chapter-3 plan of work literature review - shodhganga : a...
TRANSCRIPT
CChhaapptteerr--33
PPllaann ooff WWoorrkk&&
LLiitteerraattuurree RReevviieeww
Plan of Work
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 79
3. PLAN OF WORK
1. Review of literature
2. Selection of dosage form
3. Procurement of drug(s)
4. Procurement of polymers
5. Procurement of chemicals
6. Preformulation study:
a) Identification of drug(s)
b) Organoleptic properties
c) Solubility determination
d) Partition Co-efficient (Shaking Flask Method)
e) Particle size (Microscopic Method)
f) Melting point (Capillary Method)
g) Standard curve Of Drug(s) (Uv Spectroscopy)
7 .Optimization and formulation of transdermal gel
8. Evaluation of formulations:
Static release study.
Viscosity
Measurement of pH
Spreadability
Drug content
Stability studies
10. Results and Conclusion
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 81
4. LITERATURE REVIEW
1) Gajanan Darwhekar et al., (2011) Transdermal drug delivery is an alternative
route for systemic drug delivery which minimizes the absorption and increases the
bioavailability. Orally Clopidogrel bisulfate has a short elimination half-life (7-8
hrs.), low oral bioavailability (50%) undergoes extensive first pass metabolism
(85%) and frequent high doses (75 mg) are required to maintain the therapeutic
level as a result, dose development toxic effect. The purpose of this research work
was to Formulation and evaluation of transdermal drug delivery system of
Clopidogrel bisulfate using various polymers such as HPMC, PVP and Ethyl
cellulose by solvent evaporation technique for improvement of bioavailability of
drug and reducing toxic effects. The prepared formulations were evaluated for
different physicochemical characteristics like thickness, folding endurance, drug
content, percentage moisture absorption, percentage moisture loss and weight
uniformity. The diffusion studies were performed by using modified Franz
diffusion cells. The result of diffusion study shows that formulation, F2 (Hydroxy
propyl methylcellulose and PVP) showed maximum release of 90.06 % in 24 h,
whereas F5 (HPMC and Ethyl cellulose) showed minimum release of 78.24% in
24 h. Based on the drug release and physicochemical values obtained the
formulation F2 is considered as an optimized formulation which shows higher
percentage of drug release of 90.06 % in 24 h. The developed transdermal patches
increase the therapeutic efficacy and reduced toxic effect of Clopidogrel
bisulfate.132
2) Mutalik.s et al., (2011) In this study the significant effect of chitosan on
improving the dissolution rate and bioavailability of Aceclofenac has been
demonstrated by simple solvent change method. Chitosan was precipitated on
Aceclofenac crystals using sodium citrate as the salting out agent. The pure
Aceclofenacnd the prepared co-crystals with different concentrations of chitosan
(0.05-0.6%) were characterized in terms of solubility, drug content, particle size,
thermal behaviour (differential scanning calorimetry, DSC), X-ray diffraction
(XRD), morphology (scanning electron microscopy, SEM), in vitro drug release
and stability studies. The in vivo performance was assessed by preclinical
pharmacodynamic (analgesic and anti-inflammatory activity) and pharmacokinetic
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 82
studies. The particle size of the prepared co-crystals was drastically reduced
during the formulation process. The DSC showed a decrease in the melting
enthalpy indicating disorder in the crystalline content. The XRD also revealed a
characteristic decrease in crystallinity. The dissolution studies demonstrated a
marked increase in the dissolution rate in comparison with pure drug. The
considerable improvement in the dissolution rate of Aceclofenac from optimized
crystal formulation was attributed to the wetting effect of chitosan, decreased drug
crystallinity, altered surface morphology and micronization. The optimized co-
crystals exhibited excellent stability on storage at accelerated conditions. The in
vivo studies revealed that the optimized crystal formulation provided a rapid
pharmacological response in mice and rats besides exhibiting improved
pharmacokinetic parameters in rats.133
3) Polli je et al., (2011) The objective of this work was to gain insight into the
biopharmaceutical performance of four different but bioequivalent ranitidine
hydrochloride tablet formulations. This analysis employed a recently described
method1 to relate in vitro and in vivo data and aimed to facilitate an understanding
of oral drug product performance. For each ranitidine formulation, dissolution was
performed using the USP procedure. A four-way, single dose bioequivalence
study (n = 14) was performed. The fraction of the total amount of dose absorbed
at each plasma sample time was determined by the Wagner-Nelson method.
