TThe he CChain of hain of BBeingeing

Chaos and Order in the Renaissance Worldview

Shakespeare 207 (Spring 2002)Shakespeare 207 (Spring 2002)

IIn the n the BBeginning...eginning...

• Biblical explanation for cosmology

• Designed by a benevolent deity

• Perfection and lack of change

• Perfect order and hierarchy from God down to the most insignificant creature or object

In Principio creatavit In Principio creatavit Deus caelum et Deus caelum et terram....terram....

“In the Beginning, God created the Heavens and the Earth. But the Earth was void and without form, and darkness was upon the face of the deep: and the spirit of God moved over the waters.” Genesis 1:1

For Renaissance Christians, the act of creation is an act of imposing organization on raw chaos. For them, orderliness is next to Godliness.

The Design? The Design? A A ChainChain from from Highest . . . .Highest . . . .

• Creator seen as highest link in chain, but also outside it.

• Purely spiritual beings below the creator.

• Beings of both spirit and physical body (humans) below angelic beings.

• Then animate creatures with only physical bodies and five senses, but lacking reason (non-human mammals, fowl, fish, insects)

. . .Down to the Lowest. . .Down to the Lowest

• Then animals with fewer than five senses or inanimate bodies (oysters, barnacles, mollusks)

• Then plant life, which is both inanimate and lacking in sensory organs (trees, shrubs, bushes, vegetables)

• Then minerals and inanimate objects

Everything had a place in the hierarchy, and all was well as long as each creature behaved according to its station.

The Universe as We Know it

Versus the Ptolemaic Model

EarthEarth

Planets

The Sun

The Moon

The Ptolemaic ModelThe Ptolemaic Model Grew Increasingly Elaborate Under Medieval Theology• Sublunary Spheres

• Music of the Spheres

• Astrological Influence

• All Creation interconnected by Divine Love

• Stars and Planets corresponded to Alchemical elements, to Bodily Humors, to types of plants....to nearly everything.

FFour our AAlchemical lchemical EElementslementsFire (Highest but most volatile element, closest

to heavenly matter that composes spiritual ether and stars; its natural state was warm/dry)

Air (Second ranking element; Natural state: warm/wet)

Water (Earth naturally sinks below water, so water is higher in status. Natural state: cool/wet

Earth (Lowest but most stable element, closest to base desires. Natural state: cool/dry)

Four Bodily HumorsFour Bodily Humors

• Choler (called Yellow Bile in some models) liquid in the body that caused irritability and anger

• Tears (in some models, Black Bile) liquid in the body that caused melancholy, sadness, and depression)

• Blood (corresponded to excitement, energy, sexual arousal, happiness, desire for activity)

• Phlegm (corresponded to lethargy, boredom, inaction, fatigue, sleepiness)

From Latin Humoris: “liquid”

So What Went Wrong?So What Went Wrong?

For medieval and Renaissance Christians, the universe was created by a benevolent deity. So how did one explain the existence of unpleasant evil within a world that was thought to have been created as an ordered paradise?

Keep in mind, all of creation was bound together. Whatever affected one thing affected other things in the Chain of Being. This was called a “Correspondence.”

“What is below is like that which is above. What is above is like what is below. Thus is the miracle of the One accomplished.”

--Paracelsus

CorrespondencesCorrespondencesThree interlocking parts of the Chain corresponded to each other. These were:

Macrocosm (the universe, nature, and the skies)

Microcosm (the Human body as a map of the Universe)

Body Politic (the kingdom as a social institute, including its government and its citizens).

The Human Body was the The Human Body was the MicrocosmMicrocosm

It connected to every part of creation.

““The Body is a Little World.”The Body is a Little World.”

Created in God’s Own Image

Set in the very center of creation

Given the position of primate over the animals

Given both soul and flesh.

Immortal, never dying....

Remember those Remember those Four Bodily Humors?Four Bodily Humors?

• Choler (called Yellow Bile in some models) liquid in the body that caused irritability and anger

• Tears (in some models, Black Bile) liquid in the body that caused melancholy, sadness, and depression)

• Blood (corresponded to excitement, energy, sexual arousal, happiness, desire for activity)

• Phlegm (corresponded to lethargy, boredom, inaction, fatigue, sleepiness)

What would happen if the human body became corrupted?

Health and BalanceHealth and Balance

When the humors are balanced proportionately in the human body, mankind is healthy, and experiences no negative or inappropriate emotions.

When unbalanced, it was another story.

Unbalance Leads to DiseaseUnbalance Leads to Disease

...And to Civil Disorder...And to Civil Disorder

...And to Disorder in Nature...And to Disorder in Nature

Animals attacking people, eating their own young, stealing grain or crops, all these were signs of the fallen nature of the earth, and corresponded to breaks in the Chain of Being and disorder within the microcosm.

