c:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

93
VENTILATOR ASSOCIATED PNEUMONIAS current perceptions Dr.T.V.Rao MD Professor Department of Microbiology Sri Deva Raj Urs Medical College, Tamaka, Kolar , India Tamaka Kolar 1 [email protected]

Upload: tumalapalli-venkateswara-rao

Post on 07-May-2015

3.071 views

Category:

Health & Medicine


2 download

DESCRIPTION

entilator associated pneumonia

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 1

VENTILATOR ASSOCIATED PNEUMONIAScurrent perceptions

Dr.T.V.Rao MDProfessor Department of Microbiology Sri Deva Raj Urs Medical College,

Tamaka, Kolar , India

Tamaka Kolar

Page 2: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 2

PneumoniaStill the “Old man’s friend?”

• Bacterial, Viral, Chemical, Aspiration, Nosocomial, Community Acquired, “Walking,” Bronchopneumonia, Necrotizing, Ventilator associated

Page 3: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 3

Pneumonia can be a life threatening condition

Is Something Serious ?• Hospital-acquired

pneumonia (HAP) and ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP), is an important cause of morbidity and mortality in hospitalized patients.

Page 4: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 4

Ventilator associated pneumonia

• Ventilator associated pneumonia (VAP) is defined as nosocomial pneumonia occurring in a patient after 48 hours of mechanical ventilation via a tracheal or tracheostomy tube. It is commonly classified as either early onset (occurring within 96 hours of start of mechanical ventilation) or late onset (>96 hours after start of mechanical ventilation)

Page 5: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 5

Early concepts• As early as 1972, studies have shown that the

airway of mechanically ventilated patients quickly becomes colonized with gram-negative organisms. In the past, it was thought that pathogens came from the ventilator equipment in use. However, as the problem was studied and evidence accumulated, it became evident that the origin of the VAP was from a source other than the ventilator equipment.

Page 6: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 6

Ventilator Associated Pneumonia (VAP) - Key Points -

• VAP is the 2nd most common nosocomial infection = 15% of all hospital acquired infections

• Incidence = 9% to 70% of patients on ventilators• Increased ICU stay by several days• Increased avg. hospital stay 1 to 3 weeks• Mortality = 13% to 55%• Added costs of $40,000 - $50,000 per stay

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2003. Rumbak, M. J. (2000). Strategies for prevention and treatment. Journal of Respiratory Disease,

21 (5), p. 321;

Page 7: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 7

Centres for Disease and Control• The diagnosis of

pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients is difficult, and still there is no "gold-standard" diagnostic method. It is usually based on the combination of clinical, radiological, and microbiological criteria defined by Centres for Disease and Control (CDC)

Page 8: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 8

Challenge and Controversy• The diagnosis and

management of VAP remains one of the most controversial and challenging topics in management of critically ill patients.”

Page 9: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 9

Who are prone -High Risk Patients• For Sepsis

– Post op / post procedure / post trauma– Post splenectomy (encapsulated organisms)– Cancer – Transplant / immune supressed– Alcoholic / Malnourished

• For Dying– Genetic predisposition (e.g. meningococcus)– Delayed appropriate antibiotics– Yeasts and Enterococcus– Site

• For Both– Cultural or religious impediment to treatment

Page 10: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Nosocomial infection are Multidrug Resistant

• Many patients with HAP, VAP, and HCAP are at increased risk for colonization and infection with MDR pathogens

• HAP and VAP are a frequent cause of nosocomial infection that is associated with a higher crude mortality than other hospital-acquired infections

10

Page 11: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 11

Aspiration• Aspiration of colonized

pathogenic microorganisms on the oropharynx and gastrointestinal tract is the main route for the development of VAP. On the other hand, the major risk factor for VAP is intubation and the duration of mechanical ventilation

Page 12: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 12

Variation of Incidence Rate

• In different studies, the incidence of VAP was reported different, depending on the definition, the type of hospital or ICU, the population studied, and the type of rate calculated and varies from 7% to 70% In a large database, 1-day point prevalence study, conducted in 1417 European ICUs, pneumonia accounted for 47% of nosocomial infections

Page 13: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 13

Aero digestive ,upper airway + upper digestive tract contribute pathogens

• The primary route of VAP pathogenesis is a combination of two processes: bacterial colonization of the aero digestive (upper airway + upper digestive) tract and the subsequent aspiration into the lower airway.