Equation 1 (see below) was fitted to the in vitro vs. in vivo data. For all four
formulations, this analysis suggests absorption was permeation-rate limited, where
ranitidine exhibited a low permeation rate constant of 0.01/min.134
4) Updesh B. Lade et al., (2011) Budesonide is a highly potent synthetic,
nonhalogenated corticosteroid. The mechanism of action of corticosteroids in
allergic rhinitis remains unknown, but may involve reductions in number of
various mediator cells such as basophils, eosinophils, T-helper cells, mast cells,
and neutrophils. In the nasal mucosa, nasal reactivity to allergens, and release of
inflammatory mediators and proteolytic enzymes. Budesonide is very effective
and quikly acting as it is rapidly and almost completely absorbed after oral
administration, but has poor systemic availability (about 10%) due to extensive
first-pass metabolism in the liver, mainly by the cytochrome P450 isoenzyme
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 83
CYP3A4. The major metabolites, 6-β- hydroxybudesonide and 16-α-
hydroxyprednisolone have less than 1% of the glucocorticoid activity of
unchanged drug with a terminal half-life of about 2 - 4 hours. Polymeric films
containing Eudragit RL 100: Eudragit RS: drug (7:3:1, 7: 2:1) and Ethyl cellulose:
PVP: drug (7:3:1, 7:2:1) were selected for transdermal administration based on
evaluation studies. These polymeric films were prepared by mercury substrate
method employing PEG-400 as plasticizer. Two different penetration enhancers
Urea and Dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) were employed in the study. The patches
in each group were uniform in drug content, thickness. In Vitro drug permeation,
moisture absorption and WVTR studies were carried out on these test patches. It
was found that at all humidity condition the absorption increases which were
linear to the moisture absorbed. In PVA and EUDRAGIT RL 100 patches the
water vapor transmission rate was found to be higher at 75% RH, RT conditions.
Therefore at both % RH, RT condition the PVA and EUDRAGIT RL 100 patches
provide the best resistance to water vapor. Therefore, when applied to animals (in
further studies) these patches may provide more occlusion to water vapor loss
from skin thus making atmosphere beneath the skin more hu-mid that aid in drug
permeation.135
5) Arpad Pardutz et al., (2010) Migraine is a common disabling neurological
disorder with a serious socio-economical burden. By blocking cyclooxygenase
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) decrease the synthesis of
prostaglandins, which are involved in the pathophysiology of migraine headaches.
Despite the introduction more than a decade ago of a new class of migraine-
specific drugs with superior efficacy, the triptans, NSAIDs remain the most
commonly used therapies for the migraine attack. This is in part due to their wide
availability as over-the-counter drugs and their pharmaco-economic advantages,
but also to a favorable efficacy/side effect profile at least in attacks of mild and
moderate intensity. We summarize here both the experimental data showing that
NSAIDs are able to influence several pathophysiological facets of the migraine
headache and the clinical studies providing evidence for the therapeutic efficacy
of various subclasses of NSAIDs in migraine therapy. Taken together these data
indicate that there are several targets for NSAIDs in migraine pathophysiology
and that on the spectrum of clinical potency acetaminophen is at the lower end
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 84
while ibuprofen is among the most effective drugs. Acetaminophen and aspirin
excluded, comparative trials between the other NSAIDs are missing. Since
evidence-based criteria are scarce, the selection of an NSAID should take into
account proof and degree of efficacy, rapid GI absorption, gastric ulcer risk and
previous experience of each individual patient. If selected and prescribed wisely,
NSAIDs are precious, safe and cost-efficient drugs for the treatment of migraine
attacks.136
6) Eseldin Keleb et al., (2010) The human skin is a readily accessible surface for
drug delivery. Skin of an average adult body covers a surface of approximately 2
m 2 and receives about one-third of the blood circulating through the body. Over
the past three decades, developing controlled drug delivery has become
increasingly important in the pharmaceutical industry. The human skin surface is
known to contain, on an average, 10-70 hair follicles and 200-250 sweat ducts on
every square centimeters of the skin area. It is one of the most readily accessible
organs of the human body. The potential of using the intact skin as the port of
drug administration to the human body has been recognized for several decades,
but skin is a very difficult barrier to the ingress of materials allowing only small
quantities of a drug to penetrate over a period of time. During the past decade, the
number of drugs formulated in the patches has hardly increased, and there has
been little change in the composition of the patch systems. Modifications have
been mostly limited to refinements of the materials used. The present article
reviews the selection of drug candidates suitable to be formulated as Transdermal
system and the methods of evaluation.137
7) Raju.R.Thenge et al., (2010) Lercanidipine HCl is poorly absorbed after oral
administration with peak plasma concentrations in 1 to 3 hours after a dose.
Bioavailability is about 44% and extensively metabolized in liver. The half life is
about 4.6 hours. Lercanidipine HCl due to its low therapeutic dose (2.5-20mg) and
substantial biotransformation in liver becomes it ideal candidate for design and
development of transdermal therapeutic system. Lercanidipine hydrochloride
patches were prepared by using different concentration of Eudragit RS100,
Hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose and ethyl cellulose using solvent casting
techniques on a mercury substrate and the effect of polymer on the various
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 85
physicochemical characteristics and in vitro drug release studies, ex vivo skin
permeation studies. Formulations were prepared by taking 20 mg (Lercanidipine
HCl), 10% w/w of propylene glycol and 10% w/w of dibutyl phthalate in ethanol.
The formulations exhibited uniform thickness, weight and good uniformity in
drug content. The maximum drug releases in 24 hrs for formulations were
depending on the hydrophobicity of the polymer. On the basis of in vitro drug
release and ex vivo skin permeation studies, Formulation containing (Eudragit
RS100 andHydroxypropyl methyl cellulose) was showed sustained and extended
drug release over a period of 24 hrs. In Vitro and Ex vivo permeation of
Lercanidipine HCl shows that patches of ERS 100: HPMC are suitable compared
to ERS 100: EC patches. The results of the study show that Lercanidipine HCl
could be administered transdermally over a period of 24 h. through the matrix type
TDDS for effective control of hypertension.138
8) Vargas F et al., (2010) Aceclofenac (Airtal) (1) is a photoallergic and phototoxic
anti-inflammatory and analgesic agent. This drug is photolabile under aerobic and
anaerobic conditions. Irradiation of an ethanol-solution of Aceclofenac under
oxygen or argon at 290-320 nm affords via decarboxlation compound 2 as the
main isolated and spectroscopically identified photoproduct, besides
hydroxylamine derivates 3 and 4. A radical intermediate was evidenced
spectrophotometrically with GSH and DTNB, as well as by the dimerization of
cysteine. Red blood cell lysis photosensitized by 1-4 was investigated.