...And to disorder in the ...And to disorder in the heavenly constellations.heavenly constellations.

Enter Enter Sin Sin andand Disorder Disorder“Now the serpent was more subtle than any of the beasts of the earth which the Lord God had made. And he said to the woman: Why hath God commanded you, that you should not eat of every tree of paradise?” (Gen 3:1)

Demonic trickery leads humanity to rebel against its place in nature as paragon in divine creation.

Decay Decay in the in the Sublunary SphereSublunary Sphere

Note that the vast majority of creation was still thought to be perfect, uncorrupt. The effects of sin were limited to the earth and its immediate atmosphere, i.e., everything beneath the orbit of the moon.

Thus the references in Shakespeare to “the sublunary sphere,” and “everything beneath the moon.”

Within this boundary, the nature of the world changed. It began to rot....

MutabilityMutability• Old Age

• Death

• Erosion

• Disease

• Rain, Wind, and Weather

• Rust and Decay

• Entropy

“God commanded us that we should not eat the fruit; and that we should not touch it, lest perhaps we die.” (Gen 3:3)

So how did the So how did the Great Great ChainChain Work? Work?

• Sort of like the Death-Star, the Chain had a few pieces missing due to human rebellion.

• But enough pieces remain for it to function.

• The trick is for each creature to know its duty and its place in the Chain, and act accordingly.

HierarchyHierarchy

• Primate

• Higher on Chain had more spiritual aspects, greater capacity for rationality (as opposed to instinct), closer in likeness to God.

• Correspondences on three levels:

– Microcosm (the individual human body)

– Macrocosm (the universe and the world of nature)

– Body Politic (the kingdom)

God

• The Supreme Primate

• King of Angels (Rex Angelorum)

Angelic BeingsAngelic BeingsOrganized in strict hierarchy of seven choires (or nine, depending upon source).

“There are nine orders of angels, to wit, angels, archangels, virtues, powers, principalities, dominations, Ophanim, Cherubim, and Seraphim.”

--St. Gregory, Summa Theologica

The King and Nobility

Right to rule given by God, and could only be removed by Him.

Believed superior in his virtue, wisdom, grace, and strength.

Humanity of Various RanksHumanity of Various RanksAncient medieval model of Three Estates:

• Bellatores: Knights and royalty, those who fight and rule, protecting the physical health of God’s flock

• Oratores: The Clergy, the priests who pray and tend to the spiritual needs of God’s flock.

• Labores: Those who work, the farmers and serfs who feed God’s flock.

If those who protect the kingdom do their job, the people will be safe. If those who work the fields do their job, all will be fed. If those who tend to the soul do their job, all will have their spiritual needs met. Refusing to keep one’s place damages the Body Politic, society as a whole.

The knights’ duty wasto protect the innocent and uphold justice.

“Our duty as priests is to nourish the flock spiritually as good shepherds ought with Christ’s grain and the water of life. Your destined task, O worthy lords, is to defend the flock by force of arms, to drive away the wolves and bears that would devour God’s children. You are to smite with iron the evil and the arrogant but uplift the humble, the widow, the orphan.”

--Saint Bernard of Clairvaux,

c. 1140 AD

This entailed combat as a virtue; one’s worth as a knight was determined by one’s loyalty, by steadfastness in combat.

But this also entailed violence as a virtue--the willingness to do barbaric deeds with civilized affectation.

Even the lowest serf slaving Even the lowest serf slaving away in a field had some away in a field had some dignity and authority over other dignity and authority over other creatures....creatures....

. . . Ruling over the . . . Ruling over the Fields and FloodsFields and FloodsJust as God had authority over all kings,

and king had authority over men, lesser men had dominion over animals and plants.

Once again, this authority was believed to be sanctioned by the Bible.

“Let us make man to our image and likeness: and let him have dominion over the fishes of the sea, and the fowls of the air, and the beasts of the field, and the whole earth, and every creeping creature that moveth upon the ground.” (Gen 1:26)

“And let the fear and dread of you be upon all the beasts of the earth, and upon all the fowls of the air, and all that moveth upon the earth, all the fishes of the sea are delivered into your hands. And every thing that moveth and liveth shall be meat to you, even as the green herbs have I delivered them all to you.” (Gen. 9:2-3)

Each had its hierarchy.Each had its hierarchy.

“And God made the beasts of the earth according to their kinds, and cattle, and every thing that creepeth on the earth after its kind. And God saw that it was good.” --(Gen. 1:25)

Noble BeastsNoble Beasts

But each animal, plant, fish, and mineral had its own king, a superior example of its own “species.”

This creature was known as the “Primate.”

Among Beasts, the primate was Among Beasts, the primate was either the lion or the elephant.either the lion or the elephant.

