calibration of the accuscan ii in vivo system for i-125
TRANSCRIPT
The INL is a U.S. Department of Energy National Laboratory operated by Battelle Energy Alliance
INL/EXT-11-22663Revision 0
Calibration of the Accuscan II In Vivo System for I-125 Thyroid Counting
O. R. Perry
July 2011
DISCLAIMER This information was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an
agency of the U.S. Government. Neither the U.S. Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, expressed or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness, of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. References herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trade mark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the U.S. Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the U.S. Government or any agency thereof.
INL/EXT-11-22663Revision 0
Calibration of the Accuscan II In Vivo System for I-125 Thyroid Counting
O. R. Perry
July 2011
Idaho National Laboratory Health Physics Dosimetry Laboratory
Idaho Falls, Idaho 83415
http://www.inl.gov
Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy
Under DOE Idaho Operations Office Contract DE-AC07-05ID14517
Health Physics Dosimetry Laboratory
Calibration of the Accuscan II In Vivo System for I-125 Thyroid Counting
INL/EXT-11-22663 Revision 0
July 2011
Approved by:
Orval R. Perry
Date
David L. Georgeson Internal Dosimetry Technical Lead
Date
Lawrence L. Burke Health Physics Dosimetry Laboratory Manager
Date
v
ABSTRACT
This report describes the March 2011 calibration of the Accuscan II HpGe In Vivo system for I-125 thyroid counting. The source used for the calibration was a DOE manufactured Am-241/Eu-152 source contained in a 22 ml vial # BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 with energies from 26 keV to 344 keV. The center of the detector housing was positioned 64” from the vault floor. This position places the approximate center line of the detector housing at the center line of the source in the phantom thyroid tube. The energy and efficiency calibration were performed using an RMC II phantom (Appendix J). Performance testing was conducted using source # BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 and Validation testing was performed using an I-125 source in a 30 ml vial (#I-125 BEA Thyroid 002) and an ANSI N44.3 phantom (Appendix I). This report includes an overview introduction and records for the energy/FWHM and efficiency calibration including performance verification and validation counting. The Accuscan II system was successfully calibrated for counting the thyroid for I-125 and verified in accordance with ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 criteria.
vi
vii
CONTENTS
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................................. v
ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................................................... ix
1. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. 1
2. COUNTING SYSTEM DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................ 2
3. CALIBRATION SOURCES AND PHANTOMS ............................................................................. 3
4. DETECTOR AND LYNX DIGITAL AMPLIFIER TESTING ......................................................... 4
5. ENERGY/FWHM CALIBRATION .................................................................................................. 5
6. EFFICIENCY CALIBRATION ......................................................................................................... 6
7. CALIBRATION COUNT REANALYSIS ........................................................................................ 7
8. PERFORMANCE (VERIFICATION) TESTING ............................................................................. 8
9. MDA CALCULATIONS ................................................................................................................... 9
10. VALIDATION TESTING ................................................................................................................ 10
11. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION ................................................................................................. 11
12. REFERENCES ................................................................................................................................. 15
Appendix A—Source Certificate ................................................................................................................ 17
Appendix B—Source Decay ....................................................................................................................... 23
Appendix C—Energy/FWHM and Low Tail Calibration Documentation ................................................. 27
Appendix D—Efficiency Calibration Documentation ................................................................................ 39
Appendix E—I-125 Calibration Count Reanalysis Summary .................................................................... 47
Appendix F—Accuscan II I-125 Calibration Verification .......................................................................... 55
Appendix H—Calibration Validation using I-125 ...................................................................................... 69
Appendix I—ANSI N44.3 Phantom ........................................................................................................... 87
Appendix J—RMC II Transfer Phantom .................................................................................................... 95
viii
FIGURES Figure J-1. Canberra RMS-II (Model 2257) WBC calibration phantom. ................................................. 102
TABLES
Table 1. Calibration summary table. ........................................................................................................... 14
Table 2. Testing the 27 keV Energy Line With a Derived Yield of 43.12%. ............................................. 11
Table 3. Testing the 27 keV Energy Line with a Derived Yield of 38.25%. .............................................. 12
Table 4. Testing the 27 keV Energy Line with a Derived Yield of 40.5%. ................................................ 12
Table 5. Testing the 31 keV Energy Line with a Derived Yield of 13.12%. .............................................. 13
Table 6. Testing the 31 keV Energy Line with a Derived Yield of 12.0%. ................................................ 13
Table 7. Testing the 31 keV Energy Line with a Derived Yield of 12.5%. ................................................ 14
Table J-1. Summary of phantom comparison test count results. .............................................................. 100
Table J-2. Comparison of RMC-II and ANSI N13.30 reference phantoms efficiency ratio values and corresponding relative bias values. .................................................................................... 101
ix
ACRONYMS ANSI. American National Standard Institute
ASF. Analysis Sequence File
BE. Broad Energy
CFA Central Facility Area
CPS. Counts per second
FWHM. Full With at Half Maximum
HpGe. High Purity Germanium –also HPGe
HPL. Health Physics Laboratory
HPS. Health Physics Society
INL. Idaho National Laboratory
MDA. Minimum Detectable Activity
NIST. National Institute of Standards and Testing
PC. Personal Computer
RMC. Radiation Management Corporation
WBC Whole Body Counting
x
1
Calibration of the Accuscan II In Vivo System for I-125 Thyroid Counting 1. INTRODUCTION
This document describes the March 2011 calibration of the Accuscan II in vivo system for thyroid counting of I-125. The new calibration files were stored on the system disk and made available for thyroid counting after all verification counts were completed. This is the initial calibration of the Accuscan II for personnel thyroid counting for I-125.
The energy/FWHM-Low Tail calibration was performed on March 16, 2011. A DOE manufactured 22 ml source # BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 was used together with an RMC II phantom to establish a thyroid counting geometry. This source (BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1) is NIST traceable and is presented in Appendix A. The source has a reference date of March 14, 2011 with the current activity presented in Appendix B. The RMC II phantom was used for both the energy and efficiency calibrations. The source vial was positioned in the RMC II phantom thyroid tube and counted for 7223.15 seconds for both the energy and efficiency calibrations with the center line of the detector housing positioned 64” from the vault floor.
An efficiency calibration was performed subsequent to the energy/FWHM calibration (Appendix D). To calibrate this counting geometry, a mathematical function relating efficiency versus photopeak energy was created. The mathematical efficiency function generated on March 16, 2011 is expressed as an Empirical fit using a 4th order polynomial with no cross over. The efficiency is determined empirically by measuring known standards and using least squares fitting techniques. The efficiency function is stored as a calibration file, which is used to analyze spectra, collected under the same counting conditions.
Replicate performance (verification) counts (using the new calibration files) were performed to confirm that the accuracy and precision of the calibration satisfied ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 (see Reference 1) performance criteria and are presented in Appendix E.
In addition to the performance tests, a set of 5 validation counts were performed using a NIST traceable I-125 source (# I-125 BEA Thyroid 002) manufactured by DOE. The validation counts Relative Bias and Relative Precision were tested to ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 criteria. The results are presented in Appendix H.
2
2. COUNTING SYSTEM DESCRIPTION The Accuscan II system contains two broad energy BE type HpGe detectors used for both low
and high energy counting. This would include Whole Body, High Energy Lung, Thyroid, and Low Energy Lung (although at this time the system is not calibrated for energies <26 keV). The Canberra Apex-InVivo software system operates from a Genie 2000 operating system on a Dell Optiplex 780 PC. The counter system is located in a 9’4” high × 8’71/2” wide × 11’5” deep counting vault constructed of concrete and masonry blocks. The counting system is standup with the detectors scanning from head to foot for whole body counting. For Lung and Thyroid counting the detectors are stationary at fixed counting positions. Personnel are positioned in a counting shield constructed of 4” of low background and face the detectors which are “shadow shielded” with both lead and copper. The counting vault is located on the INL site at HPL-1618. The detectors are cooled to -185ºC by an electrically refrigerated cryostat system.
3
3. CALIBRATION SOURCES AND PHANTOMS A NIST traceable DOE manufactured source # BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 was used. The
certification for this source is described in Appendix A. The source is uniformly distributed in a WaterWork crystal SP 400 matrix in a 22 ml vial.
The source activity was decayed to the efficiency calibration date of March 16, 2011 by the Apex software. The Apex software also decayed the source for verification testing and presented the results in gammas per second. The phantom has been verified against the ANSI N44.3 thyroid phantom, Realistic torso phantom and Bottle Manikin Absorber model and is described in described in Appendix J.
An ANSI N44.3 phantom was used with a 30.0 ml vial containing 101 nCi of Ba-133 to provide Validation testing subsequent to the calibration. The phantom is described in Appendix I.
Validation counting of the calibration was performed using DOE manufactured I-125 source # I-125 BEA Thyroid 002. The source certification is described in Appendix A. The source is uniformly distributed in a Water Work matrix in a Liquid Scintillation Vial (~ 30 ml).
