ceo presentation reit

70
For ‘the 2 nd International CEO Roundtable of Chinese and Foreign Multinational Corporations’ REIT REIT Real Estate Investment Trust Prepared by: Ben Tse Valuation & Advisory Services, Greater China CB Richard Ellis 15 th November 2008

Upload: bentse0610

Post on 23-Aug-2014

7.134 views

Category:

Real Estate


4 download

DESCRIPTION

REIT presentation featuring REIT introduction, structure, characteristics, legal framework, regulations, risk & return, trends in Mainland China.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ceo Presentation   Reit

For ‘the 2nd International CEO Roundtable of Chinese and Foreign Multinational Corporations’

REITREITReal Estate Investment

TrustPrepared by:

Ben TseValuation & Advisory Services, Greater ChinaCB Richard Ellis

15th November 2008

Page 2: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 2

Content REIT Development REIT Legislation REIT Structure Characteristics of a REIT Risks of a REIT REIT vs. Direct Property Investment Impact of Subprime Crisis REIT in Mainland China Managing a REIT Conclusion

Page 3: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 3

REIT Development

Page 4: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 4

REIT Development

SINGAPORE

JAPAN

TAIWAN

20 S-REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 8.2 billion

8 T-REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 1.2 billion

4 listed CR-REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 0.15 billion

SOUTH KOREA

MALAYSIA

13 REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 1.2 billion

HONG KONG

7 listed H-REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 5.1 billion

42 listed J-REITsMkt. Cap. about US$ 23.3 billion

Data as of late October 2008

REITs in Asia REITs in Asia (excluding Property Funds)(excluding Property Funds)

Source: Bloomberg and CBRE Research

Page 5: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 5

REIT DevelopmentREITs in Asia REITs in Asia (excluding (excluding Property Funds) Property Funds)

No. of listed REITs Market Capitalization (US$ billion)

As of late Oct 2007

As of late Oct 2008

As of late Oct 2007

As of late Oct 2008

Japan 42 42 46.5 23.3 (-50.0%)Singapore 17 20 18.9 8.2 (-56.6%)Hong Kong 7 7 8.9 5.1 (-42.7%)Taiwan 8 8 1.7 1.2 (-29.4%)South Korea 9 4 0.8 0.15 (-81.3%)

Malaysia 11 13 1.4 1.2 (-14.3%)

TOTAL 94 94 78.2 39.2 (-50.0%)

Amongst others, South Korea had 5 REITs delisted leaving an 81.3% contraction in total market cap.

In Japan, although the number of listed REITs remains unchanged, the total market cap. dropped significantly by 50%

The number of listed REITs in Singapore increased to 20; nevertheless, the total market cap. recorded a dramatic 56.6% drop. Hong Kong also suffered significantly, with 42.7% drop in total market cap.

Source: Bloomberg and CBRE Research

Page 6: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 6

REIT Development

REITs in Hong KongREITs in Hong Kong

Late 2005 saw the Hong Kong REIT market burst into life, with the listing of three REITs on the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong including The Link REIT, Prosperity REIT and GZI REIT

To date, there are seven listed REITs with market capitalization of about US$ 5.1 billion (HK$ 39.8), down 42.7% in total market cap., when compared to late Oct 2007

Page 7: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 7

REIT Development

Other Asian countries planning for setting Other Asian countries planning for setting up of REITsup of REITs

In light of the rapid development in Japan, Singapore and HK, other countries are planning for setting up of REIT like India, Pakistan, Indonesia & Vietnam

India is currently in the process of formulating definitive legislation for the introduction of REIT in the Indian real estate market

Pakistan is also ready to allow REIT. It is understood that the Securities & Exchange Commission of Pakistan will follow regulatory framework similar to that of Singapore and Hong Kong REIT

Page 8: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 8

REIT legislation

Page 9: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 9

REIT Legislation

As mentioned earlier, Japan, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea and Malaysia already developed the REIT structure

