (# !=1e (# 93(6e " t5e "m93(9e3 1e (# e;! 93(6e !#te3 "t 5! =een "1ed& M6Gee %& Fee;e$ .*/ P!&+/$ +.. 8*0/)& Pee;3"n( F((d P3(d16t C(&$ In6& %& C"t4 (# !33en$ *7@ F& S199& +d 70*$ -/ 8&D& P!& +---)&

T( t!te ! 6!1e (# !6t"(n #(3 t5e t(3t (# !=1e (# 93(6e$ t5e 6(m9!"n!nt m1t !e;e t5e #((:"n;8*) t5!t t5et(3t#e!(3 1ed ! e;! 93(6e !;!"nt t5e 6(m9!"n!nt 8+) t5!t t5e 1e (# e;! 93(6e :! 93"m!3"4 t( !66(m9"5! 9139(e #(3 :5"65 t5e 93(6e :! n(t de";ned !nd 87) t5!t C(m9!"n!nt 1##e3ed 5!3m ! ! 3e1t& H!3t %OM!e4$ @/ A&+d .+$ ..* 8P!& S19e3& Ct& *00)&

T5e C(13t (# A99e! "n PA 21t 31ed !;!"nt C5!e "n ! 6!e "n%(%"n; m4 =3(t5e3 !nd#(3e6(13e 8C5!e %&F3!n6" X M133!4) 3e%e3"n; 1mm!34 21d;ment ! C5!e :! n(t t5e(3 "; "n ! m( 3t ;! ;e e !n d 5! d !6K1"3ed t5e (!n =4 !";nment 3!t5e3 t5!n =4 (9e3!t"(n (# !: !nd t51 C5!e:! (=";!ted t( 3e6(3d t5e !";nment&

T5e C(13t (# A99e! dete3m"ned t5!t de#end!nt' #!"13e t( 3e6(3d t5e !";nment 3ende3edt5e 5e3"##' !e %("d != "n"t"(&

$%en a s!se5ent mortgagee ac5ires an interest in a mortgage t%rog% a )olntary prc%ase agreement*it% t%e F&IC+ t%e mortgage %as not !een ac5ired !y operation of la* and t%at s!se5ent mortgagee mstcomply *it% t%e pro)isions of PARCP and record t%e assignment of t%e mortgage !efore foreclosing on t%emortgage !y ad)ertisement.

An4 de#e6t (3 "33e;1!3"t4 "n ! #(3e6(13e 93(6eed"n; 3e1t "n ! #(3e6(13e t5!t " %("d!=e$ n(t %("d != "n"t(&

III& RULE ** SANCTION

Unde3 Fede3! R1e (# C"%" P3(6ed13e **86)$ t5e C(13t m!4 "m9(e !993(93"!te !n6t"(n (n !tt(3ne4 :5( %"(!teR1e **8=)$ :5"65 t!te

B4 93eent"n; t( t5e 6(13t 8:5et5e3 =4 ";n"n;$ #""n;$ 1=m"tt"n;$ (3 !te3 !d%(6!t"n;) ! 9e!d"n;$ :3"ttenm(t"(n$ (3 (t5e3 9!9e3$ !n !tt(3ne4 (3 1n3e93eented 9!3t4 " 6e3t"#4"n; t5!t t( t5e =et (# t5e 9e3(n'n(:ed;e$ "n#(3m!t"(n$ !nd =e"e#$ #(3med !#te3 !n "nK1"34 3e!(n!=e 1nde3 t5e 6"361mt!n6e$,,8*) "t " n(t =e"n; 93eented #(3 !n4 "m93(9e3 9139(e$ 165 ! t( 5!3! (3 t( 6!1e 1nne6e!34 de!4 (3neede "n63e!e "n t5e 6(t (# "t";!t"(n 8+) t5e 6!"m$ de#ene$ !nd (t5e3 e;! 6(ntent"(nt5e3e"n !3e :!33!nted =4 e?"t"n; !: (3 =4 ! n(n,#3"%((1 !3;1ment #(3 t5e e?ten"(n$ m(d"#"6!t"(n$(3 3e%e3! (# e?"t"n; !: (3 t5e et!="5ment (# ne: !:87) t5e !e;!t"(n !nd (t5e3 #!6t1! 6(ntent"(n5!%e e%"dent"!34 199(3t (3$ "# 9e6"#"6!4 ( "dent"#"ed$ !3e "e4 t( 5!%e e%"dent"!34 199(3t!#te3 ! 3e!(n!=e (99(3t1n"t4 #(3 #13t5e3 "n%et";!t"(n (3 d"6(%e34 !nd8) t5e den"! (##!6t1! 6(ntent"(n !3e :!33!nted (n t5e e%"den6e (3$ "# 9e6"#"6!4 ( "dent"#"ed$ !3e 3e!(n!=4 =!ed (n