4
4. DETECTOR AND LYNX DIGITAL AMPLIFIER TESTING A Pole Zero was performed in accordance with MCP-3336 for both detectors during the I-131
calibration of March 1, 2011. No additional pole zero is needed since both calibrations use the same detector.
5
5. ENERGY/FWHM CALIBRATION An energy/FWHM calibration was performed March 16, 2011. The mixed The BEA Am-241/Eu-152
RMC II -1 source was positioned in the RMC II thyroid tube and counted for 7223 seconds with the detector housing midline at 64” from the vault floor. The detectors were in a fixed position for the count. The count was used to develop the energy/FWHM and Low Tail equations in accordance with MCP-3336 (Reference 2). The results and graphs of the calibrations are documented in Appendix C.
6
6. EFFICIENCY CALIBRATION An efficiency calibration was conducted March 16, 2011 in accordance with MCP-3336
(Reference 2) and the Canberra Apex-InVivo User’s Manual (Reference 3) and documented in Appendix D. Appendix D contains the worksheets, listings, and plots for these new efficiency calibration files. The efficiency calibration count was performed using the energy calibration count described in Section 5.0. Spectral data was transferred to a disk file at the completion of the count, using “Efficiency Calibration 3/16/2011 4:31 PM” as the ID number. The efficiency calibration used library Am-241/Eu-152. NLB and ASF file CALWBCGE for I-125.
7
7. CALIBRATION COUNT REANALYSIS Subsequent to the energy and efficiency calibrations the calibration count (performed on 3/6/2011
4:31 PM) was analyzed using the new calibrations. The results indicated a relative bias between 0.31 and -0.01. This result is well within the bias criteria of Reference 1. Except for the very low 26 keV energy line of Am-241, the results also indicated an excellent calibration. The summary result and supporting documentation is attached as Appendix E.
8
8. PERFORMANCE (VERIFICATION) TESTING The efficiency calibration used certificate BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1. A set of five replicate
verification test of the radionuclides in certificate BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 were performed March 16, 2011 with the detectors positioned 64” from the vault floor and the source located in the RMC II phantom thyroid tube. These counts were analyzed using the new efficiency calibration file and the nuclide library file I-125 Thyroid.nlb. Relative bias and relative precision, as defined in ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 (Reference 1) were calculated for these counts. Analysis results and calculated bias values for these verification counts are summarized in Appendix F. The bias ranged from -6.9% to 1.82%. The relative precision for these verification counts ranged from 12.77% to 3.56%. These results are well within the ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 criteria (–25% to +50% for the relative bias and less than or equal to 40% for the relative precision).
9
9. MDA CALCULATIONS MDA testing was conducted on March 23, 2011. The RMC-II phantom (with no sources installed)
was counted three times with the Apex-In Vivo Analysis Sequence File (ASF) counting file (Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF) containing the Detection Limit-Curie MDA Step. The Curie MDA equation of (4.65*Sb + 3)/KT was installed in the step. The MDA summary and supporting documentation are attached as Appendix G.
10
10. VALIDATION TESTING Although the performance test indicated acceptable results based on ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996 criteria,
the calibration was tested against an I-125 source manufactured by DOE as # I-125 BEA Thyroid 002. The I-125 source was placed in the ANSI N44.3 phantom. The center of the thyroid tube of the ANSI N44.3 phantom was placed 61.25” from the counter floor, 6 9/16” from the counter rearwall and 23 7/8” from the counter right wall. The center line of the detector housing as positioned 64” from the vault floor (the counter floor is 2 ¾” from the vault floor). The initial test results indicated a severe under response from 46% (27 keV energy line) to 82% (35.5 keV energy line). The efficiency calibration derivation was evaluated as a dual function, with varying cross over energies and polynomial values and as an empirical function with varying degrees of polynomial values. No reassessment made any significant changes to the I-125 activity resolution. The results of the low yield 35.5 keV energy line (6.67%) made this response vary from -11% to +14% and proved to be very unstable. The solution was to add a calibration constant or to adjust the yield of the energy lines to bring the reported I-125 values to the known activity level. Counting results were tested from 3/16/2011 to 3/23/2011 with a variety of yields introduced for the 27 and 31 keV energy lines. The yield corrections varied from 38.25% to 43.12% for the 27 keV energy line. The final yield % correction was 40.12% and was tested against all collected count data. See Tables 1, 2, and 3. The yield correction for the 31 keV energy line varied from 11.7% to 13.12%. The final correction was 12.5% and was tested against all collected count data. See Tables 4, 5, and 6.
At the completion of establishing correction yield values for the 27 and 31 keV energy lines, a second set of tests were conducted using the I-125 source # I-125 BEA Thyroid 002. These tests were termed Validation Tests. The tests were conducted using the ANSI N44.3 phantom and a 30 ml vial containing I-125. The front of the ANSI N44.3 phantom was placed 61.25” inches from the counter floor, 6 9/16” from the counter rearwall and 23 7/8” from the counter right wall. The center line of the detector housing was position 64” from the vault floor (the counter floor is approximately 2 3/4” from the vault floor). The results of the I-125 tests are attached as Appendix H. The summary notes a Relative Bias of -4.7% and a Relative Precision of 1.1% for the 27 keV peak and a Relative Bias of -3.2% and a Relative Precision of 7.3% for the 31 keV peak. The average Relative Bias was -4.0% and Relative Precision of 0.42%.
11
11. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION Final review of all calibration and verification count results confirmed that the thyroid calibration
created on March 16, 2011 for the Accuscan II counter is satisfactory for I-125 counting where the detectors are positioned in-accordance-with Reference 4 (center of the individual’s throat). A summary of current calibration files for this counter is shown in Table 7.
The I-125 Thyroid.nlb nuclide library file is the default for thyroid counting of I-125. Non-systematic and systematic errors for the in vivo system are described and quantified in Reference 5 – TEV-1275 (INL In Vivo System Counting Uncertainty).
The overall percent (%) counting uncertainty using the Accuscan II for I-125 counting is:
( ) ( ) ( )218.0 23.63 2yuncertaint counting % 125-Ifor II) (Accuscan ty Uncertain% Total ++=
Table 1. Testing the 27 keV energy line with a derived yield of 43.12%.
Maximum Minimumg/sec Adjusted Yield=43.12% 50% -25% % Bias relative Test
Activity (nCi) Limit Limit to activity Date
1730.08 108.4390513 163.95 81.975 -0.788 3/17/20111728.91 108.3657173 163.95 81.975 -0.855 3/17/20111741.08 109.1285163 163.95 81.975 -0.157 3/17/20111717.89 107.6749987 163.95 81.975 -1.487 3/17/20111783.97 111.8168029 163.95 81.975 2.303 3/17/20111737.93 108.9310786 163.95 81.975 -0.338 3/17/20111789.18 112.1433586 163.95 81.975 2.601 3/17/20111710.19 107.1923733 163.95 81.975 -1.928 3/17/20111705.97 106.9278694 163.95 81.975 -2.17 3/17/2011
1728 108.3086797 163.95 81.975 -0.907 3/17/2011
3/17/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 109.3
Testing the 27keV energy line with a derived yield of 43.12%
12
Table 2. Testing the 27 keV energy line with a derived yield of 38.25%.
Maximum Minimumgammas/sec Adjusted Yield=38.25% 50% -25% % Bias relative Test
Activity (nCi) Limit Limit to activity Date
1439.96 101.7459813 153 76.5 -0.249 3/23/20111443.81 102.018018 153 76.5 0.018 3/23/20111438.86 101.6682565 153 76.5 -0.325 3/23/20111469.61 103.8410175 153 76.5 1.805 3/23/20111427.96 100.8980745 153 76.5 -1.08 3/23/2011
1487 105.0697757 165.9 82.95 -5 3/16/20111489.57 105.251369 165.9 82.95 -4.836 3/16/20111498.2 105.8611553 165.9 82.95 -4.285 3/16/2011
1445.48 102.1360184 165.9 82.95 -7.653 3/16/20111515.23 107.0644762 165.9 82.95 -3.197 3/16/2011
3/16/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 110.63/23/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 102
Testing the 27keV energy line with a derived yield of 38.25%
Table 3. Testing the 27 keV energy line with a derived yield of 40.5%.
