case 1:12-cv-00893-tse-trj document 43 filed 10/04/12 page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 case...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA1Alexandria Division
E I L E
OCT 4 2012
CLERK. U.S. DISTRICT COURTALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA
THE HISPANIC LEADERSHIP FUND,
INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
FEDERAL ELECTION
COMMISSION,
Defendant.
Case No. I:12cv893
MEMORANDUM OPINION
This federal election lawdeclaratory judgment case presents two unusual questions:
(i) Whether a plaintiff seeking a declaratory judgment that certain advertisementsto be published in the election season do not trigger the Federal ElectionCampaign Act's1 ("FECA") disclosure requirements meets Article Ill's standingand ripeness requirements where, as here, the Federal Election Commission("FEC") deadlocked on the advertisements and then voted 6:0 that it could notreach a conclusion on them; and,
(ii) Whether an advertisement that criticizes or targets the oil or healthcarepolicies of "the Administration," "the White House," or "the Government" makesit unambiguously apparent, by context, that the advertisement identifies a specificfederal candidate—President Obama—and thus constitutes an electioneeringcommunication under FECA.
For thereasons that follow, the ripeness and standing jurisdictional requirements are met
and some, but not all, of the advertisements at issue are "electioneering communications" subject
to FECA's disclosure requirements.
The Federal Election Campaign Act of 1972, Pub.L. 92-225, 86 Stat. 3 (codified as amended at2U.S.C. §§431 etseq.)
1
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583
![Page 2: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 2 of 33 PageID# 584
![Page 3: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 3 of 33 PageID# 585
![Page 4: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 4 of 33 PageID# 586
![Page 5: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 5 of 33 PageID# 587
![Page 6: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 6 of 33 PageID# 588
![Page 7: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 7 of 33 PageID# 589
![Page 8: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 8 of 33 PageID# 590
![Page 9: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 9 of 33 PageID# 591
![Page 10: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 10 of 33 PageID# 592
![Page 11: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 11 of 33 PageID# 593
![Page 12: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 12 of 33 PageID# 594
![Page 13: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 13 of 33 PageID# 595
![Page 14: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 14 of 33 PageID# 596
![Page 15: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 15 of 33 PageID# 597
![Page 16: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 16 of 33 PageID# 598
![Page 17: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 17 of 33 PageID# 599
![Page 18: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 18 of 33 PageID# 600
![Page 19: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 19 of 33 PageID# 601
![Page 20: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 20 of 33 PageID# 602
![Page 21: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 21 of 33 PageID# 603
![Page 22: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 22 of 33 PageID# 604
![Page 23: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 23 of 33 PageID# 605
![Page 24: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 24 of 33 PageID# 606
![Page 25: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 25 of 33 PageID# 607
![Page 26: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 26 of 33 PageID# 608
![Page 27: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 27 of 33 PageID# 609
![Page 28: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 28 of 33 PageID# 610
![Page 29: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 29 of 33 PageID# 611
![Page 30: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 30 of 33 PageID# 612
![Page 31: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 31 of 33 PageID# 613
![Page 32: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 32 of 33 PageID# 614
![Page 33: Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 … · 2017. 4. 10. · 1 Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 1 of 33 PageID# 583. Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fd9f3a8ec14dd3d7c54bb19/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Case 1:12-cv-00893-TSE-TRJ Document 43 Filed 10/04/12 Page 33 of 33 PageID# 615