The legislation structure in these six countries will be discussed

Page 10: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 10

REIT LegislationJapan Singapore Hong Kong Taiwan

Structure Trust or corporate (listed REITs are all corporations)

Collective Investment scheme (Unit Trust) or corporate

Unit Trust Trust (Real estate asset trust or investment trust)

Management structure External External Internal/External Internal/External% invested in real estate

For listed J-REIT, at least 75% of assets must be invested in real estate

At least 70% of deposited property should be invested in real estate or real estate-related assets

Only invest in real estate

cash, government bonds, property, property-related rights, beneficiary securities or ABS issued under real estate securitization Act/Financial Asset Securitization Act (RESA/FASA) must form at least 75% of the NAV

Geographical restrictions

No restriction under the Investment Trust and Investment Company Act, but no overseas acquisition have been made as the requirements on real estate appraisal of overseas properties are ambiguous

No No No restriction under the RESA; subject to approval

Property developments Restricted – at least 50% of total assets are income producing and unlikely be sold within one year

Property developments and investments in uncompleted projects should not exceed 10%

Prohibited, but H-REIT may acquire uncompleted units comprising less than 10% NAV

Prohibited – this rule is undergoing revision to allow for urban renewal infrastructure or public amenities construction

Leverage No restriction Over 35% of total assets permitted with disclosed credit rating (capped at 60%)

Capped at 45% of gross asset value

Ratings of twAA or above by two credit rating agencies: 50%; ratings of twA or above: 35%; those with credit ratings: 25%

Source: CBRE Research

Page 11: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 11

REIT LegislationSouth Korea Malaysia

Structure Corporate-Restructuring, Entrusted Management, Development-Specialized, Self-Managed

Unit trust

Management structure Internal/External External% invested in real estate At least 70% in real estates or

corporate restructuring related properties

At least 75% in real estate, SPCs, real estate-related assets or liquid assets for listed REITs. The criteria for unlisted REIT is 70%

Geographical restrictions No No restriction basically, subject to approval from SC and relevant authorities

Property developments Allow Prohibited, but may enter into conditional forward purchase agreement with cover for construction risks

Leverage REITs are permitted to have exceptional borrowing up to 1000% of equity capital, upon special approval of shareholders

50% of total asset value (revised from 35%)

Source: CBRE Research

Page 12: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 12

REIT Structure

Page 13: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 13

REIT Structure

What is a REIT?What is a REIT?

A company that owns, and in most cases, operates income-producing real estate

Some of the REITs finance real estate

To be a REIT, a company must distribute certain portion of its taxable income to shareholders annually in the form of dividends. (e.g. in Hong Kong, not less than 90% of its audited annual net income after tax shall be distributed in the form of dividends)

The REIT structure was designed to provide a similar structure for investment in real estate similar to mutual funds which provide for investment in stocks

Source: THE REIT STORY, the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts

Page 14: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 14

REIT Structure

Types of REITTypes of REIT

REIT can be classified as equity, mortgage or hybrid

• EQUITY generates income from property ownership and operation

• MORTGAGE provide a source of loan to property owners and operators directly or via collateral bonds

• HYBRID a mixture of the above two types

Page 15: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 15

REIT Structure

Specific Legislative Model of Asian Specific Legislative Model of Asian REITREIT

Adopt specific legislation on its establishment, structure, investment and distribution of REIT

Services ServicesTrust Manager

Asset Management

CompanyREIT

Properties

REIT Holders

Page 16: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 16

Characteristics of REIT

Page 17: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 17

Characteristics of a REIT

REIT InvestmentREIT Investment

Focus on Property Investment but without becoming a landlord

Tax Concession Minimum Payout Ratio Better Investor Protection

• Better Disclosure Requirement• Restricted to Property Related Activities• Restriction on Development Activities• Limit on Gearing

Page 18: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 18

Characteristics of a REIT

REIT InvestmentREIT Investment

Relatively stable income with no minimum investment requirements

High Liquidity Management Expertise Access to large and high quality projects /

properties Diversification Economy of Scale Low Transaction Cost

Page 19: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 19

Characteristics of a REIT

AdvantagesAdvantages

High liquidity Transparency Tax benefit High dividend yield Inflation hedge Portfolio diversification Lower risk