Furthermore, in a lipid-photoperoxidation test with linoleic acid the in vitro
phototoxicity of Aceclofenac was also verified. The photoinduced generation of
peroxide by compound 1 was determined during the irradiation in presence of
NADPH by chemiluminescence. In relation to the photoallergic activity of this
drug, the interaction of Aceclofenac with human serum albumin (HSA) has been
studied through fluorescence spectroscopy. No photoinduced binding was
observed after irradiation of compounds 1 in the presence of human serum
albumin.139
9) Belgamwar et al., (2009) studied and evaluated the suitability of pluronic lecithin
organogels containing flurbiprofen for topical application. Four formulations were
developed using flurbiprofen, lecithin, pluronic F127, isopropyl palmitate, water,
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 86
sorbic acid and potassium sorbate. All the formulations carried 30% w/w of
lecithin phase and 70% w/w of pluronic phase. The formulated organogels were
evaluated for appearance and feel psychorheologically, in vitro diffusion study,
drug content, viscosity and pH.140
10) Byrav et al., (2009) clinical studies have demonstrated that lornoxicam has
advantageous profile in moderate to severe pain in combination with an anti
inflammatory efficacy comparable to other NSAIDs. In addition, it may be an
alternative to other NSAIDs for the treatment of painful arthritic and
inflammatory diseases. Furthermore, it possesses superior gastrointestinal safety
profile as compared to other NSAIDs.141
11) Chandra et al., (2009) studied that microemulsions increased the permeation rate
of dexamethasone compared with the control. The optimum formulation
consisting of 0.1% dexamethasone, 10% olive oil, 70% egg lecithin:IPA (2:1), and
water showed a permeation rate of 54.9 µg/cm 2 /h. The significantly (P < 0.05)
higher anti-inflammatory potential. The nutmeg oil-based transtudied
microemulsion-based hydrogel was stable toward centrifugation test and was
nonirritating to the skin. The pharmacodynamic studies indicated that
microemulsion based on nutmeg oil demonstrated a sdermal microemulsion gel
system demonstrated 73.6% inhibition in rat paw edema. Thus, microemulsion-
based transdermal systems are a promising formulation for dermal delivery of
dexamethasone.142
12) Dhamankar et al., (2009) concluded that the two novel O/W microemulsions
containing ketoprofen were designed for improving transdermal absorption. The
components and their concentration range for the formation of microemulsion
were decided constructing pseudo-ternary phase diagrams. Their concentrations
were optimized after the evaluation of their effect on skin permeation of the drug.
Both the developed formulations were free flowing, translucent and spontaneously
formed. When microemulsions were gelled, they found to have uniform viscosity,
spreadability, elegant appearance and did not produce skin irritation. Drug content
at top, middle and bottom of the formulations revealed the percentage of drug
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 87
close to 100%. The results of physicochemical characteristics are satisfactorily.
Both the formulations are superior to marketed formulation in the respect of drug
permeation across the membrane.143
13) Hinz B et al., (2009) The mechanism of action of Aceclofenac is currently
unclear. This study investigated whether biotransformation to metabolites (4'-
hydroxy-Aceclofenac, diclofenac, 4'-hydroxy-diclofenac) contributes to inhibitory
effects on the cyclooxygenase (COX) isozymes in vitro and ex vivo. METHODS:
In vitro investigations were performed with human whole blood and human blood
monocytes. A randomized crossover study was performed in volunteers receiving
100 mg Aceclofenac or a sustained-release resinate formulation of 75 mg
diclofenac to assess the pharmacokinetics and the ex vivo inhibition of COX-1.
RESULTS: In short-term in vitro assays, neither Aceclofenac nor 4'-hydroxy-
Aceclofenac affected COX-1 or COX-2, whereas diclofenac and 4'-hydroxy-
diclofenac inhibited both isoforms. In long-term in vitro assays, Aceclofenac and
4'-hydroxy-Aceclofenac suppressed both COX isoforms. However, this inhibition
was paralleled by a conversion to diclofenac and 4'-hydroxy-diclofenac,
respectively. Maximal plasma concentrations of diclofenac after oral
administration of Aceclofenac (0.39 micromol/L) or diclofenac (1.28 micromol/L)
were sufficient for a greater than 97% inhibition of COX-2 (50% inhibitory
concentration, 0.024 micromol/L) and a 46% (Aceclofenac treatment) or 82%
inhibition (diclofenac treatment) of COX-1 (50% inhibitory concentration, 0.43
micromol/L). Moreover, ex vivo COX-1-dependent thromboxane B(2) synthesis
was inhibited significantly less by Aceclofenac than by diclofenac.
