8/9/2019 Cathay Pacific Airways v Juanitra Reyes

1/3

ALHAMBRA, RAYMOND PATRICK P.

CATHAY PACIFIC AIRWAYS v JUANITRA REYES, WILFREDO ROY REYES, SIXTALAPUZ, and SAMPAGUITA TRAEL CORP.G.R. N!. "#$#%", J&n' (), (*"+

PEREZ, J.

M!-a da/a0'1, 2n 3-'a45'1 !6 4!n7-a47, 21 2n !-d'- &8!n a 15!92n0 75a7 75'd'6'ndan7 a47'd 6-a&d&'n7: !- 2n 3ad 6a275N!/2na da/a0'1 /a: 3' a9a-d'd 7! a 8a2n72; 95!1' -2057 5a1 3''nv2!a7'd !- 2nvad'd 3: 75' d'6'ndan7, 6!- 75' 8&-8!1' !6 v2nd24a72!n !--'4!0n2 7! Ma: ?,

"%%>. U8!n 4!!@2n0 and 4!n-/a72!n !6 75'2- 2057 145'd&', W26-'d! 8a2d6!- 75' a2-6a-' and 9a1 211&'d 6!&- Ca75a: Pa424 -!&nd7-28 a2-8an' 724@'716!- Man2aH!n0 K!n0Ad'a2d'H!n0 K!n0Man2a.

On' 9''@ 3'6!-' 75': 9'-' 145'd&'d 7! : 3a4@ 5!/', W26-'d!-'4!n-/'d 521 6a/2:=1 -'7&-n 2057 9275 75' Ca75a: Pa424 !4' 2nAd'a2d', 75': 9'-' adv21'd 75a7 75' -'1'-va72!n 9a1 172 !@a: a1145'd&'d. On 75' da: !6 75'2- 145'd&'d d'8a-7&-' 6-!/ Ad'a2d', W26-'d!and 521 6a/2: a--2v'd a7 75' a2-8!-7 !n 72/'. W5'n 75' a2-8!-7 45'4@2n!8'n'd, W26-'d! 9a1 2n6!-/'d 3: a 17a; 6-!/ Ca75a: Pa424 75a7 75'R':'1'1 d2d n!7 5av' 4!n-/'d -'1'-va72!n1, and !n: S27a=1 2057 3!!@2n0

9a1 4!n-/'d. N'v'-75''11, 75': 9'-' a!9'd 7! 3!a-d 75' 2057 7! H!n0K!n0 d&' 7! ada/an7 8'a1 6-!/ W26-'d!. W5'n 75': a--2v'd 2n H!n0 K!n0,75': 9'-' a0a2n 2n6!-/'d 75' 1a/' 8-!3'/. Un6!-7&na7': 7521 72/', 75'R':'1'1 9'-' n!7 a!9'd 7! 3!a-d 3'4a&1' 75' 2057 7! Man2a 9a1 6&:3!!@'d. On: S27a 9a1 a!9'd 7! 8-!4''d 7! Man2a 6-!/ H!n0 K!n0. On 75'6!!92n0 da:, 75' R':'1'1 9'-' na: a!9'd 7! 3!a-d 75' n'7 20573!&nd 6!- Man2a.

U8!n a--2v2n0 2n 75' P522882n'1, W26-'d! 9'n7 Sa/8a0&27a T-av' 7! -'8!-775' 2n42d'n7. H' 9a1 2n6!-/'d 3: Sa/8a0&27a T-av' 75a7 27 9a1 a47&a:Ca75a: Pa424 95245 4an4''d 75'2- 3!!@2n01.

ISSUEWa1 75'-' a 3-'a45'd 271 4!n7-a47 !6 4a--2a0' 9275 75' REYES and a-' 75'-':'1 'n727'd 6!- da/a0'1 Can Sa/8a0&27a 7-av' 3' a1! 5'd 2a3' 6!- da/a0'1 d&' 7! 271 n'020'n4'

HELD

8/9/2019 Cathay Pacific Airways v Juanitra Reyes

2/3

Y'1, Ca75a: Pa424 3-'a45'd 271 4!n7-a47 !6 4a--2a0' 9275 75' R':'1'1 95'n 27d21a!9'd 75'/ 7! 3!a-d 75' 8an' 2n H!n0 K!n0 0!2n0 7! Man2a !n 75' da7'-''47'd !n 75'2- 724@'71. T5&1, Ca75a: Pa424 !8'n'd 271'6 7! 4a2/1 6!-4!/8'n1a7!-:, a47&a, /!-a and ''/8a-: da/a0'1, a77!-n':=1 6''1 and4!171 !6 1&27.