! !6 (# "n#(3m!t"(n (3 =e"e#&

D"t3"6t 6(13t 3et!"n =3(!d d"63et"(n "n dete3m"n"n; t5e !993(93"!te !n6t"(n 1nde3 R1e **& L!n;e3 %& M(n!365L"#e In&C(&$ 0@@ F&+d /@$ *- 87d C"3& *00+)& T5e 3!n;e (# !n6t"(n "n61de$ ! :!3m #3"end4 d"61"(n (n t5e 3e6(3d$ !5!3d,n(ed 3e93"m!nd "n (9en 6(13t$ 6(m91(34 e;! ed16!t"(n$ m(net!34 !n6t"(n$ (3 (t5e3 me!13e !993(93"!tet(t5e 6"361mt!n6e& 5!te%e3 t5e 1t"m!te !n6t"(n "m9(ed$ t5e d"t3"6t 6(13t 5(1d 1t""e t5e !n6t"(nt5!t #13t5e3 t5e 9139(e (# R1e ** !nd " t5e e!t e%e3e !n6t"(n !deK1!te t( 165 9139(e& Id&


22/23

!n6t"(n " t( dete3 #1t13e %"(!t"(n$ !nd "6 m(net!34 !n6t"(n 5(1d n(t =e m(3e e%e3e t5!n t5(e ne6e!34t( dete3 3e9e!ted %"(!t"(n (# 31e&> G"!n;3!( %& Q"tt!t"nn4 H";5 S65& Bd& (# Ed16&$ @. F&S199& **77$ ***8D&N&J& *00)&

FEDERAL UESTIONS

*) DOES THE PROCEDURE IN PENNSYLVANIA HICH ALLOS A CITIEN ITH DEED OFTITLE FOR THEIR HOME TO LOSE IT IN A JUDICIAL FORECLOSURE ACTION HEREBY NO SINGLEMINUTE OF ORAL ARGUMENT$ TESTIMONY$ INTRODUCTION OF EVIDENCE OR TRIAL IS AFFORDEDTO THE HOMEONER,LITIGANT$ AND FURTHERMORE$ A JUDGMENT CAN BE OBTAINED ITHOUTTHESE DUE PROCESS CONSIDERATIONS$ AND REUIRING NOT ONE SINGLE ORDER FROM AJUDGE$ OR ANY MECHANISM OTHER THAN THE AVERMENT OF A BANQ ITH NO SUPPORTINGEVIDENCE OF ONERSHIP OF DEBT NOR EVIDENCE OF DEFAULT OF THAT DEBT$ BUT ONLY THESIGNATURE OF A CLERQ HO ARE FORBIDDEN BY LA TO DISPENSE LEGAL ADVICE$ MUCH LESSMAQE A MILLION DOLLAR EUITABLE RELIEF LEGAL DETERMINATION IN SHORT$ IS THEDEPRIVATION OF PROPERTY BY THE PEN STROQE OF A NON,JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATIVEASSISTANT ITH NO LEGAL DEGREE OR LICENSE A GROSS VIOLATION OF ALL PEOPLE'S RIGHT TOTRUE AND COMPLETE JUDICIAL DUE PROCESS OF LA BEFORE A JUDGE AND A PROPER TRIALITH HATEVER VERDICT THE FACTS SUPPORT AS A MANDATORY PROCESS THAT OCCURS