CONCLUSIONS: Inhibition of COX isozymes by Aceclofenac requires
conversion into diclofenac. Although 100 mg Aceclofenac yielded diclofenac
concentrations substantially lower than 75 mg diclofenac, these were sufficient for
a sustained block of COX-2 but caused a minor and shorter inhibition of COX-1
than 75 mg diclofenac. In conclusion, both COX-1-sparing and COX-2-inhibitory
actions of Aceclofenac may rest in its limited but sustained biotransformation to
diclofenac.144
14) . Hasan NY et al., (2009) Five new selective, precise and accurate methods for
the determination of Aceclofenac in the presence of its degradation product;
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 88
diclofenac are described. Method A utilizes third derivative spectrophotometry at
242 nm. Method B is RSD(1) spectrophotometric method based on the
simultaneous use of the first derivative of ratio spectra and measurement at 245
nm. Method C is a pH-induced difference (deltaA) spectrophotometry using UV
measurement at 273 nm. Method D is a spectrodensitometric one, which depends
on the quantitative densitometric evaluation of thin layer chromatogram of
Aceclofenac at 275 nm. Method E is RP-HPLC that depends on using methanol:
water (60:40 v/v) as mobile phase at a flow rate of 1 ml/min and UV detection at
275 nm. Regression analysis of a beer's plot showed good correlation in the
concentration ranges 5-40, 10-40, 15-50, 50-200, 1-50 microg/ml for methods A,
B, C, D and E, respectively. These methods are suitable as stability indicating
methods for the determination of Aceclofenac in presence of its main degradation
product, diclofenac. The proposed methods were applied for the analysis of the
drug in its pharmaceutical formulation and the results obtained were compared
with those obtained with the official B.P. method.145
15) Kisan et al., (2009) studied and investigated the suitability of microemulsion
based lecithin organogel formulations for topical delivery of fluconazole in order
to bypass its gastrointestinal adverse effects. Solubility of fluconazole in EO-
lecithin reverse micellar system was almost 3 folds higher than that in EO. Hence,
the present lecithin based organogel appears beneficial for topical delivery of
fluconazole in terms of easy preparation, safety, stability and low cost.146
16) Kannaiyan et al., (2009) studied the formulated liopsomal gel having CP of 1.5%
concentration would be stable and keeps the medicament for a longer time period
from the leaching process of the lipid bilayer. Thus, highly degradable, potent
drug can be formulated in this CP gel liposomal drug delivery thus enhancing the
potency of the Aceclofenacnd protecting the drug's therapeutic efficacy till the
desired period.147
17) Patel et al., (2009) concluded that the release pattern follows zero order kinetics,
which fits, into Peppa’s model, indicating that mechanism of drug release by
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 89
swelling. The optimized formulation containing Carbopol 934: Eudragit L100
(3:7), with enhancer hyaluronidase showed 84% drug release after 24 hours.148
18) Reginster JY et al., (2009) The aim of this article is to critically review the
potential role of Aceclofenac in the treatment of inflammatory pain and chronic
osteoarticular disorder, based on its activity on the mediators of inflammation, its
effect on cartilage remodeling and on the results of clinical studies comparing
Aceclofenac with other NSAIDs in these disorders. Aceclofenac has an
outstanding anti-inflammatory profile, involving besides a classical inhibition of
prostaglandins E2, a decrease in the expression of several cytokines including
interleukin 1 and tumor necrosis factor alpha. It also inhibits activated oxygen
species production and influences cells adhesion. Aceclofenac and its main
metabolite, 4-hydroxyAceclofenac, has positive effects on cartilage anabolism
combined with modulating effect of matrix catabolism. Clinically, Aceclofenac
has been consistently shown to have a similar efficacy than that of widely
marketed NSAIDs and a tolerance profile at least as good, if not better than the
profile observed for other NSAIDs in the treatment of osteoarthritis, rheumatoid
arthritis and ankylosing spondylitis. As of today, no head to head comparison
between Aceclofenac and coxibs have been performed, nor for efficacy neither for
tolerance. The specific profile of Aceclofenac makes this NSAID an interesting
candidate for long-term treatment of chronic rheumatic disorders as well as for
treatment of acute inflammatory episodes.149
19) Shashikant D. Barhate et al., (2009) Carvedilol, a nonselective b-adrenergic
blocker frequently used in hypertension, congestive cardiac failure and angina.
Transdermal drug delivery can be efficiently used for the active agents which
undergoes first pass metabolism, with this objectives, the transdermal patches of
carvedilol were prepared by using combination of polyvinyl alcohol (PVP) and
polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP K30) along with glycerin, polyethylene glycol 400
and propylene glycol as a plasticizers. The prepared formulations were evaluated
for thickness, drug content uniformity, folding endurance, percent elongation at
break, tensile strength, in-vitro permeation studies. It was observed that the system
with PVA:PVP in the ratio 8:6 along with used plasticizers was a promising
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 90
controlled release transdermal drug delivery system for carvedilol. Formulated
transdermal patches of carvedilol, exhibits zero-order release kinetics.150
20) Singh et al., (2009) concluded that the incorporating ketoprofen into bioadhesive
gels containing a penetration enhancer in various concentrations enhanced the
drug permeation through rat skin and in vivo performance. Bioadhesive gels of
ketoprofen containing oleic acid may offer promise as an anti-inflammatory
dosage form, ensuring more effective therapy, but additional experiments should
be performed before the formulation is used in humans.151
21) Belgamwar et al., (2008) studied and gave detail insight of pluronic lecithin
organogels (PLOs) as a topical and transdermal drug delivery system. Pluronic
lecithin organogel is a microemulsion-based gel. It is thermodynamically stable,
viscoelastic, and biocompatible gel composed of phospholipids (lecithin), organic
solvent, and polar solvent. Various types of therapeutic agents have been easily
incorporated in PLO to improve their topical drug delivery. Pluronic lecithin
organogel improves the topical administration of drug mainly because of desired
drug partitioning, biphasic drug solubility, and the modification of skin barrier
system by organogel components. Thus, in future, it has wide range of
applications and opportunities to experiment with various drugs in this type of
drug delivery system.152
22) Murthy et al., (2008) concluded that all gels were found to exhibit plastic flow.