Test Dategammas/sec nCi Bias %
1730.08 116.1712271 3/17/2011 6.2871728.91 116.0926641 3/17/2011 6.2151741.08 116.909854 3/17/2011 6.9621717.89 115.3526943 3/17/2011 5.5381783.97 119.7898271 3/17/2011 9.5971737.93 116.6983381 3/17/2011 6.7691789.18 120.1396676 3/17/2011 9.9171710.19 114.8356555 3/17/2011 5.0651705.97 114.5522914 3/17/2011 4.805
1728 116.0315595 3/17/2011 6.1591439.96 96.69028034 3/23/2011 -5.2061443.81 96.94879973 3/23/2011 -4.9521438.86 96.61641766 3/23/2011 -5.2781469.61 98.68121538 3/23/2011 -3.2541427.96 95.88450562 3/23/2011 -5.996
1487 99.84891724 3/16/2011 -9.7211489.57 100.0214873 3/16/2011 -9.5651498.2 100.6009736 3/16/2011 -9.0411445.48 97.06093671 3/16/2011 -12.2411515.23 101.7445023 3/16/2011 -8.007
3/17/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 109.33/16/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 110.63/23/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 102
Testing the I-125 27 keV Energy Line Response to an Adjusted Yield of 40.25%
13
Table 4. Testing the 31 keV energy line with a derived yield of 13.12%.
Maximum Minimumg/sec Adjusted Yield=13.12% 50% -25% % Bias relative Test
Activity (nCi) Limit Limit to activity Date
510.36 105.1334871 163.95 81.975 -3.812 3/17/2011542.8 111.8160844 163.95 81.975 2.302 3/17/2011
538.41 110.9117502 163.95 81.975 1.475 3/17/2011544.07 112.0777027 163.95 81.975 2.541 3/17/2011537.45 110.7139914 163.95 81.975 1.294 3/17/2011537.34 110.6913316 163.95 81.975 1.273 3/17/2011556.63 114.6650461 163.95 81.975 4.909 3/17/2011519.98 107.1151945 163.95 81.975 -1.999 3/17/2011503.42 103.7038563 163.95 81.975 -5.12 3/17/2011497.22 102.4266645 163.95 81.975 -6.289 3/17/2011
3/17/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 109.3
Testing the 31keV energy line with a derived yield of 13.12%
Table 5. Testing the 31 keV energy line with a derived yield of 12.0%.
Maximum Minimumg/sec Adjusted Yield=12.0% 50% -25% % Bias relative Test
Activity (nCi) Limit Limit to activity Date
367.39 82.7454955 153 76.5 -18.877 3/23/2011480.42 108.2027027 153 76.5 6.081 3/23/2011459.42 103.472973 153 76.5 1.444 3/23/2011439.25 98.93018018 153 76.5 -3.01 3/23/2011466.55 105.0788288 153 76.5 3.018 3/23/2011517.79 116.6193694 153 76.5 14.333 3/23/2011418.26 94.2027027 153 76.5 -7.644 3/23/2011451.73 101.740991 153 76.5 -0.254 3/23/2011378.9 85.33783784 153 76.5 -16.335 3/23/2011
508.73 114.5788288 153 76.5 12.332 3/23/2011
3/23/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 102
Testing the 31keV energy line with a derived yield of 12.0%
14
Table 6. Testing the 31 keV energy line with a derived yield of 12.5%.
Test Dategammas/sec nCi Bias %
510.36 110.3481081 3/17/2011 0.959542.8 117.3621622 3/17/2011 7.376538.41 116.412973 3/17/2011 6.508544.07 117.6367568 3/17/2011 7.627537.45 116.2054054 3/17/2011 6.318537.34 116.1816216 3/17/2011 6.296556.63 120.3524324 3/17/2011 10.112519.98 112.4281081 3/17/2011 2.862503.42 108.8475676 3/17/2011 -0.414497.22 107.507027 3/17/2011 -1.64367.39 79.43567568 3/23/2011 -22.122480.42 103.8745946 3/23/2011 1.838459.42 99.33405405 3/23/2011 -2.614439.25 94.97297297 3/23/2011 -6.889466.55 100.8756757 3/23/2011 -1.102517.79 111.9545946 3/23/2011 9.759418.26 90.43459459 3/23/2011 -11.339451.73 97.67135135 3/23/2011 -4.244378.9 81.92432432 3/23/2011 -19.682508.73 109.9956757 3/23/2011 7.839
3/17/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 109.33/23/2011 Source Activity (nCi) 102
Testing the I-125 31 keV Energy Line Response to an Adjusted Yield of 12.5%
Table 7. Calibration summary table. Facility: Idaho National Laboratory, Building HPDL CFA-1618 Counting System: Accuscan II Thyroid Stationary Position Counter Arrangement: Accuscan II for I-125
Detector Energy Calibration Date Time Accuscan II BE Detectors 03/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration:
Detector Energy Calibration Date Time Accuscan II BE Detectors 03/16/2011 4:31 PM
15
12. REFERENCES
1. American National Standard, American National Standards Institute/Health Physics Society ANSI/HPS N13.30-1996, “Performance Criteria for Radiobioassay,” 1996.
2. Idaho National Laboratory, Management Control Procedure MCP-3336, “Accuscan II Calibration, Proficiency Testing, and Reporting,” Health Physics Dosimetry Laboratory, Revision 0, March 2011.
3. Canberra Industries Inc., 70655586, V.1, “Apex-InVivo Productivity Software User’s Manual.
4. Idaho National Laboratory, Basis Document TEV-1273, “Basis for Positioning of the In Vivo Accuscan II Detectors ”, 2011.
5. Idaho National Laboratory, Basis Document TEV-1275, “INL In Vivo System Counting Uncertainty”, 2011.
16
17
Appendix A
Source Certificate
18
19
Appendix A Source Certificate
BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1
20
21
DOE Source Certificate I-125 BEA Thyroid 002
22
23
Appendix B
Source Decay
24
25
Appendix B Source Decay
BEA Am-241/Eu-152 RMC II-1 Source Decay
Reference Date 3/14/2011Current Date 3/16/2011Elapsed Time 2
Reference Current Identity Energy (keV) Activity (nCi) Yield % T1/2 G/nCi Reference Activity
Days GPS (nCi)
13.93 210 24.4 157835.5 37 1.90E+03 2.10E+0217.51 210 30.5 157835.5 37 2.37E+03 2.10E+0220.98 210 7.31 157835.5 37 5.68E+02 2.10E+02
Am-241 26.34 210 2.4 157835.5 37 1.86E+02 2.10E+0259.54 210 35.7 157835.5 37 2.77E+03 2.10E+02
Eu-152 121.783 179.9 28.4 4946.2 37 1.89E+03 1.80E+02244.699 179.9 7.51 4946.2 37 5.00E+02 1.80E+02344.281 179.9 26.6 4946.2 37 1.77E+03 1.80E+02
Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1
26
DOE Manufactured Source # I-125 BEA Thyroid 002 Decay
Reference date 2/28/2011Current Date 3/16/2011Days 16.00
Reference Current Energy (keV) Activity (nCi) Yield % T1/2 G/nCi Reference Activity
Days GPS (nCi)
27 133 113.9 60.14 37 5605.019 110.60655231 133 25.5 60.14 37 1254.855 110.606552
35.492 133 6.67 60.14 37 328.2307 110.606552
I-125 BEA Thyroid 002
Reference date 2/28/2011Current Date 3/23/2011Days 23.00
Reference Current Energy (keV) Activity (nCi) Yield % T1/2 G/nCi Reference Activity
Days GPS (nCi)
27 133 113.9 60.14 37 5605.019 102.03516831 133 25.5 60.14 37 1254.855 102.035168
35.492 133 6.67 60.14 37 328.2307 102.035168
I-125 BEA Thyroid 002
27
Appendix C
Energy/FWHM and Low Tail Calibration Documentation
28
29
Appendix C Energy/FWHM and Low Tail Calibration Documentation
Energy Calibration Calibration Information
Calibration Title Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:00 PM Calibration Date 3/16/2011 3:01:08 PM Performed By David Georgeson Count Used Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Is Default Yes
Counter Information
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle
Detector Group Information
Detector Group Name Left Calibration Source Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1 Analysis Sequence File Nuclide Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB Peak Search Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB
Energy Calibration Coefficients
Energy = - 0.375273 + 0.462746 * ch - 6.01373e-07 * ch^2
FWHM = 1.14092 + 0.0173155 * E^1/2
LOW TAIL = 4.01565 - 0.012525 * E
Energy Calibration Results Table
Centroid Channel Centroid Error Energy (keV)57.41 0.25 26.34
129.51 0.01 59.54264.06 0.01 121.78530.03 0.02 244.70745.52 0.01 344.28
Approved by: Date:
User: David Georgeson
30
Energy Calibration
Energy Calibration Results Table
Energy (keV) FWHM Channels FWHM Error26.34 2.24 0.5459.54 2.75 0.02
121.78 2.89 0.02244.70 2.96 0.05344.28 3.17 0.03
User: David Georgeson
31
Energy Calibration
User: David Georgeson
32
Page 1 of 3
Created 3/21/2011 8:26:26 AM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Energy Calibration Calibration Information
Calibration Title Energy Calibration (I-125)3/16/2011 3:02 PM Calibration Date 3/16/2011 3:02:15 PM Performed By David Georgeson Count Used Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Is Default Yes
Counter Information
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle
Detector Group Information
Detector Group Name Right Calibration Source Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1 Analysis Sequence File Nuclide Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB Peak Search Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB
Energy Calibration Coefficients
Energy = - 0.346161 + 0.46233 * ch - 2.30088e-07 * ch^2
FWHM = 0.631027 + 0.0248655 * E^1/2
LOW TAIL = 0.519347 + 0.00136678 * E
Energy Calibration Results Table
Centroid Channel Centroid Error Energy (keV)57.52 0.12 26.34
129.55 0.01 59.54 264.19 0.01 121.78 530.19 0.02 244.70 745.69 0.01 344.28
Approved by: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
33
Energy Calibration Created 3/21/2011 8:26:26 AM Page 2 of 3
Energy Calibration Results Table
