cci mainstreaming challenge overview final, kate morrison
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
CCI Mainstreaming ChallengeOverview of results
Kate Morrison, Vulture Street
July 3rd 2009
When & who
- Held June 8th – 23rd
- 112 invited to participate- researchers + Advisory Board + 14 externals
- 31.25% contributed ideas, comments & votes- above average for ‘ideation’ activities
(typically ~20%)
What happened?
- Generated 22 ideas, 96 comments and 103 votes
- 88% of written contributions (ideas & comments) from internal CCI participants
- Of participants >50% only commented or voted- over 11% only voted, 40% only commented- i.e. jam provides 3 different ways to
contribute
Ideas & comments over time
Mid-point
reminder sent
Votes over time
Mid-point
reminder sent
Top 9 ideas by popularity (ascending)
Rank Net Vote
s
Idea Description Contributed By
4th (joint)
4 National Broadband Network - NBN- Leadership
Brian Fitzgerald
4th (joint)
4 Launching special issues in journals cross-disciplinary
Carsten Herrmann-Pillath
4th
(joint)
4 Broadband Services Advisory Councils
Trevor Barr
Top 9 ideas by popularity (ascending)
Rank Net Vote
s
Idea Description Contributed By
3rd (joint)
5 Australian Culture Online
Brian Fitzgerald
3rd (joint)
5 CCI consulting Jason Potts
3rd (joint)
5 Hold specialist 1 or 2 year forums funded by participants
John Howkins
Top 9 ideas by popularity (ascending)
Rank Net Vote
s
Idea Description Contributed By
2nd
(joint)
7 Mainstreaming through the media – Media Training Workshops
Carrie Miller
2nd (joint)
7 The next stage of innovation research, thinking, and policy
Stuart Cunningham
1st 9 An increased focus on creative production processes
Phil Graham
Congratulations Phil
Most ‘active’ not necessarily most popularIdea All Votes
(+ and -) Net
ScoreComments By
CCI Consulting 9 5 9 Jason PottsAn increased focus on creative production processes
11 9 7 Phil Graham
The next stage of innovation research, thinking, and policy
7 7 8 Stuart Cunningham
Mainstreaming through the media – Media Training Workshops
7 7 6 Carrie Miller
join CSIRO 7 1 7 Jason PottsLaunching special issues in journals cross-disciplinary
8 4 5 Carsten Herrmann-Pillath
Hold specialist 1 or 2 year forums funded by participants
7 5 6 John Howkins
Short Courses? 5 3 3 John BanksAustralian Culture Online 5 5 4 Brian FitzgeraldNBN- Leadership 4 4 5 Brian Fitzgerald
Some topics polarised opinion
- CCI Consulting (7 promotes, 2 demotes)
- Join CSIRO (4 promotes, 3 demotes)
Long tail of contributions
1st
3rd
5th
7th
9th
11th
13th
15th
17th
19th
21st
23rd
25th
27th
29th
31st
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
Proportion of ContributionsMost to Least Prolific Participant
1
3
24
6
5
Top 3 participants by volume responsible
for 38% of contributions
Themes for moving forward
ConsultingNBN
Web applicatio
ns/ repositories/ tools
Academic:
journals/ teaching
/ conferen
ces
Long term
positioning
House in order:
website, media training
NBN
- Broadband Services Advisory Councils (Trevor Barr)
- Leadership in mapping NBN policy framework (Brian Fitzgerald)
Web applications/repositories/tools
- Lightweight content generation tools (Andrew Brown)
- Australian Culture Online (Brian Fitzgerald)
- Wikimedia/pedia (John Quiggin)
- Creative economy policypedia (Julian Thomas)
Consulting
- CCI Consulting (Jason Potts)
- Specialist 1-2 year participant funded forums (John Howkins)
- Short courses (John Banks)
- Convergence Culture Consortium Model (John Banks)
Academic
- Building international alliances with similar institutions (Carsten Herrmann-Pillath)
- Standardise teaching materials/case studies for business schools (CHP)
- Launching special issues in cross-disciplinary journals (CHP)
House in order
- Use CCI website to publish open access research results (Amanda Lawrence)
- Media training workshops (Carrie Miller)
Long term positioning
- Increased focus on creative production processes (Phil Graham)
- The next stage of innovation research, thinking and policy (Stuart Cunningham)
- Inter-disciplinary knowledge advancement (Rachel Parker)
- Creative Industries ministerial responsibility (Ellissa Nolan)
- Harnessing the creative arts to the innovation agenda (Lelia Green)
- Join CSIRO (Jason Potts)- Establish and define current impact (Jo Ann
Tacchi)
Next steps (I)
- All have read-only access to jam site for next 2 months
- We need your feedback on how to enhance the process
Next steps (II)
What actions does the Symposium want to recommend to the CCI Management Committee for taking ideas forward?- Projects?- Taskforces?- Scoping studies?- Any volunteers?
Evidence of ‘group think’?