champions and challengers - chess · pdf filechampions and challengers is designed ... more...

20
Champions and Challengers 100 Fully Annotated, Great Games of Chess, Played By Australia’s Most Talented Players. 1875 - 2004 The historical training reference by James Bonning

Upload: hahanh

Post on 10-Feb-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

Champions and

Challengers

100 Fully Annotated, GreatGames of Chess, Played ByAustralia’s Most Talented

Players.1875 - 2004

The historical training reference by James Bonning

Page 2: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

2

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................. 8

CHESS NOTATION AND SYMBOLS ............................................................................................................... 9

EXAMPLE GAME - CHEAP TRICK ........................................................................................................................ 10

AUSTRALIAN CHESS HONOURS BOARD .................................................................................................. 11

AUSTRALIAN CHAMPIONSHIP WINNERS ............................................................................................................. 11AUSTRALIAN OPEN CHAMPIONS ........................................................................................................................ 12AUSTRALIAN WOMEN'S CHAMPIONS.................................................................................................................. 12AUSTRALIAN JUNIOR CHAMPIONS...................................................................................................................... 13

GAME 1 - KNIGHT MOVES ............................................................................................................................ 14

FISHER, C - GOLDSMITH, L................................................................................................................................ 14

GAME 2 - A LOST LADY.................................................................................................................................. 16

CHARLICK, H - EIFFE, P..................................................................................................................................... 16

GAME 3 - PIN AND WIN .................................................................................................................................. 18

WALLACE, A - CRANE, W ................................................................................................................................. 18

GAME 4 - THE WANDERER ........................................................................................................................... 21

ESLING, F - WALLACE, A................................................................................................................................... 21

GAME 5 - THE GIFT ......................................................................................................................................... 24

VINER, W - WATSON, C..................................................................................................................................... 24

GAME 6 - PLAYING WITH WEAKNESSES ................................................................................................. 26

RETI, R - WATSON, C ........................................................................................................................................ 26

GAME 7 - FROM A DISTANCE....................................................................................................................... 30

STEELE, C - ANSALDO, A .................................................................................................................................. 30

GAME 8 - THE EARLY BIRD .......................................................................................................................... 32

ROBINSON, F - WALLACE, A.............................................................................................................................. 32

GAME 9 - DEVELOPMENT IS THE KEY ..................................................................................................... 34

GUNDERSEN, G - ROBINSON, F .......................................................................................................................... 34

GAME 10 - A KING WITHOUT A CASTLE .................................................................................................. 37

CRAKANTHORP, S - PURDY, C ........................................................................................................................... 37

GAME 11 - FROM THE BRINK OF DEFEAT ............................................................................................... 39

BOYCE, C - PURDY, C........................................................................................................................................ 39

GAME 12 - THE OUTSIDER ............................................................................................................................ 42

PURDY, C - KOSHNITSKY, G .............................................................................................................................. 42

GAME 13 - WEAK PAWNS AND MIGHTY KNIGHTS ............................................................................... 44

SALM, M - GOLDSTEIN, M................................................................................................................................. 44

GAME 14 - INFILTRATION............................................................................................................................. 47

LINDGREN, G - WILSON, D ................................................................................................................................ 47

GAME 15 - THE ONE THAT GOT AWAY..................................................................................................... 50

Page 3: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

3

MORRIS, A - ESLING, F...................................................................................................................................... 50

GAME 16 - POSTED KNIGHTS....................................................................................................................... 53

PURDY, C - LEONHARDT, W .............................................................................................................................. 53

GAME 17 - PAWN STORMING ....................................................................................................................... 56

BOOTH, S - FULLER, M...................................................................................................................................... 56

GAME 18 - STRIKING THE DRAGON .......................................................................................................... 60

FLATOW, A - POPE, A ........................................................................................................................................ 60

GAME 19 - REMOVING THE CROWN DEFENDERS ................................................................................ 62

KORBE, H - JAMIESON, R................................................................................................................................... 62

GAME 20 - A PAIR OF BISHOPS.................................................................................................................... 65

SELIM, N - FULLER, M....................................................................................................................................... 65

GAME 21 - UNTOUCHABLES......................................................................................................................... 69

HANKS, J - JAMIESON, R .................................................................................................................................... 69

GAME 22 - A SHORT LESSON IN DEVELOPMENT .................................................................................. 72

FULLER, M - PARR, D ........................................................................................................................................ 72

GAME 23 - CUTTING THE SUPPLY LINES................................................................................................. 75

GIARDELLI, S - JAMIESON, R ............................................................................................................................. 75

GAME 24 - THE FOX ON THE HILL ............................................................................................................. 78

JAMIESON, R - ROGERS, I.................................................................................................................................. 78

GAME 25 - MOVING FORWARDS................................................................................................................. 81

ROGERS, I - JAMIESON, R................................................................................................................................... 81

GAME 26 - A POSITION PEELED OPEN ...................................................................................................... 84

HJORTH, G - RUBANRAUT, S.............................................................................................................................. 84

GAME 27 - GIVE A LITTLE BIT..................................................................................................................... 87

JOHANSEN, D - JAMIESON, R ............................................................................................................................. 87

GAME 28 - BATTLE CHESS ............................................................................................................................ 90

MCGRATH, M - POPE, L .................................................................................................................................... 90

GAME 29 - THE ART OF WAR ....................................................................................................................... 93

GOLDSMITH, A - PRODS, A................................................................................................................................ 93

GAME 30 - COUNTERSTRIKE ....................................................................................................................... 97

JOHANSEN, D - HJORTH, G................................................................................................................................. 97

GAME 31 - THE NOVELTY ........................................................................................................................... 100

SOLOMON, S - GARBETT, P.............................................................................................................................. 100

GAME 32 - DEATH ON THE LONG DIAGONAL ...................................................................................... 103

HJORTH, G - JOHANSEN, D .............................................................................................................................. 103

GAME 33 – A PAWN STUCK IN THE MIDDLE......................................................................................... 105

MILES, A - HJORTH, G..................................................................................................................................... 105

GAME 34 - STORMING THE KINGS CASTLE .......................................................................................... 108

LANZANI, M - ROGERS, I ................................................................................................................................. 108

GAME 35 – THE PROBLEM WITH DEFENCE.......................................................................................... 111

ROGERS, I - KLARIC, Z .................................................................................................................................... 111

Page 4: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

4

GAME 36 – A POTENTIAL QUEEN............................................................................................................. 114

HJORTH, G - BYRNE, R .................................................................................................................................... 114

GAME 37 - WHEN KINGS CASTLE ON OPPOSITE SIDES..................................................................... 117

SIXTENSSON, M - WEST, G .............................................................................................................................. 117

GAME 38 – SLOWLY TIGHTENING THE GRIP....................................................................................... 120

JOHANSEN, D - GIBBONS, R............................................................................................................................. 120

GAME 39 – A KING SURROUNDED............................................................................................................ 123

GEORGES, S - LANE, G .................................................................................................................................... 123

GAME 40 – A BOLT FROM THE BLUE ...................................................................................................... 125

ROGERS, I - KUIJF, M....................................................................................................................................... 125

GAME 41 – RANKS AND FILES.................................................................................................................... 128

LEVI, E - JAMIESON, R..................................................................................................................................... 128

GAME 42 – A SUPRISE COMBINATION.................................................................................................... 130

JOHANSEN, D - RENET, O ................................................................................................................................ 130

GAME 43 – THE STRENGTH OF A PAWN................................................................................................. 132

GEDEVANISHVILI, D - WOHL, A ...................................................................................................................... 132

GAME 44 – CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE...................................................................................................... 134

DEPASQUALE, C - JOHANSEN, D ...................................................................................................................... 134

GAME 45 – A ROOK LEFT FOR THE TAKING ........................................................................................ 137

GOLDSMITH, A - DRUMMOND, M .................................................................................................................... 137

GAME 46 – BATTERING-RAM..................................................................................................................... 140

CANFELL, G - JOHANSEN, D ............................................................................................................................ 140

GAME 47 – LOCKED UP................................................................................................................................ 143

SOLOMON, S - CANFELL, G.............................................................................................................................. 143

GAME 48 ........................................................................................................................................................... 146

DEKIC, B - SULISTYA, M ................................................................................................................................. 146

GAME 49 ........................................................................................................................................................... 149

GARBER,S (2370) - WALLACE,J [C18] ............................................................................................................ 149

GAME 50 ........................................................................................................................................................... 152

DEPASQUALE,C (2280) - MYO NAING (2450) [B73]........................................................................................ 152

GAME 51 ........................................................................................................................................................... 154

ROGERS,I (2550) - MILOS,G (2515) [A41] ...................................................................................................... 154

GAME 52 ........................................................................................................................................................... 156

SOKOLOV,I (2630) - JOHANSEN,D (2485) [E44].............................................................................................. 156

GAME 53 ........................................................................................................................................................... 158

WEST,G (2405) - SEREDENKO,V (2335) [A45] ............................................................................................... 158

GAME 54 ........................................................................................................................................................... 160

SVESHNIKOV,E (2560) - GLUZMAN,M (2425) [B02] ....................................................................................... 160

GAME 55 ........................................................................................................................................................... 163

JOHANSEN,D (2485) - BARUA,D (2550) [A09]................................................................................................ 163

GAME 56 ........................................................................................................................................................... 165

Page 5: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

5

DAVIDOVIC,A (2410) - FERNANDEZ GARCIA,J (2465) [D76] .......................................................................... 165

GAME 57 ........................................................................................................................................................... 167

JOHANSEN,D (2495) - SOKOLOV,A (2525) [A26]............................................................................................ 167

GAME 58 ........................................................................................................................................................... 169

YANG XIAN (2415) - JOHANSEN,D (2500) [B66]............................................................................................. 169

GAME 59 ........................................................................................................................................................... 172

GEORGIEV,K (2660) - ROGERS,I (2595) [A57]................................................................................................ 172

GAME 60 ........................................................................................................................................................... 174

HUMPHRIES,B - PIZZATO,C [C24] ................................................................................................................... 174

GAME 61 ........................................................................................................................................................... 177

REILLY,T (2350) - WEST,G (2400) [A57] ....................................................................................................... 177

GAME 62 ........................................................................................................................................................... 179

WALLACE,J (2345) - LUKACS,P (2490) [C77] ................................................................................................. 179

GAME 63 ........................................................................................................................................................... 181

MICHELAKIS,G (2410) - JOHANSEN,D (2500) [E11]........................................................................................ 181

GAME 64 ........................................................................................................................................................... 183

ROGERS,I (2575) - PELLETIER,Y (2440) [B65]................................................................................................ 183

GAME 65 ........................................................................................................................................................... 185

WOHL,A (2400) - GIPSLIS,A (2470) [A30]...................................................................................................... 185

GAME 66 ........................................................................................................................................................... 188

WALLACE,J (2365) - JANJGAVA,L (2495) [D36] ............................................................................................. 188

GAME 67 ........................................................................................................................................................... 190

ARONIAN,L (2390) - SANDLER,L (2345) [B82] ............................................................................................... 190

GAME 68 ........................................................................................................................................................... 193

RUTHERFORD,S (2300) - JOHANSEN,D (2510) [B80]....................................................................................... 193

GAME 69 ........................................................................................................................................................... 194

ROGERS,I (2600) - WACH,M (2415) [B17]...................................................................................................... 194

GAME 70 ........................................................................................................................................................... 196

PHAN KOSHNITSKY,N - JOHANSEN,D (2510) [A43] ........................................................................................ 196

GAME 71 ........................................................................................................................................................... 198

JOHANSEN,D (2510) - CANFELL,G [E97]......................................................................................................... 198

GAME 72 ........................................................................................................................................................... 200

ROGERS,I (2570) - LUTZ,C (2595) [D58] ........................................................................................................ 200

GAME 73 ........................................................................................................................................................... 202

ROGERS,I (2618) - ORAL,T (2521) [D92] ........................................................................................................ 202

GAME 74 ........................................................................................................................................................... 205

ROEDER,M (2447) - JOHANSEN,D (2490) [A33].............................................................................................. 205

GAME 75 ........................................................................................................................................................... 207

ZHANG ZHONG (2555) - ROGERS,I (2618) [B01] ............................................................................................. 207