Page 14: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 14

When does VAP occur?

• Cook et al showed . . .– 40.1% developed before day 5– 41.2% developed between days 6 and 10– 11.3% developed between days 11-15– 2.8% developed between days 16 and 20– 4.5% developed after day 21

Cook et al. Incidence of and risk factors for ventilator-associated pneumoniain critically ill patients.

Page 15: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 15

Time frame of intubation and risk

• Risk of pneumonia at intubation days– 3.3% per day at day 5– 2.3% per day at day

10– 1.3% per day at day

15

.

Page 16: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

PAHOGENESIS– The pathogenesis of

ventilator-associated pneumonia usually requires that two important processes take place:

• Bacterial colonization of the aero digestive tract

• The aspiration of contaminated secretions into the lower airway.

16

Page 17: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 17

Mechanical device also contributes the events

Page 18: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Etiology• Bacteria cause

most cases of HAP, VAP, and HCAP and many infections are polymicrobial; rates are especially high in patients with ARDS

18

Page 19: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 19

Causative Organisms• Early onset:

– Haemophilus influenza– Streptococcus pneumoniae– Staphylococcus aureus (methicillin sensitive)– Escherichia coli– Klebseilla

• Late onset:– Pseudomonas aeruginosa– Acinetobacter– Staphylococcus aureus (methicillin resistant)

• Most strains responsible for early onset VAP are antibiotic sensitive. Those responsible for late onset VAP are usually multiple antibiotic resistant

Am J Resp Crit Care (1995)

Page 20: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 20

 Summary of pathogens responsible for VAP in a study of 420 patients.

Hunter J D Postgrad Med J 2006;82:172-178

©2006 by The Fellowship of Postgraduate Medicine

Page 21: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 21

Drug resistance a concern in Ventilator Associated Pneumonias

• A. baumanni was the most common emerging isolated pathogen many of them were multidrug-resistant (MDR) or pan drug-resistant (PDR). The other common isolated pathogens were K. pneumoniae, P. aeruginosa and methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA).

Page 22: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Other Isolates in Ventilator associated Pneumonias

– Pseudomonas aeruginosa.• the most common MDR gram-negative bacterial pathogen

causing HAP/VAP, has intrinsic resistance to many antimicrobial agents

– Klebsiella, Enterobacter, and Serratia species.• Klebsiella species

– intrinsically resistant to ampicillin and other aminopenicillins and can acquire resistance to cephalosporins and aztreonam by the production of extended-spectrum –lactamases (ESBLs)

– However ESBL-producing strains remain susceptible to carbapenems ?

• Enterobacter species• Citrobacter and Serratia species

22

Page 23: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Acinetobacter species

– Acinetobacter species

• More than 85% of isolates are susceptible to carbapenems, but resistance is increasing , Most recent concern.

• Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, and Burkholderia cepacia:

– resistant to carbapenems ?

23

Page 24: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

Newer Carbapenemases

• As of June 2010, there were three reported cases of Enterobacteriaceae isolates bearing this newly described resistance mechanism in the US, the CDC stated that "All three U.S. isolates were from patients who received recent medical care in India."

Page 25: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya
Page 26: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pneumoniae

– Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus• vancomycin-intermediate S. aureus

– sensitive to linezolid – linezolid resistance has emerged in S. aureus, but is currently

rare ?

– Streptococcus pneumoniae and Haemophilus influenzae.

• sensitive to vancomycin or linezolid, and most remain sensitive to broadspectrum quinolones

26

Page 27: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

L. Pneumophila and environment

• Rates of L. pneumophila vary considerably between hospitals and disease occurs more commonly with serogroup 1 when the water supply is colonized or there is ongoing construction

27

Page 28: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Influenza too can cause VAP• Nosocomial virus and fungal

infections are uncommon causes of HAP and VAP in immunocompetent patients. Outbreaks of influenza have occurred sporadically and risk of infection can be substantially reduced with widespread effective infection control, vaccination, and use of anti influenza agents