Page 20: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 20

Characteristics of a REIT

High LiquidityHigh Liquidity

Liquidity is a key concern to the investment. Generally, value of high liquidity investment vehicles are worth more than less liquid ones

Direct investment in property requires a large lump-sum payment and involves a high transaction cost

Direct investment faces the difficulties of matching a buyer and a seller

REITs are publicly traded on stock exchange with high liquidity

Page 21: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 21

Characteristics of a REIT

TransparencyTransparency

Corporate governance and internal control are important issues in today’s business operation

REIT, just like stocks, requires regular reporting, independent audit and appraisal

These improve the quality of investment and investor’s confidence

Page 22: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 22

Characteristics of a REIT

Tax BenefitTax Benefit

For a REIT to become qualified (in Hong Kong), a real estate company must agree to pay in dividends at a minimum of 90% of its taxable profit

By having REIT status, a company avoids corporate income tax

A regular corporation makes profit and pays taxes on the entire profits, and then decides how to allocate its after-tax profits between dividends and reinvestment

However, a REIT simply distributes all or almost all of its profits (excluding tax)

Page 23: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 23

Characteristics of a REIT

High Dividend YieldHigh Dividend Yield

Although risks are apparent, REIT receives special tax considerations and typically offer investors fairly high yields (see next slide for more details) as well as highly liquid method of investing in Real Estate

As mentioned previously, it must distribute most of its profits as dividends

The high dividend yield provides a relatively stable income stream to the investors

Therefore, it is relatively safe to invest in REIT in a volatile market

Page 24: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 24

Characteristics of a REITDividend Yield of Hong Kong REITsDividend Yield of Hong Kong REITs(As of late Oct 2008)(As of late Oct 2008)

Name of REIT Stock Code Dividend Yield

RREEF CCT REIT 00625 9.06The Link REIT 00823 5.55

Prosperity REIT 00808 16.45GZI REIT 00405 15.90

Champion REIT 02778 20.87Sunlight REIT 00435 20.68

Regal REIT 01881 24.90Average 16.20

Hysan 0014 5.24Wharf Holdings 0004 5.33

Wheelock Properties 0049 4.62Average 5.06

Source: Bloomberg

Page 25: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 25

Characteristics of a REIT

Inflation HedgeInflation Hedge

REIT invests in property market

Traditionally, investments in tangible hard assets are good for hedging against inflation

Page 26: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 26

Characteristics of a REIT

Portfolio DiversificationPortfolio Diversification

REIT has a low correlation with stock and bond investments

According to modern portfolio theory, adding REIT to a portfolio with stock and bond would improve return and reduce risks

Page 27: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 27

Characteristics of a REIT

Lower RiskLower Risk

The risks in the investment of REIT are relatively lower than that in investment of property stocks

More details on risk of REIT will be discussed in the next section

Page 28: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 28

Risks of a REIT

Page 29: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 29

Risks of a REIT

Volatility of REITVolatility of REIT

Volatility is a measure of risk

Unpredictable, unstable and explosive are some of the words, which can best describes the share market in the last 12 months

For REITs, investors need to remember that they are still buying shares, not bricks and mortar

Therefore, the share price will be influenced by what is happening in the commercial property market

Page 30: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 30

Risks of a REIT

Name of REIT Stock Code Annualized VolatilityRREEF CCT REIT 0625 43.09

The link REIT 0823 33.84Prosperity 808 40.16GZI REIT 0405 33.77

Champion REIT 2778 45.10Sunlight REIT 0435 35.06

Regal REIT 1881 38.20Average 38.46

Hysan 0014 47.03Wharf Holdings 0004 60.04

Wheelock Properties 0049 49.08Average 52.05

Hang Seng Index 49.14Source: Bloomberg

Volatility of HK REITs vs. HK property stocksVolatility of HK REITs vs. HK property stocks