GAME 76 – WHEN TITANS BATTLE.......................................................................................................... 209

JOHANSEN,D (2490) - ROGERS,I (2618) [D16] ................................................................................................ 209

Page 6: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

6

GAME 77 ........................................................................................................................................................... 211

SOLOMON,S (2435) - MAS,H (2401) [B98] ..................................................................................................... 211

GAME 78 ........................................................................................................................................................... 213

HAGESAETHER,H (2215) - WOHL,A (2438) [B03]........................................................................................... 213

GAME 79 ........................................................................................................................................................... 215

SOLOMON,S (2359) - CHAPMAN,M (2351) [C78]............................................................................................ 215

GAME 80 ........................................................................................................................................................... 216

JOHANSEN,D (2505) - MARKOWSKI,T (2568) [A21] ....................................................................................... 216

GAME 81 ........................................................................................................................................................... 218

ZHAO,Z (2341) - ROCHA,S (2374) [B07]......................................................................................................... 218

GAME 82 ........................................................................................................................................................... 220

ROGERS,I (2558) - EFIMOV,I (2520) [C10]...................................................................................................... 220

GAME 83 ........................................................................................................................................................... 222

JOHANSEN,D (2520) - LIU DEDE (2378) [A09] ................................................................................................ 222

GAME 84 ........................................................................................................................................................... 224

ROGERS,I (2528) - MENSCH,E (2349) [A57] ................................................................................................... 224

GAME 85 ........................................................................................................................................................... 226

ESCRIBANO,J (2000) - JONES,L (2000) [A35].................................................................................................. 226

GAME 86 ........................................................................................................................................................... 228

LANE,G (2448) - JOHANSEN,D (2524) [B47]................................................................................................... 228

GAME 87 ........................................................................................................................................................... 230

JOHANSEN,D (2524) - GLUZMAN,M (2400) [D34] .......................................................................................... 230

GAME 88 ........................................................................................................................................................... 232

JOHANSEN,D (2526) - SMERDON,D (2326) [A16]............................................................................................ 232

GAME 89 ........................................................................................................................................................... 233

ROGERS,I - SMERDON,D [C12] ........................................................................................................................ 233

GAME 90 ........................................................................................................................................................... 235

SOLOMON,S (2347) - WALLACE,J (2386) [C68] .............................................................................................. 235

GAME 91 ........................................................................................................................................................... 237

FROEHLICH,P - CRONAN,J [A40] ..................................................................................................................... 237

GAME 92 ........................................................................................................................................................... 239

ROGERS,I (2569) – ACS, P (2623) ................................................................................................................... 239

GAME 93 ........................................................................................................................................................... 241

JONES,B - THAW,C [D18] ................................................................................................................................ 241

GAME 94 ........................................................................................................................................................... 243

SMERDON,D - YU,R [D41] .............................................................................................................................. 243

GAME 95 ........................................................................................................................................................... 245

CHAPMAN,M - ROGERS,I [B18] ....................................................................................................................... 245

GAME 96 ........................................................................................................................................................... 247

LANE,G (2420) - JOHANSEN,D (2499) [C03]................................................................................................... 247

GAME 97 ........................................................................................................................................................... 249

Page 7: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

7

SOROKINA,A - FROEHLICH,P [B87] ................................................................................................................. 249

GAME 98 ........................................................................................................................................................... 251

WOHL,A - GINSBURG,G [A16] ........................................................................................................................ 251

GAME 99 ........................................................................................................................................................... 253

ZHAO,Z - LANE,G ............................................................................................................................................ 253

GAME 100 ......................................................................................................................................................... 255

PETER FROEHLICH IM - GREG CANFELL FM ................................................................................................... 255

LIST OF PLAYERS.......................................................................................................................................... 258

LIST OF OPENINGS........................................................................................................................................ 259

NOTE ABOUT THE AUTHOR....................................................................................................................... 260

BIBLIOGRAPHY.............................................................................................................................................. 261

Page 8: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

8

Introduction

Today chess is stronger in Australia than at any other time in our history.

Champions and Challengers is designed primarily as an historical guide to one hundred great games of chessplayed by Australia’s premier players over the period 1875 – 2004. The guide also serves as a training referencefor players of all strength. Beginners should learn a great deal from the games which are fully annotated, andmore experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess represented with reference to themodern day. The first few games are easier to follow and are a more complete overview, containing almostmove by move analysis of why each move was played; where basic themes and combinations are explained andthe openings principles have been highlighted. This learning method aims at helping the chess novice develophis or her positional understanding so that he or she can cope with the later games in the text which become morecomplex as the game numbers progress and our Chess Masters become stronger players in the post World WarTwo period. As the games progress less more obvious advice will be given and not all combinations will bepointed out as it is expected that the reader will take delight in solving these for himself in gaining a betterunderstanding of why the text moves were played. More annotation will be used explaining positionalconsiderations as the reader continues through the games.

A very important feature for a games inclusion into Champions and Challengers, was its ability to help teachchess fundamentals, and as is normally the case with a compilation of great games, these usually serve as thebest examples.

The number of games represented here is not proportionate to the number of tournaments played in the timeperiod 1875-2004. Obviously more games presented in this list were played in the post World war Two period,and in particular from 1970 onwards due to the fact that Australia had built up a wealth of talented players in thistime period who’s chess work supersedes that of earlier times. The strength of Australian chess had no doubtsteadily improved after the Second World War, up until Australia had produced two Grandmasters ; Ian Rogersand Darryl Johansen and a number of Masters. This also helps explain why a predominant number of gamesfrom these two players (GM Rogers and GM Johansen) in particular have been selected for this book; it issimply that their work has produced many a great game of chess over the last 30 years of tournament play. Thiscan easily be justified by their relative playing strength and the number of tournament games played against highclass opposition at home and abroad over a long period of time.

The chess represented here is not always perfect, actually chess is almost never without its small blemishes fromboth sides of the table. Champions and Challengers depicts the chess that we all wish we could play over theboard. The games represented here are well calculated strategies and show how the Chess Master takes the plancreated in his brain and constructs the winning position on the board. Of course a chess brilliancy is only highlyregarded when the opposition is also a strong player himself and has not blundered the game away.

A great game of chess must not contain a sacrificial attack, a pawn storm, or a great attack, but what is moreimportant is the overall strategy used by the victor. Yes, often the sacrifice makes the win seem more heroic, butwhat made the sacrifice so important was its place in the chess plan and how it helped the strategic objective ofthe chess player. A great game can be the slow building up of small advantages, it can be the release of tension atexactly the right moment, it can be a winning combination, it could be the ability to hold an almost losingposition together, even an heroic kings march in the endgame, that which makes a game of chess so great variesenormously and in this book we will see what comprises of such a game.

James BonningSeptember 06, 2004

Page 9: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

9

Chess Notation and Symbols����� �������� ����������������������� �������� ������� �������!�����"����� #������$��% % &��������('����)*��% +������,�(� �����, -� �/.!��� ���0������� 0�#������ �1.!��� �2�3���/.!� �,�0�,�������,�����$���4�4��� *'�% �4�5&������� 6��(���7���,)(� �����3����8�����9����% � �5��.!�����:� ��������);� � 0��'�'�� ��+:<0=�����)����,���3�� "� % � �(��. � �������� � �5&������� ����9�4���.?>@�� "'�)(� �������% &/�34����*+��� 0����<A �(� � �������� 4��)0�,���"������)����B�$���.1�����.C��;'�% ��&��������$��<DE���0)9� ��+����( F������,);� � �9% .1��&���'��,������������)0���,� G�,���0HI��� �3�*'�% ��&����,��#�� ��.!'��� �����(��)0�;�,����%J�����������������)4�9��)'�� ���$���1. � % %����"����K(��� ����)��3��B 4��J�(�,����)����,� ��(LM���( *'�� ���� �(��)4L1���(% % �9��+����,� ���/(��% &/�2.14��:����,���*)�� ��+(���( �����,�"����@ 4��% % &0'����#�� )���);'����:+��� 4�:8�������)��3;��� +���% � +(���9�5��&0'����� �� �����<JDE���4�������$� �J�3������ ��+;'����� ��� ��/.!� �,�/�������% +��(�����9� � �$�7����)9� �����3����� � �����.N� �������0)9� ��+��,�� O���(% �.�P

QR� ��+��@��

jklmnopqh-R/%J'�T%/Q-_gP��P��P��P��^f��������]e��������\d��������[c��������Zb�P��P��P��P�YaQ*1T# V.#R1*X�rstuvwxy�

DS4���$��� �J�(�,����)����,��8J�����;% ���������,� ����)*���� *�����,� ���,�"'��@� ���3��)4�9% ���+���� )��0�����4)(� ��+��,�� 0��<T�������� �$�(%J�,�.1�/����,���4����������������,)*�����4�$��% % ��)��,� % ����8$�(��)*���,�;% ��������,��)����,� 6�4��"�(<UV���� W$������%����.1� ��������0�������$��������,)*���,�4���(% % ��)"���(���5� �9��);���� "���(����)0�,�,� YX1�3*Z:<DE���*'�� ������� ���,�*�������,��#�� �����)4�����$���)9� ��+(% &�P�[E� ��+"\][^8$_������9�4\*_48�=����!\]=`8�aE� ����('4\ba�8�[c��� +����9\bdDE���*'���.!� . � % %����4+(� #����*��0�9�����,��#�� ����� ��0����);��� �� 0�#��� 0�(����.!� % %$���;����3��)4(��% &!. � ���/�����*�$K(�����,�0�,�����9��� 0�#���� ����:<�e(��:��f��� *'�% �;� �������*�����#��4)9� ��+(���( ��;'���./�� 4�#�� ��+0���,� F��g4�0��h0. � % %J����.!�@� �2����0���"X�< ��hS<HI���(���;'�� ���$�4��B'���.!���$�('������,���!�,���4�5&� 4���%if!. � % %J���"���$��):<j �������9�J&� *��9% ��� "'�������9�����3*������������������� ��0���,�4)��������@� ����);���(% �.�P

k�7�k

�����J��% �����$� ��+���� )��k�7�k�7�k

�$���J��% ��� K������(����� )��

l ���������l(l )�(����% �4���������m ���������� 0�����n ��#��(�3&�+���)" 0�#��n�n ������f�����% % �(���( 4�#��o �* *� ������5�o�o �"��% ����)����9��:������� ����/ "� �J�3���5�n o � ���3�������J�,� ��+* ��#��B8$�����( �� ����,���+o n )������ ����� 0�#��:8������� 0�1.1�����

Ap�4% � ����������(����% &���� �!�,�����(% % �. � ��+*�J&� *��(% � ���,�"������)/./� ���4������'��������3/./��4�J�����)��������������q� �0�4+9� #����'����� ��� ��(P

l 7 HI��� ���;����� ��. � ����� ��+4��)�#������3��+�� 7 l aE% ����� ����� ��. � ����� ��+4��)�#��(���3��+��r HI��� ���;����� ���0��)�#��(���3��+�� s aE% ����� ����� ���0��)�#���������+��t HI��� ���4�����9��)�� ��� 4��.!�����9���������(� u aE% �����������(��)�� �$� 0��.!�����:����������\ DE���*'����� ��� (�*� � ��#����

Page 10: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

10

v w9x�y�z {�|�}�~�z y y5��yJ}3������w:{���}��}�z ��{/w����(}�~��0w�z �,yJ}�},z ���4}�~��;�,�������9�:�0���4��� �����������(}�~�z y y�~����}������(�4��� �4|����0�0w3���w���*z � z ����z y$��},z �({9���!~������4�0w����}�z ��y�~������"������{/�!�@z }�}3�({*z { ���2��� ���5� }3�;����}�}���B~��9� �*z {�}�~��;x�{����9��y�}��({��(z {�|4��w� ~����"��z ��{�y ��{�� � ~���� � �9{�|����,y��

Example Game - Cheap Trick� �2� �p�����

� � �(�5���������0���� ��*�� ¡�4�*¢2�9£¤�2����¥*���  ����p�(¦5�������2§4�2����¨(��¥;���©E���(��y$��}�}z {�|;z {�}�~��*�����({�z {�|