T5' R':'1'1 'n7'-'d 2n7! a 4!n7-a47 !6 4a--2a0' 9275 Ca75a: Pa424. A1 6a- a1-'18!nd'n71 a-' 4!n4'-n'd, 75': 9'-' 5!d2n0 va2d and 4!n-/'d a2-8an'724@'71. T5' 724@'7 2n 271'6 21 a va2d 9-277'n 4!n7-a47 !6 4a--2a0' 95'-'3: 6!- a4!n12d'-a72!n, Ca75a: Pa424 &nd'-7!!@ 7! 4a--: -'18!nd'n71 2n 271 a2-8an'6!- a -!&nd7-28 2057 6-!/ Man2a 7! Ad'a2d', A&17-a2a and 75'n 3a4@ 7!Man2a. In 6a47, W26-'d! 4a'd Ca75a: Pa424 !4' 2n Ad'a2d' !n' 9''@3'6!-' 521 -'7&-n 2057 7! -'4!n-/ 521 3!!@2n0. H' 9a1 'v'n a11&-'d 3: a17a; !6 Ca75a: Pa424 75a7 5' d!'1 n!7 n''d 7! -'4!n-/ 521 3!!@2n0.

W275 -'0a-d1 7! Sa/8a0&27a T-av', 75' 4!n7-a47&a -'a72!n 3'79''n 75'/

and 75' R':'1'1 21 a 4!n7-a47 !6 1'-v24'1. T5' !3'47 !6 75' 4!n7-a47 21a--an02n0 and 6a4227a72n0 75' a77'-=1 3!!@2n0 and 724@'72n0. I7 9a1 'v'nSa/8a0&27a T-av' 95245 211&'d 75' 724@'71. S2n4' 75' 4!n7-a47 3'79''n 75'R':'1'1 and Sa/8a0&27a T-av' 21 an !-d2na-: !n' 6!- 1'-v24'1, 75' 17anda-d!6 4a-' -'&2-'d !6 -'18!nd'n7 21 75a7 !6 0!!d 6a75'- !6 a 6a/2: &nd'- A-724'"">+ !6 75' C2v2 C!d'

T5'-' 9a1 2nd''d 6a2&-' !n 75' 8a-7 !6 Sa/8a0&27a T-av' 7! ''-421' d&'d220'n4' 2n 8'-6!-/2n0 271 !320a72!n1 &nd'- 75' 4!n7-a47 !6 1'-v24'1. I7 9a1'17a3215'd 3: Ca75a: Pa424, 75-!&05 75' 0'n'-a72!n !6 75' Pa11'n0'- Na/'R'4!-d1 PNR, 75a7 Sa/8a0&27a T-av' /ad' 79! 47272!&1 3!!@2n01 6!-

J&an27a and M245a'.

Und'- A-724' (((* !6 75' C2v2 C!d' !6 75' P522882n'1, an a9a-d !6 /!-ada/a0'1, 2n 3-'a45'1 !6 4!n7-a47, 21 2n !-d'- &8!n a 15!92n0 75a7 75'd'6'ndan7 a47'd 6-a&d&'n7: !- 2n 3ad 6a275. W5a7 75' a9 4!n12d'-1 a1 3ad6a275 95245 /a: 6&-n215 75' 0-!&nd 6!- an a9a-d !6 /!-a da/a0'1 9!&d 3'6a275 2n 1'4&-2n0 75' 4!n7-a47 and 2n 75' ''4&72!n 75'-'!6, a1 9' a1 2n'n6!-4'/'n7 !6 271 7'-/1, !- an: !75'- @2nd !6 d'4'27. In 75' 1a/' v'2n, 7!9a--an7 75' a9a-d !6 ''/8a-: da/a0', d'6'ndan7 /&17 5av' a47'd 2n9an7!n, 6-a&d&'n7, -'4@'11, !88-'112v', !- /a'v!'n7 /ann'-.

W5a7 /a: 3' a77-23&7'd 7! Ca75a: Pa424 21 n'020'n4' 4!n4'-n2n0 75' a81'12n 75'2- 8-!4'11 !6 4!n-/2n0 8a11'n0'- 3!!@2n01 and -'1'-va72!n, d!n'75-!&05 7-av' a0'n42'1. B&7 7521 n'020'n4' 21 n!7 1! 0-!11 a1 7! a/!&n7 7!3ad 6a275. Ca75a: Pa424 9a1 n!7 /!72va7'd 3: /a24' !- 3ad 6a275 2n n!7a!92n0 -'18!nd'n71 7! 3!a-d !n 75'2- -'7&-n 2057 7! Man2a. I7 21 'v2d'n7and 9a1 2n 6a47 8-!v'n 3: Ca75a: Pa424 75a7 271 -'6&1a 7! 5!n!- 75' -'7&-n2057 3!!@2n01 !6 -'18!nd'n71 9a1 d&' 7! 75' 4an4'a72!n !6 !n' 3!!@2n0

8/9/2019 Cathay Pacific Airways v Juanitra Reyes

3/3

and 75' 79! !75'- 3!!@2n01 9'-' n!7 -''47'd !n 271 4!/8&7'-2