california coastal commission conservation voting...

!"#$%"#&'()'*+#""%',-.(/'0#%1.#'23"',3%45%-'!"35#65+37/'*."2"+&#"'83.7&%5+37/'

,%-+23"7+%',3%459##$#"':--+%76#/',%-+23"7+%',3%45%-'!"35#65+37';#5<3"9'=',3%45<%-9',%-+23"7+%

!"#$%&'(#)*+',#-.#/*01.*#2'*%3$45'&#*#,'%*,'678.0#9*557':#53'#)-'&&*#;719<(#)*+'#=898#$7-(8#>*(?#@8&%'#3*(#A&'+*-7',#-.#(*+-.0#*#+'&B#(A'%-*7#*&'*#84#)8153'&.#C*&-5-D'#;3*A*&&*7#8.#=898#$7-(8#E-,0'#-.#/*01.*#2'*%3#F#

*#5&1'#+-%58&B#48&#81&#%8*(5*7#&'(81&%'(G##

!"##$%&'#$()$*+,$-.#$/-+,0$&12$3+445//5+1$6+-#$+7-8+4#9

!"#$!"%$!&&$'()'*%+,-.*"$*/$-0.1$%*,+2("-$.1$(",*+'!3(%$!"%$/+&&#$)('2.11.4&($+"%('$&!5$."$-0($."-('(1-$*/$,*!1-!&$)'*-(,-.*"$!"%$)+4&.,$)!'-.,.)!-.*"

2010California Coastal Commission

Conservation Voting Chart

2010 California Coastal Commission Conservation Voting Chart


H*I#>3*5#53'#;*7-48&.-*#%8*(5*7#J8.'#-(#*#,-(5-.%5#*.,#+*71*97'#.*51&*7#&'(81&%'#84#+-5*7#*.,##'.,1&-.0#-.5'&'(5#58#*77#53'#A'8A7'#*.,#'K-(5(#*(#*#,'7-%*5'7B#9*7*.%',#'%8(B(5'DG

H9I#>3*5# 53'#A'&D*.'.5#A&85'%5-8.#84# 53'# (5*5'<(#.*51&*7# *.,# (%'.-%# &'(81&%'(# -(# *#A*&*D81.5#%8.%'&.#58#A&'('.5#*.,#4151&'#&'(-,'.5(#84#53'#(5*5'#*.,#.*5-8.G

F#;*7-48&.-*#;8*(5*7#$%5#84#LM!N:#;*7-48&.-*#O197-%#E'(81&%'(#;8,'#)'%5-8.#PQQQL#

Executive Summary>3'# ;*7-48&.-*# ;8*(5*7# ;8DD-((-8.# H;;;I# ;8.('&+*5-8.#R85-.0# ;3*&5# -(# *# S8-.5# '.5'&A&-('#84#53'#)-'&&*#;719:#/'*01'#48&#;8*(5*7#O&85'%5-8.#H/;OI:#)1&4&-,'&#@81.,*5-8.:##;*7-48&.-*#;8*(56?''A'&#$77-*.%':# ;*7-48&.-*# ;8*(5*7# O&85'%5-8.# T'5U8&?# H;;OTI# *.,# ;8*(5U*7?# ;*7-48&.-*G#

>3'('#+85-.0#%3*&5(#3*+'#9''.#A&'A*&',#48&#53'#7*(5#VP#B'*&(G

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

U'77#*(#53'#%8.5&8+'&(-*7#C*7-91#/*088.#&'(58&*5-8.#A&8S'%5G##

>3'#A&8S'%5(#*.*7BJ',#U'&'#('7'%5',#9*(',#8.#53'#48778U-.0#.8.6'K%71(-+'#4*%58&(W#LI#53'#'K5'.5#84# -DA*%5(#8.#%8*(5*7# &'(81&%'(X#VI# 53'#A85'.5-*7# 58#('5# -DA8&5*.5#(5*5'U-,'#A&'%','.5X#PI# 53'#*D81.5#84#41.,-.0#&'Y1-&',#48&#53'#A&8S'%5X#*.,#ZI#U3'53'&#53'#A&8S'%5#A&8A8.'.5#'DA78B',#8.'#8&#D8&'#7899B-(5(G##[.#D8(5#-.(5*.%'(:#53'#%*('(#*.*7BJ',#-.#53-(#&'A8&5#-.+87+',#3-03#'%8.8D-%#

-.%71,',#8.'#8&#D8&'#A*-,#*0'.5(# 58# 7899B#;8DD-((-8.'&(# 58#+85'# -.# 4*+8&#84#,'+'78AD'.5G#\-&'%5#7899B-.0#9'5U''.#*0'.5(#*.,#;8DD-((-8.'&(#-(#&'Y1-&',#9B#7*U#58#9'#A197-%7B#,-(%78(',#*.,#&'%8&,',#*(##:;%&,-##%8DD1.-%*5-8.(:#538103#D8(5#7899B-.0#'KA'.,-51&'(#08#1.&'A8&5',G!

$#,'(%&-A5-8.#84#53'#-((1'(#*.,#&'(81&%'(#*44'%5',#9B#'*%3#+85':#*(#U'77#*(#*#&'%8&,#84#-.,-+-,1*7#;8DD-((-8.'&<(#+85'(#*.,#538('#84#53'-&#$75'&.*5'(:#*AA'*&#-.#53'#48778U-.0#%3*&5(G#>3'('#+85'#

=8U'+'&:#*.B#'&&8&(#*&'#53'#(87'#&'(A8.(-9-7-5B#84#53'#A&'A*&'&(G#

!# [.# VQQ":#$2#!!L:# *1538&',# 9B#$(('D97BU8D*.#/8&-# )*7,*.*# H\6)*.#\-'08I:#U817,# 3*+'#,&*D*5-%*77B#-DA&8+',#&'%8&,-.0#&'Y1-&'D'.5(:#-.%71,-.0#'KA'.,-51&'(#*.,#A197-%#,-(%78(1&'#84#7899B-.0#%8.5*%5(#-.+87+-.0#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.'&(G#$2#!!L#A*((',#53'#;*7-48&.-*#/'0-(7*51&'#-.#VQQ"#915#U*(#+'58',#9B#]8+'&.8&#)%3U*&J'.'00'&#8.#^%589'&#!:#VQQ"G#>8#,*5':#'KA'.('(#

Background$#+85'#84#53'#A'8A7'#-.#LM!V#%&'*5',#53'#8&-0-.*7#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#*.,#53'#;*7-48&.-*#;8*(5*7#$%5#84#LM!N#A&8+-,',#48&#-5(#%8.5-.1-.0#8A'&*5-8.#*(#*.#-.,'A'.,'.5#(5*5'#*0'.%BG"#

>3'#D-((-8.#84#53'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#-(#58#A&85'%5:#%8.('&+':#&'(58&':#*.,#'.3*.%'#'.+-&8.D'.5*7#*.,#31D*.#&'(81&%'(#84#53'#;*7-48&.-*#%8*(5#*.,#8%'*.#48&#'.+-&8.D'.5*77B#

(1(5*-.*97'#*.,#A&1,'.5#1('#9B#%1&&'.5#*.,#4151&'#0'.'&*5-8.(G$

>3'#;8DD-((-8.#-5('74#-(#%8DA&-(',#84#LV#+85-.0#D'D9'&(#H*.,#1A#58#LV#*75'&.*5'#D'D9'&(I#

%8DD1.-5-'(#1A#*.,#,8U.#53'#%8*(5#58#,'7-9'&*5'#53'#D'&-5(#84#A&8A8(',#%8*(5*7#,'+'78AD'.5#A&8S'%5(#U-53-.#53'#LG"6D-77-8.#*%&':#L:LQQ6D-7'#78.0#;*7-48&.-*#%8*(5*7#J8.'G%

>3'# -.,'A'.,'.%':# 9*7*.%'# *.,# -.5'0&-5B# 84# 53'# ;8DD-((-8.# ,'A'.,# 1A8.# 53'# *AA8-.5D'.5#A&8%'((G# $77# +85-.0# D'D9'&(# *&'# *AA8-.5',# 9B# ;*7-48&.-*<(# ]8+'&.8&:# 53'# )'.*5'# E17'(#;8DD-55'':#*.,#53'#)5*5'#$(('D97B#)A'*?'&G#_*%3#*AA8-.5(#481&#;8DD-((-8.'&(:#5U8#84#U38D#