Page 31: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 31

Risks of a REIT

Volatility of REITVolatility of REIT

The volatility of REIT, which is a measurement of the daily change of stock price, is smaller than those of property stocks

The volatility of REITs is also smaller than that of the Hang Seng Index, which is a representative index for the overall movement of the stock market

Therefore, the risks in investment of REIT are relatively lower

Page 32: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 32

Risks of a REIT

Beta Coefficient of REITBeta Coefficient of REIT

Looking at the stock market, we could use Beta to measure the sensitivity of REIT to the stock market

It is a measure of the volatility, or the systematic risk of a security on a portfolio in comparison to the market as a whole

Beta is calculated by using regression analysis and it can be described as the correlation of the move of a security to the swings in the market

Page 33: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 33

Risks of a REIT

Beta coefficient of REIT (cont’d)Beta coefficient of REIT (cont’d)

A Beta of 1 indicates that the security's price will movewith the market

A Beta of less than 1 means that the security will move less than the market

A Beta of larger than 1 indicates that the security's price will move more than the market

Page 34: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 34

Risks of a REITBeta coefficient of Hong Kong REITsBeta coefficient of Hong Kong REITs(As of late Oct 2008 over 2 years)(As of late Oct 2008 over 2 years)

Name of REIT Stock Code BetaRREEF CCT REIT 625 0.74

The link REIT 823 0.61Prosperity 808 0.69GZI REIT 405 0.72

Champion REIT 2778 0.70Sunlight REIT 435 0.80

Regal REIT 1881 0.76Average 0.72

Hysan 0014 0.81Wharf Holdings 0004 0.91

Wheelock Properties 0049 0.84

Average 0.85Source: Bloomberg

Page 35: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 35

Risks of a REIT

Beta Coefficient of REIT (cont’d)Beta Coefficient of REIT (cont’d)

From the table provided, the average Hong Kong REIT Beta is around 0.72

The average Beta for property developers and the market are 0.85 and 1 respectively

This indicates that REIT is less sensitive to the market change

Page 36: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 36

Risks of a REIT

Risk associated with REITRisk associated with REIT

Performance of the Property Market• Fall in the prices/ valuations of properties will drag down unit

prices• Low occupancy and rental will affect distributable incomes

Insufficient diversification• Location• Number of properties• Variety of property type

Tenancy durations and quality of tenants • shorter tenancy terms

-> higher number of tenant changes / voids -> unstable rental income

Rental Guarantee and IPO Valuation • Special financial engineering• duration and validity of rental guarantees provided by the

property vendors • effects on the IPO valuation

Page 37: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 37

REIT vs.

Direct Property Investment

Page 38: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 38

REIT vs. Direct Property Investment

After discussing the unique characteristic and risk of REIT,

the difference between REIT and direct property investment will be highlighted

Factors for considerationFactors for consideration

Return on Investment Leverage/ Cost of Borrowing Valuation Volatility Taxation

Page 39: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 39

REIT vs. Direct Property Investment

  REITREIT       PropertiesProperties              Revenue    Property Income

-Interest Payment (depends on leverage) - Landlord's Expenses  

- Management Expenses    Net Income Yield    Operating income       - Tax         Net Income       x Payout Ratio       

  Dividend Dividend Yield       

Page 40: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 40

REIT vs. Direct Property Investment

Liquidity of Property Assets• Investment Fund Available• The potential buyers – Buying sentiment expectations• Strata-title properties available in market

Maturity of Property Market• Frequency of transactions • Legal Framework on Conveyancing, Leasing and Asset

Management• General Perception of buy / sell sides

Page 41: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 41

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Page 42: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 42

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Although REIT is relatively stable and less sensitive to the market change, the performance of REIT still suffered considerably under the turmoil of subprime crisis, followed by global credit crunch

Under the impact of subprime crisis, the entire Asian REIT market, REIT IPO, REIT acquisition, market sentiment all turn sluggish and lose their impetus

Page 43: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 43

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Sluggish REIT MarketSluggish REIT Market

The leading Asian REITs market experienced consolidation, following the broad correction in the global equity markets in the first half of 2008 as the subprime crisis spilled over to other financial market segments and the macro economic environment turned dimmer overall

The total market capitalisation of Asian REITs recorded a 9.4% contraction within the first six months in 2008, following a 4.5% decline in the second half of 2007

The three major growth drivers for Asian REITs – new listings, acquisitions and robust property fundamentals – are all losing their impetus to varying degrees.