The gel formulations showed good extrudability, spreadability and viscosity.
Formulation G6 was found to have better permeation and hence may be considered
as candidate for development of topical dosage forms.153
23) Maneiro E et al., (2008) Interleukin 1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) may play an
important role in cartilage degradation by inhibiting IL-1 activity and therefore
blocking IL-1 stimulation of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) synthesis. Nitric oxide
(NO) formation is increased during inflammation. High concentrations of NO
exert negative effects on chondrocyte functions. We investigated the possible
effects of 3 different nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAID; Aceclofenac,
piroxicam, aspirin) on IL-1Ra and NO production in human articular
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 91
chondrocytes. METHODS: Normal and osteoarthritic (OA) cartilage samples
were obtained from autopsy and prosthetic joint surgery, respectively.
Chondrocytes were isolated and stimulated with 4 different stimuli: IL-1, tumor
necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and insulin-like
growth factor (IGF). The 3 NSAID were added simultaneously to each different
concentration of stimulus. IL-1Ra was measured in supernatant by ELISA; nitrites
were quantified by the Griess reaction; PGE2 level was measured by enzyme
immunoassay. RESULTS: OA samples spontaneously produced higher levels of
IL-1Ra than normal samples (130+/-2.3 vs 30+/-3.1 pg/mI). IL-1, TNF-alpha, and
LPS produced dose dependent increases in synthesis of IL-1Ra. In their presence,
IL-1Ra was detected in supernatant at 48 h, but its highest level was measured at
144 h. The most potent stimulus was IL-1, followed by TNF-alpha. Fetal bovine
serum and IGF in turn did not modify the basal levels of IL-1Ra. In contrast to
piroxicam and aspirin, Aceclofenac 10 microg/ml and TNF-alpha 10 ng/ml
increased almost 46 times the basal amount of IL-1Ra produced by OA
chondrocytes. Additionally, Aceclofenac and aspirin inhibited NO synthesis.
Finally, the 3 NSAID reduced the levels of PGE2 detected after stimulation with
IL-1. CONCLUSION: Proinflammatory stimuli induce IL-IRa synthesis in human
articular chondrocytes. Aceclofenac may modulate PGE2 production by
increasing IL-IRa production and decreasing NO synthesis. Some NSAID exert
diverse prostaglandin independent effects.154
24) Vintiloiu et al., (2008) studied and gave a global view of organogels, with special
emphasis on the interplay between the gelator's structural characteristics and the
ensuing intermolecular interactions. A subsequent focus is placed on the
application of organogels as drug delivery platforms for active agent
administration via diverse routes such as transdermal, oral, and parenterals.155
25) Dooley M et al(2007) Aceclofenac is an orally administered phenylacetic acid
derivative with effects on a variety of inflammatory mediators. Through its
analgesic and anti-inflammatory properties, Aceclofenac provides symptomatic
relief in a variety of painful conditions. In patients with osteoarthritis of the knee,
the drug decreases pain, reduces disease severity and improves the functional
capacity of the knee to a similar extent to diclofenac, piroxicam and naproxen.
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 92
Aceclofenac reduces joint inflammation, pain intensity and the duration of
morning stiffness in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, and is similar in efficacy to
ketoprofen, diclofenac, indomethacin and tenoxicam in these patients. The
duration of morning stiffness and pain intensity are reduced, and spinal mobility
improved, by Aceclofenac in patients with ankylosing spondylitis, with
improvements being similar to those observed with indomethacin, naproxen or
tenoxicam. Aceclofenac is also effective in other painful conditions (e.g. dental
and gynaecological). In contrast to some other NSAIDs, Aceclofenac has shown
stimulatory effects on cartilage matrix synthesis. Aceclofenac is well tolerated,
with most adverse events being minor and reversible, and affecting mainly the GI
system. Although the incidence of GI adverse events with Aceclofenac was
similar to those of comparator NSAIDs in individual clinical trials, withdrawal
rates due to these events were significantly lower with Aceclofenac than with
ketoprofen and tenoxicam. Superior overall and/or GI tolerability of the drug
relative to other NSAIDs has been indicated by a nonrandomised comparison with
sustained release diclofenac in 10,142 patients, a meta-analysis of 13 comparisons
with diclofenac, naproxen, piroxicam, indomethacin, tenoxicam or ketoprofen in
3574 patients, and preliminary details of a comparison with 10 other NSAIDs in
142,776 patients. Further analysis of the above meta-analytical data has indicated
that costs incurred as a result of adverse event management are lower with
Aceclofenac than with a range of comparator NSAIDs. CONCLUSIONS: Trials
of 2 to 6 months' duration have shown Aceclofenac to be an effective agent in the
management of pain and rheumatic disease. Data from in vitro studies indicate
properties of particular interest with respect to cartilage matrix effects and
selectivity for cyclo-oxygenase-2. Aceclofenac is well tolerated, with encouraging
reports of improved general and GI tolerability relative to other NSAIDs from a
meta-analysis of double-blind trials and from large nonblind studies.156
26) Jain et al., (2007) studied that the application of clindamycin phosphate gel after
the pretreatment of skin with adapalene gel for 5 min may contribute significantly
to the increased efficacy of therapy.157
27) Lakshmi et al., (2007) studied that the Human repeated insult patch test did not
produce any significant irritation or sensitization on healthy human volunteers.