6U-,'#&'A&'('.5*5-8.:#'*%3#84#53'#48778U-.0#0'80&*A3-%*7#*&'*(#*&'#,'(-0.*5',#58#3*+'#8.'#`78%*7#'7'%5',a# +85-.0#D'D9'&# ('*5W# )*.#\-'08:# )8153:# )8153#;'.5&*7:#;'.5&*7:#T8&53#;'.5&*7:# *.,#T8&53#;8*(5#&'0-8.(G#_*%3#;8DD-((-8.'&#D*B#*7(8#3*+'#*.#$75'&.*5':#(19S'%5#58#53'#*AA&8+*7#84#

3-(#8&#3'&#*AA8-.5-.0#*1538&-5BG

b.5-7# VQQP:# *AA8-.5D'.5(# U'&'# .8&D*77B# D*,'# (38&57B# *45'&# *.# *AA8-.5-.0# *1538&-5B# '-53'&#

53'#)'.*5'#8&#53'#$(('D97B:#*.,#*77#*AA8-.5D'.5(#('&+',#*5#53'#A7'*(1&'#8&#U-77#84#53'-&#*AA8-.56-.0#*1538&-5BG#=8U'+'&:#-.#VQQP:#53'#7*U#%8.%'&.-.0#;8DD-((-8.#*AA8-.5D'.5(#*.,#5'&D(#U*(#*D'.,',:#*.,#.8U#*77# '-035#/'0-(7*5-+'#*AA8-.5D'.5(# H481&#*AA8-.5',#9B# 53'#)A'*?'&#84# 53'#$(('D97B# *.,# 481&# *AA8-.5',# 9B# )'.*5'# E17'(# ;8DD-55''# 1.,'&# 53'# 7'*,'&(3-A# 84# 53'#O&'(-,'.5#O&8#>'D#84#53'#)5*5'#)'.*5'I#*&'#%8.(-,'&',#`5'.1&',a#*AA8-.5D'.5(G#>3*5#-(:#8.%'#*#

-.#0'.'&*7#%*..85#9'#&'D8+',#1.5-7#53'#'KA-&*5-8.#84#53'#4177#*AA8-.5D'.5#5'&D#H8&:#-.#53'#%*('#

A*&5-%17*&#&'0-8.IG#[.#%8.5&*(5:#53'#]8+'&.8&<(#481&#*AA8-.5D'.5(#%8.5-.1'#58#('&+'#`*5#U-77a#*.,#%*.#9'#&'D8+',#*5#*.B#5-D'G

[.#*,,-5-8.# 58# 53'# 5U'7+'#+85-.0#;8DD-((-8.#D'D9'&(:# 53'&'#*&'#*7(8# 53&''#.8.6+85-.0#(5*5'#*0'.%B#D'D9'&(W#E'(81&%'(#$0'.%BX#)5*5'#/*.,(#;8DD-((-8.X#*.,#21(-.'((:#>&*.(A8&5*5-8.:#

84#53'#;8DD-((-8.#&'A&'('.5#53'#+-'U(#84#53'#]8+'&.8&#*.,#3*+'#-.#0'.'&*7#D'&'7B#7899-',#48&#D8&'#-.5'.(-+'#,'+'78AD'.5:#&*53'&#53*.#%8*(5*7#A&85'%5-8.#8&#853'&#08*7(#84#53'#;8*(5*7#$%5G

"#)''#;*7G#O19G#E'(G#;8,'#cc#PQQQQ#'5#('YG#$+*-7*97'#8.7-.'#*5#355AWddUUUG%8*(5*7G%*G08+d%%*5%G35D7G

$#C8&'#-.48&D*5-8.#&'0*&,-.0#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#D'D9'&(:#(5*44:#(5*44#*.*7B(-(#*.,#1A%8D-.0#D''5-.0(#*.,#*0'.,*(#481.,#*5#355AWddUUUG%8*(5*7G%*G08+G

%#@8&#*#%8DA7'5'#7-(5#84#%1&&'.5#D'D9'&(#84#53'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.'&(:#$75'&.*5'#;8DD-((-8.'&(#*.,#T8.6+85-.0#;8DD-((-8.'&(:#*.,#53'-&#*AA8-.5D'.5#,*5'(#*.,#5'&D(:

08#58#355AWddUUUG%8*(5*7G%*G08+d&8(5'&G35D7G



#@8&#VQLQ:#53'#*+'&*0'#%8.('&+*5-8.#(%8&'#48&#53'#'.5-&'####;8DD-((-8.#,&8AA',#4&8D#NNe#-.#VQQM#58#NLeG#####>3-(#,'%&'*('#-.#53'#8+'&*77#%8.('&+*5-8.#(%8&'#48&#53'####;8DD-((-8.#%817,#9'#*55&-915',#58W####LI#53'#D-K#84#*0'.,*#-5'D(#('7'%5',#53-(#B'*&X####VI#;8DD-((-8.'&(#53*5#U'&'#`.'Ua#58#53'#;8DD-((-8.#48&####53'#7*(5#(%8&-.0#*&'#.8U#D8+-.0#-.58#53'-&#('%8.,#B'*&#F####.85'#%8DD'.5(#8.#A*0'#ZX####PI#53'#'%8.8D-%#,8U.51&.#84#53'#(5*5'#,&*D*5-%*77B#*44'%5',#####53'#.1D9'&(#84#D*S8&#%8*(5*7#,'+'78AD'.5#A&8S'%5(#%8D-.0######9'48&'#53'#;8DD-((-8.#-.#VQQMG#####[.#VQLQ:#53'#(5*5'<(#'%8.8DB#9'0*.#58#51&.#*&81.,#*.,#D*S8&######,'+'78AD'.5#A&8S'%5(#&'51&.',#58#53'#;8DD-((-8.#48&#,'9*5'####*.,#-.%&'*(',#*AA&8+*7(G#

#)-.%'#LMf!:#53'#;*7-48&.-*#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.<(#+85-.0#######(%8&'(#3*+'#&*.0',#4&8D#*#78U#84#V"e#-.#53'#7*55'&#3*74#84####LMMN#58#*#3-03#84#!Ne#-.#LMM!G#>3'#*+'&*0'#%8.('&+*5-8.####+85-.0#(%8&'#48&#53'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#8+'&#53'#A*(5####VP#B'*&(#-(#.8U#"LeG

###$(('D97B#)A'*?'&#*AA8-.5D'.5(#H!"eI#815A*%',#9853####019'&.*58&-*7#HZPeI#*.,#)'.*5'#E17'(#;8DD-55''#HN"eI#######;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.'&(#48&#A&86%8*(5#+85'(G#

#]8+'&.8&#)%3U*&J'.'00'&<(#%8*(5*7#*AA8-.5D'.5(:#U38######7*00',#('+'&'7B#-.#VQQ!#U-53#S1(5#*#VZe#A&86%8*(5####%8.('&+*5-8.#(%8&':#*.,#*#VMe#-.#VQQf:#S1DA',#*3'*,#-.#VQQM####U-53#*#"Ve#%8.('&+*5-8.#(%8&'G##=8U'+'&:#53-(#(%8&'#,&8AA',######58#ZPe#-.#VQLQG

#>BA-%*77B#`78%*7#'7'%5',a#;8DD-((-8.'&(#3*+'#3*,#78U'&####%8.('&+*5-8.#(%8&'(#53*.#;8DD-((-8.'&(#,&*U.#4&8D####53'#A197-%#*567*&0'G##>3-(#B'*&#53'-&#(%8&'(#U'&'#+'&B#%78('####*5#NQe#*.,#NVe#&'(A'%5-+'7BG##

#^4#53'#(-K#`A197-%a#D'D9'&(:#;8DD-((-8.'&#g*.####H*AA8-.5',#9B#)'.*5'#E17'(#;8DD-55''I#3*,#53'#3-03'(5####%8.('&+*5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'#*5#fQe#H,8U.#4&8D#3'&#VQQM####&*5-.0#84#fPeI:#U3-7'#;8DD-((-8.'&#)5'+'.#h&*D####H*AA8-.5',#9B#]8+'&.8&#)%3U*&J'.'00'&I#3*,#*#%8.('&+*5-8.######(%8&'#84#ZLe#H(7-0357B#1A#4&8D#3-(#VQQM#(%8&'#84#P!e####U3-%3#U*(#53'#78U'(5#(%8&'#84#*77#;8DD-((-8.'&(#-.#VQQMIG