28

Page 29: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 29

Fungal pathogens can cause VAP

–Fungal pathogens.•Aspergillus species

•Candida albicans

Page 30: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 30

Pathogenesis – Entry of Pathogens

• Where do the bacteria come from?– Tracheal colonization- via oropharyngeal

colonization or GI colonization– Ventilator system

• How do they get into the lung?– Breakdown of normal host defenses– Two main routes

• Through the tube• Around the tube- microaspiration around ETT cuff

Page 31: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 31

Oropharyngeal colonization can be source of VAP

• Scannapieco et al showed a transition in the colonization of dental plaques in patients in the ICU

• Control=25 subjects presenting to preventive dentistry clinic

• Study group=34 noncardiac patients admitted to medical ICU at VA hospital (sampled within 12 hours of admission and every third day)

Page 32: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 32

Gastrointestinal colonization

• Increased gastric pH leads to bacterial overgrowth

• Reflux can then lead to colonization of oropharynx

• Use of antacids and H2 blockers associated with GI colonization

Safdar et al. The pathogenesis of ventilator-associated pneumonia: its relevance to developing effective strategies for prevention

Page 33: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 33

Viral Pathogens

• Outbreaks of HAP, VAP, and HCAP due to viruses, such as influenza, parainfluenza, adenovirus, measles, and respiratory Syncytial virus have been reported and are usually seasonal.

• Influenza, pararinfluenza, adenovirus, and respiratory Syncytial virus account for 70% of the nosocomial viral cases of HAP,VAP, and HCAP

Page 34: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 34

Bio films• Many species, including

Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus, produce bio films, which surround the organisms when attached to endotracheal tubes, and make them relatively resistant to the actions of antibiotics and host defences.

Page 35: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 35

Bio films,• The surviving

organisms may play a role in relapses by shedding infective particles from the endotracheal tube into the lower respiratory trac

Page 36: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Multidrug resistant organisms are associated with …

• The prevalence of MDR pathogens varies by patient population, hospital, and type of ICU, which underscores the need for local surveillance data

• MDR pathogens are more commonly isolated from patients with severe, chronic underlying disease, those with risk factors for HCAP, and patients with late-onset HAP or VAP

36

Page 37: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 37

Diagnosis?• A pulmonogist with

25+ years experience guesses he is only correct 60% of the time when diagnosing pneumonia before seeing the CXR. A little better than a coin-toss.

Page 38: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 38

Diagnosis is imprecise and usually based on a Combination of

–Clinical factors - fever or hypothermia; change in secretions; cough; apnea/ bradycardia; tachypnea

–Microbiological factors - positive cultures of blood/sputum/tracheal aspirate/pleural fluids

–CXR factors - new or changing infiltrates

Page 39: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected]

Strategies in Diagnosis in VAP are multifaceted

• Clinical Strategy

• Bacteriologic Strategy

• Comparing Diagnostic Strategy

39

Page 40: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 40

Diagnostic practices

• VAP– Invasive versus non-invasive techniques– BAL/PBB versus tracheal aspirate– Quantitative versus non-quantitative methods

• Infection definitions– Clinician decision or standardised definitions

Page 41: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 41

Specimen collection for Optimal Results

• Distal airway samples may be obtained by using bronchoscopic or nonbronchoscopic techniques. With nonbronchoscopic techniques, a catheter is blindly advanced through the endotracheal tube or tracheostomy and wedged in the distal airway. Various sampling methods include blind bronchial suction (BBS), blind BAL, and blind PSB sampling.

Page 42: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 42

Bacteriologic Strategy• Quantitative cultures can be

performed on endotracheal aspirates or samples collected either bronchoscopically or nonbronchoscopically, and each technique has its own diagnostic threshold and methodologic limitations. The choice of method depends on local expertise, experience, availability, and cost

doctortvrao
Page 43: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 43

Nonquantitative or semiquantitative airway sampling.