Page 44: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 44

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Sluggish REIT Market (cont’d)Sluggish REIT Market (cont’d)

Given the continuing credit squeeze, IPO fund raising and financing for on-going acquisitions have become more difficult since late 2007

Property fundamentals, although still basically resilient for most Asian REITs, they have shown signs of softening as office demand may be impacted by a growing conservation in corporate expansion plans and rental growth is decelerating after the huge run up experienced by most markets in recent years

Page 45: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 45

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Major Acquisition by Asian REITs (1Major Acquisition by Asian REITs (1stst Half 2008) Half 2008)

The first half of 2008 continued to witness REIT acquisition activities, despite the prevailing pessimism, especially on the part of financially sound REIT

One of the notable transactions of the period was Champion REIT’s acquisition of Langham Place retail and office portions from its major shareholder Great Eagle at a total consideration of HK$12.5 billion (US$1.6 billion)

However, the global credit squeeze is making it difficult for REIT to raise further funds to buy new assets. Japan saw a number of REITs cancel their planned acquisitions due to capital raising difficulties. Such situation is most pronounced among REITs with high gearings

Page 46: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 46

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Forecast of REIT performance in 2008 year Forecast of REIT performance in 2008 year endend

Against the backdrop of extremely low vacancy in prime locations and sustained high rental income, prices of many REITs in Asia have dipped below their respective net asset value (NAV), resulting in higher yield level

In Hong Kong, the yield increased from 6.03% to 6.67% in the first six months of 2008, against the 2.95% of the overall stock market

Under the current market conditions, investors are likely to remain cautious with respect to any investment decisions and pace of acquisitions by REITs could further slow should the tight credit environment show no improvement in the year’s remaining months

Page 47: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 47

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Hong Kong REIT marketHong Kong REIT market

Amid jitters in the equity and credit markets worldwide, the IPO market in Hong Kong experienced rapid cooling in the first half of 2008 and no new REIT was launched during the period under review

Total number of HK-REIT remained at seven, with a total market capitalisation of US$ 5.1 billion (HK$39.8 billion)

The dull market condition for Hong Kong REIT has forced property owners to re-consider their plans to list their real estate investment trusts

In January, Far East Consortium International Limited announced its plan to spin-off its mid-market hotels into the HK Hotel REIT. However, given the volatility of the capital market and unattractive pricing, Far East finally decided to postpone the spinoff programme in March even though the ordinary resolution to undertake the spin-off was passed in EGM.

Page 48: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 48

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Hong Kong REIT marketHong Kong REIT market

Following the SFC’s clarification in October 2007 that overseas acquisitions do not need approval, REIT started to amend their investment scopes

Investment activities of Prosperity REIT and Regal REIT will no longer be restricted to Hong Kong or Greater China region

Similarly, GZI REIT was permitted to shed its former restriction of being only permitted to invest in Guangdong Province and will henceforth be permitted to target properties in mainland China, Hong Kong and Macau as well

Page 49: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 49

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Hong Kong REIT marketHong Kong REIT market

REIT acquisitions in Hong Kong have not been active since the inauguration of the listing of REIT in the SAR in 2005

Given the current slowdown in real estate investment activities, REITs are likely to temporarily cease purchasing new assets and rather concentrate their efforts on existing portfolios to sustain revenue growth

Launching new REIT can remain challenging, if the general securities market remains in bearish mood

Page 50: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 50

Impact of Subprime Crisis

Hong Kong REITs Performance (as of late Oct 2008)Hong Kong REITs Performance (as of late Oct 2008)

