cameron yourkowski renewable northwest project 503-223-4544 integration of intermittent renewable...

17
Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544 www.RNP.org Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Upload: adrianna-daughtrey

Post on 15-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Cameron YourkowskiRenewable Northwest Project503-223-4544www.RNP.org

Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources

NASUCASeattle, WAJune, 2013

Page 2: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Renewable Northwest Project (RNP)

Objective:Promote the responsible development of renewable energy

Geography: OR, WA, ID, MTMembers: Business, non-profit, academic

Page 3: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Overview:•Renewables Growth

•Integration Challenges

•Integration Solutions

•Scheduling (“shorter is better”)•Forecasting (“don’t be afraid to de-commit”)•BAA Coordination (“strength through diversity”)•Market Formation (“build it and they will come”)

Page 4: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013
Page 5: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Renewable Projects in the Northwest2012

Page 6: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

BPA Wind Ramp:

Page 7: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

7

BPA Load, April 1-7, 2008

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

1 618 1235 1852 2469 3086 3703 4320 4937 5554 6171 6788 7405 8022 8639 9256 9873

Minute

MW Load

BPA Load and Wind, April 1-7, 2008

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

1 619 1237 1855 2473 3091 3709 4327 4945 5563 6181 6799 7417 8035 8653 9271 9889

Minute

MW

Load

Wind

BPA Load, Wind and Load net of Wind, April 1-7, 2008

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

1 617 1233 1849 2465 3081 3697 4313 4929 5545 6161 6777 7393 8009 8625 9241 9857

Minute

MW

Load minusWind

Load

Wind

Page 8: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

8

BPA Load, Wind and Load net of Wind, April 1-7, 2008

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

1 617 1233 1849 2465 3081 3697 4313 4929 5545 6161 6777 7393 8009 8625 9241 9857

Minute

MW

Load minusWind

Load

Wind

Page 9: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Northwest Market Structure

•No Organized Markets

•No Ancillary Service Market

•Hourly Schedule

•Reliance on single resource (hydro)

•No forecast of balancing reserve needs

Page 10: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Problems & Solutions:

ProblemsCostDSO 216

SolutionsShorter SchedulingForecasting Needs/De-Committing reservesDiversityBAA CooperationMarket Formation

Page 11: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Scheduling & Forecasting

Page 12: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Wind Diversity

Page 13: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Energy Imbalance Market

Page 14: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013
Page 15: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013
Page 16: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013
Page 17: Cameron Yourkowski Renewable Northwest Project 503-223-4544  Integration of Intermittent Renewable Resources NASUCA Seattle, WA June, 2013

Conclusion“demand a response”

EIM and Demand Response