Energy (keV) FWHM Channels FWHM Error TAIL Channels TAIL Error26.34 1.38 0.71 0.53 0.60 59.54 1.81 0.03 1.23 0.12
121.78 1.94 0.02 1.76 0.18 244.70 2.25 0.04 2.07 1.02 344.28 2.36 0.02 2.05 0.21
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
34
Energy Calibration Created 3/21/2011 8:26:26 AM Page 3 of 3
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
35
Page 1 of 3
Created 3/21/2011 8:27:04 AM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Energy Calibration Calibration Information
Calibration Title Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Calibration Date 3/16/2011 3:03:00 PM Performed By David Georgeson Count Used Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Is Default Yes
Counter Information
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle
Detector Group Information
Detector Group Name Summed Calibration Source Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1 Analysis Sequence File Nuclide Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB Peak Search Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB
Energy Calibration Coefficients
Energy = - 0.365335 + 0.46262 * ch - 4.49624e-07 * ch^2
FWHM = 0.848541 + 0.025188 * E^1/2
LOW TAIL = 0.623077 + 0.00135443 * E
Energy Calibration Results Table
Centroid Channel Centroid Error Energy (keV)57.52 0.17 26.34
129.52 0.01 59.54 264.08 0.02 121.78 530.03 0.02 244.70 745.53 0.01 344.28
Approved by: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
36
Energy Calibration Created 3/21/2011 8:27:04 AM Page 2 of 3
Energy Calibration Results Table
Energy (keV) FWHM Channels FWHM Error TAIL Channels TAIL Error26.34 1.76 0.52 0.69 0.57 59.54 2.26 0.03 1.59 0.16
121.78 2.43 0.04 1.70 0.18 244.70 2.68 0.04 2.00 0.27 344.28 2.85 0.02 2.64 1.00
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
37
Energy Calibration Created 3/21/2011 8:27:04 AM Page 3 of 3
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
38
39
Appendix D
Efficiency Calibration Documentation
40
41
Appendix D Efficiency Calibration Documentation
Efficiency Calibration Calibration Information
Calibration Title Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM Calibration Date 3/16/2011 4:29:50 PM Performed By David Georgeson Count Used Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Approved 3/16/2011 4:31:59 PM by David Georgeson Is Default Yes Is Multi Curve No
Counter Information
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Counter Configuration Thyroid - I-125
Detector Group Information
Detector Group Name Summed Calibration Source Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1 Analysis Sequence File CALWBCGE for I-125.ASF Nuclide Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB Peak Search Library Am-241/Eu-152.NLB
Approved by: Date:
User: David Georgeson
42
Efficiency Calibration
Efficiency Triplets Energy (keV) Efficiency Error Dual Difference
2.634E+001 4.155E-003 8.731E-005 3.389E-003 18.43 % 5.954E+001 2.468E-003 2.964E-005 3.031E-003 -22.83 %1.218E+002 2.928E-003 3.550E-005 2.444E-003 16.55 %2.447E+002 1.883E-003 4.280E-005 1.782E-003 5.38 %3.443E+002 1.377E-003 1.824E-005 1.470E-003 -6.78 %
Empirical ln(eff) = - 6.02946 + 0.756669 * x - 0.579472 * x^2 - 0.381448 * x^3 + 0.283555 * x^4 where x = ln( 185.311 / E ) where E = Energy in keV
User: David Georgeson Efficiency Calibration
Dual ln(eff) = - 6.67176 + 0.651547 * ln(E) - 0.107164 * (ln(E))^2 where E = Energy in keV
43
User: David Georgeson
44
Efficiency Calibration
Interpolated
User: David Georgeson Efficiency Calibration
45
Linear log(eff) = - 0.00100278 * E - 2.50288 + 2.17845 / E where E = Energy in keV
User: David Georgeson
46
47
Appendix E
I-125 Calibration Count Reanalysis Summary
48
49
Appendix E I-125 Calibration Count Reanalysis Summary
Nuclide/ Expected Observed Energy Activity Activity Relative(keV) (�Ci) (�Ci) Bias
Am-241/26.26 210 275.3 0.311
Am-241/59.54 210 211.9 0.009
Eu-152/121.8 180 180.400 0.002
Eu-152/244.7 180 181.100 0.006
Eu-152/344.3 180 178.200 -0.010
average 0.064
Arrangement/Geometry: Accuscan II
Summary of the Reanalysis of the Efficiency Calibration CountFor I-125 Calibration Using Am-241/Eu152
Count Start Time: 3/16/2011 12:56 PM
Analysis Library: Am-241/Eu-152 for I-125.NLBEnergy Calibration Time: 03/16/2011 3:02 PMEfficiency Calibration Time: 03/16/2011 4:31 PMCount Live Time: 7223 Seconds
50
Page 1 of 4
Created 4/27/2011 10:28:10 AM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Analysis Report - Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PMCOUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Calibration Count Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/16/2011 12:56:49 PM Acquisition Time 7223.15 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Live Time Analyze
d Analyzed Date File Name
Left 60.77 1 - 4096 7200.0 No b065b30a1256.cnf Right 61.51 1 - 4096 7200.0 No 11cc05321256.cnf
Summed 0.00 1 - 4096 7200.0 Yes 4/27/2011 10:27:59 AM 0d528c651256.cnf
Primary Review by: Secondary Review by:
Date: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
51
Analysis Report - Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Created 4/27/2011 10:28:10 AM Page 2 of 4
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 4/27/2011 10:27:59 AM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library Am241/Eu152 for I-125
Tentative NID Library Am241/Eu152 for I-125
Peak Search Library Am241/Eu152 for I-125
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis Nuclide Information No Peak
Centroid Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
Nuclide Name
Activity (nCi) Error (1SD)
Yield (%)
1 26.55 11.92 1.37E+003 8.21E+003 Unknown 5.788608E-003 100.00 M 2 57.55 26.26 7.37E+003 7.18E+003 Am-241 2.752849E+002 2.51 % 2.40 m 3 65.54 29.95 4.19E+003 1.20E+004 Unknown 4.971242E+000 100.00 m 4 75.78 34.69 8.06E+003 1.45E+004 Unknown 1.158900E+001 100.00 m 5 80.20 36.73 1.07E+004 1.65E+004 Unknown 1.607184E+001 100.00 m 6 86.89 39.83 5.92E+004 2.14E+004 Unknown 9.303807E+001 100.00 M 7 99.00 45.43 1.07E+004 1.89E+004 Unknown 1.733585E+001 100.00 m 8 107.88 49.54 5.45E+002 2.17E+004 Unknown 8.741777E-001 100.00 9 129.50 59.54 4.97E+004 1.49E+004 Am-241 2.119438E+002 1.43 % 35.70 10 264.08 121.77 4.00E+004 9.77E+003 EU-152 1.804203E+002 1.44 % 28.40 11 530.03 244.71 6.81E+003 4.09E+003 EU-152 1.811926E+002 3.58 % 7.49 12 640.53 295.77 3.66E+002 2.31E+003 Unknown 8.751176E-001 100.00 13 745.55 344.29 1.74E+004 1.94E+003 EU-152 1.782479E+002 1.68 % 26.60 14 796.32 367.74 3.29E+002 1.65E+003 Unknown 9.400238E-001 100.00 15 890.16 411.08 1.27E+003 1.15E+003 Unknown 3.833098E+000 100.00 16 961.38 443.97 1.50E+003 1.09E+003 Unknown 4.647649E+000 100.00 17 1058.58 488.85 2.34E+002 1.05E+003 Unknown 7.219349E-001 100.00 18 1106.81 511.12 7.33E+002 1.08E+003 Unknown 2.223503E+000 100.00 19 1221.17 563.90 1.86E+002 8.24E+002 Unknown 5.279418E-001 100.00 20 1491.24 688.51 2.61E+002 5.71E+002 Unknown 5.430381E-001 100.00 21 1557.27 718.97 1.27E+002 6.09E+002 Unknown 2.381721E-001 100.00 22 1686.70 778.66 3.94E+003 8.74E+002 Unknown 5.839245E+000 100.00 23 1878.37 867.02 1.16E+003 7.36E+002 Unknown 1.145140E+000 100.00
M 24 1990.58 918.73 1.26E+002 4.11E+002 Unknown 9.486010E-002 100.00 m 25 2005.07 925.41 8.29E+001 4.16E+002 Unknown 6.002627E-002 100.00
52
26 2087.90 963.58 3.83E+003 4.69E+002 Unknown 2.239571E+000 100.00 27 2177.45 1004.84 1.38E+002 3.31E+002 Unknown 6.315312E-002 100.00
M 28 2351.65 1085.07 2.39E+003 3.56E+002 Unknown 6.641177E-001 100.00 m 29 2360.33 1089.07 3.33E+002 4.61E+002 Unknown 9.008405E-002 100.00 30 2408.52 1111.26 3.21E+003 3.52E+002 Unknown 7.509426E-001 100.00 31 2628.00 1212.29 2.69E+002 3.15E+002 Unknown 3.146647E-002 100.00
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
Analysis Report - Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Created 4/27/2011 10:28:10 AM Page 3 of 4
PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis Nuclide Information No Peak
Centroid Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
Nuclide Name
Activity (nCi) Error (1SD) Yield (%)
32 3052.74 1407.70 4.05E+003 1.32E+002 Unknown 1.092345E-001
100.00 M 33 3161.55 1457.74 3.17E+002 7.80E+001 Unknown 5.747485E-
003 100.00
m 34 3167.10 1460.29 3.50E+002 7.65E+001 Unknown 6.232102E-003
100.00 For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region m = Other peak in a multiplet region F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD) Action Level 1 Action Level 2 MDA (nCi)
EU-152 1.000 1.796259E+002
1.05 % Not Performed Not Performed
2.545E+000 Am-241 1.000 2.221031E+00
21.25 % 3.074E+000
? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis @ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity ! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Na e
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA ( Ci)