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 93
The placebo and marketed gels were compared with niosomal methotrexate gel.
At Week 12, with niosomal methotrexate gel, there was reduction in total score
from 6.2378±1.4857 to 2.0023±0.1371. These results suggest that niosomal
methotrexate gel is more efficacious than placebo and marketed methotrexate
gel.158
28) Ruiz et al., (2007) concluded that formulations containing Pluronic gel as a
vehicle and permeabilizing agent for transdermal preparations has increased in
recent years. Two transdermal formulations for Aceclofenacdministration as an
alternative to oral or parenteral administration were prepared and compared. The
characteristics of these excipients may facilitate the application and may avoid the
gastrointestinal tract and the first-pass effect.159
29) Dooley et al., (2006) Aceclofenac is an orally administered phenylacetic acid
derivative with effects on a variety of inflammatory mediators. Through its
analgesic and anti-inflammatory properties, Aceclofenac provides symptomatic
relief in a variety of painful conditions. In patients with osteoarthritis of the knee,
the drug decreases pain, reduces disease severity and improves the functional
capacity of the knee to a similar extent to diclofenac, piroxicam and naproxen.
Aceclofenac reduces joint inflammation, pain intensity and the duration of
morning stiffness in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, and is similar in efficacy to
ketoprofen, diclofenac, indomethacin and tenoxicam in these patients. The
duration of morning stiffness and pain intensity are reduced, and spinal mobility
improved, by Aceclofenac in patients with ankylosing spondylitis, with
improvements being similar to those observed with indomethacin, naproxen or
tenoxicam. Aceclofenac is also effective in other painful conditions (e.g. dental
and gynaecological). In contrast to some other NSAIDs, Aceclofenac has shown
stimulatory effects on cartilage matrix synthesis. Aceclofenac is well tolerated,
with most adverse events being minor and reversible, and affecting mainly the GI
system. Although the incidence of GI adverse events with Aceclofenac was
similar to those of comparator NSAIDs in individual clinical trials, withdrawal
rates due to these events were significantly lower with Aceclofenac than with
ketoprofen and tenoxicam. Superior overall and/or GI tolerability of the drug
relative to other NSAIDs has been indicated by a nonrandomised comparison with
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 94
sustained release diclofenac in 10 142 patients, a meta-analysis of 13 comparisons
with diclofenac, naproxen, piroxicam, indomethacin, tenoxicam or ketoprofen in
3574 patients, and preliminary details of a comparison with 10 other NSAIDs in
142 776 patients. Further analysis of the above meta-analytical data has indicated
that costs incurred as a result of adverse event management are lower with
Aceclofenac than with a range of comparator NSAIDs. Conclusions: Trials of 2 to
6 months' duration have shown Aceclofenac to be an effective agent in the
management of pain and rheumatic disease. Data from in vitro studies indicate
properties of particular interest with respect to cartilage matrix effects and
selectivity for cyclo-oxygenase-2. Aceclofenac is well tolerated, with encouraging
reports of improved general and GI tolerability relative to other NSAIDs from a
meta-analysis of double-blind trials and from large nonblind studies.160
30) Gattani et al., (2006) concluded that the polymeric matrix-type transdermal films
of ondansetron hydrochloride prepared with different grades and ratios of
polymers holds potential for transdermal delivery. A slow and controlled release
of drug versus time is linear and this constitutes the basis for transdermal delivery
of ondansetron hydrochloride.161
31) Kumar et al., (2006) concluded that to overcome all these drawbacks, liposomes
of methotrexate for transdermal drug delivery were formulated and evaluated for
drug entrapment, particle size and microscopically.162
32) Kim YG et al., (2006) A bioequivalence study of Aceclofenac tablets (test
formulation: Dong-A, reference formulation: Airtal) was conducted in 16 healthy
male Korean volunteers who received each medicine at a dose of 100 mg in a 2 x
2 crossover study. There was a one-week washout period between the doses.
Plasma concentrations of Aceclofenac were monitored by high-performance liquid
chromatography over a period of 24 hours after the administration. AUCinf (the
area under the plasma concentration-time curve from time zero to time infinity)
was calculated by the linear-log trapezoidal method. Cmax (maximum plasma
drug concentration) and tmax (time to reach Cmax) were compiled from the
plasma concentration-time data. Analysis of variance was carried out using
logarithmically transformed AUCinf and Cmax, and non-transformed tmax. There
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 95
were no significant differences between the medications in AUCinf and Cmax.
