cbpr 101: making it relevant juan carlos belliard, phd, mph partners for health: communities and...

CBPR 101: Making it Relevant

Juan Carlos Belliard, PhD, MPH

Partners for Health: Communities and Researchers Working Together

Outline»Defining CBPR, what it is, what it isn’t

»Rationale for CBPR

»Guiding Principles

»Ethical Issues

»Forming a CBPR Partnership

»CBPR Resources

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

Learning Objectives»Explain the theoretical basis, definition, rationale and

key principles of CBPR

»Describe how CBPR differs from traditional research approaches

»Identify ethical considerations for researchers and community partners

Acknowledgements

This presentation is an introductory review of Developing and Sustaining Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships: A Skill-Building Curriculum.

We would like to thank Community Campus Partnerships for Health (CCPH) for granting us the permission to use this curriculum to promote Community Based Participatory Research.

Within each of us is a hidden store of energy. Energy we can release to compete in the marathon of life. Within each of us is a hidden store of courage, courage to give us the strength to face any challenge. Within each of us is a hidden store of determination.Determination to keep us in the race when all seems lost.

— Roger Dawson

DEFINITION & RATIONALE

Definition

“A collaborative approach to research that equitably involves all partners in the research process and recognizes the unique strengths that each brings. CBPR begins with a research topic of importance to the community and has the aim of combining knowledge with action and achieving social change...”

(Community Health Scholars Program)

Brookings Institution Report –“The 3rd California”

“The 3rd California”

• Underdevelopment. • Fast growth (200-2005)

• Lower %of high income households

(Kotkin, Joel and Frey, (2007).

California County Health Rankings – San

Bernardino

http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/california

San Bernardino county is ranked as one of the unhealthiest counties in CA

Rank (of 56)

Overall Health Outcomes

45

Mortality (premature deaths)

37

Morbidity 48

Health Factors 50

Clinical Care 54

Social & Economic Factors

37

Physical Environment

54

Foundations for CBPR»Action Research (Kurt Lewin, 1946)

»Empowerment Education (Paulo Freire, 1970)

Hartwig K, Calleson D and Williams M. Unit 1: Community-Based Participatory Research: Getting Grounded. In: The Examining Community-Institutional Partnerships for Prevention Research Group. Developing and Sustaining Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships: A Skill-Building Curriculum. 2006. www.cbprcurriculum.info

Rationale

»Traditional research has failed to solve complex health disparities

»Community burn out

»Community input can improve the research design and results

Rationale

»Research findings can be applied more effectively

»Improved researcher-community relationships

Hartwig K, Calleson D and Williams M. Unit 1: Community-Based Participatory

Research: Getting Grounded. In: The Examining Community-Institutional

Partnerships for Prevention Research Group. Developing and Sustaining Community-

Based Participatory Research Partnerships: A Skill-Building Curriculum.

2006. www.cbprcurriculum.info

COMPARE RESEARCH APPROACHES:

TRADITIONAL VERSUS CBPR


Identified health

concern(s)

Study design and funding

Participant recruitment

and retention system

Full participation of community in identifying issues of greatest importance.

Community representatives involved with study design and proposal submission.

Community representatives provide guidance regarding recruitment and retention strategies.

Issues identified based on epidemiologic data and funding opportunities.

Design based entirely on scientific rigor and feasibility; funding requested primarily for research expenses.

Approaches to recruitment and retention based on scientific issues and “best guesses” regarding reaching community members and keeping them involved in the study.

Increased motivation to participate in research process.

Increased acceptability of study approach, include funds for community.

Enhanced recruitment and retention.

Measurement instrument(s) designed and data collected

Intervention design and implemented

Data analyzed and interpreted, findings disseminated and translated

Measurement instruments developed with community input and tested in similar population.

Community members help guide intervention development.

Community members assist researchers with interpretation, dissemination, and translation of findings.

Measurement instruments adopted/adapted from other studies. Tested chiefly with psychometric analytic methods.

Researchers design intervention based on literature and theory.

Researchers report findings from statistical analysis and publish in peer-reviewed journals.

Potentially sensitive issues handled better and increased reliability and validity of measures.

Assures greater cultural and social relevance to the population served, increasing the likelihood of producing positive change.

Assures greater sensitivity to cultural and social norms and climate and potential group harm and enhances potential for translation of findings into practice.

PRINCIPLES OF CBPR

Israel, B. Schulz, A., Parker, E., Becker, A., Allen, A., and Guzman, J. R. (2003). Critical issues in developing and following community based participatory principles. In M. Minkler and N. Wallerstein (Eds.), Community-based participatory research for health (pp. 53-76). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass/Wiley

Principles of CBPRRecognizes community as a unit of identity

Builds on strengths and resources within the community

Facilitates collaborative partnerships in all phases of the research

Integrates knowledge and action for mutual benefit of all partners

Promotes a co-learning and empowering process that attends to social inequalities

Involves a cyclical and incremental process

Addresses health from both positive and ecological perspectives

Disseminates findings and knowledge gained to all partners

Discussing the Definitions, Principles and Rationale of CBPR-Exercise• Do you believe it is necessary to discuss these definitions

and principles of CBPR and their rationale at the first meeting? Why or why not?

• If you decide to include discussions of some or all of them, who should bring these up and how?

• What power dynamics would you want to consider in a discussion of this nature?


ETHICAL ISSUES IN CBPR


Who is “The Community”?

»Who represents the community?