Name of REIT

Stock Code Date Listed Offer price

(HK$)

Closing price as of late Oct 08

(HK$)

% change since Date

Listed

The Link REIT 00823 25-Nov-05 10.300 13.40 + 30.1%Prosperity REIT 00808 16-Dec-05 2.160 0.82 - 62.0%

GZI REIT 00405 21-Dec-05 3.075 1.50 - 51.2%Champion REIT 02778 24-May-06 5.100 1.83 - 64.1%

Sunlight REIT 00435 21-Dec-06 2.600 1.17 - 55.0%Regal REIT 01881 30-Mar-07 2.680 0.72 - 73.1%RREEF CCT REIT 00625 22-Jun-07 5.150 1.98 - 61.6%

Source: Bloomberg and CBRE Research

Page 51: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 51

Impact of Subprime Crisis

The Hong Kong Hang Seng Index (HSI) plummeted from 31,492 in early-Nov 2007 to 13,968 in late-Oct 2008, down by 55.6% over the year. Starting from Sept 2008, the HSI experienced a severe drop, triggered by global financial tsunami

Hong Kong Hang Seng Index香港恒生指数

Source: http://hk.finance.yahoo.com

Page 52: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 52

Impact of Subprime CrisisStock Price PerformanceStock Price PerformanceFrom early-Nov 2007 to late-Oct 2008From early-Nov 2007 to late-Oct 2008

Link REIT 领汇房地产投资信托基金 Prosperity REIT 泓富产业信托

GZI REIT 越秀房地产投资信托基金 Champion REIT 冠君产业信托

- 23.8% - 48.8%

- 52.7% - 60.2%

Source: http://hk.finance.yahoo.com

Page 53: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 53

Impact of Subprime CrisisStock Price PerformanceStock Price PerformanceFrom early-Nov 2007 to late-Oct 2008From early-Nov 2007 to late-Oct 2008

On average, more than 50% decline was recorded in HK REITs during the period

Amongst others, Link REIT relatively outperformed the other REITs, with only 23.8% decline during the period

Sunlight REIT 阳光房地产投资信托基金 Regal REIT 富豪产业信托

RREEF CCT REIT睿富中國商業房地產投資信托基金

- 53.6% - 70.4%

- 44.8%

Source: http://hk.finance.yahoo.com

Page 54: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 54

REIT in Mainland China

Page 55: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 55

REIT in Mainland China To date, there is no setting up of REIT in Mainland China

Due to the slowdown of China economic growth, the macro-economic control is relaxed and measures are taken as follows:-• Enable regional government to rescue the economy• Reduce the deed tax in relation to property transaction• Strengthen alarming system of property market

Under such circumstances, in order to facilitate financing, it is expected the structure of REIT will be set up at the end of 2008

Also, in order to reduce the exposure of risk from banks, the government is planning to securitize the assets, thus encouraging various methods of financing

Source: HK Wenweipo [2008-10-20]

Page 56: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 56

REIT in Mainland China

Problem faced by REIT in Mainland ChinaProblem faced by REIT in Mainland China

Setting up REIT-related limited companies and Setting up REIT-related limited companies and companies limited by sharescompanies limited by shares

May result in conflicts with relevant provisions in Company Law and Securities Law. Also, setting up special purpose vehicle (SPV) to REIT IPO is still not passed

Problems faced:-• In accordance with Company Law, the net asset value

(NAV) of foreign investment shall not exceed 50% • Conflicts in profit exist in company management and

asset management

Source: CNETNews.com.cn [2008-10-21]

Page 57: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 57

REIT in Mainland China

Problem faced by REIT in Mainland ChinaProblem faced by REIT in Mainland China

Offshore REIT management company for REIT IPOOffshore REIT management company for REIT IPO

As stipulated in Securities Investment Fund Law of the PRC, the financial assets for investment shall be:-• Publicly listed stocks and bonds• Other securities approved by regulatory bodies from

the State Council

To issue REIT in terms of securities investment fund may require amendment of relevant laws passed by the National People’s Congress