The point estimates and 90% confidence intervals for AUCinf (parametric) and
Cmax (parametric) were 1.04 (0.93 to approximately 1.17) and 0.99 (0.91 to
approximately 1.08), respectively, satisfying the bioequivalence criteria of the
European Committee for Proprietary Medicinal Products and the US Food and
Aceclofenacdministration Guidelines. The corresponding value for tmax was 0.75
(0.00 to approximately 1.00). Moreover, the modified Pitman-Morgan's adjusted
F-test indicated that the bioavailabilities of Aceclofenac in the 2 medications were
comparable regarding intra- and interindividual variability. Therefore, these
results indicate that the 2 medications of Aceclofenac are bioequivalent and, thus,
may be prescribed interchangeably.163
33) Ponsoda X et al., (2006) Cultured human hepatocytes are considered a close
model to human liver. However, the fact that hepatocytes are placed in a
microenvironment that differs from that of the cell in the liver raises the question:
to what extent does drug metabolism in vitro reflect that of the liver in vivo? This
issue was examined by investigating the in vitro and in vivo metabolism of
Aceclofenac, an analgesic/anti-inflammatory drug. METHODS: Hepatocytes
isolated from programmed liver biopsies were incubated with Aceclofenac, and
the metabolites formed were investigated by HPLC. During the course of clinical
recovery, patients were given the drug, and the metabolites, largely present in the
urine, were analyzed. In vitro and in vivo data of the same individual were
compared. RESULTS: The relative abundance of oxidized metabolites in vitro
(i.e. 4'OH-Aceclofenac + 4'OH-diclofenac vs. total hydroxylated metabolites;
Spearman's p = 0.855), as well the hydrolysis of Aceclofenac (4'OH-diclofenac vs.
4'OH-Aceclofenac + 4'OH-diclofenac; p = 0.691) correlated well with in vivo
data. The conjugation of the drug in vitro (24.6 +/- 7.6%) was lower than that in
vivo (44.9 +/- 5.3%). The rate of 4'OH-Aceclofenac formation in vitro correlated
with the amount of metabolites excreted in urine after 16 h (p = 0.95).
CONCLUSIONS: The in vitro/in vivo metabolism of the drug was surprisingly
similar in each patient. The variability observed in vitro reflected an existing
phenotypic variability among donors.164
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 96
34) Richards et al., (2006) explored the use of pluronic lecithin organogel (PLO) as
a base for the delivery of bioactive polyunsaturated fatty acids from fish oil,
eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and ketoprofen.
Oruvail gel (2.5% ketoprofen) was included for comparison. Unlike EPA and
DHA, substantial amounts of ketoprofen permeated when applied as infinite
doses. Oruvail, a Carbopol 940-based hydrogel containing 2.5% ketoprofen and
ethanol, delivered the greatest amount, although similar to the PLO gel containing
5% ketoprofen.165
35) Kumar et al., (2005) reviewed and gave an insight into the considerable potential
of lecithin organogels (LOs) in the applications meant for topical drug delivery.
Several therapeutic agents have been formulated as LOs for their facilitated
transport through topical route (for dermal or transdermal effect), with some very
encouraging results. The utility of this novel matrix as a topical vehicle has further
increased owing to its very low skin irritancy potential. The review also includes a
detailed account on the mechanistics of organogelling.166
36) Lim et al., (2005) formulated a transdermal gel containing an appropriate
enhancer for a controlled drug release. Terpenes, namely limonene, linalool and
cineole, in propylene glycol (PG) were first investigated in vitro for their capacity
to enhance the percutaneous release of an anti-psychotic drug, haloperidol (HP).
Relative to oxygenated linalool and cineole, hydrocarbon limonene was more
effective as a skin enhancer; it increased human skin permeability and decreased
lag time. Limonene was thus incorporated in an organogel comprised of gelator
GP1 and PG.167
37) Murdan S., (2005) gave an overview of organogels is presented, followed by a
more in-depth review of the gels that have been investigated for Aceclofenacnd/or
vaccine delivery. These include microemulsion-based gels and lecithin gels
(studied for transdermal delivery), sorbitan monostearate organogels and
amphiphilogels (studied as vaccine adjuvants and for oral and transdermal drug
delivery, respectively), gels composed of alanine derivatives (investigated as in
situ forming gels) and Eudragit organogels (studied as a matrix for suppositories).