• Gram staining and nonquantitative and semiquantitative cultures of tracheal secretions have the advantages of reproducibility and of requiring little technical expertise and no specialized equipment or technique. However, these studies add little to the sensitivity and specificity of the clinical diagnosis of VAP, as the upper respiratory tract is rapidly, within hours of intubation, colonized by potential pulmonary pathogens, even when pneumonia is not present

Page 44: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 44

Specimen collection• Tracheobronchial secretions were collected by

the pulmonologist , following specimen collection guidelines, after tracheal instillation of 5 ml saline. The specimens were sent to the laboratory and cultivated within 1 hour of collection. A dilution of the tracheal aspirate was prepared and inoculated with a calibrated loop on chocolate agar and MacConkey agar

Page 45: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 45

Qualitative cultures X Qualitative cultures

• Qualitative cultures were considered positive when the growth of any micro-organism occurred, and quantitative cultures were considered positive when the growth of 105 colony-forming units (cfu)/ml or more was observed.

Page 46: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 46

Culture positivity true or false?

• Qualitative cultures were considered positive when the growth of any micro-organism occurred and quantitative cultures were considered positive when the growth of 105 colony-forming units (cfu)/ml or more was observed. cultures from tracheal aspirates were calculated according to standard formulae

Page 47: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 47

Which is optimal sample ?

• Despite numerous publications on the subject, controversy still exists on the optimal method of microbiological diagnosis of VAP,As the trachea and tracheal tube rapidly become colonised with bacteria in the critically ill patient, cultures of sputum or tracheal aspirates may simply yield colonising organism

Page 48: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 48

Differentiates between pathogenic from non pathogenic ?

• Analysing samples using quantitative culture techniques theoretically permits differentiation between oropharyngeal organisms present at low concentrations and the higher concentrations of pathogenic organisms.

Page 49: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 49

WHY IS THERE NO GOLD STANDARD?

• After more than 10 years of trying multiple invasive and non-invasive diagnostic techniques, the procedure which is specific, sensitive, rapid and inexpensive is yet to be developed. No studies have shown the superiority of any specific diagnostic method currently in use, thus, medical community still has no gold standard for the diagnosis of VAP

Page 50: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 50

Good Microbiology practices reduces Antibiotic usage

• Invasive tests such as bronchoscope BAL or protected specimen brush (PSB) may avoid the extended use of antibiotics for clinically insignificant organisms, but no direct consensus or evidence suggests that one test is superior to the other; all have their advantages and disadvantages.

Page 51: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 51

Precautions in collecting and transporting

• After proper hand washing and wearing sterile gloves before suctioning, the endotracheal secretions were collected by instilling 1-2 ml of sterile normal saline into the endotracheal tube and then collecting it back with the help of sterile mucous trap. The specimen collected was immediately transported to the laboratory within one hour of collection.

Page 52: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

Gram stain is highly sensitive

Sputum or tracheal suction gram stain NO ORGANISMS

in non-neutropenic pts.

NO HAP/VAP 94%

[email protected]

Page 53: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

Gram staining of secretions are useful in early decisions

• The upper respiratory tract of patients is colonized with potential pulmonary pathogens a few hours after intubation. A positive Gram's stain may guide the initial antibiotic therapy. However prior antibiotic and corticosteroid therapy can reduce the sensitivity of this technique

[email protected]

Page 54: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 54

Bacterial culture of tracheal secretion

• Qualitative culture - non specific• Semi-quantitative

culture - low specificity• Quantitative

culture : TS, BAL, PSB

- increase specificity

Page 55: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 55

Collection of bronchial Secretions

• Distal airway samples may be obtained by using bronchoscopic or nonbronchoscopic techniques. With nonbronchoscopic techniques, a catheter is blindly advanced through the endotracheal tube or tracheostomy and wedged in the distal airway. Various sampling methods include blind bronchial suction (BBS), blind BAL, and blind PSB sampling.

Page 56: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 56

Bronchoscopic BAL

• Bronchoscopic BAL has been in use since 1988 (See Figure 1); however, the BAL technique is still not completely standardized. The amount of liquid instilled into the lung for specimen retrieval varies from 130 to 150 ml, with the first sample being discarded.

Page 57: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 57

Collection of bronchial Secretions

• Distal airway samples may be obtained by using bronchoscopic or nonbronchoscopic techniques. With nonbronchoscopic techniques, a catheter is blindly advanced through the endotracheal tube or tracheostomy and wedged in the distal airway. Various sampling methods include blind bronchial suction (BBS), blind BAL, and blind PSB sampling.