#^4#53'#(-K#`'7'%5',(a#D'D9'&(:#;8DD-((-8.'&#)*.%3'J####H*AA8-.5',#9B#$(('D97B#)A'*?'&I#3*,#53'#3-03'(5####%8.('&+*5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'#*5#MQe#H1A#4&8D#3'&#VQQM#&*5-.0####84#!"eIG

#;8DD-((-8.'&#)5'+'#h&*D#H/8(#$.0'7'(I#-(#*#]8+'&.8&####*AA8-.5''#*.,#845'.#-(#*9('.5#4&8D#3'*&-.0(G##=-(#(%8&'####48&#VQLQ#U*(#ZLe:#U3-7'#3-(#*75'&.*5'#\&G#\*.#)'%8&,####H)*.5*#2*&9*&*I#3*,#*#%8DA*&*97'#+85-.0#(%8&'#84#PfeG#####>80'53'&#53'B#(3*&'#8.'#84#53'#78U'(5#(%8&'(#84#53'####;8DD-((-8.#48&#VQLQ#*(#U'77#*(#VQQM#HZVeIG#

#g3-7'#788?-.0#*5#*75'&.*5'#+85-.0#&'%8&,(:#\&G#;7*&?#O*&?'&:####*75'&.*5'#48&#\&G#2-77#21&?':#3*,#53'#78U'(5#(%8&'#84#*.B####;8DD-((-8.'&#8&#*75'&.*5'#*5#V"eG##\&G#21&?'#U*(#'-53'&####815#84#53'#&88D#8&#,-,#.85#+85'#8.#('+'&*7#-DA8&5*.5#*0'.,*####-5'D(#-.#VQLQ:#'.*97-.0#3-D#58#%*A51&'#*#3-03'&#(%8&'#84#NMeG

Key Findings

&'(&)*#!""#$

+,&*-./0&#%&'()"*

1+.#*-2&1&.#+,-."/0/1-&2.*-3*#4+-/,*#+#332

4*1/5'#4&'

.*-#1'/.#+5/.6+#5()&678&'

.*-#4*3&+#+#&'.

.*,(*4&-3+#%)&##"'9"-:"-

1*#7+11*#1-,"-

.*-3*#,('8#%;3'"

.*-#9(*-,/.,+#<8-.&-828

3 Stone

71%

1 Sanchez

90%

3 Mirkarimi

71%

4 Burke

69%

9 Kram

41%

5 Shallenberger

67%6 Neely

50%

2 Wan

80%

10Achadjian

35%

7 Blank

45%8 Bloom

42%

4 Kruer

69%

2010 California Coastal Commissioners Overall Ranking

Average Voting Score: 61%

!Public Member !Elected Members


g3'.#&'+-'U-.0#53'#*..1*7#R85-.0#;3*&5:#-5#-(#-DA8&5*.5#58#&'D'D9'&#53*5#(8D'#;8DD-((-8.'&(#3*+'#8.7B#('&+',#8.#53'#

;8DD-((-8.#48&#*#&'7*5-+'7B#(38&5#5-D':#U3-7'#853'&(#3*+'#('&+',#48&#D*.B#B'*&(G##[.#VQLQ:#53'#;8DD-((-8.#&'D*-.',#Y1-5'#

%8.(-(5'.5#53&8103815#53'#B'*&#U-53#8.7B#8.'#.'U#*AA8-.5D'.5#-.#\'%'D9'&#HC*&B#$..#E'-((IG##[.#*.#'448&5#58#D*-.5*-.#(5*5-(5-%*7#

*%%1&*%B:#53-(#8.'#+85'#U*(#.85#-.%71,',G

^4#(A'%-*7#.85'#U-53#&'(A'%5#58#;8DD-((-8.'&(#53*5#3*+'#('&+',#

5'.,#58#9'#3-03G##=-(58&-%*77B#-5#-(#845'.#53'#(5&8.0'(5#B'*&#48&#D*.B#.'U7B#*AA8-.5',#;8DD-((-8.'&(G##=8U'+'&:#53'&'#-(#*#%8.(-(5'.5:#,-(51&9-.0#*.,#&*53'&#1.-Y1'#A3'.8D'.8.#53*5#8%%1&(#*.,#%*.#9'#.85',#9B#*#9&-'4#%8DA*&-(8.#84#+85'(#4&8D#8.'#B'*&#58#53'#

.'K5G##C8&'#845'.#53*.#.85:#8.%'#53'#;8DD-((-8.'&(#*&'#

B'*&#84#9'-.0#('*5',:#53'&'#-(#*#,&*D*5-%#,&8A#-.#53'-&#%8.('&+*5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'G##g'#%*..85#1.,'&'(5-6

A&'((1&'#A*-,#*0'.5(#*.,#7899B-(5(#48&#A&8S'%5#*AA7-%*.5(#3*+'#8.#*77#

;8DD-((-8.'&(G

>8#*-,#-.#&'+-'U#84#53-(#&'A8&5:#U'#3*+'#-.%71,',#53'#.1D9'&#

84#+85'(#53*5#'*%3#;8D6D-((-8.'&#%*(5#-.#VQLQ#

-.#*,,-5-8.#58#53'-&#8+'&*77#%8.('&+*6

5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'(G

=,9#8(/<"29"->84#53'#;8DD-((-8.#-.%71,'#)5'+'#27*.?:#)*&*#g*.:#g-77-*D#21&?':#)5'+'.#h&*D:#C*&B#)3*77'.69'&0'&#*.,#O*5&-%?#h&1'&#*.,#*&'#8157-.',#-.#971'G##

?#"(;"6/<"29"->##

8.#53'#;8DD-((-8.G#_7'%5',#C'D9'&(#84#53'#;8DD-((-8.#-.%71,'#28..-'#T''7B#HT8&53#;8*(5I:#E8((#C-&?*&-D-#HT8&53#;'.5&*7#;8*(5I:#C*&?#)58.'#H;'.5&*7#;8*(5I:#h3*5%3-?#$%3*,S-*.#H)8153#;'.5&*7#;8*(5I:#E-%3*&,#2788D#H)8153#;8*(5I:#*.,#_(53'&#)*.%3'J#H)*.#\-'08#;8*(5I#*.,#*&'#8157-.',#-.#A1&A7'G##

2010 California Coastal Commissioners Ranking Comparisons


1 Wan

80%2 Burke

69%

4 Blank

45%

2 Kruer

69%

5 Kram

41%

3 Shallenberger

67%

1 Sanchez

90%

2 Stone

71%

4 Bloom

42%

2 Mirkarimi

71%

5 Achadjian

35%

3 Neely

50%

PUBLIC MEMBERS Average Voting Score: 62%

ELECTED MEMBERS Average Voting Score: 60%

OVERALLRANKING

COMMISSIONERTOTAL

NUMBEROF VOTES CAST

PRO-COASTVOTES

ABSENCES PERCENTAGE

!" #$%&'()&* +" , " -./

, 01&*2 +" 3 " 4./

5 016678 !3 5 ! 4+/

4 09:2; !- 3 5 <3/

3 =:&7 !, , 4 4!/

4 =:9;: !- 3 5 <3/

- >):2&:)7)8 +! !. " ,!/

< ?;;1@ !4 , < ."/

! A&*$%;B8 +! !3 " 3"/

. A%&11;*C;:D;: +! !4 " <,/

- AE6*;8 +! !. " ,!/

+ F&* +" !< ! 5"/

#G;:&D; 61%

H6G;:*6:#II6)*E7;*EJ 43% A;*&E;

#II6)*E7;*EJ 65% #JJ;7C1@#II6)*E7;*EJ 75%

MEMBER RANKINGS & STATISTICS BY STATE GOVERNMENT APPOINTING AUTHORITY

Average Voting Score: 61%

1987 – 2010 California Coastal Commission Conservation Voting Scores


K;&: H6G;:*6:#II6)*E7;*EJ

A;*&E;#II6)*E7;*EJ

#JJ;7C1@#II6)*E7;*EJ L677)JJ)6*

>?@A BCD A>D CED CCD

>?@@F@? AED CGD HID CID

>??IF?> >?D @?D HHD H@D

>??B GID @GD H?D HGD

>??G GBD CHD G@D GED

>??E G>D C@D EGD G@D

>??H GHD A?D EBD HID

'J%7KL%)'>??C B>D @HD G>D E>D

'J.7#KM#6'>??C BID @AD CD BHD

>??A EBD A@D @AD ACD

>??@ BED CCD CCD EED

>??? HED ABD CBD CED

BIII EBD H?D ECD HID

BII> B@D HCD GHD E>D

BIIB EED CED EED HID

BIIG EHD CHD EHD HBD

BIIEDavis: EAD

H@D G@D ECDSchwarzenegger:

B?D

BIIH EHNHD AED HHD CID

BIIC GHD HED EBD EGD

BIIA BED ABD GHD EED

BII@ B?D HGD G>D G@D

BII? E@D AHD C?D CCD

BI>I EGD CHD AHD C>D

_.+-&8.D'.5*7-(5(# 9'0*.# 5&*%?-.0# 53'# ;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.<(# %8.('&+*5-8.# +85-.0# &'%8&,# -.#LMf!G# LMMN# -(# (A7-5# -.58# 5U8# 3*7+'(# 58# (38U# 53'#A&'%-A-581(# 4*77# -.# A&86'.+-&8.D'.5*7# +85'(# -.#53'#7*55'&#3*74#84#LMMN#%*1(',#9B#53'#$(('D97B<(#5&*.(-5-8.# 4&8D# *# \'D8%&*5-%# D*S8&-5B# 58# *#E'A197-%*.# D*S8&-5B# 3'*,',# 9B# )A'*?'&# ;1&5#O&-.07'G#>3'#3-03'(5#8+'&*77#%8.('&+*5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'#48&# 53'#%8DD-((-8.#U*(# -.#LMM!#U3'.# 53'#8+'&*77##%8.('&+*5-8.#+85-.0#(%8&'#(588,#*5#!Ne:#&'7*5',:#-.#A*&5:#58#\'D8%&*5(#&'5*?-.0#D*S8&-5B#84#53'#$(('D97BG#)-.%'#LMM!:#53'#(%8&'(:#8.#*+'&*0':3*+'#,'%7-.',#U-53#VQQf# &'A&'('.5-.0# 53'# 78U'(5#(%8&'#53-(#,'%*,'G#2853#VQQM#*.,#VQLQ#(*U#D*&?',#-DA&8+'D'.5:# 915# *(# ,-(%1((',# -.# 53'#h'B# @-.,6-.0(# 53-(# -DA&8+'D'.5# -(# +'&B# 7-?'7B# 7-.?',# 58#53'# ,8U.# '%8.8DB# *.,# 7'((# -DA*%5417# A&8S'%5(G

2007– 2010 California Coastal Commissioners Overall Ranking Comparisons

GOVERNOR APPOINTMENTS SENATE APPOINTMENTS !ASSEMBLY APPOINTMENTS

2007 2007 2007

2008 2008 2008

2009 2009 2009

9 Kram

22%6 Blank

42%

12 Achadjian

11%10 Neely

18%

1 Shallenberger

92%2 Wan

88%

3 Reilly

57%5 Clark

50%

4 Hueso

53%

8 Kruer

36%

7 Burke

38%

11 Potter

13%

8 Neely

31%3 Blank

41%

10 Achadjian

25%11 Kram

19%

2 Shallenberger

62%1 Wan

81%

5 Reilly

37%6 Clark

33%9 Hueso

28%

4 Kruer

38%7 Burke

32%

9 Potter

28%

11 Blank

56%

13 Achadjian

46%14 Kram

37%

12 Neely

52%

7 Bloom

67%

2 Mirkarimi

95%3 Wan

83%

4 Reilly

75%5 Shallenberger

71%

10 Clark

59%

1 Stone

100%4 Sanchez

75%

6 Kruer

68%8 Hueso

64%

9 Burke

61%13 Potter

46%


2010 2010 2010

7 Blank

45%6 Neely

50%

10 Achadjian

35%9 Kram

41%

2 Wan

80%3 Mirkarimi

71%

5 Shallenberger

67%8 Bloom

42%

1 Sanchez

90%

4 Burke

69%

3 Stone

71%

4 Kruer

69%

2007– 2010 California Coastal Commission Appointing Authorities Comparison

2010 GOVERNOR SCHWARTZENEGGER APPOINTMENTS#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'43%

2010 SENATE RULES COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'65%

!2010 ASSEMBLY LEADER APPOINTMENTS#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'75%

1 Neely

50%

3 Kram

41%4 Achadjian

35%

2 Blank

45%

1 Wan

80%2 Mirkarimi

71%

3 Shallenberger

67%4 Bloom

42%

1 Sanchez

90%2 Stone

71%

3 Burke

69%3 Kruer

69%

2009 2010

2007 2008

'Governor Schwartzenegger!24%'Senate Rules Committee 72%'Assembly Leader 35%

#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'44%


#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'38%


#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'64%


#G;:&D;8M6E)*D8A$6:;N'61%

2007 – 2010 APPOINTING AUTHORITIES COMPARISON


Selected 2010 California Coastal Commission Hearing Agenda Items


#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 !"#$%&

09:2;'via Parker +

=:&7'via Secord !"#$%&

=:9;: +

>):2&:)7)8 +

?;;1@ +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7F14a

#II;&18?6P8#Q!Q>R?Q",Q+5QS8TU&$2J6*QH:9C;8V&7)1@W8O*$P8X8>;*'6$)*68L6PY8

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

AGENDA ITEM F14a#

:(&,+-./0&(*3/+-#0&-/&0;

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

AGENDA ITEM W6a##

:(&<+,*3/+-#0&-/&0;

>3'# ;8DD-((-8.# 0&*.5',# *# ;8*(5*7#\'+'78AD'.5# O'&D-5# H;\OI# 58# O8('-,8.#E'(81&%'(# 48&# 53'# 7*&0'(5# 8%'*.#,'(*7-.*65-8.# 4*%-7-5B# -.# 53'#b.-5',# )5*5'(G#$# %8.6,-5-8.#U*(# 53*5# 53'#*AA7-%*.5#D-5-0*5'# 53'#0&''.381('# 0*(# H]=]I# 'D-((-8.(# &'(1756-.0# 4&8D# 53'# '.8&D81(# '.'&0B# ,'D*.,#48&#8%'*.#,'(*7-.*5-8.G#O8('-,8.#*(('&5',#53*5# 53'# ,'(*7-.*5',# U*5'&# U817,# &'A7*%'#U*5'&# %1&&'.57B# 9'-.0# ,'7-+'&',# 58# 53'-&#%1(58D'&(G# >3'&'48&':# 53'# '7-D-.*5-8.# 84#53'#'.'&0B#1(',#58#,'7-+'&#U*5'&#4&8D#53'#)*%&*D'.58# \'75*# 58# )*.# \-'08# U*(# 53'#7*&0'(5#4*%58&#-.#%*7%17*5-.0#53'#`.'5a#'.'&60B#,'D*.,#84#53'#4*%-7-5BG#[5#U*(#7*5'&#,-(6%8+'&',# 53'# *(('&5-8.#U*(# 4&*1,17'.5# *.,#-.5'.5-8.*77B#D'*.5# 58#D-(7'*,# 53'# ;8D6D-((-8.<(#,'%-(-8.#58#0&*.5#53'#%8.,-5-8.*7#A'&D-5G#O'5-5-8.'&(#A&8+',#53'#-.5'.5-8.*77B#4&*1,17'.5#*%5#*.,#53'#;8DD-((-8.#*0&'',G#=8U'+'&:#;8DD-((-8.'&(#,-(*AA&8+',#53'#E'+8%*5-8.# E'Y1'(5# *.,# 481.,# 53*5# 9'6%*1('#O8('-,8.#3*,#(19D-55',#(1AA8&5-.0#7'55'&(# 4&8D# C'5&8A87-5*.# g*5'&# \-(5&-%5#53'# ;8DD-((-8.# ,-,# .85# &'7B# (87'7B# 8.#O8('-,8.<(# -.5'.5-8.*77B# 4&*1,17'.5# -.48&6D*5-8.#*.,#%8.('Y1'.57B#U817,#.85#3*+'#+85',#,-44'&'.57BG#>3'&'48&':#;8DD-((-8.6'&(#?.8U-.07B#*778U',#*#A&8S'%5#A&8A8.'.5#58#-.5'.5-8.*77B#4*7(-4B#-.48&D*5-8.#-.#53'-&#;\O#*AA7-%*5-8.:#1.,'&D-.-.0#(5*5'#'448&5(#58#&',1%'#`0789*7#U*&D-.0a#*(#U'77#*(#53'#;8*(5*7#$%5#D*.,*5'#58#A&85'%5#%8*(5*7#*.,#8%'*.# &'(81&%'(# 53*5#U-77# 9'#,&*D*5-%*77B#