©E~��"�����!{�y$��ª���z w,z ª��« ����}~��������*�4��}��

Schwarz, H ��¬ ���$­��/�®���°¯;��� �2� ¬ ���������±�

- Bonning, J ��¬ ���$­��/�®���4²E�p���5³ ¬ � �������±�

´¤��}�µ�z y��,��x�}3�:�$¶�·:�¸�¸�� ¶�¹�¹�¶ � ¬ �����$�4���(�4�����2���� ·�¹:º$»�z x���ª$�b¼cz �({�z y�y�z �0�;½¡¾E� ��ª�¿���x��@{0»!���*��z }3À � § ¬ ����� ��¨0�(��¥;���

Á�Â�Ã�Ä"Ã�Å4Æ:Â�ÇÉÈ¡ÊËÇRÌ�Í*Ê9Â2Î�Ì�ÄbÇVÏ:Ä�ÐcÑ �Ò §��3���2��§��5��ÔÓ ������§��3���2��§��"� �/����£��$­�� � �*Õ�§����4� ­ ¬ �0� �"�p�9�4�������2 Ö�0§�¢��®��� ¬ ��¨9��×����(�*�����(§��2����� §����!Õ(��¨�� �;§��"�2���0� ��¢2��¥*�� @¨�� �� � ¬ ����� �*��­ ¬ ��Ø �©E~��;¾É� ��ª�¿���x��@{4»!���*��z }��5ÙÚ�1����¿!�4�������!~�z ª�~�������y�{���}�~�z {�|4}3�b¾E� ��ª�¿Jy �������(� �9���0�({�}(��x�}�y$��}�y �;��z }2w�(� ��w���´I~�z }��B� � ������§��2����� §��5�

Ä:Â�ÇÉÛ�Ã�Å�ÐÜ �$��z �(x�y�� �0����� z ����z {�|*�"�����!{4~���y�������{*� ��w�}:x�{�|(x����,�����:�J´I~�z }3�;��z ª�¿Jy�x��0��������0���(z y��({��(x�y������!{(��v }9z y��� �4��y�}(x�{�������y�}��({�������� �"�,����� � ���5´Ý~�z }3�4y����(��y!}3�;���4�({�}�~��*��}�}3��ª�¿��J}~�������}��({�z {�|4}~���wÞ4y$ß�x����,�:�Jàq�®áÉ����àSâ ã;z y}�~��4yJ}����({�|����B�4������àS���3� ������à;·:� ª$ä;á^wå4åB� ��ä*½,åB� ��·�ã:â���·:âpæ�ÀBåB�2������·*Þ:� ������·*����ª$ä0ç:�2áÉ��ª�ä;¾q��å�è

Ä:Â2Â�Â�é êBÅ:Ñ©E~��*���(z {�}¡��¾c� ��ª�¿ ~���y y����0��}�~�z {�|"���,�(���������:���9{��0}�~������;z {4{���}�}�z �4��w3�(�:����w�({��(z {�|0wÞ:â

Å9Â�ÇÉÛ�ÈÖë·:�2¾:��w�Þ�ì°v y y�� z |�~�}� �0����}�}3���:��� }�~���x�|�~�yJ}�z � �J� ��y�z {�|*��w�}���:·:�2����íS��Þ4å:�2áVª$ä4î���|�¶"Þ9��ïÉwÖ¸�á^wå�ð"çB�®¾q��·"½�ç:�2á���·(ìbáÉ����·ñ:�2¾:����·*ª�å�òÖì�ÀSç:�3�2� ª�å4ñ:��¾Sª5à;��å�ò¡ìSó·:�2áV|�à9ã*z y/�*�"z yJ}3��¿5�4��w3}3���9·:���3� ��·Sâ��!z {�{�z {�|*�"��z ��ª$�:�

Å9Â�Â2Â�é�Û�ê:Æ"Í9Â�ôÉÈõÁ!é Û�Ã�Ä�ö;ë:Â�ÎVÃ�Æ]ÇÉÈ¡ÊBÑ®÷

øRz ��|��@���

jklmnopqh-�%��T%/Q-_gP��P���1P��^f��������]e��������\d����'���[c�����/��Zb�P��P�#P��P�YaQ*1T# V.*��X�rstuvwxy�

ù�úûÁ � ²É� ���J³0£V� ���±�

Page 11: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

93

Game 29 - The Art of WarüEý þ�ÿ�� ������� ��þ���ý þ �� ��� ��� ���*þ���� ý �

�������� ������� � �0þ����þ����� þ������ ��� ��� þ9ý��� !�"�� ��þ��� #���

Goldsmith, A - Prods, A$&%��'���þ(ý � þ#�)(*�þ+!,�+� #������ �,-.�9ý "� %��/���10'2 31465�214573+895$;:<5�=+>?� !�@A A��� �B�C�A�D1E�þ �����#� � ���#��� ���

F�GIHKJ)L M)NKG�O?HKNQP;R�STJUGIL�JVPXWYSTZ1G�O?H1M)[<S,MUG�PXW\J,]�STSKGBO^L�N_O^L�`a?� þ+� �@þ+!

jklmnopqh-�%J'���Q-_g��P��T%�P��^f��/P��R/��]e����P����\d��������[c����P�1��Zb�T#�P�#P��P�YaQ*1� V.��*X�rstuvwxy�

b �ý ���A!�� �,�þ�� þ9ý ý A�c����+� �d U���� ���#�A���6 T ��C�A%��$ÿ.���T�C� �A����e�� � ý ����,�A����þ��f���d� � ��,� � þ+� ��þ(ý �g�6 �1+� �"�� �A� #��� þ ���*þ � !�� þ��+�A� � � � ���*þ�������QhEý þ��A�g�C� �A������� #!�þT�#� �'�3þ#���C�K4'�i � �e� � þ�����ý þ+�6� jA�9ý ÿ�!) ��� �/���!þ�ÿe ����ý þ�ÿ�� ��������, #���#��� ���e�d+� ��e� �+!4þ ���+�/þT� ���þ��+� ��þ�ý7 �� ��þ ���*þ�ý �� #%��#,� �+�$þ#�T"��)j�� �3ÿe�����6���'��� jA��� �e�6��)�C �/�������þ#�����/þ������ �.��þ+!T�T��� A�c��4

`UGk[KZ,L�Z,lUGBPXWY[KN�m�n/m8K4B4B4 � o)�C %�ý �4þ(ý �� �"�����ý þ�ÿ��+�K0$þ(ý �6� %��#.pq�� �6���d3 r s !T �jA��� ��ý � �7�9ý ÿ.�f �"�����ý þ�ÿ��+����+��þ ����ý �����c�c��þ �7� � � ���)�6��hEý þ��A�g�C� �A����K4

tKGIR�Z_OXW\MVFCmKGBP;R�Jpu+� �B�;ý � �7�����6 T����j��(ý #�T+� �e��� �����+�e"��#�� ���� � �e��þ����.��� #�A� �#� ��� % � ��� ��������� �A�f� ���� ���d ��K+� �e�+� �������+4

v R�lQF�F+G�w#J�O^x<S_F'NKGkx1ZQw Spu+� �B��"����#� ����������� ������� � �4þ��f��þ�����y�z �#� ���� ��K�� ��!4þ�ý ý ÿ�þT� � ���� �+��þ)�6 �"���� � �� #��� �+� ���)���,��þ !)��%��,"����f #��ÿ� %��U A���T�A� �����þ��d��þ+�'��ý �+�0þ9ý �� #%�� T��#�� b (ý ���A!�� �e�+� A�c�d�$þ %A��� #�e�B T������� ���K4

F�JUGBw+Za?� þ+� �@þ+!

Page 12: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

94

jklmnopqh-�'��Q-��_g��P��T%�P��^f��/P��R/%P�]e��������\d���P����P�[c��R1�P����Zb�T#�R1#P���YaQ*�� V.��*X�rstuvwxy�

{�|K}�}B}�~?���_{'�K}k�1��?�����#� � ���A� ��� �K���;�A��� �g�u�+� �f�g�������� ��� ����� �)�����f���A�C� ���e�d��� �,� �+��� �+�)�)��� ���A�d���+����� ���A�+�,���# ����U���+���A� � � ��� ����)��������¡A�����.� �  � �����e�C���'�� � �T�#�������+�e�� �U��� �A�U�)�  ���+� �+����������#�T� � �d� � ��� ��� �A�U� �A�6�)�6���,�+�+�)�+¢¤£<�  /���#���� �#� �&����'�+� � � ���)�f�����,�#�,���+� ���A���e�����d�6�  i£i ������C¢K�+¥ �#� �e�)�  ���� � �7�U� �.������+�¦�+� �f�������d�+�����+�����+���X� �����7������A� � � ���T�#�A� � ���,���+�)�T�f������T�C�#����� ����� � �e������+���#�)������� ����� �e����Q�i� ���A�g�C�+���T� �§������#���+�+���  / ����'�/¨��i� �����7���� ���C���&�����'�+� �������+�C��� �©�B�����.���  ��C� ���T�B��� ������  U�#���)�6���V��� �+�A�d�+� �A��� ���e�����A���������A���� �T�U�.����#�   ����A�����'�� ���T�#� �+��� ��� � ��¨�¥ � �C���+�)���������1�i� �����d�����e���,� � �#�)� ���������§������#���+� �,��� ����� ���e�����+�+�  ������  ��T� � � ����+���,� ���#��� �����)���A���+ª��#���)�U�e����,���6���  <���#�����q��� �B�����+�d�)� ����� �+� �6���+� � �)� ���.�c�,�C� �������T����+� �T� �C�e������ �e�+� ���C���d�  ��,� � �T� ����� �e�����Q�i� �+�A�d��� ���+�d�#�  �����6� �#�U¨��;�  ���� � ���������� ��������U�d���C�d�q�+� �B�����+�d�#�  ��� ���e���U� ��� ���������� �6� �#���U���������#�A�f�+�+�K¡������ �e� ���f� ��� � ���)�f�,� ���#�,���e����,�C� �����e ���� �«��� � �T� ���,�����#� �e�����T���B�B������¨�¥ �U� �c�c�#� ��C���A�¬� ����������������+���6���,�T� �T�+� ����� ���e�d� �6�������� � � �.��� � �7� � �g�����e�������K��� �.� ����� ���#�����d�����+� �����c��� ����U�A�+�#���K¨

­�®#�1�Q{��K}B­�® �1�V¯§­U°V{C±K}B²^�K�,³d´1�µ �# ��� ���)������ ����6 ��+���+���+����T¶ ����� �,� �.�T�  ��.�����'�f���)��� �T���6�  i�i� �����g� � �����#��� �T�������A�·���� ������f�#�����B�T���U�A��� ���������A���)�#�)��¸K¨

{�°U}B¯^´U®#���Q¯¹®#�1�Q{C�U}B¯X® �<�V²X® �9�Q{�ºK}k³g»Y|1¼�¼�u�+� �B�������d� ���T�C�+����� ���f�#� �e� ���#�.��� � ��� �����U� ���T�B�A���  �+���6���Q�X� �����d��� ���T�#���)�T�C�����U�������#� � � ��� �#¡��#����������C�A���+� �������# �T��� �6���)�C� �A� �<¨���� ���A�d�����c�d����� ���+� ���)� � �7�,�� �� � ���6� �A�U� �e�C���6�,�A� ����������� ��� �#�#¡'�½�g���A�# f�e�����6� �A���� �A���#���d� ���,�, ��+�#�d� � �������+�.��� ���e�6���)�¦�+� �f����� ���K¨��¦� � �f�T���U��� �)�+����� � �)�������,� � ���A���¿¾7À1¨½����¸T�#���T���f�f�  X¾'À1¨�¨B¨�K�6¸TÁ+ÂK¨�Ã;��¸��)� � �A�f�#� ���+�T�)���  f�)�+� �C�)� ���A�#�A�6�����1¨+¥k�����B� �����q�+� �B����� �����c�������+�C�+�+�)�e� � �7�,���+� �����+�  \�T¥½�.�f�+�'�����  ��T�  ��)���� �� � �,�����#�+� ����������� � �7�C���.�6�����+��+� �.�)���A��� �d� �)�����  ��� �U�A�/¡��A� �,��� �)�,� �C�A� �����q��� �B����¾'À Ä Å �)���A�K¨Æi���)�#�����g�# U�A� ����� �)� � ����� �e�������6�+�'�������� ���B�6�  i��� �+�A�7�e����ÇC� �T���A�)�6���T�+�+�)��� �d�)�f�  ����+�.�.� �e�6�   �q��� �6�K��?�����#� � ���A� ��� ���A�+�d�������  ��'�/¡��U� ���� ���#�����6�B�# +�d� �6���+���A� ���Q£i ������g��� ���,������ ���A� �A�,���B�f�# 6�K� ����+� �d��� �)�Q¥C� �©�A�+ ���� �d��� � �7�#� �C�,���  ��+�)�6�������u��� �6����¾7À1¨ Èg�É�� �d�,�T�����B�  /�+� ���C�K¨