Page 58: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 58

• The sensitivity of quantitative BAL is 42 to 93% with a mean of 73%. Specificity is 45 to

• 100% with a mean of 82%. Specific affected area of the lung can be visualized and sampled

• • More accurate than sputum or tracheal aspirates• • May enable physician to identify non-infectious

lesions• • Detects intracellular organisms in BAL cultures

quickly and specifically• with highly positive predictive value

Page 59: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 59

Bacterial culture of tracheal secretion

• Qualitative culture - non specific• Semi-quantitative culture - low specificity• Quantitative culture : TS, BAL, PSB - increase specificity

Page 60: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 60

Protected Specimen Brush ProBAL© PSB by Mill-Rose

• The protected specimen brush technique for the diagnosis of pneumonia has been used for 20 years. This bronchoscopic technique use a sample collection brush (protected by a sheath) inside the scope channel until the suspect portion of the lower airway has been reached. The brush is then extended into the desired specimen and withdrawn. This technique was first described in 1979 by Wimberly, et al.

Page 61: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 61

Semiquantitative

1+ : rare <10 colonies/plate2+: few 10-102 colonies/plate3+: moderate >102-3

colonies/plate4+: numerous >103-4

colonies/plate5+: numerous >104 colonies/plate

Page 62: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 62

Collection of bronchial Secretions

• Distal airway samples may be obtained by using bronchoscopic or nonbronchoscopic techniques. With nonbronchoscopic techniques, a catheter is blindly advanced through the endotracheal tube or tracheostomy and wedged in the distal airway. Various sampling methods include blind bronchial suction (BBS), blind BAL, and blind PSB sampling.

Page 63: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 63

Qualitative and quantitative

• Qualitative endotracheal aspirates are easy to obtain but have a high false-positive rate in ICU patients because of airway colonization. When quantitative endotracheal-aspirate cultures are used, a cutoff value of 106 is the most accurate, with a sensitivity of 38-82% and a specificity of 72-85%

Page 64: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 64

Differing opinions in specimen collection

• Recent studies have consistently shown that outcome in VAP may not be influenced by whether cultures are obtained by bronchoscope or from tracheal aspirates collected at the bedside. Furthermore, a cost effectiveness analysis strongly supported the employment of tracheal aspirates in the management of VAP.

• Ruiz M, Torres A, Ewig S, Marcos MA, Alcón A, Lledó R, Asejo MA,Maldonado M: Non-invasive versus invasive microbial investigation in ventilator associated pneumonia: evaluation of

outcome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2000, 162:119-125.

Page 65: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 65

Severely ill patients need

• In selected groups of severely ill patients, quantitative cultures of tracheal aspirates should not replace qualitative cultures for confirmation of diagnosis or management of antibiotic therapy.

• Ventilator associated pneumonia: comparison betweenquantitative and qualitative cultures of tracheal aspirates Luis Fernando Aranha Camargo1, Fernando Vinícius De Marco2, Carmen Sílvia Valente Barbas1, Cristiane Hoelz1, Marco Aurélio Scarpinella Bueno1, Milton Rodrigues Jr1, Verônica Moreira Amado1, Raquel Caserta3, Marinês Dalla Valle Martino4, Jacyr Pasternak4 and Elias Knobel5

Page 66: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 66

Which methods of collection is better

• Two diagnostic strategies for ventilator-associated pneumonia — bronchoalveolar lavage with quantitative culture of the bronchoalveolar-lavage fluid and endotracheal aspiration with nonquantitative culture of the aspirate — are associated with similar clinical outcomes and similar overall use of antibiotics

• A Randomized Trial of Diagnostic Techniques for Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia N Engl J Med 2006; 355:2619-2630December 21, 2006

Page 67: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 67

False negative – False Positive Results

• Investigators reported that the clinical diagnosis of VAP is associated 30–35% false-negative and 20–25% false-positive results . And also, ICU patients do not always have systemic signs of infection due to their underlying disease (chronic renal failure)