6%*5-8.#*.,#853'&#*,+'&('#'44'%5(#84#%7-D*5'#%3*.0'G#>3-(#,'%-(-8.#('5#*#9*,#A&'%','.5#48&# .1D'&81(# 4151&'# 8%'*.# ,'(*7-.*5-8.#A&8S'%5(#%1&&'.57B#A&8A8(',#*.,#53'#9&8*,6'&#*1538&-5B#84#53'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#58#'.48&%'#53'#;8*(5*7#$%5G

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2;'via Parker –

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: –

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@ –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* –

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7W6a

S;G6$&E)6*8S;Z9;JE8?6P8S+QRQ"<Q"!-8

T[6J;)'6*8S;J69:$;J8X8L&:1JC&'Y8

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

January

-+3&W##g3'.#&'+-'U-.0#53'#+85-.0#%3*&5(#A7'*('#?''A#-.#D-.,#53*5#O*&?'&#-(#*.#*75'&.*5'#48&#21&?':#]1&.'B#48&#C-&?*&-D-:#g&-035#8&#]&''&#48&#T''7B:#]&''&#48&#27*.?:#)'%8&,#48&#h&*D#*.,#/-9'&D*.#48&#h&1'&G##$#+85'#9B#*.#*75'&.*5'#U-77#9'#-.,-%*5',#`+-*#i*75'&.*5'#.*D'ja#-.#53'#.*D'#%871D.G##$77#+85'(#84#*75'&.*5'(#*&'#*55&-915',#58#53'#A&-D*&B#;8DD-((-8.'&#48&#+85'#(%8&-.0#A1&A8('(G

February


#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –


=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: –

>):2&:)7)8 –

?;;1@ –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* –

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7TH13.5a

L)E@86\8>&1)C98]L[8#7;*'7;*E8?6P8>#UQ+Q"3Q#8T^L:977;:8

_:9JE`8[&:$;1Y

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

AGENDA ITEM TH13.5a##

:*66(+<&0#=/3>#4+0/9/,*3/+-.;

[.# *.# LLFL# +85':# 53'#;8DD-((-8.# *0&'',#58#*778U#53'#%-5B#84#C*7-91#*.,#53'#A&8A6'&5B#8U.'&# 58#*D'.,# 53'#%-5B<(#/*.,#b('#O7*.# *.,# [DA7'D'.5*5-8.# O7*.# 58# %3*.0'#;R6V#J8.-.0#,'(-0.*5-8.#8.#(19S'%5#A&8A6'&5B# 58#D-K',# &'(-,'.5-*7d&'%&'*5-8.*7# 1('#

91-75:# *78.0# U-53# *.# -.*,'Y1*5'# -.67-'1#A*BD'.5# 48&# 78((#84# 78U6%8(5#%8DD'&%-*7#+-(-58&6('&+-.0# %*A*%-5B# 8.# 53-(# +*%*.5#VZ6*%&'# A*&%'7# *98+'# )1&4&-,'&# 2'*%3# -.#;-5B#84#C*7-91G#>3-(#*AA&8+*7:#'+'.#U-53#

65'.5-*7# 48&# D*&?',# -DA&8+'D'.5(# -.# 53'#%-5B<(# *9-7-5B# 58# A&8+-,'# 78U# *.,# D8,'&6*5'7B6A&-%',#8+'&.-035#*%%8DD8,*5-8.(#-.#C*7-91# *.,# 53'&'48&'# &',1%',# %8*(5*7#*%%'((#U-53-.#53'#;-5B#84#C*7-91#*.,#/8(#$.0'7'(#;81.5BG

AGENDA ITEM W7a###

:0&-/&0;

$#.*&&8U#+-%58&B# 48&#%8*(5*7# &'(81&%'(# -.#;8&8.*#,'7#C*&#U-53#53'#,'.-*7#84#53-(#0*&60*.51*.#%8.,8D-.-1D#%8DA7'K#53*5#U817,#3*+'#%*77',#48&#D*((-+'#0&*,-.0:#97144#4*%'#

'.5-&'#*&'*G##)8D'#;8DD-((-8.'&(#&'4'&&',#58#53'#5*%5-%(#84#53'#*&%3-5'%5#*.,#,'+'78A'&#*(#%&'*5-+':#915#%&'*5-+'#8&#.85:#53'#*D81.5#84# ,'(5&1%5-8.# &'Y1-&',# 58# %8.(5&1%5# 53-(#

6-J',#*.,#*AA&8+',#9B#53'#;8DD-((-8.G

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2; +

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: +

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@'via Wright –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7JW7a & W8a

L)E@8a\8?;bI6:E80;&$%8]L[8#7;*'7;*E8c8#II1)$&E)6*

8T#RSORY

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

February


April )(%*(+*,-./0123*,(14.,51(32.6-(7*/(81/+9(:

Photo: CA Coastal Records Project


AGENDA ITEM W11&12##

:*66(+<&0;

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

53-(#1.-Y1'#*&'*G#\'(5&1%5-+'#,'+'78AD'.5#3*(# *7D8(5# %8DA7'5'7B# 'K5-.01-(3',#53-(# '.,*.0'&',# (A'%-'(# 53&8103815# 53'#U8&7,:# 915# U-53# 53'# 3'7A# 84# '.48&%'6D'.5# (5*44# *.,# 53'# ;8DD-((-8.<(# +85':#-5#U-77#(1&+-+'#F#*5##7'*(5#-.#)8153#/*01.*G#

AGENDA ITEM W15a##

:0&-/&0;

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

April

#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 +

09:2;'via Parker !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord +

=:9;:'via Liberman !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@'via Greer +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7JW11 & W12

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

L;&J;de;J)JE8cS;JE6:&E)6*8a:';:8

8TH:67;E8X]&D9*&80;&$%Y8

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2;'via Parker !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;:'via Liberman !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@'via Greer –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W15a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II;&18?6P8#Q<Q[AeQ"3Q4-8

e)JE:)$E8X8A&*8e);D6Y8888888888888888888888888888888



AGENDA ITEM TH12b##

*66(+<&0#=/3>#,+-0/3/+-.#?@A;

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

April

AGENDA ITEM TH7a##

:*66(+<&0;

_-035# 815# 84# .-.'# ;8DD-((-8.'&(# +85',#58# *778U# *# 4'*(-9-7-5B# (51,B# *.,# ('*U*5'&#,'(*7-.*5-8.#5'(5#U'77(#78%*5',#8.#*#9'*%3:#,'(A-5'# ;8DD-((-8.'&(<# *771(-8.(# 53*5# *#A'&D*.'.5# 4*%-7-5B# U817,# .85# 7-?'7B# 9'#*AA&8+',# -.# 53-(# 78%*5-8.G# @1&53'&D8&':#53-(#A&8S'%5#-(#%7'*&7B#8.'#A-'%'#84#*#7*&0'&#A&8S'%5X#9B#('A*&*5-.0#53'#A&8S'%5#-.58#D1765-A7'#%8DA8.'.5(#48&#A'&D-55-.0#A1&A8('(:#*.*7B(-(# 84# 53'# %8DA7'5'# A&8S'%5# *.,# *,6'Y1*5'#A197-%#*.,#&'017*58&B#&'+-'U#U'&'#A&'%71,',G

May

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2; !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)(8 –

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* –

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7TH17a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

[;:7)E8?6P8LeQ""+Q!"8

TL6:IJ86\8R*D)*;;:J8X8A&*8]9)J8aC)JI68L6PY8


#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2;'via Parker !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: –

>):2&:)7)(8 -

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 –

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7TH12b

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II;&18?6P8#Q-QA]aQ",Q-.8TAE6168X8A&*8]9)J8

aC)JI68L6PY8


#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 +

09:2; !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord +

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)(8 +

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7TH12a

#II;&18?6P8#Q.Qe[_Q!"Q5+8

TL)E@8a\8e&*&8[6)*E8X8a:&*D;8L6PY88

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

AGENDA ITEM TH12a##

$# ;-5B# ^&,-.*.%'# U*(# *AA'*7',# 9B# )1&64&-,'&#@81.,*5-8.<(#)8153#^&*.0'#;81.5B#;3*A5'&:# C(G# R8..'# 2*&.'(# *.,# ;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.'&(#g*.# *.,#2788D# 9'%*1('#-5# %8.5&*+'.'(# 53'# (5*.,*&,(# ('5# 48&53# -.#