Nuclide MDA ( Ci)
Activity (nCi) + EU-152 121.78 * 28.40 2.5446E+000
2.5446E+000
1.8042E+002 + 244.70 * 7.49 1.0491E+001 1.8119E+002 + 344.28 * 26.60 2.8828E+000 1.7825E+002 + Am-241 26.30 * 2.40 1.0422E+001
3.0736E+000 2.7528E+002
+ 59.54 * 35.70 3.0736E+000 2.1194E+002 + = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification * = Energy Line found in the spectrum User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
53
Analysis Report - Calibration Count 3/16/2011 12:56 PM Created 4/27/2011 10:28:10 AM Page 4 of 4
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
54
55
Appendix F
Accuscan II I-125 Calibration Verification
56
57
Appendix F Accuscan II I-125 Calibration Verification
Page 1 of 2
Created 4/26/2011 5:22:10 PM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Efficiency Verification Calibration Information
Calibration Title Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM Calibration Date 3/16/2011 4:29:50 PM Operator Name David Georgeson Detector Group Summed Detector Group Thyroid Screening Source Distribution Thyroid
Counter Information
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Counter Thyroid - I-125
Count List
Num Date Name 1 3/16/2011 Verification Count 3/16/2011 3:13 PM (1/5) 2 3/16/2011 Verification Count 3/16/2011 3:13 PM (2/5) 3 3/16/2011 Verification Count 3/16/2011 3:13 PM (3/5) 4 3/16/2011 Verification Count 3/16/2011 3:13 PM (4/5) 5 3/16/2011 Verification Count 3/16/2011 3:13 PM (5/5)
58
User: David Georgeson
Database: InVivo Server: 127 0 0 1
Efficiency Verification Created 4/26/2011 5:22:10 PM Page 2 of 2
Source Certificate Am241/Eu152 RMC II-1
Nuclide Energy Certificate
Activity (g/s)
Half Life Count 1 Count 2 Count 3 Count 4 Count 5 Relative Bias (%)
Relative Precision
(%)
Am-241 13.93 1900.00 432.19 y 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
- - 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Am-241 17.51 2370.00 432.19 y 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
- - 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Am-241 20.98 568.00 432.19 y 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
- - 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Am-241 26.34 186.00 432.19 y 0.00 163.88 165.68 189.54 0.00
-6.97 % 6.29 % 0.00 186.00 186.00 186.00 0.00
Am-241 59.54 2770.00 432.19 y 2787.36 2734.35 2786.32 2727.81 3065.74
1.82 % 4.52 % 2769.97 2769.97 2769.97 2769.97 2769.97
EU-152 121.78 1890.00 4946.21 d 1796.42 1991.97 1855.09 1938.08 1902.02
0.39 % 3.56 % 1889.30 1889.30 1889.30 1889.30 1889.30
EU-152 244.70 500.00 4946.22 d 421.53 443.33 471.88 570.06 573.26
-0.76 % 12.77 % 499.82 499.81 499.81 499.81 499.81
EU-152 344.28 1770.00 4946.22 d 1783.19 1770.16 1635.56 1851.77 1785.85
-0.23 % 4.00 % 1769.35 1769.34 1769.34 1769.34 1769.34
|xbar| = 2.03 % 6.23 % For each count, the number on the top is the observed activity and the number on the bottom is the expected activity.
References: Draft American National Standard, Performance Criteria for Radiobioassay, ANSI N13.30 Certificate of Calibration, Standard Radionuclide Source, Analytics
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
59
Appendix G
MDA Determination
60
61
Appendix G MDA Determination
MDA SUMMARY CALCULATIONS FROM COUNT DATA
1. 2. 3.
Where:
Nuclide/Energy #1 Count (MDA) #2 Count (MDA) #3 Count (MDA) Average(nCi) (nCi) (nCi) (nCi)
I-125/27 keV 1.99E+00 2.03E+00 3.10E+00 2.57E+00I-125/31 keV 6.01E+00 7.35E+00 6.59E+00 6.97E+00
ACCUSCAN II COUNTER
(gross rate (CPS) x routine counting time)K = Efficiency X Abundance X 37 Bq/nCi
MDA = (4.65Sb + 3)/KT
3/23/11 4:19 PM3/23/11 4:32 PM3/23/11 4:44 PM
T = Routine counting time in seconds = 600 seconds
Sb = Standard deviation of the blank phantom counts = SQRT
MDA CALCULATION For I-125
MDA Calculations
Arrangement Geometry: Thyroid Analysis Library: I-125 Thyroid.nlbEnergy Calibration Time: 3/16/2011 3:02 PMEfficiency Calibration Time: 3/16/2011 4:31 PM Count Type/Live Time: 600 SecondsCount Start Times:
62
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 4:19:49 PM Acquisition Time 601.24 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Range Live Time Analyzed
Left 13.30 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Right 14.40 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Summed 27.65 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes
Primary Review by: Date:
User: David Georgeson
63
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 4:19:39 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20
Comment NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA (nCi)
I-125 27.00 40.25 1.9877E+000
31.00 12.50 6.0148E+000
* = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson
64
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 4:32:40 PM Acquisition Time 601.35 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate Count Rate Range Live Time Analyze
d
Right 14.62 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Left 13.44 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Summed 27.98 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes
Primary Review by: Date:
User: David Georgeson Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
65
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 4:32:13 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20
Comment NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA (nCi)
I-125 27.00 40.25 2.0337E+000
31.00 12.50 7.3530E+000
* = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson
66
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 4:44:28 PM Acquisition Time 601.4299999 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate Count Rate Range
Live Time Analyzed
Left 13.44 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Right 14.72 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Summed 28.11 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes
Primary Review by: Date:
User: David Georgeson
67
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 4:44:20 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095
Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis
No Peak Centroid
Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
1 57.75 26.35 7.98E+001 1.06E+002
For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region
m = Other peak in a multiplet region
F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD)
I-125 0.987 2.152364E+000 32.42 %
? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution
X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis
@ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity
! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA (nCi)
+ I-125 27.00 * 40.25 3.1088E+000
+ 31.00 12.50 6.5948E+000
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification
* = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson
68
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
User: David Georgeson
69
Appendix H
Calibration Validation using I-125
70
71
Appendix H Calibration Validation using I-125
Summary
Nuclide/ Expected Energy Activity Relative Relative (keV) (nCi) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 Bias Precision
I-125/27 102.0000 98.600 97.800 95.600 97.300 96.700 -0.047 0.011
I-125/31 102.0000 102.600 105.100 101.900 98.000 86.200 -0.032 0.073
Average -0.040 0.042
Calibration Validation CountsAccuscan II Calibration Validation for I-125 Thyroid
Arrangement/Geometry: ThyroidAnalysis Library: I-125 Thyroid.nlbEnergy Calibration Date: 3/16/2011 3:02 PMEfficiency Calibration Date: 3/16/2011 4:31 PCount Live Time: 600 Seconds
Count Start Times:
Count # 5 - 03/23/2011 4:05 PM
Observed Activity (nCi)
Count # 1 - 03/23/2011 3:09 PMCount # 2 - 03/23/2011 3:25 PMCount # 3 - 03/23/2011 3:41 PMCount # 4 - 03/23/2011 3:53 PM
72
COUNT 1 Page 1 of 3
Created 3/23/2011 3:27:01 PM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 3:09:07 PM Acquisition Time 601.5 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Live Time Analyzed Analyzed Date File Name
Left 18.69 1 - 4096 600.0 No 9dab9d661508.cnf Right 20.50 1 - 4096 600.0 No 0cbf77fc1508.cnf Summed 39.07 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes 3/23/2011 3:08:58 PM 03ddb8681508.cnf
Primary Review by: Secondary Review
Date: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
73
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 3:27:02 PM Page 2 of 3
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 3:08:58 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis Nuclide Information No Peak
Centroid Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
Nuclide Name
Activity (nCi) Error (1SD)
Yield (%)
M 1 59.77 27.28 3.36E+003 9.29E+002 I-125 9.859657E+001 3.75 % 40.25 m 2 67.89 31.04 8.51E+002 5.16E+002 I-125 1.026382E+002 9.08 % 12.50 m 3 77.23 35.36 2.48E+002 2.24E+002 Unknown 4.359149E+000 100.00