Source: CNETNews.com.cn [2008-10-21]

Page 58: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 58

REIT in Mainland China

Problem faced by REIT in Mainland ChinaProblem faced by REIT in Mainland China

Setting up unit trust of REIT in terms of trust basisSetting up unit trust of REIT in terms of trust basis

Despite less regulatory restrictions, there is no precedent for REIT IPO in stock markets

As stipulated in Trust Law, the single issue of trust shall not exceed 200 units

The regulatory bodies remain doubtful about the issuance of REIT in terms of trust basis

Source: CNETNews.com.cn [2008-10-21]

Page 59: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 59

Managing a REIT

Page 60: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 60

Managing a REIT

Asset Asset ManagementManagement

Provide management services from routine property and facilities operations to decision making at strategic levels

To maximize the net return and enhance the capital value of the property

Risk Management

Sustainable Development

Property Portfolio

ManagementCash Flow Analysis

Leasing

Acquisition & Disposal of Assets

Advice on Capital Market

Activities

Strategic LevelsStrategic Levels

Page 61: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 61

Managing a REIT

Property Portfolio ManagementProperty Portfolio Management

Diversification Economy of Scale Look for the best combination to maximize

return and minimize risk To formulate, implement and advise on policies

and programs on portfolio level To advise on financial viability of major

renovation / redevelopment / disposals

Page 62: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 62

Managing a REIT

Strategy Planning & SettingsStrategy Planning & Settings

Strategic levels embrace posing the proper questions and seeking the answers to fulfill long-term decision making

• Increasing recognition of Portfolio Management’s importance in preserving and enhancing the value of properties.

• Evolvement of Property Market Merge with Capital Market. • Acquisition / Disposal Strategy Look global to maximize returns and diverse risks

Page 63: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 63

Managing a REIT

Cash Flow AnalysisCash Flow Analysis

To maximize the net return, whilst preserving and enhancing the capital value of the property.

The return can be variously measured in terms of income and income growth or capital appreciation or a combination of the two Decision Analysis

Payback methodReturn on

capital employedapproach

Discounted cash flow approach

Net present value technique

Internal rate of return

approach

Page 64: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 64

Managing a REIT

Good ManagementGood Management

Portfolio and Asset Management expertise Market knowledge – ahead and strategic Transparency Good understanding of the requirement of

investors Match with management objective. Valuation Methods

• Net Asset Value (NAV)• Net Present Value (NPV)• Earnings Per Unit (EPU)• Funds From Operation (FFO)

Page 65: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 65

Managing a REIT

REIT-related services in real estate REIT-related services in real estate industryindustry

Due Diligence Purposes• Valuation & Advisory Services• Consulting Services (including market studies)• Building Consultancy Services

Pro-acquisition Purposes• Asset / Property Management• Leasing / Agency

Page 66: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 66

Conclusion

Page 67: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 67

Conclusion

There is already the implementation of REIT in Japan, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea and Malaysia. It is foreseen that there would be more and more countries launching REIT in the very future but in a very cautious manner

Traditionally, REIT is accounted for high liquidity, tax benefit, transparency, high dividend yield, inflation hedge, lower risk and portfolio diversification. It could be the alternative to direct real estate investment

Page 68: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 68

Conclusion (cont’d)

Under the turmoil of Subprime crisis, the entire Asian REIT market, REIT IPO, REIT acquisition, market sentiment all turn sluggish and lose their impetus. The total market capitalisation of Asian REIT recorded a 50% contraction as of late Oct 2008 when compared to late Oct 2007

After overcoming the regulatory impediments, the implementation of REIT in Mainland China is yet to be launched for greater financing opportunities

A strategic and specialized management of properties in the portfolio of REIT certainly adds value to the asset itself as well as investors

Page 69: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 69

Q&A

Page 70: Ceo Presentation   Reit

CB Richard Ellis | Page 70

Thank you