53'#A197-%#*%%'((#A87-%-'(# ('5# 48&53# -.# 53'#;*7-48&.-*# ;8*(5*7# $%5G# # >3'# ^&,-.*.%'#1.4*-&7B# &'(5&-%5(# 381&(# 84# 8A'&*5-8.# 9B#1(-.0#78%?',#0*5'(#*.,#1..'%'((*&-7B#7-D6-5(#A197-%#*%%'((#381&(#58#%8*(5*7#5-,'7*.,(#58# D1%3# 7'((# 53*.# 53'# D*K-D1D# *%%'((#&'Y1-&'D'.5(#1.,'&#53'#;8*(5*7#$%5:#*.,#-5#*778U(#53'#%8.5-.1',#A7*%'D'.5#84#1.A'&6D-55',#0*5'(#58#89(5&1%5#D*K-D1D#%8*(5*7#A197-%# *%%'((# 53&8103# 53'# ='*,7*.,(#,'+'78AD'.5# +-*# 53'# C-,# )5&*.,# 2'*%3#$%%'((# *.,# 53'#)8153#)5&*.,#)U-5%39*%?#>&*-7G# # >3'# ;8DD-((-8.# *7(8# 481.,# 53*5#53'# -.(5*77*5-8.#84#0*5'(#*.,#(-0.(#%8.(5-6515',#1.A'&D-55',#,'+'78AD'.5#1.,'&# 53'#;8*(5*7#$%5:# *.,# 53*5# 53'#;-5B<(# .1-(*.%'#*9*5'D'.5# D'*(1&'(# U'&'# .85# .*&&8U7B#

*%5-+-5-'(#A&85'%5',#1.,'&#53'#$%5G##

HT85'W#>3'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#U*(#(196('Y1'.57B#(1',#9B#53'#;-5B#84#\*.*#O8-.5#48&# 53-(# ,'%-(-8.:# *.,# 53'# %*('# 3*(# 9''.#S8-.',# U-53# 53'# )1&4&-,'&# @81.,*5-8.# +G#;-5B# 84#\*.*#O8-.5# %*('# 8.# 53'# (*D'# ('5#84#4*%5(G##)1&4&-,'&#A&'+*-7',#-.#53'#7*U(1-5#(5&-?-.0#,8U.#53'#;-5B<(#.1-(*.%'#,'%7*&*65-8.G#T8U#53'#-((1'#-(#9*%?#U-53-.#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#A1&+-'UGI##

AGENDA ITEM W21.5a##

:&00#'6>&10;

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

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2'via Greer !"#&!;%

016678 +

09:2; +

=:&7 –

=:9;: +

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@ !"#&!;%

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* !"#$%&

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W21.5a

e)JI9E;8S;J619E)6*8?6P8.Q!"Q!!,QRee8

T]&D9*&8_;::&$;8[&:28]]L8X8]&D9*&80;&$%Y

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

May


June



#$%&'()&* –

01&*2'via Greer –

016678 –

09:2; !"#$%&

=:&7 !"#$%&

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)(8 +

?;;1@ +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7JTH14a–c

L)E@86\8]6J8#*D;1;JW8e;IEP86\8_:&*JI6:E&E)6*8

X8]6J8#*D;1;JY

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

AGENDA ITEM TH14a–c##

:0&-/&0;

@8778U-.0# *.# 'D85-8.*77B6%3*&0',# 481&6381&# 3'*&-.0:# 53'# ;8DD-((-8.# ,-,# .85#*778U#53'#%-5B#58#(87+'#-5(#(8%-*7#A&897'D(#8.#53'#9*%?#84#%8*(5*7#*%%'((G#[5#U817,#('5#*# +'&B# A88&# A&'%','.5# -4# %8*(5*7# %8DD16.-5-'(#,'%-,'# 53'B#%*.# (87+'# (8%-*7# -((1'(#U-53# ,'.-*7# 84# A197-%# %8*(5*7# *%%'((# *.,#*((8%-*5',#A*&?-.0G

AGENDA ITEM F14a##

:*66(+<&0#=/3>#,+-0/3/+-.;

>3'# A&8S'%5# *(# A&8A8(',# 3*,# A85'.5-*77B#

3*,# .85# 9''.# %7'*&7B# *.,d8&# *,'Y1*5'7B#*,,&'((',G# ;8DD-((-8.# (5*44# &'%8D6

,'(A-5'# 53'# 4*%5# 53*5# 53'&'# U'&'# 07*&-.0#

8.# LI# U'57*.,(# ,'7-.'*5-8.# VI# D-5-0*5-8.#,8197'6,-AA-.0# H(-.%'# (8D'# D-5-0*5-8.#U*(#&'Y1-&',#48&#53'#A*(5#*55'DA5#58#91-7,#53-(#A7*.5#8.#*.853'&#(-5'I#PI#7*%?#84#(A'%-46-%(#H-.%71,-.0#5-D-.0I#48&#-DA7'D'.5*5-8.#84# %'&5*-.# A&8S'%5# '7'D'.5(# *.,# ZI# '.(1&6-.0# 53*5# 53'# A&8S'%5# U817,# .85# &'(175# -.#*,+'&('# -DA*%5(# 58# 53'# 7*&0'&# 3B,&8780-%#

&'%3*&0'IG# # >3'('# -((1'(# U'&'# 5*?'.# 1A#-.# \'# T8+8# 3'*&-.0# U3'&'# 53'# A&8S'%5#U*(#175-D*5'7B#*AA&8+',#U-53#%8.,-5-8.(G

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2'via Greer –

016678 –


=:&7 –

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7) –

?;;1@ –

A&*$%;B8 –

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* –

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7F14a

#II1)$&E)6*8?6P8#Q-QA]aQ"3Q"..8c8"<38

T]6J8aJ6J8F&JE;b&E;:8[:6(;$EY

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

June




#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 +

09:2; +

=:&7'via Secord +

=:9;:'via Liberman +

>):2&:)7) +

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W11a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

AGENDA ITEM W11a##

:*66(+<&0#=/3>#,+-0/3/+-.;#[.# @'9&1*&B# VQQM:# 53'# ;8DD-((-8.#*AA&8+',# *# A'&D-5# *1538&-J-.0# 53'#)5'&7-.0(#58#91-7,#*#N:Z"N#(YG45G#(-.07'#4*D-7B# &'(-,'.%'# 8.# 53'-&# *0&-%1751&6*77B# J8.',# LZ!6*%&'# A&8A'&5B# .'*&#_7# ]&*.*,*# -.# )*.# C*5'8# ;81.5BG##[.# 8&,'&# 48&# 53'# A&8S'%5# 58# 9'# 481.,#-.# %8DA7-*.%'# U-53# 53'# *0&-%1751&*7#A87-%-'(# 84# 53'# /;O:# 53'# ;8DD-(6(-8.# &'Y1-&',# 53'# )5'&7-.0(# 58# A7*%'#*.# `*44-&D*5-+'# *0&-%1751&*7# '*('6D'.5a#8.#53'#*&'*#84#53'#A&8A'&5B#.85#9'-.0# ,'+'78A',# 48&# 53'# &'(-,'.%'G##$#)1A'&-8&#;81&5# S1,0'# ('5# *(-,'# 53'#`*44-&D*5-+'# *0&-%1751&*7# '*('D'.5a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`b.,'&# 53'#;8*(5*7#$%5#*.,#53'#/;O:#53'#A'&D-55''#8&#53'#7*.,8U.'&#&'D*-.(#4&''# 58# *AA7B# 48&# *# (19,-+-(-8.# 8&#853'&#A'&D-5#*D'.,D'.5#*5#*.B#5-D'Ga##

AGENDA ITEMS TH8–14#

:*66(+<&0;#

>3'#(5*44# &'A8&5# 48&# 53-(#*0'.,*# -5'D#U*(#*# &'%8&,# 84# 48&9'*&*.%'# *.,# &'017*58&B#&'(5&*-.5#53*5#U*(#*7D8(5#9'B8.,#%8DA&'63'.(-8.G# >3'# ;8DD-((-8.# 1.*.-D81(7B#(1AA8&5',# '.48&%'D'.5# (5*44<(# &'%8D6D'.,',# *%5-8.(# 8.# *.# 'K3*1(5-+'# 7-(5# 84#U387'(*7'#,'(5&1%5-8.#5*%5-%(#*.,#D*((-+'#+-87*5-8.(# 53*5# %8.5-.1',# 58# D81.5# '+'.#-.# 53'# 4*%'#84# *# %7'*&7B#A8(5',# (58A6U8&?#8&,'&#9B#53'#/G$G#;81.5B#21-7,-.0#k#)*4'65B#(5*44#*.,#D*.B#D8.53(#84#D''5-.0(#U-53#;8DD-((-8.#(5*44G##$77#84#53-(#,'(5&1%5-8.#U*(# %8DA7'5',# -.# 53'# .*D'# 84# >8A*.0*#)?B7-.'# g-.'&BG# >3'# '%8(B(5'D# -.# 53-(#