Finally, pluronic lecithin organogels, descendents of lecithin gels but which are
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 97
not really organogels, are briefly discussed for their interesting history, their root
and the wide interest in these systems.168
38) Nemutlu et al., (2005) developed the Zero and first order derivative UV
spectrophotometric method for the analysis of lornoxicam (LOR). It was
concluded that the methods developed were accurate, sensitive, precise, robust,
rugged and useful for the quality control of LOR in pharmaceutical
preparations.169
39) Sen et al., (2005) studied that Transdermal nitroglycerine can improve analgesic
effects when used with other analgesics (Lornoxicam). The aim of the study was
to investigate the additive effects of nitroglycerine combined with lornoxicam for
acute pain in rats.170
40) Blot L et al., (2004) Since nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) may
impair the ability of the chondrocyte to repair its damaged extracellular matrix, we
explored the changes in the metabolism of newly synthesized proteoglycan and
hyaluronan (HA) molecules produced by Aceclofenac, diclofenac and meloxicam
in human osteoarthritic (OA) cartilage. 2. Explants were sampled from the medial
femoral condyle and were classified by use of the Mankin's histological-
histochemical grading system. Cartilage specimens exhibited moderate (M) OA in
20 subjects and had severe (S) OA in 20. 3. Cartilage explants were pulsed with
[-3H]-glucosamine and chased in the absence or in the presence of 0.3 - 3 microg
ml(-1) of either Aceclofenac, diclofenac or meloxicam. After papain digestion, the
labelled chondroitin sulphate ([-3H]-proteoglycans) and [-3H]-HA molecules
present in the tissue and media were purified by anion-exchange
chromatography. 4. In cartilage with MOA and SOA, the metabolic balance of
proteoglycan and HA was unaffected by diclofenac. In contrast, and in a
dose-dependent manner, Aceclofenac and meloxicam both increased the synthesis
of proteoglycans and HA in explants with MOA and SOA; these two NSAIDs
also reduced significantly the net loss of [-3H]-proteoglycans and [-3H]-HA
molecules from cartilage explants. 5. The data obtained in short-term in vitro
cultures indicate that, at the concentrations found in synovial fluid, Aceclofenac
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 98
and meloxicam may exert a favourable effect on the overall metabolism of
proteoglycans and HA in cartilage with MOA and SOA.171
41) Kyle et al., (2004) studied that the Fungi often infect the skin surface and
subsequently invade the stratum corneum to avoid being shed from the skin
surface by desquamation. Pharmacologic agents applied to the surface of the skin
in the form of creams, lotions, or sprays, readily penetrate into the stratum
corneum to kill the fungi (fungicidal agents), or at least render them unable to
grow or divide (fungistatic agents). Thus, topical therapies work well to rid the
skin of topical fungi and yeasts. The azole drugs are often preferred for these
types of infections. This article reviews various treatments of cutaneous fungal
infections, with special emphasis on cure rates and rationales for choosing
particular products.172
42) Muatlik S et al., (2000) The objective of present study was to improve the
solubility, dissolution rate, micromeritic properties and bioavailability of
Aceclofenac (NSAID) by formulating its spherical agglomerates. They were
prepared with different water soluble polymers (polyvinylpyrrolidone-K30,
polyvinylpyrrolidone-K90 and sodium alginate) by using acetone-
water-dichloromethane solvent system. The agglomerates were subjected to
various physicochemical properties, DSC, IR spectroscopy, scanning electron
microscopy (SEM), micromeritic properties and dissolution studies. The in vivo
studies (anti-inflammatory, analgesic and pharmacokinetic studies) were
conducted in Wistar rats and Swiss albino mice. SEM studies showed that
agglomerates were spherical in structure and formed by cluster of small crystals.
The agglomerates prepared with polyvinylpyrrolidone-K90 exhibited improved
solubility, dissolution rate and micromeritic properties compared to those prepared
with other polymers and pure drug. These optimized agglomerates showed rapid
analgesic and anti-inflammatory activity besides exhibiting improved
bioavailability of drug when compared to pure drug.173
43) Hoffman et al., (2000) studied that custom veterinary pharmacies have offered
methimazole in a transdermal gel containing pluronic and lecithin (PLO), with
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 99
anecdotal evidence of efficacy. The purpose of this study was to determine the
bioavailability, relative to i.v. and oral routes of administration, of transdermal
methimazole in a PLO gel in cats.174
44) Rosenow et al., (1998) concluded that the analgesic efficacy and tolerability of
lornoxicam, a new nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, was compared with that
of morphine. These results suggest that lornoxicam is an alternative to morphine
for the treatment of moderate to severe postoperative pain. Implications: After
surgery for lumbar disk disease, patients obtained statistically equivalent pain
relief with lornoxicam and morphine when administered by patient-controlled
analgesia. However, lornoxicam was associated with a lower incidence of adverse
events. This study suggests that lornoxicam provides an alternative to morphine
for the treatment of postoperative pain.175
45) Dreher et al., (1996) studied that the soybean lecithin microemulsion gel can be
used as a possible matrix for transdermal drug delivery. In vitro percutaneous
penetration studies of two anti-inflammatory drugs, indomethacin and diclofenac,
dissolved in the gel-system resulted in steady state fluxes of about 1 Ixg h -~ cm -
2. These studies indicated that the lecithin gel, in particular isopropyl palmitate,
affects the stratum corneum lipid organization even after 1-day incubation (FFIR,
DSC), whereas recent in vivo human skin irritation tests showed no significant
irritancy.176
46) Grahame. et al., (1995) studied transdermal non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
agents and concluded that topical NSAIDs as an effective alternative to local
steroid injection in cases of soft-tissue rheumatism, either where the injection is
not acceptable to the patient or where the doctor has not acquired the necessary
techniques. The safety profile of topical NSAIDs is good. Skin reactions are rare,
and this apparently applies to all topical NSAIDs currently available. It is logical
to treat a local pathological lesion with a local therapy, provided the agent is
delivered effectively and sagely to the target organ or tissue. Where this can
obviate the risk of life-threatening complications such as gastric hemorrhage, the
case for substituting local for systemic medication is overwhelming.177
Literature Review
Suresh Gyan Vihar University, Jaipur Page 100
47) Willimann et al., (1992) studied a composition useful in the delivery of
pharmaceutically active agents through the skin. In one embodiment of the
invention, the composition is formulated with a non- steroidal anti-inflammatory
agent, such as ibuprofen or ketoprofen; a muscle relaxant, such as
cyclobenzaprine; or other active ingredient .In another embodiment of the
invention, the composition is formulated with an antineoplastic or other
pharmaceutically-active agent. Such formulation is rapidly absorbed through the
skin to provide local delivery.178