{'ºK}B}�}B¯¹® ´K��u����� �#� ����¢VÃ;����� ��#� � ���i� �+�A���,���'�+�B� �'�T�6�������A�d�T� �K���,�C� �T�����+�C���)�6�  1�+� �)���U� ���.�C�)���T�A��� �+� �������/¨�£i ������¶ �����'�� � ����������#���  /���#���g�u�+� �f����¾7À Ä Å �T�����.�c�+�e� ���+�����,�,��� �'�f� �7� ¢,Ê.��� �.�����,�+�+�T�e�d� � ���f�#� �I¨

Ë?� �+�  ��+�

Page 13: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

95

jklmnopqh-��J'-���_g��P����P��^f���P���%�]e������T%�\d���R/��#�[c��R1�P� ��Zb�T#���P���YaQ*���V.��*X�rstuvwxy�

Ì ÍUÎ Ï)Ð#ÑÒiÓ�Ô,Õ�Ô+Ö × Ø�Ø × Ø�Ö,Ù�Ú Ù#Ø�Ô,Ù�Ú+Û6Ó�Ô�Ú�× Ø�Ô�Ü�Û+Ý�Ù#Þ,Õ+× Ø�ß�Û�× ÙUØ�Üe× Ø�Û6Ó�Ô�Ó+× Ü�ÛfÙ#àfáeÙ�Ú�â&ã�Ü�Ûà�ß ä × ß Ø)Ý�Ó�Ô�ÜCÜ�å�æ Ù#àKç�Ù ä è�ÜCÞ,× ÛÓ.Û6ÙÓ�ß�éAÔTÝ�ß ä ÝAã ä ß�ÛfÔ+è�Û�Ó�Ôeêd× ØeÚ6Ù à ëqÓ�× ÛBÔTß�ÚBÛfÔ àXì�íKî ïgÚð�× ÛU× Ü�Û6à/ã�ä áeß Þ)ß�ñ�× Ø�Ö,ß+ÜeÓ�ÔeêgÙ ã+ä è�Ó�ß�é�Ô�Ó�ß�è)Û6Ù�Ó�ß�é�Ô)ÜCÔ�Ô#Ø�ß�Ûä Ô�ß�Ü�Ûiì7ò,ÞTÙ�é�Ô�Üdè�Ô+Ô#ó#ôCß Ø�è�× Ú1Ø�Ù�ÛUÓ�Ô�Ó�ß�Üeó+ä ß�á�Ô�èTÛ6Ó�Ô,Ö�ß Þ)Ô,Ù�ÚUÓ × Üeä × ÚfÔ,ß#ØCá'êcß�áeß+Ü�ÛÓ�Ô)ÝCÙ à/àÔ�Ý�Û ÞTÙ�é�Ô,× Üó�ä ß�á�Ô+è�ÕCá.ëuÓ�× ÛBÔ�à/× Ö ÓAÛUã+ó.Û6Ù)ÛÓ�Ô�éAÔ à6á)ä ß�Ü'ÛUÞ�Ù�éAÔ,Ù�Ú+ÛÓ+× ÜdÖ�ß+ÞTÔ1î+õ Û+ÜAÓ�ÙUã�ä èTß#ä Ü�Ù�Õ�Ô�Ø�Ù+ÛBÔ�è)Û�Ó�ß�Û<öiä ß+ÝA÷7Üè�Ô�ÚfÔUØ�ÜA× éAÔTÜA÷C× ä ä'× Ü.Ù�Ú Û6Ó�ÔeÚ�× àÜ�Û+ÝAä ß�ÜCÜdß Ø�è�Ó�Ô,è�Ù+Ô�Ü�Ø�Ù�ÛKä Ô�Û ßeêd× ØeÜ�ä × ó)ßAêcß�á ø�Ó�Ô�× Üeä Ù�Ü'Û#ß�ÚfÛBÔ àUë¦Ó × ÛfÔ�Ü�ì�í ù ú Þ)Ù�é�Ô1î

û;ü�Ì ý,Ì1þ+Î�ÿ��1Ì��§Ð��� Ú ÝCÙ ã�à�Ü�ÔVö�ä ß�ÝA÷gÝCß ØTØ�Ù�Û Ý�ß óAÛ�ã�à�Ô)Û�Ó�Ô�àÙ�Ù#÷.Õ�Ô�ÝCß ã�Ü�Ô,Ù�Ú+Û�Ó�ÔTÝAÓ�Ô+ÝA÷'Þ)ß�ÛfÔTÛÓ�àÔ+ß�Û Ù Ø,Ó��Kî7â§ä ÛÓ�Ù#ã�ÖUÓeÛ6Ó�ß�Û#× ÜØ�Ù�Û6Ó × Ø�ÖTÛfÙeêgÙ à/àfáeß#Õ�Ù ã�Û/ôA× ÚUÓ�Ô�à�Ô�ßUä ä áeÝAà�ß�éAÔ+Ü�Û6Ó�ß+Û+ß<ì.à�Ù�Ù ÷«ëqÓ�× ÛfÔ.ê.× ä ä'ä Ô�Û#Ó × Þ Ó�ß�é�Ô�× Û#ß ØCá�êcß�á å

Ì�ÌKÎBû��ç.× é�× Ø�ÖTÛÓ�Ô�÷�Ø+× Ö#Ó�Û+ß,Ö à�Ô�ß�ÛUó�Ù�Ü'Û�ê.Ó�Ô à�Ô�Ó�Ôeêgß�ÛfÝAÓ�Ô�ÜdÙ�éAÔ àKÛ6Ó�ÔQöiä ß�Ý�÷d÷�× Ø�Ö�Ü�× è+ÔKôCß ä Þ)Ù�Ü�Û+ß#ä àÔ+ß+è�á.ÛÓ�à�Ô�ß�ÛfÔ Ø+× Ø�Ö)ÛfÙó�ä ß�á��UðUî� XÚ�������ß#ä Û�Ó�Ù ã�Ö ÓeÛ�Ó�ß�Û�êgÙ#ã+ä è)ÙUØ�ä áTä Ô+ß+è)ÛBÙ,Ô��#ã�ß ä × Û½áeÙUØeÛ6Ó�Ô,Ø�Ô��CÛ#Þ�Ù�éAÔ�� ô�Õ�ã�Û ÞTÙ à�Ô�× Þ�ó�Ù#à6Ûfß#ØAÛä á.ÛÓ�ÔÞ)Ù�é�Ô����1î� ^è��TÙ#ó�Ô#Ø�Üeã+óeÛÓ�Ô�ó�à�Ô�Ý�× Ù ã�ÜdèU× ß Ö�Ù Ø�ß ä Ú6Ù à#ÛÓ�Ô�Õ+× ÜAÓ�Ù ó�Ù#Ø,Õ��1î

Ì+ÌKÎ�ÎBÎfû��� 1þõ Ú1ö�ä ß�ÝA÷gÝCß ØTØ�Ù�Û Ü�Ô�ÔTÛÓ�Ô,è�ß Ø�Ö�Ô à9× Ø�Ý�ßUóAÛã�à�× Ø�Ö)Û�Ó�Ô�à�Ù+Ù ÷cÛÓ�Ô#Ødê�ÓCáeÜ�Ó�Ù ã+ä è�Ó�Ô,Ø�Ù�Û"!

Ì+ÑUÎ#��$%�'&(&öià/× ä ä × ß ØAÛ/å'ëqÓ�× ÛfÔTßU× Þ)Üdß�Û ÛBÔ�ß#à/× Ø�Ö,Ù ó�Ô ØeÛ�Ó�ÔQöiä ß�ÝA÷d÷C× Ø�ÖTÜ�× è+Ô)ß+Û+ß#ä ä�ÝCÙ�Ü'ÛfÜ�å

Ì+ÑUÎBÎ�ÎkÏ*)�+� ÛÓ�Ô àKÞ)Ù�é�Ô�Ü.ß à�Ô�Ø�Ù�Õ�Ô+Û�ÛfÔ à Ú6Ù àiöiä ß�Ý�÷�îâ-, �#ðKî�îBîkÖ���Ú.��!�!/��09î ï1��Ó��eê�× Û6ÓTÞ)ß�ÛfÔTÛBÙ2�#ã�× Ý�÷�ä ádÚÙ ä ä ÙAêeîö3,4�UðUîBî�î ï1��Ú.�/��0<î� ���Ú.����ê.× Ø�Ü+ô5 ,4�#ðUîfî�î� ���Õ�ð��/��09î ß���Õ�ð)ïeÕ��/���1î ï1��Ó��,ß Ø�èeêcÔ�Ó�ß�éAÔTÛÓ�ÔTÜ�ß Þ)Ô�ê�× Ø+Ø�× Ø�Ö�ä × Ø�Ô)Û�Ó�ß�Û�ëuÓ+× ÛfÔ�ó�ä ß�áAÜe× ØeÛÓ�Ô)Ö ß+ÞTÔ

Ì�61Î Ï1�1Ð7�'&8&9?× ß+Ö à�ß+Þ

Page 14: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

96

jklmnopqh-J'��-���_g��P����P��^f���P��T#%J ]e���1����\d������#�[c����P����Zb���V.�P���YaR/������*X�rstuvwxy�

:�;=<�>@?7AB<'CEDF?�G H�>�A2I JLK�>@M�N�O8I PLI NE<�>�M/Q�R�<�<�SBM�>*K�<TK�M�>F>@<�<�S�J�K�</<�S�H2?�P�K�I >FU�OL<�M�J�N@?�A2V�I S�M�J.I ?�S�WX�Y'Z#Z�Z\[�]^�_

`aK�<�O�<bI >�S�?/?�J�K�<�OcAB?�d�<BefK�I J#<*;1M�>gJ.K�OL<�M�J#<�S�I S�UBJh;1?/H�I P#P"<7O�<�S�J�N�K�<�N�i@A�M�J#<�>�WX�j'Z�k�]^�_�lm^�n

o J�N@?7R�G H2p�?�>@>�I V�G qBK�M�p�p�<7S�J.K�M�J�VEq*NE?�I S�N�I H�<7S�N@</M/N�K�<�>@>*p�G M�q�<�OK�M�p�p�<7S�<�H/J#?/M�J�J"M7I S�>�I A2I G M�Op�?�>�I JLI ?7S�>gJLK�M�JefK�I J#<TK�M�>*K�<�O8<'C�V�R�J�J�K�<�STo�H�?7R�V�J�K�<*;1?�R�G HbK�M�d�<�P.?7R�S�H2<�d�<�O.q*?�S�</?�P�erK�I J"<�>*AB?�d�<�>FM�>�Dg?�G H�>�AbI J�KBH�?�<�>I S*J�K�I >FU�M�AB<'W

X�_�Z#l�s%jtu P�NE?�R�OL>@<BJ�K�<TV�I >�K�?7pB?�S/K�v2S�<�<�H�>gJ.?2V�<2M�J�J.M�N�iw<�H/M�>BI J7I >�p�I S�S�<�Hx�p�I S�S�<�HBJ.?BJ.K�<2K�y/>@Q�R�M7O�<�;gK�I N�KBI JU�R�M�O�H�>gJ.K�<{zaG M�N�iFi@I S�U�PLO�?7A|N�K�<�N�i@A�M�J"<W