&'0-8.(# -.# 53'# U8&7,# 53*5# '.%8DA*(('(# *#D'&'#5U8#A'&%'.5#84#53'#'*&53<(#585*7#7*.,#*&'*G# #g8&7,U-,':# 8.7B# Lfe# 84# 53-(# &*&'#C',-5'&&*.'*.# (3&19# '%8(B(5'D# &'D*-.(#1.,-(51&9',G##>8A*.0*#)?B7-.'#g-.'&B#-.65'&.'5#A&8D85-8.(#(5*5'#53*5:#`53'#'D'&0-.0#U-.'#%8DD1.-5B#3'&'#-.#53'#)*.5*#C8.-%*#C81.5*-.(# -(# 5&17B# 1.-Y1':# .85# 8.7B# 9'6%*1('# 84# 53'# -.%&',-97'# 5'&&8-&# `0'8780Ba#915# 53'# A3-78(8A3-'(# *.,# A'&(8.*7-5-'(#9'3-.,#53'#D175-51,'#84#0&8U'&(#*.,#U-.'6D*?'&(Ga# #^.'# 3*(# 58# Y1'(5-8.#U3*5# 53*5#5&17B# 1.-Y1'# A3-78(8A3B# -(# 53*5# U817,#'DA8U'&# *# 7*.,8U.'&# 58# &'D8+'# 53'#?.89(#4&8D#&-,0'7-.'(#*.,#,'(5&8B#*%&'(#84#*#&*&'#'%8(B(5'D#-.#8&,'&#58#%&'*5'#53'#A'&64'%5:#D*.6D*,'#5'&&8-&# 48&# 53'-&#+-.'B*&,G

#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 +

09:2; !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord +


>):2&:)7) +

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7JTH8–14

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

August )(%*(+*,-./0123*,(14.,51(32.6-(7*/(<=>?:


#II;&18?6P8#Q+QA>LQ",Q"!8

TAE;:1)*D8X8A&*8>&E;68L6PY8

L677)JJ)6*8L;&J;8c8e;J)JE8a:';:J8

Tf&D6I)&*8X8_6I&*D&W8]6J8#*D;1;J8L6PY8


AGENDA ITEM W6a#

:*66(+<&0#=/3>#,+-0/3/+-.;

$AA7-%*5-8.# 9B# 53'# ;*7-48&.-*# \'A5G# 84#O*&?(# *.,# E'%&'*5-8.# 58# &'(58&'# *.,# '.63*.%'# 53'# U'(5'&.# %3*..'7(# 84# C*7-91#/*088.# )5*5'# O*&?G# >3'# U'(5'&.# %3*.6.'7(# 84# C*7-91# /*088.# U'&'# A*&5# 84# *.#1.(1%%'((417# &'(58&*5-8.# A&8S'%5# -.-5-*5',#-.#LMfP:#*.,#(144'&(#4&8D#78.0#A'&-8,(#84#78U# ,-((87+',# 8KB0'.:# 'K%'((-+'# 7'+'7(#84# *70*'# *.,# (19D'&0',# *Y1*5-%# +'0'5*65-8.:#78U#(A'%-'(#,-+'&(-5B#*.,#&-%3.'((#84#9'.53-%# D*%&8-.+'&5'9&*5'(:# %&1(5*%'*.(:#

853'&#%8*(5*7#7*088.(G#>3'#A&8S'%5#-.5'.,(#58# -DA&8+'# 41.%5-8.#84# 7*088.#'%8(B(5'D#9B# &'%8.581&-.0# U'(5'&.# %3*..'7(# 58# '.6

U3'.#53'#7*088.#-(#8A'.#58#53'#8%'*.#*.,#58# -.%&'*('# %-&%17*5-8.# 53&8103815# 53'# 7*6088.#U3'.# -5# -(# -(87*5',# 4&8D# 53'# 8%'*.G#>3'# A&8S'%5# U-77# 78U'&# 53'# 'K-(5-.0# 586A80&*A3B# 84# 53'# U'(5'&.# %3*..'7(G# >3'#

U-77# 9'# 78U'&',# 58# ('*# 7'+'7# 58# -.%&'*('#

A7*.#U-77# (*7+*0'# *AA&8A&-*5'# .*5-+'# (A'6%-'(#4&8D#53'#(-5'#A&-8&#58#'K%*+*5-8.:#U-77#&'A7*.5#*AA&8A&-*5'#.*5-+'#(A'%-'(#*.,#&'6D8+'#.8.6.*5-+'#(A'%-'(:#%8.(5&1%5#A197-%#*%%'((# 5&*-7(#*&81.,# 53'# 7*088.:#%8.(5&1%5#-.5'&A&'5-+'# A197-%# ',1%*5-8.*7# *D'.-5-'(:#*.,# -DA7'D'.5# 78.065'&D#D8.-58&-.0#*.,#*,*A5-+'#D*.*0'D'.5#A7*.#58#'.(1&'#A&8S6'%5#(1%%'((G

October )(%*(+*,-./0123*,(14.,51(32.6-(7*/(#[email protected]./:

AGENDA ITEM W15a##

:*66(+<&0#=/3>#4+0/9/,*3/+-.;

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

2&-035U*5'&# A&8S'%5# U3'&'9B# A&'7-D-.*&B#*&%3*'8780-%*7# U8&?# ,-,# .85# ,-(%78('# 53'#

,'(5&8B',# 9B# A&8S'%5# 0&*,-.0G# >3-(#$E\#;\O#&'Y1-&'D'.5#(3817,#9'#%8.(-,'&',#48&#853'&#/8%*7#;8*(5*7#O7*.#$D'.,D'.5(# -.#8&,'&#58#-DA&8+'#A&85'%5-8.(#(5*5'U-,'#48&#;8*(5*7#l8.'#*&%3*'8780-%*7#&'(81&%'(G

#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 +

09:2; +

=:&7 +


>):2&:)7)(8 +

?;;1@'via Wright +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W15a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

L)E@86\8f9*E)*DE6*80;&$%8]L[8#7;*'7;*E8

?6P8f?0Q>#UQ+Q!"8T[&:2J)';Y8


#$%&'()&* +

01&*2 +

016678 !"#&!;%

09:2; +

=:&7 !"#$%&


>):2&:)7)(8 +

?;;1@'via Wright +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W6a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II1)$&E)6*8?6P84Q",Q"358TL&1)\6:*)&8e;IEP86\8[&:2J8&*'8S;$:;&E)6*8X8>&1)C9Y



AGENDA ITEM TH8a##

:0&-/&0;

[.# *# 5-'# +85'# H"F"I# 53-(# A&8S'%5# U*(# .*&6&8U7B# ,'.-',G# _K5'.(-+'# 5'(5-D8.B# 4&8D#A&8A8.'.5(# *(# U'77# *(# 8AA8.'.5(# *,6,&'((',# 53'# A&8S'%5# *(# *# 5&*.(A8&5*5-8.#A&8S'%5:#U3-%3#-(#.85#*778U',#-.#_.+-&8.6D'.5*77B#)'.(-5-+'#=*9-5*5#$&'*# H_)=$IG##^AA8.'.5(#.85',#53*5#53'#C*(5'&#O7*.#U*(#(-DA7B#*#+'%58&#48&#53*5#A&8S'%5G# #[.#853'&#

A&8S'%5a#,8%1D'.5# &*53'&# 53*.#*#A7*..-.0#,8%1D'.5:# *(# (100'(5',# 58# ;-5B# A7*..'&(#9B# ;8*(5*7# ;8DD-((-8.# (5*44# -.# m*.1*&B#VQQQG#)-'&&*#;719#U*(#S8-.',#9B#53'#;'.5'&#48&#2-8780-%*7#\-+'&(-5B:#@&-'.,(#84#$&*.*#]17%3#*.,#;*7-48&.-*#T*5-+'#O7*.5#)8%-'5B#-.# 8AA8(-5-8.# *.,# *(?',# 53'#;8DD-((-8.#