BEFORE THE INSTANTANEOUS 8DEFAULT JUDGMENT TAQING ONE'S HOME IS LITERALLY ANINHeRENTLY ILLEGAL ACTION BY A NON JURIST ITHOUT LICENSE OR EMPOERMENT TOAARD EUITABLE RELIEF AND THIS MAJOR LEGAL EVENT IS REDUCED TO A MOMENT, AN ACTTHAT TAQES MERELY SECONDS, NOT MINUTES NOR HOURS, YOU LOSE YOUR HOME AND ALLTHAT OCCURS IS A PERSON AS LEGALLY TRAINED AS AN OFFICE ORQER ALLOS BY THE MEREACT OF SIGNING A SINGLE DOCUMENT ITHOUT ATTACHED EVIDENCE NOR ANY CRITICALANALYSIS HATSOEVER RESULTS IN THE LOSS OF THE LARGEST ASSET E EVER ON IN ADEPRIVATION PROPERTY ITHOUT DUE PROCESSZ& IS THAT A DENIAL OF DUE PROCESS

+) DOES THIS ACTION DESCRIBED IN AVERMENT [* VIOLATE THE FEDERAL RULES OFEVIDENCE

7) IF YES$ IS THE COUNTY OF CHESTER OR THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA THEN GUILTY AND

LIABLE FOR NEGLIGENCE IN NOT ENFORCING THE MOST FUNDAMENTAL PROTECTION THECONSTITUTION AFFORDS US ALL BESIDES FREEDOM AND PRIVACY

+) IF THE COURT FINDS THE FIRST UESTION IN THE AFFIRMATIVE$ IS THE ACT OF SALE BYSHERIFF BY AN ILLEGAL IMPROPER AND INCOMPLETE JUDICIAL ACTION HICH RESULTS INSEVERE INJURY TO A CITIEN BY DEPRIVING CITIENS OF PROPERTY ITHOUT DUE PROCESS8AND THIS IS INDEPENDENT OF THE BANQ'S RIGHT OR LACQ OF STANDING TO FORECLOSE) IS THEBANQ PLAINTIFF AND THEIR COUNSEL LIABLE FOR CIVIL AND CRIMINAL PENALTIES IF THEYERE AARE OF THE ILLEGALITY OF THE PROCESS

7) FOR THOSE CITIENS FORECLOSED UPON$ HO$ LIQE US$ CAN PROVE THE BANQ IS NOTTHE ONER AND IS AARE OF THIS MISREPRESENTATION$ AND HAVE BY THEIR CONSPIRACYITH A LA FIRM TO EXECUTE SHORT CUT ILLEGAL FORECLOSURES EVEN FOR LOANS AND

MORTGAGES THEY SOLD AT INCEPTION TO THE ALL STREET MORTGAGE BACQ SECURITIESDERIVATIVES MARQET HICH PAID IN THE FULL THE BALANCE OF THE LOAN BY THETRANSACTION OF CONVEYANCE TO THE COLLATERALIED DEBT OBLIGATION ORGANIATIONCALLED A TRUST HERE ITHIN A TRANCHE OUR LOAN IS NO ONED$& BEEN PLACED INFORECLOSURE AND FORCED TO DEFEND A FRIVILUOS AND FRAUDULENT LASUIT AT A HIGHFINANCIAL$ PRACTICAL AND EMOTIONAL COST$ CREATING AN INJURY THAT SEEQ REDRESSEDITH PAYMENT OF ONE TRILLION DOLLARS TO A NE .-*67 FOUNDATION TO BOTH DEFENDFUTURE FORECLOSURES AND AARD COMPENSATION TO PAST VICTIMS OF BOTH FRAUDULENTFORECLOSURE TYPE A 8BANQS FRAUD) AND B 8COURT INDIFFERENCE TO CONSTITUTIONAL


23/23

PROCESS$ PROTECTION AND RULES OF EVIDENCE) OR COMBINATION OF A \ B IN OUR CASE

FEDERAL REFERENCES

UESTION ONE

H(: 6!n Penn4%!n"! !(: ! 21d;ment #(3 #(3e6(13e :"t5(1t ! 5e!3"n;$ m165 e ! t3"!U&S& C(nt"t& Amendment V N(3 5! !n4 9e3(n =e de93"%ed (# "#e$ "=e3t4$ (3 93(9e3t4 :"t5(1t d1e 93(6e (#!:&