X�_�Z�Z#Z�k�}�_u J�K�<�O'AB?�d�<�>�M�OL<*;=<�M�i4<�O~W���W�W#W �FH�yB�7v�W�����K�vB�1�EP"�/��yW����EP.���bM�S�H2I J">�S�?�J�A/R�N�K�P8R�S�P"?�O�z�G M�N�i1M�S�q�A/?�OL<'W#x���W�W#W#�'P"y/��v'W�����K�vT��<��B��yW���K�y��cx���W�W#W#z'�@P.����v�W���K�y��

X�n�Z#k�]^7n�k�]�s�_/X���Z"��]�s�_�����s��/X��'Z#���cn��ct��@����c<�O.P.<�N4J7O(I U�K�J'R�p2R�S�JLI G�JLK�<TG M�>4J7AB?�d�<'C4efK�I J"<BNE?7R�G H/>4J�I G GEK�M�d�<2H�O�?7p�p�<�HBJLK�<Tp�?7I S�J�VEqBp�G M�q�I S�U/���'W#��K�y����2M�>M�P"J"<�O7���W�W#W#�cU�v2���'W#����V�yT����V�yBe�K�I J"<bI >�S�?TG ?�S�U�<�O�;FI S�S�I S�U/<�d�<�SBM�P"J.<�OK�</N@M�p�J�R�O�<�>gJ�K�<�J�OLM7p�p�<�Hbi@S�I U�K�J7?�SMc��Ww:3P"J#<�O'���'W���H�v��{z�G M�N�iFOL<�>�I U7S�>FM�>*K�<Ti@S�?�;=>gJ.K�M�J�JLK�<bi@S�I U7K�J�?�SBM���I >gJ�O�M7p�p�<�H2M7S�HbK�</J�K�<�OL<�P.?�O�<TK�M�>gJ#?<�S�J#<�O'M7S�<7S�H�U�M�AB<�;gI J�K�MTp�I <�N�<bG <�>@>�x ���'W���H�v�� �c<�v2���'W�����V�y�����V�y2���W���K�F�7¡

Page 15: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

97

Game 30 - Counterstrike¢a£�¤2¥�¦�§�¥�¨�©�ª�¤�ªb«E¬ ¦�§¢�£�¤/­@®�¥�¦�¯#¤7©�¨�¯#¯.¨�­�«

°'±�­�£�¨7¦�§7¬ ¦�§b¬ ¦�¯"®2¨�²g¬ ¦�¦�¬ ¦�§B¤�¦�ª�§�¨�³B¤´c¨�µEµ@¤�ªb¶�¨�²g¦�µ

Johansen, D - Hjorth, G·¸¥�µ@¯.©L¨�¹ ¬ ¨7¦Bº»£�¨�³2¶�¬ ®�¦�µ�£�¬ ¶7¼�½*¤�¹ ¾�®�¥�©(¦�¤'¼7¿@À�Á Âc¿�Á.¿wÃ�Ä�źF¿�¿�Æ�Ç'©�¤�¦�­�£7Æ�º-¹ ¨�µ@µ�¬ ­@¨7¹4È�É�µ@¯#¤�³TÆ@Êb¤�Ë/¨7¦�ªBÊ�Ì�§�ËBª�±�¤�Ê

Í�Î\Ï�Ð�Ñ�Ò%ÓBÔ'Î#Ñ�Õ�Ö2Ï�Ó2Ö�Î ×Ð/×cØ/Ð'Î�Ù�ÚcØ2×�Û�Ï�Ð2Ø�Î#Ñ3Û�Ï�Ð�Ù�Ï�Ü/Ó�Î#Ù3Û�Ò�ÓBÚ'Û�Ò%Ó2Ü'Î ÚÖ�Ò�Ø2Ý�Î#Ñ�Õ�Ö�Ù�Ò%Ó/ÞÎ�Ñ�Ò�Ö{Ñ�Õ�Óß�¬ ¨�§�©8¨�³

jklmnopqh-�%J'���Q-_gP��P������^f��/��T%��]e��������\d���P�����[c��R1��1P��Zb�P����P��P�YaQ*�� V.#�*X�rstuvwxy�

¢a£�¤2¶�©�¤�µEµ�¥�©L¤2®�¦�ª�Ê�¾�¥�¬ ¹ ª�µ�ÁÍ@à�Î\×Ø

·¸¦�®�¯�£�¤�©c¬ ª�¤�¨�á.®�©7âf£�¬ ¯"¤T£�¤�©L¤T¬ µb¿wÂcÁ�Ìa¾�Ë/Â�ã(Âä¿�¿�Á#Ì'±�­@åb¾E±�­@å'¼w²F£�¤�©L¤2¨�¹ ¯�£�®�¥�§�£TÌa¹ ¨�­�«F£�¨�µg¯�£�¤b¾�¬ µ�£�®�¶2¶�¨7¬ ©£�¤£�¨�µF¨2¶�©�¤�¯�¯�ÉB¾�¥�µ@¯#¤�ª2¥�¶/¶�¨�²g¦�á�®�©8³�¨�¯�¬ ®7¦�¼@¨7¦�ªB¯L£�¤/­�£�¨�¦�­E¤�µFµ@¤�¤7³|¨�¾�®�¥�¯7¤�æ�¤�¦�Á

Í@à'Î�Î#Î�Ñ�ç'Ðè'é.®�©�¯.£/³2¥�µ@¯�¯.¨�«w¤b©L¤�¨7¹4¶�©(¬ ª�¤T¬ ¦2£�¬ µ�¾�¬ µ�£�®�¶�µF®�¯�£�¤�©"²g¬ µE¤T£�¤/­@®�¥�¹ ª2£�¨�æ�¤T¶�¹ ¨�É�¤�ªä¿wÂ'Á#Á#Á�Ì'±�­EÀ�êë¿�¿�Á�¾E±�­EÀB¤�±�ª�Ë2®�©ì ±�ª�Ë*²g¬ ¦�¦�¬ ¦�§/¨T¶�¨�²g¦�¨7¦�ª2£�®�¹ ª�¬ ¦�§/¨2µ�¹ ¬ §�£�¯�¨�ª�æ�¨�¦�¯#¨�§�¤'Á�¿4ÂÁ#Á�Á�í¸¾EÊbµ4¯�©(¬ «4¤�µF®7¥�¯�¨�¯�¯�£�¤/ªb¶�¨�²g¦B®7¦�­@¤2¨�§�¨�¬ ¦�Á

Í�Í�Î#Ù�Ú'Ôâf£�¬ ¯#¤2ª�¤�­�¬ ª�¤�µF®7¦*µE¨�­�©(¬ á�¬ ­�¬ ¦�§B¯L£�¤b¶�¨�²g¦2¦�®�²î¯.£�¨�¯7£�¤T£�¨�µF­@®7³B³2¬ ¯#¯#¤�ª/¯"®�á8¬ ¨�¦�­�£�¤�¯�¯.®�¬ ¦�§b£�¬ µ*¾�¬ µ�£�®�¶B¨�¯�§�ÅÁ

Ñ�Û�×Ø{Í@Ô'Î#Ñ�Û�×�ØBÏ�Û�×cØ{ÍEÖ'Î à�ï%àbÕ�Ó�Í4ÐÎ\Õ�ÖÌa¹ ¨�­�«1ª�¤�á.¤�¦�ª�µ*£�¬ µFªb¶�¨�²g¦F²F£�¬ ¹ ¤b³B¨�¬ ¦�¯"¨7¬ ¦�¬ ¦�§b£�¬ µF¤�±�¯.©L¨b¶�¨�²g¦B¨7¦�ªBâr£�¬ ¯"¤T¶�©L¤�æ�¤7¦�¯"µg¯.£�¤b¶�¨�²F¦B³/¨�©L­�£¿�Ê�Á�Á#Á\ª�ÊcÁ

Í4ÐÎ�Î#Î�Ù�Ï�Ó�Í@Ø�Î#ð�Ï'ÍFñF×Ó�Í@Ó'Î ñF×Ö2à�ï(à�ï%àâf£�¬ ¯#¤*²1¨�µg¯.£�©L¤�¨�¯#¤�¦�¬ ¦�§B¯#®/­@¨�¶�¯�¥�©�¤/¯�£�¤Bá.ËT¶�¨�²g¦�²g¬ ¯L£B£�¬ µFò7¥�¤�¤�¦'Áó·3á.¯#¤7©�­@¨�µ@¯.¹ ¬ ¦�§{Ì�¹ ¨�­�«1ª�¤�á8¬ ¦�¬ ¯"¤7¹ ÉB£�¨�µg¯L£�¤¨�ª�æ�¨�¦�¯.¨�§�¤�²g¬ ¯L£*¯.£�¤b¶�¨7¬ ©�®�á¾�¬ µ�£�®�¶�µF¨7¦�ª2¨�¦�¤�±�¯.©L¨T¶�¨�²�¦7¼�£�¤b¬ µ�¨�¹ µ@®B¯L£�©L¤�¨�¯.¤�¦�¬ ¦�§/¯"®b¶�¥�µ�£�¯�£�¤/ª2¨�¦�ª�á¶�¨�²g¦�µ�¬ ¦B£�¬ µF­�¥�©(©�¤�¦�¯�¶�®�µ�¬ ¯L¬ ®�¦�Á

Í@Ü�Î#Ùmô�Ö·�§�¨�¬ ¦*¯L£�©L¤�¨�¯.¤�¦�¬ ¦�§/¯"®/­@¨�¶�¯.¥�©�¤B¯L£�¤�á�Ë2¶�¨�²g¦7Á

ÍEÜ�Î�Î#Î\×'Ð�õ�öÌa¹ ¨�­�«F¶�¥�µ�£�¤�µg¯.£�¤*²g©�®�¦�§b¶�¨�²g¦B¨�¦�ª�²=¨�¯#­�£�¤�µ*£�¬ µ�¨�ª�æ�¨�¦�¯"¨�§�¤2ª�¬ µ@¨7¶�¶�¤�¨�©'¨�á#¯.¤�©7âf£�¬ ¯.¤�µb¿wÄ ÷ ø ³B®�æ�¤'Á�½�¥�­�£µ@¯.©L®�¦�§�¤7©�²=®7¥�¹ ªb£�¨�æ�¤b¾�¤�¤7¦2¹ ¤�¨�æ�¬ ¦�§/¯�£�¤2ª�áL¬ ¹ ¤/­�¹ ®�µ@¤�ªB¨7¦�ªb¶�¹ ¨�É�¬ ¦�§ä¿@ù�Á�Á#Á á�Ê�ú7¿wÄ'Á#Ì'±�¤�å�êBá#±�¤�å�ã�ê

Í@Ý�Î#ð�û�×�Í�öí�®�²üâf£�¬ ¯#¤T¬ µg¯�£�©�¤�¨�¯"¤�¦�¬ ¦�§/¯�£�¤2ª/¨7¦�ª�á'¶�¨�²F¦�µFµ�¬ ³b¥�¹ ¯.¨�¦�¤�®�¥�µ�¹ É�¼�®�¦�¤2®�á�¯�£�¤�¯�²1®2³b¥�µ@¯�á"¨�¹ ¹hÁ

ÍEÝ�Î�Î#Î#ý�Õ�Ü�Í4Þ'Î#Ñ3Û�×Ð�Ù�Û�×'Ð/Ô�à�ÎhÕ�Û7×'Ð2ñF×Ø·3á"¯#¤7©7þE®�£�¨�¦�µE¤7¦/©�¤�­@¨�¶�¯L¥�©L¤�µ*£�¬ µ*¶�¨�²F¦�­�£�¨�¦�­@¤�µ�¨7©�¤/¨7¾�®�¥�¯�¤�æ�¤�¦7Á

Page 16: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

98

ÿ���������� ���� � ���������

jklmnopqh�V��Q-���Q-_gP��������^f����%���]e���'����\d���P�����[c����J �P�#Zb�P����P��P�Ya���*Q*�V.�X�rstuvwxy�

������� � �!#"�"$� %��&�#���'(*),+#-.����'(���/0-*����1�&��2� (0��� '�'���%031��+��4%#�($)650!#�#�!7"8(���%#'�9#�:�;���9#(<3�� %�'(�($+��=�(>�#3,�)65:?��@� �!7"<+�A7B�� +�C#(#� 5D������� � ($�(*)1�#��)EGF�?H?H? I<J#��E2EE�? I<3LKNM�O@A#P�Q1EE�?H?,?6OR!>/�SDE�T�?6UV�RFW X�E�TN? '�Y�Z�� (0%#+�):��)���� ��#���:� )[�>5:?ÿ�ÿN��\��]V\���ÿ��N���<^`_�a�bcNd[+��1)[�2A#����� %#(e9� �#5e'+#-*%e)[�#���f3;� � ��g8)H+e-*��� !#�0h>+����%#($�:%D������!8),(�!$��� �2� 5:?

