change, flip, and listen david asai [email protected]
TRANSCRIPT
Terminal Island
http://blogs.dailybreeze.com/history/files/import/46084-japanesefishermen.jpg
Fish Harbor, Terminal Island
Sadaichi Asai(b. 1914)
Race matters
1. …is a property of a group, and so can benefit a field that depends on groups.
2. …adds different perspectives, interpretations, tools.
3. …trumps ability when the problem is difficult and when there is a large number of problem-solvers.
Scott Page, “The Difference,” 2007Princeton University Press
Diversity produces excellence
An Opportunity and a Challenge
0.00
50.00
100.00
150.00
200.00
250.00
non-Hispanic White
all minorities
Pers
ons,
in m
illio
ns
2010 2050
Opportunity: increasingly diverse talent pool
“Majority Minority”:
• All U.S. by 2042
• 18 yrs and younger by 2018
Challenge: we fail to take advantage of the diverse talent pool
NSF data for 2006, from Expanding Underrepresented Minority Participation, National Academies, 2011.
U.S. talent pool
28.5%URM
Scientific workforce
White + Asian
URM
9.1% URM
NSF WEBCASPAR (2000-05)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
US population undergrads science science baccalaureates PhDs
Frac
tion
who
are
Und
erre
pres
ente
d M
inor
ities
(%)
Undergraduate years are critical
G. Huang et al., 2000, Entry and persistence of women and minorities in college science and engineering education, US. Dept. Education, National Center for Education Statistics
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Whites + AsiansURMs
Complete Persist Switch Drop out
URMs leave STEM 2X rate of whites and Asians
Three suggestions
1. Change the metaphor
2. Flip the formula
3. Listen to difference
easy
hard
1. Change the metaphor (easy)
“Light at the end of the tunnel”
“Domino theory”
Metaphors can be powerful
“Fiscal cliff”
“Red zone”
http://www.sadeem.ae/Pipeline_at_Kuparuk.jpg
“Pipeline”
STEM Pipeline is Leaking Badly*
David Marcy, Cal Lutheran
Administrator, HHMI
High School
University, B.S.
Graduate school, Ph.D.
Post-doc (x2)
Professor (x2)
Many students today….High school
Community collegeWork
Military
Baccalaureate
Next???
Watershed
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/84/SAR_Map.jpg
Watershed
• Tributaries from many different sources, different environments, different pathways, different velocities.
• Boundaries between inputs are not always exact and can change with conditions.
• Outcomes are many and diverse.
STEM watershed
• Tributaries:– family-centric – transfer students– traditional
• Outcomes:– one touch– allied professions– specialists
2. Flip the formula(medium difficulty)
STEM business model:
1. High interest – 40% of all entering freshmen
2. “Gateway” courses
3. Research
4. Focus on small number of outcomes – medicine or PhD
- “weed out” 60% all, - “weed out” 80% URMs
- expensive, - emphasizes selection
Flip the formula:
• Active learning is superior to “teach by telling”– Scott Freeman et al., 2014. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
• Course-based research experiences (CREs)– scale – early– emphasize development of potential instead of
selection of past accomplishments
Mycobacterium smegmatis
GenBank
HHMI SEA PHAGES course
Accomplishments:
• > 2,000 students at 73 schools (2013-14)• students make scientific discoveries:
– > 48,000 genes (865 novel genes), 9 new clusters– 82% of mycobacteriophage GenBank sequences
contributed by SEA-PHAGES students– 17 publications (10 with undergrad co-authors)
• students do better in class • students stay in science
Jordan et al., 2014. mBio 5: e01051-13
CostsApprentice-based summer research: $5,500 - $10,000 per student (excludes faculty salaries)
SEA-PHAGES: approx. $200 - $250 per student for supplies, EM, sequencing (excludes salaries of faculty, TAs)
Intro lab courses at 17 “very high” research universities: $56 per student (excludes salaries of faculty, TAs). Range: $10 - $337 per student.
$56. Flip the formula.
Introductory courses = opportunity to make a difference
3. Listen to difference(difficult)
Practice, practice, practice
What’s important in mentoring?
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
MentorsMentees
Byars-Winston, Benbow, Leverett, Pfund, Branchaw, Owen, 2013.
Race Gender Talk about difference
Intent vs. Impact
htt
p:/
/ww
w.w
arh
w.c
om
/wp
-co
nte
nt/
up
loa
ds/
20
10
/11
/Priv
ileg
eM
ea
ns2
.bm
p
Faculty privilege
Biology 231 is the third course in our four-semester core curriculum for Biology majors. In addition, many pre-professional students from other majors, like XXXX, also take BIOL 231. Our course is a rigorous attempt to link molecular structure with biological function. We first focus on the macromolecules of the cell, including proteins, membranes, nucleic acids, and carbohydrates; in each case the message is that structure leads to function. We then discuss in quantitative detail the energetics of cell biology, including membrane potentials, the use of ATP in coupled reactions, the metabolism of glucose and oxidative phosphorylation to produce ATP, and photosynthesis. Then we put some of these pieces together, discussing in detail selected aspects of cell biology, including signal transduction, cotranslational insertion of membrane/secreted proteins, intracellular trafficking of membrane bounded organelles, and cell motility. All exams are answered with short essays or calculations (no calculators permitted!). The emphasis is on precise problem solving. For many, BIOL 231 proves to be the “weed-out” course.