For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region m = Other peak in a multiplet region F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD) Action Level 1 Action Level 2 MDA (nCi)
I-125 0.997 9.914710E+001 3.47 % Not Performed Not Performed 5.971E+000 ? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis @ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity ! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Na e
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA ( Ci)
Nuclide MDA ( Ci)
Activity (nCi) + I-125 27.00 * 40.25 5.9705E+000 5.9705E+000 9.8597E+001 + 31.00 * 12.50 1.8374E+001 1.0264E+002
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification * = Energy Line found in the spectrum User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
74
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 3:27:02 PM Page 3 of 3
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
75
COUNT 2
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm) COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 3:25:54 PM Acquisition Time 601.42 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Live Time Analyzed
Right 20.18 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Left 18.42 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Summed 38.58 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes
Primary Review by: Date:
User: David Georgeson
76
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 3:25:12 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095
Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis
No Peak Centroid
Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
1 38.01 17.22 1.76E+002 2.72E+002
M 2 59.80 27.30 3.33E+003 8.10E+002
m 3 67.75 30.98 8.74E+002 4.47E+002
m 4 77.55 35.51 2.67E+002 1.90E+002
For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region
m = Other peak in a multiplet region
F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD)
I-125 0.997 9.878515E+001 3.47 %
? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution
X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis
@ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity
! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Na e
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA ( Ci)+ I-125 27.00 * 40.25 5.5885E+000
+ 31.00 * 12.50 1.7075E+001
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification * = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson
77
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
User: David Georgeson
78
COUNT 3 Page 1 of 3 Created 3/23/2011 4:06:05 PM Idaho Falls Id. Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 3:41:45 PM Acquisition Time 601.39 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Live Time Analyze
d Analyzed Date File Name
Left 18.73 1 - 4096 600.0 No 88d02fc81541.cnf Right 19.87 1 - 4096 600.0 No 348d689d1541.cnf Summed 38.53 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes 3/23/2011 3:41:36
PM644e5f9c1541.cnf
Primary Review by: Secondary Review by:
Date: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
79
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 4:06:05 PM Page 2 of 3
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 3:41:36 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis Nuclide Information No Peak
Centroid Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
Nuclide Name
Activity (nCi) Error (1SD) Yield (%)
M 1 59.79 27.29 3.26E+003 8.19E+002 I-125 9.564766E+001
3.76 % 40.25 m 2 67.83 31.01 8.46E+002 6.11E+002 I-125 1.018599E+0
029.10 % 12.50
m 3 77.51 35.49 2.19E+002 2.87E+002 Unknown 3.853039E+000
100.00 For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region m = Other peak in a multiplet region F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD) Action Level 1 Action Level 2 MDA (nCi)
I-125 0.997 9.645958E+001 3.47 % Not Performed Not Performed 5.614E+000 ? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis @ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity ! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA (nCi)
Nuclide MDA (nCi)
Activity (nCi)
+ I-125 27.00 * 40.25 5.6137E+000 5.6137E+000 9.5648E+001 + 31.00 * 12.50 1.9942E+001 1.0186E+002
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification * = Energy Line found in the spectrum User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
80
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 4:06:05 PM Page 3 of 3
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
81
COUNT 4 Page 1 of 3
Created 3/23/2011 4:07:12 PM
Idaho Falls Id.
Battelle Energy Alliance LLC
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 3:53:09 PM Acquisition Time 601.41 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate
Count Rate Live Time Analyzed Analyzed Date File Name
Left 18.83 1 - 4096 600.0 No 5a8847391553.cnf Right 19.97 1 - 4096 600.0 No 6f5c18931553.cnf Summed 38.48 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes 3/23/2011 3:53:00
PMb314935e1553.cnf
Primary Review by: Secondary Review by:
Date: Date:
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
82
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 4:07:12 PM Page 2 of 3
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 3:53:00 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095 Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis Nuclide Information No Peak
Centroid Energy (keV)
Net Peak Area
Continuum Counts
Nuclide Name
Activity (nCi) Error (1SD) Yield (%)
1 38.53 17.46 8.02E+001 2.98E+002 Unknown 1.426229E-001
100.00 M 2 59.82 27.31 3.31E+003 7.88E+002 I-125 9.731969E+0
013.74 % 40.25
m 3 67.75 30.97 8.15E+002 5.12E+002 I-125 9.802611E+001
9.08 % 12.50 m 4 77.34 35.41 2.74E+002 1.99E+002 Unknown 4.817942E+0
00 100.00
For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region m = Other peak in a multiplet region F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi)
Error (1SD) Action Level 1 Action Level 2 MDA (nCi)
I-125 0.997 9.742112E+001
3.46 % Not Performed Not Performed 5.516E+000 ? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis @ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity ! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Na e
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA ( Ci)
Nuclide MDA ( Ci)
Activity (nCi) + I-125 27.00 * 40.25 5.5162E+000 5.5162E+000 9.7320E+001 + 31.00 * 12.50 1.8259E+001 9.8026E+001
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification * = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
83
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] Created 3/23/2011 4:07:12 PM Page 3 of 3
User: David Georgeson Database: InVivo Server: 127.0.0.1
84
COUNT 5
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125] SOURCE INFORMATION
Primary ID 000-125 Last Name Validation Count First Name I-125 Height (in) Weight (lb) Chest Wall Thickness (cm)
COUNTER INFORMATION
Counter Name Accuscan II Counter Location Battelle Configuration Name Thyroid - I-125
COUNT INFORMATION
Count Operation Individual 10 minutes Count Reason Routine operation Frequency Comment Intake Date Acquisition Started 3/23/2011 4:05:06 PM Acquisition Time 601.51 Operator Name David Georgeson Count Status Not Reviewed Primary Review No Secondary Review No
DETECTOR COUNT RATE REPORT
Detector Name Count Rate Count Rate Range Live Time Analyzed
Left 18.59 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Right 19.96 1 - 4096 600.0 No
Summed 38.39 1 - 4096 600.0 Yes
Primary Review by: Date: User: David Georgeson
85
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
DETECTOR GROUP INFORMATION
Detector Group Name Summed Detector Group Configuration Thyroid Screening Analysis Date 3/23/2011 4:04:58 PM Energy Calibration Energy Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 3:02 PM Efficiency Calibration Efficiency Calibration (I-125) 3/16/2011 4:31 PM (Empirical)
Multi Curve No Source Distribution Thyroid Analysis Sequence File Thyroid ASF for I-125.ASF Bkg Acq used for area correction Not Performed Nuclide Identification
Nuclide Identification Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Tentative NID Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Peak Search Library I-125 Thyroid.nlb
Analysis Limits (channels) 20 - 4095
Energy Tolerance (FWHM) 1.20 Comment
PEAK SEARCH RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Peak Analysis
No Peak Centroid Energy (keV) Net Peak Area Continuum Counts
M 1 59.81 27.30 3.29E+003 7.58E+002
m 2 67.85 31.02 7.15E+002 5.62E+002
m 3 77.46 35.47 2.34E+002 2.71E+002
4 3165.65 1459.62 3.79E+001 1.61E+001
For unknown peaks we assume yield to be 100% and no decay correction is performed.