ÿ_N�HiVj'ÿ�a�_/ÿ:b��LkVlÿ=�fm_/ÿ�n��Hk ^o����\�ÿBÿ:p��������iVj�l��cNd[+��1)[�2�#��(0A�C� � ):C�9�-*���)�� ++�"q(*),+�A#�2�eB7�:�,50($)[��+�%#�2��)H),�!7">� %�29+(7� )1� +:%D��� ������'#5f)[���1����)H�:%�� %��D)H+2+:9���%0)��#�rs��� )H�&">� %��(09�+(#� )1� +�%D��%#'�� �)���� (*)t-.+&��+�+�"8(�'+D)1���f-*+��;"<'�+7-*%e)[���D3��:%#'=�D3�� � �(�?>uf%�� 5D� 3rv��� )H�2��� B7��(e�� �)1�#�=!7�#��%#!$�D),+�A#���:� %e)1�#�2��)H)H��!7"#Wÿ����t��_e^w_�xyz%#+)1�����R� %7),���;�(8)1� %�2�e+�B#�0-.�(*E:/N?L?H?6�>J7��T�W$E�{�? 3HJ7�:T=Q1E�{N?HU J#��E�S�S=�#J�7E:M]T�|N?HO��NFeUV�RFq}�XNE�{R?L?H? 3LK]T�|�? I<J>3LKI<J#��Tf-*� )��e�=(7� �2� � ����9+(7� )�� +:%e)H+0-��#�)��!$)[C#��� � 50+!>!7C��(?

ÿ~N���<�^w_=�<��\�2����6��byV)H)H��!7"<��%'D!>+�C�%#)H������),),�!7"�g�-*�#+e-*� � �>A#�D3[�(8),����S���� ��!7"��#�(0��� (0��++�"8(���� �1���'#5D� %0)[���� �G9�`� �=�&9#+(�� )[� +�%#(<3[+��)1�#�=�)H)H��!7"�-*�#��������(*)[��0rv�� )[�=�:C#���%=� (0A��)L),���G9#+(7� )�� +�%#�'N?�� )�-�� � ��!>+��=�='�+7-*%0)[+0-��#+�� (f�D+��1�&���(7+�C��!$�#3�C����%�'03;� �#J�� A� �&A#��)t-.����%e�)H)H�!#"<��%�'='�3,�:%#!$�N?�����L�H�Ha��lR�=�R��� ^`��l��]kVjGbT�F�?L?H? !8J�A#Y&T�E�?H�NJ�A#Y=I0A7KD-<��(���� (>+2�&9�+(>(7� A� � � )L5�3,+����@� ��!7"#?��ÿN�t�:�:mn&���Nm�n� � ���������

Page 17: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

99

jklmnopqh������-Q-_gP��������^f��������]e���%����\d���P��J ��[cJ'�����P��Zb���Q*���P�Ya����Q*#V.�X�rstuvwxy�

�#���H�L�H�N�#�$���� �0�#���:���������D��H�,���N����� ���N�� ��� �0�#�����#���,�0�:�>��� ���#�*�1 ����[ ����¡ ���7¢<£:����:�= #��D¡ � �H�[¡ �&� �>�1¡ �#�:�#�$����0�1 ��=����¤e�D������¤¥��� ¦�¦§L¨V©�ª=«0¬N­���`� ���� ���D�[ �=£:�#����e�:�7�,�2�=�7¡ � �: 7��¡ �e¤D������� �#�1¡ �#�:�7��� ��¡��$£�������D��H�,��#¢$� �#�=�[ ����1��:¢<�:�e���&��¡ �1 #�:�#�: D��¡ ¡ �7�f� ��D�®7�� #���#�>���e�,��¯¡ ���e�&��� �$�D�H���8��� ��� �t�#�8�,����2�����[ �D�H�#�7�:¤D�#�#�N°$��¡ � �: 7��¡ �D�#���H�[�����.��f�����L�H�L±²�³&�7´R�L± �¶µ0�N�7�������6± �#���&·��>�=¸G� ¦

­�§L¨ ¹�ºG»N¼�½7¹:ºR»¦»N§�«<¹¾À¿N¼`¼NÁVº�ÂÃ� ��D�:��¡ �e¤=�#�7�N°$�[ ��� ¡ ��#¢<£������:�e�8�1� ¡ ¡ �;� ����0 ����1�>��¡ ��������¡ �D�,�=�>���7�1�`� ��7�[�D�[�D�[ �D����¤D�N�>Ä.���$������$�&���������L�H� ·<�#�������2��<ÅÆ �� �,�� #��f¤=��H��� �=Ç�È7��N� ·<�#���ÉËÊ��#³&�Ç��L±z�Nµ>ÉÌÊR�>³=��³N� ·��$��ÉËÊR��³2��Í��L± ��³�ÉÌÊR��Ç0´�ÎN�6± ��ÇÉÊN�[³D´�µ#� ·��$³#ÏG�ÐÑ�,�H�:�����N�H�H� ·��8´]���N�L±²�Rµ#Ò7���#���@¡ ��7¢� ���0���0�.�#�e�������#�[������ �#�D�1 ��2�D�:���=��¯#�7������¦Ó

§HÁVÔ�Õ�Ô�»��¡ ��7¢� ��¯#��<�1���N�$����#�,�:�;¯¡ �#�D� �e�1 #�D�,�:��¤Ö�#���� #�&¯����$�$���D��¯��7���:°7���7��� �e���H�,���8����H�,���N���N�L�H����D�� #����¡ ���7¢�¢$� �#�� �0¡ ���,���H�2����[�:�#�D�,�:�� �� ¤D�$�:¡ �w�¦¿N§ «<¾wª�Á ¬�Â

¦Â�§�«<¾

Ó�׬N¿

¦�اHÁVº�Ôª�Á ¬�Ù�Âe­:Ú�§�«�©�¿Û

׬ӭGÕ�§�«<¾

ÓÛ:Ü@¼®7�� #���#�>���2� �0�����:¯�¡ ����� �#�e�1�����=���;�7�0°7 �2� �e¯�����#���¡ �f�[�[��� �#�D�[�0�.���;¢<���7��1 ��2¤=��$���#�H�[���8�1� �#�f�*�#�f�H�e�;� ��� �7 �1 #�=����¤D�R�

­�Õ�§H§L§×¬N¿D­ªR§ «<¾À¿ÛÅs �� �H���������*�,�&�1�:¤D��� ���#���[���,��#�#�$����°$���¡ �����������.�:��¡ ���#�D´����L± �7������¡ ������ �#�=�,�=���#�[�����´����H�H�6±²�Gµ$É´:�N�6± �#�RµfÝ,´����HÊR���&·����:É=´�´R� ·<�H��± � #�:ÉRÒ8ÞÀÉ�ß�´:���H�L� ·<�7��µ8É=´�´R� ·<�¶µ�Ý[´´R�HÊR��2·�����ÉD´��N��·<�,�&Ý`Ý[´:�N�LÊG�Rµ<·<�� #�:É�*� �[ =¤D���[�&� �DÇ�Ò ß`ß�´��N�L�H�L± �� #�:É�Ò ßN´´G�L�,� ·<�7��0��� ���� �����

­ªN§H§H§×¬Ó­¦§�«<¹�º�»2Ô�­´:�N�L�H�6± �Rµ$É��2����0����: ��¡ ¯0���H�[����´�´G�L± �7�Rµ<·<�7�Gµ$É=´:�N�HÊR���&�����]�@¡ ��#¢� #��e�#�=�# ���#¢q�0����¤D��� ��� ��N�àNá[���1�[ 2¯¡ �#�#�<´:���H�L���#´=�1���:�6�.�&�;���$�:�#�°� #�&¢$�#���.�*�[ #���[���������7 e�$£�������e�1 ��&¯�7�*�e�$�#�#���1�0� ������$�:¤e�������������,���:�� ��������,�:�:Ås � �H�D�[�=�����¡â�*� �� :°>�:�#�D�� #������� ���:¡ �.���7�*�1 #�2�>¤D��¡ ¡��# ����#�>�D�1 ����Ås �� �H�e�.�:��¡ ���¡ ��#���:�¯¡ �#�� ���D´´R�L± �7��´:���¡ ���#� �#�2�#�,�H�:�:´´R�H�H�L±V�Gµ$ÉRÒ7Ý1�>����#���[��*�,�DÅs �� �H���´�� ãLä ¤=�#�7��ß

­­N§HÁ²½�ª�ÁæåÓ­�»�§ «e½�»�ÛG¼Ã� ���ç0���8�,����¢$���7�.�.�� #���e�,�=�#�7�# #�:������ ���H�2�0�*� ���� �#�2�:�#����:¤D�N�8®>�� #���#�>�:�e�$�:¡ �#��¡ ���[��*�[ ���: #�� �����D�7���[�����7���7�[��������#���:�������¤D���#��$���#�$�&� ���*� ¡ ¡$�#��� ¤&¯#��>�7� ��¡ �0�[���@�@¡ ���7¢.�,�D�$�H��¯0�[ �D��¯��7���f�1����¤4¯����¤=���1� ����* � ¡ �2¤=��� �7�H��� �0�� #�DÅs �� �H�2�&¯�7�*�:°7�;��#�¡ ��� �#��� �e�t�.�=�7��������8�,���¯#��>�$��&¯��#�*�#�<�1����Åv � �H�e�* �� �# *�f� ¡ ¡8��� ¤2¯���>�7� �¡ �e�,�2�8�,��¯D£��������� �#���

­�»�§H§L§�«<¹�½»=­Ó§�º�¹�½�»�Û

׬�»=­�¿N§t½

ÓÁz½�Â=­�Â�§HÁ ¬�Õ>ÛG¼è��:�1�#� �#�D�� #��Ê�� �#�=�:�#�H�=�1 #�2�e�;� ¡ �e�* #���;�& #�e�*� ¡ ¡>�#�� #��¡ �=��¯�`� �>�:�#�:���>�f�1 ��D�t�*�0Åv � �[�&�1��:¢q��×

ÔӭاLÁ²½­

×Ô�»=»�Ú�§HÁVÔ�ÕDÁ²½#¹�½

Ó��¡ ��7¢<����� �#�*�1 #�=�e¯#�7�*�0�[���� �� ����¯#�#�*�#�°���7����#�� #���:�=�$��$�;°�� ¡ ��#¢���� ¡ ¡$�#��¯¡ �#��� �#�e��� �1 #�:�7�� �� �0¢$� ���&� �f�1 �����������¤=�&�#���$�:���$�&� �:� �D� ¤2¯�`� �7���#���=�:�e���e�:�7�,��� ��D��� ¡ ���

»NÕ§LÁVÔ¹�Ô�­�Û׬N»éR£����¡ ¡ �D¯��������[���G� ¡ ��#¢��.�:�¡ �� #�#�#���#���:�0��µ#�H�L�HÊ����=���G�� 7´Ë±  #³2�����H±V��:ÉÌÊN�7���2�#´R�L± �7�$�:É�Ê@�#�2���N�6±V�:µ�É�ê

»ªN§LÁVÔ:¬�­�ÛG¼×Ô»2»

¦§LÁV¹:½

ÓÁ ¹:½

Ó»�­N§HÁ ¬:ª

×Ô�­&»»�§

ש�ª

×Ô¦»Ó§HÁ ¬�ÂÌÕ8ëwÚ� �:� �0� ¤2¯#���$�7� �¡ �D�,��¯�1���7���7���[ ��DÅÆ �� �,��¯#�#�*���<�1����¤Ö£�����:��� ���N�

Page 18: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

100

Game 31 - The Noveltyì@íî7ï`ð ñ�ð î7ð ò#óDñ[ô�ï:õ1ö�÷=î7ö�í:ò#î>÷eõ,ô2í�õHõ[íî7øù ï�ô�úDôõ1ð ô�òû í�õ[ð ò#ó=î>ô�ú2ü�ð ò#í�õ�ð ô:ò#ý