Fish, Flesh, and FowlFish, Flesh, and Fowl

Vegetable LoveVegetable Love

• “My vegetable love shall grow vaster than empires.”

– Andrew Marvell, “To His Coy Mistress.”

The oak was primate among plants, with trees ranking above shrubs, which ranked above bushes, which ranked above grains, which ranked above grasses, and so on.

Mineral WorldMineral World“You Blocks, You Stones, You Worse Than Senseless Things!”

--Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar

Even rocks had rankings. Diamonds were the mineral primate, with other gems below them.

As Tillyard notes, every object in creation was thought to have unique gifts. Even the basest of objects, a stone lacking sentience, sensation, location, and reproduction, was still endowed with the trait of unusual durability and hardness.

Everything, even stones and dirt, had an important place, even if just supporting those who walked upon them.

This cosmology permeated This cosmology permeated earlier medieval society in earlier medieval society in Western EuropeWestern Europe• Barthomew Anglicus’ Natural Philosophy

• Lucretius’ De Rerum Natura

• Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologica

Any educated person would be familiar with these concepts in the days before the 1600s. Modern people know about atoms or evolution, even if they aren’t themselves physicists or biologists. Likewise, even uneducated peasants would know about the chain.

An Example: HawkingAn Example: HawkingConsider for example the sport of hawking (hunting small

animals with trained birds).

An Example: HawkingAn Example: HawkingEach rank in society had a corresponding bird to use.

• Emperor: Golden Eagle, Vulture, & Merlin • King: Gyrfalcon (male & female)

• Prince: Female Peregrine • Duke: Rock Falcon (subspecies of the Peregrine)

• Earl: Peregrine • Baron: Male peregrine

• Knight: Saker • Squire: Lanner Falcon • Lady: Female Merlin

• Yeoman: Goshawk or Hobby • Priest: Female Sparrowhawk

• Holywater clerk: Male Sparrowhawk • Knaves, Servants, Children: Old World Kestrel

To use a bird for the wrong rank was an act not just of poor etiquette, but of subversion.

For example, keeping a falcon above one's station was considered a felony and duly regarded as an act of rebellion against an inflexible social order. The Boke of St. Albans relates that the typical punishment of cutting off the hands of people who kept birds above their social rank also served as an excellent deterrent to the crime.

Another Example: HuntingAnother Example: HuntingEven the more general sport of hunting was

a re-enactment of the social hierarchy.

Ethical, Political and Ethical, Political and Literary Ramifications?Literary Ramifications?

Important to know one’s place, and not seek to rise above it through unholy ambition.

Equally important to know one’s place, and not to sink below it by neglecting one’s duties.

Important to balance physical and animal needs of the body with divine reason.

Pre-established hierarchy of literary symbols, accessible to any educated reader or writer.

Thus Pride Becomes the Thus Pride Becomes the Worst SinWorst SinPride is always an act of disobedience to legitimate authority, hence an act against the will of God, and also against the very structure of the universe. It is cosmological vandalism.

After all, it is the original After all, it is the original sin leading to Lucifer’s fall sin leading to Lucifer’s fall in medieval theology.in medieval theology.

“And thou saidst in thy heart: I will ascend into heaven, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God, I will sit in the mountains of the covenant, in the sides of the North. I will ascend above the height of the clouds, I will be like the most high.” (Isaiah 14:13-14)

Regicide: The Worst Act of Pride“If I could find example of thousands that had struck anointed kingsAnd flourish’d after, I’ld not do’t; but [. . .] Nor brass nor stone nor parchment bears not one.”--The Winter’s Tale I.ii. 357-360

The King is God’s deputy on earth, and is himself parallel in authority to God. Just as God is king of Angels and all creation, the king is ruler of his countrymen, and deserves similar awe. The unlawful death of kings always causes disruption in the heavens (stars fall from the sky, freakish storms blow across the country) and disruption in the world of nature (famines, plagues, unnatural activity among the animals, etc.)

Killing the King is attacking an emblem of Killing the King is attacking an emblem of Godhead. It is worse than even killing a Godhead. It is worse than even killing a priest. For he has two bodies, and injuring priest. For he has two bodies, and injuring the head of the state is a blow to the entire the head of the state is a blow to the entire people.people.

Explicit Presentatio!Explicit Presentatio!

Works Consulted:

Boethius. The Consolation of Philosophy. Trans. Richard Green. NY: Macmillan Pub. Co., 1962.

Douay-Rheims Translation of the Bible.

Kantorowicz, Ernst. The King’s Two Bodies. NJ: Princeton UP, 1997.

Saintbury, George, ed. Elizabethan and Jacobean Pamphlets. NY: Macmillan and Co., 1892.

Tillyard, E. M. W. The Elizabethan World Picture

•2002 © Dr. L. K. Wheeler