M = First peak in a multiplet region
m = Other peak in a multiplet region
F = Fitted singlet
NUCLIDE RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide Name
Id Confidence
Wt Mean Activity (nCi) Error (1SD)
I-125 0.997 9.487243E+001 3.47 %
? = Nuclide is part of an undetermined solution
X = Nuclide rejected by the interference analysis
@ = Nuclide contains energy lines not used in Weighted Mean Activity
! = Nuclide was corrected for parent/daughter
NUCLIDE MDA RESULTS FOR Accuscan II <Summed>
Nuclide N
Energy (keV) Yield (%) Line MDA (nCi)
+ I-125 27.00 * 40.25 5.4099E+000
+ 31.00 * 12.50 1.9153E+001
+ = Nuclide Identified during the nuclide identification
* = Energy Line found in the spectrum
User: David Georgeson
86
Analysis Report - I-125 Validation Count [000-125]
User: David Georgeson
87
Appendix I
ANSI N44.3 Phantom
88
89
Appendix I ANSI N44.3 Phantom
90
91
92
93
94
95
Appendix J
RMC II Transfer Phantom
96
97
Appendix J RMC II Transfer Phantom
The Canberra RMC-II
(Model 2257) Transfer Phantom
J-1. CANBERRA RMC-II (MODEL 2257)TRANSFER PHANTOM
This is an inexpensive and easy-to-use phantom that is intended for use during efficiency calibrations of Canberra’s various “linear geometry” in vivo counters. This phantom has been designed to adequately duplicate the counting geometries of the ANSI N13.30 (later published as HPS N13.30-1996) reference phantom configurations when used to calibrate the standard Canberra Fastscan, Accuscan (Bed), and Accuscan-II counting systems. The reference phantom counting geometries duplicated by the Canberra Transfer Phantom include the Livermore Realistic torso lungs, the BOMAB total body, and the ANSI-N44.3 thyroid. The original test counts performed to verify the suitability of the Canberra Transfer Phantom are summarized in the following pages.
The Canberra Transfer Phantom can be used to accurately simulate lung, GI region, whole body, or thyroid source activity distributions. It is easy to use because it needs no assembly and requires only a single “mixed-gamma” source in a 20-ml liquid scintillation vial for all calibration geometries.
This phantom can provide accurate efficiency calibration results when properly used with standard Canberra Fastscan, Accuscan (Bed), and Accuscan-II counting systems, as well with standard Nuclear Data “People Mover” systems. This phantom is not appropriate for calibrations involving low-energy photon measurements (attempted quantification of nuclide activity based on detection of photons with energies less than 100 keV), or for counting geometries involving one or more detectors positioned behind the subject.
J-2. VERIFICATION OF THE Canberra RMC-II CALIBRATION Phantom
For proper calibration of whole body counter (WBC) systems, it is necessary to simulate the photon emanation and absorption characteristics of a human counting subject with internally deposited radioactive material. This is accomplished by loading standard nuclides of known activities in a
98
“phantom” absorber matrix, placed at a designated position relative to the shield and detectors of the WBC system.
Canberra has developed an inexpensive and easy-to-handle phantom appropriate for calibrating linear-geometry fission and activation product WBC systems. This phantom closely approximates the source/absorber configurations provided by the more expensive and complex reference phantoms specified by ANSI N13.30 (later published as HPS N13.30-1996) and ANSI N44.3 as appropriate for WBC calibrations. This phantom is intended for use with small-volume radioactive sources (typically prepared in one-inch diameter liquid scintillation vials). These sources may be loaded in any one of four standard positions within the phantom, thereby simulating reference configurations for lung, thyroid, G.I. region, and whole body activity distributions. This phantom is hereafter referred to as the “RMC-II” phantom [with the “II” added to indicate a significant design change from the REMCAL Transfer Phantom previously developed by Radiation Management Corporation (RMC) prior to acquisition of RMC by Canberra].
The RMC-II phantom consists of two basic components: a “torso” section, and a “neck” section. The torso section is constructed from flat sheets of cast acrylic material (e.g., Lexan or Plexiglass), with the front sheet thickness chosen to provide the proper amount of absorber between the calibration source and the WBC system detector(s). Three interior source cavities provide lung-equivalent, G.I. region-equivalent, and whole body-equivalent configurations. The neck section is a cast acrylic cylinder with a thyroid-equivalent source cavity, with dimensions specified in ANSI N44.3. This configuration provides the ANSI-approved reference thyroid counting geometry.
The RMC-II phantom must be properly positioned in the WBC shield when performing calibration counts. The base of the torso section must be placed near “waist level” of a reference counting subject in the WBC shield. For Canberra Fastscan and Accuscan-II counters, the base of the torso section must be flat against the rear interior shield wall, centered between the molded guide ridges, at a height of 36 inches above the interior shield floor pad. For Canberra Accuscan (Bed) systems, the back of the phantom must be centered and flat on the bed pad, and the base of the torso section placed 36 inches from the foot plate.
J-3. PRELIMINARY TESTING OF THE RMC-II PHANTOM
The optimum values of cast acrylic sheet thickness and source cavity dimensions were determined by direct comparison of WBC system response using ANSI-specified reference phantoms and an adjustable RMC-II phantom prototype. To determine the efficiency vs. photon energy response for the reference lung configuration, a Livermore Realistic torso phantom was used (purchased by RMC from Humanoid Systems). Lung inserts simulating a uniform activity distribution of Eu-152 were loaded in the phantom, and three chest wall thickness values ranging from 16 mm to 39 mm were used.
Initially, test counts were performed using a standard Fastscan system assembled with two 4” × 4” × 16” NaI detectors). Efficiency values were calculated for six prominent Eu-152 photopeak energies, and smooth-curve functions were fitted to these measured efficiency values. The efficiency curve for the 22.5 mm chest thickness configuration was accepted as the reference “lung efficiency” response to be duplicated by the RMC-II phantom lung configuration.
Next, a series of test counts was performed using a Eu-152 point source and various thickness values of cast acrylic absorber. The source was mounted at a position near the midpoint of the lungs in a reference subject, 54 inches above the interior shield floor pad. The thickness of absorber material between the source and the detectors was varied in 0.25-inch increments until the resulting efficiency values fit a smooth curve with shape similar to that of the reference lung efficiency curve. The cast acrylic sheets were sufficiently large to intercept all straight-line photon paths between the source and detectors. The distance between the source and the back wall of the Fastscan shield was then varied until the efficiency values calculated for the RMC-II phantom were in good agreement with those for the reference
99
phantom. This process resulted in the selection of 1.85 inches of acrylic absorber and 3.5 inches distance from back of the phantom to source midline as the optimum dimensions for simulating the Livermore Realistic phantom lung configuration (with 22.5 mm chest wall thickness).
A second series of test counts was performed to simulate the reference “BOMAB” whole body phantom configuration. For this activity distribution, a 10-piece cylindrical and ellipsoidal polyethylene jug phantom was filled with uniform activity concentration Eu-152 solution (60 liters total volume). This 10-component phantom represents the head, neck, upper torso, arms, lower torso, thighs and lower legs of a counting subject. The phantom was supported in a standing configuration in the Fastscan shield, and efficiency values were determined for six photon energies as done previously for the reference lung configuration. Test counts performed with the adjustable RMC-II phantom prototype resulted in the selection of 1.85 inches of acrylic absorber, and 0.5 inches distance from the back of the phantom to the source midline, as the optimum dimensions for simulating the reference BOMAB whole body configuration.
A third series of test counts was performed to determine an appropriate G.I. region configuration for the RMC-II phantom. Because of the dynamic nature of the G.I. tract, and the lack of a specific ANSI recommendation for simulating this organ, defining a “reference” G.I. region phantom is somewhat problematic. Test counts were performed using the following three phantoms: (1) the Livermore Realistic torso phantom with 19 line-geometry sources loaded in the abdominal insert, (2) the Alderson Research Laboratories REMCAL phantom with a single line-geometry source loaded in the “G.I. cavity”, and (3) the 10-piece BOMAB polyethylene jug body phantom with Eu-152 activity distributed in the lower torso component only. Efficiency values obtained with these three phantoms were fitted with smooth-curve functions.
Test counts were then performed with the adjustable RMC-II phantom prototype. The absorber thickness and source position was varied until the resulting efficiency values closely approximated the values obtained with the lower torso component of the 10-piece BOMAB phantom. (This also provided good agreement with the average of the Livermore Realistic abdominal cavity and REMCAL G.I. cavity efficiency values.) An absorber thickness of 1.85 inches and a 5.5-inch distance between the point source and back of the phantom were selected for the optimum RMC-II phantom G.I. region configuration, based on these comparative counts.
A production model of the RMC-II phantom was then prepared by Webb Plastics in Northbrook, Illinois. This production model of the RMC-II phantom was then tested using three standard Canberra linear-geometry WBC systems (Fastscan, Accuscan[Bed], and AccuScan-II) to confirm adequate similarity of the RMC-II phantom and the three reference phantoms, as explained below.
J-4. VERIFICATION OF RMC-II PHANTOM DESIGN
Final verification of the RMC-II phantom design was completed in February 1988. Comparative test counts were performed using three WBC systems at the Canberra Industries, Meriden, CT facility. The intent was to document RMC-II phantom and reference phantom equivalence for Fastscan systems, Accuscan Bed systems (when configured for horizontal scanning of the entire bed length) and Accuscan-II systems (when configured for vertical scanning of the entire shield height).
The Livermore Realistic torso phantom, 10-piece BOMAB total body phantom, and lower torso component of the BOMAB phantom were again used as reference lung, whole body, and G.I. region phantom configurations, respectively. Eu-152 sources with activity distributions appropriate for each phantom were used in the comparative test counts. Efficiency values determined for the three counter types, using the reference phantoms and the RMC-II phantom production model, are summarized in Table J-1. Efficiency ratio values were calculated (RMC-II phantom efficiency divided by the corresponding reference phantom efficiency) and are also shown in Table J-1.