Solomon, S - Garbett, Pþzô�ú=ú=ô�ò$ÿ<÷�í�� õ[öDþ ö#í�ú��ð ô�ò#ý7ö�ð � û ÷�� ü#ô��ï;ò÷������� � �����7ìVð î7ð � ð í�òDì@î7ö�÷��7÷�ò�ð ò#ó�÷�ò����Dó� Dí�ò���� � ÷� ��7ð ò#î�� ����ð ò#ó��@ò�ó�� ð ý#ö��VõLõ[íî#ø

��� ���! �"�#��%$'&)(*��+�(��-,��� /.�,����0�1$'.�,��2$'&)+3"��1$4 �(3,5+�+6�87:90"�74��;�;��-<=,�#*>�+*?6�-@�AB@�AC@!D�"FEG�%7:,G(H7ID6;�@6�1JLK��0�3$ID6,G;2����� &C�!D6�

M ð í�ó�ï�í�ú

jklmnopqh-��J'���Q-_g�%�/T%�P��^f���P��R/��]e������T#�\d�P��R1�P���[c��R1#����Zb�P��J ���P�Ya��V.*Q*���X�rstuvwxy�

�N�#ôý�ð õ1ð ô�òFO��ð õ,÷eñ[í�ú=ð � ð í�ï:õ,ô!��� í/P7÷�ï�ý�ô#ñ�õ1ö�÷2ìVð î7ð � ð í�ò M ÷#ñ[÷�ò#î$÷G�$í�� õ1ö#ô��#ó�ö=ò#ôõ�íF�#÷�ï8P3��ï1ô:ú=ð ý7ð ò#ó!� ð ò#÷eñ1ô�ï�Qvöð õ,÷ÿ*ö#ô!� ôý>÷ý�í!� í:ï1ó�÷*��÷�ï1î>÷:ò7õ,íó�÷Dô�ñ�õ1ö#÷2óí�úD÷ý�î>ô�ò7õ�ð ò��ð ò�ó=í#ñ[õ,÷�ï'����R%R1R�ü�S5RTQsð õ�öeõ1ö�÷���ô�ý$ý7ð ü�� ÷&ø$òð ó�ö#õ:úDô/�7÷�ýQsö�ð õH÷�ö�íý�í�õ�ö�ð ý=��ð ý/�#ôý$í6�8ð õ:ð ý�÷�íýUPfõHô���ò��÷�ï�ý8õ,í:ò/�0ÿ�öVPDö�÷Dñ,í�ð ï�ýW��ôô�ïC� P=ð ò0õ�öð ýW��ôý#ð õ�ð ô�ò�R�XV÷�ï1÷=õ1öð ò#óý�í:ï1÷��ð ñHñ[÷:ï1÷�ò#õ�ü#÷î>í��#ý>÷&ì@ô�� ô�úDô�ò2ö#íýW��ï�÷��#í�ï�÷��=ý$ô�ú=÷õ[ö�ð ò#ó�ò�÷7ÿ ñ,ô�ï�õ1ö�ð ý�ó�í�úD÷eÿ*ö�ð î7ö=ð ý0òô�õ�í�õ�í�� ��î�� ÷í:ï�í:ò/�� ÷í���ý*õHôF�7÷:ï8P0÷/Y#î7ð õ�ð ò#ó=î#ö�÷ý>ý�R

�U#��1$:,0"�Z\[�vò#ô/�#÷�� õ]P0í�ò/�=î$ô:ò�ý7ð �÷�ïwð ò�ó3Qsö�ð õ[÷ý�í�� õ[÷�ï`ò#í�õ�ð �#÷ý0ð õ�ð ýW��ôý>ý7ð ü�� ÷eõ,ô_^`�#ý8õ�ð ñ%Pfõ1ö�ð ý�ý$íî#ï;ð ñ�ð î>÷fÿ*ö�ð î#öDí�ð úDý�í�õô���÷�ò�ð ò�óDõ1ö�÷=î$÷�ò#õ[ï�÷Dñ,ô:ï�Qsöð õH÷ý.ÿ.÷6� �U�÷/�#÷�� ô���÷��!��ð ÷�î$÷ý*õ,ô=íõHõHíî#ø.õ[ö�÷!�ò#î$í�ý8õ`� ÷�� � � í�î7ø�ø$ð ò#ó�R6�ba0R1c ü��*î>ô���� �í�� ý$ô&öí/�7÷&ü�÷�÷�ò*��� í/P7÷��2í�� õ�ö#ô���ó�öeí�ñ,õ,÷�ï'�TaGR%R1R]cVîVd0e � � íî#ø�ö#íýfô:ü7õHí�ð ò÷��=í3�7÷�ï\P0÷íýUP3�#ôý#ð õ�ð ô:ò�R

�U#��1�1�-��.�,0"cVí�õf�ï�í�� � P � � íî#ø<íî$î>÷��7õ,ý*õ�ö#÷=ý$íî#ï;ð ñ;ð î>÷��&ø$ò�ð ó:ö#õg�

�(6�1$'&)"*@�AC@�[hZù ÷�ï`ö#í6�#ý0ò#ô�õ�õ[ö#÷�ü�÷ý8õ�úeô��7÷&ð òfõ�ö#÷!��ôý7ð õ�ð ô�òDí6� õ1ö#ô6�#ó�ö0ñ�ð ò���ð ò#ó‘ü#÷�ý$õ

‘ úDô��7÷ý0ð ò0õ[ö�ð ýW��ôý#ð õ1ð ô:ò0í:ï�÷=í6� úDôý$õð ú*��ôý>ý7ð ü�� ÷Dí�ý*õ1ö�÷Dí�ò#í�� P7ý#ð ý�ô�ñ�ô�õ�ö#÷�ïNú=ô��7÷ý�ý#ö#ô7ÿ.ý�R

i ��� 6R8R%R �/Y7÷�Sj�kSGR1c'Y7ó�l�mHn�ñ\�o�Ud�R � ö/�HnRó��2�U�0R%pV÷� =÷/Y��� o�Ul6R%pVó� �cV÷/Sj�T�0R q_Y/�� �e�c'Y#ó� o�T�R q_Y7ó� � öVSa��0R q�ó/Soc ñ\��r\a���R1R%R q<ñf�Fas��R%p'Y����HcV÷�d�a�a0R ñ1Y7÷�d � ó�d�m*a� 6R q_Y7ó�d�q_Y#ó�d�m�a�SGR � Y7ó�dHn�Y#ó�l3a�d�R � ñ\��monRó���a���R1p:�/Sö/d3a6l6R � Yö���n�Y�ö�� � � í�î7ø<ý7ö�ô���� �eÿ*ð ò/t�a5�/R q_Y�ö/S2cV÷�S*a�a0R q�ó/Soc ñ8a*a� 6R q�ó� !cV÷�S*a�SsR q�ó�S M ï;í7ÿ*ò6e%u7 ��� 6R8R%Rtü� o�kSGR�í/Yü� ���vB�o�Ud�R ÷�d�ð ý�í�� ú=ôý8õ:ð ��÷:ò7õ�ð î>í���õ,ô0ÿ�ö#í�õ#ÿ*íýW��� í/P7÷���ð òeõ1ö#÷2íî$õ\�#í6��ó�í�úe÷Guw ��� 6R8R%Rtü� o�kSGR�í/Yü� ��/Y#÷/Sx�Ud�R%c'Y7ó�l�m2nNñ\�y�T��R � ö���nGó��y�Ul6R%p²÷� =÷/Y/�� *rz�Vl6R%R1R%c²ó/Sx�U��R%pVó� D÷/Y/�� 2�U0R]p'Y#ó/Soc ñ8�a��0R]pVó� �cV÷�S*as�/R q_Y��� !c'Y#ó� Fa�a0R q_Y7ó� � öVS�a� 6R qfó/S�m�{�t:�U�0R]pVó� �c ÷/Sx�U�R q_Y��� !c'Y#ó� Fa���R q_Y7ó� � öVS�a5�/R qfó/Sc ñ\�3a�a0R q_Y�öVS � ÷�S�a� 6R qfó�d � ó���a�S5R ñfd�czö/d3a�d0R q_Y/����mHp'Y/����a���R1c'Yö/d � Y�ö/d�a�l6R ó�S�|

Page 19: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

101

} ~���6�8�%�����o�k�G�-�/�������/�/�/�x�U���%�'�������2���\�y�T���1�s�����W�/�G�U�f��� �W���f���������8�!�/���f�/�*�����  3� � ���F�8�*��� ���H�s� ��¡/¢_�*�g����������������\�����y�U�6�%�£�/���o�G����¤0��¥g�����1�1���G� �!��6�%�1�1�G�������U���%�'��\���H�'�V�8�y�U¦��1�G���!§:���3¨�©0�]���V�\�����V�8��¨5���%���/�/�o�������¨�¨G�]§'�/�/�6�!���/�3ª«��� �1�����%¬­���/��¬��/�����`���/����®6¯�� �8��������¯/�6�=�\�����`�/�!��� �/�����F��� �f����¯����W�f�����f�!� �=��� ����������� �/ �� �/�� �/�8���f����ªN��� �8�0� °:����%�'��\���H���V�8�y�T¦G�]���/���2�������*¨�©��%§'���/�o�G���F¨s�/� �8�0�V����¨�¨G�]§4���G�

±£� �`�/��¯����o�`�/�x�g� ����� �����y�/���`�²���f�³�����´¡����¡�� ¯/��� ���µ� �:����¶������U�f�f���8���x�/�/¬·�����������`��¯��H�8���_�h� ��¡�¢o¥`�����jªN��� �1��°�f�/�����%�8��¡�¢�¡���k¸`¯��f���2¯��*���1�8���4�T¨0�%�4����¡V���!�����/¹s�/��¶3�/�/�j�U¨0�]�I���!¡V���*�����`� ��� �8���  ����2��� �/ /���H�/�����G�f�/�o�/�����`������W�g¯��f�f�/��������¶����W�/�����3�8���/�!��� �� ����3�\�����/��¬º�f���F����� � ��� �% W�/���`��� �W��� �����  =���6� ���`� � ��¶3�/�/�0�

»¼�½ ¾�¿À ��� ��¶�����¬�� � �U�`������� ����� �W��� ��¡V�������`�/�F�\��¢V��� �����6� �=���1�\��¡�¢U���3��¬=� ¡�0Á�� �s�k�5�1�1�]�:����¤y�T���%�'���������_�/���*¥z�T�G�%�1�%�h�/��T�0�]���/�����/�����x��6�%�:�������6Â�°:�U���1���������'�/��¨x�U�6�%§'����¨��6Â

»U¼0½%½1½�Ã�ÄÅ ���C�/���1���6� ¶3������¡��¯����1���f��\�C� ¢V� ���W¬=��� � �3ª«��� �8�*�`������� �/�W��� �W��� ��¡�0�T±£�*� ���1���`���U�f� ���3�6� �8���C�����f� �����8�F�`�/�3�\�/���¶3�/�/�*� �!�k�5�%�1�-�/�����y�U��� �1�������'�����y�T�0�%§'�/����Æ

»V¿6½%Ç'È6¾�É�Ê!Ë_È�¾�ÉH»VÌ�½ ¾/È�Í)Ì�Ã�È�Î�Ï0б²�����\ 3� ���\���f���U�f� ���*������� �`� ����Á�f�/�H�h� ��¡�¢_®�¯������*� �=���1�\��¡�¢U�����V ���¬��3�6� �1�f���`������ª«��� �8�!��� ��¡����Á���¯���¡���*�����6�/��8��¢T���W�����s� ��¡�¢­�f���`�����\���/��¶3���8�!� �3���/����Ñ ���V����¶3�=�����f����¯/���Wª«��� �1�������W�/���`��� �/�!�/���%�\�����f�/�6���V�6� �=���*���/�¡V�����f¯��g� ���3�f���������/�����`��¯/�=�!����¬=�F���F�f�����/�/����¶3�/���0�

»É6½1Ò'È0Ó�É�ÊGÐCÐÔI� �����`��¶

jklmnopqh-����Q-��_g�%�/J'�P�#^f���P��P���]e������T#�\d�����P���[c��������Zb�P��J ���P�Ya��V.*Q*���X�rstuvwxy�

Õ ��¡V��¯��`����/���h�U�6� �%�/����¤�¤G�U�6�1�8� �5�T��Ö»É6½1½%½1×´È0Ó�É

Å ���C�/���1�������W�/�*���f������¡��/��� ¡�!��¯����8�*��¡¡V�������`�/����� �/�/���F���W����¬�� � �U�/�����/�/�/���\���*¡��/����¡���8�3¡V���/�f¯��`�!� �����8�1���ª«��� �1�!��� ¡/¢T�W¯��W�`�/���!�/��¬=�F�6���f�������/�V��¶3�/�/��ÁV���W��� �=��¬��3®�¯�������¶*¯/�U�6¶F���������1���f�����3�f� � �W¬=�/���`�!� ��� ����1�8��¡�¢U���!�V ��f�/�3ªµ��� �8�!�`����¢/�

»Ø6½-Ë=Ù0Ä�Ê!Ë=¾�¼o»UÚ�½1Û´È�¾�¼�Î0»Ë�ÊÔI� �����g��¶

Page 20: Champions and Challengers - Chess · PDF fileChampions and Challengers is designed ... more experienced players will take delight in these classic games of chess ... in particular

102

jklmnopqh-����Q-��_g�%�/��P��^f���P��P���]e������T#�\d����*P���[c��� ����Zb�P������P�YaJ'�V.*����X�rstuvwxy�

ÜsÝ�Þ3ß�à�á3Þ!â/Þ�ß6ã ä/å�æ\ç�è`Þ�à�é é ê3Ý�Þ�à�æ�ë�ì�í�î'é à�ï/ð=ã åWì�é à�ê�ã ä�ßWñ=ã æ\Ý3à�ä3Þ�òVæfèfà�ì�ã Þ�ïVÞ�óUô«Ý�ã æ1Þ!ã åWã äFï�Ý/Þ�ï/ð_à�ä�õ�Ý�ã åWè`ç�ç�ðç�äFÞ�ö!ã åWâ�Þ�ã ä�ß3à�æ%æ8à�ï/ðTÞ�õ�÷�Þ/ø�Þ�è8ê�æ\Ý�ã ä/ß�åVà/ê�å�æfÝ�à�æ�ù�à�ègâ�Þ�æ1æ�á*ë/åæ�ñ�ã ä6íUô«Ý�ã æ\Þ�å=ïVç�á�ì/Þ�ä�åà�æfã ç�ä�ã å3ã ä*Ý�ã å=à�ïæfã ø�Þì�ã Þ�ïVÞ3åVÞ�æ\ú�ë�ìFà�ä/õ3æ`Ý/Þ!ì/ç�ç�èCé êWõ�Þ/ûfÞ�ä�õ�Þ�õHîsé à�ï/ð=ðã ä/ß�å�ã õ�Þ0í

ü�ý6þ1ÿ���ü���������� :æ�ûgã èfåæ�ß�é à�ä/ïVÞ3æfÝ�ã å=Þ/ò/ï�Ý/à6ä/ß�Þ�åÞ�Þ�á3å�æ\ç*â�Þ!ã ä!îhé à�ï/ðTå_û\à/ø�ç�ë�è6à�åFÝ/ÞWñ=ã é ébß�à�ã äFæ]ñ­ç�è`ç�ç�ðTå_û\ç�è0Ý�ã å���ë�Þ�Þ�ä�ó�â�ë�ææfÝ�ã åWã åFä�ç�æ�æ`Ý/ÞWñ=Ý/ç6é Þ�åUæ8ç�è\ê�í�� æ6ã å=à�é è`Þ�à�õ/êFÞ�ø�ã õ�Þ�ä�æ�æfÝ�à�æ�æfÝ/Þ�ðä�ã ß6Ý�æ�ç�äFõ���ã åWë�ä�û8ç�èfæfë�ä/à�æ\Þ�é ê3ì�é à�ïVÞ�õ�óà6ä/õ*á�ë/åUæâ/Þ�é ç�åæ�à/û8æ8Þ�è�æ\Ý�Þ3ô«Ý�ã æ\Þ���ë/Þ�Þ�ä3ï�Ý/Þ�ï�ðTå�æfÝ/Þ�ðã ä/ß*ç�ä3Ý��6íUÜsÝ�Þ�á�à�ã ä3è`Þ�à�åVç�äWæfÝ�à�æ�æfÝ�ã åWì/ç�å�ã æ\ã ç�ä*ã å_ø�Þ�è\êà�õ�ø�à�ä�æ\à�ß�Þ�ç�ë/å_û\ç�è6ôµÝ�ã æ8Þ!é ã Þ�åWã äFæfÝ/Þ*ïç�á*ì�é Þ�æ\Þ�õ�ã å�Ý�à�è`á�ç�äVêWç/ûGî'é à�ï/ð=ì�ã Þ�ïÞ�å�í�� æ6ã åWä/ç�æ`ã ïÞ�à6â�é Þ�æfÝ/à�æ�îhé à�ï�ðUåæ]ñ­ç�èfç�ç�ðTå=åUæfã é éVä/Þ�Þ�õFæ8ç!â/Þ*õ�Þ�ø�Þ�é ç�ì�Þ�õ*à�ä/õ!Ý�ã åWðã ä/ß!ã å_ø�Þ�è8ê3ì/ç�ç�ègé êFõ�Þ�û8Þ6ä/õ�Þ�õ0í

�GÞ�èCÝ/à6ì/å�ù�à�èCâ/Þ�æ1æ�ï�Ý�ç�åÞ����0í �_ò/õ���à�åWÝ/Þ!Ý/à�õ*ïà�é ï�ë�é à�æ\Þ�õ3æfÝ�ÞFûfç�é é ç/ñ=ã ä�ß!é ã ä/Þ����0í%í8í �=à��������/í�âVö��Wâ! ����0í#"4Þ����ß� �$*à�ä/õ�á3à�æ\Þ�ïà�ä*ä/ç�æ6â/Þ*à/ø/ç�ã õ�Þ�õ*à/û8æ8Þ�èsîsé à�ï/ð=ègë�ä�å=ç�ë�æ�ç�û�ï�Ý/Þ�ï�ðTå�����í �WÝ%���'&sß�(���öGí �WÝ! ��_ò�â�ö)������í*&sÞ%��=ïUö����� Gí*&�û+���_ò�ï,��������í*":Þ���à6ä/õ3ô«Ý�ã æ1ÞFñ�ã é éUá3à�æ\Þ�íîsé à�ï�ð_ïVç�ë�é õ!Ý/à/ø/Þ!ì�é à/ê�Þ�õWû\ç�è�æ\Ý/Þ*õ�èfà�ñ ñ=ã æ\Ý-����í8í%í �=à������.�/í�â�ö/�Wâ! ����Gí*"4Þ����0&Gß�(21,����í#"'ò/õ��3�_ò�âVö2��4`ç�è����í%í1í1îGï, 3��öGí û1ò�ß��5"'û\Þ�(�6�72��öGí �=ï�3�Wâ! �6Gí

ü8��þ1ÿ��������2��9�:�ü�ü0þ �3;�<�2ÿ�=8>�ü�<�þ ?@��=8AÜsÝ�Þ3à�õ/ø�à6ä�æ1à�ß�Þ/Bhç�é ç�á�ç�ä*Ý�ç�é õ�åWã åWä�ç�ñ á�ç�èfÞ�Þ/ø�ã õ�Þ�ä�æCóà6é æfÝ�ç�ë�ß�Ý*ã æ/ñ=ã é ébæ1à�ðUÞ�ïà�ègÞFû8ç�è�ô«Ý�ã æ1Þ3æ\ç�ïç�äVø/Þ�èfæ�æfÝ/Þì/ç�ã ä/ægíôµÝ�ã æ8Þ�ïç�ë�é õ�á3à�ðUÞ!é ã û\Þ*õ�ã û1ûgã ï/ë�é æ�û\ç�èGÝ�ã á3åÞ6é û6à�é è`Þ�à�õ/ê3âVê3ì�é à/ê�ã ä�ß����6í �_ò�õ���$21�îGïC(-��ö5í �=à/ö54+��öGí �_ò/õ� �$îGß/ö2�����0í#&GÞD�-"'û8õ�(�EF��72��ösí%í1í%î5ß/ö)������í#&5õ%�/G

ü�<6þ1þ1þ%ÿH��=8A3ü�:�þI�J���8AÜsÝ�ã å�á*ë/ï/Ý�ñ­à�å=ï�é Þ�à�è�ûfè`ç�á æ\Ý/Þ*ç�ë�æ1åVÞ�æ�ç�û�æfÝ/Þ���ë/Þ�Þ�ä�û\ç�è�æ�ñ­ç!è`ç�ç�ðUå=à�ä�õ�à'&sä�ã ß�Ý�æ�Þ/ò/ï�Ý/à�ä�ß�Þ�ó�ä/ç�ñºñ�Ý/à�æ�ã åîsé à�ï�ðUåWì�é à�ä%$5K:ç�ègá�à�é é ê�æ\Ý/Þ�æ]ñ­ç�ègç�ç�ðTå_û\ç�è6à���ë/Þ�Þ�ä*ã å=à�æ�é Þ�à�åUæ�Þ���ë�à�éUà�ä�õ�ç/û8æ\Þ�ä*â/Þ�æ1æ\Þ�è óUæ\Ý�Þ�ä=ñ=ÝVê3ã å3îhé à�ï�ðé ç�å�ã ä�ß�$3ô²Þ�ïà6äFåTê/á*ì/à�æ\Ý�ã åVÞFñ�ã æ`Ý!îsé à�ï�ð�ó�Ý�ã åWðã ä�ß�Ý/à�å3ä/ç�ï�Ý�à�ä/ïÞ!ã äFå�ë�è\ø�ã ø�ã ä/ß3æ`Ý/Þ�ç�ä/ïVç�á*ã ä�ß*à�æ1æ8à�ï�ð_à�åWÝ�ã åâ�ã å�Ý�ç�ì�ã å�æ`Ý/ÞWñ�è`ç�ä/ß�ïVç�é ç�ë�è6à6ä/õ!ã æ�ïà�äFõ�ç*ä�ç�æfÝ�ã ä/ß!â�ë�æ�ñ­à�æ1ï/Ý3à�å�æfÝ/Þ*ß�à�á3Þ!ã å=à�é èfÞ�à�õ/ê3é ç�åæCí

ü�:�þ1þ%þML��8NÜsÝ�Þ�ñ�ã ä�ä�ã ä�ß�áFÞ�æfÝ�ç�õFû8ç�è�ô«Ý�ã æ1Þ*à/û8æ8Þ�è)��ö5í%í1í1îGï,(Wñ_ç�ë�é õ�â�Þ3����í �_ò/õ� HîGß/ö2���� �íO&GÞ��­û+ 3���6í �=Þ����0&Gß� 4P���6í1í%í#"'ûQ�-��(0í%î�òû+ ��R&Gß� ���S�í �_ò�Þ�ö��0&�òVûM /�%�0í �_ò/à�(��6ú�72��(0í%î�òû+ 21�"'òû+ ���S�í �_ò�Þ/ö2�*à�ä/õHîsé à�ï/ð�Ý/à�åWä/ç*ï/Ý/à�ä/ïVÞà�ä�ê/á3ç�è`Þ�í

ü�N�þ ��9�A'TU;�>Fü�V6þOL�?WV�2ÿU;�A3ü�A0þ#L��8;�>'T��8;�>�ü�>6þI�3;�:�X�ZYBý�õ�ç�ë�â�æ�ù�à�ègâ�Þ�æ1æ/ñ_à�åWã ä�æ\Þ�è`Þ�åUæ8Þ�õ!ã äFæ\Ý/Þ!ì�èfç�â�à�â�é Þ�ïç6ä/ï�é ë/å�ã ç�ä6÷,��(�í1í1í%&5ß��-��S�í �=ß����0&�û+(/�%��í �_ò�õ�����ú