6%*77BI:#*(#U'77#*(# 58#D*-.5*-.# 53'#8&-0-.*7#+-(-8.#*.,#-.5'.5#84#53'#;-5B<(#LM!M#-.-5-*65-+'#53*5#,-&'%5',#53'#%&'*5-8.#84#53'#$&*.*#]17%3#0&''.9'75#58#9'#D*-.5*-.',#*(#8A'.#(A*%'# 48&# 3*9-5*5# *.,# U*5'&(3',# +*71'(G##>3'#48778U-.0#D8&.-.0#%8.(-,'&*5-8.#84#*#U*-+'&#84#53'#(-K6D8.53#U*-5-.0#A'&-8,#48&#A'&D-5#&'*AA7-%*5-8.#U*(#*AA&8+',#48&#53'#T8+'D9'&#*0'.,*G

October

AGENDA ITEM W17a##

:0&-/&0;

>3'# ;8DD-((-8.# D*S8&-5B# (1AA8&5',#(5*44<(# &'%8DD'.,*5-8.# 48&#,'.-*7# 84# 53-(#

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

November

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 +

09:2; +

=:&7 +

=:9;: +

>):2&:)7)'via Gurney(8 +

?;;1@ +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7W17a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II1)$&E)6*8?6P8.Q!"Q"-!8

T[&)$)9J8X8]&D9*&80;&$%W8a:&*D;8L6PY


#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 +

016678 –

09:2; +

=:&7 !"#$%&

=:9;:'via Liberman –

>):2&:)7)(8 +

?;;1@'via Wright !"#$%&

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7TH8a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II1)$&E)6*8?6P8-Q"3Q"<58

TL)E@86\8A&*E&8L:9B8X8A&*E&8L:9B8L6PY


AGENDA ITEM TH17a##,?BC#DE#.F@BF#,GHI#

:=*/<&(#*66(+<&0;

@8778U-.0# 53'# ,'.-*7# 84# 53'# *AA7-%*5-8.#48&#53-(#A&8S'%5#*5#53'#^%589'&#3'*&-.0:#53'#U*-+'&# U*(# *AA&8+',G# # =8U'+'&:# *# .'U#*AA7-%*5-8.# 48&# 53-(# A&8S'%5# 3*(# .85# %8D'#48&U*&,# U3-%3# ,8'(# 9&-.0# -.58# Y1'(5-8.#U3B#53'#U*-+'&#U*(#.'',',#58#9'0-.#U-53G##$5# 53'# T8+'D9'&# 3'*&-.0:# 5'(5-D8.B# 9B#9853#A&8A8.'.5(#*.,#8AA8.'.5(#U*(#%8.(-(65'.5W#(*+'#53'#5*&A7*.5G##>3'#;-5B:#*#9-%B%-76-.0#(A8?'(A'&(8.:#;*7-48&.-*#T*5-+'#O7*.5#)8%-'5B:# @&-'.,(# 84# $&*.*# ]17%3# H+-*#U&-55'.# %8DD1.-%*5-8.I# *.,# '+'.# 53'#;8DD-((-8.'&(#*77# (3*&',# 53-(#D'((*0-.0#A8-.5G#g-53#53-(#-.#D-.,:#'.+-&8.D'.5*7-(5(#38A'#53*5#53'#;8*(5*7#;8DD-((-8.#U-77#*A6A&8+'#*#C*(5'&#O7*.#48&#$&*.*#]17%3#53*5#0-+'(#(%-'.%'69*(',#01-,*.%'#48&#53'#&'(586&*5-8.#84#53'#'.,*.0'&',#5*&A7*.5#*(#U'77#*(#&'(81&%'69*(',#D*-.5'.*.%'# 84# 53'# '.5-&'#0&''.9'75G#>3-(#5&*.(A8&5*5-8.#A&8S'%5:#53*5#U817,#,'(5&8B#_.+-&8.D'.5*77B#)'.(-5-+'#=*9-5*5# $&'*# H_)=$I:# -(# .85# %8.(-(5'.5#U-53#53'#;8*(5*7#$%5G

November

AGENDA ITEM F7a##

*66(+<&0#=/3>#,+-0/3/+-.#?@A;

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̀ 5*?6-.0(a#8.#*.#'&8,-.0#&'D.*.5#A*&%'7#U3'&'#

'KA'%5*5-8.#58#,'+'78AG

#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2; !"#$%&

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)(8 –

?;;1@ –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7F7a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

#II;&18?6P8#Q!Q>R?Q"3Q+-8

TF;:*;EE;8X8>;*'6$)*68L6PY8


#$%&'()&* –

01&*2 –

016678 –

09:2; –

=:&7'via Secord –

=:9;: !"#$%&

>):2&:)7)(8 –

?;;1@ –

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: –

AE6*;8 –

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ –

#D;*'&8OE;7TH17a

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1

L)E@86\8A&*E&8L:9B8#:&*&8H91$%8>&JE;:8[1&*



#

:*66(+<&0;

@8&# 5'.#B'*&(:# 53'#)*+'#=898#$7-(8#>*(?#@8&%'# 3*(# *55'.,',# '+'&B# A197-%# 3'*&-.0#

-.# /*01.*# 2'*%3# 4&8D# A&8A8(',# ,'+'768AD'.5G# \1&-.0# 53*5# 5-D':# 53'# 5*(?# 48&%'#,-(%8+'&',# 53'# -.5'.5-8.*7# ,'(5&1%5-8.# 84#'.,*.0'&',# (A'%-'(# *.,# 1.A'&D-55',# ,'6+'78AD'.5#8.# 53'#A&8A'&5B#9B# 53'#$53'.(#\'+'78AD'.5#]&81A#U3-%3#&'(175',#-.#5U8#;8*(5*7#$%5#+-87*5-8.(# -.#VQQ"#*.,#VQQ!G##^.#53'#3'*7(#84#53'('#+-87*5-8.(#%*D'#,'6

%8.('%15-+'# B'*&(# 9B# 53'#;-5B# 84# /*01.*#2'*%3# -.# VQQ!# *.,# VQQfG# #$77# 53'#U3-7':#53'# >*(?# @8&%'# U*(# 53'&'# 58# %8.5-.1*77B#%3*77'.0'# '+'&B# *55'DA5# *5# ,'(5&1%5-8.#

@-.*77B:# -.# VQLQ:# 53'# ;8*(5*7# $%5# R-87*65-8.(:# *# ;'*('# k# \'(-(5# ^&,'&# *.,# (196('Y1'.5# ;8.('.5# E'(58&*5-8.# ^&,'&# U'&'#*0&'',#1A8.#9B# 53'#$53'.(#]&81A:#\&-456U88,# O&8A'&5-'(:# //;# *.,# 53'# ;8DD-(6(-8.#F#*#+-%58&B#48&#81&#%8*(5*7#&'(81&%'(:#53'# ;8DD-((-8.# *.,# 53'# )-'&&*# ;719G#>3-(# %8.('.5# 8&,'&# %8D9-.',# U-53# 53'#$A&-7# %8.('.5# 8&,'&# -.# 53'# (*D'# *&'*#H;8DD-((-8.# ;'*('# *.,# \'(-(5# ^&,'&# k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

#$%&'()&* %B!

01&*2 +

01667'via O’Conner8 +

09:2; +

=:&7'via Secord +

=:9;: +

>):2&:)7)8 +

?;;1@ +

A&*$%;B8 +

A%&11;*C;:D;: +

AE6*;8 +

F&* +

!"#$%"&#'"($ +

#D;*'&8OE;7JTH8.1 & 8.3

+ <$=+/5-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1– <$@#'&-56#$>+-#$*+,$3+&/-&?$3+1/#,6&-5+1


December

AGENDA ITEMS TH8.1 & 8.3##

L677)JJ)6*8L;&J;8c8e;J)JE8a:';:8

Te:)\Eb66'8[:6I;:E);JW8]]L88X88]&D9*&80;&$%Y8

!"#$%"&'(

)'#*+#!,('+")+-'.

For More Information, Contact

C.,,?($>31D(#3.//1(E>=A('(FGFHGFFHGGFF

8.>(%=22./D(I.14=.(7*/(E*1-21>(C/*2.+23*,('(JKLHGMLHNOPJ

!,4.>1(Q*R.D(#=/7/35./(S*=,5123*,('(FGFHGFLHNPOTD(.U2V(GPG


california coastal commission conservation voting...

Documents