H(: 6!n Penn4%!n"! de93"%e 1 (# (13 3";5t t( 5!%e ! #(3e6(13e !:1"t !d21d"6!ted =4 ! 2134 (# (13 5(me(:n"n; 9ee3 J1d"6"! "mm1n"t4 !(: #(3 POSSIBILITY 8:e !3e n(t !e;"n; t5!t t5" 6en!3"( " t5e 6!e 5e3e:"t5 J1d;e G3"##"t5) t5!t ! 21d;e :5( m!e ! m(det !!34 =e$ #3!n4$ =3"=ed =4 =!n :5( 93"nt m(ne4 !t ! 0 t(* #3!6t"(n! 3ee3%e 63ed"t 4tem Ce3t!"n4 "t :(1d =e n!"%e t( t5"n t5!t *,.] (# t3"! 21d;e !3e n(t !t e!t!993(!65ed =4 =!n ( 6(3319t t5!t t5" !6t"(n (# "n#1en6e :(1d =e !"n t( ! 9!3"n; t"6et$ ( =e3e#t (# m(3!"t4t5e4 !3e&

U&S& C(nt"t& Amendment VII In 1"t !t 6(mm(n !:$ :5e3e t5e %!1e "n 6(nt3(%e34 5! e?6eed t:ent4 d(!3$t5e 3";5t (# t3"! =4 2134 5! =e 93ee3%ed$ !nd n( #!6t t3"ed =4 ! 2134$ 5! =e (t5e3:"e 3e,e?!m"ned "n !n4 C(13t(# t5e Un"ted St!te$ t5!n !66(3d"n; t( t5e 31e (# t5e 6(mm(n !:&

UESTION THREE

H(: 6!n C5!e NOT =e "m"ted "n t5e"3 !=""t4 t( en2(4 e;! 3emed4 !nd 21d"6"! 3e6(13e :5en !:1"t "ted =4;(%e3nment !;en6"e 5!%e 93(%en t5!t :"t5 3e;!3d t( #(3e6(13e$ =!n 5!%e 3e9e!ted4 6(mm"tted 9e32134$ #3!1d!nd #3!1d 19(n t5e 6(13t$ ! :e ! 6(;;ed t5e 4tem :"t5 #3"%!(1 !:1"t :e ! 93( e "t";!nt =ed"!d%!nt!;ed =4 !: "m"t"n; (13 e;! 3emed"e !nd "te3!4 93(5"="ted #3(m #""n; 1"t 8J1d;e G3"##"t5 (3de3ed1$ "n ! e9!3!te 1"t :5e3e :e :e3e P!"nt"##$ t( NOT FILE !n4 !:1"t !;!"nt ! m!2(3 6!3m!e3 de9"te t5e #!6t:e 5!d ne%e3 #"ed ! !:1"t =e#(3e) !nd d"m"ed (13 !:1"t ITH 93e21d"6e de9"te 6(9"(1 !m(1nt (# e%"den6e8 :e d( n(t !%e3 t5!t t5e 1"t :(1d 5!%e :(n "# t3"ed, :e !%e3 t5!t :e :e3e de93"%ed$ =4 t5" !me 21d;e$ (# t5eRIGHT t( t3"! !nd #13t5e3m(3e 93(5"="ted #3(m !n4 #13t5e3 !6t"(n ! "t :! d"m"ed :"t5 93e21d"6e AFTER13%"%"n; M(t"(n T( D"m" )

RIGHTS TRAMPLED UPONU&S& C(nt"t& Amendment XIV A 9e3(n =(3n (3 n!t13!"ed "n t5e Un"ted St!te$ !nd 1=2e6t t( t5e 213"d"6t"(nt5e3e(#$ !3e 6"t"en (# t5e Un"ted St!te !nd (# t5e St!te :5e3e"n t5e4 3e"de& N( St!te 5! m!e (3 en#(36e !n4!: :5"65 5! !=3"d;e t5e 93"%"e;e (3 "mm1n"t"e (# 6"t"en (# t5e Un"ted St!te n(3 5! !n4 St!te de93"%e !n49e3(n (# "#e$ "=e3t4$ (3 93(9e3t4$ :"t5(1t d1e 93(6e (# !: n(3 den4 t( !n4 9e3(n :"t5"n "t 213"d"6t"(n t5eeK1! 93(te6t"(n (# t5e !:&'

END OF EXHIBITS

CASE [ __________________

chase bank time 45

Documents