100
J-5. CONCLUSIONS
Results of the verification test counts show acceptable agreement between the RMC-II phantom efficiency and the reference phantom efficiency for the three counter types tested. All efficiency ratio values listed in Table J-1 are within a range of 0.79-1.20, and the average ratio (all values weighted equally) is 1.02.
When evaluating the performance of WBC systems, measured nuclide activity values will be inversely proportional to system efficiency values. If the RMC-II phantom is used for WBC system calibration, a bias in measured activity values will be expected, relative to those activity values that would have been calculated if the reference phantoms had been used for efficiency calibration. Table J-2 summarizes these relative bias values for each configuration and counter type tested.
The results shown in Table J-2 confirm that the RMC-II phantom provides an acceptable approximation of the ANSI-specified reference phantoms. All relative bias values shown are well within the WBC performance criteria limits for measurement accuracy specified in ANSI N13.30 (i.e., -0.25 < relative bias <0.50). Proper use of the RMC-II phantom will allow valid WBC system efficiency calibrations and ensure accurate WBC measurement results. A diagram showing the relative location of the four source cavities in the RMC-II phantom is shown in Figure J-1.
Table J-1. Summary of phantom comparison test count results. Geometry Measured Response 122 keV 245 keV 344 keV 779 keV 964 keV 1408 keV
Ref. Eff.4 (% 2 s.d.) 8.21E-3 (5.1) 7.67E-3 (8.0) 8.12E-3 (2.4) 5.95E-3 (5.0) 6.71E-3 (3.9) 6.53E-3 (1.9)Test Eff.4 (% 2 s.d.) 7.55E-3 (5.0) 7.98E-3 (8.4) 7.52E-3 (2.1) 5.93E-3 (4.9) 6.58E-3 (3.2) 6.32E-3 (1.5)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 0.92 +/- 7.1% 1.04+/- 12% 0.93 +/- 3.2% 1.00 +/- 7.1% 0.98 +/- 5.0% 0.97 +/- 2.4%
Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 5.16E-3 (4.4) 5.23E-3 (8.9) 5.57E-3 (1.7) 4.37E-3 (4.6) 4.81E-3 (3.4) 4.47E-3 (1.5)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 5.56E-3 (4.7) 6.02E-3 (5.3) 5.73E-3 (2.6) 4.82E-3 (5.0) 5.37E-3 (2.6) 4.83E-3 (1.2)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 1.08 +/- 6.4% 1.15 +/- 10% 1.03 +/- 3.1% 1.10 +/- 6.8% 1.12 +/- 4.3% 1.08 +/-1.9%
Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 7.30E-3 (5.9) 7.53E-3 (9.6) 8.11E-3 (1.5) 6.25E-3 (5.4) 6.77E-3 (3.8) 6.33E-3 (1.4)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 7.43E-3 (5.6) 7.71E-3 (6.0) 8.04E-3 (2.5) 6.83E-3 (5.0) 7.85E-3 (2.8) 7.15E-3 (1.1)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 1.02+/- 8.1% 1.02 +/- 11% 0.99 +/- 2.9% 1.09 +/- 7.4% 1.16 +/- 4.7% 1.13 +/- 1.8%
Lung Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.71 E-3 (9.2) 2.04E-3 (11.1) 1.98E-3 (3.4) 1.38E-3 (7.1) 1.34E-3 (7.6) 1.44E-3 (3.2)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.41 E-3 (10.3) 1.95E-3 (11.6) 1.73E-3 (3.9) 1.34E-3 (6.5) 1.31E-3 (5.7) 1.37E-3 (3.5)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 0.82 +/- 14% 0.96 +/- 16% 0.87 +/- 5.2% 0.97 +/- 9.6% 0.98 +/- 9.5% 0.95 +/- 4.7%
Total Body Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.51E-3 (6.4) 1.73E-3 (7.7) 1.69E-3 (2.9) 1.25E-3 (6.0) 1.27E-3 (3.8) 1.24E-3 (2.0)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.46E-3 (8.6) 2.02E-3 (6.3) 1.70E-3 (3.2) 1.31E-3 (5.6) 1.30E-3 (4.6) 1.24E-3 (2.4)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 0.97 +/- 11% 1.17 +/- 9.9% 1.01 +/- 4.3% 1.05 +/- 8.2% 1.02 +/- 6.0% 1.00 +/- 3.1%
GI Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.46E-3 (8.3) 1.69E-3 (9.8) 1.69E-3 (2.8) 1.30E-3 (4.8) 1.28E-3 (4.3) 1.28E-3 (2.3)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.66E-3 (9.0) 1.97E-3 (9.1) 2.02E-3 (2.5) 1.55E-3 (5.0) 1.47E-3 (4.6) 1.47E-3 (2.1)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 1.14 +/- 12% 1.17 +/- 13% 1.20 +/- 3.8% 1.19 +/- 6.9% 1.15 +/-6.3% 1.15 +/- 3.1%
Lung Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 2.57E-4 (2.8) 2.33E-4 (6.5) 1.94E-4 (3.1) 1.24E-4 (5.1) 1.11E-4 (4.9) 9.66E-5 (4.4)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 2.15E-4 (6.6) 2.09E-4 (14.2) 1.83E-4 (5.7) 1.03E-4 (11.5) 1.01E-4 (10.6) 8.81E-5 (8.6)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 0.84 +/- 7.2% 0.90 +/- 16% 0.94 +/- 6.5 0.83 +/- 13% 0.91 +/- 12% 0.91 +/- 9.7%
Total Body Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 2.52E-4 (4.3) 2.03E-4 (8.5) 1.80E-4 (3.7) 1.21E-4 (6.6) 9.52E-5 (8.2) 8.09E-5 (6.0)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 1.98E-4 (4.0) 1.94E-4 (8.5) 1.52E-4 (4.1) 1.07E-4 (7.4) 9.41E-5 (7.4) 7.75E-5 (6.3)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 0.79 +/- 5.9% 0.96 +/- 12% 0.84 +/- 5.5% 0.88 +/- 9.9% 0.99 +/- 11% 0.96 +/- 8.7%
GI Ref. Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 2.59E-4 (3.3) 2.21E-3 (7.4) 1.84E-3 (3.4) 1.21E-3 (6.2) 1.05E-4 (7.2) 8.93E-5 (5.4)Test Eff. (% 2 s.d.) 2.59E-4 (3.8) 2.32E-3 (7.8) 2.07E-3 (3.5) 1.24E-3 (6.6) 1.22E-4 (6.1) 1.06E-4 (5.2)Ratio +/- % 2 s.d. 1.00 +/- 5.0% 1.05 +/- 11% 1.12 +/- 4.9% 1.02 +/- 9.1% 1.16 +/- 9.4% 1.19 +/- 7.5%
NOTES1) Reference Lung geometry provided by planar source inserts in the Livermore Realistic torso phantom to simulate uniform lung activity distribution.2) Reference Total Body geometry provided by the 10-compartment poly-bottle phantom with uniform activity concentration in a water matrix.3) Reference G.I geometry provided by a uniform activity concentration in the lower torso compartment of the poly-bottle phantom, and a blank water matrix absorber in the upper torso and thigh compartments.4) Efficiency was measured in units of counts per gamma emitted by the source matrix.
FAST
SCA
NA
CCU
SCA
NA
CCU
SCA
N-I
I
Lung 1
Total Body 2
GI 3
101
Table J-2. Comparison of RMC-II and ANSI N13.30 reference phantoms efficiency ratio values and corresponding relative bias values.
Counter Configuration Source Type Range of Efficiency
Ratio Value00sa
Range of Measured Activity
Relative Bias Valuesb Fastscan Lung 0.92 to 1.04 -0.04 to 0.09 Total Body 1.03 to 1.15 -0.13 to -0.03 G.I. Region 0.99 to 1.16 -0.14 to 0.01
Accuscan Bed (Full Bed Scan Mode)
Lung 0.82 to 0.98 0.02 to 0.22
Total Body 0.97 to 1.17 -0.15 to 0.03 G.I. Region 1.14 to 1.20 -0.17 to -0.12
Accuscan-II (Full Shield Scan Mode)
Lung 0.83 to 0.94 0.06 to 0.20
Total Body 0.79 to 0.99 0.01 to 0.27 G.I. Region 1.00 to 1.19 -0.16 to 0.00
a. Efficiency Ration = (RMC-II phantom Effic.)/(Reference phantom Effic.) (Range shows lowest and highest values listed in Table J-1 for photon energies between 122 and 1408 keV.) b. Relative Bias = (A2 – A1)/(A1)
where A1 = measured activity value if reference phantom used for efficiency calibration A2 = measured activity value if RMC-II phantom used for efficiency calibration.
102
Figure J-1. Canberra RMS-II (Model 2257) WBC calibration phantom.