Page 68: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 68

Other Supporting Bacterial Cultures

• Bacteraemia and positive pleural effusion cultures are generally considered to be able to identify the organisms causing the pneumonia, if no other source of infection is found. Therefore,

most experts recommend that investigation of suspected VAP should include taking two sets of blood samples for culture and tapping pleural > 10 ml, even though spread to the blood or

pleural space occurs in < 10% of VAP

Page 69: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 69

Multiresistant pathogens in Ventilator associated pneumonias

• The incidence of multiresistant pathogens is also closely linked to local factors and varies widely from one institution to another. Consequently, each ICU must continuously collect meticulous

epidemiologic data

Page 70: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 70

Uncommon microbes are often missed

• Legionella species , anaerobes fungi viruses, and even Pneumocystis carinii should be mentioned as potential causative agents but are not considered to be common in the context of pneumonia acquired during MV. However, several of these causative agents may be more common and potentially underreported because of difficulties involved with the diagnostic

Page 71: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 71

Immunological methods in Diagnosis

• A recently described immunological method for the diagnosis of VAP holds great promise for the future. The triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells (TREM-1) is a member of the immunoglobulin super family, and is involved in the acute inflammatory response. Neutrophils express high levels of TREM-1 on exposure to infected tissues.

Page 72: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 72

Newer Methods in Diagnosis

• Gibot and colleagues prospectively studied 148 mechanically ventilated patients with suspected VAP. A rapid immunoblot technique was used to measure soluble triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells TREM-1 in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid. They showed that the presence of soluble TREM-1 in the bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid was a highly accurate method for the diagnosis of fungal or bacterial pneumonia with a sensitivity of 98% and a specificity of 90%.

Page 73: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 73

How much a clinician needs from Microbiology

• Culture results are currently used to guide adjustment or withdrawal of antibiotic therapy rather than to decide whether to treat or not. The practice of changing therapy with culture results has resulted in reduced consumption of antibiotics.

• Conversely, studies have shown that over-treatment with antibiotics may select organisms such as Pseudomonas aeruginosaand Acinetobacter calcoaceticus

Page 74: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 74

Mortality

Appropriate Mortality

Inappropriate Mortality

Early Mortality

Evidence-based early and appropriate therapy in VAP

Page 75: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 75

Benchmarking prescribing practice

• Triggers to starting antibiotics– Regular sampling versus clinician guided– Timing in relation to investigation

• Choice of antibiotic regimen– Early empiric broad-spectrum cover versus narrow

spectrum with escalation• De-escalation practice• Duration of prescription

Page 76: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 76

Best option in choosing Antibiotics

• Considerations in making selection– Setting (community, NH, hospital)– Suspected organism (GNRs, GPCs)– Host factors (immunosuppression)– Local susceptibility patterns

• Initial empiric and broad; subsequent narrowing–Concept is to not miss the organism

with initial coverage and then de-escalate when able to do it.

Page 77: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 77

Continuous Removal of Subglottic Secretions

Use an ET tube with continuous suction through a dorsal lumen above the cuff to prevent drainage accumulation

Use an ET tube with continuous suction through a dorsal lumen above the cuff to prevent drainage accumulation

Page 78: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 78

No uniformity in treatment schedules

• However, despite these advances, the majority of issues related to the management of VAP remain unresolved and are subject to controversy. This is particularly true for the diagnostic evaluation of the patient with suspected VAP.

Page 79: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 79

Clinical diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia

What is not controversial? • Clinical criteria for the diagnosis of VAP

have a limited diagnostic accuracy.• This is true for single criteria such as infiltrates

in chest radiograph, fever or hypothermia, leukocytosis or leucopoenia, and increase in the amount and/or purulence of tracheobronchial secretions, as well as for diagnostic rules incorporating some of these criteria.

Page 80: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 80

HandwashingHandwashing

What role does handwashing play in nosocomial pneumonias? The greatest role

Page 81: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 81

VAP Prevention• Wash hands before

and after suctioning, touching ventilator equipment, and/or coming into contact with respiratory secretions.

Page 82: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 82

Epidemiological data differs from situations

• The incidence of multiresistant pathogens is also closely linked to local factors and varies widely from one institution to another. Consequently, each ICU must continuously collect meticulous

epidemiologic data

Page 83: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 83

Can we deliver a successful Treatment

• Successful treatment of patients with VAP remains a difficult and complex undertaking. Despite broad clinical experience with this disease, no consensus has been reached concerning issues as basic as the optimal antimicrobial regimen or its duration. In fact, to date, evaluation of various antimicrobial strategies for the treatment of bacterial VAP has been difficult for several reasons.