»Who represents the community?

»Who speaks for the community?

More Questions on Ethics»Is it legitimate or ethical for community members to come

from only a few neighborhoods or social identity groups, thus benefiting some communities more than others?

»What if certain neighborhoods or communities are more outspoken, have greater community organizing skills, or are more comfortable negotiating with academic researchers than others?

»Do academic researchers have a responsibility to seek participation from all communities, or just work with the groups who are the most outspoken, or easiest, to work with?

Ethical Research Principles»Respect for human dignity»Respect for free and informed consent»Respect for vulnerable persons»Respect for privacy and confidentiality»Respect for justice and inclusiveness»Balancing harms and benefits»Minimizing harms»Maximizing benefits

IDENTIFYING & SELECTING PARTNERS

Sarah Flicker, Kirsten Senturia and Kristine Wong Unit 2 Developing a CBPR Partnership-Getting Started. In: The Examining Community-Institutional Partnerships for Prevention Research Group. Developing and Sustaining Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships: A Skill-Building Curriculum. 2006. www.cbprcurriculum.info

Characteristics of Effective Partners

»They are willing and committed»Their organizational mission is in alignment»They have trust and a history of engagement in the

community »They have staff and/or volunteer capacity to participate »They have engaged, competent researchers and

research staff»They have support and involvement from leaders at all

levels »They are knowledgeable about the community

Characteristics of Effective Partners

»They strive for cultural competency»They have skills in collaboration »They have interpersonal and facilitation skills »They have technical skills »They have commitment and connections to the

community »They are committed to the partnership process and

the substantive issues being addressed by the

partnership

Incentives to Partner (Community)»Access resources»Advocate for policy change»Create jobs»Improve services»Protect the community»Solve a problem»Gain political capital

Incentives to Partner (Academics)»Attract and support students»Advance careers»Demonstrate/address inequities and injustices»Generate knowledge»Link personal and professional goals and values»Meet funding agency expectations»Obtain institutional funding

IS CBPR RIGHT FOR YOU?


Questions to Ask Before Starting»Is opportunism and self-interest driving the agenda?

»Do you and your team have the necessary skills?~ Cultural competence~ Communication~ Listening~ Sharing power and control over decisions

Questions to Ask»Are you as a researcher uncomfortable with changing your

methods and/or approach to working with participants?

»Are you a community member who simply wants an intervention or community service but who has no interest in research questions?

»Do the ethical considerations related to burden and benefits to the community outweigh potential research benefits?

»What if you don’t “buy into” the values and principles of CBPR?

"Education either functions as an instrument which is used to facilitate integration of the younger generation into the logic of the present system and bring about conformity or it becomes the practice of freedom, the means by which men and women deal critically and creatively with reality and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world.” — Paulo Freire (Pedagogy of the Oppressed)

RESOURCES

Journals

» Progress in Community Health Partnerships: Research, Education, and Action. http://pchp.press.jhu.edu

» An increasing number of peer-reviewed journals are publishing articles and theme issues on CBPR. For example:

~ The November 2004 issue of the Journal of Interprofessional Care http://journalsonline.tandf.co.uk/link.asp?id=WP6TA2TN1HAJ

~ The July 2003 issue of the Journal of General Internal Medicine http://depts.washington.edu/ccph/pdf_files/JGIM3.pdf

» For a listing of journals that publish CBPR, visit http://depts.washington.edu/ccph/links.html#Journals .

Funding» Directory of Funding Sources for Community-Based Participatory Research. Prepared by

Community-Campus Partnerships for Health for a June 2004 Conference on Improving the Health of Our Communities through Collaborative Research sponsored by the Northwest Health Foundation. This directory includes funding agency descriptions, deadlines, contact information, examples of previously funded CBPR projects, and an annotated listing of funding resource websites. http://depts.washington.edu/ccph/pdf_files/directory-062704f.pdf

» Funding resources for CBPR include:

~ Robert Wood Johnson

~ Kellogg

~ National Institutes of Health (NIH)

Training» Health Leadership Training Guide (HLTG): A Training Guide For Community Members Dedicated to

Becoming Effective Health Leaders. Produced by the City of Long Beach Department of Health and Human Services, the HLTG can be used by residents, community-based organizations, and health departments that are interested in training residents to become effective health leaders in their community. The HLTG is grounded in solid experience of the Long Beach Partnership in planning, developing, and implementing a yearlong Health Leadership Training program. The HLTG is a tool that will increase the internal capacity of residents to build and hone their community leadership skills. The guide is organized in to five main sections: 1) Identifying and Assessing Community Problems, 2) Solving Community Health Problems, 3) Community leadership Skills, 4) Group Retreat, and 5) Graduation. Each section provides a workshop description, learning objectives, teaching materials, quizzes, trainer’s note, and references. http://partnershipph.org/col2/showcase/pdf/hltg_eng.pdf

» The Examining Community-Institutional Partnerships for Prevention Research Group. Developing and Sustaining Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships: A Skill-Building Curriculum. 2006. www.cbprcurriculum.info

» Community-Based Participatory Research: A Partnership Approach for Public Health . Israel, Coombe, & McGranaghan, University of Michigan Office of Public Health Practice (www.cbpr-training.org)

cbpr 101: making it relevant juan carlos belliard, phd, mph partners for health: communities and...

Documents

sustaining community

research design

research process

community input

community campus partnerships

prevention research

research topic of importance

cbpraction research