Our course is a rigorous attempt to link molecular structure with biological function.
All exams are answered with short essays or calculations (no calculators permitted!). The emphasis is on precise problem solving. For many, BIOL 231 proves to be the “weed-out” course.
“Majority rules”
http://d1jrw5jterzxwu.cloudfront.net/sites/default/files/styles/article_header_image/public/article_media/changethemascotsign.jpg
http
://w
ww
.nik
keiv
iew
.com
/blo
g/w
p-co
nten
t/up
load
s/20
12/0
2/P
EK
IN-C
HIN
KS
.jpg
Individual vs. group
http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/files/blogger2wp/Gender-SexismMath.png
Identity defined by group
What’s in a name?
“I’m not prejudiced”
1. Unintended bias in the workplace….
• Emily…Anne…Jill…Allison…Laurie…Sarah… Meredith…Carrie…Kristen…Todd…Neil… Geoffrey…Brett…Brendan…Greg…Matthew… Jay…Brad
• Aisha…Keisha…Tamika…Lakisha…Tanisha… Latoya…Kenya…Latonya…Ebony…Rasheed… Tremayne…Kareem…Darnell…Tyrone…Hakim…Jamal…Leroy…Jermaine
M Bertrand and S. Mullainathan, 2004.Poverty Action Lab 3: 1-27.
2. What about faculty?• 6,500 faculty, 89 disciplines, 259 universities• Email request to meet to discuss grad school:
– Brad Anderson, Meredith Roberts– Lamar Washington, Keisha Thomas– Carlos Lopez, Gabriella Rodriguez– Raj Singh, Sonali Desai– Chang Huang, Mei Chen
• Whether faculty member agreed to meet “student”
K.L Milkman, M. Akinoa, D. Chugh, 2014.
Faculty are biased too…
• Faculty ignored requests from women and minorities at a higher rate than requests from white males
• Response rate decreased with:– Higher-paying disciplines– Private elite universities
• Response rate the same regardless of race and gender of faculty respondent
Milkman et al., 2014
3. What about scientists?
• Application for lab manager position• Fictitious male or female applicant• Evaluations by lab PIs:
– Competence– Hireability– Worthy of mentoring– Starting salary
Moss-Racusin et al., 2012. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109: 16474-16479.
Competence
Hireabilit
y
Mentoring
Salary
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
MaleFemale
Scientists are biased too…
Moss-Racusin et al., 2012. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109: 16474-16479
“This is for your own good.”
“mismatch hypothesis”
“…as a result of the mismatching, many blacks and Hispanics who likely would have excelled at less elite schools are placed in a position where underperformance is all but inevitable because they are less academically prepared than the white and Asian students with whom they must compete.”
Justice Clarence Thomas, 2013concurring opinion, Fisher v. U Texas
http:
//sd
.kee
pcal
m-o
-mati
c.co
.uk/
i/ke
ep-c
alm
-and
-bla
me-
the-
victi
m.p
ng
Testing the “mismatch hypothesis”M. Kurlaender and E. Grodsky. 2013. “Mismatch and the paternalistic justification
for selective college admissions.” Sociology of Education 86: 294-310.
• University of California– Elite: Berkeley, San Diego, UCLA (30% acceptance)– Not-quite-elite: Davis, Irvine, Riverside, Santa
Barbara, Santa Cruz (59% acceptance)• 2004, “Guaranteed Transfer Option” (GTO)
(2,300 students)• 491 chose to attend elite campus
• GPAs of GTO students statistically same as elite students.
• GTO students no more or less likely to drop out of elite schools.
• GTO students less likely to drop out than peers who chose non-elite schools.
• Mismatch effects no greater for minorities than for whites and Asians.
Findings….
http://www.examiner.com/images/blog/wysiwyg/image/Sonia_Sotomayor(15).jpg
“…And race matters for reasons that really are only skin deep, that cannot be discussed any other way, and that cannot be wished away. Race matters to a young man’s view of society when he spends his teenage years watching others tense up as he passes….Race matters to a young woman’s sense of self when she states her hometown, and then is pressed, ‘No, where are you really from?’….Race matters to a young person addressed by a stranger in a foreign language, which he does not understand because only English was spoken at home. Race matters because of the slights, the snickers, the silent judgments that reinforce that most crippling of thoughts: ‘I do not belong here.’”
Schuette v. Coalition…(BAMN), 2014. Justice Sotomayor, dissenting
Race matters