Page 84: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 84

Supporting Evidences• Consequently, most

experts recommend that two sets of blood cultures and a thoracentesis for nonloculated pleural effusions of ≥10 mm in diameter on a lateral decubitus chest radiograph should be part of the evaluation of suspected VAP

Page 85: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 85

Handwashing

• Hand washing is the single most important (and easiest!!!) method for reducing the transmission of pathogens.

• Use of waterless antiseptic preparations is also acceptable and may increase compliance.

Page 86: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 86

Oral Care• Dental plaque contains multiple pathogens

(may include s. aureus and p. aeruginosa)• After 48 hours, normal oral flora of

critically ill pts changes to more virulent gram (-) organisms

• Aspiration of oral secretions around the cuff and ETT occurs in all vented patients

• VAP rates are reduced when oral care measures are included in a comprehensive prevention program

Page 87: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 87

Probiotics in VAP

• Probiotics prophylaxis of VAP using Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG appears safe and efficacious in a select population with a very high risk of VAP, "Ultimately, probiotics may fulfil a role in antimicrobial stewardship programs given the reductions in antibiotic consumption.

• American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine.

Page 88: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 88

Patient examination in the Intensive Care Unit

• MORE IS MISSED BY NOT LOOKING

• THAN BY NOT KNOWING

Page 89: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 89

Interdisciplinary rivalry increases Mortality

• VAP is an excellent example of a problem that can best be solved by interdisciplinary cooperation rather than interdisciplinary rivalry and devaluing the contributions of selected members of the health care team.

Page 90: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 90

"Million Lives Campaign”

• "Million Lives Campaign" and included use of a ventilator bundle of interventions, developed and implemented the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI IHI Institute for Healthcare Improvement (Boston, MA, USA)

..... (http://www.ihi.org/IHI/Topics/

Page 91: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 91

Medical Profession is Changing from Confidence to Confusion ?

Page 92: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 92

References• American Thoracic Society. HAP in adults: diagnosis, assessment of severity, initial antimicrobial therapy

and preventive strategies. Am J Resp Crit Care 1995;153: 1711-1725. • Chastre J. et al. Ventilator Assosciated Pneumonia. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002; 10:364-368.• Cutler C> et al. Improving oral care in patients receiving mechanical ventilation. Am J Crit Care 2005; 14(5):

389-394.• Grap M. et al. Preventing VAP: evidence-based care 2004; 16: 349-458.• Keenan S. et al. VAP: prevention, diagnosis, and therapy. Crit Care Clin 2002; 18(1): 107-125.• Kollef M. Prevention of hospital associated and ventilator associated pneumonia. Crit Care Med 2002; 32:

1396-1405.• Marik, P. et al. One good turn deserves another. Crit Care Med 2002; 30(9): 2146-2148.• Anesthesiology: Pneumatikos, Ioannis A. M.D., Ph.D., F.C.C.P.; Dragoumanis, Christos K. M.D., Ph.D.;

Bouros, Demosthenes E. M.D., Ph.D., F.C.C.P. March 2009 - Volume 110 - Issue 3 - pp 673-680 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2003. Rumbak, M. J. (2000). Strategies for prevention and

treatment. Journal of Respiratory Disease, 21 (5), p. 321;• Anesthesiology: Pneumatikos, Ioannis A. M.D., Ph.D., F.C.C.P.; Dragoumanis, Christos K. M.D., Ph.D.;

Bouros, Demosthenes E. M.D., Ph.D., F.C.C.P.vMarch 2009 - Volume 110 - Issue 3 - pp 673-680• Ventilator associated pneumoniaJ D Hunter Correspondence to: Dr J D Hunter Department of

Anaesthetics and Intensive Care, Macclesfield District General Hospital, Victoria Road, Macclesfield SK10 3BL, UK; [email protected]

Page 93: C:\documents and settings\administrator\desktop\vap presentation ramayya

[email protected] 93

Presented as Guest Lecture at Indian Association of Medical Microbiologists

(IAMM)- KC held at M.S. Ramaiah Medical College, Bangalore India on 4th Sept 2010

email [email protected]